The discussion centers on accelerating societal action on climate change by shifting from fear-based narratives to solution-focused, hopeful storytelling. TED Countdown, founded by Lindsay Levin, leverages the reach of TED Talks to highlight practical, everyday climate solutions and foster global collaboration. The speakers emphasize that climate action requires diverse approaches—such as net zero, degrowth, or 100% renewable energy—without needing a single universal model. A critical gap lies in the lack of visibility and relatability of climate solutions, especially among younger generations who feel disillusioned. Sage Lanier highlights how personal experiences, including mentorship and cross-sector dialogues, transformed her from an activist to a solution-builder. James Cameron underscores the importance of entrepreneurship and real-world impact in sustaining optimism, noting that political negotiations alone are insufficient. The COP process, while symbolic and valuable, is criticized for inefficiency and siloed participation. Ultimately, the panel agrees that meaningful progress depends on inclusive, well-organized civic engagement, accessible storytelling, and a shared belief that a sustainable future is not only possible but actively being built through innovation, collaboration, and everyday action.
One of the tensions we've had is between people who feel, you know, all is lost and very disappointed and very angry, understandably, with those they hold responsible for all being lost versus folks who are super motivated by, you know, how do we get on and fix this?
And we that separation again is is very unhelpful.
What I was saying, even when I was, you know, 19 teaching at Berkeley, was there's no apocalypse coming.
There's no day where there's zero people left.
In the year 2500, there will be billions of people on this planet.
We don't know how many.
It could be very large.
It could be very small.
The whether or not they're empowered to survive or even hopefully thrive on the planet we've given them is dependent on the decisions we make today.
Hello, I'm Michael Liebreich.
And this is. This is Cleaning Up, and we're recording from COP 31 at Turkiya.
We're being hosted by TED Countdown House.
And I'm joined today by three guests, because what I want to talk about is actually not the usual stuff we talk about, which is finance and engineering and energy and transport and infrastructure and so on, but actually to talk about civic society.
How does society speed up the transition?
What levers does society take?
How does society actually have?
And my guests today are Lindsay Levin, who is a serial entrepreneur and the founder of TED Countdown.
We've got James Cameron, who many of the audience might already know.
He's the chair of our editorial council.
He is an international lawyer and a serial entrepreneur.
And then our third guest is Sage Lanier, who's an educator and a communicator on climate solutions.
So I'm hoping that one or all of the three of them will have. Lindsay, let me turn to you first.
So TED Countdown, you founded it.
What was the theory?
Because you set up this whole organisation, you set up this whole Countdown House, which is outside COP, but at the COP, to accelerate the transition.
What was your theory?
Well, Mike, great to be here.
Lovely to be with you both.
And welcome to TED Countdown House.
So, I mean, I didn't do this on my own.
So I did this with a whole bunch of people.
And the idea, going back to 2020, was to work with TED, the power of TED Talks, TED's media platform, the kind of reach that it has around the world, to talk about solutions to the climate crisis.
And climate actually doesn't have very good storytelling and it doesn't have very good media platforms.
So to take the power of TED, to work in collaboration with many others.
And what we've done in the six years since, we hold summits around the world.
We hold different kinds of events.
We make talks.
We've made, gosh, 300 plus TED Talks now on climate solutions to reach very large audiences, large digital audiences.
And we should say, for those in the audience who may not know this, I think, I'm hoping most of them would by now, is that I've been one of those.
You have indeed, Michael, just very recently.
What, a month ago and just coming out or maybe out by the time people get to listen to this, a really wonderful talk.
So what's the thinking behind it?
Well, you know, first that we need to change the story, that we don't talk about this stuff well, we don't make it relatable, we don't make it ordinary, we don't make it normal, we don't make it aspirational, we don't, you know, focus on everyday life and how this relates to the sorts of things that people care about.
So one of the things we do with, we do a whole range of talks, but one of the things we do is to make sure that we have content that speaks to everyday life and to the things that people care about.
The other is to talk about solutions.
There's so many cool things happening.
You know that.
You work in.
You work in the space.
You all know that.
But most people don't.
So how do we talk about a better world, a better life, a better way of traveling around, you know, your own city, a better way to eat, you know, a better way to power your home?
How do we do that in ways that are relatable?
So we're very focused on solutions.
And the last thing is that we're very focused on collaboration because I'm very much a yes and person as opposed to no but.
And I think we need all kinds of people in this movement.
And so that's.
That's a big piece of what we're doing.
Okay.
So if I can paraphrase, see how I do.
Feel free to correct me if I don't get it.
But it's solution orientated.
It is get the narratives right and get them out and distributed and also get collaboration.
So get people together around those.
Okay.
Now I've got one thing that I have to catch you on.
Go for it.
Which is we do have an acronym rule.
Okay.
And I realize that you just said TED.
You said TED.
TED, TED, TED.
Now TED is an acronym.
TED.
Well, TED is.
I mean, it actually, you know, it's become an, what would I call it?
Just a cultural moment.
Everywhere.
Once you do things with TED, you discover everybody's always referencing a TED talk.
So it started as technology, entertainment, and I don't even know what the D was.
Design.
Design.
There we go.
Okay.
So you've been around TED longer than me.
And yeah, it's an extraordinary formula, actually.
Because even 25.
Five years on from when the first TED talks were put on stage, the power of saying to
somebody, you may have spent your life working on this.
You've got 10 minutes.
We did this with you, right?
And you've got to boil it down.
And you've really got to think about what's the core of the story.
So one of the things that we do is we help people to take complicated things and make
them really succinct.
And I can say, I've told you this already.
I told you as I was doing it, it's an extraordinary process of being TED-ed.
But TED is really a sort of, there's a. It's a bunch of things.
It is far beyond the original conference on technology, entertainment, design.
And it's become a little bit of a social movement as well.
I mean, you have a point of view.
It's not just about communicate anything at all.
You've got a direction of travel that you're trying to impose.
I mean, yeah, TED as a whole, of course, there are talks on all manner of topics.
What we do in Countdown is specifically climate.
And climate spills into many other things.
It touches upon health.
I mean, it touches on everything.
You know that from the work that you do.
And there we do have a point of view.
