Why a $1B VC Fund Needs a $100B Exit | Elizabeth McCluskey, TruStage Ventures
from Brydge Club by Ruffin Mitchener
49m 11s
Elizabeth McCluskey, a venture and angel investor, explains the distinction between venture capital and angel investing: VC relies on institutional capital from LPs or corporate funds, while angel investing uses personal capital, often through SPVs to streamline cap tables. Despite differences in scale, both approaches involve similar investment mechanics. Her career transitioned from wealth management to venture capital driven by a commitment to impact, especially in financial inclusion for underrepresented founders. She emphasizes that early-stage success hinges not on luck but on founder quality, team credibility, and deep customer understanding—highlighting advisor testimonials and real-world traction as key signals. Misrepresentation in partnership or traction is a major red flag. She stresses the importance of authenticity in founder decks, warning against AI-generated content that lacks human insight. Angel investing has become more accessible through networks like Bridge Club, where public engagement builds visibility and trust. She notes that the venture ecosystem is increasingly dominated by mega funds, making smaller, mission-driven funds more valuable. Founders should avoid over-relying on AI and instead focus on transparency, real customer feedback, and strong founder-team signals. Her own journey reflects a blend of strategic investment, personal values, and community-building—offering a roadmap for founders to navigate fundraising with confidence and authenticity.
You're both a venture capital investor,
but you also are an angel investor.
What's the difference between the two?
Venture capital is kind of the professional version
of investing where typically people raise a fund.
That fund can either be supported
by outside LPs, sort of big sources of capital.
Angel investing is typically done
by an individual with their own money.
Even though I was someone who had spent my entire career
in finance and much of it in venture capital,
I was still intimidated by angel investing
because it has historically been a voice club.
What businesses aren't right for me to say?
Venture capital has been very much glorified
and sort of made to be the only path for funding for companies.
Companies that shouldn't raise venture capital,
ones where there isn't a big enough market,
ones where the unit economics don't make sense as you scale.
What do you think should be in every founder's deck?
So much startup success is dependent on luck,
but you cannot predict luck, you cannot screen for luck,
you cannot invest in luck.
One thing that always I look for and that stands out to me is,
I'm Ruffin and this is Bridge Club,
the girls club of venture capital bringing you
into the rooms where deals actually happen.
Elizabeth, welcome to Bridge Club.
Thank you, I'm really excited to be here.
Well, you've played such an important role
in everything I'm building at Bridge,
so it's really fun to finally meet you in person,
have you on the West Coast officially,
and get to share all of your amazing insights with my audience here.
Yeah, I'm happy to be here, excited to be on Pacific Time
and to be in person with you for the first time.
It's the best.
Well, I think it might be fun,
just like level set with folks to start here,
so you're both a venture capital investor,
so you do this professionally,
but you also are an angel investor,
so you invest your own personal capital.
So to start, can you just explain in your own words
what is venture capital, what is angel investing,
and what's the difference between the two?
Yeah, so I would say there's probably
more similar between the two things than there is different,
but generally speaking, venture capital
is kind of the professional version of investing,
where typically people raise a fund,
that fund can either be supported by outside LPs,
which is limited partners, which can be individuals,
family offices, something called institutional investors,
which is often like pension funds, foundations,
sort of big sources of capital,
or it can be a corporate venture fund,
which is actually where I work today,
where all of our funding comes from a parent company.
Angel investing is typically done
by an individual with their own money,
and oftentimes groups of angels get together
to be able to write larger checks through SPVs or syndicates,
but ultimately kind of same mechanics at work,
which is people are putting capital towards founders,
whether they're early stage, growth stage,
it's just typically kind of the instrument
and potentially the check size,
although plenty of angels can write very substantial checks
and some funds write very small checks,
so while it might seem that funds write larger checks
and angels, that's not necessarily always the case.
- Yes, so you explained LPs and limited partners,
so thank you for that.
You had another term in there, SPVs, can you explain?
- Yes, thank you, yeah, it's always good to slow down
and like break down how to pursue.
- SPV is special purpose vehicle,
which is basically a way to help founders
kind of manage their cap table,
and we'll just do like the whole big go target,
cap table, capitalization table.
This is basically the register of who is an investor
in a company, and the more entries you have on a cap table,
the more difficult it is to manage both
from a cost perspective, administration, logistics,
oftentimes when you're going through a transaction
or any major corporate changes you have to get approval
or sign off or documents from everybody on your cap table,
and so a special purpose vehicle enables multiple investors
to roll up into one line on a cap table.
So basically, instead of having like 10 or 20 different
individual investors on your cap table,
they would all go into one vehicle,
and that vehicle is then the entry for the investor
on the cap table.
- I'm sure there's going to be lots of other VC terminology
that we will have you debunk throughout this episode.
I loved that explanation of a cap table of register
for zoning, that's nice.
So venture capital is one of the most competitive careers
to break into out there.
So I want to spend some time in the beginning here
understanding kind of your career journey.
You went to Harvard for undergrad.
I believe you've then started in wealth management.
So walk us through kind of all your different career moves
and how you ultimately ended in VC.
- So when I was in college,
I was listening to one of your other podcast interviews,
and I feel like a similar story maybe
were from the same era, which is like,
I knew about law, medicine,
like kind of the basic professions.
- I had never heard of VC.
I didn't cross my radar for a long time,
but in college, I majored in economics.
I was interested in business.
So I joined the Women in Business Club.
They had somebody come in and give a presentation
about investment banking,
where they were like, it puts you through your paces.
It's a great foundation for anything.
So I did that as my internship in college,
and then actually had that be my first full time
rollout of college.
I was working for UBS in London.
