Go back

Trump’s Administration Is Lying Its Way Out of an FAA Mess

10m 33s

Trump’s Administration Is Lying Its Way Out of an FAA Mess

The Trump administration blamed Congress for the air traffic control system shutdown, alleging insufficient funding, despite having full control of both the executive branch and Congress. Officials, including Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, claimed the system’s flaws were due to past underinvestment, citing a $12.5 billion bipartisan bill passed in 2023. However, internal FAA reports reveal the system’s communication flaws—specifically the outdated FTI system—had been flagged for over two decades, including during Trump’s presidency. The administration's own plans to modernize the system, such as replacing copper wires with fiber, were announced months before the crisis, yet progress stalled. FAA Administrator Brian Bedford confirmed the system’s long-standing instability, contradicting claims of new leadership or urgent action. Historical records show Trump never discussed air traffic modernization during his campaign or transition. The administration's repeated blame-shifting on Congress or past administrations reveals a pattern of deflecting responsibility, undermining claims of leadership or innovation. Critics argue that the failure stems from a lack of sustained investment and a flawed, patchwork implementation strategy, not external neglect. The episode highlights systemic governance issues and a persistent tendency to assign blame rather than address root causes.

Transcription

1644 Words, 9240 Characters

English
Hey, it's Will Salatan from the Bullwork, so you probably saw that on Friday, the government shut down air traffic because of a technical problem. And thousands of flights got canceled. It was a total mess. But thankfully, thankfully, the Trump administration snapped into action. They came out right away and they did what they always do. They blamed everybody else. So I'm going to show you all the blame they tried to spray around and why it's all BS. Okay. So on Friday, Sean Duffy, the Secretary of Transportation, did a press conference at the White House. And he said, please, please, let's not play politics with this very serious issue. By the way, play politics all you want on all kinds of issues. That's great. And there's a lot of issues to play politics on. This is not one of those issues. This is an American issue, an American bill with an American president that knows how to do it. An American president that knows how to do it. Now, let's not play politics except for the part where I stand here and I kiss my bosses, you know what? This whole press conference, the whole thing was about playing politics. Duffy, Duffy and Mark Wayne Mullin, the Secretary of Homeland Security, spent the whole time blaming Congress for not giving Trump our amazing brilliant president the money to fix the air traffic control system. President Trump is a builder. He's going to build this network and deliver for the American people, but the president can't deliver for America unless the Congress delivers the money to make it happen. But this is critical for the American economy, which is why the Congress, I'm going to say it a million times, the Congress has to give the resources to the president so we can finish this bill. Oh, poor, poor president Trump. It's not his fault. No, it's Congress's fault. Here's Mullin saying the same thing. The president has said this, Secretary Duffy has said this multiple times our air traffic control system is outdated and it hasn't been a priority from Congress. And so this is, this is what happens when Congress kicks the can down the road. Yes, they say Congress kicked the can down the road. These two guys, Duffy and Mullin, they're responsible for air traffic control. They're the ones, they're the ones who are kicking the can over to Congress. So at this briefing, a reporter pointed out that their party, the Republicans, the Republicans don't just control the administration and the FAA, they also control Congress. The President has been in office for almost two years now, so why hasn't this been a bigger priority for the president? Republicans control both chambers of Congress and still do. Good question. So here's how Duffy responded. Oftentimes, it's a great point. Oftentimes, you need a bipartisan vote, right? So I did get partial funding through one big beautiful bill. I got 12.5 billion and with that money, we are we are we are spending it and spending it well. But the Congress at the time knew that that was not going to be enough. By the way, this is bipartisan, but on that bill, I didn't have Democrats that voted for it. Wait a minute. First of all, he's complaining that Democrats didn't vote for it. Let's remember what happened here. The Republicans, the Republicans decided to put everything in one big bill, right? Everything cuts to health care and a bunch of other stuff that the Democrats could not support. So don't give us this crap that Democrats voted against money for air traffic control. You're the guys. You're the guys who wouldn't let the Democrats vote separately for that money. Secondly, Duffy says the administration knew that the money that Congress put in that bill for air traffic control was not enough money. Really, let's take a little trip down memory lane. The big beautiful bill passed the Republican House on May 22nd of last year. Eight days, eight days after that vote, Trump sat in the Oval Office with Elon Musk and he announced that he was working with Congress to build a brand new air traffic control system. So we're going to get a brand new modern system. Congress is working with us on that and we're going to get it done as quickly as we can. But it's in the works. And then a month later, just four days before the big beautiful bill passed the Senate, Trump announced that the bill was going to modernize the whole air traffic system. After many years of decline in our air traffic control system, the one big beautiful bill will modernize this decrepit relic and give America the best, most advanced air traffic control system on earth, the best by far. It contains a historic program to update antiquated communications and radar systems to deteriorating hardware and ancient software. This is really old stuff. It's ancient with the latest 21st century tools and equipment. We're going to have all new equipment, he said. So then a week later on July 4th, Trump signed the bill. And then three days after that, Trump held a cabinet meeting and at that meeting, Duffy said that the money in the bill would let the administration replace all the old copper wire in the air traffic control system with fiber. But in the big beautiful bill, we got $12.5 billion. This is a historic investment in air traffic control. And so what the money is going to allow us to do is move from copper to fiber all over the country. So new copper lines, we think we can do that in a year and a half to two years. A year and a half to two years, he said. Now that was July 8th of last year. So it's been almost a year and a half since then. But now Duffy's complaining that the old copper wires are still there, right? And he's blaming them for the shutdown at the airports. So something is not right with this story we're getting from Duffy. And at the press conference on Friday, Mullin, the DHS secretary, gave us a little clue what it might be. What it appears to be right now is as Secretary Duffy at F.A. was going in and putting patches into the system, they were putting new equipment and a new technology and that new equipment new technology just was it was overwhelming the older system, which is why Secretary Duffy made it very clear that the patchwork doesn't work. We need one complete system. Wait a minute, the patchwork system doesn't work, right? But that's what Duffy was doing. He was putting patches on the old system. Sounds like another case of the Trump administration blaming other people for doing what the Trump administration itself was doing. In fact, the more you watch these briefings where the Trumpers try to blame everybody else, the more the whole story starts to fall apart. So on Saturday, Duffy gave another briefing. And this time, Brian Bedford, the administrator of the FAA showed up. And here is what Bedford said about the FAA's communication system. Every, I think every agency within the government for better than two decades has flagged this FTI system as a critical weakness. So this is probably one of the worst kept secrets in government that this FTI system needs to be replaced. He's saying that the problem has been obvious for two decades, right? That's 20 years. Trump was president for four of those years, right? Trump's own guy at FAA is basically admitting that when Trump was president, the first time he didn't do squat. And it's not just Bedford, check out what Duffy said at the White House briefing. Now if you look to the past administrations, going back 25 years, $15 billion has been given to the FAA to fix this air traffic control system. And guess what, barely anything was done. See, this is the problem with blaming everybody else. These Trumpers want to blame the presidents of the past, right? But Trump was, Trump was one of those presidents. So every time these guys point the finger at the past, they're pointing it at their own boss, right? But Duffy says, oh, this time, this time Trump really means that he says before Trump even came into office, for his second term, Trump was already talking about fixing the air traffic control system. He's been frustrated from my first, before I actually was sworn in, he was talking about how old the system is, how past administrations had failed and how he wants to fix the air traffic control system in America and deliver the best in the world. And it takes a president's leadership, like President Trump, to make sure we can ask the Congress and get the money and give the deliverables. Yeah, no. I've gone back and looked at everything Trump said in speeches and rallies when he was running for President in 2024. And then during the transition, he never talked during that whole year about fixing the air traffic control system. So all this stuff about his leadership, it's just revisionist garbage. Look, I'm not going to dispute that Congress didn't spend enough money to fix the system. But that was a Republican Congress. And the president who told you that the money he got from his own party was enough to fix the system, he's a Republican too. It's the same story with these guys again and again, the Iran war, the tariffs, now the air traffic control system, they screw everything up and then they find somebody else to blame. It's the only thing they're good at. See you next time. [BLANK_AUDIO]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The Trump administration blamed Congress for failing to fund the air traffic control system, despite having full control of both the executive branch and Congress.
  2. Officials like Sean Duffy and Markwayne Mullin claimed the outdated system was a result of past Congresses not providing sufficient funding, ignoring that Republican-led legislation had already allocated $12.5 billion.
  3. The administration’s own plans, including a promised transition from copper to fiber-optic lines, were announced just months before the system failure, yet the system remains outdated.
  4. FAA Administrator Brian Bedford stated that the FTI communication system had been flagged as a critical weakness for over two decades, including during Trump’s presidency.
  5. The administration claimed Trump had long advocated for modernizing air traffic control, but historical records show no such focus during his 2016 campaign or transition period.
  6. The "patchwork" approach to upgrading the system, where new technologies are layered over old infrastructure, was acknowledged by officials as ineffective and unstable.
  7. Critics argue that the administration consistently deflects blame onto past governments or Congress, while ignoring its own role in delaying or mismanaging the modernization effort.
  8. The lack of accountability and repeated blame-shifting undermines credibility, suggesting a pattern of deflecting responsibility across policy areas.

