Go back

You Have Chosen | Was it Real? The Hills Rewatch Podcast

38m 52s

You Have Chosen | Was it Real? The Hills Rewatch Podcast

The podcast analyzes season two, episode six of *Laguna Beach*, titled "You Have Chosen," focusing on the deteriorating friendship between Spencer and Heidi and their friend Lauren. Lauren's strong disapproval of Spencer leads to confrontations, including a heated exchange where she refuses to engage with him, which strains their friendship and fuels tension. Heidi, trying to maintain loyalty, confides in Spencer about Lauren’s disapproval, leading to further conflict and a breakdown of trust. The episode underscores the reality show’s tendency to dramatize personal conflicts, where characters are pressured to reveal every emotion and judgment, unlike real-life interactions, which often involve subtle distance or silence. The rose incident, where Heidi gives roses to Lauren thinking they were from Spencer, backfires and deepens the rift, showing how miscommunication damages trust. The dynamic shifts as Heidi spends more time with Spencer, isolating her from Lauren, who feels betrayed and increasingly resentful. The episode reflects on the importance of emotional boundaries, mutual respect, and the avoidance of forced "either-or" choices in relationships. Ultimately, despite the drama, the bond between Spencer and Heidi remains strong, highlighting their genuine connection. The analysis also touches on how the show’s production style exaggerates conflicts, making it seem like every relationship is at war, when real life involves more nuance, patience, and personal growth. The discussion concludes with appreciation for the characters’ journeys and the emotional depth behind the surface-level drama.

