Speaker 1Jangan lupa SUBSCRIBE, LIKE, KOMEN dan SHARE. ^^ Welcome to Books in the Freezer, a podcast dedicated to the
Speaker 2deliciously disturbing world of horror fiction I'm your host Stephanie and today I am joined by author Sarah Langan to talk about her latest novel Tradwife and tradwives and horror so welcome to the show
Speaker 3thank you glad to be
Speaker 2here I'm so excited to have you here we went through a lot of bumps to get this going this is like our third attempt we had connection issues the first two times so I'm like it's not cursed it's it's working now no
Speaker 3i'm i'm really glad i was i was have been looking forward to talking to you
Speaker 2i have been looking forward to it too you're definite this is definitely not your first mention on the podcast but it's your first time being
Speaker 3a guest no i really i feel like for good neighbors didn't we or did we just meet i think
Speaker 2we met but i've definitely talked about good neighbors and a better world but do you want to tell our listeners a little bit about your book
Speaker 3wife okay so uh it is about a journalist who's been cancelled by a group called the brotherhood of the american agenda for writing this confessional essay and she had hoped to be a serious journalist but that is not the path that exists anymore at least for someone like her and so she she wrote this essay that you know it wasn't her her best moment and it went viral and now she's in this very vulnerable position where she's been fired because of political pressure at her job which is like kind of a lowbrow vanity fair magazine which is also going to fold eventually and what she's supposed to do next her former boss approaches her and says you know i have a great idea why don't you interview this specific viral trad wife who loves your writing and thinks it would be literary catnip just to have you cover her whether it's good publicity or bad and she's conflicted because she doesn't want to be platforming this but she ultimately decides to do it because she thinks that this trad wife is a phony like a serious phony and then she goes out to the farm and becomes worried about this woman because the trad wife asks her for help asks her to stay and now she's in this position of feeling like if she prints something it could hurt this woman and she doesn't know the extent of the hurt and she doesn't quite know what's going on and so uh she agrees to go live on the farm for a week and then this this all-out horror story starts
Speaker 2i was telling you off mic earlier i love this book it is said to be one of my favorites this year i felt like there was just so much to think about and so many interesting characters but i wanted to know like how did you find out about the trad wife phenomenon like did you ever watch one or did you hear about them like what was your history with them as a cultural thing so i
Speaker 3heard about it on the soccer field you know like the parents are all standing around for like hours during the soccer games and one of the moms was kind of sort of um enthralled and disgusted at the same time and walked me through what a trad wife was and honestly i didn't really pay much more attention to it but then i had you know childhood friends uh that i'd grown up with told me that they were watching trad wives and they were ordering the products you know because i come from a more conservative place that was interesting And then I just thought, like, so it sort of gelled for me just in the way that there's been a real conservative backlash against women. The overturn of Roe v. Wade, I think, has not been discussed. It's not in popular culture. I feel like people are afraid to talk about it. Also, I live in Hollywood, and I remember having a meeting with a woman, a producer, two years ago. And I said, you know, I have the story, I described it to her, not Tradwife, a different story. And she said, you know, women are overrepresented right now in TV. We're really looking for a more muscular programming. And this was, you know, like a big head honcho. And I was like, looking at her, we were on a Zoom, and she wasn't being sarcastic. I was like, how deeply do you have to crawl up your own asshole to have that bias? And it's just like, this is what's selling. Listen, dummy, we're not telling that story anymore because people don't want to hear it. And I get that, but I also think that there's different ways to tell stories. And I also am very sure that this is also coming from a system that rewards financially conservative stories. And so I was like, this is, this is it. Like, this is this, like, it's, it's the accumulation of all of these themes that I've been thinking about into two words, Tradwife. And so I was like, I want to write this. And I think it might get attention because it's called Tradwife. I may have been wrong given there's five other books called Tradwife at this point, which is not my favorite thing. And but, you know, no shade on them. There's a lot of great books out there. But that was what I was thinking.
