Go back

Why men don’t make friends

33m 33s

Why men don’t make friends

This episode explores the evolving landscape of male friendships in modern society, challenging the notion that men inherently lack emotional connections. While current discourse often labels male friendships as shallow—pointing to activities like fishing or naming state capitals—the historical record reveals a long-standing tradition of deep, soulful male bonds, from biblical figures like David and Jonathan to 16th-century friendships celebrated as "marriages of souls." Today’s shift toward emotionally reserved male friendships is linked not just to personal choices, but to structural issues like economic pressures, rising hobby costs, and the decline of public social spaces. The show highlights how women in marriages with socially isolated men often take on "man-keeping" roles, which can undermine their own social well-being. A key insight is that male friendship problems are not solely individual failures, but symptoms of broader societal changes. The episode calls for a reevaluation of what constitutes a healthy friendship—balancing emotional depth with shared activities—and emphasizes that men are not biologically incapable of deep connection. It concludes with a hopeful message: just as male friendship culture has transformed over time, it can evolve again, offering men and their partners new ways to build meaningful, supportive relationships.

Transcription

5395 Words, 30456 Characters

English
Support for the show comes from Fetch Pet Insurance. If you have a dog or cat, here's something you need to know. According to Forbes Advisor, one in three pets will need emergency treatment this year. And every six seconds, a pet parent gets hit with a vet bill over $1,000. Vett bills don't have to hit that hard. Fetch is pet insurance that covers accidents, illnesses, and emergency visits and pays back up to 90% of eligible vet bills. No wonder pet parents give fetch an excellent rating on trust pilot. Get a free quote in minutes at fetchpet.com/save. That's fetchpet.com/save. Support for this show comes from Airbus. When the International Space Station launched in 1998, it opened up new frontiers for research in human biology and medicine. Now, a game-changing new space station, StarLab, is launching that will study agriculture, medicine, robotics, and more. And Airbus, who lead the ongoing design and engineering of the station, had designed it to be the next evolution for early research and real commercial production. With its unique microgravity environment, they can make discoveries in space that help humans down here on Earth. Learn more about StarLab and how Airbus is making it happen at fly.airbus.com/theflightpath. We've been kicking around the idea of covering male friendships on the show recently. Now, we've all heard a lot about the male loneliness epidemic, nature, but even men who have friends are getting some scrutiny. Most men don't have real friendships. The way a lot of these men see friendship is not a friendship. It's certainly not a relationship. It is at best an acquaintance. Most men don't have that one guy that they can call. And that's a sad state, right? Because we all need at least one guy. Are those friendships giving them what they need? And when they aren't, who picks up the slack? I'm Miles Bryan, by the way, I'm sitting in for JQ today. And this debate, it made me think about my friends Mindy and Kevin. What's your name, ma'am? Ma'am Mindy Iser. And a tweet Mindy sent last year. I'm wondering if you can just read it to us. Sure. My husband spent four days with nine of his oldest friends. I asked him if there was any news about their marriages, kids, families, jobs, etc. He said, no, I asked what they talked about. He said they mostly tried to name every state capital and then every African country. And just tell me about the tweet. Why did you feel they needed to tweet it? I feel like I am so dependent on my friends for emotional support and venting and dealing with problems in my marriage or in my family. And I always wonder who he turns to about that stuff. And I know it's only me. Okay, Kevin, I got to get your side of the story here. Tell us about the boys trip and tell us about how you felt and respond when you saw that tweet. I guess I just never thought of it as a weird thing that like we don't like go into the minutia of like our lives. Like if there's like something important, someone will bring it up. I'm not asking somebody. It's a camaraderie thing like we just enjoy each other's presence in a way. We can hang out around a campfire for six hours. And yeah, we might just like talk about and argue about the ranking of all the fast and furious movies or something like that. But like, you know, whom amongst us? I don't have friends. I got family. This is explain it to me from Vox. And today on the show, the great male friendship debate. We're going to start with the fellas. Everyone agrees are in trouble. The ones with no friends at all. Monica Corcoran-Harell wrote about those guys for the cut and a piece called My Husband Has No Friends. I kept hearing that refrain from friends. I talk to mostly wives and husbands in cities and suburbs. Most of them were over 40, more likely in their late 40s to mid 50s, meaning they'd been married for a decade or two. And I want to preface this by saying, "My husband does have friends." And I wrote about it because I could speak to the other side. But what I heard from mostly my girlfriends who were married was, "Oh, would