The post-election focus groups reveal that many long-time Trump voters in Texas and Iowa switched their support to Democratic candidates due to disillusionment with Trump’s negative messaging, economic policies, and the toxic tone of politics. Voters expressed frustration over the war in Iran, rising costs of living, and a political environment marked by vitriol and division. Democratic candidates like James Tallarico and Rob Sand gained traction not through aggressive messaging, but through authenticity, local presence, and a clear commitment to listening to constituents. Their appeal stemmed from a sense of individuality and independence from party ideology, contrasting sharply with the perceived loyalty to Trump. Voters emphasized that they wanted tangible, practical changes—such as lower healthcare and housing costs—over political grandstanding or investigations. They also viewed Republican candidates as uniformly aligned with Trump, making any future GOP nominee face significant hurdles in breaking that mold. For Democrats, the takeaway is clear: success in 2028 hinges on delivering on campaign promises through simple, measurable legislation and maintaining a message of accountability and compassion. The focus groups signal a shift in voter expectations—demanding not just policy changes, but a fundamental reimagining of political trust and tone. With a majority of voters now open to supporting Democrats, the party must act quickly to translate this momentum into consistent, visible, and credible action in Congress.
Welcome to Pod Save America, I'm Jon Favreau.
Today we're doing something a little different for our Sunday episode.
The week after the election, our team hit the road with our friends at Future Forward and Orchestra
for a series of focus groups in Texas and Iowa.
We wanted to understand what made this year the year that those two red states finally went blue.
Why did so many Republicans vote for James Tallarico and Gina Hinojosa in Texas
and Josh Turek and Rob Sand in Iowa?
Was there something different about these candidates or were voters just fed up with Trump?
And was this a one-off or would these voters be open to supporting a Democrat
for president in 2028?
So we sat down with Trump supporters, many of whom voted for him three times,
but this year decided to support the Democratic candidates to ask them how they're feeling about
their votes and what they want to see from Democrats going forward.
We're not going to play all eight hours of the focus groups for you.
We would not do that to you.
Instead, I sat down with David Binder and Will Goodlunas, two of the best pollsters in
Democratic politics who conducted these focus groups. We talked about what they heard and you'll
also hear a little bit from the voters themselves. After that, I talked to my old pal David Plouffe
from the Obama campaign and the White House who helped make this happen. We talked about what he
found most interesting in the groups and what it means for the Democrats' strategy as we head into
2028. All right, let's get to it. Here's David Binder and Will Goodlunas.
David, Will, welcome.
Thank you. Good to be here.
Good to see you.
Really great to be here. Thank you.
So you guys just conducted some focus groups with people in Dallas and Des Moines.
Who had voted for Trump in the past but voted for Democrats in the midterms.
I am, of course, a focus groupie. Love focus groups. Can't get enough of them.
Others might be hearing this and thinking, what the hell is wrong with you sickos? We just had
an election. Why did you guys do this? What were you hoping to understand about these voters?
There's definitely a lot you can learn by going out pretty immediately right after the election.
The election is still fresh in the minds of voters. So we do groups immediately after the
election and ask them why they voted the way they did, what they remember about the campaigns,
what were they responding to. So the reason we do them is to find out what actually led to their
decisions. What was their thought process? What were the communications and messages
they were receiving? But then there's a whole nother angle on what we're doing,
which is to figure out what does this mean for the future? And obviously it's hard, you know,
a couple of days after an election to make, you know, conclusions on what this means for the next
election. But you can get immediate guidance on what voters are thinking looking forward. What
are their expectations for the new Congress? And what does that mean for potentially a new
president in 2028? So the time was right to ask those questions and see what voters are thinking
and hearing and feeling and what their expectations and hopes are as well as their concerns. Yeah. And
obviously there's exit polling and a lot of other kinds of polling that get done right after an
election. But, you know, quantitative research, which is what polling is, you know, it can only
tell you so much. And with everyone doing sort of after post-election analysis and what it means
for the future, it seems like getting some actual qualitative info from real voters about why they
made up their minds is probably useful, right, Will? The biggest difference we heard between
2024 and now is kind of the emotions that were coming out. Whereas in 2024, before the election,
you heard a lot of one of the biggest things we hear in focus groups we do all the time is like,
I'm going to just choose the lesser of two evils. And that's what we heard about both parties,
both candidates in 2024. This time, especially after when we did these groups after the election,
we heard that it was a little bit different that, you know, we have quotes here. We're
I could remember that I didn't have to vote for the lesser of two evils, that there actually was
a choice. There actually was someone speaking to me. And I was excited about it.
So I want to start with what some of these voters said about what Trump and the Republicans did
to lose their votes. We put together a couple of these clips. Let's listen.
I will distinctly remember Trump having his speech saying, if the Democrats get in there,
it's not going to be good. And I feel like at that moment, I started paying attention to what the
Republicans were saying, because I'm like, okay, if you're saying it's not going to be good,
and you're thinking what you're doing right now is good, then I want the change of what they're doing.
If you talk about Trump, the one thing that I did not like that really rubbed me the wrong way with
him is vote my way. And I'm going to give everybody in the country money. Yeah, you're
not going to buy my vote. Politically, there's a cult that's developed. And I think we need to get
the political cult needs to be broken.
The Epstein files is what got me. I'm not going to lie. I mean, the Epstein files is what got me.
Trump says jump, and they say how high.
So when Trump first got elected, I was like, you know what? I really don't have a lot of
problems with his political stance, but he is a vile human being.
You're breaking up families. The economy's going to hell. You campaigned on America for America,
no more wars in the Middle East. And what do you do? You start something. We're still bogged down in that.
So again, these are all Trump voters, all people who voted for Trump in the past.
What was your top line takeaway from these voters as to why they moved away from Donald Trump and
the Republicans? Well, first of all, shout out to your team. That's amazing. Those clips are
absolutely amazing. They do good, quick work. Well, we look at this all the time. We look at
transcripts. We look at the videos of our focus groups. I've never seen anything stitched together
quite that perfectly.
That was really amazing. But go ahead. I thought you were answering first on what?
Well, one thing I just want to kind of heighten that you just said is it's really important to
remember that these voters that we talked to were three-time Trump voters. Everybody in each one of
the sessions had voted for Trump three times. The only couple individuals who didn't was because
they skipped one of the elections. So there were no Harris voters, no Biden voters, no Clinton voters.
It's just that they are now saying this so strongly and how different it is than what they've said in
the past where it's like, no one is looking out for me. No one is talking my language. No one is
speaking for me. And the fact that now we're hearing these negatives that Trump has totally
left them behind and is totally almost kind of taunting them that not only is the economy bad,
but now here I'm going to do all these other things and I'm going to put focus
on everywhere that's not on you. And so it almost felt like I'm
hurting every day in terms of, you know, my gas, in terms of my rent, in terms of my family,
in terms of education, in terms of all these other things. But also you're almost kind of laughing in
my face because your buddies are getting enriched and you are doing all these other things that you
said you weren't going to do. One thing that I was interested in this time and listening to these
Trump voters talk about why they ended up voting for James Tallarico or Rob Sand or Josh Turek or
I mean, we've had a lot of post-election discussion that the war in Iran and the gas prices and the
economy and the cost of living is clearly first and foremost in the minds of these voters. And
they want to change. One thing I noted, and we'll put together a report, we had a little exercise,
we get them to write down on a sheet of paper, what message were you sending with your vote?