Speaker 2I am still stuck on that as a statement. I don't know how I would be able to process that in real time. I mean, you go to like the Paramount app and it is all like Yellowstone properties. like spy thrillers like what are we talking
Speaker 3about that's what's selling people are tired you know it's the post-covid like shit got too crazy we just need to like you know the Archie Bunker song girls were girls and men were men you know it's like we just need to be that just shut up and toe the line there's it's French revolution out there it's too wild we're not going to get any changes made if we do that and um i think they're wrong you know i think i think we can we can tell honest stories without hurting anybody or whatever we can we we can tell honest stories that's where
Speaker 2yeah i mean i think you're right about this being us not properly dealing with lockdown and kovid because i feel like that's when we got the like cottagecore we're all at home baking sourdough and really falling into this fantasy of like what if i didn't have to have a nine to five what if i could just do this all day but that's also a lie like anyone who's been a stay-at-home mom or it's so
Speaker 3any guy knows
Speaker 2you're not vibing and relaxing in like a beautiful apron that's no
Speaker 3no no not at all and it's um i think tova mervis wrote a book a few years ago i forget the name of it but about all these women in new york who have kids and they can't leave their houses they just can't leave their houses and like the denouement is they all get to leave their houses and it's like a celebration you know yeah it's like oh my god i was stuck in there for so long and it's it's um so this notion that it's uh idyllic is insane absolutely well
Speaker 2i guess we can talk about your thoughts on the kind of explosion of them into like the bigger cultural discussion and then i don't know if you've been keeping up with the big names in the tradwife movement but i feel like a lot of them are kind of distancing themselves from that label
Speaker 3now yeah yeah i think they are um i think that you know it's not a good look these books are out and you know of course you would the model is make money right so if the word tradwife in your instagram isn't making money anymore call yourself a home business ceo which i think is probably more accurate i did a lot of research on like multi-level marketing and pyramid schemes and like Amway and Mary Kay there's like this great website, like Pink something or other, about people who used to be reps for Mary Kay, all just like venting, because it's such a predatory business. And there's some women who are fantastic at selling, but the majority are really not comfortable endlessly selling products to their friends, and then, you know, leveraging friendships to get more friends to get more friends so they can sell product. And then the bigger problem with this stuff is often these women who sell sell the products, they're not making as much money from sales as they are from indoctrinating new members. Yeah, who buy those products and then have to sell them. And you get under a tremendous social pressure for for returning products. And it's just I don't know if you've experienced this, but like, so many women who have kids, they are trying to make some money at home, and they fall in love with the products that they're selling. And so I'll pray to this, like, I just an insane amount of women in my life, I've had like, email me, like, be a part of this, be a part of that, be a part of this. And it's like, this is just hurtful in some way to this person. So anyway, there's that, you know, there's what that role does. And then on top of that, there's like this trad wife idea of what they're selling is, is I'm gonna have love. And this is what it looks like. And this is what you should do. And I mean, it's not a mistake, but so many of them are Mormons, Mormons, a lot of the job is you're supposed to be indoctrinating others into this way of life. It's not necessarily bad. But as anybody's parents will tell them when they get married, make sure you have a little money of your own. You know, like, it's not, this is not how you go into something equal, to give everything up. Because at some point, you'll look around and say, like, I'm not making the decisions anymore, because they don't make any of the money.
Speaker 2But yes, I definitely saw that with MLMs and the way they specifically prey on stay at home moms that, you know, for whatever reason, can't work outside of the home, because, you know, they can't pay for childcare, they might be isolated, and not have that community that they can lean on for childcare. So you know, they present this as an option, and it ends up being extremely predatory.
Speaker 3Yeah, it completely is. And I mean, it's kind of a proxy for me. I'm not necessarily talking about trad wives. And I think it's easy to think I'm talking about Hannah Nealman. And in some ways, like the portrays herself is, I think, really appealing, and sort of like the jumping off place is. But I'm not, you know, I don't think she does multi-level marketing, like my character does. And I don't think, I don't know, like, how much research have I done into her. And then you look at the other one, Nara Smith. And I remember looking at a few videos of her and thinking, like, honestly having concern. And I thought, like, I don't want, like, this woman seems unstable. And I don't want someone being upset by something I've written. So I really need to be careful. And I think, like, I don't want someone being upset by something I've written. about what is identifiable or whatever. And then I saw her on Project Runway this season. And I was like, she's not unstable. This has all been a game. She has been gaming the system. And I should just laugh and be impressed. And my daughter was like, yeah, no, she's great. She's making fun of it. She's just making fun of it. This is not real. And I was like, okay, so there's an internet literacy question. But, you know, I don't know. I don't think it's a good question. I don't think it's there's a danger. I guess what I'm saying is there's a danger in seeing women as fragile and needing to be protected. And that's its own kind of bias that's false. You know, I think women have agency. They're strong. This isn't, you know, this pernicious, we're all going to be destroyed by the trad wives. No, it's ridiculous. But there's this other issue to me, which is, is that the platforms push their content. And like, why? And why? First, it's making them richer. Second, I don't think the trad wives, there's a lot of them out there. Who's making money? Like, just like any multi-level marketing scheme, just the top. And then everybody else is just putting a lot of energy into giving the platform money. And then the platform is taking everything away from them. It's like pushing and pushing this, like, polarized view of gender. And at the same time, you know, if, if there's TikToks of women coming up and saying, like, hey, this is where you need to go to get an abortion in your state. If it's not legal, here's some steps. Or this is what you need to do about ICE. Those are getting hidden by those same platforms. And so there, it's not random. There's really a bad thing going on. My accent it's not just this idea of like, these people are bad. These people are good. Like, I fully, I like when women make their own money. I'm behind it. I just wish, I'd like it not to be a zero-sum
Speaker 2game. I know Nara Smith is on now saying that, yeah, it was a performance and I never called myself a trad wife. But if you do go back to the videos, she did use, you know, hashtag trad wife. So, oh, she fully did.
Speaker 3Yeah. Like she leaned into it.
Speaker 2And now I, I feel like she wants to distance herself and be like, well, I was a model. Like, why would you think that that would be me? That's on you, silly goose.
Speaker 3But it kind of is, you know, it's like, this is all BS, right? It's all BS, but people believe this.
Speaker 2They do, you
Speaker 3know, and someone performing that they have less agency, that they want less agency and that you will be happy is not doing you any favors. That's the scariest thing to me is like, you don't know what you don't know. And that, uh, we can have all these taken for granted realities of our place in the world and they're, they've made us smaller and we don't know it and we're reinforcing it in ourselves and in others. And so like the big theme of trad wife is everyone's calling Jenny Kaplan self and, um, women are expected to survive. Not as well.
