Go back

Young Republicans Are Openly Revolting Against Trump

21m 10s

Young Republicans Are Openly Revolting Against Trump

The Republican Party is experiencing deep internal fractures following the midterms, with a significant revolt among young college Republicans rejecting Donald Trump’s leadership. These groups, often linked to Nick Fuentes and the Gryper movement, are advocating for a more extreme, racially charged right-wing alternative, signaling a generational shift away from Trump’s populist appeal. Within this, two ideological factions have emerged: a more moderate, policy-focused Vance-oriented wing and a radical, explicitly antisemitic and racist faction. At the same time, professional Republican networks are reorganizing, with groups like American Ascent and Heritage-aligned figures building policy infrastructure to prepare younger GOP operatives for post-Trump governance. Figures such as Mike Pence represent the establishment’s push for policy normalization and stability, contrasting with the growing radicalism of the youth wing. The collapse of Trump’s youth coalition—once a key electoral strength—has exposed deep discontent, leading to fears that the party may fracture further in 2028. As younger Republicans transition from online activism to formal political roles, the GOP faces a pivotal moment: whether it can stabilize around a moderate, electable path or spiral into ideological extremism that undermines its long-term viability. The current chaos reflects a broader realignment, where trust in Trump’s leadership has eroded and a new, more volatile right-wing ecosystem is taking root.

