Which RBs To Target and Which RBs To Fade This Season (Episode 1011 with Evan Silva, Adam Levitan, John Daigle)
76m 15s
The podcast episode focuses on running back strategy for fantasy football drafts, emphasizing the position's renewed importance. The hosts (Adam Levitan, Evan Silva, and John Daigle) analyze early-round picks, noting Gibbs and Bijan as top choices, with debate over pick five between McCaffrey, Taylor, and top receivers. McCaffrey's efficiency decline and age are concerns, but his receiving prowess keeps him viable; Taylor offers higher upside due to a better offensive line and youth. ADP outliers like Chase Brown and Kenneth Walker are favored, while Devon H&N is faded due to quarterback changes. In the second round, injuries to Breece Hall and Jeremiah Love create uncertainty, with Javonte Williams favored for his touchdown potential in a strong Cowboys offense. The "dead zone" concept remains relevant, with David Montgomery as a prime example; fades include Kyren Williams and Bucky Irving, while Travis ETN and Andre Swift are targets. Later-round sleepers include Tank Bigsby, Keaton Mitchell, and Jonah Coleman. Handcuffing strategies are discussed, emphasizing direct backups like Ray Davis and Emmett Johnson for injury insurance. Overall, the hosts stress the importance of running back depth and adapting to ADP shifts, with a focus on explosive runners and receiving backs in favorable offensive environments.
(upbeat music)
Hello and welcome to episode 1,011 of The Official,
established the run.com podcast.
My name is Adam Levitan, joined by Evan Silva
and John Dagle and NFL Offences continue to evolve
back to the run.
The running back position continues to evolve as a whole
and running back remains the most important part
of fantasy football.
Evan, how's it going today?
- It's going well.
Probably my favorite position to watch in the NFL
is running back and as you mentioned,
the importance of the running game has made
at least a little bit of a return.
So it'll be fun to break it all down today.
- Indeed, Dagle, how's it going?
- Doing well, the time of the year,
where everyone tunes into establish the run,
there's always rankings and tears changes going on.
So we can feel the season getting much closer.
- Indeed.
On today's show, we are going to be talking
all things running back.
Had to handle the early rounds,
player takes, targets, busts, sleepers,
handcuffing and more.
If you have a fantasy draft coming up
and I know you do, we can help.
I promise no one dedicates more time
and frankly, money to ensuring that we have
the most up-to-date and best rankings
that you can bring to your draft.
Our draft kit pro is only $55,
includes Silva's Top 150 and Tears,
all our ETR rankings, my draft strategy,
my player-by-player notes,
Thormin's rankings in season,
tons, tons more.
And if you're really serious about the fantasy football,
you need the bundle.
Combines draft kit pro
without our in-season product, AKR projections,
Silva's matchups, Thor and offensive line,
defensive line matchup, tons of premium shows,
including Man vs. Machine in season,
tons more details on both of those products,
draft kit pro and the bundle are available
at establishedarun.com.
All right.
Let's get into it here.
I want to start by talking about some
of the early rounds stuff around running back.
So clearly, the NFL has changed.
Passing rate is down.
Passing yards are down.
Yards per target is down.
At the same time, starting running backs
have sustained health at a really high rate
over the last two seasons,
leading to running backs being,
and you may combine all that
and running backs have been overwhelmingly
the best fantasy plays on average.
Now the ADP has shifted a little bit.
We now have, I expect 12 running backs
to go off the board in the first 20 picks.
So that kind of sets the stage here
for the early rounds.
I think all of us have Gibbs and Bijan.
I know me and Silva both, Gibbs won, Bijan too.
Dagel DC, any merit to taking wide receiver over Bijan
there at the top, I think we're all in agreement
that Gibbs is our number one player.
Especially since we're talking about home league formats,
and as we move along this episode,
we'll talk about the players that we've lost confidence in
that you can draft on the comeback.
So Gibbs, Bijan firmly entrenched as one and two overall.
- Okay, yeah, and as we talk here today,
we are referring to the standard half PPR 12 team
redraft formats that I know is the most common format
out there for people.
I think the question that people have, Silva,
is Gibbs, Bijan, Chase, Puka, everybody feels good about.
When they get to pick five, people can make a case.
Well, Jackson Smith and Jigba lost Kling Kubiak.
Should we need running back?
Should we be looking at a Christian McCaffrey
or Jonathan Taylor at pick five?
Or some people have a Monroe over JSN straight up.
So anyway, Silva, when it gets to you at pick five,
what's on your mind?
Especially when it comes to the running back position.
It's wide receiver, it's a man raw for me as well.
I actually have Puka down here as well,
just due to the, at least mild suspension risk
that Adam Schaefter has brought about.
But I mean, the running backs here
that you're looking at right in this range would be
Christian McCaffrey, Jonathan Taylor,
maybe James Cook, Kenneth Walker for me.
The thing with Christian McCaffrey
is that he's 30 years old, he's coming off a career high
and carries and touches, he's already experienced
some tightness in training camp.
We don't even know if that's real.
There have been some rumors that that might be contract related.
I'm not worried about the injury.
I am a little bit worried that he, you know,
he continues to get more advanced in age
and all this, all this wear on his tires at the NFL.
He said a ton of touches at the NFL level.
Yet a ton of touches at the college level as well.
And then Jonathan Taylor, we saw how awesome he could be
when that offense was humming last year
and weeks one through a little bit after mid season.
The Colts had the best offense statistically in the NFL.
And Jonathan Taylor was absolutely killing it.
Now Daniel Jones coming off of the torn Achilles,
you know, he had the broken leg last year.
Is that going to affect the overall output of the offense?
I think that those guys McCaffrey and Taylor
at the top of this tier be long behind
Aman Ra, Jackson Smith and Jayba and Puka.
Yeah, and that's how silver has it in his top 150.
I'm more open to running back here at pick five
if you wanted to, Dagle, Christian McCaffrey or JT.
I'll get to my takes on them there in a second,
but Dagle, I assume you have the top four.
The way I described earlier,
what do you think about pick five running back
versus wide receiver?
It's to your point as you mentioned at the top of the show
because of the health of running backs the last two years.
The top 12 finishers and points per game
have all come within the first three rounds
besides Javante Williams,
who was an eighth round pick last year.
Thus ADP has been accurate.
So I want to insulate these top 12 guys
and feel confident in drafting them
on a wide open board from 105 on.
I have the same concerns that Silva does
with Christian McCaffrey coming off
the 10th most touches of the 21st century.
And there has been 24 situations
of a running back reaching 370 touches
since to Marco Marie did so in 2014.
And only four times, a 16 and a half percent outcome
did that player improve their points for game,
the following year.
McCaffrey's also had an efficiency dip quietly
for three consecutive seasons.
So I am Marie, but I also understand
the overall structure of drafting.
So whoever you want to jam up here,
McCaffrey included, please feel free to do so
since when we're looking one, two steps ahead,
I don't want to get too ahead here
'cause we will talk about these individual players
in the second round.
We are going to discuss a massive tear drop off
after Derek can reindivine HN
who may be come back to that 5th, 6th spot
in the second round.
So I just want to be ahead of running back in this spot.
- Yeah, okay, and agreed.
I think I just want to double quick
on Christian McCaffrey here for a second.
The point that Dago brought up
that is the biggest concern to me
is not how many touches he's had,
not that he's likely to get hurt.
It's that the efficiency has been in decline.
And at some point, it's going to get to a point
where if you're averaging 3.8 yards per carry,
it's hard to be the number one player in fantasy.
Now you can make up for that by catching 90 balls,
100 balls in a season like Christian McCaffrey does.
So I think that despite the efficiency concerns,
if Christian McCaffrey plays 16, 17 games,
there is very few guys going here
that I'm more confident will finish
among the top three fantasy players this season.
And that's why I am willing to take Christian McCaffrey
at pick five or pick six.
Is he a favorite to get hurt?
Yes, but I would consider every running back
that we project for 300 plus touches this season
a favorite to get hurt.
The outlier, the unexpected, the surprise
is sustaining health the previous year.
And that's why you see all these guys
who have tons of touches the year before.
That's the surprise, that's the outlier.
That's why they get hurt the next year
because that's just the standard and the expectation.
So I think that all these guys
who are we project for 300, 350 touches
are favorites to get hurt.
I think McCaffrey is so confident he will finish
among the top three fantasy players of his stays healthy.
And so I still need to take him there at five.
I wanted to ask about Jonathan Taylor again here, Evan.
I know you mentioned my take on JT is the past game
volume was so much better last year called 46 passes.
They do not have much behind them.
I think Seth McGowan's gonna end up winning the back up job.
I mean, they're gonna be hard pressed to take JT off the field
including in passing situations.
So I feel really good about that.
The bigger concern I have on JT
and the reason I'd have CMC just a hair ahead of JT
is just he's dependent on the Colts winning.
