Go back

Why JuJu Watkins Isn’t a Lock for Player of the Year

from No Offseason: The Athletic Women's Basketball Show

48m 48s

Why JuJu Watkins Isn’t a Lock for Player of the Year

This episode of No Off Season, hosted by Sabrina Merchant and Chantel Jennings, opens with a major NCAA rule change: the five-for-five age-based eligibility ruling, approved in June 2026 and effective immediately. It allows athletes who began college in 2023 to play through the 2027-28 season, giving players a fifth year of eligibility. The hosts discuss wide-ranging implications for roster sizes, recruiting, the transfer portal, and the WNBA draft, noting that programs like South Carolina and Michigan face difficult roster math under the 15-player cap. They also explain how the change complicates WNBA planning, since many projected first-round picks could return to college, leaving general managers to prepare for numerous contingencies. The conversation then shifts to player of the year candidates, with the hosts naming Sarah Strong, Juju Watkins, Madison Booker, Hannah Hidalgo, and Mikayla Blakes as the top five. A key theme is that each contender ended last season short of a national championship, and that disappointment could fuel breakout years. The hosts analyze what Booker and Hidalgo specifically need—stronger team results and marquee wins—to overtake Strong and Watkins. They also highlight other intriguing players, including Aisha Suka, Addie Mack, Addie Brown, Tayala Delfoss, and freshman Kate Harpering, before previewing weekend games such as USC at South Carolina and the WNBA Draft Lottery.

