Go back

Yes, Dinosaurs Had Feathers with Steve Brusatte

from Factually! with Adam Conover

1h 6m 50s

Yes, Dinosaurs Had Feathers with Steve Brusatte

Birds are not just fascinating animals—they are direct descendants of dinosaurs, evolving from small, feathered dinosaur ancestors over hundreds of millions of years. Feathers first appeared for insulation, later transforming into wings that enabled flight, a rare ability in the animal kingdom. Flight evolved gradually, likely as a byproduct of elaborate display structures in small raptors, eventually giving rise to modern birds through natural selection. Birds possess incredibly complex, multifunctional feathers and advanced vocal organs, allowing them to sing in intricate, learned ways that mirror human language in some aspects. These songs serve key evolutionary roles in mate attraction and social communication, and scientific studies show that bird song can even lead to the formation of new species through cultural evolution. Despite their aerial prowess, many birds have lost the ability to fly—such as ostriches and penguins—due to environmental shifts and reduced need for flight. The misconception that dinosaurs were reptilian and scale-covered stems from outdated art and limited fossil evidence; modern discoveries in China and Mongolia have revealed feathered dinosaurs with bird-like behaviors, reshaping how we view dinosaur evolution. This conversation highlights not only the scientific marvel of bird evolution but also the deep human connection to birds—through their beauty, flight, and songs—offering a moment of wonder amid global crises.