Like, it does not go well for JT
when they fall behind in games.
That's like the only hole that I can really poke in him.
And I would be fine taking him at six overall
or seven overall.
So Evan has JT here at eight overall.
Evan any final thoughts here on JT before he move on?
- Well, if we were just to compare Christian McCaffrey
and Jonathan Taylor entering this season
and just talk about who could maybe have a better season
than they did last year.
I think that Jonathan Taylor could maybe
have a better season than he did last year.
Although it's not, you know, maybe the floor is in this high
last year just because of the overall the returning pieces.
on offense, specifically at quarterback.
It's not gonna get better for Christian McCaffrey
than what happened last year
because of how much usage he was able to handle
and how healthy that he stayed.
But with Jonathan Taylor, there are situations
where he can be better.
The cults return one of the better offensive lines
in the league, way better offensive line
in San Francisco, by the way.
If Daniel Jones does return to a high level play as a passer,
he's not moving as much.
In the pocket, more dumbtons.
I think Jonathan Taylor could catch more passes this year
than he did last season.
Also, he's considerably younger than Christian McCaffrey.
So if we were just to compare those two
and talk about who's gonna have a better season,
I think the Taylor actually maybe has the higher ceiling,
at least relative to what they did last season.
I don't think McCaffrey's gonna,
McCaffrey's really gonna struggle what he did
to repeat what he did last season.
- Yeah, and clearly, you know,
McCaffrey's better in full PPR than half PPR.
I think that should go without saying.
Okay, Daniel, I want to talk about some of these
homelieg ADP outliers.
People know I've been doing a ton of the bestball stuff.
There is some pretty big discrepancies here,
even at the top between homelieg ADP and bestball.
The one that I want to start with is Derek Henry,
who is going 10th overall in homelieg ADP.
We're actually for the first time,
like ahead of the bestball market
in on the big dog, Derek Henry,
they go, "What do you think about him at 10th overall?"
- We're just expecting an entirely different offense
under Declan Doyle, and I think the emergence
of both Matthew Hibner and Jacobi Lane the preseason,
even highlights that the Ravens are going to be
something different than they've ever been
with Lamar Jackson, which we're naturally then hoping
leads to more light boxes,
and just an easier time in life for Derek Henry.
So again, I believe he is in this next tier of running backs,
but also this next tier of running backs is very large.
So you can nitpick, you can choose between all of them.
Derek Henry, I believe, is completely fine.
- Derek Henry will be 33 years old in January.
At some point, he's not going to be able to do this.
I have not seen any signs that this will be the year
that he's not able to do this, you know?
So, especially in half PPR formats, just feels really safe
that he's going to be among the league leaders
in touchdowns here.
Another outlier kind of at ADP at the top here,
Evan is Chase Brown.
Chase Brown, Home League, ADP is 22 overall.
Silver is up at 12 overall.
Now there's different ADP sources here.
Some of them have Chase Brown going a little bit higher.
We talked about this a little bit on the news show,
Evan, but is Chase Brown a target for you
in this kind of setup in round two?
- Absolutely, I mean, the Bengals are,
so I think that there is, the general consensus
that the Bengals are going to be at least a little bit
better on defense this year.
Certainly more competent, I think.
We have Brandon Thorn ranking, the Bengals offensive line,
very much middle of the pack,
and also highlighting the fact that they might have depth
on the offensive line, the potential to withstand
some injuries up front.
Those are not characteristics that we've talked about
regarding the Bengals offensive line in the years.
We had the fact that T Higgins and Jamar Chase
are obviously at the top of the passing game,
totem pole in Cincinnati.
And there's just not a whole lot else.
The Bengals have done very little to address
their third receiver, very little to address
their tight end position.
That almost makes Chase Brown the de facto
third receiver for the Bengals.
He had 69 receptions last season.
And we saw that he was really disappointing
early in the season, based almost entirely
on the poor quarterback play with Jake Browning
under center.
The Bengals finally moved away from that.
They brought in Joe Flacco and Chase Brown
are immediately resumed killing.
And obviously he's going to crush
with Joe Burrow back healthy.
I mean, he's a really, really easy click.
I think he absolutely belongs at that one-two turn
and no later.
Yeah.
The big thing for me on Chase Brown is Joe Burrow
is such a good thrower of the football
to the running back position.
And so, you know, he runs going to play.
It's going to be annoying.
But Chase Brown is going to be a pass catcher
and a touchdown scorer here.
For this team, I agree.
I like him there.
As well, the genty conversation,
Dagle is one that is tough at the top.
He goes around the one-two turn in basketball.
I've seen him much later in Home League ADP.
Perhaps people are a bit spooked off of last year.
Dagle, where does genty fit into your running back strategy
here in the early rounds?
I also like him around Kenneth Walker, Chase Brown,
which, as you mentioned, ADP doesn't reflect.
But we do have some natural regression
and just play calling Denver says coming for the Raiders.
Clint Kubiak now, who just steered Sam Darnold
into career high and yards per tent.
The Raiders go out and get 25-year-old Tyler Linderbaum
to start at center, who is PFF's fourth highest
and graded run blocking center just last year.
And last season, the Raiders quietly scored 80%
of their touchdowns through the air.
We've seen that happen 12 times only in the last decade.
None of those 12 teams were able to replicate
that mark the following season.
So that led me down a rabbit hole to think,
well, maybe we've had some breakout running backs
from those teams that actually did score
a lot of passing touchdowns the year prior.
And there was a lot of meandering in the results.
Just a lot of RB 16s who finishes RB 24 and vice versa,
which doesn't mean anything at all.
But the hits were actually massive,
including Orleans Darkwaw, who had undrafted
and finished football in 2017.
He finishes the RB 40 in points per game.
And James Robinson, we all remember in 2020,
who finishes the RB 7 in points per game.
So I just think that's a situation
for Ash and Gentie to capitalize on.
And ADP doesn't reflect that as a mid-early second-round pick.
When his range of outcomes,
includes outscoring Christian McCaffrey.
- Yeah.
- Orleans Darkwaw.
Now, there is a hell of a pull.
I mean-- - He brought me up the show.
This is how you get-- - I had forgotten that name.
A hundred percent a race from my mind.
- Okay, I'm fine with Gentie too.
There are running backs.
I prefer ahead of them.
And I think Silva does as well.
The first one up here, which I don't know if it's an IKB
or not, but I prefer Kenneth Walker.
I just did the--
explaining the default rankings for ESPN.
And ESPN's default rank on Kenneth Walker
is 21st overall.
So I'm not saying you have to reach up into the round one
or end of round one to get him.
But I think Silva and I are in the same page
that I would take Kenneth Walker over
Ash and Gentie now if Force just straight up ADP
aside, do you agree with that?
Have any more thoughts on Kenneth Walker?
- I would take Kenneth Walker over Ash and Gentie
beyond any shadow of a doubt.
And I think that Kenneth Walker actually really belongs
in that tier along with McCaffrey and Jonathan Taylor
who we already discussed.
Go ahead.
- For the first time that she's finally have a running back
that can answer whenever teams instead
drop back to defend Patrick Mahomes.
Like Isaiah Pacheco last year faced the league's lowest rate
of stacked boxes and yet his longest run was 16 yards.
Like now we have freaking Kenneth Walker
whenever teams want to defend solely Patrick Mahomes.
It's just a match made in heaven.
And I know a lot of people zoom out
and just say, well, Kenneth Walker couldn't play
on passing down the Seattle, that's the concern.
But you know the bets for season long
whenever you only have to beat 9/11 of your friends.
Like and Kenneth Walker is a bet you make in this range.
So many explosive run play opportunities
are coming for Kenneth Walker.
And what is the strength of Kenneth Walker's game?
Explosive runs.
Add to that the fact that we have the cheese
with the top 10 offensive line this year.
And I mean, it's exactly what's a match made in heaven.
- Yeah.
Just because Kenneth Walker might not play on third and 10
does not mean that he can't catch 50 balls this season.
We have seen Andy Reid, Eric B. Enemy,
scheme tons of screens to guys on early downs,
check downs, et cetera, as they played safety's deep.
So I think 300 plus touches is a borderline lock
for Kenneth Walker here in one of the best setups
that he could have.
And all the run game stats from the chiefs are so broken
because their running backs have been the corpse
of Kareem Hunt.
And I say a patch echo who like is barely an NFL player.
So yes, that's like my biggest IKB there in round one
is Kenneth Walker over a bunch of those guys
at the back there, at the back of round one there.
Okay.
One more ADP outlier here, Dago.
Devon H&N is going 13 overall, roughly on ESPN.
He's listed at 10th overall in the applet.
I was so happy to see that because I didn't wanna
like get on the clock at pick 19 or pick 20
and be like, gosh, H&N's here.
Do I really wanna bet my entire home league season
in round two here on H&N in this setup?
So it strikes me as a really good thing, Dago,
but any more thoughts on Devon H&N
and where he goes in home leagues.
