Go back

What's Worth Living For? | Dr. Atul Gawande

56m 38s

What's Worth Living For? | Dr. Atul Gawande

Dr. Atul Gawande, renowned surgeon and author of *Being Mortal*, discusses how confronting death can lead to a more meaningful, present life. Drawing from personal experiences with his father’s illness and over 200 interviews, he emphasizes that the focus should not be on prolonging life at all costs, but on living a life of purpose and dignity. He introduces a set of essential questions—about health understanding, fears, and minimum acceptable quality of life—to help patients and caregivers align care with personal values. These conversations shift the role of clinicians from mere providers to counselors, enabling better decision-making and reducing suffering. Gawande highlights that early palliative care leads to improved outcomes, including longer survival and better quality of life. He contrasts two models of aging—traditional rural independence and modern isolation in nursing homes—showing that autonomy can be preserved in supportive, community-based environments. His insights reveal how age and mortality awareness reshape priorities, with older adults valuing family and continuity over external accomplishments. He also addresses the impact of political decisions, such as the shutdown of USAID, which led to millions of preventable deaths. Finally, Gawande cautions that AI in medicine is a powerful tool but must be used with human oversight, and he advocates for global health equity as a core value in medicine. The conversation underscores that dying with dignity begins with honest dialogue, self-reflection, and a deep understanding of what truly matters in life.