Transcription

12267 Words, 66389 Characters

English
[MUSIC] >> Hey, they're welcome to Factually, I'm Adam Conover. Thank you so much for joining me on the show again as I talk to an incredible thinker and get all the delicious ideas out of their brains and into ours. You know, it's been a stressful couple of months on the show. We've been talking about the rise of apocalyptic fascism, the AI revolution or lack thereof that will either destroy the world or destroy all of our jobs or just crash the economy. One of the three, how you wanna be talking about other corporations gouging us and death of democracy, but there comes a time in your day when you have to stop working and you have to stop worrying and you just need to take a break and enjoy life on earth and the mystery of being alive, right? That's what we're gonna do today. We're gonna take a break, look out at the sky and the natural world around us and talk to an expert about something that doesn't have to do with one of our many overlapping crises, but instead is about appreciating the mystery and the magic of life itself on fucking earth. Today, we're talking about birds. Isn't that nice birds? What's their fucking deal? Aren't you curious? I mean, they're pretty weird. They have hollow bones. Some of them can talk. They fly, holy shit. And on top of that, they were dinosaurs. Apparently, what's all that about? They're also a lot of fun to watch. You know, I got into bird watching during the pandemic. I kept it up for years, it's improved my life greatly. So a wonderful way to get out in the natural world and just have an excuse to look, look at the world around you, look at the beauty of nature even if you go to a local park. And plus, you can make a little list of all the ones that you see. It's kind of like collecting Pokemon, except you don't have to make them fight. I love them very much. So today, we are going full bird and we have a fantastic return guest on the show to help us think about these wonderful creatures and explain how they evolved in the first place. His name is Steve Brissotti. He's a paleontologist, science writer and a professor at the University of Edinburgh. And he's one of the very best writers telling the story of evolution for a popular audience today. His new book is The Story of Birds, a new history from their dinosaur origins to the present. I know you're going to love this conversation before we get into it, I want to remind you that if you want to support the show and all the conversations we bring you every single week, the depressing ones, the enlightening ones, the mind blowing ones, please support us on Patreon. Head to patreon.com/addomcanover. Five bucks a month gets you every episode of the show. Add free. You can join our online community. We have a discord. We even do an online book club where we read a new work of mind blowing nonfiction every couple of months and discuss it live with you guys and publish it as a bonus podcast episode. Currently we are reading End Times Fascism in the Fight for a Living World by Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor, having a blast reading it and talking about it with all of you guys. Join us patreon.com/addomcanover. We would love to have you. And also just a reminder, my new stand-up special big divorce energy is out now on my YouTube channel. Please check it out. I'm very proud of it. And I'd love to see you out on the road. @addomcanover.net to see all my tour dates. And now let's get to this week's interview with the incredibly funny, engaging and fascinating thinker Steve Brissotti. Steve, thank you so much for coming on the show again. Adam, it's always a pleasure to talk with you. We talked about mammal evolution before. I'm excited to talk about birds and dinosaurs. I mean, I'm excited to do that too. You wrote a book about dinosaurs. We didn't talk to you after that book came out, but now you have a new book about birds. And I love birds. I went through a bird washing phase during the pandemic for a couple years after as many people did, wonderful hobby. But since you also wrote about dinosaurs, we can just jump right into it. There's this rumor going around that birds are dinosaurs. I've been hearing this my whole birds are dinosaurs and I'm like, okay, what the fuck does that mean? How is that? Tell me, is this true? And what does this mean exactly? And what's that? It's a juicy rumor, isn't it? And it does turn out to be true. It is correct that birds are dinosaurs. And I'll tell you exactly what I mean there because I know it sounds a little bit crazy, right? A sparrow looks nothing like a stegosaurus and T-Rexes and Brontosaurus and museums are in the Jurassic Park films. And of course, they look nothing like a bird. But really birds are part of the dinosaur family tree. Birds evolved from dinosaurs. Birds have all the classic features that make dinosaurs dinosaurs, which are some modifications to the hip, to the pelvis, to the backbone, to the hind legs, and allow them to walk more upright. So they are dinosaurs in a technical, genealogical sense. And maybe that seems like a bit of a sleight of hand like we're harping on definitions. But I'll pose to you this, that what would you call a bat, you know, what type of animal is a bat? Well, a mammal. A mammal, right? And why is that? Well, because it has hair and feeds his baby's milk and has molar teeth. It has all the classic features of mammals. And because it's part of the mammal family tree, it evolved from other mammals. And bats are just weird mammals that got small, evolved wings, started to fly. Birds are the dinosaur version of that. They are the strange group of dinosaurs that got small evolved wings and started to fly. But the difference, of course, with bats is that birds are the only dinosaurs that survive that gauntlet of extinction. So imagine some world as morbid as it would be, because it means we wouldn't be here. But imagine that all mammals died except for bats. You would still have mammals, just one strange type of mammal. That's where we're at today. Birds are dinosaurs. So when you see a sparrow, a pigeon, a goal outside your window, I'm looking out my window. Now there's some pigeons out there here in Edinburgh and Scotland where I'm joining you from. Those are dinosaurs. Those are real, true dinosaurs. The rumors are true. Okay, so when humanity is wiped out and, you know, the next dolphins come onto land or whatever, and they're like, hey, what's up with these bats and people go bats are apes. Bats are apes. Bats are mammals. Well, dolphins are also mammals, so that was a bad example of the next species to become a sentient. Let's make a cockroaches. Well, there you go. They'll survive the coming AI apocalypse. I have no doubt. So if, so if we had dinosaurs today, we would maybe look at dinosaurs and go, hey, it's clear to us the dinosaurs are birds. Yes. But I think it would be, and that's a very good point, Adam, because when we see bats today, it's clear they're mammals, because they have hair and feed their babies milk and so on. If all these other dinosaurs were still with us, we would actually see that a lot of dinosaurs had feathers. You know, simple feathers, not like the wings of birds necessarily, but we would see that other dinosaurs are energetic and grow fast, and they would have been intelligent. They would have moved fast. They would have had lightweight skeletons. All these things are what birds have. So yes, I think if there were still T. Rex's and Triceratops's and Brontosaurus's with us, it would be clear to us that birds are part of that same general family. Got it. So maybe even behaviorally they would have some similarities. Maybe they hop or they move in a similar way or you'd see some connection there. Yeah. And here's an example. A great example of that. There's some fossils. And these are from the goby desert in Mongolia. They were discovered by my mentor, a guy named Mark Narell, who sadly passed quite recently. Here's my PhD advisor, he's one of the great dinosaur hunters, and he took teams out to the goby desert for decades. And they discovered these parent dinosaurs sitting on their nests, protecting their eggs just like birds do today. So that's an example of a behavior. A lot of dinosaurs, classic old school dinosaurs from the Jurassic, from the Cretaceous, they would have behaved a lot like birds. And if we were watching them, we would see those bird-like behaviors undoubtedly. We would sense them as same type of animal as a sparrow or a pigeon or an eagle or an ostrich. That's fascinating, protecting the nest. But now, I think part of why this is confusing to people when we hear it is that we were told growing up that dinosaurs were lizards. And we have lizards and commoto dragons and whatnot and iguanas. And you look at that. Look, that's kind of like a dinosaur, was that a mistaken comparison? And do lizards come from dinosaurs or no? So I remember this. I grew up in school in the late 80s and in the 90s, the books we had in class, the books in the library that I go with my mom to the library and check out these books on dinosaurs. They always call dinosaurs reptiles or lizards. And most of the artworks showing these dinosaurs back in the Jurassic World, they looked like they were overgrown crocodiles or iguanas. They were green, they were gray, they were covered in scales. They didn't really look at all bird-like. Those images, that artwork, that conception of dinosaurs just isn't correct. We now know. Because of fossils found later in the 90s, that many dinosaurs had feathers. We actually find fossil feathers on dinosaurs and took a while to find those fossils because feathers don't preserve very easily. They're soft, they're delicate, they decay away quickly. You need to bury an animal really fast and sand or in mud to get the feathers locked in. And it just so happened that in China, there were these ecosystems that were buried, basically by the ash and the muddy sludge from these volcanic eruptions, kind of like Pompeii. And that preserved these feathers. So we now know something we didn't know when the people were writing those books and making that art with the stuff that we saw in the 80s and the 90s. We know that a lot of dinosaurs really did have feathers and were more like birds. However, the name dinosaur, when it was invented, almost 200 years ago, it means terrible lizard. And you know, the first people studying dinosaur bones, they saw that they were kind of reptilian. They seemed like they were giant reptiles. No, you know, a megalosaurus and iguana on some of these first dinosaurs found. These things were the size of jeeps, even bigger, some of them, of course they didn't look like a bird. So the people that first started to study these dinosaurs saw that they were kind of reptilian and gave them that name. And in the end is really a bit of a misnomer, but we've learned so much and it's really been over the last few decades that this idea that dinosaurs and birds are connected, that it has been proven. It's an old idea. It actually goes back to the time of Darwin. This idea that there's a dinosaur bird connection and that birds are like highly modified