Go back

Wife’s ‘Accidental’ Death Hides Disturbing Murder Plot: Police

30m

Wife’s ‘Accidental’ Death Hides Disturbing Murder Plot: Police

Ben Carpenter, a widower from West Alice, Wisconsin, publicly described the tragic death of his wife Erica as an accident caused by a fall in the basement. However, over two years of investigation have uncovered a pattern of deception that points to premeditated homicide. Texts reveal Erica repeatedly questioned the substance in Ben’s water, and Ben allegedly suggested she research sleep aids—indicating a plan to induce overdose. Google searches for topics like "watching someone you love die" and "crushing pills" were found on Ben’s devices, showing intent. Surveillance captured him with a new girlfriend, and he was seen inviting her to a haunted house just days after her death. Medical evidence shows significant blunt force trauma and sedative intoxication, with no medical cause for her collapse. The autopsy found no skull fracture, and the injuries are inconsistent with a fall. Ben’s story contradicts witness accounts, including his son, who said Erica appeared only mildly ill and that Ben removed her photos shortly after her death. Police discovered he collected over $230,000 in life insurance and GoFundMe funds. These inconsistencies, combined with deleted texts and suspicious behavior, led investigators to conclude he planned her death. Despite the death certificate listing the cause as undetermined, the medical examiner deemed the manner of death highly suspicious. Ben was arrested in early 2025 and charged with first-degree intentional homicide, with prosecutors arguing he lied repeatedly and orchestrated a scheme to cover up his actions. The case highlights deep inconsistencies in Ben’s narrative and strong evidence of planning, suggesting a deliberate act rather than an accident.