Transcription

10340 Words, 54792 Characters

English
Speaker 1All of these players are back at the college level. Sort of the demons that need to be exercised, they can because they're still at the college level. They can go for a national championship. Whatever place they lost at last year, there's one step further to go for all of these players. And so I think that makes this really, really intriguing because I think talent plus a disappointment or an anger or a sadness or a rage that turns into motivation can be a recipe for these huge years. And the fact that we have so many players in this category, I think the depth of this race feels really, really intriguing for this year.
Speaker 2Hello, everyone, and welcome to No Off Season. I'm Sabrina Merchant. And I'm Chantel Jennings. And today on the show, college hoops are in full swing and it's never too early to talk about our picks for player of the year and some others to keep an eye on around the country. Later on, we'll set our screens and tell you which games you should tune in to. This weekend, small hint, the letters USC will be involved. But first, let's talk about a major change to college basketball this season. The NCAA approved its five for five age based eligibility rule on June 23rd, 2026, and it took effect immediately for this academic year. In short, it allows student athletes who started college in 2023 to play through the 2027-28 season, even if that means competing for five years in college. So, Chantel, lots of implications. We're going to break down for how this affects roster sizes, the draft, recruiting. But what was your initial reaction to this ruling and how it's going to change what we're going to see in college this year?
Speaker 1You know, I think the big change will be next year because that's when we'll sort of see players who've had the opportunity to digest this and haven't made sort of plans for what is coming next. We saw, you know, there's certainly some players that, you know, one player that you and I have talked about a lot, like Maggie Dugan is a player who didn't get to take advantage of this ruling. And isn't, you know, playing at Virginia right now, like who would not have wanted to see Maggie Dugan in the ACC this season? And so, but it was like, I'm devastated, honestly. She probably had a life plan ahead of her, right? And I think now what you have is you have players who have agents an entire year to plan for what comes next. And so there will be a lot, a longer runway for them to decide what they want to do. So obviously, we saw some players come back for their fifth year. Brooke Quarles Daniels at South Carolina is a really good example, kind of a surprising player who. You know, pops up late, gets added to South Carolina's roster, just bolstering that backcourt even more than it already is. Brooklyn Meyer coming back to South Dakota State. Exactly. Just surprise off the volleyball roster. And so I think like where we'll end up seeing the most impact is with a lot of these things a year down the road when you have athletes who've had a chance to digest and process what it means for them and how they can take advantage of a ruling like this.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's tricky timing for women's college basketball. Because if you follow other college sports, you will have seen, you know, men's college players, for example, take advantage of this ruling and use their fifth years for this upcoming season. And it's high profile players. But it was harder for women's players to do that because, well, a WNBA season already happened in between the last college season and this one, which was not the case for men's players. Whereas, you know, the NBA coincides with the men's college basketball season. So players like Maggie Dugan or Cara Dunn or players you saw like on the fringes of developmental player contracts or in training camps. Who might have been a part of that? Who might have benefited from a fifth year of college basketball, didn't really get that opportunity because they'd already turned pro.
Speaker 1Exactly. And again, I think when you're looking at rosters across the country, where we're going to see this impact the most is, you know, and I was actually surprised there was signing week this week. And it was like, well, how is this going to affect signing classes? Because now you also have coaches like we're thinking of it from the player perspective, but it's not just a player decision. Like it's a coach decision to how many players are you going to sign in your freshman class? And I think we've seen the way that coaches. Coaches go about recruiting, you know, high school seniors change since the introduction of the transfer portal. And you talk to coaches across the country and they're like, do I want to take an 18 year old who's probably going to transfer after a year? Do I want to take someone who I know only has a year left or only has two years left? And they've already been in a college weight program for three years and they've already played the physicality and the rigors of a college schedule for three years or whatever it might be. And so you already sort of had that imbalance in terms of like high school and AAU wasn't sort of the only crop to go and get. Your basketball talent from you now had the entire college basketball world. And now I think you're looking at it. And not only do coaches need to think about high school recruiting. Transfer portal recruiting, but also roster balance in terms of the NCAA caps at 15. Like you can't go over that. And so how are these programs going to look at their rosters? And, you know, the ones that are stacked to the top right now, which, you know, the two top teams in the country right now, South Carolina has 15 players on its roster. Michigan has 14 players on its roster. Signing classes are coming in. You have seniors that can stay, might go. Like there's going to be a ton of really interesting questions that need to be answered by players, by coaches and really by the NCAA as it grapples with this decision that it made. Love when the NCAA introduces
Speaker 2math problems for coaches to solve, right? You look at South Carolina. You mentioned this, that they have four players that they just signed in their signing class. Look at their current roster. They only have three players who are exhausted of eligibility this year in Procurement. There's Daniels, Chloe Kitts, and Ashlyn Watkins. So, like, if Tessa Johnson wants to come back, there's a little finagling that has to happen, right?
Speaker 1Well, and not just a little finagling. South Carolina is a team that has, you know, not gone crazy with the transfer portal, but has found the players that fit really well within the transfer portal. So what happens if someone pops into the transfer portal and you're like, oh, this player is perfect for whatever it might be? The math has to math, though. Like if you're, you know, so it's you're giving something. Up somewhere, which is, you know, for those teams at the top. Same thing with Michigan. They have 14 players on their roster right now. They signed two in their recruiting class. I'm pretty sure all of their seniors can come back. And so, like, you someone has to leave. At least one person has to leave. And again, a program that has used the transfer portal well under Kim Barnes Rico wouldn't be able to use it if they don't have the kind of attrition that they need to have. And that's not necessarily something that we have, you know, talked about a ton where it's like managing a roster. Sometimes means I think coaches expect there to be attrition. There are coaches who are going to need attrition at this point because it's like you are capped at 15 and you can't go over.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, we don't spend a ton of time talking about high school rankings here just because, well, let's face it, there's a lot of other basketball to talk about. But, like, do you think that this is going to affect, you know, when high school players decide to sign? Like, are they going to try to get in the earlier window to make sure they still have a spot or how is this going to affect things?
Speaker 1Yeah, I think it's going to be fast. Fascinating. I do wonder how it's going to be used for sort of how coaches I think whenever it comes to recruiting, what I always hear about is like how it's used to recruit against other people like, oh, this coach is doing this. This coach is doing this. I think we already saw coaches looking at freshmen less like I had talked to coaches last year when it was one of the biggest recruiting weekends of the year of the calendar where there's these high school basketball tournaments happening around the country. It was also during the portal window and they were like, we didn't even send anyone to that. You know, to that AAU or that UIBL or whatever tournament it was. And, you know, a few years ago, our entire staff would have been there with our hats and our zip ups and like making sure our logo is like in attendance. And now it's like we have to be in front of the computer screen to see who's in the portal making calls, making sure that if they want to visit immediately because the window is so short now for those visits and for the portal to be open that they can be available to those transfer portal players. So, you know, I think we already saw that high school tournaments were having less of a turnover. And I think, you know, if you look at the top 20 players in the country, the players who are in that like Team USA youth roster pool, those players are going to have spots across the country. Look at, you know, the top even beyond that, maybe the top 40, like those players will find spots. It's those players that, you know, are maybe a bit outside of that, the players that can develop into something over time that aren't quite as heralded as some of their classmates. Yeah. You sort of wonder how they get squeezed out of the college basketball world in this.
