Go back

Why We Crave Gurus: A Skeptic's Reckoning With Belief, Bitcoin, and Burning Man | Vikram Gandhi

55m 40s

Why We Crave Gurus: A Skeptic's Reckoning With Belief, Bitcoin, and Burning Man | Vikram Gandhi

Burning Man began as a radical social experiment in the Nevada desert, rooted in anti-capitalist ideals, gift economies, and communal living, inspired by a symbolic man-burning ritual. While the original vision emphasized rejection of consumerism and a return to self-reliant, inclusive human connection, the event has evolved into a complex reality where billionaires build luxurious camps and the presence of money contradicts its founding principles. Vikram Gandhi’s documentary *The Man Will Burn* examines this contradiction, revealing the tension between Burning Man’s utopian roots and its current commercialization. Similarly, Gandhi’s earlier work, *Kumare*, critiques spiritual authority by portraying a fake guru who develops a real following, exposing how belief systems—whether in religion or online gurus—operate through psychological mechanisms, not truth. Both projects highlight a recurring human pattern: the creation of mythic figures (like Larry Harvey or Satoshi Nakamoto) who inspire trust and belief, even when their identities are unknown or fabricated. Gandhi ultimately argues that while spiritual traditions may be flawed or manipulative, they offer valuable tools for self-awareness and connection. The true meaning in these experiences lies not in doctrine, but in shared human moments of listening, empathy, and mutual growth. Ultimately, Burning Man and spiritual belief systems reflect the enduring human need for community, meaning, and transformation—despite their contradictions and imperfections.