On the M&A team, so got to see sort of like companies
going through formative transactions
as they were buying or selling each other
or pieces of their business got to work
with a lot of people from different parts of the world.
So it was a really great first experience,
but I think one piece of advice I would have
to some of the younger listeners out there
is look at your bosses or look at people
who are kind of 10, 15 years your senior
and see if you want to be them one day.
- Yes, great advice.
- And for me as a junior investment banker,
I saw the lives they were leading
and that they still had no work life balance.
And I was like, that's not for me.
- Totally.
- Which was actually in retrospect,
absolutely the right decision.
It was a hard decision to make at the time
because there's certain bubbles,
I think investment banking was one,
I think probably the tech bubble is the same way.
Where when you're in it, you feel like
there is no other profession that is as worthy.
- The golden handcuffs.
- Not yet, but not even just from a financial perspective,
just like you feel like you're kind of in the best industry
in the best job and you'd be a fool to walk away from it.
- Yes, 'cause it is so competitive
and cutthroat to get an IB.
- Yeah, opportunity as well.
- But I did it.
So I left and joined wealth management within UBS
and moved to the New York office.
So I had the opportunity there to work for a woman
who had kind of blazed her own trail
in a very male dominated industry.
She really gave me some great mentorship and perspective
as I was trying to figure out my footing
within the world of finance.
But ultimately we were investing
on behalf of very wealthy clients making them wealthier.
And I was just sort of like, there's gotta be more.
Again, you know, I loved the day to day.
I loved the curiosity and that I got to explore
different sectors, different industries.
Like no two days were the same, but sort of the why
and the outcome that we were working towards
wasn't fulfilling to me.
So I went back to business school to try to figure out
where I could integrate impact into my career,
thinking that I would walk away from finance
because to that point I had then had two roles,
none of which had any like reference on impact,
but actually ended up learning about impact investing
when I was at business school.
And that there was this whole sleeve of finance
and a venture capital.
That's kind of how I started to get to no venture capital
where it's like, we're gonna put our money
behind promising early stage companies,
not just for the financial return,
but for the impact they can achieve in any number of ways.
And so that kind of really got me on the impact pathway.
And I was like, I actually don't have to leave finance.
I can just sort of pick my own lane within finance.
And that's how I had the idea to go into venture capital.
Obviously then it's a different story to get a job
in venture capital.
And so a lot of people think just going to the MBA
automatically gets you a job in VC.
And I know for my experience a lot of my classmates
who went to UCLI just to get into venture
did not land roles in venture.
- Yeah, and I feel like there are more internships these days,
but it's not common to have the way they have like,
the Amazon, Microsoft, like coming on campus
and doing recruiting, that doesn't exist in venture capital.
You really have to kind of network your way in.
- Totally.
- For better or for worse. - Yeah, for sure.
- So I kind of was like, I'm gonna take anything
that exposes me to early stage venture and impact investing
and ended up working at another business school.
So I went and spent a couple of years working
at the Kellogg School of Management in Northwestern,
managing their impact investing,
like platforms, programming, funding,
and connecting with early stage social entrepreneurs
in Chicago, early stage venture funders in Chicago.
And that's how I ended up meeting impact engine,
which was the first venture fund I worked for.
And it was very much a right time, right place.
- Totally. - I have luck meets preparation moment
because they had been an accelerator up until that point
and they were just about to raise their first venture fund.
They actually were thinking about starting an angel network.
So I initially came on to be kind of part
of the coordination of the angel network.
We eventually decided that wasn't gonna make sense
when we're just gonna fully focus on the venture fund.
And that's how I kind of pivoted into a more like
deal team role, doing sourcing and diligence
on the venture side.
So a lot of luck,
but I would say also just a lot of relationship building
and leaning into the spaces that were interesting to me
and kind of being willing to see where that took me.
- Some luck, but also lots of hard work
and relationship building and compounding over years.
It sounds like.
- Nothing makes sense like until you look at it
in the rear window. - Totally.
- And then it all makes a ton of sense,
but I wouldn't necessarily know
that this is where I was going to end up.
- Totally.
- Okay, so you're now at true stage ventures
where I believe you invest $5 million annually
out of the discovery fund.
And then you've also made over 35 personal angel investments
which we get to talk a lot about, which is fun.
- So tell us more like what are you really looking for
in founders, both at the fund and as well as in angel
and what is your actual investment thesis in both?
- Yeah, so for the fund, for true stage ventures,
I'm investing in pre-seed and seed stage Fintech companies
led by underrepresented founders.
So people of color, women,
LGBTQ and veteran founders. And we're looking for solutions for financial inclusion, financial access,
really helping middle-income Americans be able to, you know, save, earn, grow their wealth,
support their families, and just kind of pay attention to their financial health as well as
their, you know, I feel like physical health, mental health have been big themes in our culture
for a long time. But I think financial health has continued to be overlooked and continued to be
an area that like kids aren't necessarily educated in. A lot of adults don't feel equipped to
navigate. And so we're trying to find the solutions that are going to help connect people with,
you know, ways to be financially healthier. On the angel side, I definitely dabbled in the first
like year or so. But now I've narrowed in my focus more to be on supporting families, improving
health and building community. Those are kind of my three core pillars also focused on early
stage founders. So typically precede and seed. I just love the early stage stuff. I feel like,
you know, that's where you can really be the most value add to companies in terms of thinking about,
you know, depending on who you are, like you can add value in different places. But for me,
because I have built a network adventure over the last decade, I can really help them think about
how do you strategically approach fundraising? Here's who you should talk to. Here's how you should
message things. Here's when you should send investor updates, things like that. Where by the time
a company gets to like a series A or a series B, that's all, yes, old news to them. And they're like,
why are you telling me this? I know all of this stuff. We know what we're doing now. Yeah. Yeah.
