We Went Out on Halloween Night and Found Something We Shouldn't Have
22m 36s
The narrator and his friends, known as the Helians, begin their annual Halloween night by meeting at the Old Tressel Bridge, where the atmosphere is charged with excitement and nostalgia. The group moves through the neighborhood, collecting candy from homes, exchanging jokes, and navigating the chaos of their traditions. Danny frequently wanders off, and Justin refuses to move past a certain point, causing tension and delays. As they near the end of their route, they lose contact with two members, prompting a frantic search. A sudden commotion from a nearby family—shouting and calling for police—marks a turning point, revealing an unsettling, possibly violent incident. The group splits apart, with Dave entering the woods and the narrator remaining hidden, narrowly avoiding a confrontation. In the end, they reunite at the park, where the group gathers around makeshift altars, and the narrator reflects on the night’s trauma and their unbroken bond. Amid the horror and uncertainty, the story ends with a quiet acceptance: although the night ends with loss and fear, the tradition of Halloween and the bond between the Helians endure, even as the narrator anticipates leaving town. The memory of that night becomes a haunting symbol of both joy and danger, reinforcing the emotional weight of their shared experiences.
I meet up with the boys at our usual spot at the end of the Old Tressel Bridge. The burbling river soothes me as I hop across the rusty beams, smelling burning leaves in the chill. I pick up the pace when I see five familiar forms under the trees, shoving and jostling each other. It's almost six by the time I reach them, and night is coming on fast, darker than usual under the heavy clouds. Danny's camo jacket and pants hide him in the twilight. I can only see his eyes and teeth as he tosses and catches his orange plastic gun. Freddy and Mike are arguing about who Zombie makeup is better. They both look terrible, the sickly green, goop, patchy and uneven, but I don't bother telling them. They're stuck with it now. Instead, I nod at Justin and tell him I like his fedora, as I always do. He's worn the same costume for years. The whip is still pretty cool though, and I'm in no position to judge. My cape barely reaches my shins now. Dave greets me last, dancing an awkward jig to show off the glowing bones of his skeleton sweatsuit. I laugh and ask if they're ready. Halloween only comes once a year, and I want to make the most of it. With everyone here, it's time to hit the streets. We all know the plan. The route we've perfected over the years. The full-size candy bars at the Miller and Franklin houses. The Reese's, Kit Kat and Snickers assortment, and the new cold to sack. And best of all, Mrs. Mahoney's homemade candy corn rice crispy streets. The boys snatch up their threadbare bags and pillowcases, and jog across the slick grass of the park. Freddy and Danny whoop and holler at the front of the back, letting the whole neighborhood know the hellians are coming. I grin as we turn on to Maple Drive, feeling the excitement as if it's my first time. The long, straight road is lined with lit jack-a-lanterns, most of which will be smashed by the end of the night. Rubber bats dangle from branches, and I duck under several as I catch up with the others. On one line, a devil chases a shrieking mummy, prodding it with a plastic pitchfork. Our first stop is Mr. Granger, my old principal. We want to get him out of the way. Two uncarved pumpkins sit on the stone steps of his house, but there are no other decorations. I maneuver around my friends and ring the doorbell, plastering on a smile. A thin man with wierry white hair opens the door slowly, staying deep within his entry way. His jaw is clenched tight. "Billy Mathers!" It's all he says as he thrusts out a large black bowl of jolly ranchers. I ignore his tone, swiping a red piece and dropping it into my bag. Mr. Granger glairs at me, then grunts, and shuts the door with a firm thud. "Geez, what's up his butt?" Pretty says. "Think we should egg his house on the way back?" I shrug in head next door. The house used to belong to our classmate, Sarah Deane, but a new family lives here now. I don't really know them. There are a lot of houses in our neighborhood like that, but the porch light is on, and the boys are already on the stoop, so I take a chance. A smiling woman gives me a few packs of smarties, my least favorite. Before the door we go, making snarky comments about lame decorations, snorting at the cleverest costumes. I recognize a few classmates, but never stop the talk. We cackle when Lindy Wilson gets her wig, tangled in a cheap cotton web. And again, when a kinder gardener spews rainbow color to bile across the curb. "Prickie move!" Danny says, clocking his tongue. "He got to pace yourself!" At the dance and house, I push aside my cape and pull a potato for my pocket. I hold it up for the boys to see. They raise their arms and cheer. No one remembers when or how the tradition started, but I've never let it die. I pull an apple from the metal tub of water by the front door and drop in the potato with a small splash. I'm happy to see a handful of half rotten vegetables already in there. Not as many as there used to be, but some. I ring the doorbell, and we fly down the walkway. By the time