Transcription

10122 Words, 53449 Characters

English
(upbeat music) Hey everybody, welcome to the 10% Happier Podcast. I'm Dan Harris. For decades, various friends of mine have very passionately encouraged me to go to Burning Man, the annual festival in the desert of Nevada that draws tens of thousands of people. And these passionate invitations and exhortations have landed for me as sometimes inspiring and intriguing and sometimes irritating. It's that people who really are into Burning Man a little bit remind me of that classic cartoon in The New Yorker from a decade ago and has two women eating lunch. And one of them says to the other, I've been gluten free for a week and I'm already annoying. And that can really happen with people who get deeply into Burning Man. So today, we're gonna talk about the truth about Burning Man. But we're gonna talk about it much more than that because my guest is a fascinating figure into culture. His name is Vikram Gandhi. He's the co-director of a new documentary on HBO called The Man Will Burn. But he's done a lot of other stuff that I wanna talk to him about. In fact, he burst onto the collective consciousness in the early arts when he made a documentary called Kumare in which he plays a fake Indian guru who is able to inspire a real following conundrum that creates a real reckoning for him. So we're gonna talk to Vikram today about whether a skeptic can find meaning, why we're so drawn to gurus, what is the truth about Burning Man and much more? Vikram Gandhi, after this quick break. A few things before we hear from our sponsors, I've got exciting news. If you love this show, but do not love listening to the advertisements, a subscription to my app, 10% with Dan Harris, now includes a private, ad-free feed of the 10% happier podcast available on whatever platform you choose, whether that's Apple podcasts, Spotify, or right inside the app itself. Plus, along with an ad-free listening experience, the app also gives you a growing library of meditations from world-class teachers, exclusive live stream events with me and many of our incredible instructors and robust and supportive discussion threads where you can ask questions, share your struggles and connect with our growing community. We've got a free 14-day trial. If you want to try before you buy, join the party, DanHarris.com. We'll be right back after this. Vikram Gandhi, welcome to the show. - Thank you, thanks for having me. - I love your new documentary on Burning Man. It's awesome. For people who don't know what Burning Man is, can you just describe what it is? - Burning Man is a social experiment. A people building a city in the middle of the desert. And in that city, there is no exchange of money and it is an experiment in sort of communal living. In some ways, people can look at it as a temporary utopia. Some people call it a festival. Some people call it accidentally. Think it's a music festival because there's so much music or an arts festival because there's a lot of art. But I would say for the people who started it and the attempt to maintain its roots, it's a social experiment and basically living in a different culture, like reinventing culture in the desert. - Your documentary, which again is called The Man Will Burn, it's on HBO, and again, I loved it. It does a lot of things, but one of the things it does is like trace the arc of Burning Man. And as you said, the original founder, I think his name is Larry, something-- - Larry Harvey, yeah. - Larry Harvey. His idea was really anti-capitalist? - I would say it's very much anti-capitalist in its roots. I mean, Burning Man first started when Larry Harvey told his friend, "Hey, I want to go burn a man on a beach in San Francisco "called Baker Beach." - Oh, wouldn't man, not an asshole man. - Yeah, wouldn't man, excuse me. And there's a lot of myths around why he did it. Was it just a spark of an idea? Was it supposed to be this pagan ritualistic thing? Did he watch the movie Wicker Man right before that? These are kind of myths that I've heard. And the idea of it being a myth is, I think, important to it. Yeah, Larry Harvey started it. And as this sort of experiment happened, it started on Baker Beach. And then, the first burn was like 10 people. And I think that what they saw was that there was this, almost religious fervor that people had when they were looking at this man burn. And it felt like a pagan ritual when you look at it, but it's happening in the 80s. And they did it again the next year. And there were like 100 people. And then they did it again the next year. And there were many, many more people. And they would start throwing a party around in those music. And at some point, so many people started coming that the cops shut them down. And they realized they had to go somewhere else. And that's when they went to the BlackRock Desert. And the burning man that we see in images started then in the 90s. It's now what, 80,000 people a year, something like that? It's 80,000 people a year who come together, build this city from scratch in the desert. All kinds of people, builders and people who are working on the infrastructure, and then all these people are coming to make art, create camps, throw parties, all of that. So 80,000 people, most of whom are 80,000 people there for about a week. And, but there's a lot of people who go there for like weeks before to build it. - And I think you mentioned there's no money. It's all, it's a fully a gift economy. - Yeah, I think the founders of Burning Man, there's a book, I'm forgetting the name of the author, but called The Gift. And I've heard that they read that book. And in it, it was the idea that things, objects that we have, they hold a different meaning when they're gifted to you. There's a story behind them. It's not about purchasing something. And I think they thought, well, what if in this environment, you just can't buy anything. And of course, in the beginning, it was in the desert, like there's no stores around there. So you couldn't buy anything. But if you brought everything to, that you could be self-reliant, and then you brought some more to share with people. And that just kept happening and happening. And you brought art, or you brought a party, that that would change human interaction. And that would become, in some ways, a release valve for capitalist society. I've heard people say that Burning Man is trauma bonding around, the trauma bonding of capitalism. And so its roots were definitely an arctic. It's definitely anti-capitalist. They had a lot of connection to performance artists and street art in San Francisco that were like critiquing culture. There were people aligned with Burning Man in the beginning that did something called the Billboard Liberation Front where they would satirize commercialism and capitalism. I would say to get it right, it was a lot more anti-consumerist than necessarily anti-capitalist. If there is a difference, I think that's debatable. But that was the idea of kind of mocking our consumer culture, that everybody was consuming things. And that's the way that we live, that we were just all about consumption as opposed to what if it was all about giving, building, creating, in their case, making art. One of the critiques you hear, and I kind of gently made fun of Burning Man and Burners in the intro, which you were sitting here while I recorded. So you heard it. One of the critiques you hear is that this was supposed to be this, if not anti-capitalist, at least, anti-consumer, or consumer culture event. And yet now it is populated in no small measure by billionaires who have a whole parking lot of their private jets in the desert. And they build these incredibly expensive private camps that they attend. And some of these billionaires, or I think you can make a pretty strong case, not necessarily nudging humanity toward its best version of itself. So how do you square that with the original intentions of the founders? - I think that what's really beautiful about the way this social experiment started is that there are so many accidents. Like, did Larry Harvey know that one day when he built the man that this city would emerge, that people were gonna all come there, and did he know that in the beginning? Probably not. Like, I think that it was an experiment in the beginning and it just kept going, and in some ways I say, I think one could say that he burnt this man and people gathered around it. And for the last 30 years, people have been debating what it means. And there was a point where Larry, you know, in our documentary, one of the early members of Burning Man explains that Larry went out on like a pilgrimage to Mexico and he came back and he said, "I have nine principles." And then this guy is Stuart Mangram jokes that he's, you know, they said to him, "You need 10, like any self-respect and cult." That is actually the tone of Burning Man, which is that, yes, we have these beliefs, but like, it's also a big joke. Like, the world is a big cosmic joke. So that being said, I think one of the more important guiding principles of what the place has been is that, you know, they kind of