Why Did a Brilliant Law Student Meet Such a Horrific Fate? | The Lauren Giddings Case
47m 49s
Lauren Giddings, a compassionate and intelligent law student from Maryland, was preparing to take the bar exam and move into a new life as a defense attorney. Living in a private apartment complex on the Mercer Law School campus, she was known for her warmth, animal love, and strong moral values. Her close friendship with neighbor Stephen McDaniel, a fellow law student, began as a harmless connection, but it evolved into a dangerous obsession. Lauren reported feeling stalked after a break-in, and she expressed fear of staying in her apartment. Despite her plans to move out with her boyfriend, she vanished on June 27, 2011. Her family and friends noticed her absence and grew alarmed. A check of her apartment revealed her keys and belongings inside, which was suspicious. Police found only blood in her bathroom and later discovered her torso in a trash container near her building. Investigation revealed McDaniel had been spying on her, monitoring her via a homemade camera, and had access to her personal data. He admitted to entering her apartment, strangling her, and dismembering her body. He placed parts in trash bins, including one near his own home, which seemed illogical for a law student. McDaniel confessed in detail during a plea deal, expressing remorse and claiming mental confusion. Though he claimed he didn’t intend to kill her, investigators concluded the act was premeditated. His father later filed a habeas corpus petition, citing constitutional violations, but the court rejected all claims, including ineffective legal representation. The case remains a powerful reminder of how personal kindness can be exploited by obsession, and how even a well-intentioned person can become a victim of a violent, premeditated crime. Lauren’s legacy endures as a symbol of integrity and compassion.
No one had seen or heard from Lauren Giddings for a few days, and her friends from law school quickly became worried because this was extremely uncharacteristic of Lauren, who was very outgoing and social.
Lauren's studies were almost over, and she was actually preparing to take the bar exam.
What people didn't pay much attention to, however, was Lauren's recent claim that she was being stalked.
Things in her house would be moved to different places, and she thought someone had been breaking into her apartment.
This, unfortunately, had been true, and Lauren would be murdered by this very same stalker.
Lauren was actually the first member of her family to attend college.
Her family was excited when she decided to go to law school.
She had been so close to achieving her goal of becoming a lawyer.
In fact, she received her law degree just a few weeks before her death.
Lauren's life cycle takes effective treatment.
Go to nocd.com to learn more.
When an intruder approaches a home, they expect a camera.
What they don't expect. Stop. This is SimpliSafe. Police are on the way.
Using smart AI cameras, live U.S.-based agents help deter intruders in under 30 seconds.
Don't just record a break-in. Stop it from ever happening.
Plan starting around a dollar a day.
Right now, get 70% off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com.
30 seconds response time requires monitoring.
Plan with outdoor protection starting at $49.99 a month.
Visit simplisafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information.
During the summer of 2011, she was cramming for her bar exam,
which was the final step before she could finally become an attorney.
She ironically intended to pursue a profession as a defense attorney.
Lauren grew up in Howard County, Maryland, in a devout Catholic household.
And she had a very generous spirit because she was brought up with the church teachings,
which focused on and taught all about compassion and charity.
And she would always showcase this when she was with her family and friends and even strangers,
which some think may have been why she had such a passion for defense work
and giving people in need a voice in criminal proceedings.
Lauren adored animals.
She actually grew up with dogs, rabbits, peacocks, goats, turkeys, chinchillas.
And I love animals, too.
I have eight pets in total in my house.
Lauren was a country girl.
She loved bluegrass music.
She was the oldest of three daughters.
Her two sisters are Sarah and Caitlin.
And they lived on a dead-end type cul-de-sac off a gravel road.
And Lauren was known to befriend pretty much anyone,
which some believe may have contributed to her death.
Lauren wasn't just nice and beautiful on the inside.
She was also gorgeous on the outside.
She had beautiful blonde hair, green-blue eyes, and long legs.
She was close to six feet tall.
And of course, to top it off, she was intelligent and hardworking.
And after high school, she moved away from her family in Maryland and was living in Georgia
so that she could attend Agnes Scott College.
This was a small college for women.
At the time, she was actually studying to become a doctor.
But she was having a really hard time with her family.
So she went to her chemistry classes.
And she called home to her mom and broke the news
that she no longer thought that the medical profession was for her.
She changed her major to political science.
And she interned at a very well-known law firm.
It's called King and Spalding.
And then she applied to law school.
She was finally accepted to Mercer University Law School in Macon, Georgia.
Lauren lived in this private apartment complex.
It was on the law school campus.
And it's called Barrister's Hall, which was specifically provided for law students.
Lauren thought that this small, quaint, two-story building that only had eight apartments would be more private.
You know, there wouldn't be people necessarily partying really loud.
And it would be great for studying and concentrating on school.