Transcription

8427 Words, 45656 Characters

English
(upbeat music) Hey everybody, welcome to the 10% Happier Podcast. I am your host, Dan Harris. As a Buddhist, I am simultaneously galvanized by and terrified by the unavoidable fact of death. Galvanized because being aware of your mortality can make life more vivid and vibrant in the present moment. Terrified because like who's not afraid of dying. Today though, I'm talking to a very famous doctor who argues that we can make this process, which again is coming for all of us, much more humane. Dr. Atul Gawande is a renowned surgeon, a Harvard professor, a writer for The New Yorker, and the best-selling author of many, many books, including the one we're gonna focus on today, which is called Being Mortal. Now you might be thinking, didn't Being Mortal come out in 2014? Yes, it did. But that was before I had a podcast, and I've been meaning to have Dr. Gawande on the show for a long time, and then I found an excuse because just a few months ago, The New York Times listed Being Mortal as one of the top five books that will lift you up in hard times, which reminded me that I wanted to have Dr. Gawande on. So here he is, Dr. Atul Gawande. Welcome to the show. Thanks for having me, Dan. When my dad was still working, he was the head of radiation oncology at the Brighamon Women's Hospital in Boston, and he used to rave about this brilliant young surgeon who was writing articles for The New Yorker, and I should read those articles, and he was talking about you. So it's very nice to finally meet you. What's your dad's name? Jay Harris. Oh my God. Yes, I've shared patients with him. That's amazing, that's your dad. He's in a very different situation than when you knew him, he's had a lot of health problems. He had a stroke and had a form of Parkinson's, so he's sometimes walking case study in impermanence. Tell him hello, but also you're going through what everybody goes through, dealing with a family member who's got significant challenges now. Yes, so that brings us to your book. Again, being mortal, just one of many, many books you've written. One of the big through lines in the book was your experience with your father. Maybe let's start there. Yeah, my father was a surgeon who saw, so I'm a surgical oncologist at the Brigham and Dana Farber in Boston. My father was a urologist. My mother was a pediatrician there. I grew up in Athens, Ohio, and he developed a tumor in his brainstem and spinal cord that started causing him to have pain in his neck and a scan revealed a tumor that was too large to actually remove. And that became our three and a half year, almost four year journey with struggling through the condition he had, and the life he would be facing with it. There were things that could be done. There was operations biopsies that could be offered, chemotherapy radiation. He would take some of those choices. He would decide not to take other those choices, but what struck me was we had over a hundred years of medical training between the three of us and my sister are coming in as well as a non-medical person. And we were no better equipped than anybody else to navigate it. And I started writing the book really because I had reached a point in my career when I was confident that if you had a problem I could fix, I could give you a great chance at fixing it. But come to me with a problem like the kind of problem my father had, and I didn't even, I was uncomfortable and I didn't know even what it meant to be good at taking care of people, let alone actually being good at it. And getting to write was an excuse to start talking to people. It's strange to go as a doctor up to people and say things like, hey, can I come watch you a geriatrician in your office today? Or, can I go follow you a patient as you navigate things at home? But when you're writing an article or then writing a book, you're allowed to do those things. And it was an amazing opportunity. I also ultimately interviewed over 200 people, practitioners, patients, family members, as they all coped with these kinds of problems. You talk about this in the book, very few of us like to talk about death or to think about it. And yet, as I mentioned in the introduction, the New York Times listed being mortal as one of the top five books to read when you need to be lifted up in hard times. Why? What is it about thinking about death in the right way that can be uplifting? - So the surprise to me was the people who were best at managing these situations, understood that it was not about death, it was about living to the very end, and what it meant to have a life worth living to the very end, or to help people, your family member, a patient, navigate coming to that space. It's shocking to me that it took me all of that time, 200 interviews, et cetera, to figure out the ultimate lessons. At the core of it is the fact that people have priorities besides just living longer. They have goals and purposes that are very meaningful to them, and they aren't just to control the disease. The most effective way to learn what people's priorities are is to ask them, but we don't ask. When we don't ask, the result is the care we provide as a family member, as a clinician, anybody trying to offer help ends up being out of alignment with what matters most in their life, and the result of that is suffering. And I saw that now grasping that, interviewing lots of folks, saw that through the lens of people living in senior retirement communities and nursing homes, people navigating tough conditions like your father is with Parkinson's disease and other things. My own father with his brain tumor. And it also gave clarity about how to approach, how to be good at taking care of folks. One of the people who I spoke to a woman named Susan Block who's a esteem national expert palliative care clinician, she described to me taking care of her father who had become ill with something very similar to my father facing a spinal cord problem. And she was the one who helped distilled for me that the goal of a clinician is to identify what are your priorities, and there are questions that you can ask. Like what's your understanding of where you are with your health? What are your fears and hopes for the future if things worsen? What are you willing to endure and not willing to endure? What's the minimum quality of life? You find acceptable. And when she asked her father this question, he said, hmm, minimum quality of life. Well, if I can eat chocolate ice cream and watch football on television, that'll be good enough for me. If I can't, let me go. And it was the best living will ever. He was telling you, not do I want chest compressions, do I want to be in an ICU? Who's telling you, here's what's worth living for me. And if you can help provide it, let me do it. And then it became my favorite question to people, I asked my dad and his response was first in the early days with the tumor. What matters to me is I want to stay a surgeon. I want to keep being able to go to the operating room. And so the goals were, could he keep working? Later, as he started to get paralyzed and have numbness and pain shooting down his hand, and he couldn't operate anymore. Then he was despondent. And it's like, I don't know what's worth living for. And then he realized what he missed most was not operating. It was helping people. And he ended up running for district governor of his rotary club in Ohio. And getting to do good through a service organization kept him going and motivated and happy and fulfilled for the next couple of years. And then when he became quadriplegic with it, it became food and family around the table. The answer changed over time. How can we get better at having these conversations? And I think it's not just about having