Go back

Unknown

52m 57s

Unknown

The resignation of NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang sparks a major debate over U.S. technology policy, ethics, and strategic competition with China. While allegations suggest he enabled chip smuggling to China, critics argue that a complete ban on GPU access would backfire, triggering economic retaliation and disrupting global AI innovation. Instead, a measured "diffusion" strategy—allowing remote access with oversight and the ability to cut off access when needed—is seen as more effective for maintaining U.S. technological dominance without triggering a full-scale trade war. Proposals like the Match Act and RASA aim to close export loopholes by regulating cloud-based GPU access, particularly for Chinese firms, while acknowledging that China is already investing heavily in domestic AI infrastructure. The discussion also underscores the importance of supply chain resilience and the risks of overreach in export controls. Despite the controversy, the conversation highlights a broader tension: while U.S. policy seeks to limit China’s AI progress, the reality is that Chinese firms are rapidly building domestic capabilities. Moreover, the absence of Jensen Huang may slow NVIDIA’s innovation, as his direct involvement in supply chain decisions and technical strategy was central to its competitiveness. The episode reflects a moment of uncertainty in global AI leadership, where geopolitical tensions, ethical concerns, and the need for innovation must be balanced. Ultimately, the long-term health of the U.S. AI ecosystem depends not just on export controls, but on maintaining strategic flexibility, strong oversight, and sustained technical leadership.

