Go back

Young Dad Executed After Meeting 18-Year-Old on Dating App

45m 15s

Young Dad Executed After Meeting 18-Year-Old on Dating App

Adam Halair, a 27-year-old father and community favorite, was found murdered in his home with a single gunshot wound to the head, a detail that pointed to execution-style violence. Investigators discovered that a targeted robbery had taken place, with items like his TV, Xbox, hats, and a cherished necklace for his daughter stolen. The investigation centered on a woman, Haley, who had met Adam on Plenty of Fish and later admitted she was part of a scheme orchestrated by Evelyn Belmont to profit from his belongings. Evidence including cell phone data, the stolen items, and DNA from hats in Andre Warner’s car linked him to the crime. Despite Haley’s detailed testimony and corroborating digital footprints, Andre Warner was arrested and charged with first-degree murder, robbery, burglary, and conspiracy. The jury found him guilty on all counts, but the judge ultimately sentenced him to life in prison, rejecting the death penalty. Adam’s family, particularly his daughter, expressed deep grief and a desire for justice, emphasizing the personal impact of the tragedy. The case serves as a sobering reminder of the risks associated with online dating, urging caution, transparency, and vigilance when meeting strangers. Though the legal outcome did not result in the death penalty, the story underscores the emotional toll on victims’ families and the importance of protecting vulnerable individuals in the digital age.