Transcription

7663 Words, 38526 Characters

English
Hey Prime members, you can listen to Was It Real? The Hills Rewatch ad-free on Amazon Music. Download the Amazon Music app today. Welcome back to Was It Real? The Hills Rewatch podcast. I'm Brody Jenner here with my co-host, Adrena Patridge, and Frankie Delgado is here as well. Frankie, how you doing? Today, we're going to be breaking down season two, episode six, You Have Chosen. All right, let's get into it. Okay, well, the drama is more drama. The drama is really building now with Spencer and Heidi's relationship with her friends. I feel like this is where her friendships really start to change, and you see that in the episodes. And Heidi is struggling, wanting her friends to accept Spencer and Spencer to accept her friends. And she wants everyone to be together, but everybody's so protective over her that it makes it hard. Yeah, I think it's really cool to see that everybody's trying to make it work, but with their own intentions. But at the end of the day, that's not how life works. Yeah. Like, life's not about, like, there's no choosing. There's no, like, I'm going to take this side or that side. There's no, like, listen, if there's something that really, like, can affect, like, where you're like, you could do this to me. I need to walk away from you, too, because of what you did. But they're also, yeah, there shouldn't be judging. It's young stuff about judging boyfriends and girlfriends and how it's each, each, each, it's each's life. It's your life. It's your life. Do whatever you got to do. And if you're happy, I'm happy for you. I can. I don't have to be verbally saying, like, hey, I want to stay away from, from you and from you. But, you know, as we all know, when you're on a reality show, you have to talk about every feeling. You have to talk about every scene, every feeling. And we're in normal life. You wouldn't always say that. But as a fan of the show, I'm watching, you know, at home and I'm like, well, I would have not even said that. I was just like, oh, I don't feel well. I have a headache or I have plans with my other friend today. Like, I can't make it. Like, I would just not like be so blunt about how things are. But because you are on a reality show, we have to understand that they have to mention everything and why and how and who and who bothers you and why you don't like them. So it is pushed to make drama. Yeah. And that's in this episode, the very first scene. It starts off with Lauren telling Heidi exactly what she thinks about Spencer and how he's basically going to screw her over. And she'll be there for her when it happens. I just I don't want to talk about him anymore. I don't want to hear about him. And I just I don't I'm never going to hang out with him. So, you know, if it's like if it's going to come between us and if you're going to like be mad at me and not be able to be around me, then it's like, you know what? I've put in my two cents and you know how I feel. I'm going to be there for you when he screws you over. Because he will. And I think it kind of sets Heidi back because she kind of feels like you think that's going to happen, like she's giving him another chance. But Lauren's not on board. So that kind of starts the tension starts there. It's pretty ironic now to see Heidi and Spencer still together. It's still like from, you know, it's wild to see as strong as could be, you know, even there was never no fucking over each other. You know what I mean? Like they kept they kept it real. They really did love each other. They really did mean it when they said it to each other. And then and they're still around with two beautiful kids. So I think that's like with any friendship or relationship, if you want to make things work. Like there's going to be ups and downs and hard conversations. And I mean, Heidi, she went through it. We all saw it, but they still they stuck it out. And I feel like Lauren and her could have stuck it out, too. But have you ever been with a friend, though, that you don't necessarily you're not you don't love their or, you know, their significant other? You don't you don't have to like them, but you just sort of tolerate them and sort of hang out with them and do things with them and keep it very just surface. Yeah, I feel like a hundred percent. I've done that so many times with like friends, really close friends of my girlfriends or boyfriends or whatever. And you just sort of tolerate them. And even if you don't like them, you just for them, you tolerate them and you're as nice as you could possibly be. I feel like Lauren, you know, didn't really try to do that. I feel like and then when she did try that one little conversation they had, it didn't seem to go very well between the two of them. Clearly, she had her feelings about Spencer and she's entitled to that. But sometimes for your best friend, you just have to suck it up. Yeah, just sort of hang around them and you don't have to be best friends with them, but kind of just say, like, if you don't want to be around them, then there's a way for you to just stay away from them without like making it so dramatic, dramatic, like having to choose a side. You should never have to choose like and that's even with my past relationships. I never made our friends choose me or him. It's like you make your choice. Which one are we talking about? Who are we talking about? Ex-husband. So it's like I, you know, it's it is what it is. So I'm not going to make you choose, but I will be very careful what you say and how much of yourself you give the person. I want to give to that person. You can just like be like skate around it and just not have to like make people feel uncomfortable about like who they're going to want to hang out with. And I think that that's the number one thing that I a lot of my relationships with everybody I have all my friends. I never and I don't want to ever have to be like it's either him or me. Like if you want to be friends with someone that I don't really like, it's all good. Yeah, I just number one. Yes, I will be careful with what I say. Take a step back and distance yourself a little bit, but you don't have to cut them out of your life or make them feel like they're making the wrong decision. It's their lesson to learn. The fact that Heidi can't talk to her about anything involving Spencer because Lauren doesn't like him so much. Sort of that severs their friendship limits the thing, which is tough. You know, if you're in a relationship with somebody, you want to be able to at least talk a little bit about them with the person or hang out or at least hang out with them. And so this episode was. Aired what in February 19th in 2007, by the way. Oh, my God, that's a long time ago. Gosh, the next scene in this episode, then Heidi, after she talks with Lauren, goes and meets with Spencer and Spencer gives her roses at lunch. And then obviously with your boyfriend, you tell them what's going on. They become your best friend. So she confides in Spencer about, you know, what Lauren has said and how she feels about them. And I think. I think that later comes out and Lauren doesn't like that because it's kind of like girl code. Like, you shouldn't tell him everything I tell you. It's true. Yeah. I mean, if let's just say, like, somebody tells me, like, I don't like Brody. I'm not going to go and instigate and say, hey, Brody, by the way. So and so said. Even though that's my best friend, I'm going to defend him when he's not around and say, hey, dude, honestly, don't talk about my boy like that. I don't need you to be saying that. That's my boy. Yeah. So if you don't feel that way, like, keep