Transcription

10078 Words, 53731 Characters

English
all right hey dylan hey jordan thanks for joining did you guys hear the uh ceo of the world's largest and most important company just resigned no you are you serious are you serious what could what could possibly had led to that i mean there's some allegations of some pretty serious conduct violations here he was uh apparently you can't sleep with your subordinates and uh keep your job yeah wait jordan i mean we've got elon we've got sergey everyone in once you get to a trillion dollars i think you're like legislated to start sleeping with your subordinates there must be something else i think the trillion dollar class might be fine but once you get to five trillion then you have problems with this sort of stuff then woke 2.0 really starts coming after you oh my god yeah we're rotating back you um so uh yeah this is truly a you know momentous day momentous moment for the future of uh america china and artificial intelligence where dylan somehow looks bored after all of this or just drained i don't know how are you processing it dude i mean i don't know like you you're like look up to some guy this guy and then like you know he does these things it's not fun you know yeah it's um look there's a lot of things going on and a lot of things to contemplate i think given we're trying to talk we shouldn't even talk about the future of nvidia we should just talk about the future of of open source and future of ai um and china u.s relations um i think like you know i'm i'm obviously i've obviously been a hawk or a fucking bald eagle as we said in a prior podcast um for quite some time and um but at the same time there's like i'm worried this is going to be used as cover to pass really stupid questions and i think it's going to be used as cover to pass really stupid questions um and you know obviously you know in gen nvidia without jensen is a much weaker company now whether you think nvidia's interests are that of the national interest of america is something that i think like most people say yes but i think some people in the audience would probably say no um i mean it's pretty clear nvidia's chips were ending up in china um knowingly or not it's probably just knowingly but yeah i mean i think i think like look jensen and nvidia were the biggest defenders against not shipping chips to china and now they are uh gone and out of play so what regulations pass you know i hope this means the match act passes right that is far more important for u.s national interest than the rasa rasa's pretty dumb bill hi everyone china talk editor lily here with some context remote access security act or rasa would amend the nvidia's chips to china's chips export control to clarify that remote access to u.s controlled chips counts as an export this makes cloud rental subject to the same rules as shipping the chip itself rasa passed the house 269 votes to 22 in january of this year but no senate vote has been held or scheduled a parallel senate version is stuck in the banking committee and no version of the current ndaa text includes rasa the senate version of rasa directly targets quote foreign persons of concern generally interpreted as china russia iran north korea and companies whose ultimate parent is headquartered in one of those countries as well as entity list firms as designed rasa would cover only single customer clusters that are big enough to provide frontier training this threshold is commerce's to set following consultation with chip makers ai labs and cloud providers rasa would not cover inference rentals smaller allocations api access smuggled chips or chips already in china perhaps most importantly rasa does not ban anything itself the text in the senate says quote may and the house text acts only if the secretary quote determines a serious risk there is no deadline nor minimum in place here likewise commerce can choose whether to wind down existing leases or run them to term these flexibilities should be viewed as a feature and not above the bill settles the legal authority adds material penalties and sets up the entire system to survive a change of administration rasa then gives commerce the tools to titrate access to rented chips as it deems appropriate i think like you know biden style diffusion controls should totally be done um but i think like again like if if the u.s government goes and passes rasa that's going to be a big issue um it's going to be really bad for american interest probably um in the long term and short medium term um so yeah i think i think this is the key key aspects of it right and the other undertoning is like you can't just ban everything because china can and will utilize the fact that their components are in every single nvidia server and every single google server and every single nvidia server and every single google server and every single server and every single amazon server etc etc etc you cannot get materials you know you cannot build these things without them so there is a level of tit for tat here um yeah i don't know i think i think that's that's my main take for this you can't add it you can't add it well this i think it's a crossover one right so we we should talk about the future of ai a little bit too but we open with match and rasa let's start with match match and rasa so match act for those who have not been tuning in to my match act shilling over the past few months is this idea that um uh basically do you uh advanced euv uh lithography alongside euv which already hasn't been able to get into china um shouldn't be able to go into allegedly shouldn't be able to go into china and rasa uh slightly different it is uh uh aiming to to close the quote cloud um cloud access loophole um by which uh you know alibaba 10 cent bite dance today currently can legally access um gpus which are banned from being exp from being imported into china by setting up these you know cutouts in malaysia which you guys have done such a great job of sort of untangling um jordan do you share uh uh dylan's skepticism about uh rasa and his potential fallout or maybe dylan why don't you why don't you expand on on why you think it's a such a bad thing i think you know the what is the u.s national interest is it is to a maintain a lead on ai as large as possible and b control china's access to ai as much as possible if your goal is to maintain a lead as large as possible for as long as possible and maintain control over china you do not prevent china from having any compute because that actually means that the u.s will have no compute too if you full cell ban anything in my world i believe that china will just also enacting economic war i don't know if you remember in 2022 i stayed up all night and i wrote um the october 7th chip restrictions regulation um and i said china and usa are officially an economic war um or i said uh it's a new cold war it's an economic war um and in there i found like 20 loopholes that i posted about that very night and i'm just one dude not an army of lawyers um and was hoping they'd get patched many did not get patched and still are not patched um but like one of the key aspects of this original restriction which i think is you know mostly true which is um there's the civil military fusion within china um the chinese military and state will and can apprehend any resource to for military and intelligence purposes even if it's a completely commercial thing right we've seen it with things like douyin and in and tiktok already and that's the most consumer you can get um so clearly they do utilize it um at the same time they will also be able to use it for their own purposes and so also enact and respond in certain ways we've seen this with the trade wars we've seen this with some of the stuff on the auto tariffs we've seen our auto um you know shutting almost shutting down american auto plants things like this um threatening rare earth minerals and things like that there's been a lot of actions that china has threatened or done some and then pulled back um to show their fangs um and so if you ban chips completely from china including rental and deployment there is no reason for china to not use it for their own purposes and so it's not just blow the whole thing up right you have to have some tit for tat now the optimum thing for american policy is what is the minimum amount of compute that china can have with the most amount of american oversight to where they will not blow up the supply chain because we we do not have the stomach to disentangle the supply chain very clearly we just don't over and over and over again and so given that you cannot have china have no chips period both internally and foreign that will blow up this blow this all up but to minimize the amount of compute and maximize the control you can have biden style diffusion laws where it's certain companies and yes it's basically a bill written for hyperscalers but hyperscalers can rent to chinese companies and companies with american sort of where america has like power over to be like hey turn it off at any moment you want all of their compute to be like that um and if you allow alibaba or oracle or bite dance or alibaba or bite dance or whoever it is moonshot to rent compute from american companies outside of china and that is their main access of compute this is supremely awesome because china will not want to send their data externally in many cases and if they do we're probably stuff that the u.s intelligence apparatus can can handle and two if shit goes tits up you can turn it a lot whereas if you turn off remote security access then there's either a lot of compute and if you turn off remote security access then there's a lot of compute even more incentive to a smuggle b um you know you know ramp your own domestic industry they're going to do that anyways by the way um, which is why you need the match act. Um, but C you, you, you sort of really prevent any, any like reason for them to continue the status quo, right. Which is a lot of Chinese industry is dedicated to making American compute, at least in the electronic space for American companies. Um, you know, the largest PCB supplier to Nvidia is a Chinese company, for example. Um, and it's not just in video, of course. Um, so I think, I think you have to come out, come in it with like a, like a game theory perspective. And the best thing for America to do is allow remote access of GPUs because the alternatives are much worse. Yeah. I mean, a few pushbacks on that. I think there is a piece of the Chinese ecosystem, you know, Xi Jinping likely included that is deeply embarrassed by the fact that, um, these companies really, really want to import the GPUs, right. Part