Go back

Why Chemistry Isn’t Always Love! Dr Tara Swart

25m 1s

Why Chemistry Isn’t Always Love! Dr Tara Swart

In this episode of *We're Talking*, neuroscientist Dr. Tara Swart explores the neuroscience of human relationships, highlighting how the brain—particularly the limbic system—forms the foundation of love and bonding. She emphasizes that love predates language, rooted in ancient biological mechanisms like protection, care, and genetic survival. Oxytocin, the "bonding hormone," is central to emotional connection, released through touch, intimacy, and shared experiences, but imbalances in its levels between partners can lead to conflict and emotional distance. Smell is revealed as a powerful evolutionary signal, influencing mate selection by indicating immune compatibility and offspring resilience. While visual and auditory traits matter, smell emerges as the most decisive factor—both in attraction and rejection. The conversation also explores hormonal dynamics, such as vasopressin and dopamine, and how timing of intimacy affects bonding. Dr. Swart concludes that successful relationships require mutual emotional and biological alignment, with physical cues like scent being more reliable than appearance or style. The episode underscores that even small, everyday interactions—like hand-holding or shared space—can build deep connections through chemistry and trust. A key takeaway: if a person's smell is unappealing, it’s a strong red flag; however, other factors like appearance or habits can be improved over time. Ultimately, the brain’s chemistry governs how we connect, and fostering emotional well-being begins with understanding these biological foundations. The episode is streaming exclusively on Peacock on November 23rd.