Transcription

5939 Words, 31924 Characters

English
He called himself a widower, a husband devastated by the sudden loss of his wife and what he described as a tragic accident. He took to social media, writing about sleepless nights and urging others to hold their loved ones close. Because as he warned, you never know when tragedy might strike. But behind the posts of heartbreak and grief, police say there was a very different story unfolding. More than two years after his wife's death, investigators now allege, it wasn't an accident at all. And the man who publicly portrayed himself as a grieving widower is now accused of orchestrating her murder. We're taking you inside the evidence, including newly revealed text messages and Google searches that investigators say expose a chilling plan when they allege was set in motion weeks before his wife was killed. We're on the case presented by Lawncrime, I'm Chris Stewart. In 2024, Ben Carpenter of West Alice, Wisconsin posted lyrics by the singer, Jelly Roll, when he talked about his wife, who had passed away and those lyrics were, I'm not okay, but it's going to be all right. Ben posted those lyrics just four days after his wife, Erica, had died and he also posted a link to a GoFundMe page that reportedly raised more than $20,000. Today, GoFundMe has taken that page down and Ben is in jail. He is facing a charge of first degree intentional homicide and his mugshot shocked those who know him in West Alice. It's a suburb next to Milwaukee for more than two years, Ben's wife has been dead. Her name was Erica Carpenter, the two of them had been together for 17 years. They had a son and the Carpenter is lived in this home on 95th Street in West Alice, but inside that home on October 13th, 2024, Ben called 911 at 1038 at night, according to police, something had happened to Erica. Please say when they got to the house, it was three minutes after the 911 call and they found Ben doing CPR on his wife, they say that she was on the floor at the bottom of the stairs in their basement and her face was blue. Ben allegedly told police that they had been out in Milwaukee the night before they went to a birthday party and then to a casino, but they came home early because Erica wasn't feeling well. In the next morning, she felt worse. She was dizzy. She took four naps in just one day. She had trouble breathing. This is all according to her husband, Ben, Ben also said that he didn't know what was wrong said his wife didn't have any serious medical conditions. She knew of other than high blood pressure on the night that Erica died, Ben said they were in the basement. They were doing laundry and Erica collapsed. Ben said Erica was still breathing. So he tried to carry his wife up the stairs. He thought she was just sleeping. He said so he was going to bring her to a bedroom. He said as he was going up the stairs, his foot slipped and they both went crashing down the stairs and he claims that his wife hit her head. Ben believed that Erica passed out around 10 o'clock. Authorities didn't get to the house until about 1038. The sound of Erica's body hitting the floor, Ben said was such a loud thud that a woke up their son who was sleeping upstairs. Erica was rushed to the hospital and the next day, Ben took to social media to explain that she had passed away. He said quote, there's no easy way to get this out. So here's my best attempt. This time yesterday morning, I picked up breakfast and we started a day of relaxing at home. Erica felt ill early on took several naps and declined throughout the day. Last night, she crashed on the floor in our basement around 10. She was rushed to the hospital where they did everything they could to save her. Early this morning, alongside my family and many of our close friends, I had to make the most difficult decision of my life. I had to end her suffering and we had to let her go today. I left the hospital with her wedding ring in a cup and a vial containing a printout of her last heartbeat yesterday started a lot better. She was my wife, my friend mom to the name of her child family to many that knew her and a friend to countless others. She will be missed by everyone that knew her. Life can be many things, but cut short is never one you anticipate hug your family, call your current and old friends and don't be shy to tell them you love them. With that announcement, he posted the picture of Erica's ring and the vial with the printout of her last heartbeat. Ben would continue to post about the community support that he received in the days that followed. He was blown away by it. He was a jujitsu fighter and he trained at a local martial arts studio. Police had been come in for an interview. Ben told police that he believed Erica had eight drinks during their day on the town before they went home early because he said Erica felt sick. Police say they also talked to a witness who's identified as BP in court records and that witness told them that Erica seemed happy and dancing when they were at the casino. She didn't appear sick. Police asked Ben about his marriage to Erica. How was it? What issues did they have? And Ben said there were no really issues or concerns at least in the day leading up to her death. They had their disagreements. The most recent one he allegedly said was two days before she died and it was about their sex life. There was also an interesting line in the criminal complaint that I want to show you when police asked Ben to describe his relationship with his wife. He allegedly said it's good with a short pause. Police note Ben said that they had been together for so long that there really wasn't anything out of the ordinary as far as any issues that they had they had been together for 17 years he said. Ben also told police that they could search his phone and Erica's phone and he told them that he hadn't deleted any messages from Erica's phone in the 24 hours leading up to her death. Remember that we'll talk about that here in just a moment. I also want to note what Ben allegedly told the medical examiner who conducted Erica's autopsy. He said when he and Erica fell down the stairs and she hit her head against the wall. It was on the left side. He said before they fell Ben had his hands on Erica's upper chest area just below her neck. He also allegedly said when they fell he moved his right arm upward to try and protect her head but could only get his hand to the bottom of her left jaw. He claimed his forearm would have been against the left side of Erica's neck now this investigation went on for months and as it continued friends and family mourned Erica. A little less