The "Cruel Kids" cover from New York Magazine in 2025 symbolized a peak of cultural dominance by young conservative activists who celebrated Donald Trump’s second inauguration with a performative, elitist, and often misogynistic aesthetic. These youth, many of whom were affluent or connected, gathered at a TikTok-sponsored event featuring influencers, influencers in MAGA hats, and displays of wealth and sexuality. The event represented a broader cultural movement rooted in patriarchal ideals, anti-trans sentiment, and a rejection of 2010s openness. However, by 2026, the movement had collapsed due to public backlash over corruption, ICE deportations, and the administration’s perceived self-dealing. The midterms saw a historic "blue tsunami," with Republicans losing more seats than in 50 years, and young voters decisively rejecting MAGA ideology. Former participants, including influencers and attendees, have distanced themselves from the movement, with many rebranding or altering their public personas. Influencers like Hannah Neilman and Nara Smith have shifted from promoting "trad wife" lifestyles to embracing more authentic, modern identities. The episode underscores a cultural reckoning: the era of performative conservatism, fueled by privilege and toxicity, has ended, and many of its participants are now confronting the consequences of their past actions. The narrative reveals a shift not just in political power, but in cultural self-awareness, as those once celebrated for their "cruel" energy now reflect on their roles in a changing society.
end of an era. Here we go. Hello, hello, and welcome back to A Bit Fruity. I'm Matt Bernstein.
I'm so happy that you're here. In late January 2025, days after the second inauguration of
Donald Trump as President of the United States, New York Magazine published a cover story that
struck a nerve. The Cruel Kids table, in bold white letters, printed atop a photograph of white,
wealthy-looking 20-somethings in slip dresses and tuxedos, partying it up in Washington, D.C.,
on the weekend of Trump's return to power. Quote,
out late with the young right as they contemplate cultural domination, read the subheading.
The article's reporting took place at the Power 30 Awards,
a MAGA inauguration youth party at the Saks Restaurant and Lounge, sponsored by TikTok.
It was swarmed with influencers in MAGA hats, popular kids from Southern fraternities and
sororities, and featured a performance by Waka Flocka Flame. You could take photos with
life-size cardboard cutouts of Donald Trump, J.D. Vance, and Elon Musk in cowboy hats.
Quote, the roaring 20s are back, wrote one.
Maga influencer on Twitter, in a tweet that now has 47 million impressions.
Listeners of this podcast know that I tend to fixate on things for better or for worse,
and for two years, I've never stopped thinking about the Cruel Kids table. I actually made an
episode where I talked at length about this with Kat two years ago when this magazine cover was
published. I never stopped thinking about it. Because as easy as it was at the time to mock
these young right-wing partygoers,
visibly sloppy drunkenness or how the photography lighting made their clothing look cheap or how
they simply came across as assholes in their gilded nightclub, that all felt secondary to
the primary truth, which was that they had won. They had won not just all three branches of
government, but also the culture. Where pushback to Trump's first inauguration in 2017 consisted of
daily marches in every major city for weeks,
the response to his second, if you remember, felt like political and cultural defeat.
The celebrities weren't at the women's marches anymore. They were at the pre-inauguration
crypto ball where Snoop Dogg performed. The 2010s culture of relative openness I'd come of age in
was replaced by alpha males and clean girls. Cruelty was cool again. Slurs were in vogue.
The person who bullied you in high school,
it was going to get the last laugh after all. And you were just going to have to suck it up
and deal with it. But that was two years ago. And two years later, the MAGA movement has,
if you haven't heard, all but completely fallen apart. As it turns out, starting in a legal war
that doubles the price of gas, covering up the Epstein files, tearing apart communities with
ICE raids and turning it into state TikTok content, complaining endlessly about the zero
transgender NCAA athletes.
Lining the pockets of your extended family through corrupt foreign dealings
proved unpopular in practice. Who would have thought?
The 2026 midterms, which will go down in history as the blue tsunami,
was an extinction level loss for MAGA. Republicans lost more seats in a single
election than they have in 50 years. People under 30 who swung rightward in the 2024 election and
helped elect Trump in the first place or second place, I suppose, just voted to eject MAGA from,
government by a margin of 50 points. But what happened to the cruel kids? The ones who graced
that magazine cover, who celebrated their work, getting Trump into office that weekend in D.C.,
who laughed and got wasted while the rest of us grieved. As one Twitter user, Madison Tate,
put it, Nita, where are they now for these busted ass clowns? Well, my friends, I've done the leg
work and I know where they are now. I want to tell you about it.
And more broadly, I want to tell you about how the conservative MAGA youth movement of the 2020s
fell apart and who paid the consequences and who made it out OK. And to do that,
we are joined once again, two years after the original cover came out by Kat Tenbarge,
who is for the first time on this podcast, a married woman.
Wow. The mood is so much more jubilant than it was two years ago when we first talked about
this.
I'm also like conservatism is dead and also Kat's now married.
Gay married.
It's right. It's gay married. So it does really play into this.
A true callback to Obama era optimism in my gay marriage.
Yeah, right. Imagine I know where all the cruel kids are now. They're all gay married.
No, unfortunately, I actually got like emotional writing that intro last night
because.
I remember the week of Trump's inauguration felt like for those of us who, you know,
follow politics really closely all the time or or even just feel its effects because one has
no choice. It was like the most miserable weekend I can remember. Oh, yeah. Because it felt like
the resistance, as it were, to Trump was just over. It felt like we had to lie down and take it.
And I wonder if you could like, I don't know, recall,
how you felt at that time.
Oh, yeah. I mean, I felt emotional just listening to you read that intro. And I mean, both times
that Trump got elected, the vibes in the immediate aftermath were total despair. But the second time
around, it was like this feeling of we even know what to expect in a way that feels more definitive
than the first time, because you're right that back in 2016 and 2017, Trump's election,
was met with a massive wave of backlash. And all of these institutions were in shock and open despair
that this had been able to happen. But the second time around, it was like a total capitulation.
I went from crying with a group of college students in a bathroom on campus to crying at home on my
couch with like my now wife and one of my best friends. And what my best friend was saying was
like, I can't do this again. I can't do this again. And it was just this finality to it where
it was like, how on earth is history repeating itself, leading into a month of genuine despair
as Trump just immediately began rolling out executive order after executive order,
enacting these horrific dystopian policies, the very things he had promised on the campaign trail.
Yeah. And I mean, even just if we were to
view American life as a whole, I mean, I don't know. I mean, I don't know. I don't know. I don't
the Kardashians, which at any point, it probably is a relevant exercise to do that.
I mean, in the wake of the backlash to Trump, the first time we had the Kendall Jenner Pepsi
commercial, famously, which was like a complete and total disaster for so many reasons. But the
fact that it was made in the first place, which if you don't remember, it was basically they had
like fashioned this Pepsi commercial starring Kendall Jenner after a Black Lives Matter protest.
And then she hands a can of Pepsi to a line of cops, and then they like shake hands and racism
is over. It was like it is one of the worst commercials of all time. But the fact that
Pepsi, this like multinational corporation, felt that the thing that was in vogue at the time
was this culture of resistance and protest did speak to the moment. Whereas on the weekend that
Trump was inaugurated the second time, I just remember on Kim,
Kardashian's Instagram story was a photo of Melania Trump arriving with that fuck ass hat
she wore that many have said was strategically designed so that she wouldn't have to actually
kiss Trump physically. But it was this like tacit endorsement by Kim Kardashian, like
I don't know, like the quintessential American celebrity to a lot of people of the fact that
like Trump's back. This is what it is now. And we're going to make it.
Fashionable. And we're going to make it hot because, you know, we're like, we're the cruel
kids. This is it now. Yes. The vibes were literally like, this is what Americans want.
And this is what Americans have decided, which was really strange, especially in retrospect,
because the election wasn't even that definitive. The election was super close. And yet all of these
elite media institutions and celebrities were acting like MAGA was 80 percent of the country.
Instead of like 51 percent of the voters. Right. And now they want us to forget that they did that
and they are acting like it is 2017 again. And I'm like, that's weird because a lot of you refuse to
say anything out of terror that you would lose your popularity or you would face some sort of
blowback, which a lot of entertainers were at the time. Which brings me to a disclaimer that I want
to make before we talk about where everyone is now. Where are these?
Cruel kids are now. Who even are they? Which is that, you know, I took this exercise upon myself
that we are going to go through in this episode.
Not just because I saw so many people online this week asking publicly, like, what happened to the MAGA youth movement? Like, where are all these young people now? Though I am naturally curious about that. But I feel on a deeper level, like, we live broadly in the US, but then especially in Trump's second term, we live in this like post accountability society.
I feel like that was very well represented by the total and complete cover up of the Epstein files. But I think it was also represented in Hakeem Jeffries right after we just won the midterms again. Hakeem Jeffries going on CNN and saying the American people don't want accountability. The American people want us to deliver on their material needs. And it's like, actually, I think the American people want both.
The American people don't want us to get even.
They want us to get things done on their behalf.
And of course, he's speaking on like, you know, holding all of these elected officials accountable. And, you know, all of the corrupt dealings of the Trump administration and holding ICE accountable. And, you know, all these people who have carried out these heinous acts that have torn up our country and communities over the last two years. But like, I also want cultural accountability.
Yeah.
Because I feel like we live in this endless loop that you were just describing.
Yeah.
Because we had this period of relative openness in the 2010s that then transformed into this, you know, conservative youth movement that so many people suffered under. And now that that's collapsed and become unpopular, like, I actually want to remember that that happened.
Absolutely. I mean, I don't even have enough fingers to count the number of podcasters who endorsed Trump, who literally appeared alongside him, let alone, you know, co-signed MAGA 2.0, who are now.
Absolutely. I mean, I don't even have enough fingers to count the number of podcasters who endorsed Trump, who literally appeared alongside him, let alone, you know, co-signed MAGA 2.0, who literally appeared alongside him.
All right. So I've always been curious about who the cruel kids were. How do you end up at a TikTok-sponsored Trump inauguration ball anyway? As it turns out, some of the attendees were famous or semi-famous influencers who we'll talk about, but most, including everyone on the New York Magazine cover, were not. They were just rich or well-connected or both. I aggressively sought out these young MAGA movers and shakers.
including putting a call on my Instagram story asking if anyone knew who they were, to which one person replied,
If you don't know who they are, it seems like they might not have succeeded at that attempt at dominating the culture almost two years ago.
Touché.
The TikTok Power 30 Trump inauguration ball was thrown by a then 27-year-old woman named Raquel Debono, who fashioned herself into a conservative woman influencer over the years.
Raquel touts the slogan, Make America Hot Again, calls herself a barstool conservative, and throws parties for young conservatives in metropolitan areas.
Raquel seemed extraordinarily proud of the clout she amassed for throwing such a viral event and posted the magazine cover on her Instagram with the caption, Cultural Domination.
I don't know, Raquel. I don't know.
What the? Barstool conservative is such a crazy self-descriptor.
But I also. I also kind of know exactly what she's getting at here.
Like, she's like, I want to be one of the guys.
One of the grossest guys imaginable.
And I'm like, okay.
That's what you want, sure.
Yeah, and I've talked about this before on this podcast, too.
But a lot of the early MAGA youth energy, especially among women, was like, we're not like these old sort of like traditionally feminine, like sexless virgins.
But a lot of the early MAGA youth energy, especially among women, was like, we're not like these old sort of like sexy virgins.
And I think that's what's so crazy about this.
We're like, actually, like, very sexual and we're hot.
Like, Raquel Debono's whole thing was like, Make America Hot Again.
But what my colleagues at InBid with the Right, what they pointed out about this form of conservatism was that it was still a sexuality based on male desire.
Yeah, and you look at what happened to all of the women podcast hosts at Barstool and how Dave Fortnoy treated all of them.