Transcription

6879 Words, 36227 Characters

English
I was at work that night, I got over a hundred phone calls. I just didn't believe, I didn't know what that, what could have happened. When a beloved young father is found murdered inside of his own home, everyone is left wondering why. There were obvious signs that things had been taken. There was a TV missing, there was no Xbox. When you shoot and murder somebody execution style, you have a depraved heart. Don't quite know what type of person you are. You want to shoot either A, a cold hearted killer. Or you wrap up in something that's a lot bigger than you. [Music] I left him in a TV gun, the Xbox is gone, he's wearing a ticket. It was unperishable, it was dead. It was dead everywhere. [Music] Adam Halair's friend, John Hunn. He had been staying with Adam. John left to go out with his girlfriend and didn't return that night and went to work the next day. They always used the back door and when he got home from work, it was locked so he went around front and that's when he saw the front door open and he went inside the apartment. News of Adam Halair's death spreads quickly and it eventually reaches his family. Who by the way affectionately called the 27 year old booby. I heard like somebody beating on my door. My family friend came over saying that my brother was found murdered at his house. I don't remember what clothes I had on it. I just do on shoes and we flew all the way to his house. I just couldn't believe it. I was like, all right, well he's he's been to jump out the bushes and said, hey man, I got y'all. It was just a joke. It was a prank, you know, but it was real. When we first got there, it was me and my brother, Angel, we waited a little bit to my mom because we wanted to find out what was going on. So it was about a good hour or two before we even called my mom because nobody knew how to tell her. I was at work that night. When I looked on my phone, I got over 100 phone calls. I just felt like I had died. All I wanted to do was to get in there and just hold me up. I just brought him to know I was there. I just didn't believe, I didn't know what to think, what could have happened. Adam was found at the crime scene face down in the kitchen with what appeared to be a single gunshot wound to his head. There was a weapon recovered at the scene, but there was a 380 shell casing that was at the scene. They didn't see any signs of forced entry or anything indicating the lock was picked in any way to try to gain access to the residence. I looked like whatever happened, somebody was able to freely walk into the house. When you walked in, you could see there was a TV missing. There was no Xbox. Adam had a really large hat collection and the hats were missing. There was money taken from Adam and we also learned that there was a special necklace that he had for his daughter. It's a daddy's little girl. Things like that were very obvious to the investigators and allowed them to understand that this was a crime for a financial gain. Once Adam's body is removed from the scene, his family make sure they're there every step of the way. I stayed until they took his body. I wasn't going to leave. The police officer came and said that we could hire a cleanup crew to come and clean his apartment. Between my sons and his friends, they said no, we'll do it. They didn't want me to see all the blood it was in it because they went in first. It was very haunting. You can see the silhouette of his body, the blood everywhere and not knowing what exactly happened. I think that's kind of why we wanted to clean it so we can get some kind of information. When I went in, all I could do was just drop where he laid on the floor, tell him to please forgive me. I'm sorry I wasn't here to protect you. So I started cleaning up because he's my son. I do anything for my children, anything that's not going to discuss me. When the medical examiner conducted the autopsy, she determined that the cause and manner of death was a single gunshot wound and it was a homicide. The single gunshot wound entered his head from the rear and it would have been a trajectory downward, meaning where it exited from his face. It made it very clear that the person who shot him was above him in some way. When detectives hear those chilling details, one thought immediately comes to mind. This seems to be indicative of execution style. Coupled with how his body was found, face down. It almost looked like he had been put on his knees and then shot. What they're doing is just eliminating a witness to a crime. It is so senseless to do this. When you shoot and murder somebody execution style, you have a depraved heart and there was something going on there. I just couldn't picture anyone wanting to do that with him because of who it was. I couldn't fathom someone he would know doing that or what he was doing to elicit someone to do that. In any homicide investigation, the first thing that they're going to do is talk to family and friends. Two of the people that they interviewed were John Hunn, the friend that made the 911 call and then his friend Chris Rogers. Both of those men had seen Adam the night before and more importantly, they saw Adam with a young, Hispanic female. It's important because Chris Rogers told the investigators that the clothing that he was found in on his kitchen floor is the same clothing he was wearing the night before. So we're narrowing down the time frame in which the homicide occurred. Unfortunately, they couldn't provide a lot of information about her because that was the first time that Adam had been around that young, Hispanic female but they learned that she may have had a first name, Haley. Chris was with Adam when they dropped the young, Hispanic female off later that night. So they knew a general vicinity of where she was staying. But I don't think they had enough information at all at that juncture to determine whether she was involved. She was just somebody that they knew he had last been with. So they certainly wanted to talk to her. While detective search for the mysterious woman that Adam was last seen with, his family and friends gather to honor his memory. He literally was born by himself. I didn't even make it to deliver room. He came on his own. So from the beginning, he always had to show off. So he was going to be like, this is my world and I'm coming into it full force and that's the way he was. Anything he did, he just picked up on it faster than anybody and was very athletic. If it was back flipping, he learned the day of. If it was like a sport, it was always the lead role in it mainly. He started MMA first, but then he went and decided he wanted to do boxing. And he always would tell me, Ma, I'm going to become famous. I'm going to be the best boxer and I'm going to buy you the biggest house that I can give you. Everybody loved him. He just had that infectious personality. He was loving, caring, friendly. He always smiled with everybody. You could not just not look at him. To give you an idea about who Adam was, when he found out that he was going to be the father to a little girl, he was not only ready to take on that responsibility, he was so excited for what's ahead. He