your husband go out to dinner with my husband?" Would your husband go hang out with my husband? Would he take my husband to a party? And the refrain was always, "Want-want, my husband has no friends." And what really surprised me was a finding across the board was these men had friends when they first got married. These were not introverts. And what was happening was, once these guys got married, they just stopped hanging out with their friends or didn't put the effort in. And what I realized was, like, men don't understand what it takes to stoke a relationship, like a campfire, right? You got to keep throwing logs on. You've got to stoke the fire, and that escaped them. You know, male loneliness is definitely a known problem at this point. We put out a call to listeners for the story, and we heard from plenty of guys who are in that situation. I don't think I've made a new friend since leaving undergrad almost 10 years ago now. And I don't know how to make friends as an adult man. I'm having trouble meeting other friends, both men and women who can just be vulnerable. I have those different, and I enjoy that. I focus on my family, the wife, kids. However, there are certain times where I would rather have a friend to talk to. But you focused on something a little different. How men's lack of friendships affects their partners, right? What did you hear from them? Well, that was really my focus. How is this affecting relationships, specifically, how is it affecting the women married to these lonely men? And what I found was women take on the onus of either making friends for their husbands, or including their husbands in all their plans. I think they're really desperate for their husbands to have a social life. And you might think it's because women are like, "Oh my God, I just want to get my husband out of the house." And that's part of it, sure. But I think it's also that women understand what they get out of having community, the support they get, being able to share their feelings. I think they really understand how important it is to life. So to know that their husbands aren't enjoying the fruits of friendship, is what drives them. You know, to push them towards, you want to call them play dates. There's a sociologist at Stanford who calls it man-keeping. And that's her word specifically for women who try to insert men into friendships, or include them, or bring them to parties, and sort of act as like an escort, and introduce them to people around it. And I've seen this. I've been at dinner parties where, you know, a woman will say like, "Oh, Jim, tell them how you make an old fashioned." He does this special thing. And you can see the husband is just sort of like cringing inside, because he knows what's happening. And it's likely the other husbands know what's happening too. Yeah, I start with Whiskey. He knows he's being man-kept in that moment. Yes, he does. He doesn't. And he knows that he doesn't put anything special in his old fashioned. It's just an old fashioned. So he doesn't even know where to go with this conversation. So you guys like the NFL or no? A lot of couples socialize together, whether it's going on family vacations if you have kids, or going out to dinner together. And for a lot of women who had men that weren't social, it had an effect on their socializing. They were no longer invited to these dinner parties, or family vacations were suddenly off the table. That's what I heard from women. And it was harder for them to make friends with couples knowing that you're only going to get me, because my husband either doesn't want to come out to dinner. He's not comfortable socializing. And one woman I talked to in particular in Colorado said, "You know, I've just realized that I'm going to go to parties by myself, because my husband's not coming. He's not interested." Or if he does come, he stands in the corner. "I feel bad. I feel like I need to walk him around the party. He's miserable. I'm miserable. So now I just go on my own." So now it's affecting women's friendships as well, or potential friendships. Okay, so we're doing a lot of generalization based on men and women. We are. And I was thinking I could hear a critical listener go, "Okay, this is just men are from Mars, women are from Venus, blah blah blah." Did you talk to any couples in your reporting that flip this dynamic? Well, I talked to some couples wherein the husband was more social, not necessarily more social than the wife. And my husband's a great example. I mean, my husband has some like weekly standing play dates with his guy friends. And he prioritizes that. You don't use the term play date, do you? I'm just using that term. because we're having fun here. But yeah, there are guys who are social. I mean, I don't think, yeah, we're generalizing. (upbeat music) I think you just have to look at your relationship and say if my husband had friends, how would that change my relationship? I do think that men having fruitful, deep, supportive relationships could change the game in a really profound way. (upbeat music) Okay, so yes, having no friends is clearly no good for a guy or for his partner. But do dudes really need to have friendships that go that deep? Is it really such a problem to just hang out and, you know, list state capitals? A defense of emotionally stunted friendships, that's coming up. (upbeat music) (upbeat music) (upbeat music) - Supporter takes when comes from Taukaya tree trying to figure out how to get the right mental health treatment can feel