Transcription

3888 Words, 21169 Characters

English
- Streaming on Peacock. - Another beautiful day in Greece. - You know my motto, work hard and never have fun. - From the creator of The Good Place and co-creator of Parks and Recreation. - We might be looking at an eight foot tall, fully intact statue. - We don't know one. - Starring Amy Poehler. - I've been wanting to take over this dick for a very long time. - And Hugh Laurie. - This is less than ideal. - Are you in? - We're all in this together, like the Three Musketeers. - Hoppa! - Plus another one. - Dig. Streaming November 23rd, only on Peacock. See you out there. - Welcome to We're Talking. In this episode, I sit down with neuroscientist, Dr. Tara Swart, to explore how our brains shape the way we love, connect, and build relationships. Why do you believe our brain function is so important? How does it inform our relationships? - I basically call the brain the CEO of the body. So it's got leadership over every aspect of your life. It's obvious with things like health and wellbeing. But if you think about the things that most people want in life, it's health, love, wealth, and perhaps some other things that keep us secure and safe, and then individual things. But it comes down pretty much to happiness, health, wealth, and relationships. So, and I speak a lot about the other things and not so much about relationships, which is why I was excited to have this conversation with you today. I remember when I got my first request to speak on a podcast about relationships, I was getting my hair blown out. And I looked at this email, which came an hour before the podcast, and I thought, I'm a neuroscientist. I don't speak about that. But actually, obviously it makes sense. That, you know, one could, and I have done a lot more research since then. I would start with the, let's start with the negative side of the coin, which is just that if anyone or both of the parties are under stress, and this applies to family and friends, as well as romantic relationships, then there's a lowered capacity to operate at your best, which is inevitably going to affect your relationships, right? - Yes. - And then on the other side of the coin, if we're taking care of our brain and doing certain practices that keep our brain not in the stress state, but in the love and trust state, then also equally you can see how conducive that's likely to be to you being able to care for a loved one as well as yourself. - Yes, yes. So ultimately, because you're seeing the brain as the CEO essentially of our life, right? That the brain ultimately is critical to our relationships. It's critical. - Yeah. - So if we're looking at the brain in the most basic sense, what are the components of our brain, the main components as it relates to relationships? - So that's actually much more multi-layered than you might think. - Okay. - Because we've got the outer cortex, which is kind of holding our working memory and what we need to do today and to survive. And to some extent to thrive. So that will be, you know, don't have an argument with my wife, don't lose my job, put food on the table, pay my bills, et cetera. And then deeper in the limbic system, which is the size of your clenched fist. - Okay. - And then we've got this layer of cortex, which is quite thick now. But since we've evolved from the cave, we see that love isn't in the outer cortex, it's in the limbic system and below. So love is an ancient structure in the brain. - Interesting. - Even when we couldn't speak and we had the limbic system with a very thin sliver of cortex around it, we had love. And then through the spine, and other nerves, we have the gut-brain axis. So actually that's important in relationships too, because if you live with someone and you share cutlery with them, share a bathroom with them, share a bed with them, kiss them, cuddle them. If you think about the skin microbiome, the oral microbiome, and the gut microbiome, you actually start to share your microbiomes. And usually the healthier partner will donate cells to the one whose immunity isn't as strong. - Strong. - Wow, look at that. The importance of having a strong partner, literally. - Literally. - Literally. We had love before we could even speak, right? We had love. How do you define love? - Well, that's the million dollar question, Paul. - That's why you're here. - In those sort of tribal times, it would have been about trust and bonding. And of course people would love their children, but there would have been a larger element of wanting to see your genes survive. So if we look at animal studies, what do animals do if they love their children? They protect them, they shelter them, they feed them, they defend them against attack. They usually, well, most mammals are not monogamous. So if they choose to be monogamous, then they're pairing up to defend themselves. They're trying to defend those children. If they're the opposite of that, which is promiscuous, then they're just trying to find as many females as possible to pass their genes on and then just leave the females to defend the young. Because if the environment's safe, they can do that. If it's an unsafe environment, then they're more likely to stay in the nest. - Okay. The definition of love there is really around protecting and providing in essence. Is there an emotional aspect to love as well? - Yeah, so again, I'm actually quoting from research about voles, little rodents. And prairie and pine voles are monogamous and marsh and meadow voles are promiscuous. And the reason is that there's sparse shelter and food on the prairie. So if the male vole was promiscuous, there's a big chance that his offspring would die. So it makes more sense for him to partner up and stay in the nest and provide food and fend off aggressors. But between the mommy and the daddy vole, there is a change in gene expression, in brain receptors, both where they are and which hormones they bind with, and differences in the levels of the key hormones here, which are oxytocin, vasopressin, dopamine, and testosterone. - These oxytocin, all the way through, is I would love for you to talk about these chemicals in the brain, because it seems as if, I often hear people misquoting what, like you're excreting dopamine. What does that mean? Like, are you really excreting dopamine? That sounds a little, you know, a little wild. So what do you think are the most important chemicals in the brain as it relates to our relationships? - I would put oxytocin at number one. It's the bonding hormone. And so that absolutely relates to romantic relationships, also bonding with your children, but also family, friends, social, and work, even. And society. I mean, when there are low societal levels of oxytocin, that's where we see the fabric of society break down in terms of things like riots and turning against the structures that we have chosen to put in place to keep us safe, like the police and the legal system. - Okay, and can we pause on oxytocin? 