conversations with your loved ones, but also like having the conversation with yourself. And part of it is, it's more of a skill than I'd understood it to be. You can't simply ask someone, what matters to you? What's your priority? Like, what are you talking about? That understanding was distilled by Susan Block and into something that we actually took in our research center and turned into a set of questions that people could ask and started training clinicians. and using them. And those became the questions I mentioned asking things like, well, what's your understanding where you are with your health? And then being able to progress through questions like what are your hopes and fears? What are you willing to endure? And not willing to endure? What are you willing to, what's the minimum quality of life you find acceptable? And those answers help, first of all, that help the other person articulate for themselves what matters. They don't always come to those answers with clarity at the first time. But it opens the door and I found it changed, it almost physically changed my position with patients as I'm talking in the office because it suddenly felt like, you know, I'd face someone as a terminal condition, they're deteriorating and they want something that's going to save them. They want to know that they're fighting and what they're fighting for. And a lot of times in these discussions, you can feel like you're in conflict. Same thing with a parent who's starting to have issues, you know, my mother when she got older, started to have issues where we feared she was going to have a fall. And I care about is she safe? She wants to know, can I live? And her answer is, well, what I want is to be able to remain independent in my apartment. And what I want is for her to not to fall. And those turn out to be the same things from a different perspective. And so now we could say, here's what we want. How do we pursue that? How do we give her her best chance to remain safe and doing well? We eventually navigated, it took time, not driving anymore, but she learned to use Uber and Lyft, learned how to even, she started teaching people in her retirement community, how to navigate Uber and Lyft and find the cheapest ride and also talk the delivery driver, the driver into carrying your groceries, you know, up into your apartment for you and things like that. And then I found a call to go see her and oh, she's gone into town. She's doing her thing. I found myself not in conflict with patients because we were having a discussion that was different in medical school. I was taught, you lay out the options for people, the pros, the cons, the risks, the benefits of option A, B, C, D. But what I found in practice was people would always then follow up with a question, what would you do, doctor? And what I was taught in medical school and residency training is you answer that by saying, no, no, no, that's not for me to answer. Only you know what matters to you. So you tell me what your choice is and they feel abandoned in that moment. And what this was teaching me was there's another way of being and that's being a counselor and a counselor understands your goals. So now if I understand your goal is to be independent in your apartment or to gather people around your dinner table and be able to enjoy that, I can then say here's within the range of capability what we have to offer and here's what I would recommend based on my experience at getting you that goal you're looking at or whether it's realistic to expect it at all and we have to think about a change in goals. You're talking about this, about having these conversations largely from the perspective of being a physician. Although you of course referenced your parents. For the rest of us, do you have any guidelines that you think we should follow when we're inevitably thrust into these scenarios? Well, I'm imagining your conversation with your father. We have had it. Well, and you know, that conversation can start with a story. This guy we were talking to talked about a man who said, "Chalk that ice cream and football on television and that's what really matters to him. What matters to you?" Or you started by saying, "Dad, what are you willing to go through in order to achieve or to live the way you want to live?" And that is a conversation I think any of us can have. And then the trick is honoring that. There are periods in time, whether it's my mom, my wife's parents, where I didn't love the choices they were making. And you know, and sometimes you just know they're ultimately the one to take risks, not you. Sometimes you're paying for it. Sometimes there are periods in time when I thought I'm just waiting for that crisis call to come when there's a fall down the stairs that that she shouldn't have been navigating in the first place. Or when my father continued to go to do surgery, even when as his hand became paralyzed. And the nurses would actually help them. They'd help get his glove on. And you learned how to tie knots with one hand kind of stiff and unable to do it. Like, that was a source of conflict saying, "This is just going to be ended in disaster. This is not good and needing to have that." But that's, you know, a counselor can do that. A counselor when you're in that function can advocate for and say, "Yeah, here's why you quit cigarettes. Here's why you shouldn't be in the operating room and navigate in and it takes a few conversations. But we got there. Mostly it felt like Albertan was off my back that's that they're living their life and trying things and going to navigate and give them some of that chance to do that. There are so many times in my life and I suspect this is true for you where you just need a little reset, some little hack to get you out of a thoughts spiral or to help you fall back to sleep when you wake up at 3 in the morning or help you recover from some sort of temper tantrum. You know what I'm talking about. Which brings me to a little meditation challenge we're launching over on my app 10% with Dan Harris. Starting on Monday, September 21st, we're kicking off a five day meditation challenge. It's called reset and it's all about getting back on solid ground when life throws you for a loop which is inevitable in all of our lives. This challenge is guided by the amazing Diana Winston who's really legendary and fascinating and very nice meditation teacher. And crucially, she has crafted each daily practice to be something you can actually do in a moment of suffering when you're struggling in some way, large or small. These practices can literally help you reset. September 21st through the 25th, reset with Diana and friends and me over on the 10% with Dan Harris app, you can sign up now at Dan Harris dot com. You know this, but a lot of patience and and perhaps this is even more true for the family members want folks in medicine to do everything, you know, like let's do everything we can. And yet there's and you talk about this in the book, there's interesting data around moving into hospice or palliative care where you're just trying to treat the symptoms so and keep people comfortable. I have a friend just by this is anecdotal. I had a friend who was put into hospice and lived there for six years. I was told he had three days to live, three days and he lived there for six years. And so yeah, I'd just be curious about your your view on this. So one thing I'll start with before I get to the research is just saying we talk about this as, you know, I want to do everything. And the debate is not, do we want to do everything or not? The question is everything for what? Everything that we can do to accomplish what? Is it control of the disease at all costs? Is there anything you would not want to sacrifice in the course of your