Go back

‘TOTAL LIES!’ Bernard-Henri Lévy x Mehdi Hasan on Trump, Iran, Gaza, Putin & More

57m 45s

‘TOTAL LIES!’ Bernard-Henri Lévy x Mehdi Hasan on Trump, Iran, Gaza, Putin & More

FanDuel is now available across the U.S., offering users access to sports betting regardless of location, though age and market-specific restrictions apply. The discussion centers on a critical examination of Israel’s military actions in Gaza, where critics, including Bernard-Henri Lévy, are challenged over claims of disproportionate violence and a lack of civilian protection. Opponents argue that the Israeli response—particularly targeting children, hospitals, and densely populated areas—exceeds what is justified in wartime, contrasting with the country’s humanitarian efforts like vaccination campaigns. The conversation also evaluates the U.S. military strike on Iran in February 2024, which many view as a political and strategic misstep, resulting in domestic backlash and no clear strategic victory. Analysts emphasize that neither Iran nor Ukraine has been decisively defeated, with Iran maintaining regional influence and the war in Ukraine continuing to be a threat to European stability. The discussion also critiques the portrayal of figures like Zelensky as heroic defenders of democracy, while questioning the narratives around Israeli policy and settler violence. A broader theme emerges: the dangers of unchecked military action, the erosion of trust in leadership, and the growing influence of conspiracy theories in global discourse. The conversation concludes with a call for accountability, moral clarity, and a reevaluation of foreign interventions in the face of escalating humanitarian and geopolitical risks.