than two weeks after she died she was laid to rest or obituary says that she loved the outdoors crafts and she was survived by her loving husband then carpenter but then an unexpected twist and please say it all began with an anonymous tip. One that would turn the entire case on its head a couple days before Erica's funeral a person who in court records is identified as J L J contacted police in West Alice and they said they had seen Ben with another woman at a bar just two days before Erica's death. J L J said that they actually struck up the conversation with Ben and this woman and the woman said that Ben was going through a divorce and his wife was aware of it. There's another person at the bar who said that Ben was going to tell his wife about this divorce and that Erica knew that he was seeing another woman. Now certainly moving on and for as bad as it may be having an affair it's not illegal but that story doesn't really line up with what police say Ben told them initially and on top of that J L J said the woman who is with Ben carpenter texted them three days after Erica died and it was an invitation to come with them. This woman and Ben to a haunted house and J L J said they thought it was odd that they were going out and this kind of excursion considering Erica had died less than a week ago on November 16th 2024. So just about a month after Erica died a charity pub crawl was held in Erica's honor to help Ben and Ben posted about how grateful he was online for it. As that pub crawl was going on police say they did some surveillance and they ended up getting surveillance video from a bar that showed Ben with this woman who has identified as AMV and they say that Ben allegedly went up to this woman and quote placed his hand around her waist and butt area days after that November 22nd 2024 40 days after his wife died. Ben went Facebook official with another woman according to the criminal complaint police spoke to several people who came in touch with Ben after his wife died and they alleged that the story that he told police was different than what he was saying publicly one person told officers that Ben allegedly said his wife got the flu shot in the days leading up to her death and that might have been the reason that she passed away. He also allegedly said that she died of something heart related. Please say at the time of that conversation there was no cause of death that had been reached police also found that on October 30th so two weeks after Erica died Ben allegedly went to a Jared Jewelers and told employees that his wife had died from complications of a flu shot and he was there shopping for an engagement ring for his new girlfriend. Police say they have records that show Ben allegedly bought a diamond bracelet for more than $3,700 just three days after Erica's funeral two days after that he allegedly contacted his insurance company claiming he couldn't make his mortgage or car insurance bills due to the cost of his wife's funeral expenses. Ben also allegedly told his friend he had been seeing this new woman identified as AMV for the past six months he said Erica knew about AMV and that the carpenters had been planning to get a divorce for the past two and a half years but the only reason they were still together. was their child. He said they slept in different rooms. This friend also noted that a lot of people in their circle who were friends with Ben and Erica found it really odd that Ben had a new girlfriend less than two months after his wife died. On December 18th, 2024, police interviewed Ben again. They say that they found that Erica had hydrocodone in her system when she died, which is an opioid painkiller. Ben said that Erica had a prescription for that. He also allegedly admitted to police that he was seeing this other woman. Police say that he claimed that he had been hanging out with AMV for about two to three months prior to Erica's death. And he claims that it wasn't a relationship. They didn't put that label on it because, quote, AMV pushed Ben away and did not want to date him until he got a divorce. So it seems that police think that as long as Erica was in the picture, Ben was not going to start his new life with this other woman. Ben also collected a good amount of money in the wake of Erica's death according to police. They alleged that he collected as much as $230,000 in life insurance money through Erica's work. He also said the couple had a joint life insurance policy for $350,000 that he had not been given at that point. On top of that, he collected six grand from the pub crawl police say in more than $22,000 through that GoFundMe page. Police would later find that Ben reached out to the county medical examiner's office to get a letter sent to the insurance company in hopes that he could get that life insurance payout. Ben was telling police that his marriage was on the rocks before Erica's death, but police know in the interviews that they did with friends of the couple. That's not what the friends saw or heard from Ben or Erica. One friend told police that they learned about the mistress three weeks before Erica's death. Ben allegedly showed them actually a naked picture of this woman. The friend also said that Ben told them that they were planning to get a divorce and his plan was allegedly, he was going to ask Erica for a divorce on October 15th, which would have been three days after Erica died. Now you can see how this looks bad for Ben. It just looks sketchy at least. The story is just not lining up. His description of the marriage doesn't match what people say. They knew about this couple and then you have January 2025. The autopsy results come back and this will be critical as this case moves forward. The final autopsy found injuries ranging from fluid build-up in Erica's lungs and what appeared to be pneumonia and it also found blunt force trauma to Erica's neck and head. There was no fracture to her skull, the medical examiner notes. The toxicology test showed multiple potent prescription sedatives in her system at the time that she died. The doctor who did the autopsy told police that Erica's injuries may be the result of asphyxia and he considered her death highly suspicious. He also said the hydrocodone and Erica system may have also led to her death. Another doctor found that the pneumonia in her system was not severe enough to cause Erica to pass out. Now as we said, Ben was a jujitsu fighter. He was a black belt and he told police that he knew multiple kinds of chokeholds but wasn't aware of any that would leave significant marks on an opponent. Friends also say that Ben allegedly was not exactly