Speaker 2Yeah. I mean, we've talked so much about how roster construction has evolved at the college level. It like wasn't really a thing we used to talk about. Like you had your team and then you just brought in, you know, freshman and that was your team again and again. And now there's so many different ways to build a college roster and apparently continue to retain and deal with attrition. It just there's there's a lot more management to have to do if you are running a college program than there was five years ago.
Speaker 1Well, and I think it's also fascinating. Because this is just like how you were saying that the decisions that are made by the NCAA bleeds into the WNBA so much more than necessarily with the NBA and men's college basketball because of how the schedules exist. But with this specifically in the WNBA, when you do have these rookies that come in and expect a player expecting to be rostered, they're not going to the G League like in the NBA necessarily. But like you now, as you had to do this week in your own exercise, put together a mock draft where it's like, are these players coming in? Are they coming out? Are they not? And you think about all of those GMs across the country that are wondering the exact same thing about like, OK, here is our list and we're going to put asterisks by like all of these names that, you know, we won't know until 10 days before the draft. 10 days. 10 days. So they're going to have 10 days to basically figure out like, you know, they'll do their prep work. They'll do a ton of prep work. A lot of it could be for not. Right. Because, you know, there there is still and because. of NIL and the opportunity to earn money at the college level and what that means for players and building their brands and whatever it is. There's plenty of good reasons to stay at the college level for a lot of players and what that means for them and the trickle effect of what it means for other college players who might get an opportunity and what that means for WNBA GMs that are sort of like looking at this roster of players and scratching their heads and being like, well, we want her. If she comes out, we want her. If she comes out and like your top players just might not come out.
Speaker 2Yeah. I mean, there's always been issues of draft eligibility with the WNBA because of, you know, you think about players, if they turn 22 a little early, then they're eligible to go early. Like I think about in 2019 when up until like three days before the draft, it was like, well, Sabrina Nesko declared and she didn't. And then the top pick ends up being the scramble and, you know, Jackie Young ends up being the number one pick. And like, maybe she should have left early. Yeah. So there's always been questions like this, you know, even like when Paige was in college, right. And there were actually four consecutive drafts that she could have declared in and she ends up, you know, declaring in the third year of that window. But this is an entirely different situation where, you know, if you look at the mock draft that we have on the site right now, 12 of the 15 players in this first round could come back for another year. And that has got to be just devastating to deal with if you're a WNBA front office. Like how do you possibly like deal with all of these contingencies?
Speaker 1Yeah. And then like I said, like we were talking about, you know, they have to have the list 10 days before the draft. And so GMs will get this list, but it's sort of like last year when you think about the CBA getting done at the 11th hour and how free agency worked then and putting together these rosters. It's kind of going to feel the same way, I'd imagine, because when they get that list, there will be names that are not on that list that they expected to be on that list. And suddenly teams will be looking further down their sort of their big boards of like, OK, who fits well here? Who did we like just as much or almost as much? Who can who can sort of be that person for us if player X, Y, Z or X, Y and Z don't come out?
Speaker 2Yeah. You know, and we mentioned all these other players who tried to exercise a fifth year or would be coming back, you know, for this current college season. The ones we're talking about now are like ones who shaped the national title race with all due respect to like the previous ones we're talking about. Like, you know, Madison Booker could come back. Hannah Hidalgo could come back. Juju Watkins already had the medical redshirt year. So the five and five doesn't technically affect her, but like she could come back. Basically, everyone who you have decided is all American type players in college basketball. Like, we don't know if they're going to go into the WNBA draft. We don't know if they're going to spend two more years in college basketball. And that's kind of fun for college fans, you know, to get to see their favorite players longer in those programs. It is going to be interesting just like when these records start being set again of like people who just spent five years at a program and it's like, OK, well, the COVID thing is over, but we're still getting five year players.
Speaker 1Are we still going to do career records like at some point? Like, is do we care? I just wonder, like, do we at some point need to just drop the career records and do like even season ones are hard because it's like the season has lengthened. So it's like you're breaking these records and it's like you're playing more. So do we just have to do like per game at some point to give it a fair shake? I think there's always just
Speaker 2like context involved, you know, like when you say that Gail Clark had the most points in an NCAA tournament run, you have to mention that. Well, she had one more game than Cheryl Switzer, right? But like sometimes players play, you know, programs that don't extend in the tournament that far. Like I remember when De'Asia Fair passed Brittany Griner on the all time scoring list. It was like, well, she actually played fewer games. So even if you're not going to be able to play five years. So I think there's just always like that addendum that you have to add, which is great because then you get to mention everybody else who's also in those conversations. Exactly. Always good to bring up some women's basketball history for people who are newer to the sport or just don't remember because our memories are all shot and we have the attention spans of fruit flies. Anyway, there's going to be a lot more to talk about with regards to this five and five role and just the implications we see throughout college, the W, high school, every level of basketball history that we end up talking about on this podcast. And rest assured, we will get to all of them. But for now, let's focus on this particular 2026-27 season and get into our picks for player of the year. Stick around. All right. Welcome back. Let's get into one of our most anticipated discussions of the college season. Who will take home the player of the year honor? So Chantel, you had an article that published last week talking about some of women's college basketball's most intriguing players and started with the player of the year honor. So Chantel, off, we sort of set the table with who could actually win player of the year because it's a pretty deep list this season. So let's get into your top five that you put into your player of the year category. I'm assuming a week into the year, we haven't budged too much from the Sarah Strong, Juju Watkins, Madison Booker, Hannah Hidalgo and Michaela Blakes.
Speaker 1Yes? Correct. Yeah. And I do have to say that a little insider journalism for any of our listeners and watchers that this was like when I asked our editor, I was like, well, how many players, you know, are you thinking? And she said 12. And I was like, how about 12 plus a really beefy graph at the top that outlines the five players of the year? Because I think they're also very intriguing. And so that's kind of how I got around that. Your 17 most intriguing players. My 17 most intriguing players. Yeah, those, you know, I think it's a small sample size. Some of them were pretty good. But yeah, I'm not necessarily at this point ready to take any of these players out of the race. And I think as we, as we do look at these players, there are factors that we've outlined on this show already about what makes them intriguing is that, you know, none of these players ended last year as a national champion. And so, and not just that, not just that all of their seasons ended in a loss, but with the exception of Juju, obviously, who was hurt. But like, you know, when you think about their final performance, you know, they're not going to be their final stretch or sort of what they, they wish they could have done. I think there's something still there. It's interesting. I saw a clip from AZ Fudd's podcast, and I think she was talking about the 2026 Final Four game and how she feels like, you know, she had more to give in that game. They lost to South Carolina and that she literally like had a nightmare about it or like earlier that week that they recorded. And just sort of thinking about all of these players. And obviously it's something that she sort of, you know, no pun intended, had to put to bed because she moved on to the WNBA. Like all of these players are back at the college level, sort of the demons that need to be exercised. They can, because they're still at the college level. They can go for a national championship, whatever place they lost at last year, there's one step further to go for all of these players. And so I think that makes this really, really intriguing because I think talent plus a disappointment or an anger or a sadness or a rage that turns into motivation can be a recipe for, you know, these, these huge years. And the fact that we have so many players in this category, I think the depth of this rage is going to be a recipe for, you know, race feels really, really intriguing for this year.