overwhelming. Taukaya tree helps you move from I know I need help to having a psychiatrist who listens and can offer a clear personalized treatment plan. Taukaya tree is a 100% online psychiatry practice that provides comprehensive evaluations, a diagnosis and ongoing medication management for conditions like ADHD, anxiety, depression, bipolar, OCD, PTSD, insomnia so much more. You get to meet with a medical provider who can diagnose mental health conditions and prescribe your medication when it's needed and because it's 100% online, we have a lot more flexibility. Unlike therapy, only platforms, Taukaya tree is psychiatry. You're seeing a medical provider who can diagnose mental health conditions and prescribe medication when it's appropriate. All 800 plus clinicians are in network with major insurers so you can use your existing insurance instead of paying monthly subscriptions or out-of-network costs. You can head to Taukaya tree.com/explain to complete the short assessment and get matched with an in-network psychiatrist in just a few minutes. That's T-A-L-K-I-A-T-R-Y.com/explain to get matched in minutes. Taukaya tree.com/explain. As soon as autumn rolls around and you swap your iced lattes for pumpkin spice, that's your signal to start thinking about the holidays. The decor, the gifts, the shopping lists, but more importantly, the holiday treats. Cheesecakes, cookies, is there anything better? And when the recipe calls for cream cheese, there's only one option. Philadelphia, the original cream cheese, made with fresh milk and real cream. This holiday season, whether you're going all out or keeping it simple, make it really, filly good. Find your favorite holiday recipe at creamcheese.com. - This is Explaned To Me, I'm Miles Bryant. (upbeat music) - I'm Tyler Austin Harper. I'm a staff writer for The Atlantic and I co-host the podcast Time to Say Goodbye. - Nice. Okay, so you're a podcaster, you're a writer. Relevant for the show, are you married? Do you have kids? - I am, yeah, I'm married to kids. - Married to kids, so your husband, a father? Do you have friends? - I do, yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm one of the lucky, I suppose, in the top 27% of men who have six or more close friendships. I've always been a pretty hobby-oriented person. I fish very, very seriously. I'm a gun person, I shoot. So I have friends mostly from hobbies. And so just in terms of the raw numbers, the bulk of my friends are people who I do activities with and know from various kinds of hobby communities. - We wanted to talk to you because this is a show about men and friendships and friendless men and how that impacts them and those who love them. And you wrote this piece for The Atlantic, called something like, I love my emotionally-stunted friendships, right? - Yeah. - What do you mean by that? I've been like many people following the discourse around male friendships and man-keeping over the last couple of years. And have really felt that they get, that they pathologize often quite normal forms of male friendship. I mean, if you just look at what psychologists and social scientists have to say about male friendships, men tend to have what they call shoulder-to-shoulder friendships where they're doing activities together. Women tend to have face-to-face friendships centered around talking and connection, et cetera, right? I mean, those are obviously crude stereotypes, but in the aggregate, that's how it kind of shakes out. And I have a lot of friends that I spend a great deal of time with in fishing season. I have fishing partners I spend 20 hours a week with. - Hey, dude. - Hey, man. - And we talk about fishing and we don't really do a lot of talking about our emotions. - How's the fish out there? - Oh, they're out there today. - You? - Yeah, another day another fish, am I right? - I was writing this article actually, the height of fishing season, where during fishing season, I fish almost every day. Fish mainly at night, the kind of fishing I do is largely nocturnal. And I'm seeing these people for hours every day and then I had read some article that was kind of talking about how men don't share their feelings with their friends and this is unhealthy, et cetera. - Was it called my husband has no friends? - Could it have been the one? - I was reflecting that I am in the top cohort of men in terms of having a lot of friends, right? And yet, very few of those friendships meet the qualifications for a "healthy friendship" according to a lot of the male friendship discourse. And that to me was flatly preposterous and it just really does feel like there's certainly important and valuable contributions that some of this discourse has. But I do think it has pathologized a lot of forms of friendship that are normal. And one thing I think it's done in particular is conflated what is a quantitative crisis in male friendships with the idea that there's also a qualitative crisis. By which I mean, it is true that quantitatively men have fewer friends than previous generations and that many men report being lonely. That men have been more vulnerable in recent years to deaths of despair, to dropping out of the workforce, et cetera, et cetera. So there's a real empirical quantitative problem that men have fewer friends than they used to. But I think that true observation has slid into and collided with a much fuzzier sort of qualitative critique that it's not simply that men have fewer friends, but it's also the way in which men have friendships. They are emotionally reserved. They're