The Ultraviolent, Wildly Successful, Uniquely American Phenomenon of Grand Theft Auto
42m 28s
Grand Theft Auto has transformed from a controversial crime simulator into a cultural touchstone, offering a satirical yet deeply immersive portrayal of American life. Rooted in the 1997 debut in Scotland, the franchise grew into a global phenomenon through its sandbox gameplay, freedom of choice, and realistic, detailed worlds. Each installment, especially GTA V, reflects societal tensions around morality, the American dream, and consumerism. The upcoming GTA VI, developed over 13 years with a billion-dollar budget, promises to push boundaries in realism, featuring lifelike environments, complex character interactions, and themes of surveillance and economic struggle. Despite the game’s cultural significance, the broader video game industry faces challenges including massive development costs, high failure rates of expensive titles, and competition from free-to-play games like Roblox or Fortnite. These pressures have led to widespread layoffs and a shrinking market for premium, high-budget games. While GTA VI may represent the last of its kind—a true artistic and economic pinnacle—its success could offer hope to a struggling industry, proving that ambitious, narrative-driven games still hold cultural value. Yet, the future of such large-scale productions remains uncertain, as technological, financial, and market forces make sustainability increasingly difficult.
Hey, it's Michael.
If you are not yet a Times subscriber,
we have some news for you.
You can enjoy full access to The Times
without a paywall for 30 days.
All you have to do is download the New York Times app
to get your first month completely free.
And if you're already a Times subscriber,
thank you.
From New York Times, I'm Michael Bavaro.
This is The Daily on Sunday.
The hell are you doing?
Wait, look who's back.
Thursday will mark the release of an entertainment blockbuster,
arguably the biggest of the year.
It's not a movie.
It's not an album.
It's a video game.
Maybe some warning next time?
Or should I do it?
Put it in your calendar?
Friday morning, bankrupt.
Come on.
Grand Theft Auto VI.
This could be the start of something good.
Keep your phones up.
The latest addition of a franchise
that has become a cultural phenomenon
and a financial juggernaut.
Consider this.
The last installment, GTA V,
racked up around $11 billion,
making it one of the most profitable pieces of entertainment
of any kind.
Ever.
Might not feel like it, but these are your glory days.
This next installment is expected to be even bigger.
The salad years, you know.
Nothing is going to beat who you are now.
Today, Zachary Small, who writes about video games for The Times,
explains how a game devoted to breaking the law
became an American institution
and why Grand Theft Auto VI might be a high watermark
in the history of video games.
It's Sunday, November 15th.
Zachary Small, welcome to the Sunday Daily.
Thank you for having me.
The last time that I played Grand Theft Auto
was, I'm going to guess, eight years ago
in my cousin's living room.
And so my memory of it is very faint.
For those who have that kind of faint relationship
to this franchise, I'm going to guess it's the first time I've played Grand Theft Auto.
To this franchise, which we'll heretofore call GTA,
give us a fresh, up-to-date picture of it.
What makes a GTA game a GTA game?
So I'm imagining you, Michael, opening this game
and you are in some fake version of Los Angeles.
This is Mad Dog on your radio.
You're listening to Radio Los Santos.
And you're leaving your wife, who is obsessed with social media
and is taking selfies.
To go to a drug deal to fuel her buying sprees.
Mm-hmm.
You got the grip?
Present and accounted for.
And you're going to go to a strip club
and you're going to spend some money.
Hey, baby, want a private dance?
And then maybe you'll see a trash truck driving down the street
and you'll say, I want to drive the trash truck.
And you will push the person out of the driver's seat.
Come out! You got the day off on me!
And take it and mow down people on the boardwalk.
I'll hijack a garbage truck
and I will use it to be extremely destructive.
I mean, if you wanted to,
I guess you could follow the traffic rules,
but I don't think you're going to.
You have all these unlimited options.
You can go commit a crime.
You could steal a truck.
You could play basketball.
So you can pursue a Tony Soprano-like version of,
you know, a seemingly placid, normal domestic life
and then go off into the, you know,
the world of a city for crime and prostitution and the rest.
You have, you know, the ability to be an absolute psychopath.
You're often incentivized to,
but it's kind of in this drama of like a South Park or family guy.
It's quite satirical about what the American dream is
and American life.
Scratch.
Who do you trust to get this state back on track?
A drug-addled, philandering former stuntman
with multiple concussions
or a successfully divorced school teacher
who knows how to talk down the normal,
like a real liberal.
Sue Murray has been. So there's like, on one hand, this, you know,
what someone who probably hates this game
would call a crime simulator.
