Why Young Women Are The Most Miserable They've Ever Been
1h 37m 11s
The speaker argues that the deep cultural and existential crises in the Western world are not political or economic, but philosophical—rooted in a fundamental denial of value and meaning. Science, while powerful, assumes a value-free world of dead matter, which is incompatible with human reality, where perception, attention, and action are shaped by values. Stories are not mere entertainment; they are the primary mechanism through which value is transmitted, internalized, and lived. Human beings naturally imitate narrative archetypes—such as the benevolent father or self-sacrificing hero—to form moral and social frameworks. When these narratives break down—such as in the reimagined Snow White where dwarfs are mocked or the "evil queen" narrative is distorted—people lose engagement, signaling that such stories reflect universal, deep-seated value structures. The speaker links this to the rise of pathological ideologies, like the "negative feminine" or envious, controlling older women, which harm both individuals and society. These distortions are evident in education and political discourse, where liberal ideologies promote nihilism and undermine natural life cycles. The core insight is that science and technology only function well when grounded in a proper value system—especially one oriented toward self-sacrifice, service, and upward growth. Without such a foundation, science risks misuse, society fractures, and human suffering intensifies. The solution lies not in rejecting science, but in reestablishing a narrative and value structure that reflects the deeper truths of human existence, such as love, service, and spiritual purpose. This reorientation is essential for restoring meaning, peace, and social harmony.
So, I want to talk to you tonight about something that's crazily difficult, and I haven't lectured about this specifically for about 10 years, so that's quite a long time.
So, I was trying to recall today, yesterday, what I need to remember so that I can make this clear, and it's a ridiculously important thing to make clear.
So, why does this have to be made clear?
Well, you can see that there's a fracture in the Western world. There's a fracture in the world as a whole, but it's particularly acute.
It's particularly acute in the Western world, and the reason for that is fundamental. It's not political, it's not economic, it's far deeper than that.
You can make a case, by definition, I suppose, that the deepest matters are religious matters, and I'm saying that as a matter of definition,
is that as you move down the hierarchy of depth towards. the abyss itself, you approach the domain of the religious. You approach the domain of what's ultimately significant.
And the culture war that we're embroiled in, in the West, that's tearing us apart, and demoralizing us, and encouraging us, tempting us,
to worship false idols, and to build towers of Babel, and to court the. court what? Court the fate of Sodom and Gomorrah,
and to tempt the flood. All of that's indicative of a problem that has made itself manifest at the most basic of levels.
And so, I want to describe. I want to try to lay out why I think that problem exists, and how it's conceptualized,
and then, I don't know if we'll get towards the conceptualize of a solution. Perhaps, in my discussion with Paggio, we'll do that.
But, I want to at least lay out the territory. And this is. because the problem's so deep, this is a very difficult thing to do.
And so. especially in 40 minutes. And so, we'll see how we. we'll see how we do.
Okay, so, the first thing you might ask yourself, and this is relevant to, say, Tammy's introduction, is:
"Why do stories play such an important role in human perception and communication?"
We find stories intrinsically compelling, so much so that we regard them as a form of entertainment.
And that reflects the fact that there's something about them that's so valuable and significant that participating in a story,
listening to a story, telling a story, reading a story, watching a movie, is intrinsically meaningful.
Right? And so that. and you can deride that as mere entertainment, and think about it as a side effect of some more fundamental psychological phenomena.
But that's a mistake. The reason it's. the reason the story is deeply meaningful is because it actually reflects, in a manner that no other form can,
something profound about the nature of reality itself,
and about our relationship to reality.
And so. and so, why is that? Why is that?
See, that's. that's. our failure to understand that is part of the reason that we're in this cultural crisis.
It's a failure of conceptualization that stretches all the way back to the dawn of science and the enlightenment itself.
And the. the problem is. The. the scientific world, this is a good way of thinking about it,
the scientific world is, by design, without value, without meaning.
Right? You hear, for example, constant claims on the part of scientific practitioners that science in its pristine form is value-free.
Right? And that every fact is to be considered as valuable in and of itself, and that
no fact is to be arbitrarily privileged over any other fact.
And so, the scientific enterprise begins with the removal of value from the world.
Now, the problem with that is that you live by value.
Right? You need a reason to put forth effort.
You need a reason to make sacrifices.
You need a reason to get up in the morning, especially if things are difficult for you in your life.
We can't. A world that's denuded of meaning is a world where no one has any motivation to do anything.
Now, but it's worse than that in a way, because you can make the positive significance of life disappear as a reality by criticizing it,
but you don't have the same luck with the suffering part.
And so, you can tell yourself that in the final analysis nothing is meaningful,
and that can make the world appear to be a hopeless and dismal place,
but you can't tell yourself that your own pain and your own anxiety is equally meaningless,
or you can try to tell yourself that, but it's going to have zero effect on the existential reality of your pain and suffering.
And so, if you remove value from the world, the paradoxical consequence is all that you leave behind in the world is suffering and confusion.
And that's not a good thing, especially if you draw the conclusion that suffering and confusion is the ultimate reality of the world.
And so, obviously. I mean, that's the conclusion that someone insanely depressed and anxious draws, or even suicidal.
And it's definitely the case that people who tilt towards a world view that denudes the world of intrinsic significance
do tend to fall under the sway of serious depression and anxiety.
And that's not all, because if you're depressed and you're anxious and you're suffering in consequence of that,
it's very easy to become bitter, and if you become bitter, it's easy to become vengeful.
And if you become vengeful, well, the sky's the limit in terms of the terrible places you might go.
And so, there are genuine existential consequences to denuding the world of significance.
Significance of treating it as if the notion of significance or value is somehow a delusional overlay on a more fundamental and primal material reality.
And that is what we think, right?
I mean, even if you're a modern religious person, the presuppositions of reductionist materialism,
the idea that the world's made out of matter and dead matter is so much part of you
that it's a self-evident axiom of the way you conduct yourself in the world.
And maybe there's a religious overlay on that because you're still a believer,
but you're a post-enlightenment scientific rationalist with a thin veneer of religious belief on the top of that.
And that's just not going to do the trick, folks.
And you can tell that because we're very susceptible to possession by a variety of forms
of pathological ideologies.
And we're very weak in the face of external pressure in relationship to our belief systems.
And we tend towards a dismal nihilism or a immature hedonism.
And none of that's going to do the trick.
Like, there's serious challenges facing us as individuals and as a society.
And that kind of shallowness in relationship to value is counterproductive,
barely begins to describe it.
It makes us weak.
And weak people are prone to the worst of temptations.
And so, this isn't good.
And the other, a more fun. But you might say, "Oh, it doesn't matter because we've pursued the truth."
And the truth is, as Nietzsche pointed out in the mid-1800s,
God is dead and the scientific revolution killed our religious presuppositions.
The world truly is a dead material place.
And we just have to make the best of that.
But, you know, before we jump to that earth-shattering conclusion. See, Nietzsche, when he said that, he knew what the consequence of that would be.
He said that we would become radically susceptible to catastrophic nihilism
and to invasion of our psychological space by a variety of utopian ideologies
and that the world would be awash in blood
as a consequence of the demise of the structures of value that had oriented us previously.
And so, now, the problem with the proposition that the world genuinely is a place of dead matter
with a thin overlay of arbitrary value on top of it,
the problem with that viewpoint, apart from the existential viewpoint,
THE EXISTENTIAL
problems that I just described is, it's not true. It's actually, it's a false view of the structure
of reality, and part of what we're actually wrestling with in our culture, and you all know
that to some degree, because you wouldn't be at this lecture if you didn't have some sense of this,
is that the propositions that have guided us through the technological revolutions of science
in the last four centuries, they're not right. It's not the case that the world is intrinsically
a place of dead matter, and that's all, and that we arbitrarily overlay a system of belief or value
on top of that. We know that's not true, partly in consequence of the scientific endeavor itself,
because, for example, we've been working at a biological level at unpacking the mysteries of
perception.
The perception upon which your idea that the world is an object depends, and what we've found is that
perception itself doesn't operate in the manner you would predict if the world was only a place
of dead matter and objects. And so, to see an object, you have to perceive it, obviously, and
if the perception itself relies on processes that aren't merely materialist, let's say,
then,
the whole notion that the world is fundamentally a meaningless object falls apart. And this is a
foregone conclusion now. Like, we know that that's not how perception works. So, for example,
when you're looking at something, when you're seeing something,
every glance you make is dependent on an action.
So, there's no perception at all independent of action, because you have to move your eyes in order to see.
And some of that's unconscious because your eyes vibrate, but some of it's conscious because you're
directing your eyes. And what you direct your eyes toward is indicative of what you're paying
attention to, and what you're paying attention to is indicative of your value structure. Now, this isn't
some idle hypothesis. There are malevolent forces that are in your body that are in your mind.
