Go back

The Texas Church Mistress Murders | The Case Of Kari Baker | UNSEEN

30m 16s

 The Texas Church Mistress Murders | The Case Of Kari Baker | UNSEEN

Carrie Baker’s sudden death at home sets off a community-wide mourning, with her husband Matt Baker emerging as a public figure of faith and resilience. However, deep suspicions arise among Carrie’s family—especially her mother, Linda Doolin—due to inconsistencies in the death scene, such as a typed letter with spelling errors, a lack of photos, and an unnaturally tidy room. These red flags, combined with Matt’s unusual phone activity and the removal of Carrie’s photos from the home, prompt Linda and her husband to investigate further. A pivotal clue emerges when Vanessa Bulls, a young woman who had an affair with Matt, testifies that he planned to kill Carrie by suffocating her with a pillow and using sleeping pills to create a lethal-looking overdose. He had discussed the plan in detail, including how to stage the scene to appear accidental. Dozens of other women corroborate Matt’s predatory behavior, revealing a pattern of manipulation and emotional coercion. Though initially dismissed by authorities, the evidence is gathered through legal action, leading to a wrongful death lawsuit and eventually a criminal conviction. On January 21, 2010, Matt is sentenced to 65 years in prison. The case underscores the critical role of family perseverance and truth-telling in exposing hidden crimes, ensuring that Carrie’s daughters, now safely protected, grow up with a mother’s love and legacy intact. Her story, though tragic, becomes a powerful testament to resilience and justice.

Transcription

4963 Words, 28116 Characters

English
This is the voice of Matt Baker. He has just found his wife, Carrie, lifeless in their bed, with a typed letter beside her. But there's one problem. Carrie didn't write the letter. Everybody is shocked. Matt and Carrie are pillars of their community, a loving couple with two young daughters. But Matt isn't just a husband. He is a respected Baptist pastor, a rising star in the church. After Carrie's death, Matt becomes the face of faith through tragedy, speaking at pulpits, appearing on television, even landing magazine covers. He tells the world how he lost the love of his life and how God carried him through it. But Carrie's mother, Linda Doolin, isn't convinced. Something about Matt's story doesn't sit right. Carrie had told her that she felt like Matt was having an affair. There's no way I could ever hurt my wife. Like every marriage, you have your ups and your downs. You have your good days and your bad days. But I loved her and I miss her. And I did not hurt my wife. The death of Carrie Baker might have remained a mystery, if not for a mother who refused to give up, driven by the fear that her grandchildren were living with a murderer. Eventually, a clue is uncovered, a secret message written by Carrie herself, hidden in the pages of her Bible, a message that will expose the truth and help Linda avenge her. Before it's too late. It's April 7th, 2006. Matt Baker is driving home in the small Texas suburb of Hewitt. It's past 11pm on a Friday night. His wife, Carrie, might still be awake, waiting for him, while their two young daughters, Kenzie and Grace, are likely already fast asleep. But, as the 38-year-old father pulls in the driveway, he has no idea that things are about to take a disturbing turn. That night, Matt had only stepped out for a quick errand, renting a movie and filling up the car with gas. Now, just before midnight, he walks in and heads to the bedroom, only to find the door locked. When he finally gets it open, he's met with a chilling sight. Carrie, his wife, is lying motionless and unresponsive. And what's the problem? Tell me exactly what happened. My wife is laying in the bed, and her lips are blue, hands are. In Hewitt, everyone knows the young couple. Matt and Carrie's love story has all the magic of a fairy tale. Both college students, they met at a camp in the summer of 1994. Working side by side, they quickly fell in love, and within just three months, the pair got married. They later settled on the outskirts of Waco to raise their family, welcoming three daughters, Kenzie, Cassidy, and Grace. Matt, the local Baptist minister, is a respected and familiar figure in the deeply religious community. While Carrie, after completing her master's in education, is a devoted mom and beloved third grade teacher. Faith has always been the foundation of their family, and their life appeared picture perfect, until now. I put my head to her chest and didn't see or feel her chest rising, no air coming out, felt for pulse, nothing. Okay, listen carefully, I need you to get her laying flat on her back on the ground to remove any pillows, okay? Okay, put her on the floor? Correct. On the bed now, put her on the floor. All right, she needs to be on the floor, yes sir. Okay, okay. The 911 dispatcher coaches the couple. They're on their way to the hospital, but they don't know where they're going to be in a few days. The ambulance is on its way, hoping to revive Carrie while the ambulance is on its way. Remarkably, he keeps his composure, clearly giving their address so first responders can race to the scene. As they stay on the line, Matt makes another request. His two young daughters are in the house. He can't risk them walking in and seeing their mother like this. He asks if they can call Carrie's parents, the Doolins, to come and care for the girls. I need to get a hold of her parents. They live in town, and I want them to come over and be with the kids. Get somebody else started on this, okay? Thank you, thank you, thank you. We received a phone call from the 911 operator telling us that we needed to get over to my daughter's house, that there had been an accident and we needed to get over there immediately. When the ambulance finally pulls up to the Baker's home, the paramedics find Carrie still lying motionless on the floor. Van Dool is now available everywhere in the U.S. Everywhere, Matt. So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places. Georgia, Houston, Cleveland, Minnesota, Buffalo, Lincoln, Chi-Town, Arizona, Tampa. Make this your most rewarding season ever with Van Dool. Age and location restrictions apply. Product availability varies by market. See VanDool.com for eligibility. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. They check her pulse and start compressions, but her body isn't responding. After a few minutes of work, the paramedics know it's too late. That's when Carrie's mother, Linda, also arrives at the scene. We ran out of the car and as I started running up to the front of the house, an EMT person stood in front of me and grabbed me and told me that my daughter was dead. The family is in shock. Carrie, a loving mother. A daughter, a loyal wife and beloved teacher, is gone. As everyone tries to make sense of the situation, the medical staff briefly consider if she had a potential hidden medical issue no one knew about. Or maybe this was all a tragic accident. But as police search the room, they find something unusual. A letter, typed and left on the nightstand. It appears to be from Carrie. The detective that night pulled me into the kitchen. He goes, it's pretty obvious what happened. And at that point my heart sunk. I couldn't believe it. That was the first time, for sure, that's what they claimed it to be. We were truly in shock. It was almost like we were in a trance. And all I kept thinking about, all Jim kept thinking about was that we didn't have a daughter. Our daughter was gone. In Texas, when someone dies suddenly or unexpectedly, it's up to a justice of the peace to decide what happens next. There isn't necessarily a doctor. There's no autopsy involved. So for Carrie, instead of a thorough medical examination, police describe the scene over the phone to Justice Billy Martin. They tell him about what was found in the bedroom and the overall circumstances. And Judge Martin makes his ruling. There's no need for an autopsy. It's April 9th, 2006. The day after Carrie's sudden death, the family is in shock, overwhelmed, and barely able to process what's happened. But despite the grief, Matt insists the memorial ends. And a burial must happen immediately. He begins making arrangements at their family's Baptist church, planning the service for the very next day. By Monday, April 10th, only 48 hours since Carrie's body was found, she is already laid to rest at Oakwood Cemetery. Her memorial, originally planned at the family's church, is moved to one of the city's largest funeral homes to accommodate the overwhelming response from the community. To Linda, it's all moving too quickly. No time to breathe, let alone grieve. But Matt, the Baptist, is ready. The Baptist preacher tells the family it's best not to delay the healing process. Waco, Texas, