Go back

What endometriosis care should look like

27m 47s

What endometriosis care should look like

A deeply personal story of a woman named Francis Muir reveals the long and painful journey many women face with endometriosis—a condition affecting about 10% of women of child-bearing age. For years, Francis endured chronic pelvic pain, dismissed by doctors, until a referral to a specialized clinic in Vancouver led to diagnosis and effective treatment. The clinic, led by gynecologists Dr. Christina Williams and Dr. Paul Young, employs a holistic, patient-centered model involving detailed pain mapping, counseling, physical therapy, and surgery. Research shows significant improvements in pain, quality of life, and mental health, with reduced emergency visits. The team has developed tools like the Endometriosis Pain Index to guide treatment decisions and has challenged harmful myths—such as endometriosis being aggressive or incurable—by emphasizing that pain is real and manageable. A key breakthrough is the finding that even brief school-based education can greatly increase awareness, with 80% of teenage boys understanding endometriosis after a short lesson. Despite no cure, the narrative around endometriosis can be transformed through education, advocacy, and access to specialized care. The story underscores that women with endometriosis are not alone, their symptoms are real, and they deserve to be heard and supported in their treatment journey.

Transcription

4669 Words, 25678 Characters

English
A devastating flood in Nepal just a few months ago has left the country with a nearly 5 billion dollar recovery bill. But who should pay for it? When countries suffering some of the worst climate impacts have contributed so little to the problem? Hey, it's Johanna Wachstaff, host of What On Earth, where we help make sense of how people are changing the planet and what we can do about it. And this week, as world leaders gather for the UN Climate Summit in Turkey, Nepal is putting a long-awaited global climate fund to its first major test, but is up to the challenge. Find and follow What On Earth, wherever you get your podcasts. This is a CBC podcast. I'm Dr. Brian Goldman. This is White Coat Black Art. Here is former CBC reporter Danielle Dan Trommel describing to us what it feels like to have endometriosis. Endometriosis feels like my insides are a boiling pot of chili. Like a cat is trapped inside my uterus and is trying to claw its way out. Like being stuck on a spinny ride, going double speed at the fair. That was eight years ago, but Danielle's words have stuck with me ever since. A few weeks ago, Dr. Christina Williams, a gynecologist at BC Women's Hospital in Vancouver, said we need to do another show on endometriosis. I really believe we can change the narrative of endometriosis. That's a bit of Dr. Williams' message of hope about a disease that can start from a teenage girl's first period and affects an eye-popping 10% of women. A bit later, we'll visit Dr. Williams at the groundbreaking clinic where she practices. But first, there's a woman I want you to meet. Francis, New York, greets me at the front door of her home in Maple Ridge, about 45 kilometers east of Vancouver. She lives here with her partner Chris Kingdon and their 19-month-old baby Olivia. Chris takes Olivia to the park. Francis leads me to a living room that looks like a toddler's cyclone. A happy albeit chaotic outcome to a journey through endometriosis that goes back many years. But I want you to take me right back to the beginning. How old were you when you had your earliest symptoms of what turned out to be endo? Oh, probably late high school. And what were your symptoms? Mostly just pain, pain with my cycle, but honestly, pain like 90% of the month, like just living with chronic pelvic pain. Tell me about the first doctor you went to see complaining of what you thought was period pain. Oh gosh, probably would have been late high school for the very first time. And I remember being so scared and trying to, you know, just drum of the courage to kind of explain like what's scared. Yeah, yeah, for sure, scared. Were you scared of? Just not being taken seriously. And what was the first encounter with your with a doctor like? Here's some samples of some pain medication, which was the pack of Advil and it's normal and, you know, not really anything, not really anything helpful. That's for sure. You'd already tried Advil at that point? Yeah, yeah. The issue with the pain that I've kind of experienced throughout my life is over-the-counter drugs like Advil and Tylenol, like just don't touch it. They don't come close to being able to manage it properly. So what were you thinking as you walked out of that to doctor's office? Defeated and frustrated because, you know, what else do you do, right? Your own family doctor is not going to take you seriously. So I mean, being in chronic pain affects every aspect of your life. It affects your work, your sleep, your relationships, like it eventually just bleeds into every aspect of your life until you can't ignore it anymore. You can't avoid it. The thing is, Francis had endometriosis and didn't know it. Neither did her doctors back then. She has normal periods that are painful and she just needs to cope with them. Later, in her mid-20s, she's in university and has a pivotal conversation. I was having a party and one of my girlfriends was over and we were having a couple drinks and we were up late and we started talking and she goes, "Francis, what you're describing is absolutely not normal." She's like, "You should go see a gynecologist. You should go see a specialist." And the next day, I think at this point, I was so fed up with my