There are malevolent forces that are in your mind. There are malevolent forces at work in the world that are making a fortune off their analysis of your eye
movements, because that's what your phones do, because that gives those machines a window into your
structure of values and a means of controlling your intention and your actions. And so, there isn't
anything more valuable than your attention. And the sophisticated people, they're not going to
be able to do that. They're not going to be able to do that. And so, the sophisticated machines that you hold in your hands, your cell phones, are watching how you
move your eyes so they can figure out what's important to you, so that they can capture your
attention because of its great value. And so, the reason I'm telling you this is to, I don't want to
move this outside of the domain of mere abstraction. Like, we understand that perception is
dependent upon attention, and that you pay it. This is the crucial thing. You pay attention
to what you value. Right. Now, if your perception of the world is dependent on attention, and you pay
attention to what you value, then what you perceive is dependent on what you value. And that's not the
scientific proposition. The scientific proposition is the world lays itself out as a set of objects,
and you lay a structure of value on top of them, and the object perception is
primary, and that's wrong! The valuing is primary. Now, we don't exactly know what to make of that,
and that's partly what I want to explore with you tonight. Now, it turns out that the way you
describe the world of value is very different than the way you describe the world of objects. Now, we
have a technology for describing the world of objects, and that's the scientific method, the scientific description.
Our scientific theories. And that does enable us to gain some purchase on the world, right? We're very
technologically powerful in consequence of this mastery. But the world of value is described in a
different way, and it appears that that mode of description is not only no less real, it has to
exist before you can apprehend the world of objects at all. And the
method that we use to describe the world of value is the story. That's what a story does. Okay, so let's
think about this for a minute. And so, you go to a movie, and we already described the fact that
that's a bit of a mystery. It's like, what the hell are you lining up, using up your time, paying
money to go see a movie? And you might say, well, I enjoy it. And then I might say, you enjoy a horror
movie, do you? Right? A horror movie disgusts and frightens you, and that's the antithesis of
enjoyment. And so, what the hell are you doing there? Why would you enjoy that? Now, there is, in fact, a
reason, but it's not obvious, right? It's not the simple pursuit of pleasure that leads you to chase
the narrative. Okay, it's something, it's the narrative outlines a structure of value. Okay, so how do you
define enjoyment? Well, that's the first thing that comes to mind when we think about enjoyment. So,
what do you mean by enjoyment? Okay, so what do you mean by enjoyment? Well, that's the first thing that comes to mind when we think about
what they attend to and how they act, all right? And so, now, and you do this in a very deeply
embodied and unconscious way, the same way that you understand other people. So, for example,
when you are talking to another person, you watch their eyes, right? And the reason you watch their
is because you want to see where they direct their attention.
And you want to see where they direct their attention
so that you know what's important to them.
And you want to know what's important to them
so you can mimic that with your own body.
That's what you do.
When you understand someone else's aims,
you can understand what they regard as positive,
so what turns them on, so to speak,
what motivates them to move forward.
And that's anything that will move them towards their aim.
and you understand what is negative to them,
and that's anything that interferes with their aim.
That stops them, it makes them anxious, it causes them pain.
And so as soon as you can infer someone's aim,
you can mimic their emotions using your own body as a representational platform,
and that's how you understand people.
And so if you're getting to know someone on a date,
and you're having a conversation,
You pay attention to what the other person is paying attention to verbally and non-verbally.
And then if you pay really careful attention, you can get yourself in sync and you can be on the same wavelength.
And what that means is your aims unite and then your emotions are the same and then you understand each other.
Emotions are the same, and then you understand each other.
And then you might say, well, is it intrinsically rewarding merely to mimic someone else?
And the answer to that is, no, that's not the whole story.
You see, because the manner in which you direct your attention is dependent on your aim.
And it takes effort and resources to pursue an aim.
And so one of the things you really want to figure out in the world is,
what are the costs and consequences of different aims?
And what should your aim be and not be?
Okay, that's what stories tell you.
And so you go watch James Bond, and you see that he serves king and country,
that he's a brave sort of character, and then he arranges his attention in relationship to those aims,
and then you imitate that while you're watching him,
and then you get a sense of how that works out,
how that frame of vision works out.
How that value functions.
And you do it without cost, because if James Bond gets killed, you don't die, right?
And so this is the advantage of narrative characterization,
is you can toy and play with different viewpoints of value,
and you can explore their significance, for better or worse,
and you can do that while experiencing all the relevant emotions and all the relevant perceptions.
But if it goes terribly wrong,
it upsets you in the moment, in the movie, and that's all.
And you can walk away.
And so when you're being told a story, when you're participating in a story,
when you're watching a drama,
when you're listening to someone else tell their story,
you're gaining insight into the functional consequences of a way of organizing the world,
a way of prioritizing the world,
and you can use that to orient yourself in the world
in a more effective way.
And so you know that when you take
your children to movies, you sort of hope that they'll imitate the hero and not the villain.
And you see the villain, and the villain has villainous aims. He's aiming down. He wants mayhem
and pain. He wants other people to suffer. He doesn't cooperate with anyone. He's narcissistic
to the core. He's resentful and bitter. And that plays out on the screen, and you see that spiraling
downward, and you think, maybe it would be better not to be him. And then you see, on the other hand,
you see the hero, and the hero is, what's the hero doing exactly? Well, he's certainly not doing
what the villain is doing, at least that. And in the James Bond example, well, he's serving king
and country in this brave manner. And so there's an implication there. It's a low-level religious
implication, you might say, that a hero is someone who serves something that's outside his narrow
self. And you could argue, perhaps, that king and country isn't the highest of all possible aims,
but you might say, well, it's certainly better than the villain, and at least it's not narcissistic
and self-centered. And then you might say, well, what would be the aim of the greatest conceivable
hero? And that would be the king of all potential kings. And as soon as you start to ask and inquire
into that question, then you're definitely in the religious domain, right? So, because you're
starting to ask yourself something like,
Imagine your favorite lecturer.
Dial that up on Macs, put that on steroids, and then add some cinematic elements to it,
that's the best way I could describe a Peterson Academy lecture.
I went to college because I had to. I go to Peterson Academy because I want to. I'm still
paying off college from 10 years ago, and I'm also still questioning the value that I got out
of college. In traditional universities, a lot of times, it's just pretty dry. They don't bring the
same energy as the professors at Peterson Academy. And it is a completely different experience to
learn from.
Somebody who actually wants to teach you.
If you've been on the fence about this, this is the time.
That thing that's calling to you, you won't have an answer for it unless you enroll and see for
yourself. You have the opportunity to investigate that calling.
Yeah, so you understand that, right? You understand that. You see how that works. And so, that also
gives us some insight right away into the Christian religious domain, for example, because you can
imagine a movie about a king, and then you can imagine 10 movies about 10 kings. And then you can
imagine 10 movies about 10 kings. And then you can
10 movies about 10 kings and then you could imagine that there's something that's common to all of those kings
insofar as they're good kings and then you could make a movie about just the greatest of kings and that would start to have like
an overwhelming religious significance
Right because you'd be portraying something like the essence of kingship itself right or the essence of heroism itself and
Religious stories virtually by definition spiral around that end point try to specify it
How should you conduct yourself in the world now you see that's the same question
This is also what you're figuring out when you're watching a movie even though you don't know it you're figuring out
What does this person worship now? We think what do we think worship is well because we're shallow materialists
We haven't got a good grip on that. We think it means
I don't know it means singing a hymn in a church
And it does mean that to some degree and it means the rituals that would go along with a religious practice
It might mean getting on your knees when you pray for example, but you see what you worship is
What you celebrate and what you worship and celebrate is what you hold in the highest degree
And so you see so to worship is to subjugate yourself to your aim
I mean this as a definition. This is this is what you want to understand
Is that every time you move your eyes, even though you don't know it you're worshiping something and what you're worshiping is the goal of your vision
Even if you don't know what your vision is. So here's an example. Imagine you're on a date and
You could worship the one-night stand in which case your eyes are going to be doing something completely different than what they're going to be
Doing if you're evaluating your date partner as a potential wife or husband, right?
You cannot you?