But on the other hand,
it is this sort of like virtual sandbox of America.
What do you think about America, Nico?
Tell me straight.
You love it, no?
I don't know, Roman.
It is the same as any other place, only louder.
People don't know how to. And what exactly is the storytelling infrastructure
of this scenario you're describing?
Are there stories that you're following?
Are you creating the story in real time?
Are there characters?
Do you become the character?
How does this work?
Oftentimes, these games have a much more complex story
than you would imagine.
There's one specific game
where you play a recent immigrant to a city like New York,
and it's all about how difficult it is
for an immigrant to obtain the American dream.
So you have a game that is giving you criminals,
but they want you to understand
the complexity of these people,
the reasons why they're doing the things they are.
And so I think having that complexity
and allowing people to explore the satire of crime
and greed is really why people are pulled into this world.
The last time one of these games came out was 13 years ago.
People are still playing this consistently.
It's a juggernaut in terms of the market
and in terms of how people sort of relate to video games
and the industry as a whole.
So I'm starting to get a feel for what makes this game
that I haven't played in many, many years so special.
But tell us the story of how GTA became
this juggernaut.
Where does that story start?
Would you believe if I told you
that the story of the American dream starts in Scotland?
I would be surprised.
Because this story starts in Scotland in 1997.
You're basically driving around the city,
stealing cars, running over pedestrians.
You have a group of pretty young developers,
including two brothers, Sam and Dan Houser,
who are trying to create this game
that's essentially like Cops and Robbers.
And as they're developing this game,
they realize, you know what?
Nobody wants to play as the cop.
It's much more fun to commit crimes.
And so the first Grand Theft Auto is like,
it almost feels like an arcade game.
And you get points for running over pedestrians
and killing people.
Wow.
There wasn't really a lot of depth in terms of the story.
Or autonomy.
Right.
And so they're creating this game
and they're creating this game
and they hire a PR person to spread to the British tabloids
that this is a scandalous game
and that this is a game that glorifies violence.
So it becomes this controversy in the UK.
This is the legacy of Grand Theft Auto.
Like, if you've never played Grand Theft Auto before,
you think of it as the crime simulator.
And that's why it's so popular.
And that's a little bit to the company's own fault
for introducing. Or credit.
Fault and credit for introducing the game that way.
And what happens when this pre-marketed
as illicit rated X thing emerges in 1997?
Well, everyone wants to play it
and a lot of politicians are very angry about it.
Under proposals being considered by the Home Office,
a health warning would be flashed up on the screen at the start
reminding players. The game is still selling well, though.
They quickly spin out.
Another sequel in 1999 called Grand Theft Auto 2.
It is much of the same.
It sells well.
It sells better than the first one.
But the reviews are kind of middling.
Where things really start running,
where Grand Theft Auto becomes a zeitgeist of the culture
is Grand Theft Auto 3.
The Forelli brothers have owed me money for too long
and they need to be taught some respect.
Grand Theft Auto 3 comes out in 2001
and this is around when you're starting to see
really, really, like, fully 3D worlds you can explore.
For tonight, a light aircraft will pass over the bay.
It will drop several packages into the water.
Make sure you pick them up before anyone else does.
You're in a city with different zones
and you're given full control.
Remember, just watch your back in Chinatown.
It's triad territory.
I think a lot of the details are really what sold this game, though.
You can drive your car and listen to a radio station. Of your choosing.
Of your choosing, and the radio station
and the radio stations, the voice actors behind it
are sometimes real radio jockeys
and you're listening to real radio music.
This is Tony on Flashback FM.
Liberty City's home for the best in disco, electro, and new wave.
This was not done in games.
Developers were not spending the money
and spending the effort to get these licenses
that really make you feel like you're in a fully immersed world.
He wants mine and more.
Mm-hmm.
This sounds really good.
It's really far from Super Mario Bros.,
where it's like, ding, ding, ding,
like, getting from one, you know, chapter of the story to the other,
but you're living in a very confined space
in that old version of video games.
Yeah, and you're not going from left to right in this game.
You're going anywhere you want.
You're creating this new genre of game called the sandbox game,
where you're given full reign.
You can follow the story missions if you want,
but you could also just go off on your own.
It's your sandbox.
It's your sandbox.
You can build your own castles, if you will.
your castles of crime.
And I believe we've made this point, but it's really worth emphasizing.
Everything that's happening in this game, it sounds like almost definitionally, is criminal or not good.
Well, let's not oversimplify things, Michael.
Okay.