Speaker 2Yeah. There was a scene where Jenny is confronted by her ex-boyfriend about how she's going to be a trad wife. And she's like, I don't know, I don't know how he's portrayed in her piece, uh, that, you know, comes to be called Drano and kind of wants her to apologize for the things she said. And like, kind of ask her, like, did she ever think about how he would feel about this? And I remember thinking like, oh my gosh, I would immediately go into people pleaser mode and she doesn't. And I was like, oh, okay. Okay. All of my
Speaker 3beta readers were like, we'd like her better if she apologized. And I was like, I don't, I don't care. Um, like I don't, I think she thinks this is her job. I think she thinks like I have a right to tell what happened to me in my life. And I shouldn't feel bad about that. And I'll tell a story. It just occurred to me, you know, and I just put it together now, but so I wrote a piece about a and it was accepted as the first modern love piece for the New York times. Wow. And I gave it to the guy and I said, is this okay? And he said, no, absolutely not. And he also was like, you know, you're always going to be a bigger writer than me. And the way people know me is through a Wikipedia article about how badly I behaved. You know, it's not that big a deal. So I pulled it. Love piece. Um, not because it wasn't true because it wasn't going to hurt somebody's ego. It's not so different. This idea of like, I was selfish if I'd gone through with it, it was really internalized with me.
Speaker 2Um, you did it right through Johnny then.
Speaker 3Yeah, no, I it's, I, it didn't occur to me before. Um, and the thing is, I always, it's hard to know what's selfish and what's not, but I don't think, um, that it's the same thing with the abortion. You know, why, why is, I
Speaker 2mean, one thing I do love about Johnny as a character is how serious of a journalist she is. You know, this was a dream she had. And unfortunately, she's a journalist in the age where journalism is dying. And so she gets fired for that piece, essentially, because the conservative, uh, owners of the paper aren't fans of it. And so she gets this like freelance opportunity to go and do this piece, but everything is. I feel like at the whims of the algorithm, like it's very much like, uh, Ooh, they switch places. Look at this clickbait. Check out this feminist who spent seven days being a trad wife.
Speaker 3Well, I mean, I think I was self-consciously referring to myself writing the book too, which was like, I felt like the book would get attention because of the name and the subject matter, but I wasn't really talking about trad wives. I was trying to talk about a larger system and I was conflicted by it. And I think Jenny is too. And I think it's this, damned if you do, obscure if you don't. I interviewed several journalists and majority have left the industry and they come out to Hollywood or whatever because that job doesn't exist anymore. And one of the guys I talked to said, it is a ladder going down. And one day I woke up and I was 40 and I was making less money and doing more work that I didn't want to be doing because it follows the algorithm now instead of the news. So it's been, it's like genuine, general in shitification and sort of following that and following like, what are the choices available in this system?
Speaker 2Absolutely. And I think everyone in the book is very nuanced. You know, Mia is such an interesting character and I don't feel like at any point you're talking bad about her or looking down at what she does, even when Jenny is there with her. And we do see her kind of through Jenny's sister's eyes first, who's a fan and kind of explains like, you know, I feel like she really gets me. Like I'm going through a lot and I just, I feel that connection.
Speaker 3Yeah. I mean, there's, there's a way that it works, you know, two levels. And the first is just, you know, there's, there's the lie of like, I see you when you don't see the person. You just want their business. And then there's the truth, which is that it's really hard to be seen when you become a mother, because suddenly you're sort of, you're completely sidelined. And I truly didn't know, because I'm like thick headed, how deep sexism was until I, after I had kids, I thought, well, there's some crap you put up with, but if you push hard enough, you get what you want. And then I was like, oh no, this is so much bigger than I realized. And it's, it's, it's a completely different vantage point to be looking through the world while pushing a stroller, usually with somebody else strapped to you. And then, you know, trying to make something on time for work, which is impossible to do. Not impossible, but hard. It is hard. So, you know, I think Melissa's point, Jenny's sister, is really strong, which is like, this is the Phyllis Schlafly of my life, who says I have value, who says I'm important, who says the work I do is important. And all of these things are completely true. I mean, like not to, you know, like diet is really important and cooking fresh food is really important for health. And if that's the job, that in itself is a big deal that no one talks about. And this is like my, my, I loved my dad so much. He died and I got all of his paintings and you're seeing them that they're, some of them are completely insane. So I love dining room, except this is my husband, a needle point of a clown that his
Speaker 2grandma did. I love it. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I, as I mentioned earlier, it was raised in kind of this very anti-feminist strict gender roles religion. So yeah, it's something I definitely struggle with and kind of like buck up against this, like idea that these Phyllis Schlafly types do want to like still use the umbrella of feminism and that like, we're all girls in this together. And I'm like, are we though?
Speaker 3Yeah. It's like the last thing you want to do is go after another woman because they, you know, it makes it easy for the system. We took each other out, but at the same time, it's like, what are these values that are being upheld and who's being sold out? And are we all just doing it for the buck? But I also think, so I was raised conservatively Catholic and it's just bewildering. You know, I don't know if you were the special daughter. I was the special daughter. Right. I was the exception, you know, but it, it holds it, it, that holds sustains you for only so long. Right. Then what
Speaker 2do you mean by the special daughter?