Transcription

9549 Words, 52665 Characters

English
FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S. So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are. Including these places. Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel. Age and location restrictions apply. Product availability varies by market. See FanDuel.com for eligibility. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. I cannot say that the behavior of IDF in Israel is more disproportionate or less. Depressing to hear Bernard-Henri Lévy still just blindly defending Israel as he's always done. In October 8th started a strange process of demonizing Israel. He told multiple lies. It is the first time in modern wars where there is campaigns of vaccination for tents, dogs. Thousands of thousands of children. And he said the Israeli army cares about people more than any other army. You and I know that's complete bullshit. Would you categorize what they're doing as terrorism? No, it's not terrorism. He's even further to the right of the Israeli quote-unquote liberal opposition. He's so blindly defensive of Israel. He can't even call the settlers terrorists, which is what Israeli opposition politicians are calling them. Well, the Uncensored Club is open for business. Visit piersmorgan.tv for ad-free episodes, exclusive content, and a lot more of me. Now, the high-stakes summit in China between Presidents Trump, Putin, and Xi could have massive implications for the world. We know that Putin wants to talk about the war in Ukraine, albeit in the absence of its leader, Zelensky. We know that Trump wants to talk about the danger of nukes, the apparent basis of his war in Iran, and we know that Xi Jinping wants to talk about free trade. China, of course, traded freely with Iran in both oil and missiles until the war began. We won't know for days or even weeks if today's talks will deliver war or peace. But my next guest, I suspect, will help make sense of all this right now. Bernard-Henri Lévy is an esteemed philosopher, filmmaker, thinker, writer, and Frenchman. His latest book is entitled Provisional Memoirs and chronicles his life through the past half-century of global history. And he joins me in the studio now. Well, Bernard-Henri, it's fantastic to finally get to interview you. Absolutely. I have never interviewed you. I've always wanted to. Resisted my entreaties, and here you are. No, no, no. I was ready since years. It's great to see you. I can't think of many people better equipped to answer this question, which is, right now, who is the biggest threat to world peace? Is it Trump, Putin, or Xi? For sure, Putin. Putin is an actual threat. He committed. He reintroduced war in Europe. He created a huge massacre in Ukraine. He destroyed all the international rules. He's the real danger for peace today, and one. The two real threats in the world are radical Islam on one side, radical Islamism, Al-Qaeda, ISIS, Hamas, Iran, and, on the other side, Putin. Where is the Ukraine war? Because, depending who you speak to, you know, I've got a lot of military in my family. I've got a lot of military in my family. And some of them, from the very start, said, "There is no way Ukraine can win this war." But here we are, over four years into this war, and there are people now saying, on the military side, "It is possible that Ukraine could triumph here." It just needs more support from both the Americans and from the Europeans. What's your view? That's exactly what I think and what I say, continuously, since not four years. Nearly five years now. I really think that Ukraine cannot lose, just cannot lose. You mean because the consequences would be too bad? No, because they are brave, because they are valiant, because they are defending their homeland, because they are defending real values, European values, and because, on the other side, they defend nothing. I know the situation by eyewitnesses. As you know, I did shoot four documentaries on the ground, on the battlefield, on frontline. I was in Bakhmut, I was in Pokrovsk, I was in Sumy, all the hot places of the frontline, I was there. And I saw with my eyes, on one side, Ukrainians, who really are true patriots, defending something. On the other side, mercenaries. I interviewed some Russian prisoners, for one of my films. And I saw, they are poor guys, not even knowing where they are, and even less why they are there. And sometimes, they have been picked up in remote neighborhood of whatever, and they have no reason to do that war. So in this sort of situation, we know that since the ancient Greeks and ancient Romans, when you have, you know, they are facing each other, a people who knows why he combats, and people who has no reason to combat, the first one normally wins. For that, true. What is need, what is needed is weapons, support, international support, American and mostly European. - I had President Zelensky sitting in the very seat you were there. - I know, I saw. It was a great moment, by the way. - It was. - It was, yeah. - It was a big moment. For me, for my show, I think for what he said was very significant. He said he feels betrayed at the moment by Donald Trump and the Americans, and he wants them to put up more. Obviously, in America, it's a contentious issue, more than you would say in Europe. Should the Americans be doing more? Their argument is, well, we've done a lot. - No, they did not do so much. They betrayed in a shameful way, and I still cannot say that, but I think they should be doing more. - I think President Zelensky, Zelensky at this place, he was completely mesmerized by the extent of the treason. The betrayal, it wasn't only a betrayal of Ukraine. It was a betrayal of American creed, of Western values. It was a true betrayal. It came from far, to be honest. Already in the Oval Office, this absolutely shameful moment when Vance, and Trump insulted live in front of all TV of the world, Zelensky. It was really embarrassing. And I remember, by the way, that day, I was in Ukraine when it was live on CNN and so on. I was in Ukraine, and I was in Pokrovsk on frontline with some soldiers of Zelensky. And I saw these guys, these soldiers watching the TV at that moment. We were in a bunker with our computers, and we managed to have it. They were strong, strong soldiers, you know, tough guys. They were crying. - Really? - Crying, crying to see their president, this brave president, this Ukrainian Churchill, insulted, humiliated, treated this way by Vance, telling him, at the end of the day, what did they tell? You are badly dressed. You are a beggar. You always ask for, you are a schnorrer, and you never say thank you, okay? These were the grievance. A beggar, never saying thank you, and dressed in a strange way. And my mates, my companions of that day, really, they had tears in their eyes. And they saw a lot, I can tell you. They saw a lot on the battlefield. So, betrayal by America, that's true. Could America do more? Of course, because you have in America a lot of dissent Republicans who remember of John McCain, who remember of Ronald Reagan, and who know that Putin is an enemy of themselves and of the West. So, there can be a sort of new awakening of dissent America. Same on the Democratic side. Of course, you have a lot of Democrats who are not isolationists, who know that the real borders of the free world today are there between the Pokrovsk, Subi. And you can, we can have a good surprise, and Ukraine can have a good surprise, hopefully, I pray, in the coming months. There are people in the United States, in particular, who like to disparage Zelensky. You know, they say he's a fraud, he's corrupt, and so on and so on. What do you say to people that have that mentality about him? Because I went to Kyiv four months into the war, and I was so impressed with him, and I have done, remained so ever since. I also remember on the night the Russians invaded, the famous spectacle of Zelensky on a cell phone, saying, "I'm not leaving." And I remember thinking that's astonishing courage right there, and leadership, whatever you think of him. Now, I'm very impressed by him. I think he's a good man, but to those who, think the opposite. What do you say to them? You know, I know him, I think, much better than those people you are talking about. I met Zelensky first time before his election, a few weeks before his election. I saw him so many times during the war. Each time I go to Ukraine, I try to meet him and he makes me the honour to invite me. And these sort of comments are pure villainy. They are villains. To say that this man is corrupted without legitimacy, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, it is again a shame, a shame. He is the embodiment of the best of European, British and American values, honestly. The values of courage. Churchill in the streets of London going in October 1940 without his. In his hat, during the bombing, naked head. This is Zelensky the