But I would say that, like, it's coming at you from this, like, Hobbesian idea of freedom where, like, everyone is their worst selves.
Their basest self, yeah.
And I can't overstate, like, that was really strange in 2001 to play a game where, like, you would be walking down the street in this game as your character.
And a non-playable character would be walking by you and just automatically say, like, you're fat.
Back of your neck look like a pack of hot dogs.
Like, it was shocking.
And then, of course, you have the ability to respond.
With force.
With force.
Exactly.
I recall that.
When this game became part of the American zeitgeist, that dimension of it became very controversial very quickly.
Yes.
But it was also coming at a moment of moral panic, right?
This is after the September 11th terrorist attacks.
This was during a time where there were a lot of questions of sort of violence among us.
There was a domineering perspective, although the research didn't support it, that playing violent games,
It would inspire violence.
Exactly.
Right.
It doesn't take a massive leap of the imagination to think of the school council board president who says, I don't like this.
Exactly.
And certainly a lot of them did.
I mean, in 2002, when Grand Theft Auto Vice City came out, which was set in this fictional version of Miami, there were multiple lawsuits.
But if you want to talk about controversy in Grand Theft Auto, you have to talk about the hot coffee incident.
Take me back to my place.
I will bite.
Tell me about the hot coffee incident in the history of GTA.
Well, can I just tell you in terms of my own personal history with Grand Theft Auto, I learned about this when I was like, I must have been 11 or 12.
And I was sitting with my grandfather, who was reading the Wall Street Journal and just placed the newspaper in front of me and said, look at this.
You play video games.
This is why they're bad and will turn you like violent.
You're going to have some coffee.
The hot coffee incident came from a part of the game that developers had put in and into Grand Theft Auto San Andreas.
The developers had created this simulated sex scene for the game.
And then last minute, they decided, you know, better not to put that in.
So they took it out.
Even for us, be on the bail.
Even for us, let's not do it.
And they took it out of the official game, but they left the code in the game.
If you have hot coffee, you're DADC Matrix.
You know, skilled gamers who understand code could still find the simulated sex scene in the game and they could figure out how to play it.
And once they did, they spread the word around.
How could you not?
How could you not?
Everyone knows about the hot coffee controversy involving Rockstar Games.
And so suddenly you have all these people playing a scene that was not intended in the game.
Or maybe was because the code was left.
Well, at one point.
Who can say?
One point was certainly intended, yes.
This is sort of like alights with already these fears about violence in video games.
Now you have sex in video games.
And now you have the Federal Trade Commission asking you questions.
Also, politicians are using the hot coffee scandal as a way to renew calls for legislation to regulate the sale of games to minors and potentially even have the government.
But Congress was upset about and what senators like Hillary Clinton were upset about was that they felt like the companies had misled the ratings agencies.
That was the important part.
The fact that you could access a simulated sex scene meant that the game should have had a higher rating.
Well, last week Hillary Clinton introduced legislation that would fine retailers up to $5,000 if they sell an AM or AL rated game to a minor.
Now, in addition to Clinton, California-
What does this controversy do to the sales of a game whose developers seem to know quite well the power of the illicit?
Well, what do you think?
The sales go up.
Mm-hmm.
They do have to sell.
They do have to settle some lawsuits.
They make an undisclosed settlement with the FTC through Congress.
But the sales are going through the roof.
Every single game in the Grand Theft Auto series makes more money than the last.
And how much money are we talking about for these games?
So why don't we look at Grand Theft Auto 4, which came out in 2008.
God bless this city!
It sold 3.6 million copies in one day.
Wow.
And then the sales hit 6 million.
And then the sales hit 6 million globally in the first week for a total haul of $500 million.
That's one week.
That's extraordinary.
The trend continues.
Later on, Grand Theft Auto 5 comes out.
I always thought I was the good guy.
God help the morally bad.
This is more successful than anyone could have predicted.
In 24 hours, the game made more than $800 million.
Hmm.
In three days, it hit the billion-dollar mark.
It's a video game that is shattering sales.
Never has there been an opening like this in the entertainment industry.
Bigger than movies, sporting events, and concerts.
Here's a little look at GTA 5.
What you're describing sounds like the ingredients for a very successful game.
But put your finger, if you can, on why you think this is a transcendent blockbuster of a video game, which it clearly is.
I think to answer that, you have to understand that the tone of this game,
is so unique.
The idea that the whole series has its roots in controversy.
It wasn't just controversy for controversy's sake.
They were really trying to say something about America.
And you can see that in Grand Theft Auto 5.