And, you know, which is that we have a crisis on our hands.
We need to take action that actually it's exciting, that the action is exciting.
You know, we have in front of us a better, cleaner, healthier, more promising and prosperous
economy if we choose to go there.
And so that's our point of view.
OK, now we'll come back to you to talk about, you know, why you find COP the right place
to do. Well, that's a good question.
I'm not sure whether I do.
You asked me.
But we'll come back to that.
Let's come back to that.
OK.
Because I want to bring James in.
James, you, I'm going to say as a young barrister, threw yourself into environmental law, climate
law, and you probably are too modest to say it, but you were one of the driving forces
behind the whole COP series back in the day.
So I'm going to assume that you believe that diplomacy and. And law and COPs are quite important, and you are here at COP 31.
COP 31.
Did I say that?
Gosh.
James, COP 31.
Do you still. You know, what was your theory of climate action and has it changed today?
You're right, Michael.
It goes a long way back.
I did write the first Law Review article on state responsibility for climate change.
And in that article, I made the case for an international treaty on climate.
As opposed to going to the International Court of Justice to bring a case against the United
States of America for failure to act on climate in the late '80s, 1988, I wrote the first.
I wrote the legal opinion for Greenpeace, which turned into the article, which turned
into a proposal to the Ford Foundation to imagine what an international treaty on climate
change would look like, what would be its key principles and rules and institutions,
and then to advocate for it by building. By building a coalition, and in this case, of small island states, which became the Alliance
of Small Island States.
But more than that, it was to find a way of arguing for an international treaty based
on the interests of those countries, which in turn represented the interests of all
of us.
So as an international lawyer with a conviction that the rule of law mattered and representing
those who had no political or economic power but could derive. Derived legal power from a legal system, their best effort to protect the interests
of their citizens came through an international agreement.
And that agreement required participation, for the powers of the world to meet regularly,
to decide how to implement that agreement, which amazingly was done very quickly.
I mean, we started in November 1990 at the Second World Climate Conference, first negotiating
process, February '91, Framework Convention.
June '92, and then the COPs began.
So in a sense, I started before there were even COPs, and then from the first onwards.
I haven't been to every single one, but I've been to most of them, and I still think it's
necessary, essential, flawed, and not sufficient.
But if we go back to that time, to what extent did you think it was job done once there was
this legal framework?
Was it the be-all and end-all of what you thought needed to have happen?
Or was it just a piece that would need lots of other pieces added to it?
That's such a good question, Michael.
And it also explains why I keep coming back, but in different guises.
So I started with an idealistic commitment to the law and a capacity to build a coalition of interests and to do things that were frankly not supposed to be possible.
To be a young, very young international lawyer using a Ford Foundation grant to build a coalition of countries that I wasn't a part of, wasn't a member of, wasn't a national.
And to do that successfully in that the small nine estates did influence the creation of those early agreements.
But equally, I can remember sitting, having not slept for several nights, because that is also a pathology of these processes, in Kyoto in 1997.
And thinking, we've won.
We have an international agreement.
It's got trade rules in it.
It's basically an economic instrument too.
There's going to be an allocation of quotas.
The coal industry is furious that they've lost, so we must have won.
But at the same time, I thought, I think I need to move on from this kind of negotiation.
And I need to get closer to the commercial world of decision making.
And the only way I could think of doing that as an international lawyer…
…was to go and build a practice inside an international law firm.
My next step, my commercial step, was actually via commercial legal practice.
I stayed being a barrister, but I helped build a practice at the big law firm, Baker & McKenzie, which was then the biggest law firm in the world.
And we did that.
And we did that, and we did it quite successfully.
But, as you probably know, the Kyoto Protocol was not ratified by the United States of America.
So a U.S. law firm thinking to build a client base there…
…had a problem.
The community I built with colleagues there stayed on, carried on.
But I found that the capacity to build other enterprises that could get at this problem was more attractive than staying within the profession.
And so I went on and did that.
And you know one of them quite well.
That's where you and I met when you were doing Climate Change Capital.
So, Sage, what you've got then is, first of all, endless episodes on entrepreneurship and finance.
You've got the finance and engineering and solutions.
You've got the narratives and you've got the convening and you've got the law.
What – you're sitting here – are you thinking they've just wasted 30 years or whatever it is because they don't understand – I was going to say X.
I don't mean X, the platform, but they don't understand something.
What are we missing?
It's Twitter.
What are we missing here?
It's Twitter again.
It was never not Twitter for me, but it's Twitter again.
No, I'm not sitting here thinking that.
First of all, wow, thank you.
Extremely humbled.
And the only reason I have any idea what you're talking about is because talk about the power of storytelling, when I came home last year from COP 30 in Brazil and that was my second COP and I learned so much about COP and I left feeling like deeply humbled by just the, you know, thousands of people who have been stringing this together for the past few decades.
Even – especially the legal frameworks and the technological progress, there was – you had no reason to believe that it was possible.
So like hats off to you.
But I went home back to New York City from COP 30 in Brazil feeling deeply humbled and then I was invited to see the play Kyoto.
I'm glad you saw that.
And Kyoto taught me to understand what you just said.
Yeah.
Kyoto is the story of how the cops came together.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
But it's told from the perspective of a fossil fuel lobbyist, which was brilliantly done, absolutely genius.
So it kind of shows how the fossil fuel industry inserted itself very early on in the process to subvert and just prevent any of the proceedings from being affected.
And of course, it's things, it's a story you can only stitch together in retrospect, because of course, they weren't being open about what they were doing. Brilliantly told, and I left that play, to be honest, sobbing. It was deeply humbling. And, and, and it just kind of helped me see, as well as our friend Ani Desgupta's book, those two things, I think, late last year really started to help me see truly, like globally, what we're doing on climate
And of course, it's things – it's a story you can only stitch together in retrospect because of course they weren't being open about what they were doing.
Brilliantly told and I left that.