Speaker 3Oh, I could, I could get a job. I could be a writer. Like they were like, yeah, we're behind you on this. We think you're the exception. Right. Um, and so I went into life believing that, which was a nice narrative for me, but I remember calling my dad and telling him that I was pregnant. And it was just like this 10 minute pause or 10 second pause. And he goes, um, well, what about your career? And I was like, I don't know. And it was like, this is over now. Now you're a mother. The whole system is engineered. Like you made a choice here and I did, and I'm glad I made it. I wouldn't undo it, um, for the world, but it was my choice, but it was also everyone around me was like, and no, I'm not going to do that. I'm not going to do that. And now your childhood is done. Like you're not that anymore. You are this new role. Yeah. Um, and I think on top of that, this idea of specialness that I think is, is common. It also doesn't let you see the truth, which is that, you know, anytime I was hit on and by someone in authority, I thought it was because I was special, right. Yeah. As opposed to it being, they hit on everybody. And actually, it's not cool. It doesn't prove anything about me other than I was in a nut. I was in a circumstance where that was going to happen because I'm female.
Speaker 2And it's a tactic they use because it works, you know, and it's awful. Well, should we talk about some movies that kind of have these themes, these trad wife themes?
Speaker 3You know, yes. You mentioned a few, I wanted to, bring up, um, hereditary too. Oh, okay. Well, it's not, it's not trad wife themed, but I think it's the same vibe very much. Um, and I remember watching it the first time being like, oh, now I know why people get mad at me all the time. Like I get it. Cause I'm mad at this movie a little bit. Like it's such a mean sense of humor. Um, but I think, I think sometimes there's a little bit of that. I think there's a little bit of that in trad. I could see that.
Speaker 2Yeah. I was trying to think of movies that had like themes similar to like the, the trad wife idea. And I guess the first one I thought of was Stutford wives. I think that was the first one I ever watched where I was like, oh my God, I completely understand this on like an emotional cellular level. And it's supposed to be like a satire. Like imagine if men wanted to do this. And I'm like, no, it's not a satire to me. I feel it.
Speaker 3It's not, it's not, it's this idea of like, I'm not sure what satire means. It's applied so liberally that it feels like, you know, light, silly things are satire, but then Stutford wives is satire. But then it's like, what's not satire at this point. I don't know. But yeah, I loved the Stutford wives. I mean, it's hokey. Uh, but the book, uh, has just a higher level of suspense. I feel like than the movie does movies like really pretty and a little campy and a little funny, but the book, even though they're almost identical, that ending of the book is straight up terrifying. Um, and her trying to flee and it's like going door to door and discovering that everybody is against her, which is a lot like not it's that Nathaniel Hawthorne story. That's not young Goodman Brown. It's like the guy goes to, um, he travels to the city to live with his uncle. Who's like, um, a colonial governor and he goes from door to door and they won't tell him what their colonial governor is. And then finally the colonial governor is being paraded down the street, tarred and feathered. It's great. It's like super grotesque. Um, yeah, yeah. It's this, this idea of like in the day people are one way. And in the night people are another way. And I think whenever there's hypocrisy, hypocrisy, which is like whenever there's more than two people in a community, uh, you have hypocrisy. There's this feeling of day world and night world, you know, the ending of Rosemary's baby. I very much thought about the structurally the same way that I thought about trad wife, which is like, there's, there's multiple endings and you have Rosemary, Rosemary has figured out what's going on and tries to get out of it. And that's like the first ending. And then the second ending is that she has the baby and doesn't get out of it. That's the second ending. The third ending is she hears and figures out the baby's still alive. Then she's out there. And then she has the final ending, which is she takes the baby back. And it's on one level, it's empowerment. And then the other level, that's why it's a horror story. because she's agreed to become Satan's mother. despite these monsters and because of them i mean the scene
Speaker 2where she kind of figures out that everyone isn't on it against her her ob-gyn is part of it and she's being like isolated from her friends oh
Speaker 3that guy is responsible yes
Speaker 2ira levin was really on like writing terrible dudes
Speaker 3yes and cassavetes just was great i also had pleasantville
Speaker 2on here which not a horror movie and not really about trad wives but i saw it when i was a kid and i think it was my first introduction to like maybe the idealized world of the 1950s even though in this case it is like a fictional world might not be all it's cracked
Speaker 3up to be i loved pleasantville i loved it i don't know why that's not like the movie people talk about like that was such a fun movie
Speaker 2i love it all
Speaker 3the time i took a film
Speaker 2class and i remember writing about it for one of my papers i was like more people need to talk about this movie
Speaker 3and like joan allen and her like falling in love with the guy and finally they're
Speaker 2being color and she's in color yes i haven't seen night bitch but i did read the book several years ago but i think that also gets to this like angst of being a mother and wife in this uh modern society that i think we're touching on a bit i
Speaker 3read night bitch and yeah i think i think that subject matter is really similar and it's still and it's got a sense of humor it does i really liked about it don't worry
Speaker 2darling which very you know in conversation with the stutford wives but i would say kind of with the modern layer of the modern society of incel culture that we have to worry about now you know what
Speaker 3i haven't seen it and i really like to because i love olivia wilde um and when i wrote a better world that was the comp some of the producers were coming up with so i should just read it because we must be in the same wheelhouse
Speaker 2yeah i'd be interested to hear your thoughts on it all right well should we talk about some books
