When you're angry or do something impulsive, that's your reptilian brain in action, right?
And if you talk yourself out of that impulsive act or gain control over your wrath, that's
your neocortex at work, isn't it?
And those emotions you feel, such as grief when a loved one dies, or joy at the birth
of a child.
Those are just things that happen to you in reaction to events in your life, correct?
And their universal across cultures, aren't they? Well, maybe not.
What if emotions are things that our brain constructs, to make sense of the signals it
gets from our body and from the world around us?
What if the way you think about your brain and how and why it functions is just plain
wrong?
Welcome to Speaking of Psychology, the flagship podcast of the American Psychological
Association that examines the links between psychological science and everyday life.
I'm Kim Mills.
The guest today is Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett, a distinguished professor of psychology at
Northeastern University.
Dr. Barrett has spent more than three decades studying emotion.
Her research has helped to develop the idea that the human brain creates emotions by predicting
rather than reacting to what happens in the world around us.
She's published more than 240 scientific papers and is also a prolific science communicator
writing articles and books about brain science for the general public.
Over two most recent books are how emotions are made, published in 2017, and seven-and-a-half
lessons about the brain, which came out in November.
Thank you for joining us today, Dr. Barrett.
Oh, it's a pleasure to be here, Kim.
I want to start with an idea that opens your new book, which is that the main purpose
of the brain is not to think, but to regulate our bodies.
This may seem counterintuitive or come as a surprise to some of our listeners.
I'm wondering, can you explain how you came to this conclusion and why it's so important?
I actually started with a question of why do we even have a brain?
That blob of meat between your ears is the most expensive organ that you have in your
whole body.
So why do we even have a brain?
What I did was I went back in the literature and I looked in the literature on evolutionary
neuroscience to a time when animals on the earth didn't have brains and looked at the
evolution of the brain.
I found some really remarkable evidence that brains evolved under the selection pressure
of predation.
So during the Cambrian period, animals learned to hunt one another deliberately and eat
each other.
It's not that animals didn't eat each other before then, but there was very little
evidence of actual hunting.
And so under the selection pressure of hunting, what happened is that bodies got bigger
and required much more coordination of internal bodily systems.
Because animals without brains don't have very much going on inside.
They have some internal coordination, but not very much.
And they really have no sophisticated senses to speak of.
That is, they don't see.
They don't hear.
They don't smell.
They really don't know very much about the world outside their own bodies.
And what you see under predation is that bodies get bigger, senses evolve, and brains appear.
And if you look at the anatomy of the brain, what you see is that at the core of the brain,
even at the core of the cortex, cerebral cortex, are the regions that are regulating the systems
of your body, your immune system, your metabolism, and endocrine system, your autonomic nervous
system, and your skeletal muscle system.
And the networks in the brain that are responsible for remembering and thinking and seeing even
are actually involved in regulating the body.
And so the bottom line is that we do think and we do feel and we do see.
But we do those things in the service of regulating the systems of the body.
Now we don't experience every feeling of gratitude or sadness, every hug we give, every
insult we bear as having anything to do with the body, but it does.
And the reason why this is important is that many of the things that we think of as mental,
like depression, illness is like depression and anxiety, or even just things like seeing
or thinking actually have important aspects to them that are related to the body.
So depression, for example, in addition to being a mental illness and having immune functioning
problems is also a metabolic illness actually.
And that's why it's important that we understand it really starts to break down the boundary
between the mental and the physical.
And so we can understand, for example, that all mental disorders actually have basic
physical processes that are in disarray.
And also things we think of as mental, physical illnesses like cardiovascular disease and so
one actually have mental aspects to them, which are really important to understand.
So a few moments ago, you talked about the brain being the most expensive organ.
What do you mean by that?
Metabolically speaking, your brain costs you 20% of your metabolic budget.
That's more than your heart, that's more than your lungs, that's more than your liver.
It's a very expensive organ to keep running.
All those little neurons and so on, it's really expensive actually, metabolically speaking.
And it turns out that metabolic efficiency is a major selection pressure, not just on
any species that's alive, it's true, that it's important for the evolution of any species.
It's also important for your health, mental and physical.
If you have metabolic dysregulation or things are not running as efficiently metabolically,
I'm not just talking about circulating glucose or something, that's one very small part
of a very large, complicated system.