And we had like 26 different participants and I counted up 11 of them, wrote down some,
uh, answer that had the word change included. That's a lot. 11 people just putting the word
change in their response to a, to an exercise in which we're writing down, uh, something on a sheet
of paper. But the one thing that I think may not get enough attention that Will and I heard in our
groups is that these voters were really unhappy with the tone and the atmosphere of the American
political system these days. And I know that, you know, Trump has kind of been kind of negative and
we had four years of him before and people didn't seem to tire of him. But this time people were
talking about the economy and the war and cost of living, but they were also saying America seems
like a meaner place and our politics border on cruelty at times, the way that we attack each
other. And we, that's the change. Not only do we need to change economically, but we need to change
in the tone and the way that we treat each other in this country. And we need to get away from Trump
and we're taking this negative tone and causing Americans to beat each other throats.
I will say that, you know, my one, I felt pretty good going into election day. My, if I had a fear,
it was, it was not that, um, Trump was as unpopular or wasn't as unpopular as we all thought he was.
Like I was like, you know, there's a war. People are feeling the effects of the war in terms of
prices. People are angry about prices anyway. They're angry about the tariffs. They know that
they're going to have to pay for it. And so I'm worried that these Republican candidates would
from Trump, or that voters would just say, you know what, I'm not really happy with Trump,
and I'm not really happy with the Republican Party, but this, you know, the governor of Texas
seems different, or this Senate candidate, and, you know, Ashley Hinson, maybe she seems different
than Trump, and if Democrats didn't do as well as we thought they would do, it was for that reason.
But it seems like these voters sort of just combined or tied together Republicans and Trump
in their minds. No, in fact, we saw the exact opposite, that there was no separation between
the Republican candidates and Trump. Not even, again, these are swing voters, these are former
Trump voters, but they're saying that there wasn't even an effort to kind of separate at all,
whereas, and, you know, we may get into this later, but there was on the Democratic side,
and that was one of the things that stood out about these candidates. I mean, we were talking
in this case in Dallas and Iowa, but David and I were all over the country doing these in other
places as well.
That's one of the things that stood out the most, is that for these swing voters, you know, again,
voters who, you know, tend to go different ways in different elections, that was one of the biggest
things that stood out to them, is that these Democrats were saying some things out there on
the campaign trail, saying that, you know, I am going to put you ahead of my party, and that did
break through, and there were some specific examples of that, both in Iowa and in Texas,
but that's something that we heard the most when we were doing this kind of, you know,
diagnostic debrief post-election, is that was one of the things that we heard
the most, both in terms of, this is why I voted the way I did, but also, this is what I want to
see moving forward. Well, let's talk about the Democrats, because, Will, I thought it was really
interesting that you said at the beginning, this is the first time in a while you can remember
people saying, I'm not just going to, okay, I don't like the Republicans, I don't like Trump,
so I'm going to vote for these guys to send a message.
I were excited about these Democratic candidates, which is new for us as Democrats.
So, here's some of what these voters said they liked about these Democratic candidates.
There was something about Tallarico that seemed different than the usual politician, or no?
He seemed to want to connect with me, with us.
And what did he do that kind of communicated that to you, that made you feel that way?
He just came across as very sincere and very honest.
You know, there should be a feel like Turek was more of a kind of an independent Democrat.
He wasn't going to just do what you want.
What Schumer told him to do, or what party leaders told him to do.
He seemed like a real Iowan.
People saying, you know, I'm for Iowa, I'm for the country, I'm for whatever state, and not for the party.
Did anything stand out to you?
Rob Sand.
And what did he say?
He said that, I mean, that's where I heard actually purple, and I never even knew that was a term.
But he said, you know, I may be Democrat, but I'm going to listen to, like, the other Republicans
and listen to everyone's voice, not just. the voice of my own party.
He said, I want to do what's right for everyone, not just the Democrats, not just the Republicans, everyone.
Like, everyone should fall under this umbrella because that's how it was supposed to be.
But somehow it got mixed up along the way, you know?
I think one of the things I heard Rob say after he won the election was that I will work very hard for everyone that voted for me.
And if you didn't vote for me, I'd like you to, if you see me out and about, I want you to stop me and ask and tell me why you didn't vote for me.
Because I want to make sure that you're heard.
So, you know, every campaign says its candidate is authentic.
What did Rob and Josh Turek and Tallarico and Hinojosa actually do that made these voters believe that they were who they said they were and that they were real and not just politicians?
I think what we just heard on the clips is really very representative of the difference between this set of Democratic candidates
and potentially some candidates in the White House.
And sometimes it could be perception of average voters that, you know, see that these candidates are kind of communicating in a way that is new and refreshing.
But this sense of I am not here to represent Democrats.
I'm here to represent the voters that elected me and the voters who did not vote for me was something that was really fresh to these people.
You know, they had, you know, I think the previous clip that said when Trump says jump, the Republicans say how high it was.
The contradiction.
I think it's a contrast between what people like Tallarico and Rob Sand and Josh Turek were saying, which is that we are here to listen to you and respond to you and to meet your needs, not the party leaders.
And I don't care whether we're a Democrat.
We're here to work for you.
That was a message it cut through in a way that seemed new to these people that they had not heard in previous from candidates in previous elections.
Yeah, that's the most important thing.
But also there is an old school kind of element here, too.
In all four of those cases, we heard from these voters in these groups that I just saw more of them.
I heard more from them.
They were out there more.
You know, I saw I saw them speak.
They were going all around the state.
They were doing these things.
And that really meant something to them as well.
Yeah, I was going to say there were Iowa voters who had heard Rob Sand on local radio over the years, seen him in their communities, knew his work as auditor.
How much of this do you think was trust that was built?
Sort of before the campaign, rather than, you know, what we tend to think happens in campaigns, which is, you know, all the TV spending comes in the final month and the message breaks through.
And that's when all these sort of low propensity voters start paying attention.
I actually think that I heard that Rob Sand visited each one of the Iowa counties twice at least.
And there were ninety nine counties.
So I do think a lot of it is visibility.
I mean, certainly he had a reputation as auditor and kind of being a Democrat in a state.
He was nominated by Republicans, gave him a little bit of extra credit, I think, or extra, you know, trust.
But, you know, I think the visibility during the campaign was incredibly important because these guys were out all over the place and at the local level listening to voters.
One of the things that we heard over and over in the groups in Des Moines and Dallas was I felt that they were listening to us.
And that is rare.
Very seldom do you hear average voters say, I think that the candidates were listening to us.
Usually they say they are never listening to.
This time they said that they were people, at least on the Democratic side.
Yeah.
And I just want to add one thing just for kind of listeners out there, base voters.
You know, when they hear this thing about saying that I'm going to vote for I'm going to support you and not my party.
It doesn't mean that a Democrat would lean over and take a Republican view.
That's not what the voters are saying.
What the voters are saying is I just want to know that you're going to prioritize me and the state ahead of your party.
And it doesn't mean that you're going to vote for me.
You're going to take a Republican view.
It just means that you're going to take a common sense view, a popular view, something that the voters want to happen that neither of the two parties are taking right now.
And that you're not going to be pressured by other politicians in your party or, you know, super politically engaged people in your party.
Basically, the people who dominate the national conversation, assholes like me, and that, you know, and that you're just going to you're going to remember us.
Right.
And think of the state voters these days view that everyone that gets elected to Congress have the desire to get reelected.
And that desire to get reelected means you can listen to the people who can help you get reelected, which are generally lobbyists, PACs, donors, people who are going to be able to fund your reelected campaign.