it to yourself. But that's my boy. But I'm not going to go tell. Brody, Brody, by the way, this guy's talking all this because that's going to create a fight that I don't know what we're. I think that's one of the problems, too, in this episode. Well, and Heidi can probably pick up on this when she comes back in. But it's like I think that caused ruckus or whatever between Lauren and Spencer because it's like, well, she said this. Well, he said this. No, I don't like her. It's more of a conflict. Yeah. Or it's better just to not say that and let them figure it out because things change over time. For sure. Especially as the more. They grow and you see that Spencer started to really take the relationship serious. You know, I think that there was a point where that relationship definitely switched. I think Heidi and Spencer in the beginning were both kind of little players. She says it. She admits it. She always is like, yo, I'm a player. I was a player, too. Like, I don't know why Lauren was being so protective of me where I was doing my own thing, too. Right. And then you can see definitely when that. The shift happened. The shift. Right. Yeah. And then I'm sure maybe Lauren, I think maybe the relationship was too tainted at that point between Lauren. Spencer. But I think that it could have shifted had Lauren seen how much Spencer cared about her and wasn't just trying to be a player and trying to, you know, be more serious. Yeah. I agree with that. Heidi comes back home to Lauren and like gives Lauren the roses, like thinking that Spencer gave those roses to give to Lauren. And Lauren's like, oh, is he going to give more to Audrina, too, or whatever? So Heidi was trying to be funny about that. But Lauren didn't know. She really thought those were from Spencer. Lauren didn't like that too much, did she? She did not like that. She ran and hid in the room. That just gave him another telly. Like, what next? I know. But like I said, it's like you're rubbing it in as well, though. Like, at that point, don't poke the bear. Yeah. Right. That was kind of poking the bear, I will say. That was. Heidi, we need. Where are you going to be, Heidi? But then if they knew off camera about the roses, like, it would be funny, like, outside of the camera. But I don't know what they did at that point. Right. The rose thing was just out of context. The rose thing. We got to get him on this show. Do you still have that rose, Adrena? You still have the rose? It's probably still at Pinkberry. Yeah, it's probably still at Pinkberry. I don't know. Oh, gosh. You kept it forever. Well, then Heidi goes to pack for overnight. She's going back to Spencer's. And I think this is when Lauren is like, well, you're always gone. You're always with Spencer. It's like Lauren gets mad because she misses Heidi and misses that friendship. So I think it's just changed. She's not liking. Yeah, she's not liking. the change between them too they're yeah they're dynamic he's like yo it was you she says this at some point in the episode she says like every day used to be hiding in lauren day lauren day you know what i mean and now it's not now it's just like we have to like schedule a meeting to like for us to have did but that's life yeah that's how the world works like like once you meet someone like i like when when i met jen it was like there was no more like hey let's go get it like nah i'm hanging with my girl yeah can my girl come right you know what i mean it was like and it makes it easier when your girl is really lovable like and it makes it easier if like you you're dating someone or they're dating someone else to do the double date thing but if you're a third wheel all the time it's like not that's so true but even if you're the third wheel sometimes i think that it's the person like if the person if you can talk about anything with the like all my boys say whatever they want around her and she just laughs you can also be the third wheel and be okay being the third wheel and yeah like i don't think there's any awkwardness like when we go to like dinners with like i know before jen you were always the third wheel frankie with you before jen i was the third wheel oh my god i was the pre remember that movie i do oh my gosh after heidi leaves and lauren just kind of comes over i invite her over for lasagna and i was kind of shocked that heidi was giving him another chance because i didn't know what was really going on on the back side of things that this was for the show and like to amp up whatever i thought that he was really like playing her so i in my defense i was kind of like why why is she getting back with him right you know and then when lauren would tell me these things i was like i just can't believe it how was that lasagna by the way it looked really good did you guys really make lasagna i did me and my mom really did it was great yeah you'll see later it's like she comes over to cook in my kitchen with me all the time that was our like talking moment of cooking us huh i know we didn't get the invite to those those are the fun ones let us say gosh yeah i could get it just frankie and i could have been on the couch yeah you know waiting for the lasagna is it a meat sauce lasagna yeah yes way to my heart oh i'll bring lasagna next time guys but that's when you really see that lauren is really starting to get annoyed with spencer and like the dynamic of everything but did you feel like you were like the mediator between the whole street did you feel like you had to be that person now at that point i was so on the outside of it that i would film and hear about it and just be like i'd believe what i was being told like oh my gosh what and i i wasn't really talking to heidi at that point because she was always with spencer so and i think with what happened with spencer and i it would be weird if we all hung out or i don't know i know everything just changed the roses yeah so i've started you kept your distance yeah kept my distance and just kind of hung out with lauren because and i don't know in real life or on the show but she was always kind of alone or like you know while most children's vitamins are filled with five grams of sugar and can contribute to a variety of health issues hyaluronic acid is made with zero sugar and zero gummy junk yet it tastes great and it's perfect for picky eaters see my kids are such picky eaters you know and they love their sugar but i'm trying to take take them away from all the sugar because uh diabetes does run in my family for me this is the perfect vitamin the perfect thing the perfect little treat for them because they think it's actually it's actually really good i tasted it and i love my sugar too as brody knows do you eat them too frankie yeah frankie steals their treats for me they're vitamins for them well haya fills in the most common gaps in modern children's diets to provide the full body nourishment our kids need with a yummy taste they love formulated with the help of nutritional experts haya is pressed with a blend of 12 organic fruits and veggies then supercharged with 15 essential vitamins and minerals including vitamin d b12 and many others to help support immunity energy brain function mood concentration teeth bones and more now same with kira frankie like she loves sugar but i try to keep her away from sugar because she gets too hyper but um it's been really hard for us to find a vitamin that she actually likes so these she wants to eat like candy yeah so we've worked out a special deal with haya for the best-selling children's vitamin receive 50 off your first order and to claim this deal you must go to haya health.com slash hills this deal is not