was the first one to have a baby. He loved his daughter. I mean, that was like his little sidekick. His daughter wasn't living with him full-time, but he did see her frequently. Every time you see him, you saw her. They would have even outfits, matching outfits, same color, same style. He said, this is my daughter. I'm going to take care of it. Nobody else is going to have to take care of her. I'm going to take care of her. That little girl, oh, that's his world. That was his life. As the investigation unfolds, detectives learn that Adam used a dating site called Plenty of Fish. I would describe Plenty of Fish as a easily accessible dating app. Anybody can join it. It would connect you with people in your direct vicinity so that they were more accessible to go on dates with. I was the one that showed him Plenty of Fish a couple years before. His reaction to it was he really liked it because it was this on your hand. You can meet people and you can talk to somebody and get to know somebody very fast because of the time between working and his daughter. That's easier and convenient for him. Now could that be how Adam met this unknown woman maybe? But investigators they need to find her and fast. The investigators with the information about where she been dropped off went to that area. It wasn't far from where Adam lived because they didn't have an exact apartment. They didn't know exactly what they were looking for so it really didn't get them anywhere until later. They get a tip from the Winter Haven Police Department. Winter Haven Police Department had gone out to a home completely unrelated to this homicide. They were looking for an individual named Haley Bustos who is a young Hispanic female. They wanted to talk to her in relation to another investigation they were conducting. As they're looking for this girl Haley, they see Haley in a white key and she takes off and she won't stop. So those police officers get with some of her family members and there's a younger male at the house who says well she just took off and fled from the police because she's driving that dead boy's car. Those were his words. Haley's cousin thought it was Adam's vehicle because they saw Haley and Adam together. They saw him driving that white car so they thought that that white car that she was driving on a day that the investigators confront her was Adam's car. Winter Haven knew that Auburndale was investigating a homicide and had not made any arrest so they reached out to Auburndale conveyed that information. They go back to the area where Chris Rogers say they dropped the young Hispanic female off because they're thinking well maybe she'll come back here and she did. With 18-year-old Haley accounted for investigators still need to find the car that she drove because that could be critical to their investigation. They see a white key and take off. They stop the car, she's not in there but there's a guiding Andre Warner who's driving that car. Andre Warner is a criminal. He's on probation. Andre Warner is a scary guy. They can see through the car windows that there are hats that are consistent with what we're missing from his house so that obviously peaked their interest. Andre tells investigators yeah I left this car to a girl he claims that he doesn't know this girl's name and she went out on a date and I was sleeping the whole night. They ask him about the hats there and he says those are not his. So it's looking like there are now two people who may have answers that detectives are looking for. Andre Warner and Haley Boostos, they start with Andre. He went on a date. Is that right? Does she say who she was going to wear? Is she saying that she's going to be the guy? Oh, she chose to do the rest of that. There was someone standing there that was going to get us the car and everything was good. I heard your car. How long was she gone on Thursday? How much of those? Your car and the property in there is not yours. It's a little bit less. So there's no global orbit. And we shoot that with your car with those hats and stuff in there. What we need to do is give you just process your car if it's potentially using this crime. You don't have a burger in this. I am. He said I had these stuff on there on Thursday. Was there anything else on that? That was there and it's not there now. Any electronics? TVs, air boxers, this game, something like that. Andre is minimizing his role, his involvement, his relationship, his friendship with this girl, Haley. He's literally distancing himself from everything. And when you start to avoid talking about people that you know, that's a red flag. Haley had a rough childhood. She's kind of bounced around from home to home. And so at this point, she's got really nowhere to live. So she moves in with his lady, Evelyn. She had just met Evelyn Balmont in the couple of days leading up to the homicide. Haley got introduced to Evelyn through a mutual friend named Josh Ellington, who had taken Haley over to Evelyn's apartment to hang out. It's there where she meets Gary Gray and Andre Warner. Gary Gray, they called him Crazy Cousin. And then Andre Warner was just in a quaint knits of Evelyn. Now when Haley is brought in for questioning, she does confirm that she met Adam on plenty of fish and that their first date, they went bowling. So what did Joe do on Thursday, you? Did he pick you up? Yeah, he picked me up. Was it just him with you? Yeah, the room went back to his house because his friend was there. Did you guys ever actually go bowling? Yeah, we went bowling. So when you guys left the bowling alley, where'd you go? I went back to his house till he had to give a dude a ride. I think he dropped me out. Well, I got home, I crashed, but I was so tired. He seemed to be really, really sweet, kind person. He used to focus. All right? All right. You know what I had him right? Do you know what happened, Adam? That's what I was asking for. Yeah, Adam's dead. I know that. He's all over the Facebook. All right. I'm going to jump right back into this, but anybody manage a business out there, own a business, run a business. Look, you don't need me to tell you that running a business is tough enough. The question I have is why make things harder doing things manually, relying on dozens of apps that don't talk to each other, right? That's where our sponsor, Odo, comes in. Because Odo is an all-in-one business management platform with a full suite of integrated apps that seamlessly connect all your operations, from sales and accounting to manufacturing, even shipping. Odo can automatically generate professional sleek-looking sales orders, invoices, vendor bills. It can automatically assign sales teams and email updates through each sales stage. Even use AI to pull reports that help with your decision-making. For manufacturing, their apps can sink inventory with real-time production and purchase updates, so you never run out of stock. And when it comes time for accounting, that's also fully automated. Odo can create invoices, track expenses, and even summarize data with AI to save you hundreds of hours. You know what the best part is? You can choose your apps and even build custom workflows, so it's all fully tailored to your business's