- Everyone knows who Devon H&N is.
The second and third highest target share in the league,
but we're also now adding an entirely different quarterback,
play collar and really offensive system for H&N.
He's the kind of player who will have usable
are B1 scores this year because
that explosive, but are they as consistent, even our projections have their doubts.
So he's really a player where at ADP, I'm fine, taken, assuming he falls.
For instance, if everyone wants to go back in the feed, we did that 12 team ETR staff
mock and he felt a 208 totally acceptable there.
Again, there's a tear break after H and if he goes that late.
But at the first second round turn, there are just other bets.
I think we all want to make.
And that includes Chase Brown who's really Christian McCaffrey light when he talk about
catching the ball consistently.
You just mentioned Kenneth Walker, Ashton Jinti, and we haven't even touched on Sequan
Barkley.
So those are just bets I would rather make the net chain, but I understand when people
want to take them or have to take them.
Yeah.
And you know, if he gets there and I'm at like pick 21, 22 and HN is there, I think it's,
I wouldn't be like excited about it, but it's a really tough pass because of what Dago
said about the tear drop there at running back.
Go ahead, Silver.
Running backs that are really reliant on catching the football, playing with quarterbacks that
are run first by nature, it's swimming upstream to expect Devon HN to have to try to have
the kind of receiving production with Malik Willis that he did with Tuo Tungo Viloa.
Yeah.
And I'd also took a special kind of play call or in Mike McDaniel and outside the box
thinker to give Devon HN 300 plus touches last year.
I mean, there are not many coaches in the NFL that would give a dude who is 188 pounds
that much work.
So we'll see if Jeff Hathley will be willing to do that, you know, that's TBD.
But I certainly think that Devon HN is at a risk of a dramatic reduction in receptions
this year because of the nature of the quarterback.
Yeah.
Well, I mean, this Boomer Hathley's already talking about how many times we run the ball
in a game.
I mean, buddy, you do not have the roster to get off 40 runs in a game.
Of course, they're going to try that.
They're going to be down 28 to 6.
And then it's like, well, now what, what do we do?
And it's like, it's just hard to see it going well.
That's another thing is that truly, I mean, the Dolphin's coaching staff and with Bobby
Slowick at Offensive Court, I mean, we've seen his act before.
These guys might just be Dolts.
Yeah.
Yeah, it's crazy like HN's basketball ADP is closer to 19.
And I hardly have any of them there, let alone at this 13 overall ADP in homelies.
Evan, you mentioned Sequon Barkley.
I just wanted to ask about him before he moved on here at the top, Evans at 15 overall on
Sequon.
I think that's roughly in line with where he goes.
I've kind of gone back and forth on this one.
Any thoughts for the people on Sequon, Evan?
Age, massive workload.
The potential rise of Tank Bigsby, who I know that you're on at them.
The Eagles have a really, really talented offensive line.
But man, it feels like it's hanging by a thread.
Lane Johnson, you know, Landon Dickerson, I mean, these guys are, these guys are, you know,
they're being held together with like masking tape.
I feel like physically and the Eagles lost their offensive.
They're great renowned offensive line coach, Jeff Stoutland.
The age really at the end of the day for Sequon Barkley and the receptions.
Again, this is a running back who is an excellent receiver, but does is not funnel the ball heavily
voluminously in the passing game because of the nature of the playing style of his quarterback.
And all those factors sort of have me down on Sequon Barkley relative to ADP.
Yeah.
It's really how much could you want to blame Petulo because I do think Sequon is a really
good receiver, right?
And like we've seen some of these minions that the offense that I expect, minion to put
in more play action, more under center, get the ball to running back in the passing game
more.
That was kind of like a leap of faith.
The concern for me, Diego, was just the efficiency on Barkley last year.
You can blame your offensive line, you can blame it on Petulo.
The bottom line is 4.1 yards per carry in a season for Sequon Barkley and not very many
explosive runs whatsoever was concerning, Diego, where you are on Sequon.
It does go back to Petulo in the offensive line.
I think the best reference point is that Sequon led the league and yards before contact
per carry in 2024.
Last year Lane Johnson was banged up and the Eagles fell all the way to 23rd and that stat,
which is an offensive line stat.
And for me, I just look and see a moving stock price that I want to buy low on, considering
everyone previously, just last year, one of them is the overall RB1.
And now here he is in the second round after finishing as the RB15 and points per game.
Not only that, but the Eagles dropped back from under center with Petulo last year at
the league's third lowest rate.
Their first play out of camp was 12 personnel under center tossed his way to Sequon Barkley.
I think we're going to get just an entirely different offense than we've ever seen from
the Eagles and Jalen Hertz and I'm really excited about it.
So Sequon Barkley is a player that I'm very high on at that first second round turn.
But again, I speak in tears, so if someone wants Chase Brown or that over him, I completely
get it.
Yeah.
Very close between those guys at the top agreed.
Yeah, I certainly don't have a Sequon fade on.
I'm just going to like in line with market.
I think he goes roughly in the right spot does Sequon.
Okay, Dagle, I think for a lot of people, it's somewhat easy in round two.
If you get a later half pick, right?
You have that huge tier of running back.
We're likely taking one of those whoever our favorite is Walker or Chase Brown or Barkley
or Gentier or Henry or whatever you want to do.
The tougher spot, I think, Dagle is if you get the first overall pick or the second overall
pick or the third overall pick and all of these running backs are gone when it gets
back to you.
Are you willing to pull up a Breeze Hall or Kyron Williams or Jeremiah Love to the back
half year around two say pick 24, 23, 22, 21?
Are you willing to bring those guys up there, Dagle, Breeze, Kyron, Jeremiah Love?
I have not been to this point personally, but there are some exceptions.
Very quickly, I mentioned the ADP for the top 12 guys being accurate due to health.
So we're the hits later on have come to replace this next group of running backs has been
this situation entirely.
The RB 13 through 24 on points per game.
So a guy you start every single week is your RB two.
The past two years has averaged a sixth round ADP.
So we are looking at these individuals and saying, well, who were the ones that naturally
then would break out and be worth taking since they've historically been misses?
And that previously for me was Jeremiah Love and Breeze Hall.
The issue now is that the receivers are going the opposite way and that we're as Hall
and Love are now battling ankle injuries from the preseason.
We have risers, for instance, like Chris Olave, who is now getting a better situation
with Jordan Tyson missing six to eight weeks.
So it's kind of gone opposite for me in that I'm still targeting wide receivers, Brock
Bowers heavily in this range. And this is a, this is a situation where I'm avoiding the
running backs here.
And if I don't, then it's those archetype of receiving backs.
I'm targeting.
Yeah.
You know, like the historical stuff is tough for me just because I think like the way that
Breeze Hall and Jeremiah Love score points is just like they can actually finish as a
top five fantasy running back because they're so explosive catching the football and they
can make such huge plays.
It's like, it's the guys that were going in round two, round three historically that don't
have that profile that are more just like grinder types.
Those guys don't really go round two or round three anymore.
So I'm open to it.
Evan has Breeze Hall 24 overall, Jeremiah Love 27 overall and Evan actually has Javante
Williams.
I actually didn't cross my mind for this spot.
But Evan does have Javante Williams here at 23 overall.
So Evan, back end of round two.
What do you think about these guys here, Breeze, Jeremiah Love and you have Javante above
them also?
Yeah, I mean, the reason that I have Javante slightly above Breeze Hall and Jeremiah Love
as well.
Number one, Javante Williams is healthy.
But number two, because of the offensive environment, I think that when you get into like, we're
talking about like secondary tears behind the truly elite talents at running back, I think
you could say Jeremiah Love is an elite talent, but isn't played in the NFL yet either.
You know, let's let's bank on the offensive environment as the Cowboys going to score way
more touchdown.
The Cowboys could score as many touchdowns as the Cardinals and the Jets combined.
I mean, literally this season, you know, much better offensive line situation.
Javante Williams is not as talented.
I don't think one for one as either Breeze Hall or Jeremiah Love, but the offensive environment
is just so, so, so much better.
And that's what I'm banking on here between these guys.
Breeze Hall, I'm not as worried about his injury right now.
I know this is not really an injury analysis show, but I'm not worried about him.
It's like what a one and a half week to two week groin injury and we're doing this three
plus weeks away from week one.
Not worry about Jeremiah Love.
I'm kind of worried about that with the high ankle sprain.
There's been no commitment that he's going to be ready for week one.
And those are injuries that are very prone to aggravation and also to just sapping the
effectiveness of a guy who may struggle to find alleys in the running game because of
the offensive offensive line situation in front of them that also deteriorated when the
The colonel's lost their projected starting right guard number one.
34 overall pick in the draft, Chase Passantes.
- Yeah, agree on the injury stuff.
Breeze Hall sounds like it's gonna be back
in a couple of weeks, maybe two to three weeks
from this growing thing.