family doctor that I went and I waited, I don't know, like, 45 minutes at a walk-in clinic and said, "Hey, I would like a referral to a gynecologist in Maple Ridge here, you know, here are my issues. I would like to see someone who specializes in this area and I was able to get a referral." So the doctor believed you? Yep. Now you're sitting in the office with a gynecologist. You give a history, you give a physical examination. What does the gynecologist say? First thing he says is, "I think you might have endometriosis." And you said, "What's that?" I'd never heard of it before. I had no idea what he was talking about. The Society of Obstetricians and Gynecologists of Canada defines endometriosis as an inflammatory disease that occurs when tissue from the lining of the uterus or endometrium spreads outside the uterus and potentially all over the pelvis, causing general pain as well as painful periods, painful sex, bowel and bladder symptoms and infertility. And even before the explanation of what is endometriosis, the fact that someone was able to put a name to this problem that I've been, you know, battling for a lot of my life at this point was a relief in a sense, obviously hearing that there's no cure. Less so. Back then, Francis was told there was no cure, but there were treatments and she tried lots of them. Birth control and other hormonal treatments didn't help. Then she had her first laparoscopic or keyhole surgery. The gynecologist found one of the key sites where there was endometriosis, but the doctor said the location made it difficult to remove. Her pain continued unabated. But then she caught a break. Her partner Chris has family that works in healthcare. They helped her get a referral to Dr. Paul Young, a gynecologist at the BC Women's Center for pelvic pain and endometriosis. Dr. Young works there with Dr. Christina Williams. I remember getting the call. I was on the ferry and I got a phone call before we like, we're out of reception and I just remember being so excited. Being like, I'm in. I got the call. I had an appointment, you know, two weeks from, you know, the day I got accepted in and I just remember being very excited and really just hopeful. What was that first appointment? Like what, first of all, what was, what was different about it? The whole approach was different. It wasn't just, uh, hi, I'm your doctor. What are your symptoms? Yadda, yadda, yadda, we're going to start this medication. Um, he took like a full history. He asked me so many questions. Um, not only was Dr. Young the first doctor that I've ever had that has believed me, has listened to me, has validated my pain, but just unlike any sort of family doctor, doctor anywhere that I've, that I've seen. Like Dr. Young prescribes Francis another medication. Then he does surgery to remove pockets of endometriosis and to lift and suspend her ovaries so they don't stick to other parts of the pelvis. And that's not all. As part of her initial assessment, doctors mapped out where Francis had pain. She had physical therapy to learn how to manage muscular pain. Yadda, counselor. Yeah. You don't really realize that you have so much, um, like, frustration and like almost resentment towards just how the medical system is set up and how previously as a patient you were treated when seeking help. Was there any treatment that worked the best? The best relief I had was after my third excision surgery with Dr. Young, um, my left ovary, I, so at this point, I've just, my pain on the left side was just getting worse and worse and worse and none of these interventions were helping. And when we went in, apparently the left ovary had adhered itself to my abdominal wall. And there were, you know, lesions. There was endometriosis. And so, you know, everything on the abdominal wall, on the abdominal wall, on the ovary in various cul-de-sacs like in all, I mean, it wasn't, I don't, again, I don't know anything about stages. I just know that when he said that, I felt so like validated in that, oh, hey, my left side has been bothering me for so many years. And it's because my ovary was literally stuck to the abdominal wall. And now it's removed. So hopefully that will give me some relief. I was really hopeful, definitely like six to eight weeks after I was, you know, finishing healing. My pain was a lot less. Like I felt a lot better for the first time in years. Since you've been a teenager. Yeah, exactly. It was very exciting. So. What point in your life were you actually thinking you wanted to start a family? I knew that being diagnosed with something like endo might make that more difficult. So like since I was in my 20s, like that was always kind of in the back of your mind, thinking, well, what if, what if it doesn't work? What if I can't? After my last surgery and after my, one of my ovaries was removed, I was extra worried about that. But Dr. Yong, I remember being, he was really, really great. He was like, that doesn't necessarily mean that, you know, it's not going to happen for you. And which is nice because at this point, I'm like, oh, I don't know if that's ever going to happen for me. You know, should I be ready for it, right? It's funny because the day I found out I had an appointment with Dr. Young to do I think it was like trigger point injections and I remember taking the test and being like well obviously we're not going through with that today but I kept the appointment and I remember seeing him and saying hey just gonna put a pause on that but guess what this is you know where I'm at and I just had some questions so I just wanted to to talk to him and he was fabulous and you know he reassured me that being pregnant and having endometriosis also didn't