100. Why Weight Loss Won't Solve All Your Problems
33m 56s
The episode challenges the myth that weight loss or physical transformation can solve deep-seated body image struggles, grief, or life dissatisfaction. Host Brie Campos shares her personal journey through emotional pain around singleness, relationship longing, and unmet expectations tied to body size—revealing how magical thinking, such as believing a smaller body would bring happiness or health, has long distorted her reality. She emphasizes that true healing comes not from changing one's body, but from sitting in the "suck" of grief, acknowledging what is missing, and accepting that desire and longing are valid. She highlights that health is rooted in medical care, rest, and self-compassion—not in numbers or diet culture. Brie dismantles the idea that thinness equals health or worth, noting that her own body pain and limitations have not been resolved by weight loss. Instead, she offers a framework for navigating body grief: writing a grief letter, using a free seven-step guide, and seeking compassionate support. The core message is that body image struggles are real and painful, but sustainable healing comes from radical self-acceptance, community, and the courage to sit with discomfort without blaming the body. This approach shifts focus from fixing to honoring, empowering individuals to live authentically despite unresolved grief.
Welcome to the Body Grievous Club. Hi friend, I am your host,
Brie Campos from Body Image with Brie. I am a fat positive body image coach,
educator and trained mental health counselor. My goal is to help you stop
hating your body and learn how to move through unavoidable body grief.
This won't be your average body image advice. No affirmations, no fluff,
no filter. I am prepared to say the quiet parts out loud.
And no matter how overwhelming or hopeless your body image feels,
you belong here. Hi and welcome back to another episode of the Body Grievous Club.
Today, I'm going to be talking about why weight loss cannot solve all of your problems.
Lessons in magical thinking, body image whack-a-mole, and sitting in the suck.
I was sad the day before my birthday. I was sitting in the suck as I was driving home from
dropping my dad off at the airport. Unlike a lot of people that I know, I am somebody who loves
my birthday. And I'm pretty sure it should be a national holiday. I think that's mostly because
it's the only day of the year I allow myself to receive without needing to reciprocate,
but that's probably a story for another time. As I was driving, I began to reflect on how
different my life looks than how I thought it would look by 36. I was already sitting
in some preliminary grief. Number one, there's been a lot of change in my life over the last year,
including that I no longer live with my dad, whom I started living with when I started grad school
in 2013. And while I am loving this new season of life, I was blissfully unaware
of how much work is required to run a house. Having him here for the week reminded me of that.
Number two, I wasn't supposed to be here for my birthday. One of my beautiful, amazing former
body-griever clients, who has become a lifelong friend, invited me to her destination wedding in
Mexico. And it just happened to be the same week as my birthday. She so graciously a year ago
invited me and a plus one to this intimate wedding. And I asked her, as she thought it was ambitious,
if RSVPing for two, that by the time her wedding rolled around, I could bring a romantic
partner for a fun weekend in Mexico. And also have a really hot date to the wedding.
We both agreed. We could totally manifest this by the time the wedding came.
But that's not what happened. Although I've made a lot of progress in my dating life,
by the time final RSVPs were needed, I was still single. I accepted this grief.
Then, unacceptedly, I became a dog mom. It wasn't supposed to happen this way. I was only planning
on fostering. But somehow, I bequeathed an old geriatric partially disabled senior pit bull,
who stole my heart from the very first day. And so due to being a very distracted dog mom and
ADHD, I didn't book my trip to Mexico in time. So I was no longer able to attend the wedding.
I had to sit in that suck. Number three, the reason I felt sad was because I thought to myself,
I'm grieving the difficulty of wanting a relationship and not being able to find what I want.
And while I can celebrate all of the growth and the progress I've made in my dating life,
while I can hold hope that what I want can exist, wanting a relationship of depth,
value, not wanting to settle, and not being able to find it, sucks. But something was coming
else, but something else was coming up for me, and I couldn't name it. Why was it causing me
so much grief? I sent a very long voice memo to a friend of mine as I was driving,
and she is a dear friend of mine for almost 20 years, and she happens to also be a clinician.