And we've heard over the years, many voters say that, you know, members of Congress, new members of Congress enter with the best of intentions.
But once they get in, something happens and they get.
They're a tool of the of the system, which is dominated by PACs and lobbyists and donors.
And for this time, it seemed like there's some hope that maybe these new Democrats we've elected may be actually putting us first and foremost and not the donors and lobbyists and PACs.
It does make sense that in a state like Iowa, Rob and Josh could have traveled the whole state that a lot of these voters may have met these candidates.
Before they got to vote.
Texas is, you know, running a campaign in Texas is closest thing to a national campaign outside like California or New York or Florida.
How did the voters in the Texas groups like what did they say about, you know, how they came to form an opinion about James Tallarico, Gina Hinojosa?
Was it ads they remembered?
Was it videos?
Was it in their social media feed?
Did they like how did they?
How did they sort of consume information about those candidates?
Yeah, it's all of the above.
And you bring up the Texas example, which is just one other thing that's just really interesting is for these swing voters, not talking about base voters, but these swing voters, they definitely heard from Tallarico first through all of those channels.
It was through social.
It was it was through ads.
It was getting introduced to him through the primary process as well.
So they did do that.
And then it was the synergy between him and Hinojosa that really brought some of these.
Voters to say, well, now I want to check her out, too.
And that really caused a lot of energy and enthusiasm for almost like a ticket going on rather than just this one individual.
But it did.
It did start with the communications going out from Tallarico.
It's funny.
I saw a quote from Beto O'Rourke in one of the post-election pieces where he said, you know, he's always thought that it would take two people running to turn Texas blue.
And that James and Gina together and sort of being able to sort of fan out and like you said, well, like run.
almost as a ticket, probably helped Democrats overall, especially since they complemented each
other in different ways. Yeah, I think even demographically, Gina and James were an interesting
reflection of the new types of Democrats that voters were looking for, because Will and I have
heard again and again over the years that what voters want is new energy, fresh ideas, people
that are younger in age than some of the party leaders of the past, and people that kind of come
out of the community. So when you see Gina and James together, they reflect kind of new energy,
youthfulness, new ideas, coming, you know, James Tallarico being everyone knew he was a teacher,
a middle school teacher, and that was kind of the type of person we want in Washington representing
us. So yeah, I think that they did complement each other in a way that gave them kind of a
rising tide. What's that phrase? Lifting all boats. Yeah, the Gina and James boats were lifted
together.
Well, the other thing I just want to mention there, too, is just how, this is a minor point
compared to what we just talked about, but just how bad the Republican ads were, especially in Texas,
and how much that really turned off voters. Now, I'm not here saying that, you know, negative ads
don't work. We know they do. We have lots of polls. We have elections that tell us they do.
But in this case, in the absence of these Republican candidates defining themselves
as either independent of Trump or as anything, really,
all the voters saw were the negatives. So, they held that against these candidates,
and that caused them to even look further into Tallarico and the other Democratic candidates.
So, that was another factor that, you know, and they were just these messages that they've been
hearing since the last election, and it just felt like this holdover message that wasn't in any way
new. Right. Yeah, you know, the one thing that I was in a way excited about was the degree to which
the voters in our focus groups told us that the attack ads turned them off and created a backlash.
You know, the idea that Tallarico, Loti, Tallarico, all those sorts of attacks, voters are saying,
don't they have anything else to talk about other than to, you know, call the Democrats' names
and make them into freaks, make them sound like they're, you know, trans or gay, you know,
all these sorts of social attacks that the Republicans waged,
especially against Tallarico. The voters in our focus group said that just told me that they had
nothing positive to say about themselves. Well, it's also, I mean, negative ads can work,
but not all negative ads are created equal. It seems to me like a negative ad that provides
voters information about the candidate that would have a direct impact on their lives that is
believable, fair, new information seems like it could be effective, but just, you know, these
in the last few cycles haven't been good at subtlety. And so instead of like hinting that
James Tallarico might not be strong enough for you, they just go with Tallarico, Loti, all that stuff.
And when they listened to James Tallarico, he seemed like a reasonable guy. So, you know,
I don't see where this freak's coming from, you know, and he doesn't seem like a vegan either.
And so just to your point, I mean, we do hear that all the time, you know, I don't listen to
negative ads, but this was, as David was saying, this was a step different that we heard this time.
Actual anger causing them to go the other direction. That's how bad they saw these ads.
And one more thing on Tallarico. I heard folks mentioned his faith as a reason that they trust
him. During the campaign, I remember quite a few pundits, journalists, Democrats expressing doubts
that Tallarico's brand of liberal Christianity would ever appeal to Texas evangelicals or even
evangelical Christians, Republicans. What specifically did these voters say about his
faith and why do you think that gave them some comfort? Just on one level, and this is what we
were saying before, is just simply that it made him stand out. And that alone for a lot of these
swing voters is all they want, is that it made him an individual, it made him unique in a way that
made them want to learn more, and it made them think that he was going to be an independent voice
for them. Yeah.
I would just add that his faith came across as kind of providing a different dimension
than voters are used to looking at in political candidates, because they sometimes associate
Bible thumping with kind of evangelical far-right Republicans that are using kind of conservative
Christianity that is generally, you know, anti-abortion and anti-gay. And hearing
Tallarico talk about faith in a way that is about helping the environment, that is about
helping the neighbor, providing empathy and compassion for your fellow human being, you know,
seemed to strike a chord with these people in a way that they haven't heard Democrats and kind of
religious Democrats talk about the values of compassion and empathy and treat each other as
we would treat ourselves, sort of, you know, that connected in a way that seemed to give
Tallarico, round him out as a candidate and human being that had faith as part of his values.
Also an antidote to what you were describing before, which is people's general view
of politics as nasty, divisive, and them being just as sick of that as they were of some
of the economic failures of the Trump administration.
Yeah, that's a really good point. And so much so that with Tallarico, when we do, you know,
we talk to these swing voters, they are not paying attention. They're paying attention
to what's going on in their state and leading up to an election, they will know who their
candidates are. Very rarely do they know who their candidates are.
They don't know what's happening in other states. It's not till after the election where
they really start following that a little bit and, you know, realizing it was a blue
wave, that kind of thing. But there were voters in different places talking about Tallarico
because of those reasons that you bring up, that he was bringing some kind of different
attitude, some kind of different feeling to this thing that they think of negatively,
that maybe this could be a little bit different. So we have one more clip of what these voters
expect from Democrats now that they're in power. Let's listen.
Let's listen to what they want to see from them.
Healthcare.
Healthcare, education.
Yeah. Healthcare, education, housing.
I just want things to be cheaper. I want things to be less expensive. I mean, I do. I just,
I feel like, I mean, it's kind of the nature of the beast, you know, as, you know, we're
never going to get gas at a dollar a gallon like we did back in the 50s. You know, things
cost more to make, things cost more, you know, and that, I completely understand that. But
I just legitimately want things to be less expensive.
All right. So Dems should focus.
Focus on not being afraid to cross the aisle and say that again, not being afraid to cross
the aisle.
Anything else that you're worried about that the Democrats might focus on now that they
have a majority of the House of Representatives and majority in the Senate?
I'm worried that they're going to try to impeach him again. They're going to get caught up
in these investigations.
So should I put that up here that they should not move for impeachment?
Yeah. I mean, you could say impeachment, you could say investigations. It's stuff that's
not helping people and it's just playing the politics.
So there's a tension here.