available on their regular website go to y-y-a-h-e-a-l-t-h.com slash hills and get your kids the full body nourishment they need to grow into healthy adults your dog knows everything about you should you know your dog better my dog shuey is i mean he knows everything about me just and i just always think where did he come from what's i know he's a puggle and i know he's a beagle mix but i just want to see like his siblings i want to know where his background i would love to know more about him and i just and that's why we're so excited to talk about our partner embark vet the provider of the highest rated dog dna tests on the market and right up top we'd like to thank embark vet.com for supporting was it real go to embark vet.com to get free shipping and save forty dollars with promo code hills yes so brody i actually texted you about my new puppy because i think he's a rottweiler husky mix maybe shepherd but i'm so excited to use embark to actually find out what his breed is especially you know to see if he has any health issues that i need to anticipate or anything health issues i like that and bark is an incredible tool for dog owners that screens for more than 230 genetic health risks across 350 breeds that's more breeds tested than any other dog dna test you can unlock their breed mix screen for genetic health risks and discover the relatives she has a bunch of relatives near us I like literally three streets from my house which is crazy no way yeah and you guys now is the perfect time to shop for an embark dog DNA test right now embark has a limited time offer on their breed and health kit and purebred kit for was it real listeners go to embark vet comm to get free shipping and save $40 with promo code Hills visit embark vet comm and use promo code Hills to save $40 today look at look at look at look who's here we need you hide I wanted to clarify something what did Lauren just always was she really sitting on that couch all the time when you came in or did they do that's like my house you come in I'm like oh she's like imprint looking at a magazine actually on and off camera that was often where she was wasn't she when you always yeah that's her spot i was wondering that because every time i was like mad dog spot like as soon as she comes in like when you come in your mom's on the couch you're like yeah oh you're home yeah exactly how are you doing over there that was her spot episode six all right and this is uh when when you're all you're trying to like kind of figure it out with uh with spencer and lauren in between being like hey so can you guys both get along i love him and telling her you know but it's like putting you in this position where it's really hard because now he doesn't want to hang out with her she doesn't want to hang out with him this is right before that you they have the little conversation at the club i think yeah this was a really tricky situation i felt like i was put in a really hard spot in real life and on camera so um lauren was like i'm not hanging out with spencer i'm not going to be around him i don't like him i don't care about him and i said to her well you're putting me in a really hard position because you're cutting out our friendship basically like you don't want to hear about my life is what you're saying so we can hang out as long as it's about you or just a surface level friendship but that's not fair so i was trying to make that happen um and then spencer if you know spencer and you're like well lauren doesn't want to you know be around you he's like well i don't want to be around her that's you know like and that's what we were talking about i think that that because it's the kind of have to say what's going on to spencer but like we were talking about like sometimes just kind of like protecting your significant other without having to say everything that's going on kind of saves the like dramatic feelings between them too that that could have kind of changed the path of the show but you're not even saying nothing to spencer so that spencer or like or even saying like hey lauren's fine now or whatever she likes you she likes you it's fine so maybe he's liking her and maybe like somehow like you could have fooled them both to like yeah each other but two things one i'm really honest like i can't not just be real with it it's like well this is really what's going on and you know it's up to other people to deal with their own emotions like that's not on me and it became a big problem so they weren't allowed to be in the same room so i'm not allowed to be with both of them it wasn't like oh i'll be around spencer in this room if he's if you're there so it was a really obvious put her foot down statement so i was put in a place where actually he had to know what was going on because he wasn't allowed certain places you're saying they were because lauren basically told production like i don't remember that i know that later on in life he is in the same room and he is talking to her and he is cool and giving even a speech about her on her birthday so like well things change and sometimes with certain scenes like everybody has to show up like it's your job you know like you don't like she said there was a time when it really was like yeah it was a no-go zone for either of them i remember at the rolling stones shoot you guys weren't talking and i was like there's no way you guys gotta lauren cut it out like this is the cover of rolling stones like we're doing this like just get over that for the day at least i know you were so great there if you weren't there that would have been an even harder shoot i had to be in between you guys like it was gnarly like physically in between us and she still wouldn't talk to me were you on the left and she was on the right or how was it heidi was on the right lauren was on the left and then whitney was next to lauren and we were dancing and like being happy and friendly and like yeah yeah we were but yeah it was a hard position to be put in on and off camera but i think this episode really sets the tone for where the relationship is going with you and lauren and then also with spencer and the whole dynamic of you guys and just the change the falling out right slowly starts to happen yeah so so you guys do go to area so we do go to area and this is and spencer was allowed to be there with production or whatever i don't remember if this is before or after she really put her foot down though i think that was way later because i do yeah i i've seen other episodes that that he's still around and she's around and well i think this too it's because we saw him flirting with another girl and then you didn't see it and then lauren was trying to have your back and be like heidi let's go let's go now and you didn't really know what was going on right i wish heidi was here to see it she won't believe me oh thank you lauren come here look at spencer until we all told you and then that's when spencer took lauren aside and like tried to clear the air but then it just kind of exploded we're so making peace by the way you can hate me that's fine i don't hate you i just want my friend not to date you it's fine if you don't like me and you don't want me to date her but let's not make it difficult for you to be best friends you made a little comments like this i don't want to be in a room with spencer when i didn't say that i said i don't really want to sit back and watch spencer use you instead of it becoming good it just went right i think a lot of the time lauren actually had good intentions like i think she was trying to be a good friend you know i think she did have my back a lot which i really appreciated she