So I just love being kind of at that infancy stage. And I just also, I have never been a founder
or an entrepreneur. So I'm not one of these like operator turned VCs, but I love being surrounded
by founders and the energy and the motivation and just their drive. And like, I love to be an
enabler of that phase and that energy. Create transition because I want to spend some time picking
your brain on all things founders should be thinking about when going out to raise their first round
of capital, meet their first investor intro. So so much to debunk and cover there. I think before
we get into that though, can you help listeners understand how you think about like what businesses
are actually right for venture capital and maybe, you know, what businesses aren't right for VC?
Yeah. I do think that is a good thing both to think about as an investor and if there's any founders
listening to think about as a founder too, because I think venture capital has been very much
like glorified, very glamorous and sort of made to be the only path for funding for companies.
And I think, you know, companies have existed long before and will exist long after whatever
becomes a venture capital, right? And there are definitely business models that make sense for venture
and there's business models that don't. And then there's some where companies can kind of choose
like where they sit within the spectrum. Seed strapping is another term that has kind of come
on to the scene of late, which is yeah, companies raising like one or maybe two rounds and then kind
of achieving profitability and going from there. So it's playing on bootstrapping plus seed. So
you're raising a seed round, but you're also mostly bootstrapping the company, meaning your self
funding. And people who are choosing that route are ones who are like, I need enough capital to get
this business off the ground. I don't personally have the dollars to pull out and like make this thing
happen. And also debt funding is typically really difficult to get for brand new companies,
because debt relies on cash flows. And when you're an early stage company, you don't have a cash flow.
So seed strapping is kind of maybe that nice in between companies that shouldn't raise venture
capital. You know, ones where there isn't a big enough market, ones where the unit economics
don't make sense as you scale like a whole big thing about ventures. You know, can this company
scale to be used to be a billion dollars? I don't even know what the new bar is. It's like,
can it be a hundred billion dollars? So I also think there's different, there's definitely
different flavors of VC. There are some venture funds who are only investing for like 100 billion
plus exits. You should know if you are hearing towards that kind of outcome or not. It's
totally fine to not be garing towards that outcome. And there's plenty of venture funds who are
trying to optimize for like billion dollar exits. Can you explain fund math and like why certain
funds need an exit of that size and why other funds are okay with a or very happy with a 500
million billion dollar exit? So the power law reigns supreme in venture capital, which is that,
you know, a very small handful, if not only a single company, are going to be responsible for
whether a fund returns a multiple of its original size. The power law becomes very difficult
to grapple with. The larger a fund is, so if you have a 10 million dollar fund and you have,
let's say, 20 investments and you have one investment that returns enough to make the fund two or
three X. That company only has to be worth, let's say, a hundred million or 200 million dollars,
where your share is then returning 20 to 30 million dollars. If you have a 500 million dollar fund
or a billion dollar fund to return two to three X, you need to have like two to three billion
dollars of return value. By the time you're talking about such late stage companies and you're
owning like two or three percent, maybe five percent of that company, that company has to be worth
a hundred billion dollars to get there. So I think the whole venture ecosystem has changed pretty
dramatically in the last few years because the difference between sort of the haves and the
have nots or like the big venture funds and everybody else has only widened, where big venture
funds used to be, you know, several hundred million dollars. And now it's like they're multi-billion
dollars and they're just continuing to close left and right. And that's where all of the LP
capital is going to. I think they're getting like not over 90 percent of LP capital or something
crazy. So all the capital is being concentrated in the mega funds, which completely transforms the
dynamics of the venture ecosystem because the majority, the vast majority of venture capital
is going towards the companies that are trying to achieve that like hundred billion dollar plus
exit. But there is a whole, what I think really cool ecosystem of emerging managers, solo GPs,
really small funds, like sort of the opposite extreme, like funds that are less than 10 million
dollars, where they can afford to invest in companies who are going to have maybe even like
eight digit returns, you know, like maybe even sub hundred million dollar exits. But because of
when they invest and what the total kind of capital pool looks like, that can return their fund
multiple times over and make their LP's happy. It's just those are not the ones getting the headlines
because the notice are a lot smaller. Yes. And glad we started there because I think that's so
important to understand this fun math when you are starting to think about like, who should be
on my target BC investor list and also like, you know, if you're getting a know from one of those
mega funds, like understand, it might not be, it's not because you have a bad idea or a bad business
or you're a bad founder. There's just these mechanics that play in the background. That is just the way
the math works. In terms of, you know, how we can help founders and how we can sort of put them on
the right path, make a list of funds and then throw that list out and start over and like make a
real list of funds because you're going to start with all the ones you've heard of before. Yes.
And those are all probably unless you are like a really rare founder, a total waste of your time.
It's just going to disappoint you and make you feel like you're not getting anywhere. And not to
say you're not going to get rejected by a lot of funds, no matter what. But if you start with the
wrong list of funds, you're going to be rejected a hundred times out of one. Yeah. Yeah. And it's
just not going to be fun. Yeah. And a good use of your time. This probably mean a whole other topic
is the use of AI, both from the founder side and from the fund side. Like there's already been
so much deal flow and you know, it's very typical for companies to get rejected a lot in the fund
raising process. I think if those numbers haven't already ticked up, I'm sure they're going to
dramatically. I mean, I hear about fund managers who are seeing two to three plus times the deal flow
coming into them because companies are starting at such higher rates. They're putting together
decks with AI so many decks. Please do not do that for anyone listening. Do not do that. It is
very obvious. And it's just like an immediate no for a lot of funds. But then also on the fund
side, a lot of them are putting decks through AI to say like, I'm not even going to do the initial
analysis because I'm so inundated. So I'm not even going to look at this unless it passes my AI
screener. So I think also as a founder, you should just be aware that that is happening and put your
own deck through your AI of choice to see like what it's going to say a VC totally on this would
be to help you, you know, you don't need you should not change your whole business because of
that. But you should definitely just be aware like these are the critiques that are going to be
pulled out based on how I'm presenting things. Totally. I've actually seen one VC that almost has
like a public version of this. And for the record, I don't do this. I still like to do things the
old fashioned way because I do think there's stuff that comes across that cannot be interpreted by AI
especially if you're looking with early stage companies like you're looking for an X factor,
you're looking for something that's different about a team or about an idea. And the whole point
of AI is like it's building on pattern recognition and packaging and you're trying to find the stuff
that's different. It doesn't like different. No, I feel like the core thing about being an investor
is like finding those outliers and AI is trained on very specific things and specific ways of thinking.