the smiley figure we see in pictures all the time. Friends say in 2011 he allegedly strangled Erica and they nearly broke up after that but Erica eventually brought him back in. When Ben spoke to the medical examiner, he said that Erica's injuries may have happened because his forearm was across Erica's neck when they fell. Police say if that was true, Ben's arm would need to be across Erica's neck through the entire fall. The doctor said Ben's story did not add up according to the criminal complaint. So you can see that in early 2025, police were certainly suspicious of Ben's story and Erica's death. Then you have May and there appeared to be some major issues in Ben's new relationship. We're talking May 4th 2025. Police were called at 315 in the morning to Ben's house and he was asking for his new girlfriend to be removed from the home. Police say AMV claimed that Ben had put his hand around her neck and strangled her. Then in October 2025, more than a year after Erica's death, police say the same woman told an Uber driver that her boyfriend allegedly beat her. She told the driver if she were to die, quote, it was him who did it. Eventually, police got the results of a search warrant for Ben's Google account and cell phone and what they found was revealing. They say that on September 19th, 2024, less than a month before Erica died, Ben searched allegedly, quote, watching someone you love die on the day Erica died. Ben allegedly searched. Can I crush pills and take them in water? He also allegedly searched the names of the detectives who were on his case. Now you compare those searches to the text messages that police say they found between Erica and Ben in September, Erica texted her husband and what the F have you been doing to my water the past few days? Ben replied your water. And Erica allegedly said, yes, my water, there's been powdery S word in it at least twice now. Ben replied, are you drinking mine? I use liquid IV always. Erica then said, that is not liquid IV. That is my cup. I don't know what you did with yours. Ben then says drip, drop liquid IV, whatever, I use both whatever I can reach. Roughly 10 days before Erica died, police also say they found this alleged text exchange that Erica had with Ben. It's a back and forth that they had roughly 10 days before she died and they're talking about sleep aids. Police alleged the text conversations you just saw were deleted from their phones, but police were able to recover them. And on top of that, police say they also found more Google searches that were allegedly deleted before Erica's death. On September 18th, Ben allegedly searched, losing someone, watching someone you love die and death of a loved one, quotes, poems and resources. Two of those searches, according to police, took place after Erica allegedly asked about her water. A key witness in the case will also be Erica and Ben's son. According to the criminal complaint, he's a high schooler. Police spoke with him a little more than a year after his mom died in October of 2025. Police say he told them that he thought his parents marriage was good that they would do things together. And on the day his mom died, he also said it didn't seem like she was that sick. It was like she had a common cold. So not the crippling illness that his dad allegedly told police that Erica had the son also said that just about a month after Erica died, Ben allegedly removed all the pictures of his wife from the house. He said that his dad's new girlfriend moved in in December of 2024. Police also spoke with firefighters who noted when they responded to Ben's call for help that they didn't find him to be "concerned upset or distraught" over the fact that his wife was dying and "carbender" appeared more upset about how he was being asked questions by both police and fire than he was about the CPR being performed on his wife or the fact she was dying. They also say that Ben claimed to the medical examiner that firefighters dropped Erica at the top of the stairs as they were carrying her and none of the firefighters say that happened. After nearly two years of investigating, this week police took Ben Carpenter into custody and on Wednesday, he made his first court appearance. This is per CBS 58 in Milwaukee. Ben Carpenter is now being held on a half million dollar cash bond and he is slated to be in court next on December 8th. The final line of the criminal complaint states, quote, "based on the above text conversations, it shows Benjamin Carpenter planned the death of Erica Carpenter within a month prior to the date she died on October 14th, 2024. Erica confronted Benjamin about putting powdery S word in her water and he asked her to research a sleep aid for both of them. The day Benjamin asked Erica to search for a sleep aid for them, she indicated she had a good night's sleep. Let's talk about this more. It's a retired detective commander of the Chicago Police Department, Will Svilar. One thing I want to note will is that the death certificate for Erica Carpenter listed her cause of death as undetermined. You know, you have the medical examiner saying it was highly suspicious. We have all this other evidence, but the fact that says undetermined. What does that tell you? Well, you know, here's the thing that I have with the death certificate. Undetermined, it's awfully hard to bring a charge of murder when you're saying it's a cause of death and the manner of death is undetermined. And there's the difference between the two is, and this is a matter I'm talking about the medical examiner's report, not necessarily the death certificate. The medical examiner's report is going to give you a cause of death. If they can determine it, acute opiate intoxication, blunt force trauma, gunshot wound, whatever the case may be, it's the manner of death is where you get your charge. And if the manner of the death is undetermined, it's hard to put a murder charge on somebody. It's been, I can't remember where we're doing it in 32 years under Chicago Police Department. There always had to be a determination of a man. It's interesting that it would be undetermined considering they have the blunt for it. You know, you have all the underlying injuries that she had, like the pneumonia, they say, did not match. It wasn't severe enough where it would have caused her to pass out. She had all these chemicals in her system. They say, you have the blunt force trauma to the neck. You have injuries to the head area. You have this fall that happened. And yet for it to be undetermined, you know, now he is charged with first degree intentional homicide. But the fact that it's took so long