If your energy regulation is not proceeding in a metabolically efficient way, you will
get sick.
And are our brains more expensive than other mammalian brains?
I mean, we have this big, big hunk of meat up there.
Yes, they are, yes.
You know, when you look at primates, let's say relative to other mammals, primates do have
bigger brains relative to their body size than other mammals do.
And humans have bigger brains.
But I would say that, you know, the size of the cerebral cortex is not any bigger than
you would expect for a primate who has a brain of our size.
So it's not like our cerebral cortex is so big relative to the rest of our brain.
It's just we have a big brain relative to our body size and our cerebral cortex is as
big as you might expect for a creature who has, you know, a brain of our size.
There is some genetic upregulation in the human brain that makes it more expensive to
run, particularly in the cerebral cortex, in particular layers of the cerebral cortex that
have to do with our ability to, so I guess you could say, compress information, summarize
information from multiple sources so that we can do things like abstraction.
Another, what might be a surprising point to some people in your book, I think I alluded
to it a little bit in the introduction, is the way that many of us were taught about
the brain is wrong.
So a lot of our listeners, I'm sure remember learning that there are three parts of the
human brain.
You've been asked this a million times.
We think there's the lizard or reptilian brain that controls our basic bodily functions.
There's the emotional brain.
And then there's the rational brain, the neocortex that's like the pinnacle of evolution and makes
us supposedly superior to other animals.
But you say this is incorrect.
So where did the idea of a triune brain come from and how do we know that it's wrong?
Okay, so I got to say, I'm happy to talk about it.
I have been asked about this a lot, but I'm so happy to talk about it because it's like
one of the most pervasive myths, modern myths in science.
It's not even wrong is what I would say, Kim.
And I also have to say that this is not my research, right, like this is, I don't do research
on this topic.
Although I do research on brain organization and its relevance for psychological functioning.
And I do research on the structure and function of tissue that is called limbic.
But it's not called limbic because it's a motion, it's really more about the anatomical
structure of the tissue.
But let me just say that the idea of a triune brain, a brain in three layers really can be
I've traced it all the way back to Plato.
Because you know, Plato talked about the soul or the psyche, which is not exactly the same
as a mind, but for present purposes, it's like close enough.
He talked about the psyche as having, human psyche is having three parts.
One part for instinct, one part for emotion, which he represented as two beasts, right,
two horses, and then a chariot here, which is human rationality, which obviously controls
the beast.
And so right there you have this idea of an inner beast and a rational part, and they're
in constant battle for control of the chariot, of your behavior.
That's basically the idea.
And so fast forward, like a couple of thousand years, and we're in the era
of modern neuroscience, like in the mid-20th century.
And you have scientists who are using the best tools
available to them, which is the naked eye,
or maybe some not-so-powerful microscopes with some dyes.
And you look at a lizard brain,
and lizard brain looks like it has a set of parts,
and then you look at a early mat,
like a small mammal brain, like a rat,
and you all look like there are some extra parts there.
And then you look at a human, you're like,
oh, wow, there's really, definitely a really big extra part there.
And so the idea that really grew out of this
that comes from Paul McLean, who was a neuroscientist
in Boston, actually, where I live.
In the 1940s, is this idea that lizards
have circuitry for instincts, and then layered on top of that
evolved the limbic system, limbic-meaning border,
which is really old cortex, consider to be old cortex,
that borders these lizard parts, which
is where emotions live.
And then layered on top of that is the new part of the cortex,
the neocortex, which is where rationality lives,
the pinnacle, as you say, of evolution.
And so there are a couple of things wrong with this view.
One is that evolution, we aren't the pinnacle of anything.
Evolution didn't aim itself at us to use
paraphrase wording from Henry G, the paleontologist, Henry G.
And animals are well adapted to their niche.
If a species still is around, after a couple of 100,000
years, then it means it's well adapted to its niche.
And other animals have some pretty miraculous abilities
to do things that we don't have, frankly,
and that we endow our superheroes with.
So yes, it's true.
We can do some pretty amazing things in humans.
But other animals can do very amazing things,
like grow back limbs.
Yeah, we can't fly.
We can't grow back limbs.
We definitely can't grow new neurons in most of our brains,
whereas other animals, there are animals who
can do all of those things, or each of those things, right?