don't tell you what you're supposed to believe. I remember when I first went, I thought, you know, I brought a tent. I went to, I went and bought like everything I just needed for myself like I was going camping. And then when I arrived and I met the people, they, we, you know, in Reno that I was going with my friends, we went to Walmart and they started filling all of their, all their carts up with steaks, steaks, steaks and in champagne and beer. And I was like, wait, what is going on here? I thought we were like camping in the desert. And when I got there, I realized it was totally not what I thought. It didn't have this sort of ethic or moral around it. It was like, this is just, this is just the planet. This is just humanity. And we just come here and do this, whatever we want to do. And there's not like a rule here, but there's like a guiding principle like where this, this is a place where you have to be self reliant. You have to be part of it. You can't, you can't just be a spectator. The early Burning Man days were, were, you know, strictly about one thing or another. I feel like I just don't think it, it happened like that. And I don't think there is a moral grounding of, of how to judge how people go to Burning Man. I do think the way people talk about it can change the way that the outside world perceives it, because they talk about in the same, in the same way that a lot of people talk about going to church or religion or some mystical experience they had. So I do think like the big conundrum, the big conundrum of that's inner documentary. And I think is in Burning Man culture right now is the exact question you're asking. Like, look at all the money. There's, I would, I think we estimated that like $400 million of things come to Burning Man. We've, we've filmed with people who have multimillion dollar art cars that have speakers on it to throw parties. And I think the bigger question is, if this place is supposed to be a way to kind of create a new culture outside of capitalist society, how do you mark where? Where what's happening inside starts replicating what is actually on the outside. I think it's human nature to think you can escape all of those rules. So you will see that it's not structured so differently. I think that the idea is that it's trying to guide people in a way that like, when you meet people, you give them a hug like their family. When you, when you go to a party, there's no, you, you can't be exclusive. It's all inclusive. And I just think that it's a rare place where that is the direction. And whether or not it actually fulfills what these principles are, I mean, it's pretty hard to act like that, you know? I sometimes think it, it works really well in the first few days. And then just like, everything else like things start falling apart. So, so I think that the criticism of it's not being what it stood for is totally like valid. And I think it's something we struggle with in the documentary and something that becomes very obvious. Hey, there's no money here. And then you see private jets flying everywhere. Like, how does this work? But at the end of the day, it's, it's a big experiment. And I think once I went to the first time and I realized that this wasn't some ethical thing I wasn't doing. Like, there's no morality to it. All that stuff we bought in Walmart, we had to get rid of. And I remember we drove through the Native American reservation on the way back to Reno with garbage bags. And there was a sign that says, said it on the reservation, we'll buy your, you pay us to take your garbage. And I was like, so we gave, we for $5 we paid, you know, people on Native American reservation to take our garbage. And I was like, this is the most American thing ever. It is not what I thought it was. It's not like, hey, you go to Burning Man and you're a better person than everyone. It's just like a full expression of it. It's not. So I think like, that's the impression that people have that there's maybe these new age or mystical or religious sort of connotations or even environmentalist connotations. But it's definitely, I think there's an effort to do that. But I would say that's not an accurate portrayal. In some ways, it's just like an alternate culture and direction that has its own kind of aesthetic and art. And it's like its own civilization for a week. But I know exactly what you mean. And I think it's still a question. Can a place actually function and be anti capitalist or anti consumerist and then still have all this money port into it? It does make a lot of burners scratch your head as well. I have to say, I came away from the documentary a lot less skeptical. Like I landed, I where you just took us, which is this is an experiment with very interesting ideas behind it. But it's also a big, beautiful, hypocritical mess. And that's kind of awesome. I mean, I think that's actually the beauty of it. I mean, it's not a place that you censor yourself. Like I think actually one of the reasons that one of the main reasons Burning Man has changed also is because of social media. Like this was a place that it was okay to be naked. I mean, it's okay to say anything. And all of a sudden when cameras start coming in there, people become less free and open. I mean, I think in some ways it felt like it transcended all this stuff that was happening, you know, in the world of cancel culture and stuff. Like I think a lot of burners didn't want that to happen to Burning Man. Like even though, I think many of the people who go to Burning Man, most of them actually believe in those ideals in the outside world. But in the, but in this like little community where it's, you're supposed to be sort of creating a family where everything is safe. And there's no rules. Those moral and ethical rules from the outside world are also scary because they're just keep pouring in. Like I would say that the world just start, the outside world is seeping into Burning Man. There's really nothing we can do about it because now people like, now there's phone reception out there. And, and you can get on the internet. So I think there was a force field around it before. And that force field is like, is very weak unless, you know, anyone can decide. So I think in a lot of ways that's happening. Like the culture is changing because it's hard to keep out the outside world. Where do you land? I mean, you, you spent many years, you and your co-director documenting, not only the event itself, but you got incredible access inside the Burning Man organization during some tumultuous times with lots of infighting, some of it involving Elon Musk's brother. Is that his younger brother, Kimble? Kimble, yeah. Kimble Musk, who joins the board and, and trust him, disrupt things, which I recommend people watch the documentary to see how that plays out. I'm just curious like, where did you net out? Will you now that you've finished the documentary? Will you go back as a, will you keep going back as a participant? Or are you kind of just like done with a thing for a while? One of the reasons that this all happened was, you know, my co-director, Johan, who is an amazing filmmaker. She directed the Val on HBO. And she, she had connected with, with a, with the CEO Burning Man and the, and the board of Burning Man. And they wanted people to document their journey. And she came to me as she was finishing season two of the Val and said, we need a director to come in who's been to Burning Man, you know? And I at that point had gone probably like eight or nine times. I would say it was not as hardcore of like a New Yorker. And so I would just go there for a few days. And I knew like my counterparts in California might have been thinking about Burning Man for, like they're the ones really building it. You know, in some ways, I was parachuting in, which is, you know, part of, not actually part of the culture. This is one of the most fun things on earth. And if I don't have to go to a wedding on that Labor Day weekend, in the end of August, and I don't have anything in my schedule, that's, that's the place I'm going to go. Of course, this has changed my relationship with Burning Man. I mean, taking a camera out and filming in that location, it's not just the camera, it's also the microphones in the sound. That is almost completely against the vibe. It took me understanding the Burning Man culture and being a being somebody went to Burning Man to, to be able to bring those cameras in there. And, but, um, so, but to also your point, we got behind the scenes. Yeah, one of the, you know, one of our, our characters who is in it is, is Kimball, Massey, Lonn, most brother in the show, in the, in the series, um, he, he also plays a, uh, a part of talking about sort of the early ideas of Burning Man that didn't have an organization. Like, when Burning Man started, it didn't have an organization. It wasn't supposed to be safe. It wasn't supposed to have any rules. And people were just going out to the desert. And in it, he actually really embodies the voice of a lot of people at Burning Man who said, we don't need an organization. I mean, it was really fascinating that it was