What the West Got Wrong About Afghanistan and Syria
from The Rest Is Politics ·
24m 32s
The episode, part of a series on existential threats, centers on Anand Gopal’s deeply human exploration of Syria through the lives of individuals in Manbij. It highlights how political upheaval—starting with the 1980s’ submersion of a farming village due to a state dam—shapes personal trauma and fuels later radicalism. Ibrahim, a young man who falls in love and is forced to end his relationship, becomes a displaced refugee and eventually joins the Free Syrian Army in response to state violence. Meanwhile, Abdul Hadi, a former footballer turned gym teacher, enters ISIS due to disillusionment with elite power and a desire for social equality, illustrating how personal grievances can lead to radicalization. The city of Manbij becomes a microcosm of chaos: with 80 armed groups, dozens of political factions, and a surge of grassroots political action, ordinary citizens like karate champion Abel Oz rise to leadership roles. However, this anarchy is exploited by ISIS, which capitalizes on fears of insecurity to gain power. The narrative reveals a profound paradox: many former militants now live as ordinary citizens, coexisting with their former enemies. This complexity suggests that without structured truth and reconciliation, deep societal wounds will resurface, threatening long-term peace. The stories underscore how individual experiences—familial, economic, and political—are inextricably linked to broader conflict dynamics.
Hi, this is Gary Lineker from Goal Hangers. The rest is football.
This episode is brought to you by WISE. It's only when you start moving money between currencies
that you really think about the exchange rate, the fee, and what might be hidden away in the
small print. Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas, or just trying to manage your
money across borders, you want a fair exchange rate, an easy transfer, and no surprises along
the way. WISE keeps things simple. WISE is a smart way to move the currencies you need around
the globe. It works in more than 160 countries and with over 40 currencies. Most transfers arrive
instantly. WISE uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no markups
or hidden fees. So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee, and get on with
it. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees by downloading the WISE app today.
Be smart. Get WISE. T's and C's apply.
Prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's
disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic
reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them, and liver problems may
occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an
infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about
Tramfiya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more.
Or visit TramfiyaRadio.com.
Sell your car today on Carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply.
Welcome to The Rest Is Politics, and we're focused here on our series on existential threats and
policy. But I'm joined today by Anand Gopal, who I must confess is one of my heroes. He wrote
the best book about Afghanistan, and he's just written an extraordinary book about
Syria. We'll have an opportunity to get into this in a bit of depth, but he, difficult to know how
to describe him, but fundamentally, he's a writer, but he's a writer who very, very patiently spends
time getting to know people in very specific places and understanding their stories and
telling them in enormous detail. And the result is totally revolutionary. I suppose maybe there's
a philosophical point about somebody who, by describing the world in real miniature,
makes a much more grand and more powerful story.
His latest book, which we'll probably begin with, charts the lives of women and men,
particularly around Manbij, a city in Syria, and their lives over many, many decades through
the collapse of the Bashar al-Assad regime, the Arab Spring, the Islamic State taking over 2014
onwards, and all the politics that surrounds this extraordinary place up on the Turkish-Syria border.
And I think it tells us a huge amount.
It does tell us a huge amount about ourselves and about other people. So, Anand, welcome to the show.
Thanks so much for having me.
I'd love it if you just tell us a little bit about a couple of the characters that you've
written about. You've written very, very powerfully about many different people,
but I was struck particularly by Ibrahim, who you opened the book with. And I'd be wonderful if you
could just, well, let's begin with him. Tell us the story of his village and his life and where
he ends up, and then maybe we'll get on to someone else.
When we meet Ibrahim early in the book, he's 16 or 17 years old. He's in a small farming
village on the banks of the Euphrates River. And this is the '80s and the 1990s. And this is a
village without electricity. There's one school. And his whole world's contained in this little
village. And he falls in love with, literally, with the girl next door. And it's a somewhat
conservative village, so he's carrying on his romance with this girl in secret, and eventually
gets discovered by him. And he's in love with her. And he's in love with
her by his parents. And he's forced to end the relationship. And this is, for his 16-year-old
self, is a source of much consternation and angst. And as that is happening, the government, this is
the government of Hafez al-Assad, is seeking to modernize the countryside, bring electricity and
roads to the countryside. So they build a dam on the Euphrates River. And that ends up submerging
his village. And I wanted to tell this story because this was a coming-of-age story of a young
man who, as far as you can imagine from anything that we would consider politics, but is now being
forced to contend in a very inchoate way, at least at this stage, with political realities. One with
the fact of the kind of rigid mores of his village that he's kind of up against, and also the heavy
hand of the state coming in to his village. One of the things that struck me as you were telling
the story, which was very human, but in a way took a bit of time to adjust to, was that the villagers told
that it's going to happen and they simply don't believe it. And one of the most moving moments is
that had they believed it, presumably in the months in advance, they could have cut down
their trees, moved their possessions, not sown their crops. And the government's saying to them,
we're not going to give you any fertilizer this year or seed this year because you're going to
be flooded. Tell me a little bit about that, because it's a very strange and moving moment.