And I think that's what I'm going to say.
action where the gaps are um what's been tried what failed what succeeded and kind of start to
map out for myself like where do we need to go from here so i got two questions one is you just
mentioned anita gupta's book you got to give us the title because we'll put a link in the show
notes um so anita skupta is the ceo of the world resources institute which is the world's largest
environmental think tank which was also recently described to me as kind of the back office for a
lot of global governments environmental policies and that was helpful for me to understand them
and his book is called the new global possible the new global possible but i just thought like
for any young person or anyone who's new to climate that's a good resource and my second
question was going to be give us a bit of background uh i introduced you described you as a
an educator and communicator um and then unfortunately i just sort of had you dive in
to say what are we what are we missing and you gave a fantastic answer but what is it that you
do uh how do you how do you how are you trying to get purchase on this problem of acceleration
well we can talk more about what's missing as well um so here so how i got to here so when i
was an undergraduate at uc berkeley i was quite frustrated with education i was getting on climate
and the environment it was very oriented around how bad the problem was and the depth of the
problem and how screwed completely were and i was like i think these things have to be solvable and
also I was watching all my peers like sprint, like people were moving out of the major, transferring
out of the college, went out to resources and just being like, this is too depressing. I think
I'm just going to study marketing. And I was like, okay, so we're not building a generation
of solutions. We're not like, you know, like empowering people to feel like they can move
out into the workforce and solve this. So it was kind of my personal search for the truth about
everything. I went all around the college. I took every sustainability class I get my hands on to
the business school, the, I studied policy, food systems. I tried to get it all. And I wrote a
curriculum that I taught to my peers, which became the largest student-led class in Berkeley's
history. And it was about climate solutions. It was kind of the whole spectrum. I have a question
about that. How do you just start teaching your peers? Is that something that you decided to just
do in a, you just hire a church hall somewhere off campus or is that part of UC Berkeley? Did
they encourage you to do that so the decal program democratic education at cal i know that thank you
very few people know what it stands for um i was hoping to catch you on a on an acronym but i
didn't it was started by the students in the 70s who started their first afro studies program
african-american studies program in the nation who were saying you know we should also have the
right to educate ourselves and so it's a very robust program at berkeley but mine was the
largest okay very good um and one of the well you were going to you were going to say what are we
missing do you want to do you want to go there or do you want me to to continue and and try and
frame um how we might think about this question of acceleration well i think we'll get there in
the conversation a few points so what one of the things that struck me and it was partly lindsey
through going through that sort of process i was going to say the ringer but you call it a process
But the TED talk process is that really what I've done with the talk is propose a model of acceleration, a model of change, which is this idea.
And I've actually spoken about it on one of the episodes of Cleaning Up, so we can put a link to the – it's called the Pragmatic Climate Reset Part 1.
I did this four-line model, and the four-line model essentially says that the way we'll solve this problem is not going to be by banning boilers and fossil fuel cars or by focusing on the emissions we want to get rid of, but actually by growing the solutions.
And we've just got to grow them to the point where they're crowding out the fossil.
Right.
And that is a model of how we're going to get the transition done.
But there are lots of other models that have been proposed over time.
I mean, I obviously think mine is the best, but it just strikes me that when you have, whether it's narratives or law or all of the work that you've done, sort of comparing and contrasting and trying to educate yourself and others, that one of the things we need to do is actually have a model.
So we've had models like net zero, which we've just spent 10 years trying to do.
You had a model called Cap and Trade, which we tried to do via Kyoto, really.
There's been some of your, I don't know if I would say peers, but there's a lot of people, not just Gen Zs or millennials, but degrowth.
It's a model of how we're going to solve this.
There's contract and converge.
James, you will remember contract and converge.
I do, yes.
100% renewable energy, anybody?
100% nuclear, anybody?
You know, there are all these, these are all just models.
How do we, I mean, is that, Lindsay, is that why we look for a model first?
I think some models can be useful and they're useful for some people and there's not one model for everybody, I would say.
So this whole. This whole. But the sort of walk and chew gum at the same time, you know, there is this is a deeply worrying topic.
You can't sort of study climate without realising that we are we've made some big mistakes.
So we're moving too slowly and so forth. And at the same time, change has always happened.
That's really where you come from. You know, that's what that's the nature of society, of economy, of change, of innovation.
There's always change coming. And so, you know, on the one hand, there's the stuff you can run towards and be excited about.
And there's also the stuff that you're kind of running away from, which are the problems.
And different people have got different ways of expressing that.
So I struggle with the idea that we need one model.
And I think we've made lots of mistakes with with language and jargon, which in a way, as soon as it becomes adopted, it becomes tired.
And then, you know, we've had all these words that become expendable and then we have to kind of move on to new words.
So I'm not sure.
I'm so caught up. I'm with you in the sense that I actually think this is about an economic transition.
But that is not good language for speaking with most people.
For most people, it translates into, you know, what's my work? What's my kids work?
You know, are we healthy? Can I improve my standard of living?
You know, can I ever got clean water, clean air and so on and so forth?
And somehow that stuff has been missed out whilst we've had those of us in the climate space has spent a lot of time arguing with each other.
About, you know, the different push and pull.
And we kind of lost society along the way.
So I'm in favour of many models, if that's useful as a way to structure an argument or a way to think about something.
And we've got to really build a bigger tent and we need this to be relatable for people.
You started with the question about how do we get society much more involved?
It's got to be normal. The stuff's got to be normal.
And that means a different kind of conversation.
I also think the politics, you know, I live, despite the accent, I live in the States, just had a big election one week ago.
Many things surprising for people, you know, coming out of that in terms of how big a shift there was in so many things.
And actually climate wasn't really on the agenda, but actually it is as well behind the scenes.
So change happens and the ways in which you talk about things, you know, changes.
And I don't think we should.
I don't think we should be attached to one frame only.
But you've talked about the push and the pull, so the push away from what we don't want and the pull towards.
And I've got empathy for both of those.
So I get the people who say we've got to stop the fossil fuel stuff.
And I also really understand and actually I agree with you, Michael, when you say, you know, we'd be better instead of banning things or perhaps you could say alongside banning or trying to ban things.
We've actually got to lean into what we're building.
But in a way, at the heart of what.
What I say is that there's this huge smorgasbord of things that we can do that are relatable because they're cheaper, better, they're more resilient.
And so why don't we do those?
And of course, I don't talk nearly as much about the things that won't go that way.
And they could be clean cement or green steel or something.