happening. You know, scenes happen kind of before Kimball's brother was, uh, was working on Doge, but it was similar. Like, it was interesting, it was an interesting parallel in that, like, a critique of the governing body, you know, of Burning Man that was, um, spending money and, um, and, and people who were, who loved Burning Man were saying, Hey, like, why do we have this organization? their questioning leadership. And I think in our film, Kimball really embodies, I think a lot of the opinions of a lot of people who maybe just like we're afraid to speak up. And I think in some ways that's the dilemma that like if you can have the organization do things and set things up or you can have the people with means and resources help you set up. And that's not dissimilar to the outside world, you know, if you want to rely on the government or do you want to rely on big corporations? And I think the same thing that happens in the outside world is happening inside Burning Man, the same question and it's a threat to the organization, what he says, but I think in some ways he also embodies the real feeling of people who go to Burning Man is like, why do we even have this organization? And the organization really believes that they're helping make sure that some of those cultural elements that we're talking about before that they stay in there. And so it's a funny back and forth and it's not that dissimilar to the outside world. And I think that's actually what's so interesting about inner mechanisms of a place like that. Like you just keep replicating the same thing. You know, you can't change the human nature. You can change the look and feel of it, but human nature is the same. So I may be feeling less skepticism than what many of your viewers may walk away with. Part of the reason why is that I have spent a lot of time up close with meditation organizations, including retreat centers. And I've seen that even people who have spent decades of their life practicing the Dharma, practicing deep meditation, when you bring any group of humans together, no matter how enlightened or close to enlightened they may be, there will be politics. And of course that's going to happen with, even with an organization like Burning Man where the principles are super idealistic. Yeah, it's just hard to get humans together to cooperate on a joint project. So I was less surprised by that. - I was always seeing the story of Burning Man resembling a lot like any church or religion. I mean, in the Burning Man story there's a schism early on with a lot of these ideals built into how Larry was thinking about it, you know, Burning Man has a temple, Burning Man has a symbol, Burning has a ritual, there's a hero's journey that goes through that week that leads up to a communal ritual. And there's an organization that's running it that's trying to keep the place pure, but of course there's donors who come in and I mean, you can hear the story of the Catholic church and almost any like large religious organization, if it whether it's Buddhist or anything or Christian, all of these organizations have a similar kind of thing that they have to deal with. Like you're talking about donations, you're talking about people with more means, do they get access to something? And Burning Man's just struggling with the same thing, but also at the same time, it's also a city. So they have to provide, they have to build, they have to have a hospital and then they have roads. And so weirdly this experiment is very complicated and you definitely need some kind of organization. And I would say that Larry Harvey, in some ways, was sort of like a Messiah figure to it. I think the joke is that he's at once that, but he's also the opposite. Like as far as I know, he was just a great storyteller who loved talking to people. And they were just all building it around him. Like it's not like he actually, there are other people who are there who are like, we should build a road here, we should shape it like this. But he just kind of gave everyone this vision of like, well, why don't we just go for this thing? And then everybody's sort of aligned. And in that way, it does resemble like a cult or religion in the way that it's happened. And then just like all of these things, we hear the story of like, is this church or is this society or this culture or this meditation group? Is it still authentic? Can you still have an experience? And I think that's also what we try to explore. Is can you still have like an actual mind-blowing mystical experience in this place? And I think you can. And even though maybe the whole city has changed, like it's like Brooklyn or something, like it's, Burning Man has been gentrified. But can you still have a really good time and find what you're looking for? I think we've seen that people are still having that experience. So it's not over, you know, I think to some degree, it's like, oh, well, I would have gone 20 years ago. I don't think that's true either. I think it's just evolved and more people have come. I remember when I was a kid and I would go to summer camp and every summer all the kids would say, yeah, the summer's okay, but last summer, man, last summer was the best one. I want to broaden the discussion though, because this is not the only film you've made. Let's go back to the film that kind of got you noticed, Kamare, I was telling you this before we started rolling. I'm kind of embarrassed to admit that I've known you for a while and I hadn't watched it until today. It's extraordinary. Basically in it, you kind of masquerade as an Indian guru, even though you're not. And you're this fake guru who develops a real following. Why did you do it in the first place? - You know, looking back after years, it becomes very obvious. Like I grew up in a home where my father started temples. Like there was a Hindu temple that started in my basement in New Jersey. And his father before I'm started a Hindu temple in Burma. So I was around these sort of mechanisms of how a religious organization worked, because like my father was running one and my parents were deeply involved. They're still very involved in like their community. But I also met a lot of gurus growing up and I met a lot of pundits who did rituals and I just had an inside look. I mean, we went to a lot of osherms growing up. I was in my father started meditating and so, and doing yoga and so we went, we really just like we're very much in searching for spirituality in America, or Indian spirituality in America. And I think my parents wanted us to keep our culture. And so what was around was less, you know, was was the sort of American version of it, you know, which was the Tri-State area. So we would go to osherms and I would meet all these different swamis and I would watch their reaction. And some of them were like, this place is not for us, you know, like it may have been too hippie-dippy or New Agee or the person who was running it seemed like a charlatan and we ended up, I ended up going to an osher when I was a kid and got really close with the swami who ran it. And he was kind of like, you know, like a grandfather figure. So I was very close to watching it, but I always was the guy, the kid in the class who was like pointing out the mistakes, you know. Hey, I remember I had this whole, I remember outing one of the swamis who we were cooking for small hours and everything was supposed to be vegetarian. I said, isn't a gelatin in this like have animal products and he was like, you know, don't ruin it. And then at the campfire and he got angry at me. I remember that and I remember I outed him at the campfire and be like, swami just lied to us. I was always like seeing these people as regular people. I never believed any of these gurus had any kind of like magical powers or were any way enlightened. Even the idea of enlightenment seems so ridiculous. It felt like it was just like the heaven or, you know, angel myths being, you know, transformed into an Eastern version. So I was always like really skeptical, but also really incredibly knowledgeable out it about it. Like I mean, the mythology I grew up with, like kids were reading like Marvel, I was reading like Hindu comic books. Like, so I was super educated in it and I was around it and I had a lot of questions. And then what really made me want to make Kumaris that I just, I was watching yoga, meditation, and Eastern philosophy becoming a big trend in New York and becoming a scene and being commercialized to in a way that was in its roots in its early days back then. Now it's indistinguishable from like wellness. But I was watching that happen and all of these kind of, you know, crazy gurus getting followers. This is like this bizarre version of what was happening in India. And what happens in any society with like, you know, mega churches and the critiques we can have about anything. So this was my way of kind of looking at my entire life up to that point and trying to reflect on it to see how I fit into American societies and indeed American. I also would say that in a lot of ways I made an entire movie that was talking about cultural appropriation. And