I said to her in my voice memo that I was sitting in the suck of being single. And I couldn't figure
out why it felt different today. I said that I put my heart and soul into finding the house in just
three months. So if I were to just put the same effort and energy in, would I be able to find what
I'm looking for when it comes to dating? Is it really just a numbers game that I'm not investing
enough energy in? And my friend, first and foremost, said she was sitting in the suck with me,
that she too understands the grief of wanting and knowing that we deserve a relationship with
someone who loves, adores and cherishes us, and not to settle. And that was it. I think many people
don't know how to do this step of just acknowledging this sucks. She said, I think number one,
a lot of people will settle. And that the numbers game doesn't mean that they're happy. It doesn't
mean that their life is perfect. It doesn't mean that they have everything that somebody who single
doesn't have. And I can attest to this. I have seen people who are married feel lonelier than some
of the single people I know. She said, it's not comparable to buying a house because with a house,
we can make a lot of concessions. And we could do that with finding a partner, but that's not what you
want. She invited me if I wanted to see if I could acknowledge what story was coming up that the
part that was feeling the grief around my singleness on that day. If could it communicate us what it
needed to hear in reflection, I was able to see the magical thinking that my brain was playing out,
being that it is my birthday, being somebody who has RSD or rejection sensitivity dysphoria,
and I put so much pressure on wanting my birthday to feel special, but then also being a people
please and not wanting to ask people to make me feel special, but then simultaneously being
worried that I'm not going to feel that way. And then I'm going to be disappointed.
The story I was telling myself was if I had a partner, then my birthday would always feel special.
And as soon as I said the story out loud, I knew that it wasn't necessarily true.
I know a lot of people who have wonderful amazing partners and they still have to remind their partners
to celebrate them on their birthday. It's something I had to do with my dad when I lived with him
for years. The first year I moved in with him, he sent me a happy birthday text.
And I was in the beginning phases of learning how to communicate my needs. And I said to him,
"I like to have something to open on my birthday." And almost every year since then, he has gotten
me a card or a gift, even if it was just something small or silly, but I was able to communicate
what I needed to feel loved. And he followed through and it didn't make it any less special
and I didn't feel any less loved. The magical thinking that if I were to somehow have a partner
that I wouldn't need to feel the burden of asking people to celebrate me,
sounded a lot like the magical thinking. I used to believe that if I could just lose weight,
all of my problems would be solved. I used to believe that weight loss would mean
my body pain would cease to exist, that my ability to find cute clothes would be more readily
accessible, that if I could shrink my body, that then I would be able to find a partner,
even though I want a partner who doesn't care about my body size, but I still thought it would
make it easier. What I said I wanted, and what I desired was thinness, but really what I wanted
was privilege. I wanted the privilege of existing in a smaller body to have access to clothes,
so that I could go to the doctors and not be assumed, that I am the cause of my own pain or sickness,
that I could go on a dating site or on a date and not fear for one second. Somebody might say
something about my body. I wanted privilege, but it was never just about weight loss. There have
been so many moments in my life where magical thinking distorted reality. I believed buying a house
was going to solve many problems as a child of divorce, and having an inconsistent address for
many of my adult years, there was something really healing about being able to know I was going to
know where I'm going to live for the foreseeable future. But I wasn't prepared for how much work
was required to uphold a household. I was unprepared for expenses that you don't plan for,
and you don't need to when you're renting. I didn't anticipate my cost of living going up
significantly, and where I used to be able to spend money without thinking too hard about it,
and a privilege, that is, I now have to be a lot more strategic.
For example, my trip to Mexico, I had to save intentionally for a year.
While I loved my home, it has come with problems I didn't anticipate.
It never solved all of my problems.
There were so many times I wanted a dog.
Which is why I started fostering.
I thought it was a way I could give back and feed this part of my heart.
Now, I wanted to love an animal and give it a safe home.
But there was a lot of stress and unforeseen hurdles that came with fostering.
And I didn't realize how much was required.
And how much puppies specifically put me out of my window of tolerance.
When I started fostering honey, the responsibility of taking care of this life.
That I am now responsible for is a great privilege.
But it is also a burden.
