Go back

This is the BIGGEST Property Downturn in 40 Years: Tim Lawless and Eddie Dileen's insights

from Built Different Podcast | Australian Property Investing with Aaron Christie-David

1h 8m 32s

This is the BIGGEST Property Downturn in 40 Years: Tim Lawless and Eddie Dileen's insights

The housing market is experiencing a significant downturn, with values falling rapidly and confidence at a historic low. While the market may not reach its bottom until mid-next year, data shows a clear correlation between consumer pessimism and declining transaction volumes. Melbourne stands out as a potential growth opportunity, particularly in underpriced, high-yield units and townhouses in older blocks, where prices have remained stagnant despite rising rental yields and construction costs. These structural factors—such as high replacement costs and limited supply—act as a market floor, shielding values from deep collapses. Though inflation remains stubborn, analysts believe a stabilization in interest rates around mid-next year could trigger a recovery. The downturn is unlike past cycles, driven by a confluence of factors including rising interest rates, political shifts, and loss of confidence, not just credit tightening. Despite these challenges, contrarian strategies—particularly in affordable, high-yield segments—offer strong upside potential. For first-home buyers, the removal of negative gearing and rising prices have made entry harder, though long-term wealth outcomes may improve with time. Overall, the data suggests a period of volatility with a clear path to recovery, supported by structural imbalances and shifting market sentiment.