needs. Take your business to the next level by consulting with an Odo expert today for free at odu.com/primecrime. If Adam's dead and working on the investigation, you need to start focusing here real quick. Tell me about the hands. Do you mind if I say, "Bring back me down"? No. So who's Kia is this? Kia is saying this all. Whoever is, whoever is, whoever is, whoever is running, that's his far. During the interview of Haley, a number of names get thrown out, referring to the same person, Drew and Dre. That happens in normal conversations in neighborhoods. People are known by other names other than their given name. There's nicknames. So it's up to detectives to just put two and two together and figure out who she's actually speaking about. Detectives quickly connect the dots. Drew is actually Dre, 26-year-old Andre Warner. Drew said these apps came from you. Because earlier you said they had been in his car. So how did they get in his car? You're the one who, uh, I don't know. I don't want to, yeah, I don't want to talk to you in the problem. So you bother our new boss. Okay, how'd you do a follow-up? I think he was a gentleman. Well, gentlemen Adam is dead. And he'll never pay for anybody else to follow in the rest of his life. Don't you think I know that? It hurts. It was a great person. I'm going to have to be honest with you. I don't believe what you're saying. So here's what I'm thinking. I don't quite know what type of person you are. So can you look at him please? You want to have two people. You use your A, a cold-hearted killer. Or you're wrapped up in something that's a lot bigger than you. And you don't know what to do at this point. Now, I personally do not think you're in a cold-hearted killer. These hats were from Adam. Okay, so once you take a deep breath, rethink this and this goes through this. We want the person that killed him. Do you understand? I don't know what they can do. Initially, Haley is not being forthcoming. And that is very typical in any interview. Especially when the stakes are that high. There's no higher stakes in murder. time went on. She did start telling what we believed to be the truth. And despite this appearance of, you know, being strong and independent, I mean, we were talking about a kid. And the fear of any kind of retribution, once Haley started talking, she just told the whole story. Haley finally comes clean. This wasn't a date gone wrong. It was a setup, and it all started. With Evelyn Belmont. She admits that Evelyn is frustrated that all these people are living at her house are kind of free-loading. And she wants money. So she says, "Hey, this is what you have to do." She gives her the idea of going on plenty of fish. Get on these dating apps and either do things with men to get money or scope out what the men may have. Evelyn helped her create the plenty of fish account that Haley ultimately ended up using. She tells the detectives that when she was dropped off from her date, Evelyn Belmont and Andre Warner, they're being persistent on her telling them what she saw in Adam's apartment. She ultimately tells them that she saw, she had cash in his wallet. She saw that he had a game system. They take Andre's car back to Adam's location in his residence. They all get in the car because Haley has the point out where Adam lives. Josh gets in the vehicle. He's going to be the getaway driver. Andre and Gary get in the vehicle and they drive to the location. Haley makes one thing clear. Once they all arrive, it's only Gary and Andre who exit the vehicle and enter Adam's apartment. When you guys got there and you guys parked what happened? Walk me through it. Do you have a bottle of the car? Do you have a gun? Who had the gun? Don't know which one. I don't think I know. Do you have a puff? Do you think they both walk up to the front of it? He actually opened the door. That's how they got in. Then one of them came back to the car. Who came back from the car? Cranko. He was like, "Jargo, wait up until the front of the house." They were bringing us to them. What did they bring out? Two or three thoughts for them. What else did they bring out? They spoke, what games had. So after they loaded that stuff, what happened? We took off and they were loud about that it was funny and it was amazing man. 'Cause he was begging for his life. That's what they were telling you when they came back. You have to be extremely cold-hearted to be in front of somebody who is begging for their lives and still execute them. And then to find that amusing, particularly with Andre Warner, he had a young child similar in age to Adam's daughter. I've been taken. I'm not some jewelry. Was there any jewelry that they took? So where is any of the stuff floating that we can find? 30 sold, it's not mine. So how do these hats get into the vehicle? They put them in the shoes. They just do that. They cut them his own head spot. So this stuff is just true. Andre got the cash. He got the hats. Gary and Hailey, they kept the Xbox and the gold chain, which they sold to Gary's sister. So they got a little bit of cash. Josh Ellington got nothing. We know the group stole televisions. The problem was, as they're putting the televisions inside of the vehicle, they damaged the televisions. So they had to throw the TVs out. Nobody was going to buy those TVs. What did you think they was going to do when you're out there? Just get rid of, take the little bit of cash. You didn't get anything. I mean, at this point, if you did, it just, I mean, it makes sense that you did get something. Did you ever get out of the car and go back up to the apartment? No, I already got one. She didn't want to go back in that house, because I already told you I know what they're capable of. I know. They know people really don't care what I don't know. Okay. It's going to be, it's going to be just like him. Nobody's going to kill you. Okay. What happened? That's what happened. Do you not know that? I was listening to you not knowing people who get it with these things. Well, you're, if you want to. They took it and it's too high for an hour, isn't it? Well, so I can see you being worried about it. We're not going to let nobody get you, but you need to tell us. You need to tell us the truth. It's your son. And how do you know it's your son? He said that he could have wanted to be in the kitchen, crash my hands, because I didn't know if he was hurt or if he was a kid. And then they lied to me, and they said that they got him in his car, because they wouldn't tell me that. And why did Drew shoot him? Because they went in bare face. Also, they didn't use that cover up when? Well, why didn't they cover up? Maybe I don't could at least live through this. Though detectives now have Haley's confession, they still need to corroborate her story. Detectives start executing search warrants. The detectives go to Gary's sister's house. They locate some of the stolen items, and one of the items that they located was a necklace with a charm on it that said daddy's little girl. The hats found in the back seat of Andre's car. They sent them off for DNA testing, and those hats had atoms DNA on it. During the course of the robbery, they take Adam's phone, but as