Speaker 2So we've already seen two of these players that we mentioned win a national player of the year award, Juju Watkins two years ago and Sarah Strong last year. So we already know the case of what it looks like if Juju or Sarah were to win this award again. Let's get into the other three and what would have to happen for them to eclipse those two. Let's start with Madison Booker. We look at Madison's stats from last season. She averaged 18.9 points, 4.8, sorry, 6.7 rebounds, 3.7 assists, wins an SSC title with Texas. Still not quite enough to eclipse Sarah Strong in this player of the year race or frankly, I think she finished behind Mikayla Blakes in that All-American voting too. So looking at what Texas has on their plate this season, you know, there's a lot less talent with all due respect to the Longhorns, a lot less proven talent, I should say. So maybe there's an opportunity for her to stand out more in this situation. But like, is this going to be like a team success situation? Does Madison have to put up a fight? bigger numbers? Like, where do you see her factoring into the player of the year conversation?
Speaker 1I think team success always plays a factor. You look at, you know, we'll get to this, but Notre Dame last year, I felt like the fact that Notre Dame lost so many games was really the point against Hannah Hidalgo in her case, right? Like, you can play really well, but if your team loses, are you really playing that well? You know, ultimately, in terms of how you value a team sport. But like you said, Madison Booker wins an SEC title and does not win, you know, the national championship, doesn't actually get to where she wants to be as a name the player of the year. And so everything plays a factor here. I think with Madison, what's interesting, she's shooting more threes already this year, which I think, you know, we'll get to this in terms of what her, you know, maybe not on this show, but like, what her draft stock looks like and what she has to do there to sort of expand her game and prove herself as pro ready in that sense of like her game, not just physically and defensively. But yeah, it's hard to say because like, what hasn't she done other than be not quite as good as Juju and Sarah Strong? And that's not a knock against her. Those are two incredible players that at the end of the day might be quote unquote generational. And I feel like we overuse that word, but they literally might be it. And so I don't know, what does Madison Booker have to do to win player of the year? I would, I don't know.
Speaker 2I would assume either the volume has to come up a bit, like she's got to be in the 24 to 25 point range and Texas has to pick up some wins that you would not expect, right? Like they've got to beat South Carolina. They've got to maybe pick up a couple wins in this player's era classic that is going to be happening in December. So not a tournament, not a tournament. I was just thinking of the word that describes the situation. You know, you just have to have those marquee moments. I think like we in football, you always hear about like the Heisman moment, right? Like when a player solidifies their case, just because like it's a highlight that you can point to. And I don't necessarily think that like we should be judging off of highlights, but like it helps to have a big show popping, you know, like thing that about to really get yourself in the conversation or like the efficiency just has to tick up incredibly like i think that was sarah strong's you know big argument last season was she was just so effective from every area on the court and it's like maybe she's not getting the ball as much but it's you know she's only playing 30 minutes and uconn's winning every game by a bajillion points so like what she's able to do in her minutes has extraordinary impact because of her efficiency so madison's gotta really you know hit the like toggle in one of those two directions if not both uh just to make it like a more stronger statistical case i think because you know as we mentioned the field is just so
Speaker 1deep yeah and i think you look at texas's schedule specifically they don't have a game against uconn they don't have a game against notre dame they do have a game against vanderbilt and i think those opportunities when you have two player of the year candidates on the floor at the same time i think that's a chance to really like at least move yourself a notch above someone else right like if blake's and madison booker are on the floor and texas wins and booker's the best player on the floor that day i think you have a harder argument if you're arguing blake's over booker even if the stats might not be quite as you know a hundred percent you know the same because it's like what the committee does where it's like head-to-head results matter um and obviously that south carolina game is going to be super important in terms of how teams you know they are the creme de la creme in the sec so if you can beat south carolina i think that's like you were saying those resume boosting wins those heisman moments those naysmith moments whatever you want to call them i think those are those are it wade
Speaker 2moments you know yeah lots of names for all these trophies anyway uh i think that sort of leads us nicely into mckayla blakes who uh was right up there for player of the year last year and i think because of the volume argument right like she was doing so much for vanderbilt a team that kind of came out of nowhere right people didn't expect them to necessarily be in the number one seed conversation or you know contending for an sec title obviously their postseason ends uh a little bit earlier than they would want both at the conference level and at the ncaa level uh i i imagine vanderbilt's gonna tweak its system a little bit so that she doesn't have to do as much this year like you know she is one of the best scores in the country you can count on her to get you a bucket whenever but like if she's only putting up 22 points a game in the non-con like the early non-con portion of the schedule when you really get to to rack up some numbers uh i do wonder if this is like going to be the year where yeah she's still excellent and we still consider her one of the very best players in the country but i'm not sure she's like on a box score trajectory towards player of the year again
Speaker 1yeah and i think that's and in the sec it's like they have to win these big games like if you're a player of because there's multiple players in that conference right on uh within this conversation and then there's also south carolina where it's like because of the dearth of talent there like there are players like a joyce edwards who might not be in this conversation simply because don staley doesn't have to utilize her as much as vick schaefer has to use madison booker or as much as jay ralph has to use mckayla blakes but i do think with vanderbilt like they need to win those big games they need to be able to beat south carolina they need to be able to beat texas they have an old miss problem like vanderbilt cannot beat old miss like they need to beat old miss this year and and mckayla blakes needs to be able to show up in those games in big ways
Speaker 2yeah i uh i actually voted for blakes for player of the year last year just because i thought she was so good in those big sec games and just the night in night out difficulty of what you have to do in the end of the year and i think that's a good thing i think that's a good thing i think that's just is harder than like if you're playing in the acc or the big east or the big 12 the big 10 slightly different i think i haven't quite decided how you know top heavy that conference is gonna be relative uh to the sec but we'll you know we'll get there
Speaker 1you haven't decided yet and we're a whole week into the season what's wrong with you we're actually 10
Speaker 2days into the season so really i'm wasting
Speaker 1time here shanta yeah hurry up pick it up