There's a tension here with voters wanting change and progress on affordability, cost
of living issues, also wanting Democrats to work with Republicans. They want action on
fraud and corruption, but they don't want impeachment or investigations to take over
the agenda.
How do you think, what do you think they expect of Democrats to sort of deal with both of
these desires?
Yeah, this might be one of those occasions in which these kind of Trump, Trump Democrat
voters are different than voters that have been Democrats in every election that they
can remember.
These voters that we talked to were really adamant about they need, Democrats need to
go to Congress and pass legislation, put it on Trump's desk that is going to help me and
my family economically.
And whether that's, you know, changing the, the healthcare subsidies, Medicaid eligibility,
they are really focused on, I want to see the Democrats push Trump to end the tariffs,
renew healthcare subsidies, things that we are going, they're gonna make a difference
in our pocketbook.
And, and as that clip indicated, the idea of spending time investigating may detract
from that focus.
But at the same time, there is a desire for some level of accountability.
They just don't want that to be, to take precedence over the economics.
Yeah.
I mean, they, in some way, when we asked them that question, they made it clear, Hey, you
know, we just voted for you.
This is simple.
Do exactly what you said you were going to do during this campaign.
Like that's it.
And if you do that, we're, we're going to be happy.
Listening to the podcast that Dan actually did with secretary Buttigieg.
And he was talking about this, this exact topic and things that the Democrats could
do.
And he brought up this, which I thought was just a great idea and something we hear from
the swing voters all the time was, you know, if the Democrats could go there and just get
some bills moving that aren't larded up with, you know, 200 pages of, of, of stuff and,
you know, that are just very clear and simple that voters could understand so that they
could say, we could say this.
This is what the Democrats are doing
right now. Now, whether it gets vetoed or not, that's another issue. But it's very simple. And
not only does that live up to their campaign promise to do that, but it also shows that,
hey, this is a little bit different. You know, maybe this is different. Maybe this whole class,
this whole movement right now is a little bit different than what we've seen before,
where people get in there and they just do the same old thing.
And one thing I just add real quick is that while the idea of impeachment seems like it's something
that could be a waste of time in the minds of these voters, ethics is not. And if there's some
kind of a package that Democrats put forward about whether it's banning stock trading by members or
prediction markets by members, that is something that voters want to see moving forward that's
going to kind of clean up Washington. Because they say one of the promises that Trump did not
keep was he promised to drain the swamp. Well, the swamp seems swampier now than it ever was before.
Now the Democrats have an opportunity to kind of drain the swamp, at least with regard to
prohibiting stock trading and prediction market betting and the sorts of things that they're doing
that they can make money off inside information. Looking ahead to 2028, what do you think it would
take for these Trump voters to support the Democratic nominee? Well, right now they say
they're going to. I mean, just to jump ahead, we did ask them that at the end of the groups. And
most people say that if they had to, you know, if we force them to,
to choose right now, most of the voters that we talked to said that they would lean that way
based on what they heard in this election. So yes, they want to see some progress from the Democrats.
But those feelings that they're having right now, because of the messages that the Democrats were
putting forth in this election, if they're still there, if they're still in place,
voters are going to be open to that and want to hear more from some of the candidates that
they're going to hear from. I mean, in fact, when we asked them that question about, you know,
could,
could you design kind of a candidate that would be ideal for 2028? You know, we expected to hear
kind of, you know, a lot of some of the names that are out there and some of the qualities
that we always hear. A lot of these voters were saying, you know what, someone like James
Tallarico, someone like Rob Sand. They were actually saying the people that they just voted
for, understanding that's not realistic, but that's the kind of thing that they, they, they want.
The other thing that, that we hear is they really want the Republicans to change their ways.
At this point,
uh,
the idea that Republicans are lockstep with the president and you don't see any Republican ever
speaking negatively about the president or challenging him in any way or saying, Mr.
President, on this issue, I differ. The mindset now, at least according to the voters that we
listened to, was that the Republicans are lockstep, no space between their own politics
and the president's politics. And it seems to us that if that is the way it's going to be all the
way through the campaign of 2028, they're going to lean for it.
They're going to lean for a Democrat who's going to be, uh, independent and offer their own ideas and not just the ideas of the president.
Can you talk about, um, some of the thoughts they offered on the current crop of potential Republican candidates for president?
Potential Republican candidates?
Uh, we didn't hear a lot of enthusiasm for J.D. Vance.
Um, I don't recall a lot of enthusiasm for Marco Rubio.
Most of them said they'd like to get somebody that seemed not to be tied to the president's administration.
Yeah, I mean, David nailed it.
It's like they are. There were some people, and again, there's people in these groups who have said that they voted
Republican almost every election, you know, leading up to this. And they're saying unless
somebody could emerge that is not tied to Trump or is showing that they're opposed to that, then
I don't see hope for 2028.
So it's a real good question as to what happens with the Republicans, especially those that may
want to run for president between now and when they start to launch their campaigns. Because if
they don't show any degree of
independence at all from the president, I think they're going to have a hard time at 2028.
Yeah, and it's interesting because, I mean, these might not be the types of voters who
participate in a Republican primary. And so if you were sitting there with a couple of Republican
primary voter groups, they might, you know, be more willing to go with a J.D. Vance or Marco
Rubio or someone tied to the administration. But it does seem like there is clearly a lane
for a viable general election candidate on the Republican side for someone
who, I mean, everyone's like, oh, it's going to be more extreme than Trump. But it seems like there
could be a lane for a Republican who is a little more reasonable. But I don't know how that
Republican gets through the primary.
Well, even candidates like Ron DeSantis, you know, people that are outside of the administration
that are, you know, governors that have done work inside the states, you know,
they might be a little bit better positioned because they have a track record they can point
to for how they've governed their state. But even someone like him would have to indicate where he,
differs from the president, at least on one issue.
Yeah. Now, did they mention any of the potential Democratic candidates who've been mentioned?
Yeah.
And what did they say about them?
Well, Will's right to mention that they, you know, they have the, you know,
kind of the recency effect. I'm going to talk about Tallarico and Sand and people like that.
They're not totally clued in yet. So nobody's really out there. And there's no real front
runner there. There's some that had heard of John Ossoff, and he obviously was,
you know, in the news with his own victory and winning reelection in Georgia. So he's,
there's some that are talking about him and, and AOC is still someone who is out there. Although
with this set of voters that voted for Trump in the past, they're not kind of saying that she's
what they're looking for in the future right now. But obviously she has some name recognition and
has that same kind of like young, new, fresh energy that they are looking for.
Overall, I mean, there are other names that were definitely mentioned.
Um, uh, Pete Buttigieg, as I mentioned before, Gavin Newsom, um, were names that were mentioned,
but just overall, there is not just an optimism coming out of this election,
but also an optimism looking at the class as a whole of the people who are likely running in
2028. Just the idea of, you know, I don't know a lot about these candidates right now.
I don't know if they are going to put me ahead of their party necessarily, but they all do
fit some other categories, which is they are young. They do seem like they have energy behind
them. They do seem like, you know, and they were picking out individual one saying that, you know,
okay, this is a Democrat who did well in a red state, or this is a Democrat who led a blue state
successfully. So there are things that they could point to that check the boxes that they were
looking for in this election. Um, but they, as David said, they, they still need to be
introduced to them. Yeah. I mean, these voters are still at the space where I'm not really
thinking about 2028 yet. You know, I'm kind of relieved that all these commercials are over
and my mailboxes are going to be inundated with these awful mailers that I hate. Uh, so, you know,
they, what we learned through these sets of focus groups is that regardless of individual names,
what they're looking for in 2020 is a candidate who says, I'm going to put you first. I'm going
to listen to you over my party leaders. And, um, you know, I really want you to focus on,
you know, on making our lives a little easier because right now they're freaking tough.