I didn't even know what that word was back then when I made it. I wonder if I knew that word if I needed to make the movie. But ultimately it starts off about that, like an Indian American pretending he's from India. And I, but I also look at it as like a deep experiment in sort of showing that like religion is also an illusion. And you know, it's a structure that we don't really need. And it's maybe it's not part of spirituality. Maybe these gurus don't need to be part of spirituality. And maybe nothing is in a way I looked at the whole thing to Zen Cohen, like, that's the idea. Like, it's a big joke or big thing. And at some moment, you get this like flash of realization, oh, I don't need anyone. And that was like my hope, like, can people watch that and go, oh shit, like, I, I start following people. I believe in stuff that's not real. I'm, I'm looking for an outside person to help me and I'm not empowering myself. So in a lot of ways, it's aspirational of like, what I wanted to believe in. And, you know, by changing my voice and changing my character, I could embody the character who could deliver that message. And also the part that I was fake is actually, to me, the strongest part of Kumari the Guru was that, like, the strongest and, you know, the most, the most enlightened Guru is actually the one that's like not real. Because all humans are flawed, but like Kumari isn't real. So you could, you could say that he's, he's a fraud. And he's like, that's actually part of my identity, part of Kumari's identity as he wasn't real. So there are so many questions that arise out of this social experiment. We really start as a social experiment. You set up the movie, you talk about your background, you talk about why you're doing it. And you say, okay, I'm gonna go to Phoenix, Arizona where nobody will recognize me. I'm gonna, I'm gonna see if I, as a fake guru, can develop a real following. But very quickly, like, it gets complicated because you do develop a real following. And then you start feeling quite conflicted about the fact that you, you have essentially tricked these people into a relationship with a guru who they believe in, even though he's not a real guru. So just talk a little bit like, at what point did you start in this process to develop feelings of like, oh, no, what have I gotten myself into here? And what am I doing to these people? - You know, some of the slight of hand in the storytelling process and editing process is to kind of create this hero's journey where realizations come and different emotions happen at different times. But I think the reality is that from the first moment I started, which I think is portrayed more like a joke and we go into it, like, hearted and not knowing. From the first moment I started, it was terrifying that I was crossing a taboo that I shouldn't be crossing. And all the way in the last moments where it feels, you know, later on where it feels really heavy like when you're revealing the truth to the followers. - Yeah, and when people are telling me really intense things, like it was really heavy, but we were also still laughing every day because it was so ridiculous. And I think in the narration of it, it feels like, okay, it started as a joke and became really serious. And it is true, we went deeper and deeper. As I got deeper and deeper, I lost myself in it. But from the very second, I mean, I thought, this is actually playing with fire. The first time I tried out mutual friend of ours helped me set it up and I went to New Jersey to try out the character to see, hey, can this work? You know, like I grown out my beard, you know, a little bit longer than this and I went to a yoga studio. We were shooting like some, you know, some images to kind of fundraise off of and basically, we shot in a yoga studio with like extras that we hired. And then the woman who ran the yoga studio said, who is this guy? Like, can he teach in my studio? So we're like, this is a great opportunity to really do it and test it out. When we tested it out, there was a woman who came up to me, I was making up rituals, making up mantras. I was doing exercises that made no sense and I had this ritual that I did where I put my forehead against someone else so I could shoot like, you know, spiritual energy into their third eye. And this girl looked at me and said, I will, I will just like follow you anywhere. And from that moment, I was like, oh, shit. Like, this is some real shit. This is not like me. It was a joke before and I thought maybe I could do it and I was going blindly into it, like just, yeah, I could do it. And then all of a sudden I had the realization, like maybe I can do something. Maybe this is actually like a real film. Yeah, and that's when it started. Sorry, I'm rambling here. What was the-- - Well, I guess my question for you is like, there have been, I mean, the film was extremely well received at one of the audience prize at South by Southwest for best documentary. I personally loved it. I think it was critically reviewed very warmly. And yet there were some criticisms about the ethics of it. You know, was it fair to the followers who thought they were in a real thing but they were actually in a fake thing? Where do you come down on that? - Well, I was younger back then, you know, and it's almost, I almost felt like I had my own ethical code, you know, which is very cult leader like I guess, but also like this was the art I wanted to make. And I gotta say, I felt more strongly about this, doing it in this way than I feel like I've ever really felt about any project. I would tell people like I would feel, maybe I feel weird about doing this, so I feel strange, but I would feel worse if I didn't tell this story. 'Cause I just kind of felt like nobody else was saying it. I felt like hey, I grew up with all this thing that's sort of new in America and with this insight and this education from my childhood also studying college and I was like, this is the thing that I wanna do. And so I just felt like the message was more important than anything that like nobody is telling you this message. And you could do it in a scripted movie or you could write a book about it, but like nothing is better than actually seeing it play out in real life. It's a science experiment or social experiment. And the message is what? - People can believe in something that's not real and change themselves and empower themselves and it doesn't matter if the thing they were focusing on is real and that's what Kumari was. I mean, he was sort of a talisman or an icon, but he was completely like empty vessel. There was nothing in there. I wasn't really teaching anything. Actually, what I told people was I asked them to make a plan about how they wanted to change their life and just to promise me they were gonna do it and look me in the eye and say, I'm going to do this. And that was actually the catalyst for them doing things. So when they looked back at like, what was the teachings of Kumari were giving them? Yeah, there were a couple like chance and things that were just sounds that I made up. But really the thing that people benefited was like, because they thought of it themselves. And that message, I felt like this was saying something about all of religion. Like it was a take down of all of religion. It was like, these are just stories. They're mechanisms to getting us to believe in things. I recreated all those mechanisms. I made a formula recipe of like, have a myth, have a character, have a chant, have a ritual. Like just imitate what all the religions are, make your own and people will believe you because that's just like been working for thousands of years. So I think I was trying to take down all of religion. I was trying to show that gurus were fake. I was trying to talk about cultural appropriation. All of it was like the most meaningful thing at that time in my life I could say. And now I look back and I'm very happy I made that movie. A lot of people watched it. They were often, they were like, I totally agree with this movie. Some people would even say, my guru actually says the same thing. And then some other people go, I really love your movie. But I'm kind of worried that this other person I know is going to be really offended. And I was like, everyone's sort of, it was interesting to nerve it hit because I felt like other people thought other people might be offended by it. But they weren't because they actually believed in that too. And so I think in everyone's heart they kind of already believe that they don't need any of these people. We don't even realize sometimes when we're following things and following people. And now I think it's even more relevant because there are so many online gurus and so many people selling a lifestyle. And we gradually just see all of them fall. So many of them fall. I mean, every big yoga guru in America is pretty much fallen from OSHO to BICRUM. There's always the darkness behind them. Are they worse than the average person who has a lot of power and influence? Maybe not, but they definitely were making it seem like they were ethically higher than everyone else. And I think