The U.S. Electoral College system currently awards the presidency based on state-level electoral votes, often diverging from the national popular vote—most notably in 2016 when Donald Trump won the presidency despite Hillary Clinton winning the popular vote. This disconnect has fueled a growing movement to reform the system, led by the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. Under this proposal, participating states would award their electoral votes to the candidate who wins the national popular vote, rather than their state’s popular vote. As of now, 18 Democratic-leaning states and Washington, D.C., have signed on, totaling 222 electoral votes—though the compact only activates when at least 270 electoral votes are pledged. While the reform is seen as intuitive and democratically appealing, it faces significant legal challenges, including constitutional questions about state authority to bind electors and whether such a change requires a constitutional amendment. Political resistance is strong, especially in battleground states where losing electoral influence could reduce political power. Democratic governors in key states, such as Arizona, have shown cautious support but have avoided direct endorsements. Though momentum has increased due to recent election outcomes and bipartisan recognition of the system’s flaws, the compact remains a long-term possibility with substantial hurdles, including legal battles and political hesitation. For now, it represents a critical test of whether the U.S. can modernize its electoral process in a way that aligns with public expectations of fairness and representation.
Okay, pop quiz time. Every four years, who elects the president of the United States?
If you said voters, partial credit. But if you said the Electoral College, give yourself
a pat on the back. There is a growing movement to change that, and we are going to talk about
it today.
It's the NPR Politics Podcast. I'm Danielle Kurtzleben. I cover the White House.
I'm Ashley Lopez. I cover voting.
And I'm Myles Parks. I also cover voting.
All right. We got the voting dream team here, and we have them here for a reason.
Like we said, we're talking about the Electoral College and potential huge changes to it. So,
Ashley, let's start with you. Refresh our memories. How does the Electoral College system
currently work?
Right. So the way that we elect a vice president and a president in this country is that they
have to win a simple majority of the electoral votes in this country. So that's 538 electoral
votes. They need to win 50 plus 1. That is 270.
Sorry, that's a lot of math. But basically, you know, the national popular vote is not
factored into who becomes president, which is why we're talking about this today.
Right. So we've gotten to this situation where each state, 50 plus 1, so Florida, Arizona,
Michigan, each one of those states, even if the vote is 51-49 in those different states,
they're winner-take-all states, right? And so you have this situation where the Electoral
College is sometimes out of control.
Because of that, because the states are winner-take-all, and yet people are voting
all over the place, right? And so five different times in U.S. history have we had where the
Electoral College elected one person that was out of whack with the national popular vote,
most recently in 2016, when Hillary Clinton won the popular vote, but Donald Trump was
elected president.
Right. And we should say that the electoral votes are a portion based on population. So if I want
to become president, it really behooves me to win California, Texas, Florida, New York, as opposed
to going out and winning.
Going out and winning North Dakota, South Dakota, Wyoming.
Yeah. Technically divvied up according to how many members of Congress you have,
which is related to population.
Right. Yes.
So yes, that's absolutely true. And the situation we have now is that basically when you run for
president, the voters you think about the most are folks in these swing states where they sort
of like are the tipping point of whether you get that simple majority of electoral votes.
Right. Okay. So what is the proposed change to that that we're talking about today?
So what could change all this is something called the National
Popular Vote Interstate Compact. It's basically an agreement among states to require their
electors to vote for the national popular vote winner instead of their state's popular vote
winner, which is what most states almost all have right now. Those are winner take all states. Like
basically, if Trump wins the popular vote in one state, all the electors, regardless of party,
vote for that candidate. He gets all of those votes. And what this says is no longer will the
electors be required to vote for the national popular vote winner. It's basically an agreement
to cast those votes for the presidential candidate or vice presidential candidate who wins the
statewide vote. It has to be the national popular vote winner. So even if it's a Republican and
you're an elector in California who is part of this compact, they have to vote for the national
popular vote winner. Which is important because this is basically a state workaround to impacting
how the president is elected. For many, many years, it's been thought that this needed to go
through the constitutional amendment process. But basically over the last few years, we've seen more
and more states,
sign on to this compact. And basically what they are doing is agreeing to change how the president
is elected without getting Congress involved. I mean, I reported a story that touched on this in
2019. And it was it even then seemed really far fetched. And then over time, more and more states
have gotten on board to now to the point where because the midterms were so overwhelming in
Democrats favor, they now control enough state governments to potentially potentially is the key
word here, right? Put this thing at least on the table, put this thing on the table, put this thing
at least on the table, right? And there are a lot of hurdles that this compact would face. But for now,
we're still going to drill down more into how this would work. So you're saying that the momentum
we're seeing right now is because Democrats suddenly have their own momentum. It's Democrats
by and large who want this. There was a period in 2012, where a majority of Republicans were in
favor of reforming the Electoral College because at that time in the 2012 election, President Obama
won a wide margin on the in the Electoral College, even though he won the popular vote by,
by less than five percentage points. But right now, at this point, I think because directly,
because 2016 election results, it is more Democrats than Republicans who are in favor.
