Viall Files Plus Preview: The Future Of Mormon Wives w/ Jimmy Sotos
9m 51s
The departure of Taylor, Frankie, and Paul from *Secret Lives of Mormon Wives* signals a major turning point for the show. The producers acknowledge the intense personal conflicts and online toxicity that have defined the series, questioning whether the show’s raw, unfiltered reality has crossed ethical boundaries. While the show's format was groundbreaking in leveraging internet fame and real-life drama, it now faces significant challenges in sustainability and moral integrity. Michaela’s decision to leave is framed as a courageous, self-determined choice, highlighting the emotional toll of the experience. The cast’s ongoing struggles—rooted in personal and interpersonal conflicts—raise concerns about the show’s future viability. The producers suggest a potential pause to allow time for healing and a more positive revival, though they emphasize that the current state of the show is deeply problematic. There is also debate over whether the show should pivot to new formats, such as a "Mormon Dads" spin-off, which many view as inappropriate and harmful. Ultimately, while the show may continue to draw viewers due to its controversial appeal, the narrative and emotional toll on the cast suggest it has lost its original authenticity and moral grounding. The producers stress the need to prioritize the well-being of the participants over commercial interest, cautioning against further exploitation of personal pain.
what's going on everybody what you are about to hear is a little preview of our vile files
plus content where myself jimmy and bailey our producer uh talk a little bit about the exit of
taylor frankie paul leaving secret lives of mormon wives and we give well i give some thoughts on
the future of the show and what we think about it and uh here it is if you like what you listen to
you should check out vile files plus in addition to this type of content uh we also have a pop
episodes uh we dive deep in reality tv topics like this one as well as also to discuss life
because this episode we talk about the reality tv bubble is there one uh also like adult friendships
we also have our update specials
which is your favorite updates from your favorite ethnic calls so uh check out this preview uh sign
up for vile files plus all episodes are ad free just go to vilefiles.com and you'll enjoy bye
do we want to talk about taylor frankie paul leaving the mormon wives i i mean i'm i think
it's i think it had to happen i think she's certainly i think putting it or at least on
pause or putting herself on pause and yeah he's going through a lot like yeah i don't even think
taylor thinks she's in the best spot
right now um and i think the struggle i have with this show is i don't think they really i don't
know what the future of this show is i don't know if they know what the future of this show is
yeah and you know the the the challenge when it comes to this type of stuff is this is a show that
was literally you know really tried to lean into the reality and in reality tv and tried and they
found a real messy group that um was willing to push like limits and topics and things like that
and i think it just the wheels fell off a little bit and now you have a cast of women you know
their job is like ever since the show existed they've been fighting online they've they've been
messy they lean in it's it's and that's been kind of the brilliance of their show is because they
started online and for a long time a lot of tv uh networks and production companies had a hard time
transitioning reality like internet fame to tv and they've been fighting online for a long time and
tv fame i can't i can't list but i bet there's you can make a list of of of shows that never
really popped but like you know tiktok or whatever just people from the internet as the internet has
grown anyways uh mormon wives is one of the first like in terms of like this type of format
finding internet people to like really take off and i think their brilliance has been to be also
messy online and like it's been this thing that you're back and forth and jumping around it's
like a
second show and so these this is what these women do for work and and yet they're still like i just
wish i wish everything would be put on pause you know like but i get i from their standpoint i you
know i i get it credit to michaela like yeah she's still not coming back she feels that she's making
the right decision for herself and i it's a it's a tough decision and that the difficulty of the
decision shows that she's not coming back and she's not coming back and she's not coming back
is how what am i trying to moral fortitude yeah the earnestness in her decision so whatever you
if you agree or disagree with with michaela i credit to her for trying to do the right thing
yeah she stuck to her guns yeah she left she announced she's leaving yeah even even though
taylor is leaving as well and we'll see but like and i think it's also fair to point out that this
is a show where people have quitting the show is is a storyline right you know
like i hear all this and i can't help but think like there is an opportunity here like taylor
frankie paul is leaving michaela's leaving somebody else probably leaving like whoever is left
yeah like but i will say i will say i i hear you and in in the tv world there's always opportunity
i will but i would say like i just think right now i think i i think there are people in a bad
way right now and i think honestly the show really doesn't matter and i'd like to see the people
like you know before we worry about opportunities i'd like to see just everyone be okay but i i
i empathize with the challenge that these women have of like what is the right thing to do and
how do you move online and and how do you talk about it and how do you engage with it what if
they flip the script and it just becomes secret lives of mormon dads and dakota's the star and
chase is the star no and it's just i would i would quit tv i would quit tv i would hate that
we'd be talking about it
though dad talk famously listen i i generally roll my eyes when words like patriarchy and
matriarchy are brought up because it's like they're just so buzzy and i don't think they
have any real meaning behind the people what they say it's just like i feel like
for if if you're gonna view this world from a patriarchal lens
and there's credit to that like you know the historically you know yeah the emphasis the
like
allowing those type of men to be the center of a show bleak yeah would be you want to talk about
city sweetie setting back society shit but like to like to the degree that you whether you whether
you even disagree or agree that a patriarch or like but like even if you're a guy who like is
patriarchal and misogynist who's like who's like just men should you know be in like make all the
decisions like you can't have these types of men representing you you can't have these types of men
represent men you know that would be bad that would be bad is there a no i'm just like in my
producer hat like is there a good guy's version of this shit but then is that good tv like no
it's not it's not you know listen like i i i resent that right i i think sometimes when it
comes producing i think it's lazy producing to always lean into tropes and i think in a in a
world of of of labels and you know i think it's lazy producing to always lean into tropes and i
If you're from a TV producer, the best TV producers, they might have their politics and I'm sure they'll vote.
