“There Must Be MORE Than Us!” - Astrophysicist on Aliens, David Grusch & God | Brian Keating
3h 1m 46s
Abercrombie’s holiday collection offers stylish, versatile clothing that simplifies outfit planning during the busy season, making it a go-to for shoppers. The host highlights how the brand provides essential pieces for everyday and festive wear. The conversation then shifts to a deep dive into higher dimensions, using the Flatland analogy to explain how a four-dimensional tesseract would appear as a three-dimensional cube in lower dimensions. This leads to a broader discussion on the geometry of the universe, where triangles of astronomical size reveal whether space is flat, spherical, or hyperbolic—currently indicating a flat universe. This flatness is seen as a rare and likely coincidence, possibly enabling life and consciousness. The segment also critiques science communication, noting that popular scientists often present bold, unverified claims without acknowledging uncertainty. The host emphasizes the importance of humility, peer review, and diverse perspectives in science, referencing the need to avoid oversimplification and fear-based narratives. He contrasts this with real scientific inquiry, where data and evidence are central. The discussion ends with a nod to the origins of the word “podcast,” tracing it to the film *2001: A Space Odyssey*, illustrating how cultural references shape language and innovation.
It's officially the holiday season, and Abercrombie's new collection has outfits for everything on your calendar.
It's the busiest time of year, and between shopping and party invites, I don't have time to plan every look.
But Abercrombie's always got me covered.
Their sweaters are the perfect easy layer for low-key plans, and on a nice night out, I'm reaching for their classic trousers.
Fill your closet with the pieces you'll need all season long.
Have a very Abercrombie holiday. Shop in the app, online, and in stores.
See what I got right here this time?
What's that?
You want to see what I got down in the hole?
We usually keep it over there.
You got any guesses?
That is a fragment of Elon's baby mama's umbilical cord.
Yeah, no.
No idea.
No, there'd be too many baby mamas to choose from there.
This is actually wonderful.
This is way more up your lane.
Okay.
Speaking of things that aren't umbilical.
No.
Atmosphere gas from an exosolar planet.
I'm going to. This is painful. You're very far off.
Ooh, an infinity cube.
It's a tesseract.
You can see me in there. Yeah, there I go.
It's a tesseract.
Wow, you got it from the infinite dimension.
No, Murph!
No, leave him!
That's right. It's like right out of the movie right there.
Can people see that on camera right, Thief?
Can they see into it?
Yeah.
Matthew McConaughey's like banging around in there somewhere.
Chris Williamson, I'm sure.
I see him. There it goes. Wow, nice.
Mine to keep? No.
Not that one, but I am going to send you one for your studio.
That would be nice, yeah.
Yeah, I'll treasure that.
That's right.
Nice little center.
And we're going to go deep into this one.
That is cool. From the fourth dimension. How thoughtful.
I've never gotten a gift from the fourth dimension.
How does this even work, by the way, like the fourth dimension?
I still don't understand that science from that movie.
A real tesseract?
Yeah.
So the honest truth is that nobody, not even the most brilliant person,
you know, whoever lived in Michio Kaku,
can understand. Can visualize exactly what a fourth dimension looks like.
And that's because, you know, we're doing something cool right now.
We live in three dimensions, right?
Can you see three dimensions? Can I see inside your body?
No.
We have these magical telescopes in our head.
We have two telescopes in our head, right?
They're refracting lens-based telescopes like your cameras over there.
They take images onto your retina.
What dimensionality is your retina?
I'm taking you back to math class.
Is your retina one-dimensional, two-dimensional?
Is it a point? Is it a plane?
What is it?
It's a shape.
It's a sheet, right?
It's a plane in the back of your head.
Actually, as, you know, good old Andrew Huberman says,
it's the only part of your brain that's not inside your skull,
which is pretty crazy.
Like, why would nature risk putting something outside of the skull's protection
that's so valuable?
It's your eye.
It's because we need this more than any other sense, basically.
I mean, you could get around without taste, and people do.
But so we have two retinas, and they're each two-dimensional.
From those, we get a stereo projection of what the world looks like.
Right.
So we're actually. We're actually synthesizing a three-dimensional world
from two two-dimensional worlds.
Does that make sense?
It's not. It's not. We're seeing into three. If I could see into three dimensions, I'd see inside this cup,
or, you know, this. You know, I'd see the vodka in my Irish coffee over here.
Right.
Or my whiskey.
I should have gotten that.
I'm, you know, part Irish.
We can put some in there if you want.
I know.
You got everything over here, thanks to your crew here.
I brought my whole crew with me, by the way.
That's it.
You're looking at them.
All right.
I like that.
So we can really only visualize things
by making simple extrapolations from things that are simpler,
like lower dimension things, right?
Hey, guys.
If you're not following me on Spotify,
please hit that follow button and leave a five-star review.
They're both a huge, huge help.
Thank you.
So the easiest way to think about a tesseract
is not to think about a tesseract at all.
So don't think about a tesseract.
Don't think about the fourth dimension.
Think about if you lived in two dimensions,
like you're on a creature called a flatland.
You're living in the flatland.
That means you don't know about the perpendicular direction
of the flatland.
You don't know about the perpendicular direction
in three dimensions.
You might be able to figure it out,
but you can never see it.
Your eyes don't work in that dimension.
They only work along the axis of the plane, right?
So if you see something like, what, the F over here,
and you're in this dimension, you see this thing,
it looks the same from every angle you perceive it,
no matter how you go.
So you could be smart, and you could figure out
there are certain things that are symmetrical, right?
They look the same in every direction.
This thing is a straight line, right?
Visualize that as a straight line.
This looks very different as you go around it.
Sometimes it looks like a zero-dimensional point.
If I'm poking over here, if I'm going like this,
or I'll hold it up there, if you look along the axis,
it's like a point, right?
But if I look like this, it looks like a line,
and then it's a point.
This thing, it always looks the same
if I'm in two dimensions looking along the line.
And actually, my favorite book of all time,
I give it away on my website, is called Flatland.
Flatland is a science fiction story.
It comes from the late 1800s, set in England,
but it's not set in England.
It's set in this fictitious world called Flatland,
where there's a two-dimensional dude,
and he gets visited by a man,
and he gets visited by aliens from the third dimension.
Whoa.
So he's just sitting around one day,
and they have this whole society,
and society's pretty racist back then,
so you're judged by the number of sides that you have.
So a triangle is a low-educated man in the society,
because he has these three sides.
A square is a little bit better,
a pentagon better,
until you get to a circle.
The priests are circles.
They're perfectly symmetrical.
The men that are low-class, worker drones, whatever,
they're triangles.
Because the more points you have,
the more high your status is.
The fewer points you have, the more dangerous you are.
Because in this world, if you have a point,
you can poke somebody and kill them.
So if a round person's not dangerous,
they have huge high status.
They're very powerful.
But the lowest status people are women.
Women are lines in this fictitious story called Flatland.
Oh, so this is like misogynist.
So it's misogynist, it's racist.
I mean, the British had it all.
Checking every box, man.
Yeah, the British had it all, right?
You know, like, God love them.
And this is your favorite book.
It's my favorite.
This is the book.
Takes you back to a nice pastime you wish you had.
My racism?
Yeah, that's right.
Aspirational.
No, it's called A Romance of Many Dimensions.
The reason is it helps you visualize the fourth dimension.
It starts off with this guy in two dimensions.
Then all of a sudden, he's visited by aliens.
What he thinks are aliens from another dimension.
A sphere, which is a three-dimensional object,
comes to visit Flatland.
So now start to imagine,
what would you see if a sphere started coming into your,
universe, if you could only see in two dimensions?
Well, first you'd see, like, a tiny little point.
Then it would come into a little bit of a circle.
You could see it's a circle.
Then a bigger circle.
Then it would reach maximum diameter.
Then it would start to shrink again.
So you can start to visualize what the third dimension is
from the perspective of a second-dimensional object,
like the square.
That's trippy.
The name of the author is A Square.
Come on.
It's pretty funny.
But the thing I want to get to is that
they don't visualize things by what they would look like.
You can't visualize.
That's the problem.
You try to visualize.
You try to visualize a test track.
Can't do it.
What you can do is visualize the projection
from a higher-dimensional space.
You've heard of holography.
You've heard of this notion that we exist,
and all the information of Black Hole
can be contained on its surface.
That's called a hologram.
You ever get your credit card,
and it's got the eagle, and it's, like, flapping it?
That's a hologram.
It looks three-dimensional,
but it's printed on a two-dimensional thing.
It can't be three-dimensional.
Right, so, like, if you're going to, like,
IMAX 3D or something similar kind of concept.
That's not a hologram, though.
It's not?
That's not, no.
That's two different eyes stereographically projected
with different colors or different polarizations,
and they fictitiously synthesize in your eye.
And that's sophisticated, but it's not a hologram.
Retains, when I look at you, I see color,
I see intensity, and I see, technically,
a little bit of polarization.
We talked about that last time.
But we don't see the phase information of the light.
What actually tells me that your ear is farther away
than your nose is the phased lag
between the light coming from your ear
coming from your nose.
They're different, and my eyes can synthesize what that is.
A hologram is taking that,
that phase information called the conjugate fourier transform.
That's what they do.
They take it from a two-dimensional image.
They synthesize it.
It looks like a three-dimensional image.
You see the eagle flapping its wings, right?
You move it around.
It looks like a, that's a hologram, okay?
That's different, but you can visualize these things
from the projection.
So now go back to, again, go back to being in Flatland.
If you're in Flatland, when you see this pen,
you only see it either as a point
or a line of different directions
as you change your perspective around Flatland, right?
That's right.
So it can go from, you know,
it can go from that.
Now imagine there's a light from above,
like in your studio here.
It casts a shadow of this thing, right?
It can look like one of two things.
It can look like a line or it can look like a point.
Right, depending on the angle.
Exactly.
Now take a, take a square.
A square can look like a projection,
will look like a square,
or it will look like a line,
four different lines as you go around it.
A sphere will always look like a circle
if you project it light from above.
The shadow of a sphere always looks like
a two-dimensional circle.
The shadow of a pen can look like a zero-dimensional object
or a one-dimensional object.
And a cube can also look like the shadow of a square,
but no matter how you rotate it,
you'll see the same thing.
Imagine in four dimensions,
the shadow of that tesseract is a three-dimensional cube.
Imagine you're sitting here.
How can you see a shadow in three dimensions?
How do you see a shadow in two dimensions?
It's the absence of light.
So you're projecting beams of light, rays,
you can look at lasers shooting out this thing.
Right, but then you couldn't,
maybe I'm thinking this wrong,
but hypothetically,
you could then argue that it's more dimensions.
You'd be like, well, actually, it's eight.
How do we know?
So an eight-dimensional,
the shadow of a five-dimensional object
is a four-dimensional object.
When you project something,
you're always reducing it by one dimension.
This is a line, which is one-dimensional.
The projection of it's a point, which is zero-dimensional.
Yes.
A square, the projection of it is a two-dimensional object.
Projection of it is to a one-dimensional object.
Yes.
The cube projection of it is a two,
so it's always going one minus the dimension
that you start with the object.
Right, but you understand what I'm saying.
It looks the same in the end result,
when you're talking about the shadow?
- Well, the shadows, what we call the geometry of the shadow
shadow is what determines the dimensionality and the property of the space so the rulers the angles
the protractors those are how you measure geometry and what you don't change is topology so you know
we don't have any mugs here but topology is not the oh there you go a big telescope guy how could
i how could i that's right okay so careful you're you're smudging it oh okay just remember i write
it on it's so expensive i know i need you i'll put on the accent that's right big pop pack podcast
guy yeah we can use camera too for this steve so when you if you were to take this cling it was
once made of clay right you could smush it you could make it into like a donut right but without
patching it up or putting more holes in it it will always have this one hole that you can't remove
so this tells you the topology of the space and there are a lot of people that study physics
including people that study extraterrestrials that say that they're actually creatures that
can travel not only from different dimensions in other words they can come from four to remember
this guy grush he's david grush i haven't had him on okay um very skeptical of a lot of the
uh i want to talk to you about that okay um because i think it's it's probably the most
important story that nobody's interested in that is going around that people believe in things
without evidence but then don't have then do have evidence and don't believe in that that's bizarre
it's never happened in human history let's talk about it but there's also a possibility of
topological dimensional beings beings that can only exist in different topologies in other words
different holes different pinch points different you know uh cones and stuff like that so what's
interesting about the dimensionality is that you cannot access a low dimension from a high dimension
but you can you can access a hot from a high dimension you can access to a low dimension
but the reverse is not possible so that starts to set constraints on these aliens right if they're
saying that these are interdimensional does that mean that they're auto does it automatically
communicate to you that they're higher dimension or lower dimension to me it would automatically
when i hear that communicate that they'd be higher dimension because it's like they could
look in on us rather than up to us but there's nothing that says that you there's actually a
more you know dimensional space there's it's available for two-dimensional like if you think
about evolution did evolution start with podcasters and you know start with killer whales definitely
not the highest form of evolution the two two white guys with a microphone yeah i think i think
we're cooked if that's the case so evolution goes from primitive to advanced right so the universe
should be filled with primitive things and only a smattering like we see on earth we don't see
there's only one species of humans you know many different types of monkeys apes primates
and the third there's literally thousands of different species bugs there's billions of
different types of species of bugs probably sea creatures why is there only one homo sapien why is
there only one creature like us that knows it has consciousness existing consciousness can make
forecasts can make tools knows that it's going to die knows how to live there's and knows that it
may not be alone in the universe there's only one species like that but why julian why why are there
10 20 different types we are trying to get a dog around the keating household you know i want some
big you don't have one yet i don't have one i have a killer cat i'm an attack cat we gotta get you a
dog yeah i know my talk to my wife she'll get you a nice like golden retriever instead of a german
shepherd i love german shepherds like you should start with i know no my uh my brother-in-law's uh
he's a military um uh marine recon and he's got uh he's got a serious marine dog okay we got mike
ritland train a dog for you oh yeah that fucking thing will probably eat your dog whisper yeah i
know that's right like yeah he's gonna have my uh my my toddlers for snacks
yes black friday and the holiday season is here which means if you're a business owner out there
you need business to be a booming and if you got product to sell far and wide there's nothing
better to use than shopify this is the easiest place to set up your selling platform online where
your customers get a great experience and get from point a to buying the product in the easiest way
possible shopify helps you launch a store and start selling in a few simple steps you don't
need to be an e-commerce expert sidekick you don't need to be an e-commerce expert you don't need to
be an e-commerce expert sidekick shopify's ai assistant can help with business tasks along the
way from store setup to planning promotions and their pre-built themes and ai site builder can
make it easier to create a professional storefront you want it to look good and they're going to help
with that shopify's mobile app also helps you manage key parts of your store from anywhere
including inventory customer support and most importantly payments and spotify's checkout with
shop pay is so good that it converts at a 36 higher rate than the competition and obviously
time is of the essence right now if you go on and launch right now you're going to be able to
take advantage of the extra online traffic so don't wait if you're ready to launch your business
before black friday go to shopify.com slash julian link them out of search and below to start your
free trial once again for effect go to shopify.com slash julian today to hear your first it's
officially the holiday season and abercrombie's new collection has outfits for everything on your
calendar it's the busiest time of year and between shopping and party invites i don't have time to
plan every look but abercrombie's new collection has outfits for everything on your calendar it's
always got me covered their sweaters are the perfect easy layer for low-key plans and on a
nice night out i'm reaching for their classic trousers fill your closet with the pieces you'll
need all season long have a very abercrombie holiday shop in the app online and in stores
but uh but in reality there's many different species that's a great mystery it's one mystery
that we have we have no explanation for i'm talking to richard dawkins tonight i'm hosting
him yeah we'll talk about that he's evolutionary you know
it is beautiful it has incredible attractiveness it has parsimony it's simple it's occam's razor you
can believe but it can't explain the most diverse things like music why do you like music what's the
evolutionary advantage of music right why can't a dog and why can't a dog keep a beat you know
what i mean like seriously like we can appreciate one dog that keeps a beat his name is snoop okay
it's actually the same age as me and he's a grandfather i think it's amazing look at that
okay come on come on i got it already when you become a dad you'll be you'll be doing dad's
you haven't become a dad since i saw you last time have you as far as i know no couple close
calls don't ever say that the more famous you get there's gonna be people out there yeah anyway uh
so you'd expect low dimensionality to proliferate throughout the universe and yet your brain
immediately goes because you're smart and and you think scientifically your brain goes to no it
should be higher dimension but there's no reason for that now there's a lot more i want to tell
you something very interesting about the universe for for a second in the universe it's possible
to have different geometrical shapes to it i want to explain what that means on earth on this table
on this piece of paper i can draw a triangle right that triangle has three angles duh right
the angles inside the triangle add up to 180 degrees remember this from you know high school
okay but on a sphere here's a sphere right on a sphere you can make a triangle that does the
following it starts at the north pole i hope this isn't like some huge podcast or it looks like a
that's beautiful so at the very top i've been to the south pole so i'll do it like this upside down
but imagine at the south pole antarctica i've been there twice we should talk about that there's crazy
stuff going on down there you can go from the south pole to calcutta you know or you know
mumbai or something like that and then you can go all the way around to san diego hold it up just a
little bit like this yep so you can go from the south pole up to the equator around say mumbai
and then you go all the way across that equator till you get you know to new mexico city right
that triangle will have three 90 degree angles three times 90 is 270 degrees that's called a
non-euclidean triangle those triangles can have very different shapes than 180 degrees only in
the universe when the universe is flat do the angles add up to 180 degrees and i'll give you
some examples there's one other type of geometry it's called hyperbolic or negative curvature
the easiest way to see that is a pringles chip which you know hopefully maybe amanda can get
me some pringles chips for lunch just
kidding uh i should have requested them earlier she's so helpful i mean it's right downstairs
i know i don't want to i don't want to i don't want her to miss on on my boring cosmology
lectures right she's falling asleep over there brian a pringles chip you draw a triangle the
triangles bow in like this the angles bow in to less than 180 degrees okay so three different
geometries you detect the geometry by the number of degrees inside of a triangle negative pringles
chips less than 180 degrees flat exactly 180 degrees spherical greater than
180 degrees okay in the universe let's say you take you make a triangle from earth to the sun
to uh mars make that triangle okay wait earth sun mars that's a triangle okay yeah yeah and you add
up the angles inside that triangle you get 180 degrees that's right now go uh mars go to alpha
centauri the you know which is way the fuck away yeah four light years away yeah and then you go
from there uh back to the sun okay so you make it you make this really other huge triangle you make
a triangle that's not gonna no that does add up to 180 okay yeah yeah now here's the next one
you've heard of the andromeda galaxy it's the closest galaxy to there it's three million light
years away from the earth is that the one kipping talks about uh he's looking at exoplanets he looks
at exoplanets but in our galaxy he can't i don't think you can see him in another galaxy but yeah
he he does look at exoplanets and their moons and some of the moons have moons so they're
going crazy but bart several doesn't believe that those moons exist okay we got to talk about that
uh sorry no it's your favorite bar under the bus uh
he's my buddy now we you know we we hung out on piers morgan oh you didn't yeah yeah i went on
and debated him oh you know what i did see that i did see that i was fucking hysterical it was
hilarious piers is like you're full of shit you know i was like i don't have to say piers piers
please explain why why they wouldn't swear on a stack of bibles okay listen i think i think there's
some part of the moon story that is certainly questionable i just don't think he's a great
spokesman no he's not and i know i heard you and danny talking about how that's by design let's talk
because it's important, you know,
I'm going on this Jubilee show, hopefully in a couple of months
and I'm going to be surrounded
surrounded by flat earthers, moon landing deniers, big bang deniers.
Oh, your favorite people.
No, they are my favorite people, Julian.
I get paid.
I'm a public employee.
I'm an employee of the state of California.
Gavin Newsom ultimately is my boss.
That's not a flex.
That's not a flex.
It's a flex for him, right?
So I serve at the pleasure of, you know, Gavin Newsom, the regents of the University of California,
and the taxpayers of the university, and every scientist.