day you are mentioning. Yes. When the whole world thought that he was going to beg for an exit door, for an exfiltration, and when he replied to President Biden, Mr President, I did not ask for a taxi, I asked for fuzils, for weapons. This is the best of British creed, American creed, European creed. This man is risking his life every day. He does not know when he goes to bed at night if he will get away the day after. His children, his wife and so on, how dare they? How dare they treat him this way? And moreover, he is fighting also for them, for us. I mean, we all reasonable people today know that if the Ukrainian line is broken, it will be the turn of the others. Of course. On Ukraine, you and I completely agree. I believe we agreed about the Iraq war back in 2003. I opposed that very vociferously when I was editor of the Daily Mirror. Me too. So we're aligned on many of these issues. I want to talk about two things where we're not necessarily aligned. Let's go back, first of all, to October the 7th, because I know that you flew, to Israel the next day, the first plane you could get on. And you went to some of the kibbutz where the worst imaginable horror had happened. And you've covered war zones all over the world. And you said you'd never seen anything as horrific as what you saw that day. And I very loudly said from the start it was an appalling terrorist attack and that Israel had not just a right to defend itself but a moral duty to its people. Because Hamas was saying, we're going to keep doing this again and again and again. My problem with the way that the war in Gaza has developed is for the last year or so in particular, I have felt that the Israeli government response to October the 7th has become woefully disproportionate. And I also think that when you listen to the rhetoric of some of their government ministers like Ben-Gavir and Smodrich, these are the worst kind of far-right, far-right headbangers who talk in. I've not said there's a genocide there. I don't think it has reached the bar of genocide. But they talk in a language which is brazenly ethnic cleansing. Let's call it that. They want to get rid of all the Palestinians from the West Bank, from Gaza. And so it's no surprise to me that the world has slowly but surely turned against Israel because of the actions of this Israeli government. And I feel very sad about that. What's your view now? In 2024, a year into the war, you didn't think it was disproportionate. Have you changed your view? About Ben-Gavir and Smodrich, we totally agree. I think exactly the same. I say that here, but I say it also in Israel. When I spoke on Hostage Square one year and a half ago, I said it loud and clear. Number two, the. World feelings against Israel did not start in the last year. It did not start. It started on October 8th. Oh, no, it did. I saw it. I saw it. I remember in Kensington, where I live, there were mass protests outside the Israeli embassy. And I thought they were protesting in support of the Israelis. They were protesting in celebration about what had happened. And I was horrified. In my country, same. Jean-Luc Mélenchon, a few days after when France, French Jews and friends of French Jews demonstrated, Mélenchon said, I will not commit myself because the friends of genocide are out in the city. Israel did not even start to think how to retaliate. OK? The response did not even start. So this antipathy of the world, Mrs. Francesca Albanese, even Gutierrez, who said the day after that it was not out of context. And so, in October 8th, started a strange process of demonizing Israel. This is the third point. More disproportionate than other wars, you say? I don't think so. I am eyewitness of another war. Before that, it was in Mosul, when the Western and Arab coalition, did start a war against Daesh in one of its capital, which was Mosul. I was there, again, on the battlefield, shooting a movie, the battle for Mosul. Yeah, I remember. I saw, I was under the bombs. I was with the Kurdish and the Iraqi fighters. Honestly, it was not better, if not worse, than what happened in Gaza. I don't say by experience, I cannot say, that the behavior of IDF in Israel is more disproportionate or less disproportionate. Let me put a counterpoint to that, which is this, which is that Gaza, pretty well uniquely, has a 50% population of the 2 million people who live there are under 18. So it has an enormous percentage of children, legally aged children. And 75% to 80% of Gaza has been razed to the ground. So it's been obliterated, pretty much. And 20,000 plus children have been reported to have been killed in this conflict. Obviously, all of them innocent victims of what's happened. And even Donald Trump said, you know, if you're going after one Hamas terrorist, you don't need to take down the tower block to get them. And that's been my point. I've not directly accused the IDF of deliberately targeting children, as other people have done. But I've not said that. What I have said is, I think they've been, not indiscriminate, but they have been uncaring about how many people die collaterally when they believe they're targeting a Hamas terrorist or a group of Hamas terrorists. In other words, if there is a tower block and they get information there's a Hamas operative in there, they take the whole block out. That, to me, has been a policy which I think has caused people to dislike what they've been doing. Yes. About children, if you are completely honest, you have to be honest. You have to recognize, at least I observed that, it is the first time in modern wars where there is campaigns of vaccination for tens, dozens of thousands of children. I never saw, during a war, an army, like the Israeli army, organizing or permitting a campaign of vaccination against polio elite, as Israel did. I never, about concern about, about children, I never saw, as the IDF did, an effort to take out of Gaza thousands of children one year ago who had rare illnesses which could not be cured in Gaza, taken out of Gaza with real effort. They've also been attacking hospitals where children have been killed while they're having sex. Surgery. That has happened. They attacked hospitals which were headquarters. Right. But that comes back to my point that they. But that comes to my point. If you know that Hamas are using a hospital, does that entitle you to take out the whole hospital? And that becomes the argument about proportion. Absolutely. But the hospitals which were targeted were generally, generally military headquarters. There was no children. needed it. So if you take a war is always horrible. This war in Gaza is horrible. These civilian victims is unsufferable as every war. And I saw so many wars in my life. I really mean what I am telling you. What I don't think is that Israel does not care. Israel cares. And I never saw in such wars an army caring as much. Caring as much. organising these campaigns, taking the children out to cure them and so on, and. I mean, only this week, I would point out, the Trump Board of Peace criticised Israel for limiting humanitarian aid deliveries into Gaza and called the access completely insufficient. It is always insufficient, but on the contrary, really check the statistics honestly, I never saw an army bringing in so much humanitarian aid than Israel since October 7, 2003. What is your view of what's happening on the West Bank with the aggressive expansion of settlements and the blatant terrorist activities of some of these settlers? These aggressive settlers, they should be sanctioned, of course, and this is the responsibility of this government. They should be. Would you categorise what they're doing as terrorism? No. No, it's not terrorism, but it is violence, it is activism, it is illegal, it is against the law, and I pray for a new government in Israel. Well, I was going to ask you, who would you like to see win that in the end? I would like to see Netanyahu out of office, of course, and Eisenkot making a coalition. And do you think he can? I mean, it's a complex political system, then. It's very complicated because he has difficulty. He has a political choice, he needs some allies and so on, but I hope, of course. I have always been in favour of the two-state solution. Yeah. So the second state, it will not be in the moon, it will be in West Bank. So there has to be human, political, material conditions for the Palestinian state. So, of course, I am against these colonisations, of course. Let's turn to Iran, because there is obviously a connection here. You know, it is pretty clear from a lot of reporting several weeks into the war, particularly by The New York Times, that the decision to attack Iran again after the successful 12-day war last year appeared to be successful. Trump came out and said we put back their nuclear aspiration in decades, and we took him at his word. And then only eight months later, apparently this attack had to happen