And I'm just like scratching my head a little bit at what they think their own personal outcome is going to be here.
Anyway, I reached out to Raquel for comment, and she did get back to me.
She said,
Despite what people think, Trump himself is culturally far more socially liberal than the traditional religious right.
MAGA was becoming a movement that wasn't necessarily defined by religion or social conservatism, but by a broader cultural movement.
I think the movement has lost some of its power.
Some of the cultural momentum that made it so exciting in 2024.
I support enforcing immigration laws, but why are we turning deportations into a spectacle on social media?
It's tacky in bad taste.
My biggest concern, though, is the apparent self-dealing and conflicts of interest within the administration.
Corruption and political opportunism aren't unique to Trump, but the scale and brazenness of some of what we're seeing is particularly troubling.
And then there's the general circus surrounding the White House.
The messaging is terrible, optics worse.
It feels more like a reality show than a functioning administration.
She added that she does not regret her participation in the movement.
Okay, Raquel.
Look, the morning after the 2024 election,
I called a friend.
A friend of mine.
A woman who's a little bit older than me.
And she was like, Matt, a lot of people are just going to have to realize they were duped.
And that is exactly what happened.
And like, on one hand, I'm happy that it happened.
And then on the other hand, I'm like, you didn't think that Trump was going to be a self-dealing, corrupt politician with conflicts of interest all the way throughout his administration?
Why?
Why?
Why?
Why?
Yeah.
Why did you?
Why are you shocked?
Also, calling ICE deportations fine, but the aesthetic tacky is, in fairness, a take I haven't heard before.
So, you know, whatever.
Can I give you my most cynical reading of this?
Yeah, absolutely.
I find it very hard to believe.
I know we talk about this sort of amnesia that people, to be fair, across the political spectrum, but especially on the right, will exhibit around Trump and his administration.
Because it's like, if you were sentient during the first Trump administration,
you can't forget the fact that it was already a reality TV show administration.
You can't forget that Trump is a reality TV star.
You can't forget the circus.
You can't forget the social media antics.
You can't forget any of this stuff that he just repeated his second time around in office.
So, my take on this is, I don't actually think they forgot.
I think that they overestimated how much other people were on board with this type of stuff.
And I think they are.
I think they are.
I think they are.
I'm pretending that this took them by surprise now that they realize they don't actually have that popularity that was dramatically oversold in the first place.
Again, the 2024 presidential election was close.
There were a lot of people who did not want to see Donald Trump return to office.
But there was this cultural inflation around the popularity of this cruelty.
And I think a lot of these young people just assumed that that would hold out now that it very obviously is going to happen.
But I think a lot of these young people just assumed that that would hold out now that it very obviously is going to happen.
They are picking that low-hanging fruit of, well, who can disagree with how greedy and self-interested he was?
Who can forget that that's who he's always been?
Yeah.
Always.
And also, this sort of like smoothing over of the past with saying Trump himself is culturally far more socially liberal than the traditional religious right.
You know what?
I actually think on a personal level, that is to a certain extent.
Like, I think Trump, in his heart of hearts, I mean, I do think he is as racist, truly, as anyone on the traditional religious right.
I don't think he is as earnestly queerphobic, but his administration and his platform was from the beginning.
The 2024 election was in large part run on anti-trans messaging.
His most famous ad was, Trump is for you, Kamala is for they, them.
Raquel had a longer response.
To me, where she was talking about how she's actually friends with a trans person.
And I'm like, Trump was always going to come after trans people in the way that he did.
It just like how he was going to turn mass deportation in a spectacle as evidenced by the fact that he had rallies where people held up Trump campaign printed signs that said mass deportations now.
What are you talking about?
Yes.
Look me in the eye and tell me that you didn't know from the jump that this was exactly what was always going to happen.
This is why I get emotional.
This is literally what they voted for.
Because these people.
No, go ahead.
You wanted to go to a party.
You wanted to live out your fantasy of cruelty.
But don't pretend that this wasn't always going to be the way that it played out.
Okay.
Time to tell you about the actual people on the Cruel Kids cover. I am going to introduce you to
all of the characters of this magazine cover, and I'm going to tell you what they were up to
at the time of Trump's second inauguration. And then we're going to put a pin in them,
talk about some other stuff, and revisit them towards the end of the episode. So that's how
this is going to shake out. Grab a beverage and maybe pull up a visual aid if you are not watching
the YouTube video version of this podcast, because I have a lot to get through, all based on publicly
available information, by the way. I'm not doxing anyone. I have kind of like a lot to rattle off.
Did I send you my spreadsheets that I made when I was collecting information about these people?
I'm hearing about the spreadsheets for the first time.
I was like, my boyfriend was like, Matt, like you need to like remember to go to the bathroom.
All right. Do you have your Cruel Kids Table magazine pulled up, kids? Here we go.
First off, in the. The American flag hat, we have Edward O'Neill. Edward O'Neill is from Birmingham, Alabama,
and at the time of the Trump inauguration, was a recent graduate of the University of Alabama.
Now, Edward's father is a man named Kraft O'Neill, the chairman and CEO of O'Neill Industries,
an Alabama-based family-owned metals manufacturing business, which employs between
three and four thousand people.
Globally, and has an annual revenue of roughly three and a half billion dollars.
Oh, my God.
Edward did not respond to my request for comment about his participation in the inauguration
weekend or how he feels about it now.
Kraft O'Neill is the craziest name I've ever heard.
To Edward's left and in another famous photo with her tongue out holding a vape and a glass of white
wine.
Do you remember that one?
Oh, I sure do.
Is Sarah Petsnick, who I believe is Edward's girlfriend, or at least was at the time.
Sarah is a couple years younger than Edward, a fellow University of Alabama alum, and she
would have likely been a senior here on inauguration weekend around 21 years old.
Sarah did not respond to my request for comment about her participation in the inauguration
weekend or how she feels about it now.
On the other side of Edward is Ben McCool, another University of Alabama graduate.
Ben previously volunteered for Habitat for Humanity and was in a frat.
Of course.
Ben did not respond to my request for comment.
What I think about Raquel's comment about how the deportation videos were so tacky,
I was like, looking back at these photos, what do you people know about class?
Because these are some of the tackiest displays in recent memory.
Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm.
On the other side of Ben is Clay Shoemaker.
Yeah, that's his name, who is a graduate from California State University, Long Beach.
He's a little bit older than the rest of the people in the photo.
He's worked in a variety of staff roles for different Republican politicians, including
as a communications assistant for Donald Trump during his first term.
He was, I believe, at this point, working as a communications assistant for Donald Trump.
He was also a communications director for America First Works, a conservative 501c4,
where he had an annual salary of $153,281, according to ProPublica.
Hmm.
Clay did not respond to my request for comment.
But let's get to why you're really here.
The two young women who are inarguably the focal point of the cover,
the one famously in a black slip dress, are sisters Anna Claire and Mary Louise Howland.
At the time of the inauguration, Anna Claire was a,
at Southern Methodist University, and Mary Louise was a recent graduate from SMU's graduate school.
We're going to revisit all of these people, but we're going to revisit them specifically.
Anna Howland, of black slip dress fame, was the only person on this cover to speak publicly about
the event after it went viral. She gave an interview to an Alabama newspaper about how
she felt she was smeared, where she said it should have been called the kind kids table.
And she even got a Fox News primetime interview with Jesse Waters.
New York Magazine's taking the mean girl motto to heart,
smearing a group of young conservatives as the cruel kids table. But the college student at
the center of that hit piece is finally speaking out. Here she is. Anna Claire Howland joins me now.
How you doing, Anna?
I'm good. How are you?
Good. So what's it like being famous?
It's definitely been a whirlwind of a week. I've received a lot of unexpected attention.
Positive and negative from this article. So it's definitely been interesting for sure.
So they call you a cruel kid. Are you cruel?
They do call me a cruel kid. I wouldn't consider myself one, but thankfully I've had a lot of
people standing up for me on the internet. People I know and then also just people that
have the same beliefs as me. So that's really helped me through this process.
Have you gotten any marriage proposals?
Gotten a few of those if you asked some Mavs games. So might have to take some people up on that one.
Anna, was Johnny one of those people who proposed to you?
Maybe I can't say names.
Okay. Well, you hear about these numbers. These women won't date MAGA supporters. I'm sure you've
dated MAGA supporters. Have you ever dated a liberal guy?
I haven't.
No. Okay.
Oh my God.
They go into a whole thing about like, would you date a liberal?
Like, I shouldn't be surprised that that is the
direction the interview immediately went in, but I'm still like, what the fuck? Like,
you're immediately going to start asking her if she got proposed for marriage.
But why are you shocked?
I shouldn't be shocked. It reminds me of that one video that I know you know because of who you are in our friendship
of Britney Spears when she's like eight years old and she does that singing competition where she is
just like hits the craziest notes that an eight-year-old girl could ever possibly hit.
And the first question, the guy who's hosting the talent
show asks is if she has a boyfriend.
Oh my God. Yes. Yes. And that's the thing too, is this is not an exclusive to Fox News
phenomenon where a woman is brought on or a woman like does an interview or displays a talent or is
eight years old. And the first thing that the interviewer asks is like, and what about your
dating life? And what about your marriage prospects? But it is just so like blatantly
patriarchal. And at the same time, it's like, well, what the
fuck else should we expect? Like, this is the exact culture that she's championing.
It doesn't really sound like she's being smeared either. If all she really has to say about it is
like, my friends defended me online. I got asked to several football games. Like, okay.
Sounds like a really tough week for you.
Yeah. I hope nothing worse happened to anybody as a result of the policies you championed over
the following two years. Literally. So Anna Claire and
Mary Louise are the daughters of Rob Howland, an Alabama real estate developer. And before you
accuse me of sleuthing too much or anything, this was printed at the time in the New York Post.
The Howlands grew up in a 6,800 square foot home that was featured in a spread in Birmingham Home
and Garden. Kat, I have included photos of their home, which were printed in a magazine in our
outline. Okay. So,
is it wrong of me to say that the interior design of this house is kind of hideous?
No. I mean, I know the Cheesecake Factory has been in the headlines a lot lately,
but this is very much like a Cheesecake Factory. There's so much like clashing going on here. I
mean, when I look at the dining room picture, it is obviously very expensive. There's a lot happening,
there's a lot of patterns that don't go together here. But it's when I scroll down to the next
picture and these like carpeted marble stairs and the carpet is ugly. And I'm just like, wow,
money gone to waste on some of these people. Money indeed, though, because this is a palace.
And, you know, I don't I don't know. I don't want to get too far down the rabbit hole because I'm
going to sound insane. But this house is worth millions and millions and millions of dollars.
Of course, they have a fireplace in the bedroom.
Anyway, neither Anna nor Mary Louise responded to my request for comment. Another viral image
from this New York magazine piece showed three young women and one young man in MAGA hats against
a gilded club wall. On the left is Caroline Murphy, then a recent graduate from the University of South
Carolina, who did not respond to my request for comment. Next to her is Brooklyn Tucker,
a master's graduate from the University of South Carolina.
Next to me is a man who I could not identify, but next to him is a third. We'll call these MAGA women
one, two and three MAGA hat one, two and three MAGA hat three is Jordan Wright, a then recent
University of Georgia graduate who'd begun interning at the House of Representatives
and didn't respond to my request for comment.
Lastly, the conservative influencers in attendance.
Mm-hmm.
because there were some i don't know if you could call them big names but like i guess like riley
gaines is a big name to a certain type of person right but uh you know riley gaines was there uh
cam higby a charlie kirk style campus provocateur formerly part of the conservative hype house
early 2020s was hell yeah also in attendance was xavier de russo a i would argue the sort of black
gay and famously flamboyant maga influencer who often made content for the right wing content
farm prager you as well as early tiktok star turned boxer bryce hall and his then girlfriend
michaela la fuente we have the conservative hype house and we have the actual hype house as well
he was in the real hype house oh yeah no bryce hall peaked when he dated addison ray and thank
god she got away from him and thank god she got away from him and thank god she got away from him
she didn't peak when she dated him thank god i know those were a lot of characters i hope i
didn't bore you maybe i intrigued you i want you to put a pin in all of them uh and we'll take that
pin out a little bit later i would like to take a quick break from the show to give a shout out
to the sponsor of today's episode this show's longest running sponsor blueland the holidays
are coming up and one of my
great
and very tasteful friends hannah louise poston once gave what i think is the best holiday gifting
advice which is get someone the nicest version of the thing that they already love you don't
have to reinvent the wheel and i think blueland is a great version of that principle applied
blueland is a line of home cleaning products that is luxurious it is tasteful and it's sustainable
blueland makes dish laundry and other household cleaning
products designed to reduce single use plastic there it's also just an elevated line all the
way around blueland has a really streamlined and simple system you basically buy one of their very
beautiful very chic forever bottles and tablets for whatever cleaning solution you're buying
whether it's window cleaner mirror cleaner multi-purpose cleaner you fill your forever
bottle up with water pop a tablet in and you're all set to go and when you run out you're going to
have to get out instead of going out to the store buying a new bottle paying for shipping fees because
the weight which is mostly just water in cleaning products anyway you just refill that same bottle
pop in a new tablet and you're good to go and those tablets start at just two dollars and 25 cents so
it's a bang for your buck especially over time and especially so because right now blueland is having
their biggest sale of the year ahead of the holidays which is up to 30 off this only happens
once per year so if you'd like to go check it out you can do that at blueland.com slash fruity
that is blueland.com slash fruity and now let's get back to the show speaking of conservative young
people who reached the peak of their cultural domination around 2025 i want to revisit our
friends the trad wife influencers while the cruel kids on capitol hill ushered in trumpism in its
most explicit form
influencers showed aspirational lifestyles compatible with conservative politics could
you refresh people for those uh fortunate enough to have forgotten on how lifestyle trends and
politics were working together at this point in time really always yes that's the thing is i think
they are always sort of a reflection of the other and a lot of times the shifts in politics that
will soon be shown in electoral results are very evident
in our cultural shifts beforehand which was absolutely the case in the early 2020s and what
would end up happening with trump getting re-elected because a lot of the dominant strains
of online culture at this time were trad wives and these patriarchal aesthetics for women and then
alpha males and these aesthetic patriarchal standards for men on the woman side we had
homesteading content we had
your big religious family content we had your clean girl aesthetic and it was like
this literal chipping away at all of the body positivity and the colorful digital maximalism
of the 2010s into this like beige overtone and it bled into everything it bled into our fashion
our makeup where we lived how we decorated our houses how we talked about raising children
and how we even talked about our relationships with one another and no trad wife was bigger than
hannah nealiman oh yeah aka ballerina farm kat and i have talked a lot about ballerina farm over the
years do you want to refresh people on the backstory of ballerina farm i know it's a long one that we
can like truncate a little bit but yeah i mean tldr on ballerina farm is that she started as an actual
ballerina she was at juilliard right at juilliard she was in this incredibly prestigious competitive
role when she met her eventual husband the heir of jet blue the heir of jet blue he decided to
exert that influence by selecting a seat next to her on a flight so that he could ask her and i
married and then start having a baby with him and then they move out into what from instagram
appears to be this glamorous yet rural and rustic homesteading property in the middle of nowhere
and the reality is it kind of is in the middle of nowhere but it's mormon country and these people
are mormons which is pretty central to their identities and their lifestyles and she begins
like popping out kids at an astonishing rate
and she is playing little house on the prairie farm wife she has this really expensive stove
where she bakes homemade bread and she posts these elaborate photo shoots with the kids wearing like
prairie dresses she has an egg apron like i know that egg apron has bothered the shit out of you
for ever since she got it the egg apron which was a gift from her husband sorry not to interject and
content about it and she opens it and it's a fucking egg apron and people were like you should
you should kill your husband and she wanted tickets to greece yeah she wanted a break from
her one million children and he got her something to stuff eggs into oh i can't i can't let it get
too far i can't get sorry we gotta stay on task we gotta stay on task but no i think that like
hannah neilman valerita farm sold this fantasy of being a trad wife to millions of people so
highly curated instagram shoots but the reality behind it as was later exposed in reporting
for multiple outlets journalists went to visit her and they saw that her life was not as picture
perfect as it would seem online as is so often the case she had a crew of nannies and staffers
at the home helping perform the daily tasks of actually caring for a farm and this family and
they weren't eating every day and she was like oh my god i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry
every single meal out of a cast iron pan they were also getting delivery and going to restaurants
they just weren't photographing that uh and also she would not get out of bed for days at a time
because she was so exhausted and probably a little bit depressed because she left this life of
dancing and living in new york city behind so that she could live in this kind of isolated
almost trapped fantasy world ballerina farm in
recent months seems to have been sort of taking a conscious look at the criticism
that she and they have received from the sort of cultural left it's changed their content and it's
changed the way that she talks about what ballerina farm is she gave an interview in
june of this year to vulture where the topic of ballerina farm essentially being anti-feminist
was brought up to which she said i know i'll never be loved by everyone
but if there's things that i'm sharing that people think are actually doing harm to our sex
then okay let me take the feedback interesting use of the word sex versus gender
it's one of my first notes there i mean i don't know how woke we're expecting ballerina farm to
get no but yeah but you know something that's fascinating to me now is if you scroll through
ballerina farm's instagram feed and even if you read more into some of the interviews she's given
recently she is now much more open about the fact that she
is a businesswoman and a ceo she talks about that she has nannies who help oversee her
nine children she gave an interview to business insider where she says she has around a hundred
employees welcome back girl boss welcome back girl boss exactly we're we're like you know and
i was thinking about that i was like okay so ballerina farm is sort of supplanting a little
bit of like girl boss feminist aesthetics into what ultimately people started to realize was a
unrealistic fantasy of trad
furry that she was never actually living yes and is girl boss capitalism better i don't know but
like at least we're not pretending yeah that's a good point because i do think that the nuts and
bolts are functionally the same yeah but there is a big difference between selling this fantasy to
women of like quit your job stay at home have a million babies don't have any help there is a big
difference between that and like go to college get an mba and get a job like yeah there's an
important distinction there now another one of the most popular trad wives who seems to have made a
drastic pivot in her content uh over the last i would say year or so as the cultural tide has
continued to change is a one nara smith cat would you like to explain to our audience who's unaware
of nara smith lore nara smith when you would
you
google the word trad wife would pop up in the top images along with ballerina farm but nara smith like
she's best known for the iconic cooking videos on tiktok where she would be in this stark white
kitchen she would be wearing these absurd like fashion couture outfits met gala-esque gowns
and she would be doing something like making oreos from scratch for her children she was
always in the kitchen she was always emphasizing like clean ingredients like minimal processed
foods we're not gonna buy cheez-its from the store we're gonna spend seven hours which has
been chopped up into a two-minute clip making cheez-its for my husband and my children and i
won't let that like nasty walmart packaging like touch their little lips like it was elitism but it
was also fitting into the trad wife label because she was this young beautiful homemaker right and
i i was wondering what nara smith has been up to uh and i went to her instagram the other day
she's literally she's a she's a fashion baddie now she is a she's an insta baddie and she looks
amazing but now she has completely rebranded i'm sure with the help of a team uh into like a new
york fashion week like girly do you see the the instagram that's crazy and no sign of the kids
something that always really struck me about her is she had four kids by the time she turned 23
she had her first kid at 19 years old so it was just like back to back to back so young and they
were also mormon yes yes yes and they had crazy names her kids names are literally like rumble
honey yeah rumble honey
slim easy which is like of course the type of name you would also give a child when if you
were basically a child yourself when you were having them fair enough fair enough they also
sound like startups yeah slim easy it sounds like a vape company
yeah i'm taking a boxing class at rumble honey um
a few months ago nara smith appeared on the call her daddy podcast where
years of being labeled one of the internet's leading trad wife influencers she explicitly
rejected the label acknowledging that she travels and works constantly and that her parenting with
her husband is 50 50 and i think if you were thinking about how much effort goes into this
stuff it's obvious that yeah these are people who work constantly that they are not traditional
wives despite you know sort of wearing that as a costume but what really struck me is the
sudden urge over the last few months to change people's perception yes of their content yes i saw
a tweet recently that was like i should have known that the blue tsunami was going to happen
when nara smith and hannah nealman started explicitly saying that they were no longer
trad wives which i think is a really astute observation i mean there's been a massive
cultural blowback against the trad wife since donald trump got re-elected
one thing i point to here that i think was actually very significant in sort of at least
calcifying this backlash is the book yesteryear which was an instant new york times bestseller
if you haven't read it i won't spoil it but to me it's like very almost explicitly
uh based on hannah nealman a ballerina farm yeah yes yes and it is about the hypocrisy
of the trad wife and of the conservative woman you know it's going to become a major motion
picture starring anne hathaway and it's about a woman who actually has to go back and live
in i believe it's like the 1860s is the the decade that she's transported to i think people had woken
up to the reality that you would not want to live this lifestyle in reality you would not want to
actually have to be a homesteader you would not want to abandon what modern feminism has granted
you if you actually had to suffer the consequences of it and the thing is
the women that we've been talking about so far from the howland sisters to the influencers the
a-list influencers at the point in which the cultural tide is turning and i don't want to
spoil my thesis but all of them have enough money and privilege and access to sort of change the
costume the costume that they had been wearing which was that of a conservative woman well if
that goes out of vogue they're not stuck with the worst
consequences of where being you know an actually trapped conservative woman might leave someone
but another trad wife influencer who's eschewed the label since trump took office again is a woman
named bernadine barber bernadine doesn't have nearly the following of hannah or nara she's got
around a hundred thousand subscribers on youtube and around half that on instagram an open
conservative in her 30s with six children her posts were more overtly
political than hannah's or nara's she advocated for donald trump and the maga movement she told
women to forego their ambitions that their most useful place was in the home having as many
children as possible as of course god intended unlike everyone we've discussed so far from the
cool kids to the a-list trad influencers bernadine did not have a wealthy family as a safety net
nor an empire of her own at the height of her trad posting she could earn a
couple thousand dollars a month on which she supported her eight-person family in a small
home in rural missouri her life was a traditional conservative maga fantasy until one day in may 2025
bernadine took out a restraining order against her husband cat and i spoke with bernadine about
what happened and that's going to be the next portion of this episode starting now bernadine
i
just for starters could you tell us how old you are and uh how many kids you have
i'm 36 years old and i have six kids um oldest is 14 the youngest is one almost two could you
tell us the story of how you got there how you ended up a quote-unquote trad wife yeah so i was
born in the philippines my whole family was born in the philippines my mom died when i was four
and then at seven years old we moved from the philippines to america and i mean we moved
around all over the place because my sister was in the navy and we moved everywhere she went she