But more importantly, the evidence from molecular genetics,
when you peer in deep into the cells,
the molecular structure of cells,
and you look at the genes deep within what you see,
really clear evidence, that brains
did not evolve like sedimentary rock.
Or the way I think of it as you know,
you've got this deep animal beast, like inner ancient beast,
and then what evolved on top of that
was rationality like icing on an already baked cake.
Brainst in all that way, they just didn't.
That's the evidence.
And the evidence has been around for more than 50 years,
and yet hasn't managed to percolate its way
into, not just into the public sphere,
but into psychology textbooks.
Like, yeah, anytime you read that the amygdala
and other parts of the limbic system, which I would put
in scare quotes, because there is no limbic system
in your brain.
Anytime you read that the amygdala or the limbic system
is being regulated by the prefrontal cortex,
that is a phrasing which rests on this old,
really mistaken idea that you have this inner beast lurking
inside your brain, which is constantly in battle
with your more sensible rational self,
and that the outcome of your, you know,
that you're, when you're rational side wins,
you're healthy and moral, and when you're inner beast wins,
you're either, you know, if you're inner beast wins,
because you didn't try hard enough, then you're not moral,
and if you're inner beast wins,
because you, you know, there's something wrong and then you're sick.
That's just a, that's just a, it's a morality tale,
but it doesn't reflect actually the biology
of how we got these miraculous brains to begin with.
- You make another really interesting point
in your new book that I think is something,
another myth-busting point, I think a lot of people have the sense
that parts of our brains kind of go dormant
from time to time, and then we're not using them,
and I think what you're saying is neurons are firing all the time.
Maybe you can explain a little bit about how that works and why.
- So if you look back in the history of how neurons were,
were discovered and how they were studied,
like in the 1950s, for example,
one way to study the properties of a neuron
was to take a big squid neuron,
like literally take it out of the brain
and lay it out on a table.
And when you lay out a single neuron on a table that you can see,
'cause these are like really giant squids have like very,
they have a neuron that you can see with the naked eye
as I understand it, it's dormant.
And then you have to stimulate it with electricity
to get it to produce an action potential down its axon.
And this is very convenient.
We consistent with the idea that the stimulus response idea
that has really been around in psychology
really since the inception of psychology, right?
So psychology as a field was a field of fundamental philosophy
until the mid-19th century when philosophers
and neurologists and physiologists
started to use the methods available to them
from the physiology lab and from patients with lesions
to try to search for the physical basis
of the psychological categories that were in mental philosophy.
So the physical basis of memory, the physical basis of emotion,
the physical basis of perception and so on.
And the idea was that the brain is stimulated,
the mind is stimulated by something in the world,
and then maybe some processing goes on inside
and then there's a response.
So it's stimulus response jazzed up.
This was very consistent with what happens
when you look at an individual neuron lying on a table.
It's dormant and you have to stimulate it
in order for defy her.
But that is not how neurons work
when they are actually in situ with other neurons
bathed in chemicals and oxygen and so on.
Neurons are constantly talking to each other.
Your brain is basically having a conversation with itself
throughout your entire life.
And that's ongoing and information from your body
and information from the world
merely modulate that ongoing activity.
And that is the way the brain works.
It's trying to say and therapists know this,
they use different words, but it's exactly the same idea
that the brain is running a model of the world
an internal model of the world.
That's not quite right.
The brain is a model and it's a model of the body
as it receives information from the world.
So we don't model the world.
We model the information that arrives
to our sensory surfaces like our retinus
and our colchlia and so on and so forth
and all the sensory services inside our body.
And the brain is receiving this information
and it's attempting to make sense of it
so that it knows what to do next
to keep itself alive and well.
And it's using past experience to make these guesses.
So what you see and what you hear
and what you smell and what you taste and so on
and what you feel in your body
'cause you don't really feel anything in your body.
You feel everything in your brain.
Everything is felt in your brain.
You see in your brain, you don't see in your eyes,
you hear in your brain, you don't hear in your ears.
Everything you experience
and everything you do is a combination
of what's in the world and in your body
'cause from your brain's perspective,
that's outside the skull, right?
So what's in the world?
What's in the periphery and what's in the past
that your brain re-impliments as the present?