reptiles. That idea is old, but it was really the discovery of these feather-covered dinosaurs in the 90s that showed everybody in beautiful, obvious detail. Oh my goodness, there's all these dinosaurs with feathers on their bodies, of course. They must be closely related to birds. >> Wow, what's fascinating is that the 90s kind of were peak dinosaur. You know, obviously Jurassic Park, growing up, there are a lot of like cartoons, you know, set, like- >> The sitcom, you remember the dinosaurs? >> Yeah, yeah, yeah, that was great. >> That was incredible. >> That was the Simpson's it was, but with the dinosaurs, with Carlson Claire and Fran and, oh yeah. You're right, it was peak dinosaur. The land before time, the first ones that came out in the late 80s, but there were a bunch of new ones in the 90s and that's when I got into it. And it was really through my youngest brother who was obsessed with dinosaurs in the 90s. And he turned his bedroom into a dinosaur museum and had all these books, watched Jurassic Park on a loop. And so I think the 90s was a great time to become enthralled with dinosaurs and that's what happened and here I am. >> Well, I was gonna say that it seems like the image of dinosaurs that we had in the 90s was, even at that time, slightly out of date, that it was artists from a couple decades prior, looking at the fossils, talking to scientists, saying, okay, I'm gonna compare this to something that I know when I'm drawing it, but that they sort of chose the wrong group of animals to have them resemble. What I find interesting is that I've heard this for a while, oh, dinosaurs don't look the way that we think they do, they had feathers, et cetera. But I have not seen a popularization of a depiction of dinosaurs that is more accurate. It seems like where's all of the movies and drawings and textbooks of, or kids' media, of feathered bird-like dinosaurs? We, it's one of those interesting things where there's other examples of where the cultural conception of something is locked in the past and we don't realize how much we're looking at a 19th century version of, like a gyptomania is a good example too, where like America got obsessed with Egyptian stuff in what the forties, right? And so a lot of our conception of like what Egypt was like in the US descends from that period. - From that. - Does this make sense to you? - Yeah, it does, and you know, and it's interesting to hear your perspective here. This is one of the reasons why I wrote the new book was called The Story of Birds, which is about the whole evolutionary journey of birds from their dinosaur origins to today. But the main reason I wanted to write it is because I agree with you. I think, you know, this idea that birds came from dinosaurs, that many dinosaurs were much more bird-like than reptile-like. It's an old idea, more than 150 years old, and we've had these feather dinosaurs from the '90s that proved it, but I don't think it's really percolated into pop culture yet, at least not as much as it could. And we're starting to see bits. And so I'm the consultant, the paleontology consultant for the Jurassic World films. That's one of the fun things I get to do. It's all because I wrote these books, and people making the films read the books. But in Jurassic World Dominion, not the last film, but the one before then, finally, there were some feather dinosaurs. The director, Colin Trevor, when he hired me, he set the first thing he set was, I want to finally put some feathers on these dinosaurs. So he knew it was time. So there are some dinosaurs with feathers in that film, but that's Jurassic Park 6, you know, by that time, that concept of Jurassic Park T-Rexes and Velociraptors has already really baked into pop culture. You do see kids' books. I've written someone with my wife and we do kids books together. And we've written some about dinosaurs that have a more modern version of dinosaurs. There's a lot of great art on the internet, a very bird-like feathery dinosaurs. So there's content out there, but it hasn't quite broken through yet. And that was one of the main motivations for writing this book. I really love the idea of the director going, you know, it's past time to have a feathered dinosaur. Representation matters, and all the feathered dinosaurs are watching it at home going, finally, someone who looks like me in the movie. - I love it. I love it. I best exactly what happened. College Trevor, he was thinking about those poor raptor dinosaurs, having to look at this outdated scared life type of these Velociraptors covered in scales. Yeah, put some feathers on him. - Absolutely. Well, let's talk about birds, and you know, birds are such special animals. And if I can, I would like to know your connection with them, but if I might share a little bit of what I sort of got interested in bird watching, I was, I suddenly realized when I started doing it, why people watch birds as opposed to other animals? Because there's like compared to mammals or bugs. Some, you know, in Japan, they love to collect bugs. Like bugs are interesting. But like birds, they, there are many different types of them. They have a wide variety. They move around a lot seasonally throughout the year. They're a little bit hard to spot. But they also have like, they have this sort of beautiful variety that a lot of other species lack. Like if you, there's no such thing as mammal watching, because in your area, there's probably only like, like a dozen mammals in your area that, you know, you might reasonably see. And they're not moving around so much. And they're not brightly colored. And they're not, there's something like very special about the amount of like variety and beauty and different behaviors that birds have that is like distinct from other major animal groups. And does that track for you at all? And what is your specific interest in them? - Yes, absolutely. You're spot on there because so many people go bird watching, as you say, I've never really heard somebody say, I'm going mammal watching. And that's because there are so many birds, there are nearly double, or actually maybe even more than double, depending on how you divide them up, roughly double, let's say the number of bird species compared to mammal species. So in that sense, we're still in a dinosaur world. No, we like to think of ourselves on top, but there's just more birds than mammals. And they're more conspicuous. Some birds are very hard to spot. Of course, and that's the goal of the bird watcher to get every bird on the list. But many other birds, they're in your face, they're out there, they're out there in the daytime. A lot of mammals only come out at night. A lot of birds, as you say, have very flamboyant plumage, these feather patterns and colors. That's because birds can see in color really well. Most mammals cannot, we are unusual among mammals to be able to see in color. There's only a few mammal species that can do it. So most mammals are drab colored because they're not seeing each other. And so birds, they're out there. They make themselves known, they're flamboyant. They sing such incredible songs. It's the richness of the melodies that birds can sing. That's because they have this vocal organ that's different than ours. It's called the searing. And it's where the throat goes into the lung. There's this vocal organ. And it's so sophisticated. Some birds can even make two different sounds from each side of that vocal organ. Be like, speak in English and speak in French at the same time. One person, I mean, so birds are just capable of beauty in their colors and their feathers in their songs. And there's a lot of them and they're out there. And I'm looking out the window now. And I'm seeing a few birds. I'm not seeing, okay, there's a squirrel out there. - Right. - But there's a bunch. There's pigeons and there's sparrow. And there's, because we're close to the water here in Edinburgh, there's a gall. I mean, that's just me looking out the window, right now. So, yes, bird watching is great 'cause you can see them. And there's such incredible variety. Those of us that like to collect stuff. I like to collect baseball cards when I was a kid. I still have you can see behind me. All kinds of sports familiar from back home. Like those of us with that mindset, I think are really drawn to bird watching and to fossil hunting too. And so for me, that's what it's really about. It's the great variety of birds that get me excited. Yeah. And we shouldn't leave out. They fly. This is a source of, yeah, and so would you like, why are humans fascinated by birds as opposed to other animals? The plumage, the variety, the sort of like, you know, the spontaneous appearance and disappearance of them in our field of view. And then also these motherfuckers fly. And it's incredible, right? But all humans have always wanted to do since the dawn of time, right? We humankind has aspired to break the bonds of earth and fly through the sky. And it's hard to do that. I mean, there's other animals that fly. But birds are very unusual because they don't just glide passively, you know, like say, a flying squirrel kind of glides around stupid flying squirrel, just gliding. I hate them. You know, I've been fighting a reputation as a bad gift giver ever since I was five years old and I gave a candy apple to my toothless grandmother. How was I supposed to know those were dentures? I thought old people could just take their teeth out. And honestly, I was looking forward to having that happen to me when I was old. I'm disappointed. Well, you know, ever since that moment, now I try to find the perfect gift for everyone in my life. And that is why I am so excited to do my shopping this year on uncommon goods. Uncommon goods makes it easy to find the coolest, most one of the kind gifts for everyone on your list all in one place. They feature products that are high quality, unique and often handmade or made in the US by independent artists and small businesses. These are gifts you're not going to find at the mall, handmade jewelry, home decor, clever kitchen and bar gadgets, DIY kits, games and puzzles, even experiences. You can even get your loved ones some sweet treats like Kentucky bourbon chocolate balls. Just make sure they have teeth. Many of their handcrafted products are made in small batches. So shop now before they sell out this holiday season. Plus with every purchase you make at uncommon goods, they give back one dollar to a nonprofit partner of your choice. And they have donated more than $3.1 million to date. The clock is ticking on gift giving season. So don't wait. Cross those names off of your list before they rush to get 15% off your next gift. Go to uncommon goods.com/factually. That's uncommon goods.com/factually for 15% off uncommon goods. We're all out of the ordinary. You know, some of you might know this, but for many years, I relied on public transportation for all of my transportation needs. Not just because I had a fear of driving that I had a lot of trouble getting over, but mostly because I also loved meeting weirdos on the bus. You know, I have learned so much from just regular citizens I encounter on public transportation. Like