You you obviously, you know that and if you're both playing one-night stand
Well, then maybe there's not going to be any disagreement about what the eyes should be doing
But if one of you is playing one-night stand and the other is playing I wish I was married
Then that's not that's not going to be a date that goes very well and all the body language will indicate that and then you
Might say well you can see that there's different
Objects of worship in those two approaches because one worships short-term hedonistic sexual gratification
at all cost
absent any relationship or
responsibility and the other worships
marriage as the foundation of
What the proper relationship between men and women and the foundation of society?
those are very very very different things and
Though those different see this is the kicker those different aims structure your perceptions your aims
structure your perceptions and so
Given that you see that's why the
scientific worldview in its fundamental
Propositions is in incomplete because that's not an axiom of the scientific world
The scientific world assumes the facts are dead. They're all equal you look at them
Neutrally as a scientist and the science of perception indicates that you cannot look at anything neutrally
It's not possible
you have to inhabit a value frame because
your
Values determine your pattern of attention and your pattern of action and your perceptions are attention and action
Predicated there's no escape from the problem of value now
We don't know we don't know what to do with this exactly because I'm not a post-modernist
I don't think I'm not going to make a claim that there's no such thing as scientific fact right and that that
That somehow everything's up for grabs because the world of value is real
That's a that's a mistake and it's erroneous
But by the same token
The fruits of the scientific endeavor will be dependent on the aim of the scientist
And we already know that because you guys you go to movies and you see the evil scientist
It's like how many bloody evil scientists. Do you have to see before you clue in it's like evil scientists produce
evil science and so how can that be if the scientific venture itself is value free because
an evil scientist could produce good science because what the hell difference does it make and everyone knows that's
not the case and you can certainly see that
You can certainly see a terrible danger in the scientific enterprise because we all know that if the technological power our
scientific viewpoint
Provides to us is misused then
Then heaven help us you know I read a book once that was written by a KGB ex KGB officer
And he talked about scientists in the Soviet Union and their goal was to produce a hybrid between Ebola
which is a
Hybrid between Ebola and smallpox and so that's a perfectly valid
Scientific question just like gain-of-function research in Wuhan you might say and so seriously
And we saw we saw what happened as a consequence of that particular value predicated in death
Right and we shut down the bloody world for two years because of that and turned the entire west into a totalitarian state
That's right, so watch out for the aims of your scientists, and so then you might think well. What should those aims be right?
Well, that's the problem of narrative. What should your aim be?
Okay, so I
Want to lay out for you, too?
It's a Tammy told the story of Snow White for a particular reason
And I want to lay out for you
Partly how narrative in its most fundamental way?
Characterizes the world of value so let's say you know ha ha I remember once when I was a kid
I went to a drive-in and I saw a Burt Reynolds movie
And I don't remember what is smoky in the bandit
I think and Burt Reynolds was zipping around in some fast car and being a cool dude and
when all the teenagers drove out of the
Parking lot at the end of the drive-in they were all spinning their tires and like racing down the highway
And it's like they're imitating they were imitating
Burt Reynolds, and you know fair enough and and
What you see what?
that's how we
Develop our patterns of value we develop our patterns of value through imitation
That's a good way of thinking about it so you imitate your father for example you
You imitate your father you imitate even more particularly the spirit of your father, so here's a way of thinking about it so imagine that you're
A little boy, and you're inviting a little girl to play house, and you say to her
Do you want to play house?
And she says yes, which is a good start to the game because she has to say yes
or it's not a game in case you didn't notice when you were three and
And so then you might say well the boy who now is going to play the father is imitating the father
Right but imitation like if I was imitating you I'd sit with my legs crossed like this right that's a direct imitation
I'm using my body to precisely duplicate what your body is doing, but you see if you watch little kids play
That's not what they do they do something way more sophisticated so a three-year-old or a four-year-old has watched his
father operate as father, so with the goals and names of a father, over many
different episodes, and he's watched fathers and adult men in movies, and he's
seen fathers in books, and what he does is he pulls out a abstraction of what
constitutes the father, that'd be the spirit of the father, that's a good way
of thinking about it, he pulls out an abstraction of what the father is from
all of those examples, and then he plays that in the pretend game, and so he's
possessed by the spirit of the father, okay, so one way that the world of value
that characterizes human society is transmitted from generation to
generation, is through imitation of the spirit of the father, okay, now if you're
thinking at all, if you're paying attention at all, you can see that
there's a very, very thin line between that, and, well, you might
say both Jewish and Christian forms of worship, because what you're enjoying to
do as a Jew or Christian, there's other religions that are oriented in the same,
towards the same paternal end, is that you're called upon to imitate the
benevolent, the spirit of the benevolent father, now that's not all, like in
Catholicism, for example, you have Mary, who's an example of the spirit of the
benevolent feminine, and that's a different thing, but
part of what the religious process is doing, in its complex narrative, is
abstracting out the essential spirit of celebration and worship, and utilizing
character and personality to produce a pattern that can be, that can be
imitated, right now, you see, the girl who's playing with the boy, he, she knows
this, because if the boy who's playing with house with her, imitates the spirit
of the benevolent father, properly, then she'll enjoy the game, and then she'll
want to play another game with him, and then they'll become friends, and so, the
test for whether or not his imitation of the spirit of the benevolent father is
valid, is whether the girl will continue the game, and if you can't see the
relationship between that and your marriage, you're just not trying, right, so,
because that's exactly, that's exactly what,
you're both aiming for in your marriage, whether you know it or not, your, your
wife is trying to encourage within you, your embodiment of the spirit of the
benevolent masculine, yes, and you are attempting to encourage the same
development in her, with regards to the feminine, and those are two cardinal ways
of characterizing the world of value, that's a good way of thinking about it, and so,
so, I'll give you an example of that, so, I already made allusion to the fact that
Christ, in the Christian tradition, is the king of kings, and so, you could think
about him as the central pattern of sovereignty, to which all sovereigns, who
are genuine, have to bow, right, and you know you don't want a king or a president
who believes that he's on top of everything, right, that's a tyrant, that's a tyrant,
if your leader, despite his position of authority, is beholden to a principle
that's transcendent, that, that is beyond him, and upward aiming, then he's someone
who's serving the, he's mimicking the benevolent spirit of the father, instead
of allowing himself to become possessed by power, and that means that he's the
sort of sovereign that you can trust, just like if you're doing that in your
household, then you're not a tyrant as a husband or a father, okay, and that's
all nested inside narrative, and developed in character, and so, we, we use
character and story to portray the world of value, and that's what teaches us how
to direct our attention, and to organize our actions, right, now, and if you
understand that, you can also see how that unites us socially, because if your
vision of what constitutes the benevolent masculine is
the same as mine, then we can understand each other, and we can work together, not
only can we work together, we can, we can compete peacefully, because we could
assume something like, we're playing the same game, because we have the same aim,
and we can let the better man win, and that would be good for both of us, because
that way, we'd learn a bit more about who the better man is, and maybe we could
imitate that, and both improve, and so, the, that,
that union of aim, upward aim, brings peace even to competition, productive
peace even to competition, that's a very useful thing to know with regards to
masculinity, because men tend to be very competitive, and you could make a case
that competition, per se, is a manifestation of the oppressive patriarchy,
so that's the negative masculine, and that's true if the competition is for power, but
it's not true if the competition is the maximization of the proper aim, and then
you have to ask yourself, well, what's the proper aim, and we've touched on that a
little bit, and it's something like, whatever's represented by concepts like
the king of kings, or the spirit of the benevolent father, and so that's how God
is characterized, for example, often in the Old Testament, he's the, he's the God
of Abraham and Isaac, right, he's the spirit of benevolent masculine and
as it makes itself manifest across the generations in the world, and it's up to
the individual man, like Abraham or Jacob, any of the biblical heroes, to ally
themselves with that spirit, to invite it through prayer and worship, to possess
them, to sacrifice everything that isn't appropriate along the way, and then to
develop upward, right, and that, the narrative that's laid out in the biblical corpus describes
that spiraling upward process, and it culminates in the idea that the ultimate upward aim
that's the spirit of the king of kings is something like the voluntary spirit of self-sacrifice
that mature families and communities are founded upon, and so that would mean that as a mature
man who's worth his salt, so to speak, it's not all about you and your pleasure in the most narrow of
senses, but that you're in service to the future, and to your wife, and to your children, and to the
community, and the city, and the state, and, right, right, right, and the, the thing that's so wonderful
and remarkable about that is that, imagine that really what you want is to make your dreams come
true, and you might say, well, if I want to make my dreams come true, I will pursue what's in my
self-interest, but you'll find that if you do that, you become a narcissistic pretender, and people do
everything they can to make their dreams come true, and you'll find that if you do that, you
become a narcissistic pretender, and people do everything they can to distance themselves from you, and if you take the
opposite tack, and you say, I don't, don't, I'm not going to live for my narrow self, I'm going to find
myself in service to the future, my wife, my children, my community, my state, my nation, under God,
let's say, then everything that you need and want will come to you, right, and see, your nation knows
this, that's a very strange thing about the United States, because you guys have got this more right than
any other people in the world, and maybe more than any other people in the world ever have, which is
that if you can pursue the spirit of benevolent self-sacrifice without envy, then you can produce
a land of abundance, and that's exactly right, and that ability, the ability to do that should
be the highest of aims, okay, so, right, okay.
And you can, you can see, you can see how that's dramatized in narrative, obviously, because the
self-sacrificing hero is the mainstay of an action-adventure movie, or a romantic adventure, I mean,
was it the last James Bond, where he ends up sacrificing himself to the woman he loves, and
society at large on an island, right, yeah, well, that motif of voluntary self-sacrifice, well, that's
obviously deeply Christian.
