President Trump’s recent Asia trip, including a high-profile trilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, was marked by extensive rhetoric but minimal substantive outcomes. Despite claims of progress on nuclear disarmament, AI "guardrails," and peace efforts, the talks yielded no binding agreements—particularly on denuclearization, which China has historically resisted. The notion of joint AI guardrails, while notable, lacks detail and appears to reflect Trump’s alignment with tech industry figures like Jensen Wong and Elon Musk, rather than a serious policy shift. Internal disagreements within the administration over technology exports to China highlight a lack of clear strategy. Trump’s persistent framing of himself as a global peacemaker, especially regarding Ukraine and his praise of Putin, seems more symbolic than practical, emphasizing photo ops over policy results. The meeting, while historically significant as the first trilateral encounter between the three powers, is viewed as a low-impact diplomatic gesture. The expiration of the Busan trade truce in January adds pressure for renewed U.S.-China cooperation at the upcoming G20 summit, but ongoing tensions over AI, tech exports, and global competition suggest unresolved challenges. Overall, the trip underscores a foreign policy driven by image and optics rather than tangible progress or mutual benefit.
It's the NPR Politics Podcast. I'm Danielle Kurtzleben. I cover the White House.
I'm Deva Shivaram. I also cover the White House.
And I'm Mara Liason, Senior National Political Correspondent.
And we're recording this at 1.54 p.m. Eastern Time on Friday, November 20th, where President Trump has just wrapped up a press conference at the White House.
Vice President J.D. Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio were also there, and they also spoke.
Now, ostensibly, this press conference was to cover the president's trip to Asia and his meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin.
However, the president covered a lot more ground.
And so let's start by just getting a pulse check from you both.
Deva, you were just in Asia with the president, so let's start with you.
What were your big takeaways from today?
From the press conference today?
Well, one, we as the press corps didn't hear from the president yesterday in China at all.
He did not come speak to us.
He did not answer any questions.
We had a long flight home, almost 15 hours, which the president was quick to point out at the top of his press conference.
That was the longest flight that Air Force One has ever done nonstop, which is why he wanted to share that news.
But anyway, all of that to say we did not hear from the president yesterday.
So this press conference is the first time we're hearing about this trip.
And Trump really took the opportunity to try to sell the trip, try to make the point that, hey, you know, there was stuff that happened over there when I was there.
And we did things.
And he had the vice president and Secretary of State.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio standing behind him to also weigh on in this and say it was important.
And not only was it important, but it was important for the American people.
It was a lot of that at the top of this presser.
Well, and are you saying this is the lady protesting too much, that they're saying a lot happened because not very much happened?
Well, yeah.
To be honest, there weren't really a lot of takeaways.
I was trying to write a digital story about the takeaways from this bilat with Xi and the trilat with Xi and Putin yesterday.
And I was really struggling to write the story because I was like, there's not a lot to take.
There's not a lot to take away from this.
Right.
Mara, what about you?
I've never seen a president try so hard or talk so long without any substance to report from a trip where he met with two other world leaders.
I mean, I thought it was remarkable.
They met.
That seemed to be the whole purpose, that they were engaged and they promised to be engaged in the future.
But there were no specific takeaways about nuclear weapons.
There's something that the president said.
There was a peace declaration where all three leaders agreed that nuclear war must never happen.
That's kind of substance free.
There were little bits of news.
For instance, he has a fantastic relationship with Putin.
He has a very good relationship with Putin.
We've heard that before.
But he has never let up on that.
And I would say that lately he's been more tilting to Putin than he ever has, even though he's made his preference for Putin over Zelensky.
That's very clear.
So I think that the president is about to confront a very new reality in Washington.
It's going to start in January when the new Congress comes in.
And this is kind of like the last moment when he can be astride the world stage without sharing power with anyone.
That's going to end soon.
I want to drill down into one thing that the president said during this press conference.
Deepa, you and I were near each other in the newsroom when the president was talking.
We both kind of sat down.
We sat up straight and looked at each other.