to get to this point. When you read through the criminal complaint, it's 17 pages, a ton of information, allegations in there. How strong of a case does it seem police and prosecutors have against this guy? - I think they got a great case. I think it's a dead bank case. Again, I don't really fully understand the, now I don't know if the medical examiner can go back in and make a determination, 'cause a lot of times we get, when you talk about those, she had drugs in her system, she had blood-force trauma, she had some strangulation, that can all be listed as the cause of death, contributing factors in the cause of death. You don't have to have one single cause of death. It could be a bunch of different factors. It's the manner of death. And all you have to really prove is the fact that she didn't put all these drugs in her system herself and she couldn't sustain these injuries the way they were described. And I think they did a great job in a complaint of approving that he didn't tell the truth when he was talking to the detectives. - As Erica Carpenter's parents reportedly talking about the cause or manner of death is undetermined on the death certificate. Per some of the local television stations in Milwaukee, this one, I'm just looking at WISN here. You look at the story that Ben Carpenter allegedly told police saying he had a good marriage said that his wife was feeling ill and it just seems like everybody who was around them is like, that's just not true. And then you have, or at least she seemed to be feeling okay and then you have people who are shocked to learn that the marriage was actually on its way out. Like it's not illegal to have an affair and it's not illegal after someone dies to move on to somebody else. But how does that factor into the case that prosecutors are making? - You know, it just shows a pattern of him being dishonest. If he's lying about one thing, what else is he lying about? He's dishonest with the police through the whole thing, obviously, because she didn't sustain the injuries, how he described it, you know, she wasn't sick, she wasn't, it's just a pattern of dishonesty. And then you put the, you can get into reconstructing the crime scene and say there's no way this happened this way. And again, and when you interview people, you're gonna interview everybody. You're not just gonna interview him, you're gonna interview family members and you're gonna interview, and I hate to say it, the kid, which I, another thing is he brought the kid into this early on like calling him over and I don't like that at all. You make your kid a witness to his mother's murder basically. And, but you're gonna interview everybody. You're gonna, you're gonna talk to her doctors if you need to to see if she has any kind of, you know, problems or she's prescribing any kind of drugs, the parents, the friends. And if you know about the girlfriend, you're gonna talk to her too. - Well, and I think on the note about the stairs. And, you know, so he tells the story, she passed out. You know, I thought it was weird where his wife passes out and then he's like, oh, she must be sleeping. So I'm gonna carry her up the stairs and take her to the bed where it just seems like if someone were to pass out. And according to him, she had high blood pressure. It's like not, it's like not like she was someone who regularly passed out. It just seems weird that in that moment, you wouldn't call 911, but I wasn't there. But what are the challenges when it comes to, 'cause following down the stairs, like you can have a heavy hit. Like, and he says it was a big thud when she fell. He's a big guy. They go down the stairs. Like how difficult is it to prove that someone may be the victim of a murder as opposed to being the victim of someone who slept and fell down the stairs? - Well, like I said, you're gonna do crime scene. You're gonna look at the entries. You're gonna see where there's a strike. Did she strike the back of her head? Was he on top of her? Did she fall down and strike the front of her head? What caused the most trauma? And usually when you get somebody falling down the stairs or falling down from a spot where you're gonna hit multiple things, you're gonna have more than one injury. You're gonna have other injuries consistent with falling down the stairs. Not necessarily consistent with a fall because sometimes the fall from my distance, it's just the initial impact. But when you went down the stairs, you're gonna hit some things like other stairs, maybe you're railing, maybe the wall. And another question is what kind of injuries did he have from falling down the stairs? - Yeah, and it didn't seem like they really talked much about that. I did find it interesting that they mentioned he's a black belt in Jiu-Jitsu. I mentioned that multiple times. And they talk about previous allegations. There's one that's back in 2011 where he allegedly strangled her. I don't know if this goes to trial. Are you able to talk about that in front of a jury? But at the same time, at least at this point where you're trying to get someone charged and accuse them of this crime, how important is it as you're putting together a narrative to add in like, hey, by the way, this is a guy who does a martial art where choking someone, anybody who watches MMA, like that's one of the things that they do in that martial art. And then on the other hand of it, this is a guy who is not the smiley person who's quote and jelly roll on Facebook all the time. People say that this is a guy who once strangled the woman who is now wound up dead. - So you know, when you talk about that kind of stuff, there's a thing called prior bad acts that you're really not supposed to talk about at trial because it'll influence the jury, it'll prejudice the jury. But you can talk, you can skirt around it, you can talk about there's been calls for service to the house alleging this. You know, if you talk about he's convicted of strangler before you really can't really say that 'cause you really can't put the prior bad acts in 'cause he's on trial for the murder, not for what he did, you know, the several years prior. So you gotta be careful. You can get it in through interview, which you have to be careful how you introduce it. You can talk, talk about calls for service to the house. You can certainly talk about his training at martial arts. And then you can bring an expert on it says, you know what, martial arts, this is common to do a chokehold in this manner. And if that matches any type of injuries on her neck, then you can get that in. - What do you make of the timeline? Like it took more than two years to