It seems like if I was a potential 28 Democratic candidate, I'd look to some of these campaigns in
Texas and Iowa and elsewhere and, uh, and, and try to learn something from the messages.
Yeah. I'll tell you one thing. I'm sorry to interrupt, but the, um, this wasn't,
I'm not sure if this was mentioned in our, in one of our focus. I think it was actually,
and I get, we do a lot. So they sometimes get merged together in my mind, but the idea, you know,
this, uh, clip of Scott Cologne going to a Trump rally and walking down the line of, uh, Trump people
that were there to see president Trump and just ask them what's on your mind, what issues are
most important to you that really stood out to people in the sense that he's listening to people
that are going to vote for the other, other side. Wow. That's new. That's different. I mean, oh my
God, he actually cares what the other side thinks. And, you know, so that's the sort of thing that I
think that they're looking for.
next time. There's also not necessarily, it doesn't necessarily have to be an ideological
valence to that because it reminded me of how Zoran Mamdani started his campaign for mayor,
which is going into the Bronx and interviewing Trump voters in the Bronx. And so this idea that
you can just reach out and talk to Americans regardless of their political party, who they
voted for, about what they want to see in politics, it seems like common sense and simple, but feels
like, you know, we've moved away from that quite a bit in the Trump era. Well, he asked questions
and he listened to the answers. The word listens comes up all the time in our focus groups. I want
a candidate who listens to us. And, you know, when Colon goes down that, he asked him questions and
he listened to their answers. He said, oh yeah, I'm against data centers too. How about that? We
have common ground. You know, so that's the sort of thing that I think voters are looking for.
David, Will, thank you so much for doing these groups and for stopping by to talk about them.
Pleasure to be here. Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Before we come back, my conversation with David Plouffe.
Plouffe, welcome back.
Jon Favreau, it's always good to see you, particularly after an election like we just
had a couple of weeks ago. It's been a while.
It's been a while. I said this to Binder too. I was like, when's the last time we were able to
feel this good? It really, I feel like it's 2008 because 2020, we were all stuck inside and then
there was an insurrection. So.
Right. And it wasn't a blowout. So it's been like a long ass time.
So I want to talk to you about that.
I want to dive into these focus groups, but I did first want to get your thoughts on the midterms
since you and I haven't had a chance to talk yet. Aside from the sheer size of the win.
Have the results changed your thinking in any way about where the country is, what's possible, what's next for Democrats, what should be next for Democrats?
Well, John, I think we have a pretty big opening here.
You know, whether we seize it or not, I think is the question, because I don't think the Republicans, at least over the next two years, can change who they are.
And I think there's a large majority of the country, including in some states we're surprised by, who are open to voting for Democrats.
So I think we need to really, really study the people who underperformed and overperformed in both parties to learn if there's something there about the recipe going forward.
But it was definitely mostly a protest vote against Republicans.
But I think there's a lot of Democrats out there who provided people what they're looking for from a character standpoint, from a focus on people's problems standpoint, new, fresh leadership.
I think there's a lot there.
So, yeah, I mean, I think this was the largest margin since 74.
And I think the question is, is this going to be a four year?
Period like 06 and 08 or 74, 76, even though the presidential was close to 76, the generic was huge.
And I think that's how we should approach it, which is let's have an expansive view of who can win, where we can play and how we how we run campaigns in this modern era.
I just talked to Binder and Will about their focus groups with Trump voters in Dallas and Des Moines who just voted Democrat in the midterms.
Before we get into the specifics, what was your biggest takeaway from watching those groups?
Well, John, you and I, when we talk, are probably not the most optimistic couple.
And I will confess being pretty enthused about what I heard.
I thought what we and, you know, you just talked to Binder and Will, you showed some clips.
I mean, these are tough voters.
The fact that any of these folks in any of these rooms voted for us once was hard to believe.
The fact that a lot of them are saying they're open to doing it again because they see Trump and the Republican Party as a cult because they're not focused on their problems because they saw something they liked from some of the Democratic candidates to me was an optimistic read.
Now, all that means is we have maybe a bigger opportunity than I would have thought to retain some of these voters and grow.
But we have that.
And I think the party needs to understand that these moments don't come around very often.
And so when you have this kind of atmosphere where maybe you could have two really good election cycles in a row, you've got to maximize that.
Back in August, when we talked on the show, you told me that Trump was doing most of the work for Democrats.
But a candidate like James Tallarico could go find an extra point or two.
Turned out he found a few extra.
Gina Hinojosa as well.
After watching those Dallas voters, what part of Tallarico's win, Hinojosa's win, do you think another Democrat could repeat without maybe the good fortune of running against a Ken Paxton or even Greg Abbott or, you know, in an environment where Trump is unpopular?
Like, what was it about those candidates that you think really appealed to voters in a way?
That other candidates might be able to replicate?
Well, first of all, it's really interesting to listen in Texas to the conversation on Tallarico.
You know, the Tallarico attack that Trump and others would lodge.
By the way, like two years ago, some of the people in this room might have worn T-shirts.
They're just done with it.
Like the character part of this, we've been waiting for 10 years for this to be the case.
And I don't want to overstate it because he's still got 85% hard support in his party.
But there are Republicans now who voted for him.
Many of these people had voted for him all three times.
Who are kind of done with the character.
And so the Tallarico attack actually hardened their support for Tallarico.
The fact that Tallarico went everywhere, was willing to have tough conversations in tough places, seemed very focused on bringing the country together.
So I think there's a recipe there.
I think Gina Hinojosa focused very much on education and local issues and really tapped into.
It's a reminder that the politics can be seen as a circus and who's got the like cleverest, like nastiest ad.
But voters really.
Really are going to vote largely in their own interest and particularly for a governor's race.
People know that the governor matters to them.
And I think the other thing that's, you know, Abbott was trying to, you know, win a fourth term.
So I think there's a reminder there for Democrats that voters want new and they want different and they don't want people who overstay their welcome.
Yeah.
No, that came through loud and clear.
On Iowa, would you maybe put Iowa back on the map for 2028?
Or do you think once we get a presidential?
Electorate, a state like that is going to be tougher.
I imagine that you would put Texas on the map in 2028.
Well, John, you know, you and I have been through this electoral college puzzle before together.
And I would say a couple of things.
One, we don't know who the nominees are yet of either party.
We don't know what third parties will be looking like.
We don't know what the economy is going to be like, et cetera, et cetera.
That being said, yes, I think you would start with a much more expansive view than we've had really since 2012 or maybe even 08.
Now, you have to get.
You're 270th electoral vote.
So you don't want to miss that trying to get your 360th.
Right.
So I think the core will still be the blue wall states.
But but I do think Texas, I think Iowa, I think Ohio, Texas, by the way, Florida is really hard.
But, you know, if you look at some of the movement in Florida and we were very under resourced there, it gets interesting.
So, listen, I think for us as a party and listen, I get how expensive these states are.
But these campaigns.
The campaigns are a wash in money.
The super pet.
There's plenty of money to fund battleground states, even if we take a very expansive view of it.
So I think you'd start by saying, yeah, let's start with a really, really wide map.
A lot of smart work will have to happen in 27 and 28 on top of the great work that's already happened.