- Let's turn to your work on emotion,
which is also fascinating.
And one of the big ideas that you've developed
is that the emotions aren't things that happen to us
but there's something that our brain constructs.
Explain that.
(laughing)
- Well, yeah.
- In 25 or so.
- In 25 or so.
(laughing)
- So, you know, what goes along with this idea
that we're born with these ancient circuits, right?
Very deep inside our brain, kind of hardwired already.
There is this idea that emotions happen to you.
Something happens in the world like you see a snake
and it triggers fear and then fear produces
this whole cascade of events.
You make a particular facial expression.
Your heart rate goes up.
Maybe you freeze or you run.
And the idea is that this, you know,
that this is universal with everybody in the world.
And if everybody was a neurotypical brain
who has these circuits, which, you know,
are derived from ancient mammals
or were, you know, evolved in hunter-gatherer society,
you know, in Africa or whatever.
There are different versions of it.
And I'm painting kind of a, you know,
you might want to say is a straw man,
sort of a description.
But. You know, you can add bells and whistles and nuances, but the basic idea is that emotions
are universal, they have a single set, you know, anger has a single set of features, maybe
with some variation, but not so much variation that you can't recognize it in someone's face
or in their body or in their body movements or in their voice or whatever.
And all I can say is, I know it feels that way.
It feels that way to me too, you know, when I get angry, when I'm, you know, when I feel
gratitude or any rush of emotion to me feels exactly the same way as it feels to you, but
that is not how the brain works and that is not what the evidence shows.
I mean, so the evidence shows really clearly, it couldn't be clearer, frankly, that emotions
are not universal.
What is universal, however, is that the human brain is constantly constructing experience.
It's constantly trying to make sense of the world around and the body, or actually I would
say it's trying to make sense of what's going on inside the body in relation to what's
going on around us outside in the world, and it's doing this using past experience and
it's always doing this.
So the way I would say it is kind of like this, the evidence to me suggests very strongly
that your brain receives sense data from the world, sites and sounds and smells and
so on, and it receives sense data from the body.
And so when there's a loud bang or a tug in your chest, your brain receives that information
as the outcomes of some sense set of causes.
But what caused that loud bang?
Is it a car, a backfiring?
Is it somebody slamming a door?
Is it a gunshot?
What's happening, what caused that tug in your chest?
Is it anxiety?
Is it that you over ate, to what you have heartburned from eating too rich of the meal?
Is it the beginning of a heart attack?
Your brain actually doesn't know.
It only receives the outcomes.
It has to guess at what the causes are.
This is called an inverse problem.
You know what the outcome is, you don't know what the cause is.
And so your brain has one other source of information available to it.
And that is past experience, memory.
So it's not like you walk around consciously remembering things in order to perceive the
world.
Your brain is constantly remembering, meaning it is constantly reassembling bits and pieces
of past experience in order to make sense of what's going on in the body in relation
to the world so that your brain knows what to do next.
Because frankly, if a loud bang is a door slamming, you would do something different in
a particular situation than if it was a gun shot.
And so what your brain is, if you were to anthropomorphize a bit, you'd say, what your brain is constantly
doing is it's asking the question, what is similar in my path?
What is similar to what this sensory array looks like and what caused it and what did I do
about it and did it work?
Now in psychology, things that are similar to one another are category.
So your brain, you could say, is constructing categories.
It's a category construction organ.
It's constantly using the past to construct categories to make sense of the present in order
for the purposes of guiding action and regulating metabolism.
But we also know that a representation of a category is a concept.
So you could say also that what the brain is doing is it's doing concept generation,
ad hoc concept generation.
Your brain is constantly remembering, reassembling past experience as concepts that are tailored
to the specific situation that you're in to make sense of what your body means in that
particular situation so that it knows what to do next to keep you alive and well.
And that's what emotions are.
Emotions are just when your brain uses past experiences of emotion to make meaning of
the present and guide action.
If emotion is something that our brain creates, then can we will ourselves to feel emotions
differently?
How much control do we actually have over our emotions?
Well, I would say that we definitely can.
But it's much harder to do than actually sometimes we make it out to be.
And every client that every therapist has ever had knows this to be true.
It's actually very, very hard to do.
And also what it means is that what control looks like doesn't only happen in the moment
when a person wants to change how they feel.