they're driving away from the scene, one of them has a thought of a tracker on the phone, so they throw it out of the car window. Haley's interview led them to an area where they had to search for the phone, but did recover it. The detectives were never able to recover a firearm. Andre had gotten rid of the gun. Andre Warner is arrested, and when he's brought back in for questioning, his attitude is noticeably different. Josh Ellington and Gary Gray are tracked down to, and even though they deny involvement, the evidence tells a different story. Everybody leaves a digital footprint. It is so much easier to solve crime these days, and in this case, the digital footprint was strong. All their cell phone data were all at the same location at the same time. These guys were together before, during, and after the crime. All four of them were charged with first-degree murder. They were all charged with robbery, with a firearm. They were all charged with burglary while armed. In Florida, you are able to charge the individuals involved in a crime where somebody is murdered, even though they may not have been the one that did the actual killing. I just couldn't believe that many people to come at him that way, because he would have gave him everything. He begged him, begged him, begged. They should have just, no, took what they wanted and just left him alone. Because at the end of the day, I know, I know. He would have let it go. To be there for his daughter, he would have let it go. The state already has enough to arrest Andre Warner, but that doesn't mean the investigation is over. No, there is a jailhouse phone call that emerges between Andre and his grandfather, and that just cements the prosecution's case against him. His grandfather was telling them that the grand jury proceedings were happening and that he had been told by one of the grand jury witnesses that the prosecutor was showing the grand jurors a picture of Andre's hand with gunshot residue on it. It was not true, but that's what his grandfather was telling him. He's not confessing to firing a gun, but hey, tell me you shot a gun without telling me you shot a gun. Our office decided to pursue the death penalty because of the consistency in his actions leading up to the homicide and the homicide itself. We knew that he was a violent person, capable of committing violent acts. - As Andre Warner's trial approaches, Adam's family remains determined to seek justice for Adam. - My mom, she would come off of work and go straight to court but no sleep. I mean, my mom was actively involved in the trial. Every single one of those proceedings, my mom did not miss a day. I wanted to make sure everybody knew that he was a human being and I wanted justice for him. If I wasn't there, then who gonna care about him? - Adam Hilar was 27 years of age when he was executed. On occasion four, he was forced to his knees at gunpoint by his assailants. All while he was begging them for his life for the sake of his five-year-old daughter. Adam lost his life or an Xbox, some games, a little bit of cash that he had in his wallet, a gold charm bracelet, and a gold necklace that he had for his little girl that had a charm on it that said daddy's little girl. Andre Warner, this defendant, shot Adam, and the reason why, is because he chose to go into Adam Hilar's apartment without a cover on his face. - Talked to Ivan, the Haley Bruce Dez. Haley Bruce Dez said this, Haley Bruce Dez said this, Haley Bruce Dez said this, Haley Bruce Dez. It's based on Haley Bruce Dez. Mr. Warner had nothing to do with that. - The defense was just point the finger to somebody else. We knew that that was gonna be their strategy. That is a common strategy when you have a case where there's multiple, you know, code events involved. - The defense is ready to challenge Haley's credibility. And both sides know that her testimony could either make or break the case. - Was there any conversation in the car after you left Adam's apartment? - They were laughing. What were they laughing about? Haley was begging for his life. - Mr. Warner, making these statements. Yes. - By cooperating with the prosecution, by testifying today, you're hoping that you don't have to spend the rest of your life in prison, correct? - That's not what I'm here for. - I'm just here out of the goodness of your heart. Is that what you're saying? - Yes. - But you also agreed to fully cooperate with the state, correct? - Yes. - And if they feel that what you're doing rises to the level of substantial assistance that could assist you in getting a better deal, right? - Yeah, I don't know. - Yeah, I can't hear you. Let's shout it out. Yeah, it'll help you get a better deal, right? Yes, I'm safe. I couldn't hear you. I want to hear you say yes 'cause that's the truth, right? Do you want to get a better deal? - I really don't care if I spend the rest of my life in prison, along with he's behind bars too. - I had it for giver. She did not hide anything. She never, never, never once. Change her story. She was willing to take responsibility. And everybody else was trying to find a way to get out of it. - And when it's time for the defense to present its case, Andre Warner decides to take the stand. - On the night that Haley Boostos went out on this date through plenty of fish, was that anything that you really even for paying that much attention to? - No, sir, everybody has it, so it's just some of my damn pay attention to it. - Did Haley talk to you about barring your car? - Yes, she did. - When did you first notice the hats in the car? - Around the time I left around seven o'clock that morning, that's when I noticed them. - When you got back to jasking me about the hats? - Yes, I asked him. I asked Haley, which is the person that asked to use my car. I asked the way they come from. - Then what did Haley tell you? - She told me that she met some dude that had a box of hats that was sent to hats and she ended up buying them. - Did information start kind of delight about something going on with the guy that Haley had gone on the date with? - Yes, there was. - You were just kind of piecing things together that something had gone on and you're trying to figure this out loud. - Yes, sir. - Every case is different as to what your approaches on cross-examination. In this case, I really just wanted to kind of hit the high notes and quickly get out of there. - Now, Mr. Warner, you have the biggest motive in the outcome of this case, isn't that right? 