I don't care who you are.
You're supported by the government, right?
My job is to give back.
And that's partially why I come on podcasts.
I have my own podcast, because you guys pay my salary.
Into the Impossible podcast.
You guys can check it out on YouTube and Spotify and wherever you get podcasts.
Wherever you get podcasts are not sold.
You know, I got to monetize.
You do have, probably, if anyone, the best library of physicists and scientists on the internet.
Oh, thanks.
Yeah, I just have my-
I mean, it's like pretty unbelievable.
28th Nobel Prize winner to come on.
He won the Nobel Prize last week for the discovery of high-energy neutrinos from extra galactic and galactic sources.
We're going to come back to that.
We'll come back to that.
Okay.
But the thing I want to point out, I got to flex a little bit, because you're my buddy.
So I wrote him, and he was on my show a couple years ago.
And I wrote him.
His name is Francis Halzen.
And I took classes with him.
I've known him very well for 30 years.
And I just wrote him an email.
Like, first of all, I got an email that night that he won from a guy who won the Nobel Prize in economics three years ago.
Guido Imbens at Stanford.
And Guido and I become a little bit friendly.
And so Guido, Guido, Guido, but it's pronounced Guido.
He's Dutch.
He won the Nobel Prize in economics, okay?
Okay.
Then he writes to me, congratulations on your interview with Francis Halzen.
So it's a Nobel Prize winner writing me, Brian Keating, non-Nobel Prize winner, loser of the Nobel Prize.
That's right.
Right?
And then he writes to me, great interview.
I'm so glad to see Francis.
Congratulations.
I hope you're doing well.
Then I was like, oh, wow.
He saw it.
That's pretty cool.
So I wrote to Francis Halzen, who won it that day.
I said, Francis, I know you're too busy to respond.
I just wanted to let you know, thinking of you, I'm so glad and blessed that you have the time to spend with me a couple years.
He writes me back almost instantly.
And thank you so much for your kind message.
Being on your podcast is making me more famous than the Nobel Prize winner.
Really?
Yes.
Wow.
Yeah, yeah.
He's a sweet guy.
He's a man.
She's 82, 83.
He's an incredible guy.
I just wanted to flex that a little bit because of the Gavin Newsom.
It's got to be the antidote.
Consider it flexed.
Right.
All right.
So we're back to this triangle.
We were talking about Alpha Centauri and how it still makes 180 degrees.
And no matter how far you go out, you go out to Andromeda Galaxy, you go out to the Whirlpool Galaxy, any triangle.
Of three points, a triangle is just three points.
No triangles exist, Julian.
I can't hand you a triangle.
And an LLM cannot have a concept of what a triangle is only mathematically.
But the human mind can, right?
Because I can't give you something zero-dimensional.
Here's a zero-dimensional object, Julian.
Is that zero-dimensional, that dot?
Technically not.
No.
What is it?
It's three-dimensional.
That's right.
Most people say two-dimensional.
No, you just made ink.
Yeah, there's ink that's raised.
There's billions of molecules there.
It's a huge amount of stuff, right?
It just appears like it's.
It appears.
It appears.
It appears to our eye.
That's the resolution of our eye and that so forth.
Any triangle you make in the universe, no matter how big it is, you can detect the geometry,
the curvature of the universe out to that distance using this triangular method, as
long as you have objects that exist.
But they're only, you know, they're mentally, they're geometrically, they're mathematically
existing, right?
That's right.
We've done those measurements.
We know that the universe has zero curvature.
It means that it's flat.
That means no matter if you make the triangle out to the beginning of time, when the first
objects form, the earliest galaxies.
The earliest galaxies in the universe, for example, or that microwave background that
I studied, any triangle you make will always have.
But that's weird.
I didn't tell you another fact, though.
How many different types of spheres are there?
There's this sphere.
There's a golf ball.
There's a BB.
There's the Earth.
Technically, anything that is on some different angular whatever is going to be a different
type of sphere down to the point zero, zero, zero, zero, zero, one percent difference from
one to the other.
There's an infinite number of spheres, right?
Okay.
Pringles chips, horse saddles, negative curvature spaces.
Same thing.
There's an infinite number of those things because there's an infinite number of what
are called real numbers.
Real numbers are numbers that have the properties that they do.
They're basically any number you count with plus rational plus irrational numbers.
Terrence Howard might argue with that.
He definitely would.
He might argue with that.
Yeah, exactly.
He might cook, too.
He might.
Yeah, I haven't.
He might cook.
I have not followed his culinary adventures.
The weird thing is that so the universe could have one of three possibilities.
Imagine if I told you you can live in one of three different places.
You could live in one of three different places.
You could live in Hoboken, New Jersey.
You could live on Earth somewhere.
You could live in the universe somewhere.
Which is more probable of all those things?
Somewhere in the universe or specifically in Hoboken, New Jersey?
Which is more probable?
Somewhere in the universe.
Somewhere in the universe, right?
So because there's an infinite number of places in the universe, there's only one Hoboken,
New Jersey.
Yeah, this is the center of the universe.
This is the center.
That's right.
Yes, I love it.
I actually grew up, you know, Hoboken.
That's right.
It's like hobos are here.
It's an awesome place.
Congratulations.
You were at the forefront.
You were at the forefront of this.
This is going to be Austin, Texas.
You're going to describe this as Hoboken of the South.
I tell everyone, it's terrible here.
Don't come here.
Do not come here.
That's what I said about San Diego.
Do not come.
Oh, the weather's terrible.
There was a cloud yesterday in San Diego.
There was a cloud.
Yeah.
So anyway, you're absolutely right.
When you have an infinite number of possibilities, that's much more likely.
And you just correctly identified there's an infinite number of spheres we could live
in.
There's an infinite number of Pringles.
But why do we live in the only, there's only one flat universe.
There's only one.
Why is that?
Why do we live?
But are you saying that symbolically?
As in like how it looks versus how it actually is?
Because it has to be 3D.
No, no, no.
Or more.
We live in three dimensions.
But three dimensions can have one of three different curvatures.
Negative curvature, like a Pringles chip.
Positive curvature, like a sphere.
Or flat.
But there's an infinite number of negative curvature surfaces that you correctly identify.
There's an infinite number of spheres that we could live in.
But zero curvature, flat universe.
Not flat, zero dimension.
Three dimensional, flat universe.
There's only one.
And we live in that one.
That's a great mystery.
So we live in a three dimensional, spatial dimensions.
One time dimension.
And then we have different possibilities for the curvature of light beams as they travel in space.
Here's another thing that would happen.
If we live in a flat universe, these all go back to Euclid, you know, 2,300 years ago, right?
Euclid said you have two parallel lines.
You shoot two lasers parallel to each other and they'll never come together.
Okay?
They're perfectly parallel.
They're perfectly parallel, yeah.
Everything in math is perfect, right?
But if you're on a sphere, you're on a sphere.
If you're on a sphere and you shoot two laser beams, they're perfectly parallel at the equator, right?
They'll come together at the North Pole or the South Pole, right?
If they travel only along the lines of what are called the lines of longitude, right?
So they'll travel along the surface.
They'll converge.
So they don't stay parallel.
They started off parallel at the equator, two guys shooting lasers, and then they went out.
Yeah.
And on a Pringles chip, what do you think happens?
On a Pringles chip universe, horse saddle universe, you shoot two lasers parallel initially, what happens to them?
I mean, they're not going to be parallel pretty quickly.
That's right. But what will they do? Will they converge, diverge, or stay parallel?
They're not going to stay parallel. They're going to diverge, right?
Yes, exactly. 100%. Those are the only three options. But there's an infinite number of ways
they could go away from each other, right? They could start off really slowly and diverge. They
could diverge really quickly. But if they diverge, are we on. Now I'm getting real meta here, but
are we on some sort of plane to where they cross over at some point and then reconvert?
Exactly. And that would mean that we could go out in a direction. You could come to San Diego
in our universe. San Diego.
And you'd eventually come back around and you'd come back to Hoboken, right? But we don't see
that. There's an infinite number of ways they could converge. There's an infinite number of
ways they could diverge. There's only one way they can stay parallel, and that's the universe
we live in. Why? Why do we live in a universe that has this property that light beams do these
crazy things? And oh, by the way, it happens to be fit for life. And it happens to be fit for life
that can develop consciousness. And that's the universe we live in.
And that consciousness can contemplate the very parallelism that defines the geometry of the
universe. That's what physicists are trying to do. You wonder, what is Eric Weinstein trying to do?
What is Michio Kaku trying to do? What is Brian Greene trying to do? What is Terence Howard trying
to do? They're all theorists, okay? I'm an experimentalist. Very different thing. I don't
work on theories of what the universe could be like. I could give a crap about what the different
types of the universe could be. I want to know what it is. And I want to collect data to actually
falsify or verify the difference.
And I want to know what the universe could be like. The thing I hate about most scientists is that they don't, as much as I have problems and beefs
with Michio Kaku. You got some beef with the Kaku? Well, I've given him a war. Yes, I have a beef
with him. He was on Diary of a CEO, or I've been on before. And he said and spouted out some of the
most ridiculous and quite frankly, unscientific claims. Like what? Okay. So he said, he was
talking about, first of all, I want to say something to you. It's Chabad. It's not Chabad.
Chabad.
Can you say that with me?
Chabad.
Chabad.
Yeah. That's like the guys out in Brooklyn, right?
It's like guys in Brooklyn. Yeah, yeah.
With the tunnels and shit?
What's that?
With the tunnels.
Yeah. The tunnels is the one thing, right?
I'm just saying. I don't know what the fuck's going on.
Okay. We can go there. But here's the deal. Chabad, not habit or chabit.
I never said chabit. Why are you saying that to me?
You and Danny said chabit.
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
Joey, pull it up, brother.
That's a Danny Jones mistake.
Danny Jones.
Hold on a minute. Don't you put that on me, Forrest.
I got it. I want to-
Don't do that.
But here's something the Chabad rabbi said.
That is totally something Danny Jones would do.
I'm going to throw him right under the bus right now.
I love Danny.
but yeah yeah but uh but uh but uh it's it's chabad okay yeah has nothing to do with it here's
my beef okay the beef with the cock with the oh don't do that i was stuck i got stuck okay glitched
yeah i'm an old man he's afraid of me now um i know i know you you accosted him you know i didn't
hold on hold on tell the story i actually gotta tell it so i had him on three and a half years
ago in my parents house about eric weinstein yeah this is like at the height of when i was like sick
because the dog was with eosinophilic asthma so i was about 45 pounds lighter and he comes on we do
a really fun podcast that was one of my favorites i ever did nicest guy ever and then this past
december so like three years later roughly i'm walking down six avenue in new york from my
doctor's office and i'm coming up on bryant park where the bank of america building is and i see
michio kaku and his wife it was like really cold out walking like towards the bank of america
building i'm like oh shit i've been trying
i'd love to get him back on the show so i like kind of beeline it for him and i hold out my hand
to shake his hand i go dr kaku how you doing and he looks at me with with total fear in his eyes
his wife begins to reach for what i can only surmise is pepper spray and then like i'm like
smart lady you remember me you're on my podcast a few years back and he goes
no i don't think so actually i don't i know i was like well i'd love to get you back on at
some point he's like okay you reach out to team and i was like all
right thanks and i'm pretty sure they thought i was there to mug them i was not would love to
have you back on but let's get back to your beef you have so the beef is that scientists have an
obligation to share what we do with the public because the public pays our salary imagine you
worked at dunkin donuts okay you're working there you know you got to step up uh you got a promotion
you're working behind the i don't know they're making the donuts remember the commercial in the
in the in the well you're too young but i remember in the 80s okay and there's a guy with the mustache
he was making the donuts and they were trying to say oh you know the donuts are fresh all the time
and so you
see this guy and he wakes up in the morning and his wife's like where are you going it's 4 30 in
the morning time to make the donuts then he goes out he goes to work you know time to make the
donuts and then eventually he meets himself in a parallel universe and they both the both of
these copies of this of this clerk say to each other time to make the donuts okay anyway it's
it's a classic for people of a certain gen xers okay you zoomers don't know what i'm talking about
one of the most annoying parts about shopping for fashion online is when you have
way too many options and you just endlessly scroll without making a decision it's like they've
put too much sensory overload in your face and nothing ever happens and this is why revolve man
is so awesome as a tool they create a field that feels curated not chaotic it's edited in a way
that makes sense everything's styled so you can see how it works it's not just a product on a
white background it's the whole outfit and that's another thing when you get the full look instead
of just one piece you get help knowing what goes with what so you're not just guessing the two-day
shipping is free and if you order a couple options for a trip or an event it's genuinely stress-free
to be able to shop for a few days and then you can shop for a few days and then you can shop for
a few days and then you can shop for a few days and then you can shop for a few days and then you can
send back what you don't end up using when you go on their site you find one piece you like and
the site will then show you similar options or the full look so the whole thing starts to come
together all in one place you can also shop by vibe i love this that includes night out vacation
weekend dressed up you're not just searching by category and with the lack of endless scrolling
it's a place that actually respects your time joey d if you got something recently from revolve man
what'd you buy i'm a big fan of going to them for my polo ralph loren where'd you wear the ralph loren
where'd you wear the ralph loren where'd you wear the ralph loren
around my house i like to look good respect whether it's a big night out a wedding a trip
or just impressing the four walls around you like joey def revolve man always has it go to
revolveman.com slash julian to shop link in my description below and use code julian for 15
off your order it's going to come with free two-day shipping easy returns and it just makes
everything better that's revolve.com slash julian link in my description below and use code julian
for 15 off your entire order offer ends soon don't sleep on it
when you shop kroger delivery you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered
right to your door our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed
to getting every detail right carefully selecting and packing your order with care because bringing
you fresh quality groceries is what we do best and right now enjoy 20 off your first online order of
75 or more restrictions apply see site for details kroger fresh for everyone
but anyway um imagine you're working there and the head the head the manager comes in and says hey hey
he's got deep sky hold on yeah put it up oh this is great early is this that's not danny
devito i saw that really quickly play it it's not danny devito is is it an indian guy
no it's not it isn't easy owning the duncan donuts time to make the
because unlike most supermarkets we make up to 52 varieties fresh day and night of course when you
make donuts they're not fresh they're not fresh they're not fresh they're not fresh they're not
fresh they're not fresh they're not fresh people buy a lot of them morning books
look for duncan donuts money saving coupon in your local newspaper
when did he cross over yeah he didn't cross over that crossover yeah there he is oh this one
crosses over let's see the crossing okay off to make the donuts are always fresh i made the donuts
we make them at least once every day we had to make the donuts there's not a few guys like super
marketing job of your dreams
this is like the fucking bart simpson that's the first example of the multiverse yeah there it is
that was the first ever demonstration of the multi okay you're working at duncan donuts and
then the owner comes in that guy comes in says hey hey uh julie judo um what's going on how did
you know what um i'm doing stuff you cannot buy i'm doing stuff you cannot buy i'm doing stuff you cannot buy
possibly understand what these donuts i have this technique these interdimensional spices name with
made with non uh terrestrial biologics uh um here mr mr duncan dun manager um you can't under people
say like f you like you'd be fired in a second most of my colleagues say that to the public
they say you can't understand what i do if it was so advanced and i could explain it to you
it wouldn't be worth a nobel prize or it wouldn't be worth the attention that i get
so scientists should not do that they're bad scientists when
they do that so i want to say first and foremost mitch is a good scientist by those definitions
okay he does a lot of outreach he's comes on podcasts he's he's been on mine he's been on yours
um he's been in the diary ceo but when you have the platform that he has that neil degrasse tyson
has brian green has eric weinstein has brett weinstein has um and you're known quote as a
scientist most average people will never meet a scientist you've met a lot but i bet you wouldn't
have met this many if you didn't have this podcast so not too many people have top zero point and
zero one percent podcast right so you're in a privileged position i'm not saying this to make
you feel guilty i'm just saying you have this vision that there are a lot more scientists than
there actually are there are very few scientists i mean there's more people that play in the nba
than do what i do oh yeah no i actually don't have that i'm not under that illusion sometimes i think
about all the all of the like strides that we make and yet how small and almost like ivory tower the
feel is and i don't and the field is i don't mean that in the bad way of ivory tower like it's very
very like just yeah it's to get all the way through and actually be someone leading a
research project i think of all the hurdles you got to go through not just that just to go to
college i mean we act like there's everyone goes to college like 40 of people go to college and
then elite colleges and then once you get out of college you have to go to grad school and so what
i'm saying is he's doing something important i don't want to say be misconstrued that he's doing
something bad or evil because he's actually doing something good but the way that he's doing it
has has some consequences that are troubling a
he talked to stephen bartlett he went on the irv ceo which next to the you know julian dray
dory uh podcast is number two it's pretty it's pretty high up there i think he made more money
yesterday and i've made it my entire life but thank you well but but soon to be you because
you're younger than him you're doing more i would say he's going to be more popular than rogan he
will have more followers than rogan um it doesn't mean rogan's not doing a good job but you know
people say that like how could you say that he had you on well it's just true he's doing he does
experience he has a team of 30 people it's more than that in the room
than that actually in um his team no i mean i was in the room i mean i i'm just saying in the room
30 people there's photographers there's people making gift baskets when i left there's a bound
i don't know how they did it a bound you know 3d photo album with me and steven and all that
it's incredible i went on on this past summer and i'm not just i bought you a coffee i know
all right you want me to uh man yeah we got you the idea yeah amanda did it okay let's be honest
um so i'm getting you a tesseract
too i want to get that in the mail yeah so uh so what what happened was when he when he goes on
these shows he has this huge megaphone platform and what they say gets amplified and you get the
message that this is what scientists believe and that it's uniform and when you say things that are
scary right now we're in a very scary time ai global nuclear thermal war conventional war
hot spots going around but but particular ai and there's a lot of hype there's a lot of doomer i
mean they even have a term for it doomerism
i've interviewed the guy who's like the number one doomer this guy roman yampolsky
he looks like rasputin he's coming on yeah he's great and i love him and we're friends and i
respect him but he has this concept that it's guaranteed essentially that doom is going to
happen i have counter arguments against it but when you're on the side of the boat and it's
tipping over so much everyone's on that same side doom doom doom you have to think well what's on
the other side so when mitchio's on dire vco he's saying things like quantum computing will destroy
it will destroy capitalism capitalism will be destroyed because of
quantum computing. First of all, the, you know, the best thing a quantum computer has ever done
in history is optimize the next quantum computer that we know of that. Well, uh, actually I can
say that with, with great knowledge because I've talked to a Nobel prize winner who won for quantum
computing, who developed this concept called quantum supremacy or verified quantum supremacy,
meaning a quantum computer can do something that no classical computer could do in a finite time.
This did it in a few minutes and it solved problems that, but the problems that it's
solving have to do with either taking a large number and turning it into two smaller numbers,
prime factorization, or it's simulating the quantum mechanical Lagrangian of a quantum
mechanical system, which the computer is based upon. Okay. Are you going to use that? Are you
going to have iPhone duo 22? Is it going to have a property with a quantum computer in it? No.
Are there other types of mechanisms that can do the exact same thing as cloud as quantum computers?
Yes.
They might take longer, but there's, there's many more, you know, there's like 150,
maybe a thousand total quantum computers on earth. There's literally 6 billion classical computers on
earth. So 6 billion can Trump in some, to some extent. But here's the thing. When you tell people
that it's going to destroy capitalism, it's something made by physicists. It's something
the public should worry about. What do you think that does to notion? Why should I like, would you
give money to the national science foundation to fund quantum computing research? If I said it's
going to destroy capitalism, it's going to destroy quantum computing. It's going to destroy quantum
capitalism, which will lead to mass starvation, destruction, death. I don't care who your mayor
is across the street over there in New York. Communism has a horrible track record, right?
I agree.
So what would you say would be the net effect of capitalism being destroyed on planet earth,
not just in America, good or bad, just good or bad?