care? You know, my mother, she died just this past year. No, I'm sorry. Yeah. Well, she was 89, though. And she had six years with stage four ovarian cancer. And she, you know, we had a clinician who asked her these questions. I knew which clinicians to go to who'd gotten the training. And I went to one who did. She was great. And so, you know, my mother, as I said, wanted to keep her independence in her living facility. But, but enjoyed her life and wanted to be able to do the things she did from ping pong to taking walks at sunset. And, and so she did take the chemotherapy. But we, you know, the oncologist also identified the one of the drugs causing a neuropathy, a loss of sensation in her feet that could cause a fall. And when she started to get that numbness would stop that that treatment. And that's what she did. That she got surgery to remove the tumor partially. And that she navigated a colostomy understanding that that was something she was willing to to work to navigate all of those kinds of things. But then as the treatment started to take away things that were important to her, that after six years, she fell. finally halted it. She got much longer with stage four of airing cancer than anybody would have predicted. Now what I'll say is that so the research study was one that randomized people with incurable lung cancer, stage four incurable lung cancer, and randomized them to have their usual oncology care, or also see a palliative care clinician from the very beginning of their care. Often people would say, "Hey, you know, it's not time to see the palliative care clinician. We still have options." It was thought of as like a last thing you do when you run out of medical options. And instead, they said, "Let's have people getting palliative care consultation right from the very beginning." And they found that the group who got those early palliative care discussions and plans focused on things like, "How do I maximize your quality of life as well as your quantity of life?" Those people end up choosing to stop chemotherapy two months earlier than the group who were in the regular arm just continued care as normal. They had much better control of symptoms and quality of life. They had lower costs. They were less likely to spend time in the hospital. And they lived 25% longer. Because when your answer to every question is, "Well, let me just find another treatment to give. Let's get another operation." Put you on the table. You're getting all the complications and none of the benefits. And losing the things that matter to your real life when it's not planned in a way that's aligned with your goals. So it isn't a question of, "Do you get everything or do you not get everything?" It's, "Do you get to choose the assets and the options and the treatments and the capabilities that accomplish what's most important to you and your goals?" And at a certain point, your quality of life starts to become more important than your quantity of life. And ironically, caring for that quality of life helps you live better and longer. Other main focus for many of us, especially as we get older, is staying independent. But you have a whole chapter in the book that compares to grandparents, one of yours, and I would think a grandparent in law, one who insisted of living on her own and the other who just lived surrounded by his family. Yeah, can you tell the story? And also, what does it say about our thirst for independence? And they're both complicated cases, right? So one was my grandfather, who was in India, a farmer in a rural village, and living the way, you know, farming societies have lived for thousands of years, that you have an extended family, you know, your children would inherit the farm and they'd become farmers. And that extended family would end up taking care of you into your old age. He continued, he died at the age 108. He continued to be, you know, sit at the head of the table at dinner and be the first one served. He was still continued to be largely with it. He would still walk his fields. He, you know, he died falling off of a bus when he was still wanting to do his thing. He was headed to the court to contest someone who'd failed to pay back alone and hit his head. And, you know, that kind of society where family takes care of you and right to the end and you remain the patriarch or the matriarch or the family succeeded, but at the cost of the freedom of your child in India, in this case, it's particularly the daughter-in-law. The one who marries your eldest son becomes the person to take care of you and then in this case when they died because he lives so long, you know, it'd be the next oldest daughter or daughter-in-law. And people as economies improved sought freedom for themselves. Young people wanted freedom and we became, you know, nuclear atomized families and you had the rise that you see in India now even of nursing homes and senior retirement communities and all of those things. The other story was of the life and ultimate death of my wife's grandmother, Alice Hobson, and Alice lived for years in a home on her own valued that independence. But gradually became more and more isolated, started having some cognitive issues. Someone working as a landscaper took advantage of that and had her write multiple checks to him for the same services over and over again. And she had a car crash that went into the yard of her neighbor across the street and that ultimately landed her in a assisted living facility in a place that was more like a hospital than a home. Whenever we'd come to see her, she'd always say, when am I getting to go home? And you'd say, you are home, this isn't home. And understanding what does it mean to enable freedom for young people, lives that everybody wants to live. And the fact that even when adults even have their choices, older adults, they often prefer not to be in the home of a child because now I'm under their rules. I'm living the way that they insist I live. And so, you know, sociologists call it the people prefer an intimate distance that you live nearby, but just far away that I also have my independence and community and education and goals and activities that go beyond Bingo and watching television. Those kinds of places exist more and more. My parents are in a place like that. And it's been very interesting to, you know, my mother has her cat with her and is very, was not particularly social as a, you know, in her prime, but she's very, she's like the mayor of this assisted living facility. And yes, it's really thriving at one point said, you know, I'm just the happiest period of her life. If you get it right, I mean, so many people, I mean, so many parents of my friends who, you know, if I bring up assisted living, you know, that it strikes terror in their soul, but if you get it right in assisted living can be fantastic. Yes. There's these distinctions between senior living communities that have assisted living and nursing homes. And the best way to understand it is that the places that many people end up plugging into are ones where you can live in independent apartments, independent apartments. You can get services there. Some end up needing assisted living where you are at a higher level of services. And then some need full 24 hour day nursing home assistance. And enabling those in environments that don't feel like you're in a hospital, you know, I interviewed people being admitted for the first time to a assisted living or a nursing home level facility. And they react, their experience was that it was like jail. They couldn't have their own furniture. They, you woke up and went to bed at the same time every day. You know, you'd wake up, you'd get changed by an orderly. You'd be, you'd get in the pill line. You'd go eat, you know, what