And there are these things that in the end, there is a piece that's just going to cost more so that there's got to be something beyond just the, in a sense, the pull to a better, to an easy, better life.
I do.
Acknowledge there's got to be some of that.
I get that.
But I guess a challenge I would put back to you, Michael, is that I think many of you who are deep experts on this stuff, if we have too many open arguments amongst ourselves about it's this and not that, we just really confuse the wider public.
Sage, have you got a model in mind?
Have you kind of settled after you've done, you've dived in and you've done all of this, you know, you've taken every course, you've taught the course now.
Have you got a model?
Have you got a model for how this actually plays out?
How do we get this done?
Girl, I could do 12 hours of curriculum on that.
Certainly.
There's certainly some solutions that went out amongst over others.
Where I think I can diagnose where our gaps are right now is I think to Lindsay's point, there's like two things that I think are like essential here.
One, there's not enough of a populist message.
There's not enough of a populist message around why these solutions are winning.
I try my best to put myself inside an echo chamber of climate and it's still really hard.
It's really hard to hear about climate solutions.
It's really hard to hear about how much investment is happening.
It's really, really hard to hear about like the miracle stories coming out of Pakistan right now about people all of a sudden being able to save 30 percent of their income that they were previously spending on diesel as farmers and being able to send their kids to school for the first time.
There's like not enough of a populist message.
There's not enough of a like it's really hard to green pill yourself, you know, and get down that rabbit hole.
Can I ask, is that because the messages are being drowned out by fossil shills or is it because the clean energy or the climate are just really bad at telling beautiful stories that are digestible?
I think we do need to we do need to get ahead on the new media ecosystem and really understanding how public opinion is formed.
Are we the crap guys?
No, no, no.
And so that kind of brings me to my second point, which is literally just a translation layer.
And this is something Lindsay and I have.
I'm talking about we I wander around the sector because I feel like I've been in the climate space for three years.
And it also like is much more like backloaded, right?
Like in the beginning, you don't get invited to as many events.
You don't know as many people, whatnot.
Now it's like I get to like hang out and understand who I'm talking to and what they do for work and stuff like that.
So I'm wandering around these events and wandering around talking to all these people who have done, you know, this thing or they made this much money or they pass all these policies, whatever.
And I'm like, you're freaking amazing.
I want to be.
You.
When I grow up, like I want you should be an icon.
You should be a role model.
Like, I want everyone to know your name.
You know, how do I get and there's a we're lacking a translation layer between the really dope things we're doing in climate that like are building fast, making money, getting things done, innovating like this really attractive and incredible sector that we have.
And then just the general public who I think there's this large conversation amongst Gen Z about how we'd love to have more purpose in.
Our work.
Right.
And millennials as well.
But I think there's like this nihilistic like I mean, my student loans, whatever.
And then it's like, I'll take the job at, you know, whatever consulting company, whatever.
And it's like definitely like a growing trend.
But I still hear constantly this undercurrent at cocktail parties in New York City of people being like, man, like, I wish I cared about what I was doing for work if people saw that they could have a good job with good benefits and, you know, purpose in their work and be part of something
exciting.
And I think that's where we're at.
And that's been missing.
So we've we've gone down a very narrow definition of who speaks about climate.
Yeah.
Activist and scientist.
You're very positive, Michael.
You had a fabulous electrician.
We did.
Gave us a TED talk the same day as me.
And I want to put a link into the notes.
Yes.
It wasn't about climate.
But my goodness, she was fantastic.
It was about jobs.
It was about jobs.
It was.
It was about jobs.
But it's funny because I so.
So, Sage, what you're saying is that that there aren't enough people, you know, sort of shouting in a sense about what they do and how fantastic they are.
And there's me thinking I probably do a bit too much of that about the stuff that I've been involved in.
James, the problem is you never told anybody how fantastic you are and what the wonderful things you've done.
Well, the one thing that it's lovely to hear that, by the way, I I do think building enterprises is a fantastically creative thing to do.
Yeah.
And it draws in people of many different talents.
And it's it's a great experience if you can start with an idea and produce an enterprise.
It's that fixes things, has purpose.
It's hard and it's quite hard to sometimes find the capital and the right backers.
And things go wrong.
And things go wrong and you can be too early.
You know, I've had a go at a number of different things and and I've I've found that that it's always educational.
You try and you can fail, of course.
But the stories are still important.
And the relationships you build by making the effort endure.
And perhaps we haven't.
I mean, we did have it.
I started a business called Climate Change Capital a long time ago, 2002.
And I had never done a day's work in finance before.
And I didn't really have many of the skills required either, I have to tell you.
But but I was able to attract people to the mission, to the idea of it.
And it was a very unusual organization.
And it's it began very well.
Lindsay knows its story, too.
We attracted very good people.
Now, that particular enterprise eventually was acquired and it didn't end well.
They acquire it and do what they promised to do.
And it sort of faded out.
But the idea of building an enterprise that attracted capital, aggregated it and directed towards these solutions that that that sustained that has carried on.
And crucially, I think the people that you attract.
I meet them all over the place.
Yes, the diaspora of the alumni, the Climate Change Capital and you can still.
You can go on LinkedIn, and there's a climate change capital group, and they still meet.
It's 10 years or probably more since it came to an end.
But that network is powerful, and the networks are crucial.
And even here at COP31, walking the halls, how many of your former pupils or your former recruits at climate change capital have you run into?
I love that.
Now, by the way, that's one of the things that's really good about the COPs.
Can we just return to this?
Right.
All right, because although every now and again you do have some kind of breakthrough in the lawmaking process, this particular one isn't one of those.
There is value in the gathering, right?
I mean, I happen to love sport and live music.
It's different if you go to the final.
Yes, it's different when you're there.
It's different when you're there.
You have a different feeling about having been at that event at that time with the person or people who you were alongside.
You know, going to Glastonbury is great.
It's a gathering, and it means something to attend.
And this is a gathering.
It's an annual gathering.
It's actually a pretty good way of meeting other people who are fixing this in their various ways from all around the world.
I happen to like it.
It gives me a lift.
I don't like how they're organized very often.
You know, the ludicrous traffic going to and from the centre day, that's bad.