So like if we're all just following like AI investment memos or AI pools to get decks out like
you're not going to be finding those outlier companies. So you might find like the consensus
companies. Exactly. And maybe that is where you want to be. But most people don't want to.
Okay. So for especially first-time founders that have like no network of investors,
how do you advise those founders to
kind of like start to get introductions and meetings with VCs like what advice would you give to them?
I mean the first advice which is both the easiest and the hardest is to build in public as much as
you can so you know you can pick the platform of choice but LinkedIn is a pretty like obvious
easy one and when I say build in public what I mean is you know you talk about yourself you talk
about where you're building you talk about wins you talk about losses like you try to be transparent
without obviously giving away the whole business but showing people how you think how you adapt
you know if you just talk about all the positives people are not going to believe you because
everyone knows startups are very difficult and there's always going to be highs and lows so talking
about the lows but talking about like oh what did we change as a result of this how do we learn from
this and putting your asks out there I think yes making public asks is like severely underutilized
because people inherently want to be helpful and people also don't know like what that could lead
to for them and so if you're like hey does anybody know somebody in you know customer success at
Airbnb like you don't even know who in your network might already know that person or who in your
network might be like hey because in Joe like just got married to somebody who works there like I can
put you in touch but you're never going to know if you don't ask and so the more public and frequent
you make your ask I think you know the better outcomes you're going to get so that's the first one
building in public I would also say starting to be really organized and intentional and methodical
about communicating with anybody who has expressed any modicum of interest in you as a person
or your company over time so this means like every past colleague that you've had every friend
from college who's interested or who's like hey like what are you up to these days you're like well
I'm building this company like can I put you on my update list you always ask they can always say
no you always give like the opt out of the bottom don't have to open it right yeah but just you
know sending out like a monthly update again with some version of what you're talking about in
public as well that's sort of like here's here's what we're doing here's kind of the reminder one
line or of what we do because also especially if you are in the venture world you're seeing so many
companies you need to remind people again and again and again yes even my own portfolio companies
like I have 30 venture fun portfolio companies 30 plus future companies like sometimes I need
you remind me in one sentence how do things change people are pivoting yeah so like keep it simple
remind people what you do talk about what's changed in the last month you know have you gotten
any customers have any people churned and why have you brought new people onto the team what's the
product roadmap what's your cash position you know you might decide which audience that's what
before yes because if you're trying to woo a new investor and you have like less than 30 days of
runway maybe that's a difficult sell but I think especially when you have a lot of runway keeping
that number in the mix to show people like hey we actually don't need cash right now but we just
want to keep you in the loop and then that could make people feel like oh maybe I need to kind of
like preempt something or you know get in front of them before their next round that's the other
thing I would recommend people do and you've also been building in public so I have to ask what has
been I guess maybe like the coolest opportunity that has come from building in public I have one in
mind for yes I would say that's probably we have the same one in mind given my interest areas I'm
trying to keep up on a lot of things one of the headlines that crossed my desk recently was
about a company that's trying to build a decaf coffee brand and I've actually been an exclusively
decaf coffee drinker for probably 10-ish years wow at some point caffeine just started to like
make me dinnery give me anxiety and I was like I can't do this anymore and the decaf coffee
options are always terrible like if even an option as I'm even considered yeah yeah I read this
article and I was just like oh like what a great idea this brand really speaks to me and they made
this analogy that this company is called heist they're trying to do what decaf coffee did what
athletic brewing did for NA beer which is basically like hmm the category exists great one liner yeah
great one liner got me hooked me but like the category has existed for a long time and there are
people who are kind of part of the category even though there aren't any good options and so
giving them like an actual high quality brand and choice and making it something that's cool
to talk about and to to consume and participate in again and they were working with some incredible
like creative and brand partners some of the companies who were behind the branding of groons
the you know the vitamin gummies that have like been just such a huge success and a few others
magic spoon cereal which I feel like if anyone is ever on social media every influencer ever
has pushed that one and so I made a LinkedIn post about this just saying like what a cool brand
if you are still looking for investment my DMs are open like ha ha and he actually messaged me
I don't think I knew exactly what the post said that's so good yeah yeah I was just like I saw
this this is really cool wouldn't it have been fun to invest in this and he reached out and he's
like hey so good you know I love the personal story that you shared I love where you're coming from
like we're open to taking a couple of small angel checks and I was like okay well my personal
check is too small to meet your minimum but I'm part of bridge club which is a community of women
who are you know trying to get more women on cap tables like would you consider pitching to us as
a group and he was like yes his co-founder is a woman his wife they were actually the co-founders
of Corksicle which had a successful exit back in the day and so he was like you know she knows
that women are definitely going to be a big consumer of this product we want to have more women
on our side on the cap table so we got the deal done in like record time they pitched to our group
definitely record time they pitched to our group we had a lot of interest we got the SPV oversubscribed
and now we're investors amazing love it that was a very cool and you know watch unfold
and just again goes back to the power of building in public building your personal brand honestly no
matter if you're a founder and investor you work at a company like the option is that can come
from that are just insane and I would also say yes I mean a lot of stuff is compounding for me over