What you're talking about is one of my favorite concepts that I bring up for everything all the
time, which is the universal law of physics for every action, there's an equal, but opposite
reaction. And what I always say is that it's to create equilibrium, but like you're never going to
live in a world that has perfect equilibrium that would make life meaningless and dull. There'd be
no happiness, be no sadness, no ups, no downs, but you want, you want your actions to be like
this. You don't want them to be like this. And I hear your point on that. What I do want to ask
though, is it seems to me like when I see some of the titles that Steven does, because I look at
that a lot, obviously they're the greatest in the space at doing that stuff. He, he, he, he, he, he,
he does seem to have on people that like, he'll have on Michio who might say something like that.
And then he'll have on some other guy who kind of says the opposite.
No, no, no. But, but I was saying Eric Weinstein, but maybe some of them are the same, but like,
all right, so let me look at it, how I do it here. I'm going to have on Roman in January or February,
right? Amanda, when we're doing it, Roman's coming on there. But like I just had on Lee Cronin who
thinks the whole AI thing's a fucking joke. Right. And then I had on Connor Leahy, who's not a doomer,
but he's highly
concerned. And now I'm having on you who probably comes at it at the similar, like opposite end of
like Connor does not all the way to like, we shouldn't be concerned, but like, I don't think
the world's ending. So like, I think when you're doing it, at least speaking from my angle here,
it won't speak for anyone else when you're doing it to where multiple perspectives are allowed to
be hashed out. And when you're in there, you're actually like, I don't even mean pushing back,
but you're asking questions about it. You push back.
People don't push back as much as you do. And, and Danny does it to some extent, but I
think you do it. You do a good job of it. You push back on me, you know, which is quite frankly,
sometimes annoying, but I love you for doing it because this is the thing, this is the thing that
your guests, I, and I wish you would have pushed back harder on people like Brett. Okay. Cause
there's a lot of 9 11. Uh, we didn't talk about 9 11 for that. We talked about, yeah, well it was
the day before. Yeah. It was pretty quick. Uh, Charlie Kirk, um, um, uh, Israel Netanyahu. Um,
uh, it was, there was some amount of it. Um,
but nobody pushes back on him and, and I'm, I've even been guilty. People don't push back on him
that, and he, and he doesn't, he doesn't go on shows where people will push back on him.
But anyway, I'm not, he's not a scientist anymore. He's a podcaster. That's a, that's his job. He's
not doing science anymore. Eric's not a scientist. He's not doing science. He's making, he's writing
papers. He's got some ideas, but then he doesn't believe in peer review. And I love Eric talking to
him yesterday. Um, there, there, there's an issue when you say to a real scientist, Graham Hancock,
not a real scientist, Mitch, your cock.
was a real scientist, did legitimate work is old. And I hope I'm as sharp as he is,
but I hope I reject you when I'm 82 or whatever.
It feels like you're defining scientist is what have you done for me lately?
No, I'm saying what is a scientist? You asked me something I have no fucking expertise in
like a nine 11 or, um, magnetic pole shifts or, um, uh, you know, a structure underneath the
pyramids in Egypt. You know what I should say, Julian? I don't fucking know. Don't ask me that.
Because I don't know. Like tonight I'm talking to Richard Dawkins. He's going to ask,
we're going to talk about stuff. I'm not going to talk about my extensive knowledge of, uh,
extended phenotypes. And I'm going to say, how can I connect this to something the audience can
relate to and make it about him? It's not about me. And what he does spectacularly well is he'll
say, I don't know when he'll talk about stuff. Now he also does this. It's called ultra crepidarianism
when you think, because you're, it's a halo effect. You're an awesome podcaster.
This is phenomenal. If I asked you like, what's it like to be
the, make the Stephen Colbert show number two, you could probably figure it out. But if I said,
Hey, can you make Lawrence Livermore national laboratory produce a, you know, the, the, uh,
laser fusion project, you should say, no, I will tell you God save us if we do it. How often have
the scientists on your show said, I don't know more than you think more than you think, but I,
your point is taken. Roman will say that he's a good scientist. Lee will say that Lee has his own,
by the way, you can have your own, you know, kind of people will say, oh, you're a grifter for NASA.
You believe in the round earth or whatever. People will say you can have an agenda that
doesn't make you a grifter, but you cannot have an, a, you cannot be an expert in all things.
The greatest thing a scientist can do you, you gave Isaac Newton's, you know, first law, every
reaction, there's an equal opposite reaction. Um, uh, so Arthur C. Clark said for every expert,
there's an equal and opposite expert. That's oh, wow. That's I'm going to use that. Who said that?
Arthur C. Clark. He's long dead, but, but yeah, uh, he was a 2001, a space Odyssey. He wrote the book.
The podcast, by the way, do you know where podcast comes from?
This is your job. You should fucking isn't afraid because it was invented by,
it's like a, it's a play on the word with Apple. Apple took it from something else. So what did
Apple take it from? There used to be these things when you were, uh, before you were born, uh,
called iPods. I do remember that Joey bring up an iPod on this. I think we have a relic of those
somewhere. So the iPod was a thousand songs in your pocket. His first MP3 player that
reached mass appeal. And it was this white thing. Yeah. You see what the
circle and the disc. Oh, look at that thing. When, uh, Vinny, what a primitive object? Yeah.
But you wouldn't have your iPhone if without this thing, right? I don't think Amanda was alive when
that happened. Apple would not exist. You did have an iPod. What were you two? It had a black
and white screen. Okay. Wow. So, uh, there's an engineer at Apple
who invented this and he took it to Steve jobs and they said, what should we call it?
And the engineer, this guy, Vinny said, it looks like the pod from now call up the pod
from two, uh, 2001, a space Odyssey, please Joey. And it looks like the pod in the movie,
2001, a space Odyssey with how, how is the open the pod bay doors. How, right? So see how it's
white there. Click on the left. Wow. That's what they thought it looked like. Everything comes back
to Kubrick, bro. Okay. So Kubrick, right? Epstein, Epstein landed on the moon. Don't you know that?
He was probably digging around there. He found the dark side, you know, I'm in the Epstein files.
He's like, I got it. We got to shit. We got to talk about that.
Um, so anyway, that's where podcast comes from. Okay. It was first on iPods.
iPod name came from 2001, a space Odyssey. Arthur C. Clarke wrote the book that 2001 space Odyssey,
and that led to what you do for a living. So you should know that anyway, most people don't know
that. How do we get on a subject? You should know things that you're an expert in, but I always tell
my students, you don't know, like when they start to say, well, like we studied the big bang, but
I'm really, you know, I heard about this thing with aliens or whatever. I was like, okay, it's
great to do that. Do that in your spare time, because you don't know enough, even in your
own subject, because I don't know enough in my own. So I'll never know as much as I can know.
And that's why AI is so delightful and exciting and dangerous because it can extend my powers by
thousands and thousands of times leverage. We'll, we'll talk about that. But what I'm trying to tell
you is when you know, how do you know this is a good podcast or a bad podcast right now? How do
you know? You're a professional. I don't think about that when I'm doing that.
Never think about that? No, I'm very,
I'm very present. The only time that thought really comes is if someone goes on some in
sanely boring tangent and I literally feel deep falling asleep. That's about the only time the
rest of it is like, I'm so into every podcast feels great. I'll give you two tips. I mean,
far be it from me, you know, much, much, much fewer kind of, uh, success in podcasting. Cause
it's not my, it's not my full-time job, but you're a professional at this. I use two heuristics. One,
um, someone comes on the show, they have people like, I don't have people,
but they have people saying like Sam Harris, you get Sam Harris on the show.
Uh, you want to get on the show. He has people handler that will interface
with you. Sam's got, uh, 45 minutes to talk to you, Brian on this time. And that's it. And he
can't do it in person, even though I live, you know, a couple of minutes an hour. Um,
fine. 45 minutes, I get 45 questions, you know, whatever it's going to be.
Three and a half hours went by. We're still talking. I know that's a good podcast. I know
that he wants it. We took eight bathroom breaks, you know, I mean, we're both, you know, men of a
certain age, so our prostates don't hold out. I got a shitty bladder. I can't tell.
So in real time, you have this here, it's called a heuristic. It's a, it's a code. It's an
algorithm running in your mind. This guy told me he's got an hour, but he's here for two hours.
I must be doing something good. Right. Or, and they say something like this. You ever had someone
say, wow, no one's ever asked me that, but mean it, but all the time, that means we're
you're a fucking good podcaster people we need these heuristics but i say to you um what's it
like to rebuild you know 1948 dodge power wagons you know carburetor you say i don't i don't know
unless you do i don't know maybe you do i i'm trying to work on one right now i don't know how
to do it i'll hire an expert to do it when these people talk about shit like 9-11 and charlie
kirk there was a drone swarm and all this other crap and and um you know what netanyahu's you
know secretly staged uh october 7th in order to have a re-election and whatever i don't care what
it is there is evidence for okay fine but he's an evolutionary fucking biologist sure but i think
we're conspiracy theorists but that's that's also those are that's not science those are stories in
the public it is science everything is science what do you mean oh i disagree with that like
you're everything is a drone flying over an arena no because what you're saying you're describing
the fact that people should be able to speak on things based on their level of expertise in the
subject matter itself when you are looking at science like let's take a look at you know being
being an astronomer for example right because you would understand that very well this takes
decades of schooling and research and projects and being in it and experimentation and stuff
so if i suddenly say you know brian i'm really interested in this stuff which i am i know a thing
or two which i do i know fucking nothing and if i suddenly say here's my new theory of everything
on how fucking mars happened you're gonna look at me and be like you're out of your mind but when
there are things that are in the public domain that are not actually like you know related to
understanding like how to do math to be able to properly do science correctly or understand that
i think it's perfectly reasonable when someone can take that information and distill it and make
cases out of it i had baron coleman in here who's like literally a litigator like he is a lifelong
lawyer brilliant man and so he looked at the charlie kirk case from a litigation standpoint
right away and from an evidence standpoint and from a how is the investigation carried out
that's what i'm saying i see very little difference in how brett does it
in fact i think brett's training as an evolutionary biologist leads him to be able to be someone who
can ask questions no on those good scientists should be able to say this is not an area of
my expertise but i'm going to research it see you said something like should like i think somebody
should of course everybody should it's not like proprietary thing only nasa should look at the
moon only nist should look at building seven collapse only um evolutionary biologists should
look at you know uh dawkins theory of memetic behavior no of course not
anybody can can do it okay but when you have a platform like he does and when you give your
platform which is even bigger than his platform in some sense then there is a responsibility not
to not to shut him up not to censor him but just say how would you know that you're wrong how would
you know that you are wrong ask him things like that he did and and and he did say i i don't know
on some stuff like we also spent the day with him too you know and went to dinner with him
afterwards and stuff and like oh he's a great guy i got him on twice it's not even
just that he's a great guy i went to his anniversary you know party which he is it's
just like he he's such a he has such a curious mind like in in the best way possible but here's
here's my point to him and and you know i've had him on i i had to stop following him because of
just the this this overreach in some ways that he was getting and the attention that he was
getting and putting it into you know quite frankly using things like his friendship with charlie kirk
um and saying that this gave him special knowledge that he said he didn't know him that well i know
he made that pretty clear he said it was on his anniversary of he spoke on september 10th his
anniversary and it's my friend charlie kirk and i feel a special responsibility and it's fine i
mean i'm not i'm not calling into question he had some tax or whatever but there should be at some
level you know when when you hear about when you hear about claims that are so explosive to say
that like it is strange like if i told you i'm gonna have a zoologist on is he a scientist yes
does he know about charlie kirk's assassination
does he have any special knowledge about it and furthermore how would you know that you're wrong
not are you wrong not that he is wrong he may be right i may be wrong but do you understand why
there's a way different barrier to entry when you're talking about someone being able to figure
out particle physics versus someone being able to look through an fbi report and deduce what seems
to be backed by evidence and what's not what they are doing is so much more significant than what
i'm doing i think who charlie kirk's assassination the 9-11 conspiracy theories the the jfk assassinate
see there's one thing you need to learn about scientists especially professors like me and
brett used to be a professor for for some time yeah um and and he was fired very courageous you know
and his wife heather i've had her on too um but when you know about scientists what we do is
important but it's not significant and i'll give you a difference between when i'm like um a
fireman saving you know a life that is really important and it's significant because you're
here um is that important is that important how fast they going no buck 20
they're using the new tesla roadster what time would you put a deposit time a day
okay it doesn't matter it's important that we have laws in america this does matter
you can go on the road 3 a.m you want to go 120 down the straightaway between exits 7 and 9 on
the turnpike be my guest until a deer comes out no there's no deer there's no deer on the turnpike
okay fine yeah whatever the point is it's important right we need laws we need traffic
put it this way if someone's like starts tailgating you you're going to be like this
guy should get pulled over like you ever said uh where's a cop when you need one right no you just
hit your brakes and take the insurance money okay i don't know if you want to censor that for your
usaa insurance that's okay okay listen up the point i'm trying to make it's important but it's
not significant it's not going to change the world that you got a ticket this guy got a ticket right
what i do is important i mean i'm trying to understand the origin of the universe
origin of life in the universe the impact of artificial minds on consciousness to divine
and to derive new physical ones that's important is it significant is it curing one life no i think
being a parent being a friend being a husband i think those are much more significant i think
that's what i'll be that's what i judge myself on by the way i don't fucking care about the nobel
prize i don't care about going on podcasts or having my own podcast to the extent that it like
it gives me fulfillment and in the moment it gives me happiness and joy it's not my career
but but it's something that's that's you know it's important but it's not significant
let's be honest very few people achieve significance but all people want to be
significant right you read uh victor frankl's man's search for meaning probably it's a podcast
thing right um i read it it's a great guy he's a concentration camp psychologist who survived and
said that man's ultimate desire is not for sex it's not for money it's not for food it's for
meaning yes meaning is the thing that drives people well what if you're a scientist somebody
like brett you know was a scientist was a professor was influencing young minds doing a field
research excellent writer very charismatic and now you can no longer do that now you have this
opportunity to be significant to influence people hopefully for good and i'm just saying with kaku
with with eric with brett with with graham hancock you know graham's not a scientist but but in that
sense my point is that these platforms amplify things and they communicate to the public dangerous
things and some ideas not to censor them but if i go out there and say every freaking thing you do
and and and and is is
is potentially catastrophic implications not only for you but for humanity as a whole how are you
supposed to operate i don't think so i i i see your point i also i think there needs to be a little
more faith in people with how you look at this and here's what i mean by that i'm not numb to the idea
that public opinion can be moved and it can be just kind of hit a little bit over and over again to get
more people into one camp i understand that and it doesn't mean people are stupid with that we are all
to that you and i included but i also think like people can spot more bullshit than you think and
i'm and i say that across percentages there's always going to be someone who's going to be a
contrarian on every goddamn thing to the fullest extent no matter what yeah right anti-vaxxers
whatever it might be but you know there's also a lot of people who operate in the middle there
and they want to hear a case made and they may hear michio kaku come and make something up maybe
he goes on there and says you know
destroy capitalism okay destroy capitalism and someone at home might think about that and they
may they may go yeah you know capitalism is not having its best moment right now but i feel like
that's probably not the best idea ever to get rid of the entire thing like you know are we just
going to go to communism across the river here i seem to think that's okay yeah but like that's in
a cut and and i'm not discounting it that's in a concentrated area and it all there were other
factors that went into that he didn't zoron mom donnie didn't win that race because he's a
you know and so i like charismatic very things come in things come in phases and i think that
you have to look at it that way and like yes there will be some times where people may get
really moved by a certain movement at that time and you may you may be like sitting there going
why did we give that so much of a voice or why didn't we push back on that as much but like
i've seen these cycles and i think they kind of fade to where people kind of come out on the other
side eventually they're like you know what that got a little crazy i think they don't fade but
you're right they do something in physics
called they they oscillate their pendulums i'll take that yeah yeah so you look who's going to
win the next election it's not going to be republicans trump's going to get crushed in
this election right yeah um everybody thinks there's only one red and white mushroom turns
out there's a whole family of them and lately i've been into the less famous one the mushroom
i'm talking about is called amanita muscaria the red one with the white spots you've seen in every
video game and fairy tale ever and right now we're at the tail end of harvest season these pop up
from late summer through the fall usually under birch pine or spruce they grow in partnership with
which is why nobody really farms them.
The caps are wild harvested,
every fall, and then dried, which is how people have been preparing them for centuries. And here's
what most people don't know. Amanita isn't just one mushroom. There are Muscaria, the classic red
one. There's Amanita regalis, and then there's Amanita pantherina. Same family, different
personalities. One other thing, though, that's very worth noting. The Amanita family also includes
some of the most toxic mushrooms on the planet. So please don't just go out into the woods picking
these for yourself. Bad idea. Don't do that. Leave that to the people who do this for a living.
As for how Amanita feels, people describe it as calming without feeling foggy, settled,
but still clear. Because Amanita is going to get you that relaxed, warm feeling, but you're going
to wake up feeling ready to roll. And the only brand I trust for this is Amantara. Clean sourcing,
no synthetics, no sketchy additives, and they actually educate people instead of just pushing
product. I personally like their blue lotus extract capsules before I go to bed sometimes,
especially if I'm feeling really wired. These things calm me down, give me deep sleep with
vivid dreams, and I wake up ready to roll. So if you want to check out Amantara today,
just head to www.amantara.com slash go slash Julian, link in my description below,
and use discount code JulianHarvest22 for 22% off your order. That's www.amantara.com
slash go slash Julian, link in my description below, code JulianHarvest22.
And so it's a pendulum, and Biden got crushed before that, right? So things oscillate back and
forth. That's the way of the world. That's right. But the question is, are you trying,
are you gaming things so that you're always on the side where the pendulum's going?
Are you doing it in good faith? That's a good question.
Are you doing it in a way that you could admit that you're wrong,
and that what you're saying could potentially have negative implications? Not that you should
censor yourself, but just get both sides of the equation. For example, for Michio Kaku,
he could have said, look, going as far as, say, capitalism and democracy could be destroyed,
right? That's pretty far-fetched. It's hard to say, well, here's the steel man on the opposite
side of that spectrum. You could say, here are these challenges. We know that these are really,
really bad, and that-
Capitalism, let's say, even if you want to say capitalism could be at risk,
here's what we do to prevent that. Here's how we could adjudicate that. Here's how we've seen
examples in history, and this is one of the problems with people that talk about AI doom,
which we have to talk about, is that they never give a, even Roman, and I push Roman really hard,
he's been on three times, and never give him, you know what this concept called P-doom,
the probability that super alien, not alien, artificial super intelligence will lead to
runaway, recursive self-improvement that ends up destroying,
destroying humanity.
Like Bostrom's worst idea that, you know, of like how bad, yeah, exactly, the paperclip problem.
And when that happens, it will be runaway, out of our control, and they're unpredictable. And I
said, fine, fine. Roman, I stipulate you're correct, because you're, he is an expert in
this field. He wrote, he wrote the first paper and book that coined the term AI safety. We take
it for granted. He was the one, Roman Ippolito.
No, he's an OG.
So, and his beard. I mean, I have beard envy. He's like Rasputin. You have Rasputin in your
freaking studio here.
Yeah, I have pubes. I got nothing. He's got a whole fucking, yeah, there's nothing.
You still got the hair on your head. And he's very charismatic, but he has only one direction
of his ratchet. I call it Roman's ratchet. In other words, you know, ratchet wrench. It only
goes one way, right? I said, Roman, is, what could you do to reduce your P-doom from 99.999%
certainty of, no, not a hundred percent, no good scientists are a hundred percent certain.
99.999, that, what could you do to reduce it? And he's like, I've seen nothing. And he'll say
the same thing to you. I'm sorry to preempt it. You know, you should watch, everyone watch it,
right? It's going to be a great episode, but he has, and in fact, I had a guy who was kind of
a little provocative in a Yosha Bach and Yosha said, it's, I don't talk about liking guests or
not. I enjoy him. Is he like, when you say like, I think of, you know, what I want them to babysit
my kids. And most people wouldn't want to babysit my kids. Okay. But, but, but Yosha, I don't know
that well, but, but he said to Roman the following thing, he took the two simulation podcast bro
topics that we always, you know, by law have to talk about in podcasts, AI and the simulation
hypothesis. And he melded them together. And he said, it's impossible to believe as Roman does
in P-doom being essentially a hundred percent with all intents and purposes, and also believe
in the simulation.