how much Cologne is too much of Cologne. And Armando, if you're listening, thank you so much for calling me out on that. So anyway, I eventually started driving again. And although I am no longer afraid of Armando's critiques, I am afraid for my life every time I get on the road. But you know, I have people who love me and rely on me and actually are really into the way I smell. And that is why I decided to get life insurance. And with ethos, it has never been easier. Ethos makes getting life insurance fast and easy and it is 100% online. You can get a quote in seconds from their network of trusted carriers, apply in minutes and get same day coverage. There's no medical exam, just a few simple health questions and policies start as low as $30 a month. You know, there's a reason ethos has 4.9 out of five stars on trust pilot with over 5,500 reviews. That's 5,500 reviews. Take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through ethos. You can get your free quote at ethos.com/factually that is ETHOS.com/factually. Application times may vary, rates may vary, trust pilot rating as of 81226. Why is it that the most important tasks are always the most annoying? Like I know I should be flossing every day, but it never stops being painful. And honestly, would that even be enough for my dentist? I mean, dentists love complaining and if everyone started flossing, they'd be out of a job. But you know, when it comes to running payroll for my small business, I know it needs to get done and I know I don't want to do it. That is why I rely on gusto. gusto brings payroll, benefits, HR and time tracking together in one place so small business owners can spend less time managing their workforce and more time growing their business. Instead of doing it all yourself, gusto automatically calculates files and pays your payroll taxes so you don't have to agonize for hours. On average, gusto runs regular payroll in just 8 minutes. Plus, the gusto app is user-friendly for both you and your employees. On the app, employees can access onboarding payroll and they're 401k right at their fingertips. Now, if only there was a gusto for flossing. Okay, payroll, benefits, compliance, all in one place, get started at gusto.com/factually and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com/factually. One more time, gusto.com/factually. These birds, of course, they flap. They flap. They have active, flapping powered flight. So that's how they get lift and thrust. Lift to get into the air, thrust to move into the air. They flap their wings. The only other animals with bones that do that are bats that live today. There were tarot actles in the past, which were not birds or dinosaurs a different group. They also had wings that they flap. But that's it. Throughout the entire history of life, only three types of animals with bones have evolved the ability to flap wings and get airborne. It is so unusual. And it really defies so much about the norms of physics and gravity. It's very difficult to do. And birds eat big wings and they need big muscles in their chest. That they flap. They need to eat tons of food. They need to breathe tons of oxygen. They need this fast-blooded metabolism. They need great stamina. And so they really are a biological super machine. And you're right. That's another reason why we're fascinated with them. Because they fly. We see them fly. We see them soar. We see them migrate overheads. And these are just things that we as humans cannot do. But I think many of us would love to be able to do. So how did flight evolve? And also tell me a little bit more about how tarot actles are not birds or dinosaurs. Because you think of the tarot actles as being the arch-typical flying dinosaur. Again, in the 90s, the pop culture version. So tell me how does flight evolve in the first place? Yeah. So for the tarot actles, tarot actles are a type of reptile. And they did not have wings made of feathers or anything like that. They're a different group of reptiles. So they're cousins of dinosaurs and birds. And they evolved flight first actually. They evolved way back in the triassic period. This would have been over 210 million years ago, probably a little bit earlier. So they actually beat dinosaurs and birds into the skies by maybe about 50 million years or more, which means when the first birds evolved from dinosaurs, they were not pioneers that were entering virgin territory in the sky. No, they were interlovers in a tarot or a world. They were mounting an insurgency. They had to usurp these rolls in the food web and in the food chain in the air from the tarot source. And how did they do it? Well, they did it by starting to fly. And that is a great question. How did a ground-bound dinosaur mold itself into a flying machine? It was something that did not happen overnight. There was not one freak mutation or just a few genetic changes. No, it was a longer term process, many tens of millions of years. And we have evidence for this in the fossil record because we have a series of transitional fossils that we see step by step change from a ground-living dinosaur into a small bird with feathers, with wings that can fly. Now, we don't have every fossil in that sequence. We're always finding new ones. There are some gaps in the record, but by and large, we have a good spread. And what we see is that feathers came first, but feathers started off, not for flying. The first dinosaurs that evolved feathers, these feathers were very simple. They were just little strands, little hairy strands. They looked like hair. And so they could not fly. Any more than, you know, we can fly with our hair. And many dinosaurs had these simple feathers. And they were probably used for the same reason that we have hair, insulation, keep ourselves warm. And most dinosaurs had these simple feathers. They were normal for dinosaurs. It's just that we don't often find them as fossils. But the same way, when we find a saber-two tiger, we don't normally find the hair, you know, hair and feathers break down quickly. So we have to just get this image, this classic image of dinosaurs out of our head. Either the image from like the 80s or before in art or the image we have of skeletons in a museum. Yeah, those are just the bones. Yeah. The rest doesn't normally preserve the rest of it. Are those famous charismatic dinosaurs, the t-rex, the stegosaurus, etc. Would they have had these strands? And should I update them in my mind to look furry in some way or feathered? Yeah. Okay. Some of them would have undoubtedly. We don't know if every single dinosaur did what we do know is that where we have these ecosystems that were buried by volcanoes, and you got all this detail of the soft tissues preserved, locked in stone. We see big dinosaurs with feathers. There's a tyrannosaur in China that's like 30 feet long and weighed over a ton, and it is covered in these simple feathers. Wow. Then there's also many small dinosaurs with feathers. There's meeting dinosaurs with feathers. There's some plant-eating dinosaurs with feathers. So when you take the family tree of dinosaurs, and you map onto it, which species have been found with feathers, really the only Reasonable conclusion is that the common ancestor of all dinosaurs must have had feathers or the capacity to grow feathers But simple feathers not the wings of birds they came later So what happened was most dinosaurs had those simple feathers that they probably used mostly for insulation But one group of dinosaurs started to modify to elaborate those feathers These were the Raptor dinosaurs the Velociraptor group They were doing something that you don't think of when you think a dinosaur something that seems most undidocer-like And that is that over time they were getting smaller that bigger not all dinosaurs were huge You know the huge ones are the most famous ones but a lot of dinosaurs were small the same way We celebrate elephants and rhinos and blue whales and the big mammals today But most mammals are actually small mice and shrews and so on So dinosaurs most of them were big but these Raptors were getting smaller over time As they were getting smaller they were packing those feathers ever more densely around their bodies Probably to help them stay warm better You know when you're smaller it's easier to to cool down And they started to line up some of those feathers on their arms And in some cases on their legs and their tail But those feathers they started to line up and they got longer And they changed from simple little hairs into brushes they branched out And then some of those brushes flattened out and got rigid enough that they turned into a quill pen shape The classic quill pen shape of a bird feather What's incredible is the first dinosaurs with these quill pen feathers on the arms forming What you can only call a wing I mean it's a bunch of these quill pen feathers on the arm It looks like the wing of a bird today but these first dinosaurs that evolved wings Were the size of sheep up to the size of horses and these wings were like the size of a laptop screen So no way just by the laws of physics could those little wings get a dinosaur like that airborne Which must mean that wings themselves even evolved for some other reason other than flying And you think why evolve a wing I mean wings are used to fly how do airplanes fly with their wings But birds today use their wings for many things they use their wings to protect their babies in the nest Some birds use their wings to swim Some birds many birds actually use their wings for display to attract mates and intimidate rivals And so we think we don't know for sure because we weren't there to see it happen 150 million years ago But we think one of the leading reasons why wings might have evolved was as a display structure Basically an advertising billboard of feathers sticking off the arms to attract mates to scare away rivals And because these raptor dinosaurs were getting smaller over time and because display structures often get bigger More ostentatious over time, more flamboyant over time There might have just been a threshold that was crossed where all of a sudden now the body small Those display billboards are big that just by moving those things around a little bit the laws of physics took over And you got a little bit of lift a little bit of thrust from moving those billboards And so that's probably how flight evolved basically by accident by happenstance By the circumstance of these small dinosaurs having these display billboards for wings That's what we think and it's not like these first dinosaurs that could fly that they would have just launched into the sky No, they would they would have been awkward flyers they could probably only say airborne a little bit But that's important for evolution because now evolution has something to start with Natural selection could take over it could mold these dinosaurs into ever better flyers And it's from that that today's birds ultimately evolved that's what we currently think Man, I really trip out when I think about natural selection you know ever since I read some Darwin in college I was read a book called the Beaker the Finch, do you know this