Speaker 2pick it up lazy so i think there still is a pathway for blakes and booker because they're gonna have all of those games like you mentioned against lsu carolina um just opportunities against these other player of the year candidates where you get to make your case um and that leads us into someone who is gonna have a ton of opportunities as well just maybe outside of conference play and that's hannah hidalgo uh all of those box score arguments i mentioned about these like players not putting up big enough stats that's not a hannah hidalgo problem everything runs through hannah she's gonna get the shot attempts she's gonna get the free throw time she's gonna get all those steals like her steal rate is just obscene every time i look doesn't make sense how one player can get this many takeaways and people still dribble around her when you're the opposing team just like stop stop doing that um but i think the case for hannah hidalgo to win player of the year is pretty clear like you mentioned last season they lost a lot of games at the start of the year and by the time she picked it up and notre dame goes on a very good tear to end the regular season they obviously make it to the elite eight of the tournament i think the diet sort of been cast by january where like they had gotten you know roughed up all of these bigger games uh they were still figuring out their team and unfortunately like just so much of the thought was settled right and by the time you get to march it was like well you know we're two weeks removed from notre dame being like ninth in the acc so like how are we really gonna vote hannah hidalgo as player of the year i think they just need a better start to the season and that's could be problematic because they play everybody in non-con so like there are going to be opportunities for hannah to make her case uh and that's why i think like the path is very straightforward it's just who is going to help notre dame win these games so that hannah's not just putting up empty
Speaker 1stats yeah and it wasn't just the start i mean they started 15 and 9 they only had three ranked wins by the end of the regular season like it was just they they as a team did not show up in the games that the team needed to win and i think that's ultimately what harpooned her case was like she was putting up these crazy stats no one was arguing that she is one of the most effective players on the floor but her team wasn't winning and i think at the end of the day that's what you need to do a lot of times people think of you know player of the year and i'm not saying this is right or wrong but like best player on the best team notre dame wasn't that like and i think in in college basketball it's not always that because there are teams that sort of use a committee approach in a different way or you know whatever it might be and we also vote for these awards before the end of the season and so the quote-unquote best team or the last one standing um those aren't always yeah yeah and diagram is not always a circle um but yeah i think they notre dame has to win those games like they have to win you know they don't have to go undefeated in all of their non-conference games like you said they play west virginia vanderbilt yukon usc south carolina and then they stretch yeah and then they host duke at home uh early january in the acc like those are all really important games and it's really important that hannah shows up in all of those but also that the rest of the notre dame team shows up and gets the job done too yeah
Speaker 2that notre dame vanderbilt one is one that i have my eye on because they did meet in the sweet 16 last season and it was a very underwhelming performance from michaela blakes and hannah just absolutely took that game by the horns and was like i am going to get to the elite eight this is happening we are going to do it and it was just a really really good tournament showing from her you know starting with that ohio state game in the the round of 32 as well um so like if we see that hannah you know against vanderbilt's putting up
Speaker 1triple double almost triple double hannah
Speaker 2and even even the hannah dalga we saw in that elite eight loss to yukon was really good so much better than she had been earlier in the season um when they played uh back in the non-conference portion of the schedule so like those five games you mentioned uh plus the two so like those six games they don't need to go six now but like four and two and we're talking about hannah and a player of your conversation i
Speaker 1think yeah and i think the thing that is exciting about hannah and also for any of our viewers that are now seeing the sun just come through i'm about to get a crazy tan line on my face um but the thing about hannah is that like opposing coaches you know even if maybe an opposing coach might not say like she's the best player in the country they do not want a game plan against her because she is a player who can create havoc anywhere on the floor we've we've said this on the show before the two players in the country who had the most self-rebounds last year lauren betts hannah hidalgo like how is that possible on the offensive boards she is just like destroying people defensively she is destroying people she can hit the three she can drive like she is able to impact the game at every level in every facet and coaches know that and you know you have a player like lauren betts who is a match-up nightmare but she wasn't a match-up nightmare from everywhere on the floor like there were very specific places on the floor where she could give you a headache hannah hidalgo 94 feet like you have to account for that and she's a match-up nightmare and she's a match-up nightmare and so i think that is where you know again best player on the best team someone that coaches when you talk to them are like god i really don't want to see hannah hidalgo in the postseason um you know i i'm excited to see what she looks like this year another player obviously who could come back and whose wnba future is intriguing simply because you wonder how her game translates at the next level um these are all conversations we'll have throughout the year but um i mean her impact is is undeniable at the college level and for notre dame
Speaker 2yeah uh it's gonna be a very fun player of the year race and frankly it could extend far beyond this list of five that we just talked about because we've seen some excellent performances to start the year like we didn't mention anyone from michigan i feel like if you know olivia olsen she was she's a returning all american she could put herself in this conversation if michigan has the type of season that they are you know on a trajectory towards um but this is probably where we should get into some of the other intriguing players on your list uh unfortunately, the first one I'm thinking of is someone who's not on your list. So let's have you
Speaker 1start. Please do. Please do. I love when you correct me live on air.
Speaker 2As we're talking about, you know, player of the year candidates and WNBA future, like I can't stop thinking about Aisha Suka because, you know, she already is has been drafted in the first round by the Chicago Sky. Her WNBA like rights are taken care of. But she's 20 years old and just like looks like a frickin menace on the court because she's played against professional players for a long time in her career. And, you know, the non-conference schedule that Kentucky is putting forth is not of the same caliber, let's say, as players that she has played, you know, throughout her basketball tenure. So someone who I think is really interesting just because of like the crossing worlds of the WNBA in college where like you can be an international prospect who has your rights already in the WNBA, but you can still decide to come to college. Like we're going to see that more and more often. There's a couple of third round picks in previous WNBA drafts were also playing college basketball this year. And Aisha's just a little more interesting because she was a first rounder, like obviously more talent that you would expect. But I kind of think she's a player who if Kentucky does good things like the novelty of her is going to get her into at least All-American conversations, if not player theater.
Speaker 1Well, and not just the novelty of that, but like how often do we see the words 6-4 slash 6-5, we can debate what it is, and guard put together? Like that's just in and of itself like a novelty in terms of the position she's playing, the fluidity with which she plays. Yeah, I think that's a really good question. And this one is particularly hurtful for me as a Minnesotan.
Speaker 2I can't believe you did this, Chantel.
Speaker 1No, I feel like I owe a mea culpa to the state. Sorry. Addie Mack, the pride of Minnehaha Academy, go Redbirds. What she did in the second half specifically against South Carolina, you know, I think Maryland is always one of those teams that, you know, you have your eye on them. Brenda Freese has won a national championship. Maryland can cause problems. In the ACC, they have the talent. How deep can they get? That is always the question mark when it comes to March with them. But like if you have a guard like Addie Mack who's going to go and like drop 30 and a half, you know, I think the ceiling for Maryland really raises. And I think her playing with Aluchi Okunanwa, like them together in the backcourt, Bree McDaniel, like they just have talent and excitement. And the Terrapins are, I think Brenda is a coach. She's a coach who knows how to get the most out of her players in these times. And so if they can do that at a consistent pace and at a consistent level, Maryland becomes more intriguing. And Addie Mack is certainly a player that we need to be talking about more.