When he said that he and Chinese leader Xi Jinping agreed there would be, quote, joint guardrails that the two countries would craft on artificial intelligence.
That seems relatively new.
What do we know about those plans?
Yeah, I stood up and kind of was a little interested in that for several reasons.
One of them being the word literally guardrails is not something that Trump has ever used when he talks about AI.
He is someone who, as we know, is very deeply friendly with the tech industry and tech leaders.
He has been insistent.
Since he came back into the White House, that there would not be any kind of regulations on AI.
I think at best there was a blip of time in which, you know, a lot of these AI leaks and hacks were happening with big tech companies like OpenAI.
And they were sort of floating different kinds of terms like safeguards.
But to say guardrails is important and punchy and different.
And so that really stood out to me.
I thought it was interesting that it came from Trump and not from Treasury Secretary Scott Besson, who is usually the figure in the Trump administration, who comes out.
And talks about AI related updates.
He's someone who, as has unfolded in the last week, is taking a different approach to China and sharing technology with China compared to someone like Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick.
There's been a little bit of a split on that in the Trump administration.
And Trump has talked about that publicly.
But we haven't seen anything, you know, like any kind of a joint statement from the U.S. and China on this.
We haven't seen any paperwork on what kind of guardrails there would really be.
I think it's just significant in the fact that he said.
I will put some added context into this, which is that last year at APEC, when Trump and Xi met amid this like very high tense moment, right, escalating trade war, a lot of AI conversations that were going on in the universe, they met.
And one of the takeaways from that agreement was that the U.S. and China would, you know, talk and have conversations about AI.
Very loosey goosey.
Nothing concrete was supposed to come from that.
And the only thing that really has come out since I was just talking to Sam Sachs from the New America Foundation about this.
She was saying really.
Since then, the latest concrete thing to come out was in September when President Xi visited the White House.
The U.S. and China agreed to have like a notification system that they would set up.
So if a big hack happened, you know, something with AI technology was going awry, the two countries would communicate.
That is the last and latest and only really thing that has come from the U.S. and China communicating or collaborating in any way on AI.
So for the president to come out and now say that they're doing joint guardrails, I have a lot of questions on what actually comes.
But it is definitely significant that he said it.
Deepa, I have a question for you.
He did say he didn't want the most advanced computer chips to go to China.
He wants to win the race.
But he also leaned pretty heavily into supporting Howard Lutnick, also saying nice things about Jensen Wong, two people who have been associated with the let's not put too many restrictions on what we sell to China.
Right.
Does that tell us anything?
I think it tells us that the president is not himself an expert when it comes to AI.
He is.
Listening to a lot of different people in his circles, Trump puts a huge emphasis on people like Jensen Wong and Elon Musk when it comes to learning about this technology, what to do when it comes to trade tariffs, China, sharing the technology, all of that.
There's kind of two schools of thought.
And this is where that Lutnick-Besson divide kind of comes in.
The idea right now is that the U.S. is sharing some of our chips with China.
It's not the most advanced chips.
It's not the best ones.
But it is some chips.
And there are some folks.
You know, in the U.S., lawmakers who are really concerned about that, that we're sharing our technology with China.
We're in this global AI race.
Doesn't this benefit China and their innovation?
There's an argument that Trump almost kind of got into as he was talking in this press conference.
And he alluded to Jensen Wong making this point as well, which is that if we limit our chips to China, if we don't share anything, does that spur Chinese innovation?
And does that give China almost a boost or an edge as they develop more technology?
Right now, experts say the U.S.
is more advanced when it comes to developing this technology.
But it's not like it's a huge gap, right?
Well, that's the Jensen Wong argument.
And, of course, Trump did say in this press conference that we were 10 years ahead of China.
I can't think of a single expert who agrees with that.
I don't know if 10 years, but, like, there's some wiggle room here, but not a ton.
But 10 years is a very long time in the AI-accelerated universe.
And Trump is constantly talking about making sure China doesn't beat the U.S. on AI.
I want to get to one other topic.