bird? Yeah, that's I read that book in college too. That's a great book. It won the Pulitzer Prize Yeah, and it's about the Galapagos and the great variety of these Finches there and how Darwin studied them and how later on Peter Rosemary Grant the great husband and wife super couple at Preston the great evolutionary biologist How they chronicle for decades like every bird on these islands and they saw How these birds Evolved over time over short periods of time as the weather client changed the climate change yes And I don't have to tell you you read it But I'm just saying this to people. I know it's a great book and you know and and pick it up If you want to understand how evolution by natural selection works and how it's actually working around us right now in the real world Yeah, it is the one to read that's what blew my mind about it. It's about you know The the weather gets a little bit colder and then the seeds of the of the plants get a little bit smaller And then the birds with smaller beaks do a little bit better that year little bit just a little bit better Yeah, but they get a little bit more nutrition and that's enough to give them an advantage It's enough to maybe allow them to have one extra baby or something like that and that's that's really what evolution by natural selection is about surviving Anything that allows you to survive a bit longer to have a few more babies whatever that is over time that can cascade through the population And the entire population will change that is evolution by natural selection And that's what's so fascinating thinking about okay these animals without even realizing it some of them are getting A little bit of lift maybe they are moving a little bit better in some way And then some version of that pressure that makes okay How about a little bit more lift a little bit more lift it just sort of takes off And eventually molds them without anybody doing it on purpose Molds them into the extremely elaborate wings that we have today Yeah, and I think you're right. I think you know imagine you're one of these dinosaurs with these wings And you can get in the air a little bit that might be a great advantage you could escape predators maybe more easily That might make you live another day if you were hunting maybe it would allow you to leap onto something and get a bit more food I mean there's a lot of reasons why you can imagine as you say that there would be a small advantage To being able to just move around a little bit in the air and that is all Evolution needs yep to take over. I kind of picture like a chicken you know chicken can't really fly But they can get a little bit higher than the other animals on the farm because they jump and they flap a little bit or whatever So maybe maybe there's some probably a bad Comparison, but I don't know. No, you're right. I mean chickens don't have to be able to fly like an eagle Right when they're in the barnyard. I mean it just helps them to yeah as you say just leap up a little bit flap a little bit away If you know if something's trying to get them if a fox comes in you know to the handouts. Yep And in the wild there's you know there's ground birds that are similar The feather though is such like a special intricate structure There's another wonderful book. I have what it's like to be a bird that is you know really gets into the anatomy of Of bird not to not to plug books other than yours People should be getting your walk I'm here to I'm here to plug the story of birds. What is this? How talking about pull a surprise when in books by other people be Well, sorry Steve Well, that book really impressed upon me the the beautiful like structure of feathers is like The way that they sort of you know interleave or align with each other to create like a very specific Just tell me a little bit about about that feathers are incredible They're one of I think the most remarkable things that have ever evolved and they're so unique And that's why when these feathers were found on dinosaurs in the 90s like that clinched it That was time. There's just no way feathers have evolved multiple times There's so intricate and they're made of a very particular type of protein These these beta proteins are very similar to keratin in our fingernails, but different They're hollow inside They grow out of the skin so feathers are actually stuff that that grows out of the skin and they grow you know Beginning when a bird is very young this little butt and it's it actually looks like a little scale So you see you sense the reptilian ancestry of a bird and you can even get feathers kind of turning into scales if you tweak the genes and you play with how a bird develops So there is this intimate relationship between feathers and scales feathers did evolve in a sense from scales It was not a simple process, but but they're related Um, and so these feathers start growing in the skin of a bird and they start as the simple little hollow tube Of this beta protein that looks a lot like the simple hairy feathers of the most primitive dinosaurs with feathers Then that hollow tube it starts to branch out looks a lot like those more advanced feathers of raptor dinosaurs And then you get those branches linking together like velcro into you know The two veins of a feather you have the central shaft and you have the two veins down each side And you can zip an unzip a feather if you if you you know if you feel a feather Right and I encourage you any of you listening go touch a feather So you know, they're soft like velvet, but they're strong. They're actually hard to break And you can run your finger down and you can zip an unzip it and and and and there's just nothing else in nature like that I mean our hair is you know pretty simple compared to to feathers maybe sometime in the future a hundred million years from now some mammal will change a simple hair and it'll branch out and it'll become something like a feather but you know that's never happened in anything other than dinosaurs and birds and and what that means is that birds have this this super structure that they use of course to make their wings to fly but also those wings can protect the babies in the nest and those wings can be used for display but birds also use feathers to keep warm they use feathers to waterproof themselves so feathers are really Swiss army knives they have lots of different functions and if you find a feather today if you see a feather just fluttering in the breeze I mean you know a bird was there there's just nothing else that has anything that looks like a feather it is the calling card of birds but what the fossil record tells us and what we've learned from paleontology something we would never know if we just look at the world around us today and that is that many dinosaurs have feathers too and feathers are actually a dinosaur feature that modern birds of inheritance you know I feel like I'm always shopping for other people I'll be out and about and see a cool piece of art that will look great on my friends wall or a dish where I said for my mom that I know she'd love and that I might even like to inherit but you know I never really treated myself until I lost my favorite sunglasses that's what I got myself a gift that I actually needed a new pair of classic brow line prescription sunglasses from Zeni Zeni is an online eyewear shop with stylish prescription glasses sunglasses and customizable lens options and prices that make it easy to treat yourself and your loved ones you go to Zeni.com pick a frame enter the prescription or grab a gift card and Zeni will ship right to your door and if you're as picky as I am Zeni even has a virtual try-on so you can see how a frame will look before you buy so it doesn't feel like a shot in the dark with over 150,000 five star reviews chances are you're going to love them I decided to switch it up for my usual sunglasses style and I was shot at just how customizable my new frames were there were at least five different lens colors to choose from and I landed on green because you know what if I'm treating myself I'm going to go bold so give the gift of Zeni this holiday season glasses sunglasses whatever they need go to Zeni.com/podcast and use code podcast 15 for 15% off plus free shipping over $65 style sell out so don't wait that's ZEN and i.com/podcast promo code podcast 15 Zeni.com/podcast code podcast 15 tell me about bird song that is we've done flight we done feathers uh bird song one of the last most important features of birds uh is i mean we're dinosaurs singing to each other how did outed bird song evolve it's a great question it's it's a difficult question to answer about how bird song evolved because of course we know modern birds are capable of such incredible ranges of sounds all the the tweets and the squawks and the cracks and the chirps and all the different things birds can do um and they're complex and they communicate and they change over time and they do and some birds as you say you know the songs the actual songs you know so not a duck clacking or whatever but and songs of songbirds these are in some ways similar to language they're not you know quite the same as human language but there are similarities and there's similarities in the brain of birds as as these songbirds are singing and some of these birds learn these songs i mean it is called vocal learning and they actually learn these songs similar to how we learn language as a child these birds start off in the nest making sounds try and to talk they babble basically there's this bird version of babbling kind of like what uh what an infant does um and then they get better and better they and they're taught some of these birds they actually learn from a tutor and and they perfect these songs that is i mean that requires great brain power and birds are smart i mean it's so birds have a better reputation bird brain you know this was an insult remember back on the playground the dumb insult it's more insulting to the birds themselves than any person being called a bird brain um birds are super smart birds have you know their brains are small because both birds are small yeah i mean i don't know how many you know pigeon brains could fit inside of our brain are hundred i don't know but compared to their body size birds have brains that are basically in the mammal zone you know brain to body size and that's what's more important for intelligence and that's what helps to underpin all this great diversity of sound that and that searing where the throat meets meets the lung this set of cartilage structures powered by fast twitching muscles that allow birds to make lots of sound so we know modern birds can do this the question as you pose is when did this evolve it's tricky because i mean it's not like there's some cretaceous cassette tape out there that we can find in the fossil record so we can look at the structure of the throat we can see if any of those structures you know are preserved a voice box or or what have you but um they're not made of bone so they don't fossilize as easily but the bird searing is made of quite strong cartilage and cartilage often can fossilize and so there actually is a fossil of a