It is an anxiety that I did not know that I would have and I didn't have as a cat mom.
That the things that I used to be able to do, like leave a room or go to therapy or a Pilates class.
I can't do now because he has so much separation anxiety.
Or how much physical pain he experiences on a daily basis.
His inability to get up and down the stairs, the accommodations I need to find and create for him.
It is an honor and it is also a burden.
I didn't anticipate having a dog.
And while it has brought me so much joy and fulfillment.
It has also brought me problems.
All I can say is thank God I was saving for Mexico.
Because a lot of that money has gone towards taking care of my boy.
I have so many clients who believe that thinness, health and the absence of pain will take away all of their problems.
I used to believe this magical thinking too.
I used to think if I just had a consistent movement practice that my body wouldn't hurt.
My clients in my body reverb group said that they wish they could just get themselves to move their body more so they wouldn't feel pain.
And I shared that I moved my body consistently.
And I still experience body pain.
But I am not resentful to my body for feeling pain.
I am frustrated with pain and thankful that my body is communicating to me in the only way she knows how.
I used to desire thinness so much so I used to dream of what it would look like to exist in a smaller body.
I used to imagine the compliments and praise and adoration I would receive.
The clothing I'd be able to buy the ease of going to the doctors.
I remember believing I would be a more confident person if I existed in the smaller body.
But then I recall the times that I was in a smaller body.
It didn't make clothes shopping any more a pleasurable experience.
Even if I did fit into more clothes.
Because though my body changed, my brain didn't.
It didn't make me hate photos any less.
I still hated my body.
And there was never going to be a world in which changing my physical appearance changed the feelings I had towards and about my body.
Magical thinking is a dangerous game that especially around our bodies becomes body image whack-a-mole.
And that is evidence in my story that this sadness that showed up on my birthday around dating and being single and not having a partner is the same thread that was tethered to believing that having a smaller body would fix me.
And as soon as I recognized the magical thinking, I took a step back.
I recognized I am deeply loved.
I have so many people in my life who want and are willing to celebrate me.
I was reminded how many people I have in my orbit who care about me.
And I didn't have to do anything to earn it. It was given freely. And even in my most healed body image state, sometimes that still feels hard to receive.
If changing your body could truly transform your life long term, you wouldn't still be trying to change your body.
The ability to move through that momentary grief into the radical acceptance of I can sit in the suck of not having what I want and desire and still believe that my life is whole and complete.
Sitting in the suck doesn't mean that we fix it right now, but it also doesn't mean pretending it doesn't hurt.
Sitting in the suck is acknowledging what I want does not exist right now and maybe that it doesn't exist at all.
And maybe this is the moment I pause in a world where we are constantly bombarded by the pressure of thinness.
And now especially under the guise of health, it can be really hard to stay tethered to your convictions and beliefs when everyone around you is telling you otherwise.
There was a moment in my healing journey where I remember thinking, what if I'm wrong? What if the approach that I am taking is harmful? What if encouraging people not to lose weight is the wrong decision?
What if I am promoting harm like all of the people who accuse me of promoting obesity tell me that I'm doing? And I thought about it for a moment and I asked myself two things.
Who would need to speak on this topic with authority that would give me buy in?
Who would I need to hear from to say this is right for me to take 100% solace that I'm choosing the right path? I couldn't name anyone.
Number two are my convictions out of a place of defensiveness and if so, what am I defending?
As always, you have the right to do whatever you want with your body. There are people I love and respect and disagree on the take that they have with intentional weight loss.
When I thought about the things that I am convicted of, I am convicted of my values like compassion and helping others.
I am convicted of my politics and my skills as a therapist and there is no authority who has told me how to believe.
I have come to it on my own. It might be verified by other people's beliefs, but it is what has felt right in my soul.
I truly believe that I am doing the least harm and if I get to the end of my life and I was wrong about health at every size and intuitive eating and body acceptance and not being in support of intentional weight loss, I will have done so believing I was doing the most good.
I cannot say that if I was still promoting weight loss, especially because of the ignorance in our culture around eating disorders.