of what we learned over the course of the Trump administration so far is even, even when Trump is offering them, the Chinese government is like, I'm not entirely sure we even want these companies to buy it. So yes, we have some equilibrium right now, but I definitely see a world in which, um, you know, chunks of the Chinese government see something like Rasa and say, all right, great. You know, these companies, they thought they could, you know, get cute and not really invest in the domestic ecosystem. And now they're going to really have to play ball. I think there are also other kind of things that are going on with Xi that would make, make him less likely to want to declare economic warfare on the U S by doing something as dramatic as, um, you know, shutting off all, uh, uh, global manufacturing of chip production, even if it, you know, ends up, we ended up figuring out how to do. Yeah. Well, we already shut them off. Why wouldn't they, why wouldn't they retaliate? Because, because then you get into a tit for tat and by the way, this economy isn't growing and unemployment's at 20%. I mean, it's like single time we've, we've gotten into that tit for tat. Um, there met led to a compromise and there was no, there was no, there was no, there was no tit for tat, right? Tariffs got reduced. Um, you know, there was, there was some restrictions that went up, but mostly China didn't just take it. They did retaliate and the U S economy and, and administration would not be willing to stomach the pain. Yeah. I mean, they didn't 2022, they didn't in, um, uh, 2022, the loophole, the rules had so many loopholes. Yeah. They didn't. Okay. They didn't in 2023, they didn't in 2024. Um, and then I think like, Trump like kept doing the war in Iran, even though he lost him 10 Senate seats. Like, I think there, I think there is a aspect of, um, pain, especially in a sort of second term lame duck when, um, you know, all, all the cabinet is leaking against Lutnick cause they're pissed and they've already, you know, there's an Axios report that said that like, China's already breaking the trade deal and they're already doing economic warfare against the U S I don't think that, you know, escalatory dominance is necessarily something that should be completely assumed on, on the part of, of the Chinese government. The other argument I would make is that in Rasa, um, if China has access to compute outside of China, they are now paying humongous margin dollars to the U S ecosystem, right? If you take a megawatt of compute outside of China, um, there's multiple layers of margin stacking. First of all, Nvidia is making, you know, um, you know, $7 million of profit per megawatt that gets deployed. In addition, the cloud provider is making a $7 to $10 million of profit. If it's selling at today's pricing, there is a tremendous amount of profit that we get to get, which companies like Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, um, you know, Amazon, Meta, et cetera, do either less, you know, they don't have the cloud or they're deploying their own chips that margins, the cost structure is so different. Why does China win? They have economies of scale and their cost structure is better. Why does American AI win? We have, our cost structure is better and our economies of scale is higher. And so, you know, allowing them to ship all this money out, right? If ByteDance wants to compete with Meta in the global market on video recommendation algorithms, Meta has a fourth of the cost of compute potentially. Um, if you don't let ByteDance directly buy the chips, but you do let them rent them. Yeah. Well, but I mean, here's the thing. This is like this kind of, you know, we want to do ByteDance and Meta like, uh, uh, Zuck was totally fine letting TikTok spend billions of dollars on Instagram ads. Right. Um, but if you just don't let them play the game, then you kind of win by default. And also Dylan, I mean, isn't there an enormous, um, sort of even, even in our, you know, shaky AI times over the past week, an enormous demand, like, like, do you really think it wouldn't be sort of better for the U S to be able to get ahead by having, um, you know, however many gigawatts are currently flowing, um, you know, through Malaysia into the Chinese ecosystem by just like helping open AI anthropic and deep mind make better models. Um, I think, and make more money. I think, I think that, um, there's also a reflexive nature of this, right. I'm just gonna, I'm just gonna devil's advocate this shit for a while because I think we're generally pretty close, but it's fun to do the devil's advocate just so people hear, um, you know, and this is, this is sort of what Jensen's argument was to some extent was, Hey, you know what? AI, uh, AI diffusion across the U S is largely aided by Chinese models, right? If we look at total ARR of the AI ecosystem, um, you know, if you add up all the application layer companies that are running on open models, it's actually well north of $10 billion, right? It's not like it's some like tiny little amount, um, of open model revenue that is going to American companies and deep seek mates because deep seek for flash and their revenue is less than fucking base 10 and fireworks and, and, and all these guys serving the Chinese model. Actually, America is making so much money off of the Chinese models and it's like amazing. And it lets us accrue and invest more and more and more. Um, you know, yes, bite dance bought a bunch of ads on Tik TOK. And Zuck didn't really see the threat immediately. Yes, of course, everyone's short-sighted. Everyone makes mistakes, right? You know, Jensen got a little horny, right? It's his short-sighted mistake at the end of the day. Um, but, but it's, um, he did more, he did more than that, right? I mean, it's clear that what he did over a long period of time. Yes. It's not, again, it's not just the women it's doing a little more than turning a blind eye to the fact that his suppliers were not only doing the Malaysia thing, which like, like again is like kind of legal even today, but bringing the chips into legal. I don't think it's not, I don't think it's kind of legal. Yeah, no, no. I mean, I mean, it's like, this is like, like ethical hoops. This is like, it's like unethical hoops. I think it's about the letter of the law versus the spirit of the law. Like Jensen is in these closed door meetings with a lot of the leaders of the U S who clearly have the spirit of wanting to slow down China's advance and his decisions that he can make. And they did not necessarily. I don't, I don't think that's why. He's losing his job. I think he lost his job because there is some evidence that he had, you know, had that, that they knew the chips were going into the affair. Yeah. And, and look, man, I mean, circumstantially around Jensen, um, his Taiwan sales manager is indicted for smuggling, uh, chips out of Taiwan. His closest OEM partner, super micro, had their COO, uh, and co-founder or, you know, head of sales, whatever Wally, um, has been arrested. Um, one of their sales managers is currently a fugitive in Taiwan. So it's not necessarily like, uh, out of the blue that they were cracking down on this and that people around him are, uh, being caught with clear evidence, right? Like the picture of, of, uh, the super micro Taiwan guy with the hairdryer in his hand, moving the stickers from the fake servers onto the real ones or from the real ones on the fake servers to pass an audit in September, last year, it's pretty like damning evidence that they're aware of. And there was no honeypot required to get Jensen to do that with super micro. Well, I think the, the evidence that's required that needs to pass the test would be Jensen actually knowing about this and Jensen being complicit in it and doing anything, but either way, I had to guess. I bet the board has some evidence here. If I had to guess the board has evidence on this. I mean, like, how do you explain no longer reporting Singapore revenue? Yeah. I mean, like the circumstantial evidence is there. And when I think this is a, the big thing is like people, even in the case of his, these affairs, they would point and say, well, it's not technically illegal, except the spirit of his actions is against the interests of other people who have a different opinion about the relationship that the U S should have with China and the technology that they're working there. And a convenient time, right, right around the midterms is when he gets whacked. So. I mean, the cover is gone, right? Like, uh, you know, it was basically like the, the, uh, the cabinet members, like, you know, took the blue wave is okay. It's fine. We can now blow the cover and it's, it's over for, for let Nick and Jensen. Yeah. I mean, it's pretty clear. Let Nick always, you know, and, and, and Trump wanted to make deals and they used export restrictions as a deal making thing. But like, you know, in another sense, right? Like it's the fucking law, right? You can't negotiate with the law. You make a law, you make a law and you, you enforce it. Um, and so there's clearly like issues there. No, I think enforcement has been a big question so far. Like if you look at the Biden era diffusion framework, it was passed and then just not enforced. It's still on the books. Trump just directed people not to enforce that framework. Really? The diffusion laws aren't like they didn't remove them. It was super weird. Like he had like a comment and there was like a thing and a footnote, but they did not, they never repealed in 2025. They, you know, uh, wait, sorry, these are laws in effect. I didn't realize the diffusion. I thought we would have to repass them. It's not really a law in the traditional sense. It's like a. of action no no it's it's like guidance to the bis basically yeah and then he never published like a real kessler never this kessler he's just i don't know what the fuck he's been doing apparently he shows up in the office but like you know he never passed a real piece of guidance saying we are no longer doing this he just like made a footnote somewhere which is like by the way guys don't worry about this like we're gonna bring a new thing for you soon and that was in may of 2025 so no it's it the level of like indecision and and incompetence that we've seen and just like you know cognitive dissonance on the part of of this uh policy process is um really breathtaking but anyways i want to come to jordan jordan what's your what's your rasa take where do you want to put the temperature on just how many chips we should let uh china have access to remotely well yeah i think um what dylan said about having the us be able to monitor what chinese is doing