Hypothesis simulation hypothesis would predicate itself on the sustenance of this illusion that we
exist. And therefore the simulation, once it achieved recursive ASI wouldn't have, would have
eliminated us already. So we wouldn't even be here to have the discussion of whether or not we believe
in the simulation hypothesis. So Roman believes in two contradictory things. Okay. What did he do?
They're both scientists. He's presenting a scientific hypothesis. I said, Roman, if a
asteroid crashed into Silicon Valley, would that reduce your P-doom?
And he wouldn't say anything, but it has to, right? If the sun went into a supernova, right? There has to be something that reduces if a global pandemic took off because of AI, but would that reduce P-doom from AI itself? Not, not just the pandemic would be the immediate proximate cause, but would it result in eventual destruction? Is it, or would it reduce your P-doom? And he wouldn't say. So I want you to push him on that. I want, and he's going to love you. I mean, I push back. He loves me. I think, I don't know if he loves me.
Yeah, he's a nice guy.
Here's the point. When you're talking to scientists, have that heuristic in your head. Are they staying longer? Are they saying, I'm asking good questions? That's great. You're not a scientist, but you do have a responsibility to push back, even on me, especially on me. I mean, you shouldn't believe all the shit I'm saying, but, but push back. And that's why I like to do demonstrations. What are the empirical, verifiable, or falsifiable piece of evidence that someone with these astounding claims, whether it be Andrew Bustamante, who you connected me to a long time ago, thank you,
John Kiriakou, whatever.
John Kiriakou.
Those guys battle each other, right, too? What are the pieces that could prove them wrong? What sources of evidence? Where's the chain of custody? That's what I asked with these alien guys. I asked Tom DeLonge, you know, the Blink-182 frontman, who is really responsible in many ways for the current attitude of being open to disclosure, right? In 2017, New York Times.
Yeah, he was an OG for it, for sure.
He was on my show, and I asked him, well, you claim that Bigelow, Skinwalker, whatever, you collected pieces of alien, you know, craft, and that's very interesting.
And there are many scientists and people in and outside of the academy. I don't want you to think only NASA people can touch them, whatever. And I said, I just want to know one thing, Tom. Can you determine the chain of custody, what's called provenance, right? You want to go buy the Mona Lisa. You want to know that's actually the Mona Lisa. It's not some fake, right? What is the provenance? Who owned it before you? Who owned it before them? Back to the original source. And he said, I can't give that to you. We lost it. We lost the chain of custody. We didn't lose the object. We don't know exactly what happened.
We don't know exactly what happened to the spacecraft or biologic. I forget what it was five years ago. And that made me just have a lot of simultaneously doubt, but also respect. The doubt is why you should have the respect. When someone says, I don't know, that means you should doubt me.
Right, right.
Respect that.
No, I have actually talked about that a lot. I have a ton of respect for people who are willing to say that, because you are correct about one thing. We do, unfortunately, live in a world that incentivizes you to have a fucking answer and opinion for everything.
Exactly.
And that's not what it is. If there's something I look really closely at, I'll tell you it's my opinion. And I'll also tell you, you ain't got to fucking listen to me on it. You know what I mean?
Even your solo episodes, which are awesome.
Thank you.
And you're focusing on, like, and you make it very clear. You almost have a disclaimer. You know, like, this is what I'm, you're free to, it's a free country. You don't have to listen to podcasts even.
Right.
But believe or not, believe. And I gave the same advice, by the way, to this guy, Raj Shimani, who's got, he, okay, so Joe Rogan is great. He's the OG goat.
Steven Bartlett's going to take him.
He's going to take him over. That's my prediction. He's going to surpass, you know, just subscribers, popularity.
Are you saying that by, like, followers?
Followers, monetization of the podcast, you know, because he does.
He's definitely good at monetizing.
He does an incredible job.
I mean, Joe's been great at monetizing his stuff.
He has been, but he does it through, yeah, he does it through something.
I own a Honda. What am I doing wrong here, Brian?
Well, you know, you got to get into UFC commentary.
Totally.
Nothing. You're not doing anything wrong. In fact, you're having on a lot of the same people. I'm here. You've got on Brett. You know, you're doing great.
You look at people like Lex Friedman, you know, he's.
He's just dropped out a lot, you know, friends of Lex.
Well, he's going and doing science and stuff now.
Not really. I mean, he's doing tourism. He's going around. He's looking at stuff. And I love that. I have his phone number. I can text him now and tell him I love him.
But, you know, he did some things, and I think it really came back to bite him when he interviewed Zelensky.
And he didn't do, like, a corresponding, you know, pushback or push, you know, on people like Putin or things like that.
And it was one-dimensional. And people gave him so much shit. And he was getting death threats.
I mean, the poor guy. I love him. He's a simple guy in some ways.
He's not doing research. I mean, he's not a professor. He's not like what I do or what, you know, Roman does or something like that.
Yeah, I think that wasn't his lane.
No, it wasn't.
But the podcast is great.
I don't think that's what made his podcast good.
This whole thing is that he has a deep connection and people feel close to him.
So Lex had, you know, huge, huge, you know, he was in shit.
Yeah, he had a lot of world leaders and stuff.
Exactly.
And then you become friends with, you just can't do it.
Yeah, and then it's hard to, yeah, Ivanka Trump and then you get this.
So I agree with you. And I love my wish him success.
Joe does not innovate.
He does not experiment.
He is not doing, he has the same set that he's had for decades.
He has the same people as three people, you know, Jamie, and that's it in this room with him.
They're not doing multi, you know, a hundred counts.
camera. And I'm not saying you need to do that. I'm just saying, when you look at experimentation
in physics, in science, in bio, whatever, the more things you fail at, the better. Because
the more things you fail at, the more things you're trying. The more things you try, the more
opportunities you have to learn. If I just say, oh, this has 180 degrees in the triangle, and
we're not going to do any experiments, what if it's slightly wrong, right? You could push back.
What if we actually live in a slightly, slightly curve? Can you say with absolute precision
that the universe is 100% flat or 0% curve? No, you can't say that. So what are the limits on it?
And what would be the implications if you're wrong? Okay, so now we live in a closed universe,
like a sphere, or an open universe, like a Pringles. And those take you down the rabbit
holes. That's right. Because once you go there, you can say, well, will the universe collapse?
That's a consequence of positive curvature. Will it rip apart? That's a consequence of negative
curvature. Aren't those more interesting? I tell my students, flaws lead to laws.
Flaws lead to laws. Flaws lead to laws.
Is that a NASBAR? No, that's a motto of the New Jersey State Troopers.
Um, flaws lead to the laws that they're going to pull you over for doing a buck 20 in your,
in your accord. Uh, so when you see a crack, that was a low blow. Sorry. That was a low blow.
Uh, and it's a CRV by the way. When, um, when, when Einstein noticed that Newtonian gravity had
these flaws that had these, these, these, these, these problems, these gaps, it could not explain
certain phenomena. Then it led to general relativity. Those are new laws. Now it's
general relativity, the ultimate word in science. No, no, it's going to be wrong.
Someday too. The best minds are working on things like that. That's why she's working.
Yeah, exactly. Right. Um, and people like Eric and other, other people that are interested in
these topics, right? So that's, what's important. You, you want to find where you could be wrong
because that teaches you how to be a better scientist, not to be so confirmed in your
beliefs and unshakable and unwavering that everyone else is going to get it wrong if they
challenge you. So, so that's just my thing. So Michio had a bunch of other things. I wrote them
down, but, but the main things are, are usually really regarded hype.
And the problem is science doesn't need hype. I said this on Rogan. I was like science, you know,
for like when, when you have a movie come out, okay, there'll, there'll be something,
there'll be some promotion or something like that. A podcast, right? Do you advertise your
podcast? No, no, I've never done it. How does it spread? It's organic, organic, meaning word of
mouth. Okay. Right. Word of mouth is the, is the gold standard. You tell someone, read a book,
listen to a podcast, they're going to do it. And that's much better than if they see an
advertisement for it on YouTube or whatever, right?
Sure. But could you see how, and, and I actually mean this as a huge compliment, but like, look at
someone like, you know what, let me not even put a name on it. Let's say physicist A over here
talks about how the square root of X to the fifth minus S to the five equals the fact that, you know,
two particles fuck somewhere in the universe. And here we are, right? Like someone sees that
and they may be, they're probably cooking. Like they're probably like straight up Michelin chef
cooking.
You know what I'm saying? They're probably cooking up there. But like, you know, I see that and I'm
like, that sounds really smart. I have no idea what the fuck you just said. I'm going to watch
this video of orcas killing each other. Right. If Michio Kaku comes out though and says, we could
talk about how dimensionality could potentially lead to time travel. And let me give you an example
of that. Now you're like, oh wow, this cool, you know, really smart Asian guys tell me about time
travel. That shit's interesting. Let's get the bowl out and roll. You know? So like, I think
there's a place for the balance of time travel. I think there's a place for the balance of time
travel. I think there's a place for the balance of both. Now where your points well taken is like,
if there are places where you feel, whether it's Michio Kaku or someone else is stepping out of
their lane or going to something that they're speaking with a little more authority, even than
they should be speaking on it. Okay. That's fair. This is talking about capitalism. That's,
that's fair. That's fair. And I think some of that could, I would have definitely pushed back
on that. Why does it need to talk about capitalism? Because not sensational enough to talk about
quantum supremacy, quantum qubits cooling down to absolute zero. That's not, I don't know that
he's thinking about it that way. I don't, I don't think he's thinking about it. Like what, what's
going to be exactly. That was the hook. Exactly. I think it's, I think it's taken that way. By the
way, he does like 30 thumbnails, 30 different hooks. Um, he, he AB tests each thumbnail before
it goes out on Facebook to see who clicks on it first. You guys should try that. I have, you know,
here's my team pregames. It figures out, Oh, let's not waste YouTube's AB test, right? Let's do it
on Facebook where it's not going to count against the view.
Okay. So I think that's a good point. I think that's a good point. Let's do it ourselves, right? Yeah, I do it. We do it a little. Yeah, tell me, I want to learn
from you. You're an expert. Listen, listen, you're an expert. If I was curious about stuff,
I'm going to ask you and I'm going to learn from you. I'm going to be humble. I'm a, I'm a, you
know, full chair professor of physics at a top university, right? So like if I can learn from
you, but wait a second, I'm telling you something. Listen up, Julian, please. I'm giving you a
compliment. He's gassing me up right here. I want you to listen
because you are, you have a good quality, which is that you're very humble. To be a scientist,
I know you have an attitude and I love that, but you have a personality and people come to
you for taste. AI has no fucking taste. Nobody gives a shit. I can make an AI podcast two
seconds. No one's going to listen to it. That's right. I can write an AI book. No one's going
to read it. You have taste. You have a perspective. You have a point of view and you contextualize
beautifully. To be a scientist, you need to have humility. You need to be like, I could be so wrong
that I could lose the Nobel prize, be completely humiliated and maybe never have a job again. I
word is in Chabad. Okay. It's a Chet. Chet. Can you say Chet? Chet. Good. Perfect. No, no. I know
how to do this. Danny Jones is the- Let me do a snip snip, Joey. Come on. Danny Jones is killing
me right now. Come on, Schneerson. Let's do it. Let's do it. Jesus Christ. Go to the O'Hell down
the street. Okay. Listen up. He was definitely on there with Zhang. Like, yeah, this Chabad thing,
what's going on there? That's definitely what he did. Oh, here's a great thing. Zhang. Beautiful.
You guys were ripping on Zhang. No, no. Don't laugh. I didn't have him on. No, I know that.
No, Danny had him on, right? Chinese Billy Carson. That's what he called him. That's hilarious. Andre Carson. I have great ambivalence about him. He calls himself
professor. He teaches at high school. Professors, to me, like if somebody talks to their mom and
calls it a podcast, it's not going to bother you. Professional courage, it's like stolen valor.
When you say something, it's like, you know, I'm joking. Obviously, people serving the military
have more courage in their fingernail than my whole body. But when you do something,
and you claim that you're somebody that you're not, a professor, this guy, Scott Galloway,
Professor G, he calls himself. He's got a huge podcast, Empire, Kara Swisher. He hasn't taught
a class, as far as I know, maybe in 10 years. And I like what he, I listen, I subscribe to him,
and I think he's, I've invited him on my show. They call themselves professors. This guy,
Professor Dave. He's not a professor. Professor Dave explains on YouTube. When you say that, it's a form of credibility washing, laundering somebody else's credibility
for your own purposes. Professor Zhang. Let's get back to him.
He says crazy stuff. He talks about his, you know, his theories. He claims to have predicted
this and that. His channel name is Predictive History. Okay. We got Professor Zhang right here.
Where is that? Right here. Joey D. Yeah. Joey D. Professor J. Professor Zhang. Professor J. Oh,
yeah? Bust it out. Come on. Yeah, we got to hear your Professor Zhang on the spot. You got to do it
in the mic. There we go. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. So we have this thing here. Okay. And that's the
end of the world. So we're going to write that up here. Okay. Okay. Okay. End of the world. So,
you think about the Romans. Okay. Okay. And we have Romans up here. Okay. Oh, Joey, man. If you
ever leave Julian, come to San Diego, brother. So here's the thing. I think Joe's headed to
Hollywood. The straw man is Professor Zhang is a fraud. He's a credibility laundering,
entitled professor. He's a shill for the CCP. He has, you know, these outrageous takes in order
to get clicks and he grifts. Okay. That's the, that's the straw man. Okay. But I want to give
you him a steel man. Got to take a sip before this. Sorry. Yeah. The Irish coffee. Can you
Irish up the coffee a little bit more? He's the most intoxicating thing that ever came out of
Wuhan, China. No. It's the most dangerous thing. Zhang, I heard him on a podcast. Oh, it was with
Raj Shamani. So Raj Shamani is going to be to Stephen Bartlett, what Stephen Bartlett is going
to do to Joe Rogan. Okay. He is going to surpass. Who? Raj Shamani. Look him up.
Is this a real person?
Sounds, sounds like it's not right. Uh, check out his, uh, subscriber.
Oh, he's real. Look at that.
No, no. Go to YouTube and look up Zhang.
Okay. Raj Shamani clips. One point. Okay. All right. Yeah.
That's his clip.
That's his clip. Yeah. So I'm saying, so it's big John's gotta be.
There it is. He remember.
Yeah. All right. So let's hit it.
Click on that one. Become mentally.
20 million. Shout out Raj.
Yeah. And it was, uh, is it 20 for, uh, where does it say it?
I didn't know he moved like that. Yeah. Throw that man a subscribe. Let's see if we're number
20 is 19.9 20. I'll give you guys a signal. There you go. So who's this? So he's.
Yeah. I take it. He's in another country.
He's based in India, but he comes to him or he came to LA on Sunday. I'm good for him.
Three hours. Same thing. Iterating, experimenting, testing, thumbnails, testing title, all the stuff
that you guys are doing, but he's got access to a billion people in Asia. He's like the Joe Rogan.
So he's the Stephen Bartlett of Asia. Basically he does the exact same kinds of things. Ask the same
kind of questions. You know, Steven asked me at the end, like, you know, what would you tell to
a younger Brian Keating or whatever? He does the same. It's beautiful. And he's made millions and
millions of dollars. There's Scott Galloway, the other professor I was talking about. Um,
and Zhang was up. So Zhang at the end, he asked him, what is the cost to be Brian Keating?
He asked me, he asked me, he asked Zhang, what's the cost to be professor Zhang? And he said,
um, the cost is that, um, I have a horrible, miserable life.
My life is, is awful. Uh, it was ruined. I live in a communist country, a dictatorship.
I was so impressed by that. You know how dangerous it would be to say that, to say, you know?
So why can he say that and go back?
i don't know i don't know but i never heard him say it the reason is interesting why am i bringing
this up to show that i can revise my opinion if brett is saying something and he wants to come
back and talk to me about like what's the physical evidence that a drone was used what are the sonic
the the uh the um electroluminescence optics what are the different perspectives that would be
required and that's the that's a hypothesis and then the null hypothesis is he was shot by this
this crazy guy tyler robinson with a 30-06 which was found which has all these things and not go
down the candace owens you know rabbit hole um of conspiracy after conspiracy with no evidence
backing it right wouldn't you like someone i mean whether you love her or not wouldn't you like her
to just like sit down and debate she did do this guy the guy he paid her like 300 grand or something
whatever um that was good but he was you know he's not like the perfect i think you should do
it the way we did it with joseph scott morgan and baron coleman that's that is the and and
i had i literally had nothing to do with it i was just sitting in here watching
them cook but like that's that's the most perfect podcast i've ever been a part of experimental that
you were doing the best podcast i've ever been a part of you have a hypothesis something would
happen you have a method of how you're going to get them together you had techniques you had data
background research then you iterate that's a scientific method but one crucial step in there
the most crucial step is i could be fucking wrong and i am likely to be wrong not i'm not saying
you're stupid in any way i feel like i'm in the lab all the time i'm fucking wrong all the time
i wrote a book about being wrong let's be humble you have that you have that characteristic of
humility which is great because nature will fucking spank your ass right in public in the
most humiliating way possible karma is a real thing but you need a little bit of arrogance
i'm gonna fucking take you on mother nature i'm gonna understand the mind of god i'm gonna do it
but not when it comes to the purpose of i cannot be wrong you have to have those things in your
pocket at the same time that's right no i i i like it you gotta take it all right we'll be right back
by the way by the way if you start trying to say that julius irving can't call himself dr j we're
gonna have an issue okay that's not stolen valor right there he's the best doctor in the history
of philadelphia that's dr dunk yeah yes that's goddamn right that's right but what would you
pull up oh you pulled up the chabad is this oh did danny say it on my show did he say chabad
deep you got this yeah no are we about to kill i'm sorry danny i love you dog i love danny too but
i already kind of threw you under the bus a little bit
ago in my bed yes so brother let's get the proof people that are all tied to the chabad stuff there
it is see it was him not me i told you we'll see i'll have to check if you ever said and that face
right there all right danny have me back on i'll tell you how to pronounce the letter in hebrew okay
he probably won't have it but i know he won't you can try he had uh he had me on once and that was
pretty he's the one he he likes the one except bart sibro well bart came back to to do the debate
with charlie duke which was a fucking train wreck shout out to danny on that one sitting there for
that whole time but yeah i don't i i think i think he's done with that too yeah yeah well you know i
love tampa but i'm not sure i'm going back unless the devil worries when you know yeah yeah they
dropped the devil like 20 years ago but no they i saw it on their jersey is it back now back they
put it back i agree they dropped it and i was like politically correct no shit devils oh you
couldn't say devil is that why they did it so oh come on cleveland
i used to root for them now i root for the guardians well anyway guardians we just but
right before the bathroom break we went on like an insane hour and 12 minute tangent which i loved
and yeah because i was thinking like right at the beginning i was going to ask you a question and
we didn't get there so i thought i'd bring it back yeah but i brought this up by pulling out
the tesseract yeah from can they see that again on the camera d if i do that the tesseract from
interstellar yeah where again where you see like mcconaughey hitting on there like no go back you
know the whole bit
but you know yeah it's just the the top nolan wants his prop back he wants it back but this
this this movie obviously was advised by kip thorne it's like a past very very big show on
your show as well so you know him personally but like you know one of the things that got credit
for is some of the science and it actually was like kind of interesting i still have never
understood though because we got into like talking about the dimensions and didn't bring it back to
the actual tesseract is like scientifically how that like
what it what it meant in in interstellar can you explain that so the main device that kip thorne
created for both that movie and a movie called contact which is actually my favorite science
fiction movie of all time uh is called a wormhole so wormhole uh is essentially a device used only
in movies as far as we know so far that is theoretically possible but by all you know
practical intents and purposes seems essentially impossible but we can talk about how credible it
could be this is essentially if you took two imagine in this table here okay you drill two two
uh holes and those are black holes those are the result of collapsed stars no i'm saying you come
this way a little bit sorry you're good you're good you guys gotta get an overhead camera
experiment number 74 that's it get when keating comes on have an overhead camera sorry but back
to what you're saying yeah so you have two black holes here's a black hole uh and another one and
these are stars of incredible mass that eventually get get close they
get um so massive that their gravity collapses upon themselves right and the curvature of space
goes from being flat to extremely extremely positively curved so there's so much mass in
one concentration that light beams diverge converge remember i said the hallmark of a
positive curvature is that parallel lines will convert they converge to the singularity right
point at the very center where the curvature actually goes to infinity so it's not just
positive it's in positive infinity there's a theory that it could be possible for a
wormhole once it goes to basically this this point of singular density and and gravitational
pull that actually if two of them were in a certain proximate relationship to one another
that you could essentially enter into one and come out the other one and this would be called
a wormhole a wormhole is basically two black holes that are established and the space between them
you could propagate at basically at the speed of light so no time would pass for you remember in
the movie he starts off as a young man then he goes and sees his daughter she's like
elderly woman right because so much time has passed on the star near a black hole and it's
not that the star has this gravity it's the proximity to the black hole gravity slows down
time speed slows down time so those are two two consequences of einstein's theory of general
relativity and special relativity respectively the wormholes could then be used instead of going
across this dimension to get from point a to point b to travel you know say a mega parsec a million
light years or something like that in this direction it would actually be used to travel
you basically be shortening the distance making a shortcut through space time and you'd come in
one side and come out the other side this also has relevance then called teleportation or uh
let's it's called epr the einstein podolsky rosen um in that there there could be a connectivity
between the properties of say objects on one side of the wormhole and properties on the other side
of the wormhole but going in one side effectively to simplify it means that you'd come out the other
side now what would you have to do to make the wormhole work?