'Cause your life is literally on the line. Mr. Warner, when you were first pulled over, you told Lord Horseman that you didn't know Haley's name didn't you? - Yes, I did. A girl that you hung out with? - Yes. - On a daily basis? - Yes. - But you didn't know her name? - No, I did not know her name. I don't ask names. - No beef between the two of you? - No, no beef at all. - Okay. - You didn't know Josh Ellington either. No beef with him? - No, I had no beef with anybody there. - You had no beef with Gary? - No, I did not. - And according to you, these are people that you got along with. - Yes, I do. - No reason for them to tell anybody that you're the one responsible for Adam's murder. Right? - That's what I thought. - Now Mr. Warner, you have the biggest motive in this, in the outcome of this case, isn't that right? - Well, I could have had it so I also had the choice to sit back and not come on the stand and say anything, at all. - Yes or no? - You could say that. - Thank you. (upbeat music) - You cannot have a murder in hell with angels as your witness is. And as a result, the witnesses that are available are the people that are involved in the crime. I can't stress this enough. Everything that Hailey told you is corroborated by something else. We know that Andre Warner armed himself when he went into Adam's apartment. He knew that he was going in bare-faced. He knew Adam would be able to identify him. So what was the last thing he did before he left Adam's apartment? As he was on his knees begging for his life, he put that gun to the back of his head. A place that he knew would end his life. Do you have any reasonable doubt in your minds that Andre Warner is not the person responsible, I'm confident that based on the evidence, the answer to that question is no. - Two sides to every story, right? And oftentimes when you only hear one side of the story, you can be misled into the wrong conclusion. - We've got people who are minimizing their role in the crime. - What is common sense telling it is the best way to minimize your role when you know the police're on to you, if you want to minimize your involvement. You find a escape if you follow the law. You'll be in a position to make the right verdict. - They came back with a verdict that same day. - We, the jury, find as follows as to count one. The defendant is guilty of first degree murder of Adam, C. Hillair, as to count to guilty of robbery, as to count number three, guilty of criminal conspiracy, as to count number four, guilty of burglary. - Tell me what you were thinking when the jury came back with that verdict. - When it came back, we're all four charges guilty. I said, "Oh God." - Tell me what this means to get justice for your son. - Not just movie, that's what birthday gift. She just turned nine years old Monday and look what she gives for her birthday gift. Finally, finally she get justice. - In Florida, death penalty case unfolds in two phases. First, the jury has to decide guilt. And if the defendant is convicted, then the jury has to determine what the appropriate penalty should be. - During the guilt phase, the state is able to present evidence that proves that the defendant is the one responsible for the crime that they're charged with. The penalty phase has the ability to introduce aggravating circumstances that they believe warrants the jury imposing the death penalty. - And just as they're about to enter the penalty phase, everything suddenly stops. - We started the guilt phase in March of 2020, which is when everything shut down because of COVID. Picking a death qualified jury is very time consuming. After Andre Warner was found guilty, the judge put the case on hold, which makes it difficult because we can't bring the same jury back together some time in the future. We have to pick a whole nother jury. So we ended up doing that. a year later for the penalty phase. - And finally, five excruciating years after Adam's murder, his loved ones get the chance to say their peace. - When I hear victim-impact statements, that is a very hard day for me. It really gives the jury a sense of what it is, the friends and family and community lost. - Adam was better known by the family and friends of his booty. I pray no one has to go through what I suffered as a mother by losing my son, Booby. I was supposed to leave this world before my child. Everyone in our family, friends, anyone who knew Booby, all are hurting for his loss. Most of all, his baby girl is hurting the worst. He would never be able to see right away from school. Walk her down the aisle. When she gets married, he was taken away when he was just starting his life. - Here, my mom gave her impact statement. It really broke me down to a point where it was hard for me to read all the other ones 'cause I had to read maybe 30 or 40 impact statements. - Just like the Guild phase, the jury reaches their verdict that exact same day. - State of Florida versus Andre, Maurice Warner, we, the jury, unanimously find that Andre, Maurice Warner, should be sentenced to death. - To be honest, which I feel sad, because when you look at it, I lost my son. And here's someone else, you know, where jury asked for him to have the death penalty. Two lives, you know, gone like that for nothing. And I felt so sorry for his mother 'cause she had no fault in what happened. - But the jury's verdict is only a recommendation. - In Florida, the judge has the discretion to override their recommendation, which is what happened in this case. So the judge can consider the same evidence, the aggravating factors in the midi-gang circumstances. And in this case, the judge did that and sentenced Andre Warner to life in prison, despite what the jury had come back with. He just did not feel like the facts itself weren't at the death penalty. - I was really hoping for the death penalty 'cause you take somebody, you gotta pay for that. But when they decide to switch it to life, I totally understood the situation because if we would have got the death penalty every so many years, he can appeal it. Having my mom or our family go back through that again, I was like, you know, he's never getting out again. - For Boobie's family, learning to move on without him remains a daily struggle. - As time goes on, it gets harder, harder, so they're forgiven, slips away. And you see his daughter become a woman, what I heard that. We being a father of girls, knowing how important that is. It slips away a little bit here and there, but I gotta pull myself back together. - I forgive all of them because it's not for me, you know, to hold anything of hatred. Hatred is not gonna bring him back. And I know that at the end of the day, if Boobie was alive, he would have forgave him. - It's hard talking about him whenever I go into my closet, his jersey is right there and his hats right there. We try to do our best to keep Boobie's memory alive as much as we can, especially on anniversaries of the incident and his birthdays. Because of what happened to him, maybe some more lives can be saved. It's unfortunate that he had to die for it, but there is a plan to everything. - I think 99% of dating apps, you're gonna be fine, but you still have to be careful. You don't know who you're meeting up with. Tell somebody who you're going with. - Meet in public places. Don't pick them up somewhere, don't have them, know where you live. Don't drive them home. The relationships gets more established down the line. You have to protect yourself when you're meeting strangers because you don't know until that relationship gets more solid if you can trust this person. - I just wish that a lot of people could have got a chance to really get to know him more 'cause they would have realized that he was something special. The love he had for me, I want everybody to learn to love like he loved. If he wouldn't have stopped this, we don't know how many more people would have died. Boobie's a hero. (gentle music)