Transcription

4366 Words, 24031 Characters

English
Hello everybody, welcome to Bullwork Takes, Ugly Christmas Sweater edition. I am Andrew Agger joined by my colleague, Will Summer, to talk about some unbelievably interesting fractures, some fault lines that are opening up in the GOP after last Tuesday's midterms. Anytime you have a party that goes through a big loss, there's going to be a lot of infighting afterwards. And it was a really, really, really big loss. And there was a lot of pent up infighting that had been waiting to happen for quite some time anyway. A lot to talk about. Well, in your latest newsletter, you wrote about how Donald Trump is having some problems with the youths, certain college Republican chapters in particular that have been among the loudest voices who seem to be ready to, at least in some sense, to move on from the president after the midterms. Can you just talk us through what it is that you reported on and how widespread of an issue is this for the president? Yeah, I mean, I think basically this newsletter is about Trump facing a revolt among the college Republicans. And the day after the election, the college Republicans is this group calling itself the college Republicans Patriot Coalition, which is sort of a previously unheard of group, but one that represents a lot of big states and universities and federations came out and said, you know, you might say, wow, after they got shell-acked, maybe they want moderation? No, no. They are, they want more deportations. They want, you know, more cruelty, all of this kind of stuff. And they see Trump as too weak. And so they came out and essentially said Trump has betrayed us for Israel, and he needs to, you know, step aside, we need a new champion on the right. So on one hand, these are just a bunch of college Republicans. But on the other, I mean, these are the guys we're going to make up the GOP operative class. A lot of them in the future might try to be Republican politicians. And so you have this kind of like crack up among kind of the young intelligentsia of the right, this idea that they're rejecting Trumpism for something more extreme after the midterms. Yeah, I mean, this has been one of the longstanding stories that I know you've covered a lot. We've covered a lot over the last couple of years is just how insane the youths have become especially, you know, these kids who have come up in Republican politics, never having known anything but Mac. Right? I mean, they've been sort of on the right and specifically on the Trump right for basically their entire adult or attention-paying lives. And so there's, they are, it's not like they have any sort of fond memories of the before times in their Republican party, but also Trump kind of is the establishment to them. And maybe they are a little bit faster to turn the corner on him than, you know, some of these other groups that took so much longer to get to MAGA like in the middle of their careers or in the middle of their voting lives or something like that. Since you bring that up, I think it's interesting because it also suggests that they're sensing a real weakness in Trump world. I mean, these are guys who in a normal political system would sort of be anticipating getting internships, getting, getting think tank jobs, whatever, basically starting their careers as Republican operatives. And they're saying, who cares? We can just go ahead and offend Trump and kind of raise our pirate flag or what have you. So I think that, you know, there's that aspect and there's just a sense of like, you know, I should say this Patriot coalition, they are the Guardian reported, their domain is owned by Nick Fuentes, the White Nationalist pod gaster. So reading the statement, I was like, this seems like very kind of gropeery. But then actually, no, it is. I mean, it seems to be some kind of strange Nick Fuentes op. But to be clear, I mean, the University of Florida College Republicans, the Georgia, federations, sort of sort of the state college across the state, all of these big NYU college Republicans, all of these big universities, their college Republican branch is often in conservative state. Presumably, this isn't like the Oberlin College Republicans with like three people. They are, they're saying, you know, we're done with Trump. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I'd like to party with the Oberlin College Republicans. What a, what an interesting crowd I bet there is in that group, but let me drill down on that a little bit because this is one thing that I am still kind of trying to wrap my head around. This is a new union of the actual sort, the umbrella group that is pulling in these signatories is new. And that's what appears to be at least in some sense affiliated, not with like the national college Republicans organization, but with the Gryper movement, with Nick Fuentes, but the signatories you're saying are all of these individual college Republican chapters. Yeah, exactly. They are like actual groups. And so even within that, you know, the college Republicans have all these different national groups that kind of war with each other, but there's already kind of like a Gryper themed one called the College Republicans of America that I think a lot of these belong to. And now they're even clashing with that as not extreme enough because I think the College Republicans of America were like, whoa, you guys can't be signing things. They're doing all what we call fast wave imagery. So kind of like, you know, black and white imagery of like, you know, that is dead. And it's the statute of liberty on fire, but America first lives. And so I think this national group was like, whoa, you got a chill. And so suddenly these university chapters are disaffiliating. So there's a lot of turmoil. And you know, to some extent, yes, this is kind of a tempest in a teacup situation. You know, these are people who I think often kind of suggest the future of what the Republican establishment or what the staffer class is going to look like. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I mean, it is such a remarkably different ecosystem out there from a decade ago, 15 years ago. I mean, when guys like you and I, I feel like we're coming up because I think you were a little bit in this universe, too, of just being around these sort of like, I don't know, how would you even describe groups like young Americans for liberty or like the college Republicans the way they used to be? It was kind of like finishing school for like these 20-year-old, you know, want to be George Will types or-- Yeah, exactly. Republicans. We love Paul Ryan. We want to cut entitlements, you know, whereas now, I mean, you know, one thing I think is striking I mean, we can look at the Heritage Foundation, too, right? Where this group that was very focused on like very conservative, raganight policy. And suddenly it becomes all about they sort of torn apart because they get all into these culture war issues and kind of this this tumult and the populism and the anger and the culture war. This episode is sponsored by Cometeer. So my day cannot begin without a good cup of coffee. I had a couple this morning, maybe three. And there's nothing worse than sitting down for your first cup of the day and it's just bitter. Burnt grounds are, you know, watery, weak brew. Now I never have to worry about that. I have a great cup of coffee every morning, thanks to Cometeer. Cometeer sources coffee from the best roasters in the world. It brews it to perfection and then it flash freezes it to lock in peak flavor and freshness. Comes on dry ice right to your door in recyclable aluminum capsules. All you have to do is melt it to make hot coffee or you could do ice coffee or you could do espresso style drinks like lattes and it's just in seconds. No machine or plastic brew path is required. These capsules are loved by coffee fanatics everywhere. In the former president of Nespresso, invested in Cometeer after just one sip. We have Cometeer right here in the office over there and there's nothing easier than popping open a capsule and pouring over hot water. And for the younger folks on our team who are always craving ice coffee psychopaths, those same capsules are perfect and have become a hit in the office. So get $20 off at cometere.com/boortakes or use cold boortakes. Cometeer.com/boortakes for $20 off. Can you just like broaden the focus out a little bit because obviously the college Republicans are just one group, one set of groups, one big constellation of groups. But the whole rest of the ecosystem is totally different too. And I guess the biggest player right now is turning point USA, which is experiencing plenty of its own sorts of factional rifts and things like this. But is this one axis of the young Republican network that's out there and is there some other kind of group that still has major purchase or is this sort of representative or at least illustrative of kind of where the youth energy is at for 25 and under Republicans right now? Yeah, I guess I would say that I don't think there's a rival group of more moderate Mitt Romney, 20, some things that's coming up. I mean, I think basically we're looking at sort of two options among younger Republicans. One is what you might call like the Vansian wing where we're like a little more draconian, a little more racist than Donald Trump. You know, we're keeping the deportations, but maybe like a little more disciplined and a little more like crush our enemies in a more rigorous way. So we have that branch and then you have a and that branch is like kind of cool with his real, you know, a little bit. And then you have a much more explicitly racist and antisemitic Nick Fuente's Groyper is a team. So you really have sort of these two varying shades of extremism on the right, even after the midterm defeat. It's not like anyone really on the right is calling out for like, whoa, we need to hit the breaks here. You know, Christopher Rufo said he's like, we need a policy that is like strong on national defense, good on the economy, all the like good on good on immigration, but not, but doesn't come off as evil or stupid. And it's like, well, yeah, that's kind of, you know, yeah, that would be good if you could figure that out. You know, for your political prospects, but that seems essentially impossible. Yeah. Yeah. No. And I mean, I, when you get into the way that like in this little universe, it's like the big vance heads who, who see themselves and in fact kind of are like, like the less insane of the two coalitions. I feel like that, that's pretty illustrative of, of just how far off the reservation sort of culturally young republicanism is, is right at this moment. And that certainly has a lot of bearing on not, not just how the party looks right now, but how it's going to look as you, as you mentioned earlier, in five or 10 years as these people age into, you know, being the next professional class of the, of the, you know, young republicans. But just to bring it back around to, to Donald Trump. I mean, I think it's, it is worth dwelling on how generational of a fumble this is from the president. I mean, 2024, that was one of the big stories is how his winning coalition with Kamala Harris was like the best Republican, Republican had done with the youth vote in like a generation. I mean, it's, this had been a stronghold of the Democratic party that, that you had a lot of, a lot of these guys, but then also just sort of more moderate young people who didn't like, you know, the idea of wars and didn't like the inflation and, you know, the whole manosphere thing and they all kind of clustered around Donald Trump. And now not only has he lost, you know, all those moderate types, but even the, the, the people who were there for the Trump stuff to begin with, even the people who were titillated by, you know, the, the A, ASMR ice deportation videos and all, you know, that sort of thing. Even these people are now starting to get a little bored, it seems, of his coalition. >> Yeah, that's who the memes are for. >> That's who like the malfoyed memes and the, you know, it was starting to be a lot of these college Republican chapters were posting like Anakin Skywalker and he's kind of like crying, but he's like, but I'll become Darth Vader. I mean, this is not like much of a message of electability, right? I mean, I do think, you know, kind of building on this point we're making about the, the kind of the divide in the far right, which is kind of a more, are we going to go at slight, sort of a more palatable, probably more electable, dance way, or are we just going to go like a Nick Fuente's way? You know, a lot of the kind of extreme commenters like, like Bronze Age pervert, the guy from passage press who's at the blaze, Jonathan Kieperman, they've gone in this kind of more okay with Israel direction, and this is enraged the more anti-Semitic elements, and they're calling this more moderate faction, Bronze Age Barry Weiss. So it's taking these kind of quasi-fascist feelings of Bronze Age pervert or, you know, these other guys, or kind of blending it into this thing where it's like, but also Israel's cool. So there's a lot of, there's a lot of tumble, even within the far right, and there's also just generally a lot of discontent with Trump. Yeah, yeah. No, that's so interesting. I wanted to talk a little bit as well on kind of the flip side of this whole story that you've written. I had an item in our morning shots newsletter this morning that was the more kind of buttoned up and already adult professionalized version of this fight, which is, which was something we're already starting to see in professional Washington right now, where a lot of the shine seems to have come off the Trump project faster than expected. Everybody knew there was going to be this big, factional post-Trump fight in 2028, where, you know, all of the Republicans who have been kind of rowing unwillingly in the same direction under the personal spell of Donald Trump's cult of personality that has organized the party for the last decade, then finally Trump was going to be gone, and they're going to finally have this knockdown drag out fight over whose preferred policy set is going to go forward under the next presidential nominee. And of course, on the one hand, it's the same as what you were talking about on the one hand here. It's the Vance heads. But as far as professional Washington is concerned, you know, insofar as the Nick Fuentes types are here already, they're not really calling the shots in DC yet, right? There are a lot of like 23 to 26-year-old junior staffers, junior members of various groups and things out here. So the big professional bite that's shaping up now is between Vance and the old heads, you know, it's like the old school professional Republicans, the guys who, the Heritage Foundation used to be the Reagan, you know, you mentioned Reagan before, the people who still are somewhat besotted with Ronald Reagan and still believe in his vision of fusionist politics. And they have seen an opportunity now as well in the wake of last week's catastrophe. We have Mike Pence, you know, Trump's first vice president, probably the most prominent Republican politician in this vein operating today. You could argue that guys like Rubio and DeSanis are a little bit this way, but Mike Pence is, you know, whole hog, Reaganite fusionist, he wrote not bad the day after the elections where he said the midterm election wasn't a route. It was a reckoning. And he said that the American people had rejected Trump's shift toward economic populism and that they didn't like the deficit spending and they didn't like the tariffs and that they didn't like, you know, the government seizing stakes in private companies and that the war in Iran hadn't gone far enough that we really should have gone in and finished the job. And this is a thing that, you know, the MAGA groups around here who are also looking forward with some trepidation to 2028, they, if they get everything the way exactly they want it, there will be an easy, seamless handoff from Trump to Vance and Vance will stick with them on the policy fights and that will, that will go fine, but they are worried and probably not without reason that that the handoff from Trump to Vance was always going to be a little rocky. Vance is not necessarily a really easy inheritor of the Trump coalition, especially the parts that weren't really organized around America first policy, but just were organized around Donald Trump and his personality. And now, you know, that now that the whole Trump thing is starting to implode, at least in certain respects with the electorate, that that handoff to Vance might be harder than ever. So we're seeing the organization of new groups, new, with quite a bit of money pouring in from some of these new right donors, to set up candidate recruitment and policy groups that are basically explicitly designed to, designed to squish the mic pinces of the world back into the box. You know, keep them, keep them in the pain shed. No, don't do it. Yeah. We're not going back. So, I don't know, like, I don't know if you pay much attention to that world, but it's weird that there's like this, this like parallel fight that's playing out, basically just everyone in the, anywhere you are in Republican politics, you have a lot of factional enemies in Republican politics right now, and you're in your feelings a lot processing all of that out on May. And it seems like. Yeah. I think that's right. I mean, I, obviously, the key group here is American Ascent, which is kind of the molding these. I feel like there's a lot of talk about, like, how can we take these, these proto-gruipers, these group chat trolls? How can we make them, you know, so they can go work at the Department of Labor or something? And put on a suit, boys, stuff like this. So, in this case, American Ascent is run by this guy named Ryan Newhouse, who got canned from the Heritage Foundation or quit after the whole flap with Heritage sticking with Tucker Carlson after his Nick Fuente's interview. So that's where this guy's coming from, because it was kind of his idea to stick with Tucker. I think you're right. Essentially, I guess the point here is the bad feelings are really high right now on the right. And there's this big fight from a lot of different directions about what is going to happen in 2028 and after. And Tom Trump is like kind of on the sidelines. I mean, he's touring the ballroom construction. He's talking about the Lincoln Memorial, all this stuff. You know, and this is a moment I personally, as an observer, and someone who prefers when things are interesting on the right than not, I've been waiting for it for a while, because for so long, you've had this kind of presidential hegemony. You've had this presidential hegemony. And you don't worry. I liked it the way you said it before, where you couldn't get that, like, you got a little bit off the reservation. You could get a little crazy, but if you went too far, Donald Trump would say, don't