At this point in life, it really seemed like Lauren had everything she was dreaming of.
She even had a romantic relationship.
She had a love affair that blossomed while she was interning at King and Spalding with a man named David S. Van Diver III.
He is an accomplished trial attorney that was 20 years older than Lauren.
What was Lauren doing the last time anyone saw her?
Well, Lauren's sister, Caitlin, had gotten married that summer in their home state of Maryland.
And Lauren had attended the wedding before returning to her Barrister's Hall apartment in Macon to continue studying for the bar.
And her family had absolutely no idea that this would, in fact, be the very last time they would see Lauren alive.
She had already told her family and friends that she wouldn't be on her phone or social media in the weeks leading up to the bar exam
because she wanted to disconnect from any distractions and really focus on her preparations.
On a warm summer night, Friday, June 24th,
Lauren met up with some friends.
They met at a bar downtown where two of her classmates were performing in a band.
So she went to a bar called The Rookery and then she headed over to another bar called Bottoms Up
before she went to a friend's house to spend the night since her boyfriend was out of town in California.
The next day, Lauren went swimming at the Macon Country Club and she headed back to her apartment around 6:30 p.m.
She was caught on CCTV.
The CCTV cameras entering a fast-food drive-thru.
And it was said that later on they did find receipts in her car that confirmed the time that she was there.
But the only other evidence of Lauren's whereabouts that Saturday night was an email that she typed to her boyfriend at 10:00 p.m.
and she had confided in him that she thought somebody had possibly broken into her apartment on Thursday night.
And she was actually saying she was afraid to stay there.
But since she was actually set to move out in just a few days, she didn't give it much thought.
So where was Lauren?
Lauren's friends and family had stopped hearing from Lauren by June 27th.
Everyone assumed she was studying, just like she told everyone.
But several days passed with no word from her.
And on the 29th of June, her family was convinced that something happened to Lauren.
And when you are close to someone, this has happened to me, tell me if it's happened to you, I'm sure it has.
You do get this sick feeling in your stomach.
Even if it turns out that nothing happened, I always have this pit in my stomach when someone doesn't answer.
Or they were supposed to meet me somewhere and they're not there and they're not answering.
So I can only imagine, especially with what ends up happening.
They weren't the only ones who hadn't heard from Lauren.
In fact, nobody had any form of communication.
Lauren had been on vacation with Lauren for days.
Not even her boyfriend.
So that's suspicious.
Lauren's sister, Caitlin, was one of the first people to notice that something was definitely wrong.
The silence from Lauren seemed really out of the ordinary.
And one of her friends in childhood, named Katie O'Hare, texted Lauren with a question about makeup.
And she thought it was out of character for Lauren to let a text go unanswered.
Because they were so close.
So Katie grew worried and she also had that sick, bad feeling that something had happened.
Katie had gotten so worried that she reached out to Caitlin to ask if Lauren had contacted her family.
But no one had heard from her.
And all the texts had gone unanswered and calls went straight to Lauren's voicemail.
So now I'm going to take you to Lauren's apartment.
On the 30th of June,
Lauren's friend Ashley Morehouse and Ashley's boyfriend decided to go check on Lauren's apartment.
She later recalled asking her boyfriend to be prepared to face whatever horrifying situation they could possibly find in the apartment.
Which I found a little odd.
But I think because I watch so much true crime, I would definitely feel that way.
And then they ended up checking the apartment twice.
The first time, they saw Lauren's car parked in its usual spot.
They went up to her apartment and they knocked, but they got no answer.
They thought that she could possibly have gone out to do a few errands.
So they came back to the apartment a little while later.
But Lauren's car was still in the same spot.
It hadn't been moved.
And Lauren was still not responding to anyone.
It was then that they remembered that Lauren kept a spare key hidden in a candle jar on her balcony.
So they used it to check inside the apartment.
Okay.
I'm going to stop like I've done in some other videos.
Would you, do you, keep a key?
