This holiday shopping season is all about the deals
25m 45s
The U.S. has enacted new restrictions targeting China’s access to advanced AI chips through remote data center access, closing a long-standing loophole that allowed Chinese firms to bypass direct export bans. While the rules are framed as a national security measure, their enforcement remains uncertain due to political tensions within the U.S. government, particularly between the Treasury and Commerce Departments. This policy clash underscores the broader geopolitical stakes of the AI race, especially as it looms over upcoming high-level diplomacy between U.S. and Chinese leaders. At the same time, growing concerns about AI’s environmental impact—such as energy consumption and carbon emissions—highlight a critical blind spot: no public, granular data exists on the climate footprint of AI operations. California’s recent carbon reporting requirements have forced some tech firms to disclose emissions, but a federal court has blocked more comprehensive supply-chain reporting, limiting transparency. Meanwhile, consumer behavior is shifting toward early holiday shopping due to economic caution, with retailers like Walmart signaling potential spending declines. A major travel disruption caused by a ground stop led to severe rental car shortages and price spikes, revealing systemic fragility in transportation infrastructure. The episode also reflects broader societal trends, such as rising interest in affordable, hands-on hobbies like miniature crafting, which offer emotional relief amid economic uncertainty. As AI becomes more central to global power dynamics, both political and environmental accountability are now under intense scrutiny.
This being a day that ends in why there must be news of artificial intelligence, huh? From American public media, this is Marketplace. In Los Angeles, I'm Kyle Rizdole. It is Monday. Today, this one is the 16th of November good, as it always is, to have you along, everybody. This is going to be one of those weeks, I think, where the politics of this economy drives the coverage of this economy. I speak, of course, of the president's trip overseas, his meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping, and most immediately the world of artificial intelligence and the chips that power it, who makes those chips, who gets to buy those chips, and who gets to use those chips. This bit, who can use them? There was news this morning on a Swanson had the story from the New York Times, hey, on. Hey, how are you? I'm well. I'm well. Thank you for taking the time to be with us. What was the rule that White House, the Commerce Department, came out with today? Yeah. So this was a very long awaited rule. It's something that has been a subject of debate and contention for a long time. But basically, it's something that closes down this loophole that was allowing companies in China to get access to advanced AI chips. So for several years, the US has banned exporting these chips to China directly. But there was a situation where data centers were popping up in Southeast Asia where Chinese firms could log in into them remotely and access the same AI chips. So essentially, the US just kind of built this fence around China and people were coming right outside the fence and handing things back and forth over. So US officials have seen this as potentially problematic. And today, they moved ahead with rules that would clamp down on that. I'm going to go ahead and continue with the farm/fence analogy and go with this one, horse and barn door. We have now closed the barn door, but it does kind of seem given all that we've read in the news the past like 10-ish days that kind of the horse is out of the barn a little bit on the Chinese getting these chips and access to them. Yeah, no, I mean, I do think there, it seems like there is a study supply of AI, compute in China, both through illegally smuggle chips and this kind of situation, which people refer to as remote access. This regulation, you know, it's supposed to put pretty extensive controls on this. And it would go into effect in 90 days. The tricky thing is that it is supposed to be enforced by the Commerce Department, which was kind of pushed back on this whole idea. And when the Commerce Department issued the rule today, it basically said that it was doing so because the Treasury Department and the NSC had forced it to. So there's a real question about implementation and enforcement for what is a pretty significant rule. Well, now we need to get to the domestic and internecine White House politics of this thing because Treasury Secretary Besent and Commerce Secretary Lutnik do not get along on this particular issue. Right. They have been sparring kind of openly in the past few days. And now the two men are on a plane and we'll be on a plane to China together. So that's going to be a very long plane, I wish I was a fly on the law for that one. But yeah, they have come out, Besent, in some public interviews recently expressed dismay that the U.S. had not moved forward with a sanction against mega speed. This is the company that's involved in the NVIDIA scandal linked to this woman that Jensen Huang had an affair with. Besent was saying that for months that he had pushed to put this company on a trade sanctions list and that the Commerce Department had not done it. The Commerce Department holds the pen. And then today you had this kind of passive aggressive announcement from Commerce saying they were putting out this rule but only because Treasury made them. So it's kind of an open, pretty open feud at this point. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Last thing. You've got 30 seconds on this one. This, with the caveat that this is really sort of a fight about who's going to win American AI or Chinese AI. This is an interesting prelude to President Trump meeting Xi Jinping, no? Absolutely. Yeah. So Trump officials have said that they don't expect this to figure into the dialogues. They say this is a national security measure. These are not up for negotiation. But this is absolutely hanging over the meetings. And it remains to be seen if it provokes some kind of a reaction from China because, again, this is cutting the country off from a, it would be cutting the country off from a rather large supply of an important resource, which is these AI chips. And this once and has been all over this story at the New York Times. I'm going to thanks so much. Really appreciate it. Yeah. Thank you. See ya. Wall Street today, you know, look, if you really want to know, I will tell you, it will be in the wild was when we get their details numbers, you know the drill. We are embarked here in mid to late November on the great shopping season. That is, this is, in fact, a big week in retail before a big month in retail. Our last dance to check in with and to check on companies and consumers before the holiday shopping season really gets going. October retail sales numbers will be upon us tomorrow morning courtesy of the Census Bureau. We're also going to have third quarter earnings from Walmart and Target, TJ Maxx and Home Depot, did you want coming up later on in the week? Marketplaces, Kristen Schwab starts our retail one, two today with the preview of the data and the gifting season. Mari Shore was out and about this weekend running errands, browsing a bit the usual. And you would have thought it was like Christmas week. It was so busy and it's hard to know what was driving it. Well, I was shocked by the number of people that were out this weekend, but then like I was out this weekend, so what was I doing out? Maybe you were doing holiday shopping. Sure, who's a retail analyst at Columbia Thread Needle Investments says this holiday creep is happening because consumers are hunting harder for deals and retailers are eager to offer them. Because the business over the holiday period can be so lumpy, a lot of the companies have tried to like pull forward holiday promotions and get people to spend earlier and maybe more over time. A promotion already got Mark Matthews for shoes from a brand his wife likes. It just flashed across my screen that they were on sale. Matthews is chief economist at the National Retail Federation, which represents retailers. I think there's an error of cautious optimism. The NRF forecasts holiday retail sales will grow 4.2% year over year. Reminder, economists estimate the last inflation reading was around 4%. It puts real sales at a slight bump. The recognition that the consumer is concerned about gas prices and the economy is and is going to be very, very careful. How careful? Shara's me on, director of research at SAX, says he'll be looking for that in Walmart's earnings on Thursday. The retailer is a good window to consumer spending because it has shoppers across income brackets. But what happens to Walmart has implications in the broader retail space? If Walmart is worried about the holidays, other retailers should be worried about the holidays. And if Walmart is running more discounts, that makes life problematic for a host of other retailers that are also targeting that same consumer base. Because it'll force those retailers to compete. Mian says we won't be able to fully assess the holidays until January. We do it because we do we consumers really matters according to the most recent data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. Personal consumption expenditures, that is what you and I and every other person who participates in this economy spend on a regular basis. That accounted for nearly 68% of gross domestic product in the third quarter, more than two-thirds of everything that happens in this entire economy. But you know what? It hasn't always been that way. Marketplace's Stephanie Hughes has today's history lesson on the role of the American consumer. Three big sources of spending drive the U.S. economy. Spending by consumers, by governments, and by businesses. And the mix of that spending has changed over time. You know, when you look back to the 19th century, the big spenders are businesses. Sue is high and is an economic historian at Johns Hopkins. He says, back in the late 1800s, businesses were dumping money into railroads. Meanwhile, everyday workers weren't making all that much, so had less money available to spend. That started to shift in the early 1900s. Through most of the 20th century, the story was about rising wages, spending consumer demand and how to get consumers to.