bird from antarctica from the end of the cretaceous period it was living at the same time as t-rex as the bird called the gavis and it has that cartilage voice box preserved and so we know that at least by the end of the age of dinosaurs there were true proper birds living alongside t-rex alongside triceratops that not only were proper birds in the sense that they had big wings of feathers and that they could fly not only did they have beaks not only could did they grow fast and reproduce fast and not only were they warm blooded in the way that modern birds are but they also could make sounds like modern birds but we need to find now are more fossil examples of this searing structure and it would be wild if somebody found one and say a t-rex or something like that that would be a revolutionary discovery and we just don't know we don't know until somebody finds them you know they might be out there and is is the fact that bird song you know changes over time that they learn it from each other is this unique in any way because I often think of you know for a while I thought of you know humanity one of the things that distinguishes as a species as a species is that we have culture right and that culture changes faster than evolution and so our behavior changes faster than biological evolution I use the thing that was unique until I started learning about bird song and how quickly bird you know you can listen to a recording of a bird song from 30 years ago that sounds different than the song today right yeah and so this now this gets in the realm of stuff that I'm not an expert on I must say you know once you get into the detailed behaviors of modern birds but yeah that's my understanding of it and there are you know scientists that do study cognition in birds my colleagues I work with a team because we're working together to try to understand how cognition and intelligence have evolved over time so my colleagues Mattias Osvath and Helena Osvath and Sweden there another husband wife power couple they have a raven enclosure on their farm outside a lune and they do these different tests with the ravens in that enclosure they put a mirror in front of them they hide food they they play games on they see how the ravens respond and and these birds are incredibly smart and and you know I also work with with neurobiologists who study the neurons and the brains of modern birds you know those actual the computer chips basically yeah you know that power cognition so we're learning a lot more about this and there are some of these folks that study modern birds that do you know argue that there are aspects of culture and you know how that maps with human culture that's where I'm out of my depth but you are right that that I mean there is of course you know Darwinian natural selection in birds and we see that as we talked about earlier on the Galapagos in real time but there's also something that's not really as genetic it's not really written into the genes it's more of this cultural evolution with the songs and in fact even on the Galapagos the the grant you know they they've taped these birds they made recordings they've studied their songs and they've seen how little changes in bird song relate to mating to mating success they've even seen how there was a new hybrid that was formed by two species of different finches just randomly mating and having a viable offspring and that those babies they sang in a weird way that didn't quite match either parent then those babies started reproducing with each other and now like 40 years later 50 years later or so there's a whole group of finches that's just that bloodline they started out as this hybrid they've only bred with each other they sing a unique song that nothing else sings and so basically that's a new species so a new species they've witnessed a new species a new reproductively isolated bloodline forming wow the songs and really the more kind of cultural you know way that these songs change was a key part of that new species emerging that's really fascinating and what what purpose do bird songs serve evolutionarily what is the evolutionary or natural selection pressure that is operating on bird song these are you know again these are things I don't know a huge amount about but birds use their songs to communicate with each other they they use their songs to attract mates you know to to show off their evolutionary fitness and they they use their songs I think you know it not the same way as a [BLANK_AUDIO] in language but I mean they are talking to each other in a sense they're communicating and I think anything especially that promotes reproduction you know ever more rich baroque intricate melodious songs is probably something that can promote reproduction and therefore that's the way that that can then be passed on. How much of that is genetic and how much of that is learned is something I don't know a huge amount about but I think it's both I mean there's like a genetic underpinning to birdsong the same way we have a genetic underpinning that allows us to have the capability to learn languages but of course what language is spoken at home or a kid you know that's sort of thing that nurture aspect is a big part of it too so I think with with bird song there is a nature component and a nurture component. Yeah it's it's another way that birds if you want to say birds are intelligent and similar to humans or a similarly intelligent in a lot of ways bird song is really an example because I can't think of many other groups of animals other than birds and humans that are constantly making noise in order to communicate right we're blah blah blah birds are cheap cheap and we'll you know wolves howl but they do it you know every once in a while it's not the same you're yeah you're right I mean the soundtrack of the world once you get out of this what's the city's basically yes although you sense it in the cities too but the soundtrack of the world really is the sound of birds yes there's insects make sounds a lot of insects are quite you know vocal they're doing it a different way than birds too but when when you're out in the country out away from the cities and the bird song goes quiet you notice it really notice it or you know we saw recently there was the eclipse here in Scotland where he had nearly the total eclipse and as you know the the moon went across the sun and we had like 95 percent you know or whatever near totality I mean the bird stopped yeah you know they sent something was weird and they stopped and and then and then immediately we senseless whoa it's so quiet so still the birds have stopped chirping and squawking and tweeting and clacking and singing and honking and yeah and so it is it's just such a part of being a bird it is are those vocalizations and it is really tempting for me I mean I don't know when it's tempting for me to think of some of these at least raptor dinosaurs is maybe being similar just being just chatterboxes yeah I was just constantly chattering about making themselves heard making themselves known I mean they were hunters so they probably wouldn't want to give themselves away but to communicate with each other and you know if they were living in packs and stuff so I think it's a very evocative you know thing to think about to have the sounds in your head of raptor dinosaurs squawking at each other right yeah just like making a little working as a pack or or letting each other know where they are in terms of after flight evolved right we do have flightless birds is this a matter of those birds never evolving flight or was it you know what do we have birds that flew and then you know they then lose the power of flight yeah that's a great question because there are birds today that don't do that most birdie thing and that is there are birds that don't fly ostriches emused cassowaries are some of the prime examples but penguins are another you know they don't fly through the air they use their wings as flippers to move through the water and there's many other birds that don't fly as well and there's a lot of fossil birds birds that recently went extinct that didn't fly a lot of these birds lived on islands and they went extinct quite quickly when humans came and colonized these islands these birds all had ancestors that could fly they gave up flight we see that in the hallmarks of their skeleton we actually see their bones we can tell there's the remnant you know of flight there's that ancient echo of when they were flying just like the shape of the breastbone where the flight muscles attach and the way the feathers attach to the arms and so on so it's not like these are primitive holdovers from the dinosaur age that never crossed the threshold of flight they had ancestors of flu which meant that they gave up flight which might seem crazy it's like okay birds fly why would you stop flying but flying is expensive it takes a huge amount of energy huge amount of food huge amount of oxygen to power those muscles to flap the wings and so if you're a bird and you're living in a place where you don't really need to fly maybe there's no predators maybe your food is all on the ground a lot of birds just don't fly very much and over evolutionary time you can see how natural selection would you know maybe take away the ability to fly all together so there there've been hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of birds that have given up flight and there's many still around us today some birds probably did it for those reasons they didn't need to fly so they just gave it up other birds like the ostriches and the emus it seems like they gave up flight their family line gave up flight soon after the asteroid that killed the other dinosaurs and it seems like what probably happened was all these classic canonical dinosaurs died out T-Rex gone triceratops gone the duck build dinosaurs gone the long neck dinosaurs gone so there were all these jobs open at the top of the food chain and mammals filled a lot of those jobs a lot of mammals got bigger and filled those roles but in some places birds supersize themselves to fill those roles to become the top predators the top plant leaders and the bigger you get the harder it is to fly you know it's one thing if you're an airplane and you have a fixed wing with an engine but if you are flapping wings wings that you have to maintain wings that you don't want to break wings that have to be powered by muscles on your chest there's going to be a limit and the physics to say there is a limit you know it's something like maybe around you know 20-foot wingspan or something like that even that's very difficult so some of these birds gave up flight probably as a trade-off so they could get bigger to fill some of these ecological niches left behind by the big dinosaur right okay so when you bring up ostriches this the dinosaur connection really makes sense to me because this is a large animal and so maybe there's a bird flapping around dinosaurs are wiped out and then you know the this one species or group of birds fills that niche comes back down to the ground becomes super sized I can see the connection between an ostrich and you know what might have been