we've cleared maple drive, my bag has a solid heft to it. The sickly sweet scent of sugar and chocolate wafts from it. And my stomach growls as if it knows what's coming. I'm surprised the boys have mostly behaved so far, only chasing off a few groups of younger kids. But I catch chilly looks for more than a few grownups. The first hour flies by as we wind through the flats. The boring cluster of streets where all six of us were born. They were turf. But we run out of houses on our side of Main Street, and have to cross into the dark, winding roads of the heights. The houses are farther apart here, imposing structures pressed against the gloomy forest rising at their backs. It's quieter, less laughter, more sighing wind. But bigger houses offer bigger rewards, so the bravest kids from school have always made the trek, including the Helians, of course. Tonight, the backs are few and far between. We spot only a handful of groups as we climb the first hill, panting, and knock on a thick wooden door. A middle aged couple answers immediately. The wife clutches a basket to her chest. Her husband nudges her to offer me a candy bar, but his eyes dart behind me as she does. I resist the urge to look, who knows what the boys are up to. I thank them and duck away. Halfway down the long walkway, I check my watch. Only 35 minutes left. The hill keeps rising. The temperature drops as the moon slides behind a cloud. Dogs bark angrily in the distance. Even the boys have lowered their volume, though their crude comments carry across the broad, still streets. I slow my pace, drag my feet, get my bearings as we enter a particularly desolate stretch between two very familiar mansions. "Hey, I gotta take a leak." Danny says, "Be right back!" The boys laugh, waving him away. "Captain, tiny bladder strikes again!" Justin jokes, "Make it fast!" Danny flips him the finger and takes off running, practicing his soldier moves as he weaves between the towering brick houses. He stops twice to shoot at nothing. I have to expect him to do a flip, but eventually his silhouette vanishes into the shadows of the trees. He pace the sidewalk for several minutes, scuffing our shoes in the cracks, debating the coolest ghost buster. Making bets on the upcoming baseball game, those dogs finally shut up, which is a relief. Freddie yells into the forest for Danny to zip it up. A few passing families shoot me startled looks, another minute passes, and our laughter dies out. Then a twig snaps, heavy footsteps crunch across fallen leaves. We pick up our bags, ready to go, but Danny doesn't appear. There's another crack, but this one doesn't sound like splintering wood, it's too sharp to clean. "Did you hear that?" Justin asks, staring into the woods, "What was that? And what is taking that dork so long?" No idea. He say, he probably got distracted. Freddie punches Dave's arm, "Dave to go in there and find him." "Yeah, right. I did the gum dare last week. It's my turn to dare you." Dave shoots back. "You go." I shake my head. "No. No one needs to get him. We're wasting time. Let's just go. You'll catch up." Freddie and Mike share a long look. Freddie taps his bag against his thigh. Mike cocks his head, listening to the now quiet woods, up ahead on a broad porch. A group of little kids in bedsheet ghosts sing song they're greeting to the family inside. The family gushes over the lame costumes, and the ghosts squeal when they get their treats. They must have gotten something good. Dave's eyes lock on their overflowing bags, practically salivating. "Yeah, he's messing with us, I bet. Forget him." Danny does have a habit of wandering off, so the rest of the boys agree not to let him ruin our night. We resume our trek. I lead the way, urging them to hurry as we collect treats from five fancy houses filled with fancy families. I don't recognize most of them, but they smile politely and coolly as the Helians visit. None of the adults in their thick, festive sweaters and pleaded pants bothered to ask what we're dressed as, or how our night is going. But I get the premium candy, and that's all that matters. Despite Danny's endless bathroom break, we're more or less on schedule, but then we reach the end of Briar Street, and it becomes clear we're going to lose Justin too. He plants his feet next to the fire red maple in the corner, refusing to go any further without Danny. We protest in unison. None of us want to go back and give up on the final leg of our route, and Dave doesn't want us to split up even more. It would ruin the fun. Freddie and Mike remind Justin that Danny has done this shit before. Like the year he snuck off to egg our math teacher's house, and we barely talked him out of it. For all we know, he's trying to pull something similar. When none of that works, I insist that Danny knows the route like the back of his hand, and he'll catch up when he's good and ready. Justin won't hear it. He's always been the most stubborn of our group. He was the one who refused to let us try the old rope swing down at the point. The rope snapped a week later, and broke Johnny Mitchell's arm, so we didn't raz him for that one much. So although I go through the motions of trying to stop him, I only argue for five more minutes of valuable candy time before giving in. "I'll find him and drag his butt back." and promises before striding confidently down the hill, his whip trails.