buy all those products. But that doesn't mean consumer spending kept rising and rising. In 1944, it accounted for less than half of GDP. Hyman says during World War II, there's a push to get people to save instead of spend. Because they were afraid of the inflationary pressures that came after World War I. There was also, of course, rationing. Which meant there were limits on how much people could buy. Consumer spending as a share of GDP did rise again in the postwar economic boom. And by the 70s, financing was also more of a thing. Lily Geismers, a professor of history at Claremont McKenna College. One of the things that happens with the recession in the 1970s is like now as people don't have as much money in the bank, they had access to credit cards in a new kind of way. She also points out with globalization, consumers got access to cheaper goods. And the rise of super stores meant there were more places to buy them. Stores like Walmart begin in the 1960s, but it's really in the 1970s and 1980s that they grow. Policy choices have also enabled the consumer central role in the economy. Says Cornell historian Lawrence Glickman. We have sort of made the choice to keep marginal tax rates low, to disinvest in many public goods, and to leave it up to the consumer, to spend and borrow, to drive the economy. But he says today is affordability crisis could drive a debate about whether that should still be the case. I'm Stephanie Hughes from Marketplace. Couple other quick retail-ish things before we go on. On the theory that bad things come in threes, today's rolling outages at some of the big Wall Street banks should complete the trend started by the Microsoft outage last week in the ground stop on Friday. For those not yet familiar, JP Morgan Chase, Bank of America, and Wells Fargo were reporting slowdowns earlier today. Transactions were taking more time. Nobody and this is important. Nobody lost access to their accounts or lost their money, which is the really important part. Also, just because we gave it airtime when it was on the way up, turn about is fair play. Triple A has a gallon of diesel today back under six bucks, $5.99 per gallon. That is the national average your mileage. Literally your mileage may differ. [Music] Okay, that FAA ground stop on Friday. It happened. We all know what happened. Airlines are just about dug out from under it. But stick with me here for a second because not all of the chaos was of the air a lot. And I mean a lot of people who couldn't get on a flight tried to rent cars all basically at the same give or take time. That meant rental car agencies upcharging by hundreds of dollars. And some of them just running out of cars. And as Marketplace's Caitlin Tan reports, this is not the first time there has been a crunch like this. Yesterday, Noel Smith, her husband and two kids were stuck in Wichita, Kansas. Their flight home to Wyoming was cancelled. And the next best option was a flight out of Oklahoma City the next day over. So I immediately ran over to the rental car place at the airport. The rental agent initially had bad news. No cars left. But then she said, but we do have this other car, but it's $500. Smith rented it after fees $680 just to drive a few hours. I mean, in hindsight, I'm like, well, that's crazy. What just happened? But at the time, they needed to get home. They had worked today. Jonathan Weinberg is with auto slash a third party rental booking company. Here's what he had to tell some people. Sorry. There's literally nothing that we can get you to go from location to location B. Weinberg says this happened a few years ago. Rental companies had downsized their fleets during COVID when people weren't traveling. And they weren't prepared for the travel surge in 2021, which meant high rental prices. You know, two, three, four, five, $500 a day, people were renting you whole trucks to get around. And it wasn't easy for rental companies to restock. New cars were hard to come by and expensive. Rental car companies were actually buying vehicles on the used car market. And that had never happened before. Weinberg says some companies never fully returned to their pre-COVID fleet numbers. So when the ground stop happened this weekend, they weren't a pinch. Chris Moronka is with Deutsche Bank. It's not like they can bring thousands more cars. Those cars aren't there. You know, there's a finite supply at any given airport on any given day. The rental companies didn't count on all this one way travel. And it costs them money to transport the cars back. I think for prices to kind of go back to normal, we just need to get the cars back to kind of where they were supposed to be the first place. Just in time for thanks giving when rental prices jump again. I'm Caitlin Tan for Marketplace. Coming up 100 teeny tiny strawberries like smaller than your finger now. We'll wonders never cease. First though, let's do the numbers. I don't pick the music, but I kind of knew it was going to be the wallows. Down industrial down 739 points today, 1.4%, 51,600 and 8th. And asdaq down 626, that is 2.5%. Closed to 24,509 SMP 500 down 145 points, 1.9% of 1% 7416. Investors saw opportunity in airlines today. American Airlines picked up a half percent delta added 4.10% of 1%. In video, reports quarterly earnings tomorrow, it's laid 4.10% of 1%. I should say another 4.10% today, right? Other chip companies followed suit. Micron technology gave up 7.6%, A&D, advanced micro devices, dipped 5.6% of 1%. Bonds went up yield on the 10-year T-note fell. 5.13%. You're listening to Marketplace. This is Marketplace. I'm Kai Rizdal. The conversation around artificial intelligence at the current moment. I don't really need to update you on, right? It is a tangled web of politics, national security, market incentives, and a bare-knuckled fight to finish first. There is a subtext, though, of what it's doing to the environment, water and land use, noise pollution, energy needs, and climate change. The catch is that that last item, climate change is something of a mystery. Most of the big AI companies