That's bad in every possible way.
It's a poor organization.
The time it takes to get in.
The fact that we have, for, strictly speaking, reasons you can understand if you're in the system,
the way we have to agree everything literally gaveled down in triplicate with the president of the process being advised every step of the way what each bit means by the secretariat.
If that was shown live to an audience, it wouldn't last the week.
People would say, you are kidding.
Right.
And much of that.
That is learned behaviour from 19th century French and British bureaucracy.
Right.
It's not good for today.
It can be made better.
So I'm 100% in favour and quite supportive of the need to gather and lovingly critical of how we actually do it in practice.
Cleaning Up is proud to be supported by its leadership circle.
The members are. Actis, Alcazar Energy, Arup, Climate Imperative Foundation, Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners, Signum Capital, Davidson Kempner,
Eco Pragma Capital, EDP, Euroelectric, KKR, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, National Grid, Oakland, Octopus Energy, Quadrature Climate Foundation, Schneider Electric,
SDCL, and Wärtsilä.
For more information on the leadership circle, please visit cleaningup.live.
To keep up with all that's going on at Cleaning Up, sign up for our free newsletter,
which gives the latest on the episodes we're recording, events we're hosting, and stories we're watching.
To sign up for the newsletter, visit cleaningup.live.
We've done an episode, James.
We've done an episode on how you might reform the process, and I had some ideas about restricting it to 5,000 people and sticking it on an island so there were not enough hotel beds for more.
Because I look at it and I say, there's 100,000 people apparently going to come to this, and I just ask, if you got each one to write what good looks like in their organization, what they would like to achieve, I'm going to say 90,000 of them wouldn't add up to a hill of beans in terms of actually solving climate either mitigation or adaptation.
It's purely recreational.
No, I'm not having that.
They're having a marvelous time.
They're not.
No, I'm not having any of that.
That's just not even close.
I would say the opposite, that most people who come here come for a reason.
They bring something with them.
They learn something by coming.
They interact with someone they probably didn't know or didn't perhaps understand, even having a better appreciation of what the opposition looks like or why they're here.
There's a barrier to what you thought was a great idea or maybe finding someone who's going to show you a better way of getting it.
I would say I think it's an outlet, actually, for people's frustration and desire to participate.
So the reason I wouldn't stick on an island is that actually lots of people want to be part of solving this.
Lots of people have.
We all have a stake.
So in that sense, the sort of wider inclusion really matters.
My complaint, I very much am with you, James, is if you're going to host a COP, please get organized.
Organized and do it well.
And, you know, bluntly, especially for the civil society piece, this week is not well organized to enable all those people who've, in many cases, you know, spent money, done a ton of preparation, are working really hard all year on this for them to truly participate.
So the organization matters because it's just disrespectful of people's time.
I hear you on the need to have some kind of a climate.
It's almost like a climate expo is what you're saying.
And there is that.
I just don't know that we need to do it once a year.
Sage, do you want to come in on this?
I absolutely appreciate the mind you have for efficiency and streamlining the process.
And it definitely badly needs improvement.
I would also say, though, coming as someone who's really come in from the bottom truly up and trying to really, for myself, construct an understanding of what the hell is going on on this planet.
What are we doing?
What could we else do?
And, you know, we could talk about it, but I'm thinking about perhaps this really big idea.
And thinkingly leaning in it into like specifically rooting in an American strategy for the 28 elections.
I wouldn't have ever been able to get to that level of understanding, if not for the redundancy and the kind of chaos.
But also, that is a great frustration of mine.
It's like, why did I have to get on all these damn planes and come to all of these things, these climate weeks and these cops and stuff?
I felt like I felt like last year in Belém.
I really was able.
I was able to in two weeks sort of really finally speed run understanding like this sector writ large.
But I feel like we could have gotten much more done if someone like me had a more visible layer where it was like easy to find on social media, easy to figure out who the who I'm supposed to be cheering on.
Like, who are the big who are the big wigs who are like supposed to be, you know, like, look at the tech industry.
Right.
They turn their CEOs into titans.
Right.
They put them on podcasts and they make sure that.
You know who to root for or or despise, you know, whatever your stance is on that.
But they create a culture of, you know, having a scoreboard in a way that I don't think we do well enough yet, such that I had to show up in person and have so many dumb conversations where the other, you know, like.
I think I just wasted so much time not knowing what I didn't know and having to, like, like figure out retroactively.
Oh, that's why that.
Person thought I was crazy because they do this.
I thought they did that.
Right.
I didn't understand the function of that organization or whatnot.
So coming from, you know, from like absolutely zero understanding of how this world works up, I can see once you're a few years in or, you know, you know, you've been in this for a lot longer than me where you're like, just scrap the whole thing.
But I have to say this last three years, I'm so glad that there was as much redundancy and opportunity for someone like myself.
To show up because, I mean, I hope I can have an outsized impact.
You know, I hope that in two years, five years, I can say, oh, we got X, Y, Z done.
But it wouldn't have been possible if not for this sort of learning circle.
Right.
This participatory process.
Yeah.
I do think there is great capacity for learning, for building careers, for keeping connections.
There's value in showing up.
There is value in showing up and there's value in being in the room, to use that other cliche.
But it's not sufficient.
And from just to revert back to the kind of law entry point for me, it's not sufficient either for the lawmaking.
Because the lawmaking increasingly has to be distributed as well.
At its best, you get a pretty good approximation between what matters to the decision makers in the economies that will most affect the outcome.
If they adopt laws and policies.
If they adopt policies that help drive down emissions or increase opportunities for investment or whatever, that matters.
The multilateral process is the meta process for all of that.
But it's obviously not sufficient.
So figuring out how you can break bits off, have smaller agreements, more specific agreements, more easily implement agreements, that's always been a task.
And we haven't done it nearly well enough.
But it's possible to do.
It's possible to do better.
Well, I've always said that there are…
Every COP is actually three.
There's three COPs.
There's a negotiation COP.
There's a kind of business and real economy COP.
And then there's an activist COP.
Right.
And actually, it's interesting that the activist COP, we don't really see that much of here.
And we didn't see it much in Dubai.
You know, with the kind of…
Although, you know, we're not going home until we get a…
Not so easy to be.