was constantly being restationed so i've lived in san francisco i've lived in virginia i've lived
in texas but my family was catholic like growing up we'd always go to catholic church every sunday
i didn't really understand most of it partly because i'm young probably because i'm just not
interested and partly because um half the thing was like in latin and i didn't understand what
they were saying yeah um but i do remember my dad was big on like going to church every sunday
and praying like to mary and baby jesus at night he would have us join him and pray with him like
that just before i turned 16 years old i went through a quarter life crisis i'm just kidding
i went through a life crisis i left my friends and family in san diego we moved suddenly abruptly
out of like an urgency type of um situation we moved from san diego to like middle of nowhere
virginia and so all of my friends my boyfriend at the time the life that i knew everything that i
and i was just really depressed at that age and for the first time i was like what is the point
of life yeah like what is the point of life like my point in like my purpose in life before this
was to have fun to be with my friends to go out you know and then now it's like all of that's gone
so like i was for the first time looking inwardly and looking deeper into life and wondering why the
heck am i even here like why am i even on this planet really it was the summer of 2006 so i'm
well i already told you my age in the summer i was staying with my oldest sister in texas and
there was a book that i stumbled upon um it really intrigued me and piqued my interest
just based off the title alone the purpose-driven life by rick warren but i was like that's literally
what i'm trying to figure out right now like what is the purpose of my life like why why the heck
should i keep you know even trying and so i read that book in one of the bedrooms at my sister's
apartment and i was all by myself and then one of the chapters what it was saying just really
hit me and it was basically telling me that god loves you he's loved you this entire time he's
been watching you all of this time even as you did not give a flip about him like you didn't care
about him you're just doing your own thing you had no regard of what he he thought about what
you're doing what you're not doing and you know you're doing things you shouldn't have been doing
and i was just like whoa like i am i have sin like i i'm selfish by nature i am selfish and i don't
care about god and he's the god who created me and here i'm learning that despite of that despite
of my selfishness he still adores me and loves me and wants to be with me wants a relationship
with me um and so it hit me that i needed god and i offended god but at the same time he still
loved me even while i was a sinner and i remember at 16 just bawling like crying on my bedroom floor
when i was crying i told god for the first time i called him father and i said father forgive me i
don't want to be this way change me i felt like he was hearing me like he knew me and i was like
he loved me and that connection was there all of a sudden and from that moment on my whole life had
been changed like i had a relationship with god so after that again more moving so now
i'm in college you're in college you did go to college i did go to college for college right
before college because it was um i was just about to start senior year but that's when i met my
future husband future ex-husband
i met him at a youth
study actually um so we met at age 17 we're both the same age and then fast forward to that phase
where i'm in college i went to community college which i recommend it's cheaper you know it was
close to home so i did two years of community college i got my associate's degree in early
childhood education with an emphasis in art i'm a creative through and through but then i did get
married um i started a one semester in texas a&m and then i
stopped i got married what did you want to study there um i wanted to proceed with teaching yeah
with education um teaching and you stopped after one semester after the yeah the first semester of
my uh junior year why is that just but i was dating him and then we decided to get married
and then um you know he felt like we should trust god with the number of kids we have and we
shouldn't like withhold that if he wants to send us a child then it'll happen and sure enough it
happened
we had our first baby um we were both 22 did he ask you to drop out so that you could prepare to
have kids not not directly i would say but it was like this is our priority and then of course when
i got pregnant and had a baby i was like well who's gonna stay home with the baby it was gonna
be me so yeah i was a full-time stay-at-home mom for a long time for many many years i was
a full-time stay-at-home wife and mom well that's kind of something that i wanted to ask you about
um so i was a full-time stay-at-home mom for a long time so i was a full-time stay-at-home mom for a
long time so i was a full-time stay-at-home mom for a long time so i was a full-time stay-at-home
i guess you were married for 15 years about 14 about 14 like basically half of that time
is spent pregnant or like immediately postnatal i suppose yep correct i mean i had two under two
more than once is that what you had discussed with your ex-husband like wanting to have that
many children wanting to have as big of a family as possible it was basically um framed like to
trust god with the number and if he wanted to expand and wanted to send us kids then we should
trust god with that it's called like this um quiverful movement apparently now that i'm
registering everything like oh that's what that was but basically like hey you trust god and if
you don't trust god you're lacking in faith like he will provide and he will you know all of this
and that you say that this was like god's will and i mean on a like basic level does that just
mean like we're never using contraception if i happen to have a baby and i'm like oh my god
like we are following through if we are able to you know physically um is that is that kind of how
that went yeah it's basically um the mindset is basically like if you get pregnant it was god's
will so yeah you don't like you don't use birth control you don't yeah during that time like you
don't do condoms and things like that so you know i'm pretty fertile i guess i'm quite fertile for
me like if we kept going on this i'd be pregnant with number seven like right now or postpartum
with seven because it's like not like oh let's see what god does it's like i get pregnant every
time you know what i'm saying like it's not a mystery what was that like financially having
so many young kids oh orland i don't recommend it was it was a lot and you go without a lot
you know what i mean yeah can i uh ask because i speaking of that uh i know you
would end up supporting the family by making content online which i'm about to ask you about
but first i i was wondering about your ex if i may and just kind of like the nature of your
relationship you obviously met when you were really young uh what was that like how did the
relationship progress yeah so it wasn't always like as bad as it got at the end um and looking
back now i do see some
signs and red flags that i did not process before but it unfortunately around the same time that i
you know read the other book that changed my life not for the best the lies women believe book was
the same time that this red pill stuff was exploding online and so that's some of the
things that he was getting exposed to and getting into and not even just the andrew tate myron
type stuff it was also like biblical quote
biblical red pill stuff which i now refer to as red pill pharisees like they're red pill pharisees
because they use the bible to justify their attitudes and behaviors towards women which is
that women are not equal women are beneath them and so the the spiritual packaging around this
misogyny was even worse because i am a christian so now i'm like well i need to be a better woman
and if i'm not i'm not only displeasing a man i'm displeasing god you know what i'm saying
and so that it it it got it changed it changed over time and then and not for the best you think
both of you as sort of you were going down this like trad femme i i suppose like very religious
pipeline which also you know there would end up being like an ecosystem of content for that online
but at the same time he was like being this like red pill manosphere
also religious pipeline online cat and i often talk about how those are like two sides of the
same coin so you were really on that journey together yeah unfortunately and i couldn't
even explain to you while i was in the relationship what the heck was going on and it wasn't until
i recently got out and went no contact because of the restraining order
that i was able to like look back and be like what was that what was happening what was i in
can i was able to connect the dots and like rethink things unlearn things learn things and
it's like that's what that was so it's like fundamentalism it's christian fundamentalism
where they have these extreme rigid um gender expectations and roles i thought when i read
the book lies wouldn't believe that this was like a good thing this is a good thing this is the
answer to the problems i've been having in my marriage you know my marriage was confusing and
it was frustrating i felt like i was being pushed into this box and
pressured to be someone that i really was not you know what i mean but it was like when i read this
book oh that's what's wrong it's it's feminism feminism is the problem feminism is the problem
the only reason i even want to do anything outside the home is because of feminism because that was
me i wanted to do things outside the home i wanted to speak i wanted to use my creative gifts and i
wanted to teach and i want to do all these things but those were framed as distractions at best
for like a sin at worst like you're sinning because you're now you're not focused on the
household you're not focused on your your homemaking duties your husband and your kids
so when i read that book i'm like oh this is the answer living in the bible belt that was even part
of it it's like even people outside of my marriage believed similar things the wife needs to submit
you don't need to nag you need to let him lead you know so if you have a dispute or something
you want to bring up in the relationship you're not an adult with valid concerns you're a nagging
wife you know what i mean yeah so i mean you you were struggling inside of your marriage
partially because you weren't allowed to pursue any sort of ambition and then you consume this
conservative religious content that says that actually the problem is having ambitions in the
first place yep yeah and and only reason you want to do any of that is because of feminism famously
uh so i mean somewhere along the way you sort of sublimate these ambitions into making content
online talk to me about that i've i've looked through some of the content we're gonna look
through some of the content but i'm curious just how you first got into that and uh and where it
yeah so what was it 2018 the same season we'll call it season that i decided okay so this is what's
what's wrong with my marriage and i need to fix it i need to fix myself so i stopped trying to do
the things i was doing prior which was like booking events speaking um specifically spoken
word poetry i would perform spoken word poetry at churches or at banquets and i was like okay
okay, well, I don't need to pursue anything like outside the home. I'll just do everything
in the home. And so I stopped trying to do other stuff. And then I would like go use the internet
while the kids were napping. And it's so funny because I'm like, okay, I'm not going to do
anything else. And then I'm like, I need to do something. And then I was like, well, I have the
internet. So I had to have a creative outlet and the internet was the solution for that. And then
on top of that, we were increasingly getting isolated. We had moved to San Antonio that year
and, you know, trying to build a new life, have new connections, a social network. And that was
always stifled. Like I wanted to go to church and then nothing was good enough. So we didn't go to
church. And I remember getting like a gut feeling and realizing this is going to be like mission
impossible for me. It's going to be really difficult to establish new relationships here.
All of my attempts were being discouraged by my husband. He didn't want you to have friends. I
mean, I wouldn't have been able to say that.
But looking back now, yeah. Cause I would always say like, Hey, there's this church. Can we try to
go to this church? And then we'd go to that church. And then he'd say, I don't like what
the pastor said. So we never came back. And then I suggested another church. And then he was like,
I don't like, I don't like, um, I don't want to get a membership and they're pressuring us to do,
to be a part of the church and get membership. And so it was like, I was like, I don't, I'm just
the wife, you know? So already I'm not like the head of the household. I don't get to make these
decisions. I can make suggestions. And he was constantly blocking and blocking.
And I'm over here juggling the kids at the same time, you know, and he's working,
he was working at that time. And, um, I was just like, I just remember feeling gut feeling. I'm
like, this is going to be really freaking hard. It's going to be really, really hard. And I don't
know how I'm going to make friends here. And then I like, that was another thing that the internet
fixed because I remember now it's called a dopamine hit. I was getting a dopamine hit
because now I'm online creating and talking to people and they're replying to my stories and
I'm talking to them in my DMS and my comments. And
how sad and pathetic, but I was like, yay, interaction, interaction with people, you know,
I don't think that's sad or pathetic. I mean, I think it makes actually total sense given the
context. So between, um, needing a creative outlet and needing social interaction, the internet was
like the perfect fix. And I'm still home full time, stay at home, wife and mom still here with
my two little kids. And I am doing more housework and I am investing more in the home and things
like that. I'm learning new recipes and I'm decorating
the home or I literally was trying to apply that book. Unlike many trad wife creators online who I
think issue overtly political messaging and instead choose to showcase the trad lifestyle as like a
form of political messaging. Of course, I'm thinking of who has been dubbed the queen of
the trad wives, ballerina farm, who really avoids talking about politics, but just shows, you know,
herself in this glorious house with her gazillion children on this farm. You explicitly,
drew the link between the lifestyle that you were living, uh, and the right wing political movement
that you had chosen to support. Could you talk to me about that? Because I, a lot of your,
your content was explicitly, you know, attaching itself, especially to MAGA.
Yeah. So, um, 2018, again, the same year is funnily enough. I'm like, I'm not gonna,
I'm not gonna show anything outside the home. That's when my online content started going viral.