So one thing I haven't done is made the distinction between affect and emotion.
And that's a really important distinction in the science that we do.
Emotions are easier to change.
Affect is not as easy to change in the moment.
So let me back up a little bit and explain that distinction and then I will answer your question.
Your brain is always controlling your body.
And your body is always sending sense data back to your brain.
And for the most part, we are not aware of all of those sense data to the same degree
that we're aware of sites and sounds and smells and things.
At least I hope you're not.
If you are aware of what's going on inside your body, I feel really bad for you because
it means that you've got a whole drama unfolding there.
And if you're aware of it, that means that you're probably insignificant discomfort and
I'm really sorry.
But what evolution has done is made available that information to us as affect, as simple
feelings.
I feel pleasant.
I feel unpleasant.
I feel calm.
I feel comfortable.
I feel uncomfortable.
So your brain is regulating your body 24/7.
Your body is sending information back to your brain 24/7.
And you feel affect 24/7 regardless of whether you're emotional or not.
You feel affect.
Affect is universal.
Now what affective features are associated with different things is not necessarily universal
always.
But affect is universal, the ability, the capacity to have affect is universal.
And most likely all mammals and many vertebrates, probably maybe all vertebrates, and maybe
even some invertebrates can also feel affect.
That's an interesting, you know, more ass of confusion there.
But it's interesting to talk about and think about.
But you know, I would say affect is definitely not a human specific ability.
And sometimes when we're making meaning of the sensations and the affect that goes
with it, sometimes we make episodes of emotion by, again, creating categories or concepts
on the fly.
In fact, there's a convenient term called a conceptual category, which means that the
concept, that knowledge is what makes a bunch of things similar to each other in a category.
Because a bunch of things can be similar to each other by virtue of their function, not
by virtue of what they look like or smell like or sound like or taste like.
And many things that we deal with in life are categories of that sort.
And infants learn those kinds of categories in the first year of infancy, they're called
abstract categories, where the similarity that draws the instances together are not
perceptual, they're functional, that is, they serve some kind of function.
And this is something I talk about in seven and a half lessons.
And so affect is hard to change.
Because you don't have volitional control over your heart or your lungs and you do have
volitional control over your breathing, and you can try to practice breathing in order to
control your heart and so on and so forth.
But you can't stop your blood from flowing.
No.
And so it's really, most people can't speed their heart up just by thinking about it.
So affect is actually really hard to change without drugs in the instant.
And that's really often why people use drugs, both prescription, you know, chemicals
and unprescribed chemicals because they're attempting to relieve discomfort or distress,
which is affective in nature.
But you definitely can change how you make sense of affect and the sensations that give
rise to it.
And but there I would say in the moment, for example, what James Gross and others call
reappraisal is just you could think of it mechanistically as your brain is recategorizing
a set of the set of sensations is recategorizing what they mean.
That is, it's conjuring a different category, a different concept to make sense of those
sensations and therefore give rise to a different action.
So in the moment, you can do that very deliberately, but sometimes even that is really, really,
really hard to do and on one way to have more control over your emotions in addition to
just, you know, keeping making it easier for your brain to regulate your body, which
is like get enough sleep, eat healthfully, you know, surround yourself with people who,
you know, care about you and who you love and have good relationships with in addition
to those things, you know, you can learn and practice reconsexualizing.
is changing the categories that your brain can make easily. So it's kind of like exercise,
you know, or like driving. You know, first of all, it is like exercise because it's very effortful
to do this and so it's like an investment in a healthier you. But it is also like driving where
at first it's really hard, but then when you practice it really a lot, you know, it gets easier
and pretty automatic. So you can take anxiety and turn it into determination or exhilaration even.
You can take anger and turn it into awe. The affect stays the same, but the meaning is what's changing.
And if you practice in advance, you're like seeding your brain to be able to do this much more
automatically. So for example, you know, I'm like skeptical by nature, but there is research to show
the gratitude and compassion and awe are very good for your nervous system and therefore for
your mental health. And right down the hall for me is a colleague who studies gratitude and the
importance of gratitude. So I'm like, okay, fine, you know, all right, I'll try it. And so I set
myself the task of, you know, gratitude I was already on board with, but awe was a trickier one.