I would say the other thing about these states, you know, North Carolina looks more doable than it did two weeks ago.
I think Georgia does.
I think Nevada, which I think was trending away from us, looks like maybe it's snapped back.
So really, really encouraging signs.
From an Electoral College and from a Senate standpoint, I noticed that in these groups, they I mean, they voted for all four of these candidates, but there was more discussion in Texas about Talarico.
People had sort of seen him first, been exposed to him first.
And in Iowa, it was more Rob Sand.
Yeah. What do you what do you think that that Rob and James did that, like, really helped them stand out even nationally, you know, outside their states?
Well, listen, I was a smaller state than Texas.
But so many of these voters in the groups and again, these are hardcore Republican voters.
They had met Rob Sand or a family member had met Rob Sand.
They, you know, don't go to Democratic dinners.
Talarico, you know, less about in person, but they saw him on Fox, on conservative podcasts, you know, with conservative influencers.
So I think that there's a message there.
Work really hard.
Be everywhere you can, whether that be content or in person.
And the blend of that is the most powerful thing.
But I also think both of those people, Sand and Talarico, were the same person day in and day out, whether they're having a good day, a bad day, whether the winds are blowing in our direction or against it.
They just and I think that kind of steadiness matters to people.
And I also like I know sometimes we get criticized, those of us from the Obama era of being naive and too idealistic.
I still believe there is a majority in this country that wants good, decent human beings in power.
And I think that was ratified.
In part in 26.
I hope it is again in 28.
Well, I think there's a good argument that that more so now than at any time since our boss first won.
Yes.
Like and, you know, Axelrod always talks about people want the remedy, not the replica in the next presidential candidate.
And you can see sort of just in hearing from some of these voters, especially in Texas, just hearing how sick they were of the vitriol.
And I know everyone says, like, we don't like negative ads.
And then, you know, negative.
That's work on people.
But there was something about this slew of negative ads and the negativity from Trump in this and the Republicans in this campaign that didn't.
It's not like it offended people as much as it was just like, what are you doing this?
This is like repetitive and I don't believe it anymore.
And it's recycled.
And like, aren't you going to do anything about my problems?
Right.
And my life is not going well.
And you're, you know, engaged in this kind of politics.
I mean, Tallarico might have, you know, endured one of the most negative and expensive campaigns in America.
In American history, and one in a dominating fashion, it wasn't just Trump and his opponent in the NRC, you had Elon Musk, I mean, you know, he had hundreds of millions of dollars rained on his head, and he was able to not just withstand that, but I think he was strengthened by it and, you know, in an interesting way that, you know, really resonated with these voters, who clearly saw something in him that they think is missing in politics today.
All the women in the Dallas group called themselves moderates.
They were all.
They were also all pretty pissed off about the abortion bans, school vouchers, Ten Commandments going up in the public school classrooms.
How do you think these voters, like, define moderate?
Like, what does moderate mean to these voters?
Well, probably not the way that we traditionally understand it.
I mean, these are people who are hardcore Republicans, vote, some of them never voted for Democrat in their life, all had voted for Trump multiple times.
But it tells you that, you know, in 24, you know, those voters stuck with Trump, even though they had those concerns.
Because they thought he was going to be better on the economy.
Again, voters kind of excused Trump the COVID year, kind of remarkably, and it was really those first three years.
So, I think that moderate, I think it's just commonsensical.
People are tired of being told that they have to agree with one party or one person on everything.
So, these voters obviously showed that they might have different views on some issues than a lot of MAGA voters.
But I think there was a view that Trump was going to be better on the economy.
And Democrats weren't as focused on, you know, day-to-day economic needs of working people.
So, when those two things change.
when they see Democrats who seem like they're going to run through the wall to help them.
And Trump not only is not delivering, he's doing things he promised he wouldn't do the Iran war.
Obviously, he doesn't seem like he cares about economic prices. He says it's a price that people
have to pay. You know, and I think that was a big part of this campaign is that really,
really hurt the Republicans. Trump out there saying, you know, the economy is great. It's
never been better. Anybody who says the economy is bad is basically woke and is lying. And people
are their own judge of their economic situation. And so I think that's going to be interesting,
John, looking forward to 27 and 28, the Republicans who run, you know, I think for
them to have any chance of winning a general election, they're going to have to find some
distance from Trump on the economy. But that's going to really, really be hard to do in their
primary. If you're a Democrat in Congress watching these focus groups, what do they tell you about
how to handle the next two years with a big majority, but also
Trump still in the White House? Well, John, I think this is so key because we obviously have
what, 75 percent of the country now living in states with Democratic governors. Some of those
are trifectas. So in those places, we'll actually be able to deliver things that will help lower
costs and improve people's lives. Then we still have to communicate. In Congress, this is a DEFCON
one situation. I think that floor speeches and press conferences outside the Capitol will reach
no voter we care about ever. So to me,
it's good what I've heard. I'm sure you've heard the same thing. They're going to have smaller bills.
They're going to vote on them all the time. They're going to. But like, what's the advertising
behind that? What's the content play behind that? And I think we're going to have to be as focused on
message delivery in this next, let's say, 15 or 16 months till we have a nominee as we were in the
last two months. That's kind of the way I think about it, which is if we somehow don't keep up
the intensity of the messaging. And I get that that's expensive. But again, we have to spend more
the last 60 days in an election because we want voters, these voters and these focus groups need
to be able to say, hey, I voted for Democrats and they passed something on energy. They passed
something on health care. They've passed the anti-corruption bill 12 times. You know, they're
trying to get rid of the tariffs. But if that is left to Capitol Hill communication, these voters
are going to get very discouraged very fast. So we have to be in their feeds. We have to be on
local TV. We have to be actually running ads, boosting content so that we're telling a story,
which is, hey, listen, if we have an opportunity to work with Trump on something, we should take
it. But if we most of the case, I think we won't. So they have to get the sense we passed something.
Here's why we did it. Here's who would be helped for it. But it's not going to pass because Trump
and the Republicans oppose it. So I think the intensity of communications, if I'm a Democrat
watching these groups, A, I'm encouraged because it looks like we have a bigger opportunity than
we realized. But B, I'm kind of frightened because it's very fragile. And, you know,
if we don't if we don't.
And I think particularly as it relates to Washington Democrats,
I hope they're able to actually get some things done. But a lot of it's going to be trying to
get things done. And voters have to know that we're focused, you know, zealously, you know,
zealously on the things we campaigned on. There could be no distance between the ads and the
messaging that these candidates just ran and how we conduct ourselves in Washington. And, you know,
John, that's I'm worried about that because historically there gets to be a pretty big
delta between those two. Yeah, my big fear for the next two years,
is the expectations from voters. Right. And so there's basically three options the Democrats have
over the next because, you know, you were talking about messaging and communications,
which is obviously key. But this is like a strategy question, too. They can pass bills
that Trump vetoes. They can use their majorities in funding fights to shut down the government to
try to actually force changes. And they could try to work with Trump.
And then they can do investigations. And it feels like, OK, a shutdown investigation,
that feels like a real deliverable, maybe maybe working with Trump if he actually agrees.
But they don't actually, you know, the shutdown and the investigations. I don't know if that
actually leads to a deliverable beyond we just did it and and can also be counterproductive at
times. Like, how are you how are you thinking about that?