you're told to eat. And that has evolved considerably, but not consistently. Many, many places are quite different from one another. My mother, for example, was in a senior retirement community located on a college campus. And she could take courses in the college with the students. And as she was a former pediatrician, so she loved the connection to young people. The young people worked at their center. Sometimes, you know, some of them were learning physical therapy students. Some of them were staffing the cafeteria. Some of them were involved in activities in vice versa. And she started a ping pong club every day. And I remember walking in one day to pick her up for lunch. And the group was all bursting out into tears, laughing. Three of the four were at various stages of dementia, some cognitive significant cognitive impairment. My mother had mild cognitive impairment, nothing, nothing near dementia. And she, I finally got to say, what are you guys laughing about? And my mom said, none of us can keep the score. I'm the only one who can keep the score, but I can only keep the score if I call out the score every time at the end of every point. And I forgot to call out the score at the end of the last point. And now we're lost. And what brought home to me, I, you know, if I answer the question, what are my priorities, you know, what's a minimum quality of life I'd find acceptable? I would have said any thing that would give me dementia is not an acceptable life. And here were, here one of her best friends had significant dementia, but she was having joy in her life. She could enjoy and play ping pong, you know, enough to have fun, turned up every day, and had lots to talk about with my mom, didn't necessarily remember everything. And my mom loved her and she loved my mom. And that was an extraordinary lesson to me. And she wasn't, you know, imprisoned. She was in a place she actually felt was her home. It's now been more than 12 years since you wrote your book Being Mortal. Where are you in terms of processing your own mortality? I'm now past 60, so that was a different place than when I read the book in my mid 40s. And I would say, you know, when we looked for, we moved to DC for work in the, in the last administration. And we actually decided that we would look for a place that's on one floor, just in case we're staying long enough that we should age and want to, you know, make it, make it convenient. But I would say I'm still, you know, at age 60, the average American who has access to healthcare, access to good public health as well, will live 90 years on average. So I'm aware on the one hand that I'm on the back end of the, of the age curve. Living my life still as the way you do when you think you have an infinite amount of time. I have plenty of things I'm ambitious about trying for, et cetera. But Laura Carson, since the Stanford researcher that I wrote about, has followed people as the age or as they became ill. She started studying the 1980s as the AIDS crisis hit. And it included people who suddenly became ill with HIV AIDS at a time when there was no treatment available and that a descends. And what she saw was people who are older or facing their mortality behave differently than younger people who have a long time ahead of them. Younger people will prioritize spending time with going to a nightclub on a Friday night and hoping to meet new people will focus on their job opportunities, acquisition of contacts, income, homes, you know, your status in the world. And as we get older, you think you're going to become unhappier, you're going to become depressed. In fact, as you get older, anxiety and depression decline, you develop capacity for a wider range of emotion, like, there's a bittersweet feeling of nostalgia, being able to live with, you know, a contradictory sense of things being bitter and sweet at the same time. And you tend to close your circles more, you focus more on family, the closer friends you have, relationships, and less on those other things. And the interesting thing was during this study, that's the pattern you saw even when young people became sick. It wasn't a brain development thing, it was a perspective, it's whether you had a perspective that you had a shorter amount of time or essentially an infinite amount of time. And if you had less than 10 years, then you felt you had a shorter amount of time. If you had more than 20 years, you basically acted as if life was infinitely long. And you really fell into these two categories. But there would be moments that came during the study, 9/11 happened. And they were doing the study in Hong Kong and the SARS epidemic happened. And at that moment, everybody reverted to a life as fragile approach. They wanted to go home instead of hanging out in the nightclub. They wanted to see family, they cared about pulling together and what really matters. And they were actually relieved of some of the anxiety, depression, things like that. And then six months later, they were back to how we lived. And so I'm still in the stage of trying to do stuff, going on a podcast with you. I still have things that I'm excited about and interested in solving in the world and trying to address and new things I want to try and new people I want to meet. But I am transitioning to also nurturing these friendships that have gone on now for 40, 50 years in my life and make time for staying close with them. Just came back from a week, summer holiday that we take with five other families where we've been gathering together for 40 years. And those things start to matter more and more where I was kind of liable to blow it off a couple of decades ago. It's so interesting that you can write a whole book about mortality and still kind of in the back of your mind, even though you know it's irrational, feel like you're going to live forever. Because I don't have evidence every day of my mortality. I have things that, you know, they're different from my 40s. I'm aware that I'm having losses, that I'm not gaining things back, I'm not as fast as I used to be. I don't think as fast as I used to think and finding ways to compensate for those things. I'm an avid tennis player and I now having to change my game considerably at 60 where, you know, I was power and to some extent speed and now I have to be much smarter. I think I actually played better than I used to and I'm holding my game up at least by playing smarter. It's such an interesting kind of bug in the human operating system that we know intellectually we're going to die, but we don't live like it. You know, I think there's a great line in the Indian epic, the Mahabharata. I think that's how you pronounce it and the line is one character asks the other, what's the most wondrous thing in the world and the other person says that we're surrounded by aging illness and death and yet we don't think it's going to happen to us. What do you think that's about? Well, I mean, the average lifespan of human beings right into the beginning of the 20th century was to your mid 40s and the fact that we doubled the human lifespan worked against nature and now we're living beyond our nature and in that period we have an extended range of being able to live with fragility and our management systems, our internal biological management systems are made for expecting demise to occur fairly rapidly once you start having aches and pains and limitations and cardiac condition or lung condition, whereas now you can live decades with all of those things and live a much higher quality of life than ever in history. And so we adjust our perspective based on what really Lower Carsonson's work showed is that we tune our perspective based on the evidence of whether we're actually mortal and fragile and when we don't have immediate