bring Ben Carpenter in and charge him with this crime. Where it does seem like I mean in the beginning, I'm sure detectives just based off of what they were able in the first six months to piece together that they felt like they might have a case, but the fact that it took more than two years to actually take him in the custody. - I don't have a problem with it. I think that they were being very thorough. And if they had to overcome, if they had to overcome the medical examiner's report, if in fact the medical examiner's report says, whatever the causes and the matter is undetermined, you gotta build a hell of a case to overcome that. Because how do you charge murder? If it's not being called a murder by the person that did the post-mortem examination. And there's two things, two concepts. When you're working on a case, what do we know and what can we prove? And sometimes they start out like this and then maybe it takes two years to bring him together. So I don't really have a problem with the timeline. - I think it's interesting too. So it seems like the second interview gave, I think what he gave was in like December after his wife passes away. And then he called police related to an incident involving this new girlfriend who he had. I think in May of 2025. So it's like it's not like he was hiding from law enforcement. Like he was the one who allegedly called them. Do you think, and we don't know for sure, but do you think he knew that he was still under investigation? Just the way that he acted? Like would he have known in like cases you've done where it's like you're kind of in it for the long haul and figuring things out. They were doing surveillance on him at this bar crawl right after Eric had died. I mean, how likely was it that he knew that this was not a closed case? - I think that he knows what he did. And anytime you know what you did, you gotta be looking over your shoulder. I guarantee he's looking over shoulder. I don't know if he knew the extent of the surveillance or what they were doing. But if they're out there interviewing other people, the other people are probably gonna tell me, listen, the detectives came to me. We're talking about this and that. So I have a feeling he knew that he was under surveillance or not that, but he was a suspect possibly and they were still working it. Now, as it got farther and farther out, I'm sure he got more comfortable with, while they haven't come and got me yet. Maybe I got away with it. But he knows what he did. So I guarantee he was looking over his shoulder. - I also wonder too, I mean, these Google searches, like he said, he hadn't deleted anything from the phones or from his Google searches, but clearly there were some things that he searched that don't look good. How much does that factor into this? 'Cause I couldn't see a defense attorney say like, "Look, he likes liquid IV. He's an athlete. He does martial arts." You know, of course, you know, there's no proof that you have. She had a hydrocodone prescription at one point in time. Like, yeah, there were other sedatives in her body and I'm kind of playing devil's advocate here, but what did those messages and the fact that they were deleted according to police, how did those factor into this? - Well, you delete stuff for two reasons. When you're trying to free up space on your computer or whatever your device is and two, you're trying to hide what you did. Now, what people shouldn't know by now, if you don't know it already, you can't delete anything. You think you deleted it, but it's there. And this is why it took two years, Chris. This is why it took so long to bring this prosecution. Everything you just said as devil's advocate is something that the investigators think about. But we'll sit down around a table and say, "Okay, we got this in this. How can they impeach that? How can the defense attack our theory on this or our evidence in this?" So that's sometimes why it takes two years. We got prosecutors involved in. It's a lot that goes into a murder case like this. - Yeah, and we'll see what happens next. I mean, you just think of the work, you know, reading through this complaint. I mean, the work that investigators did, this was not a quick investigation and we'll see what other evidence they have against Ben Carpenter, shocking arrest. We'll reveal our retired detective with the Chicago Police Department. Always great to have you on long crime. You have your own podcast where can people find it? - We're on YouTube in Spotify. It's called Big City Crime Inside the Red Tape. And it's just four people with over 100 years of law enforcement experience. And we talk about crime scenes and current events and things that we've been out on from inside the red tape, meaning we're inside the crime scene. We were inside the crime scene. It's our perspective from that. And, you know, give us a listen. - Absolutely, always great perspective to have, especially in cases like this one, Will, thanks. - Anytime. - Ben Carpenter is innocent until proven guilty. We'll be keeping a close eye on this story as it continues to develop. That will do it for this episode of On the Case, presented by Law and Crime. I'm Chris Stewart. We'll see you next time. [BLANK_AUDIO]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Ben Carpenter, who publicly portrayed himself as a grieving widower after his wife Erica’s death, is now accused of orchestrating her murder, not an accidental fall.
  2. Investigators found conflicting evidence
  3. Google searches and text messages show Ben searched for topics like “watching someone you love die” and “crushing pills,” indicating he was planning her death weeks before it occurred.
  4. Surveillance footage and witness accounts show Ben was seen with another woman shortly after Erica’s death, and he allegedly invited her to a haunted house, which is inconsistent with his grief narrative.
  5. Medical evidence reveals blunt force trauma and sedative intoxication in Erica’s system, with no medical cause for her collapse, and her injuries do not align with a simple fall.
  6. Ben allegedly concealed his new relationship, removed photos of Erica, and collected over $230,000 in life insurance and charitable funds, raising suspicion of financial motive.
  7. A key witness, their son, stated Erica did not appear sick and that Ben removed her photos from the home shortly after her death.
  8. Police found inconsistencies in Ben’s statements to law enforcement and medical examiners, including false claims about the fall, her health, and the marriage’s stability, leading to his arrest on a first-degree intentional homicide charge.