china's doing with the chip as well as being able to have the option to cut off their access and then start to use the chips for what they want in a future where the intelligence wars are playing out and there's an escalation i think is important optionality for them i think the other thing is that it's so clear how much american companies benefit from a mutually benefit from a relationship with china with chinese companies with chinese researchers with uh chinese software um and just with chinese people so there's lots of you know chinese citizens that work for the frontier labs today right who are born in mainland china and it's really complicated for me to understand like we work with engineers who are based in china sometimes that work for nvidia that work for amd that have access to early products that bring up the new gpus that work on the software low-level hardware stuff like this and um as you escalate tensions all of this relationship breaks down and everything just gets harder for everybody so insofar as you are as as anybody is pro ai this is a bad day for ai progress so as as test as i mean it seems like a bad day for ai progress that would be my high level take um the one thing about rosa is that that makes it clear you know to me is like like you said china is trying to get off gpus so like in our tracking in february um glm was released with support for seven domestic accelerators not just huawei but they included more threads high gone camera con kalungson meta x and flame deep seek published a mega kernel with huawei ascend for their v4 model uh meituan claims they trained long cat entirely on ascend like people don't even train on amd you know it's it's like only nvidia or tpu that you can train on in the u.s so that's happening like with or without the remote access laws being passed it's just more about motivation i think it's a lot about inference as well like are you going to let bite dance compete globally with inference capacity from these providers on nvidia gpus or you're just going to like not let them into the u.s and not let them have a business or you know in southeast asia or anything like that or make them serve it from within china that's that's an open question but you know maybe the the final thing is just like there are there are so many ways in which me personally and many people i know are going to be able to do that and i'm going to be able to do that and i'm going to be able to work at the american labs just like learn from people in china and uh if you cut off those like like direct working relationships um i think it's a one-way street like it's i think it's really hard to understand how you just roll this stuff back but then to dylan's point i'd love to get your take on this like i think you can do all the meaningful restrictions just focused on asml and the match act like just expand beyond euv stop them getting access to euv tools too they need a bunch of if they're going to produce any of these chips that go into these centers and make them build lithography from scratch right that's kind of the easiest way to stop them making any progress here the the main thing i think that people just don't understand is that they think like if you remove one item at all of at the top of the supply chain they won't do everything and i've used this analogy a hundred times but it's the jigsaw puzzle right you remove one piece they'll fucking engineer the one piece if you blow up the board it's harder um at the end of the day this is an economic war um if you think you can get away with something without much blow you know without huge ramifications across supply chains you're not going to be able to solve the issue you have to just flip the table if you want it to happen the best way to flip the table is to prevent them from buying relatively low value or low total market cap value goods and make them buy the expensive stuff don't buy don't buy asml equipment and make chips and make models make them not allowed to buy the asml equipment don't let them buy chips make them rent the chips don't let them rent the chips make them buy the ai right you know make them transfer up the value chain where the value chain is much larger and larger and larger and if you do that then china has an economic disadvantage massively so and this is a scale game um and therefore the west will win and so i think that that's that's the key reason why you know look they're going to be pissed about whatever you ban ban the thing at the bottom of the totem pole and chop the legs out underneath them don't just attack only the top spear the ai aspect the chips focus on how you make the chips focus on the equipment to make the chips that's what's more important yeah i think it's also a tiny thing like we're kind of watching um china on the rise and i think that in response to a lot of these actions they don't want to escalate because the longer that they wait in these intelligence wars the more time they have to catch up and there's a lot of discourse about is the gap wider or smaller i would say the gap in the model capabilities is wider at this point but the gap in ship capabilities is like as close as it's ever been but the question the question is not just like capability it's also scale right and that's where it comes back to the equipment like yes it sucks um or it's not ideal that um you know china has been able to break through the sort of 14 nanometer line which we like kind of sort of tried to draw on the sand um in in 2022 but you know this again it's a scale game right it's not just make a thousand chips you need to make a hundred thousand you need to have megawatts upon megawatts of like advanced hardware in order to be able to um both train train and deliver this ai it's such that it like makes a difference to your um economy and um you know as long as you're um getting the equipment the the equipment side right it's just like just makes it so much harder for the chinese ecosystem to compete with the american ones if they can't sort of rely on uh the japanese and the way it's like they already can't buy the stuff from the americans so it's not it's not like screwing over u.s companies on the sme side it's making sure that the japanese and dutch and koreans can't like um you know make up for the fact that we're not able to um to sell into them i hear you jordan on the on the interpersonal stuff like there is an aspect of this which is deeply tragic like their ai has the potential to deliver like incredible things for humanity and um you know like a kind of beautiful you know humanity scale experiment so make the future now but you know problem is like uh u.s and china have a lot of issues with each other and china happens to be run by authoritarian leader um who runs a leninist system and it's like you know not not necessarily liang wenfeng's fault that that is um the case i mean it it absolutely isn't like there's old blog posts of him um talking about how he's not interested you can kind of read in in his writing like a vision of the world which is much more um kind of uh unified and holistic than what you see out of xi jinping and his speeches and and you know his frame of the world is this uh you know uh struggle for um commanding heights but like you know liang wenfeng doesn't run the country right she does um and he's been doing it for 15 years and he's going to be around for a long time to come and that's the reality that um uh people need to operate under and jensen clearly didn't like he did not buy in to this framework he didn't think that um uh sort of china advancing uh at the same at the same clip as the u.s was something which was a problem and there is enough of a consensus um among uh america's elected officials that that's wrong that um we've come to the place that we're not we're at now um uh dylan any any closing policy thoughts i do want your guys's take on like um just how bad this is that jensen's now off the table for the future of american innovation and and we should talk about open models i mean he was the big champion right like dylan you were talking earlier like i still don't understand quite why someone didn't spend a few billion dollars and make something better than kimmy or deep sea you can open source it because i guess that was supposed to be funny not that easy it's not money it's talent man like you know like all of the most talented people primarily work at major anthropic opening eye deep mind and meta tbd right and then you know those who don't are split across the board across a hundred different startups um there's no start i mean like yes thinking machines as a crack team but it's thinking machines as good as moonshot like no like moonshot skill wise is probably just as good as the u.s labs they just have a big deficit in computing deployment um you know so i think this is like if we if we if if we don't have a um a scale advantage then you don't win these you know that yes you know these these smaller labs have spent a lot of money on models but deep mind grok meta have regularly fallen behind the frontier of Chinese labs and they're spending more. So it's not just, oh, spend a few billion dollars and you can make a model that's better. Like that's, you know, the innovation and the quality of the engineering and researchers in the Chinese labs is just very funny. Wait a second, by the way, NVIDIA did spend this money and try to do it and still not produce anything with Nemotron that was better than the open source models from the Chinese labs. So even though he's a big supporter of open source, it's not like you're guaranteed to be effective just because you pour money and time into it. So, kind of hard, like definitely hard. You need compute, you need people and you need data. So we just got to get Alex Wong on the case. That's the only zero to one we've had which has been successful in the past three years. I mean, they hired a ton of great researchers and have a ton of compute for sure and spent a bunch of money on high quality data. It's part of it. I don't know. Look, I think there's two things that I see the discourse shifting towards which I'm a little, like, not completely against, but just trying to be more nuanced on. One is like ramping up export controls in the form of Rasa and Match and the diffusion framework is like an obvious good thing and the US should be immediately doing it. Like, I'm not sure people are thinking through all the implications, which is what we tried to discuss here. And then the second thing is people are like, immediately oh, Jensen leaves NVIDIA and it's like guaranteed the company's going to zero and could never run without them and it's such a unique work structure. And