The stereotypes that we believe about eating disorders, we put into a nice pretty box so it makes sense and we let clinical diagnostic criteria determine who is "sick enough" and who is maybe just a little disordered.
I found in my own experience what I have found in the experience of my clients is that the way I take around bodies is the only one that is sustainable.
When I look at my messaging around body image, it has not changed very much in the last eight years.
I created my page in 2018. It will be eight years. Have some things that are different.
One, I used to call bad body image gremlins and I used to use Burnay Brown vernacular that we should dispel the body image gremlins shame in the darkness and bring it into the light.
I no longer see "bad body image" as something we need to disarm and destroy, but instead parts that we need to embrace and listen to and sit in the suck with.
I also think I have become far more trauma informed and hopefully far more intersectional and inclusive in my language.
But the tenets of my message have not changed in the last eight years.
Can you say the same thing for weight loss?
Can you say the same thing for diet culture and the wellness industry? Has there been longevity? Do we have evidence of long term sustained health more than five years that does not promote it?
an eating disorder or disordered eating, what I can tell you from my own
lived experience as somebody who was very concerned for my own health, who did
believe that my fatness was an indication of me being unhealthy because how could
a fat body be healthy? I am the healthiest I have ever been in my entire life and
I am also in the largest body of my entire life. A question you might want to
ask yourself is how do you define health? If thinness is the only way you define
it, then sure you being in a larger body, you'll never be able to reach your
definition of health. But when I thought about health, how will I know that I'm
healthy? I started with I wanted to have improved blood work. I'm going to tell
you right now that's still a slippery slope. This can still be disordered
because unless you can review your blood work with neutrality and is data, then
it just becomes a diet by another name. It is just diet culture and body image
whack-a-mole. It becomes about numbers and control. But weight loss was not
something that helped improve to my health. These two things were. Number one,
most importantly, going to the fucking doctors consistently. For years, I
avoided going to the doctors because every time I went to the doctor, I was
shamed. I was told that any ailment, even so much as having orthostatic hypertension,
which means my blood pressure drops, which is not a known side effect for a
person in large body, was because of my fatness. Really? It was because I was
dehydrated because I was working out too hard and too much and not drinking
enough water. I have set really firm boundaries around by doctors of what
treatment and what behavior and conversations I will and will not accept. I have
stayed with my provider and will not entertain conversations on weight loss
anymore. And if my providers insist on talking about weight loss, they're
not the provider for me. I have been with my provider since 2017. And for at least
the last five or six years, she has not brought up weight loss and she has
been very intentional on working with me on improving my health without needing
to change my weight. Number two, the second factor that helped improve my
health medication, being on the correct medications, adjusting those
medications ongoing helped me to regulate some of the numbers that were off,
figuring out how to work with my body, recognizing that chronic GI distress was
not a normal body experience, quote unquote, how do I allow myself to have a
better quality of life? How do I advocate more for myself when I'm being dismissed
at the doctor's office? I'll tell you, even healing my GI distress among other
things, it didn't magically change my A1C, but a lot of other markers have
significantly improved. Number three, I gave myself sexy, unconditional
permission to rest. That is right, rest. I'm sure many of you may be thought I was
going to say movement, but I tell my clients we can't talk about movement until
we talk about your relationship to rest. During the pandemic, I have never
worked harder in my entire life. After working a full day, I would collapse on
the couch, I'd watch reruns of the office, and I'd say I need to go to bed, and
I'd find myself stuck in a holding pattern. Patterns where I would sit in my
car and just knock it out. Or if I had plans on the weekend, I would feel sad
because I would be dreading it. I blamed it on being an introvert. I blamed it
on being an introvert, and the reality is I was burned out twofold. One, I've
chosen a career where I only get compensated by the hours, and it does a lot of
energy exchange to do 101 work. And two, because rest felt unsafe. When I was
not working, I felt anxious of what work still had to be done. Before I could
improve and heal my relationship to movement, I needed to give myself sexy,
unconditional permission to rest. And let me tell you, it was not a pleasant
experience. It didn't feel great. I had to sit in the anxiety and the distress
of the work being unfinished. I had to sit in that suck, but it is through time.