telling over the pristine sidewalk with the leathery rasp. I watch him until he disappears behind the slight bend in the road. Have sure he'll find Danny already long gone. Sighing, I hustle to catch up with the boys. They're still muttering about Danny and Justin being jerks for splitting up the group. I don't want the night to end on a sour note. So I try a string of terrible jokes I've memorized. Why did the skeleton cross the road? Freddie snorts, Mike rolls his eyes. To get to the ball. A single sharp scream rises from two or three blocks below us. Bouncing among the gated homes and stone walls, we jerk to a halt. Body shop. I finish laughing awkwardly. I guess someone chose trick. The boys don't crack a smile. They keep looking back down the hill, jumping at the jingle of wind chimes, skirting the darkest areas where the lights don't reach. They're twitchy and I don't blame them one bit. I rub my arms, smoothing down the raised hairs. I tried to warn jokes before giving up. If you're into horror with a heavy dose of sci-fi, classified experiments, and things humanity was never meant to understand, check out my other podcast, The SCP Experience. Each episode pulls you into the hidden world of the SCP Foundation, where dangerous anomalies are studied, contained, and sometimes unleashed. These aren't just scary stories, they're classified nightmares. Click here to listen now or search for the SCP Experience wherever you get your podcasts. We reach the far edge of the heights, about to make the final turn down Linwood, which runs all the way back to Main Street. The town is behind us, filled with thousands and thousands of people, including our own parents and siblings. But we are alone up here, entirely alone. The nearest trick or treaters are almost half a mile away. Some blobs of color already retreating home. We stop at the tiny parklet that serves as an overlook to catch our breath and fix our costumes. I trace the forest as it arcs downward. A pitch-black canopy stretching all the way to the riverbank. The helians have explored every inch of that wilderness during long hot summers, but on this cold, dark night, I have no desire to set foot in there. Dave pressures us to get going. We've never managed to squeeze in every house in one night, and we're so close. There's probably a curfew for kids our age, but nobody enforces it. The real deadline is eight o'clock, when the porch lights go off. After that, we always kill an hour at the park, staking our claim on the merry-go-round to count our haul, make swaps and watch for classmates on their way home. - Maybe Danny and Justin are already headed to the park. I tell the others as we start descending. - Or maybe they went straight home. Danny probably tried to climb a tree and knocked out a tooth. - They don't seem reassured. Probably because even if Danny had heard himself, he'd be in our faces, eagerly showing off his bloody wound. This isn't how our big night was supposed to go. We hustle through the last row of houses, going through the motions. The plan is to cut back to Briar Street afterward and retrace our steps to where we lost Danny. Maybe we'll find some hint of where he and Justin went. We hop off the steps of the mayor's house in the nick of time. I feel his sad stare burning a hole in my back as porch lights wink off one by one. Candles are blown out, locks click into place. The air turns smokey and dim. It's as clear a get-out signal as I can imagine, but we can't leave. We duck into a narrow side street and access alley at best and spill out onto Briar Street a moment later. Ed's swivel, looking for any sign of our lost helians. The road is so empty and quiet that we can hear the creek of an invisible swing set swaying in the breeze. There are no signs of life, not even locals coming and going from their own costume parties. They're staying inside tonight. We huddle in the small pool of light under the street lamp. I stuff my hands into my pockets as the boys debate our next step. Should we look for Danny and Justin or go straight to the park and hope they beat us there? A small creature, a cat or raccoon, darts across the street and scuttles under a car to our left. A garbage can lid bangs on our right. A tissue paper bat breaks loose and flutters through the air. I want out of this neighborhood so badly. My throat is tight as I tell the others we should leave. They won't admit it, but they must be as uneasy as I am. Because Freddie and Mike stop pitching their awful ideas and start jogging down the hill. Park it is. Dave and I follow close behind. None of us willing to get further separated. As we run, my heart pounds and cool sweat gathers on my forehead. I've long forgotten the bag clutched in my numb hand. I already feel