Summary:

The Trump administration blamed Congress for the air traffic control system shutdown, alleging insufficient funding, despite having full control of both the executive branch and Congress. 5 billion bipartisan bill passed in 2023. However, internal FAA reports reveal the system’s communication flaws—specifically the outdated FTI system—had been flagged for over two decades, including during Trump’s presidency.

The administration's own plans to modernize the system, such as replacing copper wires with fiber, were announced months before the crisis, yet progress stalled. FAA Administrator Brian Bedford confirmed the system’s long-standing instability, contradicting claims of new leadership or urgent action. Historical records show Trump never discussed air traffic modernization during his campaign or transition.

The administration's repeated blame-shifting on Congress or past administrations reveals a pattern of deflecting responsibility, undermining claims of leadership or innovation. Critics argue that the failure stems from a lack of sustained investment and a flawed, patchwork implementation strategy, not external neglect. The episode highlights systemic governance issues and a persistent tendency to assign blame rather than address root causes.

FAQs

A technical problem with the aging air traffic control system caused the shutdown, leading to thousands of flight cancellations.

Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy and Secretary of Homeland Security Markwayne Mullin blamed Congress for not providing sufficient funding to fix the system.

Yes, the administration claimed it had long promoted modernization, but evidence shows no prior focus during the 2024 presidential campaign or transition period.

He stated that the FTI communication system has been flagged as a critical weakness for over two decades, indicating a known issue long before the recent shutdown.

The bill provided $12.5 billion for air traffic control modernization, which the administration claimed was sufficient to replace old copper wiring with fiber optic technology.

Duffy argues that the patchwork upgrades did not fully modernize the system, suggesting the old infrastructure still causes instability and failures.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.