not opening up. They're not talking about their feelings. And what I wanted to do with this piece was kind of separate that quantitative and qualitative dimension and say, yes, it's absolutely true. It's a problem that men are having fewer friendships. But there's nothing wrong with the preferences a lot of men have for activity, oriented, emotionally light, camaraderie. I wanted to ask you about like stage of life. You know, you're describing situational friendships. What happens when you get older, you get married, life gets busy, maybe you have kids, and like finding that time to have like activities that you just share together gets harder and harder. Yeah, I think that's a real challenge, just in terms of financial resources. One of the reasons I'm able to maintain a lot of shoulder to shoulder friendships is that I'm in a financial position to afford being able to fish a lot. I assume I can afford to go to the range even as that's getting more and more expensive. Something else I've written a lot about is what I call hobby inflation. The fact that hobbies are getting more and more and more expensive, right? We've covered it on this very show. Having hobbies is now apparently seen as like a social status because right now with inflation everything we're going through the cost of living crisis. Yeah, yeah, and bowling is no longer a cheap activity. Fishing is no longer a cheap activity. Whatever, pool, anything you want to name, not to just use stereotypically masculine activities, but they're getting more and more expensive, right? And what that means is if men disproportionately have these kind of shoulder to shoulder activity-based friendships and people are being priced out of those activities, friendship becomes socioeconomically coded in a certain kind of way, right? Like I do think men need to be a little bit better about getting themselves out there, joining those clubs, doing what, calling the friend from college, whatever. But the reality is that the reason male friendships are declining are related to structural crises within our economy, within affordability, within the decline of civic institutions, whether those are clubs, social groups, whatever, right? And that is a public problem. And that's not an easy problem to solve and you can't snap your fingers and reinvent civil society. But it is to say, I think we should be somewhat suspicious of ways of talking about the male friendship crisis that put the burden exclusively on the behavioral choices being made by men, when this is a public crisis in my view. So maybe some dudes are all right with just fishing friends or bowling buddies or whatever, as long as they can afford to play. But what about the guys who want to be closer to their bros, but just don't know how to get there? We're gonna look to the past for some ideas, starting all the way back with Aristotle. - Support of the show comes from Bombus, as the days get shorter, which they just did, and temperatures drop, which they actually haven't yet in DC, but they will surely by the time you hear this. You may find that you're drunk. drawn to your winter uniform. But no matter how bundled you are up top, it won't feel like it unless your feet are cozy and warm. And I'm gonna be honest while I'm recording this ad right now, my feet, their bear, and their cold. Bomba socks are the perfect addition to your winter wardrobe, interesting. They're made with cozy materials like Marino wool and cashmere to keep you warm. And if you're looking for gifts this season, Bomba's has something for everyone's socks, slippers, cushy footwear that can take on the chill. Plus sports socks, hello, for runners and skiers of life. You can even find buttery, soft t-shirts, buttery? I want a buttery, soft t-shirt, underwear, and base layers. You can head over to bomba.com/explained and use the code explain for 20% off your first purchase. That's bombas.com/explained. Code explain to check out. The support for today explained comes from Open Door. Strangers walking through your house, a never-ending list of demands, a deal falling apart at the very last minute. That is what selling a home can look like. Open Door is a real estate company that is intended to make selling your home simpler. With Open Door, you can skip the staging, the showings, the open houses. As a little list of repairs, Open Door buys your home directly from you in cash and lets you pick the closing date. You can close in as few as 21 days or take up to 60, giving you control over the timing of your move. Perhaps best of all, you can leave the nail biting uncertainty of closing the deal behind. Open Door gives you a cash offer in hand and a clear timeline to work with. That could mean fewer surprises and more time focusing on finding your dream home. Selling a home is hard, but it doesn't have to be with Open Door. Get your free offer at Open Door.com/explained. Open Door.com/explained. Open Door. Move on. [MUSIC] We're back with Explained To Me, I'm Miles Bryan. Tiffany Wattsmith is a historian of emotions. I asked her how male friendships today compared to those of yesterday year. Well, as a historian, I could definitely tell you that men in the past had much more intimate and romantic and involved friendships than we see today for sure. The idea that women are the great experts in friendship is a really modern idea. For thousands of years, it was really men who were considered the great experts in knowing how to form the highest kinds of friendships and the most intimate kind of bonds. Their