outside of your home i'm not thinking of breaking in but i i wouldn't but maybe that's because i'm
paranoid one of lauren's neighbors from the apartment next door heard ashley and her boyfriend
so he became aware of what was going on and he got really concerned and he also helped them search
for lauren so all three of the friends were distraught they were completely confused about
what was going on and what could have happened whatever the horror that they expected to find
it wasn't there everything seemed to be completely normal and in its place the only odd thing that
they found was lauren's keys wallet and purse were also still there the keys stood out the most of
them because if she had left by herself on her own accord why would she leave the keys inside the
apartment
you're listening to the story of lauren and ashley
listening to a quick ad you know what else is quick selling your car on carvana just put in
your vehicle information and we'll give you an offer done no hassle no negotiation no guy from
an online listing lowballing you which means by the time i'm done explaining this you could have
basically done it still haven't started hey better late than never sell your car today on carvana
pickup fees may apply
knowing that she wouldn't be able to get back in without them but then i was thinking
you just came in her house with a spare key but still it would be unusual if her car keys and her
house keys were inside this is when they called lauren's sister caitlin who called the macon county
police to file a missing persons report police arrived at the scene and they didn't find anything
out of the ordinary so they decided to do a luminol test it's the one where you spray it
you can see remnants of the car keys and the car keys were inside the car keys were inside the car keys
and the car keys were inside the car keys and the car keys were inside the car keys
they weren't finding any blood within you know the living room or the kitchen but when they tested
lauren's bathroom it just lit up everything was glowing in the bathtub on certain portions of the
tile and they would later state that her bathtub had actually been full to the brim with blood
so investigators now believed that they were looking for lauren's body so sadly they expanded
their search for lauren's body and they were able to find her body and they were able to find her
search to the surrounding buildings and then police stumbled upon lauren's body or at this point what
was left of lauren's body it was found in an outdoor trash container that the tenants all
shared which was located in the front of the building just below lauren's balcony they only
found lauren's torso and it was wrapped in plastic but everything else was missing they knew it was
lauren because they matched the torso's dna to her body and they were able to find her body
what's really creepy is they almost missed the opportunity to find lauren because the dumpsters
should have been emptied that morning but they were blocked from getting to it because of all
of the police cars that's incredible police started to interview anyone that lived in the area
or anyone that knew lauren so that they could find out if anyone saw anything this is when the
Lawrence apartment came forward because he was very concerned. His name is Steven McDaniel and
he lived right next door to Lauren and also attended the same law school. Obviously a lot
of people in the community came forward to help and probably get more information because they
were also scared about what was going on. He was standing outside of the building as these news
crews came to report on Lauren's murder. This was the first time that he found out police may
have found Lauren's torso. So I'm going to play that interview for you. No one's heard from her
since. Did you see her hang out with anyone at the time? I mean no no no one has seen her since
Saturday. I haven't seen anything. I've always seen noise outside but it's people walking by
pretty much.
She just recently graduated as a person? Yeah she and I were we were both JD students.
We graduated back in May. What kind of person was she? I mean how did you what did you see her as?
She's as nice as can be. I mean very personable very much a people person. Do you know anybody
that any enemies she might have had somebody that might want to hurt her? No I'm we're we don't know
where she is. I mean the only thing we can think is that maybe she went out running and someone
snatched her. Because I mean
we went at we went over one of her friends had a key we went inside and tried to see if there was
anything amiss but I mean she had a door jammed that was sitting right by it so there was no sign
that anyone broke in. I think the door was locked when everyone got here and we just don't know where
she is. What about um in the like the parking lot area? I know they've been doing a lot of I
think that's where they have recovered the body or whatever they recovered from there. Body? Had you
heard any had you seen anything there? Had you seen anything there? I mean we don't know if this
is the same person you know what I mean like they took out a body there earlier we don't know if
it's a person or not so that's how we're trying to ask people if they know who lived there.
Are you okay sir? I think I need to sit down. Okay.
So you heard the interview and when investigators reviewed it they described his behavior as being
unhinged. Okay to me personally it didn't really seem that unusual because everybody
reacts differently to hearing news that someone they knew or they cared about or both
may have just been found dead. But police were still suspicious when he collapsed on the sidewalk
that's not that unusual but then he got up and continued to go through with the interview so I
want to play the rest of it. I am going to take some of the information out because it's not as
relevant but let's take a listen. No one had seen her since Saturday because I we all just
there's not a whole lot of interaction unless we're doing classes so I hardly ever saw her
I mean I would see her like go out running but I mean. What time would you go out running?
I don't even know when. At night or morning? I saw her like midday a couple weeks ago I mean that
was the last time I saw her she she ran all the time I mean she she had a group that she would go
running with I mean I don't know anyone that would want to hurt her she was as nice person as there is.
As you just heard,
he said it was possible that someone snatched Lauren while she was on a run
and from the interview it was clear Stephen seemed to know way too much about Lauren's schedule just
to be an acquaintance and a classmate or even somebody that lived next door. Because he had
been claiming to police that they weren't really close but that he just knew her from living next
door. Was she moving too? Did you know anything about her? Yeah yeah she was going to be moving out
today. We
he got onto her computer last night to see if she's anything she'd sent an email out to some people
that afternoon talking about like going out to eat or something and the last thing that anyone
there was an email that she sent out after 10 that night where she she sent to I think it was someone
in Atlanta a friend of hers in Atlanta and he she said that she she was afraid in her apartment that
she thought someone had tried to break in on Thursday night and she she was afraid to stay in
there. At this point I think maybe Stephen should have used his law school knowledge and just
completely remained silent. I think that's what Lauren would have told him to do considering she
wanted to focus on being a defense attorney. Remain silent, plead the fifth, zip it. A lot
of times murderers completely incriminate themselves by not knowing how to shut up.