Transcription

12790 Words, 70984 Characters

English
We're definitely seeing housing values are falling quite rapidly, at least in from an historical perspective. Probably not quite approaching the bottom just yet, I think it won't be until probably the second half of next year. And the 200 plus properties at the moment, it's your strategy on the end game. Ironically, it's usually sometimes the best times to acquire an asset during these sort of bad times. If I was to pick any market around the country, you could probably prime to see some growth in medium-term. It's probably Melbourne. Get everyone walking back to another episode of Built Different. I've got two really good heads with me. We're going to get inside those heads very shortly to talk about the market and where we are headed based on kind of the data that we're seeing at the moment, also a lot of sentiment as we move forward. I want to start by saying thank you very much. Obviously to you guys, Tim and I, you've been super busy and very accommodating. So I want to say thank you to you Eddie. Thanks very much. And notice what absence today is Jeremy is a nilly which wants to say congrats to you on the birth of your third baby. He was very heavy-hearted that he couldn't be here and I just want to say his apologies, I want to say thank you very much. A big thank you to our listeners and viewers as well. You could be watching and listening to any other podcast, but you're choosing to be here and I want to say thank you very much for all the ways that you guys are showing up. I want to return served by saying if you're going to spend the time here today, we want to make it worth your while, which is why I've got you two guys here, very much to share what you're seeing and what you're experiencing on the ground and with the data as well. So Tim, as the head of research at Cotality, people may know that it's called Logic or RP data, 25 years in the game. We're going to talk about what you've seen over that time period, but also again, what the data is saying is at a different story to what say you're experiencing on the ground as well, Eddie. And hopefully we cover a good amount of turf. But gentlemen, welcome, how you doing? Thanks very much. Great to be here. Yeah. Eddie, hey, gone. Doing well. Good to be here. Thank you. May I start with you, Eddie? Just go right. Since the budget, what have you seen, experience, and what are your investors giving you as feedback at the moment? I'd say what I've experienced and what's got, what has been going on, particularly when it first started was a lot of unknown hesitation, panic, people freaking out. Obviously, the removal of probably the biggest one for me personally, and also a lot of the clients and the people that we help on on every day to day basis would be the removal of the ability to buy a residential through self managed super funds. The whole negative gearing thing that didn't like didn't phase me at all. It didn't phase like my client base and investors and my methodologies for investing has never been focused essentially around negative gearing to begin with. We've always had other strategies that we've been focused on. But people just really have been hesitant, but however insane that I've noticed a big turnaround in the last one to two weeks of the sentiment kind of changing and people just more of the sentiment getting back to like, you know, life goes on. It's shit right now. I don't think I think most people are not happy with the government changes in the government that's in power right now. I certainly am not. But I think a lot of people are starting to realize that life goes on. We've got to just keep getting on with it. I'm glad you said that because that's something that we're trying to really foster, which is I think we've all had our moment where we're throwing out toys out of the court. Had our little tantrum and there's people are going to be stuck in the hole and then stay there and there's people have gone, what can I do? These are the cards have been dealt. Now I'm going to try and get on with it. I think you spot on there, which is in the last couple of weeks. I'm going to be really open with our numbers. For example, in the last two weeks, we've put up some of our biggest numbers in the year. It's even pre-budget as well. And I really felt that sentiment start to shift where I think there's people have gone through that acceptance phase. The rate rise happened and people have been just gone on with it and there's potentially another rate rise or even two more to come and they're going right. Well, if I don't act, boring capacity is going to continue to fall and at the same time we're seeing confidence just start to go through the shift. So thanks very much. If anyone comes to yourself, Tim, your busy man with the podcast and everything that's going on from a data perspective, so you're in demand, what are you seeing and experiencing from a data perspective at the moment? Well, it's definitely a good time to be an analyst for that way because there's a lot going on. So I think it's important to say you start the podcast with the budget this weakness we've been seeing in the housing market was evident well and truly before the budget was handed down. So there's a lot of other things going on in the housing market. In fact, we saw the peak number of sales was about October last year. So you remember that time, so about a year ago, that's when we started to see inflation, starting to pick up confidence was starting to weaken a little bit the RBA is becoming a bit more hawkish in the language, which results has ultimately in rate starting to rise and February and then Iran happens confidence plummeted even further on the back of just fuel prices being so high. And then the budget was handed down. So in many ways, this is a bit of a perfect storm and we're definitely seeing housing values of falling quite rapidly at least in from an historical perspective at the moment. So we're six months into a housing downturn, probably not quite approaching the bottom just yet would be my view. I think it won't be until probably the second half of next year until the market is stabilized and maybe moves into some level of growth. But that itself provides some opportunity. So even though service ability is still really challenging given how high interest rates are and how high household debt levels are falling prices can be a real opportunity for people to get their foot back in the door of the housing market. As Eddie was saying, I think one of the biggest risks in the market is interest rates go higher and service ability just becomes more and more challenging, especially when you have to demonstrate ability to service a mortgage, three percentage points higher than the going rate given given the appra service ability buffer. So nice to say, I think sitting behind that is probably yields and yields have started to pick up so mentor returns have really started to prove and strengthen as well. But I think the talk of rate rises is still enough to keep people at bay because they're going to make well. Yeah, function of borrowing capacity and then confidence has just started to wait. So look at the two seismic confidence and capacity. We're really not seeing that kind of match at the moment. What are you seeing again from a data perspective around the country? Yeah, I mean, confidence is so important. And you can measure confidence. There's a couple of indices. There's a weekly one from A&Z in Roe Morgan. There's a monthly one from Westpac in the Melbourne Institute. They both show pretty much the same thing, right? Consumers are deeply pessimistic. And when you overlay the number of home sales against these these two confidence indices, it's almost a perfect correlation, which is pretty intuitive to me. When you're lacking confidence about your finances, about the domestic economy, about geopolitical uncertainty, you're not going to make a really high commitment financial decision like buying a home. So I think that's one of the key reasons why we're seeing transactional activities so low at the moment on our numbers. The September quarter was down about 20%, nationally, on a year ago, excuse me. So yeah, down from relatively high levels, though. So we're definitely seeing turnover tracking below average now. And I think that's a real reflection of just the confidence is deeply pessimistic as it is. And if we do see another rate hike, if we see inflation tracking even higher than what it currently is, or not even falling, hopefully as we expected to, you have to think that's going to keep confidence relatively low. So you're saying we're going to say midway through next year before we start seeing some real improvement. What makes you kind of peg that time period before we start seeing an inflection point in the market? Yeah, good question. So we sort of look for, I guess, evidence of any sort of catalyst that might change the marketplace. So historically, a positive catalyst would be something like, just rates coming down, or even before that inflation coming down in the RBA becoming a little bit more dovish in the language. That starts to influence confidence positively. Or other factors could be, you see, like a freeing up of credit policy. For example, APRA could reduce their serviceability buffer back to two and a half percentage points, not saying they will, they probably won't. Or it could be some sort of fiscal policy comes to rescue the market. Like think back to 2009, we saw the first home buys grant boost along with falling interest rates. And that really saw the market pick up out of the global financial crisis. So our view is we probably won't see inflation trending towards the RBA's target range until probably around the middle of next year. And I think the RBA is going to be quite cautious about their interest rate decision making. Because I think they probably recognize that they brought rates down too early and inflation rebounded. And they're going to be quite cautious in doing that again. So they probably want to see inflation getting very much firmly towards the top of their target range, around 3%. It's 3.6% of the moment. I think it's going to be quite stubborn. Most economists think it's probably not until around the middle of next year. There's any chance of rates coming down. And I think that's probably the catalyst to see the market improving. I mean, we can. We can argue around inflation for hours, I'd feel. Because anyone listening that has a mortgage, for example, even renters, to that extent, so people that are investing will tell you, may have made every single cut back I possibly can like I've cut my budget back towards absolute bare bones. How much more can I actually save or not spend to do my part of it? around inflation. So why is it so stubbornly high? And why do rates not seem to be working? Are rate increases seem to be working? Do you think? - It's just so frustrating. So I don't even agree with you. Consumers have pullback hard. In the old sort of our ASIC description, they're drinking a lot less wagyu, and sorry, a lot less charazan and wagyu. - Now I don't think they're even, I don't think they're doing red wagyu. - Charazan wagyu, man. I think it's bloody off cuts and slow cook meat, you know? - Yeah, it's eating it and drinking it all. - That's it, mate, it's, it's spending too much. - Yeah, that's, well, that's definitely part of it, I think. But there's also things like, you think about how CPI has calculated housing, which has got the highest inflationary figure at the moment. It's also the biggest weight in the CPI calculation. And what's really driving housing inflation is high building costs. So it's costing a lot to build a home, and that's starting to pick up again, because of high oil and fuel prices and materials costs and tight labor markets. The other thing that's really driving inflation is, as you say, government spending and high services costs. So things