really did and then it just became like it was all or nothing i'm done right it was all or nothing so it would have been great if we could have continued on that trajectory like hey he was flirting with me and i didn't want to be in a room with him and i didn't want to be in a room flirting with someone else okay great well i need to go deal with that with spencer or whatever or i need to figure that out right right and don't don't hate him for the things if i don't hate him you you don't have to hate him right or you don't need to like him but still be my friend yeah that's what we were talking about before you came in right that's exactly so yeah that became the tricky part because yeah was that appreciated no was i maybe flirting with someone for that i don't know probably you know like i used to be yeah i was and i was a really big flirt too and spencer was a really big flirt and during this time we still like we were official but we both kind of flirted with other people and we actually had a really serious conversation about that in february i think it was even after we were official and spencer was like you need to stop flirting with people he has a different mentality at that point right well when i met spencer the reason why we weren't like official right away when it was you and kristen were together he was like i don't want a girlfriend right it was like a very anti-girlfriend like want nothing to do with that you know so to even right to even think of having a girlfriend went against everything he was going towards in his life goal at that time and then having one publicly was another thing he really didn't want to do you know going at that time in his life so you know i mean i think he felt that he was kind of like that too with kids like we remember with it you know you didn't at first he was kind of like i he was scared to have kids i don't know if it's not that he not didn't want kids but he was kind of like nervous to have kids you know he was kind of like i i don't know if i you know i don't know if i'd be a good dad and this and that and then sure enough look at him he's like one of the best dads i've ever seen yeah sounds familiar brody we've had this conversation i mean yeah that does yeah i think yeah we'll see she's not out yet we'll see that was the conclusion right after our area yeah like the the little yep and jen was there jen bunny which of course she was she's gonna be in the next episode with us yes well let's let's get into some fan calls before we bring jen in for the next episode this spring you need nutritious convenient meals to energize you for warmer active days and keep you on track reaching your goals factor america's number one ready to eat meal kit can help you fuel up fast with ready to eat meals delivered straight to your door you'll save time eat well and tackle everything on your to-do list factor offers delicious flavor-packed options on the menu each week to fit a variety of lifestyles from keto to calorie smart vegan plus veggie and protein plus prepared by chefs and approved by dieticians each meal has all of the ingredients you need to feel satisfied all day long while meeting your goals i love factor i have their keto brownie smoothies in the morning and i have one of their keto calorie meals for either lunch or dinner it's so easy you just pop it in the microwave for two minutes and you have a delicious healthy meal ready and the best part is there's no cleanup head to factormeals.com slash hills 50 and use code hills 50 to get 50 off your first box i said 50 that's code hills 50 at factormeals.com slash hills 50 to get 50 off your first box and for all of our listeners we just wanted to tell you that we've gotten so many messages about whitney and we absolutely love her and our we're so happy to report that whitney's actually coming on our podcast for a special bonus episode so if you guys want to send us voicemails questions at speakpipe.com slash the hills or leave us a message on our instagram page at the hills rewatch um and check out our youtube page so the first question hi my name is dina i'm calling from honolulu hawaii this message is for audrina audrina i'm wondering what is the meaning behind your neck tattoo you kind of see it throughout the season but it looks like you mostly cover it up my second question is did the producers make you cover up the tattoo for television or was that your idea just because you don't really get a full shot of it on the show all right guys thank you so much so my neck tattoo i got when i was 17 um and it's it's a heart with four chambers that turns into an apple with a snake around it so it's the whole adam and eve story like about life and destiny and temptation um but it looks like a strawberry with a worm so i wear my hair down a lot but i think in this time of my life i wear a lot of ponytails because i got a lot of comments about the tattoo let's see it oh gosh you guys i wanted to have it removed but i can't it's too deep and then yeah they said they can add to it but i was like oh no i don't want to add okay there you go guys it's not that bad it's not that bad no i have two more i have one on this side it's the constellation of my daughter's month june and then on this side is a wave that represents life and just like everything that life is about now you're balanced with the three i like it so that so that uh so that apple do you bite it or do you not bite it well eve did bite it i'm asking you you're the temptation yeah i've suffered through it that's the temptation right so i'm asking you do you fall for the apple you don't oh i've fallen yes i've fallen for the apple yes i've bit the apple before i've learned my lessons many times it's hard not to no one's perfect frankie i think you bit the apple a couple times too buddy it was eve but adam did what eve did he was very easily all right next we have another question hi guys um it's lisa here i'm from ireland and i'm really enjoying your podcast i listen to it every week um i know you can't say too much but you've often mentioned lauren and was the star of the show and i just wondered how much final say did she actually get about what was edited what was brought in what was left there like could she have talked to the producers and have something cut out and made herself look more favorable and also um she doesn't really seem to want to have much to do with anything to do with the hills anymore but she recently went on um kristin and stephen colletti he's back to the beach podcast and I just wondered what your opinions on all that was okay thank you bye now so I actually asked Kristen about this question because I was like how did you get Lauren on your podcast because we've had we reached out to her agent her publicist like one of the showrunners that used to be on the show and Kristen said well I called her out and she basically came on to like save face or to talk about everything otherwise we were just going to keep talking so I don't know and I'm sure Steven had his say in that too but right I think the um rivalry and hate she had for Kristen is this small compared to how she probably feels about me personally at least um and leaving the hills behind so I I think it'd be very challenging to get Lauren on this um yeah I don't think that would ever happen I I think with um with the right attitude and the right mentality on the for her to come on and be able to say and give and be peaceful I think she would come on her side and what she was going through with the producers and like maybe she was being pressured too or like she was going through some I don't know yeah I think everyone's going I'm sure if anybody