that happen well one thing you need is a black hole at on earth somewhere near near earth they
have it in near jupiter or something i think in the movie um and in contact the movie contact
with jodie foster they make the spinning spaceship on earth in florida and this crazy religious guy
blows it up and then they go to japan they built the second copy so they build one entrance to the
wormhole in one place then you need the exit wormhole the black hole to be in another part
of the universe that you want to go to so you almost need to know where you're going to go
or assume it's a black hole and then you need to know where you're going to go and then you need
it's going to be random that the scientific inaccuracy in the movies in both those movies
is that somehow they placed exactly where you want to enter the subway station and exactly where you
want to get out they happen to have stops the stops are black holes they're connected and the
physics that connects them that's accurate but the pre-establishment implies a causality chain
that's hard to verify how would you know to put this other black hole the exit of the wormhole
exactly where you want it near cooper's planet and interstellar right
that's exactly where you want it near cooper's planet and interstellar right
that is a a device that they use uh purely cinematographically there's nothing in that
that has to do with teleportation or anything like that they use it to establish this library
and then he's moving the books and that has nothing to do with any i mean there's there's
no physics behind that it's a beautiful maybe device and what is that book about actually the
book is about longing or the movie sorry it was it was not from a book but it's a movie it's about
longing to
to um to go back in time it's it's really a movie about time travel in reverse the poignancy of it
when he gets there and he realizes his daughter you know that he loved more than anything she's
gone maybe he saved the earth and whatnot but they're never he's never going to have that now
you don't have kids um i have a teenager now who's like learning how to drive and i've got young kids
when i look at my teenager i like you know when he's he's taller than me now i look at him i'm
like you know he's like how is it how's it going to work i'm like i'm like i'm like i'm like i'm
you know whatever and i'm like well i used to change your diapers you know so you can't be too
as long as he's not spitting on his head and saying it's raining that's right i thought i'm
not joking he's not not quite that tall yeah but that's the craziest thing will chamberlain ever did
but imagine so like looking you know imagine you woke up like when you had 25 subscriber you know
before we restart you had 25 listeners in 2020 or something like that right you look you got
1.2 million plus 3 million 4 million across all your channels right you'd be like wow
did i appreciate that did i was i living in the moment when that was happening we're all fixated
on the climb and getting to the
top i asked this of of steven bartlett i was like when you get to whatever number you have at that
time it was 20 million subscribers like what are you going to do the next day you're going to quit
and he said no i'm going to keep doing what i'm doing now because it's not the destination it's
humans can't you said something before equilibrium remember you're talking about equilibrium so
here's an example of equilibrium i won't draw on your desk right here's a pen and it's standing
it's a felt tip pen i use it to grade my students papers right if i try to balance it and i had
perfect control or i built a machine to move the table i get you know uh elon musk spacex
they build us a tip could this be balanced on its tip perfectly yeah you probably could do it right
but it's very unstable it's very out of equilibrium because one little butterfly
flapping its wings in t-neck will cause us to fall over right the instability is a statement
about the lack of equilibrium human beings cannot perceive when they're in equilibrium
and
in fact if you go to equilibrium now with this room you'd be dead like if your body temperature
drops from 98.6 to this room temperature would i love the temperature in here you know spending so
much time in antarctica i love it cold you'd be dead your body would come to thermal equilibrium
you'd be at 68 degrees and you die before you get there right yeah so equilibrium is dangerous for
the human being if you got like satisfied we don't like that we want to we perceive change
entropy increasing that's what we strive for so the same thing you don't want things in
equilibrium but you can't perceive when things are in equilibrium so when i look back at my kids
and i'm like wow i kind of wish i had been more in the moment like when you were at you know one
hour last time i was here you had a million and it was like the day before and i was like i said the
same thing to you are you so you're done now right you graduated right julian i knew what you would
say no away right you're going to keep going that movie is about that longing and that the
melancholic feeling of being older and my feeling in life is you should try to maximize the number of
opportunities to feel melancholy regret and depression that sounds weird why i don't get
fucking depressed no no because when you're depressed that means something meaningful has
passed it doesn't mean nothing in the future will be meaningful in the future i bet people said in
high school it's the best time of your life right julian high school is going to be the best time
of your life is it was high school the best time of your life high school was a good time was it
the best time in your life they always say college is the best time of your life did you have fun
there yes okay what if they said that what about now now it's pretty good you're doing can i say
doing with yeah yeah yeah so you guys are doing a fucking feature-length movie you're recording
you're gonna be doing multi that's gonna be pretty awesome it's gonna be draining it's gonna be it's
gonna be awesome right i always want to say like if i'm ever at a point i say that was the best
time in my life like maybe that's my life is not that great even the failures even the loss those
things make it painful you should do things that would devastate you oh yes you need you need to
you need to experience really difficult things in life you need to experience
sad things you need to experience tragedy in some ways and it sounds awful to say that but like you
can't know what happiness is and what a great feeling is and and like you can't appreciate
love without having completely had your heart broken that's right i truly truly believe that
100 yeah and so you're doing meaningful stuff with young people older people um and this movie
is trying to communicate to mostly young people who don't have kids what that feeling would be
like and the only way to do it is that time
dimensions space and time right there's up down there's left right there's backwards and forwards
in space there's only forwards in time why is that why is there only one way that we all move
through time at but we call space time the same thing you've heard the fabric of space time the
ripples in space time the the the wormholes in space time but that's a fallacy it's a lie we
physicists are lying because we're basically telling the public something that they know not
to be true i have like gray hair and i have like a lot of hair and i have a lot of hair and i have
gray hairs right i how am i traveling for like could i go back in time and make the gray go away
i don't know i use just for men you know and that's fine but yeah yeah you know not too bad
uh i've got the uh you know the the mind of a 55 year old and a 45 year old's mind that's right
um i wish but the point is that movie is not about the physics and the math they're not about
it's a device to illustrate things that are essentially invisible and comprehensible
but indisputably real and part of physics would you say that
a lot of the physics that's represented in in it even some of the theoretical stuff that we
haven't fully proven yet is represented in what you would characterize as a decent scientific way
no i made a joke on twitter and people you know piled on me i said i believe that project hail
mary is more scientifically accurate than interstellar god damn it and i said that
kind of tongue-in-cheek but but again the wormhole requires this this tool it sounds plausible
like i just said you drill a hole in the table you actually pop out in the other side of the
universe instantaneously so you've like shortcut an infinite what would take an infinite time
linearly you've shortcut it through this parallel dimensionality of space-time which is not
accessible now imagine what it would take to do that you actually need something which is known
not to exist called negative energy you've heard about all sorts of you know interesting forms of
energy zero point energy and stuff like dark dark energy dark energy but you didn't actually type
of negative energy why because i told you that gravity is going to produce the black hole when
you have enough mass right it's it actually turns the space-time into having the singularity
now that's a consequence of einstein's theory of general relativity the other type of singularity
happens at the big bang we can talk about that separately so you need a singular so you need
massive amounts of density now you've pinched space down space-time down into this cone this
point this cusp of infinite positive curvature right now how do you get rid of that curvature
how do you actually then have another side of the wormhole and get a person through something
that has zero dimensionality okay so you can't do that can't do that normally you need if you
insert in something that has anti-gravity so ordinary matter has positive gravity
anti not anti-matter but anti-gravity would be required that something has negative energy
density this is the surprising thing we have no idea how to make that we don't have any idea how
much energy but there's some estimates and you may have heard of these alcubierre
warp drives and and how the aliens are getting from point a to point b interdimensionally like
grush has talked about and i do want to talk about grush we'll come to it but but um but not him alone
and so you need infinite near infinite amount correspondingly of negative energy all along the
root of the wormhole that would keep it inflated it would have to be of a diameter that a human
being could fit through right because if you want to traverse it you would have to be be able to
come out the other side and actually ed witton
uh you know who's the allegedly the smartest man on earth or whatever he's pretty good one of the
one of the pioneers of strength theory at down here in new jersey at the institute for advanced
study he um he has worked on on these problems one mel the sana who i've had on a few times
another just ultra genius they have uh done basically calculations on how could you make
human traversable wormholes not for interstellar some interstellar to um the the search for cooper
but uh but actually to see if it's even
possible in principle and there's essentially no way to do it it doesn't mean it's not a beautiful
literary device i mean look at like uh the time machine hd wells or look at um you know any of the
classic books in literature that book i told you flatland flatland influenced me more than any other
science book okay um not because of the racism or the sexism or or the you know uh classism but uh
because it it taught me to visualize the third dimension it's actually not hard to you know
visualize the third dimension and use those as a stepping stool ladder to get to the possibility
of never visual it would never be no i don't care kaku weinstein edwitt and no one's can visualize it
because evolutionarily we're not designed to operate we don't see four-dimensional tigers
jumping out of a wormhole to eat us right right we've evolved our brain and our sensory organs
have and our culture has evolved so that we pay attention to what matters to us which is
what happens in three-dimensional space so we can't functionally visualize it no
people say that they can they make devices like tesseracts but again that is a three-dimension
right you bought it's real it has a usb charger on it right it's actually four dimensions no it's
not four dimensions it exists in three dimensions you're not seeing four you're just seeing an
infinite number of mirrors and copies i'm seeing four okay all right what's in your coffee um okay
so so when we don't laugh at him deep so you have these structures and we make models of reality and
that's what scientists do but again you'd have to ask the question how could i be wrong about that
how could now in a movie i'm not going to ask how could it be wrong with joey deep's new movie
that's not the purpose of the purpose of it it's flawless huh that's flawless um so yeah so
hopefully we'll be in cons and you'll invite me there and uh you know what when we get in there
i'll i'll think i'll look at the invite list and we'll see if you make the cut yeah top 1000 guests
um yeah he's like no yeah cut him off so yeah so that so there are things that we use we simplify
to to complicate that's what you have to do as a scientist simplify break it down two-dimensional
world to visualize what a three-dimension and four-dimensional world will be like make a model
of this of this thing make a projection of something make a hologram those are beautiful
things yeah the brilliant people can think about those things before the analogies exist and that's
what's so that's what's so intoxicating about people like kaku and witten and weinstein yeah
have you ever heard the alternate theory of interstellar no i don't know so obviously
chris nolan brilliant filmmaker he puts all kinds of devices in in in his
films and how he shoots things and you know easter eggs if you will there is a repetition
he does though one of the very first scenes if not the first scene it's been a while since i
watched it but it shows you know the crash in space with the craft that same exact camera shot
the same exact one it's not different is used like an hour later or something in the film
when mcconaughey and the team are actually going on this mission to like save earth
so when you look at this theory and then look at the devices he uses in the script for the rest of
it and how mcconaughey is experiencing his new reality with time being distorted and looking
down on earth that you know his his family and and all the time passing by
there's actually a theory that nolan was telling you that he died
in that crash and so when dr man is like you know one of the things that happens when you cross over
is
you
We have to think about your kids it's like oh wait a minute is he speaking to him as if he's
like the man at the gate saying hey take a look down on the things you love because it's about
to change from here and did they then square that whole plot point by using physics as the cover for
it right it's a vehicle yeah so it agrees with what i was saying that and i hadn't heard that
before it seems plausible but it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging yeah but it's doing
something difficult it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging but it's doing something
difficult it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging but it's doing something difficult it's
doing something difficult it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging but it's doing something difficult
it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging but it's doing something difficult it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging
but it's doing something difficult it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging communicating to like the three of you
it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging but it's doing something difficult it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging guys who don't have kids yet
but it's doing something difficult it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging you're gonna feel that longing you're gonna
but it's doing something difficult it's a movie about longing and poignancy of aging feel something that you've never felt before
it's gonna be like you are you have your heart
your your insides are on your outside
anything could hurt you
destroy you it has nothing to do with you no decision that you make and you're
programming your little kids not in an evil way to give them their survival
skills so they can make that interstellar voyage but you have to do
that and then guess what they leave and they'll never pay you back
they'll never give you back what you did you'll never give your parents back
what they did for you but the the way you pay your parents
back is you get your kids exactly 100 i wish that on you i wish you have that
pain the the pain of just like uncertainty and not knowing this part of
your body is outside of your control it's officially the holiday season and
abercrombie's new collection has outfits for everything on your calendar it's the
busiest time of year and between shopping and party invites i don't have
time to plan every look but abercrombie's always got me
covered their sweaters are the perfect easy layer for low-key plans and on a
nice night out i'm reaching for their classic trousers fill your closet with
the pieces you'll need all season long have a very abercrombie holiday shop in
the app online and in stores when you shop kroger delivery you can
expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door
our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed
to getting every detail right carefully
selecting and packing your order with care because bringing you fresh quality
groceries is what we do best and right now enjoy twenty dollars off your first
online order of seventy five dollars or more restrictions apply see site for
details kroger fresh for everyone
did your
i don't want to say like scientific world view
but did your general
maybe spirituality change when you had your
kids
not at first
because when they come into the world
they it's it's like
would you ever invite here's uh i have a friend he's coming into town julian um
he's uh 20 you know two feet tall
uh he shits everywhere he doesn't speak english
you're gonna have to be up seven times a night plus during the day you're gonna
spend thousands of dollars on this person he's gonna be here and he won't
even be able to visually have the acuity to have focus of his eyeballs on you
for the first six months he's living in this beautiful house
take him in if he's my kid yeah no well of course
you're gonna die but i'm just saying no rational person it's like if you looked
at a person walking a dog you told me to get a dog i'm thinking of getting a dog
right get a dog get a dog i i grew up with dogs my wife just like you know you
have kids you have dogs who knows um but the purpose the the if you were to
look as a rational alien and you look down on the earth
and you see there's brian and he's walking behind this creature the creature
has four legs brian only has two legs okay and this guy and brian's following
around and and this thing is like eating
whenever he wants to eat going wherever he wants to go and brian's following
everything and then the thing takes a and then brian picks up the as
if it's like gold and collect you'd be like this this dog is an advanced
creature and brian's like like no rational person so what is the
lesson you do things irrationally because they give you rational benefits
that you can't seek tangibly for many years later so no i didn't at
first no because it's about survival like literally the first night my first
child was born i turned to my wife and i was like honey
where's the instruction manual like i mean you have an instruction manual for
your iphone like nobody knows nobody reads it
but for the most complicated thing in the known universe
a human there's nothing and i don't care who's the fucking expert
they're not an expert in your kid that kid has never existed before
ever the combination of chromosomes the the exact sperm that was you the exact
those things could have been different and so so such chance and it makes you feel yes
it's so precious now once they're for a man by the way i'm only speaking because
i'm a man and for the first six months of my life with my kids rather it was to
just make sure they survive and i don't kill them but mostly it was giving them
to my wife trying to you know help her give milk and keep her comfortable and
so she wasn't mad at me with postpartum depression whatever that's the man's job
okay women have it a little bit harder reminds me of a story a friend of mine
had had girls recently um had a had a daughter
and but he was like she his wife is in labor for 48 hours and the guy and he
just couldn't take it and i'm like i felt bad he couldn't what should i do what should i do yeah
so he goes what should i do what should i do and he goes i'm just like go for a walk go for a walk
48 hours it's probably not coming now go for he went for a walk got something to eat and then they
called him on the phone and he's like keating you're wrong like they want me back and
she's about to give birth she's about to give birth he runs sprints back to the delivery room
runs up into the into the liver she's there with the baby and he can't you can't tell what the
baby's a alien when it comes covered in blood and like other stuff that comes out you don't
want to look too closely right um and there's a bunch of nurses you know doctors he's like what
do we have what do we have and he goes you had a girl oh he's like thank god a beautiful baby girl
thank god oh god this is what and the doctor's like you know it's beautiful that you're so
supportive of having a girl but you know a lot of dads they kind of want to have like a little
boy you know i'm just curious like why didn't you want to have a boy and he said are you
kidding me if he had a boy someday he might have to go through what i went through oh wow
yeah 48 hours of labor not easy so uh you'll never really appreciate what a woman goes through
to have that and that's why you should call your mother yeah i don't know i'm not uh i try to do
that i'm gonna call her in about an hour and a half but but but in reality i think um you know
for uh for for changing me spiritually it's it's more that i found purpose that was outside myself
like for example when you're you you're
trying to be the man i mean you're trying to like accumulate resources um get get a career that's
stable that's on track nobody gave you what you had right you earned every thing you're
self-made right nobody gave you like rogan didn't come out like i see like lex and like rogan like
made like super popular my parents my parents let me have a studio in their house for three years so
i i kind of think the podcast is like half there's a lot of people don't get that that's beautiful
and that means that you are uh you have integrity and someday you'll give them back a little bit of
what they gave you you'll never be able to pay them back right but you did it you're self-made
in this sense um when you have this purpose right now it's accumulate resources it's it's get
attention because attention can be used for good things right it's for bad things but you're using
it for good it's to it's to build media you have own media empire right it's it's not as big as
roger steven yet but let's say yet when you're a parent it's not about you anymore man like one of
my friends told me he's not about you anymore man like one of my friends told me he's not about me
i had a my rabbi actually the rabbi was closest to married me and my wife uh ceremony i've known
him for 25 years um he presided my father's funeral okay which is very emotional um he
knew my father briefly but you know my father's been dead for 20 years now but i i think about
him all the time and you will you're going to want to call you i want to call my dad and say
i'm at carnegie hall tonight he's dead you know you can't do it you can't pay them back
but and i said like to one of my friends like i'm really depressed you know like my rabbi is moving
back to israel you know he was like a brother or uncle to me he's like don't you get it it's
not about you anymore it's about your kids like they need support they need around they need to
have an advisor they need you they need at a certain point i had to realize that that's what
means to grow up like once you have that that phase change and it's not about you but right
now it is about you so that the car the corollary to that mathematically is make as much hay
as you can right now because you will have those kids you will have that mortgage you will have
that you know choose between what public school private school whatever you're going to go to
carpool soccer games all i don't have much time you know i the one good thing about being a
podcaster nowadays that every single book i listen to and i listen to every single person's book i
don't know if that's true with rogan every single what every book of every author that comes up i've
had 500 guests on the podcast you listen to all of them every single book yeah see you're smiling
so you know that it's true that most podcasters don't i know stephen didn't they had their team
read it raj didn't do it i like coming in blind i actually read all the books that i've read and i
read way more after the fact yeah i like doing blind podcasts i've heard that i've heard like
steve um what's his name chris chris williamson said like well my job's not to be
like short form or blink you know one of these book summary too but but to me it's like i've
distilled 20 years of my life into this 300 page document you can download all this information
i would say like if you could read your great great great great grandfather's you know life
story about what he went through whatever he was doing you would pay a lot of money for that book
i told this to rogan too he's like i don't care people can listen to my pocket no one's gonna
listen to your fucking podcast like like no one's gonna go back to episode you know whatever i am
326 with brian keating you know 30 years from now right but if you have a book and you just
say well that one day you know when i met with michio kaku you know whatever when i had that
experience this is what it conveyed to me and blah blah they will read that in a book even
though books are you know much less popular than they were because of ai and and videos now there
is um there is an ability to have that you're making that meaningful contribution that can be
randomly accessed i want to read every author's book now i can't read physically because it just
takes too much time but i can listen you know i talk pretty fast you probably noticed that by the
third time i've been on um i can listen at two or three x and i can i'm pretty smart i mean i can i
can i can retain a lot of what i would hope so yeah yeah but i'm saying when i read a book about
consciousness robots or ai i'm not an ai expert right but i'm reading roman's book because i want
to have mon because i wanted to still a question that no one's ever fucking asked him and i can
only do that if i engage with this thing that he spent five years of his life writing and i hope
that you will too i mean his that book's really really technical and dense it's a math book really
but that's just an example yeah um so i want to do that that's part of that's the only brand that's
the only thing i do i think differently than any other podcast i will not have like richard dawkins
he's got 40 books like i can't read them all listen read as much as i can right and then i can
be the best possible host i can be what are you doing with richard tonight at carnegie hall so
richard's on his second swan song i don't know how that happens when you have like you know swan
song is usually like the end of your career you gotta go how old is he 85 yeah so he's like the
world's most prominent atheist yes and he hasn't come off that opinion no not at all he's still
thinks it's more from nothing well you'd be amazed when so i host him uh once before uh in in person
in vancouver canada in 2024 like two years ago he had written a book called the genetic book of the
dead like the tibetan book of the dead like the doors you should listen to it um and so he had
written uh and many other books like the genetic book of the dead like the tibetan book of the dead
his most famous book is the book that turned 50 this year called uh the selfish gene in that book
he coined the term meme okay so you know he invented the term meme that's true richard
dawkins invented the term meme that's kind of savage fact check yeah we're fact checking in
real time in this book wow so i'm right okay and uh well this is just a fact deep's like we'll see
yeah exactly british evolutionary biologist richard dawkins
coined the term coined the term meme in his 1976 book the selfish gene you are right brian kidding
okay good for you so what is a meme he meant it to be first of all it has a double entendre as a
french would say it's a double meaning mem is like a memory a memetic desire you've heard of that
renee gerard peter teal's you know favorite philosopher um this is something that memetic
desire means i want what you want it doesn't mean i want what you have i want what you want you've
convinced me that it's actually really good maybe i should want to have like a