It is through the abundance of rest that has allowed me to heal and regain
things I've missed out on for a long part of my life. I used to avoid going to
bed, because I'd stay up and watch just one more episode. My body naturally gets
tired now. I naturally want to go to bed now. But back then I couldn't. I would
stay up and watch one more show, because the fear was I'm not going to get what I
need tomorrow. So let me reclaim it now. We call this bedtime procrastination. I
have also learned how to work with myself, and I know that with ADHD, I'm a one
weekend plan kind of girly. So I sent really firm boundaries around my plans
for the weekends, and I try not to make concessions that has helped safeguard my
time. I have become more strict with my schedule and not just taking on one
more person, because I want to help, because I will be a better provider if I don't
have seven, eight client calls a day. Knowing what I have needed and knowing that I
can trust myself is what allowed me to be able to bring some things back into
my life. I gave myself permission to rest. I gave myself permission to have a
body that was not mobile. That my body wasn't broken or bad if I didn't have
mobility. The mobility that I think I should have at this age, that me having
inability was not shameful. It did not make me a bad person. It was just data. And
as soon as I could neutralize body pain, body inability, it was through that that
actually allowed me to desire movement again. And my desire for wanting to move
again really came from a desire to wanting to sleep better. I have ADHD. So a lot
of times I would fall asleep at night, but I didn't feel tired. I wanted to
feel sleepy. And by starting to move again, I got that feeling back. And I have a
relationship with movement that I am not afraid that I will lose it. Getting my
dog, my movement practice has been far more inconsistent than it has in the
last year. And I'm not scared that I am missing out on days, because this is
life. I am adjusting to the life that I'm living right now. And I know I
naturally desire movement. And so when there is time and space, I will go back
to it. The more I move my body, the more I got to learn my body. The more body
image wounds showed up. But I also realized they weren't actually body image
wounds. I would become frustrated that there were moves that I couldn't do or
that I wasn't good at. Or when I used to be able to do 10 years ago. But what I
realized is I would have felt the same way if we were talking about singing or
theater or therapy or anything else because the wound is not because of my body,
it's because I'm not good at not being good at things. Weight loss was never going to
fix that wound. Weight loss cannot solve all of your problems. You have the right
autonomy over your body. But if we don't acknowledge the grief that our current
body costs us, we will continue to scapegoat our body as the problem. As the
happily ever after that we can't get. And we will continue to fund the 70
billion dollar industry that praise on our insecurities. They don't profit when
we are not broken. My clients always ask me, "Bree, how do I grieve?" And that I
cannot tell you. I don't know. I don't know how you grieve. I don't know how you
experience or you process emotion. I don't know your capacity and your coping
skills. But if I didn't know these things for myself, here's where I'd start.
Number one, I would write a grief letter to or about my body.
Why does being in this body feel so unsafe?
What is the cost of living in this body?
What is the worst part about it?
Number two, I would download my free guide.
You can comment seven steps on Instagram or you can go to my website, bodyimagewithbrie.com
and grab my seven step guide from body grief to radical body acceptance and it is free.
And I have a list of questions that I call curious questions that's an acronym to help
you navigate the worst part of the grief.
And number three, I'd reflect on how I would sit in the suck with someone else on this
same issue.
If someone else were to come to me with this feeling, how would I sit with them in this?
Would I rush them along?
Would I be impatient that they were feeling something illogical?
Or would I feel compassion?
Would I acknowledge the pain?
Would I ask how I can show up for them?
I want to lead with sometimes self-compassion, though great in theory is inaccessible.
I love self-compassion, but if it is not accessible to you, if it's like here's where the
self-compassion would be and there's nothing, we need something else.
We need something tangible in that moment.
For me, it looks like I cannot access self-compassion right now.
This isn't aligned with my values, but I have to stop speaking to myself in a way that
I would never speak to anyone else.
I can spiral in this moment, but this spiral is not actually going to bring me any closer
to what I want to feel.
I want to feel less out of control, and spiraling is only making that worse.
We have to find the most accessible rung on the ladder.
Not the rung on the ladder we think we should have.
The best thing we can do when we are grieving is see if you can find and trust someone
to sit in the suck with you.