Speaker 2Yeah. Another Addie that you have on your list, Addie Brown. There's a lot of Addies in the Big Ten, actually. You know, Addie Deal did stay in the conference after her year at Iowa. But Addie Brown is a particular intrigue. To me, just because UCLA had to rebuild its entire team. They get an absolute haul in the portal. You know, Donovan Hunter, KK Bransford, Addie Brown among them. And she had her pick of teams that would have welcomed her coming out of Iowa State. And to go to UCLA and be coming off the bench in a year where like maybe she's playing for the WNBA draft. I don't know anymore because obviously she could have another year in college. It's I don't know if that speaks to like the culture at UCLA, what certain players are practicing. the culture at UCLA, what certain players have promised there. Maybe they like their lineups better without Addie to start, but she is maybe the best player in the country who is not starting right now. So anytime you have a player with that level of talent who you're bringing in as a sixth woman and can just change the tenor of your game with her playmaking, with her shooting, just everything that she does on a basketball court, I think that's the definition of intrigue there,
Speaker 1Chantel. Yeah, I think a player that I have already had the chance to see in person this year that I feel like I will pat myself on the back for this one, Tayala Delfoss. Great call. When we talk about this Michigan team so quickly, it's sort of Silas Swords, Olivia Olsen, Emile Holloway. Like, that's the core of the players that we talked about a lot last year. They were the core where it was like, you think back to their freshman year when they were playing South Carolina, like the freshman group that showed up and just sort of lit the college basketball world on fire and was like, we're going to turn this Michigan program around. Teala Delfaz was in that class, but just sort of not as prominent. She was only averaging 10 minutes or so a game her freshman year. I was talking to a college coach the other day who, you know, I mean, even Kimbard Zurico has described her as a deer in headlights sort of her freshman year. Like she was out there and you're like, what's going on? And I think I look at her and I think back to kind of when I was covering the Big Ten for ESPN and I was covering men's basketball at the time. And I think about Karis Levert. And I remember when he got to Michigan as a freshman and he was this guy who was supposed to go to, I think, Ohio. He was going to play at a Mac program, ends up at Michigan and he shows up and you're looking at this like very skinny kid with braces, baby face. And you're like, you don't belong here, kid. Like, what are you doing? Like, OK, good luck. And now he's had what, like an almost 10-year NBA career. He develops into this great player at Michigan, has a lengthy pro career already. And I think Tayala Delfaz is sort of on that same trajectory where it's like you don't hear many players who go on to, I think, potentially be a lottery draft pick at some point in their, you know, potentially, like if her ceiling is that high. Like, how many of those players are ever described as a deer in headlights during their college career? Not many. Like, a lot of the players that we see—
Speaker 2I feel like Gino would describe a lot of them as such, and so you could just put the whole UConn team on that list.
Speaker 1That's fair. I think he might not—true, okay. But, like, I think the endearing nature of it, like, she just sort of, you know, who she could become during her career at Michigan, the fact that she could be there for five years. And we've already seen what development at Michigan looks like for her. Two years and change into the program, two and a half years into the program. She could literally have double that runway before she goes to the pros. And she just, you know, she has broad shoulders. I think she can put on more weight. I think she can be even more physical. But she has the length to defend in a way that like, you know, I think about like a Gabby Williams-esque where everyone just talks about how disruptive she is as a defender because as a defensive mismatch, she's just like so annoying for players. And I think Tayala Delfaz can be that. And I think Tayala is a player that Barnes-Durico can rely on defensively, but also offensively. Like, again, if she's going to hit threes at a 67% clip like she did through the first, you know, against UConn, then, you know, it's a big F. But like, bust the doors wide open on this player of the year race.
Speaker 2As we mentioned, Yukon, I realize Blanca Quinone is among those players, great bench players in the country. So I apologize for making such a blanket statement about Addie Brown. But I think she's, you know, top three at the very least. Anyway, other players on this list who we should talk about. You know, you mentioned South Carolina earlier. I think Tessa Johnson, just how that point guard role works out for her is going to be just fascinating because she has been so predominantly off ball in her first three years at South Carolina. I think Jaden Wooten at TCU, who's entering a situation where like point guards have absolutely thrived under Mark Campbell and got an opportunity to show off so much in that pick and roll offense. Like, what can she do coming from Oklahoma State? Is she in that same line as Haley Van Lith and Olivia Miles? Or does the offense look a little bit different, you know, with her running the show? Just a lot of opportunity there. So, like, that's definitely a program to have your eye on, if not a certain player to have an eye on.
Speaker 1I think the only player that we haven't mentioned so far that I definitely want to add into this conversation is Kate Harpering I think you know to have the first week of your freshman season feature both South Carolina and Oklahoma like welcome to college basketball Kate um you know I think watching that Oklahoma game you could tell how frustrated she was getting these are you know when you think about these top players at the high school level that come into college they're not used to losing they're not used to losing on national tv um and Courtney Banghart has really, you know, kind of given the keys to the car to Kate. And so it's like, this is, this is her team. I think she's aware of, you know, the responsibility that's falling on her shoulders and what she needs to do for this team to be successful. And that's a tall task to do against, really against any team your first week freshman year, but a team like South Carolina, certainly a huge challenge. And she shot like 19% in that game, 17% from three. And you can just sort of, you know, every time the camera zoomed in on her, I was like, we don't need another sad Kate shot. I don't think we need frustrated Kate again. But sort of how does she how does she react to that? You know, I think she has a real shot at being named the freshman of the year if she's able to sort of like harness this again. Talent plus motivation via frustration can be a recipe for a breakout year. And I think she could still be, you know, those two games don't take her out of the freshman of the year conversation. I think it's larger than I thought it was. Here, I think we could add another UConn player. Jovana Popovich has had a really impressive start for UConn. you know, another player that. played overseas professionally comes in and is sort of like, you know, this is cute. Like college basketball, I can do this. Like I've played professionally for several years. This is, you know, the lights, I'm used to it. And so I think the freshman of the year race will also be very intriguing. Yeah.
Speaker 2As far as freshman of the year, I find it hard to believe that anyone's going to eclipse Sanaya Hall, but I am locally biased. But she's had what a start to the season. But when you said there was one intriguing player that we had to talk about that we couldn't get out of here, I assumed it was going to be the other Minnesota girl. So I am going to mention Aaliyah Crump.
Speaker 1Go for it.
Speaker 2Who is going to be very important to what Duke is doing because they graduated their starting backcourt of Tyena Mayer and Ashlyn Jackson. There is, you know, a big gaping hole there of who is going to handle the ball for us. And yeah, they have Emily Skinner, you know, who was redshirted most of last season. But Aaliyah Crump has, you know, just a lot of opportunity there to score, to create, to do a lot of things in that offense, to do a lot of things in that defense, because that is the way you play for a Carol Lawson team. So interested to see how she looks. She had just very impressive flashes at Texas her freshman season. And she can't be a flash in the pan type of player anymore. She has to be consistent night in and night out because, well, for one, Duke has very high expectations. And two, their schedule is another team that is absolutely loaded during the non-con.