You can see it with the characters' relationships to their own phones.
You know, they might not have Facebook, but they have an app called Life Invader.
They might not have X, but they have something called Bleeder.
There's this real attempt to, like, get a genuine satire
of American life right now in a way that, you know, allows you to follow protagonists who are greedy and cynical.
And in going into that world, though, you're not just asked to accept them.
You're asked to reckon with them, which is a very different thing.
It's something that's special to video games as well.
It's an arena, especially if you're trying to understand American culture today and say, like, how did we get here?
It's arena for you to explore those fields.
And I think viewers have rewarded them over the years of consistency saying,
we're looking to you to tell us what this crazy time we're living in is like.
What it means.
Exactly.
That feels like an unexpected level of cultural insight and criticism to get from a video game.
It's something special, and I think that's why this series has become so popular.
So as compelled and intrigued as I am by everything you're describing here,
I think there's no substitute for playing GTA.
And so in front of us is a PlayStation where we are going to play GTA V,
and you're going to show me how it is that I hijacked that garbage truck.
It's my honor.
We'll be right back.
So Zach, I couldn't think of a more perfect snack for us than Oreos.
So I think we should have an Oreo as we start to play.
Do you know Oreos are vegan?
No.
Whenever I made it vegan, I go, well, you can eat Oreos.
It's usually where the conversation ends, because then they get angry and hungry.
Yeah, well, maybe I should come up there and practice my backhand on your face.
So as you can perhaps hear in the background,
our crack team of engineers here at the Sunday Daily have wired up this room so that we can play GTA V.
And I wonder if you could just describe, Zach, what's on the screen.
We are driving across a bridge into downtown Los Santos,
which is this game's version of Los Angeles.
And I have just committed grand theft auto.
I am driving a stolen car and looking for trouble.
I'm looking for your trash truck.
Oh, your cell phone's ringing.
Someone just called me.
On the screen.
I also just jumped out of the car by accident while trying to answer the cell phone.
And now someone has pulled a gun on you.
Someone has pulled a gun.
It's a cop.
I just killed the cop.
And I'm going to steal the car, his cop car.
We should have given people a warning.
This is the thing.
Like, we started this game a couple minutes ago, and it already has gotten. It's so intense.
There's a helicopter above me.
There's so much adrenaline.
Someone's shooting at me through the overpass.
Well, I was just killed.
I was wasted.
So this is like in every game.
When you die, you're wasted.
So, Michael, this is where dead men come back to life.
So we start all over again.
all over again.
- Kind of.
with him, like, I think
he's probably coming out of the
police. Yep, he's coming out of jail.
Michael's coming out of jail. No, I'm coming out of the
medical center. And Amanda's calling.
Don't touch me! Oh, you
don't have to call to tell me that.
Not you! The Dieter Sachs door
detainee. So there you go. This is part of the story.
I need you to help clear it up.
Okay, so he. We have the option to go to Amanda. Yeah.
Alright, I'm coming. So this is
trying to get us back on track with the story
after we've committed something. Yeah, Amanda
sounds like maybe an ex? Amanda is
the wife who's just, like, really obsessed
with becoming an influencer. Got it.
Let's see where she
is. Yeah, so she's up there. She's
up sort of out of the
main city in the burbs.
So I need. I don't have a car with me. What do you
think I should do? Oh, what to do?
Oh, you just. Suddenly you're
brandishing, like, an AK-47.
Oh, see, that's just someone who randomly
got out of their car with a gun themselves.
But it's just a shootout now.
Yes, and so now I'm trying to get in
the car. You're in the car.
So don't you hate it
when you go to
Ground and Pound
and they don't have your smooth latte?
So you have to pull out your. This is a radio call. And chop off
the weight of hands. Oh my god.
Don't you hate it when you go to
Cool Beans and they
don't have your strawberry? I'm trying to take you to go shopping
now. Actually, sorry, I thought we were going shopping,
but this is a strip club.
But some of the satire in the background is about,
like, overpriced L.A.
life that a criminal encounters.
You know, my parents never thought I would be on the daily
explaining to you that we're outside of horny
girls.
The streetscape is
very vivid. Yes. Like, it really
looks like Los Angeles. Yes, and they do a lot
of study to make these. Like, the
scale, the variations of things.
Yeah, they have urban planners that they'll
consult. They'll also try and, like,
faithfully recreate as much as they can.
But you see how the neighborhoods also change?
Yeah, it's becoming a little bit more
fancy. Yeah, we're kind of getting into,
like, a Beverly Hills adjacent
space.
