237. “We bought our dream house. Then he lost his job.”

It's kind of funny when I talk to small business owners who are super frustrated by the vendors that they work with because I'm like, you all know you're the boss, right? You can fire them. You can make changes today. So if you don't like the platform that you are working with, move off of it. I've done it many times. If a CPA that you are working on goes dark on you after April, find somebody who's better. And that is where our partners at Gelt come in. Gelt is a modern CPA firm that helps your business take control of your tax strategy year round. By working with Gelt, you get access to one dedicated tax strategist with real human expertise powered by cutting edge technology that handles the rest. And right now they have two Q3 exclusive offers. Extension Rescue, where Gelt takes over your tax extension with fast onboarding and no stress, keeping you deadline safe. The retirement catch up where Gelt models your prior year retirement contribution opportunities to maximize what's on the table before October 15th. This offer is included for all new clients this quarter. A great CPA is a year round partner who stays in touch with you. And Gelt is taking on new clients now. Now is the time for business owners to get ahead, not in January. So find out if you qualify at join gelt.com/rami that's join glt.com/rami. Do you make a lot of money, but you cannot figure out where it's all going? Well, I want to help you and your partner. I'm now taking applications for the next season of money for couples apply at iwt.com/apply. And if it feels like a fit, my team will reach out. Dad lost his job and tech was laid off, it's been a 50% cut. We're in this house, we're in this neighborhood because we were indexing on a different salary before. You know, and buying necessary things even makes me feel terrible and guilty. We're paying an interest only on he-lock. I ask for help from my family. They helped us pay that off. How much? $180,000. It was a hard call to make for me. It feels dishonest because not everything is okay all the time. It's the same conversation you always have. There's nothing to be done. We definitely could struggle in the next few months to make that mortgage payment. How the fuck am I talking to a couple with zero dollars in savings who has a 4,200 square foot house? Maybe we're just poor now. And we're just going to be poor for a little bit till we're not. What would you do if your income went down by 50% just like that? What if you suddenly couldn't afford the life that you've become accustomed to? This is a deep American fear. The idea of going backwards socioeconomically terrifies us, especially the higher up we go. That's one reason that you'll meet people who even though they recently suffered a job loss, keep spending the same amount of money eating out and traveling. They cannot stop spending on those items because to confront the reality that they have gone financially, backwards is one of the most shameful ideas in American culture. Today, I'm about to speak to Karen and Chad. They are 45 and 44 years old. They have three children and they are scrambling to afford the life they've built together since their combined income unexpectedly dropped. I'm looking at their conscious spending plan or CSP. It's the same tool that I use in every episode and I'm going to go through their numbers right now. Assets 1.2 million, investments, $665,000, savings, zero and debt, $514,000. All that worth is 1.37 million combined income, $175,000. What do you notice? Yes, they have a high net worth and a high income, especially for a couple in their mid-40s. But they have zero dollars in savings. They are in trouble. I suspect that because they have a large investment portfolio, but nothing in savings that they have recently drained that savings account to pay for life. We'll find out though. Before I speak to them, I want to hear from you in the comments, what would you do if you lost half of your income? Could you still afford the life you've built? Would you have to move? Would you have to downsize? How many months could you draw from your emergency fund before it hit zero? And I want to ask you in your comment below, be realistic because it's really tempting to say, "Oh me? I'm so perfect. I would immediately cut out all of our discretionary expenses." But in truth, almost nobody does that. Now let's get started with Karen and Chad. Karen, on your application, you wrote something that caught my eye. You wrote, "We are no longer able to invest or save. We have no emergency savings. It feels as though we are one paycheck away from disaster. Can you take me through the circumstances that led to this situation?" Sure. Absolutely. So about three years ago, Chad lost his job and tech was laid off and found a really great start-up to be a part of however, he took a 50% pay cut and up to that point we had been living. The lifestyle that met the previous salary. For the past three years, we've done well. We had been smart and saved and had what we needed. I picked up extra work, however, after three years, we're finally out. So for three years, you were using your savings and now you are out. We're out. Okay. I'm proud of us that it lasted as long as it did, but there are circumstances in our life that we can't necessarily change because we made purchases while we were making quite a bit more money. Got it. Okay. Chad, as you hear Karen's description, do you agree with that? I agree that we were kind of indexed into a different income previously. I would agree with the characterization that we haven't really changed our lifestyle since then we had to kind of draw, we have a HELOC, a home equity line of credit, which a couple of the times last few months have had to. I call it draw forward, but like borrow against the HELOC in a short-term way to pay the mortgage, and then I pay it back a few weeks later, running a little bit close to the wire here and we need to change something about how we're operating. How does it feel for you? I mean, I guess I have mixed feelings on one hand, I'm pretty comfortable with taking a little bit of risk. On the other hand, I don't want to be reckless. I want to do the right thing, and I want Karen to be aligned with me on the choices that we're making, and that we're not spending recklessly. I'm struck by my question was how do you feel about it, and you gave me a very cerebral answer about risk tolerance. Is there a feeling where you are right now or no? The feeling would be a little bit scared that we're going to get ourselves into a dangerous situation pretty quickly. You're scared, or the two of you are scared. We're collectively scared. How about you, specifically Chad? I'm nervous, more than scared, I would say. Nervous about what? I'm really getting ourselves into a situation where we can't pay the mortgage anymore. Which has happened a couple of times, and you had to pull from the HELOC. Yes. Which I pay back quickly. What happens if nothing changes? If we end this call and nothing changes, what will happen? Right now, if we don't do anything, I think we'll still stay afloat, but we're not hitting any of our goals, saving for retirement, saving for any day, or any of those other things that Karen's looking for. Most people don't hit their retirement goal, they don't even have a retirement goal. What's the big deal? I guess the big deal is we have three young children who I don't want to burden. If we get older and don't have retirement and can't take care of ourselves financially. And it's more than the retirement goal, I'd like to have an emergency savings in case Chad for whatever reason. If something happens with his job, I am not in a career where I can make up the difference and support our family where we currently live. So the emergency savings even more than the retirement is very important to me. I don't feel like we're planning a very solid future financially for our children. As well as ourselves, I'm also kind of tired of living in this more austere lifestyle where every penny we spend, we feel guilty about. I'm kind of struck at the difference between what you both just said to me and what's in the application that you wrote to me. What you said in the application, Karen, is this is dire. I feel as though we may lose our home in the next few months. Compare that to what you both told me about. We may not be able to provide for our children and I'm tired of living this austere lifestyle. It's seen quite different. Don't you think? Yes. Why the difference? I think one of the differences is we did have a large payment, fortunately taken off of our shoulders. However, we definitely could struggle in the next few months to make that mortgage payment. Ah. Well, okay. So I do want to clarify a couple things. One is we did take a hard look at where our money drain was happening. One of the biggest drains was this remodel we had done a couple years ago, if I got laid off. We were paying an interest only amount of $1,300 a month on the HELOC. We were very fortunate. I asked for help from my family and they helped us pay that off. I