like I'm going to jump out of my skin when something huge and angry slams into the wooden fence beside us. The blanks bow outward as a new volley of barks erupts from the other side. The muts are so loud that I clap my hands to my ears. Freddie and Mike shriek and break into a sprint. They're already a block ahead when Dave trips over the too long hand of his brother's sweatpants and tumbles to the sidewalk. On instinct, I turn back to help him and I lose my own footing. For one chaotic moment, I lose track of up and down. I roll, feeling the sting of scraped knees and palms. I scramble to my feet and away from the fence. The dog's claws and barking, setting my teeth on edge. Hey, guys, wait up! Dave yells, staggering upright. He hikes up his pants and shuffles forward. Then, he scans the road in freezes. Where? In the 30 seconds, we were pancakeed on the ground. Freddie and Mike vanished. From the rise of the hill, we can see all the way down to where the street flattens out. Two running zombies would be impossible to miss, but they're not here. Oh, come on! Dave says, "He's breathing hard as he looks at me. Hair must. A.L.I.'s wide." "What is going on? Why is everyone disappearing on us?" I swallow hard. "I don't know. I don't know why. This happened. We have to find them." Still holding the waist of his pants, Dave strides ahead. He pauses at the enormous spaces between houses, body tends. I can't tell if he's afraid the dark corners of the heights will swallow him up, or if he still thinks our friends are hiding in there, waiting to jump out at us. When he asks if we should knock on the door and get help, and I have my answer, I shut down that idea. It's Halloween night, and we're the hellians. No one will take us seriously. They won't understand, so we keep walking. That way down the hill, roughly where we left Danny so long ago, we spot a smear of orange in a patch of neatly trimmed grass. It's a bright, unnatural color, not to be mistaken for a leaf or a pumpkin shard. I recognize it, even before Dave creeps closer to pick it up. He lets out a low ground as he holds up the toy, face as white and skeletal as his costume. We both know Danny would never have left his precious prop gun behind. He probably slept with it. Dave looks around, whispering Danny's name over and over, until I can't take it anymore. I motion for him to be quiet. He quads, shaking badly. Dave drops the gun into his bag, and clutches it to his chest. What do we do? Dave asks, his voice barely audible. I don't answer. I desperately want to keep going to run out of this nightmarish neighborhood without looking back. But Dave is braver than me, or more naive. He inches away from the sidewalk toward the woods, peering into the darkness. He's so focused on the trees that he nearly steps on a small white bag crumpled under a bush. Justin's candy bag. Dave plugs it out with his fingertips, revealing the fedora it was hiding. His mouth drops open. Billy, something really bad is happening, isn't it? I slam my eyes shut and nod. My stomach clenches. I hate this. I don't want to see it anymore. Three doors down. A couple steps out the back door under their deck, laughing softly. The happy sound is so at odds with this moment, but then the man lights a teaky torch, flooding the yard with dancing orange light, and the woman starts shouting, screaming, begging someone inside to call the police. Lights snap on in the surrounding houses. More voices join the commotion, but they're too far away to help. Dave mumbles something about getting help and barrels along the strip of lawn between the backyards and the forest, aiming for the couple. I don't follow him. I stayed planted in the gap between the houses, well within the pale moonlight. Even if I wanted to go with him, I'm not sure I could feel my feet, but then I see it's all shadow separate from a tree trunk and slink behind the next one. My body unlocks. I call out to Dave, but my voice is a rasping croak. I take a step back, then another. Voices are coming from across the street now. Maybe they can see me, but not Dave. He's hidden behind the house, so close to those trees, and that shadow. I spin around, putting it all behind me, and when I hear Dave's muffled yell, the crash of a body through the undergrowth, I run. I run past the house and it's manicured flower beds. I ignore the people calling to me and fling myself onto briar street, straight down the center line. I run into all the houses are dark again, and the distant sirens fade, only then do I slow down. I lean against a stop sign, hands on my knees, and gather the courage to look back up the hill. But silent and still once more, the violence is over. It's been over for a long time, but somehow, it always comes back.