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Adam Halair, a 27-year-old father, was found murdered in his home with a single gunshot wound to the head, indicating execution-style violence that suggests a motive rooted in financial gain.
  2. Investigators discovered missing items including a TV, Xbox, and his collection of hats, leading them to believe the crime was a targeted robbery rather than a random act.
  3. A key clue emerged when a young Hispanic woman, Haley, admitted she met Adam on Plenty of Fish and that their date ended with a planned robbery, which was orchestrated by Evelyn Belmont and her associates.
  4. Andre Warner, a man on probation, was identified as the primary perpetrator after his car was found with Adam’s hats, and his inconsistent statements and attempts to minimize involvement raised red flags.
  5. Haley’s detailed confession, corroborated by digital evidence and physical items like the “daddy’s little girl” necklace and stolen electronics, confirmed the robbery and murder.
  6. Despite the jury’s unanimous guilty verdict on multiple charges, the judge sentenced Andre Warner to life in prison, rejecting the death penalty due to lack of sufficient aggravating factors.
  7. Adam’s family, especially his daughter, remained deeply affected, emphasizing the personal and emotional toll of the loss and the importance of honoring his memory.
  8. The case underscores the dangers of online dating, highlighting the need for caution, public meeting places, and transparency when forming new relationships with strangers.

Summary:

Adam Halair, a 27-year-old father and community favorite, was found murdered in his home with a single gunshot wound to the head, a detail that pointed to execution-style violence. Investigators discovered that a targeted robbery had taken place, with items like his TV, Xbox, hats, and a cherished necklace for his daughter stolen. The investigation centered on a woman, Haley, who had met Adam on Plenty of Fish and later admitted she was part of a scheme orchestrated by Evelyn Belmont to profit from his belongings.

Evidence including cell phone data, the stolen items, and DNA from hats in Andre Warner’s car linked him to the crime. Despite Haley’s detailed testimony and corroborating digital footprints, Andre Warner was arrested and charged with first-degree murder, robbery, burglary, and conspiracy. The jury found him guilty on all counts, but the judge ultimately sentenced him to life in prison, rejecting the death penalty.

Adam’s family, particularly his daughter, expressed deep grief and a desire for justice, emphasizing the personal impact of the tragedy. The case serves as a sobering reminder of the risks associated with online dating, urging caution, transparency, and vigilance when meeting strangers. Though the legal outcome did not result in the death penalty, the story underscores the emotional toll on victims’ families and the importance of protecting vulnerable individuals in the digital age.

FAQs

Key signs included missing items like the TV, Xbox, and hats, along with stolen cash and a special necklace for his daughter. These items were taken for financial gain, indicating a planned robbery rather than a random attack.

The woman was Haley Bustos, a 18-year-old Hispanic female. She met Adam on Plenty of Fish, and investigators found evidence that she was part of a scheme with others to rob him and take his belongings.

Detectors identified suspects through cell phone data showing all four individuals were present at the same locations before, during, and after the crime. Additional evidence included stolen items and Haley's confession.

Haley Bustos admitted she met Adam on Plenty of Fish and went on a date with him. She confessed that she was part of a group that robbed Adam's apartment and that she helped plan the crime with Evelyn Belmont and others.

Yes, Andre Warner was identified as the person who shot Adam. Evidence included his presence at the scene, the discovery of Adam's body with a gun in a position indicating execution, and DNA matching on the stolen hats.

The murder was described as execution style because Adam was shot from behind with a downward trajectory, and he was found begging for his life. This suggests a cold, calculated motive, possibly driven by greed or personal gain.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.