a whole career and you know it's not to say like I'm starting from scratch but I only started angel
investing like less than three years ago so this can all happen pretty quickly if you dedicate yourself
and you just put yourself out there and us I think the majority of people including the ones who
do post regularly always feel a little bit uncomfortable about it but like you just push through
it because so many great things come from the other side completely agree you just got to be
a little shameless and it's amazing what will come your way yeah you've probably seen thousands
of founder decks and pitches at this point in your career so what do you think should be in every
founders deck so one of the things I love to see whether the team is just the founder or maybe
them plus a co-founder or like a team of three typically teams are pretty small one thing that always
I look for and that stands out to me is who else is at the table to begin with they don't necessarily
have to be investors but like who have they recruited as an advisor who has been an early higher
who is potentially an investor just like people who can kind of be character references or
demonstrate the power sort of the magnetism of the founder already so they may not have a lot
of traction from a revenue perspective or from like a you know customer perspective but the
first way that a founder has to sell is actually not to the investors it's to like who are they
bringing into their inner circle and what do those people say about them I remember actually
I posted something on LinkedIn within the last like few months about would you invest in a six out
of 10 founder and it got a lot of surprisingly mixed responses for me the answer is obviously
not I want to invest in 10 out of 10 founders and there were a lot of people saying like well it's
sort of subject to the interpretation of like who's giving them the rating and what are they
rating them on which is fair enough but for me I was asking that question to someone who is an
advisor of this company so as part of my diligence process I was talking to an advisor and I was
like how would you rate this founder you know based on other founders you work on steam great
and he was like you know like they're a great team promising like I'd give them like a six out of
10 I was like that doesn't feel strong you know this is someone who this company has recruited
to work with them has chosen to work with them and like that's the rating they're giving the
company and it's not speaking to do I think this is a great product or a great market or this
or that it's like does this founder have adaptability do they have the vision do they have the drive
like do they have the intangible qualities that we need to see and I think also I fully acknowledge
that so much startup success is dependent on luck but you cannot predict luck you cannot
screen for luck you cannot invest in luck you can invest in quality and so to give yourself the
best shot of having good luck you have to invest in really good people and you have to see that
the people who they've already surrounded themselves believe in them and they're like this is the
best founder I've ever worked with this is the best founder I've ever backed like if I had money
I would personally invest in like you want to hear those kind of testimonials about someone so
and maybe a little bit hard to convey that in a deck but I would start with listing who is in
that inner circle and saying like please reach out to these people and they will tell you what an
incredible founder I am especially in the early stages where we spend most of our time investing
it really does go back to who is the founding team yeah yeah and do really really really believe
in them yeah built something big yeah what were the reasonings for saying yes to a six out of 10
founder I think people were like you know it's about potential not actual performance to date or
again like someone might have encouraged me harshly for like something that I did but it doesn't
speak to who I am kind of holistically as a founder I think in fairness to people I think they
were misinterpreting like what my criteria were totally yes I'm six out of ten that can mean a lot of
things how are you doing the founder scale yes I'm
And then people are like a 10 out of 10 is like a fake rating.
Like nobody can achieve a perfect score.
No one is perfect.
You get like the drift here.
What are some of your green flags?
And then red flags when you are in diligence with the founder immediately
the red flags are going to come to mind first, right?
A big red flag for me is misrepresentation.
So I think a lot of times companies in particular when they're talking about
like traction or partnerships, they want to lead with, you know,
name brands or things that people have heard of or like things that you can grasp
on to.
So, you know, for example, on a partnership slide, they'll have a couple of
logos that are more aspirational.
Like we could work with these brands in the future or they're in our pipeline,
but we're kind of representing them as like closed.
And they kind of like get a little squishy with that.
And I think if you ask them about it and they sort of clearly state like,
this is potential versus this reality, like maybe we can move forward from
there, but it has happened more times than I can count where,
especially when I'm looking at FinTech stuff because it's a small universe.
I'll see a logo on a page.
Guess what?
We've invested in that other company.
And like I go ask that other company, Hey, I see you're partnered with company
X. Like tell me what you think about them so far.
And they're like, Oh, interesting.
We're not partnered with them.
Like our sales guy had one call with them.
And then I'm like, you're done.
That's tough.
So that's a big red flag.
I would agree.
Like, and I know it is a difficult balance for founders because you do have to
think big.
You have to sell big.
You have to kind of make it to get into the door and get beating.
So I feel like you do need to put your big feet forward.
But there is a fine line.
Yeah.
So I would just say like, be, be transparent about that line.
And what, you know, what the actual status of things is.
I mean, green flag is traction.
Obviously, like, and I think traction is sort of a deliberately vague term,
because it can mean different things for different people.
But for me, especially as an early stage, like investor, for me,
traction doesn't necessarily directly translate to revenue.
But I want to see that you have deeply researched and understood your customer
and that you have connected with them through multiple touch points and
that you have really strong conviction that if given the capital,
this is like how you're going to run with it.
And this is where the kind of customer adoption is going to come from.
I mean, I love investing in companies where they're like, I have a focus group
of, you know, 10 or 20 or 100, whatever.
Like families, moms, potential customers who are giving me feedback on the product,
who are speaking to like what they like about it already in the beta version,
what they don't tin can was a company I invested in pretty early, you know,
they're still in early days, I think, but like they've been quite successful.
That's a fun one.