Summary:

Ben Carpenter, a widower from West Alice, Wisconsin, publicly described the tragic death of his wife Erica as an accident caused by a fall in the basement. However, over two years of investigation have uncovered a pattern of deception that points to premeditated homicide. Texts reveal Erica repeatedly questioned the substance in Ben’s water, and Ben allegedly suggested she research sleep aids—indicating a plan to induce overdose.

Google searches for topics like "watching someone you love die" and "crushing pills" were found on Ben’s devices, showing intent. Surveillance captured him with a new girlfriend, and he was seen inviting her to a haunted house just days after her death. Medical evidence shows significant blunt force trauma and sedative intoxication, with no medical cause for her collapse.

The autopsy found no skull fracture, and the injuries are inconsistent with a fall. Ben’s story contradicts witness accounts, including his son, who said Erica appeared only mildly ill and that Ben removed her photos shortly after her death. Police discovered he collected over $230,000 in life insurance and GoFundMe funds.

These inconsistencies, combined with deleted texts and suspicious behavior, led investigators to conclude he planned her death. Despite the death certificate listing the cause as undetermined, the medical examiner deemed the manner of death highly suspicious. Ben was arrested in early 2025 and charged with first-degree intentional homicide, with prosecutors arguing he lied repeatedly and orchestrated a scheme to cover up his actions.

The case highlights deep inconsistencies in Ben’s narrative and strong evidence of planning, suggesting a deliberate act rather than an accident.

FAQs

Ben claimed his wife, Erica, died after collapsing in the basement during a fall while they were doing laundry, and that she had been feeling unwell and took several naps before passing out.

The autopsy found blunt force trauma to Erica's neck and head, signs of opioid intoxication, and pneumonia that wasn't severe enough to cause unconsciousness, which contradicts his claim that she simply fainted and fell.

Ben searched for phrases like 'watching someone you love die' and 'crushing pills and taking them in water' less than a month before Erica's death, suggesting premeditation.

Yes, investigators found evidence that Ben was seeing a woman named AMV for several months before Erica died, and she reported being strangled by him in May 2025.

He collected over $230,000 in life insurance, allegedly bought a $3,700 diamond bracelet, and raised over $22,000 via a GoFundMe page that was later removed.

Texts show Ben was giving Erica water with a powdery substance and asking her to research sleep aids, with her responding that she had noticed the substance in her water, indicating possible poisoning.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.