do have an obligation to pay them back, but we don't have that ongoing payment now. That did swing the tip of the scales a little bit for us. That's what's going to keep us afloat. We no longer have to borrow to pay our mortgage. Is that the first time you've had family help? Uh, yes. Oh, was that your family chat? Yes. What do you remember feeling when you Were about to ask for help nervous shame? You know, I did not want to do it. I thought Hey, I'm an independent person. I've been surviving 30 years. I don't want to ask for help now But you did it I but I did it because I there was a few times where I had to draw on the healer lock which gave firm empirical proof to this severity of the situation and That was the biggest lever we could pull on. So that's what I did. I wish Chad that you didn't feel shame or bad about this You were dealt a bad blow. This was all Elon fricking musk laying you off. Oh, Elon did it Yeah, and he cut my work too. So what the fuck this guy the company firmly known as Twitter All right, and Chad should not feel guilt. We're shame about that. That's not well. We also did the remodel Right before Yeah, but Maybe we should have cash and hand. How did they receive it when you asked for help? My father said he'd have to look into it, which is perfectly reasonable And then he said he'd he'd have to Sell some assets help us out actually that made me feel pretty bad actually And then he took over the payments for a while, but then he didn't like how we had structured the deal where we're just paying interest on There right now, which is admittedly shortsighted. So he Some more comfortable is paying it off and now we have a obligation back to him. How much? $180,000. What if your family had said no, Chad? We might be looking at more dramatic option, which would Include downgrading our house. I think we'll be the next thing we be looking at Okay, how often did the two of you talk about money pretty frequently? I would say daily in little ways just yesterday We were talking about my son's upcoming birthday party and his concern that What we had was too simple and most of his friends because of the area we live in have Kind of bigger fancier parties and ours was pretty simple and I think Chad was much more interested in just throwing money at it Okay, and blowing the budget to buy our way out of that and I was very uncomfortable with that and we did have to Hashtag out because I felt like it was keeping up with the Joneses and then Chad Where are you in these conversations? What was your reaction? I think my reaction was I don't want to disappoint him You know, I wanted to have a great birthday He kind of came to the same conclusion once he saw that the facts laid out in front of him So I was a little bit proud of him for that actually. Wow. I think we handled it well But my concern was that he felt the tension between us when when I was saying no and Chad was saying yes I wasn't saying yes. I was I was talking you know, it seemed like you were instantly googling Options for bigger event like parties you're right. I probably was I don't want to disappoint my son. I guess like the birthday party thing like The emotions can drive in the moment like I want to have him. I want to make sure he's happy He has the best possible birthday. What's your ethnic background Chad? Scandinavian is what we like to joke so Cool, Phil Pino My mom's side and I'm Scandinavian on the other side talk about feelings when you grow No, the reason I ask is Not just that when I asked earlier about like how would you feel and you gave me a cerebral answer But even when you describe feelings, it's abstracted. You're like the emotions can cause as if emotions are this thing over here You know as somebody who was raised in Indian family where we don't really talk about feelings Certainly not guys really talking about feelings that much. I just recognize Some of my own way of talking about it in the same way that you are describing it. Yeah, sounds about right I mean ever to talk about feelings grind up I remember distinctly like when I graduated high school my mom wrote me a letter and she's like basically Will you talk to me about your feelings more? Your mom said that and the letter. Yeah I want to jump in here because Chad's mom calling him out for not talking about his feelings is a huge clue And I personally relate to this I had a hard time talking about my own feelings or even Knowledgeing them until I actively started working on them, especially getting help in therapy And that shows up in multiple ways as we're discovering which had it shows up in how he communicates how he speaks Have you noticed the kind of vocabulary that he's using? It's clinical. Maybe even a little robotic He definitely struggles to articulate what he's feeling Notice the story of Chad having to reach out to his dad for money and you also notice the feeling of shame Now I'm curious how this plays out when they don't agree, especially about money. Those moments really reveal a Dynamic between them. So let's dig deeper. Can you think of a time in the last three six months where you were not on the same page with money? Chad, do you want to go ahead and leave that one? You know, I'm working on a startup right now So I was like oh once we get some we look some revenue. I think I can ask for a raise So it's kind of selling that dream a little bit and Karen who's much more pragmatic. It was like not comfortable with that. That's banking on a dream. So that did Ultimately force the decision to ask for help Karen what was it like for you when Chad as he put it was quote selling the dream Here we go again. Oh wow Here we go again This has been a constant I think in our marriage of don't worry the next raise is around the corner Don't worry. I'm getting a bonus when we chose to do the remodel on the house There were concerns there financially if that was a good idea to take out money, but he said don't worry I've got a bonus coming. It's a frequent thing But the reassurance that don't worry there's money around the corner. Don't worry. There will be a windfall or this idea of mine will take off and We'll bring in tons of money to support me. Does it work? She says no. Chad, is that a phrase you use commonly? Don't worry. Yes. I think it means that I got us like I'll make sure we're we're gonna be safe and secure. Do you? I Think so, but Maybe I don't just feels like a record on repeat. Okay. I don't feel like I'm being heard I don't feel like my opinion is valued or my intelligence or my ability to see things clearly I Can see by the reaction you two have talked about this before we have this is how our conversations always start Oh, it starts and then what happens it devolves it will devolve eventually as I get frustrated and feel like maybe I'm talking to a brick wall and Like I need to be more direct Yeah, I find it it feels dishonest Because not everything is okay all the time Right, and sometimes we do need to sit down and talk about it, and sometimes worry is warranted Okay, and when I'm being told don't worry all the time that read Reads is untrue to me probably what we Are looking for is more communication to work together to build a common understanding sort of kind of a common Reality that we agree. This is what reality looks like and then jointly survey our options to decide what decisions if any, you know, a lot of times doing nothing is perfectly reasonable Are you all this polite when it comes to other parts of life parenting and day-to-day life and food and all that stuff? I think my interactions with Chad are different because I have noticed if I don't handle it in a certain way He takes it as a personal attack. Whereas my kids don't Hmm. They're they're much better about understanding. I think where I'm coming from got it. How old are your children? They are 5 8 and 10 11 11 And Chad what about for you? Why the careful? Diction and the walking on eggshells today the abstraction to things like we probably need to communicate better Why what's going on? I mean, maybe I'm protecting my ego to be perfectly honest like if I am incompetent Trying to protect my ego. Wow. What else? Karen's right. I do get defensive. I feel like she's attacking maybe me personally and But I also feel like maybe she's complaining about things that we don't have short-term control over sometimes like what can we really do? Is this complaining just for complaining sake? There's certain things we can do in the short term and Maybe more dramatic things we could do in the long run and we don't seem to lay those options out and drive a decision anyway We just complain. We don't or she doesn't we don't Do you lay out the options? I would say that I put a lot of options out of bounds like I don't want to sell the house Everything else that we can cut. I feel like we've cut. We used to have things like maids. Those are gone I had a gym membership gone. We had some laundry services gone We cut everything we can possibly think of so you're saying I'm kind of saying we don't have any more options I'm saying we've done everything we can do Beyond selling the house because we're already