Obviously, although there are radical precursors to the idea, for example, in the Jewish scriptures
and throughout the Old Testament, the idea that sacrifice pleases God, and that there's an ultimate
form of sacrifice that's ultimately pleasing, and that's, that's all, and then you might say, well,
is that true, and the answer to that is something like, well, it's not true from the narrow materialist
reductionist perspective, but that's because that is forbidden from the beginning when you're playing
that game, but it is true if you're trying to figure out, for example, how you bring peace to
your household, and meaning to your life, and productive abundance to your society, all those
things seem relevant, and so serving that kind of relevance also seems to be something like serving
the truth, or maybe the essence of serving the truth, and that's not the same viewpoint
that underlies the scientific enterprise as such. Now, what that shows is not that the
scientific enterprise is correct and the religious enterprise or the narrative enterprise wrong,
but that the scientific enterprise is radically incomplete in its current form,
and prone to spiral badly sideways if it isn't encapsulated within the proper structure of value.
And I think we're at a point where we know that.
Okay, so that's a quick outline of two different ways of looking at the world, right?
The object world, and the world of value, and the way things seem to be constituted is that the world of value
is the foundation, proper foundation for the world of objects, not the other way around.
Is that unless you're an ethically self-sacrificing scientist,
the truths you discover will serve malevolent purposes rather than producing abundance and peace.
Right, and so what that means is that the aim of the scientist is the paramount issue
with regards even to the productivity of science itself.
Yeah, and that seems to be, I just cannot see for a moment how that can be disputed.
And even if it is disputed, we bloody well know it, because you can see the motif of science gone wrong
permeate our movies, the Terminator series is a good example of that, for example,
and which we're likely to live out in our lifetime,
because we're foolish enough not to pay attention to our own warnings, you might say.
You know, the Chinese surveillance system is called Skynet.
It's literally called Skynet.
700 million closed-circuit TV cameras.
Full-gate analysis, those systems can assess where you are and who you are, even if you mask yourself.
And when the engineers were called on that, the Chinese engineers were called on that,
why do you name it Skynet? Didn't you see the Terminator series?
They said, because they're engineers and nerds, they said, of course we saw the Terminator series,
we're building the good Skynet, which is of course exactly what the engineers in the Terminator movies thought, right?
And so, if your good is defined by the tenants of the Chinese Communist Party,
you're not going to build the good Skynet.
Okay, so, I wanted to talk to you about this.
I talked to you a little bit about the positive masculine and the way it's portrayed in narrative and in movies.
And I wanted to tell you a bit about the negative masculine and the positive and negative feminine.
And Tammy touched on that a little bit with her discussion of Snow White.
But there's only so much you can do in 40 minutes.
And so, I think what I'll do, I'll do that with the discussion with Jonathan,
because he's very good at that sort of thing.
Because the characters can go right and go wrong.
And male characters can go right and go wrong.
And female characters can go right and wrong, and there's a pattern to that.
And our deep stories, like Snow White, which is a cultural phenomena and has to be hit the target squarely to work even as a commercial product,
our pop cultural narratives are reflective of the disorder of our ethical systems.
That's a good way of thinking about it.
And I want to talk with Jonathan about that, and we'll walk through that, and see if we can get that straight.
For now, I think I'll just reiterate, so hopefully we'll make this clear, so that there's two problems you have to solve in the world.
There's another way of thinking about it.
You have to know what the world's made of, right?
But that's not enough.
You have to know how to orient yourself in the world.
You have to know how to navigate.
And to navigate, you have to prioritize.
You have to establish a destination, an aim.
That's the promised land.
You might say, assuming you're aiming up.
Or the shining city on the hill, or the heavenly Jerusalem.
Those are all abstractions of the idea of the proper aim.
And if your aim's appropriate, the world shows itself as a pathway forward.
And the person who walks that pathway to the proper aim, that's the hero.
And the hero is characterized in drama and narrative.
As an example to imitate.
And you need to know that, because you have to walk through the world.
If you were just a passive recipient of sense data, value-free sense data, which is sort of the ideal scientist from the enlightenment perspective,
well then, if you didn't have to navigate, and you were just a passive recipient, then value wouldn't be necessary.
But because you're a limited perceiver, and everything has a cost, and you can only do so many things,
you have to prioritize.
You have to do one thing rather than the other.
And you have to organize all the things you're going to do towards some end.
And the organization towards that end determines the manner in which the world makes itself manifest to you.
And that's a terrifying thing to understand, too.
You know, one of the things you can ask yourself very seriously is that if the sacrifices you're making aren't being met by appreciation from yourself,
others, or God, so to speak, it's very possible that there's something pathologically wrong with your aim.
Right, and that's very, very, that's a terrible thing to contemplate, you know, especially when your failures appear to be radically arbitrary.
But it's a hopeful realization as well, because if the reason that the world's in disorder around you is because your aim is pathological,
then you have some hope of fixing it.
If the world itself is just turned against you, well, you know, too bad for you.
There's nothing left for you.
But if you could get on your knees and figure out why the hell you're wrong and stupid,
that's a big book, that.
Then, you know, then you'd have the possibility of rectifying it, moving forward effectively.
And since there's no limit to your ignorance, if you admit to that ignorance, there's no limit to what you could learn.
If you have a simple attitude that there's no limit to what you could learn in consequence of facing your error,
then you'll walk the self-correcting pathway up to the shining city on the hill.
That's exactly right, yeah.
So, and those are the ideas.
Those ideas are coded in our deep narratives.
And you see, we don't understand that.
And the scientific mind dispenses with all that and proclaims that the world's a value-free place,
that the narrative is nothing but delusion and superstition.
And that's wrong enough to make all of us sick, disunited, and unhappy.
Right.
Okay, well, that seemed to make a certain amount of sense, I hope.
And even though it's very, very complicated.
And I think what I'll do now is I'll invite Jonathan to come out and offer what he has to offer.
And we'll continue this discussion, so.
How are you feeling?
That's a lot.
Well, like I said, I haven't done that for a long time.
You know, it's like 2016 or something like that.
And so it was fun to go back and revisit that and see if I could get a little clearer.
Because it's nice to get something a little clearer every time you revisit it.
You know, and so, did that happen today?
I think I got the explanation for why the value structure is so important.
I think the value structures have to be characterized more clear than I did when I was lecturing for Maps of Meaning, for example.
So I think I understand that in a manner that's more compressible.
Yeah.
All right, so.
Okay, so I want to start.
And I also went to see the Snow White movie.
And I guess a way to resume what Jordan is saying is to ask yourself the question, why was it so boring?
Like, why was it inane?
Why is it that no one cares about it?
Right?
And so what Jordan is trying to portray is that stories are not infinitely malleable.
That unlike, in accordance with the kind of postmodern world, we are saying that there is an overlay of value that brings the world of facts together.
The postmoderns say that too.
But the postmoderns think that that world that is overlaid is arbitrary.
And that it is only.
A sense of force and a sense of power.
But what we're trying to say is that actually the order of attention, the hierarchy of attention, is objective.
And the reason why you know it's objective is because the Snow White movie is boring.
Because no one likes to watch it.
What I mean is that no one cares.
Right?
This idea that Jordan is talking about where it is that you put your attention on something that reflects a universal structure of values.
And that's what makes people care about it.
Now you can push on that.
Right?
You can push on it towards extremes.
It is possible because we do have in us a desire for exploration.
Right?
So you can push on that and create horror stories, do this type of pushing into the margins.
But at some point, if you don't order the story in the proper way, people just stop paying attention.
Right?
Because no one will pay to watch propaganda.
Well, it isn't even exactly that people stop paying attention.
It's that their attention isn't there.
Their attention isn't gripped.
Right?