goes and watches these episodes you could see yourself be like ah yeah I should have been better with her with this and I'm sure you see this and you were like yeah I could have done this you've said this before so it's it's like it's easier to see it now and be like ah man Lauren today wouldn't do this or Heidi today wouldn't do this Brody today wouldn't do this yeah I mean all jokes aside obviously we all have a love for Lauren and I appreciate everything that she's done and to answer this question she had a lot of say in this show you know it was her narrative and she had like you will hear later um or from other people she if she didn't want someone on the show it was pretty easy for her to kick people off it's what she wanted to do but at the same time she was dealing with business executives and producers yeah being pressured to make a good show and family I'm sure she had a lot of pressure on her shoulders you had your own fan base that probably was also on her well she had to carry the show do you know what how much pressure that is with a lot of respect to Lauren and to everybody the show was carried by each and me watching this I see everybody carrying the show in their own well I mean in the beginning yeah in the beginning yes of course but once you guys develop like your like you see Heidi just become this like like superstar on tv well you were your you became your own person and had your own life outside of just being Lauren's friend right Audrina it took some guys to like bring you up how did Whitney get out of I guess we'll ask her when she comes on because she's coming on but how did she get out of sort of not having to bring her personal life into it because you only see Whitney in that little room with Lauren with the shoes because she was the person you could go I know she got lucky but then she got her own tv show no it was shocking when Whitney got this spin off I think I was shocked right I literally was like Whitney she's not even like hardly on the show you know so it was interesting that they took the person who was on it the least which I think was the point like let's take someone you don't know spin them off into their own world you get to know her for the first time she is likable we've kept her pretty right out of it and I do want to reiterate this part about Whitney she texted all of us and she wanted to make sure we knew that she has nothing but love for us and we have nothing but love for her and we've always had this relationship with her where we've oh there is no animosity between like and people text us about like oh well they did the show first that what you guys are doing the podcast we all having fun and enjoying life like we love her and we want we want her to come on our show and it's going to be amazing when she's on because she was such a big part of the show in her own little way just like everyone that was part of it you know and I think that it'll be so cool to have her on and um and we also have Jim Bunny coming up on the next episode that's going to be amazing and um I think we need to go to the last fan question hi my name is Tyler my question is for Heidi Pratt uh how did you and Lauren Conrad meet what were your first impressions of Lauren and what are three nice things that you can say about Lauren or your friendship with her I met Lauren my first day of fashion school in San Francisco and I was um 17 actually because I went to fashion school early I left high school and there was a rumor that this MTV girl was going to be there but nobody knew who it was or what it was and Laguna Beach wasn't out yet um or it like just aired that month or something but I thought we all thought it was made I want to be a prom queen or like someone who was on an episode anyways I met her for my day of class and we sat next to each other because we were very similar and we're both pretty scared in a big city and we immediately just connected and then a few months or like a month later she's like oh I'm going to the VMAs and I was like oh my gosh how do you get to go to the VMAs you must be so rich or whatever and she's like oh I'm on this show and I was like you're that girl I thought you're gonna be such a loser oh my gosh and you never watched so you didn't watch Laguna Beach or you kind of wasn't out yet yeah first it wasn't out when I met her and then when I was like oh my gosh I was like oh my gosh I was like oh my gosh I was like oh my gosh I was like and fashion school so I didn't understand Laguna Beach was even such a thing and then she's like come back with me to Laguna let's do Halloween we're all gonna go to Santa Barbara and then I went there with her and I met Steven and all these people and then people were dressed up as them and following them and I was like you're like really famous and she's like I know I keep telling you and I you know I'm immersed in my own world you know thinking I'm like so cool I just came back you know that's right you went to college study abroad I did so I just was in Italy and I thought that I was gonna be this big anyways whatever um so then yeah we were really great friends and then she left half um halfway through the season because she wanted to go back and film and we both hated San Francisco it was really challenging so she's like why don't you come live with me in the summer we filmed a few episodes of Laguna Beach I lived with her family for like a month and then the next thing she was like I want you to be on it with me and Adam was like no we don't want Heidi I think I already said this he's like we want you to move alone he didn't even met with me and everything he's like I don't we just want Lauren and she's like I'm not doing this show without Heidi and she's like she's my real best friend I don't want to be living with a stranger I want to live with Heidi and you know she advocated and I wouldn't thank God Adam did that Jesus you made the show yeah so that was it three positive things about my friendship with Lauren is we had the most fun ever I like some of my favorite memories to this day are with Lauren when we went to New York and when you know our first red carpet and the clubs I mean we just had a lot of fun together and just sitting on the couch and just sitting on the couch was great um another moment totally another great thing about my friendship with Lauren um was how loyal she was for a really long time you know like we really confided in each other we went through such a period of time together that no one else would understand um and another positive thing I really always respect and love about Lauren is she doesn't take anything from anyone whether it's overboard or not I remember hearing her talk to her agent on the phone I'm like whoa you are a boss at 20 years old you know chewing out this adult man who's trying to convince her to do something she didn't want to do um so she is a real you know kind of savvy businesswoman who knew what she was doing from a very young age and I really respected that as very commendable how she handled her business we're great love all those three we're not gonna do confessions today because everybody uh we have Jen Bunny I'm gonna save my question for her okay that's okay that's okay Frankie Brody all right well thank you so much for listening please follow rate and review the hills rewatch wherever you listen to your podcasts and if you'd like to watch us check us out on our social media platforms and we'll see you next time bye bye on YouTube and you can also listen to exclusive bonus content plus ad-free episodes by signing up at castmedia.com slash cast plus that's cast with a k media.com slash cast plus see you guys later