locked in we got this path dependence thing we're We're in this house we're in the state we're hood because we were indexed on a different salary before so we're kind of like locked into a different Standard I guess I guess that's cut gets to the heart of what we're trying to accomplish here is like if we sell the house down grade Karen seems to think this is gonna magically sell our problems I think we're gonna be back in this same boat because we haven't actually identified the root of the problem selling the house would just be a bigger band-aid than we've done today. What do you think the real problem is? I think we don't have any discipline right now in how we spend When we're preparing our CSP, you know, we're kind of looking into Amazon like look we're spending like thousands of dollars on Amazon, what is this and Karen got very defensive. She's like, whoa Why are we nitpicking all these purchases? This isn't the spirit of the CSP and I was like, well, I'd like to identify the general theme Like if this is all like shampoo can we like put it in a spending hundred dollars on shampoo and you know Can we get a theme out of this or not? I know it's opaque. It's just like Amazon So that's is that's what's going on here Amazon purchases I don't know. We have $3,700 a month that is in your catch all bucket at the bottom there. It seems like a lot to me Okay, we'll go through it for sure I want to understand it as well as anybody trust me But you you mentioned something which I that was really strong hypothesis Hey, even if we downgrade the house We may be back in the same situation in the first place. So what is the root cause problem here? Just over spending on miscellaneous items Yeah, I feel like there's a lot of kind of reactive buying in the day-to-day on Amazon Maybe buying things to solve perceived problems that aren't actually problems Like, oh, we need new lunch boxes or we need I don't know Cat scratching protectors or things like these aren't problems. We actually need to solve These are just things we can live with in my opinion I want to quickly explain why I'm pushing Chad here to tell me what he thinks the problem is The way that he talks about what he perceives the problem to be is just so matter of fact Just a little too clever that it is evident he is staying on the surface level In fact, I think he's minimizing the very issues that brought them here today. Nope It's not that they struggle to pay their mortgage with a salary that's been cut in half Nope, it's not the $180,000 family loan that they needed to stay afloat. Nope I think it's the Amazon lunch boxes. He's minimizing what they actually need And I want him to grapple with the fact that he doesn't know what the solution is because I can't help someone who thinks they know everything Sometimes the hardest part of getting help is admitting that you actually need it that you actually don't know the answer or sometimes even the problem I see this all the time people who think they've got it all figured out and are probably very smart in other parts of life But they don't even understand the main issue. It takes me back to one of my high school classes where our teacher told us that if we take our car into the shop to get fixed Don't tell them hey, I think it's a gas line Just be quiet in fact the only thing you tell them is hey my car is making a pinging noise every time I go above 25 miles per hour Let them figure out the solution you just tell them what you notice Turns out lots of people are obsessed with finding the perfect teacher the perfect coach the perfect book But they spend a lot less time obsessing over becoming the perfect student And being a good student means admitting you need help that you can't do it alone and that you are ready to trust someone else Chad isn't there yet though, so I have to push him Because if you're just here because your wife wants you to be We're probably not going to get anywhere if you are hearing this and you're thinking that sounds like us But we don't know how to fix it. That's exactly why I created my money coaching program It's a monthly program where you get expert guidance Accountability and a community that will help couples break through these blocks and create a clear actionable plan towards their rich life If you are ready to take control of your money and you are ready to admit you need help check it out at iwt.com/moneycoaching You mind if we um take a look at the numbers right what was it like doing the csp? I know that there was a little bit of conflict around the amazon numbers We'll get to those. What was it like like what was the tenor of the conversation? It was polite. Oh It was polite, but it was good. I mean we nothing surprised us. I would like to ask Chad to read off the word in bold and then the number in full next to it for this entire box, please Assets one million two hundred and twenty five thousand nine seventy six dollars investments six hundred and sixty five thousand six hundred and eighty five dollars Savings zero debt five hundred and fourteen thousand total net worth one million three hundred and seventy seven thousand six hundred and sixty one dollars Speaking of debt five hundred and fourteen thousand dollars. Can you break that down for me? It's the mortgage. That's what we go on the house. Where's the family obligation? We didn't put that in there. Yeah, we just wiped it out. Yeah, we should put that in there A hundred and eighty-k. You're just like dad doesn't count What is that because the agreement we wrote upon was we would pay it back if we sold the house. It's secured against the house Yeah, but it should be in that there's no payment plan. Yeah, so yes, you would add a hundred and eighty-k Even though your payments don't reflect it because that will decrease the amount you will make When you sell your house decreases the equity. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. All right. No worth one point three million. What do you think about that? I think that's great. Yeah, it's all um, non-liquid assets, but non-liquid assets means we can't blow it Wow, interesting response. It's non-liquid assets, which is like kind of implied to be bad But because it's non-liquid, we can't spend it protecting us from ourselves, which seems to be good Did I read that right? I think so So you both agree that the number is Sounds like good But it's stalled stalled. Yeah, we have not contributed 401k since like I laid off from my job So if anything, it's going down by tiny increments, which is not where we should be It's also heavily indexed on windfalls from the house, which you know, we wrote this wave of housing appreciation Over the last seven years. Okay. Wow. I appreciate the nuance So the numbers tell us one thing, but what you're saying is it's the quality of those numbers It's largely illiquid. It's actually declining. You've been pulling from your savings, which is now at zero You're not contributing to your investments much and that may even be decreasing and then the illiquidity the house Appreciation may have stalled. Yes. Okay. Good to know Obviously, you're pretty in sync with your numbers. That's good. Let's go to income now Karen, can you read off the combined monthly income? Please the combined is 642 All right, so you two you make $175,000 together. Did you know that? Yes, okay. What about you do for a living chat data scientist? I work for a startup great my income is firm. It's a base salary. Uh-huh and Karen I'm in RN and I do clinical research monitoring my contracts tend to be anywhere from two to six months And then I'll have a large break depending on if there's a study $25,000 a year. That's then a conscious choice Tell me when we started having kids we made the agreement that one parent would be home Whoever was making more would be the you know the so-called breadwinner and I wanted to be home with my kids while they were young and while they wanted me And while Chad was making a good income. It was fine. Totally comfortable. All it was kind of idyllic. Did you grieve? The loss of income I did not mean so much it was more like the The job change was kind of a welcome welcome change for instead of on the I would say Part of what's happening is that you're comparing yourselves to when you use to earn Hundreds of thousands of dollars coming down from that income level is actually emotionally catastrophic your socioeconomic status has changed literally the things you buy off the shelf may have changed and that is Grief it sounds Shallow. Oh just stop buying the premium cheese But in America especially a lot of the things we buy Whether for ourselves our pets our kids Define who we are that's part of the culture like it or not And to not be able to do those things that we used to be able to do feels sad It feels draining. It feels empty. It feels lonely. And I think maybe Chad hasn't gone through that or acknowledged that And tends to dismiss My feelings around that when I I feel like I have kind of grieved and a lot of it is thrown back as well It's just material things. It's not a big deal Yeah, I totally do that. So I haven't really felt like