Not so easy to do that here.
It's not that easy to do here.
And it wasn't in Sharm.
And it wasn't in Dubai.
Well, but that's actually an interesting question about, you know, why?
We keep having cops in countries where cops do that.
I mean, one of the issues, so I spend time in all those different worlds. And the problem is I go
into the room of the activists. I'm very comfortable there. I get them. I'm one of them.
I don't see anybody from the business or the innovation or the entrepreneurship room. I go
into the entrepreneur's room, same story. So the siloing of this is a problem. And actually we end
up, you could speed ahead with the technological solutions, but if you don't bring the voters with
you, you know, if people can't see how they belong, it doesn't work. So that separation's a problem.
I'm smiling because the last Davos WEF, World Economic Forum, I went to, I went to the Occupy
Davos camp with a bottle of very nice cognac, which I gave them because they looked absolutely
freezing. And I talked to them.
I talked to them. So I'm a big believer of, you know, getting them talking to, you know,
talking to the activists as well as to the negotiators.
And vice versa, right?
And vice versa, yeah.
I guess I worry, though, that, Sage, I worry that what you at the moment look at and you say,
well, that's the real, this is the room where it happens. And my problem is I don't understand it
and I need to decode it. My worry is that you may get to the point like me where you realise this
is not the room where it happens. That these are a bunch of, you know, chief sustainability
officers who are not, they don't have a budget. They're not the decision makers. They're not even
on the investment committees of anything. It's a bunch of, you know, countries that really should
be focusing almost exclusively on adaptation, because whether they put solar roofs on their
airport or on their homes, they're just too small to affect the mitigation conversation.
And there's a lot of people trying to sort of spread, you know, either fear or hope based on
what their job description is. And it's just, just got almost nothing to do with solving
the problem. And maybe I'm being now sort of, I'm sort of hamming it up as a cynic because you're,
you're very optimistic and you're at a different point in your journey. But, but yes, I do worry
that this isn't actually the room where it happens. Yeah, but it's a different, Sage, as I
interpreted, wasn't saying that. She valued being present at the gathering. She valued learning from
others who are participants in the several worlds which are connected when they come here. Now,
it's sufficiently connected. I mean, they don't move freely between them. The way the world works
is messy. You go some steps forward, you go some steps back. One of the things that I find very
encouraging about you, Sage, is that you are, you know, of your generation and you are very
interested and excited by how do we solve this? And, you know, perhaps rather than thinking about
it generationally, one of the tensions we've had is between people who feel, you know, all is lost
and very disappointed and very, very, very disappointed. And I think that's a very, very
angry, understandably, with those they hold responsible for all being lost versus folks who
are super motivated by, you know, how do we get on and fix this? And we, that separation again is,
is very unhelpful. So I love it when I see you and other people of your generation really excited
about what can we build. And, and we, we have to kind of cross that over, I think.
Yeah. I mean, I, it was like growing up and being a teenager and hearing like, you know, there's just no
point in even planning for the future. Um, cause I think for me it was like topsoil collapse. They
were like, Oh yeah. Like when you're in your forties and fifties, the world would be like
basically running out of farmable soil, et cetera. And I was just like, okay, well, like that
obviously set my compass North. I was like, why spend your life like focused on anything but that
problem? Not that I'm in soil specifically, but you know, it's an example. I think, yeah,
it's not about, it's not about being optimistic. I think it's just about trying to
stay as solutions oriented and action oriented, extra focused as possible and trying to tunnel
vision that for yourself. Because I really do believe that every fraction of a degree matters.
And what I, what I, what I was saying, even when I was, you know, 19 teaching at Berkeley
was there's no apocalypse coming. There's no day where there's zero people left in the year 2,500,
there will be billions of people on this planet. We don't know how many, it could be very large.
Whether or not they're empowered to survive or even hopefully thrive on the planet we've given
them is dependent on the decisions we make today. So there's no, you know, running out.
And this reminds me, you're, what you're talking about reminds me very much of, um,
Hannah Ritchie. We've done two episodes with Hannah Ritchie. I don't know if you've,
if you've come across her, we'll put, again, we'll put links in the show notes
because she started off believing all of these terrible stories that it was pointless and that
it was, you know, it was an unmitigated catastrophe.
And then because she's got this extraordinary brain and she dived in and started to discover
things like the topsoil was not going to all disappear. Um, not only, well, either that the
trend was being exaggerated or that we have agency. And I want to come back and perhaps,
um, draw this to a close. Lindsay, you started us by talking about the narratives that one of
the main things that you do is narratives, but you haven't chosen within what,
Ted Countdown does. You haven't chosen to emphasize the fear narrative, the negative
narrative. You know, we have basically, we're four optimists. That's the extraordinary thing
about us. We're all optimistic. Why did you make that decision?
We do put those things on stage too. So we, we've, you know, we've had plenty of talks by people who,
who tell you the, the fear story or the sad story or the deeply, or the, or the lack of justice
story. Um, so we're not actually trying to exclude anything.
I think my natural orientation is I'm a builder. And I also think that, that, um, despair doesn't
work. I mean, it's paralyzing. So the, the pragmatist in me is much more interested in
how we build. And, and so I guess in that sense, you see my influence in, in what we're doing
with Ted Countdown. Um, yeah. So it's, it's not about, uh,
And Sage, you've got a lot of, there's a lot of Gen Z who are intensely,
intensely negative and they could have gone on your journey. Um, and I'm not going to name any
names. You may know them. I don't know how many of the kind of the, of the, the, the climate
activists of similar age to you, you, you know, and have hung out with, but they've made very
different decisions. And, you know, many of them are embracing degrowth or they're embracing this
kind of, you know, I don't know, the sort of the just stop oil is I find the sunrise movement is
kind of weird because it's called sunrise, but it's actually intensely negative in many of its
outlooks. They've become much more so. Why, why was your, was your journey different because you
just happened to, you happen to look a bit further and a bit deeper or, or is there something about
your personality? Why have you taken a different route?
