Speaker 1Before we begin, this episode is brought to you by Biogland Smart Minds. The clocks have gone back, it's dark by tea time, and if bedtimes have quietly gone sideways in your house, you're not alone. Mine were just the same. Biogland Smart Minds are tasty, sugar-free gummies designed to support growing minds, balanced moods, and restful sleep. And they're the ones I'm happy to recommend. Available online and in store at Holland & Barrett. I want to start with something which I hear from parents more than almost anything else. I know something is wrong, I can feel it, but every time I try to get them to talk, they shut down. And the more I push, the worse it gets. If that is you, this episode is for you. Today, I want to do something a bit different, because most advice about getting children to open up focuses on technique, the right questions to ask, and the right things to do. The right moment to choose. And those things matter, we will get to them. But I want to start somewhere deeper, because no technique works without the thing that makes it possible. Connection. And that is where we are starting today. Now, before we get into it, if you are new here, or you've been following for a while but haven't yet hit follow, please do. It means the next episode finds you automatically, and I think you will want to stay for where this is going. Now, let's start with why do children go silent? Why does it happen? Because understanding the reason changes everything about how we respond. Children go silent for different reasons at different ages. And the most common ones are these. They don't want to worry you. This one is more common than most parents realise. Children, even quite young children, are extraordinarily attuned to their parents' emotional state. They know when you're stressed, when you're fragile, when you're already carrying a lot. And they make a decision, often unconsciously, to protect you from one more thing. Or it could be that they go silent because they're ashamed. There is a painful, irrational, but very common belief in children that if something bad is happening to them or around them, it's somehow their fault. Saying it out loud, means admitting to something which feels humiliating. Or maybe they've tried before and it didn't help. Or it made things worse. If a previous attempt to tell you something resulted in you panicking, overreacting, going straight to school, or telling them not to be silly, they filed that away. The door closed a little. Or they don't have the words. And this is especially true for younger children, but also for teenagers who are carrying something that is emotionally complex. They know something is wrong, but they can't name it. And not being able to name it makes it even harder to bring to you. All of these make sense. None of them mean that you have failed, and all of them are workable. But before we work with any of them, we need to talk about connection. So how do we build that connection first? And here is the thing, and the reason why I've approached this podcast episode in this particular way. No strategy that I share for getting your child to open up will work if the connection is not already there. You can't manufacture a vulnerable conversation in the moment of crisis or pre-crisis if the relationship has not been kept warm in the ordinary moments before it. Connection doesn't happen in the big conversation. It actually happens in the small, pretty unremarkable, repeated moments of the daily grind and daily life. And the good news is that it doesn't require time you do not have. It requires attention and intention. Here is what it looks like in practice. So number one, leave notes. This sounds small. It isn't. A note in a lunchbox, a post-it note on their pillow, a message on their desk before school. Not long. A sentence is enough. I thought of you today. Hope the maths test goes okay. You are brilliant at hard things. Notes land actually quite differently to spoken words. They can be read and re-read. They are evidence, physical, tangible evidence that you thought of them when they were not in the room. And for children who find face-to-face conversation hard, a note can open a door which talking could not. So maybe you leave a note or you come back to what you said. And if you don't, you can leave a note. And if you don't, you can leave Not how was your day, which often gets a grunt. Fine. Okay. But instead, how did you get on with that presentation? Because that's the thing that they mentioned on Tuesday. The name of the friend that they had a falling out with. The match that they were nervous about. Coming back to what they told you last time is one of the most powerful things that we can do. It says, I'm listening. You matter enough for me to remember. The ordinary things you tell me are the most powerful things I tell me. Stay with me. That is the feeling which makes children more likely to tell you the difficult things. Or just be present without an agenda. Side-by-side presence, being in the same room, doing something alongside them, not trying to have a conversation. That's often underrated. Just that side-by-side presence. For many children, and particularly for teenagers, shared space without pressure is enough. It keeps your account topped up. It says, I like being near you. I'm not here to extract something. Watch something maybe together. Be in the kitchen while they're doing their homework. Drive somewhere in companionable silence. The conversation does not need to happen for the connection itself to be real. Or you can follow their interests, even when those interests bore you. Ask about the game. Watch the five-minute clip they want to show you. Know the name of the character they care about. Find out what the drama is in the show they're watching. This is not about faking enthusiasm. It's about demonstrating repeatedly that what matters to them matters to you. That you're curious about their world, not just managing it. Children who genuinely feel seen in their interests feel seen full stop. Or we might protect the ritual. Whatever yours is, the good night moment, the drive to school, the Sunday morning routine, the 10 minutes after dinner, protect it. These small repeated touch points are where children file away the knowledge that they are loved and that they are seen. They are the scaffolding of the relationship. When they are consistent, children carry them through the day. When they disappear, because life gets busy, because a sibling arrives, because work is demanding, or even we see that they're getting older