that's the thing also that I was trying to say, like these people are not, you don't have to dress like that, act like that to be spiritual. That doesn't mean anything. To me, the most moving part of the film, and I, you know, I'm watching it with the lens of BICRUM's friend. So I may be almost certainly unbiased in some ways, but to me, the most moving thing, and in some ways, the most important message of the movie, and again, this is just me, and I'm not saying that all the things you just listed are not important, but there's a point in the movie where it becomes clear that you playing this character who is essentially just the best version of BICRUM, a guy who makes and holds eye contact, listens very carefully, is encouraging and loving. That's just the best version of you. Somehow channeling the best version of you actually started to make you into the best version of you. And I found that very moving, but also instructional, like we can identify the best versions of ourselves and kind of fake it until we make it. - I totally agree, and that was actually, there was an experience of feeling like everybody loves this guy. He's such a good listener. He, I mean, I would practice almost like when I would talk to people, the practice that I had internally was I was just seeing light in them. I told them that that's what I was seeing, but I actually would try to do that. I would look at people in the eye, hold eye contact, and I would actually try to look beyond what was in their eyes. And I was just doing this thing. And in some ways, you could say it's method acting or something, I was, I've never trained in acting, so I don't really know. And I don't think of myself as an actor in any way, but I was just doing this thing. Like what if you were stuck in that position? What if somebody put you on a pedestal, which I'm sure happens sometimes and they're looking to you for advice and you realized every word you say has so much weight, so much power because of the position you're in, that you got to step up. And I think, I think that is the experience of being a spiritual leader from the inside that is experiencing. I honestly could have been anybody could have been in that position. And in some ways, it's just optics like, hey, if you decide to sit in the center of the room and everybody's looking at you, all of a sudden, it seems like you may be the, you know, the person in charge, and that's kind of what was happening. And, but it also made Don Don me like, I don't act like that with everyone. I'm not like, I would say Kumari was incredibly mindful. Like I was mindful in every interaction. I was mindful saying, I have a moral code to how I speak. Someone's asking me for advice and demanding that I tell them what they should do. And Kumari's philosophy is never tell anyone what to do. You don't know anything. You're saying that everybody's equal, never break that rule. So Kumari was all about, like, he's kind of an idiot. In some ways, my, you know, my model was like, you know, the movie being there, like a character who just, people projected things on. And that's actually, I think the most powerful part of that character that I learn from, it's like, I didn't tell people what to do. I said, what do you think you should do? And I would learn from them and just give it back to them. And they would hear it in my voice, like they were looking in a mirror and this, the person in the mirror, me, me was just telling them like the same thing that they already knew. And so I learned about, that's possible. And I would have to say that after I made Kumari, I'd be, me started making more documentaries and interviewing a lot of people. I was, I was a correspondent advice. And I remember embodying a lot of that when I would interview people. I was like, Kumari was taught me how to talk to, to interview people and make them feel safe and talk to them because that's kind of all I was doing in that character. I was basically just a documentary filmmaker too, but I trained myself through the Kumari method, if you will, in interviewing. It was kind of pointing you to that there's, there's another moment in the film where you say that you connected more to people as Kumari than you ever did as Vikram. Yeah. I mean, these, there was a group of people who were total strangers who didn't know anything about me. They thought I was from the mountains. And I mean, I, you know, I meet them for an hour, like I was like, I'm bonded with this person. That's what was so real. Like you felt, but I was like, I mean, this is real connection. I kind of feel like that way with everyone I film with, if I go deep with them. But that was different. Like the cameras were invisible. It was just me and them. But also, I think, I mean, there's so many reasons I felt like that, but I think the truth is that it, that was Kumari's gift. I went in thinking, oh, I'm going to do some Sasha Baron Cohen thing like it's all going to be jokes. We're going to take the piss out of everyone. And very soon I realized that's not Kumari's gift. Kumari's gift is the ability to make people feel comfortable, feel heard. I mean, the guru is standing in front of like thousands of people. My guru, Kumari, was going over their house and staring into their eyes for like listening to every word. So I do, I do feel very connected to those people. So I'm still in contact with some of them. It's been a minute since we're communicated because they're all over, you know, across the world, across the country. But yeah, I mean, I felt bonded with all of them. They were all part of this thing that was also very important to me. Like they unwittingly were part of like the full expression of what I was going through in my life. They were part of my art. I sort of trapped them in there. So there was a contract that happened where, hey, like we're in it. We're in this. So that's why I did keep in contact with a lot of them for a while. And I wanted to make sure they were cool with it, you know, in a way like very few people are really mocked in it. It's actually just like, none of those people deserve to be fooled. And that's why I think they were also very confused at the end where like, they didn't, a lot of people were like, but I lost a bunch of weight. I got only good things. What is this weird prank where you make people feel good? Yeah. We're almost out of time, but you also, you have another film coming out soon on the mysterious founder of Bitcoin, Satoshi, that's this, that's his kind of nom to coin, right? We don't actually know who Satoshi is. We don't know. Just tell me about the project because it, we were texting before we started recording. And your mind like this, this thing on Bitcoin kind of is in line with Burning Man and Kumare. Yeah. 100%. I mean, I think it's funny. I think, I think sometimes it's funny to me to think, maybe we all, we just keep telling the same stories over and over again. I keep making the same film over and over again, but like, you know, when Bitcoin was created, there was a person named, who named Satoshi Nakamoto, who wrote a white paper explaining what Bitcoin was and created it. And that person, some people perceived as a person in Japan, but it turned out that it was a pseudonym and nobody knows who Satoshi Nakamoto is, which is an incredible idea. If you think about how many billions of dollars have gone and been invested into this thing called Bitcoin and the creation of all cryptocurrency, you know, there's a line from, what's the author of Sapiens name, Noah, you, you've all. Harara. Yeah. He says that, you know, the greatest story I ever told is the story of money because money is the only thing that we all believe in. And, um, and that was like, you know, an interesting parallel that this mythical person that no one knows, named Satoshi Nakamoto, who has, is totally become a mythical character. People have been searching him for him since the beginning of Bitcoin. So people looking for 15 years. And I just got so fascinated by the fact that an entire world and economy and the economy of nations, um, and the, and the wealth of people, um, we're all being, we're all trusting that this person, who nobody knows, knows created it. And I love pseudonyms and, and all three goes as you know, and this was the greatest one of all. So I decided to go in a search to go find him. And since, um, I started, there have been, I don't know, dozen like long form articles, several books and a bunch of documentaries, uh, that people have made looking for Satoshi Nakamoto. But, um, it's funny because the entire time I was like, this is actually all about the belief system. I'm just fascinated how, uh, we can all put so much trust into this person. I mean, right now whoever Satoshi Nakamoto may be, would be worth, I don't know about, I don't remember the price of Bitcoin right now, but 80 billion dollars and put a certain point, um, could be one of the richest people in the world. And nobody knows who it is, five percent of Bitcoin is owned by this person. Um, and it's, it's crazy that we put our belief system. But what's so interesting is that, you know, on the dollar, it says, and