Clicking a rookie running back
with a high ankle sprain in round two
is gonna be a tough click for me.
And that sucks 'cause I really like Jeremy I love.
I thought he was probably a good deal,
but it's really gonna depend on ADP.
Like would I take Jeremy I love in the back half
of round three, definitely.
Like I think you're accounting for enough risk there.
So if he slips to 30, 34,
but right now, you know, I'm still seeing
Jeremy I love ADP up here round 27 overall.
The guy in this tier day, go,
and I know he's not in this tier for Silva,
but the guy in this tier ADP-wise
is Kyron Williams that we did not hit on.
The Rams are expected to be, I mean, everybody had not just me,
but I think they're the most talented team
in the league on paper.
They're gonna score an astronomical amount of points
from a projection standpoint.
When you factor all that in,
it's really hard not to get there on Kyron,
even if you give, like we're still giving Blake Korum,
a lot of work and projections.
And Kyron still comes out as a reasonable pick here,
round two, round three, turn, early round three.
So, Dago, what do you think about Kyron here
as part of a running back?
Have you build at the outset?
- And we know Sean McPhase backfield historically
does not get targets whatsoever,
basically finishing bottom two
and every season since he's coached there.
I am out on Kyron Williams personally at the cost.
Last year before the buy,
he handled 74% of the team's backfield touches.
And then in 13 games post buy,
dropped all the way down to 60%
because Blake Korum is a very good player
who finished second only to Devon H-Anne
and their rate of 10-yard carries.
It's similar to my argument against Javonte Williams too,
Sylvan, I've talked about this off the recording as well
to where we just differ on it.
Last year, 59 running backs ran 100 routes.
Javonte Williams finished 57th and Yars Per Outrun among them.
I agree both the Williams, the Williams tier.
This is when I usually check out mentally in the drafts.
They have high floors,
but I don't think I'm chasing higher floors at these cost
when you don't carry receiving profile with you personally.
So, Kyron and Javonte are two guys.
I'm really underweight on.
- Well, that was kind of my point about
are you capable of finishing as a top five running back?
Can I take you in round two or in round three
if you're not going to catch a ton of passes?
You're not that good in the receiving game
and you're not going to break really long runs.
That's why I thought Jeremiah Loves profile,
Breeze Hall's profile was better for taking in this range here.
- So, I think that Javonte Williams can finish
as a top five running back
because of the touchdown upside.
And also, he's not a good receiver.
I mean, as you mentioned,
but Javonte Williams has caught a lot of passes in the NFL.
He's played five seasons in the NFL.
He had a 43 catch season, 47 catch season, 52.
Last year, only 35.
But the Cowboys did nothing to upgrade
the running back position in the off season.
They didn't draft the running back
and they also did not sign one in free agency.
I know we've heard some buzz on Jaden Blue
and I think he's a very intriguing late round pick this year.
You know, absolutely like I draft Jaden Blue.
But not because I think that he's necessarily a threat
to cut heavily into Javonte Williams work.
The touchdown upside with Javonte Williams,
you know, I think he's got a chance to compete
for the league lead in rushing TDs.
You know, in a very friendly offensive environment
behind a really good offensive line,
the Cowboys gave him a bunch of money.
That was the second move,
the second transaction of the Cowboys off season
was to lock up Javonte Williams.
That's what I'm banking on.
- The point that no one is making also.
So I'm gonna sell your point on Javonte Williams too.
Who again, I don't personally take
but also high floor.
Don't think he's a terrible pick.
Is that the Cowboys defense is going to be better.
That is the one point everyone keeps saying.
So we're going to get different game scripts.
Will they run their offence
through their elite passing talent most likely?
But also just adding Caleb Downs
and key pieces in free agency,
bringing over an intuitive play call
or like Christian Parker to replace Eber Fluce.
Like it's going to be league average
if not slightly better,
which is an entirely different case than last year.
So there will be great situation for Javonte Williams.
Who if he outscores DeBon A. Chan or Derek Henry even,
I don't think it'd be shocking.
- Okay.
We're doing a draft strategy show later this week.
I don't want to get into strategy here really,
but running back, running back starts,
even running back, running back, running back starts
are certainly viable depending on where you pick
and how the ADP goes.
But again, stay tuned for the draft strategy show
for more on that.
I want to go the middle round of running backs now here.
And you know, people who have been in the fantasy streets
for a while understand this whole concept
of the dead zone at running back.
And we've done a bunch of articles and content
and shows over the last few years
under kind of the same theory,
which is is there even a dead zone anymore
because fantasy drafters have gotten so much sharper.
And by the way, I define a dead zone running back
as a profile that isn't exciting.
Not a pass catcher, not an explosive runner,
not a really talented guy.
But he's just, he's going to get all the volume.
So he ends up in the dead zone.
And you know, like poster example of that
is like what happened with Alexander Madison
or Mike Davis or guys that just like,
we're not good at football for any reason,
but we're going between rounds three and round six
because we projected them.
There was no one else to give touches to,
basically the bottom line.
The only guy in here, Dago,
in these that goes in these middle rounds
that actually think fits the bill.
And he doesn't really fully fit the bill
as a guy know your own.
That's why I want to bring it up.
And that's David Montgomery
because I don't see David Montgomery as an explosive player.
I think he's actually a decent pass catcher.
And that's why maybe he doesn't even fit here
as a dead zone back.
But the reason people are excited about David Montgomery
is not because the offensive line, not because the offense,
not because he's an explosive.
It's literally because he's going to get 350 touches.
And I actually don't disagree.
He probably will get 300 to 350 touches.
That's the only argument that I can make
really for a dead zone back through here, Dago.
So do you think he is?
And there's anyone else in the mid range there
that you think might be a dead zone candidate?
- So unfortunately, the risers in this tier
that I thought we had in Cam Skataboo
who was ninth in target share in 12th and Yard's Per Outrun
until he was injured last year.
We lost, in my opinion, with the nausea hair as signing
and just the overall vibes coming out of preseason.
Also, Quinshaw and Jutkins,
I still think as a fine pick
was targeting on 23% of his routes
when he was activated in a week two last year.
But we can also poke holes there
giving the injuries coming back from.
And the last four players to return from that Febila fracture,
they averaged six and a half fewer points
for game the following year
as less explosive, less efficient players.
So that's how you nitpick the potential risers.
So there are a few guys that stand out.
Dave Montgomery is certainly one of them,
especially when he plays those slowest
Bill's linebackers in week one.
But beyond that,
quietly he was targeting on a higher rate of his routes
than the guys that I've heard argued for in the tier before.
Cavern Williams, Javonte Williams.
To me, Dave Montgomery is the same bit as Javonte Williams,
just a couple rounds later.
And so that's why I like these kinds of players
who I think think can emerge a couple rounds ahead
and be hits at their ADP.
- Yeah, I mean, the offensive environment is gonna be different
and the offensive line play is gonna be different
for Dave Montgomery versus Javonte.
But Evan, do you have a Dave and Montgomery take here
for the people?
- I think you guys have summed it up pretty good.
I just wanted to pause for a second,
take a time to acknowledge the sweet soliloquies
coming from John Daigle on today's show
who, I mean, you must think that I must have cleaned up
on man versus a machine with all the anti-Cavern Williams
and anti-cam scottaboo stuff.
I want to appreciate, Daigle, do you want to be friends?
Do you want to come live with me for a little while?
- I don't think I'm over the last time we did that yet.
I still, I'm still scarred mentally.
- Okay, this range, and this is why I argued,
and Daigle's point is well taken.
If you like these guys through here,
you can get them a couple rounds later.
The reason I argued more for running back heavy starts
is 'cause I don't feel great, Evan,
about where these guys go.
Juggins goes 39 on ESPN.
Cam scottaboo goes 40.
Baschel Tutten goes 41.
That is ahead of flowers.
Ivan T. Higgins, Lad McConkey, Jamo Waddle, Birdon.
So for me, like, I want to be taking wider seaver
through that range.
Guy that Daigle just mentioned,
we haven't spent a lot of time on Evan's Quinchon Juggins.
Quinchon Juggins coming off of a severe injury.
Team is expected to be bad,
and like the biggest argument against Juggins
is a two down running back on a bad team.
Monkin seems to be pretty excited about him.
Though, have any thoughts on Juggins here in the mid range?
Yeah, I think he's good.
I think that Quinchon Juggins is a dead zone back, though,
to me.
I mean, maybe a pretty classic example of one.
And I do think that he's good.
I really liked what he showed as a rookie
in a really bad situation last year.
But, you know, some of the Twitter doctors,
you know, and you could take them or leave them.
Some of the Twitter docs say that the injury
that he suffered was actually worse
that the one that still has us worried about CAMS Academy.
They were sort of similar in nature.
But some people say that the Quinchon Juggins injury was worse.
Now, we haven't heard anything negative
about Quinchon Juggins health through training camp.