a dinosaur prior to the asteroids yeah and by the way it was blows my mind that the asteroid thing was real because that's part of that's part of the 90s story of the dinosaurs that happens to the dinosaur sitcom here comes the asteroid and it just seems like well that can't have literally happen but it literally a big asteroid hits the man just tell me I've heard the story on I think we talked about the last time you were on the show but just give it to me one more time so I remember it yeah I mean it's the most bombastic story it's like a bad disaster movie you know and it's so in a way it's almost like kitschy you know and so hyperbolic it doesn't seem real but you know this was the biggest asteroid that's hit the earth in the last half a billion years this was not a normal day but literally one day 66 million years ago this six mile wide rock fell out of the sky and really it didn't fall out of the sky it was moving like 10 times faster than a speeding bullet or more than so it was shot from the sky and it smashed into what's now the Gulf of Mexico and it impacted with such force it released more energy than a billion nuclear bombs well yes and it punched a hole in the face of the earth a crater over a hundred miles wide most of it's covered by the water of the Gulf but you can still see the trace of some of it on land in Mexico near cancun today and we have in the the record the geological record of the rocks that formed after the asteroid we have the evidence of huge tsunamis you know massive tsunamis that carved up the world's ocean we have evidence of wildfires over much of the world all this charcoal and burnt wood all over the world we have evidence of acid rain and so we have evidence of this complete breakdown of ecosystems and 75% of species that were there right before didn't make it across so if you were alive back then you know it's a gun it's four chambers that there's three bullets those are your odds some mammals survived we had ancestors that stared down the asteroid because our mammal ancestors were small they could burrow away hide away easily they could eat lots of different foods some bird survived and why do those birds survived well a lot of birds didn't first of all a lot of birds did die there were still birds that had teeth and had big claws on their hands birds that really looked like rapture dinosaurs that were still around the day the asteroid hit they didn't make it through the only ones that made it through were the modern style birds that had beaks instead of teeth that had huge wings and big muscles so they could fly really well they grew super fast so they could go from a hatchling into an adult within a few weeks or months so that comes in handy if the world's gone to hell around you if you can grow up really quickly and just get through childhood that helps have with those beaks probably helped too because a lot of times when ecosystems collapse like a volcano obliterates an island the last thing that survives that edible are seeds and that's how plants start to regrow so if you could eat seeds it wouldn't get you through forever but it would be a get out of jail free card at least for a little bit of time so that's probably why some modern bird survived and then when they survived you know, there wasn't another asteroid that followed. So the earth healed and the earth started to heal quite quickly. And now these birds were in a new world where all these other dinosaurs were gone and they had abundant opportunities. I'm sort of imagining they asteroid hits and there's so many ecological niches that no longer exist because the world changes in a day, right? But the few that do still exist, certain bugs, certain birds, they end up being the seed that becomes all the species that come afterwards. I know we have to let you go in a second. So I want to, I'll just leave on this last question if that's okay. Of course. I can talk forever. I have to take my son to his Boy Scouts. I know. And I did listen to you talk forever. So I do it again. Well, every time I have a book to hawk, I promise you. I would love to have you back any time. Can I ask you one last question around the course? Of course. So I think of the asteroid. I mean, what a massive, you know, we're talking to scales of hundreds of millions of years that evolution happened on suddenly there's a massive change on one day. Yeah. Yeah. The only thing I could think of happening to the earth that quickly that changes the ecology of the planet is humanity itself, right? Because we've done, we've changed so much in a couple thousand years. That's basically a day and an evolutionary time scale. That's right. So tell me about how evolution is happening to birds today and how humans are affecting it. Birds are in a perilous state. They're probably the most perilous state. They've been in sense. They stare down that asteroid. Well, no. And there have been a lot of birds that have been going extinct. But what's even more worrying is just the loss of standing diversity of birds, the raw number of birds over the last like 50 or 60 years in North America. There's been a loss of like billions of birds. Yeah. So if we could go back in time to, you know, those glory days of the 1950s, everybody wants to remember, which of course weren't as glorious as everybody thinks. But there would have been a lot more birds. There would have been billions of more birds. I read once we lost a third of birds. Yeah. Yeah. That's it. A third of the standing diversity is gone. It's not a third of species of gone extinct. No, it's like a third of the sparrows are no longer here. There used to be, you know, whatever, you know, 300 million sparrows. Now there's only 200 million or something like that. I mean, those these are big numbers. And it's because of us. It's because of climate change. It's because of pesticides. It's because of how we've cleared a lot of land for agriculture for our cities. It's just the number of humans putting pressure on birds. And so it's not it's not great. But what I what I'll say is that birds are resilient. Birds survive that asteroid. Birds are adaptable. We've seen with the work of the grandson, the Galapagos, how birds continue to evolve as the climate changes around them. So and that's in real time, you know, so birds are able to get through this. I think we will lose more species probably, especially if we don't change our land use practices. And we don't mitigate climate change. But I'm more confident that birds are going to survive this better than we are. We as a species are so used to this particular world, this particular climate. Birds have been through a lot of this stuff before. So I'm hopeful that birds have a bright future, but again, they are under real threat. And that's a sad thing to see because, you know, they've been around for a hundred and fifty million years. They are real true dinosaurs, the last sions of the dinosaur empire. And it is a shame, of course, anything that we're doing to them that affects them. Well, that is a really sobering thought, the idea that we are the next asteroid. And the birds might make it through the asteroid better than we ourselves will. Well, Steve, I'll let you go. I can't think of it for being here. The name of the book is The Story of Birds. Folks can of course pick up a copy at our special bookshop FaxiallyPod.com/books. Where else can people find you? And what if you have a call to action to folks for the for the very end, what is it? Yes. So you can find me online pretty easily. I'm on most of the social media platforms. I'm University of Edinburgh's where I teach here in Scotland. I'm a professor here. So I'm University website. Look me up. I'm easy to find. If you read my books, please do get in touch. I love hearing from readers. Even if you have some feedback that's, you know, maybe not the most positive. It's all right. Get in touch. I just love it that people read the books. And, you know, last words of wisdom, I'll just say, I don't know. I don't think I'm particularly wise, but two things. I'll say, birds are adaptable and resilient. I have great faith that birds will continue despite everything we're throwing at them. But one thing we can do, keep your cats inside the house. Yes. The biggest number of birds that die every year of kind of unnatural causes are from cats, billions. Yeah. So put your cats in. I'm not saying get rid of your cats. No, no, no, but just don't let them eat all of these or, you know, kill all of these birds, especially baby birds. Steve, you're speaking my language. Thank you so much for being here. Thank you. Well, have you back soon. My pleasure. Thanks Adam. Always, always a joy. Well, thank you again to Steve for coming on the show. If you want to pick up a copy of his new book, the story of birds, a new history from their dinosaur origins to the present, you can do so factuallypod.com/books. Every book you buy there, I'm not just his, but any book you buy from that link will support not just this show, but your local bookstore as well. If you'd like to support the show directly, again, that URL, patreon.com/addomconover. Five bucks a month gets you bonus podcast episodes. Every episode of this show, add free. You can join our online community, our online book club. Please consider it. It's a lot of fun hanging out on the internet with all you guys. But if you want to support the show at a higher level, I'll read your name in the damn credits this week. I want to thank Henry Crawford, Melissa, Aaron Stark, Shell B. Drill. That's a Pokemon name, Agent FVMF, Dakota Tevis, Virginia Beckinbauer, and Rebecca Champa. Thank you so much for listening. If you want me to read your name or silly username at the end of the show, once again, that URL patreon.com/addomconover. And of course, go to Adamconover.net for all my tour dates and check out big divorce energy out on YouTube now. I want to thank my producers, Sam Roudman, Tony Wilson, Maddie Schmidt, everybody here in Headgun for making the show possible. And we'll see you next time on Factually.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Birds are descendants of dinosaurs, sharing a common evolutionary lineage despite appearing vastly different.
  2. Feathers evolved first in dinosaurs for insulation, not flight, and were later modified into wings for flight.
  3. Flight in birds evolved gradually through natural selection, starting with display structures in small raptor dinosaurs.
  4. Feathers are a unique biological innovation, made of hollow, protein-based structures that serve multiple functions including warmth, waterproofing, and display.
  5. Bird song evolved as a complex form of communication, influenced by both genetics and learning, playing a key role in mating and species formation.
  6. Some birds, like ostriches and penguins, lost the ability to fly due to environmental changes and reduced energetic demands.
  7. The fossil record shows that many dinosaurs had feathers and exhibited bird-like behaviors, such as nest protection.
  8. Public perception of dinosaurs has been shaped by outdated 19th-century art, but modern paleontology reveals they were far more bird-like than previously imagined.