'Cause you said this is the most important, right? So oxytocin, men, women, we all produce it. How is it produced? What drives the increase in our production of oxytocin? - So mostly through physical touch. So things like holding hands, cuddling, stroking. You would get it if you stroked your pet as well. Bathing, 'cause you're immersed in warmth, so it kind of feels like a hug. Obviously sex. Particularly at orgasm, really high kind of like levels of oxytocin then. And I think the one that, you know, if you've had a child, you know that incredible feeling of just being so in love, like you're in a love bubble, that's oxytocin. - You're producing that, so that's your perception. And does it matter if the partner or the person is also producing oxytocin as well? - No, so I think you're referring to something that I speak about much more, widely, which is the effect of cortisol between people. So leakage of cortisol into the atmosphere, affecting other people's stress levels. With oxytocin, it doesn't work like that. We're getting our own levels of oxytocin and we could have very different levels of oxytocin for different reasons. And actually this is one of the most damaging things to a relationship when the levels of oxytocin become very different. So one partner is still bonded, but the other partner is losing that connection because it creates both often shows of contempt in the partner with lower oxytocin, but also a kind of need to hold on and fix things and try to make it better in the person who still has a lot of oxytocin and can feel that that's not mutual. - Wow, well, is there an optimal level of oxytocin we should be aiming for? I mean, should we all have a full tank in essence of oxytocin? - Yeah, I mean, like you can't spread too much love, can you? The world, I think, will be a much better place if we all have like higher levels of oxytocin all right done we should package this up can you we should we should do this are people no one's because everyone injects everything else can you can you can you actually be have oxytocin injected i do not want anyone to do this but if you google oxytocin nasal spray there is such a thing really and in experiments where men and women were asked to rate photos of people on attractiveness um before and after so they rated them just by looking at the photos then they took oxytocin nasal spray they rated everyone as more attractive afterwards oh my gosh but the stuff that's available on the internet please it cannot be clean we don't know what it is don't do all right fair fair that's interesting a lot of people are running to google oxytocin nasal spray um so what are the other chemicals that you believe are important streaming on beacup not a beautiful day in greece you know my motto work hard and never have fun from the creator of the good place and co-creator of parks and recreation we might be looking at an eight foot tall fully intact statue we don't know what starring amy polder i've been wanting to take over this dick for a very long time and hugh laurie this is less than ideal are you in we're all in this together like the three musketeers plus another one day streaming november 23rd only on peacock see you out there finished your essay a day early that deserves a finally folded that laundry that deserves a parallel parked on the first try that deserves a no matter what you accomplish today celebrate with an ice cold coca-cola because even the little wins deserve a big enjoy coca-cola so i rated oxytocin number one because it's the main one that correlates with love and trust okay but there's one called vasopressin which in both genders is responsible for blood pressure the number of um electrolytes in your blood and blood volume but in men it is also to do with bonding aggression but aggression related to protecting your partner and your young okay and sexual interest the higher the vasopressin the more sexual interest yeah so if a heterosexual couple are dating and the woman's enjoying it she's likely to have high levels of oxytocin and dopamine and please remind me to come back to why dopamine is important next okay for the guy it's going to be levels of dopamine oxytocin and vasopressin as long as they're dating but haven't had sex yet so the longer sex is withheld the higher those levels are going to get in the man and the more likely he is to bond to the woman once they have sex the level of vasopressin plummets and so it changes how influential oxytocin can be on their testosterone because yes we both produce oxytocin but because men produce so much more testosterone than women it has a buffering effect on oxytocin okay um so you if you are you know wanting to form a bond then you actually would try to keep the vasopressin levels high for as long as you can if you have sex immediately with your partner then there's a low likelihood that you will bond with them well let me just slightly rephrase that because i'm assuming they're not partners yet okay correct so correct the bonding the bonding may or may not come if you work on it but in terms of the hormones helping you to get that to the right place to make this relationship more likely to succeed it's going to go against that it's going to go against that so if we're thinking about neuroscience if we're thinking about our brain we're thinking about biology in trying to help us to form a connection it sounds like you're saying it's to our advantage to hold back from having sex early to delay to delay and do all the other things that build up oxytocin like hand holding cuddling stroking kissing um and you know eye contact and obviously the other stuff that you talk about like talking and listening talking is important yeah yeah yeah but i'm just sticking to like the angle that i can bring you now how important you think smell is with regard to selecting a partner this is a really interesting one so of the five senses i would say that for humans visual is the first one and that sound is the second one so the voice and accent of the person and then the second one is the voice and accent of the person and then the second one is the first one okay and smell is third um and then touch and then taste so smell isn't the biggest attractor but i think it's the biggest detractor so let's say you had a fantasy about a supermodel your whole life and then you met her but she had bad breath yes it would put you off these are facts yes these are facts yes yeah yeah um but in terms of bonding we think this is partly mediated through smell that there is something called the major histocompatibility complex which is an imprint of your immune system so if you like someone's smell it's likely that they have a very different um mhc to you because that's going to make your children essentially bilingual in their immune systems and that's advantageous for them okay and i'm sorry mhc is major histocompatibility complex i was trying to not make you you make me say it again oh my gosh okay so this is interesting you know people can go out with somebody that they don't necessarily think are really good looking um but physiologically it's quite hard to be with somebody if you actively don't like their smell if you like their smell then it means it's more likely that their immune system is very diverse to yours and that's why okay so this this isn't a predictor of a relationship success it's a predictor of successful offspring yes i see and and literally successful offspring mean the viability of that offspring will they be able to survive not just will they be able to survive but there could be many babies that would survive but have quite a limited um gut microbiome and mhc which means um but to to give your children a bilingual or much more broad um immune imprint is advantageous for them wow well do you advise people dating to see if they to to literally