friendships were considered the most meaningful and enduring and deep kind of friendships. [MUSIC] Right, if you look back at David and Jonathan in the Bible. First Samuel, 181. The soul of Jonathan was knit to the soul of David, and Jonathan loved him as his own soul. All Achilles and Patroclus in the Iliad. Patroclus has fallen, he who my valued more than all others and loved as dearly as my own life. You see these very sort of dynamic and committed male friendships. When we look at the writings of Aristotle, so the fourth century BC, so such a long time ago, he's talking about the deepest kind of friendship he calls it, the perfect friendship. One cannot be a friend to many people in the sense of having friendship of the perfect type of them. Just as one cannot be in love with many people at once. And this is between two men who he sees as a soulmate. And he does say that there are other kinds of friendship, which are less of friendship. So he says that you might make friends because it's kind of convenient, or because you enjoy doing the same kinds of things. Or maybe you're trying to help each other out. There's a kind of quid pro quo type of friendship. So he does see these kinds of friendship all around him. One of the most famous pieces of writing about friendship ever is Michel de Montaigne's essay on friendship. Montaigne was 16th century essayist and lawyer. And he had this very, very close and committed friendship with another writer called La Boise. And then after La Boise died very unexpectedly, Montaigne wrote about their friendship. And he said, they had this kind of ideal friendship, the kind that Aristotle wrote about. This kind of perfect friendship, this meeting of souls. And that this was rare and extraordinary. If a man should importune me to give a reason why I loved him, I find it could no otherwise be expressed than by making answer because it was he, because it was I. He was very explicit. He said, men can have these kinds of friendship, but he very explicitly said, women are just incapable of having this kind of perfect friendship. They don't have the kind of emotional stamina, they're not clever enough, they're not educated enough. The souls aren't strong enough, essentially, to withstand the complexities and difficulties of friendship. So it's complete inversion from what we see today. - You used this word when you started Romantic. What did you mean by that? Where was the Aristotelian conception of a perfect male friendship? Was there a kind of romantic element in the way that we use the word romance? - Yeah, so this is a really good question. So historians call this style of friendship romantic friendship. It doesn't necessarily mean that they were having a physically active relationship or they were having sex or that they were even saw themselves as a, well, they did see themselves as a partnership and some of these male friends talked about themselves as marriage, you know, this was a marriage of soul. But it wasn't. - Oh, really? - Yeah, so there's a very important tombstone in Christ College in Cambridge, which commemorates these two doctors in the 16th century, who basically lived their whole lives together. They traveled together, they did their research together and so on. And when they died, they were buried together. And the tomb does look like a conventional tomb between a husband and wife. - There are more portraits are linked by a nod of cloth, symbolizing in Finch's words, a beautiful and unbroken marriage of souls, a companionship undivided during 36 complete years. - Now, we don't know anything about that relationship in practice. I mean, the thing that really matters is the fact that this French, because it was commemorated as a friendship, the fact that it could be commemorated so vividly and publicly in such an extravagant way, shows us that this is a culture that accepts and idealizes this kind of male friendship. - So how do we get from there to here? - So beginning in the 18th century and certainly by the 19th century, there's a series of things that happen. I mean, one is that we get a distinction between the public space of the workplaces, cities are expanding, offices start to exist. The male sphere is fashioned as one of being in public, having being a sort of more rational sphere. And the female sphere starts to be connected with the home and intimacy and emotion. And then those ideas have been kind of floating around for a while, but they start to get really consolidated in the 19th century. And at the same time, women, a kind of new ideal of femininity starts to emerge. And it becomes a real sort of middle-class, aspirational goal really for middle-class women that they have very close friendships as, there's almost as evidence that they can do all of these things. You know, so young girls in this era are taught a very particular style of friendship, which is, again, it's very romantic. There's lots of kissing and declarations of love and so on, but also it's very committed, it's very thoughtful, it's very caring. And this has seemed to be a kind of training ground for motherhood and for marriage. At the end of the 19th century, we start to portray male friendships as kind of blundering and kind of superficial and lacking in intimacy. And then, of course, men carry on having close friendships, but by the beginning of the 20th century, and sort of another nail in the coffin as it were happens, which is that there's a rise in understanding of homosexuality across Europe and America and gay culture becomes