That founder personally installed the first, like two or three dozen
phones in the customer's homes. He did not have to do that.
That's incredible.
But he was like, I want to get to know who are these people?
Because they were a brand new company.
Like who are the people who are buying this from this unknown company?
It wasn't as cute of a version of a phone as it is today.
It was like literally looked like an old fashioned landline.
That's so funny.
But he's like, you know, who are these families?
How old are their kids?
What are they going to use them for?
What are the problems that they're facing that they're trying to solve by having a
landline versus cell phones or versus whatever?
And I think that deep customer knowledge at the beginning can never be replicated
because he's always going to keep them in mind when he's thinking about like,
how do we grow?
How do we spend?
How do we continue to serve our customer?
And you just have to be focused on who your customer is and what their needs are
versus like getting kind of in this continuous loop about the product.
Yes.
I feel like if you deeply understand your customer, the product,
yes, falls into place.
Yeah.
So going back to your question,
Reenflag, for me, what I mean when I say traction is just like deep traction
with your customer and traction can be revenue, but it can also just be like,
you're building loyalty, you're building distribution.
You know your customer well.
A significant part of your job is actually passing and saying no to founders.
And so curious or founders listening, like if they do get a no from an investor,
very common, how should they think about like keeping that investor updated
in the loop for maybe a potential future round or how should they know?
Like this is always going to be a no.
Maybe I should just not even waste my time with that investor.
I mean, I think one way you can tell is sort of the depth of the no.
Like if it's like this is out of thesis for us, thanks for reaching out.
Probably just take them off your list.
If you had a call with them and they're like, Hey, you know, too early is kind
of a famous, yes, get out of jail card for venture funders.
You do have to read between the lines for a, this is too early.
Like sometimes I say that and I do want to keep it.
I'm guilty of saying it to sometimes I say that and I don't want to keep in touch.
So like I'm not even necessarily kind of being helpful.
We're all to saying that to founders.
But I think you can either ask like, could you be specific about milestones?
You would want us to hit and can we stay in touch in the meantime?
Or like, can you give me any more detail on that?
And if it is a founder that I'd liked and I just didn't have the time in the first
email and they've come back to me, I usually will kind of take the time to give them
more specifics or I'll just not respond to them for a few days.
Like I will respond to them.
But sometimes timing of like how long it takes a fund to get back to you can also be
assigned. Yeah.
So I would say don't pester funds that seem like they're forever knows.
But ones that are maybe knows like I have invested in companies that I was tracking
that I said no to at first.
And then I invested in like a year or two later.
I don't want to give founders false hope because I know that there are a lot of
investors who they don't really track for any use to early as like a blanket.
Yeah, like passable.
So there's not a clear rule here.
You just have to feel it out.
That's the unfortunate part of venture in general.
Like there's no standard does process.
I was joking with someone the other day.
Like I wish there was like a common app for founders to apply to funds because I
would just make the process a lot better.
But it's it's a lot.
Yeah.
But every every VC is a snowflake.
And nobody wants to be treated with a common app.
Exactly.
I would never work.
Yeah.
I would never expect to.
Ego is way too many.
Yes.
Good idea and theory.
But no one would adopt.
So curious to also understand like what was the thinking behind getting into
Android investing?
And when did you decide that was like the right time for you to know?
I think there were a couple of things that coincided.
So I've been at funds now for over a decade.
And I've been really fortunate to work on great teams and to be able to invest
in companies that I do really believe in.
But ultimately, like I'm always pitching things to an investment committee
and needing the approval of like a group of other people.
So there are some great investments that I've wanted to make that have
gotten rejected over time.
And so that's hard.
Hard as part of the job.
Yeah.
And so being an investment committee of one was just like appealing to me
because, you know, the other part of this was like, I became a parent six years
ago.
And as I continued to see some of the stuff that we were struggling with as a family
and as parents and was like, there's got to be founders building to support
families.
And there's got to be stuff going on in this space.
But there's the notorious statistics around lack of funding to female founders.
And so, you know, I wrote my friends and family a manifesto on my
40th birthday and was like, I'm going to invest in more female founders.
Like, even though I've been doing this professionally for a decade,
like I really want to put my personal money where my mouth is, there's,
well, there's a lot less female founders also in Fentac, which is your current focus.
And I was just like, I want to put more capital towards female founders.
I really want to, as I'm thinking about sort of the world I want to leave
behind for my kids and the legacy I want to make, you know, I try to explain
what investing is to my kids and they sort of get it.
But not really.
It's not the most like cleared profession.
But I think over time, when I get to talk to them about the types of companies
I've invested in, like, 10 can.
When in our house, you must have a 10 can.
Yeah, like we, I gave that company money because I believed that this could
be a great product for families.
So being able to just kind of tell those stories to my kids was definitely
part of the motivation.
And then I think from a just like ecosystem sort of perspective,
the barriers to angel investing have really come down over the last five years.
So even though I was someone who had spent my entire career in finance and
much of it in venture capital, I was even still intimidated by angel
investing until fairly recently because it has historically been, you know,
a boys club, large check sizes.
And you're just like, how do people hear about these deals?
Like, where do they access them?
How do they invest in them?
And even I still had a lot of questions because although like we talked about
venture and angel are kind of the same thing at a high level.
The whole like access ecosystem,
finding deals, sourcing deals, also like we look at all types of companies
from the angel perspective.
So I feel like even being able to like trade notes on like, what does a seed
CPG deal look like?
Like looks very different than what you were saying in your day and I.
Yeah.
And preseed seed FENTAC companies.
Yeah.
And so once I decided that I wanted to do more angel investing, my next step
was like, okay, I do need to become more educated.
I need to become more exposed to deals.
So I joined a few groups.