to consciously examine if they like the smell of their partner yeah yeah first date and ongoing ongoing yeah so literally it's like gathering data lift lift up the arm and take a sniff yeah wow okay okay okay so this is interesting because the importance of smell is something that i don't think is talked about enough but i'm with you it's incredibly important and it's a it's a it's a it's an evolutionary game and it's an evolutionary game gift that's been handed down to us because for animals that's actually probably the primary one in terms of um knowing who your cubs are um loving them and protecting them okay and and because of this immune system broadening smell would be a much more important modality for animals than visual or sound all right fair can we spend a moment on visual and sound because i think with visual there's a lot of conversation around um what is considered to be attractive i would imagine that attraction it's relative it's it's relative so so what informs our perspective of physical attraction i think we can probably all agree on certain looks that are pleasing not and i'll use that word instead of attractive because you can look at someone and say they're really beautiful but not be attracted to them okay but and of course this will vary around the world you know so there are different ideals and different cultures for example um i imagine there'll be something genetic i i always have this theory that you're either a gene pool expander or a gene pool solidifier so you either go for someone that looks like they could be your sibling or you go for someone that's like completely opposite to you yes um and i haven't got the science to prove that but i've i've have a lot of anecdotal evidence of it all right fair so i think there's so many factors involved here it is obviously what people look like what they sound like what they smell like what their values are um you know common goals and interests family situations but it'll probably be something partly genetic as well okay um and it will definitely be something that is an indicator to you of that the other person's fertility even if you don't want to have kids that is a factor in our in our choice of partner so can we break that down i've heard many people call it the golden mean and and i think okay is is this really a thing and and ultimately what the golden mean stated was that if you look at a woman and look at the differential between her waist and hips if the hips are if the margin is 50 percentile or greater it suggests that she is fertile And so therefore appears to be more attractive. So certain cultures have people, women tend to fall into a more of an apple shape or more of a pear shape. And so if that's the norm in your culture, then you as a man are going to find that attractive. So you're describing more the pear shape, which applies to many cultures around the world. But if you look at sort of like South Asia and Southeast Asia and the rest of Asia, the shape is quite different. But for people of that culture, there's a different indicator of what look makes you look fertile. That's fascinating. And that comes from, that's just evolution. Yeah. So basically, there's a theory about the monsoon diet. You know, the sort of Asian diaspora, which is that it was advantageous to store a bit more belly fat for times when, you know, it's kind of feast or famine. And so if you think about the fact that Indian women wear saris and they show their belly, that's attractive to Indian men. OK. Whereas in, you know, the Western world, it's attractive to have a flat belly, a small waist and, you know, a larger bottom. Look at that. Larger hips. Larger hips. Yeah. Yeah. It's all the same. All the same. Are there indicators for men that appear to be, I wouldn't necessarily, I actually, it would be still more fertile, right? For the men. So what are the indicators? Because I've always heard it's shoulder to waist ratio. The first one, which I'm sure you see on all of your data, is height. Yeah, that's just the absolute sort of given. And then, yes, broad shoulders. Musculature. But again, that will vary from culture to culture. If someone is not physically pleasing or the sound is not pleasing or the smell is not pleasing from that first interaction with them, should you give them another chance? I think I'm going to say something you're not going to expect. If the smell, smell is the biggest detractor. So if the smell is not pleasing, I would say probably not. With the other two, I would say give people a chance. So what I hear a lot of my friends saying is something about the way he dresses or, you know, the state of his body. And I always say those things can change. But you can't change your smell. And you can't change your voice. You could change your accent if, you know, that was an issue. But so I think because I'm, you know, I'm just such an oxytocin person. So I just want everyone to be happy and like give more chances and let things work out. So, yeah, I think as long as you've got your boundaries and your intentions right, there's no harm in giving people a future. Like I said, in moderation, go on two or three dates. Right. Don't drag it out for 10 dates if you really don't find them visually pleasing. But if it's something that could change, like if they change their weight or they, you know, toned up in a different way or they dress differently or something, then, you know, I think that could still be OK. Yeah. So, you know, that was shocking to hear from you, but I'm with you. Oh. Yeah, I agree with that. I absolutely agree. I'm pleased. I absolutely agree. Absolutely agree. And if you want to hear the full unfiltered stories from today's guest, you can check them out on the We Need to Talk page. Drop a like, leave a comment and hit subscribe. See you next week. We Need to Talk. Plus another one. Dig. Streaming November 23rd. Only on Peacock. See you out there. Finished your essay a day early? That deserves a. Finally folded that laundry? That deserves a. Parallel parked on the first try? That deserves a. No matter what you accomplish today, celebrate with an ice cold Coca-Cola. Because even the little wins deserve a big. Enjoy Coca-Cola. Enjoy Coca-Cola. Enjoy Coca-Cola. Enjoy Coca-Cola.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The brain acts as the "CEO" of the body, fundamentally shaping our ability to love, connect, and build relationships.
  2. Love is rooted in ancient brain structures, particularly the limbic system, and is present even before language or speech evolved.
  3. Oxytocin is the primary bonding hormone, released through physical touch, intimacy, and shared experiences, and is essential for trust and emotional connection.
  4. Differences in oxytocin levels between partners can cause emotional imbalance, leading to contempt or excessive need to fix the relationship.
  5. Smell plays a critical evolutionary role in mate selection, as it signals immune system diversity, increasing offspring viability.
  6. Visual and auditory cues are important in attraction, but smell is the strongest deterrent to relationship formation.
  7. Hormonal dynamics, such as vasopressin and dopamine, influence bonding and sexual interest, with delayed intimacy potentially strengthening emotional attachment.
  8. A balanced, healthy relationship requires mutual emotional and biological alignment, not just shared preferences or aesthetics.