again because Iran was about to get nuclear weapons. I've never been able to. I've never been able to work out what happened in those eight months to go from decades putting them back to suddenly it's immediate. So we can come to that. But there is a general belief that Netanyahu and the head of Mossad in a crucial meeting at the White House in the Situation Room with the Mossad head joining remotely, that they pitched to Trump and his top people a sequence of events if they attack now. They said we've got the traffic lights in Tehran, we know how the Ayatollah is moving, we can take him out and his top people. And if we do that, then the IRGC will collapse, the people will rise up and we'll all be too distracted to worry about the Strait of Hormuz. Well, the first part happened because Trump bought into this sequence of events and nothing else has happened. In fact, the opposite has happened. The IRGC appears to be as strong as ever. The people haven't risen up at all, certainly nothing like we saw in January with the protests. And the Iranian regime has worked out if you control the Strait of Hormuz and you let off rockets at your Gulf state neighbours, it's actually as powerful as having a nuclear weapon. And we are where we are now, heading towards the end of the year. Trump said this is going to be over in two to three weeks. It's clearly a quagmire, a mess. It's caused him enormous political damage with the mid-term shellacking that he got. I know that you were broadly supportive, I think, of the strikes on Iran back in February, but given what's happened, are you as supportive now? First of all, I was supportive of one thing. When Trump said, in the middle of the demonstrations in the streets of Tehran, when Trump said aid in on its way, I was in favour of the promise to be held. So when you promise to a people we are coming, you have to come, number one. Number two, we all know, before Trump, that Iran is at the edge of having a nuclear weapon. The last two have said it before Trump, it was Antony Blinken in July, before the election, he said that Iran was a few weeks far from being able to make the bomb. So this had to be stopped in a way or in another. So, of course, I was in favour of these strikes. Now, the whole narrative which you summarised, which you described, the meeting at the Oval Office, the detainee of Trump, the whole narrative is absurd. Why? Because such a war, such an operation with destroyer, with marine, with huge military means, it does not. it is not organised like this in a minute. It takes months, it takes probably years, the decision. So this idea of Netanyahu hijacking or hacking the brain of Trump and convincing him with a good pitch to launch this story is completely moronic. It's absurd. I know that it is a theory which is all around, but it is a conspiracy theory. Do you think so? There is. Any military expert knows that such a war is prepared, needs months, with an S, to be prepared. Not an afternoon with a good cup of tea between two, two false friends, which are Netanyahu and Trump, who are not as friends as Netanyahu believed, by the way. It doesn't work this way, you know. In the time of Perik in Aten, in the fifth century before Christ, you could organise a battle overnight. Not today. But I would argue part of the problem is they did rush into it, they didn't plan it properly, they didn't game out that the Iranians might control the Strait of Hormuz in the way they have. And they certainly didn't game out that they would attack all their Gulf state neighbours. I'm not telling that Trump is a good president and a good general and a good commanding chief, for sure. But right now, do you support this war? I mean, if they were to take more military action, would you support that against Iran now? My belief is that Iran has lost, and lost since month. And for that, it shouldn't be. Lost why? Because Iran had two objectives, number one, to be. to be a big power outside, but also to be a sort of prosperous regime inside. They are wrecked, they are ruined, they. But are they? Of course. I mean, people like to think they are, but at the moment, they're still firing off a lot of rockets, they still control the Strait of Hormuz. You now see the Houthis attacking the Saudis and getting the upper hand there, with all the ripple effect that may have. And you're seeing, apparently, President Trump and a number of his top Cabinet ministers, you know, being hidden away in the last few days before Trump went on the trip, because of a threat of a dirty bomb attack on Washington DC. So, if you look at it objectively, you say, "Well, if the Iranians have lost, "they're putting a very good spin on it." Like Iran is a sort of big, cultivated, well-learned North Korea. North Korea also is able to organise a huge hackney, huge hacking on your hospitals or on our schools. North Korea also is probably able to organise a terrorist, a little chemical attack in Washington DC. But the whole people of North Korea is dying with hunger. And same with Iran. They're certainly able to expand, to organise big attacks abroad, but they lost their people forever. So, in this sense, they lost. It takes time to a regime to understand that he lost. It is not done again overnight. It takes maybe some years. I'm not as convinced as you are about that, but history will judge us, we'll see. Two quick things before we finish. One, the French riots have been. I've been in America the last three and a half weeks, and there's no doubt there's a narrative that's built on the Conservative riots. There's a narrative right in America in particular that these riots are actually about the rise of Islamism, there's a Muslim takeover of Europe, particularly in France, particularly now in the UK. I don't recognise it in the UK, I have to say. And my understanding, but you're in a better position to tell me, of what's happened in France, is that most of the protests were legitimate, protests of the kind we've seen for 100 years in France, but they were hijacked by people who had nefarious reasons to cause damage and attack police and so on. But I don't get a sense that they were Islamist protests, do you? No. Islamist protest is, again, a theory of people who are obsessed by their obsessions. That's not true. Hijacked? Yes, for sure. Hijacked by extremist forces, but not Muslim. The French, La France Insoumise, the Unbound France, the extreme left, look at them. I don't think most of them are Muslim, far from it. All the leaders are probably from. Catholic or Protestant origin, so nothing to do with Islam. Hijacked, yes. You have some forces, some extreme radical leftist forces who blow on the fire to make it stronger, for sure. But it is not part of the so-called world of civilization depicted by Samuel Huntington 20 years ago. This is not what happens in France today, no. Just to wrap up, I want to mention your book, Provisional Memoirs. It's the story of your life and the people you've met along the way. Who's been the most impressive public figure that you've ever met? Alas, because I begin to be old, but I met a lot of impressive figures. You could choose one. If I had to choose one, I could choose Zelensky, but we already spoke a lot. The other one I could name is Commander Massoud, the Afghan moderate Muslim leader who was battling, combating Talibans, who was combating Al-Qaeda, and who was killed two days before September 11 by the Talibans, by Al-Qaeda, Commander Massoud. He was a real pious Muslim. Yes. Yes. And he was in favor of wheelchairs. Yes. Yes. He was in favor of women showing their face. He was in favor of a form of secularism. He was in favor of peace with the West, of a true dialogue between civilization. He was a man of peace. He was the embodiment of enlightened Islam. And this man, I knew him well. I invited, I brought him in France in order, a few weeks before his assassination, to meet the political leadership in France. I admired him. He was, like Zelensky, one of those resistance who fight alone, back on the wall, against a tremendous force. At this time, it was not Putin. It was radical Islam, but it was the same. And he did that with a bravery that honestly obliged me. And when I think about him, like Zelensky. Yes. Like in Sarajevo, Alija Izetbegovic, I am full of admiration and gratitude for them to have given me a little piece of their friendship. Finally, you were such a close neighbor of President Macron. You could basically see his residence, I think, in Paris. And you share insomnia with him. And you would message each other in the middle of the night, comparing your notes of your inability to sleep. Is that true? Absolutely correct. Absolutely correct. Absolutely correct. Not to sleep is an illness, in a sense. And it is an advantage. You live twice. And this is probably what happens to him, what happens to me. And we communicated. Yeah. And France-- I have a current bet, $300,000 bet, with