I invested in a number of SPVs led by other people.
And then I also started talking more publicly about what my interest
areas were, what my learnings were, the types of companies I was starting
to invest in.
And then that has really kind of like built on itself.
Because now I have other investors who are also interested in the same
space as saying, Hey, have you looked at this deal?
Or like, could you send me that deal?
And similarly with founders who are saying, you know, I'm building in
this space and I would love to get your perspective.
I'd love to.
to pitch to bridge club or whatever. So I do think again, the title of this episode should be
compounding, right? Like, you know, it kind of all just builds on itself. And so the more I learn
and then the more I share, the more the opportunities are now coming to me versus, I mean, I still seek
them out. Because I think it is, you know, you want to chase the, you want to chase the opportunities
that you're excited about. But I also am seeing a lot more coming to me, which also goes back to your
building and public and yes, just compounding over years of being in venture, which is so
cool and amazing to say. So what has been your big breakout so far and what are you kind of like
learning and taking away from that investment going forward? So we had a couple of companies that
exited from my impact engineers, but I was part of a team. I was kind of more junior at that time
so I don't take like full ownership for them. The one that I'm proud of that has been like a very
recent success story as a company called Fritch, which is part of my true stage discovery fund portfolio.
It was one of the first investments I made when I joined to lead the discovery fund. I think our
first investment was probably 2021 or 2022 in that company started by two Gen Z women. I am a
millennial. So, you know, I recognize what I do and don't know about like different generations.
And I felt like they had a really compelling idea and company that was speaking to an entire
generation about, you know, how do you become financially literate? There's a whole different
comfort level with social media and kind of sharing information by Gen Z. And so their whole
thing was like, let's build a social finance platform where people can ask what have previously
been taboo questions. They can compare data with each other with their peers with other people
at their universities. And to our earlier conversation about traction, when I invested in them,
they didn't, they had zero revenue, like they were pre revenue. But what I loved about
what my version of traction is is that they were going campus to campus at universities and like
building their user base from the ground up by hearing what college students were interested in,
what they felt mystified by when it came to finance and using them to build word of mouth with
each other. So once they would go do a campus activation, they would get so many users because
the first people who signed up would then invite other people to sign up. And I don't know, maybe
I feel like I feel like IRL has made like a big push recently. But 2021-22, this was like
post-COVID. People were still not doing things in person. So that felt differentiated and unique.
And it was enough for me to say like, I really like the team and I like their distribution strategy.
And maybe not every venture investor would say this, but you know, I was like, we'll figure out
the revenue model. Like, we don't really know how this is going to be monetized, but we'll kind of
figure that out down the road. And they ended up figuring it out in the form of partnerships and kind
of paid ads on the platform. And they have gotten such a large and loyal user base. Amazing. Well,
we have a conversation in Bridge Club about this coming up on being an LP and a VC fund. So curious
to hear like a little bit around kind of your decision process of why you became an LP and like,
how people can even like get into an opportunity like that. Yeah, that's another kind of like
next frontier of like question marks, access. How do you do this? I think the thing that is again
intimidating and also probably even more of a factor at least today is check size. Because I
think typically you do have to write a larger check size to get into a fund than you would to make
a direct investment. I have asked this question multiple times and have not found anybody who's
doing it yet is like, is there an SPV for funds? I just had a combo about this.
Is there one? Yes, you can do it. Okay. The total LP base still is capped at the 99 investors.
Okay. So I think you have to be smart about how many people you bring into the SPV and they're
probably still has to be minimums. Yeah, involved in this, but yes. Yeah, it's typically been like
too much of a headache for people to pursue because the administration of a fund is different
than the administration of a like single company cap table. So that's one like real barrier that
does exist. The two funds that I'm in, you know, they both lowered their minimum for me because
I knew the GPs. And so they were like, we're willing to bring strategic value. So we're willing
to take a smaller check. And for me, those were, you know, I wanted to support emerging managers
raising their first time funds. So some of it was just kind of a vote of confidence in the person.
It was also investments that I will likely never make or look at in my fund or in my angel portfolio.
So doing something kind of with a totally different strategy than my strategy. So it gives me
diversification versus what I'm going to do with my direct investments. Can you share which funds?
One is called outside VC, which is Ethan Austin, who's another California guy, the family office.
Yes, he's great. Yeah. So he and I met in Chicago years ago. And he's a previous founder.
Yes, he was a co-founder of a company called Give Forward.
Okay. So she was like donating to people who were raising for medical expenses,
and the other one is called Park Rangers Capital, Erica Wenger. So she is also like master of
maybe a mastermind. Yes. And I feel like I kind of was lucky to meet her as her
star was rising. And she's like blowing up as this whole empire right now. But she invests in
her whole thesis with fund one was like elephant companies. So building really loyal consumer
bases like category defining. But she's investing in stuff that I just have never heard of.
We'll never look at. So I kind of like that's fun when I read those updates because I'm like,
oh, what new crazy company have you invested in now? I mean, it's like, well, we're coming up
on time. So I'm going to go into our rapid buyer set of questions, which are always fun.
What is one piece of investing advice that you swear by? Honestly, for anything non venture,
like for public markets, buy the S&P index and forget it. Like I used to work in wealth management.
I used to be an active manager. Don't waste your time. Don't waste your money. Open a vanguard
account or whatever your platform of choice is by the S&P 500 ETF. And don't look at it for 10,
2015 years. Great. But what has been your hardest lesson in investing? I mean, I think to trust
your gut because it is always there. Like the little voice is always there. And you are always
tempted to override it, either to the positive or to the negative. Like sometimes there's companies
that I feel like I should say no to, but I end up saying yes, or I feel like I should say yes to
what I end up saying no. So I think it has gone in both directions. And I regret it sometimes.