And this is something that President Trump talked about today.
He talked about the U.S.
He talks about it fairly often, is this idea that he wants to be a peacemaker.
He called Russia's war on Ukraine ridiculous.
And he also said he hoped he could broker a resolution between the two countries.
He also said he wants to get rid of nuclear weapons, though he acknowledged that would be difficult.
And he repeated more than once that he thinks he deserves the Nobel Peace Prize.
He said that many times before.
So there's a lot here.
What do you both think of his fixation on this idea of being a peacemaker at this point?
Mara, let's start with you.
Well, he clearly wants the Nobel Peace Prize.
He talks about that a lot.
The interesting thing for me is in his comments about Ukraine, he seemed to be fixated on this idea that the reason there's a war between Ukraine and Russia is not because Russia invaded Ukraine and wants to subjugate it, but because these two individual people hate each other.
And that's it.
It's just a Zelensky versus Putin spat.
He repeated over and over again that Putin would love to end the war.
But Putin has never shown any indication that he wants to end the war in any other way than on Russia's terms.
So I thought we got pretty much nowhere.
There were some questions to Trump.
Jared Kushner has floated this idea that Ukraine, if they have to give up some territory, would get some kind of security guarantees, maybe as a member of NATO, which is something that Putin has adamantly ruled out many times, or that there would be some other kind of Article 5-like.
Jared Kushner has floated this idea that Ukraine, if they have to give up some territory, would get some kind of security guarantee, maybe as a member of NATO.
as the week began on Monday and Trump was leaving to go to Manila, he kind of
all of a sudden floated the idea that he was going to meet with Kim Jong-un, the North Korean leader
on this trip. That did not happen logistically. It would have been close to impossible to make
that happen. But it struck me because I think Trump sees himself as a peacemaker in the idea
that he can have these meetings where other presidents can't. So the meetings are the
message. In other words, it doesn't matter if nothing comes out of them. But that either is
obvious, like, of course, you have to talk to each other to make any kind of agreement,
or it's a total cop-out. You just get to meet and nothing happens. But you get,
at least in Trump's idea, a lot of kudos for just meeting.
And you get to have this image of you and these two other superpower leaders
standing with each other, sitting at this big circular table, whatnot, just
to show the world, look at us, we're meeting, we're doing things.
Exactly. I was going to say, this is a president who governs by photo op. So with that reality,
like, this isn't entirely surprising.
Okay, time for a break. More in a moment.
Welcome back. We're going to back up and focus on the president's trip to Asia this week. He was
in the Philippines to attend the Association of Southeast Asian Nations Summit, or ASEAN Summit,
and then in China to attend the APEC Summit. That's the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation
Summit. Deepa, like I said earlier, you were in China with the president. Broadly,
what came up in these two summits?
Well, Trump went into China, and particularly into this trilat with Putin and Xi,
he says to talk about denuclearization, which is the idea that there are too many nuclear weapons
in the world, and we need to reduce the stockpile of nuclear weapons. Famously, this is a conversation
that China wants no part of. Even last week, the White House held a background call on this,
and a White House official who was not authorized to speak on the record acknowledged that, you know,
yeah, we know that this is not a conversation that China wants to be a part of, but they basically
said, you know, it's time for China to step up to the adult table, have this adult conversation. So
there was this push from the U.S. that this engagement on this issue specifically was,
I should point out, China doesn't typically like having these conversations because they don't have
as many nuclear weapons as the U.S. and Russia does. And so they kind of have that, you know,
less of an edge in the conversation. One expert I talked to also said that China didn't really
want to set a precedent, right? If they talk about denuclearization here in China on their turf,
does that mean they have to keep talking about it at other summits in the future?
That was essentially what the point of this trilat was supposed to be about. Trump also
said that they would talk about Iran. When he was leaving the White House on Monday,
he said he wanted to talk about Ukraine.