evidence of our own mortality when you're not waking up and every few weeks realizing your cancer is progressing or your heart disease is bringing you to an end stage, then you have purpose and things that you do live for and that's why those questions matter, one of the things I argue in the book is everybody has a loyalty, something that they're willing to sacrifice themselves for, even die for, that matters to them and that might be your kids, it might be an idea, it might be a project and accomplishment, it might be beauty, religion, getting to serve, figure out those things and then serve them is what matters and can matter all the way to the very end. And I think in our, as we get older and get to live these long much longer lives than human beings had, we get to serve purposes like that for much longer periods of time. What are your purposes? You know, what would I really sacrifice myself for? My family for one, my children, my wife, my sibling, my sister? Number two, I would say, is I've found purpose in trying to make the systems around health better. I've been fascinated for my whole career around the idea that we have learned how to double the human lifespan, but don't know how to deliver it affordably, effectively give people these opportunities to achieve their loyalties. I'm interested both in the human experience and how we make our systems more effective at addressing those kinds of problems. And a lot of my work and jobs is sort of at that public level of making our systems better and more effective over time for solving these problems along the way. Those are my two big ones. For whatever reason, I get a lot of pleasure and joy out of whacking a little yellow tennis ball around a square box, and that also goes right in there. It's one of my priorities. I can't I can't figure it out, but I'll do that for hours. I buy it. I get tennis elbow, so I can't really do it, but when I get a chance to do it, it's very fun. And you're doing it with other people. You're moving the body. All those things feel good. I've been talking with my friends that there's ball people and nonball people I've decided. The ball people can't make any sense of people who want to go biking three hours up a mountain or endurance running or any of those things like runners. Put me 10 minutes down a road. I'm like, what the hell am I doing? Why am I doing this? This seems crazy. But then they say the nonball people say, why are you chasing a little yellow tennis ball around? What keeps you going for two and a half hours doing that? And the ball people just like throwing a ball in a basket or hitting one over a net, that talk about strange wiring. Both of those are bizarre. I'm not non-binary in this regard. I like both. You do both. So there are people who are both. Yeah. I mean, I do much more of the nonball stuff because I have so many injuries that prevent me from playing tennis or doing other things. But I would, if left in my own devices, I would liberally do both. Speaking of aging. After the book, you move to Washington, as you mentioned, and we're running USAID, which is for people who don't know it. One of the self-power wings of the US government, where we spend money to help people in other countries. And we've just lived through a time where the Trump administration gutted it. One study from the Lancet, I believe, said that this conservatively has probably led or will lead to tens of not hundreds of thousands of unnecessary deaths. I'd just be curious what your, yeah, how you're processing all this, what your thoughts are, how you think we should think about it. Yeah. And my role there wasn't leading the whole thing. I led the global health work of USAID, which is one of its biggest areas. My observations all stem from why I even took the job in the first place. Much of my work that I'd excited by including this work around aging in the end of life is around making it possible for people to get the benefits of everything we have discovered to enable a longer, better life. And one of those gaps comes from simply poverty in the world. The lowest income places in the world have half the survival rate of other places. And getting to USAID, and then you'll lead its global health work, turn out to be the best job in medicine I've ever had. And likely the best job in medicine you've never heard of. I had 3,000 people in 65 countries and Washington, DC, employing on the one hand, what seemed like a lot of money, $8 billion a year. On the other hand, was about half of my hospital budget in Boston. $22 per American taxpayer out of $15,000 in American tax bill. But with that, we were reaching hundreds and millions of people by strengthening systems for vaccination, for reducing deaths in childbirth, for addressing HIV, malaria, TB, for fighting outbreaks and preventing those outbreaks from reaching home. And the result of that was has been documented to be over the last 20 years, 90 million lives saved. In the countries where we worked, we cut the child mortality rate, 32% and the overall mortality rate by 15%. It was great for the people we were serving and supporting. It strengthened countries to get onto their own feet. And I saw this from India, where my parents grew up and where I would visit as a kid. That, you know, not only did we give food aid, but we provided the technology, scientific training and so on, for what's called the Green Revolution, where India went from a food recipient country to the fourth largest exporter of food in the world, feeding the rest of the world and not only itself. And in those kinds of accomplishments, I got to build on. It was incredible as an experience. So to come out the day that I left, noon on inauguration day as the great American tradition, and the election changed the president, and we peacefully handed over power and responsibility to the Trump administration. And then with an hour's trumpet sign in order to freeze and halt all of the work of USAID. Like overnight, a complete dead stop. Food, aid, left to rod in warehouses, medicines on the shelf, not allowed to be used. Staff pulled out and sent home. I've been bearing witness to what has happened. It was on an argument that USAID was a criminal enterprise, was corrupt, didn't accomplish anything. And what's difficult is that was just a lie. The work immediately had consequences. And there have been now two different estimates that have put it in the ballpark of about 700,000 lives lost in 2025 from the shutdown of everything from HIV drug distribution to TV programs to outbreak prevention and surveillance. So we are still in the bomb blast radius. There's more ongoing damage. There's some of the work that has come back. Then there's been a strong backlash. Not only from liberals, this has been a longstanding bipartisan supported effort over 60 years since John of Kennedy formed USAID. And I don't think it's for nothing that on the one hand, there's been a cut of 40 billion dollars for overall assistance to countries. But a rise of half a trillion dollars in the war costs that we have because we've walked away from the idea that we offer a helping hand first before we show a fist of domination to how we approach the world. And it's not only unpopular broad, it's unpopular at home. We see America as being a force for good in the world. USAID was one of the ways that did that and people want to have those kinds of efforts continued. So the Republicans and Democrats came together to vote the budget that restored funds for foreign assistance and keeping the shell of USAID intact. The administration is not necessarily going to spend that. They have held that funding back, but we'll see what happens. One last question from me before we get to our final segment. What's your take on AI in medicine and how