put this person on TV anymore or something like that. Whereas now, people don't care what Trump thinks. They're running wild and they're kind of doing their own pet projects and we'll see who succeeds. Yeah, yeah. And it's also, I mean, you brought up American Ascent, which was the group that I was alluding to a minute ago. And they are brand new, but I also feel like they kind of represent, they're like the second stage in the evolution of, you know, this very woolly online Trump era and Trump native right, aging into Republican politics, because you, we've already for years had groups like American moment, which was sort of a similar thing, right? And that was, you just got to Washington learn to put on a suit, learn to shower and like, go and network with people so we can put you to work at the Department of Labor, right? And like, that's kind of been an ongoing project, which had a lot of success because Trump got back into power and they had all these like shovel ready little mega heads who were ready to, you know, go off and join Doge or, you know, start doing, you know, anti-immigrant policy at DHS or whatever, right? And now, American Ascent is kind of the next thing where it's like, all right, now some of these kids are old enough, let's get them running for office, you know, let's get them, let's get them into some of these house races and really start to solidify as far as the whole electoral class is concerned, not just, not just sort of junior staff in the executive branch solidify some of this policy thought that has come up around Trump because it's like, oh no, Trump's going away a little faster and a little more explosively than we thought. We can't let, I mean, all these other guys are still sticking around, right? Like Mike Pence and his advancing American freedom, which is like this, this, basically this group of castoffs from heritage and places like this, but has money behind it. It's like, it's a real policy operation of its own accord and it might have, I mean, Mike Pence could run for president again for all we know, like these guys are still here, right? And they still have some base of support out there among the voters. And so like, we've got all this youth and we've got all this energy, but we can't just have them ready to do the grunt work jobs because if Trump's gone and Vance, you know, crashes and burns and somebody else who is more from the old school establishment wing manages to take power, it's not like these grippers can like do that much good or do that much, you know, what the grippers would consider good in that administration. So you're kind of sunk. And so it's like, it's weird to see this sort of like second, second tier of the evolution of these guys into politics in this way. As you said, there's this attempt to kind of mature the Trump movement, prepare it for this post-Trump world. You know, right now, I think electorally, you'd probably be better off with someone like Mike Pence, I think people are crying out for normal kind of a pre-Trump world. Unfortunately, the Republican Party has shackled the Donald Trump to a lesser extent JD Vance and look, the impulse among the people who make these decisions is clearly get weird. You know, get worse, make Stephen Miller the chief of staff and, you know, you have people saying, you know, if Democrats looking to oversight over the Trump administration. Maybe we'll criminally prosecute them. I mean, there seems to be really no interest in moderating. So, you know, ultimately, as you said, I mean, this could really all be decided much more in the presidential race than, you know, whether, you know, a certain great bird learns to comb his hair, take a shower once a week. Yeah, yeah. Well, we're going to keep following it. I guess it is sort of weird. We're going to, we're going to find out whether any of these guys, you know, clean up fast enough to get some American assent cash behind them to get into some house races, to get into Congress, to put their policy agenda in shape, or whether the entire, you know, the wheels will fall off the MAGA project too fast. You know, it'll be like the, you're watching movie 2012 where like it's like the car driving down the interstate and like the ground is just sort of like falling away behind them. You know, the collapse of MAGA may end up taking some of these people with it as it goes. We don't know. We're going to keep watching it. We're going to keep following it. And we'll let you know as it all happens. But thanks, Will, for coming on to talk about all of this. I mean, the fault lines are crazy. It's just, it's just going insane. It's bloody, it's getting bloody out there folks. And you know, this is what we're, we're all about watching here at the covering at the bulwark. Yep. And we'll keep doing it. So thanks everybody for watching. We hope you will subscribe to the feed and we will. See you all next time.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. College Republican chapters, particularly those affiliated with the Patriot Coalition and Nick Fuentes’ Gryper movement, are openly rejecting Donald Trump, calling for a more extremist and aggressive right-wing leadership.
  2. These youth-driven groups represent a generational shift in GOP ideology, moving away from Trump’s populist appeal toward more radical, racially charged, and anti-establishment policies.
  3. Internal divisions exist between two factions
  4. The decline of Trump’s coalition—especially among younger, moderate voters—is now evident, with even longtime supporters expressing fatigue from his policies and persona.
  5. Professional Republican circles are fracturing, with groups like American Ascent and Heritage Foundation allies forming policy networks to prepare future leaders and counter Trump’s influence.
  6. Key figures like Mike Pence and Ryan Newhouse are central to efforts to maintain a "Reagan-style" conservative establishment, viewing Trump’s defeat as a reckoning that demands policy normalization.
  7. The youth Republican movement is undergoing a transition from online activism to formal political careers, aiming to enter legislative offices and shape post-Trump governance.
  8. The GOP’s internal instability suggests a potential collapse of the MAGA project, with ideological extremism and factionalism threatening to undermine electoral viability and party cohesion.