So I feel okay about his health right now.
But man, this is another really, really rough situation
with a revolving door at quarterbacks, you know,
a question.
shinable at best offensive line, a team that is not built to score very much, and a new coach.
I mean, look, we all love Todd Monkin. We love Todd Monkin. But even, you know, can Todd Monkin
even do anything with the pieces that the Browns have on offense? It's just, it's a really,
really tough sell. You know, add to that the fact that Quinchon Judkins has a very limited
receiving background. And it's not a fun click whatsoever. Quinchon Judkins in 2026.
Yeah. I mean, he goes 45th overall in the homely gate EP that we're pulling in. I haven't
met 60. Yeah. ETR ranks are at 56 here on Mr. Judkins. I wanted to hit on the Tutan stuff
through this range, Dagle, because I was shocked. Like, when we first started this a few months ago,
I was like, man, Tutan's going to go in the fifth round in Best Ball for sure. Like, he has the
exact profile. But in homelys, I thought that maybe we could sneak Tutan past some people and get
him in round seven or around eight. The normies, not even people that listen to the show, nobody
not on fantasy Twitter. I'm saying like normal homelys people are in on Tutan. He is still going
in the 50s in homely gate EP, which surprises me a little bit. I struggle with this with the
Tutan stuff, Dagle, where you at in homelys on Tutan. At Best Ball, it's easier to nitpick and say
Chris Rodriguez will be a hamper to his ceiling, but still in this range against again 9 or 11 other
of our friends. I think it's a bet I make every time and just understand the process even if it
misses. It's a lot like, honestly, the Kenneth Walker argument in the second round where I'm
closing my eyes and saying if this leads to a bigger role than this profile, the most athletic
running back to ever test at the convime until Mike Washington did so earlier this year, can win.
The Jaguars last year had a terrible offensive line. I'm not sure it's gotten much better,
but they had a terrible offensive line finished 25th in yards before contact per carry.
Individually, though, Tutan still finished sixth and success rate and converted four of his six
carries into touchdowns inside the five yard line. He showed that they can trust him on short
yards down as well. So all we needed is that additional receiving role, which he didn't really
even have an opportunity for last year. And suddenly, this is a player who hits at this ADP. So I
still love Tutan at his cost. Yeah. Gosh, I wish I wish he was cheaper, man, because like we we
think he's good. Then a foul made him a day three pick. He wasn't like, I thought he had a good.
He didn't even hit 40 400 yards from scrimmage as a rookie. Yeah. I mean,
they were, you know what? It's a good thing that we have differing opinions on guys like this.
Because I mean, there is a there's a crazy group of people online, terminally online, who love
Bayshal Tutan. I mean, and I experienced this in March when, I don't know, one of our producers
clipped me saying that I thought that Chris Rodriguez was going to be the the week one lead back
over Bayshal Tutan. No, my God, just people roaring online on social media at me. And actually,
that's starting to look kind of good again, by the way. And people were like, oh, this is going to
be on fantasy receipts that, you know, that I had Chris Rodriguez, maybe as the jaguars week one
lead running back. It hasn't been the greatest camp for Bayshal Tutan either. First of all,
I have him dead in line with ADP right now in the mid 50s. And I never get him because every
because in every single draft, I think of drafts and like once and like 50 drafts. It's because
there's some crazy person who's willing to take him in the 40s, like be on any shadow of a
doubt. Bayshal Tutan in the 40s. And I just, I can't do it. Also, it hasn't been a clean training
camp for him. There were some comments recently from Liam Cohen being like, and Liam Cohen had
talked him up like crazy, Bayshal Tutan throughout the spring. And at the start of training camp,
and recently Liam Cohen was like, we kind of want to see him take another step. And that's not
the kind of rhetoric that you want to hear coming from a coach, especially when it's when it
coincides with the time which Chris Rodriguez is healthy and getting a ton of first team reps.
And you know, even LeQuint Allen, I know is banged up right now, but he was drawing some first
team reps as well early on. I just, I think at the end of the day, this is going to be a three-man
committee. And it's going to be very frustrating trying to pull fantasy, can any kind of
consistent fantasy production out of it because they're going to play three running backs in Jacksonville.
Yeah, I prefer. There's two guys in this range. I'm curious your guys takes on that. I prefer
to Tutan. And they're a little bit different costs. But the Andre Swift, I prefer over Tutan.
I think he is much better than Kyle Menongai. Feel really good about Ben Johnson there. And just being
part of that bear's offense. And then the second one is Travis ETN. I know he got a little boost today
with Alvin Camera being out for a week from the torn ACL. Again, be part of this St. Setup,
which gets back Eric McCoy adds David Edwards plays a ton of games in the dome is going to play
extremely fast. So in this range, like, if I miss on these running back heavy starts, ETN
Swift and a little bit later, Jadarian Price, those are more targets for me, dagel, any thoughts on
those guys or anyone else you want to mention in the mid range that you like.
You could argue ETN should be all the way up with Javonte and Kyron, given that now 31-year-old
Alvin Camera is already out for the next month and dealing with an injury. The Saints also projected
with a second easiest schedule in the entire league. So I like ETN a whole lot. I didn't even know
he was in this range of so that's my pick. That's my favorite among all these guys. Also then,
are we considering Ramondri and Jonathan Brooks in this tier? Are we going down later for the face?
On the 80 feet. Yeah, I think that's a little bit later into the, you can go guys in the 70s. So
yeah, I think we that's a little bit later. I mean, Travis ETN is probably going to go in round four
somewhere. But I think Tutan is going to go in round five, you know, and at cost, I'd much
rather have ETN in round four than Tutan in round five personally. And then Jadarian Price is just
a player I'm out on. If everyone goes back and listens to the draft show, we already had
this discussion. We're still put on his Cloverleaf glasses and got very upset at me. But I'm just
seeing what the Seahawks are saying. Like I understand, no, I don't understand why they drafted him
actually. 295 college touches on his resume. So now we're pushing this guy up like Mike Davis,
who has never handled a large workload. And suddenly we're saying he's going to get a large workload
just because Zach Sharbney is injured and the team drafted him first overall. But even on that,
that light workload fumbled four times, only 15 career receptions. And then also he, whereas
if everyone argues, Jeremiah Love got targets because he played a lot. Jeremiah Love led this class
and being targeted on his routes. His rate of targets on his routes. Jadarian Price was second
lowest in this class. So even when he played on a per-route basis, he could not earn targets. So
I'm going to push back. I'm going to hero call the Seahawks on Jadarian Price. We like my bottom
pair is going to beat you. That's fair. He also is going to go in round six or like the very end
of round five, round six. And so you're not paying a huge cost for him there. And I agree with
you. He's not going to play on the passing hours. They're going to have Halani on the passing
downs to beginning. And once Sharbney gets healthy, they're going to have Sharbney on the passing
downs. What you're betting on is that price is such a good runner that when Sharbney comes back,
price still ceases and controls that. And this is one of the most run heavy teams in the entire
league. And the last thing you're betting on, Degel, that you didn't mention, you have not watched
hard knocks. If you watched hard knock, it is impossible not to get the full 3.9 for Jadarian price.
They're loving him. But yeah, Silva, go ahead on Jadarian price.
Yeah. I mean, you know, Degel can sit here and rally off as many statistics as he wants,
you know, about Jadarian price. But at the end of the day, how many super, how many Lombardi
trophies do you have, Degel? Because the Lombardi trophy winning Seattle Seahawks is drafted Jadarian
price in the first round. I'm going to go with them here. Okay. But also with Jadarian price from
a fantasy standpoint, it's not that fun. I mean, I actually think that Jadarian price is good.
Degel builds a case against him being very good. I think that Jadarian price is good. And it's
still going to be difficult for him to really help us in fantasy because of the fact that it's
going to be Holanian passing situations initially. And it sounds like Sharbney could return. And
that the Seahawks love Zach Sharbney. Even if he's out there averaging 3.6 yards of carry,
they don't care. They feel confident with them. They believe that he's the best pass-protecting
running back in the league. They like him at the goal line. Jadarian price can have a really,
really good rookie season and still not really moved the needle in fantasy. Be like a 12 points per
game kind of guy. He doesn't have very much upside because of the situation around him. Whether or
not, you think he's good. I mean, the biggest reason that I don't have a ton of Jadarian price
right now is because I'm afraid of the peptides. The reports around Sharbney are out of control,
out of control. Like they're saying that he could be back September, October, which is mind-blowing
to me. But yeah, I don't want like in this new age of modern medicine, I don't want to assume
that Sharbney is not going to be back until December anymore. You know, I just don't think we can do that.
Okay, three more guys in this range. I want to touch on quickly. The Skatibu stuff will talk more
next week on the news and the wake of the Naji Harris signing. A dagel already gave his take.
My take is that like the giants have been linked to running backs in free agency, in the draft.