we as patients should be interacting with AI if at all when it comes to our health? The best description I've heard is to say that AI is not going to replace your doctor, but doctors who use AI are going to replace doctors who don't use AI. And as an intelligence at our side, I already see the ways that it can be dramatically useful. You know, most of many clinicians have adopted AI, they call them ambient scribes that will record and do your note-taking for you. And it's reduced the time that doctors require to write their medical notes and spend more time with patients. You'll see patients getting more people turning to AI can get better information and more clarity. Taking it as gospel is a bad idea. I often, when I'm asking questions of an AI bot, will ask multiple ones so that I'm triangulating among different sources. It might be Claude, it might be Gemini, it might be OpenAI. So I think there's important value that AI is bringing And not seeing the signs that AI is different from other technology breakthroughs that have come before. We have had technology breakthroughs that gave us the GLP-1 drugs, for example, for controlling obesity that have replaced surgery for ulcers with a pill. And AI is going to be another one of those things. It might be very soon the best reader of your mammogram. It may be the best initial diagnostic for some dermatologic conditions, but knowing which ones it's going to be the best for, which ones it's not, and what to do now based on what it's advising, how to deal with the risk of being wrong, et cetera. Those are still things that you want to have a copilot with. And I'd want a clinician who uses these capabilities alongside, and as a patient, I want to use this kind of information with people I trust as clinicians. A lot of promise, a lot of peril, a lot to be figured out. Let's do this. We've been doing this closing segment, we're just a couple of weeks into trying this. It's called What's Good. Just ask the guests, what are you excited about, and it could be a book, movie, record, don't say anything in tennis. You've already used up all of your tennis chits here. Could be just some little practice or habit you've formed in your life, and then I'll give you one for mine. The first thing I thought of was the lunch I had today where my wife has showed me that if you put chimichurri on a ham and cheese sandwich, it's amazing, and it is amazing. So, there's that. That sounds disgusting, we need to talk about it. It's absolutely delicious. But life is good right now because I finished my first draft of my next book. I've got a cool project we're working on to find new ways of addressing our shortage of mental health beds for people, I just get excited by things like that, and a little chimichurri. What's the next book? The next book, and I haven't learned how to describe it really adequately, but the topic is how minds change, so how do people change their minds about things. We've at a time when we feel kind of hopeless that anybody is going to change their minds, it is mining and understanding how do we do things like, we got cigarettes out of bars and restaurants and airplanes, we have solved many problems, and are in fact solving, continued to solve many problems, and so it's understanding how people actually get things done in the face of resistance, including things that I've tried to get done. There's many failures I talk about along the way as well, but that's the next book. That's fascinating. Will you come back on when the book comes out? Yes. I'm going to hold you to that. It's not so probably until the end of next year, but I do have the first draft on. Great. Congratulations. I'll give you one from my side. It's a TV show that I just started watching with my wife called Furious, it's on Hulu. It's incredibly well done. All of the performances are just incredibly powerful, but the writing and the subject matter are very powerful. It's really about female rage. It's about female rage. It's about a female serial killer and the female cop who chases her down. When I first heard the conceit, I was like, I don't know, but actually it's extremely well done. Not, again, not only just on the level of the performances, but on the issues it explores. Elizabeth Mary Weather is the woman who created and wrote it. She also wrote and created a show called The Dropout, which was about what's on that woman who had that bullshit blood testing company- Oh, Elizabeth Holmes? Yes. She did that when that won all the awards a couple of years ago. Now she's back with Furious, and I'm annoying my wife because as we watch it, I just keep saying this is so good. This is so good. That's amazing. Well, that's a great recommendation. I always end up watching these mainly cop shows, especially British cop shows, watching this Irish, well, Northern Irish cop show called Blue Nights now, which is- The Nights are blue lights. Blue lights, you're right. Blue lights. I've been meaning to check that out. It's harrowing, but I'm completely absorbed. I might use that on a future, what's good segment after watching it. Such a pleasure to finally meet you again. You heard about you decades ago and have read you in the New Yorker and it's great to meet you and I really appreciate your time. Thanks for asking me on. Look forward to it again. One last thing before I let you go. If you want to listen to this show without ads, check out 10% happier plus, which is a subscription that is available right inside Apple podcasts. If you become a subscriber, you'll get every episode ad free. That's new episodes and all the episodes from our vast 10-year plus archive. Look for 10% happier plus in Apple podcasts and just hit subscribe. And a quick heads up. If you're already a subscriber to my app, 10% with Dan Harris, you've already got access to ad free podcasts. Ad free listening is baked right into your app subscription, along with everything else, so please don't pay twice. You can check out the app at Dan Harris.com and you can check out 10% happier plus inside Apple podcasts. Thank you very much for listening to the show. I deeply appreciate it. See you soon. Dooses. Thank you so much to everybody who worked so hard to make this show. 10% happier is produced by Tara Anderson, Marissa Schneiderman, DJ Cashmere, David Hart, and Hayden Broome. Our recording and engineering is handled by the great folks over at Pod People and Nick Thorburn of the Indy Rock Band Islands wrote our theme. Thanks for listening. Peace.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Dr. Atul Gawande argues that facing mortality humanely requires focusing on living a life of purpose, not just extending lifespan.
  2. The most effective way to understand patient priorities is through open, compassionate conversations—especially asking about fears, hopes, and minimum acceptable quality of life.
  3. Early palliative care integration improves quality of life, reduces hospitalizations, lowers costs, and extends survival in patients with terminal illness.
  4. Independence and autonomy are deeply personal; environments like assisted living can be fulfilling when aligned with individual values and goals.
  5. Societal shifts—from extended family care to nuclear families and nursing homes—reflect evolving desires for personal freedom and meaningful connection.
  6. People’s behavior and priorities change with age, shifting from external achievements to deeper family bonds and emotional continuity.
  7. AI in medicine enhances care but does not replace doctors; its value lies in supporting clinicians, not replacing human judgment or empathy.
  8. True progress in healthcare requires addressing global inequities, as seen in USAID’s work saving millions of lives, and protecting such efforts from political dismantling.