Yeah. These villagers, their primary interaction with the authorities was one that was
extractive. The authorities would come to take from them, or they would be forced to give bribes.
And you may have seen this, Rory, in Afghanistan too, that people in some of these very rural,
underdeveloped areas have a very love-hate relationship with the central authorities.
And often when authorities show up in a village, it's not for a good reason.
And so there was years of distrust when the local officials were the same ones you have to bribe,
get your identification documents to go to school, to get a job.
So when people showed up at the village and said, hey, listen, we're building a dam,
and this is going to flood your village. So you should take compensation. The community
was divided. People didn't really know what to trust. And many people refused to leave their
land. And you see this in other cases. I mean, in my country, Hurricane Katrina, there's people who
refused to leave during the hurricane for all sorts of reasons of distrust.
So the flood comes,
his village is wiped out. He's displaced with his family. And then fast forward. In this case,
one of the big inflection points is the Arab Spring. And following on from the Arab Spring,
Syria collapsed.
So the Arab Spring collapses into civil war. Tell us what Ibrahim does next.
So Ibrahim's village is flooded, and he's cast out as basically an internal refugee in
his country. He ends up in the city of Manbij, which is a city of about 150,000 people that
is near the Turkish border. It's a kind of middle of nowhere type of place. If you asked Syrians
before 2011, most of them wouldn't have even heard of this place. I certainly hadn't heard of it when
I started this research. So he ends up there. It's a kind of gritty border town. And he ekes out
a living as a day laborer. During that time, in those 10 years, Bashar al-Assad,
the son of Hafez al-Assad, takes power and institutes a series of reforms that
lead to the gutting of the social safety net and to the rise of a sort of mobile
class of laborers who end up in the Gulf states, who end up in Lebanon. So Ibrahim is one of them.
So he becomes a bricklayer in Beirut and in Jordan and elsewhere. Eventually, in 2011, protests
emerge against the dictatorship. And at first, Ibrahim isn't really taking part in any of this
because he doesn't see himself as a protester. He's not very political. The government starts
to suppress the protests and people pick up weapons to defend themselves. So the protests
mutate into a civil war. Now the government is bombing houses and he's seeing his own government
killing his neighbors and he feels he has no choice but to pick up a weapon. And the way he
tells it and the way I understand it is this is really kind of, you know,
the seed of anger that had first been planted in him 15 years earlier when he witnessed what
happened to his village. Now it flowers into full rage and he takes up a weapon and he joins
a rebel group, the Free Syrian Army, to fight against the dictatorship in the name of democracy.
We had a conversation with Umar Mohammed, who wrote Mosul Eye,
and one of the things that he describes after 2014 when ISIS comes into Mosul is the strangeness of
neighbors of his that he'd known for some time suddenly becoming ISIS commanders. I guess you
get similar accounts from the Second World War where suddenly people are becoming Nazi officials
and it's like the guy that runs the local gym or the local postman or the professor.
Tell us about that. Tell us about what you sense about how that happens, how people decide. I mean,
some of your characters are passionate poetic revolutionaries from the early
80s who have been imprisoned for 15 years. Some of them are laborers. But people make different
decisions, right? Whether to stay with the regime, go against the regime, what to make of ISIS. Two
Tell us a little bit about how you think as a human that happens, what it feels like in a place like Mambitch when suddenly characters that you've been tracing in your book pop up in completely different roles.
One of them suddenly a militia commander.
What I've realized is it's very, very, very hard to predict in advance where people are going to end up.
And I found that a person's stated ideology is usually a pretty poor predictor of where they end up.
And I'm always able to construct a story after the fact.
You know, oh, this person has an independent streak.
This person kind of is courageous.
This person has always had this raison d'etre against his betters, you know.
But it's very hard for me personally, and I think for most people to see it in real time.
And I can give an example of this from one of the characters in the book.