make me high-risk because that was also something that I was worried about as well and like what if I continue to have pain what if I'm one of those people that gets pregnant and still has my endometriosis pain throughout my pregnancy like I just I was terrified I was really lucky I had a really really nice really comfortable pregnancy I'm like my body owes me this kindness at this point that wasn't the end of the story was it you had something else happened after that fortunately it wasn't but you know what as is the nature of my story the pregnancy was great and then everything went downhill after my daughter was born it was actually the day that I was supposed to be discharged from the hospital at about one in the morning I got up middle of the night to go to washroom and I hemorrhaged and I had a massive post part of hemorrhage I lost over like I was around like three liters of blood I had five units three units of plasma that were required miraculously I didn't faint I was able to continue to talk to the nurses and kind of tell them what was going on and your life saving treatment yeah and try to help it was yeah it was it was a really crazy experience and the worst part was my partner was like right there next to me when it all happened and so he had to take the baby and leave the room and watch you know ten fifteen nurses and doctors come in by the way there's a potential link between endometriosis and postpartum hemorrhage to prevent bleeding the uterus needs to contract following the birth endometriosis can sometimes prevent that from happening it was in the aftermath of her postpartum hemorrhage that Francis started having nightmares every night and lots of anxiety around her period returning I had to see a counselor because I was diagnosed with posttraumatic stress disorder and I was terrified of my period coming back because I'm like if I see any blood I'm gonna lose my mind so I ended up doing EMDR which I found insanely helpful and so when my period did return I was as cool as a cucumber as one could be and it you know wasn't as terrifying as I thought so you actually had PTSD from the medical trauma from from the life threatening medical trauma yeah well EMDR is eye movement desensitization and reprocessing it's a psychotherapy treatment to help people process painful and traumatic life events everyone on the doctor there's some random child that was like oh that cute baby's back Chris brings baby Olivia back from the park as Francis partner he's been with her throughout much of the time she's been dealing with endometriosis and it's worse how bad was it and I'm asking you as a witness I mean you can't you don't know you weren't feeling what she was feeling but but you you knew that she was suffering it's really hard to say she doesn't complain a lot about it you could always tell when she was in discomfort driving to and from work you get the sort of the the exhales and I'm like I'm in pain kind of stuff you know it was always so frustrating for me in the sense of I'm a here's the problem let's fix it and we couldn't do that with this I there was no well if this is broken we do this if this is if you're hungry you do that but it wasn't it was just kind of let's figure it out and keep trying another appointment keep trying a different scan keep trying a different procedure is this going to be the next one that solves it is there ever going to be one that solves it last question I'm gonna ask you what's your message to guys listening to this who have women in their lives who have endometriosis I mean I'd say take their word for it right like it it's when she's talking about pain and I'm like is it really that bad and then I hear that her ovaries stuck to the inside of her stomach like oh probably should have been a bit more sympathetic to that because I can only imagine how much moving would hurt right it's just constantly flexing against you so yeah I mean take their word for it and then just do as much as you can we'll be right back Daniel Smith says it's time for a woke hiring practices to go the Alberta government is scrapping diversity equity and inclusion I'm Kathleen Petty in this week on West of Center what is behind this policy shift Emily Williams here a producer on the show I'll tell you which other premieres might be paying attention plus a former UCP cabinet minister who says this won't make things more fair this week on West of Center find us now on your favorite podcast app you're listening to White Copeland Black Art this week Francis me or is one of the roughly 10% of women of child-bearing potential in Canada who have endometriosis many don't know they have it and even fewer find a specialist who is as knowledgeable as the doctors at the center for pelvic pain and endometriosis at BC women's hospital all right so let me show you around Brian just so you get a sense of what our clinic is like after Christina Williams is a Vancouver gynecologist she's been at the clinic since it opened its doors in 2012 the clinic sees around a thousand new patients a year and this is Alexis who books ORs and this is Amy and it's one of several in Canada that specialize in endometriosis here their world leaders in research and are developing advanced treatments so if we keep walking our age will bring the patients in as Francis me or found out the clinic staff take a holistic approach to endometriosis that includes a detailed history and physical map of each woman's pain their treatments are also holistic with counseling physical therapy even diet you approached me at a gynecology conference with an invitation to come to this clinic what made you want to do that well first of all I have to say I'm so grateful to you for