God, we trust and nobody really understands what, what the concept of God is and that's what money is sort of based on and nobody understands who Satoshi is and that's what Bitcoin is based on. And in some ways, a lot of people believe that the reason that Bitcoin is still around and saw these other coins aren't, is because no one knows who Satoshi is. If we found out it was one of, you know, some of the billionaires or tech moguls that we, that some people that aren't doing so well in popular opinion, like people might divest out of it, but since we don't know, he remains a myth and there's more trust. And I think it's fascinating that we could put more trust into something where we, that's a black hole or void, um, which is kind of what Kumari was then a real person. And so yeah, I mean, it's very much in line with belief systems. I do think a lot of people believe that cryptocurrency is a religion and people talk about it in the same way they talk about burning man in the same way they talk about their guru. Um, so those are a lot of the parallels and I, and that's what drew me to it as opposed to the story of an economic story or, you know, um, it's, so I've made a film that's, um, the definitive story on all of it, um, kind of goes beyond, above and beyond all the other docs. Um, and it's, and it's been a long term journey and, um, and, uh, and I think it has strangely similar themes as like all the other films that I've made once it come out. We're hoping it comes out in the fall, but the more, more on that, uh, there's been some updates into the story, the New York Times point of their finger at somebody, um, that's quite interesting. And so we're kind of just making sure that the whole thing is, um, the whole story is kind of revealed in this, in this film, uh, but yeah, excited to get out to the world because it's also probably the longest thing I've ever worked on. I asked you earlier, were you? you net it out on Burning Man, but I want to ask where you net out on meaning and belief for yourself. You've built this career as a skeptic in the fields of belief, but not fully a skeptic because you're not mocking it, but you're not actually fully buying into it. So where do you, Vikram Gandhi, derive meaning? I know, I know just from personal experience that you take part in this group of guys that I put together to do meditation to get once in a while. You show up and practice with us, but what does it for you? I think when it comes to Eastern religion and philosophy and tradition and stories, I mean, I think this also goes for Western, but Eastern philosophy, I mean, there's just like an incredible amount of useful information, tools, insights that were combined with the way we think in the Western world is profound. And so I appreciate the writers of these things. I look at the people who maybe people think of as gurus or philosophers, I think of them as writers. They're like artists expressing things or they have a way of looking at it. I would say I have that the sort of Kumari ideals is the sort of like when you meet the Buddha in the road, kill the Buddha, that's very much like a way of looking at things that I see. But I don't think it's necessary complete. As I get older, I realize like you need to have, you know, sometimes like the meditation happens because there was somebody there to say, hey, you want to meet me at 2 p.m. You want to go on the walk? Like it doesn't happen. And that's actually what's really important. Like people come together because somebody said, hey, let's do this, who had the motivation. And then of course, like humans are flawed. So I really just have tried not to throw out the baby with the bath water. I mean, there's just such a, you know, the tools to deal with stress, the tools to deal with things that we take medication. It's all like in these ancient books. It's all very much there. The, you know, the ideas of the Buddha are profound and you keep coming back to it. And even as technology and society grows, we get closer to the ideas that are in Buddhism. But like I, you know, I don't really revere the Buddha. I think of the dark Gotham as kind of like all of us in America, just like rich kids. People in like this, you know, privileged society, who had to slum it a little bit to try to figure out how the world works. And all the stuff that he says is not really that profound like, oh, people are suffering. But the thing that's been created from that is like an amazing wealth of wisdom and to deny it because you're like, I don't want to, you know, oh, I'm not Buddhist. Like there's so much in there and there's so much in like kind of every faith. So I've just tried not to be cynical. Like I think when I, before I made Kumari, I was like, I had gotten really academic about all this stuff. I studied in college. I was like, basically, you see the mechanism of religion. It's all bullshit. This is all just human psychology and people praying on each other. And after I made Kumari, there was a moment of being like, no, you can't throw that out. There's actually something great in here. Yeah, it's just the mechanism of human, human nature is flawed. It's the same thing that maybe you could say the burning man, like humans, humans fuck it all up in every situation. And I think that's the thing that I try to hold on to is that there's actually real, real wisdom here, but all the apparatus, all the thing around it, you don't have to call yourself a Buddhist to meditate. You can still believe in all of these ideas and think about it with a different language and context and you're still like, you know, coming to it. So I just try to think like, I think I have a lot of reverence and I see the importance of doing practices. I just don't, you know, like, I don't, you know, any club that would have me a member, I don't want to join kind of vibe, you know? That's why I'm glad you show up at my club sometimes and I just want to remind everybody if you want to watch The Man Will Burn, I think you should watch it. It's available on HBO, the Satoshi documentary, who knows when that's going to be available. Kumara, I watched it on 2B, is it available anywhere else? We are figuring out distribution, the rights are just up. Yeah, I think it's on 2B, I know people are watching on YouTube, but we will have a more proper place to watch it. Right now, just, I think people should enjoy where it is free for the time being. You do amazing work. Thanks for coming on the show. Thanks for having me. I was looking forward to this. So I'm happy we did it. Thank you so much to everybody who worked so hard to make this show. 10% happier is produced by Tara Anderson and Eleanor Vasili. Our recording and engineering is handled by the great folks over at Pod People. Lauren Smith is our managing producer, Marissa Schneidermann is our senior producer. DJ Kashmir is our executive producer and Nick Thorburn of the band Islands wrote our theme. Also, one last thing before I let you go. Our summer Sunday live series is officially underway. Every Sunday at 4 Eastern, you can join the legendary meditation teacher Sharon Salzberg for a deep dive into the Buddha's cookbook for happiness, the eightfold path. You can catch up on replays if you've already missed a few of the sessions and you can join the next live meditation in Q&A, only on the 10% with Dan Harris app. Go to DanHarris.com to start a free trial.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Burning Man began as an anti-capitalist, anti-consumerist social experiment in the desert, rooted in a symbolic man-burning ritual and built on principles of gift economies and communal living.
  2. Despite its original ideals, Burning Man has evolved into a sprawling event with high-profile attendees and expensive camps, raising questions about hypocrisy and the erosion of its anti-capitalist ethos.
  3. The documentary *The Man Will Burn* explores the tension between Burning Man’s utopian roots and its current reality, highlighting internal conflicts, infighting, and the influence of external forces like social media.
  4. Vikram Gandhi’s film *Kumare* is a critical examination of gurus and religious belief systems, showing how people can be deeply influenced by fictional or fake spiritual leaders—revealing the power of belief, not authority.
  5. Both Burning Man and Bitcoin feature mythic, anonymous figures (Larry Harvey and Satoshi Nakamoto) who inspire belief systems despite lacking verifiable identity, illustrating how human trust operates in absence of transparency.
  6. Gandhi argues that while religious and spiritual traditions are often flawed or manipulated, they contain profound tools for personal growth and emotional insight that can be used without full allegiance.
  7. The core of spiritual practice, according to Gandhi, lies in human connection, mutual listening, and shared intention—not in dogma or ritual—making it accessible to skeptics and seekers alike.
  8. Burning Man and spiritual movements alike reflect a deep human tendency to create shared meaning, even when the structures are artificial or unverified, revealing the enduring power of belief and community.