this is all true, but I think that in that case as well, the more nuanced take is like, in the short term, NVIDIA is fine. Like, they need to deliver on commitments to customers and build a bunch of GPUs with the supply chain that they've got. And like, nobody set them up for success as well as Jensen could, but now they just need to execute on the stuff he set up them for, for like Ruben and Ruben Ultra. And I think a lot of people know what to go do. I think they know their marching orders, they know their responsibility, they know the mission. I think the really big test for NVIDIA is like, Jensen has been incredibly good at retaining talent, especially amongst his executive team. There are very few high-profile departures from the NVIDIA executive team. A lot of people retire and basically only Rene Haas has gone to ARM and like, gone on to be a CEO anywhere else. Like, there's no EVPs, SVPs, VPs that like, really leave that often from NVIDIA. This is a time where, you know, Jensen and the mission isn't at the helm. Somebody needs to continue to give them compensation and direction and keep them and retain them. And this is probably when the sharks are in the water. The VCs are going to come in and offer people billions of dollars to start their own chip companies, their own NeoLabs. Hey, you should come join us over here. I mean, we're going to see in the medium to long-term whether NVIDIA can operate with Jensen. I think that question is up in the air because if a year from now we've seen like a bunch of departures from NVIDIA, I'm going to be really concerned about their future. If a year from now everybody's still like rowing in the same direction and Colette is driving things or they've got somebody else like especially a technical leader who has emerged like in Buckstep or something. Maybe they transition Michael Kagan out of CTO or something. I don't know, whatever that looks like. Then I would be coming back and saying, hey, I'm, you know, much more confident in NVIDIA. But I mean, I really think people are underestimating the dominance they have in the supply chain, in the sales and support that they have, all the relationships with the NeoClouds, all the investments they have in the labs, and all the startups. The ability they can use their balance sheet to backstop everybody and make them be partners with them. They can invest in everybody. They can acquire all these companies as soon as they're successful. It's still NVIDIA's to lose. I think there's a very high chance that they're still doing just fine two, three, four years from now. And another open question is like, okay, say like some people get poached, they raise big rounds and they start doing new things. Is that really like the worst thing or are we sure that's like the worst thing for the Western ecosystem to have, you know, different people trying new bets? The other question is like we're going from a founder to someone who is not the founder. And I imagine there are just like aside from executing on the roadmap, there must be some like, you know, big, wacky, out of consensus things, which Jensen probably would have done over the next five or ten years, which maybe wouldn't have paid out for another five or ten years, which I guess potentially wouldn't have happened. And, you know, to what extent does that, you know, happen? But like half as much, to what extent is that just like, okay, instead of it happening within NVIDIA, it happens from, you know, some EVP's new startup. That's kind of the question that I have going from like, you know, the jobs to the Tim Cook era of NVIDIA. I'm certainly not sitting here saying like, this is a really good day for NVIDIA. I don't understand why NVIDIA is not down a lot more. Yeah, I think it's really bad for sure. But people, like I'm talking to people and they're like, NVIDIA's a zero. And I'm like, you use the Apple versus Steve Jobs analogy. If you bought stock when Steve Jobs went on leave and then passed away, you'd return a ton of money with Apple stock since that time. Yeah, but didn't he come back and like. No, no, gone 2.0. I think we're, I think, you know, Apple, this is Jobs leaving in 2015, not leaving in like 90. Okay, got it, got it, got it, got it. I thought you meant the original gone. Okay, Apple in 2015, looking back is a bum. The thing is, Steve Jobs was not a maniacal guy who ran every single part of his company. He was, yes, he was a maniacal guy who cared about every aspect of his firm. But at the end of the day, I don't think Steve Jobs exerted as much control over Apple as Jensen does over NVIDIA or Elon does over his companies. Really? I don't think so. I mean, I don't know Steve Jobs. I don't know Apple as well. I've only read some books but like, it doesn't seem like, like he was absolutely so tremendously important but like, I just don't think it's the same level of like work. Steve Jobs is a pure visionary and like, Jensen is like, negotiating every supply chain contract and Steve Jobs is not doing that. So, Dylan, like, how do you think they, if they start faltering, like, on what dimensions will they start faltering? I think Rubin, you know, if there's any manufacturing issues with Rubin, people are distracted and Jensen's not there. Things get solved slower. Things get solved by committees. Things don't get escalated up. I mean, I don't know how many times it's semi-analysis if we fucking email Jensen and for a thing to get solved. Like, what the fuck? Like, why are we emailing Jensen to fix something on some open source software? And yet, that's the only way we get it solved. And we're irrelevant, right? Like, compare that to like actual companies in the space. How often is it Jensen going out there and solving a problem? I can, from what I've heard from everyone around the ecosystem, it's a lot. How many times is it like, you know, Elon tells Jensen something, Jensen goes and tells his team and the team fixes it. Because the team was trying to work with the team. Yeah. And it doesn't work out. All of these examples of the reasons why NVIDIA would technically have problems going forward, I think we're actually already present with Jensen at the helm. Like, they have a big problem with all the custom chips coming up. Yeah, exactly. But I'm saying Ruben could slip. The yield curve could look worse. Feynman could slip. Feynman could be not as aggressive. You know, one of the popular stories I love saying is like, Volta didn't have Tensor cores until three months before tape out. Jensen is the one who fucking decided this, right? There's bickering little people and Jensen's like, no, AI is the way. Let's do fucking Tensor cores. Like, this is like, and it's like, fuck everything else. I don't care that, you know, we're three months away from tape out and you say it's going to take six months to incorporate the change. You're going to do it and you're going to do it now. And stack on a hundred of these decisions, Feynman's going to be much worse than it is and it's going to come later. Ruben's going to be, could be, yield ramp could be slower. Ruben Ultra could be slower. Oh, the despec on Ruben Ultra would take longer to do slash might not even get done and therefore the volumes that NVIDIA can ship are lower. Like, there's a bajillion things that you can decide. XYZ things on software. Oh, yeah, like DeepSeek open sourcing all this software and DPP and like all this stuff that Moonshot's doing and making KDA work. That shit's going to take forever to get up and running at high efficiency at NVIDIA relative to before. Maybe it's only a week, but each of these things and decisions and him driving and leadership and the supply chain giving them 70% of their supply instead of, you know, much less because it's Jensen. You know, all of these things are exacerbating and it could be like in 2029, the best chips aren't NVIDIA's and they don't have the majority of the supply chain. Yeah, well, I mean, that's relevant to the stock, right? But I think like this is this is 2026, not 2022. There are lots of other competent teams who are running at this in a way in which there kind of was only one before. NVIDIA is still the fair water mark. NVIDIA is still the leader. They're still driving the industry. If NVIDIA slows down, it's not like someone else accelerated. NVIDIA slowed down. And so someone else is the best. Yeah, it's like a question mark. Maybe depends on your situation for inference. And then no matter what industry is progressing slower hardware, it progresses slower without Jensen at the helm of NVIDIA period. Yes, there are competitors, but without NVIDIA in the lead, people are running less fast or even if they're running as fast as they were before because NVIDIA was in the lead and they're no longer, you know, as relevant. Progress has slowed. This is a real slowdown in progress. Yeah, this is a pretty pretty morbid for all of us here. I mean, it's sad. This is very Shakespearean. And I was so sad. I've been a Jensen fanboy since I was a teenager. I don't think people like understand how much I fucking like look up to the man and love him. Like, you know, it's crazy. It's sad. The circumstance like I think a lot of us were always impressed by NVIDIA and just to see I think a lot of people like trying to excuse conduct that's like it's just so bad to read about this. I see all the memes about it. I mean, I don't know. Dude, the memes are fire. This is probably some of the best memes in like you know, the memes the past few days is up there with like Republican primaries in 2014-15. Like the memes are that fucking good. I laugh and then I'm sad. That's what the memes are doing to me right now. Um, so Eliot Spitzer you know, as a little high schooler into politics, he was my hero. He was like crusading against corruption, governor of New York State. And then it comes out, he had passed an anti-prostitution law. And then it comes out that he was, you know, had $2,000 an hour escorts. And then it has to leave the governorship. That was my wake-up. I realized these like, you know, men with egos aren't necessarily all their cut out to be moment. So, you know, it's, it's not surprising, but it is depressing. And it just kind of remind you about how, you know, humans are frail and, you know, don't, don't ever meet your heroes. But I don't know, man. Like we can still look up to Lisa Su, right? She's, she's still, she's still there for us. Like Dylan, um, who's your dream new NVIDIA CEO? Who are we, who are we putting in if we can snap our fingers? If I could snap my fingers, Lisa Su, but I don't think she'll do it. Charlie Kawas, Johnny Shroji, Charlie Kawas, Charlie Kawas would be the best. How about you, Jordan? Well, if