But of course I'm really glad he did speak up because he was voluntarily inserting himself
into the situation which did make him come off very suspicious especially when he told reporters
that he wished he could have done something for Lauren like offer one of his firearms
so that she could protect herself. Yeah I heard something maybe I could have helped.
Okay don't worry.
You want to sit down for a second? You got something to drink?
I could have lent her a handgun. I've got a little handgun that I have for defense.
And this is when he became a person of interest and the investigators turned their attention to
him. They interviewed some of Stephen's friends and his friends described him as strange.
They said that he had a zombie fetish, not really sure what that means, and he would often ask people
how they would carry out the perfect murder. And at this point the police asked him to come
in for an interview at the police station and he ended up becoming the prime suspect in Lauren's
murder. About this girl right here, you know her? Yes. Who is that? Lauren Giddings.
Does she live next door to you? Yes.
when's the last time you seen her two or three weeks ago okay was you friends with lauren yes
look at me and talk my son okay was you friends with her yes close friends we were good i mean
y'all were friends right both of y'all were law students you're studying to be an attorney right
yes what kind of law do you want to go into criminal law yes is that what you want to do
for a living yes okay are you almost finished yes okay so you don't have too much more to do right
no all right the investigators decided to bait him observe the north american dad 50s
great polo collection he enters his vehicle information on carvana an offer appears in
minutes remarkable he squints reads it again smiles and says dang that's a good offer the
highest form of approval no haggling no hassle no one called him boss he's still on the couch
astonishing sell your car today on carvana.com pickup fees may apply think glp1s are too
expensive on row you can access fda approved glp1 weight loss treatment at your lowest possible
price if you're covered start with rose free insurance checker just upload your insurance
card to see if you're covered for certain glp1 shots whether you use insurance or pay cash row
helps you find an option that works best for you plus rose membership plans help you save even more
see if you qualify at row.co health rx only
side effects of glp1 medications including boxed warning go to row.co safety additional
row membership fee required they told him that he hadn't cleared out all the blood in his apartment
and that they were able to recover some of it he didn't respond to this either there's blood in
your apartment steven that's right there's blood in your apartment steven this is hard buddy i know
this is hard and i can tell
there's blood in your apartment steven you didn't get it all up it didn't all come off you scrubbed
and you wiped but we can tell that don't you watch csi yeah we know it steven why is there blood in
your bathroom i don't know yes you do know why steven i don't know does anybody know
has been in your bathroom the police were in there other than the police
who else has been in there no one that i know no one and you recently cleaned your bathroom didn't
you no how long ago i don't remember a couple days ago no over the weekend no no you don't know
i don't remember they saw a couple scratch marks that he had
told them that he scratched himself in his sleep i don't think i've ever done that so i found that to
be very odd show me that scratch again that you showed me earlier that was it a
what would you say happened there i think i scratched myself in my sleep
but something that ended up making police connect him to the crime later
was a statement he made about being a virgin he said that he was saving himself and he was celibate
i don't know about how you like to look at porn on the internet um you expressed to me that you're
a virgin correct yes they decided at this point they needed to search his apartment
investigators ended up finding a collection of guns knives and oddly he also had a huge collection
of wait for it toilet paper rolls he had a bunch of canned food like he was expecting the world to
end so maybe this was part of his
zombie fetish another interesting thing you might want to look at after this video and i'll leave it
in the description box are the collected writings of steven most of them are copies of emails that
he sent around to his law school campus to different people one of them in particular
was sent at the height of the 2008 presidential election it was on the morning of october 15 2008
and this was when the third presidential debate between john mccain and barack obama was going on
i'm gonna skim over this and you can see that there's a lot of information about this video
you can take a look later if this interests you but as you can see he's addressing this to the
mercer law student body with the subject line political hypothetical tell me what you think
about this is this something that people normally do and you'll notice he ended the email by saying
steven mcdaniel a true born son of liberty one that i thought was funny because it is actually
a pet peeve of mine maybe we'll learn something maybe steven's right but someone sent him an email
and they were letting steven know that irregardless is not a word saying it's logically absurd to
combine the negative elements of ear and less within the same word unsubscribe me surprisingly
steven wrote back saying irregardless is a word while it's considered to be a non-standard
expression of the conceptual term synonymous with it such as regardless and irrespective
it is recognized as a legitimate term funny enough i did look up the word irregardless
because it is a pet peeve of mine and surprisingly i guess it's in the dictionary he also said he
was working on a fantasy novel that he claimed would rival lord of the rings they also stumbled
upon what looked like a homemade mask and it was made out of a pair of panties what's up with the