You know, there's always that gut feeling. Yeah. Yeah. Always listen to this. Listen to it.
How do you manage imposter syndrome? I think I acknowledge it. I think there is definitely more of a
movement towards people just being like fully authentically themselves. And so asking the question
that you feel like is a stupid question because it turns out five other people have that same question
or like admitting the mistake that you made that seemed so foolish. And then other people are like,
I did that too. Like wasn't that hilarious? I mean, everybody will still always have it to some
degree. But I think just owning up to what you feel like an imposter about often brings a lot more
like solidarity and empathy from other people than you think you will get. Totally. We can't all have
all of the answers. No. So that's literally impossible. What? Well, then has been the biggest
advocate for you and your career. I mean, I got to give a shout out to my mom. She has just always
been so supportive in everything I do. But from a professional perspective, I would say my boss and
mentor when I was at impact engine Tasha, she had been successful venture capitalist for like 20 years,
kind of transitioned into impact engine because she also as a parent wanted to like leave an
impact on the world for her kids. And she really is the one who shepherded me into venture and taught
me everything I know incredible. And finally, what impact do you want to leave for the next generation
of women? I would say making every woman feel confident that they can invest in the future that
they want to see and that can come in the form of venture capital or not. But like when I say
investing, I mean, putting your time and your effort and your social capital to work on behalf
of what you want to see. It's very cool to be able to find careers where you can do that. Yeah.
So feel very lucky. Yes. Absolutely. Well, amazing. Well, Elizabeth, thank you so much for coming
on to Bridge Club. This was so much fun. I knew you would have incredible insights to share with
everyone. So such a great episode. Where can everyone find you and where can they pitch you?
Well, they can find me in California now. We live on the West Coast. LinkedIn, I'm obviously very
active there. I did also start a newsletter recently. Elizabeth McCluskey dot b hive dot com,
which is primarily geared towards other angel investors, where I'm sharing deal flow and just
these sectors. All right. Thank you, Ruffin. I have to approve you. I know. I know. I was like,
am I going to get here approved? Okay. Yeah. Those are the two places you can find me.
Amazing. Well, thank you so much again. This has been so fun. Thanks, Ruffin.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Venture capital involves pooled capital from institutional investors or corporate funds, while angel investing is typically done by individuals using their own money, often through SPVs to simplify cap table management.
Both venture and angel investing share similar mechanics, but access and check sizes differ—fund investments are often larger and more structured, while angel investing allows for more personal and flexible engagement.
Ruffin's career path from finance to venture capital was driven by a desire to invest in impact, particularly in financial inclusion for underrepresented founders, including women, people of color, and veterans.
Founders should focus on deep customer understanding and team credibility—especially early traction based on real feedback and advisor testimonials—rather than just revenue or flashy metrics.
Misrepresentation of partnerships or traction is a major red flag; transparency about real versus potential is essential in due diligence.
Angel investing has become more accessible due to community-driven networks like Bridge Club, where founders and investors build trust through public engagement and shared learning.
The venture ecosystem is increasingly dominated by mega funds, making it harder for smaller funds and solo GPs to compete, highlighting the importance of diversifying investment strategies.
Founders should avoid AI-generated decks and instead prioritize authenticity, transparency, and strong founder-team signals—especially in early-stage fundraising.
Summary:
Elizabeth McCluskey, a venture and angel investor, explains the distinction between venture capital and angel investing: VC relies on institutional capital from LPs or corporate funds, while angel investing uses personal capital, often through SPVs to streamline cap tables. Despite differences in scale, both approaches involve similar investment mechanics. Her career transitioned from wealth management to venture capital driven by a commitment to impact, especially in financial inclusion for underrepresented founders.
She emphasizes that early-stage success hinges not on luck but on founder quality, team credibility, and deep customer understanding—highlighting advisor testimonials and real-world traction as key signals. Misrepresentation in partnership or traction is a major red flag. She stresses the importance of authenticity in founder decks, warning against AI-generated content that lacks human insight.
Angel investing has become more accessible through networks like Bridge Club, where public engagement builds visibility and trust. She notes that the venture ecosystem is increasingly dominated by mega funds, making smaller, mission-driven funds more valuable. Founders should avoid over-relying on AI and instead focus on transparency, real customer feedback, and strong founder-team signals.
Her own journey reflects a blend of strategic investment, personal values, and community-building—offering a roadmap for founders to navigate fundraising with confidence and authenticity.
FAQs
Venture capital involves professional investors who raise funds from institutional sources like pension funds or family offices, typically investing in larger checks. Angel investing is done by individuals using their own money, often through syndicates or special purpose vehicles (SPVs), and usually targets earlier stages with smaller checks.
A special purpose vehicle (SPV) is a legal entity that allows multiple investors to pool their capital into a single entry on a company’s cap table. This simplifies cap table management, reduces administrative overhead, and makes it easier to manage approvals during corporate transactions.
I prioritize deep customer understanding, strong team dynamics, and real traction—defined as meaningful customer engagement, not just revenue. I also look for founders who are adaptable, driven, and supported by advisors who have a high level of confidence in them.
Businesses with small or uncertain markets, poor unit economics, or lack of scalability aren’t ideal for VC. Some companies may thrive through bootstrapping or debt financing, making venture capital unnecessary or even counterproductive.
I invest in pre-seed and seed-stage fintech companies led by underrepresented founders—such as women, people of color, LGBTQ+ or veterans—focused on improving financial inclusion and helping middle-income Americans achieve better financial health.
Founders should build in public on platforms like LinkedIn, share their journey honestly, and regularly update their network. This increases visibility and helps attract investors who may know someone in the founder’s network.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.