Charlie's on the table, I'll just say Hawk Tan, man. Bring the guy in. I think, I think Hawk is too good of a businessman. I think, I think Charlie is really good at, is, is, is a bit more technical and less businessman than Charlie than, than Hawk, even though he's a really good businessman. It's like, I think like that dynamic, you actually want Charlie. Yeah, I think my personal opinion is, um, a lady named Colette Kress. I really look forward to working with her, and I, uh. Well, we do love Colette. She's great. There is no. I know, I know you guys are buds. There is no way the CFO of NVIDIA isn't implicated in whatever has been happening with these chips. It's just, it's not possible. I could not fathom a world. We don't know how deep this web goes. Yeah, we don't know how deep this web goes, but like, I don't see how it's possible that like, you know, Jensen and Colette don't both, aren't both like, I don't know. Yeah, it's hard. I mean, Colette's not the one that's in Asia like, making the agreement, so maybe she could like, pretend like, oh, I didn't know. I signed a lot of pieces of paper. Like, I don't know. But, but she's, look, she's gonna, she's gonna have to testify in front of Congress just how much she didn't know. And there's gonna be, you know, congressional investigations to this. So like, look, it may, it may be true, but like, like the way it, and that's, that's kind of why you want the technical CEO, or why you want someone from outside, because I just don't understand how you know, someone who is deeply involved with the operations and, and kind of interact with the clients. Yeah, and the new CEO's not gonna be called to testify and like, for like days and days and days, and they get to focus on the company. Look, I think the fact that this originates from the intelligence community kind of rules out the fact that the person who's immediately installed at CEO has like in-depth, deep knowledge of it. Like, the board has clearly been briefed on something initially that Rubio knew back in May before they did the visit to China and stuff. I think that would be really strange. It's not that, no, it's not the Chinese spy. It's, it's, it's like, look, all the facts with Supermicro, it's not the affair anymore. It's Supermicro, it's Megaspeed, it's the, it's it's chip smuggling into China. And the sort of willful um, uh, you know, covering of your eyes, of Yeah, willful ignorance, yeah. Yeah. I think anyone who's kind of complicit in that is gonna have a really hard time staying out of the line of fire, of all this. Yeah, I, I'm watching the Supermicro indictment really closely to see how they actually play out prosecuting this stuff, because they flipped the guy who was doing the hairdryer stuff, taping, moving the stickers, um, who deleted his encrypted messaging app the day he got arrested. And, uh, apparently he's working with the prosecutors now. So, we'll see, you know, what happens there, right? Like, there's not really obvious ways to hide this stuff and be willfully ignorant in the technology-connected, you know, internet world that we live in right now, where you're trying to do things in Taiwan from the U.S. So, we'll see. Um, but I would find it, again, I would find it really strange if, um, they immediately installed somebody who was, like, completely complicit in all the same stuff that Jensen was that's motivating the change. Maybe. I don't know. I hope, I hope not. I hope not. I hope she does a great job. I hope she, you know, delivers all our new chips online and, you know, brings me, brings me AGI, but we'll see. Um, I mean, any closing thoughts? Yeah, sorry. Yeah, I think there's, there's, like, the closing thought is just that there's potential that NVIDIA just goes into civil war here over this. Because she's interim, she's not full-time. Uh, I think there's a constant clash in any company between finance and technology and sales. Kind of three big areas. Sales wants to do deals, technology wants to make big bets, finance needs to figure out how to pay for it. Finance is in charge now. Well, we know what's going to happen to the NVIDIA business going forward. It's going to be probably very profitable for a little while. Um, and then medium to long term, it's probably going to look a lot different. But, uh, yeah, closing thought on, like, maybe the political side is just, like, I hope, I really hope the people that are. Pass the. Yeah, I really hope. Pass the fucking match act. Just think this stuff through, guys. Yeah, please. I, I, I think, like, you can be a hawk and have a debate on, like, Rasa, but it's hard to, hard to have a debate on. Yeah. It seems obvious. Like, uh, anyway. Um, we'll be watching closely, guys. Yeah. Tune in for more. Um, I have, uh, I tweeted on Monday. I'm like, I did my emergency pod. Or, we should, let's just end it. Let's end it. Say it, say it. What's up? Oh, no, I was, I am, uh, I was, uh, I think I did my emergency pod on, uh, Friday. I was like, oh, man, how many days is it going to take before I have to do another one? It's six days. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Tight turnaround. Yeah. A daily emergency pod. That's what we were saying internally. Every single one of our pods has to be named emergency right now. It's just like, yeah. See you next week. Dylan, what do you think's going to happen next week? How can we go, how can we ramp up from here? We thought the Anthropocene was going to be the capital markets, but now the CEO of the biggest, most valuable, most important company in the world goes away. What are we doing here? What can, what can. Look, in 27, they said China wakes up to AI in November. So we've got a, we've got a big bear awakening. Next November? Or the. No, no, we got to nationalize it. We got to nationalize Anthropic and SpaceX. And then, you know, Dario gets thrown in jail. Oh, no, no, no. I'm just, like, like, for season two, you know, we got to, we got to up the stakes, right? For our next emergency pod, like, you know, if they wanted to go crazier. Just to be clear, what, how do you think, functionally, it plays out to nationalize a company of that size? I have no idea. No, it's not actually going to happen. Sorry. We got to end this podcast, like, three minutes before. We lost the, we lost the thread here. I have more things going over. Okay, we can cut all this, but. I mean, I know, I know Jordan's a. I mean, yeah. I know Jordan is a socialist and he loves and admires China so much, so. Wait, what? No, no, Schneider, Schneider, Schneider. Oh, Schneider. You need to pass some more power law, AI, you know, AGI. Like, there needs to be some legislation around it. I don't think the executive is going to just nationalize it. Cut this part out, but what I'm, what I'm getting at is that I think you're just, we are watching the nationalization of NVIDIA play out right now. Like, this is the equivalent of Jack Ma disappearing. I don't think so at all. I disagree completely, Jordan. All he had to do was not sell chips to people smuggling them to China, and he would have been fine. That's all he had to do. Yeah, so he does something against the national interest, and the national intelligence community comes in, takes him out, and installs somebody that they have more influence over. Yeah, when you break the law, there are consequences. Just don't break the fucking law. Yeah, just don't break the law. Okay, sorry, guys. Sorry for the confusion, Gary. He can advocate for all he wants. He can scream to the ravenous. He could have done age 20 all he wanted to, and we would, like, he didn't break the law. He did age 800, he didn't break the law. Wait, all you're saying right now is he deserved to be nationalized, which, like, fair enough. No! I'm saying. Between don't break the law and nationalized. This is a fucking massive chasm! Are you saying that they are not. This is not. They are not nationalizing NVIDIA right now. That's crazy. No chance. Absolutely no chance. What is the difference? Again, he could have. What would they have to do for it to look like nationalization to you? I don't know. What does nationalization even mean to you, President? What does nationalization mean to you? Does it mean a CEO? Yeah, they have to be. Who doesn't break the law? No, you. No! Like, I don't know. Any of the people we've said for CEO are not nationalizing the company. They're just logical CEOs. Right, so let's see who it is. Jared Kushner for CEO of NVIDIA. When Donald Jr. becomes CEO, then we'll know really who was behind this from the beginning. Oh my god. I don't know. Maybe this is too far gone for you guys, but I think that's exactly what's happening right now. Anyway, cut this part out. - Aligning the country. it's aligning a country with the laws of the book like leave it in Jordan alright alright we'll leave it in alright you guys got on camera looking back at my wild conspiracy theory that I told you about and this and this stop financial advice don't come after me please wait m-m-m-m-match m-m-m-m-m-m-m-match m-m-m-m-m-m-m-match hoi it's the dutch aligned in spirit it's true it's our biggest export what else can we do Biden and Gina told us it was fine we only sell a little to some friends of mine sorry boys new sheriff in town this congress is gonna shut it all down more free rides no more we'll see you don't circle back you answer to me please just one more scanner out that door try it I'll pull the plug on your whole damn floor m-m-m-m-m-match every scanner every screw if I can't then neither can you m-m-m-m-m-match every service call every crew match it or I'll make you try me m-m-m-m-match every scanner every screw if I can't then neither can you m-m-m-m-m-m-match m-m-m-m-m-match every service call every crew match it or I'll make you try me try me try me try me m-m-m-m-m-match ever said for nato babe I'm so proud now zero percent de minimis say it out loud nikon say cheese now say no tokyo electron put the etcher down slow BIS got 12 guys and a fax machine still the scariest office I've ever seen did you like the stroopwafels at our reception too sweet sorry no export exception 36 to 8 in markup we slay now put us in the big beautiful ndaa m-m-m-m-match every scanner every screw if I can't then neither can you m-m-m-m-m-match service call every crew match it or I'll make you can't we keep having productive conversations just ask us nicely take it slow three years of that no text no citation repeat after me n-o m-m-m-m-match every scanner every screw if I can't then neither can you Neither can you Every service call, every crew I'll match it Or I'll make you Ma-ma-ma-ma-match Ma-ma-ma-ma-match Policy of d-d-d-d-denial Denial Ma-ma-ma-ma-match