are staying mum on their climate impact. Some of them, though, those big ones have significant operations here in California, where there was a deadline last week for large companies of all kinds to come clean on carbon. Marketplace's David Bruncacho reports. If you want to know how much CO2 gets emitted on a drive to the supermarket, there's an app for that. But how much climate gas gets spilled when you ask, say, chat GPT, how to cook with what you just bought, there's not an app for that. No way to know how much CO2 for a single AI search or to figure out the carbon footprint of the whole AI industry. We don't know for sure, and that's because we don't have the data. Eric Massinet, a professor at the Bren School at UC Santa Barbara, is on a quest to piece together AI's carbon numbers indirectly, because a lot of the tech companies that operate the data centers don't report emissions, and when they do, sometimes the reporting can vary from company to company. And even if researchers can estimate some of this, they can't always be sure what's really going on inside these data centers. Is it AI number crunching, or maybe just streaming some Netflix? Sure, some companies like Google and Microsoft publish their overall carbon numbers. That's what the EU already requires. But these reports are a bit like submitting a non-itemized restaurant receipt where you can't tell the food from the booze. Currently there's no line item for AI and most, or any ESG report coming from the tech industry. But last week, some of the biggest companies have had to spill the beans on the greenhouse gases they're emitting, plus any CO2 produced by the power they use. It's a deadline in California, which applies to any company, public or privately held, that does a billion dollars or more business in California. The hope is that once we start actually disclosing this data and is publicly available, companies are going to be pressured into cleaning up. Mary Nichols is the former chair of the state's powerful air quality regulator, the California Air Resources Board, and now at the UCLA Law School. It's about 2,500 firms, and that includes big AI companies. Until now, there's been no carbon report from, say, Open AI or Anthropic, the biggest of AI fish, same with some big data center firms. One of the things that now people are beginning to realize we don't know enough about data centers. What do they actually do? What do they actually use? How much of our grid capacity? What can be done to make them acceptable in communities? Or not? There's been a flurry of outside consultants offering to help firms gather the data. Barnaby Lynch is at Watershed, a sustainability data platform. I have my flight data from all my employees traveling around. I also have all my energy bills.
And we can say, "Okay, well, where are your trucks driving?" And what type of truck are they? And where are you consuming energy? And we can then get the most granular version of what your carpets operate looks like. And just hours before the deadline last week, a federal appeals court upheld this set of reports, but in a plot twist, the court decided more detailed carbon reports due next year are illegal. Those would have forced companies to assess greenhouse gas emissions up and down their supply chains, touching not just the companies themselves, but third parties, including suppliers. The California Chamber of Commerce called this a "victory for business," but the state could still appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. Anyway, the industry prefers a different kind of accounting. Again, you see Santa Barbara researcher Eric Masinet. Let's be honest, there could be some ways that AI could lead to societal level efficiencies or savings or emissions reductions. That's what the tech industry is promising us. The challenges we don't know if they're going to be real and if they'll be large enough to offset our use of AI data centers and infrastructure. Proof will require more hard data from the industry. In Los Angeles, I'm David Brancache for Marketplace. David covers future effects for us. Decisions we are making today that could make trouble for us tomorrow. All of his coverage lives at Marketplace.org. (upbeat music) You know, sometimes hobbies are useful. You knit a sweater, it keeps you warm. You ride a bike, you stay fit. It's okay though to admit that sometimes the reason we do something and spend money on it is just because it's fun. And it gives us pleasure. Here's today's installment of our series, My Economy. My name is Madison Darbyshire and I'm a senior writer at Bloomberg Weekend. (upbeat music) I think I was looking online, just like, rotting. And I saw a listing for many strawberries. And you could buy like 100 teeny tiny strawberries like smaller than your fingernail for $5. And I was like, why am I so moved physically by how cute these are. Why do I want them so much. And I started looking into the world of minis. And I realized that there was a really enormous community of people who did this. And there's an organization called the International Guild of miniature artisans. And they, I realized, have like an annual gathering every year. So then I decided that I absolutely had to go to miniature school. And I talked to my editor and I said, listen, I think there's a story here. So I wanted to understand what the value was of doing this thing that kind of had inherently no value. No one's going to ever pay money for the cheese board that I spent several thousand dollars to make. Why are so many people willing to spend thousands of dollars to travel to this tiny little town in coastal Maine and stay in bed and breakfast for a week? (upbeat music) Not a coincidence that the popularity of miniatures happened after the pandemic. 