Summary:

The Republican Party is experiencing deep internal fractures following the midterms, with a significant revolt among young college Republicans rejecting Donald Trump’s leadership. These groups, often linked to Nick Fuentes and the Gryper movement, are advocating for a more extreme, racially charged right-wing alternative, signaling a generational shift away from Trump’s populist appeal. Within this, two ideological factions have emerged: a more moderate, policy-focused Vance-oriented wing and a radical, explicitly antisemitic and racist faction.

At the same time, professional Republican networks are reorganizing, with groups like American Ascent and Heritage-aligned figures building policy infrastructure to prepare younger GOP operatives for post-Trump governance. Figures such as Mike Pence represent the establishment’s push for policy normalization and stability, contrasting with the growing radicalism of the youth wing. The collapse of Trump’s youth coalition—once a key electoral strength—has exposed deep discontent, leading to fears that the party may fracture further in 2028.

As younger Republicans transition from online activism to formal political roles, the GOP faces a pivotal moment: whether it can stabilize around a moderate, electable path or spiral into ideological extremism that undermines its long-term viability. The current chaos reflects a broader realignment, where trust in Trump’s leadership has eroded and a new, more volatile right-wing ecosystem is taking root.

FAQs

It's a newly formed coalition of college Republican chapters, including major universities, that has publicly criticized Donald Trump and called for a new right-wing leader. Its significance lies in representing a shift among young, politically active Republicans who feel Trump has become too weak or compromised.

Yes, the coalition is linked to Nick Fuentes and the 'Gryper' movement. The group's domain is owned by Fuentes, and some of its messaging and imagery are explicitly aligned with far-right, racially charged ideologies.

One is the 'Vance wing,' which supports more disciplined, extremist policies but avoids overt racism; the other is the 'Gryper wing,' which embraces explicit racism, antisemitism, and white nationalist ideas, often associated with Nick Fuentes.

After the midterm losses, younger Republicans—especially those who once supported Trump’s populist and anti-establishment message—are disillusioned by his policies, perceived lack of effectiveness, and the shift toward more extreme ideologies within the party.

Mike Pence represents the traditional, establishment wing of the GOP, advocating for fiscal responsibility and a return to pre-Trump policies. He sees the midterms as a reckoning and is positioning himself as a potential alternative to Trump’s style of leadership.

American Ascent is a new policy and recruitment group formed by former Heritage Foundation staff, aiming to transition young, online radical Republicans into formal political roles. It marks the next stage in the professionalization of the Trump-era right into mainstream Republican politics.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.