Even President Trump, as you showed me, Miles unearthed a tweet from President Trump from 2012
that was like, this is a mess. I can read it. President Trump in 2012 tweeted,
the Electoral College is a disaster for democracy, which I don't know. I was like,
actually, look at this. Trump said this 10 years, 12 years, 15 years.
There's a tweet for everything. Exactly. Exactly. And just to,
to give people a lay of the land here, right now, it's 18 states plus DC,
Democratic states that have signed onto the compact. With those states, it's 222 electoral
votes that are part of the compact. And in order for that to go into effect,
it needs to get to states adding up to 270 or more. Okay. Yeah. So this isn't in effect right
now, even though a bunch of states have signed on. And this wouldn't go into effect until they
reach that magic number of 270 or more. You don't want those states sort of holding the bag. No state
wants to be in the bag. No one wants to be in the bag. No state wants to
basically be giving their electoral, their voters power away until it's positive that this would
actually impact who is elected president. Right. So crucially, let's just underscore here,
not every state has to sign on. No, no. They just have to get to 270 electoral votes. And as
Miles was mentioning, right now, there's like a big open lane for that because during the midterms,
Democrats won trifecta power, which means that Democrats have won
majorities in both their lower and upper chamber and their governor.
Which means that they have the ability now and probably the political will right now to sign
onto this compact. And if they do, those five states, which is Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin,
Nevada, and Arizona, their electoral votes add up to about 61. That gets the interstate compact to
more than the 270 votes that it needs. Now, if you listen to the states I just mentioned,
those are the battleground states in America. Right.
There is a very complicated political question in front of these states, which is like, do I want to
join the 63 percent of the population that does not like the Electoral College? Or do I want to
give up this very elite political status I have as basically one of the few presidential pickers
in how our current system works? Okay. We are going to dig way more into that. But for now,
time for a break. Welcome back. And Ashley, I want to pick up on something you were saying
just before our break. You were talking about how these battleground states might not want to give up
their massive electoral college power. And thinking about this after a lifetime of thinking
about battleground states is kind of breaking my brain. Maybe lay out for me, how would adopting
this compact change the way that presidential candidates campaign? Well, broadly speaking,
it would change the fact that they would have to campaign for everyone's vote. Right now,
for president, the states you really got to spend most of your money on are these seven or could be
nine coming into 2028 battleground states where, you know, you have a lot of electoral votes.
It's a swingy population. The mix of voters there is enough where like if you just spend
money there, you could get to 270. I mean, it changes the calculus tremendously. And I think
that is the underpinning argument for this from the people who are pushing for the national popular vote,
which is right now, presidential candidates have very little impetus to appeal to everyone.
And that is not a good thing for a democracy. You know, they argue presidential candidates
should be thinking of America in a more holistic, more majoritarian way, as opposed to more
strategic, like looking at a chess map and thinking, which voters can I pick up in these
really essential states? Right. It is a really complicated question for the battleground states,
though, because you think about the dissonance, which we've had the five different times I
talked about, where there was a dissonance between the national popular vote and the
electoral college result. Right. If this compact were to go into effect, you almost certainly would
see an opposite dissonance, where if you think about 2016, what would have happened then if you
were a voter in Michigan and you're looking at it and you're saying President Trump won my state
and yet Hillary Clinton is being elected president. Like, I don't know, you're going to have a lot of
moments like that, potentially, because the way this compact would work is that they're basically
saying it doesn't matter what our state level result is. It matters what the national result
is. And so you're going to have these results in individual states, potentially, if this were to
go through. And I think we can dig into that a little bit more, that there are still a lot of
different hurdles, even beyond the political ones before this thing would take effect. But I do think
it's worth noting that the dissonance would still exist to some level somewhere. Yeah. Yeah. But it
also would strip away this way we think about presidential politics right now, where we have
like blue states and red states, where no matter what the outcome is, you pretty much assume in
some states, if you're like a Republican voter in California, you're going to have a dissonance.