pair of underwear that was in your apartment it was like a mask it was cut out like a mask
you cut underwear out to look like a mask
no but remember when i told you that he told the police he was a virgin and then they would
connect him later to the crime they found a huge collection of unopened condoms in his bedroom
and they asked him why would you need condoms if you were a virgin and this is when he actually
admitted that he had stolen them from one of the other apartments in the building and at this point
there was definitely enough evidence to make an arrest during a police interrogation steven just
stared directly at investigators in this really eerie manner he almost looked as though he was
pretending he was psycho i mean after you hear all this maybe you'll think he is but he acted like he
had maybe a psychotic break or he was delusional maybe he was trying to end up being able to use
insanity as a defense but his eyes appeared to just be glazed over and he would stare at the
wall he wouldn't look the detectives in the eye and he would stare at the wall and he would stare at the
eyes and at one point the detective even asked him if he was counting the pores in the cement wall
you came down earlier at night me and you talked all right you don't have any weapons all you do
that's just you what's wrong you know i'm detective patterson right yes you remember
put your hands up here you remember us talking earlier tonight right you remember me earlier
in the day yes we came down here and talked a little bit and then we left no matter what they
asked him steven's reply was i don't know what happened steven i don't know another thing i
noticed about this case was that a lot of memes were made regarding the way that steven reacted
to all the questions they're pretty self-explanatory as you can see asking steven anything a lot of the
memes focused on the investigators especially this one who kept leaning back in his chair so
a lot of memes are
created with him doing twister this one i'm not the best at understanding memes but i guess these
are self-explanatory to people that know their memes and this one is him looking like he's doing
setups he blamed this lack of empathy and the lack of cooperation on his lawyerly instincts
and he said that he was very protective of his space but of course he disrespected other people's
space going into their homes and stealing condoms
and we'll soon find out other things in addition to the other suspicious items in his possession
police found a master key and a key to lauren's door so he could open any of the doors in the
apartment complex they also found a flash drive belonging to lauren which included hundreds of
personal photos the search history on his computer revealed that he was looking at lauren's facebook
and her linkedin accounts and sometimes he would be looking at photos of her while watching
violent pornography they were able to link that from the times he was on certain sites
and then they found lauren's underwear in his apartment steven tried to be slick and delete
some evidence off of his computer but of course forensics were able to pull it up
and they discover deleted footage of lauren steven's
evidence and so steven had actually obtained this footage while he was stalking her on the night
of her murder he had actually built somewhat of a selfie stick if you will
he had taken a wooden pole and he duct taped a camera to the end of it and then he raised
the pole up to her window so that he was able to record her inside
They eventually found a hacksaw.
I'm Hannah. I've lost 75 pounds in 20 months with GLP-1s, plus diet and exercise.
On Rho, I've gone from struggling to run a mile to running farther every day.
You can access FDA-approved GLP-1s online.
Get the support you need to reach your weight loss goals.
Go to Rho.co slash weight to see if you qualify.
I'm a paid Rho partner.
20% average weight loss in one year in non-diabetics with obesity or overweight
with a weight-related medical condition versus 3.1% in placebo arm.
Rx only. To stay informed about serious side effects, go to Rho.co slash safety.
The best holiday finds aren't always the ones you went looking for.
At Ross?
Discover unexpected gifts, fashion, decor, and plenty of reasons to keep looking.
Ross. Expect the unexpected.
That wasn't supposed to be in there, in a utility area of the building,
which they then suspected was used to dismember Lauren's body.
Upon further investigation, they found the packaging that the hacksaw came in
when the person bought it.
And the person had to be Stephen.
Because the packaging was found in his apartment.
And then they confirmed that Lauren's blood was on it.
And even after being confronted with all of this evidence, he still maintained his innocence.
And they just kept pressuring him and pressuring him until he finally broke.
At that point, he admitted to what he did.
And he took a plea deal.
And he told police everything that happened that night.
Here's the truth about what happened to Lauren Giddings.
Stephen had gone to the hospital.
Lauren had gone to her apartment while she was sleeping.
And she woke up to see him standing over her bed.
He actually said that she was calm.
But she told him to get the fuck out of her apartment.
I would be way more creeped out.
And maybe he's lying about that.
Maybe she got right up and screamed.
Because again, she was afraid to be staying in that apartment
because she thought someone had broken in just a few days earlier.
But remember, this is his version.
Of what happened.
He says he then attacked her before strangling her to death.
We won't know.
Because we don't have her whole body.
He didn't know what else to do with her at this point.
So he left her in the bathtub of her own apartment.
And then returned the next day to dismember her.
He placed her body parts in different garbage bags.
And then deposited these garbage bags into various trash cans.
All around the law school campus.
However, he decided to put one of the bags into that dumpster in front of his own apartment.
Which just strikes me as completely odd.
Considering you have a law school education.
You want to be a criminal defense attorney.