Because, you know, you might think, well, you could go to Snow White and you could feel sorry for Disney because they spent. quarter of a billion dollars on this movie and so you'd expect it to grip
your attention but it doesn't and and and that's so weird you see this is this
is the crucial thing here with regards to Jonathan's comments about the the
reality of the value structure you see because if you had any sense and and you
could control what you thought was important you'd think well I spent you
know you bring your family I spent $50 going to this movie goddammit I'm gonna
enjoy it and that just doesn't work right you cannot force yourself to care
about a movie that you don't care about it has to entrench you right it has to
grip you now the question is why does it grip you see this is and this is an
unbelievably important question this is exactly the same question that the
religious types grapple with when they talk about the issue of calling you know
there are things in the world that attract your attention now sometimes
those are pathological things and you know you should get your act together and
straighten up but so it's not it's very common that it's your destiny calling to
you it's the next step on your journey calling to you it's your higher purpose
calling to you and if you have the courage to attend to that calling then
you magically transform that's how it works and everyone knows that and so
then when the narrative deviates from the pattern it no one cares it's because
it doesn't call you anymore it doesn't call you because it doesn't reflect the
transcendent pattern that's that's it and and it's insane like we've been
we've been told now for decades that the idea of a the story of a princess that
finds her prince is ridiculous and you know it's passe and it's antiquated that
is literally how the world continues to exist like a woman and a man coming
together and get it coming together and then that is how the world continues to
exist the idea that that is ridiculous and inane is passe is the dumbest thing
in the world you can have all the political ideology and revolutions you
want if you have no people you have no world right yeah well and you can have a
narrative that's bent enough that you proclaim that a world without people
would be a better world right and that there's a villainous narrative for you
you know and you can make everybody guilty about the fact that they want to
get married and and have children because children are part of the force
that's devouring the damn planet and then you might ask exactly whose aim
underlies that narrative as you should and so and we're in that we're in a
situation where that's literally the case like the New York was the New York
Times last year talked about the morality of limiting the number of children that
you bring into the world because of the planetary burden that you're placing on
I don't know what the goddess of nature some damn thing so yeah but I think that
it's encouraging now like actually this to me this most recent version of Snow
White is actually hopeful right and the reason why it's hopeful is because when
you watch it you can see that they went way too far and they're actually trying
to backtrack and they're trying to fix it and it ends up in this jumbled confused mess
but you can feel that they're trying to fix it which means that it feels like
we're at the end we're at the nadir of this type of ideological storytelling
and that hopefully it's all uphill from there so you know
so the original trailer for the Snow White movie back then that was a year and
a half ago or something like that they decided they were going to replace the
dwarfs with like a diversity crowd and that see there's a
there's an unbelievable arrogance in that because especially for storytellers
because there's actually reasons that those dwarfs were who they were so I can
go through the reasons so in the original Grimm Brothers fairy tale the
dwarfs are partial manifestations of the positive masculine so they don't have
names so they're not they're not stellar individual men but they're they're men
who work hard to do the things that are necessary
so they're minors and they keep a clean house and so this is very different than
this new Snow White because they're like messy little rats in the Snow White movie
and the woman who's like this progressive princess has to come in and
clean house though she tells them what to do yes she tells them how to clean
their house yes that's true that's true Jonathan that's true in the original the
dwarfs kept a good house and now the Snow White the princess is getting away
from the Evil Queen okay so whether you know it or not that's what all the young
women in your country are trying to do right now they're trying to get away
from the Evil Queen who is attempting to feed them poison apples so that they're
infertile and unattractive and it's working and so so so so you can't you
can't muck with that story and it's it's partly because there is a negative
feminine you might say and we could flesh it out a little bit and so the
negative feminine is the older woman who instead of being a mentor to a young
woman is holding on desperately to her primarily sexual attractiveness and the
power that confers on her to be envious of the upcoming generation including her
own daughters and to hurt them so that she maintains control and that's that's
an eternal story
man and you see that reflected in all sorts of psychological investigation so
for example one of Freud's primary discoveries was the pathology of the
Oedipal mother in the pathological family and so one of the conundrums that
human beings have is that we have a very lengthy dependency period right far more
than any other creature like your kids are autonomous maybe when they're 80 18
or 40 and and so they're unbelievably they're unbelievably dependent and what that means is
that there is very little that's more important than mother maternal love especially for very
little kids but it also means that because that force is so powerful and children are so dependent
on it if it pathologizes and overextends itself it's literally a world-destroying force and so
the Oedipal story in the Freudian world is the mother who's
a little too close to her son in particular and you can imagine a situation like that arising
where there's a lot of tension between the father and the mother and the mother turns
inappropriately to her son for as a source of support and attention and because she's desperately
needs that she sabotages his attempts to become independent and attractive and this is exactly
by the way what's portrayed in the Disney movie Sleeping Beauty you remember that Prince Philip
is caught in a dungeon by the evil queen and she basically tells him that although he wants to go
find Sleeping Beauty and like have a life she's going to lock him in the dungeon till he's laughably
old right and then these fairies come along they're the benevolent feminine and they get
rid of his chains and they encourage him to leave and he escapes and she turns into this
horrible dragon that breathes fire like she's she's the force of nature itself gone pathologically
wrong and she stands in his way and he has to fight his way through her he uses the sword of
truth and the shield of Virtue to overcome the dragon that the evil queen turns into and then
he hacks his way through the thorns and finds Sleeping Beauty and wakes her up and you can't
mess with that story because it's always happening and it has to happen because
otherwise the prince doesn't meet the princess and the princess stays unconscious and asleep and
the evil queen rules and the dragon emerges and burns everything to the ground and it's strange
that we don't know this when we're watching the movies but it doesn't matter because they grip us
right and they grip us by our most fundamental presuppositions yeah right and and if you deviate
from that everyone's bored and you can spend a quarter of a billion dollars and it doesn't
make a bloody bit of difference yeah we we started we started with you know Dustin Hoffman being
seduced by the his girlfriend's mother and the graduate in the late 60s early 70s I think it was
and you know a bit provocative a bit enticing and at the end of that if you follow that line you end
up with I'm sorry I'm going to say the word but you end up with milfs you know it's like you end
up with like these old ladies
old what how they call them like the cougar cougars or whatever like completely degenerate world of
women in their 50s you know acting like they are still little starlets you know and that's really
like that brings about total chaos in our society well and it's also the case that it's also the
case frequently that it's oh God we're gonna get in such trouble here it's that
like there is a developmental course that's appropriate to the propagation
of life and so what you want as you age if you're a man or a woman is well you start out young and
you have your romantic adventure with one another and you have no children
and then you have children and then all of a sudden it's not about you anymore it's about
them and then if you sacrifice for them and they grow up courageous and attractive they
find their own mates and then they have children and then your role is grand parent it's not it's
not competitor for the
of the
virile young man, and you'd only want that if you hadn't had your life, right? Because then you're. See, the evil queen wants to hang on to her youth and beauty for a reason, and I'm not trying to say
that, like, every older woman who's trying to look attractive is falling into that pit. I'm just
saying that there's a desperation that comes from not following the appropriate pattern properly,
and it becomes pathological. It's like being the oldest guy at the frat party. It's like when you're
18 and you're at a frat party, it's like, no problem, because you're 18. But if you're 40
and you're at the frat party, people should be wondering just who the hell you are and why you
think you're 18. Because a 40-year-old, an 18-year-old 40-year-old is a pretty ugly sight,
much less a 13-year-old 40-year-old. Right. And so it's everything in its place, right? And so
you can see in these narratives, the evil queen narratives, you can see,
in for a penny, in for a pound, you can see exactly what's happened in the universities,
too, because they're basically, they've become, they're basically, they've basically been taken
over by evil queen types who are poisoning the young women. And, you know, I'm not saying this
lightly. We bloody well know that the most miserable people in the United States are
liberal women between the 18th and. 18 and 34. And, and, you know, here's, here's the dreadful, here's the dreadful thing. Like,
you'd hope that education would illuminate and enlighten and free. But what's happened in the
universities is that the more educated, educated, the more poisoned apples the young women have
been fed, the more unconscious and miserable they've become. And this is, and that's because
they've fallen under the sway of. of the evil queen. And so then you might ask yourself, because this is all about how the women
are going wrong, you might ask, well, where the hell are the men? And that's a really good
question, too. And so, because they're not standing up and saying, enough of this.
Yeah. And so the, the story, when you see the roles, especially in fairy tales, when you see
the roles of the feminine and the masculine, you know, you, you realize that these are really,
they're archetypes, obviously.
They play a structural role. And if you think about it, you know, to bring it back almost to
the beginning, when you talk about science, there is this sense, even in the scientific
endeavor, there is a sense in which there is this union, you could say, of masculine and feminine
that is productive, you know. And so you have, and you really have to reduce it to its elements.
It's difficult because people get, take it personal. It's like, all of us are more than
our gender. All of us are more than our sex, right? But when we have sex together and we
produce a child, that's what we are, right? That's the reality of, of that moment. And there's a,
there's a reality to that, which is that the woman provides the body for the child, right?
The man provides necessarily for the pregnant woman that has the baby in, in her, in her belly.
The man will provide protection, will provide, you know, sustenance, will protect her because,
of that moment, will provide direction for the family. And that is how the scientific endeavor
works as well. You have a body, you have facts, and then you have a vertical. You have a reason
why you're looking at the facts, right? There's a reason why you care about certain facts and not
others. And that gathers it towards a productive scientific endeavor. You know, when you are, it's
really very similar to the prince coming and kissing Snow White. Because when you're doing
science, you, you're not studying everything at once.
That's not possible. You have to select something and you have to bind it and bring it together.