The neighborhoods in this game, they're all based on
Los Angeles neighborhoods, but they have
different names. Oftentimes, some puns.
Mm-hmm. Such as?
Vinewood, which is Hollywood.
They also have, instead of
Venice Beach, they have
Vespucci.
There's also, instead of Westwood,
they have a neighborhood called
Morningwood.
Meet me behind the
pawn shop in Morningwood.
We're on the wrong side of Vespucci Beach.
You should know, a block makes a difference.
What do you need? Just a few
Vinewood souvenirs for my
museum.
You just smashed a really nice Lamborghini into, like,
a 1975
Oldsmobile, and now into another
one. You're a
terrible driver. Do you want to try?
Yeah, I
think, I mean, I might need a little bit
of coaching on this. It's
complicated, but you,
once you start going, you'll figure it out. So, the
triangle button is to, like, get into
a car. So, like, if you want
to try and get, get into,
you could get into that one. It might say
mission field, though. Okay. That's, I've just
stolen a, oh, wow.
The console is vibrating. Yeah.
How do I steer?
Famous last question.
Ooh, jeez.
That took 10 seconds to drive
into a tree. That took out your windshield, and,
mission failed. So, let me, it'll,
Amanda was arrested
again.
There's your trash truck.
Oh. I know. After
that, if you crash into it, and then you
compress triangle to get out of your car,
and then triangle to steal his car.
Oh, amazing. Yeah, triangle. Triangle?
Yeah.
Go. Go, go, go.
Tremendous.
Dump it.
The trash truck's name, by
the way, is dumping in your street.
No. Oh, wait. No, I just
got thrown out of it. So, you gotta throw him back. You gotta
hit him. You gotta knock him out.
Yeah, there you go.
You're a natural at this.
Oh, wow.
This is tremendous.
Oh, my God. You see the
blood spurting out of him? I don't know.
You're catching on to this pretty quickly.
Here we go. I got myself a garbage
truck.
Okay, I gotta slow down, because I'm just gonna, oh, I'm just gonna
crash into all these. Alright, hold on.
But this is what a lot of people's, like, first hours
with this game are, is just, like,
being, getting
used to the controls, but also, like, being
shocked by how interactive the world is.
Completely. But I just do
want to describe how my baseless instinct is coming
into play. Like, I, for no reason at all,
I just decided to take out this motorcyclist.
Because I could.
I mean, like, I could not have, but I could.
That's really funny, because, and I might be in the minority
here, I really do try and play this
game and abide by the traffic
rules. That says a lot
more about you than it does about me.
Yeah. It says a lot about both
of us, I suppose.
But you can see how people play like this
for hours, without, like, doing
any mission.
Oh, jeez. I could, I'm
gonna spend ten minutes just figuring out how to
get this dump truck out of this
intersection. Everyone plays this differently,
but you're kind of playing it like the parallel
parking simulator.
I'm outta here. I'm outta here. Yeah, okay.
You can see the trash
falling out of the truck as you make your
getaway. I've totally
mastered the driving part now. Oh, jeez.
I just flipped the truck over.
So this is like a day in the life
of Grand Theft Auto. Yep. Just to give you
the global view here, this
is like an early mission.
It's only gonna get weirder from here,
and so for the new game, like, you know, people
are just imagining, if this is how
crazy fake LA is, how crazy
is fake Miami?
And now that I've got a sense of how good
and mesmerizing GTA
5 is, I can only imagine
what
this next version that
has been developed over
13 long years must be
like, and I bet it's rather impressive.
Let's talk about it.
I just feel like I'm in my parents'
basement in, like, 1996, eating
Oreos, playing video games with you. I'm so glad
I became an investigative reporter at the New York Times
to do this.
Okay, Zach,
I'm a lot more familiar with
GTA. I now truly
understand why it is such a hit.
It's immersive. It's
a sandbox. It's a choose-your-own
adventure romp.
It's a delicious parody of American
life. I get it.
We just played
GTA 5. The big
question I have is, why on
Earth did it take 13
years for this
next generation of this franchise,
GTA 6, to come
out? In a
sentence, everything's
really expensive and hard
to do. The reality
here is that to make a video
game, even in
2013, let alone
2026, the
technology is so advanced and so expensive
and requires thousands of people to
work on it, that any major
game today, the development
timeline is usually six to seven years.
Wow. That's become accepted.
What we just played, like, just think about it.
You got in a car
and you sped off.
There's an auto-repair place by the airport
where we can get a tow truck. How much
work do you think goes in
to getting in a car and speeding off in a game?