Candace Owens, the commentator in America, who has claimed, in my view, preposterously, that Brigitte Macron is a terrorist. And I have bet her $300,000 to charity. It was $150,000, then we doubled it. That is complete nonsense. I believe the legal action the Macrons are taking will prove that. And my bet will be sound. Do you have a view about this? This woman, Candace Owens, is not even worth a bet. What she said, what she did there, is infamous. To treat a woman, a lady-- Who's had three children. --who's had three children. To treat a woman, a lady. Who's had three children. She has three children. She's a great and charming lady. Anyway, no lady deserves this sort of treatment. This woman, Candace Owens, is an anti-Semite, by the way, conspiratorial and so rude, aggressive and shameful. It's a shame. And honestly, take out your best. I would not be proud even to win a bet against her. Take your bet out. I want to take her money. Bernard, it's brilliant to see you. Thank you very much. What a fascinating conversation. Thank you, Peter. You're welcome any time you're here. I really appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. We'll turn it now to the communications disaster surrounding the big tech meltdown in the US and the very clear communication that seems to suggest a major escalation is imminent in the Iran war. Joining me is Mehdi Hassan, founder of Zateo, and the former White House Deputy Press Secretary Hogan Gidley. Well, welcome to you, gentlemen. Well, Mehdi, you were listening there to Bernard Omri-Levy. Your response to that interview? Yeah, depressing to hear Bernard-Henri Libby still just blindly defending Israel, as he's always done. I've interviewed him in the past, and Palestine's always an exception for him, Piers. He's supported wars and humanitarian interventions in Libya, in Bosnia, in Ukraine, and go through the list. He's famed Syria. He always says, I want to protect civilians abroad. But there's one group of civilians he never wants to protect, which are Palestinian civilians, especially in Gaza right now. And he told multiple lies. I'm sorry, Piers. He said the response from Israel had not started on October the 8th. That is not true. 300 Palestinians were killed by the end of October the 8th, including 20 children. Within 24 hours of October the 7th, Israel had injured 2,000 Palestinians and killed 300 Palestinians. So it's just not true to keep saying that Israel hadn't responded immediately after October the 7th. He compared it to Mosul, Piers, which is classic whataboutism. I was a critic of the U.S.-U.K. actions in Mosul, as you know, in 2015. But in Mosul, the U.S. Army say they killed, what, two civilians per ISIS fighter. Israel's own military database says they've killed five civilians per Hamas fighter. And by the way, in Mosul, we allowed people to leave and go to safety. In Gaza, they're trapped in there for the last three years. It's just not 8,000 dead in Mosul, 80,000 dead in Gaza. Just not a valid comparison. He even said the Israeli army organized a campaign of vaccination. Just a lie. In fact, the WHO did the vaccinating, and the Human Rights Watch and other aid groups criticized the Israeli military for blocking the vaccination campaign in Gaza. So, again, not true. Piers, you and I know that's complete bullshit. We've seen Israeli soldiers film themselves on TikTok, blowing up houses, laughing about it, singing about Amalek, wearing Palestinian women's clothes. This is absurd to say the Israeli army cares about Palestinians. And, in fact, Israel's own opposition leader, Piers, you asked him, does he support Gadi Eizenkot? Gadi Eizenkot has referred to Jewish settlers in the West Bank attacking Palestinians as terrorists. You noticed that he refused to say that to you when you asked him. Yeah, that is true. Are they terrorists? So he's even further to the right of the Israeli, quote-unquote, liberal opposition. He's so blindly defensive of Israel, he can't even call the settlers terrorists, which is what Israeli opposition politicians are calling them. Hogan Gidley, on the subject of Ukraine, you know, he was striking a very different tone. He's very resolute in defence of Zelensky, urging America in particular to step up more, making the point, which many have made, of course, which is if Ukraine was to fall, to Putin, then that could be the start of a Russia-led charge through Europe. And why wouldn't we fear that, given what he's done with Ukraine? What's your response to that? The fact is, it is very obvious that Russia wants more land. They want more dominance in the region. They want to march forward. You see no indication from Vladimir Putin that he wants any type of deal that would give back the lands he's already gotten, whether it be Donbass, of course, or Crimea. Zelensky fighting him tooth and nail with a lot of the weaponry that Donald Trump gave him in the first term, of course. So how this ends up moving to any semblance of peace is anybody's guess. And maybe Donald Trump's trip to the trilateral meeting with President Xi and President Putin could maybe discuss some of that, try and figure out a path forward. But you have to have willing participants on both sides. And it just seems every time they come to the table, Those sides don't want to have an agreement or a deal because they're so far off in where they want to begin the negotiations. What Vladimir Putin was able to take militarily, he doesn't want to give back. Zelensky wants it all back. And so starting there is a very difficult place if you're going to have any type of lasting peace or any type of pullback from Russia. I just don't see that happening. And on Iran, Hogan, I mean, Trump has a massive call to make here because the mid-term shellacking gets worse by the day. We saw Alaska falling, another Senate seat today to the Democrats. This is the biggest flipping of Senate seats since the 50s, right? So it's been an absolute repudiation, I believe, of Trump's decision to go to war in Iran and the economic fallout from all that. A lot of people are still pushing him, including Netanyahu, to recommence military action against Iran and to finish the job, as they put it. Bernard Omri Levy believes, in a way, the war is over. one, Iran has been so decapitated that you could declare victory. And my response to that would be, great, then get out of there, because I don't see any upside for the Americans in particular prolonging this, given the political damage it's caused and the economic damage to the American people. Interestingly enough, I think there are large swaths within the Republican electorate that either want him to pull out, as you just said, or wipe them out. I think those are kind of the two camps right now. It seems as though Donald Trump is content with executing patience and also a complete stranglehold on Iran economically. The back and forth, the responses to the responses of the military attacks just recently by Iran on America's interest in Bahrain, Kuwait, etc. I would warn, as I have before on this program, if you think Donald Trump was executing some semblance of caution here or a slowdown because of the midterm elections, now that Democrats have control of the House and Senate and Donald Trump has no further election to really be concerned about, if I'm Iran, I'm a little less apt to start attacking America and her interests and her allies, her partners in the region, because with a man who has nothing to lose like Donald Trump, you don't want to push him to that point where he says, fine, we've tried to bring you guys down, you've pushed us to the table, you've lied repeatedly, you've pulled back on all the negotiations, see what happens. I think they run the risk of facing the strong might of the American military if they keep this up. OK, Mehdi, my reading of it, as I said to Bernard-Homri Levy, is if they've won the Iranians, well, if they've lost, I mean, they're putting a pretty good spin on not having lost because they still control the Strait of Hormuz, they're still attacking their Gulf state neighbours, apparently with impunity. The regime, remains clearly firmly intact. The Ayatollah's been replaced, we believe, by his son, who's even more hardline. We don't see or hear from him directly, but he is believed to be in charge. And the people so far haven't risen up in the way that was predicted when Netanyahu sold this concept to Trump. So I don't really see the Iranians as having lost. I don't think they've won. But I certainly think if there was an escalation, the Iranians have made it very clear, if there is, we will attack America and we will attack the United States. Now, there's this report at the weekend of a potential dirty bomb threat to D.C. and so on. Who knows if that's true or not? We do hear that there are reports of cabinet ministers having to live on military bases, Trump being kept away from the public gaze for a few days and so on. There