And that the attention that you give to that, that circle, let's say bound together amount of
facts is productive towards. Well, and so that, that plethora of valueless facts is,
to, to further your metaphor, it's, that's the chaos that's potentially productive.
It's potential to avoid the problem. It's potential.
It's potential. Right. Exactly that. And then the act of prioritizing is the act of the,
of the, what do you call that? The fructifying logos. That's the right way of thinking about it.
Use it, the image. You have the seed that is placed in the earth.
Yeah.
Right. The seed is bodiless purpose or bodiless pattern. And the earth is a body without a
pattern, right? So in the seed is the whole tree, but the tree is nothing without the body.
So the seed fall goes into the earth and the earth provides a body for the seed.
And then you have a new tree. It's the pattern of everything. It's the pattern of life,
but it is also the pattern of the sexual union in, in, in, especially in the narrative form,
especially the one you see in the fairy tales or you see in the Bible, you see in the mythology.
Now you see, you might say, if you're a scientific materialist, you'd might say, well, that's,
that's ridiculous symbolism and spiritualist nonsense. But then see the most famous
reductionist materialist atheist alive today is Richard Dawkins. And Richard Dawkins wrote a book
where he claimed that, and this is a pure biological claim as far as he was concerned,
that an organism could not survive in an environment unless it was a microcosm of that
environment. Okay. So now that's a very interesting claim because it means that the organism itself
reflects the entire structure while we see, we see the very essence of human survival is the dynamic
between masculine and feminine. And if that's the fundamental biological reality and the fundamental
biological reality has to be a microcosm or a reflection of the environment, then you have to
conclude that the masculine element of the environment and the feminine element of the
environment are the superordinate principle.
I mean,
this is Dawkins' own argument. I tried to make that case to him when I talked to him like two
months ago, three months ago, but it, he, he knew what I meant, but we never got anywhere with the
discussion, you know, cause it's very annoying to be proved wrong by your own ideas. Right,
right, right. Seriously, seriously. And yeah, he couldn't deal, he couldn't deal with the
consequences of what that meant and how it does ultimately do what you proposed at the outset,
which is that the narrative,
the structure precedes the scientific endeavor almost just necessarily, you know, in the scientists, in the things we care about, in the way we decide what to study, in the way that people fund certain studies rather than others in every single way that science happens. It has to be framed within the narrative of the hierarchy of values. There's no way around it.
Yeah, well, and it's, if you know anything about scientists, like the actual science, first of all, most scientists aren't scientists, they're just functionaries. And so, and that's partly
because you need a lot of functionaries.
The functionary to genius ratio
has to be pretty high for anything to work.
So I'm not complaining about that.
Look, there has to be beginner scientists,
like graduate students and so forth,
and the science they do isn't very good,
but they have to learn,
and there has to be scientists who kind of publish,
but nothing real useful, but they teach,
and then there's people who are real scientists,
and there aren't very many of them,
but they do a lot of work,
and those scientists, see, they're not pursuing money
because if they were pursuing money,
they wouldn't be scientists
because it's not a way to make a lot of money.
So then you might say, well, what are they pursuing?
And the answer is, well, what the true scientists
are pursuing is what calls to them.
They have a religious commitment
to their object of inquiry,
and what's the nature of the commitment?
This is worth studying, right?
This interests me, this engages me.
I would voluntarily spend all my time chasing this.
Chasing what?
You know, Barbara McClintock, I think that was her name,
she studied the genetics of corn coloration
in Indian corn for like 30 years, something like that,
and she was kind of an outsider.
Everybody thought, what the hell's with this crazy broad
studying like variations in color in corn?
And she made a discovery that was foundational
to a number of cancer cures, you know,
and so everything's a mystery,
and if you study it enough, you get to the bottom of things,
and the genuine scientists are called by a burning bush.
That's the right way of thinking,
right?
It's the right way of thinking.
It motivates them, and it's something that's,
it's a manifestation of a superordinate value system
that precedes them even, because they chase it.
They don't pick what they're interested in.
It picks them, and then they devote their life to it,
and that's not in the scientific model.
It's completely, it's prior to it,
and so what else is prior to it?
You have to believe the universe is intelligible.
Well, what's the proof of that?
You have to believe that,
attempting to understand the universe is positive.
Well, maybe it is, and maybe it's not.
You have to understand, assume that you could understand,
and that there's communal value in that,
and those are all a priori commitments
before the scientific endeavor even gets off the ground,
and then you have to assume that pursuing what interests you
is justification for your sacrifices, right?
And so that's all part of the narrative
in which science is embedded.
And if that narrative is upward-oriented
in the proper manner,
then science becomes a productive enterprise.
Otherwise, it becomes like Dr. Evil and nuclear annihilation.
right same data indeed all right i want i want i think we're going to bring tammy out but i want
to i want to make a shameless call to all of you which is that right now in hollywood in the world
of storytelling everything is shaking we can feel like the model of this kind of ideological
propaganda type stories are falling apart but now we all need
you everyone here in this room has something very precious and that is your attention
and so we all have to be deliberate about what it is we give our attention to
what it is we and so we can criticize and we complain about how bad the stories are
but we also have to move into a new form of storytelling we have to be able to move towards
better stories and so i'm gonna if you are interested i myself and my team we are
rewriting the fairy tales right now we're doing it in a mode that is celebratory that is trying
to elevate them to the highest level that we can uh and so if you're interested in that we wrote
a version of snow white called snow white and the widow queen and we're hoping to prove hollywood
wrong we're trying to prove to them that if you tell these stories beautifully with a type of
honor and a type of celebration that that is actually the stories that matter and it's the
stories that people will care for so thank you for that little
so you know i'll just i'll just put a capstone on what jonathan just said if you understand that
there's no difference between what you worship and what you pay attention to if you actually
understand that you'll be a lot more careful with what you do with your attention right because
what you're doing with your attention goes all the way up all the way up or all the way down
right so beware and that's especially true
given these machines that you're going to be increasingly interacting with because
they will take you wherever your attention
where they will take you towards whatever you orient your attention toward and so be careful
that's for sure okay tam let's come out have you come out
hi
ready ready okay
what's your take on the heated political situation between the u.s and canada
there's a little bit more how can we work to keep the friendship going
between our two great nations
do you want do you want to start sure i'll start the first thing that you have to know is that
most of you really don't want canada to join the united states right i'm just saying the next
elections will not be great if that happens and so that's the first thing i think the second thing
that i'd like to say is you know we're watching it's hard to tell like donald trump he there's
something that he wants he hasn't yet completely revealed what that is
he's just he's pushing and prodding he's making everything shake and at some point it will become
clear what he wants my intuition is that what he wants is for canada to get its act together
you know militarily uh economically and you know and so i think that that's what he wants and if
that's what he wants then i'm all for it you know but if but if there's a darker aspect to it which
is if it is this just kind of america trying to find someone to bully to make a difference
make itself look strong then i don't see that playing out well you know in the long term so
yeah well you know trump is a mystery and i suspect i suspect to some degree even to himself
and as we all well as we all are right as we all are and he's a complex character and he's playing
a very complex role so i'm not saying any of this lightly you know and i do believe that there's a
part of him that
is hoping that your northern neighbor gets its act together even if he's primarily indicating
that by contempt because like well i think one of the most productive ways of viewing what trump
is doing without being naive is by observing that he couldn't be dismissive and contemptuous of
canada if the groundwork for that was to be dismissed and he couldn't be dismissive and
contemptuous of that hadn't been laid and it has been laid i can say that as a canadian and it's
been laid in a bunch of ways the last 10 years of trudeau government have been appalling we were as
rich as you were 10 years ago in fact because we had a slight advantage and now you make you produce
a dollar for every 60 cents we produce that's not good and the prognosis for canada is worse
performance over the next 40 years we've become almost entirely reliant on
your country for our fossil fuel production because we're too clueless to build pipelines
across our country east to west and when the leaders of germany and japan i can't say this
without it hurting my heart when the leaders of germany and japan came to trudeau when the
russians started saber rattling in the ukraine they both asked him for untrammeled access to
canadian liquid natural gas for like the next 40 years
and he told both of them within the same month that he couldn't make a business case for that
and trump signed a billion dollar deal a trillion dollar deal this month that should have been
canada's and could have been and so and then our country our leader trudeau who has you know he's
done some terrible things he locked down canadian's bank accounts which was utterly
unforgivable that was the most totalitarian thing i've ever seen a western democrat leader do
and then he also he's a wf puppet to the core and he also has told canadians for 10 years that
the country has absolutely no national identity of any value except that of colonial patriarchal
oppressor essentially and now trump says well you've got a pretty pathetic country there
why don't you just be one of our states one how insulting is that it's like
how about 10 of your states you know no one you deserve one it's like oh just one it's like
and and what canadians do they don't go oh you know what the hell are you talking about look at
us like you know we're together they go quit picking on us it's like that's pretty sad you
know because it should be just laughable but the problem is and this is what trump's trying to
do is he's trying to do it in a way that makes it worse and that's what trump's trying to do he's
trying to do it in a way that makes it worse and that's what trump's trying to do he's trying to
do it in a way that makes it worse and that's what trump's trying to do he's trying to do it in a way
that makes it worse and that's what trump's trying to do he's trying to do it in a way that makes it
worse and that's what trump's trying to do he's trying to do it in a way that makes it worse and
the people in the country go well that's unfair that's the best defense they can come up with
and so and our military in canada is in oh my god like your military is suffering under you know
after 15 years of dei idiocy but you should see ours our bloody soldiers have to buy their own
boots and really that's that's the truth and so you know there's some well-deserved contempt
some contempt towards that is well deserved and trump is a bull in the china shop and i think he
was very careless in his comments about canada and he made a big mistake because he the liberal
party in canada so that's the trudeau party they were dead in the water a month ago dead the party
was going to cease to exist because trudeau's been such a disaster and trump came out
and you know saber rattled and threatened canada and canadians like to feel all virtuously
anti-american and so now the liberals are riding high and so that was careless i mean unless trump's
goal is truly to destabilize the country because that'll happen if we elected liberals again
you know carney who's now canada's prime minister he's a net zero advocate man and like on a major
scale he was governor of the bank of england every stupid idea of the last 20 years has mark carney's
name stamped on it on the international scene he loves diversity equity and inclusivity he's a
a central planning wef uh mainstay he was un climate envoy and he thinks that three quarters
of the world's fossil fuels have to stay in the ground and that's that's like the canadian economy
is like mostly a natural resource economy and oh so i'm actually i gotta say
i'm happy that trump trumped around like a madman and i think he made a big mistake politically
because i'm not happy with the fact that the liberals are back riding high in the polls that's
quite the cataclysm and i think he's going to be a sorry man if carney gets elected because carney
will do absolutely everything he can to undermine everything trump does on the international scene
and he will do that effectively because he has the connections so that's not good strategically
but i'm thrilled that he
maybe woke the country up a little bit and forced it to get its
attentional priorities straight maybe we'll see so so yeah yeah right vote pierre yeah that's right
yeah yeah
Or else, right?