You already think of your vote as basically a wash, as basically a waste. And this would be a
huge change to that. And one of the arguments that the proponents of this make is that this could
have the effect of making people want to vote more, like voter participation could go up because
people don't automatically assume that I am in a state where the majority of the people here
are not in my political party. So my vote doesn't really matter.
Right. And now that I think about it, there's such a basic thing that doesn't happen in our
elections right now, which is if you're a Republican candidate, you are
not going to major population centers like L.A. and New York and doing speeches as you might do
in, say, Philadelphia, in that swing state of Pennsylvania. Similarly, the good people of
Mobile, Alabama, are not hearing from the Democratic candidate. And so you just have
plenty of people who just get no attention. Yeah. We just don't know how this is going to work,
right? It's an open question. You know, this might turn out to be a thing where, like,
everyone spends all their money now in California and Texas. Sure. You know, who knows? But I think
what this is aiming to solve is a frustration that people have right now with the current system,
which is that, you know, it is basically up to a few states to decide who is the leader of the
free world. And that is becoming increasingly unpopular for a number of reasons, but mostly
that this has only happened five times in history where the person who wins the presidency doesn't
win.
the national popular vote and twice since 2000. And so, you know, people our age, this has happened
twice in our lifetime. Right. So it feels like it's happened a lot. You know, we're all millennials
here. So for our listeners. So if you're a millennial, this has happened twice in your
lifetime. So it feels like it's happened a lot where historically it hasn't. I do think the one
thing this idea has going for it is that generally speaking, the sort of pro-democracy reforms that we
talk a lot on this podcast about rank choice voting being the one that comes to mind, they
make things a little bit more difficult. Yeah.
more complicated for voters, which is a real struggle, which is why we saw so many rank choice
voting proposals get voting down, among other reasons in 2024. This one is a little bit more
intuitive. It actually makes the mechanics of how it works would be complicated. But intuitively,
people understand the idea of if you get more votes, you win at the national level. Right. And
it's also this is not a new thing of trying to change it. I think that is really interesting
that there was there was an effort something like 50 years ago in Congress that passed
overwhelmingly in the House. It stalled in the Senate.
To reform the Electoral College then. And so this is a problem that people have thought about and
known about for decades. I don't think it would be as much of a shock as some of these other sort of
pro-democracy reforms like proportional representation, even anti-German reforms,
I think are a little complicated. This one feels intuitive.
I have one question I thought of as you guys were talking about that, though, which is
I think about people in rural areas because wouldn't they be disadvantaged by this or could
they be? Because you're talking about people spending all their money where all the people are. Well,
a lot of people aren't in Wyoming. So would would they get even less attention than the little
attention they get right now? Yeah, possibly. Yeah. And this is what I mean. Like, we don't
know what the outcomes of this are going to be. But that one's an easy assumption. This is what
I'm saying. Like, it could be that the major population centers, the states and the cities
with the most people are where people are going to campaign. But doesn't that make more sense?
Doesn't it make more sense to try and appeal to more people? Like, I think that is what is
underpinning a lot of this.
You know, if we have right now, I talk about this a lot, but like the way American politics in a lot
of ways works is very, very much minds for minoritarian views like that is very baked into
the system. And I think that's where you're seeing a lot of frustration with with folks right now.
And, you know, whenever we talk to voters, you know, they they they get really frustrated with
the system that says, oh, it doesn't seem to reflect what I want. And it's like, well, in a
lot of ways, it's like, well, you know, we don't know how our system works, like things like the
filibuster in the Senate, for example. And this is one of those vestiges of this like
minoritarian rule we have in our system, which is, yeah, we do not elect presidents with the
majoritarian system.