And so, um, I remember,
initially talking about what biblical womanhood that would be what it's called and then i had
some posts about the politics like political things going on at that time and those went
super viral and so i just kind of like when you get into something you get into like i mean it
just keeps going you know people are like well what do you think about this and what do you think
about that why did you say that i didn't really post about family life too much i didn't want to
put my kids on there you know um their faces and stuff i had to censor all of that but i did i was
more like talking about the cultural political side of these things um not so much me cooking
or baking things like that but more like arguing for that side it was in 2019 where i did that
miami debate i was labeled a trad wife for the first time ever i saw the flyer i'm like oh
they really solidified me as a trad wife yeah the event that you're describing it was a speaking
event in miami and per the new york times
you
mean you were really arguing for sort of the most maximalist ambitions of the patriarchy
um you were you argued on stage against women's suffrage uh you said that women were to
submit to their husbands completely at that point i think you were in your 20s and had three kids
already um how do you how do you feel about that now um i would never say that now
i would not say repeal the 19th um at the time it was it's so funny because i don't think everyone
does it like this because i don't think for example savannah stone was in a marriage where
she was like being persuaded to think certain types of things but a lot of these women who
are online talking about these things they they do own it like this is what i believe that's what
they say and i did i really thought i believe this but what's funny is that you don't see
the conversations that these women have with their husbands their husbands are talking to them about
why this is a good thing and everything is truly framed as like this is the answer to our society's
problems like this is what's going to fix our country this is what's going to fix families and
they're really good at convincing you like they're really good at talking you into this
and i remember though i would debate like with
my husband like well what about this what about that so it wasn't like i was just like oh yes tell
me what to believe and that's what i believe i remember having conversations and be like well
what about this and that and being persuaded but they would literally just be like you know
this is why this would fix the country and so i did believe at that time i truly did believe that
having um a one vote per family was a good thing meaning each family voted as one unit
the husband you know puts in the vote but
they voted as a team you know what i mean as a group but there's so many problems with that
you know but you're not i should say yeah it's just like it's a beautiful thing that the man
is the head of the household you know you vote together you're one unit your team but no i would
not ever say that now because i that's a whole nother tangent but there's so many things that
could go wrong and have gone wrong i'm curious how you squared at the time the idea of like your
husband is the head of the household and he's sort of the one in this persuasive role not just
plainly telling you what to think but really encouraging and developing that mindset through
these conversations then i'm just curious like why were you the one doing the debates why wouldn't
it be the husband doing the debates but instead like it was you speaking to another woman and you
having this frontward facing online persona how did you sort of square those contradictory things
in your mind
um i think part of it is a skill set issue
i don't know why but i what you were a better speaker than he was
apparently so i don't know but but you were also ambitious i have always been and still am um
i was always ambitious outspoken before i got married during and after and i've always wanted
to make like an impact in the world i think part of it is that they do recruit women more um like
right wing side i mean i guess it goes both ways but they do want to recruit uh recruit women who
like are aspirational or decent looking that have like you know good communication skills or
whatever so yeah they put you on these platforms they like it when they can hear from women because
first of all there aren't a lot of women outspoken in politics there's not a lot of them on the right
wing yeah um side of things and so it's like when you find someone who can do that for you can be
your spokesperson and do a good job and it's like me talking versus like a dude i'm i'm probably i
come off more friendly and i probably i'm probably going to convert a lot more women for me it was
like everything was totally fine because what i was saying was supporting was supporting the right
wing beliefs right so it's funny because they will look at a woman who's outspoken and driven
and ambitious but if she's you know she's single or if she's a feminist well then that's an issue
you know what i mean
you know what i mean
because what she's saying what she's promoting it doesn't line up with what we want per the right
wing like extremist right wing side of people i'm referring to but if it's a woman you know
oh well she'll make more women aspire to do what we do then that's totally fine that's okay
at this point your career was growing you were being offered more opportunities you were getting
viral videos you were growing a following did you ever think that you would hit a ceiling or that
there would be like an aspiration you would be able to achieve in the future
um yes it was just last year i gave birth to my sixth child uh and i was still online making
videos on youtube it wasn't easy it was very hard but i don't recommend that kind of stuff
like realistically how many children can you have before you simply can't be a youtuber anymore
yeah yeah i mean i think for me the answer would be like probably one but you know
one of your viral posts from a number of years ago was uh when brett kavanaugh was
nominated to the supreme court and he famously was accused by christine flossy ford of rape when they
were in college together uh and I found this when I was uh sorry for stalking your social media but
I found it and uh it's you and your hand is up and you wrote on it hashtag him too I believe
Kavanaugh yeah yeah that went viral everywhere um yeah yeah go ahead the whole um conversation
about that around that from right-wing people which I was part of obviously at that time was
that men are falsely accused of things and women are automatically believed just because they're
women but yeah that was really pretty freaking dumb did you believe that Christine Boise Ford
was lying um I'm not sure honestly I don't even think that at that time I like did deep research
on it it wasn't really about like information it was just like a jerk reaction a knee jerk reaction
oh this is a sexist thing they're being sexist towards the man because he's a conservative
everybody was just saying he's being persecuted simply because he's a politician who's not a leftist
it was like dogmatic talking points ready to go whenever a woman came forward
about abuse yeah and and because he's a male and he's you know leans more traditional conservative
than he's a victim because that's literally all they're doing right now
is just attacking him because he's about to gain more influence in our politics but behind the
scenes behind the screens you were it seems surviving abuse within your own marriage yes
yes and it's not on it was on and off it's not like all the time uh so I feel like that's a huge
misunderstanding when people hear like oh a woman was being abused they think it's like every day
the worst part about it is that it's not always physical
uh probably more often than not it's emotional psychological spiritual like a lot of people
don't even think that counts as abuse you know what I mean uh they when they think abuse they
think physical oh he's punching you and things like that but when a woman is in an abusive
relationship the physical is not always every day and it's not always like the the thing that
comes out of nowhere like there's already the other stuff happening and then that probably
happens you know what I mean um so my point in saying that is to say it was an on and off thing
um and that was the thing that made it so confusing and this is a cycle that women in
abusive relationships are in things explode and then the next minute you're in a honeymoon phase
and he's apologizing and things are going to be better and we're going to get over this and
it's never going to happen again and then nothing like that big explosive happens and then it
happens again and so this cycle it's so confusing and at the same time the relief you get from when
you hit the reconciliation phase again is so addicting it's like this massive relief that
you get this dopamine hit where you're like oh okay everything's fine like we're gonna make it
it's gonna be okay I don't need to change anything I don't need to leave I don't need a divorce the
kids can have an intact home it's like a dopamine hit of hope when I say yes I was in an abusive
relationship and yes it was physical I want to educate like people bring awareness that when
women say this they don't mean like he's in a wife-beater drunk punching you and kicking you
no it's so much messier and so much more complicated than that which is unfortunately
the reason why a lot of women stay but yeah that was a thing that was going on behind the scenes
especially after more of this red pill stuff was becoming a regular thing that these men consume
how do you feel now looking back
about the fact that you were putting out content like this giving this message to a good number of
women that that you were sort of putting out this message while experiencing the consequences of it
privately knowing that you know they could have been subjecting themselves to that as well yeah
well I I there were some things I said that are true that I still believe but there are things
that I said that are not true that I don't believe um so I've spent like the last year
separating the good from the bad the truth from the lies um because I do still believe in family
values you know I still I still do believe in family values I still do believe that the ideal
is for children to have an intact but wholesome actually safe and happy family you know just the
fact that you're together doesn't make it better um I still believe that men and women are different
in some ways but I don't believe that men are smarter than women I don't believe that men are
inherently more intelligent than women I don't believe that men are inherently more intelligent than women
I don't believe that men are inherently more intelligent than women I don't believe that women are weaker
willed or too emotional or unstable or hormonal I don't believe that men are superior spiritually
um and those were things that I either explicitly said in the past or hinted at yeah and and those
were things that I unfortunately did believe you know um and unfortunately was taught to believe
even in my own relationship um that's unfortunate and I'm speaking
out against those things now that I've processed what the hell that was and what I do believe
on my own now um but I do hope that you know these women are okay and I I want them to talk to me like
I want to hear I've seen what it's like for someone to not have accountability and to think
like they're they're just perfect the way they are and I don't want to be that person I want to
have accountability because I've seen how bad it can get when someone does not have that yeah and
so I I do want to hear feedback from the women who actually did
follow me and applied what I believe you know what I mean like people can hate on me oh you
said this and that but have no idea what I used to say and didn't apply any of it like okay that's
one thing but the women who actually did follow the advice and then were harmed by it those are
the women I want to hear from um and and one of my problems right now is like when I post online
I will get some of these guys in my comments and they're like the ones who used to love what I used
to say and now they're like oh you're a feminist you're a feminist you're a feminist you're a feminist
now and you're you know oh this is not in the bible this is against what the bible teaches you
should submit blah blah blah you should submit blindly part of it's like triggering because
that's the same shit that I used to hear when I was married and then part of it is like these are
the people I attracted these are I partially created these people do you know what I mean
and it's like oh god y'all are so just so blind just so self-serving and I'm like yeah this is
a problem and I don't know what to do with it I don't know what to do with it I don't know what to
do with it I don't know what to do with it I don't know what to do with it I don't know what to do with it
contribute to this and um yeah that's just why I still have my platform and I still um
have the drive in me but what I'm saying now is different and what I'm saying now is my own
you know what I mean the programming in my mind is mine um sorry it's okay take your time it's just
like it's scary because I somehow managed to escape it I managed to get out of this like
multi-layered trap it's spiritual it's emotional it's psychological it's logistical it's physical
it's financial it's practical and it's so hard to get through all of those it's a miracle that I got
out and I'm like I could be silent now I could choose to just like disappear and like never get
back online and live my new life and just be normal like I finally have a chance to be normal
yeah but I can't
just be quiet I cannot just disappear because I know what it's like to be in that
and I know some women are still in that um or they're gonna get into it if they keep believing
these lies because they are so appealing to some people it is the packaging is appealing in some
ways and I don't know part of it's just a part of me just needs to be easier to just like
get a waitressing job or something you know just delete the internet
but I want to help women I want to um
I want to explain what it was like to be in that not just to the women who need to understand what
they're going through but to society at large because I think if more people understood what
was going on they would be more able to help they would see the warning signs they would know how to
approach these women in a way that these women don't like
get even more defensive and cling to their husbands
like they need to be rescued but they can't become reactive um but anyways because I went
through all this I can explain it and I would give up my platforms and things like that because
honestly part of me is just like wants to live a normal life but I feel like I have a responsibility
to use the platforms that I've built and to use the same gifts that I've had to live a normal life
I had all this time I still want to speak I still want to make a difference in the world I still I
am still opinionated but now I am have the freedom and the autonomy to think for myself truly
do you feel like you are still on a journey of processing and unpacking both the relationship
that you were in and also the belief system around it do you feel like you're kind of working through
these things and you're like I'm going to do this I'm going to do this I'm going to do this I'm
going to do this I'm going to do this I'm going to do this I'm going to do this I'm going to do this
um and it's so liberating because things make sense you know what i mean like things actually
make sense now and again because i have a restraining order he can't call or text me
my ex-husband can't call and text me so i don't have somebody else telling getting in my head or
like pressuring me and so when i learn something new when i and now i can read and listen to
whatever i want when i learn something new i can like think about it i and then when i have a
conclusion i can keep that conclusion if that makes sense without it being like being pulled
away from me or having it manipulated or changed you know what i mean and so this past year and a
half has been so amazing so so much clarity and so much freedom it's yeah but yeah i i think
as i'm posting online
I will get feedback and then that introduces a whole new question like well what about what
this person said or you know what do I think about what they asked or I will have people saying I
know exactly what you went through and that's what I went through with my ex-husband or they're
asking me how do I get out what do I do and so across the spectrum I'm getting feedback from
all kinds of people like everything from hardcore fundamentalist extremists who's even more extreme
than I was you know like attacking me or on the other side of the spectrum is like a hardcore like
I don't even know what to label them but like they're feminists and they're like well too little
too late blah blah blah you know and then in the middle um it's people who understand people who
are going through it and I take it as like this is like um I don't really take it as a personal
attack on me because I'm just one person I'm really not that powerful this is about a bigger
conversation and a bigger phenomenon that's going on now in our culture but also historically and