And now throughout this process with dusty veterans here in the summer, it just makes me feel like
they do not feel that great about Kim Skatibu as their feature workhorse back. And so,
as much as I think Kim Skatibu is an awesome
profile for fantasy. Great goal line runner. Really good pass catcher. I think we have to dock him
and we did dock him in the ranking. So civil, we'll talk more about this on news next week, but any
initial thoughts on the scataboo thing in the wake of Naji Harris.
You know, I've been down on cam scataboo since the outset. So to me, like all this kind of stuff
is just confirmation bias, you know, the fact that he's coming off a really, really rough injury.
And I mean, Sam brought in our slack. They was like, there's also a chance that cam scataboo
just might be mentally insane. I mean, you know, like, I mean, he is a crazy guy. That's kind of
what what kind of makes him great too. You know, at least it was a great college player and he had a
really nice rookie season, but he's coming off this this really, really bad injury. Tyrone Tracy was
getting a ton of first team reps at the expense of cam scataboo. You have a changing offensive situation.
You have an entirely new coaching staff now coordinated offensively by Matt Nagy, who I don't think
that any of us trust. And now they bring in Naji Harris, who really, from a skill set standpoint,
overlaps with cam scataboo. They're both four six guys. They're both coming off bad injuries.
And they're both guys who are good, close in in scoring position, and also are good in past
protection and good in the passing game. So yeah, it's it's not a comfortable situation. What's
so ever for cam scataboo? I I have him at 62 right now. Yeah. And I have not even moved him down.
Yes. And I think I'm going to have to move him down after the Naji signing because it's just I
don't trust him. I don't trust the offense as a whole either. I think it's telling that
Silvan, I came to the same conclusion, despite coming into the argument on different sides of it.
Since I have lost confidence along the way. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, and scataboo is still ADP in
home league. We're pulling in as around 37. I don't think that's going to be accurate by the time
we draft in a couple of weeks here. But ETR ranks are down at 50 overall on scataboo. And it's
possible we get lower if we hear more good, if we hear good things about Naji here. The other two
guys in this range, I wanted to touch on quickly. Dagle. Bucky Irving is one who like
when he was going in round three and round four, I thought was one of the worst picks on the board.
Now Bucky Irving, we're getting home league ADP here closer to 48 49 overall. Still kind of a
toughish click for me there. I thought in round six more. He was someone I was interested in,
but Dagle and he thoughts on Bucky and the ambiguous box backfield. Not a player. I would be
high on even at this price of zero carries inside the five. Then they returned Sean Tucker who led
the team in that range as a as a touchdown or bust guy brought in Rashad White who can't handle
load. Oh, I'm sorry. Brought in a thing will who can't handle load, but as a carbon copy of Rashad
White and definitely going to play and the passing game. And perhaps it was because Bucky Irving
then returned injured in a week 13, but from that point forward, everything just plummeted 36%
route share, 3.4 yards per carry, not explosives at all. So just a player, I'm worried about in
season long. Whereas, you know, best ball you can take on that floor. I question his ceiling in a
committee. Yeah. Um, I agree wholeheartedly with Dagle here. On man versus machine, I thought
that Leonie actually did present a decent argument for Bucky Irving. I still disagree with them,
but I thought that he made a pretty good argument. I think that Levitan, well, of course,
Levitan awarded him the win on Bucky Irving. But he pointed to the return of the Bucks offensive
line. The Bucky Irving is a fairly offensive line dependent running back relative to other running
backs. Um, and the Bucks their offensive line just collapsed last year. And now Brandon Thorn has
him up at number three overall. Um, due to the healthy return of Tristan Worives, the healthy return
of Casey Malk. Um, and so that gives me at least a little bit of optimism to where if Bucky Irving
falls past his ADP, I'd be willing to maybe at least consider him. But ultimately, I, I, I'm on
the side of Dagle that he's not a priority draft pick for me this year. Yeah, I agree. And close
it around six, you know, it would be better. But I think he's going to go more early round five
here, which is a little bit steep for me. I'd rather go wide receiver there personally.
Last one in this range, Silva is Travion Henderson. I mean, I, this is another guy similar to
Tutton, who I thought will be going much later this year in homelies. I'm seeing homelogue ADP
on Travion Henderson around 51, 52 overall. So, you know, we're kind of in line with rank there.
You can see how it goes really well when Ramanja was out last year. Travion was awesome.
Silva, what do you think about Travion here around 52 overall?
What did you say 52 overall? Yeah. Yeah, that's literally my ranking. Yeah, of Travion Henderson.
And yeah, I draft him sometimes. He gets to me and I take him right in that range.
See, like, to me, it's not that similar to Tutton, because Tutton was a fourth round pick,
who in his rookie season, he didn't even hit 400 yards from Scrimmage, whereas Travion Henderson
out Ramanja missed some time, which obviously helped here. But Travion Henderson had over a thousand
yards from Scrimmage and 10 touchdowns as a rookie. If you were to pop them in an algorithm
and be like, oh, you know, high second round pick in the NFL, who had, you know, 1100 yards from
Scrimmage and 10 touchdowns as a rookie, Travion Henderson is like going to pop out as like,
you know, a future Hall of Famer. I mean, these are really, really good, you know, statistical
indicators for Travion Henderson. And I know, like, all the rhetoric has been, hey,
Ramanja is returning as the starter. They still trust him in past protection more.
Henderson is really, really talented, though. And he's a player that I'm willing to bet on his
talent. A situation is pretty good, you know, other than having Ramanja there, but I mean,
the offense, the offensive line, you know, the quarterback, they're getting bit Josh McDaniel's
just trustworthy, Vrable. But to me, it's, there's enough upside here that I get excited when I
get the opportunity to draft Travion Henderson. I don't think anyone in a normal two running
back league is starting Travion Henderson in week one, but it's such a sweet setup from 106 on.
If you double tap that second and third tier of running backs that we've discussed,
because then if you have Travion Henderson, who also, you know, you wouldn't want any other
back at the starter was injured in the entire lake. He proved that last year. It's such a sweet
up sweet setup because then you lead your drafts with what only four running backs and you can
stack the rest of your roster. So Henderson is certainly usable regardless of how we project them
in week one or the first month. Yeah. Agreed. I like that take. We're a little bit lower in the
ETR race. We're at 59 overall in ETR ranks on Travion. You know, we have a ceiling boosted if
you get to find that ceiling, you know, and that's part of the reason we have them there. On base,
it's hard to see it on Travion at 52 overall, but yeah, the ceiling outcomes are really awesome
there for Travion. Let's go to later rounds and we get to a lot of ambiguous backfields here,
Dagle. The thing that people say about ambiguous backfields is just take the cheapest one,
take the cheapest one, take the cheapest one. I don't know that that's always the best strategy.
So I'm just going to run through some of these here. I'm curious to you guys take. Let's start with
Washington here. Dagle, Jacori Croskey Merit, Rashad White. Some people think K-Tron Allen's going
to get in the mix. Dagle, what do you think about playing commanders backfield if at all?
I've been a Jacori Croskey Merit bull all off season. We talk about stock prices, and remember,
he was a sixth round pick in homeligs last year. Now we can get him several rounds later.
Not only that, but what he showed us still was impressive. Will the receiving resume come along?
We're crossing our fingers. Probably not, but there's still a range of outcomes here after he had
nine, no, seven collegiate receptions and nine NFL receptions so far. Having said that,
still his explosive rate of carries, so the rate in which he's reached 10 yard runs,
finished sandwich between Bijan Robinson and Derek Henry. He proved he's a very good runner,
and we're expecting David Blatt on that offense to also have more multi-tightened sets helping
him out and assisting Jane Daniels this year. So I just look at a second year running explosive
running back and say, you're letting me have him three or four rounds later. I'm going to make
that bet. We are on Croskey Merit also. ETR ranks are at 87 overall on Croskey Merit, his ADP
in homeligs around 105. I don't think that he's going to have an improved pass-catching role,
but when you play running back and you can have explosive runs with Jane and Daniels,
we know those opportunities to make those explosive runs here for Jacori Croskey Merit.
Keep him moving with ambiguous backfields here, Silva. Let's go to the Panthers where we have Jonathan
Brooks versus Chuba Hubbard. I know we talked about this a little bit in the wake of Chuba's
hamstring injury. It's really hard to get a feel for Jonathan Brooks ADP because it's just
changing so, so fast. We're pulling in 92. Right now, I do not think that will be accurate by the time
most drafts happen. I think when most drafts happen, Jonathan Brooks will likely be going in round
six maybe. Silva, what do you think about Jonathan Brooks versus Chuba Hubbard at that price?
I don't want anything to do with Chuba Hubbard. What's so ever this year? That was the case
before the hamstring injury. Again, we can debate the talents of these running backs.
And I still think that, you know, especially with guys
that aren't truly, truly like super natural freaking talents,
like the situation is, it can be really tough to overcome
when it's really, really bad.