like, um, insurances, healthcare, education, things we can't really pull back on as consumers are things that are really driving inflation. I think a lot of Australians, most Australians have pulled back as hard as they can, as you say, but it's not enough. So the RBA has the one blunt weapon, which is interest rates. They'll keep on putting rates up until inflation starts to come down. Do you think it'll work? Here is an opinion. Yeah, absolutely. It will work over time. It probably isn't going to work as quickly as what the RBA would like to. And if you listen to any of the commentary coming from the RBA, it's not like they want to put up rates to quell the economy. You know, it's a pretty good chance where we're on the brink of a recession here if we see rates going up further. But if inflation-- remember, the RBA has two mandates. They've got keeping inflation between 2% and 3% and full employment. So if you listen to the fireside chat with Deputy Governor Hauser from the RBA, he's seen a bit skeptical that the loosening in labor markets was real as what the ABS numbers are saying that there's been a few methodology changes. And he's also pretty frank that he doesn't think inflation's coming down as soon as the RBA would like it to. It's stubbornly high. Everything you're saying there at the moment, I feel, he's really consistent across a lot of leading voices here, so you take yourself, Christopher Joy, for example, and he plugs into a lot of your data as well. Had Tommy Panos on last week as well. We're looking at all the bank's economists. So there's a lot of consistency around how there's still a lot more pain to come before we start seeing improvement as well. I want to come to yourself Eddie and say, mate, you're in pretty vocal. You're buying a lot at the moment. What are you buying? Where are you buying? And why are you buying at the moment? All right, well, a few questions. I'll probably start off with why in my different, I guess, thesis on where I see certain markets going and how I view certain markets. During the time right now, like obviously, inflation has been through the roof. And people say the market is coming down. And a lot of the stats and data and statistics have showing that the market's coming down, right? I look at and always have looked at the property market as different, obviously, everyone says there's different segmented markets. There's different markets within markets. We get that, we know that. But I like to take it one step further personally and people can disagree with this or not. But this has worked for me going from zero to like 200 properties to myself. Is that there are certain brackets within the marketplace. And this is just the way that I view it. Like I would say brackets would be 750,000 and under, 1.5 to downwards to 750, and then 3 million and over in terms of residential investment properties. Now, if you look back on history and data could potentially match this, but at the same time, I do believe in some instances data can be skewed in certain realms. That when times of uncertainty like this, that we are currently going through, generally, I see and have researched and seen over the years of course of my investing career, is that usually the volatility, the highest amount of volatility in price corrections and drops is in the higher tiers price brackets of markets. So 3 million, you know, coming or $4 million, probably $6 million, $7 million. And that's what we're, you know, even well-known property people where you mentioned Tom Parnas before. Like even he said that as well. So many people that are in that seeing the on-the-ground results every single day are seeing that. I'm seeing that. Properties that were $7 million, yes, some of them have come back 15, 20% like massive amounts. But in the flip side of that, I've seen the affordability markets. We're talking properties under 750, under 650, in metro markets, particularly right now in the state or capital city of Melbourne, which I have seen has been very held back in a bad market due to multiple, you know, government land tax changes and just the negative sentiment in general with, you know, all the other stuff. But from my investing methodologies of one would say, investing with a contrarian value-style investing, I'm always targeting markets that I see are undervalued. And one would say being a very bad shit time to invest. That's why I generally see the biggest amount of opportunity. And I've generally had the biggest amount of upsides from when I've invested in locations such as Brisbane or Perth, as an example, Perth after that long run of stagnation, absolutely went like crazy. Same with Adelaide and things like that. So I'm seeing affordability properties in Melbourne. And we're talking about the types of properties. Like, anything under 750 within that radius of like 30 to 40 minutes of Melbourne, I see actually moving, I don't see actually coming back at all. If anything, the lower the price point, the higher I've seen it actually move in the last three to six months. About 12, probably 18 or 24 months ago, it was very controversial, but I said in social media and I got ridiculed for it, that I believe that a lot of types of assets in Melbourne such as different, not necessarily houses, but townhouses, villas, and units, particularly in old school blocks where they have a good land component of ratio, actually are undervalued and have the biggest amount of growth potential ahead of them. And everyone were like, a lot of people just called me absolutely crazy for saying that, but I've noticed since that the last 18 to 24 months, there has been a massive influx of 1,000 different buyers agents jumping, switching the standard sentiment from houses to townhouses, villas, units stock, especially in the Melbourne market. - Is that a function of price point? Is that a function of yield? Is that a function of opportunity that what's driving that? - I see at least three to four things. I see there's obviously the yields there, like the properties as an example in boutique blocks or townhouses, villas, like I've mentioned these suburbs before, and it's not necessarily just about suburb, I've invested in-- - Pillars example, yeah, right with it. - You know, L. Wood, St. Kielder, all those kind of eastern Southeast locations within Melbourne, you know, you could pick them up for like 300,000, and some of those are 300, 400, 500,000 old school blocks. So you get them at roughly, you know, sometimes 70 to 80% land content when you break down, it's a block of 10 on a thousand square meters, and the per rate square meter land rate is X amount. You know, you're buying base, you might be paying 450 for a unit, but the land content might be worth $3.7380. So you're picking up the building for like 70 grand. Now those prices have been stagnant for a long period of time from what I've seen and what I've researched, like I've gone through thousands of transactions, we bought thousands of properties there too. But essentially, we're buying them basically at like some of them at 2011, 2012 prices. Now, what I think about is the flow on effect from a data standpoint is back then, you also look on a totality RP data, and the average rents around there were half of what they are now. But the prices back then were the exact same price almost as what they're selling for now, which goes to show me that the rental yields have doubled over the last 10 years. The prices might not have moved, but the rental yields have doubled, and then on top of that, the replacement cost has like four to five Xs in the last 10 years. So now to rebuild those villas, townhouses, boutique blocks, you can't get a developer to build it for less than like, and add their margin and buy the land and construct it. So like a unit or boutique or townhouse in those really good blue chip locations, where houses are like six, seven, 10 million bucks. You can get an entry, property like that for like 500K, 450K. And the replacement cost is like 1.2, just to replace it. So to me, the yields there, the growth is there, the year, I'm buying in line with the cycle. It could never get any cheap, because it can't be replaced for a third of the price. And you're actually buying it at a blue chip location. So like these are already exploding. Like this is the biggest opportunity, and since I've mentioned it, like everyone's just jumped on the bad bandwagon, and they're all starting to target these style properties now. - You're 200 plus properties at the moment. What's your strategy and what's your end game, Eddie? I don't necessarily have an endgame, okay? I just um. I believe in the, in order to life you've got to continue progressing on my shape of form, whether it's buying property, whether it's helping people, whether it's business, whether it's doing a podcast, whether it's spreading goodwill information and karma. It's just in China, continue to progress on my shape of form and then enjoy it with my kids and go on as many holidays as possible. Tim, when you hear that, for example, when you hear Eddie doubling down on Melbourne units, what's the data saying about, we can roll it up a little bit so you have Victoria, then you have Melbourne in a ring, units for example, sub 500, 600 for example, what's the data's winning to them, eh? Exactly what Eddie's been saying, so that's a pretty tough market for the last 10 years, Melbourne units. Terrible. If they have a move in value that they've gone backwards, I think, I mean, hopefully like COVID, yeah, everything low rates, you know, a threat period, yeah, sorry, yeah. So I think if I was to pick any market around the country that's probably primed to see some growth in the medium term, it's probably Melbourne, right? It's undervalued as a whole city, not just talking about where Eddie's buying. I mean, you look at the difference between Sydney's medium value and Melbourne, it's nearly 60% now. It's never been that wide, normally it's about a, you know, 15 to 20% difference. So I think it really highlights that Melbourne, sure, it's had a pretty weak run of growth over the past five or six years, it's had some challenges, both politically and economically, very high levels of state government debt, higher unemployment. But you can see interstate migrations coming back into Victoria, after this mass exodus of people leaving during the pandemic, they're starting to repatriate themselves now. I think a big part of that simply comes down to the fact that if you did leave Victoria through the pandemic and you bought into Melbourne, sorry, bought into Brisbane or Perth or Adelaide, you're probably sitting on a lot of wealth, at least compared to what Melbourne's been doing and your capital goes a lot further now. So I think, yeah, absolutely, the data is showing exactly what Eddie's saying. I think the benefit of a specialist like Eddie is, you know, where in Melbourne is probably a good investment at the moment. So for me, as an analyst, I look at sort of more broader trends, but, therefore, what do you say, mate, it makes a lot of sense to me, and I think the fact that we're still seeing construction cost rising quite quickly and now just showing the first signs of re-accelerating, this highlights the replacement cost is going to be a real challenge, and feasibility for getting more supply into the marketplace is going to be with us for some time yet. That's what I've generally called the floor in the market, which replacement values is where we're at. I mean, I've been very open, we've done a couple of builds and constantly just getting re-updates on pricing, and we think we're going to go backwards. That's what again, we talked about the cup of coffee, schooner of beer, later of petrol. We just had a new price that's moving forward, like I don't see them suddenly just dropping back their prices. Do you see that playing out in the future as well? This is just getting used to the new norm around, this is what it's going to cost. Oh, mate, I