Speaker 3yeah yeah i brought a stack down to the garage with me and that's where they are do you remember
Speaker 2what they were
Speaker 3you 're talking about no um i brought let's see uh i pulled out oh the ecstatic victor laval's first book
Speaker 2oh i don't know that
Speaker 3one it feels there's a lot of similarities in the tone of like people behaving in ways that they don't understand um but the reader understands and i think there's like a a little bit of a comedy in that but it's also horror um i love that book the ecstatic what's it about a kid growing up in the bronx um and his he's dropped out of cornell and hasn't told his family and moved home and is back with his sister and best friend and is morbidly obese and kind of can't figure his way out of things and what i remember most about the book was i thought victor this is so good um is they're in a movie theater and his best friend is trying to like hook up with his sister and he doesn't know himself why he does this but he goes and pulls the fire alarm and then nobody knows he did it and it's like oh he didn't want his he's so unable to express what he wants but he can't stand the idea of his sister with this jerk best friend of his so that's how he handles it it's really good oh i'll
Speaker 2have to check it out i love you all of the victor lavelle books that i've read my first book was accumulation i
Speaker 3haven't read that yet and we have the same agent so it makes sense it could be
Speaker 2similar i would say there's an interesting like theme it's exploring but i think you guys are doing very different things uh so this is by amy pakwatka this came out earlier this year and it's about a woman named uh ten who relocates for her husband's job and kind of as a consolation prize not really but like you know they buy this beautiful victorian house of her dreams and it is an understanding that he has this very demanding job and he's going to be gone a lot like there's a possible promotion in the works and that she as kind of the like artist in the relationship you know the unspoken understanding that like your job is more flexible so like you're picking up the child care duties and dealing with the kids and the house and you're like you're like you're like you're like you're like stuff it becomes this like haunted house story where the house is being weird the relationship with the kids is weird like they start acting weird um there's people getting locked in the attic uh you know things stop working but i remember texting my friend anna when i was reading this i'm like the part that sent me the most dread was that she's interviewing for a job and she gets that like she sees that uh elementary school number pop up on her phone and i'm like oh the dread the dread of like no not the call from the school not right now i can't do this right
Speaker 3now yeah yeah and you don't know if it's like no they were late for this class or if it's like they peed their pants and started screaming you need to come here you
Speaker 2need to come here now and take care of this um but i would say like night bitch it is about the ways that that accumulates and you know the husband is not a bad character he is not evil it's just you know pretty soon more and more just get it starts getting put on your plate it's just assumed you're going to be the person that's going to take care of this and then that becomes all you have time for and what does that mean for you yeah yeah i
Speaker 3wasn't taught and i think most women were not to just discuss that before you get married like just to have a conversation like it's just like we don't know how to ask for raises we also don't know how to or like advocate for a good job we also don't know how to be like so these are my lines this is what i really want this is what i feel should things should look like what do you think they should look like nobody i know talked
Speaker 2about that no and it's just i feel like tough i mean as a millennial working mom i think it's just tough in the modern day you know you work a full-time job and they say like millennial dads out of like all the dads in history are spending like the most time with their kids they're the most involved and it's still hard well
Speaker 3the thought that's the weird thing is like every generation is spending more time with its kids than it ever has before and you kind of have to go is that good like i don't know like i do wonder i it feels excessive it feels very big brother to me um i remember when we were driving across the country we packed the kids in the car and we drove from brooklyn to los angeles about 10 years ago and we stopped at a park in colorado and kids were going wild in this park i thought it was amazing it was the coolest thing i'd ever seen and a lot of them were by themselves which was even cooler because in brooklyn you could have the police called on you if a child were uh alone in a park you know someone would be like this is neglect i'm calling the cops and then while we were there police showed up and uh this dad had been in the bathroom with the baby and had to now talk his way out of the police you know giving him some kind of record because he wasn't on the playground like someone had called the police and when you live in a system uh that's not helpful that's not a nice thing to do you're not trying to help anybody yeah you didn't go hang out with that kid you didn't see what they were up to and if you had you would have found out that their parent was in the bathroom you just called the cops and you know like this whole like you read the articles about people whose kids aren't allowed to walk home from school because the cops get called and so there's this incredible pressure on us to be with them all the time at the expense of their ability to socialize with people their own age and it's i think it's bad i think it makes for nervous kids and so yeah i mean that's my little aside but i just you know and then it's sort of opens the door to these judgy judies who usually don't have kids of their own and are like nursing wounds and anger they have about their own childhoods and then they've got to come up and tell you how to do it and you're like you know you can be helpful or you can keep walking these are the options but they're not the options in the system we have
Speaker 2yeah no so yeah that was accumulation by amy pakwatka all