Summary:

In this episode of *We're Talking*, neuroscientist Dr. Tara Swart explores the neuroscience of human relationships, highlighting how the brain—particularly the limbic system—forms the foundation of love and bonding. She emphasizes that love predates language, rooted in ancient biological mechanisms like protection, care, and genetic survival.

Oxytocin, the "bonding hormone," is central to emotional connection, released through touch, intimacy, and shared experiences, but imbalances in its levels between partners can lead to conflict and emotional distance. Smell is revealed as a powerful evolutionary signal, influencing mate selection by indicating immune compatibility and offspring resilience. While visual and auditory traits matter, smell emerges as the most decisive factor—both in attraction and rejection.

The conversation also explores hormonal dynamics, such as vasopressin and dopamine, and how timing of intimacy affects bonding. Dr. Swart concludes that successful relationships require mutual emotional and biological alignment, with physical cues like scent being more reliable than appearance or style.

The episode underscores that even small, everyday interactions—like hand-holding or shared space—can build deep connections through chemistry and trust. A key takeaway: if a person's smell is unappealing, it’s a strong red flag; however, other factors like appearance or habits can be improved over time. Ultimately, the brain’s chemistry governs how we connect, and fostering emotional well-being begins with understanding these biological foundations.

The episode is streaming exclusively on Peacock on November 23rd.

FAQs

Oxytocin is known as the 'bonding hormone' and plays a key role in love, trust, and emotional connection in romantic, familial, and social relationships. It increases through physical touch like hugging, cuddling, and sex, especially during orgasm.

The brain acts as the 'CEO of the body,' guiding our emotions, decisions, and behaviors. In relationships, brain functions like stress levels and emotional states directly impact how we connect with and care for others.

Physical touch stimulates oxytocin release, which strengthens emotional bonds. Activities like holding hands, stroking, or cuddling promote feelings of safety, trust, and love between partners.

Yes, both men and women produce oxytocin. However, differences in testosterone levels can affect how oxytocin influences behavior, especially in men, where it may be buffered by higher testosterone levels.

Smell is a powerful evolutionary indicator of genetic diversity. People who like each other's smell often have different immune system markers (MHC), which can improve children's immune health and survival chances.

Yes, significant differences in oxytocin levels between partners can lead to emotional disconnects, feelings of contempt, or excessive attempts to fix problems, undermining mutual trust and connection.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.