But at the end of the day, they're storytellers and they don't really care about like kind of the outside world in a sense.
So when they're producing, they're just looking through the lens of storytelling.
In that lens, a lot of people are saying maybe because Whitney is so on top right now, she's like crushing everything.
She might be the new lead in a way or even Demi because Demi appeared in a TikTok with a bunch of the girls.
Yeah, I don't know.
Listen, I don't think there's much of a show right now.
I think it's honestly premature given the context of the situation to speculate.
That's true.
A lot happens between the scenes.
Whitney's going to be on Traitors and I'm sure will do very well on a very popular show.
Again, if you're Whitney, maybe the ego of being the star of the show is appealing.
But maybe this is an opportunity for Whitney to really. Try to do what very few people can do is to break away and have independent success outside of a monster franchise that you got your start from.
And she has an opportunity to do that.
And she's kind of on her way to doing that.
And this show is like, I think it's struggling right now with the issues it has.
I mean, good, bad or ugly.
Taylor Frankie Paul takes up a lot of oxygen in a room and that's a lot of oxygen to fill.
And there's no discount to the rest of the cast.
But like. The show was centered and built around Taylor Frankie Paul.
You can discuss whether that was. At this point, I think it was the wrong decision given what we're dealing with right now.
It was the decision.
This is what I struggle with though.
Because I'm still relatively new to reality TV and I think I'm starting to get what sells.
This feels like not the worst thing in the world in the eyes of the producers.
All this controversy, all this like. Raw and like real pain she's going through though.
They've really pushed the limits on I think what is. They've definitely crossed a lot of lines for people in terms of like,
should we be watching this?
And you're right.
I think at the end of the day it will always perform and I'm not here to play like the moral please.
But I think it's safe to say that they've gotten into controversial territory.
But I think it's. At the point where you can't go any further.
Don't let Taylor Frankie Paul hear that.
She's going to say, watch this.
I mean, you know, like unless, you know.
Yeah, but like again, I think you got to worry about the people.
You got to try.
I hear you though.
You got to try.
It's been for five seasons and then it's going to be six.
So that's a pretty good run.
Like if they pause for a while, come out the other side later on in a few years once all the dust has settled.
And then it's a more positive environment.
That might be fun.
Like kind of seeing a more. A positive comeback.
Maybe, but like that. Yeah.
It's not what it could have been.
Their 10-year anniversary is going to slap.
I'm like crazy.
I'll tell you that right now.
That's going to be crazy.
That's what I'm saying.
Like give it some time.
Thank you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Taylor, Frankie, and Paul have exited *Secret Lives of Mormon Wives*, marking a significant shift in the show’s trajectory.
The cast’s ongoing conflicts and online turmoil have created a messy, controversial environment that challenges the show’s authenticity and sustainability.
The producers face uncertainty about the show’s future, with concerns that its core appeal—raw, unfiltered reality—has crossed ethical boundaries.
Michaela’s departure is seen as a deeply personal and principled decision, reflecting the emotional toll of the show’s intense dynamics.
The show’s reliance on internet-driven fame and conflict has been both a strength and a liability, as it risks becoming unsustainable amid personal crises.
There is speculation about a potential shift in format, such as a "Secret Lives of Mormon Dads" spin-off, which is viewed as a troubling and unappealing direction.
Whitney’s rising popularity and potential move into independent success offer a contrast to the show’s current struggles.
The producers acknowledge that while the show may still perform commercially, its current state raises serious ethical and emotional concerns.
Summary:
The departure of Taylor, Frankie, and Paul from *Secret Lives of Mormon Wives* signals a major turning point for the show. The producers acknowledge the intense personal conflicts and online toxicity that have defined the series, questioning whether the show’s raw, unfiltered reality has crossed ethical boundaries. While the show's format was groundbreaking in leveraging internet fame and real-life drama, it now faces significant challenges in sustainability and moral integrity.
Michaela’s decision to leave is framed as a courageous, self-determined choice, highlighting the emotional toll of the experience. The cast’s ongoing struggles—rooted in personal and interpersonal conflicts—raise concerns about the show’s future viability. The producers suggest a potential pause to allow time for healing and a more positive revival, though they emphasize that the current state of the show is deeply problematic.
There is also debate over whether the show should pivot to new formats, such as a "Mormon Dads" spin-off, which many view as inappropriate and harmful. Ultimately, while the show may continue to draw viewers due to its controversial appeal, the narrative and emotional toll on the cast suggest it has lost its original authenticity and moral grounding. The producers stress the need to prioritize the well-being of the participants over commercial interest, cautioning against further exploitation of personal pain.
FAQs
The producers believe the cast members are going through difficult personal circumstances and need a break. Taylor, Frankie, and Paul have chosen to step back, citing their well-being as a priority.
The show is currently facing significant internal challenges and controversy. While it may struggle in the short term, the producers suggest a potential comeback in the future once the situation has settled.
The show has pushed boundaries with raw, sometimes painful content, raising questions about whether such material is appropriate or ethical for audiences to consume.
While some speculate about a format shift, the producers believe such a move would be inappropriate and could harm the integrity of the original show and its cast.
They view such terms as oversimplified and politically charged, arguing that reality TV should focus on storytelling rather than ideological labels.
Whitney is seen as a rising star who may pursue independent success beyond the show, potentially using her platform to build a career outside the franchise.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.