film like if i if i had a producer and i had a a coordinator and i had maybe i want because julian
wants it and he i i want what he wants not that i want what he has like i'm not gonna steal joey
joey did you get the rolex i sent you uh you got the meteorite right amanda uh so i want what they
want we still have one right here oh nice i keep it on it's better than rogan he smoked his he
smoked his meteorite yeah i got a pipe and he just threw this in the pipe if you did yeah you'll
he'd probably be in the hospital
so uh richard coined this term because it's something that replicates like a gene in the
cultural space so it's a call why do ideas like god why are they ubiquitous throughout not just
civilization today but throughout civilizational history god is a meme it's an idea it's something
that people i want to have a religious figure guru like jesus because the christians have a
religious figure like like christ so islam is based you know has respect for christianity
christianity jesus was jewish he came out of the jewish tradition of prophets of messiahs
of kings and priests right so so uh and and that's and then you know jews were influenced as well
right so we want what other people want and then those ideas that are fertile that are that are
efficient that are um survival of the fittest memes propagate and that this has gone on and
everybody knows the distracted boyfriend you know looking at the girl's ass right um everybody knows
that that's due to richard right this is something of cultural longevity so we're celebrating the
50th anniversary of the book the concept of the meme uh the uh the evolutionarily driven uh
desires not of he claims the gene is selfish and that it wants to continue its propagate it's not
that you want to continue its propagate you are somehow robotically entrained by the genes for
their purposes of procreation but the only you are the vehicle by which you will procreate
the genes just like if one person dies the bad boyfriend meme doesn't go away right it gets it
gets so distributed in your your priority in life is to pass on your genes not and the genes are
like they can vary right like i have different kids they're not the same i have twins the twins
couldn't be more different one's a boy one's a girl right so they couldn't be more different
in some sense but they're very similar in other senses but even at that level you can't predict
the individual will replicate ideas communism capitalism we talked about right
those are ideas those are memes they propagate and they some flourish because they're survival
of the fittest right they are naturally selected against evolutionary prejudice this is an area
where you should talk to uh brett weinstein about he is an expert in evolutionary and thinking in
these evolutionary terms um but you know if i asked richard dawkins tonight um well who do you
really think did 9-11 you know like what happened to wtc7 he he's not gonna say he's not gonna say
well you know it's it's probably you know um not adelson but uh
silverstein uh took out an insurance policy i know again i do think it's different when you're
looking at publicly available evidence versus looking at things that require actual academic
training to be able to substantiate your claims via mathematics science etc so really so if i said
to if i said to brett so he's an expert in telomeres right so the telomeres are so-called
they were so-called junk dna interestingly enough um i believe although i would defer to brett
that for a long time these are thought to be useless types of dna and there's a branch of
religious fundamentalism in some sense called intelligent design which believes that we're
designed by god not only at the level of our genes and and sort of the dna code replicators as they
are but actually the universe was designed finely tuned with zero curvature all the things we talked
about those can only be explained by the fact that a mind is behind the information structure
everywhere you look in the universe from the computer code to printing to type the rosetta
stone you find a hieroglyphic you go into a cave on mars and there's writing in there would you
think oh the wind just blew this cave and made this so these are what people like stephen c meyer
john lennox uh very very um interesting you know i'm i have my problems with them and i push back
on them as well they believe that um there was a purpose to the to this telomere that these junk
dna and these extended things within the within the our chromosomal content and they claim that
they predicted that there'd be existence of stuff that would seem to be useless but would actually
serve a purpose and now biologists agree so they actually made a prediction
and they made a prediction about the fact that there would be existence of stuff that would seem to be
useless but would actually serve a purpose and now biologists agree so they actually made a prediction
and it wasn't wrong in fact it was it was verified that there's some validity to it
and i contrast that between string theory which has made lots of you know kind of hype and
attention but makes no predictive claims you know jang like claims that could be falsified right
there's nothing we can do to disprove string theory right now as far as we know and there
probably never will be because these 10 dimensions are wrapped up in dimensional scales that no human
being can ever access but if we figure out those dimensions well the figuring out how to figure out
the dimensions it's not just like oh can i visualize can i get a 10 dimensional tesseract
these are things that are in principle below the plank length below observational scales such that
if you tried to visualize them you create black holes there would be so much energy injected in
them okay but that's not my point my point is that if brett believes that and let's say he doesn't
believe in the intelligence i can just say well you know well you know what what do i what do you
know i have publicly available information brian keating the cosmologist has publicly available
information i can just say i believe that world trade 7 was it was it was an inside job or a
conspiracy in other words i'm a cosmologist do i yes i have a right to question brett and say you're
totally full of about telomeres but who are you going to listen to more i could say if brett
says well i could actually have been wrong about telomeres you know he he made some he would say
that about telomeres i don't know that he said that about wt7 or 9 11 in general and what happened to
the other planes and oh they weren't designed um you know they were hit by this plane right um but
um and uh but no 737 could this 737 was going 555 miles an hour the the previous impact in by a
plane in new york city was at was actually it was a plane that survived it was a small little
propeller plane 1933 yeah it was at the empire state building right the structure of it but you
know who did analyze it who nist national institutes of standards and technology i think it's oh they're
like nasa it's a shill yeah every day you drive in the car okay there's a lot of problems with
everything and by the way i'm with you i do believe those were planes yeah to be clear
like like i've i've never seen people i've never seen a good argument that they weren't planes
that went in there but you know i think it's a lot of the other things around what happened that
day and the way the buildings fall the speed at which they fall and like i i'll also say this as
well this was a really tough topic for me of course because you could see it from here well
i didn't live up here i lived in south jersey no i'm just saying where you are now right i'm from
this part of the world we knew flying on september 11th you were you were in a plane flying on
september 11th yeah my plane was canceled turned around went back well i you know we knew people
that that died in those towers and living up here i know a lot of people i i friends whose fathers
died i know people that worked at lutnick's firm right survived yeah i just had two of them in here
because they were jewish from chabon joking don't do that don't do that i know you'll clip it yeah
you know when when you look at it it was it's the first day of my life i can remember every single
thing that happened yeah i can remember some things before that but i was really young i was
eight years old and i can remember
you
every second of that day so it was always a personal day to me in that way a very you know
kind of hallowed day and i will admit for a very long time you can even run the tape on my podcast
in the early years it was really hard for me to open my mind to some of the irregularities here
and things that went on and i've had to slowly do that over time why because i've seen tremendous
evidence that there are enormous problems with the narratives there were
enormous things that were that were covered up across the board across multiple countries my
own government saudi arabia israeli implications all these things i don't know what the full truth
is but i do know that there are issues with that story and i think when you are able to look at the
evidence and then distill that and ask questions about that which is what i believe brett does
i think that that should be perfectly fair and if i want people doing it you know no offense i would
prefer if i had my druthers that like an evolutionary biologist with an extremely high
iq like brett were leading the way rather than like me a youtuber you know what i mean like i i agree
however i will say would you rather have a structural engineer with a phd in physics
mechanical science material science looking through the evidence and also looking at the
psychological profile sarah adams have her own what are the profiles of these people what do we
know about them you know that the hijackers all trained at the flight school where i not all i'm
sorry two of the of the flight uh training took place at the flight school uh the airport that i
currently fly my plane out of okay they were known they they had they had they were in america they
were so they were supposedly in a 20th hijack i mean again i want to say i agree with that but
okay i do agree i agree so you have to life is about uh i agree making making judge trade-offs
right there are no solutions as sol said there's only traps right yes so the trade-off is like
uh do i have you um versus brett okay i knowing nothing else i would say yes an evolutionary
biologist with some training and then i'd say a nist engineer with with uh experience with flight
you know characteristics with video evidence capability forensics then that's higher than
that person potentially right and if you want to say well it's a cover-up so it goes this deep
okay who's paying them what's that who's paying who's paying this who but by the way this is
that's not a simple way of asking it
what conflicts of interest could exist beyond the scope of what we can see in the public sphere
with a place like that was something this monumental we are talking about the most
monument in my opinion when you look at the reverberating effects the most monumental
event of the 21st century okay to this point do you do you think that there could have been some
reason your mother had you other than just oh she just wanted to have children she just loves you
and you think there's a possibility that there's some other reason now that you're wealthy successful
like are there things that you get very small right you would say very small it's it's not likely
99.99 you know p doom is zero right but but your mom is so there's always what's called residual
of anomalies there's always going to be things that science cannot explain sure a good scientist
will say that up front when my students tell me um that force equals mass times acceleration or
whatever and they say this is how much force is how much mass is how much acceleration i say great
tell me how you know how wrong you are and i'll say like no i thought the answer is the point
to get there right now the answer is not the point in fact it's almost irrelevant to me how
do you know how wrong you are if i say julian you're less than 200 kilograms that's right but
it's meaningless who gives a crap anybody could do that if i say you weigh exactly you know the
protein powder outside you know you're exactly 100 kilos you know you're with an uncertainty of
one milligram you know one thousandth of a gram that's much more impressive and it's much more
hard to be right right yeah so asking questions great brett go at it um but
you propose hypotheses and in a way and you say things like it's impossible for steel to collapse
or it's in free falls chris martinson's like who are the experts that he's going to he as a scientist
should say i have experts the only expert i've heard him reference because he's been on the show
is this guy chris martinson who has a podcast and i used to subscribe to his stuff and and he's also
one of these charlie kirk was you know assassinated and there's some israel connection all these other
things he's tucker carlson you know he's been on tucker carlson uh he published a paper in nature
toxicology in the 1990s or 80s or whatever is he a scientist still is he a scientist like at what
level is brett still a working scientist i don't think even brett would say that is he's thinking
scientifically yes of course you can think scientifically that's your whole point you
have but he's applying a lifetime of scientific work to be able to do in biology the tools of
biology are not the tools of string theory is he a scientist so shouldn't he be able to do string
theory in that same i feel like i feel like you know we're talking about sex and you're like well
it doesn't count if there's a condom on you know what i mean like there's something i i don't want
to make a baby like like like my grandfather was a doctor he retired from being a doctor
when i have a problem i still go to my grandfather did he stop being a doctor
no no is he is what i say now especially because he's way older now and it's been a while like now
he's in his 90s circumcision now he's gonna do later yeah well he's not gonna do that but like
now he's in his 90s it's like is he quite as meant to forget being a doctor is he quite as mentally
fast as you want to be a doctor and he's not going to be a doctor and he's not going to be a doctor
when he was 82 of course not quite right but like from the time i guess he retired when he was 70
so from the time he was 70 to 85 i mean he's out of his mind he still bikes like fucking 10 miles
a day like he's literally out of his mind speaks from the time he was 70 to 85 yeah like he like
he he's the ultimate go-to and was but if you had a problem i don't what was the specialty
he was a dick doctor he was a urologist okay so if you had a problem god forbid with your
pulmonary artery or something like that he and you said grandpa yeah what should i do
he would probably say i know this great specialist he's my friend we play golf we do this yes he would
go to a spot brett i want to know who is brett going to is he going you're making this up like
that's fair that's fair but but and by the way does does does brett have an incentive you ask
well who's backing them who is a nist working for right they're they're working for the taxpayers
and by the way you use every single day everything in this room everything you buy drive on using the
and on a daily basis is traceable it's safety in some way or it's legitimacy like when you
buy a cup of coffee how do you know they're not putting their thumb the donut guy that we saw
before how do you know that he's not putting his thumb on it oh you actually got a cup but you
didn't i'm making a little bit of penny here penny there well they serve millions of people a day
right how do you know that nist thank nist that you're not getting ripped off this is this is i
want to teach you something from the torah hold on a second from the torah there's torah you're
gonna get circumcision you better know the torah come on your name is jew your first name is jew
you're defending you're defending nist with the torah the nist okay in the torah i can't
you shall not you shall not have it has only been like an eye for an eye it has all these
different things right thou shall not murder not kill murder right so all these different things
right what murder honor your mother and your father fifth commandment right there's a there's
a punishment and it's very rare it says you will not have two sets of weights and measures
because that is an abomination which means that's a really bad thing abomination is like
you know many many evil like like genesis whatever it's horrible thing it's called the torah when
the torah in hebrew goes like
an abomination means basically the worst thing you could possibly do and you'll probably be put
to death for doing it for having a different set of weights the duncan guy gets put to death
well why is that society is built on trust we cannot have a civilization if we don't trust
each other we trust each other we're speaking a language right now we're communicating we have
weights we have measures we have money we have uh travel we have all these different things
conventions that human beings have to use in order that we have a civilization and culture i don't
have to point to north sentinel island or go to some other country where they don't have a
civilization some of these places don't have even an alphabet right let alone a civilization with
weights and measures we just take it for granted we're so we're so ungrateful but i want to say to
you that in that sense we rely on this every day so to say that you don't trust okay fine so don't
buy any food don't no no i didn't say that i'm not saying you i'm just saying when people say
i have incentives but then i can ask but i don't do this to brett i don't say who's paying you brett
are you trying to get more views for the dark i don't say that to him i'm not impugning who he is
or he's grifter by the way if you want to find if you want to search brett weinstein and grifter
you'll see about a hundred different videos i will never call him that i have respect for him i have
affection for him and that's why i want to hold him to a higher standard and i'm telling him now
come back on i want to talk to you about we can talk about now we talk about whatever you want
but i want to hear those words like if i say to you here's my theory of telomere that you published
in in your paper in 2001 when you were a postdoc um i want to actually i think it's total bs it
doesn't make any sense to me i'm smart i'm a cosmologist brett and i want to hear him say well
you might be a scientist but you have no subject matter expertise and we need that subject matter
and i would defer to you brett on that when you say to other things i want to know if you're not
an expert who are the experts you're going to and it's not that expert again for every expert
there's an equal and opposite expert but just to say i'm just asking questions and whatnot well
you're right there's another point you've been raising here that is something that you know
kind of makes me out on an island as a thinker it feels like this day these days and i'm not
there's i believe there are a lot of people out there that think this way they just get less
attention online and that is we make the cause about the people who are most pressing it and
the people who are most pressing it regardless of where it is and what direction it's headed in
are quite literally personally incentivized to in a zealotry fashion yes that's not the proper
way to say it get to an end result that they have predetermined it is a human fallacy that
we are all susceptible to confirmation bias yes you and i included and i do believe that they're
even
on some of the most controversial things where i'll even say something like like let's stay with
the 9-11 example where there are objectively enormous problems with the story 100 that does
not mean that if like if it's 100 this is the 9-11 commission report right it does not mean
everything goes to zero it was right but like could it be at 25 could it be at 35 i agree with
and is that a huge deal yes and that's where i think like and i and i i believe that's where you
have to have the yin and the yang with it well i
what i will admit is that depending on what the subject matter is especially in today's society
with 280 character tweets to say fuck you behind a keyboard it can get more violent yeah with that
rip them a roll and i do whatever little part i can here to like try to you know that's why i'm
bringing on different perspective i think that's why you would be you know if brett were to come
on i would be on with you and him i would love and i have a fact i have affection for brett i
would love to we will make and if he wants to do that we will make that happen yeah i would love
to do that and i would think it would be instructive to talk as scientists
who are both not experts in this very field of not you know of of what happened that day and
who both agree with the very heart and passion and patriotism for our country that i think he and i
have and you have as well yeah we would i think that would be for as we say the sake of heaven
okay what else do we want to talk about well we we've been putting a a pin in the entire time on
like the the david grush stuff yeah so i don't want to comment on this yeah why were you bringing
that up specifically so um i've never met grush he was on rogan
so i've never met grush he was on rogan
a couple years ago i mean he was just on again i think he was on again a couple days ago or a
couple weeks ago he was on right yeah he was and a couple years ago he mentioned me and and joe and
we're talking about me and how i don't believe you know believe quote in in in these narratives
that are coming out and it was right around the time when he was becoming more prominent
as a whistleblower in late early 2024 maybe late 2023 uh soon after i was on and they were talking
about it and and i started i didn't know about who he was before that
i just knew he was a really interesting guy um he was air force veteran um he had uh you know
served overseas um and he had operated i believe drones and things like that and he kept saying
you know these incredible things and and he kept horrifyingly saying that he was being
doxed threatened targeted and uh he had suffered bouts with ptsd i think that's known to the public
um including uh reports allegedly you know that that have been reported to the public
to uh you know the officials from his maybe from his wife i don't know maybe joey can look that up
um and that he was under a tremendous amount of stress now a i want to say my stepfather
served in the in the vietnam war he was a refueling pilot and a f4 phantom pilot he had
probably had some ptsd as well seeing you know like a refueling plane blow up next to you is
going to traumatize you for life right i have the utmost respect for military people that serve in
the military i don't want anything to happen to my brother-in-law's military um my best friend
three tours um and um and you know i talked about this on sean ryan i have incredible respect so
much so that when i was on sean ryan i gave away 250 meteorites to anyone who's serving overseas
with an apo post office and they i loved it and the people writing to me um fighter pilots and and
uh seal team six members it's incredible yeah i have the utmost respect i don't want anything bad
to happen to david crush that said uh there are things that he claims that he has not seen that
he'll have seen and communicated to him and they include some of the most difficult shall i say as
a scientist but not you know an expert in the military to believe and they involve things that
actually this would be a great thing for you and brett to talk about without me they involve um
biological materials they involve um something called bipedal creatures creatures that walk on
two legs um they involve interdimensional beings now interdimensional i could come into play with
the most recent joe rogan episode last month he said that he had been in contact or he had been
requested to get this material and transfer it to eric weinstein i just want you to sit with that
for a second um now he didn't do that as far as i know and as far as i know he has never seen one
of these creatures or objects or biologic himself but he has it on authority but he cannot talk
about it you know why he doesn't have whistleblower protection which everything i agree with he should
be protected and he should be protected and he should be protected and he should be protected
god forbid if i would fucking kill somebody if they try to hurt him you know because hey he's
great bravery again more bravery in my so he meant that figuratively not literally you too i'm not
gonna kill i'm not gonna rush we gotta i'm gonna kill you know if somebody tries to hurt a service
member right i would that was one of the worst things you can do i'm very patriotic however
he is not the firsthand primary source here by his own admission that's right he is saying that
people in the community from intelligence to um
to uh private industry and and investigators and whatnot that they have communicated things to him
that would be if proven to be true you know eric talked about aliens fighting above the skies and
and not being drones and not being chinese uh object and i say to him i don't want anything
to happen to david but you know who does have the power to do everything and not get doxed and not
worry about losing her job and not worry about people coming to her door because she's got 24
hour security it's coming to her door and she's got 24 hour security and she's got 24 hour security
congresswoman anna paulina luna now she is a friend of my good friend avi lobe who i've had on
many times he's actually surpassed eric weinstein on my show avi lobe is up at harvard three eye
atlas uh three eye atlas he made the claim that it could be potentially but he ruled he did rule
out um the criterion that he he had the escalation ladder the unlock keys that you would have to
provide in order to to falsify his claim he did do that you can he writes every single day he's
like when i'm on the podcast with him i'm like show me your hands because i'm like you're
you're either you know writing another book or another uh medium essay so he anna paulina luna
went to harvard and was in avi's telescopes and looking at the galileo project instrumentation
avi's doing this with hardcore you know support with backers of you know he's at harvard so he's
got access to billionaires filmmakers um technology scientists um and and and scholars of all types
she went there okay she's not averse to doing this she's seen the evidence
allegedly if she has seen the evidence that crush has why isn't she coming forward
she's the chairwoman of the committee on uaps why is she not taking the the metaphorical bullet and
standing up in front of the american people and saying here's the non-human biologics here are
best scientists including avi lobe who you you just said three you're kind of smirking that's
fine but he has a vested interest let's agree on that right he has books multiple books about the
first visitor okay and i pushed him on that i i'll push on anybody but he's not averse to doing
because i think that's a sign of respect when i push back on you and you push back on me it means
that you take me seriously if i say something like oh this is like interventional two plus two equals
nine or whatever or two times two equals equals uh one times one equals two right the math is so
complex i can't keep track of everything that the my friend terry's doing here we go she has no
incentive not to do it and yet she hasn't disclosure is nonsense there is no disclosure it's the it's
the uh hottest topic on the internet and it's the hottest topic on the internet and it's the hottest
in history right even what putting what i do to shame like beginning of the universe who cares
we're not alone in the universe and then you have people like her criticizing people like
dr sean kirkpatrick who led this aaro this uh anomalous uh uh aerospace anomalous reporting
agency or whatever yeah i would give the same criticism to him that i'm giving to some of the
whistleblower class from a different angle for the same reasons it's that he's not alone in the
he's he's total like yeah who the fuck cares none of this is real shut the fuck up no i don't i
disagree i have to i i don't i don't i that's totally how i take it from i haven't talked to
him so he's a scientist a legitimate when he comes out and talks about it and he's giving public
opinions it's it's basically like come on people well first of all this is the thing that's hard
to get across to someone who isn't a scientist again there will always be anomalies in everything
if i told you i said last time and this went viral clip the only time i went viral on you on
you know in history was on the show i said something like uh
do you believe the earth is round it's perfectly round and you said yeah i said do you believe it's
flat you said no and i was like well it's more round than it's flat but it's not round either
and people can go look at this right right you got me caught in the trick question i didn't like it
come on so tell me so say shut the fuck up when you shop kroger delivery you can expect the
savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door our refrigerated trucks keep
your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting every detail right carefully
We'll be right back.