I'm allowed to grieve about it without feeling materialistic and shallow I mean, it's just stuff I guess but what about okay? So we have one of our daughters has A learning disability and she may need extra intensive schooling Mm-hmm, and I'd like to provide that for her and I feel like we could if we weren't so stuck on living at the level we were when we were making more. I don't know if I'm articulating that well, but it's not just the things. It's about offering our kids resources that they might need. - What Karen is describing here, potentially not being able to afford resources for their children is the emotional toll of losing a big part of your income. We know that it can be financially devastating, but it can also be psychologically devastating. I'll never forget this LA Times article that I read during the 2008 recession. And it was about these wealthy women whose husbands used to make a lot of money and they lost their jobs and the families lost everything. No more country clubs, no more eating out. Their social circle immediately shrunk and the life they knew went away. And I remember commentary about this article. A lot of people saying, "Boohoo, rich people can't go to the country club anymore." But I remember thinking, no, this is actually real loss. And in many ways, regardless of whether you are wealthy or you are working class, not being able to live the lifestyle that you used to can be incredibly painful. In fact, it can actually feel like losing a part of your body because in America, what we spend reflects who we are. The car we drive is not just a car. It is the status of what we have achieved in society. The food we eat, the streaming subscriptions we have, the toys we buy for our kids, they make up who we are. And to be very candid, if somebody told me that I could never stay at really nice hotels anymore, I would be devastated. It sounds silly. Is it superficial? Maybe, but it's also real. So if this happens to you, if your income drops, the tactic that you need to embrace is to make immediate changes. Do not wait, hoping things will get better. They might, but they also might get worse. And I learned this in a very difficult way in my own business. Years ago, my business took a steep downturn, way worse than anything I had ever projected. And I realized it can always get worse. Even Karen and Chad, they've been able to sustain for three years because they had savings, which is amazing, but things haven't gotten better. They've gotten worse. So when you face a financial emergency, the first step is to admit it. Hey, this is a major red flag. We have to stop and change things immediately. We have to slash our guilt free spending. That's why you have the conscious spending plan. It's already at the bottom. Cut it immediately. Trim your fixed costs that are above what you can afford. Go into survival mode. Treat it like you are stranded on a mountain with limited rations. I would ration every damn thing 'cause I don't know if rescues coming in a day, a week, or a month, and I would rather get rescued with extra rations and be a little skinny when the rescue team comes around than run out of food after a week. This is how you survive an income drop. All right, so you make $175,000 a year. And what is that number that fixed cost number, Karen? Fixed cost, that's 70%. Okay, 70%. So it's a bit high. I can see why you feel stressed out. Let's go down to investments at zero, savings at zero, and then guilt free spending at 30% or $3,400 a month. Savings are at zero. Why is that? I feel like every time I try to bring it up is something we should do because we are so polite. It doesn't go anywhere. Let's just do it right now. I love to see a polite conversation. Go ahead. Show me the last time you talked about savings. Go ahead, Karen. Let's do it as if you were actually having the conversation. Go ahead. Okay, I am very concerned that we don't have savings, but I'm not sure where we're going to get that money from. So we need to kind of sit down and look and figure out where we can get money to move into savings. Okay, I can look at that. I feel like we've cut basically everything we can cut. Where do you think we can get the money out of exactly? If we reverse engine near this and maybe pull the savings aside first. Okay. But I do agree it might be tight because we are down to last dollar most months. We talked about how if the kids ate school lunch, we could save $240 a month, even if we could take that small amount and start putting it into savings. Maybe a savings account that has some interest or money back, maybe it might take a while, but it's a start. Okay, school lunch is definitely a good option. And I know the kids aren't going to like it, but we can just say no. Yes, you have to eat the boiled hot dogs today. You know, and we've talked about me working more so that we can have savings. Kids are only young for so long. So part of me is like, okay, well, the kids are only young for so long. Maybe we're just poor now and we're just going to be poor for a little bit till we're not. But it makes me very nervous to not even have a month's worth of savings in case something happens. Yeah. I mean, ideally, we want three, right? Because we've seen how hard it can be to find work. So what would that be, said $30,000? Yeah. So $250 a month, how long does it take us to get to $30,000? Might a while. Yeah. I can hear myself, and basically I sound like I'm making excuses for us not to do anything. Yeah, but like you said, we've already done this. We've already really dug in and we've cut a lot of subscriptions. We've cut a lot of extras. So my big question is how many austerity measures do we really want to put in place before we're just not enjoying life anymore? That was like even more polite than usual or more involved. Again, it always starts like that. Well, what does it get to? Usually it'll get to me being frustrated because I don't feel like Chad always will contribute ideas. Outside of it'll be fine. We're just going to be poor for a while. It's got to be frustrating to talk about the same thing over and over and over and not really make any progress on it. Very. It makes me not want to talk about it. Like we're just going to come to the same conclusion, do nothing. So what's the point of talking about it? So what's the solution? I don't have an answer right now. And yet you are in the financial situation that you are in. That's the disconnect. I think the biggest one is who bought this house indexed on a different salary. And you didn't make any changes substantively after your income dropped? Yeah, totally. In fact, you've resisted making any changes by taking it out of the equation. By having the family helps me. No, by saying like we don't want to get rid of this house, like that's off the table. Let's talk about cutting our Amazon spending instead. Yeah. I have resisted that change. I guess when I have evaluator options, I've come to the conclusion changing our house. Well, first of all, we'd be trading a two and a quarter interest rate for whatever it is right now, six and a half. So I backed into it. If we wanted a reasonable house in this area, it would save us on the order of like $700 to maybe $1,200 a month. Seems like a lot. I thought it didn't sound like that much, I guess. Are the two of you a financial team? I would like to be, but I often feel like we're almost at the service. Mm-hmm. Chad? No. Not really. We don't. I do the taxes, and I just show it to her before I file it, but she's not involved with that at all. I thought you talked about money every day, though. We talk about spending, but like planning wise, we don't do any planning right now. It's very difficult to get ahead if you're adversaries. It's very difficult to get ahead if you don't have a shared vision. Again, I thought we did. The past few years have maybe shown me a different side of Chad than what we in theory talked about. Has your financial status shown you a different side of you? Definitely. I think I've become more of a warrior than I expected. I feel like I've become, oh, no, if I can come up with the better word or articulate it, but much more uptight about it, much more concerned about the future than I used to be. Uptight means what? Just always stressed about it. I always want to talk about it, just constantly carrying that heavy load, and I feel terribly guilty even when I go to buy the kids a new pair of shoes because their shoes wore out. And that is not, I don't think, how I used to feel about it. Even though I've always been fairly frugal, I never felt kind of an existential dread over it. Chad, how about you? I don't think I've changed too much. I think I haven't really, to be honest, not too much about money for the most part, which is probably why we're here. I've been focused a little bit more on trying to achieve impact on my job and make sure the family is happy, healthy, and the kids are doing well, but I don't specifically think about money. The kids come first. And the marriage comes second, my opinion. They do at this point because I see more return on my investment there. It's pretty