clearly have been a lot of rumblings and concerns about the Iranians maybe launching some attack, to which I would say, well, that's not surprising, given the Americans took out the supreme leader of Iran. So, of course, they might be considering that. But if, you know, I think it would be. It would be fundamentally a massive error if the Americans went back into a proper war again with Iran. What's your view? No, obviously, I agree with you on that. Please, you won't be shocked to hear. I also think you summarised it very well, that it's insane for anyone to suggest that America has won this war and Iran has lost, when, as you pointed out, we replaced Khamenei with Khamenei, we gave them control of the Strait of Hormuz, which they still have. They are able to project power across the region against US allies. And, of course, they still have their enriched uranium. Remember the BS? Another lie. Bernard-Henri Lévy told that there was a nuclear threat from Iran, supposedly, because they have enriched uranium. Well, they still have that enriched uranium. So the whole thing was nonsense. And you said, you know, Iran hasn't won. Well, true, neither side has won, but some would argue that when you're in a conflict, the weaker side wins by not losing, right? Iran is the smaller, weaker party. The fact that the US superpower hasn't been able to crush or defeat Iran or do regime change is a sign that Iran is winning, whether we like it or not. A couple of things Hogan said that jumped out at me, one which I agree with, which is, a man with nothing to lose, much more dangerous. I've always worried that post-midterms, Donald Trump will be much more reckless abroad. And also, most lame-duck presidents tend to do more abroad because they have more freedom to operate in foreign policy. Barack Obama did some good things in his last two years in office with the Iran deal, with the Paris climate, with the opening to Cuba. But Donald Trump may do more harm. It's interesting, though, that Hogan said, you know, you shouldn't test him, et cetera, et cetera. We have a reckless president who couldn't find Iran on a map if his life depended on it, who's being called by, by Benjamin Netanyahu every day. He betrayed his base, the MAGA base. He said no new wars. He said, I won't start a new war. And then he's pushed us into this ridiculous, unnecessary war of choice. Even J.D. Vance wrote a post-mortem piece after the election saying Iran was the reason they lost the midterms, which is 100% correct, the only time I've ever agreed 100% with J.D. Vance. So I think, on the one hand, yes, he's free to do more damage, and I'm worried about the next few days and weeks. On the other hand, you know, it will further destroy the Republican Party here at home. One last thing on the dirty, bomb stuff. Come on, Piers. You and I covered Iraq. It's one thing we've always agreed on. This pops up at a very convenient time. It pops up, Piers, just days after the director of the Mossad arrived in D.C. to talk to the CIA. I wonder where the U.S. got this intel from about a dirty bomb. My colleague Swin Soobsang, writing for Zateo this morning, spoke to sources in the intel community, the JC, in the JSOC community, and he says that his sources are saying it's horseshit, this intelligence, horseshit. Well, look, I don't think we know. That's the point. And, you know, we'll see. And, Hogan, let's talk about what. You just made two points. Yeah, sure. Very important. Quickly, yeah. You just made two points very important. So, on one hand, you're saying that Iran is completely intact and watch them as they carry out all these attacks in the region. Also, the thought of them even attacking America, that's just foolish. Of course they want to attack America. They state that every single day of their existence. They most assuredly have marked many U.S. officials for death. And I'm telling you, if you think the Iran war is. But it was the U.S. that killed. It was the U.S. that killed Iran's leader, not vice versa, Hogan. It was your former boss who killed, who assassinated illegally the leader of Iran, not vice versa. I'm not defending Iran. I don't think they should be assassinating anyone. We can have a conversation about what's legal or not legal based on the war they've waged on America for the last 30 years. No, you can't assassinate the sitting head of state of another country. If you think it is unpopular, this Iran war, which by all polling data it is, I'll tell you what's going to trump that. When Iran tries to set off a dirty bomb here or attacks or kills one of the American people, our citizens in this country. You've said this from the Republican body before. fear-mongering to justify an illegal war. You're fear-mongering. This nation is trying to attack and kill our citizens. It is their state of the world. Because we attacked them, Hogan. Hogan, we attacked Iran. It's what they want to do. Hogan, we attacked Iran, unprovoked, February 28th of this year. We bombed Iran while we were in the middle of nuclear negotiations, while the Omanis had a deal on the table. It's not unprovoked, Matty. We attacked them. You know it was. We were in the middle of negotiations. So why were we in negotiations the day before? Why were we scheduled? Why were we scheduled to have negotiations with them? Why did the Omani foreign minister, our ally, say that there was a deal close between America and Iran, and then we went to war in the middle of it? We went to war on February the 28th in the middle of nuclear negotiations. We killed, assassinated their head of state. And if they do attack on American soil, I hope they don't. I condemn it if they do, obviously. I'm an American. I live in America. I want my family to be safe. But Trump is to blame for that. You can't go around assassinating other leaders and then say, well, they're not going to assassinate us back. This is what the Israelis have done. You can't attack and kill. You can't attack and kill Americans and not expect some blowback, number one. Number two, Democrats for decades in this country, whether it be Kamala Harris, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, George W. Bush as a Republican, George H.W. Bush, have all said Iran is a threat to this country. All of a sudden, one president has the guts to do something about it, and now he's the pariah for doing everything that all of the other powers. Well, no, I would say, Hogan, Hogan, hang on, hang on. I would say, Hogan, hang on. No, you hold on. Ten seconds. Ten seconds. One second. Hang on. Ten seconds. I waited 45 minutes to do this discussion. Ten seconds give me to respond to Hogan. Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, Barack Obama, Joe Biden, every single president, Netanyahu asked to bomb Iran. None of them were dumb enough to do it. Only your former boss was dumb enough to do it, and we are in this disaster because even George W. Bush wouldn't touch this. The point I was going to make about that, Hogan, the point I was going to make about that is my point would be whether you think, it was a good idea or not, it's clearly turned into a bit of a disaster because this was supposed to be over in two to three weeks. Another Venezuela. It's turned into a political disaster for sure, but I would not argue military or economic disaster. I think in every possible way. It's not an economic disaster. In every possible way. Have you looked at the U.S. economy? Indisputably so far, it has been a military, political, and economic failure so far. Now, I agree, in the history of wars, it hasn't gone on necessarily that long, but again, Trump campaigned. Not to get into wars like this, definitely not to get into forever wars. We heard Vance talking about this will take as long as it takes. Well, that's a forever war. I want to end with one question for each of you about something completely different. Hogan, for you, Polly Market puts your odds of being the next White House press secretary at 3%. Ben Ferguson is leader at 12%. I actually think you'd both be quite good appointments, and I do think the White House needs a bloody press secretary. There isn't one after the crazy five-day spell of the last, last incumbent of the position. Are you interested in coming in to save the show? Serving this administration in the first term was a blessing to me beyond measure, and when Donald Trump comes calling, it's very difficult to figure out a way out of it. He's quite persuasive, as you know, Piers. You know, if this country needs somebody to help focus the outside organizations, the cabinet secretaries, to begin to push this incredible message of the administration, but also piece back together the electorate, They do need somebody in that role. I think Donald Trump knows that and sooner or later he'll make that pick. So you're available? Well, again, when he comes calling, we'll have that conversation. Absolutely. I'm quite tempted to throw my own