much more visible. And in that moment, men become really anxious about having intimate and close relationships with other men. They're worried about what that looks like and how that might be read. And that, in addition, kind of leads to these anxieties about close male friendships. - Okay, so if a guy's hearing this and he's interested in having more fulfilling friendships, he wants to go deep, but he doesn't know how to get there, where should he start? - Well, it's a great question. I mean, think about history is that it shows us how much things have changed, but it also reminds us that things keep changing and can change again. I mean, that's what's so interesting. So yes, we've had this amazing history of these very romantic and tense, effusive male friendships. I mean, I think a lot of men, certainly the listeners here probably would find that kind of overwhelming and unappealing as a kind of model of friendship, but is there something in between? And one of the things I think that is important to remember is that we can make these changes and these shifts in style and these shifts in the patterns in the art. approaches to friendships. So one thing I think it's really worth listening to remembering is that since friendship has changed in the past, it can change again. There's nothing biologically innate about the inability to make friends or which is freeing. The fact that friendships is not a fixed category for men or for women and that things can be what you what you want them to be. You're not held back by some innate aspect of our biology. I think there's, yeah, I think that's absolutely true. You know, we get this notion that, well, men are sort of naturally worse at making friends or something or they naturally have less kind of desire to connect with other people. I mean, that's completely not true. The history of male friendship shows us that that is completely not true. So we can be released from that idea. That's our show, hope you listened with a friend. We're working on another episode about people flaking on plans. When you flake on somebody, how do you feel? Relieved? Sad? Guilty? What about when people bail on you? Is the drive you crazy? Give us a call at 1-800-618-8545 or shoot us an email to [email protected]. And here's something else to consider. Listening to this podcast, add free. Sounds pretty good, right? All you have to do is become a vox member. It's the best way to support us and come to the ton of cool perks. Head to vox.com/members to learn more. This episode was produced by Ariana Asburu, who was edited by Avashai Artsy. It was fact-checked by Melissa Hirsch. It was engineered by Bridger Dunnigan. Our executive producer is Miranda Kennedy. I'm the guest host today, Miles Bryan. Thank you so much for listening. Bye-bye. Who wouldn't want to be best friends with this guy? He's so funny. He's like a walking Wikipedia. And I get to have sex with him. It's like- Okay, okay, okay. It's a family. It's a family podcast. We're gonna hear this. Support for the show comes from Gira by Atlassian. Your work lives in scattered places. And it's not only your team searching for context. Your AI agents need it too. Gira taps Atlassian's teamwork graph to bring that context together. Across Gira, Confluence, Slack, GitHub, and more. And makes it easy to share with the agents you already use. Like Claude, Persir, and GitHub Copilot. Assign them work directly or connect your agents through MCP. Spend less time hunting for context. Less time asking, wait, what did we decide? And more time actually shipping. With Gira, learn more at gira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com. I'm a voice agent powered by deepgram. I don't just understand words. I understand context. Like when you're fixing the sink and say, we've got a leak. You're talking about a pipe. But when you're a new parent and you say, we've got a leak. You mean that you're going to have to change into a clean shirt. Oh, it's everywhere. Deepgram understands words and context. Across STT, TTS, and voice agents. That means better conversations at production scale. Learn more at deepgram.com/context is everything.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Men today often lack deep, emotionally connected friendships, with many relying on activity-based, superficial bonds like fishing or bowling.
  2. The decline in male friendships is not just a personal issue but tied to broader economic and social changes, such as rising costs of hobbies and shrinking civic spaces.
  3. Historical records show that ancient and medieval societies valued deep, romantic male friendships, often seen as soul-level bonds akin to marriage.
  4. The modern ideal of friendship has shifted, with women increasingly associated with emotional intimacy and men with public, activity-driven camaraderie.
  5. Critics argue that current discourse pathologizes normal male friendships, placing undue blame on men’s behaviors while overlooking systemic issues.
  6. Women in relationships with lonely husbands often take on the role of "man-keeping," inserting their partners into social settings, which can strain both their own social life and the relationship.
  7. A growing movement suggests that men can build meaningful friendships by redefining what friendship means—balancing emotional depth with shared activities.
  8. Solutions to male loneliness require societal change, not just individual effort, including accessible, affordable social spaces and rethinking traditional gendered roles in friendship.