striking comment. What if that just keeps up? The two of you, the way you described it, we have one person who describes herself as worried, concerned, uptight, and other describes himself as not really thinking about money focusing on having impact at work, making sure the kids are okay. Just play it out two years from now, five years from now. Where does that leave us? I mean, the tension will continue, it will continue, and it's not good for my health and well-being, or is, or the families in general, not to mention the financial implications, but it will impact our relationship, how we relate to each other. That feeling of not being heard definitely permeates the rest of the marriage, which is obviously destructive. So I think it will get worse and I may just kind of tune out, turn off and do my own thing, and I think you see that when we start talking and separately, we're not saying we when we talk about certain things because I do feel I've approached Chad many times and it's almost dismissive, like, oh, here she goes again with this and what does she know, she's just worrying again. So I'm just going to reassure her and pat her on the head and say it's going to be fine. So it's just a really unhealthy dynamic. What would you want him to know if he could actually hear you? I would want him to really know, I know the numbers, I am smart, I do have valuable opinions, I do have a pretty solid grasp on our situation, I am not overwhelmed and I'm not overreacting. Chad? I'm going to say an answer I know you're going to shoot me down for, but I hope they're for a windfall eventually that will solve all our problems. But yeah, barring that, Karen's absolutely right, I'm going to, I'm a trajectory where we're going to probably increasingly resent each other because we're not, we're not on the same page, we're not pointing the same direction, we're not moving the same direction. Is there anything you would want to tell Karen if you could be uncharacteristically honest? I mean, I love that you're at home with our kids as much as you can be, I think the kids are the most important thing and I don't care for poor, I guess, at the end of the day. Right now I don't care for poor, I think it's more important to spend time with kids. So I really appreciate that you do that and you're here for us. But your actions aren't reflecting those words. You're not willing to make any changes to make that a long term possibility. You are shut off or you shut me down or you won't, how do I want to word this? You're not willing to come up with ideas with me to make that possible or even sit down and talk it through, well enough to decide if that is possible. It's kind of a vague statement of, I love that you're here and with the kids and I don't mind being poor, but what does that mean? Because that's what we're doing right now and it's not sustainable, that's not a place we can move forward from. I'm looking for solutions, not platitudes. I don't know what to say, let's clap at the plans all I can say. What if Chad doesn't change and what if you still need to build up savings for your family? I'll just have to go it alone. Wow, I have to say that I love the honesty that I'm hearing from Karen. We are finally moving past polite and I am a little bit puzzled by Chad's responses. What'd you notice in that interaction? I noticed that Karen is crying out for partnership. She's saying give me a seat at the table. Notice that we are in trouble. Believe me when I say that I'm smart and I understand the numbers, what she's really saying is connect with me and Chad responded with, we're going to have another windfall, it's going to be fine and I don't care if we're poor. He's abstracting the severity of the situation to these pat little phrases like I love my wife and I'm glad she gets to be home with our kids. It's like watching a politician wave away millions of people losing their snap benefits and instead say some abstract comment like we should all have the opportunity to work in America. Okay, the issue here is becoming clear to me. The spending alone is not the problem. The disconnect is a much bigger problem and until we bridge that, no amount of calculating numbers is going to fix it. When we come back, we're going to go way back to their childhoods to see if we can get to the root of this dynamic. Karen, what do you remember your family saying about money when you were young? They didn't talk a lot about it. I would say we were solidly middle class until I was about 12 when my parents divorced and then there was definitely a transition there financially. My mom pretty much stayed where she was but then my dad basically moved into like basement apartments, studios, stuff like that so I would visit him there and he kind of worked his way up to buying smaller, more modest homes and not the nicest neighborhoods and I lived with him primarily. So it was definitely a modest lifestyle. I needed to get a job fairly early if I wanted to pay for gas or clothing of my own any extras I had to work for. What did it feel like that your mom was at a certain level and your dad was literally in a basement? It felt unfair. It did. It felt unfair. But also he seemed happier and the money didn't really matter because he had more peace of mind. He had more freedom. The money didn't matter. Right. It's just ringing in my ears because I heard something very similar just a few minutes ago. Do you remember that? What did Chad say? I don't care if we're poor. You don't care about the money as long as the kids are okay? Yeah. Quite similar. Mm-hmm. What do you make of that? Well and that's what I mean by previously I thought we kind of had that shared vision of it's not about the money, it's not about all the nice things, it's not about being able to keep up with the Joneses and the more about safety and security and freedom and time to spend together mostly it's that freedom, freedom of time, which is I guess what I'm pointing out with my dad. I saw him have more of that less money but more freedom of time. Mm-hmm. Okay. Yeah. Like, you know, I have these things and I can afford them and-- Why aren't you more relaxed with less money now? Because we still have the same high amounts of bills to pay. I see. And so we don't have that freedom of time or we can't go do things as a family because we are constantly working. Including me. I'd like to point out I am working and I am working full-time. Do you want that like less money, more freedom of time? Yeah. Or the same amount of money that we have now, but yeah, more freedom of time. Well, okay. I mean, why don't you just move to a much smaller apartment and you'd have more money? Would you be down for that? Yeah. Okay. We come from--we have different views on that. I think we can stay within our community and move to a smaller, more modest house but still enough space for our family and still be within our school system. Not much would change and I think our kids are really flexible and adaptable and they'd probably just see it as an adventure and maybe they'd see that mom and dad are more relaxed and happier and have more time for them, which I think is healthier than-- Then what it is today? What phrases ring when you think about money as a kid, as a teenager? What phrases echo from your family? Gosh, you know, one that I think of specifically was my dad being pretty apologetic that he couldn't pay for my college or help with college and a lot of that guilt that I still think he cares, carries today that he couldn't help more financially to kind of set me on a better footing in my young adult life. Were you angry or resentful at him? No. I figured it out. Figured it out. I joined the military, I got a GI bill, it all turned out fine, you know? Why did interesting? I was raised resilient and then on my mom's side, the opposite, as far as she very much would say, you have to make your own money, you have to be very careful with money at any time the others you could drop and you could find yourself with nothing. How did you internalize that? How did you make sense of that? Definitely felt very insecure, I think, about dad, as far as, yeah, you're right. Tomorrow something could happen and I could have nothing and I can't really rely on my partner to be the one in charge of it and to always be a little bit cautious about what they're saying. How did that come up when the two of you met each other and you were dating? I don't think we were particularly challenged by it because we both were making fairly solid incomes on our own, so we never really had to face it until recently. Gotcha. That's a pretty honest answer. Karen, when you look back and you reflect on the lessons that you took away from your family about money, what occurs to you? What surprises you? What sticks with you? Again, I think it's that how quickly your fortunes can change. It happened for you when you were 12. It happened for you just recently when Chad downsized to a different job. Right, and both times were very uncomfortable. It's frustrating because I thought we had future-proofed. I thought we had done a pretty good job and they still do. I think we