hat in the ring because I couldn't possibly do worse than the last incumbent. And it would be quite right. I might even outdo Scaramucci, which would mean I would only be the third worst at worst in the last five years. Mehdi, I want to talk to you very quickly. I want to play a clip. This is you and Russell Brand 13 years ago. There's a reason I want to play it. I'm just going to get straight into it because time is short. We want to get through lots of questions and give in the audience as well. Russell, are we going to do yoga? In 2007, the Observer did a profile on you and they asked the question at the end of the piece, what will become of Russell Brand? Six years later, millions of people have watched you on YouTube railing against the wall. I don't know. You do. There was a plan. Well, I mean, obviously the attributes applied to me from the outside, whether they're flattering or derogatory, I can't take credit or blame for. But I'm only pointing out the fact that I'm not a fan of the Observer. I'm not a fan of the Observer. Now, my only point of playing that is not to have any critique of you for sitting with him. I did myself a few times. There's just been an awful lot of, to me, revisionism about Russell Browne from people connected to the way the media platformed him and so on. Because in the end, you know, I've interviewed thousands of people and a few of them have turned out to be convicted sex offenders. The idea that you're supposed to know this before you sit down with any of these people and then make a calculation about whether you platform or not, to me, is absurd. But is there a wider part of it? When you look at that clip of you and Brand, do you wish you had reacted more to alarm bells you may have heard from other people? Yes, obviously, in hindsight. I hadn't heard alarm bells. When I did hear alarm bells years later, I very quickly distanced myself from Russell Brand. You'll notice that you had to go back 13 years to find an interview. In fact, he invited me on his podcast multiple times here in the US. I refused to go on because I'd heard horrible things, not that I knew were true or not. And now he's proven wrong. To be a rapist. I would point out a couple of things, Piers. One is I've been following the UK media debate where they've been jumping on the left. And Ed Miliband, you remember, did an interview with him in 2015 and trying to attack the left, which is hilarious because Russell Brand was on the left. He conned a lot of us over a decade ago. But in recent years, he was on the right. He was hanging out with RFK Jr. at the Department of Health just a few weeks ago. He was at Mar-a-Lago. And interestingly, Piers, he switched to the right, knowing this was coming and knowing that the right would protect him. And Megyn Kelly's still defending him, shamefully, right now on our radio show. Right. And being convicted by a jury. So the right are happy to protect him. And it's funny that you mentioned, like, we didn't know about stuff. Obviously, he wasn't convicted of anything in 2013. But I would just point out, Piers, serious point. You just said a moment ago that you'd be happy to go be a press secretary for a man who has been found liable for sexual abuse in a court of law, has been accused by multiple women of rape. And you said you'd happily go be his press secretary. So this is my worry here. We have a guy in the White House right now who's been accused of horrific crimes against women and found liable for sexual abuse in a court of law. Yet people like you are still happy to defend him. Well, just to be clear, I wouldn't actually be his press secretary. But Hogan wants to. So, Hogan, maybe you can take that as the first question. I didn't. First of all, I didn't say I wanted to. What I said was, if Donald Trump calls me, it's always an honor to serve an administration or my country in any shape or fashion. You said it was a black eye. You said his presidency was a black eye on the way out. These have all been proven to be ridiculous. As many world knows, he's going to keep beating this drum. And that's fine. Donald Trump is not focused on people from the past who clearly have lost their lives. He's not focused on people from the past who clearly have lost their lives. He's not focused on people from the past who clearly have lost their mind. The people in those court cases, as you well know, Pierce, complete lunacy. You heard them testify. You heard them talk. Two dozen women are lying. Absolutely insane. I can tell you all of these cases Donald Trump has been proven. All two dozen women are lying about him harassing, assaulting, raping them. All of them are lying. And Donald Trump's telling the truth. And by the way, a jury in New York found him liable for sexual abuse, which a judge didn't. To be fair to Donald Trump, he's never been convicted in any criminal court of any sexual assault, right? You heard Russell Brand until now. That's the whole point, right? That's the whole point of your question. I'm responding to your question. Sure, but you're convicting him without any trial. No, I'm not. I said he was accused of rape by multiple women, and he's been found liable for sexual abuse in a civil court where the judge said it could be called rape. And accusations are not indications or proving of guilt, as you well know, in this country. I never said they were. I simply pointed out that two dozen women have accused him of a horrific crime. The mistake the left made with Trump on these cases was that they decided that the most important thing to take him through the courts with was the Stormy Daniels one-night stand paper shuffle. If you're going to ask me to defend Merrick Garland, you've got the wrong guy. No, no, I'm not saying you are. I'm just saying that if, as you say, Trump's guilty of all these things, well, they should have gone after one of those and not the most pathetically petty thing they could possibly think of, which I thought embarrassed. That's what the next Democratic administration does. Well, it may be that Hogan is the one defending it all. We shall see. Thank you both very much indeed. I appreciate your time. Thanks. We want to keep a close eye on the Uncensored channel on Tuesday. We're launching a brand new series, one-on-one with Piers Morgan, presented by Uncensored in collaboration with Time Studios. I've teamed up with Time to bring you in-depth interviews and conversations with influential people across sport, politics, business, showbiz and culture. Here's a small taste of what's to come in our first show. One-on-one with Bill Maher. How many times have you been properly in love? Oh, Jesus, Barbara Walters. What's my best achievement? Endurance. Do you contemplate retirement? I know it's going to happen. I've never phoned it in. Some people do. I asked AI about you. AI? Yes. Aren't you adorable? It says longtime media figures have characterized him as a sharp-edged opportunist. AI's such an asshole. We're both of Irish heritage. Both raise Catholics. We both interview people for a living. We could be twins. Yeah, but I'm funny. I went off to college, never asked for a dime, you know, sold pot, moved to New York. I was too embarrassed to say, you know, I'm trying to be a comedian. Your first ever appearance on Johnny Carlson. You come through the curtains. I mean, you're crapping your pants, of course. Do you remember what you were wearing? I was wearing like red, white and blue. That was my way of saying it. You're saying, hello, America. Comedy is king. Is it? You certainly can get at truths, I think, in comedy and get people to listen. What's been the biggest mistake, do you think, in your career? Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. FanDuel is now available nationwide in the U.S., with eligibility and location restrictions applying.
  2. Bernard-Henri Lévy is criticized for defending Israel in a way that critics say is disproportionate, especially regarding Gaza and settler actions.
  3. The Israeli military response to Hamas in October 2023 is accused of being disproportionate, with high civilian casualties and lack of protection for children.
  4. Critics argue that Israel’s actions in Gaza—such as hospital attacks and large-scale civilian deaths—contrast sharply with its humanitarian efforts like vaccination campaigns, which are misrepresented.
  5. The U.S. military actions against Iran in February 2024 are seen as politically and strategically misfired, causing significant backlash and political damage.
  6. Experts warn that no clear victory has been achieved in either the Ukraine or Iran conflicts, with both sides still capable of escalation.
  7. There is growing concern over Iran’s continued regional aggression and its ability to project power, despite U.S. strikes.
  8. The conversation highlights deep divisions over leadership, accountability, and the moral consequences of modern warfare, especially in Gaza and Ukraine.