His name is Abdul Hadi.
When we meet him, he's in his early 20s.
He was a rising footballer in his city.
And his dream was to make the equivalent of the sort of Premier League of Syria.
He was always frustrated in that goal.
In part because he came from a pretty poor background.
And to succeed in football in Syria, typically one needs to have time away from school, have higher trainers, etc.
So he wasn't able to do that.
So he ended up not making it to the big leagues and winds up as a gym teacher.
So when the protests begin in 2011, he throws himself into it.
And he sees the protests as a vehicle for not just democracy, but a kind of social equality as well.
And for the first time in the protests, he experiences some.
Kind of version of this where he's now marching with the poor and the wealthy arm in arm against the common enemy, the dictator.
Eventually, the protesters succeed in the city and are able to overthrow the dictator just in the city.
And they end up creating like a mini, mini government, a little city state.
And he sees that some of the sort of class divides that he had been seething against earlier reappear now in this new polity.
And some of his old resentment starts to bubble up again.
And he begins to see slights everywhere, sometimes real and sometimes imagined.
And it leads him in a very dark path that when ISIS appears as political actors on the scene, he gravitates towards them, even though he at that point is he would consider himself a secular person, doesn't have a religious boner in his body.
But he sees that these are people who are going to stick it to the to the elites.
These are people who are going to fight for the common man.
And so he ends up joining ISIS.
And that's the other surprising.
I found in this book, I interviewed hundreds of people who had joined ISIS, and I found that most of them were radicalized after joining.
And I think we have the idea that people are usually read books or see YouTube videos.
They get radicalized and then they join in Syria.
At least it was the other way around.
People were joining for all sorts of sort of nonpolitical reasons, jealousies, rivalry, wanting a better job once they enter the organization.
Then they were indoctrinated and became very religious.
And that's the case with Abdel Hadi as well.
So he becomes a very important figure in ISIS as a result.
And you could have never predicted this, I think, if you had seen him.
He was in his 20s, whiskey swilling.
Actually, he I think he's bisexual or gay.
He you know, he was the last person you would expect to end up in that position.
How do you even access somebody or interview them?
I mean, presumably these people would be very worried about openly talking about being a member of ISIS.
If there are bombs raining down or they think they could get arrested or indicted for it.
I mean, are people willing to talk about that, talk about their lives in that way?
So many of the people in ISIS that I interviewed, I interviewed them right after the caliphate fell, was defeated in 2017, 2018.
And at the time I was thinking, imagine if if you were in Europe in 1945, would you try to go and find some some of the Nazis and try to understand what happened?
You know, I had a similar approach where I was trying to change.
I was trying to track down all these people who had now repudiated their past and were trying to shift to the new order, some successfully, some not.
In Abdel Hadi's case, because he remained in ISIS throughout the course of my research, it took a lot more careful work to win his trust.
And it was often through friends, you know, many of the people who I worked closely with who are researchers for the book were themselves revolutionary activists in the city.
And everyone was on the same side at one point, even though they ended up on opposite sides.
Eventually, so I was able to make use of that fact that there was these networks of trust that you could rely on.
But it took years. It took years for me to be able to win the trust of Abdel Hadi and for him to open up.
And often I would have to get aspects of his story from somebody else and bring it to him and say, is this true?
And then he'd be forced to respond to it.
One of the things I think was very, very confusing for anybody covering the Syrian conflict was the incredible variety of different organizations.
I mean, we could sort of get our head around the fact that there might be a Free Syrian Army and there might be ISIS.
But there were dozens of other things in between, some of them being funded by intelligence agencies, people from Gulf states with cash, people coming in and out of Turkey, al-Qaeda splinter groups that have broken off from ISIS and were then fighting against ISIS.
What was your sense of that and how an ordinary Syrian in Membage or wherever navigated their way between this?
Or have I sort of slightly misunderstood what's going on with all those groups?
I think that's right.
It was extraordinarily complex.
This is one reason why I decided to really focus on one city to be able to render that complexity legible in a way that I think it's much harder to do if you take a bird's eye view.
But all these different factions were not just acronyms on a page, but for people were, you know, it's a matter of life and death to know what's the identity of the group that has a checkpoint down the road from you.
You better have a pretty clear understanding of who's who.
So people learned pretty quickly on the ground what was happening.
They're only factions.
In Membage, in the year and a half that the city was, quote unquote, liberated from the regime, there was about 80 armed groups.