did pretty well, but we do seem stuck. Karen, thank you very much. Chad, what do you remember about your family when you were young? What did they say about money? My dad said, "I can't remember the exact number." I think he said, "Every paycheck always saved 10%. That's one thing I definitely remember. One thing I remember is don't bank with the banks, bank with the credit union because the banks rip you off. Third thing is don't buy American cars, buy Japanese cars." Wait, this guy has great advice. (laughs) I agree with 100% of what he said. Out of curiosity, what happened to the 10% rule? I don't see that happening in your finances. - I have not followed his advice, I suppose. - You'll drive an American car, please don't say yes. - No. - Oh, thank God. All right. And what about your mom? - She wasn't really involved with the financial planning so much. - Your dad was the money person. - And what was your mom's role when it came to family and finances? - My mom was a homemaker, my dad. I'll call him a company man. So she would keep the house going and he would work long hours at work, I would say. 60 plus hours a week. So we wouldn't see him that much in a week and a little bit in a week, I guess, but. - Did you like that or resent it? - It's all I knew, so I don't know. He was working for us as far as I could tell. - And did your mom spend money for the family? How did she go about that? Did she have to ask your dad or what was the arrangement there? - Yeah, so it is an arrangement that I've cared for today, which is that I had had an account and he would move money over to her account. Mention you at it. - And you do that today? - We have a joint account, but right now my paycheck goes into my account. I've had all my life, which is an accrediting, and when Karen needs money, I do move it over, but we don't manage a joint account actively right now. - Yeah, on the occasions, which isn't all the time or frequent, I will just text him and say, "Hey, I need X amount. Can you transfer that over today?" - How do you, since you earned less, Karen, you mentioned you don't frequently have to ask for money, but how does that work? 'Cause your expenses are relatively high compared to your income. - My expenses are mostly, what do I take care of? I take care of the injured car insurance and the bone bill, most of the kid stuff. So I actually wouldn't say my expenses are high. Just want to point out, this is very, very common in a way that I hate. Dad pays the mortgage, mom pays the kid expenses, and then as the kids get older, which means they're more expensive in a lot of cases. Nothing changes, and then mom is now put in the position to please, please, can you transfer an extra $500 and then dad's like, "Why do you need the extra $500? Why aren't you being efficient with them?" And it just gets perpetuated. Why are you both nodding so much right now? - I can see that dynamic. - I can see it too. - Yeah. Okay, Chad, back to you growing up. Are your parents both alive? - Yes. - Okay, how are they doing financially? - They're doing well. I call, I characterize them as upper middle class. - Okay. And what about debt in your family? Was there any debt as you were growing up? - No, no, I mean, I would almost say my dad's like allergic to debt, but I mean, other than the mortgage, no, we don't, never run debt. Apparently my mom did have some credit card debt when they got married, but he paid it off immediately. So no debt. - Your dad seems very methodical about money. - He's an engineer. - Yeah, he's an engineer. - But you're a data scientist, right? - Yeah, I call, characterize myself as a quasi-engineer. He's the type of engineer where you have to get everything right or the chemical factory blows up. I'm more in the trying to look for the insights in the trends and the data and yeah, trying to see the big picture in what's going on in product or the system and trying to drive insights to affect change in the system. And then follow up to make sure those insights are actually active on. - You do that at home with your finances? - No. - There's so many parallels to draw from from Karen and Chad's early experiences with money. Karen is almost mirroring what her own dad went through. He was forced into a more modest lifestyle, but do you remember what she said? He emotionally thrived with more time and less money. It's no surprise that these are the very things Karen says she would be fine with. That can also understand why she said earlier that she would go it alone if she has to. Those messages of resilience, of not relying on anyone else, those have been ingrained in her for decades. Interestingly, Chad has done almost the exact opposite of what his parents did with money. His own father was debt-avoidant, yet Chad took out a home equity line of credit and borrowed from the family. He skirted past the advice to save and invest 10%. But one thing though, that he has replicated is his father's commitment to work. Chad himself admitted that he would rather focus on work-related goals than work through the financial issues that affect his entire family. One thing I'll say that I've noticed is it is very interesting when people grow up with strong money messages. One of two things often happens. One, they follow them exactly. They basically recreate what they grew up with. Or two, they go completely the opposite direction. But here's the fascinating part. You can never predict what is going to happen. There is no rhyme or reason to which approach someone is going to choose. Okay, let's shift our focus now back to the numbers. Their housing costs are 33.6%. A little bit higher than the 28%, I recommend. They've hinted at it multiple times, but we finally need to address the elephant in the room, which is their house. What does the house mean to you? It means a stable place for the kids, I guess, is an ending, I think about. I think safety is something. Maybe we take a little bit for granted here, or we just assume everything says we don't unlock our doors here. I don't want to be moving to a place that's not safe, that's not worth any amount of money to me. The house, I mean, I've been working out of the house for the last five years. So it's like also a place to work out of, but didn't have that. I'd have to figure something out, go work in the space or something like that. We haven't had a conscious plan, so if you can come up with an actual plan, that would go a long ways to addressing this concerns, do you agree? It's more than a plan, Chad. And action. It's more than action. Before any of that, you could have come up with a plan before you even saw me. If you look at your CSP, it's quite obvious what to do. It literally jumps off the page. I'll show you. Why you haven't been able to get to the plan is the crux of why we are here today. The plan is not the hard part, you're both very intelligent. And the idea that, oh, it's just things, well, let me try to take that argument with you, Chad. Why don't you just get rid of your house? It's just a thing. Yeah. I mean, it should be on the table, for sure. Yeah, but why haven't you? Why have you been so resistant to getting rid of the house, including in this conversation? It's just a thing. It feels like short term thinking, I guess. Well, you have zero dollars in savings. Don't you need to think short term right now? Maybe. Yeah. Yes. Like the **** house is on fire, because we don't have savings. That's why the house is on fire. Yes. Three kids, one person who's already lost a job in the past, that's a massive risk, massive. And it's not the two of you. Even if it was the two of you, you would be in a really, really precarious position. But with three children, it is a red alert level of risk. Okay. Finally. When you think about the financial environment that you want to raise your kids in, what kind of environment comes to mind? I want them to learn responsibility, I guess. Maybe that's not something I'm teaching them to my actions right now. Which we do different. Great question. We can propose ideas. Go ahead. I'm listening. One, we start a written doc so we can document it. Maybe just throwing ideas. Maybe we can each have like little soft targets, right? Like, okay. Well, I'm going to try to save $300 a month. You're going to say $300 a month. We'll bring our receipts to a little like party at the end of the month and we can have a little like celebration to join the sub like we can have a special beer or something, I don't know. Go ahead. It's great. So we need a forum for that. Right. So I think a standing meeting, that's what we do at work, right? With documentation. Let's put some process around it. Let's have some goals. Let's see, some goal tracking, some metrics tracking. What is the goal? I think the goal personally is to hit that 10 and 10 number. That's what we'd like to be. 10% investments, 10% savings. Yep. Is that enough? How do we know? It's a starting point. Okay. Fair enough. We need feedback from the stakeholders on whether that's where we want to be, but that's where we're headed right now. Okay. And we need accountability on the results. So that's where we need