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The resignation of NVIDIA’s CEO, Jensen Huang, follows allegations of enabling chip smuggling to China, raising concerns about national security and ethical lapses.
  2. Critics argue that a complete ban on GPU access to China would backfire, as it would trigger countermeasures and disrupt global supply chains, undermining U.S. technological advantage.
  3. A strategic "diffusion" approach—allowing remote access with oversight and the ability to terminate access—is seen as more effective than outright bans to maintain control without escalating economic warfare.
  4. The Match Act and Remote Access Security Act (RASA) aim to close loopholes in export controls by regulating cloud-based GPU access, with significant implications for China’s AI development and U.S. strategic autonomy.
  5. Despite the controversy, experts emphasize that China’s internal AI progress, such as domestic training on non-NVIDIA hardware, shows a strong motivation to reduce reliance on foreign chips.
  6. There is growing concern that the U.S. leadership has failed to consistently enforce existing diffusion policies, leading to a lack of strategic coherence in tech export controls.
  7. The debate highlights a deeper tension between national interest and innovation
  8. A shift in leadership at NVIDIA could slow innovation, as Jensen’s hands-on technical and supply chain management were critical to execution, and his absence may lead to reduced agility and speed in product development.

Summary:

S. technology policy, ethics, and strategic competition with China. While allegations suggest he enabled chip smuggling to China, critics argue that a complete ban on GPU access would backfire, triggering economic retaliation and disrupting global AI innovation.