can't see builders and developers dropping their prices to meet the market. They need to maintain a profit margin, so that's the real challenge here is when you've got an established market that's going backwards, in most parts of the country, and you've got construction costs rising, you've got this stretched target from the federal government to build 1.2 million homes, where everyone knows they're going to miss it massively. There's a lot of focus on getting more supply into the marketplace, but remember, this is the private sector of this building, they're not going to do it for free, they're not going to do it without an acceptable profit margin for the risk they're facing. I think the next couple of years we'll continue to see these feasibility pressures, which for the market, if you're looking for price growth, it doesn't necessarily mean prices are going to rise just because it's really expensive to build, but it probably does help to insulate the market from a downturn that otherwise would have been more significant if we hadn't hadn't had enough to supply of housing. Okay, cool. So as a property analyst, this guy around the country a little bit, and just get a feel for half far we've come off the pace, for example, so we've got a Brisbane, what you read on Breezy at the moment. Yeah, well, Brisbane's come out of a massive growth run, obviously, it's been down and value over the past five months to the end of September, the market's down about four to five percent since then. So, you know, say, for example, in a market like Brisbane, Adelaide of Perth, if you saw housing values fall, say, 15 percent, kind of worst case scenario or pretty grim view of the market, you're getting back to where the market was in sort of early 2025 in Perth or sort of late 2024 in Brisbane and Adelaide. So Brisbane— For any gains since then, I'm pretty much gone in the last year or two. In the last year or two? Well, in the last year. Yeah. In the last two years. You're probably still in a pretty good equity position, I would say, given the growth in the market. So Brisbane's clearly slowing. We've seen about a 27 percent drop in sales activity, September quarter compared to the same quarter a year ago. I think some of the fundamentals easing off as well, like interstate migration into Queensland's getting back to much more normal levels now, and I think that's probably a reflection of just the affordability challenges that have crept into the mid-size capitals, given how much values have risen over the past six years. And then you've got, say, Sunshine Coast Gold Coast, are they performing differently or are they all kind of rolling at the same level? Not really, man. You can broadly put South East Queensland into a very similar basket now. The Gold Coast is probably a little bit weaker. It can be a little bit more speculative. The sunny coast doesn't have as much density. To Wombas, a very affordable market, hasn't worn as much of a downturn as what Brisbane has. But South East Queensland broadly kind of peaked around the same time and values are generally trending lower across all those South East Queensland markets. All right. Cool. So we keep going around. Darwin seems to just come off the ball just a little bit, but I mean, it did really well. Darwin's always a little bit countercyclical, but yeah, it looks to be pretty clearly easing in the rate of growth. And I wouldn't be surprised if it joins the downturn club as such over the coming months. It looks like the September quarter was only just holding it a positive territory. So I think even though Darwin is an extremely affordable market, it's got, by far, the highest rental yields, it can still be a pretty fickle market. It is a relatively small market that can be driven or turned on, on big infrastructure projects or government announcements around spending that type of thing as well. But it is very affordable. A Perth? Yeah. Perth, kind of some of the other mid-sized capitals clearly moving through down to now. In fact, values are falling a little bit more sharply than what they are in Brisbane or Adelaide. So in the same sense, I mean, Perth was just so far leading that the housing upswing, rising from a very low base back in 2020, but I think that period of catch-up kind of expired by sort of 2024 or so, and, you know, it's been seeing Perth moving well beyond catch-up now. It's now the third highest median value after Sydney and Brisbane. Yields are starting to rise a little bit, but have been depleted. Listing numbers are up nearly 70 percent compared to a year ago, again, off almost record lows. So there's a lot more stock to choose from and it looks like that market's certainly now going through the correction it had to have, I'd say. Yeah, absolutely. Adelaide? It's not falling in value quite as quickly as Brisbane or Perth, but clearly declining. If I was to choose any capital city around the country with the highest risk profile, it's probably Adelaide, I would have to say. It just doesn't seem to have the same underlying fundamentals of, say, Brisbane or Perth, in a sense, it's got a shallower economy, it's got negative interstate migration, has for a year now. It's the most unaffordable capital city when you adjust for local incomes against local values as well. So it does look like it's probably a little bit overheated in Adelaide, and I wouldn't be surprised if that market does languish a little bit longer than other markets. Yeah, right. Interesting. Tazzy? Tazzy bucking the trend, I'm sorry, down a little bit as well, so values are still lower than what they were back in 2022, back in Tazzy, and that's as a reflection of how weak that market has been since interest rates started to rise in the middle of 2022. But it does seem to be coming back a little bit now. We're not seeing values actually falling across Hobart. Some of the regional markets, like Launceston, seem to be quite strong as well, or strong at least in relativity, then, in a sense, that values aren't falling in those markets. And again, it's pretty affordable. It's got a positive rate of interstate migration that's coming back. I think that wave of empty nesters and baby boomers looking for a tree change is probably benefiting Tazzy as well. Okay, cool. So I've gone through Melbourne. Sydney seems to be like, every time we look at this red line, it's a very tough market. It's obviously extraordinarily expensive. It's been through a pretty decent growth run over six years. Not as strong as the mid-sized capital, but it was already rising from a relatively high base, from a pricing perspective. It has been, like most cities, it's generally been that lower end of the market or the lower end of the price point, so it's been a little bit more insulated to falling values. Like out of western Sydney, it's been a little bit more resilient, but that's starting to fade now as well. So we're seeing a bit of a convergence of the trends across the upper quarter on the lower quarter of the market. I mean, that's happening everywhere, but it seems to be most, most pronounced or most visible in a market, like Sydney, where I think the affordability pressures are a lot more evident than other markets. I mean, Adelaide's the same sort of thing. Yeah, cool. Thanks so much. So if you look to the data and said, where is opportunity sitting in here, what would the Cotality Crystal Ball tell you? Yeah, the Crystal Ball is a bit murky, to be honest, but I still say Melbourne. We talked about Melbourne a bit earlier in the podcast. It just stands out as having that affordability advantage that no other major capital city has. And that's the silver lining of its week performance over the past five years. Yields are a little bit higher, but in saying that like a 4.1% gross yield is the broad yield across Metro Melbourne. It's better than Sydney at 3.1, but it's still when you've got rates for investors up around 7% with high strata fees, higher insurances, higher maintenance costs, a gross yield of about 4.1% across the board. It's still a pretty low one, the agreety, but the unit market definitely has some pockets of higher yields. Outside of Melbourne, if I look at markets that might offer a little bit of opportunity, it's probably going to be the satellite cities, like your classic gelong, Newcastle, Wollongong, to Wombat, outside of Brisbane. So they still have a bit of a affordability advantage over their capital city counterparts, but also I think we've seen this structural change where more people can base themselves in these commutable satellite cities because they can work remotely, at least part of the time and commute back without too much of a massive commute coming in for those markets. Thanks very much. I appreciate it. Do you worry about like some of the political unrest and this massive state debt that Victoria has? Does it factor in as part of this, or do you go and manage to play on? Well, it's probably said yes to both parts of your question, absolutely. This is a concern, the fact that we are seeing federal government debt ramping up, Victoria is probably the epitome at a state level and introducing a lot of taxes, which maybe they think is going to raise more revenue, but lowering the land tax threshold and having a very high stamp duty rate definitely hasn't seen Victoria raking in more property-related taxes has been the opposite. So I think absolutely it does put Australia in a more risky position to be fair though. I mean debt to GDP ratio in Australia is what I think it's from memory around 50 percent now. The US is up around 130 percent. Government debt in Australia is very low from a global standpoint, but it's rising pretty quickly. And kind of like an CPI conversation, the government does seem to be spending quite freely at the time when consumers are trying to pull back pretty hard. So yeah, it does concern me, but I think, I mean, that's kind of like the changes to taxation in the federal budget, it's the framework we're working within. It's not like you can just stop making decisions and trying to build your wealth. You need to be working around that and working within it, I suppose. So it's one part of the equation, but I don't think it'll be standing in the way of people's decision making over the medium term. Cool. Do you think we're headed for a recession? It really depends on where interest rates go from here. I think even if we don't technically go into a recession, for most of us, it feels like a recession. Correct. We've been in a. Not a year. I'll come back to you in a second. Yeah. I mean, we've been in a per capita recession in a year now. And the fact that consumers are feeling the pain so severely probably means, even though we haven't had two consecutive quarters of GDP going backwards, for most of us, it feels like we're in a recession. That's probably what matters. What do you. What did you not do? Yeah, I just think, like, to me, obviously, you know, it says, if you look at the stats and all that stuff, technically, we weren't in it, but I think from speaking to clients every single day and over the months and over the last six months with, especially all the changes, you know, the inflation, the interest rates going up, the budget changes that remove all negative gearing, like, it's a combination of all of that tied together, which, I believe, has obviously taken a lot of confidence out of the market for the average type of, you know, buyer. So to me, it's already, like, it already feels like we're already in one. Like, I feel like, obviously, there's certain metrics that just put it in there. But like, I would dare say we're already in one. We've already been in one to me for like two, three months. Even if you look at something like unemployment as well. Unemployment? It's going up. Wages growth? Yeah, yeah. So, just wages growth for inflation, we've already begun through four quarters of negative real wages growth, and there's more to come. So, yeah, I think for an every