It's nice of you Americans to notice, by the way.
Well, here we are on stage and everything.
Hopefully they noticed.
You have stated that you cannot think of a single negative interaction with your mother.
How does one become a mother whose children remember them so fondly?
Well, do you think that you. I mean, my mom and dad had some trouble in their marriage.
Primarily because my dad suffered from depression.
And that made things difficult for my mom.
And genuinely so.
And it's not like my dad was happy about that.
But apart from experiencing second-hand the difficulties in their marriage,
did you ever have any negative interactions with my mom?
No.
Well, so then she's. My mom was. Her mother-in-law.
So think about that.
So why was that?
Well. Oh my God, I'll tell you a funny story.
This is such a stupid story, but it's my mother in a nutshell.
Oh my God.
I can't believe this popped into my head.
I went to Manhattan 20 years ago with Julian, my son.
And he was singing at Carnegie Hall.
He was singing in this choir.
Kerosene.
Yeah, yeah.
He was singing songs.
That a Canadian composer had set to poetry that was written by kids in a concentration camp in Nazi Germany.
And we went to Carnegie Hall and to the UN to hear his choir.
And I asked my mother and her sister to come to Manhattan.
And she was always up for an adventure.
So they had never been to Manhattan.
And they were pretty thrilled about that.
And we got to go see Julian at Carnegie Hall and at the UN, which was like, that was cool.
And we were in Manhattan.
And my sister, who's a bit of a troublemaker.
And has a good sense of humor.
Decided that she would take my mother and her sister, both of whom are somewhat sheltered farm girls, to a drag club.
And it was a Chinese restaurant.
This was before the whole, you know, everything that's happened in the last 15 years.
So it was a joke.
And it was this Chinese restaurant that had this big black drag queen as the emcee.
And, like, girls were going there with their stagettes to have a time.
You know?
And so we went to this restaurant.
And there was this huge black drag queen there.
And my poor aunt, who was even more naive and sheltered than my mother, just sat there the whole time like this.
But they have good senses of humor, both those women.
And anyways, this black drag queen came along and got a look at my mom.
And my mom had, like, snow white hair and was a very fair person.
And then the black drag queen said, "You are the whitest person I've ever seen."
And my mother got, like, she kind of blushed and she was kind of laughing.
And the black drag queen said, "I bet you make a mean apple pie."
And my mom said, "Oh, yeah, yeah, I actually do."
So, it was so funny because those two people, like, you couldn't believe they were both part of the same species.
They were so far apart and they had a fun time.
And that's my mother.
Like, she was up for an adventure and she was a sheltered person in a way, but she was no pushover.
And she was very good-natured and hospitable and she could laugh at herself and she was a delight to be around.
And it is the case, like, the day she died, I was in a helicopter flying over the Grand Canyon.
We had done a show in Las Vegas, you know.
For a couple of years, I was banned in Las Vegas.
Isn't that good?
I'm so happy about that.
It's like gambling, mafia, murder, prostitution, no problem.
But Peterson, no way.
So, I definitely regard that as an accomplishment.
Anyways, we were flying over the Grand Canyon and I had traveled quite a bit with my mom.
On tour as well.
And we did that partly because we knew that she would have been up for that adventure.
And I spent the whole day thinking about her.
And I really, and still, even since then.
Like, I think the one memory that stands out, and this is typical of my mother too, is my sister and me and my little brother.
I was probably about 10 and he was about 5 and she was about 7.
We were orangutanging around the house and causing trouble.
And making noise and torturing my poor mother.
And she took out a wooden spoon and she whacked one of us with it and it broke.
And so, we laughed and she burst into tears.
And then, you know, we felt like absolute wretched, nasty, horrible little savages.
Which is exactly what we were for, you know, bothering our mom to the point where she actually got upset.
And like, that's my memory of a negative interaction with her, you know.
So, that's pretty good.
So, yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
And that's, she was a very hospitable person.
And a very self-sacrificing person.
And maybe to a fault.
Although, you know, when push came to shove and she had to stand up for herself, she went out and had herself a career once her kids hit school.
And she got a pretty decent position in our town.
She ran the library at the local college.
And she set her career in order.
And so, she was a successful wife.
And she had a successful mother.
And she had a successful career.
And she was a lot of fun to be around.
And so, you know, two thumbs up for my mom.
Do you want anything to say about her?
I love her.
Why?
She's a good mom.
I love her.
Yeah.
Yeah.
She supported us.
And played with us.
And was brave.
And came along with us for fun.
And she was just a great person.
Yeah.
She was a good grandmother.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah.
And Julian loves her.
I mean, good memories.
All good memories.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So, what are your thoughts on underage drinking?
I was an expert at it.
Yeah.
Well, I grew up in northern Alberta.
And I don't know how to explain northern Alberta to you.
Do you ever watch the Trailer Park Boys?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Well, that's eastern Canada.
But western Canada has its version.
And it's even more whatever the hell that is than eastern Canada.
And Fairview was like that a lot.
And it was dark and cold for much of the year.
Like, the year I went to college, it was 40 below for 38 days in a row.
And it was like, what?
It was like, what?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
What?
Oh, my God.
38 days in a row.
Right.
Well, so of course you drink.
What are my thoughts?
It's a bad idea to drink when you're a teenager, really.
Alcohol is a very destructive drug.
And it's very addictive, especially for people who enjoy it.
And I really enjoyed it.
And you learn how to socialize only when you're intoxicated.
And all your friends drink.
And a lot of my friends became, like, not good alcoholics.
And it's amazing we didn't die on the back roads.
Because we used to drive around drunk all the time.
Way the hell out in the middle of the prairie in the dark of night.
And the poor, bored policemen out in that northern outpost would chase us around.
And that was their job.
Chase stupid, drunk teenagers.
And our job was to avoid the cops and not die.
And mostly we did that.
It was too much, really.
And alcohol is a bad drug, you know.
So, alcohol is the only drug we know that actually makes people more aggressive, chemically.
Half of people who are murdered are drunk.
Half the people who murder them are drunk.
There'd be almost no domestic physical abuse if it wasn't for alcohol.
Like, it's a major contributor to heart disease and cancer.
Like, it's bad news.
And it's a bad idea when you're young.
Because I started drinking when I was probably 13.
Something like that.
And you structure your social life around it.
It took me a long time to even figure out that you could have a social life without drinking like 30 beer.
And so, better not to do it.
Now, it's tough, eh?
Because you don't want to be completely sheltered.
And one of the things that's happened to young people now is they don't date.
They don't go out with their friends.
They don't drink.
And you might think, well, that's an improvement.
No.
Doing nothing isn't an improvement over breaking some rules.
But, alcohol is a bad drug.