Yet you're going to leave evidence right in front of your own house.
Doesn't make sense to me.
This is the portion of Lauren's remains that police were able to recover.
Unfortunately, the rest of her remains had already been taken to landfills by the time Steven had confessed.
So it was impossible to recover them.
There was this one news article that I read.
And it was so sad.
They interviewed her dad.
And he had come to the police department because he thought that he was going to be identifying Lauren's body.
Because they had told him that they found a body that they believed to be his daughter's.
But they were stalling.
Or what seemed like.
Taking too long for him to go identify her.
And so he's wondering, why are they not leading me to her body to identify it?
And one of the detectives just couldn't bring himself to tell this father what had happened.
It was just so unbelievable that they were actually holding back.
But at some point they had to be the bearer of bad news.
And let her father know that he wouldn't actually be able to see his daughter, see her face or to hold her.
But that all they had was this one portion.
I, especially as a parent, don't even like to think about these things.
These are the things that do keep me up at night.
One question that everyone kept asking themselves was why?
What was the motive?
Why did Steven do this to a friend, to a person that he admitted was sweet and nice and a good person?
Steven said he never intended to kill Lauren, that he got scared.
And he panicked and that all he wanted to do was get closer to Lauren because he liked her and he thought that she was really pretty.
He said that all he really wanted to do was go in her apartment and watch her sleep.
And he actually tried to make this look like it was innocent and normal.
It's not.
Investigators believe that the murder was premeditated and that Steven had become obsessed with Lauren during the time she lived next door to him.
Lauren was planning to move out of the apartment complex.
Just days after she was killed because she was moving in with her boyfriend.
They think that his obsession reached the point of no return because she was leaving.
And instead of just letting her move on with her life, Steven chose to end it.
As part of Steven's plea deal, he wrote what is called an allocution.
According to the American Bar Association, after pleading guilty, a defendant is typically
offered a formal opportunity to address the court to express remorse and explain personal
circumstances that might be considered in sentencing.
The allocution statement provides an opportunity for defendants to accept responsibility, humanize
themselves, and to mitigate their sentences to ensure that their punishment is appropriate
for both the crime and the person who committed it.
A lot of times a family will allow the death sentence to be taken off the table so that
they can hear the confession as part of the sentence.
And that's exactly what happened in Lauren's case.
Of course, Lauren was against the death penalty and that's one of the reasons why it was taken
off the table.
But Lauren's mother actually made a deal with the DA that if he confessed and told the unknown
details about the killing, that they would take the death penalty off the table and he
would serve life in prison.
We'll never know if what Steven confessed to was true, but I do want to read you his
statement.
On Sunday, June 26, 2011.
Around 4:30 a.m., I entered Lauren Giddings' apartment with a master key that I possessed.
I was wearing gloves and a mask.
I walked to her bedroom door and stood there, observing her sleeping.
As I took another step, the floor creaked and she awoke.
She sat up in bed, saw me, and said very calmly, "Get the fuck out."
I leaped across the bed onto her and grabbed her around the throat.
We tumbled out of the bed and onto the floor, and in her struggle to get away, she moved
her legs to the side of the bed.
I held her legs and lower body under her bed, preventing her from getting away or kicking
me.
I kept my hands around her throat as we fell to the floor.
She reached up and was able to grab the mask and pull it over my head.
She said, "Steven, please stop."
I continued to strangle her until she stopped moving, and I remained that way with my hands
around her throat for several minutes, possibly as long as 15 minutes.
She did not move anymore.
I dragged her into the bathroom and placed her in the bathtub.
Then I returned to my apartment.
I remained in my apartment mostly on my computer throughout the day, Sunday, June 26th.
I returned to Lauren's apartment around midnight Sunday to begin to dismember her with the
hacksaw that was later recovered from the laundry room and maintenance closet.
I removed her limbs and head, wrapped them in several black trash bags separately, and
discarded them in the Mercer Law School dumpster across the street from Barrister Hall Apartments.
I cut up the mask.
I put on my gloves and my shirt and flushed them down my toilet.
I wrapped her torso in black plastic trash bags and placed it in the green Barrister's
Hall trash can on Tuesday, June 28th before daylight.
I then cleaned up her bathroom.
I never used the refrigerator in apartment 1.
At no time before Lauren's death did I sexually accost her.
At no point after her death did I perform any sexual act of any kind with respect to
her remains.
She was wearing the pink robe.
She wore pink running shorts when she died, and I never removed them.
They were found on her torso just as I had left them.
On Monday, I stayed home from bar prep class.
Over the next several days, I rarely slept, used my computer extensively, yet still attended
bar prep class on Tuesday and Wednesday.
I joined the Bar Prep Class on Tuesday, June 28th.
Starting a business can seem like a daunting task unless you have a partner like Shopify.