At the same time, there were dozens of political bodies, debating clubs, incipient political parties, different organizations, assemblies.
Then there were different councils.
There was a dozen newspapers.
This is in a city that before 2011 had one state-run newspaper.
So there was, at the same time as this explosion of different political factions and armed groups, there's also a kind of effervescence of democracy at the same time.
For somebody who is a laborer in Membage, or somebody who's running a small stall selling cigarettes and sweets, what on earth is your experience from the Arab Spring through, well, for the next sort of 10, 12 years?
I mean, presumably the economy is collapsing in Membage.
There are people walking around with guns.
Your friends are getting killed.
There are checkpoints everywhere.
And then, on the other hand, there are newspapers springing up, and there are political parties, and there's some sort of public services operating.
I mean, some people are going as refugees.
Other people are presumably trying to cross the Mediterranean into Europe.
Help me understand a little bit about what on earth that life is like.
It's like the world had been turned upside down in every way.
And I'll give an example with one of the characters from the book.
His name is Abel Oz.
He was a roadside vendor.
And a really big, muscular karate expert, because his name is taken from the fact that he says,
Oz, whenever he's doing his karate punch.
That's right.
He was kind of the foremost karate champion of the city.
And after the protests start, he throws himself into it, becomes an organizer.
And in the period in which the city was self-governing, becomes a pretty important figure in the city whose opinions and voices could command the allegiance of thousands of people.
And you can imagine.
This is just a roadside vendor who I think if he had a seventh grade education, knew nothing about politics, except in sort of the immediate sense of his neighborhood, all of a sudden become becoming somebody who is the mover of people.
And you saw this again and again, that that all the old mores, the old social structures, it kind of just disintegrated.
And on the one hand, there was something liberatory about that because it gave the opportunity for people like him to have a voice in the political stage.
On the other hand, there was also.
There was also something utterly anarchic and chaotic about that, as you referred to the insecurity, both physical insecurity with crime and the material insecurity because of the rising prices during this period, even though it was being bombed, it was still relatively safe compared to other parts of Syria.
So people were actually coming to the city to seek refuge.
So now you had a housing crunch.
It was rents were going very high.
You had a fuel crisis.
So the question of how to how to.
Turn life normal again, how to just have some basic modicum of material, physical security became the overriding political question in the city.
And it was this political question that ISIS, when they first appeared in the city and they were just six individuals who came to the city, they were able to exploit very adroitly on people's understandable, legitimate fears around security, physical and material security, exploited in such a way as to eventually be able to topple the political experiment from within.
The six people is extraordinary, isn't it?
Because it's a mini version of this story that in Mosul, a few pickup trucks of ISIS route three divisions, the Iraqi army and take over the city of many millions of people.
I mean, all the time when I'm listening to you, I keep wondering whether that's what the fall of the Roman Empire felt like, you know, whether, you know, if you were in Roman Britain after the legions retreated, whether the equivalent of the local street vendor who ran the karate club is suddenly running it and then suddenly some warlord turns up from next door.
One of the things, though, that I find most difficult when I go to Syria at the moment
is that presumably everybody remembers what people were doing, even if they've reinvented
themselves. So I'll sit down with a guy who crossed the border into Iraq, joined Al-Qaeda
Iraq, fought with Zarqawi, who was one of the most brutal commanders in Iraq, was jailed by
the Americans, comes back across the border, is close to Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, is coming back to
set up ISIS Syria, breaks away, reaches out not to bin Laden because bin Laden is now dead, but to
bin Laden's successor to get approved as running Al-Qaeda Syria, and therefore presumably is
absolutely wound into suicide bombs and all the kind of mechanisms of these terrorist groups.
And then he reemerges as a respectable government figure sitting across the table from you or
talking to you about budget issues in Damascus. I mean, how do people process this?
I mean, I've had-
I've had that exact experience many times, sitting with a, who's now a Syrian official and
very genteel person who's talking about prosaic issues. And I'd learn after the meetings over,
oh yeah, he ran a suicide squad 10 years ago. It's hard to wrap one's mind around,
but the conflict and the revolution really inducted large portions of the society into
some kind of activity. So people are all on different sides at different times. And in
members today, you can go in the house that I stay in when I'm there, you can go get a bread at the
bakery across the street. And the person working as an assistant in the bakery was a member of ISIS.
And then the person next door in a kind of haberdashery is, it was tortured by ISIS and
people are forced to live side by side. Ideally, you would want to see some kind of truth and
reconciliation commission, some kind of process that could bring some of these perpetrators to
justice. And there is, there are movements in Syria today clamoring for just that.