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The episode highlights growing tension between Spencer and Heidi’s friendship with Lauren, as Lauren strongly disapproves of Spencer and refuses to accept him as a part of their dynamic.
  2. The drama is amplified by reality show conventions, where characters must openly criticize and confront each other, unlike in real life where people might simply distance themselves subtly.
  3. Heidi’s decision to confide in Spencer about Lauren’s negative opinions creates conflict, as Spencer feels betrayed and Lauren interprets the disclosure as a breach of trust.
  4. The rose incident, where Heidi gives roses to Lauren thinking they were from Spencer, backfires and deepens the rift, symbolizing the breakdown of trust and friendship.
  5. Lauren’s resentment grows as Heidi spends more time with Spencer, shifting their dynamic from close friendship to one of emotional distance and conflict.
  6. The episode illustrates how real-life relationships require patience, compromise, and emotional boundaries, with no need to make dramatic "either-or" choices.
  7. Spencer and Heidi’s enduring bond, despite the conflicts, shows their genuine commitment and emotional depth, contrasting with the toxic dynamics of other friendships.
  8. The show’s reality format often exaggerates interpersonal tensions, masking the complexity of real emotional negotiations and personal growth.

Summary:

The podcast analyzes season two, episode six of *Laguna Beach*, titled "You Have Chosen," focusing on the deteriorating friendship between Spencer and Heidi and their friend Lauren. Lauren's strong disapproval of Spencer leads to confrontations, including a heated exchange where she refuses to engage with him, which strains their friendship and fuels tension. Heidi, trying to maintain loyalty, confides in Spencer about Lauren’s disapproval, leading to further conflict and a breakdown of trust.