Quality groceries is what we do best.
And right now, enjoy $20 off your first online order of $75 or more.
Restrictions apply.
See site for details.
Kroger, fresh for everyone.
You know what I love, by the way, Julian, when people say, you see on our podcast, Stephen
Barr leans in with his his mellifluous British accent.
He says, say more, say more.
So my thing now is say less, you know, shut the fuck up.
So that's my that's my trademark.
Say less.
When when Sean came on, he talked about the fact that it's impossible to resolve.
It's a resolution office.
That's what it is.
Anomalous aerospace resolution.
They're trying to resolve.
What are these things?
I think most people, even the most diehard people, Tom DeLonge, David Fravor, David,
they'll say 95 percent of what's out there is unexplained.
But there is is explainable in terms of things, whether it's balloons, spies, flares from
a camera and the Trump administration as unfortunately doing.
A lot more damage than I think they're doing good because they're releasing things.
And one day they'll release like, here's this data dump, the biggest disclosure dump
in history.
And yeah, because they attack Iran.
And then they're like, yeah, we got to get we got to get the story out of the FCA.
But but then they'll put out a go to aliens.
Aliens are real.
Go to aliens dot gov.
And it's about illegal aliens.
I'm like, come the fuck on.
This is a joke.
We're not a serious country.
Right.
But that just shows you.
Are you going to trust?
Let's say he does that.
Aliens dot gov.
And you go there and there's some horrible image of a.
Of ice, you know, collecting people or whatever.
Right.
But then the next day there are alien, you know, whatever.
And there's on the front lawn.
Marco Rubio holds up, you know, a skeleton of a biped, you know, of a gray.
No one's going to believe it.
Right.
But is that by design?
Are they trying to prime the pump?
Like you said, you know, with Bart.
Are they having the worst spokespeople in the world out there to guard against what
is truly going on?
I think you might be on to something there, man.
I think you might be on to something there.
I, you know, I've stated this before.
I just always like to be clear for people that haven't heard me talk about this.
I do firmly believe that, you know, we are not alone in the universe.
I am very honest about the fact that I don't know what that looks like.
And intelligent life can mean a lot of different things.
I'm not going to sit here and say it's definitely this gray alien, big eye.
But you think it's intelligent?
I don't.
Yes.
I think there is intelligent life.
I think there has to be intelligent.
Walk me through this.
Say more.
Say more.
If you look at the universe.
I think there, just from a mathematical probability standpoint, I think there has to be intelligent
life out there somewhere.
The idea that we are the only spot where everything went right and, you know, we're able to have
bipedal life where the top of the food chain are people that, as you said earlier, are
conscious, understand they're going to die, can think and do, and also are like, you know,
potentially the largest killer animal as well because of the tools and technology we're
able to create.
Right.
Right.
I think that it doesn't necessarily need, there doesn't need to be like a parallel human
form somewhere else.
I don't know that.
I'm not going to sit here and be like, that definitely exists.
Right.
But, you know, something that I can't conceive that's incredibly intelligent in other ways
that may even be far beyond our advancedness as a civilization, for sure, I think that
can exist out there.
It can, but now you've qualified it.
I said, do you believe?
You said definitely.
Now you're saying it can exist.
I'm sorry.
Where are you?
Let me be more clear.
I think that definitely exists out there.
I am also open to the idea.
Like if someone, if someone wants to say, Hey, I think they've been here or they're
here, whatever they are, I'm open to it.
I can't falsify it and say that definitely hasn't happened.
And I think that would be pretty cool.
I could see how that could go really bad though, too, you know, but at the same time, that
doesn't mean that I'm going to sit here and listen to every whistleblower story and be
like, I want to believe.
And that, and that must be true.
And I got to tell you, like, I've talked about it so many times now, it just went viral for
some reason when I went on Sean Hazlett's podcast like a month ago, but I've said it
for well over a year and a half.
When I did the Jason Sands podcast with James Fox, that was a real red line moment for me
because I knew I was told behind the scenes, like the sourcing on how Jason was put into
James's film.
And that brought a lot of the house of cards of other whistleblower stories down for me
because I'm like, wait a minute, they.
In my opinion, and James will push back on this at this time.
I'm talking with him about it because I think there's a lot of like, I think James is in
a really bad spot because, and I'm not speaking for James right now.
This is my opinion.
This is not what James thinks.
I think it's a very similar psychology and I've told him this to a blackjack player who's
kind of going on tilt a little bit and it's, yes.
And it's like, you're so deep into it.
You're trying to get back.
Back to even.
And I think that there was a trust that was broken here with, with some sources.
And as a result, it is really hard when you've done such amazing work like James and care
as much as he does.
And he does, man, does he give a shit about what he does?
You know, I think it's really hard to pull back on that and say, okay, let me look at
the other pieces of the puzzle here and see where things may not fit.
Right.
And for me, I was able to pull back on that and I said, okay, if they're bringing this
guy forward.
If they're bringing this guy forward, who else have they brought forward?
And do I need to question that?
And when I look at that, there were things that I, you know, I questioned other people
for sure without naming names, but then there were things that I'd kind of been like, yeah,
a lot of that makes sense that now I was like, hmm, does that mean I'm a hundred percent
right?
No, but that's my perspective on it.
And so when I see these guys come out and say, I saw an alien in fucking 1947 that maybe,
maybe you did, but you do have to not to be like a debunker on it.
But you have to at least introduce the possibility again of like this whole being Fermi's paradox
thing, where it's like, people are bringing forward think claims that aren't backed by
physical evidence.
Maybe that's not their fault because that evidence is able to be removed by some sort
of power that we can't fucking conceive possibly, but like, we still don't have it here on our
3d earth.
And so I have to like, not as a scientist, but if you're saying like, quote unquote,
scientifically, I have to question that.
I think everything you said makes perfect sense.
Where you're sitting in your perspective.
And remember you have a job, you actually have a job, which, you know, podcasting is
the hardest three hour a day job in the world.
But, um, but you have a job and that's to contextualize, right?
You're not going to generate new scientific hypotheses.
You're not going to influence politics, you know, directly by introducing the Dore law,
whatever, um, that everyone has to do 70 grams of whey protein, every meal, uh, the whey
proteins.
I'm just like, I will not tolerate lactose.
I hate it.
I'm in Tottenham.
I'm fine with everything except stopping eating.
I have one allergy and that's when I stopped eating.
I break out.
Um, but you said something that's very critical and that no scientist should say, but you're
not a scientist.
You said, believe.
And there's that famous meme, you know, I want to believe, right?
With the X-Files, right?
I don't want to believe.
I don't fucking care about, but I don't care what you believe.
I care what you know.
And I care the epistemological humility that you have by you, by which you gather your
evidence, right?
That's why that's going back to this whole problem of everything.
It's any conspiracy theory.
What sources are using to glean your evidence?
And by what methods could I reduce your P doom or P nine 11 was inside or whatever.
If you say to me, you cannot do it, you cannot reduce it.
And you sound like you've reduced a little bit of credulity and your belief in certain
things.
And maybe you've increased it in other ways, but you have a, you have a, a ratchet that
can go both ways, which is the way it should be.
I could be wrong about everything I've ever done.
And I have been wrong.
And I've written books about how stupid and foolish and things I did wrong and others
there.
But that doesn't mean that you give up.
And for me, I don't want to believe, like I always say, I have a video on my, you know,
I do explainer videos.
I'm one that I don't believe in gravity.
No, we have evidence for gravity.
I don't believe in evolution.
Like clip that astrophysicist top universe does not believe in evolution.
There's a title.
Okay.
There you go.
I have evidence for evolution.
We have copious evidence for evolution.
We have evidence for a lot of the context.
Please do.
Astrophysicist evolution is fake, fake, fake.
No, that's candies.
You cannot.
No, that's trademark candy.
I didn't say it, but he said it.
He did now.
Remember the last time we had the Candace Owens fly, remember when I was in here and
I was like, I had a fly that was going around.
It was Candace spying on her drone.
So what I want to say, don't think when people talk about believing in aliens, I love to
push back.
I say, I've been to Antarctica twice.
We had a viral clip about that once too.
Antarctica is about the size of the Western United States.
It's a huge, a continent has rocks underneath.
I've given you a lot of information.
I've given you a rock story.
A lot of dust down there.
No, there's not much dust there.
The dust is in the galaxy.
You didn't get the joke.
No, I know.
The dust is in the galaxy, unfortunately.
But what ends up happening when I'm there, I can literally be like the heaviest guy there.
You know, I could have like, literally, I was the only Jewish guy there once, and the
whole continent.
Like, whatever you think about Jews.
I mean, by the way, how many Jews do you think there are in the world?
I have no idea.
You don't have an idea?
I don't.
But Israel's really powerful, right?
Israel's extremely powerful.
But how-
They have significant influence in America that they shouldn't have, for sure.
Well, yeah, okay.
So, shouldn't have a huge value, but I'm just saying, they're big, right?
A lot of them.
Yeah, they don't have our GDP.
GDP per capita, pretty good.
Pretty fucking good.
Actually, they're going to be known to everyone.
Yeah.
Just make a ballpark guess.
How many Jews are there in the world?
Well, there's like 9 million there, and then I think it's been reported that,
What is it?
like another 20 million or something like that total in in the diaspora somewhere in that area
i think you'll be shocked i think it's probably higher 30 40 50 million yeah okay i think i think
it's probably higher world jewish population yeah that's what they say 15.7 to 15.8 i know that's
what they said i know that many i know that many in new jersey right that's the whole thing that's
that's that that is your proximity bias you have a lot because a lot of jews live in new york right
20 percent of new york is there's two million people in new york that are jewish i won't make
the joke there's one right here right okay not everyone's perfect right now that was a joke
you're gonna make um but i want to say you have this you have this notion that that they're way
outside the influence is so big but it's actually like it's actually 0.2 percent of the world's
population about 2.2 two out of every thousand people on average i mean are jewish right but
here you said the exact same thing the perfect thing you know that many here you're joking right
but but you know a lot of jewish people one's right here right in front of you by odds
you know a lot of jewish people one's right here right in front of you by odds you know a lot of
you you should go through many days without meeting a jew but you you do and so when i make
the analogy that because there's a lot of space there's a lot of star literally space but stars
but planets you think like oh because there's a lot of people here on earth there should be and
there's a lot of life on earth by the way there's much more life on earth than people on earth right
yeah so all the more so there's that's why i asked you intelligent life remember i asked you
do you mean yes yes that's even more rare right if i say to you like it's very rare i saw a car
rare could it be so rare as to be insignificant
In other words, there's another, there's an advanced species of, of hyper-intelligent
dolphins on a star that are using iPhone, you know, 29,000 that are just put us to shame.
They're doing all sorts of crazy stuff.
They know string theory.
They think of it like they learn it when they're babies, you know, in their mother's womb or
whatever.
And that's what they're, but they're on, uh, they're, they're in, uh, the, the globular
cluster, uh, that's in the Centaurus Centaurus or those galaxies Centaurus.
You'd say, okay, that's interesting, but they can't reach us.
They can't communicate with us, at least with the lone laws of physics.
Then people go to the next thing.
Well, maybe they violate the laws of physics because there's so much.
So it becomes unfalsifiable.
And that's the gap.
That's the, the leap that is used to be known in religion.
God used to serve that purpose.
God is now replaced by AI, aliens, and all sorts of other things that we can't explain
or understand or control.
It used to be called the God of the gaps.
This is one of Dawkins most famous things.
He wrote a book called the God delusion.
And the God delusion is basically centered on this fact that people have this necessity
and this need that's culturally evolved to believe in God.
But God is just a name that we give for this process that we don't understand.
Because in the past we used to say, oh, this woman is acting really weird.
She must be a witch.
She's responsible for our crops failing.
Let's burn her.
She's a witch.
And some of that is in the Torah.
I have to admit, you know, there are stuff in there.
There's slavery in the Torah.
There's a lot of bad stuff in the Torah.
By the way, that should give you confidence that it's true.
Most religions don't talk about themselves negatively as the Jews talk about themselves.
The word Israel in Hebrew means we fight against God.
That's a weird thing to call your religion where God fights.
Islam means we submit to God, right?
They're very different approaches.
What are you, a fighter or a submitter?
How do you view that?
I'm from Jersey.
I'm a fighter.
Right.
So I'm just saying what these things say about themselves is important.
So getting back to the aliens, the capacity for probability is not possibility, right?
You say it is possible.
Of course, it's possible.
But in Antarctica.
I see what you're saying.
One-seventh of the Earth's continental count, zero percent of the Earth's population.
But by odds, you should say, oh, it should
have 1.1 billion people there.
But it doesn't.
It doesn't have anywhere near there.
Just like, you know, by odds, you should almost never.
Someone in Indonesia, you know, should never meet a Jew.
Like we'll never meet it.
But they have because they're ambassadors or doing business or whatever.
The fact is we have this proximity bias and it causes us to have other types of fallacies.
Like you said, the gamblers fallacy, the sunk cost fallacy.
I've been doing this so much.
It's got to come true.
And with these whistleblowers, just to reconnect stuff.
I mean, do you ask them, do you say like, what is your incentive?
I'm going to admit, you know, I'm going to be doing this debate about flat Earth, right?
What is my incentive?
Like you might say I'm an expert.
Like what do you believe?
Is the Earth flat?
Do you believe the Earth is flat?
No.
No way, right?
I don't.
But you don't have, you know, could you prove it?
I can prove it.
Can you prove that the Earth is not flat?
It looks flat.
Something's going around us.
When you say prove, like write up scientific equations to prove it or like show you data
that I've seen?
Make a logical scientific argument.
It could be data.
It could be a logical scientific argument.
Okay.
Like also like pictures from space and stuff like that.
Yes.
I feel like I could prove that.
The existence of people-
I say that as a total amateur.
Right.
And you could.
But the existence of, you know, I joke there's people all around the globe that don't believe
the Earth is round, right?
Right.
There's many people who would say, well, actually, why do you trust NASA?
Those pictures came from NASA.
You know, don't you, how do you believe NASA?
What's their incentive, Julian?
You can always ask.
I'm not asking you to defend it.
I'm just saying those types of questions are not for the sake of clarity.
They're to impugn the character and attack ad hominem the person who's making the argument.
And that's the thing.
I think you have to look at things.
This is another trap that I try to avoid and that I think sometimes, a lot of times gets
caught up today in the modern era is you have to-
Don't think about it, by the way.
If it's a criticism of me, I want you to tell me.
Like Brian, you're fucking, I don't know if this is your-
No, no, no, no.
I'm saying-
But feel free.
Because that actually means you respect-
I'm saying people like anyone on the internet, regardless of who it is, huge audience, small
audience, small account, big account, you know, when you go to look at things, there's
a lot of baby out with the bathwater.
And once in a while, it might actually be fair.
A lot of the times it's like, I want people to look at things more situation by situation.
Okay.
So let's talk about an organization that I know less about the full history about, because
it's a good example.
You brought up NIST.
Mm-hmm.
Because NIST may have completely fucked up aspects of the 9/11 investigation, perhaps
because it was brought in above their head and they said, "Hey, this is what you're going
to fucking write."
And we just never saw that.
Does that mean that every other thing they've ever done is completely fake and wrong?
No.
No, it does not.
No.
It's like, "Hey, these are safer in your car so you can get home safely."
It also doesn't mean that they're going to be right about 9/11.
Sure.
That is true logically.
Exactly.
You're making my point.
It works both ways.
Right.
And people, and like, that makes things harder because it makes the world very gray.
Of course.
But like, I live in that world where the things are gray.
It's very, very rarely all here or all here.
I know it's fun.
That's right.
To say that.
But like, it's here.
That's why it's not. Right.
That's why it's not here.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Exactly.
That's why it's here.