Elizabeth Cougaross, the creator of the stages of grief, says that grief must be witnessed
to be healed.
And sometimes, when we let our grief be witnessed, it can make the load just a little less
burdensome.
And over time, in community, in activism learning, that is where we see radical change.
Hey friend, thank you so much for listening to this episode of The Body Grievous Club.
Like all of our podcasting friends, we ask that you like, subscribe and share this episode
with someone who you think needs to hear it.
I know that Body Grief is tough, but I hope this episode helped you to feel less alone.
To learn more about how you can shift your body grief to radical body acceptance, be
sure to check out my free seven step guide designed to help highlight how you can transform
your body image story.
You can also learn how to work with me inside of the show notes.
Remember my friends, your body grief is painful and real, that you are never alone, especially
when you're part of The Body Grievous Club.
Thank you for listening, and until next time.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Weight loss does not solve body image struggles or life challenges, as evidenced by the speaker’s personal experience of grief over singleness and unmet desires.
Magical thinking—such as believing a smaller body will lead to happiness, health, or relationship success—is a recurring pattern that distorts reality and fuels body image whack-a-mole.
The speaker identifies sitting in "the suck" as a vital, non-negotiable practice of acknowledging grief without denial or false hope, especially around body size, relationships, and autonomy.
True health comes from consistent medical care, proper medication, self-compassion, and rest—not from weight loss or diet culture.
The speaker emphasizes that body pain and limitations are data, not flaws, and that rest and acceptance are essential foundations for healing and movement.
Radical body acceptance is not achieved through affirmations or changes in appearance, but through trauma-informed self-reflection, grief acknowledgment, and community support.
The speaker rejects the idea that body image issues must be "fixed" and instead advocates for embracing body grief as a natural, valid part of the human experience.
Long-term health and well-being are sustainable only when autonomy, self-compassion, and authenticity are prioritized over external expectations or industry-driven ideals.
Summary:
The episode challenges the myth that weight loss or physical transformation can solve deep-seated body image struggles, grief, or life dissatisfaction. Host Brie Campos shares her personal journey through emotional pain around singleness, relationship longing, and unmet expectations tied to body size—revealing how magical thinking, such as believing a smaller body would bring happiness or health, has long distorted her reality. She emphasizes that true healing comes not from changing one's body, but from sitting in the "suck" of grief, acknowledging what is missing, and accepting that desire and longing are valid.
She highlights that health is rooted in medical care, rest, and self-compassion—not in numbers or diet culture. Brie dismantles the idea that thinness equals health or worth, noting that her own body pain and limitations have not been resolved by weight loss. Instead, she offers a framework for navigating body grief: writing a grief letter, using a free seven-step guide, and seeking compassionate support.
The core message is that body image struggles are real and painful, but sustainable healing comes from radical self-acceptance, community, and the courage to sit with discomfort without blaming the body. This approach shifts focus from fixing to honoring, empowering individuals to live authentically despite unresolved grief.
FAQs
Weight loss does not address the root causes of body grief or emotional pain. As Brie explains, magical thinking—believing that physical changes will fix deeper issues—fails because emotional well-being comes from self-acceptance, not appearance.
Sitting in the suck means acknowledging painful emotions like longing for a relationship or feeling inadequate without trying to fix them. It's a form of radical acceptance that allows you to feel the grief without denying it, which fosters healing and self-compassion.
Magical thinking leads people to believe that changes like weight loss or improved fitness will magically fix emotional pain, health issues, or relationship struggles. This ignores the fact that our feelings and desires are not dependent on physical appearance.
Yes, body pain is a signal from your body, not a failure. Brie emphasizes that pain is a form of communication and that avoiding it or trying to eliminate it through weight loss doesn't resolve the underlying issues or improve overall health.
You can start by writing a grief letter to your body, asking questions like 'Why does this body feel unsafe?' or 'What is the cost of living in this body?' Brie also recommends using her free seven-step guide to navigate body grief more effectively.
Yes. Brie shares that her health improved through consistent doctor visits, proper medication, and rest—not weight loss. True health is about holistic well-being, not numbers on a scale.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.