the metrics tracking. And then the crux of it is we need a strategy. So what is the strategy? The strategy is identifying a point of leverage over the problem. Right. It's a single. I won't call it a single thing we can do. There's no silver bullet, but a set of tactics that jointly work together to solve the challenge. There are some example tactics that you will probably have to do in order to hit the 10% savings and 10% investment goals. Sell the house. I'm going to the house. Go somewhere with your schools, because I mean, that's a lot when you get cheaper houses. You go to a school district with your schools. Oh, I didn't realize we're insulting our options. I thought we were just putting them out on the table. Right. It feels a little bit taboo. I like taboo. What do you think this freaking podcast is? Because the truth is only found in the taboo, sometimes taboo is where the truth is. You shouldn't run away from taboo. You should actually run towards it with a big old flashlight. And the key insight here is that money is deeply emotional. It's not the numbers on the page. The numbers on the page are the least interesting thing of this whole conversation. We can knock those out in five seconds and you're going to see that. The fact of why you have not been able to look at it is that you. Both are locked into a dynamic. Where each of you has their own role, you can't move any different squares in this game. And what I'm saying is y'all are not actually playing chess. You can move any direction you want. But you have to be able to talk about what are the rules of the game here? What is the even game we're playing? We are not playing a game of we need $250 a month in savings. That's a (beep) boring game and nobody wants to play it. That's why the two of you don't play. 'Cause it sucks, that's not actually fun. I think the game that you are playing here should be much bigger. How does that strike both of you? Yeah, I think that makes sense. Yeah, we're just kind of winging here right now to be honest, being very reactive. If we start from a common vision, then we can work backwards to understand what we need to do to achieve that. Y'all wanna do it real quick? What's the Rich Live Vision? I keep emphasizing time. I would rather have freedom and time to spend with my kids to be home after school, to give them a snack to help them with their homework. Great, that's good, freedom and time. Let's go, we're gonna go rapidly, Chad. I don't have to go back to a nine to five. I can do my own startup ideas. Run my own startup, let's say. Yep, Karen. Opportunities to be healthy and be outside. Chad, be able to pay for a kid's college. Don't have to worry about that. Being able to provide that extra schooling and education if we need to. I'd love to take a gap here with the kids and take 'em around the world. Yeah, that would be amazing. When I wanna volunteer my time, doing things I'm passionate about rather than going to a job that I don't love. Great. To me, this is personal. Also, I wanna note that you probably can't do all these things right now. That's also okay. Your Rich Life is a vision. Some of the things you may not be able to do today, but you can do 10 years from now with savings and investment. The real secret is that the Rich Life is in the journey, not necessarily in checking off the boxes. What I see here is just a powerful vision of a family that wants to be able to do a lot of things with kids, a lot of things with freedom. That's so clear what the two of you value. Here's my question for you. Compare the Rich Life I just wrote down versus where you are spending your money. What do you notice? All of our money is going to build some things. To supporting our current life, our current lifestyle. Not even current life. You're supporting a past life when you used to make hundreds of thousands of dollars more. Nothing about the future. Very little money being spent on the vision of any of this. Like, you all wanna take a look at the CSP and make some changes? Yes. Yeah. So here we are with your CSP up on the screen. As a refresher, you make $14,000 a month gross. Your fixed costs are 70%, investments and savings are zero, guilt-free spending, 30%. Chad, tell me the first thing you'd like to change. Yes, I mean, cut that mortgage in half, be nice. What? How are you gonna do that? Don't grid the house, only option. Damn, hold on, this is crazy. I never had anyone who ever started with the house. Ever, this is crazy. Can you get housing for your family for $2,000 a month? We could, if we take the equity we have and put it as a down payment on a smaller place here. I need the number that you would actually walk away with. 500,000, that's minus the 180. I believe minus the transaction costs. It's a lot. Say the number. 72 grand. All right, 72 grand in fees. What else? Isn't there some other fees associated with selling? I think we dodged the cap gains if it's under 500. Right. I mean, yeah, I don't know how you want to think about it. If you want to move over to renting or buying a new place, but you're gonna buy a new house, there's a lot of fees involved with that transaction too. Okay, so you have some math to run, but seems to me that's one big option. Immediately, I'm thinking of all the friends that kids play with every day across the street. And we won't have that anymore. And that seems sad to me. You might not. If we can find a way around it, I would love to. It is so ingrained in us to have home ownership. That's the pinnacle of adulthood in this country, right? And that's success. And to pay for your kid's college. Right. But who paid for your college, Karen? Me. You paid. And did you build responsibility? Were you resourceful? Yes. You know, one of the ideas I had to bear with me here was, we can rent out our house for a fairly big chunk of money, like our current house, and then we could rent something more affordable and more within our current budget. Nice. How much could you rent it out for? Comps around here were about 6,500 a month. 6,500. And if you could rent something, how much could you rent a place that you all would need? How much? Between three and four. Whoa. Yeah. Have to run the calculations more carefully. Because we'd be, basically, you could just scale up my square footage if we're going to have 3,000 square foot house, scaling down to a 2,000 square foot house, so a third less. 3,000 square feet with the [bleep] No, we're actually in 4,200 square feet. All right, the basement, yeah. What the [bleep] Chad thinks that this is a normal sized house, in a modest house and a modest neighborhood. How the [bleep] am I talking to a couple with $0 in savings who has a 4,200 square foot house? This is crazy. This is what I've been screaming. Chad, do you not, do you see my reaction? Why do you think I'm reacting the way I am? Seems like a big house. It's like in the top 1% of the size of houses in the entire world. And also your income, I don't know the exact desil or whatever, but it's up there, really high. And you know what's at 0, the 0th percentile? You're savings. All right, so we put the house, that's an option. Whether you would choose to sell and buy another place, whether you would choose to sell and rent, or whether you would choose to keep the house, and then potentially rent another place. Those are three very interesting options. Let's keep going. I think there's more options. This time, Karen, what would you do? I could pick up my work. 1,500 is your net right now. How much would you make? I could make up to 6. 6,000 a month, net? What the [bleep] But I wouldn't be home, ever. Or I'd be working night shift at the hospital. Something in the middle, maybe? Something in the middle, if I could find reliable part-time work, I could make something in the middle. All right, what else, Karen? I think groceries. Groceries. $2,000. I think we can get that down, but not much less than 1,500 to 1,800. Pick a number. 1,800. What the [bleep] No. I know I told you pick a number, but that number I'm not taking. 1,800, come on. What food do you guys order? Tell me. We do Amazon grocery delivery. Through Whole Foods. I think the reason I picked that number is I looked up the average that a family of five spends around here and went with that. I don't care what that family makes maybe more money than you do. Oh, they all do here. No, that number's anchored in reality. That's our long-term average. Yeah, when you were spending without looking at prices, you are living a different life now. I certainly didn't hear that in your Rich Life vision. Let's go fill up our cart with a bunch of [bleep] going to look at the price of. So you think we can realistically bring that down? Way down. And I'm honestly openly asking that because it's-- There's definitely ways, like 1,000%. You can just search cheap grocery food and you'll find people. There's entire subreddits about how to order food that is healthy for a family for a much, much, much cheaper place. Probably one of the ways would be just to not shop at Whole Foods as well. What would be a range on groceries? Like maybe you're like 50 to 75 centiles? The magic number, believe it or not, is $800 to $1,200 a month. Almost everybody falls between that number regardless of whether they're two people or five people. That seems to be the magic number. I think that if the two of you were like, "Hey, we want to get more disciplined but we also do really like having X or Y." You know, we're probably going to end up being at like 1,300, maybe 14. Okay. That's still huge. Yeah, it's a big savings. Yeah, that's great. Let's take groceries and turn it into 1,400, okay? I'm going to give you a little leeway. I think you'd get a lower but 1,400, nice and easy. Look at your fixed cost number. It dropped from 70 to 64% right then. Amazing. That's great. It's great. You know, especially with your housing cost, fine. Investments, what do y'all want to do? I mean, it'd be great if we could get back up to that 10% investments. 