Summary:

This episode explores the evolving landscape of male friendships in modern society, challenging the notion that men inherently lack emotional connections. " Today’s shift toward emotionally reserved male friendships is linked not just to personal choices, but to structural issues like economic pressures, rising hobby costs, and the decline of public social spaces. The show highlights how women in marriages with socially isolated men often take on "man-keeping" roles, which can undermine their own social well-being.

A key insight is that male friendship problems are not solely individual failures, but symptoms of broader societal changes. The episode calls for a reevaluation of what constitutes a healthy friendship—balancing emotional depth with shared activities—and emphasizes that men are not biologically incapable of deep connection. It concludes with a hopeful message: just as male friendship culture has transformed over time, it can evolve again, offering men and their partners new ways to build meaningful, supportive relationships.

FAQs

Fetch Pet Insurance covers accidents, illnesses, and emergency vet visits, paying up to 90% of eligible bills. It helps reduce the financial burden of unexpected pet medical costs.

StarLab is a new space station launching to study agriculture, medicine, and robotics in microgravity. Airbus leads its design and engineering, aiming to advance both research and commercial space applications.

Many men report fewer close friendships, leading to loneliness and emotional isolation. This has sparked debate about whether traditional male bonding is declining or being mischaracterized.

Man-keeping refers to women encouraging or including their husbands in social gatherings, often without their husbands' consent or comfort, which can lead to feelings of discomfort or exclusion.

Yes, some argue that activity-based, emotionally light friendships are valuable and normal. These may not meet traditional emotional intimacy standards, but they still provide meaningful connection and support.

Historically, male friendships were seen as deep, romantic, and soul-based, like in the stories of David and Jonathan or Patroclus and Achilles. Today, such ideals are less common, with male friendships often viewed as superficial or lacking emotional depth.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.