Ukraine. So these were all the things that were going to come up theoretically. We don't know the
exact contents of what happened in this conversation, but I will say the part where the press
was brought in, the three leaders made their introductory comments. And that is where Trump
said, you know, it's important that these conversations keep happening. One more thing
I'll add is that Xi was in the middle between Putin and Trump. And there was sort of a sense
from the Chinese side that, you know, this is a meeting that holds a lot of significance because
it's historical and it's the first time it's ever happened.
Sure.
But China's really trying to position themselves as a balancing force, a stabilizing force in the
world. And quite frankly, I think Putin was just happy to be there.
Right. I mean, I want to drill down a little bit more on that. Like you said,
this is the first time the leaders of these three countries met together, which is a huge deal.
And there's this big list of big things they could talk about. You know, like you said, Iran,
the Russia's war in Ukraine, AI. Specifically, former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang and the U.S.'s
that he was targeted by a Chinese spy. He may have wanted to ask Xi about that.
Do we have any sense of what they talked about in these meetings? Or is it all just a black box?
Feels like a black box. There wasn't a joint. To be clear, there wasn't an expectation that
Russia, China and the U.S. would come out with a joint statement and say, this is what we all
discussed or agreed on. Because to be clear, there also wasn't any expectation that anyone
would agree on anything, which begs the question, why did this meeting happen? But yeah, we really
don't know what the actual
contents of it were other than, you know, what the leaders said at the top and what they intended to
talk about.
So, Mara, I want to turn to you. The U.S., China and Russia are three of the world's
superpowers, if not the three world's superpowers. What did this meeting say to you about America's
place in the world?
Well, I think it showed once again that Trump likes authoritarian leaders. He's drawn to them.
He talks a lot about how strong they are, how Xi controls 1.4 billion people.
So this is just the kind of meeting he wanted. And he actually talked kind of
wistfully about the fact that Kim Jong-un wasn't there. He had hoped to have a separate meeting
with him. But I can't think of another time in history where a U.S. president said more positive
things about Vladimir Putin than he ever has about America's own allies in Europe or elsewhere.
And that's pretty extraordinary. But on the other hand, I also think this meeting is a kind of sugar
high. You know, he's met with Xi before. He's met with Putin before. Can we think of anything
lasting that came out of those meetings? No. And I think that's a really important thing.
And I don't think we're going to be able to do that with this meeting either.
Well, this meeting, like you said, the vibes between Trump and Xi and Putin were all so
warm and the leaders were all pretty cordial with each other. Is that a low bar for a meeting such
as this when there are so many practical points of conflict between all three countries? There's
to be honest, it seems like there's kind of a disconnect there.
Well, it's a very low bar. But but Donald Trump wanted to inflate that low bar as much as he can
to say this is the most amazing thing that just happened. And then you drill down.
And think, well, what actually just happened? Not much.
So this was the third time Trump and Xi have met this year and a fourth time is scheduled for later
this year. So I want to end by asking how important is this relationship for both countries? And
I keep wondering how mutually beneficial is the relationship?
Well, I would just say it's very beneficial for Putin, who's been an international pariah,
very beneficial for Xi, who wants to position China as the rising number one power in the world. Soon it
will overtake the U.S. economy. I think the question is, is does this help Trump domestically?
I mean, is there a pro-Putin caucus in Congress that's going to be thrilled about this? No.
Right. I think between Trump and Xi, one thing that was supposed to happen in that bilateral
meeting between the U.S. and China that didn't really happen in China was an extension of the
Busan Agreement, the trade truce that came out of Busan last year when Trump and Xi met at the APEC
Summit a year ago.
That expires in January, and they didn't extend it in this meeting in China. So that means that
they have this other meeting that you're talking about coming up in Miami where Trump is hosting
the G20 next month as kind of this ticking clock deadline to make this happen. It's been a frosty
truce. It hasn't been perfect. There's been a lot of problems on both sides. But I'm kind of curious
where that develops and between all of the other tensions going on in the world, this NVIDIA stuff,
there's a lot going on, AI developments, question mark, question mark, how in between now and G20,
you know, that might impact some of the extensions and the conversations about
this Busan Agreement getting renewed.