And your life is a lot.
Like, you know, we travel a lot.
I'll tell you one more thing about that.
We travel a lot, Tammy and I.
We've been on the road for eight years.
And we've gone to like, I don't know, 600 cities.
Like, we've traveled a lot.
And in most of those cities, we meet people for dinner and lunch.
And they're often cultural leaders of one sort or another.
And sometimes, we don't know.
they'll have a drink or two, and after two drinks, they all get less impressive, you know, and like,
I don't drink anything, and neither does Tammy, and partly because what we're doing is high stakes,
and there's no room for error at all, but it's noticeable, and so I would also say, if you have
something that's important to do, alcohol is not improving your performance, so better to step
lightly. You've said that children need to understand that malevolence exists in the world.
At what age should you go about that, and how should it be explained?
Well, you probably do that mostly with stories. You know, I was talking to my son. He's reading
his son, who's
only four. He's reading his son, Harry Potter, and that's pretty rough for a four-year-old, but this
little guy is, he's pretty verbally proficient, and he's got a long attention span, and he can
handle a complex story, and you know, I exposed my kids to relatively rough narrative material pretty
young, and I taught them to watch the hero, right? So, you know, because it's scary. Disney movies
are scary. Lord of the Rings is scary.
Harry Potter is scary, and so what do you do about that? You can shelter your kids from it,
or you can teach them to keep their eye on the hero, and that's what you want to teach them in
their life, right? It's like, keep your eye on the hero. He'll get through it, and so then you teach
them to be brave, and resourceful, and courageous instead of sheltering them, and if you don't
shelter them, then the evil queen doesn't inhabit your house, and that's very, very important, because
she's also malevolent, so, and how do you know when you should do that with your children? Well,
you've got to know, you've got to get to know them. You know, some kids,
some kids are very hard to frighten, and other kids are very easy to frighten, and so
you've got to watch your kid, and so if it's too much, you think, well, that was a little too much, and you wait for
a while, and you know, you've got to, well, this is what you do when you're playing with your kids,
is you, you push them, you know, like a good game with a kid is a game on the edge, you know, if
you're a father, you know this, you're, you're playing with your kids physically, wrestling with
them, and throwing them in the air, and you know, it's so interesting, even little kids, little tiny
kids, you know, like my son-in-law, I watch him now, he's got this little guy who's about
a year old, and my son-in-law's a pretty big guy, he's about six, six, I don't know, he's a pretty big guy.
He's bigger than I am. Yeah, yeah, and you know, he throws this baby up in the air, and it's like, I'm
thinking, wow, what's that like to be that baby? It's like, you know, you're like, you're 30 feet off the
ground, and a giant is throwing you in the air, and that's pretty exciting, and he loves it. This kid's
pretty, you know, rangy kid, and not easily scared, and so, but if the kid's laughing, and having a good time, then that's not
too much, and if he's like, crying in terror, and your wife is like, hitting you with a frying pan, then
probably you've pushed the limit a bit, and so, you can figure that out. If it's not fun,
then it's too much, you know, and, but it's tricky, because the most fun is right on the edge of
disaster, right? So, that's where it's most fun. Yeah, I've always thought that fairy tales, especially
there's something like, I don't know how to say it, like trauma preparation for children, and that's
why when people tell me, I don't like telling these fairy tales to my kids, because there's like a big
bad wolf that's eating the child, there's all these horrible things, I'm like, you know, the big bad
wolf is an imagistic, you know, story, and the child can take it in, you don't have to tell them
about the horrible rapist that's hiding in the dark, you tell them the story of a big bad wolf, and it
can tell them the story of a big bad wolf, and if they encounter real situations of danger, they have that spider sense already in them, and they can recognize opportunities, sometimes it's not just negative, opportunities as well, but then also the negative aspects of our possible story.
Yeah, your job is not to protect your children from serpents, your job is to teach them how to handle serpents, right? And so, yeah, right, and that's, that's a tough game, that's, that's very hard, and, and you have to be awake to
play that game properly, and your children want to see that in you, they want to see that their father
in particular, but also their mother, has the courage to contend with the terrible forces of
the world, and they want to see that the father in particular, but also the mother, if she's playing
her role properly, has faith in their ability to prevail and adventure, and so, and that's, so that's why you have to offer your children
to the world, that's what Abraham does with Isaiah, when he's offering them upward, it's like you have to offer your children, God, you have to offer your children to be destroyed by the world, or you're the destructive force, right, so, and the thing is, this is what happens in the story of Abraham, is that Abraham is willing to offer his son to God, and God gives him his son back, and what does that mean? Well, if you, if you're parents, and you offer your children to the world, they'll become competent, and, and courageous, and
and, and adventurous, and they'll like you, and want to have a relationship with you, and then you'll get them back, and so, that's a good deal, kids are tough, yeah, kids are tough, and, and, and, and you can teach them a lot, and they can surprise you with how brave they are, and that's what you want, you want your kids to surprise you with how brave they are, and you want to encourage that, and that takes some risk, so,
you do that within the confines of love, right, and you want to make it a game, and then it's okay, no force, right, or minimal necessary force, okay, good, thank you, everybody, lovely to see you.
Thanks, Tim.
You're welcome.
Thank you, Jonathan.
Thank you, Jonathan, it's been great.
Thank you all very much for coming.
Thank you.
Yep, good night.
Good night.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The cultural crisis in the West stems from a deep denial of intrinsic value and meaning, rooted in a materialist scientific worldview that removes significance from reality.
Perception is not neutral or objective; it is fundamentally shaped by value, as attention and actions are directed toward what one believes is important.
Stories are essential because they encode and transmit values, allowing individuals to imitate and internalize moral and existential frameworks, such as the spirit of the benevolent father or self-sacrificing hero.
The scientific method describes the object world, but it fails to account for the world of value, which is foundational to human perception, action, and social cohesion.
When narratives deviate from fundamental, universal value structures—like the journey of a princess finding her prince or male/female roles in family life—people lose interest, indicating that these patterns are deeply embedded in human psychology.
Pathological ideologies, such as the "evil queen" or negative feminine, reflect distorted values that harm individuals and societies, especially when they promote enmity, envy, or suppression of natural life cycles.
The proper aim in life—such as serving a higher purpose beyond self-interest—is linked to peace, abundance, and social harmony, as demonstrated in Christian and narrative traditions of self-sacrifice.
The crisis of modern culture, including political and educational systems, reflects a collapse of these deep value structures, leading to anxiety, depression, and social disintegration.
Summary:
The speaker argues that the deep cultural and existential crises in the Western world are not political or economic, but philosophical—rooted in a fundamental denial of value and meaning. Science, while powerful, assumes a value-free world of dead matter, which is incompatible with human reality, where perception, attention, and action are shaped by values. Stories are not mere entertainment; they are the primary mechanism through which value is transmitted, internalized, and lived.
Human beings naturally imitate narrative archetypes—such as the benevolent father or self-sacrificing hero—to form moral and social frameworks. When these narratives break down—such as in the reimagined Snow White where dwarfs are mocked or the "evil queen" narrative is distorted—people lose engagement, signaling that such stories reflect universal, deep-seated value structures. The speaker links this to the rise of pathological ideologies, like the "negative feminine" or envious, controlling older women, which harm both individuals and society.
These distortions are evident in education and political discourse, where liberal ideologies promote nihilism and undermine natural life cycles. The core insight is that science and technology only function well when grounded in a proper value system—especially one oriented toward self-sacrifice, service, and upward growth. Without such a foundation, science risks misuse, society fractures, and human suffering intensifies.
The solution lies not in rejecting science, but in reestablishing a narrative and value structure that reflects the deeper truths of human existence, such as love, service, and spiritual purpose. This reorientation is essential for restoring meaning, peace, and social harmony.
FAQs
Stories are deeply meaningful because they reflect the fundamental structure of value and reality. They show how our perceptions and actions are shaped by our underlying values, making them essential for understanding the world and navigating life.
The scientific worldview assumes a value-free, material reality, but this fails because human perception and action are inherently value-driven. Without value, motivation, suffering, and purpose disappear, leading to existential despair and societal dysfunction.
When value is removed from life, suffering and anxiety become inescapable. Since personal pain is real, denying its significance does not alleviate it, leading to depression, bitterness, and even suicidal tendencies.
Attention is not neutral—it is shaped by our values and aims. We only perceive what we value, and our perception of the world is directly dependent on where we direct our attention, making values foundational to reality.
Stories portray different value systems through characters and plots, allowing us to explore the consequences of various aims. By imitating heroes or villains, we internalize values like self-sacrifice, service, or power, and learn how they shape lives and societies.
Stories resonate because they reflect deep, universal patterns of human values—like the struggle between good and evil, or the need for self-sacrifice and rightful succession. When these patterns are violated, people lose interest because the narrative no longer aligns with their inner values.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.