Speaker 3right i can't wait to read it sorry for that sidetrack amy who was great and i'm looking forward to reading it i say this a lot but i really love kat ward's work um i thought the neverland book was really cool that she just came out with and i think um i'd still always recommend needless street and i don't know how related they are but i do think we're both kind of playing with the form and uh trying to look at things in a different way i would
Speaker 2agree i still haven't read her her neverland book but i've heard really good things yeah i
Speaker 3mean it's wild and weird uh and i think that's how you i think that's how cool stuff happens as a writer
Speaker 2yeah my next book is lady of the house by grace reynolds which is a horror poetry collection yeah so it's about obviously this fictional tale of a lady who was a 1940s riveter turned housewife trapped in a loveless marriage and societal framework that made it difficult for her to abandon her current circumstances and this is i want to say like fun because it's like female rage with like a 1950s apron like making a pie but it is a about a part of history that i get really angry when i think about and it is that like post-world war ii the men are coming back from war like the women were working and holding down jobs until the men came back home and they were pushed out of the places they used to work and expected to be at home and provide a sense of normalcy and you know perpetuate a certain post-war america for these men coming back that didn't want women in the places where they were working their jobs as they saw i want
Speaker 3you know i wonder how people will look up back on these times because they do feel very regressive i'm yeah that sounds really interesting i'm still stuck on the abortion thing i'm like why doesn't anyone why is no one talking about roe v wade got overturned like it's been years and everyone's still like don't talk about it someone might get mad i don't get it i just don't yeah
Speaker 2i don't know i mean i feel like this is a time we're definitely gonna look back on with this um but i i really liked this as uh a poetry collection of like a woman who's been kind of placed in this role against her will and i don't know you're just kind of rooting for her if you like an unhinged woman which you know that's its own genre but if you want like unhinged woman poetry collection in the 1940s this is a good one all right all
Speaker 3right no that sounds really good um i was thinking of uh the bus on tuesday or the bus on thursday i read that years
Speaker 2ago did you
Speaker 3okay and i feel like shirley hazard is the name of the book i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know it yeah the bus on thursday shirley barrett shirley barrett yeah that's her name again it's not like obviously about i mean there's no trad wife in it or there's no like um she's not married but it's sort of this slow pull into insanity um that's fun and wild and grotesque in every way and she's like a teacher and she's in charge of kids but she's so inappropriate and then the town is everyone is sort of aggressive and weird i think it's australian which makes sense because there's that crazy australian movie like wake and fright that also feels similar to that oh so wake and fright is like this guy who's a teacher um and is making like no money and he's gonna have to work for another 10 years or something to pay off his loans travels to this town and and like by gambling loses all his money and can't leave and gets stuck in this like cyclical heavy drinking killing kangaroos insanity in this town and like how is he gonna get out but also like he's so messed up now can he get out it's so nuts um yeah australians he's so messed up he's so messed up he's so messed up and he's so messed up he's so messed up
Speaker 2i remember really loving the bus on thursday and i don't feel like people talk about it much but i feel like it was early like it would i feel like if it was released now in our like weird girl lit unhinged woman it would do really well i think this is what people need to check out i think blew under
Speaker 3the radar it did it was
Speaker 2before it hit before the trend it was early it's great
Speaker 3it's like she's um recovered from the pandemic and she's like oh my god i'm gonna die i'm gonna die from breast cancer treatment yeah she takes this job doesn't know anyone yeah it's like after a
Speaker 2breakup it's her fresh start and she's very much like i'm gonna be in this town i'm gonna like be a teacher and meet a cute guy and like life's finally gonna
Speaker 3go my way it's just like oh no oh my next
Speaker 2book was uh the devil and mrs davenport uh by paulette kennedy i really loved this one this is set in 1950s missouri and follows a woman named loretta davenport who from the outset like lives a pretty picture-perfect life her husband is a bible college professor and a local girl is murdered and subsequently loretta starts receiving what she thinks are these like psychic visions and her husband is chalking this up too you know female hysteria and wants her to just focus on being a housewife and not bother with these like weird things that she's seeing but she starts to hone in on these visions and her husband does not like that i really liked this book it felt very shirley jackson in the way it was examining like this era of domesticism and isolation i love that book yeah yeah like she has even this like nebby which is a very like pittsburgh world word like this very nosy neighbor who's like also checking in on her and making sure like she stays in line i
Speaker 3feel like it kind of in an oblique way was addressing the enormous fantasy lives of women uh at that time just why why were weepy romances so big why were soap operas just becoming um big and it was it was this notion of the dream was the only way they had of uh escape like you know walter mitty should have been a lady
Speaker 2but it's also like a very i mean it's at times frightening when you know her husband starts dealing with her but i think over time she's like oh my god she's like oh my god she's like oh my god she's like oh my god she's like oh my god she's like oh my god she's like oh my god she's like a beautiful story about a woman like coming into her own power and like believing in herself and like pushing through so i absolutely love that that is the devil and mrs davenport so what's your next pick
Speaker 3um you know what i just finished walter tavis's man he fell to earth and i mean it's not there's the journey of the martian has a lot in common with jenny's journey let's say that now i'm interested it's it's great i love this book i love walter tavis i think he's terrific um but it's this idea of uh yeah someone who um discovers their humanity