I do wonder also whether the time is a little bit ripe right now because President Trump did
win the popular vote. I almost feel like if this was being brought up in 2018, 2019, it would be
a complete nonstarter because it would so immediately feel tied to that result.
Sure.
Whereas now I think both political parties can look at it and say it's possible.
It's possible for us to win in a national popular vote setting. And so I guess I wonder whether this
is a unique period that this maybe, maybe won't get the level of outrage that it normally would
have.
Republicans show that they can win a popular vote. And then Democrats during the midterm
showed that they can win in big states to win an electoral college vote as well. Now,
I do think it's different voting groups, different, you know, electorate in a midterm.
But this could be a very interesting time to have this conversation.
OK, we've talked a lot about the effects, which are fascinating. But,
I want to talk about the legality of this because, Miles, the Electoral College is
in the Constitution. Now, I understand that this compact wouldn't abolish the Electoral College,
but aren't there grounds to say, wait a minute, wait a minute, this this compact is illegal?
It's a little bit more complicated because the Electoral College, as we think of it,
is not in the Constitution. What the Constitution says is that states elect electors and the
electors elect the president. And so the states have latitude on how those electors are elected.
I mean, like Ashley said, the Electoral College is not in the Constitution. It's not in the Constitution.
We've already seen states change this in Maine and in Nebraska. They allocate their presidential
elector votes based on congressional districts versus based on the state's popular vote. And so
I think for proponents, that is an argument that this is clearly constitutional. States can change
the way they do this. There are a lot of legal questions, I think, that will get parsed out.
And I think that the legal process is slow. And there are going to be many questions about this
that will probably be fought out in courts across the country, which is why I personally think it's
very unlikely that this goes into effect, even if there is political support in some of these states.
The idea that this is an effect for 2028 feels very unlikely based on just the amount of legal
questions that are going to have to be sorted out. Yeah. And so the court has weighed in on
the state's ability to, first of all, like bind their electors as well. So, you know,
the proponents of the national popular vote, they feel like that aspect of the legal hurdles aren't
as high. The one that could be significant is if the court changes the way they do it.
The court says, hey, something this big needs to be done through a constitutional amendment,
which is this really difficult process. Basically, like all the states have to sign on. Congress needs
super majorities to pass. It's just very difficult. Just think of like the Equal Rights Amendment.
Sure. That has been, people have been trying to get that passed for decades and it hasn't passed
because it's just such a tough process. And we don't amend the constitution a lot in this country.
So this is basically like a way to circumvent that, a little bit of an end run. It is a test.
It's important. You know, there's, you could call this a movement, but, you know, I see this as a
test of maybe making a very not so agile democratic system maybe meet a moment right now. And it could
fail and it could fail on a bunch of grounds. It's also just clear that even the Democrats in
some of these states that would have this power, I think are probably mulling this right now and
playing out, trying to think through how voters would perceive this. I mean, Katie Hobbs to me is
going to be, she's the governor of Arizona. She's the person. Democratic governor. She's the
democratic governor of Arizona, which is one of the states that would need to sign on to make this
a reality. She sponsored a bill to get Arizona into this national popular vote compact a few
years ago. So, you know, that in general, she's in favor of it. In a TV interview recently,
she was asked directly as governor, would you support something like this? She completely
changed the subject. She didn't say yes or no. She just started talking about affordability. And so
this is what democratic voters want us to focus on. Did not give a yes or no answer on this very
direct question.
And to me, that was an indication that I was like, oh, man, they are. This is a complicated
thing that they do not want to engage with yet. OK, so it's complicated. It may not happen soon.
It may not ever happen. We don't know. But there's momentum. So what are you guys going to be
watching for as this debate continues? Well, I mean, I'm going to be watching the governors and
the Senate and House minority leaders in all these five states that have new democratic majorities.