Summary:

Dr. Atul Gawande, renowned surgeon and author of *Being Mortal*, discusses how confronting death can lead to a more meaningful, present life. Drawing from personal experiences with his father’s illness and over 200 interviews, he emphasizes that the focus should not be on prolonging life at all costs, but on living a life of purpose and dignity.

He introduces a set of essential questions—about health understanding, fears, and minimum acceptable quality of life—to help patients and caregivers align care with personal values. These conversations shift the role of clinicians from mere providers to counselors, enabling better decision-making and reducing suffering. Gawande highlights that early palliative care leads to improved outcomes, including longer survival and better quality of life.

He contrasts two models of aging—traditional rural independence and modern isolation in nursing homes—showing that autonomy can be preserved in supportive, community-based environments. His insights reveal how age and mortality awareness reshape priorities, with older adults valuing family and continuity over external accomplishments. He also addresses the impact of political decisions, such as the shutdown of USAID, which led to millions of preventable deaths.

Finally, Gawande cautions that AI in medicine is a powerful tool but must be used with human oversight, and he advocates for global health equity as a core value in medicine. The conversation underscores that dying with dignity begins with honest dialogue, self-reflection, and a deep understanding of what truly matters in life.

FAQs

The book emphasizes that people should focus on living a meaningful life rather than just extending their lifespan. It argues that understanding and honoring personal priorities—like independence, family, or hobbies—is essential for quality of care in end-of-life situations.

By asking open-ended questions like 'What matters most to you?' or 'What would make your life worth living?' These questions help patients and families clarify their values and goals, leading to care that aligns with their true priorities.

Because discussing death is uncomfortable and taboo, but Dr. Gawande shows that doing so allows people to focus on living fully and authentically, which can actually be uplifting and empowering.

Examples include being able to eat chocolate ice cream and watch football, staying independent in their homes, helping others through service work, or maintaining meaningful relationships and daily routines.

Early palliative care leads to better quality of life, reduced hospital stays, lower costs, and longer survival—because patients make informed choices aligned with their values rather than pursuing treatments solely to extend life.

Independence means living on one's own with autonomy over daily decisions, while senior living communities offer support and services. When designed well, such communities can foster joy, connection, and purpose rather than isolation or confinement.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.