10%? All right. Let's just say you're investing about 1,100 bucks a month. Savings? I want to get that up to at least 30,000. So we have three months. Okay. So how much you want to put here? Notice by the way that we are now drawing from down here. You're guilt-free spending. You can see it decreased it. You're now at 27%, but you have 10% that moved up to investments. Not bad. Savings? How much? 500 a month. 500 a month. Be nice. All right. Let's do it. 500 bucks a month on savings. You're at 4% savings. Seems a bit low to me. Considering you have zero, I don't like it. What do you think? So we need at least 10%. I think so. All right. So now you're at 10% savings, which is 1,100 bucks a month. And you have 17% in guilt-free spending, which is $1,988. I think that looks good. I do worry about one-off medical emergencies. They don't come out of guilt-free spending. We eat clear lines of demarcation. We need to be saving for medical emergencies. You have three kids. Things come up. I need to jump in and clarify this really quickly. [BLANK_AUDIO] They first off, if you have several small kids, your financial risk is way higher than a single person or a couple with no children. Like emergencies when you have kids aren't just, oops, I forgot to pay a bill. They are medical bills, urgent travel, even job loss that can blow up your finances overnight, like it did with Chad and Karen. And the stakes are much higher. With kids, you can't afford to be caught off guard. You absolutely want a six plus month emergency fund that covers your bare essentials, including medical emergencies, automated, make it non-negotiable. That is how you build real financial freedom. For Chad and Karen, we set aside $250 a month. Now I want to hear from you in the comments, what is your current setup for emergency savings? Do you have anything automated right now? And what are the numbers that you are aiming for? Tell me in the comments below. Let's keep moving along. Okay. That's 65% on the fixed costs, which, well, not ideal is okay. It's fine. Savings at 10% good, good. Investments are at 10%. That's good. That's way better than it was before. That's great. Your investments using your current strategy of contributing zero will yield you about $2.68 million at retirement. Thanks to the work that you've done contributing over the years that puts you in a pretty good position. You're current CSP, by the way, by adding the extra $1100 a month, you will instead of having $2.68 million, you'll have $3.26 million. So it's a considerable amount more just with that simple change. Tell us about that. Not bad, especially if you own a house, kids are out, not bad. I would like it to be more. I get the sense based on your description. You probably want to live a pretty nice life, but that part is not on fire. Great. You could even contribute a little bit less to your investments. You could model it all out. If we did 500 a month instead of a thousand a month, what would it look like? If we paused for one year, really built up our emergency fund, what would that look like? If I were in this situation, I would run all the calculations, but just instinctively, I would probably sell the house or rent the house out. Probably sell it because renting it out has a lot of expenses that you're not going to cover or predict, and historically, you have not been particularly effective at putting that money aside for those big house expense. I would sell that freaking house. I would pay off the debt. I would take most of the money and invest it. I would go rent a place that is somewhere around but cheaper, way smaller, way smaller. You have a lot of options on that side. The problem is that the challenge is actually talking about money in a way that aligns with your vision. Gotcha. I was going deeper than just the math, like you said. Yeah. I mean, that's the thing. It's interesting. Now, seeing the pieces come together, when I asked you, Chad, were you resentful of your dad because he was working all the time and your answer was, that's all we knew. I might ask your kids 20 years from now, were you resentful that your parents created a family mission? We're going to actually start to spend more time together, we're going to do more arts and crafts together, we're going to do all this stuff together, and by the way, we're going to have a cozier house where we can actually spend more time together, which is going to be, let's just say, 2200 square feet, were you resentful, they're like resentful? We loved it. We got to spend more time with our parents, we got to travel more, we got to do all this stuff. We were talking about resentful. That was awesome. We didn't know any different. What do you think? Karen's got a big smile on her face. Chad, what about you? Sounds good. Yeah. I think our financial situation hadn't sunk in quite yet. Has it sunk in now? Yes. I think you really got into the heart of it, which is communication between Karen and I, needs to improve, and without that, we don't have anything. We're going to get to their follow-ups in just a second, but first, I want to share my analysis. Their story goes a lot deeper than the numbers in the way that they truly feel about money. They're stuck in a cycle of fear and pride and miscommunication. The House is not just a mortgage, it's a symbol of identity and security, but one that is also keeping them potentially trapped. The real problem, of course, is not the Amazon spending or even zero savings. Karen and Chad have a chance at taking back control because they're finally naming the real issues. But in my opinion, it's going to take a lot of honesty and some really tough choices. That is the path to a rich life. Now, let's check their follow-ups where the real progress begins. Thanks again for spending time with Karen and I. They really appreciate it. The opportunity to go deep on our money problems. Biggest takeaway is that Karen and I, we really need to come together as a team and improve our communication around money. We really need to solve this problem of getting us on a better financial footing to move forward in our relationship and our marriage to keep it strong. We're going to take it seriously, we're going to act with some intentionality. We're going to take some concrete steps. We are going to start some marital counseling to improve our communication. We are actively now contributing $1,000 a month to our emergency savings fund with a goal to get that up to $30,000 or so as quickly as possible. Then once we have that kind of go on, we'll start to look at some of the other secondary goals re-engaging on the 401k and college savings and things like that. I think those are the main things. Thanks again. My biggest surprise from the conversation was that a lot of our issues actually boiled down to communication, not the situation we're in, but how, shout and I, communicate about money and our own kind of money psychology and how that's getting in the way. Our biggest takeaway is that we need to work together as partners and watch our tone. We tend to be adversarial when we talk about money and I think that shuts down the conversation and we can't move forward. Specific changes we've decided to make as we are now allocating lump sum of money to savings every month, paying ourselves first, which, fortunately, what we can do now is I've picked up more work hours, so we are taking that money and saving it for our emergency fund and we are also going to try to work on that grocery budget and kind of take that challenge on to see if we can cut down on those costs. Anyhow, it was an absolute pleasure working with Vermeat a couple of weeks ago and we really appreciate the time that he took. If you want my help with your specific money questions, you can apply to be on this podcast at iwt.com/apply or you can become a member of my money coaching program instantly at iwt.com/moneycoaching. In money coaching, you get access to monthly calls where I answer your questions directly on a private call and I get the chance to go much deeper on the concepts of money that have made a huge change in my life. Plus, you'll get access to a community of other people like you who will inspire you and push you to live your rich life. Check out money coaching at iwt.com/moneycoaching.