day Australian, it's definitely some pretty hard yards that, if we move into a technical recession, it's even worse, right? And, you know, we're kind of losing the benefit of the really strong population growth. We've had that supported GDP over the past few years because population growth is mostly normalised now. It's about 1.4%. So, if you just for population growth for GDP, that's kind of what's been buoying our overall GDP numbers and keeping us out of recession. As you guys are talking, I'm probably, you know, through the perspective of the listener, so migration has been up, inflation has been up, interest rates are up, cost of living up, for example, unemployment's up, massive tax changes in the last few months, prices are down, rent's still going up, so there's a lot that's happening, like people are just getting, you know, suck a punch, they're fried in centre. How do people make sense of this from your perspective to go, man, sentiment is a real driver and confidence is such a driver in this. How does someone mentally weather this storm to come out this stronger and better? Everyone's going to have their own tactics, for sure. I mean, definitely it's a case of batting down the hatches and weathering the storm. I think that's probably the best advice is, this isn't going to last forever, right? There will be a time where inflation is not as high as what it is currently, when interest rates do come down, reliable markets stabilize. It's certainly not on the horizon at the moment, but it will happen. So I think for most people it just means keep a chin up, do as best as you can, make the most of it as best you can and hopefully, as I said, around the middle of next year, hopefully we're in a bit of a better position financially as a country. Because we're talking about this as a 40-year downturn at the moment, so what are the property cycles coming to look at, I mean, before we jumped on, what 2017 to 2019 felt like, and I was smack banging the middle of that in terms of lending and the restriction around lending, then the interest only caps as well, after all commission, ERA 2, does this feel different? Does this look different based on, you know, 25 years experience and how does it compare to say the 80s as well? Yeah, it is very different. So if you go back 40 years, Australia has gone through 10 housing downturns that have last at least three months, the biggest one was during a period of credit tightening. So the middle of 2017 to the middle of 2019, so that was preceded by a couple of rounds of macro potential from APRA, which is simply, you know, a 10% speed limit on investment credit growth, 30% limit on interest only lending, which I'm sure you remember fondly. Very cool. And then just amplified by the Royal Commission, the source serviceability standards really tightened up and lenders become quite conservative. So we saw housing values form across the combine capitals by 8.2%. Sydney was down about 15% in that downturn as well. So that's the biggest downturn we've seen in 40 years. The second biggest was, as interest rates rose off the record lows after the pandemic. So May 2022 to January 2023, really short and sharp, values fell 8.1%. And again, Sydney saw a larger fall, perth hardly anything and hardly broken stride. So I think when you look historically, there's generally been almost like a singularity that was driving a housing downturn, credit tightening or rising interest rates, but this time it's a multitude of factors. Started with affordability and serviceability then went into higher interest rates, then a crisis of confidence is around, the war in Iran happened, and then a structural change from the federal budget was handed down that's seen a really sharp pullback in investment, but also less activity from other segments of the marketplace as well that were supposed to pick up. So I think at the moment, there is this multitude of headwinds facing demand in the housing market. You'll probably add to that just slowing population growth, which I think a lot of people would be a good thing, but again, it's not going to last forever, right? There are going to be some factors that see demand start to become supported, and I think that's probably going to be inflation getting under control, and interest rates started to come down. Whatever the timing of that is. Okay. Great. Thanks for much. Budget is always intended for first home buyers. What's your first home buyer activity? I'll come to you in a second, Eddie. What's your first home buyer activity indicator is looking like at the moment? They're hard to come by, to be frank, so I mean- Why is that? Out of curiosity. Well, the best way to understand first home buyer movements is the ABS lending data. It's quarterly. It's pretty lagged. We've only seen the June quarter data release now, and that only includes half of the budget hand down period. It did show a pullback in in first home buyers, a larger pullback in investors, also showed a pullback in non-first home buyer or owner occupiers as well. Here's some anecdotes from brokers and from lenders as well. First home buyers are probably down around 15 to 20%. Yes. What they were pre-budget, I think that's probably just a reflection of really low confidence. First home buyer does want to buy when prices are falling, only enough, because they don't want to have an asset that they've saved so much for and have so much invested in suddenly become less than what they paid for it. I think a lot of them are going to be trying to time the market. But if I can say this, I mean, there's a rare piece of positivity from the federal budget. forward say, you know, a year. a year or a year and a half is the market does stabilize. I firmly believe we'll see much less level of investment in the market, whether that's positive or not. It could be anyone's view, but I think we will see more first home buyers. And I think that probably first home buyers were relish not having the competition with investors in the market as well, because they do tend to compete with for similar types of property. So maybe that they will actually come to plan. I think the fact that we're not seeing as much first home buyer activity in the market at the moment probably doesn't have as much to do with the budget as it does with just the cyclical factors that are playing out and the serviceability challenges. Even if you're on a 5% deposit guarantee, it's still pretty hard to demonstrate an ability to service a 95% of the outlaw. Eddie would chuckle to yourself before our first home buyers find the budget? Would you experience that? Look, the policy changes to me are just absolutely ridiculous. If you're going to try to help first home buyers, you basically pull it up the ladder up behind you. People with grandfathering, the negative gearing benefits and all that kind of stuff. I've got children properties in my individual name, so they're still negative gear. But what about for someone else out there starting again wanting to start from the very bottom? A lot of people need a stepping stone investment property to get into an owner occupied house. They do investing strategies or whatever, but I think it's made it even harder for people to get in the market if anything, especially starting out. There's a lot of variables, but how's it got harder? Do you think? A combination, obviously, with the changes, obviously, interest rates have gone up as well. It's hard to say. It's hard to say, like, interest rates have obviously gone up. I've lost my train of thought there. I'm going to come back to you because when did you buy your first property? I'd say $18.19. You bought your first property? So what year are we talking there, man? 2008-2009. So GFC, you bought your first property? So you're nearly 20 years in the game, investing. Have you said the course of that 20 years? We've gone through a few iterations, so GFC, what would be the next one? 2010-12. Interest rates were going up, and I had the GFC downturn. We probably should have had during the GFCs. Yeah. And then we go forward a few years, with the 14, 15, 17, 19, COVID, and now. Yeah. Heaps of ups and downs. Yeah. How have you said on course? Investing in the types of properties that I've always invested in. I haven't gone to higher end, like I own some properties that are very expensive, 5, 6, 7, 10 million bucks, but the bulk of my property portfolio has always been in the affordable markets. Like out of the 230 properties I have, I'd say like 30 or 40 of my houses and the rest of townhouses villas and blocks of units and stuff like that. So I bought strategically stuff that had a really high rent we owed, which would cash flow itself, relatively all far better than just buying the average stand alone house with a 4% gross yield that ends up to being like a net 3% yield. So I've been, and then I've obviously stacked unit blocks on top of that where I've scaled to buy bigger assets, but still had an incorporation of individual affordability units. So I might buy a block of units of 5 million as an example that has 15 units in it, but I'm getting the growth from an affordability perspective based on each individual unit if it was to be resold individually, whereas if I'm buying a $5 million house to invest in and getting a terrible one or two percent yield, whereas a block of units might get me a gross six or seven percent yield as an example. Are you buying blocks of units to then straddle or what's the strategy with buying blocks of units? The strategy for me is I've always, like I have 11 different key things that I always look at in terms of investment strategy or philosophy, and that is the ability to buy an asset and then extract the equity out of it within a short time frame or so a clear recycle exit strategy before I buy the property. So if I'm buying a property individual or a block of units or whatever it is, affordable or expensive, I'm only personally buying that. If I know that I can essentially get my capital back out within my control in a liquid form by refinancing and topping up or doing a side loan and extracting that equity within six months. So essentially I'm acquiring the asset and then if I'm putting in 20 or 30 percent to buy it or more, I'm only buying it if I've done the feasibility that I can get it extracted within six months or so afterwards. So if your goal is to buy a re-value within a six month period and we're looking at all the data going made, it's all red in the red at the moment, not the black. How are you ensuring that you call it a six month period that there is equity to strip on that? Yeah, good question. So depending on the type of asset, and this is where like I believe the rise of like so many changes are happening right now, and I called it probably six or eight months ago even longer than that, then like the especially the property investment realm or the buyer's agent space, people are moving on from houses. A lot of buyer's agents have started to be like, oh now we see value in town houses, now we see value in villas, now we see value in units. So the standard sentiment is changing because of many factors, but one of them's affordability. So what was the question originally against? Yes, so how are you ensuring that you got, so you can actually strip out of it? Yeah, so ensuring we can actually get the equity out of it as an example. So if I'm buying a certain type of property, let's say on the bigger scale. So the bigger sell properties that I buy for myself, and then also do very unique needs strategies for clients is the unit block or townhouse or villa complex, existing bulk deal strategy. And this is essentially where I'll buy properties from a vendor in a one line transaction. This is what we're doing a lot in Melbourne, a lot in Sydney right now. I've been doing the strategy, which isn't very well known for probably like four to five years now. Started off in Queensland, then I moved around the country to Perth, then add and different