They have the tools you need to start and grow your business, from designing a website,
marketing, to selling, and beyond.
Shopify can help with everything you need.
There's a reason millions of companies like Mattel, Heinz, and Allbirds continue to trust
and use them.
With Shopify on your side, turn your big business idea into. Sign up for your $1 per month trial at shopify.com/specialoffer.
I joined a search party Wednesday night into the early hours of Thursday morning, June
30th.
Still in a dreamlike, delusional state, in which I believed at the time while taking
part in the search that Lauren was still alive.
And then I had no idea that I was still alive.
I had no idea that I was still alive.
done, even searching the empty law school in a delusional hope of finding Lauren alive
and well.
As if I had not really killed her.
During the weeks leading up to my actions and the days following, as I look back on
it now, I can only describe myself as divided in mind, unable to account for how I could
have committed these horrible acts and at the same time also be able to carry on daily
routines.
It is difficult for me to explain why I killed Lauren and attempted to conceal my deed the
way that I did.
The difficulty in explaining it lies in my own inability to understand it myself.
I know that it was very wrong, I am not delusional or without any morals or decency, yet I acknowledge
that something in my makeup, my psychology, my neuropathology, my own particular pathology
perhaps must explain it, but is beyond my reach.
Lauren was my friend.
Not a day goes by that I do not grieve over her death.
I am extremely sorry for what I did to Lauren and her family.
I do not expect the forgiveness of Lauren's family, and there is no way I can ever deserve
it.
No words are sufficient to take away their pain.
If only I could take back what happened, I would do so.
If I could restore Lauren to her family, I would.
All I can say to Lauren's family and her many friends is "I am very sorry."
Signed, Stephen McDaniel, April 24th.
However, just four years later, McDaniel's dad helped him file a writ of habeas corpus.
This is a fundamental right in the Constitution that protects against unlawful and indefinite
imprisonment.
Translated from Latin, it means "show me the body."
Habeas corpus is very important to safeguard individual freedom against arbitrary executive
power.
This was a 73-page document that argued that his constitutional rights were violated.
This document is related throughout the investigation and pretrial process.
The four grounds that McDaniel cited are: 1.
He claims that he was in a catatonic state and that a proper warrant wasn't filed to
search his apartment.
2.
McDaniel said the state gained insight into his defense strategy and used it against him
through intercepted records of his legal research while imprisoned.
3.
He says that the judge was prejudiced against him.
4.
McDaniel's claims that he was in a catatonic state and that a proper warrant wasn't filed.
5.
McDaniel's claims that he had ineffective assistance from his lawyers.
6.
Steven's father decided to do a press conference about the habeas corpus and this is an exchange
between him and one of the reporters.
Just right out the gate, is your son saying that he's innocent today?
What we're saying, we're not saying this, a habeas corpus has nothing to do with innocence.
What we're saying is this concerns the state's misconduct, making it impossible for him to
receive a fair trial.
That's all we're saying.
But can I ask you, has your son told you that he's innocent?
I'm not going to go into that.
How are you, as a father, how are you handling this?
Well, of course, I'm very concerned about what's been going on and what Steven's gone
through and we feel bad about what's going on but we see some hope in the future and
we're hoping that the truth will come out.
That's all we're hoping.
But your son confessed to doing this.
Do you think it's fair to put the Giddings family through a new trial?
Well, this has nothing to do with him.
This has to do with the misconduct of the state.
As part of the plea agreement, Steven gave a pretty detailed account of what happened
that night and how detailed Lauren's.
So, is he saying that that is not true?
That that's not what happened?
Well, I think that hopefully he'll get, if he gets a new trial, that will be addressed.
Stephen gave a pretty detailed account of what happened that night and how detailed Lauren's,
so is he saying that that is not true, that that's not what happened?
I don't know about you, but I found it to be completely insensitive that Stephen's dad would
make a comment that this has nothing to do with Lauren's family. This has everything to do with
Lauren's family. McDaniel then appeared before a judge in February 2018 pro se which means he's
representing himself. Although he had planned to question more than a dozen witnesses according to
court documents only three out of the five people subpoenaed actually showed up. When McDaniel
questioned his former defense attorney Floyd Buford this is when things took a real turn.
Apparently, his attorneys thought he was innocent until they heard him confess in
detail about what he did to Lauren. Until the last couple of weeks of your case,
I was strongly in your corner believing you were innocent. But this computer evidence that came in
from GDI, the fact that you peeping in this Giddings apartment.
The graphic, specific, detailed confession that you made
to find Hogan and I, which we were shocked about in the jail,
and which you went into terrific detail about how you killed Warren Giddings,
How you went about decapitating her, carving of her body.
How you even sat down and cut off every finger and thumb and appendage on her hands
and threw them all in the toilet and flushed it at one time.