I have no idea. Once you start
parsing it out, though, you're thinking, okay, what are the
physics? What's the physics engine in this game? Who
developed the physics engine? Who decides what's
speed that car is going? Who makes the animation?
What if the character's getting in from the
right side versus the left side?
Tow truck is at the lot.
Already, I've given you an overwhelming
number of options, and each
one of those, of course, has about a thousand
other things that a developer, an animator
would have to do.
That requires hundreds of man
hours. And today,
because we expect, or the
consumer expects, realistic,
sophisticated games,
I mean, this is a triple-A game,
and by triple-A, you mean
what? It's like a blockbuster
movie. It's like the biggest budget
production. And you get to 13 years.
You get to 13 years, and you get to a
budget that people estimate to be around
a billion dollars. Just for this latest
version of GTA. Yeah. It's like,
you know, video games
Cleopatra budget.
What have you
come to know
about GTA
6, insofar as you've either
been able to play it, or glimpse it, or it's been described to you?
What has all that time and money
given us? You know, as someone
who reports on video games
and also plays video games, I've seen
a few in my day.
What I have seen, both in previews and
sort of in first-hand demos,
has actually been astonishing.
The level of detail that
goes into these places. We were just on the
beach in Grand Theft Auto 5.
We didn't see a lot of people.
Grand Theft Auto 6 has like a
true Miami beach stuffed with people
of all shapes and sizes, having
individual conversations.
They're playing fetch with their dog who
runs into the wave, and the wave splashes
against the dog. They're throwing the
beach ball, and it makes an imprint in the sand.
Like, the amount
of work, once you start
thinking of how hard it is to make
anything in a video game, really
blows your mind. I think of what I just
played as something that
artificial intelligence would
really accelerate. It seems
like precisely the
thing that the AI coding
in the world would,
would catalyze. It's not? Not yet. Many companies, because of how expensive it is to produce games,
are hoping that AI can help them cut some corners. In my reporting, a lot of the places where that's
going to happen, though, are not necessarily on the big development costs. You know, maybe instead
of hiring play testers to find all the glitches in your game, you can have an AI agent run through
things, for example. But the cost of production has skyrocketed. So even if you have a game that's
super successful, a bestseller, the studio may still shut down because they haven't made enough
money. Which leaves everyone in this sort of trap. I mean, the industry has had over 30,000 layoffs
in about two years. They're calling it a crash. Executives are calling it a crash. And yet we're
here on the brink of one of the biggest game releases, or truly anticipated to be the biggest
entertainment release ever.
What happened to the rest of the non-GTA video game industry that means there have been all these
layoffs?
So on average, a AAA game, you could imagine the budgets are around $200 million. It's like you're
producing a Marvel movie, and you're taking six years to make it. In those six years, you have to
anticipate what viewers will want. Oftentimes, that gamble does not pay off. And we've seen that in
these stratospheric,
mistakes.
Would you just give me an example?
So for example, Sony had a game called Conquered. And it was a shooting game, let's say. It came out,
it had a budget of hundreds of millions of dollars. They shut it down in about two weeks.
Wow. That's how badly the sales were.
They took it off because the sales were so bad, and they didn't want to pay for it to be,
it was like a live service game to be streamed. So it was taken off the air. They ate that loss.
They missed the mark.
What about Conquered didn't work?
It's the competition in that space. I mean, these games, like if they don't pop off immediately,
there's not really such a thing as like, steady growth, right? You can have a cult game, you know,
that becomes popular.
But it's not going to make back the $300 million budget.
Exactly. So it's easier for them in some cases to just cut the cost completely.
Competition at the same time, which is coming from,
other studios or countries such as China, they're creating games that are free to play.
So like, they're not technically amazing games. You could play it on your phone.
But they're community games. So there's things like Roblox, you might have heard of, or Fortnite.
And you don't have to pay to get into it. You pay for like, character costumes or weapons,
whatever. That's how they make their money. But it's pulling so many players. So the audience,
the audience has decreased. The audience for these prestige games, let's call it, has also gotten older.
So there's a narrowing, there's a mature market that's happening, where they've lost the audience,
the product is too expensive to produce. And AI, while it has some promise to cut costs,
is not so significant. AI has actually built another challenge, which is that to create these
games, or to even develop the machines to play the games, they use the same,
hardware that AI companies need for their servers. So the cost of all that hardware has gone up.
Consoles have increased their prices by hundreds of dollars, when usually within the lifespan of
this product, the price is supposed to go down. So we should see GTA and the expected success of
GTA 6 as an outlier. And perhaps, maybe, am I overstating this? The marking of the end,
of an era in video gaming?