wanting to come and the reason I approached you is because you know I've dedicated my career to pelvic pain and endometriosis and I've observed lately in the last few years there's been an increase of awareness even though many people still don't know what it is but the narrative that I see out there and our patients talk about is very negative and scary that's what I would like to share with you my my experience and what I've learned that might change that narrative that endometriosis doesn't have to be scary you got it you've personally seen lots of women here in the clinic and have and have heard lots of stories haven't you I've heard so many stories Brian that I I don't know in it they keep coming you know they're like yeah very very I mean heartbreaking stories actually I've spent you know I always say to the residents when I teach that the hardest part of Endo is not the difficult surgeries that it requires it's just hearing that the stories of that the journeys of our patients through the disease you said heartbreaking how has it come to touch you so that that you find these stories heartbreaking because it is different well because I see how you know our our patients that that what they've gone through it's it's really impacted their quality of life well now you see a young a young person with pain and endometriosis and failed surgery and and the time it's taking her and and the things that she believes and how it affects relationships or mental health her sexual life her digestive health so so their bodies and minds are in a state of like high alert and an extraordinary pain and not being understood not being supported when they say well I can't go to work because I mean a lot of pain and nobody knows what's happening to them and and that's really hard to cope with is that not knowing and not being validated validating their pain is a big part of what Dr. Williams does there's pain from uterine contractions during menstruation there's pain from what Dr. Williams calls inflamed lesions of endometriosis Williams says all of that puts the body on high alert for incoming pain signals and then it comes from also for some patients probably half of the patients we see it comes from the system of pain that has become hyper agitated in the woman's body and this is what we call have a name it's no seplastic but just to explain it it would be like the body feels there's something internally wrong in the peritoneum in the cavity or the uterus and then it's trying to give a signal that something dangerous is happening it's like when we have appendicitis our abdominal wall becomes very painful so this is not the endometriosis itself producing the pain but the signals are really amplifying the pain to tell the woman there's something wrong there's something wrong internally the women who come here also deal with lots of misconceptions what are some of the myths that you're trying to break here you know there's no way once you have the diagnosis is it's going to completely affect your life in an extremely negative way, which is mostly hopeless. And the other myth that I think is very prevalent out there is that it is a very aggressive invasive disease that can affect your organs and, you know, obstruct your colon or your lung. And those cases are very, very small proportion of true endometriosis, but their presence in the media and the conversation as this is going to take over a woman's body. That's another myth, which is not real. That mythology is very hurtful for women because it brings an element of fear that it really basically impairs recovery. The pain has reached a state of nervous system dysregulation that itself perpetuating and virtually felt to be incurable by most women who suffer that. But that's because of their experience, not because it's incurable. Exactly, it's because of their experience. We believe in our clinic that it is very possible. It's maybe not curable, but the improvements in quality of life with the proper addressing the different pains of endometriosis is excellent. And our research validates that. Among the things their research validates is that teenage girls and boys can be taught in high school about endometriosis. That is an actual research experiment they did. - Oh, damn. Tell me exactly what you did in that state because it's fascinating. - Yeah, it was fascinating. So basically what they did, they went to high school and they had two groups of high school students. And at the end, they could see that everybody, because they had that seminar, the little 10 minutes, they were able, their boys had 80%, they knew, they felt they knew what endometriosis was in 10 minutes. - So 80% of teenage boys knowing what endometriosis is? - That's mind-boggling, that's amazing. I mean, there's no reason why it shouldn't be. It's just education. - Exactly, exactly. - In the middle of my conversation with Dr. Williams, her colleague, Dr. Paul Young, Francis Muir's gynecologist, joins us. - Oh, hi, I'm Ray. - Nice to meet you. - Well, Dr. Young and his colleagues wrote the SOGC guidelines on endometriosis that I quoted at the top. He's also the clinic's research director, and research is a big part of what they do here. They've gathered data on thousands of current and former patients with endometriosis, histories, physicals, ultrasounds, and even surgical specimens. Dr. Young says it's with the future in mind. - Yeah, so really excited to share this. So we have a large registry. I'd say the largest in Canada, amongst the largest in the world, with a biobank of surgical endometriosis tissues. And through that, we've been able to show our care model at our clinic here. We've been able to show that the improvements over