Speaker 2i love that i also wanted to talk about or at least mention house of beth by carrie collin oh i don't
Speaker 3know this one this was a debut
Speaker 2novel that i believe came out last year but it's about a woman who has harm ocd and just one day she kind of quits her new york job kind of blows up her life moves back home to new jersey you but then that's also unstable like her parents are selling the house and she's kind of really stuck and she meets up with her old high school friend who is uh has recently become a widower and they start spending time together and just kind of on a whim they get married and she becomes like stepmother homeschool teacher to his daughters and they're kind of like isolated home as she's taken on this role she starts to feel the presence of or like be influenced by his late wife beth who was like the ideal housewife and i know it sounds very rebecca and that was my thought when i read this but it really ends up going such a different way and i thought it was such an interesting debut but i also found it really interesting to read this book because i think it's really interesting that it is this directionless aimless young woman who kind of sees this as a relief like oh finally i have like a purpose and a place to land and then realizes like you know this might be more than she signed up for all anybody wants
Speaker 3when you're a woman is to see you settled yeah so you you're like oh i guess i need to be settled and settled means you know living in a house yeah with a man who has a job that's settled and then you're like oh i guess i need to be settled and settled means you know living in a house yeah with a man who has a job that's
Speaker 2settled well it's also interesting because she suffers from this harm ocd where her you know her brain is constantly telling her that she's done these terrible things
Speaker 3oh that's a tough one so she also kind
Speaker 2of is struggling with this idea of like can I even trust myself I'm constantly telling myself like no you didn't do these things like don't that's not true and then you really as you explore the late wife Beth's character who was kind of born and groomed for that lifestyle she's such a fascinating and tragic character and I just really love everything Carrie Cullen did
Speaker 3with this that sounds
Speaker 2amazing yeah that is House of Beth by Carrie Cullen
Speaker 3Cat Person Kristen Rapinian it's a fun one oh so it's a collection of stories uh Cat Person went viral and um it's just this uh sort of weird girl mono wad kind of voice yeah yeah that I highly recommend and actually to go with that recommend Out There by Kate Folk she wrote Sky Daddy uh which is a novel I really like this one better I like Sky Daddy a lot but Out There is is a collection of short stories that um interconnect so it's it's a wild pleasure I I thought it was terrific I'll have to check those
Speaker 2out those sound like right up my alley I also had Comfort Me with Apples by Catherine Valente on here it has been a wild since I've read this but I remember when I watched Don't Worry Darling I've I felt like this was the closest comparison to that and kind of reality with like a tinge of surreality and it's got this like Stepford Wives Edenic society that I thought was really interesting and I remember it being a short book but I thought it was worth a mention on this
Speaker 3episode I'm out of recommendations but I I would say Wilder Girls I just liked it I don't think it's similar but I liked it and I think her other book was really fun too what was her name Rory Power Rory Power those were fun
Speaker 2books they were I don't actually I only read Wilder Girls I don't think I read her other one but I did have fun with it yeah and then I still haven't read Saratoga Schaefer's Child Wife I've heard very good things I've heard it's bonkers in like a fun way and I did read Yesteryear by Carol Clare Burke which I feel like has been very divisive I personally liked it but a lot of people that I know and love did not and I respect that I think my personal upbringing I am set to like it more and relate to certain parts of it and I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I know people are saying it is mean-spirited and okay I think it has its place in the ecosystem in the like media landscape within this conversation yeah
Speaker 3I mean it's it's hard for me to say because what I'd say is like if they weren't all these three books weren't about trad wives they would not have that much in common yeah you know so it's like uh yeah yeah they're really different books all three of them they are
Speaker 2very different and I know Carol Clare Burke is like a culture internet culture like podcaster so I think she was very interested in the phenomenon of tradwifery as it may be so I I think it's good for what it is which is like you know book club debut lit fig that is kind of hitting the major points of the conversation you're
Speaker 3right it does hit the major points of the conversation that's definitely true and I think
Speaker 2yeah like as we were mentioning earlier I think you know these books coming out I think have played a role in the kind of pivot away from the title
Speaker 3yeah I mean but it'll be taken over by something else this is you know are we going to go back to the book club
Speaker 2back to like Sheryl Sandberg Lena and Girl Boss I
Speaker 3mean I doubt it uh just because those aren't the talking points that people are happy about right now what they're happy about is is the notion like I mean we have a guy on in the administration who doesn't want women in the military so uh they're really pushing some some bad stuff out there it's not so bad to take out bad stuff out there it's not so bad to take out bad stuff out there it's not so bad to take out tradwives I mean obviously that's some of what I'm doing with my book but it's a it's a wave and it's not just about tradwives and it's real yeah
Speaker 2I think tradwife did a very good job of really showing the insidiousness of kind of the larger system and ecosystem that it's all a part of and I meant to ask you earlier because but uh like Mia is not the the kind of religious framework within a tradwife was really interesting I'm trying to talk around it and not be spoilery but you know it goes a different direction it's not like American evangelicalism