And Carolina has a potentially really, really bad situation
that without both of their starting offensive tackles,
their quarterback can barely see over the offensive line.
They're not gonna score a lot of points.
They've got a multi-headed backfield period,
even if you don't like Chuba Hubbard,
he's gonna play.
He's like a freaking team captain.
They're gonna use him in past protection situations at least.
They're gonna give him a handful of carries
because he's like a leader on the panthers
when he, whenever he comes back from this hamstring injury,
I am in, I like, I'm definitely more optimistic
than Adam is about Jonathan Brooks.
And I still, you know, kind of shudder to draft him
because the situation is so rough.
Because again, you're having, you're, you're placing,
you know, essentially a financial bet on Jonathan Brooks
coming back from double ACL tears.
And in a committee backfield on a,
what I think is gonna be a bad team.
- Yeah.
- So that's not fun to me at all, Jonathan Brooks.
And I do take him sometimes, but you're right.
In every draft, he goes in a different spot
because you just kind of never know
because there are so many varying,
sometimes I'll go in the fourth round.
- Yeah.
- You know, and I wouldn't take him until like the seventh.
- Yes.
- This is super priced dependent for me real quick,
single super priced dependent for me. If he goes in the seventh
or eighth round, I'm taking Jonathan Brooks.
I just don't think that he is going to get there.
Go ahead, Dago.
- This is where we can't hand feed you with our rankings.
You have to temperature check these two players.
Like I think more so than any other backfield
because there's also going to be times
where the guy who has a six month old at home
shows up to your draft with a magazine
and he drafts Chuba Hubbard in the fourth or fifth round.
Now suddenly Jonathan Brooks is a value.
So you're just gonna have to watch it
because it's gonna differ every single draft.
- Yeah, okay.
Another ambiguous--
- That's how it is these days.
You see a guy show up with the fantasy magazine.
Oh, there's the fish right there.
- There's Chuba Hubbard.
Fourth or out.
- Okay, come more ambiguous backfields, Dago Denver.
People are surprised that RJ Harvey is still going first here
in ADP, speaking to what Silva said
about plugging something into a model.
I mean, RJ Harvey's rookie year from production,
from a raw production standpoint.
He would be exciting for year two,
but there are a lot of flags here based on
what Denver did in the off season
and the way RJ Harvey played in the underlying stats
last year.
- That's why I also think it boils down to his ADP
and how far he goes.
He's a player where I've already done several industry
mock drafts and just leagues in general,
12 team, 14 team.
And I've taken RJ Harvey multiple times
just because as I talked about with JJ Zacharyson
on his recent late rounds perspective show,
RV is a second round receiving back.
So if you remove everything else,
including that you have to scroll
to the last page of every rushing stat to find him,
you remove everything and that's the kind of player
you typically want to bet on at a dipping ADP.
So totally fine grabbing him,
but I also still want to make sure everyone's making
the bet with Jonah Coleman and this ambiguous backfield.
ADP is not catching up in either best ball or homeligs.
It seems like Coleman's really going under the radar
despite being removed on the first drive
because Sean Peyton, the offense even said,
they had seen enough.
Like we got to get this guy off the field
because we have to keep this genie in its lamp.
And also a great profile coming out too.
AD catches on 90 targets over the last three years,
1.73 yards per route run,
last season would take second only behind Jeremiah Love
in his class.
So also a player I want to bet on.
And I think it's perfectly okay given their large discrepancy
and ADPs that you come away with both.
Yeah, I think that's fair.
And like RJ Harvey is not going to play
on the passing downs.
I don't think they trust him there,
but he's still a passing back.
And that's kind of like a weird profile,
but they are going to throw to him on early downs.
Obviously he played well around the goal line last year.
But yeah, I don't know, like at the right cost,
I would take all three of these guys.
And it's really just a cost thing for me.
Silva made his case for JK Dobbins
on the Manverse Machine show if you want to check that out.
Last one, Silver Frame.
He goes back there as I had with the Tennessee Titans.
It's been really hard for us on the projection side
to keep Tony Pollard where we want him to be.
Nobody's excited about Tony Pollard.
It's just hard not to give him a lot of touches here.
That is the definition of Dead Zone
and why I've been trying to avoid Tony Pollard
where I can.
We also talked about this some on the news show.
Silva where the snaps were in favor of spears
in that first preseason game.
But then I noticed that Tony Pollard was listed
with a foot injury on Monday.
So I kind of want to take back what I said
about some of that snap count stuff there
from preseason week one.
But Silva, any final thoughts here on Titans Backfield?
- Just another really, really bad situation.
Like this is maybe the worst situation.
- Yeah.
- Because we got the worst offensive line in the league.
We have a multi-headed backfield.
We got an offense quarterback by Kim Ward,
who sees, I don't know.
I'm starting to get real, real worried about him.
Tony Pollard's ADP is like 80.
And I have him at 81 or something like that.
And even when he falls past his ADP I'm not,
it's not an exciting click.
So Tony Pollard finished last season like gangbusters.
I mean, he was legit like one of the best running backs
in the league over the final four games of 2025.
And still, it's an ugly one.
- For sure.
- All right, let's go to whatever he wants to hear about.
Sleepers.
And you know, it's hard to give sleepers,
especially the running back position,
especially in today's fantasy football landscape.
Silver mentioned one that was on my list already.
Chris Rodriguez goes very, very late for a player
who I think will have the goal line role
in a good offense and a chance to win some more base.
The other late round target that I will give
is Keaton Mitchell.
I don't know exactly what Keaton Mitchell's role is going to be.
But if you have injuries and you have bi weeks
and you tell me Keaton Mitchell is going to get nine touches
or 10 touches in a game, I could do worse
than putting that into my lineup, you know.
And I'm more of a volume guy typically
than an efficiency guy.
But Keaton Mitchell is such an outlier
even on nine touches, 10 touches.
On a nine or 10 touch projection,
I think you can start him in the right kind
of deeper formats.
So those are the two that were on my list,
Seerad and Keaton as late round sleepers.
I like Dago's call of Jonah Coleman here.
Also, Dago, any other sleepers or late round guys,
you want to get off your chest and running back?
As you said, love Keaton Mitchell.
I also think it's going to be much easier
to flex Keaton Mitchell, no, when to flex him
than a lot of other people are suggesting,
given probably the choices will be wide receiver two's
on bad offenses compared to Keaton Mitchell's eight touches.
And I'm going to take the explosiveness
and good matchups with a great offensive play collar.
We just talked about the Titans backfield.
I look at all the late round handcuffs, though,
that we'll discuss in a moment towards the end of the show.
And I see that they all have to have an injury ahead of them
to really supplant that guy.
Nicholas Singleton, I would argue is the one player
who I'll probably drop in week five,
but also I would argue he doesn't have
to have an injury ahead of him
to suddenly win that job towards the end of the year.
Given that Tony Pauler, George Peralron
have decreased now for three consecutive seasons,
Tajay Spears has yet to come for his job.
So he's not really anyone.
I'm worried about taking it.
It's at least open for Singleton to do something.
And he's another guy who's averaged
a one and a half yards per out run
the last three seasons in college.
So I like stashing that chance
as a really last round guy.
And then another one, which fits aligned with Silva
if you think Quinch on Juck and Zyre
they're going to struggle in returning from injury
or be a dead zone back.
Only three running backs averaged
two yards per out run last year.
Bijan Robinson is a first round pick.
Jalen Warren, it's a strong mid-round selection
and Dylan Samson who you can get for free
and stash in a Todd Munkin offense.
So I've come around a lot more on Dylan Samson
the last month seeing his ADP go so late.
That's a player I'm really high on.
- Yeah.
I've been out on Singleton just as the third running back
and I think a return man for a really bad team.
Samson is one that is interesting to me.
That was his calling card coming out
and like play really well in the passing game.
And I think with Todd Munkin, I think Dylan Samson
is okay there.
Silva, any later round guys you want to get off your chest
before you move to handcuffs here?
- The thing is that my stuff veers right into handcuffs.
So you want to just jump right to handcuffs?
- Let's go to handcuffs.
So last topic here today is handcuffing.
Just a strategy point I want to make.
Handcuffing to me in redraft is very different
than bestball.
In bestball, I like taking other people's handcuffs.
In other words, if I had Bijan Robinson,
I would take Tank Bigsby over Brian Robinson.
Because in these bestball tournaments,
I'm trying to get a super team.
But in a 12 team league, I don't need a top 1% outcome.
And so more of a four play, which I want,
rather than a ceiling play in bestball.
So if I have sake one in a 12 team league,
I'm going to take or at least think about taking
Tank Bigsby.
So just a strategy point there for me
on handcuffing Silva, go ahead with your favorite
or any thoughts on handcuffs here.
- Yeah, and at the same time.
And I agree with that.
I do think that even in a redraft season long,
like people should be willing to just stack their bench
with backup running backs,
regardless of whether or not they have the starter.