Speaker 1Yeah, I feel like this is, you know, we should do like a come back to this conversation even like three weeks from now after sort of a lot of the meat of the non-conference schedule has gotten underway to see who we've also missed, because I'm I'm certain that like in these big games and, you know, I think this weekend we have the battle of the S.C.'s for the real S.C. Don't spoil our C-block, Chantel. Oh, my gosh, I won't. I won't spoil that too much. But yes, I think the three headed monster of the West Coast S.C. Sanaya Hall, I think that was one of our big questions coming into this year was how does Lindsay Gottlieb manage the expectations, the minutes, the scoring load, all of it with these three players, three number one players, three potential lottery picks, like all of these these wonderful players. How do you do it? And Sanaya Hall is having the best start to a freshman season in the Big Ten since Kaitlin Clark. Yeah, that's good company to be in. Decent company. Way to go, Sanaya.
Speaker 2All right. Well, again, we'll have plenty of time. We're going to talk about all of these storylines as they evolve over the course of the season, how these players, you know, rise to the level of intrigue that we have assigned them. Maybe more players will enter this particular discussion. But all suffice to say that there is a lot of good to keep an eye out for in college basketball over the course of the season. And there's a lot of good to keep an eye on this weekend. So coming up, we're going to tell you what we're watching over the next few days. Last but certainly not least. It is time to set our screens. A lot of good games on this weekend's slate. Chantel, what are you going to be watching?
Speaker 1Well, I feel like Sunday I'm just going to be parked in front of the television. Noon Central, 10 a.m. Pacific. For any of our listeners who don't want to do math, that'd be 1 p.m. Eastern. You have the battle for the real SC or what is it called? The real SC.
Speaker 2It is the battle for the real SC. Yeah, that's what it is.
Speaker 1That's what it is. So that is USC at South Carolina. They're playing in Green Bay. The South Carolina fans travel so well. You know, when I've been there for the SEC tournament, it is the Gamecock home court advantage for sure. So I'm really, really interested to see how, you know, specifically like Saniya Hall plays in that game. This will be Juju Watkins' biggest game since she's been back. Like the lights are going to be bright. This is going to be huge. And then at the same time, Vanderbilt and Iowa is playing. So that first game's on ABC, second game's on FS1. Like, just like. I think you have to double screen it. I don't think you can go back and forth. I think you just need to double screen it. I'm really fascinated to see how Iowa responds following that UConn loss. Obviously with Vanderbilt, there is some UConn flavor to that with Shea Ralph leading the charge over there with Commodores. But how Ava Hyden responds, how Jan Jensen sort of fires up this team to get them to put forth, you know, a better foot on the national stage will be really interesting. Then obviously later in the day, 4.30. You've got Louisville-UConn. So don't leave your couch. There's no reason. Just order pizza and sit down there.
Speaker 2Fun fact about the battle for the real SC. This is not the only time that USC has had to battle for its initials. Back in the day, Santa Clara University used to be called USC. And the University of Southern California sent palm trees to line the walkway into the admissions office of Santa Clara University so that they could take the initials USC. And now Santa Clara is. SCU. So I don't know if the University of South Carolina would want palm trees, but it's just, you know, a card in the deck if you want to throw it out there. Is this something you learned as a history major at Duke? This is something I learned while taking tours of colleges in California.
Speaker 1So here we are. You know, you know, what's hilarious is that my now husband went to UCLA and the first time he brought me to UCLA's campus and gave me a tour. I had this epiphany moment where I was like, there are palm trees in college. What? As someone that only toured Midwestern campuses and most of it in the winter, I was like, you can have palm trees in college.
Speaker 2You can even have them in Santa Clara where they're not native to the habitat, but they have. All you have to do is have the same letters as USC. Well, I think you covered a lot of the great games to watch. So I'm just going to say that you should also watch the WNBA Draft Lottery on Sunday. That'll be after the UConn-The-Wobble game. And if you want to have some fun, Her Hoop Stats has this awesome draft simulator where you can play with the. With the ping pong balls and see. I already did mine. Okay. Who did you get number one? I'm getting terrible luck. Every time I play this, I get Toronto first and then I get Toronto again. And it's like, we got to spin again and we got to spin again.
Speaker 1Oh, I got Washington first. I did it once and I got Washington first. I thought that was very interesting.
Speaker 2Well, anyway, it's a very fun time pass. You know, just click a couple of buttons and watch the ping pong ball swirl and see if your favorite team or the team that you're rooting for, you know, gets good luck sent your way. The Her Hoop Stats Simulator.
Speaker 1Are there any. Are there any under-the-radar games or any other, like, less. I picked the three obvious ones, right? Like, Sunday has a ton of bangers. Like, are there any less obvious games that you think people would maybe want to tune in for where it's like when we're thinking about those, like, 12 lines when it comes to the NCAA tournament that fans should be watching?
Speaker 2Nebraska and Kansas on Saturday. I like both these teams quite a bit. Nebraska is the only one that's currently ranked, but I have both of them much higher in my top 25. Britt Prince, Samaya Nichols, good times to be had all around. I think this will be a quality. I think this will be a quality win for either of them when they're thinking about hosting or just seeding down the line, like you mentioned, in March.
Speaker 1I think also Oklahoma State is traveling to South Dakota to play South Dakota State, the Brooklyn Meyer hello, I'm back game, we can call it. She's only averaging 13 points a game so far this season, but I think this is an opportunity for her with, obviously, Liv McGill, Adi Crooks on the floor, welcoming them to South Dakota. Could be a really good game there, too.
Speaker 2Yep. Lots and lots of good stuff to watch. Apologies to any of your family members who were hoping to spend time with you this weekend, but it's not the one. Anyway. It's not the right weekend, guys. That is all we have for today. You can catch me and Annie back here on Sunday night for a special live stream where we're going to react to the WNBA Draft Lottery and all of these big college games from the weekend. Until then, don't forget to sign up for the Athletic Snow offseason newsletter that drops every Tuesday. And be sure to follow our show. If you're watching on YouTube, please subscribe. Tell your friends. Check us out. Give us a rating. Drop us a comment. We read all of them. I promise. We love to hear from you. And last thing, if you haven't already, be sure to make your way over to YouTube and check out The Athletic's latest show, The Athletic Live. Watch the biggest matchups alongside folks who know what they're talking about. And keep an eye out for some women's college basketball stuff coming up during the course of this regular season, we hope. The Athletic Live is presented by Google Gemini. Check it out and subscribe now on YouTube. On behalf of The Athletic and Chantel Jennings, I'm Sabrina Merchant. Thank you for listening, and we will see you next time.
Speaker 3No offseason? No offseason is hosted by Xena Keita with Chantel Jennings, Sabrina Merchant, and Annie Hostable. It's produced by Tanika Burrell. Our executive producer is Andrea B. Scott. Monica Compton is our video editor. Our theme music is by Marcus Fagala. Shannon Ryan is managing editor of women's basketball at The Athletic.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The NCAA's new five-for-five age-based eligibility rule, approved in June 2026, allows athletes who started college in 2023 to compete through the 2027-28 season.
  2. The ruling creates complex roster math for programs like South Carolina and Michigan, which are near the 15-player cap and must manage attrition, transfers, and freshman signings.
  3. The change complicates WNBA draft planning, since 12 of 15 projected first-round picks could return to college, leaving GMs with major contingency planning.
  4. The player of the year race is deep, with Sarah Strong, Juju Watkins, Madison Booker, Hannah Hidalgo, and Mikayla Blakes as the top five candidates.
  5. A common thread among the top contenders is that each ended last season short of a national title, turning disappointment into motivation for a big year.
  6. Madison Booker needs either higher scoring volume or marquee wins for Texas to overtake Strong and Watkins in the player of the year conversation.
  7. Hannah Hidalgo's case depends on Notre Dame starting stronger and winning big non-conference games, since her stats alone were not enough last season.
  8. Other intriguing players include Aisha Suka at Kentucky, Addie Mack at Maryland, Addie Brown at UCLA, Tayala Delfoss at Michigan, and freshman Kate Harpering at North Carolina.