and they don't want it, children do notice. Not always consciously, but they do notice. Now, for teenagers specifically, a voice note during the day, a meme or a reel which made you think of them, a text which asks nothing and expects no reply, saw this and thought of you, no need to reply, just thinking of you. These are low-pressure signals of connection, which don't require teenagers to perform or response as a single emoji. They land. The goal is not to manufacture a conversation. It is to keep the account topped up so that when something is wrong, the relationship has enough in it to hold the weight. Now, I want to move on. So these are the things that we can do to begin to build that connection. What I now want to talk about is when they still won't talk. So maybe in this situation, we've got the connection. But no, but our child is not working. So if you've got, if you have no connection and your child is not talking to you, focus on the first sort of options that I've suggested. If you have the connection already, but your child is still not talking and you're, because you're doing all of the above and they're still not telling you what's wrong, here's what works. And these are my five tips. Number one, don't ask, observe and reflect. Now, most parents open with a question. What's wrong? Are you okay? What happened? And the question, however well-intentioned, requires something of them. It puts them on the spot. It makes the silence feel like a failure to perform. It's almost like the headlights are on them and they're these rabbits that are caught in it. So instead, try something like this. I've noticed you seem tired this week. You've seemed a bit flat since Wednesday. Something feels a bit different with you. Not going to push, but I'm here when you're ready. So it's not a question. It's simply a question. It's simply an observation and that requires nothing from them, but it shows that you're paying attention. It opens the door without pushing them through it. And then, and this is the hard part, you leave it. You do not follow it up five minutes later. You trust that the door is open and you let them come through it in their own time. It's almost like the episode that I've done previously about this sort of drip drip. We're just slowly providing opportunities and note that we're observing them, that we've noticed that something's different that we're here for them when they're ready and then they will come particularly if we just create that space for them to do it number two get the conditions right timing matters enormously the worst time to try and have a meaningful conversation with a child is the moment they walk through the door yeah their bucket is full their nervous system needs to decompress they need space before they can share the best time is later often after they've eaten in the evening or in the car when you're sort of going somewhere together and the physical setup matters too side by side not face to face eye contact is often too exposing and feels a little bit like a terror interrogation when someone is carrying something particularly difficult the car is one of the best places in the world for hard conversations you are both looking forward you're going somewhere there's a natural end point and neither of you has to manage your face or alternatively you can do this particularly with older children you can do this via messaging i found that some children work better when you're beginning to have those conversations via a messaging system it seems odd i know it does because obviously we want to have that in person but sometimes that can start the conversation and then we can move it to a side to side in person number three go first so this is one of the most underused tools parents have when it is used well and when we don't launch into lecture mode so share something of our own a time something was hard something that we found difficult within that week a moment when we were not sure what to do or how we felt about it not a lecture not a story with a tidy moral at the end just something true told simply i had a really hard conversation at work today and i'm still thinking about it when i was your age there was someone in my class who made me feel really small i never told anyone this does several things at once it models emotional disclosure it shows that difficult things can be named without the world ending and it creates permission if this family is one in which hard things can be said then perhaps maybe i can say something about it say something hard too it doesn't always result in an immediate conversation but again it's planting the seeds it's sowing this drip dripping so it feels something else that they have that they can then come back to us on number four stay regulated when they do open up and this one is critical and it's the one which often closes the door again so the moment your child or teen tells you something difficult you're not going to be able to do it again you're not going to be able to your reaction in that moment will determine whether they ever tell you anything again if you gasp or cry or immediately start problem solving or bombarding them with questions or say why didn't you tell me sooner the door closes our response when they open up is instrumental in the experience that they get and the template that they get about how does how does my you know me when i give them difficult things if there's any of those and of course it's not about not feeling them but it's how we respond in those moments that will speak volumes as to whether they come back they learn that telling you adds to the weight rather than sharing it when we do that gasping crying that judging all that problem solving the goal is to receive what they offer with warmth and tenderness and steadiness you know thank you for telling me that sounds really hard do you want me to help figure something out or do you just want me to listen i love that last statement because what we're doing is instinctively we want to help figure things out or in fact we just want to tell them what the answer is you know that last sentence do you want me to help figure something out or do you just want me to listen is a standard statement that we can remember time and time again and can be used in so many situations where we're instead of asking them what do you need from me after we've acknowledged what they're going through it's a very simple choice you know do you want some help figuring this out or do you just want me to sit here and listen and then they can respond that you know because it