S. technological dominance without triggering a full-scale trade war. Proposals like the Match Act and RASA aim to close export loopholes by regulating cloud-based GPU access, particularly for Chinese firms, while acknowledging that China is already investing heavily in domestic AI infrastructure.

The discussion also underscores the importance of supply chain resilience and the risks of overreach in export controls. S. policy seeks to limit China’s AI progress, the reality is that Chinese firms are rapidly building domestic capabilities.

Moreover, the absence of Jensen Huang may slow NVIDIA’s innovation, as his direct involvement in supply chain decisions and technical strategy was central to its competitiveness. The episode reflects a moment of uncertainty in global AI leadership, where geopolitical tensions, ethical concerns, and the need for innovation must be balanced. S.

AI ecosystem depends not just on export controls, but on maintaining strategic flexibility, strong oversight, and sustained technical leadership.

FAQs

The CEO of NVIDIA resigned amid allegations of enabling chip smuggling to China, which violated U.S. export control policies. This is significant because NVIDIA is a dominant force in AI hardware, and his departure marks a pivotal moment in U.S. tech policy and AI development.

The RASA Act targets remote access to U.S. chips in China, while the MATCH Act aims to restrict China’s access to advanced semiconductor manufacturing tools like EUV lithography. Both are crucial for maintaining U.S. technological leadership and controlling China’s AI development.

China could respond by accelerating domestic chip development and reducing reliance on U.S. technology. Additionally, such bans may disrupt global AI innovation by limiting access to compute power for Chinese companies like ByteDance and Alibaba.

Circumstantial evidence includes the arrest of Supermicro executives and a sales manager accused of smuggling chips using fake server stickers. These actions suggest awareness and possible complicity in violating export controls.

While NVIDIA may face short-term challenges, its strong supply chain, relationships, and technical foundation suggest stability. However, long-term innovation could slow without the CEO’s hands-on leadership and decision-making speed.

The U.S. focuses on strategic restrictions—like remote access control and chip export limits—rather than total bans, to maintain technological edge while avoiding supply chain collapse or economic retaliation.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.