There's something almost deeply meditative about choosing to be that disciplined and choosing it
over and over again. And don't get me wrong. There are times where I've, where like, you know,
even earlier this year, I was like, I don't think we can do this. And then I read Bill McKibben's
Here Comes the Sun. And I was like, okay, I think we can do this. Great book, by the way, Jesus,
that really brought me back to life. Yeah. There's something quite meditative and it,
and it's been 10 years now that I've thought about climate change every single day. And that's like,
you know, my entire formative life so far. It is isolating. I do have a lot of peers in that sense.
They can hang out in a group in a way that I can't with them. And so I'm trying to build a bigger,
you know, tent and bigger, you know, trying to find more people who are of this cohort and on
this build mentality. But for a long time, it was, I was like, I just, I think actually for a minute,
I was very much like pushed into the activist mold when I started getting a lot more like
recognition, um, and invited to give talks and stuff like that. People were like,
you're a climate activist. And I was like, I guess. And so I, I definitely owned it for like
a solid nine months. I called myself a climate activist and I, you know, met all those people
and I went around and I, um, said some inflammatory things on stages. Um, and it,
it didn't resonate with me over a year for a series of events. Like, like to your point
about chief sustainability officers, I was invited to web summit, the world's largest
summit to give what was my third speech ever to an arena in Lisbon that seats 15,000 people.
Just bizarre. I've had some good, bizarre experiences. And here I am like,
no mentors, nobody's like telling me who and how and what. And I was like, well, what do I want to
talk about? I don't know. I want to talk about the circular economy and I want to talk about
lithium mining and I want to, but I, I just, I said it in the most, you know, in the most, um,
stick it to you kind of way I could. And then that night I got invited by the CEO of the,
of web summit, Catherine Marge. She's wonderful. She's,
she now leads NPR, um, to a dinner. And I was like, oh my God, I'm in trouble. What did I just
do? I'm in trouble with the tech mafia. Oh my God. And you know, this whole day passes. I could make
this story a lot longer, but I'm trying to be succinct here. I was sat between her. She was
wonderful. She was like, so excited to meet the climate people. She like, that was, that's her,
something she's passionate about. She wanted to do this between her and then Melanie Nakagawa of
Microsoft. Oh, she was one of the first like powerful people I met, you know, and, and Microsoft,
um, has historically uniquely empowered third CSO. It's kind of built into the ethos.
of the company. But Melanie was so freaking kind and thoughtful over the last few years in, you
know, taking an hour to get coffee with me after a climate and just explaining things. And she had
all these, you know, about your point about Hannah Ritchie. Sometimes she had, you know, PowerPoint
slides or things that proved me wrong and stuff like that. And, you know, one of the things she
had said that night, which just blew my mind and I think sent me on this learning journey that kind
of made me be like, you know, and to your point, Lindsay, I respect the hell out of and honor every
single theory of change in the sector. And I love the activists and I love what they do. And I think
we need it. But trying to be, but trying to both follow my truth and then also be of the most
service, I think this experience really sent me off into another direction because one, I'm at
this table full of people that includes like the Prince of Luxembourg. And it's, it's slowly
dawning on me that out of everyone in this table, I'm the only person who has enough institutional
power. And the way for me to get any sort of accomplishment done, any progress,
was going to be on these kinds of people thinking that I'm likable, smart, you know, logical,
like have good ideas. And then I'm having this conversation with Melanie and she's like,
oh, well, you know, like I'm, I'm talking to South Korea and Japan about greening their grids,
but if they don't do that, I can't get lower carbon chips. And I was like,
yeah, yeah. I'm, I'm, I'm talking to Japan and South Korea. You, you, you do big things. Wow.
That's quite effective.
Melanie, of course, I met her because she was working with John Kerry when he was secretary
of state. And, and she, she was the liaison when I invited him to speak at Bloomberg New Energy
Finance Summit, which would have been, I don't know, 2016, 17, something like that. So yes,
she's a, she's a, an extraordinary, I mean, if that's your mentor, you're in good hands.
Oh, no, no, no. I mean, Melanie and I, like we, we chat a few, a few times a year, but like,
I do feel like every time I talk to her, she, I learned so much.
Sounds like a mentor to me.
She's brilliant. She's absolutely brilliant. I don't know if she was like, she's a friend,
I guess, but like, I just mean that to say, like, I was so floored by so many of the things I learned
through experiences like that, or COP 28 that year, I was just sort of like sent off on this
journey where I was like, I don't know what I don't know anything I need to learn. And I feel
like that's why I've been sort of in a way, deeply studying the climate sector and all these different
actors and you know, what the gaps are. That's very, very interesting. It does strike me as
being it links to conversations I've had with other people and other environments about almost
like activation points, those points in your career, where I know sliding doors moments where
you've met a certain person had a certain conversation, and it changes what you do.
I want to, I do need to draw this to a close. I want to finish with James. Because there's a point
about optimism. So you've been through the ringer, right? You've you're responsible for cops. It's
your fault that we're all here. And, you know, in some ways, there's plenty of people out there
who will be saying, you know, we've done 31 of them. And we can't even stop emissions growing.
And how do you do you and how do you stay optimistic? Please bring us to bring us to
a conclusion here. Bless you, Michael. Yes, because actually, the short answer is by
seeking the company of those who have an optimistic offer to the solutions. You know,
I mean, entrepreneurs have an optimism bias, right? And I must be one of them, because I've
started lots of organizations. And it's true that being in the process as a negotiator,
it really wears down your spirit. It's hard, it's boring, a lot of it feels inadequate. You know,
you can stay in this for ages and think, well, what have I done? What did I do? I moved a comma,
I changed a subordinate clause, I really, really did well to get the subordinate clause in that
right. But fortunately, the experience of building an enterprise with someone else
can lift your spirit. And it gave me an appreciation of the many different types of power
that you need to bring together in order to make change in the real world.
Even when I practice as a lawyer, I had lots of opportunity to advise,
occasionally opportunity to represent somebody's case in a court, you might win, you might get
a judgment in your favor, but that's within the legal system. It hasn't arrived in the real world
yet. So there's an equivalence between the professional success, negotiating success as a
diplomat. And neither of them actually changed the real world. Whereas there are other enterprises
you can be involved with where the feeling of solving a problem is more direct. And it tends to
be in conjunction with people who make stuff, who build a machine,
or who apply a machine or offer a service, and they tend to find them in enterprises.