It really could be the last of its kind.
Just say more about that.
It's the last of its kind in that this, it's perhaps the last true prestige game,
where the developers have sought to create something worthy of an Oscar, you know,
that has all of these different elements that are artisanal, right? Like artisanal,
artisanal shadows and lighting.
Um, it just requires such an immense amount of effort that it's unclear to developers who I've
spoken to that their own studios could make the same thing and make enough money to make it worth
it.
So will there be a GTA 7, 8, 9, 10, 11?
It's kind of, it is, it's unclear is the truth. It might be the only one of this scale to continue
on. But that's just because, again, this, this is sort of in a league of its,
own. The industry is hoping, as, right, the saying is that the rising tide can lift all boats.
They're hoping that Grand Theft Auto can sort of be a salvation to the industry.
But does that seem likely?
You know, you can't just bet on like one game to do this. We're also in an affordability crisis
where the consoles and games have gotten more expensive. You know, games used to be $60 just
a couple years ago. Now most games,
most new releases are priced around $80 or $70. People are, people are choosing not to buy them.
I'm sure many people listening to us will think that if video games of this sort
wither away, it's not going to mean all that much to them. They may not spend that much time
playing these games. As you could tell from my driving, I don't spend a lot of time playing
these games. So for them,
explain what in your mind is lost if video games of this kind go away.
Well, economically, you're losing billions of dollars, quite literally. It's hurting a major
sector of the economy and an industry that's bigger than music and movies combined.
Wow.
Culturally, you will be damaging in an art form that people spend hours and hours
with. So even if you don't play it, you're talking to people that could spend 100 hours in a given
game. We've talked a lot about Grand Theft Auto and the controversies, but also some of the merits
of the story that it tells. And so to lose that, you know, it's a similar thing as people are
looking at Hollywood and the budget crisis is there. You know, where do artists get an outlet
today?
Right.
Can't all be painters.
Some of them are going to be designing,
that shadow against the wall in that video game.
Some of them will be, yeah.
And it sounds like a lot of them have lost their job over the last few years.
Yes. But in terms of Grand Theft Auto and its studio, Rockstar Games, I mean, this game has
probably had close to 10,000 people working on it. And they've been very steadily working on it
over 13 years. Like the size and the scope here is really significant. And I think the question
for a lot of people will be,
will, you know, can the studio sustain itself off of the sales of this game?
Well, just to end our conversation here, let's talk about the game itself, GTA 6. What do you know about this game? Have you played it?
I have watched people play it.
That's as close as they'll let you get?
That is as close as they'll let you get in the Rockstar Studios. The way this is handled is as if they had the Pentagon Papers. You walk in, they want you to sign up for a ticket.
They want you to sign an NDA to see it. I, as a New York Times reporter, did not sign the NDA.
Did you just kind of like broadly move your hand across a piece of paper as if you were signing it?
I said, that's really interesting, but I can't.
Because then you couldn't talk to us about it.
Exactly. You know, in terms of what I saw, though, it's what I can speak about is what is also seen in some of the trailers as well. It's just like they understand that Grand Theft Auto, as much as it is a game that you play,
is also a zeitgeist. And they've tried to live up to the expectation of Grand Theft Auto as being sort of like a second life, you know, you in the virtual world. If you go to a convenience store, there's going to be like 45 options of different food and drinks that you can get. Maybe you start vaping while you're in there, and you open up one of the magazines in the kiosk, and there's like a full magazine for you to read through with fake articles inside of it. No New York Times. I did check.
So I think it's just like, this game is going to show people what is possible when you have what is essentially an unlimited budget.
Earlier in our conversation, you mentioned that GTA V felt like a cultural commentary. From what you've been able to see of GTA VI, what is the comment it's making about America, about Florida?
You know, there's a lot of these colonies in the game, which you can experience yourself. You know, they're playing around, certainly, with the stereotype of the Florida man, for example, in the game. But I do think at Grand Theft Auto VI, it's really a Bonnie and Clyde story.
Jason. Lucia.
Here.
Yeah.
We gotta go.
Go?
Yeah, go. Like right f***ing now. What you think I needed a lift for?
These cushions are right.
who can be in a relationship if you want them to.
and these, like, two criminals that are just trying to make it,
you know, in a situation that's incredibly difficult to.
I think there's also elements of the game
that lean heavily into surveillance culture.
You know, in previous games, if you robbed a store,
like, you just got to get away from the cops.