'Cause they have cycled in and out of popularity throughout history, usually in times of extreme technological progress. You know, where you see a rapid jump forward in terms of human understanding. And then you see kind of a retrenchment in wanting things that feel controllable and small. And I think another reason that would be very hard to overlook would be affordability. So in ages, when it becomes very hard for people to access things that they dream about, you know, like houses or the design that they want and they're cutting back on things and not spending on things that aren't essential, then you also see an interest in people doing affordable hobbies that make them feel good but also give them a sense of control over their lives. And I did spend a hundred dollars on mini cakes and so there's just mini cakes slices dotted around my apartment and a bowl of cherries. But they bring me a lot of joy, so I'm keeping them around. (upbeat music) Madison Darby Shire, she went to miniature school and wrote about it for Bloomberg. Whether it is a hobby that makes you money or when you spend money on or when you do just 'cause it makes you happy, let us know what's going on with you, would you? Marketplace.org/myeconomy. (upbeat music) This final note on the way out today in which capitalism might once again not be reading the room. The Wall Street Journal reports today that Kalshi, the famously minimally regulated prediction market, is getting ready to start offering stock and ETF trading in the next couple of months. I will spare you the oats who easy what could possibly go wrong or join her here. And simply note that Robin Hood was the big loser when this news broke. Yes, that Robin Hood shares down seven and a half percent. (upbeat music) Amir Babawi Kailanesh, Noy of Cars, Steve Mullison, Stephanie Seek, are the marketplace. Editing staff Kelly Silvera is the news director. And I'm Kyle Rizdal, we will. See you tomorrow, everybody. (upbeat music) (upbeat music) This is APM.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The U.S. government has issued new rules to close a loophole allowing Chinese firms to access advanced AI chips via remote access in Southeast Asia, effectively restricting their access to critical AI infrastructure.
The regulations, set to take effect in 90 days, face significant concerns over enforcement, especially since the Commerce Department stated it acted under pressure from the Treasury and National Security Council.
A growing political rift exists between Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen and Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo, highlighting internal White House disagreements over trade sanctions and AI strategy.
The policy is framed as a national security measure but remains a major point of tension ahead of President Trump’s meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping, with potential for a strong Chinese reaction.
There is increasing awareness of the environmental cost of AI, including energy use and carbon emissions, though major tech companies remain silent on detailed emissions from AI operations.
California’s carbon reporting deadline for large firms, including AI companies, was recently upheld, but a federal appeals court blocked more detailed supply-chain emissions reporting, citing business concerns.
Consumer spending remains a key driver of the U.S. economy, with retail activity rising due to early holiday promotions and shifting consumer caution amid inflation and gas prices.
A surge in demand during the travel disruption caused by a ground stop led to rental car shortages and exorbitant prices, illustrating how systemic vulnerabilities can amplify economic stress.
Summary:
S. has enacted new restrictions targeting China’s access to advanced AI chips through remote data center access, closing a long-standing loophole that allowed Chinese firms to bypass direct export bans. S.
government, particularly between the Treasury and Commerce Departments. S. and Chinese leaders.
At the same time, growing concerns about AI’s environmental impact—such as energy consumption and carbon emissions—highlight a critical blind spot: no public, granular data exists on the climate footprint of AI operations. California’s recent carbon reporting requirements have forced some tech firms to disclose emissions, but a federal court has blocked more comprehensive supply-chain reporting, limiting transparency. Meanwhile, consumer behavior is shifting toward early holiday shopping due to economic caution, with retailers like Walmart signaling potential spending declines.
A major travel disruption caused by a ground stop led to severe rental car shortages and price spikes, revealing systemic fragility in transportation infrastructure. The episode also reflects broader societal trends, such as rising interest in affordable, hands-on hobbies like miniature crafting, which offer emotional relief amid economic uncertainty. As AI becomes more central to global power dynamics, both political and environmental accountability are now under intense scrutiny.
FAQs
The U.S. Commerce Department announced a rule to close a loophole allowing Chinese companies to access advanced AI chips through remote access to data centers in Southeast Asia. This effectively restricts China's ability to use U.S.-made AI chips indirectly.
The rule will go into effect in 90 days from the announcement date, giving companies time to adjust to the new restrictions on remote access to AI chips.
The U.S. fears that Chinese firms gaining access to advanced AI chips through remote data centers undermines national security and gives China a strategic advantage in developing AI technology.
The Commerce Department is responsible for enforcement, but it has reportedly been pressured by the Treasury Department and the National Security Council to issue the rule.
Yes, there is a notable disagreement between Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen and Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo, with Treasury pushing for stronger sanctions and Commerce citing external pressure to act.
The rules are seen as a significant national security measure and may provoke a reaction from China, especially since they cut off access to a vital resource—AI chips—used in China's tech development.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.