So I said, all right, I'll try to, you know, cultivate a sense of wonder for five minutes every day,
where, you know, I'm a spec and therefore my problems are a spec and, you know, let's see if I can do it.
And sure enough, you know, it was hard at first, but I did it just like, you know, I learned to,
you know, do a plank, hold a plank for a minute or two, whatever. And, um, and eventually it became
really easy. And now I can switch in and out of, you know, that particular state, my brain can make
it easily when I need it. And, um, and give my nervous system, you know, if you're a spec for a minute,
your problems are a spec for a minute, and that gives you a break for a minute. And that changes how
you breathe and it changes how you comport your body and it changes what you do next. Um, so a lot of
the things that we kind of know by different names, we misunderstand mechanistic way in which they
occur, right? So appraisal or reappraisal is a description of something that happens.
It's not an explanation of the process that produces it. And by understanding how your brain works,
you can generalize that process and start using it in new other ways. So for example,
you can learn other emotion concepts from other cultures that don't exist in our culture,
but that might be really useful for helping you to make sense of your affect and the sensations
that give rise to it so that you can broaden the repertoire of actions that you can potentially
take. And we know from the wonderful work of George Bonanno that flexibility is the key to resilience
in any situation, even a really stressful one. And so that's a way you can control your emotional
life, cultivate, cultivate your emotional life, architect your life, architect your experience
in a way that is before the heat of the moment. So what are the big unanswered questions in your
field? And what are you working on now? Oh my god. Well, I have a lab of 25 full-time people and,
you know, 100 or so undergraduate researchers. So we have many, many questions that we are trying
to understand. But one thing we're trying to understand, for example, is the name for your brain
sensing your body is called interception. And usually interception is studied as your awareness
of your physical sensation. Are you aware of your heartbeat? Are you aware? But that's really
a very small part of what interception is. Your brain is estimating the state of your body.
It's modeling your body, basically. And most of that state estimation is happening outside
of your awareness at all, completely. You just have no awareness of it. And so that's a question
we're really interested in. Not the question of like, are you aware of your heartbeat? But how well
is your brain actually tracking what's happening in your body? Because one cause of depression, for
example, could be that your brain has a mistaken model of your body. And there are some disconnect
there. So that's one thing that we're really mechanistically trying to work out. Another is,
you know, in the way that we understand some things that we think something first and then we act
or we think something first and then we feel something. So we go in and we try to tinker with how
people think in order to change how they feel and what they do. But actually the way the brain works
is that your brain prepares your actions first and your experience is derived from that.
It's not the other way around. And this is also something that I explain in both books actually.
And there's a very strong likelihood that what's happening is not that you think bad things
and then you feel bad. More like you feel bad and that leads your brain to think bad things.
So it could be that there are problems with the way that your brain is modeling your body or
literally problems with your body. For example, maybe your mitochondria are not as effective as
they need to be. And that could be a source of depression. That could be a source of, you know,
this disconnect. Your brain is attempting to model your body. Your body is not functioning well
in this really, you know, subtle way that you would not be aware of, but maybe you'd just be aware
of feeling bad. And that that is actually what's driving those negative thoughts, not the other way
around. To me, this seems, first of all, very plausible from a neuroscience standpoint.
And what it means is that when we go in and we break what we go in and we get people to change
how they're thinking or to change how they feel, what we're doing is actually just breaking a cycle.
We're not changing the cause of the problem. We're just interrupting an ongoing cycle.
And again, I would say there are real lessons there about things that you might want to do differently
if this is actually, it's not that what we're doing is bad. It's just that there might be additional
things that we might want to think about doing for treating mental illness.
Well, it just sounds amazing the work that you're doing. I really appreciate you're taking
the time to speak with me today. And I highly recommend, I mean, maybe I shouldn't say this,
but I think your new book is very accessible and a great read. So I appreciate the time that you've
taken. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks very much. You can find previous episodes of Speaking of
Psychology at www.Speakingofpsychology.org or on Apple, Stitcher, or wherever you get your podcasts.
If you have comments or ideas for future podcasts, you can email us at
[email protected]
that's Speaking of Psychology All One Word at apa.org. Speaking of Psychology is produced by Lee
Winerman. Our Sound Editor is Chris Cundayan. Thank you for listening. The American Psychological Association. I'm Kim Mills.
[Music]