stuff like that. But basically targeting existing unit blocks that one vendor owns, they might have owned it for 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 years. It's on a big block of land and they're either individually titled or strata titled. If they are strata titled, that is the key metric of one of the things that I personally have done. And giving this away is obviously going to ensure a lot more copycats, which has already been happening like nonstop the last 12 months, because I never used to be vocal and actually share my, you know, in-depth strategies behind the scenes. Is your secret source? Some of the secret source, yeah. There's still more out there, but everyone's been copying the bulk deal strategy. But essentially, even from a valuation perspective, and you look at valueors, you know, acumenters and all that stuff, right? They have a valuation, you know, this ensures a broker. A very experienced broker would be that they have a one in one line valuation. When they do often value these unit blocks, which are, or, or complexes, townhouses existing, when, if let's say there's 10 or 20 in the block of five or six, in one line valuations, often appropriates a discounted valuation of five, 10 percent roughly from being sold individually basis. And then I think of what is the, why is that from a, you know, reasons behind the scenes, is because if it's sold in one line, you know, it's like, it's a discounted price generally for circumstances. It's like in between an arms length and not an armament transaction, because you've got various factors, you're selling them all together, like buying at Costco. So, valueors do that. And then they also put special, the banks and finance arms put special policies within that on the back end that say, you can't do certain valuations if you own the entire block. Like, if you own more than 25 percent, then we won't allow you to do desktop valuations. Why is that? So, all these back end policies, basically, which I've figured out over the years and then figured out the nitty gritty's of it, is essentially target those blocks, secure them at a discounted price by buying them in one line with good terms. And, but I'll price them not on the cap rate of the yield. I'll price them from an alternative point of view, which is from an individual sales basis if this was to sell individually to an owner occupier, not teneted but vacant. So, I'll compare as an example of blocks of units myself. I own about 30 blocks of units, ranging from 2 million each to like 12 million each. And some of these blocks as an example, I'm picked them up in a one line transaction because the vendor was like, they need it sold within three to six months. And they're so, if they were to sell it individually to an owner occupier, they would have to vacate all the tenants and then target an owner occupier individual to get the highest purchase price because obviously owner occupies buy with the motion. So, I basically only buy a property to summarize and structure it if I can do the feasibility of it, if I can know that I can get it valued. And I can even do that from how you let's get these valued prior to even entering a contract based on comparable sales. So, you bind that all for yourself, for you to spin that with clients. - For example, what's your. - Yeah, but you go to the market. - But the last four years, I stumbled across this strategy, like, you know, probably 2020 or maybe five, six years now. And I would basically, it was negotiating one town else in Queensland. And I was buying a lot of properties off market for clients or investors. And the agent basically was like, I've got a developer who owns like 36 and they've had owned it for 10 years. They just want to flock it all off. But they need the money now. So we're negotiating that. So basically if they're already individually titled or if I can orchestrate or put a deal together where it's not shredded title, but it'll be shredded title prior to settlement, we do all that kind of creative, you know, innovative ways to where you can pick up equity on the way in. And you can see that you're actually getting a discount on the way in of, you know, sometimes 10, 15, 20, 30%. Like, it's crazy. - All right, cool. Thanks very much. Appreciate it. And we come back to yourself, Tim, and go, right, upon reflection of the budget and kind of what's happened. I mean, hindsight's a beautiful thing, yeah. What do you think the government could have done differently to get to an outcome that housing could have been more affordable for first-time buyers? - Yeah, good question. So I think, I mean, firstly, I'd say the fundamental timing of, well, first of all, the 5% deposit guarantee. And then-- - And just brought forward by months, right? - Yeah, well, that was October last year, brought in a lot of first-home buyers to the marketplace with a very slim margin of equity, yeah, 95% of the art. So, and then they had the budget in May, in May 12th, which kind of just whacked the market or amplified the downturn. Logically, those two should have been done in reverse, right? Bring in the budgetary changes and then bring first-home buyers into the marketplace. They can take advantage of lower housing values and maybe provide some support for demand rather than doing it the other way around. So I think for a lot of first-home buyers that took advantage of that 5% deposit guarantee, they're probably, yeah, a little bit of anguish at the moment that their asset is gone backwards in value. And maybe they're in negative equity in some instances. - Need a bit of a first-home buyer. I mean, if someone did a guarantor loan, they'd be 105% from day one anyway, right? Their parents bank a mum and dad or they'd do a security guarantor. So I try to kind of put some perspective on this guy. May you're always gonna be a negative territory for quite some time. Do you think that's probably hurt them is how far the market's slid? - Yeah, well, it's one thing to be a negative equity with your parents as a guarantor, as the government. But also, I think for, I mean, negative equity, it only becomes a problem if you can't service your loan. So I think most of these first-home buyers is gonna power through and given the benefits of time, they'll probably be in a stronger wealth position over the meeting to long-term. As long as they keep their job, they don't have a change in financial circumstances, which there's a bit of risk of that happening at the moment. The other thing around the federal budget in terms of maybe what they could have done a bit better, I mean, it looks pretty clear to me, it wasn't strategically thought out well enough, given the fact that the budget was handed down, and then all of a sudden there's a lot of carve outs, there's a lot of pullbacks and a lot of reversals, which tells me that, you know, you'd think in something that's so important, so fundamentally important every Australian and the government, all these things would have been considered. You know, there's always gonna be some factors that I suppose are the unintended consequences, but there seem to be a lot of them after this federal budget. And then finally, when it comes to property investment, you know, having a this blanket approach to canceling negative gearing for established properties, overall, you know, given the fact that Australians have about 60, well nearly 60% of their wealth is in housing, I think they probably could have had a better approach. You know, if you look at the stats, the vast majority of investors only have a couple of negative-league-eared properties, one or two, there's a few exceptions, as in the case of any here, but, you know, I think in terms of a popular policy, if they had actually just kept negative-gearing, it'd say, two properties, or they kept it at the amount that you could actually, the amount you could, you could niggle be gear. That probably would have been a much more acceptable or welcome policy across Australians, rather than this, this, this been a very much a blanket, malnut approach or a sledgehammer approach to the property investment. And, and seriously, I don't think a lot of, a lot of investors are going to be deflecting to new to take advantage of those taxation policies that there's some will, absolutely. That's, I think investors will still see that there's a premium to pay on new housing, the resell market might be a bit shallower, given, - You can't really resell to it, you can't really keep it. - Yeah, exactly. - Well, you can sell to another investor, but they won't get the same taxation treatment. So, arguably your resell market might be a little bit shallower, which would be some caution around that, unless investors, they often tend to target scarcity, which quite often, you know, the outer grain field or inner city density markets simply don't have that level of scarcity that investors are looking for. - Yeah, thanks very much, I appreciate it. Eddie, what are your thoughts if you look back? I mean, you are an exception, like, I look at some of the, you know, the Jack Henderson's of the World Sammy Gordon's yourself, super, super investors is a different category of what you guys do, Victor Kumar, has, you know, hundreds of properties as well. So, I don't think you guys are the benchmark or a good example, 'cause you're such an anomaly there, but, may you run the country? What are you doing differently? - Well, I guess before I get to that, there was one thing that I wanted to add to the last thing, which I think was really important, with the removal of negative gearing, and this goes back to one of the points I was making before in terms of, like, the different brackets, and the movement in the lower brackets versus the mid and the high brackets as an example. I think the flow on effect of that first, which I want to touch on, which was like, you know, they're removing negative gearing, hasn't it? They've removed negative gearing. That is, what is the flow on effect of some of that, which can also push more activity into the lower markets and change people's perspective of what would be a good performing asset over the next two to three years? You think that the people that actually used negative gearing to its maximum benefits, which is still not a good strategy, would be the ones that people were buying the, you know, 1.8 million dollar houses in Sydney or 2 million dollar houses, and then running it out for a thousand bucks a week, which was like 2% yield, which is absolutely stupid anyway, right? Hoping for growth, but they're getting a tax deduction. So if you're automatically removing the negative gearing for existing properties, then to me, that's another contributing factor to those markets suffering, especially in the high end to mid-tier, whereas the flow on effect of what, you know, the average investor that sees from an opportunist perspective would be to look at, all right, well, what is actually have decent cash flow? Now that I can't negative gear, and I don't want to buy brand new, which is what we're seeing in the investment space, especially with these buyers agents everywhere now, where do they turn? They can't, they don't want to buy brand new, they don't want to buy the houses where they can get negative gear, which is going to be negative 30, 40, 50 grand a year to hold. What else can they buy? They're going to buy affordable stock, which has land component, and they're going to be more, the sentiment of an information is just continuing to change, and people are going into the townhouses. Commercials, obviously, in other units, or commercial, but I wouldn't bet on commercial right now, personally. Why not? Well, you think about the unemployment rate through the roof. Businesses have, obviously, the people that are employing these people. So like commercial in itself, and people think, oh, you're going to get a positive cash flow, like most people, when they buy commercial, if they're buying a formula or