The episode underscores the reality show’s tendency to dramatize personal conflicts, where characters are pressured to reveal every emotion and judgment, unlike real-life interactions, which often involve subtle distance or silence. The rose incident, where Heidi gives roses to Lauren thinking they were from Spencer, backfires and deepens the rift, showing how miscommunication damages trust. The dynamic shifts as Heidi spends more time with Spencer, isolating her from Lauren, who feels betrayed and increasingly resentful.

The episode reflects on the importance of emotional boundaries, mutual respect, and the avoidance of forced "either-or" choices in relationships. Ultimately, despite the drama, the bond between Spencer and Heidi remains strong, highlighting their genuine connection. The analysis also touches on how the show’s production style exaggerates conflicts, making it seem like every relationship is at war, when real life involves more nuance, patience, and personal growth.

The discussion concludes with appreciation for the characters’ journeys and the emotional depth behind the surface-level drama.

FAQs

The episode explores the growing tension between friendships and relationships, especially focusing on Spencer and Heidi's relationship and the difficulty of maintaining trust and open communication with friends.

Lauren disapproves of Spencer and feels threatened by his involvement with Heidi, leading her to cut off communication and express strong emotions, which strains her friendship with Heidi.

The podcast notes that reality shows require constant emotional disclosure, leading to dramatic confrontations, unlike real life where people might simply avoid conflict or express feelings subtly.

Spencer is upset because Heidi reveals Lauren’s negative feelings about him, which creates tension and highlights the breakdown of trust and the difficulty of maintaining friendship and intimacy.

They emphasize that healthy relationships involve mutual respect, allowing individuals to distance themselves without drama or forcing others to choose between them.

It symbolizes an attempt to maintain friendship and humor, but Lauren misinterprets it as Spencer favoring her, which deepens the divide between them and shows the miscommunication in their relationship.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.