so I'm like learning from all of that and I'm asking questions and I am going through this
journey of like you you started like processing everything but I'm so freaking happy that I get to
actually process everything now you know I feel like too I mean correct me if I'm wrong but in
terms of sort of going back into the world and doing typical work offline um of course you know
one could argue that you could you know if you want to like try to get a job in a restaurant or
something like that you could you know you could you know you could you know you could you know
you could do some sort of you know service work like that but you don't really have a job history
right right because you've been married and having children for so many years yeah that's why I was
like I guess waitressing um because yeah I know so I have my associate's degree but that's it I
got that like 2013 or 2012 I have not had a corporate like nine-to-five job or an employer
since then I've been a stay-at-home wife and mom all those years but then in 2021 that's when I
found a way to to monetize the online platforms because that's what my ex told me to do because
of COVID blah blah blah which also made you the breadwinner yeah since 2021 I was the breadwinner
although he would never say that he would never agree he um you know he was with the kids and
then I worked a few hours a day and was able to monetize it thank god because it was literally
like what are we gonna do can't feed my kids if you don't work and I don't monetize this but
that's how it is for the I guess what two-thirds no almost half of my marriage I was strictly a
stay-at-home wife and mom so I don't have work history yeah when I did start making money it was
like sole proprietorship it wasn't like someone hire me you know and and the New York Times
interview you did outlined I think it was like a couple thousand dollars a month so it wasn't like
you weren't talking ballerina farm money oh god I wish not even close no but it was like enough to
get by pay the bills that was basically how it was could you talk to me a little bit about the day
everything changed the day you left yeah so obviously everything couldn't happen in 24 hours
there was a progression of things that happened before that but the day I literally left um
that was gonna be an exciting part of my book when I I had already filed to get a restraining order
and then he asked me about it and found out about it and he told me to go cancel it he told me
he told me to go to the sheriff's department and tell him to cancel it because I was just
exaggerating but so I was like okay I'm gonna go and then I go there and I instead of canceling it
I tell the police officers to serve the restraining order so we come back I followed two police cars
to the property and they serve him the restraining order and so he leaves and my two sisters had been
driving all night from out of state to come get me because I told him about it the night before they
showed up thankfully shortly after he left and me and the kids went with them and stayed at hotels
because I didn't have a car I didn't have a car if I didn't have a car I would have been stranded
on that tiny off-grid cabin um and the rest is history it was uh definitely survival mode
that day how long were you were you staying in hotels I mean what was your living situation
for a while after you left him I was staying at hotels like all
summer wow and it wasn't until it was like three months I was staying in hotels and then I finally
moved into a rental after that so it was nuts and I mean to get a restraining order famously
is very hard so it must have it must have taken a lot yeah oh my gosh it was like hours and hours
of hearing I had to testify I had a pro bono lawyer at the time so she was doing it like
for free I couldn't afford a lawyer and um we had to present exhibits and my ex even like
I was there being cross-examined by my ex basically being gaslit in court like that's
not true what about what you said here on on twitter what about when you said this good thing
about me and that magically denies the bad things right so this the social media content that you
made during your marriage
the right-wing sort of triad wife content was used against you when you tried to get a restraining
order absolutely 100 okay you praised me here and you said you liked this and that it was nuts
um but yeah it was uh hours long I had exhibits being cross-examined blah blah blah and then I
was granted a full order of protection wow you're now divorced you
are a single mom living in St. Louis you wear what you want you go boxing you're in a business
women's club you're in charge of your finances congratulations thank you I know that you spent
years online lambasting feminism given everything though how do you feel about it now um I feel that
part of what I understood about feminism was entirely inaccurate um
and but I do feel like I wasn't very educated on what feminism was yeah so in the right-wing
circles feminism is literally demonic and evil and it ruined the family unit and it made women
miserable and it believed like feminism according to right-wing circles just hates men blindly like
all men for no reason um and of course feminism was the reason why I had ambitions outside the
home right um so part of it was like I didn't even know what that was like I was like I was like I'm
like I don't know what the heck feminism was um and then part of it is that I just was blissfully
unaware of all the things that would have been impossible for me um in my escape in my divorce
if it wasn't for feminism you know what I mean and that whole year was I was scared I was scared
that I wasn't going to be believed I was scared that you know the the judge is a man like he's
not going to listen to me he's you know like there's just so many things I didn't I didn't
have a sense of security like I was going to be given a fair like fighting chance because I'm a
woman and because of all the rhetoric that women are unstable and hormonal and emotional blah blah
blah I felt like nobody's gonna believe me they're just gonna say I'm crazy and then all this whole
process of filing I'm the one that filed for divorce clearly so that was something I was able
to do I was able to you know just live life with my own bank account and like spend how I want and
like drive where I want like without having a male chaperone or you know I mean like getting a
restraining order like back in the day who's gonna believe a woman she's just she's just being
emotional she's off her meds or whatever you know like she's speaking poorly about her husband
that's a no-no you know there's so many things that I'm like oh my god if the attitudes and the
laws back then were what I had to deal with now I'd be I'd be trapped yeah I'd be stuck and
then I wouldn't be able to rebuild my life and so there's just so much that I'm like oh my god like
this I don't see that feminism is just all men bad you know I I'm understanding that it's more of
an attack on ideologies and systems that put women at risk or at a disadvantage compared to men
especially if these men believe like they're God's greatest gift on earth like how do you combat that
you know what I mean they never are
yeah if they're entitled if they have this entitled belief entitled lifestyle you're
not going to have a fair fighting chance because you're not you're not as good as men and you're
they're entitled to using you or treating you how they want and so i all i have to say like i just
have a completely different understanding of feminism i'm not a rabid blue-haired feminist
although some right-wing people say that's what i'm gonna become hey i was tempted when i'm done
with you bernadine i was like should i do that for halloween just like have a blue wig um you
know so i i'm not trying to like swing sides just to swing sides and be reactive i'm trying to really
learn you know so i don't want to be pressured by groups or people i'm done being pressured into
what i believe you know i fought so hard to have my own mind i'm not gonna rush or be pressured
into something else but i am like oh my god this is a completely different story than what i've
been told what i was
believing back then and so now i'm like reading books and it's like wow there's so much that i
can explore and so um right now i'm reading the making of biblical womanhood um and the feminine
mystique um and there's just i mean i could be whatever the heck i want i can read crazy right
wing crazy left wing and just compare the two you know what i mean and so it's a exciting times
exciting times for me what
would you say to your younger self and a woman who was in that position where you were very young
you were very religious and you were preparing to basically get married and have kids and forego
educational and professional opportunities what would you say looking back now with all of the
life experience you've gained since then i would educate her on what spiritual abuse looks like
because honestly i didn't even know that's what i was signing up for at first it was like have as
many kids as possible
then okay we're pausing and then it was like you need to home school and i was like the goal post
kept moving to where i was like okay where do i get my chance so like when is it my turn like i i love
this i love kids but it's like the person you knew before you married me where when does she
get to live again yeah because you when we were dating and when we were friends you knew that i
was a very like driven person and now all i'm allowed to do is i'm not allowed to live again
have kids and now i gotta homeschool them and i gotta stay home and it's like when do i get to
breathe you know what i mean and it didn't all happen at once and it didn't all happen out
outright like up front i would go back and educate my younger self on what spiritual abuse and course
of control looks like if i had the language if i had the words and the definitions for the things
that i went through i would be able to flag it immediately and set stronger boundaries i would
educate my younger self on what isolation is and how it happens
because it's not so much like you're not allowed to talk to this person or that although that
happens too it's gradual it's it's aversive and everything is framed morally and so the whole
guilt-tripping christian women into submitting that's a huge problem and i would educate my
younger self on the psychology of all of these things like how this happens what tactics they
use so that you can have the tools and the knowledge to be like absolutely not i know
what you're doing you're not special um this has been special
studied a lot of men have the same playbook and it's like and women too but a lot of men use their
gender or their supposed role in the spiritual dynamic of the home to manipulate and control
and monitor and then eventually harm their women and i would the women i would say they're women
caught yourself in real time they're women i ain't your woman no i'm just kidding um
i would just prioritize teaching her the language and the mechanics of how these things happen and
remind her that you are god's daughter first and foremost and god would not tolerate would not
accept that kind of treatment from a man because you are god's daughter before you are a man's wife
bernadine thank you so much uh for being so open we appreciate it and uh you know if you ever do
want to try out some blue hair dye
my door is open thank you matt for having me it was great talking to you and kat
oh it's great talking to you thank you for sharing your story and i'm really
glad that you're with us today thank you so much
i would like to take a brief moment from the show to give a shout out to the sponsor of today's
episode factor i am not a chef i think i do a relatively fine number of things relatively well
and i'm not a chef i'm not a chef i'm not a chef
cooking is not one of them and i know i could put in the time but oftentimes lately just doesn't
feel like i have the time and i frankly don't really want to devote the time and one way to
circumvent that is with factor factor is a meal delivery service with chef made gourmet meals
that are all ready to heat and eat in just two minutes they have a rotating menu of over 100
different meals every single week so you're never going to be bored or forced to settle with the
not any of meal prepping a week's worth of dinner in advance there are tons of different menus you
can try for your specific nutrition goals or dietary restrictions some newer options include
salmon burgers collard greens shredded beef and so much more and of course listeners of this podcast
can get a special deal right now if you go to factormeals.com slash fruity 50 off you can get
50 off plus one free breakfast item per box
you can get 50 off plus one free breakfast item per box
for a full year that is factormeals.com slash fruity 50 off thanks so much to factor and
now let's get back to the show bernadine is gone and kat and i are back before we get back to
our friends the cool kids is there anything you want to say about that interview i mean
i was really moved by that interview my heart really broke for her as she was describing
being trapped and isolated and abused by that man and i think there is this sentiment that i see all
the time which is that we shouldn't have empathy for these women we should not you know waste our
precious empathy which is not a concept i support but we shouldn't extend any forgiveness or any any
sympathy toward women who had adhered to maga ideology at one point but i actually really
disagree with that i disagree with that from the point of view of a woman who is a woman who is a
from the standpoint of advocating for victims of domestic violence and for wanting to engage in
domestic violence education and prevention i think that's the wrong pathway if you really care about
those issues but also on a very human level i have a lot of empathy for bernadine and for other women
who are in her position i think it is all too easy in a culture that ultimately remains deeply
discriminated against and so i think bernadine is a woman who has a lot of power and she is a woman
who has a lot of power and she is a woman who has a lot of power and she is a woman who has a lot of
power and she is a woman who has a lot of power and she is a woman who has a lot of power and she
is a woman who has a lot of power and she is a woman who has a lot of power and she is a woman who
even while she was in this relationship and the influences that she was subjected to
and how she's trying to work through that now. And I do think it is important to recognize that.
I'm glad that she's now making content about this and that although, as she said, it would be easier
for her to just leave the online world behind in a lot of ways, her testimony about this and
showing other women the reality of this, I think that's really commendable.
Yeah. I was actually thinking about this as I fell asleep last night because we did that
interview yesterday. I agree with everything you're saying. I think there's without a doubt
going to be some people who feel a particular way about the fact that she was making content
about it and that she was advocating for other women to be in a position that she was
privately suffering under.
And ultimately, I think everyone is entitled to their feelings about that type of content. I also
think it makes a lot of sense why she did the things that she did, even if I personally don't
agree with them, obviously. One thing we didn't have time to get into was she was tweeting some
stuff about gay people and gay marriage. And I wanted to ask her about that, but I was like,
we have to stay on track. But I think people are entitled to feel the way that they feel,
especially given how much. Suffering. We've seen, you know, as a result of the sort of rhetoric that she was engaging in.
But the bottom line is whether we like it or not, she was also suffering under that rhetoric,
which is just a complicated truth we have to make space for because it's what happened.
Exactly. And I see this all the time. I see this all the time when it comes to the people who hate
women like Amber Heard and Blake Lively, the people who subscribe, the women who subscribe
to the rhetoric of Nick Fuentes.
And Donald Trump. So frequently, those women are themselves victims. Sometimes they don't even
recognize it. They don't even realize that what they experienced was abuse or sexual violence or
harm. And that doesn't ultimately detract from the harm that they are doing when they defend
abusers, when they support Brett Kavanaugh, when they vote for Donald Trump, when they post victim
blaming language online. Multiple things can be true at once, but I see so much of the work of
unraveling this as a form of community care where we're acknowledging that everyone is at a different
place in this journey and some people may never complete that journey. It's complicated. It's
more nuanced than I think a lot of people would like to believe. Do you want to take the pin out
of the cruel kids? Let's do it. We've kept that pin in them for a while. We need to alleviate
their suffering. I'm imagining people with their cruel kids voodoo dolls. Should I sell that as
merch? Sorry, no. No, no, no. We're not about revenge. Okay, Hakeem
Jeffries. Coming next to the pod. Don't you guys want to hear Hakeem Jeffries on the A Bit Pretty
Pod? I know you do. All right. Let's take the pin out. I want to revisit all of the cruel kids,
and tell you what they're up to now. That's the big question that started this off, right?