Summary:

, offering users access to sports betting regardless of location, though age and market-specific restrictions apply. The discussion centers on a critical examination of Israel’s military actions in Gaza, where critics, including Bernard-Henri Lévy, are challenged over claims of disproportionate violence and a lack of civilian protection. Opponents argue that the Israeli response—particularly targeting children, hospitals, and densely populated areas—exceeds what is justified in wartime, contrasting with the country’s humanitarian efforts like vaccination campaigns.

S. military strike on Iran in February 2024, which many view as a political and strategic misstep, resulting in domestic backlash and no clear strategic victory. Analysts emphasize that neither Iran nor Ukraine has been decisively defeated, with Iran maintaining regional influence and the war in Ukraine continuing to be a threat to European stability.

The discussion also critiques the portrayal of figures like Zelensky as heroic defenders of democracy, while questioning the narratives around Israeli policy and settler violence. A broader theme emerges: the dangers of unchecked military action, the erosion of trust in leadership, and the growing influence of conspiracy theories in global discourse. The conversation concludes with a call for accountability, moral clarity, and a reevaluation of foreign interventions in the face of escalating humanitarian and geopolitical risks.

FAQs

Yes, FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S., including all major regions and cities.

Age and location restrictions apply. Eligibility varies by market and region. Check FanDuel.com for specific requirements.

Yes, FanDuel is available in all U.S. areas, including rural locations, so you can access sports action no matter where you live.

Yes, FanDuel offers sports betting and other gambling services, but users must meet all age and location eligibility requirements.

If you have a gambling problem, contact the National Gambling Helpline at 1-800-GAMBLER for support and resources.

Some international critics argue that Israel's response to the October 7 attacks has been disproportionate, especially regarding civilian casualties and hospital attacks.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.