Summary:

Burning Man began as a radical social experiment in the Nevada desert, rooted in anti-capitalist ideals, gift economies, and communal living, inspired by a symbolic man-burning ritual. While the original vision emphasized rejection of consumerism and a return to self-reliant, inclusive human connection, the event has evolved into a complex reality where billionaires build luxurious camps and the presence of money contradicts its founding principles. Vikram Gandhi’s documentary *The Man Will Burn* examines this contradiction, revealing the tension between Burning Man’s utopian roots and its current commercialization.

Similarly, Gandhi’s earlier work, *Kumare*, critiques spiritual authority by portraying a fake guru who develops a real following, exposing how belief systems—whether in religion or online gurus—operate through psychological mechanisms, not truth. Both projects highlight a recurring human pattern: the creation of mythic figures (like Larry Harvey or Satoshi Nakamoto) who inspire trust and belief, even when their identities are unknown or fabricated. Gandhi ultimately argues that while spiritual traditions may be flawed or manipulative, they offer valuable tools for self-awareness and connection.

The true meaning in these experiences lies not in doctrine, but in shared human moments of listening, empathy, and mutual growth. Ultimately, Burning Man and spiritual belief systems reflect the enduring human need for community, meaning, and transformation—despite their contradictions and imperfections.

FAQs

Burning Man is a large-scale social experiment where tens of thousands of people gather in the Black Rock Desert to build a temporary city, live without money, and engage in art, music, and community-based activities. It began as a radical anti-capitalist and anti-consumerist venture inspired by a simple idea to burn a man on a beach, evolving into a cultural event focused on self-reliance, giving, and shared experience.

While Burning Man's origins were deeply anti-capitalist and anti-consumerist, it now faces criticism for attracting wealthy attendees and private jet owners who build expensive camps. This contradiction highlights a tension between its founding ideals and its current reality, showing how the event has evolved and sometimes replicated capitalist practices.

The event operates on a gift economy where participants bring goods and services to share, and all interactions are based on mutual aid and generosity. This system, inspired by the book *The Gift*, fosters a sense of belonging and community, emphasizing shared creation over material exchange.

Burning Man began in the 1980s when Larry Harvey, inspired by a joke, proposed burning a man on Baker Beach in San Francisco. The event grew from a small gathering of 10 people to a massive festival, eventually moving to the desert where it now draws 80,000 participants annually.

The documentary explores the original anti-capitalist roots of Burning Man and traces its evolution into a complex, sometimes contradictory culture. It highlights the tension between its idealistic principles and the reality of wealth, media influence, and internal conflicts that have shaped the event over time.

In his film *Kumare*, Vikram Gandhi portrays a fake Indian guru to investigate how people form deep attachments to spiritual figures. His work challenges the idea that gurus are inherently enlightened, revealing that belief systems often rely on myth, ritual, and human projection rather than objective truth.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.