is the last one is is one of the most useful things that we can ask because sometimes they want a solution and sometimes they just want you know to feel that they've been heard getting that wrong so when we offer solutions when all they wanted was listening or sitting quietly when all they want is help leaves them feeling misunderstood even after they were brave enough to talk and not all children will be able to tell you what they want and what they don't want and what they don't want and what they don't want and what they need but when we offer them that sentence do you want me to help figure something out or do you just want me to listen that gives them a framework so ask and then follow their lead number five hold it lightly do not make talking to me a pressure in itself a child who feels that you need them to open up who is managing your anxiety about their silence is a child who is carrying more than they need to you the weight of their own difficulty plus the weight of your worry about their silence that's too much trust the connection you have built it does the work even when the conversation is not happening children are always filing things away the warmth the notes the remembered details the ritual all of it is accumulating into knowledge i am loved and i am safe and when the moment is right that knowledge is what makes the door open we don't have to force it we have to keep showing up now how does this look at different ages because i think it's really helpful to do that so when we think of our children that are probably well under seven children this age have a limited vocabulary they're still building their vocabulary for emotion they often can't tell you how they feel not because they won't but because they genuinely do not have the language yet what you will see is behavior maybe a regression bedwetting clinginess sleeping difficulties more tears than usual aggression which feels out of proportion the approach here is to name what you see not what you think they feel your body seems really unsettled at bedtime this week you seem like you've got a lot of feelings right now and then offer the word tentatively as a suggestion i wonder if you're feeling a bit worried about something you do not need to extract a confession you just need them to feel seen and that is enough as we move up to our sort of older primary school age our seven to eleven shame starts appearing around this age as does peer loyalty so children this age are beginning to have a social world which is separate from us and they guard it telling us something which happened with a friend for example can feel like a betrayal of that friend or like admitting to something they should have handled themselves so the telling tales fear is real and we need to work with it not against it i'm not going to do anything you don't want me to do i just want to understand and give them control over what happens next if they tell you what will you do with it making that clear before they decide whether to share reduces the risk they perceive in opening up with our 12 to 15 year olds privacy becomes identity at this age you know separating from others and then sharing with others and then sharing with others and then from parents emotionally psychologically is the developmental task of adolescence and that separation involves keeping things to themselves they would have previously shared so this is not pathological it's not a problem it's normal and it's part of growing up but it can feel like rejection and parents who experience it as rejection sometimes respond in ways which push teenagers away by increasing pressure by expressing hurt by making them feel guilty for doing something that is actually developmentally necessary the approach here is to stay available without crowding to be curious without interrogating to make it clear repeatedly in low stakes moments that the door is open i'm always here no judgment no drama whenever you're ready and then mean it the first time they test that the first time they tell you something and you stay regulated determines everything which follows if we're unregulated that also determines whether they the fact that they probably are unlikely to disclose to us again for our older teens 16 and above at this age they are capable of articulate silence yeah i'm fine is often not evasion it's it's a considered choice they have assessed the situation and decided that it's not what they're supposed to be and they're supposed to be able to do it what they want to bring to you right now that choice i believe deserves respect even when it is painful to watch what works here is not technique it's actually relationship it's the accumulated evidence over years that you are someone worth talking to someone who listens before they fix someone who does not make their distress the center of the conversation keep the connection warm keep the door open and trust that when they need you they know where to find you and now a note for parents of neurodivergent children There is a word I want to introduce here, alexithymia. It means difficulty identifying and describing inner feelings. And it is common, not universal, but common in autistic children and in children with ADHD. When a neurodivergent child says, I don't know, in response to how are you feeling? They may well be telling you the truth. They're not deflecting. They're not protecting themselves. They genuinely do not know. And the strategies which work for neurotypical children, tell me how you're feeling, put words to it, don't work here. What works instead is offer options rather than open questions. Do you feel more angry or more sad? Does it feel like something happened or like a general heavy feeling? Use the body as a starting point. Where do you feel it? In your chest? In your stomach? And give them time, much more time than they think, than you think they need. The processing happens. It just happens more slowly. And the words do come later. Patient, low pressure, option-based conversations work. Open-ended emotional questions often do not. Now, that's it for today. If any of that landed, if you find yourself recognising something or thinking of a note to write, please let me know in the comments. And I'll see you in the next episode of the show notes. If you have two minutes to leave a review, I'd be genuinely grateful. It helps more parents find the show when they need it most. And if you haven't already hit follow, please do. The next episode lands Monday, and it's not one to miss. Until then, I'm Dr. Mary. And you're doing better than you think.