So as for Edward O'Neill of American flag hat fame, I could not find his LinkedIn,
but given that his father Kraft is, as I mentioned, the third generation O'Neill to own
the billion dollar O'Neill Industries metal manufacturing company, I would personally be
shocked, and this is just speculative, if Edward isn't given some job he doesn't deserve at that
company. At least he'll have that $3.5 billion valuation to fall back on if things don't work
out. Good for her. Ben McCool with the perfectly coiffed hair and tuxedo is an engineer at
Hyperscience, an AI software company, according to his LinkedIn. Clay Shoemaker still seems to be
making a six-figure salary at that conservative 501c4. But in light of the interview you heard,
I want to talk about the women of the
cool kids table. Sarah Petsnick of tongue-out vape white wine fame.
Not everyone's always talking about. She got her master's degree and now works in sales at an office
catering company called Hungry, per her LinkedIn. Caroline Murphy, who we can call MAGA hat one,
is an account executive at Cherry, a fintech company that's, as far as I can tell, basically
for health care payments. Wow. Wow. Wow. Hell is hot. Caroline Murphy.
Oh boy. Wow. Pay your doctor's bill in installments with interest. We're going down.
We're going down. Crazy. Brooklyn Tucker, aka MAGA hat two, has two degrees, a fellowship at the Heritage Foundation,
and is now Deputy Assistant Secretary for Congressional Affairs at the U.S. Department
of Transportation. But of course, before we started filming, I made like a remark about
how these people were going to be fine because they were going to be able to get like Heritage
Foundation. Did you not even see that before I just told you? No. Oh, she literally has a
fellowship at the Heritage Foundation. Yeah. Sounds about right. Jordan Wright,
aka MAGA hat three, worked as an intern, then press assistant, then press secretary for Republican
Representative.
Rich McCormick, and is now press secretary for Senator John Neely Kennedy. And who could forget
the sisters? Mary Louise Howland, the blonde one who did not get a Fox News interview,
much to her chagrin. Just kidding. I don't know how she felt about it.
A senior tax associate at KPMG, which is a huge, huge company. This is all according to their
social media accounts. So I'm not sure if that's true. I'm not sure if that's true. Who is like also like one of the most, by the way, racist, like nakedly racist, like when when we did
the the Ramadan celebration at City Hall with Zoran Mamdani, which I was at, he tweeted and he was
like, it's like 9-11 is going to happen again or something like total piece of shit, but likely,
you know, likely place for Anna Claire Howland to be. And, you know, being a staff assistant
for a senator is a relatively low wage entry level job on Capitol Hill, which I only,
mention because according to her Instagram, Anna Claire Howland is always on vacation.
Could we really quickly just run through some of the vacations that Anna Claire Howland has
taken since Trump got into office for a second time?
Please. Also, I'm like, wherever she goes, she brings the kind kids table with her.
Oh, God.
In March 2025, Anna Claire went to Casa de Campo, which is a luxury five star resort
in the Dominican Republic. And to your point, her Instagram caption was,
I need a vacation from this vacation. Oh, I'm sure you do. I'm sure you do.
Looks rough. In May 2025, not a vacation, but she did graduate from
Southern Methodist University. Congrats, Queen. One month later, though, in June 2025,
she posted a carousel from a bar, a guest ranch in Wyoming, which I looked up and costs $800
per person per night, not per room per person, because I guess like the horseback riding is
included or something. And so you pay $800 per person per night. But of course. And then a
couple months later, in September 2025, Anna Claire was back at a guest ranch in Wyoming.
She couldn't get enough. A few months later, in February 2026,
she took a ski vacation to Aspen, Colorado, which if you're unfamiliar,
is one of the most expensive ski resorts in the United States. A few months after that,
two months after that, in April 2026, she had a house at Coachella.
Whoa. Money.
One month later, she was in Corfu, Greece with her family. And she had a really nice dress.
She has good outfits. Like she has good outfits.
She does. Yeah. She should have worn one of these to the cool kids party.
Right. Instead of that fucking black slip dress that everyone said was from Shein.
Yeah, exactly.
One month after that, she was in Saint-Tropez, France, where, shout out, she's holding in this
photo.
So from her, what looks like her hotel room, she's holding an Yves Saint Laurent
Raffia beach bag that costs $5,300 or like two months of rent.
No, baby. That's like one day of rent wherever she's living.
And then one month after that, geez, she's on a vacation every month. She was on a boat in Croatia.
Mm hmm.
And that brings us to August 2026. I don't know if she's been on vacation in the last
three months. Unfortunately, she hasn't updated us via Instagram.
She's probably on one right now.
Right.
Right.
You know, one thing I'll say about this, too, is like, as somebody who also like tries to get
the best pic for Instagram when I'm on vacation, these Instagram pics are so curated. Like,
this is a young woman.
This is a young woman who wants her wealth to be seen and noticed. You don't take the mirror pic
with the $5,300 YSL bag if you don't want people to see it and be like, Oh, my God, she has the
$5,300 Raffia YSL beach tote. Like this picture in Croatia is specifically taken so that all of
these yachts are in the background. Like, she wants to be seen. She wants her wealth to be
admired. And she wants to be seen. And she wants her wealth to be admired. So if anyone thinks it's like, you know, you guys are stalking her Instagram
vacation pictures. I'm like, she she wanted them to be stalked. That's why she took all of them
and posted them on Instagram. And they also have 1000s of likes. So she's like on her way. I'm sure
she would love to be like a mid tier influencer. So to answer the question of where are the cruel
kids now? As that viral tweet from earlier this week said, Where are these washed up people now?
The answer is, they're fine. They are absolutely fine. And I've structured this episode the way
that I have. Because Bernadine, I think lived of all of these people, the most honest interpretation
of conservatism in her own life. Yeah, like she really practiced it. She really walked the walk.
And despite Raquel de Bono, who organized that cool kids party to
begin with, who said, you know, we're barstool conservatives. If you think of yourself as a
barstool conservative, or a trad femme religious conservative, it doesn't matter. Because the
policies within the Trump administration and the rhetoric that came out of the Trump administration
has been very clear about where they see a woman's place. Yes. Conservatism is conservatism. Yes.
And the truth is, Bernadine practice it the most honestly, without a safety net of
millions of dollars and look where it ended up for her.
versus look where it ended up
for all of these other women
who essentially were LARPing.
Yes.
This reminds me of that book,
I believe,
that Candace Owens put out
where she's like sitting on the floor
holding a sign that's like,
make him a sandwich.
Like these conservative female influencers
and pundits like the Megyn Kelly's
and the Ann Coulter's
and the Candace Owens,
they preach to women
that they should be subservient to men.
They preach this idea
of not pushing back
against the status quo,
of rejecting feminism.
And to your point, Matt,
like Bernadine actually did that
and she did it with no safety net.
She did it in a raw, authentic, honest way
where at a very young age,
she dropped out of Texas A&M
so that she could have her babies
and live at home
and be a stay-at-home mom.
And when we ask,
about like the financial realities of that,
she said it was hard
that they went without.
And when I look at Anna Claire's vacation photos,
it's like one thing she's not going is without.
She is going with,
like she has everything she wants.
That is the difference
between somebody who works on Capitol Hill
for a Republican senator
and helps craft those policies
versus the actual lived realities
of those policies
and of the reality.
Rhetoric that is spearheaded
by these wealthy conservative elites.
And people act like it's the same
on both sides of the political spectrum
because of course,
Democrats in Congress are also wealthy,
but it's not the same
because they're not preaching
that you need to make him a sandwich.
They're not preaching
that you should have four kids
by the age of 23
and that you should live
this godly, subservient, wifely duty.
They're not.
So it's,
it's not the same.
And I think the consequences
for women are so stark
when you actually have to face that reality.
And every single one of these cruel kids,
most of these women have two degrees.
Most of these,
which is why I didn't just focus
on Anna Claire Howland,
even though she does have the best Instagram
to her credit.
They, they all have two degrees.
They all work either on Capitol Hill
or in marketing jobs.
They're,
they're conservatism is a LARP
and they were always going to be fine.
And the same can be said for the men
because I, you know,
I don't,
I don't want to view this solely
through a gendered lens
because a lot of men have suffered
over the last few years
in this country and around the world,
but not these men,
not the cruel kids,
men at the Trump inauguration weekend.
These people were always going to be fine.
The rest of us were the experiment.
I mean,
millions hurt and killed around the world
from USAID cuts in the last two years,
Medicaid cuts in rural hospitals
on the precipice of shutting down
immigrant communities destroyed by ice raids,
trans people and their families
sent from their homes,
fleeing in red States
where they felt like they wouldn't be able
to get healthcare anymore.
Palestinians and Iranian school girls
and Lebanese people butchered
by Trump's party.
Trump's bombs everyone in this country left
holding the bag who's unable to afford
their gas and groceries anymore,
but not the cool kids.
They are fine.
They were always going to be,
this was all an experiment where they could dress up
and pretend to be Reagan Republicans in the eighties
and say the R word and be racist without consequences
for a couple of years.
I hope it was fun.
It's bleak.
The last thought that I had about these women
and sort of juxtaposing their lives
is I also think that when it comes
to these conservative women
who occupy these positions in elite society
and have all of these privileges,
what unites them with women like Bernadine
who don't is that they are also not immune
from the patriarchal violence that afflicts women
at all levels of society,
we see this regularly.
I think of Lauren Southern.
I think of Hillary Crowder.
I think about women at each strata of the Republican party
who have come forward or been exposed in some way,
shape or form.
- Megyn Kelly.
- Megyn Kelly and these dynamics.
The difference though, however,
is still at the end of the day,
there is a massive material difference between Bernadine
telling us that she's glad that there are so many,
free things to do with her kids in the area
because like taking six kids to the zoo is really costly.
- Which I think she told us
before we started recording, by the way.
- There's a big material difference
between making $2,500 a month from Instagram
and having to figure out
how you're gonna take care of six kids off of that
versus having a $3.5 billion family fortune to fall back on,
assuming that you stay within the family's good graces
and are allowed to take part in that.
- Which by all means.
- If Edward O'Neill plays his cards right,
it seems that he will.
Now, as a little bit of an epilogue,
remember those influencers I mentioned
were also at that party?
Can I tell you about them?
- Please.
- Because they're literally,
I mean, just talk about a cherry on top
of a movement completely fucking falling apart.
The influencers are a goddamn disaster.
So Cam Higby, who was at the Cruel Kids party,
he hosted a show for PragerU,
a time in the second Trump administration
in December of 2025, almost a year ago.
He became a credentialed member of the Pentagon Press Corps
after he agreed to sign a 21 page written agreement
that no traditional outlet agreed to sign
because it restricted their ability
to accurately cover the Pentagon.
- God.
- Which as a journalist,
I would imagine you have feelings about.
- I mean, it's just like, ugh.
We saw this so much at the beginning
of Trump's second administration,
where it was like all of the mainstream outlets
were ejected from these positions.
And it was totally staffed with influencers
who have no business serving as the Pentagon Press Corps.
I personally feel that I would have no business
serving in the Pentagon Press Corps.
What the fuck do I know about how the Pentagon operates?
But Cam Higby certainly has no business
in the Pentagon Press Corps.
- So a little update on Cam Higby.