time. Subjectively, there's our average improvements in pain, improvements in quality of life, improvements in mental health, and importantly, less healthcare system utilization. So patients less often, for example, having to go to emergency. So we have, I guess, proof of the efficacy of this care model. We also have done research showing how can we predict ahead of time which patients will respond to the different treatment options we offer. So for example, we just published that for endometriosis surgery. We created a tool called Endometriosis Pain Index, and now we can better counsel patients. You know what, you're gonna be a better responder for pain, or not as good a responder for pain for surgery. And so that will guide the decision-making. - Dr. Christina Williams, look at the last word. - Well, my last word is that I really believe we can change the narrative of endometriosis. I wanna tell you if you think or you know you have it, please find out what type you have, find out what's inside your body, and the sources of pain, and then seek changes in your lifestyle, physiotherapy, good surgery, and eventually the life can be very positive after diagnosis of endometriosis. This is our feeling in our clinic. - Dr. Christina Williams, Dr. Poion, thank you so much for speaking with me. - Thank you, Brian. - Thank you very much. - The doctors here are on a mission to let women know that there's hope, and there's help. But as Dr. Williams said, the disease has no cure, at least not yet. Francis Mior knows about that. Here's what's happening with her now. Now that your periods have come back, what about the endometriosis? So as they've started to come back, obviously I've noticed more pain, you know, over the past months, unfortunately, it was getting worse on my right side, where my existing ovaries, and a couple months ago, three, four months ago, I went in my doctor, my family doctor who I love, sent me for an ultrasound, and so now turns out I have no very insist on the one remaining ovary, and it's so nice that you came out to visit me today, because tomorrow would have been a challenge, 'cause I have a follow-up ultrasound, just to check on that, because not only do I have had pelvic pain during my cycle now that it's returned, but my whole sort of like fertility window around ovulation has been incredibly painful as well. So I'm just trying to figure that out, and I might even call Dr. Wrong again, just ask him for some advice. - It could be what they call an endometrioma, couldn't it? - It could, yeah, I know it. - Like an indication of endometriosis coming back. - It could, and so obviously that, you know, that weighs on your mind, and that's always a worry. Right now it's about three centimeters in size, but we will find out tomorrow if it's any worse, any bigger, I don't think it's gone, just because of the amount of pain that I've had, especially this month, so we will see the saga continues. - What's your message to women who are listening to you listening to this conversation? - Okay, so if there can only be one takeaway from this interview to anyone currently living in pain, it would just be to continue to advocate for yourself. You're not alone, it's not all in your head. - Sorry. Sorry. - A lot of feelings still there. - Yeah, you're not alone, it's not all in your head. Your symptoms are real, and you deserve to have your pain taken seriously, and be involved in the decisions about your own treatment and your own care. - Francis Muir, thank you so much for speaking with me. - Thank you so much, Brian, I really appreciate it. Following our interview, Francis had an ultrasound and sent this update. This is she talked about is still there. She'll get another ultrasound in January to see if it's growing. She promises to keep us in the loop. That's our show this week. If you've been dealing with endometriosis, write to us at [email protected]. Whitecoat Black Art was produced this week by Andrea Belmer and me with help from Stephanie Dubois and Samir Chabra, our senior producers calling Ross. I'm Brian Goldman, and I'm proud to bring you stories from the Canadian side of the gurney. See you next week. For more CBC podcasts, go to cbc.ca/podcasts.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Endometriosis affects approximately 10% of women of child-bearing age, often causing chronic pelvic pain and infertility, yet many remain undiagnosed for years.
  2. Francis Muir’s journey highlights the systemic failures in healthcare, where initial doctors dismiss symptoms, leading to delayed diagnosis and worsening pain.
  3. At BC Women’s Hospital, a specialized clinic led by Dr. Christina Williams and Dr. Paul Young offers a holistic, patient-centered approach with detailed pain mapping, counseling, physical therapy, and advanced treatments.
  4. Research at the clinic has shown significant improvements in pain, quality of life, and mental health, with reduced emergency care use, validating the effectiveness of their model.
  5. A key innovation is the Endometriosis Pain Index, a tool that helps predict how patients will respond to surgery, improving treatment decisions.
  6. Misconceptions about endometriosis—such as it being aggressive or incurable—are widespread and harmful, leading to fear and poor outcomes; education is vital to change the narrative.
  7. Early education in high schools, such as a study showing 80% of boys understand endometriosis after a short lesson, demonstrates that awareness can be achieved through simple, accessible teaching.
  8. Despite no known cure, patients can experience major improvements in daily life, and advocacy, self-education, and seeking specialized care are crucial steps toward healing.