Right.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
you know some oligarch or whatever or this do you want your daughter to be just like some nepo baby
no you don't you want her to be of a high quality and a high caliber that's why i say but date you
have to date because you need a statistical sample in order to know things i'm not a prude
i dated enough i met the first woman i married her my daughters if they're you know if they
continue they'll be like her and they won't be like her but but they have the character of her
they'll be their own person so i i think that that's you know i give that that little piece
of advice the second piece of advice uh second piece of advice uh we'll come back to it haven't
we'll come back to that senior professor moment yeah we kind of got off it by the way what did
so you and dawkins what what are you guys specific you're you're doing the 50 year for the for the
book celebration but you know audience questions oh one thing i did i remembered i did want to say
yeah when uh when he's when i hosted the last time in vancouver in 2024 um we took audience
questions we're taking audience questions tonight but carnegie
hall so it's three thousand plus people i mean i'm like a little nervous to be honest you know
go get ready take my take my quaaludes uh but my xanax you know
amanda can you give me a xanax smoothie please i need a ketamine uh smoothie with a with a twist
of lemon uh so um we took live audience questions and people came up and they were like well you
know were you right about the extended phenotype you know why did you come up to me and then
somebody got up and
started weeping that's hard when a man is weeping in front of you like you know about a little closer
a little farther away than you are he said i was raised in a young earth creationist household
and that means that they believe literally the bible is completely true the earth is 5 787 years
old and um you know dinosaurs were you know brought about to test your faith and science is
fake and you know what else and whatever and um and i read the god delusion and i read uh the
selfish gene and i read the god delusion and i read the selfish gene and i read the god delusion
and it converted me to be an atheist and i want to thank you for that and i remember feeling kind
of ambivalent because obviously you don't want to minimize somebody's pain and trauma that they had
right that they had a you know this this horrific upbringing it sounded like almost abusive right
but then you know the question is does religion do any good and i think that's an uncomfortable
question for richard you know in what sense does the meme have a utility even if it's not true
like the tooth fairy not very useful and i think that's an uncomfortable question for richard you
know the tooth fairy is a very um not very uh correct scientifically is it harmful to believe
in the tooth fairy now sam harris will say things like oh yeah you know it's like you're you're lying
to your children you should never lie to your children but then he believes stuff about the
buddha had infinite knowledge you know of quantum mechanics and and uh and strength theory or
whatever else he believes and and that you know he's the most like calm meditative person on earth
except when you mention elon musk or donald trump and then he's completely unhinged and to the point
where he said famously you know he he said he's the most calm meditative person on earth except when
he didn't care what hunter biden's laptop had on it if it exactly said i do i care about someone's
character i care about their children how they raise their children as a reflection on how they
are right for good or for bad so i'm gonna push back on him you know but because i respect him
if i was just fawning over him weeping about how he influenced me he didn't influence me i'm actually
i mean i read his books i i he influenced me as a scientific writer but would i ask would i ask him
to babysit my kid well he's 85 now i'm not gonna ask do you think richard dawkins is happy well
that's a good question i think he's a good guy i think he's a good guy i think he's a good guy
that's a very important question we conflate intelligence with with success and success is
correlated sometimes with happiness but often it's not einstein incredibly brilliant person
many people want to emulate him he was a shitty father he didn't see his kids one of whom was in
a mental institution for the last 30 years of his kid's life um richard feinman brilliant man
he still likes sleep with the graduate students um you know wives allegedly uh of his students
at caltech um you know other miles davis another another you know incredible you know talent you
know one of the best on earth uh tupac i mean these are great people the biggest danger is
to want anyone else's life do not ever want live the life maybe this is the other piece of advice
live the life that you know you want to impress yourself with yeah you're the only person you're
gonna be you're born with your mother you're gonna die you're gonna be off this earth you're
but you by the way i want to say to people out there i'm blessed to have kids you may not be
blessed to have kids i don't know don't do that you go on that you go in the hot tub too much you
go in the cold plunge the sauna you gotta balance it out get the cold plan get the andrew huberman
pass dude let's say i told this to andrew i said andrew you know you're 50 years old now he's almost
he's 51 um probably biologically 32 uh and it's kind of jack too you see oh yeah he's just putting
some work in bro yeah he is yeah he's no he's he's getting after it and he and he's a quality guy come
on the podcast
andrew yeah he should i'll talk to him i text with him um but but the you know the question is
you might not be able to have kids or he i'll say to him andrew might not be like i don't know maybe
he will maybe he won't um but you can have ideological kids you can create ideas and and
and a culture and and and instill values you know richard's book tonight is called the selfish gene
he claims the gene has a there's a virtue in being selfish in order such that the gene will
propagate and will do good through the inculcation of replicators that then proceed to then but
colonizing for what purpose you know like why should we why does elon want to colonize the
universe why does he want to go to mars i talked to him on my podcast 10 15 minutes i asked him
his kid x was on his back during the podcast his mom was on the call and i said you want to die on
mars you said i said i hope it's not on impact but you want to die on mars you said but you're
in the eye and say goodbye because he's not coming with you you you might bring you know
another astronaut you know a 17th baby mama with you and maybe he will maybe he won't but by the
way imagine being on a spaceship for a year with elon musk like it sounds good for five minutes but
would you want to be on it for a year i don't think so and then no disrespect let's say he has
kids once he gets there and let's say he survives which is not at all guaranteed like those kids
that grew up there they didn't ask to be born on mars right i mean it's crazy the psychological
you have to be thoughtful you have to be charitable and other people's motives
and you know marie curie said be more interested in ideas and less interested in people and i think
that's like the inversion of a lot of podcasts and a lot of culture today you know and i'm guilty of
it too look i was talking a lot about brett you know hopefully he knows i love him but but in
reality you get a lot more attention when you talk about people than ideas but ideas are the
fundamental unit like i said don't pass on your biology only pass on your ideology look at that
elon's passing on he has one child who transitioned to be female he doesn't talk to his father
or mother yeah oh no sorry father yeah she i think her name is justine i i yeah i'm just sorry
because he's got 14 15 you got it he might have another kid right you got it just yeah if i felt
like that if i god forbid one of my kids was like that i would not only be a failure as a father
julian i'd be a failure i think in some ways elon's a huge failure
einstein was a huge failure great men great women can be great failures i've always believed this
and the older i get the truer it seems when i observe more and more people over time
with great genius comes a great price yes and it exhibits in different ways and i don't think
the geniuses get to prove that price and that is not to excuse bad actions they may take by the way
but there are more different
difficult hurdles for certain people to avoid being their own worst enemy in certain ways when
they're dealing with prices and paying the piper that they didn't get to choose and you know i the
other thing is i and and i think we all have to be so humble in it we're all flawed and we all don't
everyone loves to say the phrase and i really try to be careful with this i'm not perfect but i try
to be careful with this if i were blank then i would blank and the if
i were part is like something big time like something really serious if i had you don't
fucking know till you're in it you don't know until you are at the road standing at the fork
and it says go left or go right young man you don't know where you're going until you're actually
two feet on the fucking ground standing there and you know that that's where i think we have to look
at the with people as well and i like that quote what was it marie curry said it yeah i like the
idea no pun intended of like looking at ideas before people because people can brand ideas
and remove them away from their actual like distilling the idea itself i mean you didn't
know where dawkins came up the mean i i agree but i think that you have to look at people as
gray too and i think obviously that includes all of us in this room and you know people listening
to us who don't know us you know like it's not this no one has this magic button that like you
know what they got it all figured out and the danger of saying you know i want someone has
i want what they have you have to take the full package like i brought up previously when i was
on jim simons who was my godfather in a certain sense a girl i knew him before i was born his
wife was my babysitter i'm having dinner with her tonight um you know one of the richest people in
the world most humble gracious loving um classy brilliant people ever had three careers jim was
a mathematician a code breaker a philanthropist a hedge fund manager a father a grandfather a
He died two years ago and I'm, you know,
starting to put my memoirs together about him because he didn't write his own memoirs there's
a book about him called the man who solved the market which is a huge bestseller about him his
success in the hedge fund but that was one sliver of his dimension of his personality people used
to say oh you know him like can you introduce me to him like i'd really like to be him i said oh
really yeah he lost two adult sons two sons died in different accidents and you know i barely knew
them but i knew their parents we dedicated two telescopes to their memory on the mountaintop in
atacama chile where we have the simons observatory and you know he's more of a father to me in many
ways than my own father um you couldn't you can't handle him and and that that to me but i can't
convey it it makes me sad emotional thinking about it i can't convey what his greatest
accomplishment was because i don't even want to think about going through it everyone wants to
think about being a billionaire everyone wants to think about being a mathematician top top
scientist of the world knowing politicians
billionaires having a mega yacht uh gulf stream i i can't even i can't that's the whole thing about
living a devastating life the most devastating thing is to lose a child yes to lose two children
incomprehensible that they're the most gracious individuals that i've ever met and loving and
kind and just you know i'm like nobody but they still keep me in their lives you know to me
that's a sign of a life that it it's so well lived and it's so impossible to convey that
you know it's it's again don't want to be everyone wants to be the cowboy but no one wants to ride on
the range for days on end right that's that's the lesson don't wish to be anybody else yes
you you had said you're agnostic the first time i talked with you yeah and you know obviously
you're a scientist who looks at things on data and evidence and questions
many things and tries to you know steal man and straw man from both ends like the whole thing
like do you ever just sit back though and and say to yourself there's no fucking way
all this could have happened without something i can't explain
um certainly i think that there's things i cannot explain um you know aristotle said i'm wise
because i know how little i know and he was a pretty fucking smart guy right um at the same time
again you have to have humility but you can't only have humility you have to have arrogance
but you can't only have arrogance you have to say i can cake on and confront mother nature
and punch her in the fucking wherever you know i can do it but i'm probably gonna fail but that's
okay when no one gets out alive right we're all gonna be the same worm food in the future
um why do i call myself an agnostic i call myself a practicing agnostic and it actually relates to
dawkins the first guest on my podcast was freeman dyson uh inventor of the dyson sphere
the dyson vacuum no no he didn't invent that i was gonna say he's doing that i was trying he
came to my house for dinner once and i was like i gotta get a vacuum and like put it next to him
and say here's a freeman dyson i always think that ari gold line where he's like yeah she
sucked like a dyson fucking vacuum machine oh my god so um freeman dyson he came up with
so much stuff and he won the award called templeton prize from philadelphia and it is was given such
that religion and thinking about religion scientifically would be as prominent as the
nobel prize so john sir john templeton endowed the prize that would be worth at least one dollar
more than the nobel prize so that people would care about religion and want to win this okay
be that as it may he won the templeton prize and he said i don't know why i i won it i think a most
be it must be the most you know undeserving winner but whatever he said i'm an agnostic
and i said oh that's interesting on my first podcast freeman you say you're an agnostic
your friend richard dawkins you guys are both british right um
if an intelligent alien was looking at you and richard dawkins on a sunday morning
they would both see that you both don't go to the same church right richard doesn't go to church and
he doesn't go to church he's just an agnostic so i said how physics wise because he's a physicist
how could a physical way of proving that you're an agnostic be determined and because i said i
think you're an atheist but you just don't have the courage to say i love them and i said i just
don't think you want to call yourself an atheist because i think you think it sounds too absolute
which it does
atheism means the affirmative belief that god does not exist theist means you you affirm to
the postulate that god does exist and all your reasoning in both camps goes to those to those
two conclusions you reason from a conclusion to an axiom right that's what they're doing
um an agnostic in the truest sense agnostic means not knowable it doesn't mean some days i believe
on thursdays i don't but sunday it means that it's not knowable the proposition of god's existence
is not knowable knowable science
science means knowledge in latin that's where we get the word science from i believe that that's
true i believe it's not knowable if gods exist or not um i believe i also don't believe in the
god that richard dawkins doesn't believe in you know he believes in some guy with a white beard
and says that's what i also do not believe in that um einstein said a lot of ambivalent things
about god god is the old one and he would be he doesn't play dice right and what about the morgan
freeman god i was just watching
now you see me three or four or whatever that's part of it takes place right up the road
bruce almighty right evan almighty i love those shows um so yeah so do i believe in some guy
actually uh to make it even more concrete the soviet union the ussr in the 60s um they were
you know background of their religion of their of their politics is to not believe in religion
as atheist uh country and when yuri gargaran made the first orbit around the earth in um in
nineteen ninety-one years ago he was the first one to make the first orbit around the earth in
nineteen ninety-one the uh the press asked him what did you see up there and he said to the press
that adored him in russia they said well i'll tell you i didn't see a guy with a white beard sitting
on a chair oh so brilliant yuri gargaran you know uh it's it's trivial like a child might believe
that when you're sophisticated you might start to say there are certain propositions that can't be
explained as you said we live in this incomprehensible universe doesn't that make you think
that something else created that is the fallacy of the god of the gaps which is which is not to say
that's stupid what you said but it's not stupid it's not stupid it's not stupid it's not stupid
it's just because there's things we can't explain then there has to be an explanation for it
therefore there must be some explainer for the explanation right i would say if there's a big
bang does that mean there's a big banger right um in the case of let's say the elements so aristotle
believed that there were four elements right now we know there's 118 elements right um do we know
what any of the elements were back then no they thought there were four earth air wind fire right
they didn't or water and fire they didn't think of it so they explained it and then they would say
well there's some
unknown thing that is present in every molecule but now we know what the element theory of atoms
is we know quantum mechanics so the room for god shrivels up in that or the room for explanations
just because you don't know something gets smaller and smaller and so scientists get this get this
arrogance like we have to have that we can understand more and more and as we expand more
and more this gets great but imagine this i make this bigger and bigger circle on this table in
two dimensions all right i go back to flatland where we started this whole exploration the
the circumference of this circle gets gets bigger and the area gets bigger as i expand it right
imagine this is an island the island is in an ocean of ignorance and the area of the island
is increasing he's holding up a coaster he's looking at a coaster so this coaster gets bigger
and bigger the circumference increases and the diet and the area increases it's expanding into
the sphere of ignorance that we don't know about so we're getting more and more capturing more and
growing and it's growing at a different rate so i think that's part of the humility we'll never know
everything what i say is i want to give people the permission to seek evidence for god including me
i'm part of people right so i have permission to seek whether or not there's evidence for god
i have the permission to not be for because we don't live in a thought crime society i cannot
do things but how do i differ from an agnostic like freeman dyson and that i practice religion
in other words i
go to church you know i i keep i go to temple i keep kosher i learned hebrew at a late age was
hard to do uh my kids know a lot more about it than i do um uh and and i have a community and i
do things one of the things i do and this is one thing i wanted to ask you and we're gotta wrap up
soon because i gotta i don't want to be late but um you talked about 9-11 it was very meaningful
to you you've talked about epstein you've talked i want to know and i'm not going to blame you at
all and i said this to sean ryan too sure if that's true i'm not going to blame you at all
sure that you guys care so much about these things as i believe you do are you forget about
the politics or the or the ambiguity of these things are you donating money to like tunnels
to towers are you doing things to raise awareness of these of the victims of 9-11 the families who
died the the firefighters the the first responders who died and their families because it seems to me
i really care about this um too and i have given money i'm not i'm not doing that virtue signaling
um are children trafficked by by um by child traffic
workers and predators like epstein and and worse um you know the the the network that supported
epstein horrible horrible thing do you support the victims of these things if you don't and if
your viewers don't i think that they should because it's one thing to say you care the
government's lying to me fine but we know for one thing for sure we don't know who did this or who
did that we can argue about trade seven we can argue about epstein and trump and whatever we
can't argue they're victims let's help the victims that we know about let's use this let's let's
do it let's do a fun we want to do a fundraiser we can do it for tunnels to towers why not
i'm willing to do it i'll give up my revenue share yeah had a new
pay anything i i think you make a great point with that you know how invested are you in
in the people that actually are most affected by it that we know for sure yes suffered we suffer
our minds and we lose confidence in the government these firefighters gave their lives for us or for
people that were here oh yeah all right brian keating yeah you got to go talk with richard
dawkins thanks so much for popping through while you were in town i wouldn't miss it for the world
all right we will obviously we'll collab this so people could check out brian's channel and check
out the into the impossible podcast on youtube and spotify it's great stuff thanks for coming
through down here my brother all right let's go hit the whey protein you know what it is give it
a thought get back to me peace hey guys if you're not following me on spotify please hit that follow
button and leave a five-star review they're both a huge huge help thank you it's officially the
holiday season and abercrombie's new collection has outfits for everything on your calendar
it's the busiest time of year and between shopping and party invites i don't have time to plan every
look
but abercrombie's always got me covered their sweaters are the perfect easy layer for low-key
plans and on a nice night out i'm reaching for their classic trousers fill your closet with the
pieces you'll need all season long have a very abercrombie holiday shop in the app online and
in stores when you shop kroger delivery you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries
delivered right to your door our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates
are committed to getting everything you need to get your groceries delivered right to your door
getting every detail right carefully selecting and packing your order with care because bringing
you fresh quality groceries is what we do best and right now enjoy twenty dollars off your first
online order of seventy five dollars or more restrictions apply c-site for details kroger
fresh for everyone
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Abercrombie’s new holiday collection offers versatile clothing for all occasions, making it easy to plan looks without stress.
The brand’s sweaters and trousers are practical and stylish, ideal for both casual and formal outings.
The holiday season brings shopping and social demands, but Abercrombie provides ready-made solutions for everyday wear.
A discussion on the fourth dimension uses the concept of a tesseract, explaining how higher-dimensional objects project into lower dimensions.
The Flatland analogy helps visualize higher dimensions, showing how a 3D object might appear as a 2D shadow in a 2D world.
The universe’s geometry—flat, spherical, or hyperbolic—is determined by measuring angles in large triangles across vast distances.
Scientists like Michio Kaku and Eric Weinstein are criticized for making unverified claims that oversimplify complex scientific concepts.
The discussion emphasizes that true scientific communication requires openness, humility, and the acknowledgment of uncertainty.
Summary:
Abercrombie’s holiday collection offers stylish, versatile clothing that simplifies outfit planning during the busy season, making it a go-to for shoppers. The host highlights how the brand provides essential pieces for everyday and festive wear. The conversation then shifts to a deep dive into higher dimensions, using the Flatland analogy to explain how a four-dimensional tesseract would appear as a three-dimensional cube in lower dimensions.
This leads to a broader discussion on the geometry of the universe, where triangles of astronomical size reveal whether space is flat, spherical, or hyperbolic—currently indicating a flat universe. This flatness is seen as a rare and likely coincidence, possibly enabling life and consciousness. The segment also critiques science communication, noting that popular scientists often present bold, unverified claims without acknowledging uncertainty.
The host emphasizes the importance of humility, peer review, and diverse perspectives in science, referencing the need to avoid oversimplification and fear-based narratives. He contrasts this with real scientific inquiry, where data and evidence are central. The discussion ends with a nod to the origins of the word “podcast,” tracing it to the film *2001: A Space Odyssey*, illustrating how cultural references shape language and innovation.
FAQs
A tesseract is a four-dimensional hypercube. It's hard to visualize, but we can understand it by imagining how a 3D cube appears as a shadow in 2D space. Similarly, a tesseract's shadow in 3D space looks like a cube. This concept is inspired by the idea of higher dimensions beyond what we can see.
No, we cannot directly see into the fourth dimension. Our brains are limited to perceiving three spatial dimensions. However, we can understand higher dimensions mathematically and through projections, like how a 3D object casts a 2D shadow.
Flatland is a fictional story set in a 2D world. It illustrates how a being in that world would perceive a 3D object as changing shapes—like a point, then a circle, then shrinking. This helps us understand how a 4D object might appear in 3D space through projections.
Scientists have determined the universe has zero curvature based on measurements of distant triangles. This flatness is a mystery, as it makes the universe ideally suited for life and consciousness to emerge—something not found in positively or negatively curved universes.
In a flat universe, parallel light beams never converge or diverge—they stay parallel. In a curved universe, they either converge (on a sphere) or diverge (on a saddle). This behavior helps scientists detect the universe's overall geometry.
We live in a three-dimensional world, and our brains are limited to perceiving only two dimensions (via retinas). We can only simulate or project higher-dimensional concepts, not truly visualize them as they exist in reality.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.