commercial, most people are going to use part equity. They're not generally going to have it after tax dollars in their account, and then put down 30% and then chuck it in there as an example. So they're a cash flow. If it's a net six and a half percent yield, you could get them as the same thing with buying a block of units as an example, which is why I've ironed commercial properties, like a fair amount, and they're the worst ones that I like at all. Like, they're my least favorite. To me, they're absolutely just shit. If I was going to be in that place and whether it's like, where do I find the thing? I can't get in houses now. I can't get in the house of granny flats and all that shit. I would be like, oh, do I go commercial? I'd be like, no, I'm going to block units every day of the week because commercial as an example, let's say I buy a $5 million commercial block or a $5 million block of units. Well, a commercial as an example, usually have the set rates on how much that you can increase the rent, you know. - So inflation as an example. - But the tenant pays all the art goings on commercial. - Is the account sometimes? - Sometimes. - I own a lot of commercial and sometimes like depends on the lease, depends on the lease. Then you're in one thing and then there's companies, you have businesses and then you're against a business owner. Like, then you're suing each other. It's like, people, it gets glorified a lot. And I, yeah, anyway. So however, on the rental perspective as an example, you've got a block of units. You can see the rents they might have been rented on overdue leases for like, that haven't been upped in three or four years. So the rents might be $3.50 when the market rents should be $5.50 now. If that tenant as an example moves out and you get the rent goes from $3.50 to $5, if you're just not saying to go above and beyond and be a crazy person, put the rent up excessively. But just to where the market standard now is based on that, that's like an increased rental amount of like $35.40. Which you never see that amount of jumping commercial. and then the ability to actually raise it. finance, pull out equity, use residential valuations against commercial valuations. This is how it's scaled, noticing the tricks of the trade on how to scale one asset to another one and continue to build a large base towards generational wealth. Yeah, look, I hear you again with a commercial. I was tempted to pull out of the video this morning, so I was on a high street near our office, I'm like Philease, Philease, Philease, I'm obviously, you wouldn't be going anywhere near investing on a high street, retail in this market. You're right. The business confidence ultimately commercial comes down to the quality of the tenant that you have and the actual asset type you are going to be buying. So yeah, buy, beware around commercial. It can suit a portfolio, it can suit a portfolio, but yeah, do your homework. I want to come back to yourself, Tim, I've got a couple of stats that I've been following for a while. I think it's over 93% of all properties across the country, in value, like across a couple cities, and we've seen it on a 1% rental vacancy rate at the moment. When you say these numbers, what are the other headlines, like metrics that you're looking at going? This is not jelling well for the Australian property market at the moment, and particularly who's being squeezed because renters are probably feeling a good amount of the pressure at the moment too. Yeah, I think we're lucky enough as a country to have a very good set of property statistics, but not try to flood our own trumpet here. No, I mean, you guys are effectively the go-to. It's a great town. Great position to be as an analyst, so I'm drinking from the property data fountain. But anyway, so I'd definitely be looking at the monthly trend in housing values and how that's changing, but peripheral devalues, and also be looking at the underlying fundamentals, how many listings are in the market, and is that going up or down? We're seeing this really fascinating trend at the moment where there's definitely a slow down in the flow of new listings coming to market, so vendors don't want to sell, because selling conditions are pretty challenging. Because there's less demand, there's this accumulation of listings in the market. So I mentioned perth earlier on about 67% increase in listings. Brisbane's up about 55% on a year ago, even, you know, Sydney's up 22%. In listing numbers. That's great news for buyers, but it means for sellers, it's a pretty tough selling environment. And then you can look at things like clearance rates that come out weekly, probably a lot more important from Melbourne, Sydney, and Canberra clearance rates. That's where you generally see a large portion of homes are auctioned. And then you've got the private treaty metrics of, you know, what's the median selling time, what's the median level of discounting in the marketplace. And beyond that, obviously, you want to be looking at all your macroeconomic stuff, inflation, interest rates, labor markets, confidence or sentiment readings, stuff like that as well. So yeah, I think, I mean, they're all macro trends as well. For anybody that's making a decision about buying a property, you need to build that bridge between, well, that's the macro environment, what's happening in the micro, right? I think you made some really good examples, Eddie, of, you know, if you're buying into, say, St. Kilda or something like that, it might have a completely different trend than what you're seeing across broader Melbourne, but especially if it's a niche like St. Kilda, oldest-style apartments. So I think any investor looking to do their due diligence would be a really well positioned to make sure they're doing that deep dive. You don't just look at the headline numbers, you need to really be understanding the micro markets. You mentioned macroeconomic. So how do we compare other markets at moment, I don't know, Canada's where we similar markets in New Zealand, you can. Cool. Those trends are all quite similar, right? Or be it with their own subtle differences. So for example, Australia didn't put interest rates up anywhere near as high as what New Zealand did after the pandemic. New Zealand's seen a housing downturn of 17% and values are pretty flat at the moment, but still holding 17% down on where they were. Where it's got an inflation problem. So high inflation is a global issue, not just here in Australia. As well, look at some of the migration numbers, they vary massively from state to state, country to country depending on policy, Canada's a really good example of where they really tighten their international borders a year or so ago and that seems to be slowing their housing market down as well. So I think there are some pretty broad trends that are quite similar from country to country. I think that the key nuances in Australia probably come down to your much more sovereign factors around taxation policy, what's happening with migration policy, what are rental yields and rental markets look like as well, which can be quite different as well, like New Zealand's rental markets, nowhere near as tight as ours. So yeah, definitely some fundamental differences, but I think for most investors who are investing in the Australian market, that's probably what they're going to be focusing on the most is what the domestic economic outcomes are. Thank you very much. Eddie, what's your outlook for 2027? Let's say we're sitting back here in a year's time. What's your view of the world and I guess for investors that are listening, what's your message to them? My message look would be similar to, it flows onto what Tim said a little bit like bad times do not last forever. They don't last forever and ironically it's usually sometimes the best times to acquire an asset during this quote unquote bad times. I bought my first property and it was during the GFC and everyone, you know, people called me crazy and everything and I bought a lot of properties during that 20, 17, 2019 period like I bought my first principal place of residence during that time in Sydney and they're like interest rates are up my now and if you have the ability to actually buy a property then you should do so because if interest rates come down towards the middle or end of next year, 2027, you just look at the information of what has happened in the past that shows that buyers come back in one sentiment changes, buyers come back, property price is going even further so you can never really time the bottom of the market but to me it's right now it's the best time to get in if you've got the borrowing capacity like you need to get in right now before you miss out. Cool. Thanks. So on the market, what are some of the metrics that people could be looking at from a data perspective with fatality? Yeah, well definitely look at the trend in housing values, we update that every single month. We'll have our next set of data coming out on, I think it's the first working day of the month so I think it's going to be the third of November. What's your interest rates, of course, I think that's probably going to be the key one going forward is whether or not we see another rate hike or maybe even two rate hikes and to understand where rates are going, you need to understand where inflation's traveling as well. What's the political cycle as well, I think as unpopular as a federal budget has been mid-term for politicians, right, it's probably a good chance, we'll see a lot of the next political campaign with housing is a centerpiece. General, so thank you very much, I really appreciate your time, I think we covered a good amount of turf as well, but for listeners I really wanted to just elevate the conversation a little bit to go. We've had our time of mulling about what's happened and the changes and at this point now where we've really got to accept these are the cards that we've all been dealt for someone like Eddie and heaps of the buyer's ages that we're being in a very close contact with, I think we're galvanising a lot of those clients and just going man, this is a very good time if you've got the opportunity to get in, you might have a period where you haven't had that rapid capital growth that we've probably experienced in the last few years as well, but if you're investing for the long term then it does make sense that this is an opportunistic time to get in, so Tim, Eddie, thank you very much for joining us, hey guys if you loved it, we always love your feedback, love your comments and love you at DM, so keep them coming in, that's a wrap for another episode of Build Different, we'll talk to you next time.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Housing values are falling rapidly, with the downturn already six months deep and likely to stabilize only by mid-next year.
  2. Consumer confidence remains deeply pessimistic, directly correlating with low home sales and reduced market activity.
  3. Melbourne’s affordability and undervalued unit markets—especially in older blocks—offer strong long-term growth potential despite current weakness.
  4. Higher construction costs and replacement values act as a structural floor, limiting supply and protecting property values from sharp declines.
  5. While inflation remains stubbornly high, a shift in rates and economic confidence around mid-next year could trigger market recovery.
  6. First-home buyer activity has declined significantly due to uncertainty, rising interest rates, and reduced affordability, though some see long-term benefits from lower competition.
  7. The current downturn is driven by multiple factors—including rate hikes, political changes, and loss of confidence—unlike past downturns which were isolated to credit or interest rate shifts.
  8. Strategic investments in affordable, high-yield assets like townhouses and units in Melbourne are seen as a contrarian opportunity amid broader market weakness.