Summary:

This episode of No Off Season, hosted by Sabrina Merchant and Chantel Jennings, opens with a major NCAA rule change: the five-for-five age-based eligibility ruling, approved in June 2026 and effective immediately. It allows athletes who began college in 2023 to play through the 2027-28 season, giving players a fifth year of eligibility. The hosts discuss wide-ranging implications for roster sizes, recruiting, the transfer portal, and the WNBA draft, noting that programs like South Carolina and Michigan face difficult roster math under the 15-player cap. They also explain how the change complicates WNBA planning, since many projected first-round picks could return to college, leaving general managers to prepare for numerous contingencies.

The conversation then shifts to player of the year candidates, with the hosts naming Sarah Strong, Juju Watkins, Madison Booker, Hannah Hidalgo, and Mikayla Blakes as the top five. A key theme is that each contender ended last season short of a national championship, and that disappointment could fuel breakout years. The hosts analyze what Booker and Hidalgo specifically need—stronger team results and marquee wins—to overtake Strong and Watkins. They also highlight other intriguing players, including Aisha Suka, Addie Mack, Addie Brown, Tayala Delfoss, and freshman Kate Harpering, before previewing weekend games such as USC at South Carolina and the WNBA Draft Lottery.

FAQs

The NCAA approved a five-for-five age-based eligibility rule on June 23, 2026, effective immediately for the academic year. It allows student-athletes who started college in 2023 to play through the 2027-28 season, even if that means competing for five years.

A WNBA season occurs between college seasons, while the NBA runs alongside the men's college season. As a result, women's players on the fringes of pro rosters had already turned pro and couldn't take advantage of a fifth year.

Rosters are capped at 15 players, so coaches must balance high school recruiting, transfer portal additions, and returning seniors. Some programs, like South Carolina and Michigan, will need attrition to make room for incoming players.

WNBA general managers won't know which players are declaring until about 10 days before the draft. In a recent mock draft, 12 of 15 first-round players could return to college, forcing teams to plan for many contingencies.

The top five are Sarah Strong, Juju Watkins, Madison Booker, Hannah Hidalgo, and Mikayla Blakes. None of them ended last season as a national champion, which adds motivation to their cases.

Booker likely needs to raise her scoring volume to around 24-25 points per game or improve her efficiency significantly. Texas also needs marquee wins, such as beating South Carolina or Vanderbilt, to strengthen her case.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.