Here, there are cameras.
There are a lot of surveillance cameras.
There are people with their phones taking videos of you
as you're committing a crime.
So, like, in a way, I think that feels really true to the moment today.
Wait, did you steal my friend's car?
Yeah.
Holy s***, Chet!
What do I do?
Jesus.
If cynicism and greed and crime were the bywords of GTA up until now,
is there a new word to add?
That's a great question.
Cynicism and greed are definitely still in play.
I think this game,
in terms of it feeling more grounded,
also has a little bit of hope in it.
Hmm.
Of what sort?
Of making it.
Keep your phones on.
Does this mean we're in his crew?
Yeah, I think so.
You think he can help us?
We don't have any better ideas, do we?
You know, I think, again,
where the country is right now,
of people being worried about affordability or prices,
is. having a game where they fantasize
about being these criminals in Florida,
trying to make a big score.
There is something there,
as tainted as it might be,
to talk about crimes this way.
There is an element of hope.
Well, Zach, thank you very much.
Thank you so much.
Appreciate your time.
This episode was produced by
Alex Barron,
with help from
Lena Richards.
It was edited by Wendy Dorr,
contains music from Dan Powell,
and was engineered by Sophia Landman.
Special thanks to Wilder Barron.
That's it for The Sunday Daily.
I'm Michael Barbaro.
See you tomorrow.
Thank you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Grand Theft Auto has evolved from a controversial crime simulator into a cultural phenomenon, reflecting American life with satire and depth.
The franchise’s success stems from immersive, sandbox gameplay that offers freedom, realism, and a dynamic world where players create narratives through choices.
GTA’s cultural impact is amplified by its bold commentary on American society, including greed, surveillance, and the modern American dream.
GTA VI is expected to be a massive release, built over 13 years with a projected budget of around $1 billion, showcasing unprecedented detail and realism.
The game’s realism—such as lifelike physics, character interactions, and environmental details—demonstrates the pinnacle of video game craftsmanship.
Despite high development costs and industry challenges like layoffs and declining audiences, GTA represents a rare artistic and economic outlier in gaming.
The game’s themes of criminality, surveillance, and economic struggle reflect current societal anxieties, particularly around affordability and trust.
GTA VI may mark the end of an era for large-scale, artisanal video games, as rising costs, competition, and AI limitations threaten the sustainability of such projects.
Summary:
Grand Theft Auto has transformed from a controversial crime simulator into a cultural touchstone, offering a satirical yet deeply immersive portrayal of American life. Rooted in the 1997 debut in Scotland, the franchise grew into a global phenomenon through its sandbox gameplay, freedom of choice, and realistic, detailed worlds. Each installment, especially GTA V, reflects societal tensions around morality, the American dream, and consumerism.
The upcoming GTA VI, developed over 13 years with a billion-dollar budget, promises to push boundaries in realism, featuring lifelike environments, complex character interactions, and themes of surveillance and economic struggle. Despite the game’s cultural significance, the broader video game industry faces challenges including massive development costs, high failure rates of expensive titles, and competition from free-to-play games like Roblox or Fortnite. These pressures have led to widespread layoffs and a shrinking market for premium, high-budget games.
While GTA VI may represent the last of its kind—a true artistic and economic pinnacle—its success could offer hope to a struggling industry, proving that ambitious, narrative-driven games still hold cultural value. Yet, the future of such large-scale productions remains uncertain, as technological, financial, and market forces make sustainability increasingly difficult.
FAQs
Grand Theft Auto VI is the next major installment in the popular video game franchise, set to be a high-budget, immersive experience featuring a fictional version of Florida with deep storytelling and realistic simulations of American life.
The franchise has become a cultural phenomenon due to its satirical take on American life, sandbox gameplay that allows player freedom, and its ability to reflect societal issues like greed, crime, and surveillance in a fictional yet relatable environment.
GTA VI is expected to introduce more realistic environments, advanced AI, and a deeper narrative centered on a 'Bonnie and Clyde'-style story, with greater emphasis on surveillance culture and the challenges of making it in a difficult economy.
Players have full control over their actions, including committing crimes, exploring freely, and engaging in social interactions, with no strict story paths, allowing for a personalized and creative experience.
The franchise has faced criticism for glorifying violence, such as the 'hot coffee incident' in GTA San Andreas, where a simulated sex scene was left in the game code, leading to controversy and calls for stricter game regulation.
Development of GTA VI has taken approximately 13 years, reflecting the game's massive scale, high production costs, and the complexity of creating realistic, immersive environments and interactions.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.