Well, a shutdown that ends in a positive outcome where you look strong and principled,
you know, potentially, I think could be valuable. And listen, there is all sorts of corruption that
should be investigated. If we don't do that, we kind of don't have a country. But we have to
understand that things like investigations, even things like the popular vote, which I'm very much
in favor of, those are going to drive coverage. Us passing a bill that Trump's not going to cover
doesn't get covered. So as we think about this, it's going to be really hard for us to do that.
We're going to have to figure out what we're going to do. And we're going to have to figure out
what we're going to do. And we're
So as we think about this, it's going to be really hard and difficult. You have to overwork then and
overspend in this period to communicate on the things you're trying to do to lower cost and
increase wages because they're not going to get naturally covered. The other things have the
chance to define who we are. And that's not what voters just voted for.
How much do you think what happens in Congress over the next two years matters
to the 28 primary and like what's happening on the trail?
Well, I guess my sense is the higher the water
mark can be for our nominee as it relates to our Democrats. So I saw some polling recently that,
you know, we had a 12 point advantage over the Republicans on who's focused on the problems
most important to you. And I think back in 24, we were down six or eight points. So for me,
that's just one measure, which is if our nominee can start the general election, maybe it's not 12
points, but it's six, eight, 10. We have an advantage over the Republicans on that. That's
incredibly important. Now, the governors have a role to play there, but I think our Democrats in
Congress have a role to play there. And so I think it's really important to look at it as how do you
provide as high a watermark as possible and as low a watermark as possible for the Republican.
So, you know, I think that and the other reason that this communication is important, like we are
trying to lower energy costs and health care costs and stop the war is one of the arguments that we
made in the presidential campaign is you don't want to give the Democrats a trifecta. But the more
people realize that the stuff that would improve their lives is blocked by Republicans, people will
be more open to that. You and I went to the House of Representatives yesterday and the House of
Representatives next week. And I went through this in 08. That was one of the arguments that was
made against Obama after the big 06 win for the Democrats. So that's really important. So again,
I think if we enter the, let's say, next spring of 28 and people don't view either party as an
advantage on looking out for you, fighting to lower costs, we would have blown like a 10 or 12
point lead. And that to me would be suboptimal. So that's the way I look at it, which is let's
hand the baton over to our nominee.
With us in as strong a shape as possible.
When you listen to those groups, which potential 28ers come to mind as candidates who
seem like they'd appeal to those voters?
I knew you'd do this. Well, listen, first of all, it's not a dodge to say we don't know
because we don't know how people will perform out there. But I do think generally people are
going to be looking for younger voices, voices out of Washington, new voices. I do think even
Democrats will be looking for people who will challenge the entire status quo, including whether
the Democratic Party's falling short. We know these voters will. So, you know, and I think
somebody who just comes across as a sane human being who seems to understand the struggles of
everyday people. But the short answer is, you know, it may be that someone who's, you know,
run before or someone who spent all their life in Washington ends up having that magical moment at
the right time and they're a nominee. But I think all things being equal, voters are going to be
looking for somebody sort of new and different. And I think in many
respects, this is as important on the Republican side. What's clear in listening to these groups
is they're not anxious to put J.D. Vance bumper stickers on their trucks, OK?
Marco Rubio either. Yeah. So, you know, that's the question. If there is somebody who is seen
as a direct descendant of Donald Trump, a core believer in the MAGA movement and somebody who
is involved in it, that gives our side, I think, a bigger advantage, particularly if we have
somebody who looks like they're going to challenge the status quo, who looks,
and is saying things. And John, I think one question is, I think voters are willing and
they're ready to have bigger discussions. What does AI mean for our future? What does an aging
population mean? What does mechanized warfare means? You know, how do we actually not just
fiddle around the edges on health care, but fundamentally change it? Like, I think the
Democratic message, of course, we should raise taxes on the wealthy and we should invest more
in health care. We should support unions. All those things are critically important.
But my question is, is there a bigger message there? Because as you see with voters,
they're really scared for their future, for their kids' futures, for the grandkids' future.
And so I think strength is also going to be important here, particularly in a presidential
race. It always is. But I think particularly now, because people are feeling really, really uneasy.
So it's a bunch of different attributes. But I do think that people are not looking for more
of the same. So I think there's a huge opportunity, quite frankly, in both parties
for somebody who kind of fits that bill. Last time you and I talked, I think we both agreed
that skill and communication and your talent as a candidate and your ability to sort of tell this
kind of story that you're talking about is maybe the most important attribute. I think because
the election was such a big victory, it's kind of choose your own adventure for everyone. And like,
it's confirmed everyone's prior. So like, I would like to say that, you know, all the candidates who
were great at getting attention and communicated really well were the ones who won. But like,
there's plenty of candidates who just kind of flew under the radar. And I think that's a big victory.
Like, I'm thinking about a Roy Cooper, right, who just trounced his opponent. And we barely
heard from Roy Cooper the entire campaign, which is probably how they wanted it.
But like, how do you think, has it changed your view at all about sort of the need for
someone who is just a really talented communicator?
No, not at all.
Well, listen, this, you and I have been through elections.
I mean, 06, I was very involved in the House effort.
And, you know, there were people who won election night that, you know, you had to go find their
phone number for.
So let's be honest that when the winds are this strong, whether you ran a great campaign
or not, you're going to, a lot of people are going to get swept over the finish line.
So, but this, so this was not a neutral environment.
It was the best political environment since 1974, I think in a more neutral environment.
And I think we should expect that a presidential year will be more neutral, even if there's
some advantages for us.
Yeah, the ability to communicate, to inspire, to engender trust, to handle tough questions,
to go anywhere and everywhere to deliver your message, I still think is the coin of the
realm.
So I think that that is, and I think that'll be one of the things that decides our primary
is.
People will be looking, yes, at positions, yes, at biography, yes, about a clever debate
answer or not, but like who can build that kind of relationship with the American people
to both win a presidential election and lead them.
So I still think it's incredibly important.
You know, the old adage is true.
You're never as smart as you look when you win, as you're never dumb as you are when
you lose, right?
But listen, if you look at, you know, we had, whether it's Sand or, you know, Tallarico,
obviously John Ossoff.
Mary Patola, um, you know, I think that, um, we had candidates all across.
I'm, I'm, I'm not, this is not a sin of commission.
I just stopped naming.
We had people who in a neutral environment would have been tremendous candidates.
And, um, and I think by the way, in these focus groups, you saw that people would lift
up things that a Tallarico or a Sand said where they saw them that stuck with them.
And by the way, it's important to understand none, nobody talked about ads really.
It was, I saw this.
I saw them here.
They said this, and that made me feel better about supporting them.
And I think that's important, which is ads have their place, but particularly in a presidential
candidate, it's going to rent campaign.
It's going to be the performance of the candidate.
Um, that I think is what matters most to people.
The last thought I had when I was watching these is it seemed to me that, you know, we
always forget that the, the, the 28 primary, it's just a different environment.
It's a different set of voters and candidates are going to be hearing from that universe
of voters.
And it felt to me like these voters who voted Democrat, just could not be more different
than probably what the candidates would hear from focus groups of democratic primary voters.
Um, and I wonder how you think about that challenge for the campaigns going forward.
Well, John, what's interesting is, yeah, I think it would be fundamentally different
for maybe 25 to 35% of democratic primary voters, but I think the majority of them still
would say many of the same things.
You know, I'm tired of the status quo.
I want new blood.
I, people aren't focused on my, uh, costs, you know, politics is too ugly.
Um, you know, healthcare systems a mess.
We're not funding our schools like now plenty of democratic primary voters will say those
things.