A minute later, I finally reached the park, our park. The mulch crunches softly beneath my tennis shoes as I pass the empty merry-go-round. I run my hand along the rusted railing, trying to remember what it felt like when we spun and spun until we threw up, or until one of us flew off. That was better, funnier. Local kids don't use it much these days. Parents have started complaining that it isn't safe. I hope they don't remove it. Clearing the playground, across between the baseball diamond and the tennis courts, and a crowd comes into focus. They're gathered under the pavilion, spilling out among the grills. They form a large circle around makeshift altars on the picnic tables, candles, flowers, framed photos and bags of candy. I hear low murmurs and sniffles, the droning chant of Reverend McComb. Everyone's back as to me as I climb the bleachers, so no one sees me take my usual seat at the top. Half the town must be here tonight, including most of the parents I just nabbed candy from. They always come straight here after. Time passes, and a few wandering eyes find me. The murmurs grow louder, ripping through the crowd. No one comes closer, but no one makes me leave either. They never do. They fear me and pity me, the lone survivor of the infamous Halloween massacre. I sit on the ice-cold metal, fidgeting with my bag, thinking about the good parts of the night. I remember our antics with a smile. Eventually, the sad families, teachers and classmates disperse, leaving the five small altars alone in the dark. I walk into the pavilion and touch each photo, Danny, Justin, Freddy, Mike, and Dave. They're cheesy class photos, posed, and full of awful, forced smiles. But even the terrible backdrops and worse lighting can't hide the true faces of the Helians. I chew on a Snickers bar and pull my own offerings from my bag. I'll never forget their favorites. I tell them goodbye for now and glance at my watch. It's after midnight, no longer Halloween. But that's OK. I'll see the boys next year. We'll trick or treat together like we always do, even though we never quite finish our route. But the year after that, I'll be away at college. What happens if I don't come back to town? You will keep the Helians in line.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The group meets at the Old Tressel Bridge to begin their annual Halloween trick-or-treating journey, marked by excitement and tradition.
They encounter varying levels of enthusiasm and chaos, including Danny’s frequent wanderings and Justin’s stubborn refusal to move, disrupting the group’s coordination.
The night unfolds with escalating tension when Danny and Justin vanish, prompting a tense search and a disturbing discovery of their abandoned props.
A violent confrontation is revealed when a nearby couple begins screaming, signaling a possible outbreak of fear or danger in the neighborhood.
The group splits, with Dave heading into the woods, while the narrator stays hidden, revealing a moment of horror and moral ambiguity.
The climax occurs when the narrator realizes the group’s disappearance and the potential for real danger, leading to a frantic, disorienting chase.
At the park, the survivors gather in a circle, where the narrator becomes a symbol of the "lone survivor" of a traumatic event.
The story ends with a bittersweet reflection on tradition, memory, and the fear of losing the group as the narrator prepares to leave town.
Summary:
The narrator and his friends, known as the Helians, begin their annual Halloween night by meeting at the Old Tressel Bridge, where the atmosphere is charged with excitement and nostalgia. The group moves through the neighborhood, collecting candy from homes, exchanging jokes, and navigating the chaos of their traditions. Danny frequently wanders off, and Justin refuses to move past a certain point, causing tension and delays.
As they near the end of their route, they lose contact with two members, prompting a frantic search. A sudden commotion from a nearby family—shouting and calling for police—marks a turning point, revealing an unsettling, possibly violent incident. The group splits apart, with Dave entering the woods and the narrator remaining hidden, narrowly avoiding a confrontation.
In the end, they reunite at the park, where the group gathers around makeshift altars, and the narrator reflects on the night’s trauma and their unbroken bond. Amid the horror and uncertainty, the story ends with a quiet acceptance: although the night ends with loss and fear, the tradition of Halloween and the bond between the Helians endure, even as the narrator anticipates leaving town. The memory of that night becomes a haunting symbol of both joy and danger, reinforcing the emotional weight of their shared experiences.
FAQs
The Halloween tradition is a long-standing, group-based ritual where the Helians trick-or-treat together, following a specific route to collect candy. It's a shared experience that fosters camaraderie and keeps the spirit of the event alive even when the group splits or faces challenges.
Danny frequently wanders off, especially during the night, which leads to concern among the group. Despite his habit, the others usually assume he will rejoin, and the group continues, believing he is safe or will catch up.
A sudden and terrifying incident happens when the group spots a possible threat in the woods — later revealed to be a violent confrontation between a family and unknown figures. The group is scared, and a physical confrontation with strangers ensues, leading to chaos and the disappearance of Danny and Justin.
The group becomes anxious and divided, debating whether to search for them or head straight to the park. They eventually decide to continue, but the tension and fear remain high, especially as they find evidence of Danny’s missing prop and Justin’s candy bag.
At the park, the group is left in silence and fear, with the survivors gathering around makeshift altars. The narrator reflects on the trauma of the night, the loss of friends, and the emotional weight of being a lone survivor of the 'infamous Halloween massacre.'
The adults are polite and do not ask questions about the group's costumes or intentions, suggesting they are either unaware of the group’s traditions or are indifferent to the children’s activities.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.