A few months ago in May of 2026,
he went to Delaney Hall ice concentration camp
in New Jersey during protests against it,
antagonized people and was pepper sprayed.
Oh no, that's not the end.
Last month in October, 2026,
Cam Higby was charged with felony election fraud
related charges over content he made
where he pretended to be a Muslim woman
and wore a hijab and spoke to election judges
by using the identities of real Muslim Minnesota voters
without those voters' knowledge or permission
in violation of state law.
And each of the charges he's currently facing
carries up to five years in prison
and a fine of up to $10,000.
- Whew, I found the election fraud
that conservatives are so worried about.
- Yeah, exactly, exactly.
The election fraud was me all along.
We were all wondering how this could have happened.
- That is so despicable,
but I'm glad that there will actually
be some accountability here
'cause it reminds me of the long held Republican tradition
of just making shit up and impersonating people.
Like what they did to Planned Parenthood
where they pretended to be pregnant teenagers.
Like they do this all the time,
but I'm glad that he crossed so many lines
specifically related to election fraud.
That now he's gonna have to face consequences.
- Now the election fraud is me.
- Yeah, seriously.
- And then remember Xavier Deruso,
the flamboyant black gay Zionist PragerU personality.
Xavier spent much of the last two years doing Zionist.
I feel like I'm in like the end credits of a movie
where it's like, what happened to all of these people?
And it's like, they're all in jail.
They're like, what happened to all of these people?
And I'm like, what happened to all of these people?
And then I'm like, well,
zionist propaganda including trips to the gaza border sponsored and handled by the israeli
I don't know what happened to all of these people.
government where he took videos of himself at the i don't know if you remember this he would like
take videos of himself at the gaza humanitarian foundation sham aid sites the ghf was set up by
the U.S. and Israeli governments to try to fix the problem that they completely made up about
Hamas doing some like systemic circumventing of aid for Palestinian people in Gaza. So like the
U.S. and Israel had to set up their own sites and then the Palestinians would go to those sites
and the IDF would shoot and kill them. Until the GHF was shut down after I believe less than a
year but Xavier was one of the people who Israel sent to those sites to make
propaganda content about look at all the food we have oh my god and he would
make that content for PragerU until last week Xavier filed a lawsuit
suit against PragerU alleging racist and anti-gay discrimination, hostile work environment and
retaliation. Well, I don't know who could have saw this coming. I mean, God, to be clear, nobody
deserves to face discrimination, a hostile work environment or retaliation. And also,
it is not whatsoever surprising that a conservative propaganda outlet would not treat
its most marginalized employees in the kindest and fairest manner. That was beautifully said.
And I'm just going to keep it moving. Bryce Hall. Remember how he was at the Cruel Kids party with
his then girlfriend, Michaela Lafuente? Yep. Well, last month, Bryce was arrested and charged
with a murder. And he was charged with a murder. And he was
charged with a domestic violence felony and a domestic battery misdemeanor against that very
woman. Oh, that is really, really bleak. I've covered Bryce Hall for a really long time because
I used to report on YouTubers and TikTokers at Business Insider. Yeah. And Bryce has a really
long violent history that I think a lot of people have totally overlooked. All the way back in 2020,
I remember I did this story about
Bryce Hall physically attacking restaurant workers at a Mexican restaurant in LA because they asked
him to stop vaping. And he literally violently attacked people there. It seems like a proportion
reaction. Totally. He has this aggressive, violent pattern of behavior. And yet, so many at the time,
you know, semi-liberal, I suppose, institutions like TikTok itself, and also like all of these
influencer industry organizations uplifted him because he had a bajillion followers. And he was
a member of the Hype House, or the Sway House, actually. I think Bryce Hall was Sway House.
Sorry, correction. No, that matters. Yeah.
But it's absolutely despicable. It does not surprise me at all that he would be accused
and charged with domestic violence. And
I feel like it ties back to what we were just talking about with regards to
conservative women, regardless of whether they're at these parties or whether they're at home with
their six kids. Like, you're not immune from gender-based violence. And this is a political
party and a community that valorizes patriarchal violence against women.
Yeah. And I also, I felt ending talking about Bryce Hall feels like a very honest note,
because Bryce Hall, you know, charged with domestic violence, felonies, and misdemeanors.
We didn't have time today, because there was so much else to cover, to get into some of the biggest,
like, manosphere influencers of the last two years. But I think most people probably know
that Andrew and Tristan Tate have been charged with sex trafficking in multiple countries.
Who else? Well, Clavicular was charged with rape. Clavicular was charged with rape.
On one hand, it's like, look where this right-wing youth movement of the 2020s
has left us, with a lot of women brutalized and a lot of men under investigation for brutalizing
women. And then on the other hand, it's like, well, yeah. Exactly. And I hope that Michaela
Lafuente is okay. Yeah. And lastly, I suppose the kingmaker of MAGA youth, Charlie Kirk, is,
you know, dead, so. We didn't laugh, so you can't get us in trouble.
I'm silent. As the great Jen Welch said, no comment.
Good luck to Erica trying to hawk the Kirk hot sauce.
So, conclusion. I wanted to finish this episode by just saying that I think in the blue tsunami of it all,
there is this feeling that,
like, well, that's over. And I have, to a certain extent, treated the subjects of this episode in
that way, because it does feel profoundly, like, the thing that was happening for the last few
years in the culture is over. And it really did crash and burn. But no loss, I hope we've learned,
is forever. And also, no win is forever, politically or culturally. The voting public,
as we all know, has the collective memory of a goldfish.
And I think, to tie this back to, like, hard politics, I just, I want to reiterate that,
like, the win, the blue nami of it all, it's not the end. It is very much the absolute start of
what Democrats have to do to meet people's material needs. Because otherwise, that void
gets filled with grievance and anger, as it has, as it did over the last couple years. And minorities
are always the first to win. And I think, to tie this back to, like, hard politics, I just, I want to
always the first people to be scapegoated in that. And they were.
One of the sort of pieces of data to come out in the results of the midterms was that a lot of
former Trump voters, when they voted for Democrats, and just in general, when people
voted for Democrats, a lot of them were voting directly in opposition to Trump. I think that,
like, the progressive vision espoused by a lot of these candidates was a motivating factor.
And an energizing factor in getting people to vote for a vision of the future they believed in.
But I also think a lot of those votes were simply a rejection of what Donald Trump has done to this
country over the past couple of years. And when people vote to punish the incumbent,
that is a pattern that can just as easily be repeated with whoever they replace that incumbent
with. It's a pattern that we see time and time again, in the voting habits of Americans, where
we don't like what's currently happening. So we're going to punish whoever is in charge.
I even think that was a motivating factor behind why some people voted for Trump the second time.
So to your point, Matt, like, you have to do something once you actually are in office,
because the public will just swing right back if you don't.
And I cannot do another fucking cruel kids table.
No.
I can't do it.
No. We at least have to come up with a different name.
The kind kids table. The kind kids. Maybe the
kind kids table is what I will rename the A Bit Fruity podcast and all of its listeners.
We're the kind kids table.
Oh, God.
Kat, I love you so much. Thank you for this undertaking that we did together.
Where can people find you?
Thank you so much for having me. People can find me at my YouTube channel, which is just Kat
Tembarge. Or you can read my newsletter, which is SpitfireNews.com. And it is free to subscribe.
I love you all so much. Thank you for listening to this episode. I really wanted to, like,
push myself in a sort of creative direction. We had multiple filming sessions. We had
interviews. We did the whole thing. And. Journalistic AF.
Journalistic. My Instagram DMs are crazy. I reached out to all of these people for comment.
And as of right now, still only Raquel Debono responded and told me that she thought that
the ISG portations were fine, but that the TikToks were tacky.
So, you know, please let this never happen again. Call your senators and tell them to
replace Chuck Schumer as Senate Majority Leader, because we deserve better and we deserve change.
And I love you so much. Until next time, stay fruity.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The "Cruel Kids" cover from New York Magazine in 2025 captured a youth-driven MAGA movement celebrating Trump’s second inauguration with overtly performative, culturally charged aesthetics.
The event, hosted by conservative influencer Raquel Debono, featured young, wealthy attendees who believed in cultural domination through displays of entitlement, sexuality, and political alignment.
The movement relied on a patriarchal, hyper-masculine, and performative conservative identity, often centered on traditional gender roles, class privilege, and anti-trans messaging.
Despite initial cultural dominance, the MAGA youth movement collapsed in 2026 due to widespread backlash over corruption, ICE raids, the Epstein files, and anti-trans policies, leading to a significant defeat in the midterms.
Many former participants, including influencers and attendees, have distanced themselves from the movement, with some, like Raquel Debono, expressing regret or disillusionment over the administration’s transparency and conduct.
The cultural landscape has shifted dramatically, with former "trad wife" influencers like Hannah Neilman and Nara Smith rebranding or rejecting the lifestyle as outdated and harmful.
The collapse reflects a broader societal reckoning with the excesses of conservative culture, including its toxicity, financial privilege, and gendered hypocrisy.
The narrative suggests that those who once celebrated cultural domination are now reevaluating their identities, with many embracing more inclusive, financially stable, or personally reflective lives.
Summary:
The "Cruel Kids" cover from New York Magazine in 2025 symbolized a peak of cultural dominance by young conservative activists who celebrated Donald Trump’s second inauguration with a performative, elitist, and often misogynistic aesthetic. These youth, many of whom were affluent or connected, gathered at a TikTok-sponsored event featuring influencers, influencers in MAGA hats, and displays of wealth and sexuality. The event represented a broader cultural movement rooted in patriarchal ideals, anti-trans sentiment, and a rejection of 2010s openness.
However, by 2026, the movement had collapsed due to public backlash over corruption, ICE deportations, and the administration’s perceived self-dealing. The midterms saw a historic "blue tsunami," with Republicans losing more seats than in 50 years, and young voters decisively rejecting MAGA ideology. Former participants, including influencers and attendees, have distanced themselves from the movement, with many rebranding or altering their public personas.
Influencers like Hannah Neilman and Nara Smith have shifted from promoting "trad wife" lifestyles to embracing more authentic, modern identities. The episode underscores a cultural reckoning: the era of performative conservatism, fueled by privilege and toxicity, has ended, and many of its participants are now confronting the consequences of their past actions. The narrative reveals a shift not just in political power, but in cultural self-awareness, as those once celebrated for their "cruel" energy now reflect on their roles in a changing society.
FAQs
The cover, published in late 2025, depicted young right-wing partygoers at a MAGA inauguration event and symbolized the cultural dominance of the MAGA movement at the time. It highlighted a shift in political culture, showing the celebration of conservatism, alpha male aesthetics, and overtly anti-trans messaging.
The cover featured Edward O'Neill, Sarah Petsnick, Ben McCool, Clay Shoemaker, and the Howland sisters Anna Claire and Mary Louise. Others included Caroline Murphy, Brooklyn Tucker, Jordan Wright, and conservative influencers like Riley Gaines, Cam Higby, and Xavier de Russo.
The movement quickly lost momentum after the 2026 midterms, which saw a massive blue wave, with Republicans losing more seats than in 50 years. Young voters who had supported Trump shifted away, rejecting the movement's culture of cruelty and self-interest.
Yes, they celebrated a hyper-masculine, sexually charged, and culturally regressive ideal, often promoting 'alpha male' and 'clean girl' aesthetics, anti-trans views, and a return to traditional conservative values, often at the expense of inclusivity and social progress.
These influencers rebranded or distanced themselves from the 'trad wife' narrative after facing backlash. Nara Smith shifted to fashion and New York lifestyle content, while Hannah Neilson acknowledged the fantasy of her lifestyle and began discussing her role as a businesswoman and CEO.
Events like the TikTok Power 30 party amplified the visibility of young conservatives, creating a viral culture around MAGA values. Social media platforms enabled influencers to promote these ideals, shaping a generation’s perception of political and lifestyle norms.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.