All right. We're going to have to leave it there for today. Our executive producer is
Muthoni Mathuri. Casey Morrell edits the podcast. Our producer is Bria Suggs.
Special thanks to Dana Farrington. I'm Deepa Shivaram. And I'm Mara Liason, Senior National. National Political Correspondent.
And thank you for listening to the NPR Politics Podcast.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
President Trump’s press conference following his Asia trip emphasized the importance of his meetings with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, but offered few concrete outcomes or substantive takeaways.
The U.S.-China trilateral meeting with Putin lacked tangible agreements, particularly on nuclear disarmament or AI regulation, with China showing little interest in denuclearization and no joint commitments emerging.
Trump introduced the idea of “joint guardrails” on artificial intelligence with China—a significant shift from his past stance, as he rarely discussed AI regulation, but the details remain vague and unverified.
Internal divisions within the Trump administration, especially between Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and Treasury Secretary Scott Besson, reflect contrasting views on technology exports to China, with Trump leaning toward Lutnick’s pro-sharing approach.
Trump’s repeated claims of being a peacemaker, including his desire to broker peace in Ukraine and his praise for Putin, appear more symbolic than practical, reflecting a photo-op-driven foreign policy rather than strategic engagement.
The meeting between Trump, Xi, and Putin was seen as a diplomatic spectacle, with warm but superficial exchanges lacking real policy progress or mutual accountability.
The expiration of the Busan trade truce in January creates urgency for a renewed agreement at the upcoming G20 in Miami, amid ongoing tensions over AI, technology exports, and global competition.
Experts question the mutual benefit of the U.S.-China-Russia engagement, noting it serves more to elevate China’s global standing and Putin’s international image than to resolve pressing geopolitical issues.
Summary:
President Trump’s recent Asia trip, including a high-profile trilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, was marked by extensive rhetoric but minimal substantive outcomes. Despite claims of progress on nuclear disarmament, AI "guardrails," and peace efforts, the talks yielded no binding agreements—particularly on denuclearization, which China has historically resisted. The notion of joint AI guardrails, while notable, lacks detail and appears to reflect Trump’s alignment with tech industry figures like Jensen Wong and Elon Musk, rather than a serious policy shift.
Internal disagreements within the administration over technology exports to China highlight a lack of clear strategy. Trump’s persistent framing of himself as a global peacemaker, especially regarding Ukraine and his praise of Putin, seems more symbolic than practical, emphasizing photo ops over policy results. The meeting, while historically significant as the first trilateral encounter between the three powers, is viewed as a low-impact diplomatic gesture.
-China cooperation at the upcoming G20 summit, but ongoing tensions over AI, tech exports, and global competition suggest unresolved challenges. Overall, the trip underscores a foreign policy driven by image and optics rather than tangible progress or mutual benefit.
FAQs
The meeting covered broad topics like denuclearization, AI, and Iran, but no concrete agreements were reached. China expressed reluctance to engage in denuclearization talks, and there was no joint statement or tangible outcome from the discussions.
No significant agreements were reached. While the leaders expressed a desire to continue dialogue, there were no joint statements or concrete outcomes on issues such as nuclear weapons or AI regulations.
Trump stated that he and Xi agreed to establish joint guardrails on artificial intelligence, a term not previously used by him in AI discussions. However, no details or official documentation have been released to confirm the scope or implementation of these guardrails.
Trump highlighted his strong rapport with Putin, suggesting a closer alignment with Russia, which contrasts with his previous support for Ukraine. This reflects a shift in his foreign policy, leaning more toward authoritarian leaders and less toward Western allies.
It was the first time these three global powers met together, signaling a potential effort to foster dialogue on global issues. However, the meeting lacked substantive outcomes, raising questions about its real strategic value.
The trilateral meeting did not extend the Busan trade agreement, which expires in January. This suggests ongoing tension in U.S.-China trade relations, with no immediate progress on renewing the truce despite previous diplomatic efforts.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.