And then combine that with the searches on the internet,
The fact that you had done searches about having sex with dead people, things of that nature.
All of that combined to a heavy, heavy evidentiary problem in your case.
On top of that, you possess the most horrific child pornographic photos I've ever seen.
And I've been practicing law for 33 years.
And we worked out a deal with the United States Attorney's Office where if you entered a plea in front of Doug Sims, then they were not going to prosecute you on child pornography.
Started off facing a death penalty and ended up with life or the possibility of parole.
You could get out one day, Steven, and viciously murder a woman in this order,
and you still could be paroled. So I don't see how that's ineffective assistance.
We were working with allocution before that, which I thought was a very good idea to get
all the details down. And we had put it in there just like you had said,
including cutting off all 10 of her fingers and you read the allocution you suggested some minor
changes but then you said you wanted it deleted about cutting those 10 fingers off so that was
not in your application the judge denied his appeal and he continues to serve time in the
hancock state prison serving a life sentence with the possibility of parole what are your thoughts
So in the end, Lauren actually saved Stephen in a way because of what a good person she was.
It turned out that Lauren was one of the only people who actually bothered to talk to Stephen and treat him respectfully.
And for this kindness, Stephen repaid her by taking her life.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Lauren Giddings, a bright and compassionate law student, was murdered by neighbor Stephen McDaniel, who stalked and attacked her in her apartment.
McDaniel, a law student and former classmate, had a obsessive fascination with Lauren, motivated by a desire to be close to her as she prepared to move out.
He entered her apartment at night, strangled her, dismembered her body, and discarded the remains in trash cans, including one near his own building.
Surveillance and forensic evidence, including digital searches and a hacksaw found in his apartment, confirmed his involvement and detailed his crimes.
Despite claiming innocence and citing mental distress, McDaniel admitted to the murder in a detailed allocution and faced life in prison.
Lauren’s family and friends were deeply affected, and her death highlighted the dangers of stalking and unchecked obsession.
McDaniel’s father later filed a habeas corpus petition, arguing constitutional violations, but the court rejected claims of ineffective counsel and mental incapacity.
The case underscores how personal kindness can be exploited and how psychological disorders can mask premeditated, violent crimes.
Summary:
Lauren Giddings, a compassionate and intelligent law student from Maryland, was preparing to take the bar exam and move into a new life as a defense attorney. Living in a private apartment complex on the Mercer Law School campus, she was known for her warmth, animal love, and strong moral values. Her close friendship with neighbor Stephen McDaniel, a fellow law student, began as a harmless connection, but it evolved into a dangerous obsession.
Lauren reported feeling stalked after a break-in, and she expressed fear of staying in her apartment. Despite her plans to move out with her boyfriend, she vanished on June 27, 2011. Her family and friends noticed her absence and grew alarmed.
A check of her apartment revealed her keys and belongings inside, which was suspicious. Police found only blood in her bathroom and later discovered her torso in a trash container near her building. Investigation revealed McDaniel had been spying on her, monitoring her via a homemade camera, and had access to her personal data.
He admitted to entering her apartment, strangling her, and dismembering her body. He placed parts in trash bins, including one near his own home, which seemed illogical for a law student. McDaniel confessed in detail during a plea deal, expressing remorse and claiming mental confusion.
Though he claimed he didn’t intend to kill her, investigators concluded the act was premeditated. His father later filed a habeas corpus petition, citing constitutional violations, but the court rejected all claims, including ineffective legal representation. The case remains a powerful reminder of how personal kindness can be exploited by obsession, and how even a well-intentioned person can become a victim of a violent, premeditated crime.
Lauren’s legacy endures as a symbol of integrity and compassion.
FAQs
Lauren was known for her outgoing personality, generosity, and deep compassion, which stemmed from her Catholic upbringing. She was also intelligent, hardworking, and passionate about defense work, aiming to become a defense attorney.
The final step was passing the bar exam, which she was preparing for in the summer of 2011. She had just received her law degree a few weeks before her death.
Lauren claimed she was being stalked, as items in her apartment were moved to different places and she believed someone had broken in. She expressed fear of staying in her apartment, especially after a recent incident on Thursday night.
They became increasingly worried, especially when there was no communication for several days. Her sister Caitlin and close friend Katie O'Hare noticed the unusual silence and began to suspect something was wrong.
Investigators found blood in Lauren's bathroom, her torso in a trash can outside her apartment, and a hacksaw used to dismember her body. Additionally, surveillance footage and digital evidence showed suspicious activity by a neighbor, Stephen McDaniel.
Stephen McDaniel lived next door to Lauren and was a law student. He became a prime suspect after confessing to entering her apartment, strangling her, and dismembering her body. He had a history of obsessive behavior, including viewing violent pornography and possessing a collection of unopened condoms and homemade masks.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.