So I have drawn satisfaction from being in the story for a long time, because I've met a lot of
other characters in that story, and had an opportunity to work with them and use their
skills and connections and energies to actually fix some things in the real world. I still believe
it's valuable to gather. I still deeply believe in the rule of law. I think it's valuable to
think it's essential. You can't get stuff done, commercial stuff, as well as political stuff done,
unless you have confidence that the rule of law works, that you can confront abuse of power,
that the little guy can actually win against the big guy. But in the end, it's the combination of
powers. It's the different ways one can connect creativity, organization, delivery of an answer
that lifts the spirits. And I'm going to see if I paraphrase, which is, it's a process.
And I think too often we can be at these events thinking, well, if we don't have the answer,
then it's a failure. And I think for me, certainly, it's a process. We're going to be
negotiating or narrating or innovating on climate forever. It's never going to stop.
But as long as we have forward momentum, the bicycle doesn't fall over,
we're actually doing okay. And I find myself, I'm going to be honest, at this COP,
31, I've been to about eight of them. I'm massively more optimistic than most of the
people in those halls. Because I look at it and say, you know, the IEA, International Energy
Agency, has said we're 37% of the useful energy, the energy that drives the economy, is already
electric. And we know that 46%, nearly half of it, is clean, either renewable or nuclear. And
as you know, Lindsay, from the talk, batteries are doubling.
Totally.
Every two years.
Solar every three years, wind every five years. You know, with the forward momentum, in fact,
we've got Chinese emissions are down, flat to down. No, they're down for nearly three years.
And India's are not growing. They're not following the China path.
I mean, it's a fantastic story.
It's a fantastic story.
And what amazes me is that nobody seems to be telling that story in
those halls. They're all busily doing their thing. But nobody's actually saying, do you know what,
we're actually winning. We're actually winning. So they're not doing that.
No. With that optimistic note from four optimists. Let me just wrap this up. So
That was beautifully said, by the way.
Thank you very much. I'd like to thank our guests. We had James Cameron. We had Lindsay Levin. And
we had Sage Lanier. And I'd also like to thank Oscar Boyd, our producer, Jamie Oliver, our video
editor, Kendall Smith, head of operations, the whole team behind Cleaning Up.
Also, very specifically, Lindsay Levin, who lent us Ted Countdown House here in Antalya,
Turkey. I'd also like to thank, of course, our leadership circle, without whom none of this would
be possible. And you, the audience, for spending some time with us here today. So please make sure
that you go to cleaningup.live, sign up for our free newsletter so you never miss an episode.
And please join us this time next week for the next installment of
Cleaning Up.
The members are
Actis, Alcazar Energy, Arup, Climate Imperative Foundation, Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners,
Signum Capital, Davidson Kempner, Ecopragma Capital, EDP, Euroelectric, KKR, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries,
National Grid, Oakland, Octopus Energy, Quadrature Climate Foundation, Schneider Electric, SDCL,
and Wärtsilä. If you're enjoying this episode, please hit like, leave a comment, and also recommend it to friends,
family, colleagues, and absolutely everyone. To browse our archives,
of around 300 past episodes, and to subscribe to our free newsletter, visit cleaningup.live.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The conversation emphasizes the need to shift from fear-based narratives to solution-oriented, hopeful storytelling to inspire action.
TED Countdown uses storytelling and global events to make climate solutions relatable, accessible, and aspirational for everyday people.
A key challenge is the lack of a unified, widely understood model for climate transition, with multiple models (like net zero or degrowth) competing without clear consensus.
Civic engagement and societal participation are crucial, but currently hindered by siloed communities and poor communication between activists, policymakers, and entrepreneurs.
The COP process, while valuable for gathering diverse voices, is often inefficient, bureaucratic, and fails to fully include or empower grassroots actors.
Personal experiences—such as mentorship, cross-sector conversations, and direct engagement with innovators—shape individual pathways from activism to solution-building.
Hope and optimism are sustained through real-world impact, entrepreneurship, and collaboration, not just through legal or political frameworks.
The transition to a sustainable future depends on collective action, shared narratives, and the trust that meaningful change is possible today.
Summary:
The discussion centers on accelerating societal action on climate change by shifting from fear-based narratives to solution-focused, hopeful storytelling. TED Countdown, founded by Lindsay Levin, leverages the reach of TED Talks to highlight practical, everyday climate solutions and foster global collaboration. The speakers emphasize that climate action requires diverse approaches—such as net zero, degrowth, or 100% renewable energy—without needing a single universal model.
A critical gap lies in the lack of visibility and relatability of climate solutions, especially among younger generations who feel disillusioned. Sage Lanier highlights how personal experiences, including mentorship and cross-sector dialogues, transformed her from an activist to a solution-builder. James Cameron underscores the importance of entrepreneurship and real-world impact in sustaining optimism, noting that political negotiations alone are insufficient.
The COP process, while symbolic and valuable, is criticized for inefficiency and siloed participation. Ultimately, the panel agrees that meaningful progress depends on inclusive, well-organized civic engagement, accessible storytelling, and a shared belief that a sustainable future is not only possible but actively being built through innovation, collaboration, and everyday action.
FAQs
TED Countdown focuses on spreading positive, relatable, and solution-oriented narratives about climate change through TED Talks and global events to inspire action and empower everyday people.
Poor storytelling makes climate issues feel overwhelming or distant. Effective narratives connect climate action to everyday life, making it relatable, aspirational, and actionable for the general public.
Collaboration is essential—bringing together diverse voices, industries, and perspectives fosters innovation and ensures that climate solutions are inclusive, practical, and broadly supported.
It suggests that climate transition happens not by banning fossil fuels, but by growing clean energy solutions until they naturally outcompete outdated systems, creating a more sustainable and resilient economy.
Different models (like net zero, degrowth, or 100% renewables) serve different audiences and contexts. A variety of models allows for flexibility, prevents consensus fatigue, and reflects the complexity of real-world transitions.
By focusing on tangible benefits—like lower costs, improved health, and better jobs—climate solutions can be framed as positive, everyday improvements rather than just environmental fixes.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.