But I think there's more of the people voting the democratic primary voters who will be
somewhat in league with these hardcore Republicans in these focus groups.
Hmm.
That's always important to remember, like to win a democratic primary, um, you know,
there are a lot of moderate democratic primary voters.
Um, you know, there are in South Carolina, there certainly are going to be in parts of
Virginia in terms of the early States, the upper peninsula of Michigan, but you're going
to see that particularly as you, New Mexico, as you go into super Tuesday States.
So I think that, listen, a presidential campaign in the primary, um, is going to be very focused
on getting the finals.
Yeah.
Because they don't have the luxury of thinking through the prism of a general election.
But I, I really think the route to the nomination and the route to winning 270 plus electoral
votes is not as dissimilar as we think in terms of the desire of a lot of these voters.
David Plouffe, thank you as always for joining.
And uh, I look forward to talking to you again.
Once the field is a little more set, we can actually dig into these campaigns.
Once we have 20 or 25 people, we'll go through the, uh, the process of analyzing each of
them.
John.
Yeah.
One episode.
Yeah.
All right, buddy.
Take care.
Yeah.
Bye.
That's it for me today.
Love it.
Tommy and I will be back with a new show on Tuesday.
Pod Save America is a Crooked Media production.
Our show is produced by Austin Fisher, Saul Rubin, McKenna Roberts, and Michael Goldsmith
with Ree Cherland, Elijah Cohn, and Adrian Hill.
Our team includes Matt DeGroat, Ben Hefcote, Jordan Cantor, Charlotte Landis, Kenny Moffitt,
Adam Lippert, Joseph Dutra, Desmond Taylor, Dan Farrow, David Tolles, Mia Kelman, Ryan
Young, and Naomi Singel.
Our staff is proudly unionized with the Writers Guild of America East.
Hey, everyone.
My name is Elijah Cohn, and I've been a producer here at Crooked Media for a decade.
I love making our shows with the smart, creative people who work here and hearing from all
of you who listen every week, but the thing that I'm proudest of is that video we made
of Vivek Ramaswamy grunting while hitting baseballs.
No, wait.
Sorry.
The thing I'm proudest of is the work we do through Vote Save America.
See, we don't want our shows to only leave you feeling anxious about the state of the
world.
We want to give you something you can actually do.
And that's what we're going to do.
We're going to do something you can actually do about it.
And just this year, our listeners raised millions of dollars and filled thousands of volunteer
shifts to help candidates and causes win up and down the ballot in the 2026 midterms.
And we have no plans to slow down as we head into 2028.
As far as I know, there's no other media company that does what Crooked does.
We make entertaining, thoughtful content that brings people into politics, and then we give
them a direct way to get involved.
And if you believe in that mission, one of the best ways to support us is by becoming
a paid subscriber.
Your subscription helps us keep making the shows you love and building a media company
that doesn't just talk about politics, but helps people change them.
And if the mission sounds great, but you feel like you need some sweet subscriber benefits
to get you over the finish line, we've got you covered.
Subscribers get ad-free shows, plus excellent exclusive podcasts, newsletters, and much,
much more.
So, thank you for listening and supporting what we do.
Head to crooked.com/friendstoday to learn more and become a subscriber.
T'was the night before Toyotathon and all through the land.
Not a creature was saved.
Tundra was stirring.
Not even Jan.
That's me.
Winter plans were made.
Skiing, skating, hiking, and more.
And they came to fruition with Tundras, Camrys, BZs, and RAV4s.
In bed dreaming of the places they'd gone, everyone knew Toyotathon is on.
Dealer inventory may vary.
Current offers on these vehicles end November 30th.
Offers are subject to change throughout Toyotathon, which ends on January 4th.
See your participating Toyota dealer for details.
Toyota.
Let's go places.
This is Martha Stewart.
Have you ever started a new tradition?
Here's a hint.
Do it with Lenox.
Lenox has always meant timeless holiday beauty, and the Lenox Space Village is the perfect
holiday gift.
Imagine ginger from a Georgian townhouse or pepper from your favorite Swiss chalet.
Lenox has brought timeless beauty and quality to tables and homes for generations.
Baking together, sharing recipes, decorating, suddenly simple pleasures become part of your
holiday story forever.
When you give a gift that lasts beyond the holidays, it's an amazing feeling.
When you give Lenox, you just might start a new tradition.
Discover the full collection at Lenox.com/SpiceVillage.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Former Trump voters in Texas and Iowa shifted their support to Democratic candidates due to fatigue with Trump’s negative messaging and perceived lack of accountability.
Voters cited economic hardship, war-related costs, and a toxic political atmosphere as key reasons for their change in loyalty.
Democratic candidates like James Tallarico and Rob Sand stood out by emphasizing authenticity, listening to constituents, and rejecting partisan loyalty.
Visibility, community presence, and genuine engagement—especially through local outreach—built trust and made candidates seem more relatable and trustworthy.
Voters expressed strong desire for Democrats to pass tangible, affordable legislation on healthcare, education, and housing without engaging in political attacks or investigations.
The Republican Party’s lockstep alignment with Trump and absence of internal dissent created deep distrust and made voters wary of future Republican candidates.
Voters viewed the 2024 election as a protest against political extremism, and many believe a 2028 Democratic candidate must embody independence from the president.
Success in 2028 will depend on Democrats demonstrating consistency between campaign promises and legislative action, and on distancing themselves from negative ad culture.
Summary:
The post-election focus groups reveal that many long-time Trump voters in Texas and Iowa switched their support to Democratic candidates due to disillusionment with Trump’s negative messaging, economic policies, and the toxic tone of politics. Voters expressed frustration over the war in Iran, rising costs of living, and a political environment marked by vitriol and division. Democratic candidates like James Tallarico and Rob Sand gained traction not through aggressive messaging, but through authenticity, local presence, and a clear commitment to listening to constituents.
Their appeal stemmed from a sense of individuality and independence from party ideology, contrasting sharply with the perceived loyalty to Trump. Voters emphasized that they wanted tangible, practical changes—such as lower healthcare and housing costs—over political grandstanding or investigations. They also viewed Republican candidates as uniformly aligned with Trump, making any future GOP nominee face significant hurdles in breaking that mold.
For Democrats, the takeaway is clear: success in 2028 hinges on delivering on campaign promises through simple, measurable legislation and maintaining a message of accountability and compassion. The focus groups signal a shift in voter expectations—demanding not just policy changes, but a fundamental reimagining of political trust and tone. With a majority of voters now open to supporting Democrats, the party must act quickly to translate this momentum into consistent, visible, and credible action in Congress.
FAQs
Former Trump voters shifted support because they felt the Republican Party had abandoned them, especially due to negative messaging, economic struggles, and a perceived lack of care for everyday issues like cost of living and family well-being.
Voters appreciated that these candidates appeared sincere, authentic, and focused on listening to them personally rather than prioritizing party lines or political establishment interests.
The negative, repetitive, and emotionally charged attacks—especially those targeting identity and values—backfired, making voters feel alienated and reinforcing their desire for change and a more respectful political tone.
Yes, voters perceived a significant difference, noting that Democrats were transparent, focused on real-life issues, and genuinely tried to represent voters' needs, unlike Trump, who was seen as disconnected and divisive.
Voters emphasized affordability, healthcare, education, housing, and economic relief, especially in response to rising prices and inflation, as key priorities for future Democratic action.
Candidates who were visibly present in communities—like Rob Sand in Iowa—built trust through local engagement, making them more relatable and credible, which significantly influenced voter support.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.