Summary:

Birds are not just fascinating animals—they are direct descendants of dinosaurs, evolving from small, feathered dinosaur ancestors over hundreds of millions of years. Feathers first appeared for insulation, later transforming into wings that enabled flight, a rare ability in the animal kingdom. Flight evolved gradually, likely as a byproduct of elaborate display structures in small raptors, eventually giving rise to modern birds through natural selection.

Birds possess incredibly complex, multifunctional feathers and advanced vocal organs, allowing them to sing in intricate, learned ways that mirror human language in some aspects. These songs serve key evolutionary roles in mate attraction and social communication, and scientific studies show that bird song can even lead to the formation of new species through cultural evolution. Despite their aerial prowess, many birds have lost the ability to fly—such as ostriches and penguins—due to environmental shifts and reduced need for flight.

The misconception that dinosaurs were reptilian and scale-covered stems from outdated art and limited fossil evidence; modern discoveries in China and Mongolia have revealed feathered dinosaurs with bird-like behaviors, reshaping how we view dinosaur evolution. This conversation highlights not only the scientific marvel of bird evolution but also the deep human connection to birds—through their beauty, flight, and songs—offering a moment of wonder amid global crises.

FAQs

Yes, birds are descendants of dinosaurs. They evolved from small, feathered dinosaurs, particularly within the group of theropods like theropod dinosaurs. This evolutionary link is supported by fossil evidence showing birds share key anatomical features with dinosaurs, such as hip structure and lightweight skeletons.

Fossil discoveries, especially in China, have revealed dinosaurs with feathers that are remarkably similar to bird feathers. These fossils show that many dinosaurs had simple feathers for insulation, and over time, these feathers evolved into complex wing structures used for flight. The transitional fossils bridge the gap between ground-dwelling dinosaurs and flying birds.

Yes, many dinosaurs had feathers, especially small theropods like Velociraptor. Feathers first evolved for insulation and display, not flight. Over time, as dinosaurs grew smaller and their feathers became denser and more structured, they developed wing-like feathers that eventually allowed flight in some species.

Flight evolved gradually through natural selection. Small dinosaurs with display feathers on their limbs likely gained a slight advantage by moving slightly in the air. As these wings grew longer and more effective, even minor movements created lift and thrust. Over millions of years, this led to improved flight capabilities, eventually resulting in modern birds.

Birds have a high degree of color variation because they can see in full color, unlike most mammals. Their vibrant plumage and complex songs are used for mating displays, attracting partners, and intimidating rivals. This led to intense evolutionary pressure to develop bright, elaborate features for reproductive success.

Yes, birds sing using a specialized vocal organ called the syrinx. Bird song evolved as a form of communication for mating and territorial defense. Modern birds learn songs from adult tutors, blending genetic predisposition with environmental influence. This cultural learning is unique and shows birds possess advanced cognitive abilities.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.