- Yeah, agree.
- Because those guys provide ample, ample upside.
Mike Washington is a guy who stands out to me
behind Aston Gen T.
With the Raiders, it seems like Mike Washington,
who was a total freak athlete, sort of an underachiever
[BLANK_AUDIO]
But a total freak athlete who the Raider selected in the fourth round and
It seems like he has run away with the Raider's number two running back job in an improving environment
In a situation where Genji looks like he's gonna get a lot of a ton of touches
And that will put him at risk of injury Mike Washington is one of my favorite handcuffs slash sleepers the yeet cannon
March on Lloyd, I mean, there's enough buzz around him now that I'm not sure that he's you know a true sleeper
But he's definitely an upside handcuffed
He can play in the passing Amy ways 220 pounds when he was coming out of USC
He ran in the four fours. He's behind a player in Josh Jacobs who's already been banged up and
There's still some lingering risk that he could be suspended before the season Tyler Algear
Behind Jeremiah Love who already has a high ankle sprain in Arizona
We know that Tyler Algear can at least play a little bit and that coaches can feel very comfortable giving him the ball at
The goal line Jaden blue we talked about him. You mentioned tank Bigsby
Those are some of my fair. I
This is gonna be gross, but I was kind of into Alvin Camera
Before we learned today that he has a sprained MCL so I'm taking him off of my list
That helps Travis ETN though because there was some risk that
Alvin Camera was gonna get the ball and scoring position in in the passing game
Yeah, when I think about these late-round picks
I want to know in my head
What is the bet that I'm making am I making a stand-alone bet or am I making a bet where the starter has to be injured because when you get into
Spots we might have to drop guys. I think you have to understand what you're going for
I try to keep as many of these guys that are clean handcuffs on my bench not all of them
Art clean like I would not consider Jaden blue a clean handcuff if Javante Williams went down
I think we would see other guys believe Davis Filmafa whatever the reason I think tank Bigsby is such a clean handcuff
Is because if sake one Barclay went down he would have the sake one Barclay role and I just think
Tank Bigsby is really good. You could say the same thing Dagle about Blake Korum
Although you have to pay way way more to get Blake Korum because he will have some stand-alone value there himself
Dagle any more thoughts here on hand cover
That's why when we're nitpicking. I don't mind going to my players direct back up if that player is in fact a direct back up
Like if I have James Cook
And I go Ray Davis that makes a lot more sense than if I go
DJ Giddens or Seth McGowan instead of Ray Davis even though I have Jonathan Taylor because we're just not sure right now
So I'm still leaning those guys. Silva mentioned a lot of them Mahayana Marsha on Lloyd is a really sneaky one - because maybe Josh Jacobs has to get out of the way
But we don't know their roles since Marsha on Lloyd has never been healthy
He's healthy maybe he just gets 8 to 10 touches per game since Jacob's efficiency has declined
Might at least the last couple years beyond that though
I would also throw in Woody Marx because we already saw the Texans give him 20 touches per game going into the playoffs
That's the kind of guy that I want given if a starter is injured
Last one that I wanted to ask you guys about is Emmett Johnson
There has been buzz lately out of chiefs camp that Emmett Johnson is getting a lot of the reps directly behind
Kenneth Walker Evan and I are both really high on Kenneth Walker
So I want to try to get this one right Evan. Are you thinking or you have any optimism for Emmett Johnson as a direct handcuff to Kenneth Walker?
Yes, and I love what we've heard about him so far in training camp in the preseason
He's a guy who can he caught a lot of passes in college and we know that historically at least when Andy Reed has had a running back like that
He's going to use that
And it seems like Emmett Johnson has pulled ahead for the RB two job in Kansas City
In Kansas City that's really shouldn't be surprising because I'm already Marcaro is just using very good
So yeah, I have a to-do list and that's to get Emmett Johnson into my top 150 and to make him a player
That I want to draft. I mean, you know here sitting here three weeks away from
You know the start of the season like I want to make sure that I get enough Emmett Johnson as my RB five RB six
Going forward because I don't have any I don't have a whole lot of them
Right now. I want to change that. Yeah, they only thoughts on that or any final guys you want to throw out before we get out of here
No thoughts really the second running back, but again, I think we're all even our projections comfortable betty-gon Kenneth Walker taking the pass catching role
So Emmett Johnson strictly a direct back up there
Yeah, I think I've said no with handcuffs. All right
This was good. I'm glad we did this running back remains the most important position
In fantasy football for more on strategy be sure you're subscribed to YouTube. We will be talking about
Running back strategy and all other draft strategy later this week
You can also find my thoughts on strategy and every player in the player by player notes and the draft strategy column
Dagle and silver continue to work on the tears when you're drafting of course you should be drafting
Through the tears and as we get set for official home leaks slash redraft season remember the extension
That we put out for you guys if you have draft kit you have access to it
Views the extension you will be able to see our rankings while you're doing a draft on ESPN Yahoo or sleeper
And it'll cross the names off as guys get picked. So be sure you are using that
all right
for
Dagle
For silver
Prisa Ryan Prisa Luke guy madam good luck everybody
(upbeat music)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Running back remains the most important fantasy football position, with 12 running backs expected in the first 20 picks due to NFL trends favoring the run and improved running back health.
Gibbs and Bijan are consensus top-two picks, with debate at pick five between running backs like Christian McCaffrey and Jonathan Taylor versus wide receivers like Amon-Ra St. Brown and JSN.
McCaffrey has efficiency decline and age concerns (30 years old, career-high touches), but his receiving upside keeps him elite if healthy; Taylor has a higher ceiling due to a better offensive line and younger age.
ADP outliers include Derrick Henry (safe touchdown upside), Chase Brown (target at pick 12-22 due to Bengals' passing game), and Kenneth Walker (preferred over Ashton Jeanty due to Chiefs' explosive run opportunities).
Devon H&N is a fade at pick 13 due to quarterback change (Malik Willis) and potential reduced receptions; Ashton Jeanty is a target due to Raiders' regression in passing touchdowns.
In the second round, Breece Hall and Jeremiah Love are debated due to injuries, with Javonte Williams favored by some for his offensive environment and touchdown upside; Kyren Williams is a fade due to Blake Corum's role.
The "dead zone" running back concept persists, with David Montgomery as a prime example; Bucky Irving and Quinchon Judkins are fades, while Travis ETN and Andre Swift are targets.
Later-round picks include Tank Bigsby, Keaton Mitchell, Jonah Coleman, and Chris Rodriguez as sleepers; handcuffing strategies emphasize direct backups like Ray Davis and Emmett Johnson.
Summary:
The podcast episode focuses on running back strategy for fantasy football drafts, emphasizing the position's renewed importance. The hosts (Adam Levitan, Evan Silva, and John Daigle) analyze early-round picks, noting Gibbs and Bijan as top choices, with debate over pick five between McCaffrey, Taylor, and top receivers. McCaffrey's efficiency decline and age are concerns, but his receiving prowess keeps him viable; Taylor offers higher upside due to a better offensive line and youth.
ADP outliers like Chase Brown and Kenneth Walker are favored, while Devon H&N is faded due to quarterback changes. In the second round, injuries to Breece Hall and Jeremiah Love create uncertainty, with Javonte Williams favored for his touchdown potential in a strong Cowboys offense. The "dead zone" concept remains relevant, with David Montgomery as a prime example; fades include Kyren Williams and Bucky Irving, while Travis ETN and Andre Swift are targets.
Later-round sleepers include Tank Bigsby, Keaton Mitchell, and Jonah Coleman. Handcuffing strategies are discussed, emphasizing direct backups like Ray Davis and Emmett Johnson for injury insurance. Overall, the hosts stress the importance of running back depth and adapting to ADP shifts, with a focus on explosive runners and receiving backs in favorable offensive environments.
FAQs
Running backs are highly valued, with 12 expected to be drafted in the first 20 picks due to their health and production. They remain the most important position in fantasy football.
Jahmyr Gibbs and Bijan Robinson are consensus top picks, with Christian McCaffrey and Jonathan Taylor also strong choices around pick five. McCaffrey has efficiency concerns but high upside if healthy.
It depends on preference; wide receivers like Amon-Ra St. Brown and Jaxon Smith-Njigba are solid, but running backs like McCaffrey and Taylor offer high ceilings. Many experts lean toward running backs given the position's importance.
Yes, if he plays 16-17 games, he's likely a top-three fantasy player, though his efficiency has declined. He's a risk for injury but has a high ceiling in half-PPR formats.
Taylor's success depends on the Colts winning and staying competitive, as he struggles when they fall behind. However, he could improve his receiving role and has a higher ceiling than last year.
Chase Brown, Kenneth Walker, and Ashton Jeanty are popular targets. Chase Brown benefits from being the Bengals' de facto third receiver, while Kenneth Walker has explosive run potential in Kansas City.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.