Summary:

The housing market is experiencing a significant downturn, with values falling rapidly and confidence at a historic low. While the market may not reach its bottom until mid-next year, data shows a clear correlation between consumer pessimism and declining transaction volumes. Melbourne stands out as a potential growth opportunity, particularly in underpriced, high-yield units and townhouses in older blocks, where prices have remained stagnant despite rising rental yields and construction costs.

These structural factors—such as high replacement costs and limited supply—act as a market floor, shielding values from deep collapses. Though inflation remains stubborn, analysts believe a stabilization in interest rates around mid-next year could trigger a recovery. The downturn is unlike past cycles, driven by a confluence of factors including rising interest rates, political shifts, and loss of confidence, not just credit tightening.

Despite these challenges, contrarian strategies—particularly in affordable, high-yield segments—offer strong upside potential. For first-home buyers, the removal of negative gearing and rising prices have made entry harder, though long-term wealth outcomes may improve with time. Overall, the data suggests a period of volatility with a clear path to recovery, supported by structural imbalances and shifting market sentiment.

FAQs

Housing values are falling rapidly, especially in an historical context. The market is likely not at its bottom yet, with stabilization expected around the second half of next year.

Sentiment is deeply pessimistic due to high interest rates, inflation, and economic uncertainty. However, there's a noticeable shift as people are beginning to accept that the situation is temporary and life must go on.

Properties under $750k, especially townhouses and units in older blocks, are undervalued. Rental yields have doubled over the past decade, and replacement costs have surged, creating strong long-term growth potential.

Melbourne is considered the most promising due to its affordability, undervalued assets, and strong signs of recovery from the pandemic-era exodus of residents.

High building costs and tight labor markets are increasing replacement costs, making it difficult for developers to build new homes. This acts as a structural floor, limiting supply and protecting the market from deeper downturns.

Inflation is driven by high fuel and material costs, government spending, and elevated service costs. These pressures are pushing interest rates up, which is further reducing housing affordability and buyer confidence.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.