On the other hand, there's also a sentiment among some people, especially those who are
in power, that it's better to let bygones be bygones so that old wounds don't fester and tear
the country apart. But my sense is that these old wounds can't stay hidden. They will reappear in
some way or another, unless they're addressed head on through some kind of truth and reconciliation
process. One of the stories of your book is that often people do seem to explain their anger and
their radical actions 20 years later on the basis of what's happened to them when they're younger.
You know, Ibrahim will be angry because of what's happened to his village. Somebody else will be
angry because they didn't make it to the national soccer squad. Maybe Abu Uth is carrying some sort
of burden because he's been very badly treated by people who've lent him money and he didn't
manage to repay his debt and he's lost. So I guess that seems plausible that these things reappear.
To hear the rest of my interview, sign up at theresthispolitics.com. That's theresthispolitics.com.
Theresthispolitics.com.
Theresthispolitics.com.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The documentary explores the personal and political transformations of Syrians in Manbij through intimate stories of individuals like Ibrahim and Abdul Hadi.
Ibrahim’s early life in a village submerged by a government dam exemplifies how state actions and rural traditions shape personal trauma and later political activism.
After the Arab Spring, many Syrians, including Ibrahim, become radicalized or join armed groups, such as the Free Syrian Army or ISIS, driven by deep-seated anger and a sense of injustice.
Abdul Hadi, a former footballer and gym teacher, joins ISIS not due to religious beliefs but because he sees them as defenders of the common people against elites—showing how personal grievances can lead to radicalization.
The Syrian conflict involved a complex web of armed factions, political groups, and shifting loyalties, making daily survival and political navigation extremely difficult for ordinary citizens.
In Manbij, grassroots figures like a roadside vendor (Abel Oz) emerged as political leaders, highlighting the collapse of traditional hierarchies and the rise of local, often chaotic, governance.
ISIS exploited widespread fears of insecurity, using physical and economic instability to gain power, illustrating how desperation can drive radical ideologies.
Many former combatants or militants now live peacefully in society, creating a paradox where perpetrators and victims coexist, underscoring the need for truth and reconciliation processes.
Summary:
The episode, part of a series on existential threats, centers on Anand Gopal’s deeply human exploration of Syria through the lives of individuals in Manbij. It highlights how political upheaval—starting with the 1980s’ submersion of a farming village due to a state dam—shapes personal trauma and fuels later radicalism. Ibrahim, a young man who falls in love and is forced to end his relationship, becomes a displaced refugee and eventually joins the Free Syrian Army in response to state violence.
Meanwhile, Abdul Hadi, a former footballer turned gym teacher, enters ISIS due to disillusionment with elite power and a desire for social equality, illustrating how personal grievances can lead to radicalization. The city of Manbij becomes a microcosm of chaos: with 80 armed groups, dozens of political factions, and a surge of grassroots political action, ordinary citizens like karate champion Abel Oz rise to leadership roles. However, this anarchy is exploited by ISIS, which capitalizes on fears of insecurity to gain power.
The narrative reveals a profound paradox: many former militants now live as ordinary citizens, coexisting with their former enemies. This complexity suggests that without structured truth and reconciliation, deep societal wounds will resurface, threatening long-term peace. The stories underscore how individual experiences—familial, economic, and political—are inextricably linked to broader conflict dynamics.
FAQs
WISE is a currency transfer service that offers fair exchange rates, no hidden fees, and instant transfers in over 40 currencies. It uses the mid-market rate like Google, ensuring transparency and simplicity for users moving money across borders.
WISE provides clear exchange rates, no markups, no hidden fees, and fast transfers. It works in over 160 countries, making it a reliable and transparent option for people living abroad or sending money overseas.
Tramfiya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis. It should only be used after consulting a doctor due to potential side effects.
Serious allergic reactions, increased infection risk, and liver problems may occur. Patients must be checked for infections or tuberculosis before starting treatment and should inform their doctor if they have any symptoms.
The book explores the lives of ordinary people in Manbij, Syria, over decades, tracing how political events like the Arab Spring, the collapse of Assad’s regime, and ISIS’s rise shaped their personal and collective experiences.
Life in places like Manbij became chaotic with armed groups, checkpoints, rising prices, and insecurity. Despite the chaos, there was also a surge in political participation and community-based self-governance among ordinary people.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.