As Miles mentioned, like right now, we don't know where Katie Hobbs stands. We know where Josh
Jones stands. We don't know where he stands. We don't know where the governor is. We don't know
where he's going. And by the way,
in 2019, a bill passed for a national popular vote in Nevada and the Democratic governor at the time
did not sign it. It'll be very interesting to see what the sort of leaders in all these in all these
states have to say. The one thing I'll also note is there's a kind of a truism in voting that if
you're going to change the rules, you always want it to be bipartisan because otherwise the accusation
of cheating or rigging the system is just so easy to make. And so, yes, we're going to be watching
what these democratic majorities do and what these democratic governors are thinking. But to
me, I'm also going to be watching to see if some Republicans, if any Republicans come out in
support of this thing, any high profile Republicans, because I have to imagine that will play a big
part of the calculus, especially these battleground states where these governors and these senators
and all these representatives need the votes of Republicans to stay in power. You do not want
this to be a strictly democratic thing. All right. We've gotten into a lot,
so we're going to leave it there for today. However, one last thing, a quick reminder to
all of you super fans and public media nerds, if you've ever wanted to see the NPR news operation
in person, well, now's your chance. We're bringing one lucky winner and a guest to our headquarters
in Washington, D.C. for a behind the scenes tour. You will get to watch a live broadcast of all
things considered and have lunch with an NPR journalist. No purchase or donation required,
but you do have to be 18 years or older to enter. For links to the official rules and to enter,
go to npr.org slash giveaway. Deadline to enter is December 1st. I'm Ashley Lopez. I cover voting. And I'm Miles Parks. I also cover voting.
And thank you for listening to the NPR Politics Podcast.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The Electoral College currently determines the U.S. president through a winner-take-all system in most states, often resulting in a disconnect between the national popular vote and the presidential outcome.
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact proposes that participating states award their electoral votes to the nationwide popular vote winner, aiming to make presidential elections more reflective of the overall electorate.
As of now, 18 Democratic-leaning states plus DC have joined the compact, totaling 222 electoral votes, but it requires 270 electoral votes to become effective—meaning it is not currently in effect.
Political momentum behind the compact has grown due to Democrats’ gains in state governments during recent elections, giving them the ability and will to push for reform without Congressional action.
Critics raise legal and constitutional concerns, particularly about states binding electors and whether such a change requires a constitutional amendment, which would be difficult to pass.
The reform is seen as intuitive and less complicated than other democratic reforms, making it more palatable to voters who feel the current system ignores their voices.
Battleground states face a dilemma
Despite growing support, there is uncertainty about long-term viability due to legal challenges, political resistance, and the potential for bipartisan opposition, especially in swing states.
Summary:
S. Electoral College system currently awards the presidency based on state-level electoral votes, often diverging from the national popular vote—most notably in 2016 when Donald Trump won the presidency despite Hillary Clinton winning the popular vote. This disconnect has fueled a growing movement to reform the system, led by the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
Under this proposal, participating states would award their electoral votes to the candidate who wins the national popular vote, rather than their state’s popular vote. , have signed on, totaling 222 electoral votes—though the compact only activates when at least 270 electoral votes are pledged. While the reform is seen as intuitive and democratically appealing, it faces significant legal challenges, including constitutional questions about state authority to bind electors and whether such a change requires a constitutional amendment.
Political resistance is strong, especially in battleground states where losing electoral influence could reduce political power. Democratic governors in key states, such as Arizona, have shown cautious support but have avoided direct endorsements. Though momentum has increased due to recent election outcomes and bipartisan recognition of the system’s flaws, the compact remains a long-term possibility with substantial hurdles, including legal battles and political hesitation.
S. can modernize its electoral process in a way that aligns with public expectations of fairness and representation.
FAQs
The U.S. president is elected by a group of electors chosen by each state, who cast votes based on the state's popular vote. A candidate needs at least 270 out of 538 electoral votes to win, not the national popular vote.
It's an agreement among states to award their electoral votes to the national popular vote winner, rather than the state-level winner, effectively bypassing the current winner-take-all system in many states.
Supporters argue it makes presidential elections more democratic by ensuring the president wins the most votes nationwide, reducing dissonance between the popular vote and election results.
Yes, five times in U.S. history, most recently in 2016 when Donald Trump won the Electoral College despite Hillary Clinton winning the popular vote.
As of now, 18 states plus Washington, D.C. have joined, totaling 222 electoral votes. It would need 270 electoral votes to activate the compact.
The compact is considered constitutional because the Constitution allows states to determine how electors are chosen; however, legal challenges could arise, especially over whether it requires a constitutional amendment.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.