Speaker 3no no um but I think I there was I was trying to make a point about religion which is like yeah it can it can say anything so there is this religion in tradwife but it's also like as a as someone who was raised Catholic I'm very suspicious of religion just because I was raised to be suspicious of it you know there's like the book speaks I wish I could I could explain it better without saying too much but there's there's a whole religion in the book that I made up that um I think fits the story I'd
Speaker 2agree um and there was a commonality in some of these books that when you start to like dig deeper into the like husbands sometimes they are a little incompetent or wanting and it just reminded me of this tiktok I saw where someone was you know criticizing one of these tradwives for making this book and they were like I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know a video where she's baking and talking about how you need to submit to your husband and you know that's the natural order of things and someone said do you notice how they always say like your husband because if she said like you need to submit to Kyle or Cody you just couldn't take that seriously
Speaker 3like listen to that sentence that's really funny yeah I mean that's weird the whole thing is weird no it's um I've spoke to a woman who was a trad wife and it was insidious it was really hard for her to get out of it and the entire system tried to pull her back in the community tried to pull her back in a husband went from adoring to abusive it's like the minute you say no you're in a lot of trouble yeah I mean it's reinforcing you can see why someone would say I guess I'm going to stay in this but then you have like um yeah no I spoke with a lot of uh people you know I did a fair amount of research and there's all these small side underground railroads for women that exist to get them out around the world and uh there's a need for them yeah
Speaker 1absolutely um and
Speaker 2then I had another question I know that you have a degree in your master's degree was in like environmental science yeah
Speaker 3with a specialty in toxicology yes
Speaker 2and I know in like a better world and good neighbors there's kind of this environmental horror going on I was going to say in the background of good neighbors and then at the forefront of a better world but in trad wife we do have this yellow fog so was that a little bit of that as well or was that not a
Speaker 3yeah I mean it's always fun to try and give a reasonable explanation for why something's happening that in fact may be uncanny uh to just to play around with it and I think that's a good plan with it but there is a town um that has a yellow fog I forget where it is and that actually is the reason it's like seismic activity that carries through the rocks for miles which is
Speaker 2fascinating that is fascinating yeah I loved that a tradition we have on this podcast is to ask our guests for a chilling obsession or something they've been enjoying
Speaker 3in horror lately well um I don't know I sadly I I it's a week before a pub date and so I'm super stressed out and have been deep diving Pride and Prejudice because which one oh so definitely the book but also the mini series the PBS fantastic so good I love it also watched the Jane Austin or Miss Austin which was okay on PBS um yeah super into that but what's the horror that I'm reading you know I I don't know I don't have a ton on my desk. I just got Emily St. John Mandel's new book.
Speaker 2Oh, Exit Party?
Speaker 3Yeah. And I'm excited to read that. Like that weird stuff is always fun for me. Yeah, yeah. I've been reading Audley B. Blake, and I like her a lot. And I've been reading, I'm excited to get the next, I read Tender's The Flesh. The next, Augustina, can't pronounce the last name. Asterica? Yeah. And then Marianne Enriquez has a new one coming out that I'm really excited about. And then Maisie Wood's coming out. Yeah. Or maybe, I think today's pub day for Maisie Wood. I think it's October. I think it's now. Is it? You know what? Maybe, yeah. It's like this, we're all coming out within a week of each other.
Speaker 2That's crazy. Yeah. Well, I'm excited. I'm excited. Yeah. About all of those. That's cool. I saw, I was thrifting yesterday, and I saw a VHS set for the PBS Pride and Prejudice miniseries. And I was like, should I get it? I don't have a VCR, but I felt like I should grab it. Did you get it? No, I didn't. I was like, I'm trying to get rid of stuff. And I'm like, what is, why should I buy?
Speaker 3Do you, so do you like that one?
Speaker 2I love the 2004 one, because it's the one that I grew up with. It's like, it's the one.
Speaker 3The movie with Keira Knightley.
Speaker 2I went to Blockbuster. I had a gift card for my birthday, and I bought it. I bought it from like the pre, you know, the used DVD table, so I could, you know, stretch my gift card further. And my sister and I watched it like every week. So that's like the one we have the, that's the one we have our like close connection to. But I do love the series as well.
Speaker 3I, yes. I get that. I completely get that. And Matthew McFadden is super cute.
Speaker 2Yeah. And the music, the visuals, like it's just, it's like a beautiful, comforting movie.
Speaker 3It is. It's completely great. And that moment when she's on the swing, but now the seasons have changed.
Speaker 2It's so good. Oh, and she's like, yeah, turning around. It is very good. Well, the second tradition we have on the podcast is to ask our guests for their final girl song. If there was a horror movie and you're the last person standing, what's the song you
Speaker 3want playing? Oh, my gosh. Level it up. Boots Riley. Okay.
Speaker 1Mm hmm. Mm hmm.
Speaker 2All right. Well, I have a running playlist where I put everyone's answers. So that's going to get added to the playlist. So people can get their final girl energy. Awesome. I love that. Well, Sarah, thank you so much for coming on here today after several tries and talking to me about Tradwife.
Speaker 3Thank you. I love being here.
Speaker 2Books in the Freezer is a bi-weekly podcast. We post episodes every other Tuesday. You can find us on Instagram, Threads, Blue Sky, and TikTok at Books in the Freezer or send us an email at booksinthefreezer at gmail.com. Show notes for this episode. And all previous episodes can be found at booksinthefreezer.com. If you are interested in supporting the show, please consider becoming a member of our Patreon community at patreon.com slash books in the freezer. I have been your host, Stephanie Gania. Thank you so much for listening and see you next time on Books in the Freezer. Books in the Freezer.