Summary:

A deeply personal story of a woman named Francis Muir reveals the long and painful journey many women face with endometriosis—a condition affecting about 10% of women of child-bearing age. For years, Francis endured chronic pelvic pain, dismissed by doctors, until a referral to a specialized clinic in Vancouver led to diagnosis and effective treatment. The clinic, led by gynecologists Dr.

Christina Williams and Dr. Paul Young, employs a holistic, patient-centered model involving detailed pain mapping, counseling, physical therapy, and surgery. Research shows significant improvements in pain, quality of life, and mental health, with reduced emergency visits.

The team has developed tools like the Endometriosis Pain Index to guide treatment decisions and has challenged harmful myths—such as endometriosis being aggressive or incurable—by emphasizing that pain is real and manageable. A key breakthrough is the finding that even brief school-based education can greatly increase awareness, with 80% of teenage boys understanding endometriosis after a short lesson. Despite no cure, the narrative around endometriosis can be transformed through education, advocacy, and access to specialized care.

The story underscores that women with endometriosis are not alone, their symptoms are real, and they deserve to be heard and supported in their treatment journey.

FAQs

Endometriosis is an inflammatory condition where tissue similar to the lining of the uterus grows outside the uterus, causing pain, infertility, and symptoms like painful periods, pelvic pain, and pain during sex.

It affects approximately 10% of women of childbearing age, making it one of the most common gynecological conditions, though many women remain undiagnosed for years.

Many women experience chronic pain for years before being diagnosed, and initial doctors often dismiss symptoms as normal period pain, leading to delayed or missed diagnoses.

The clinic provides a holistic approach including detailed pain mapping, physical therapy, counseling, lifestyle changes, and specialized surgeries, with a focus on improving quality of life and mental well-being.

There is currently no cure for endometriosis, but treatments such as surgery, hormonal therapy, and pain management can significantly reduce symptoms and improve daily functioning.

Common myths include the belief that endometriosis is an aggressive, invasive disease that can obstruct organs or that it is incurable. In reality, it's rare, and many women experience significant improvement with proper care.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.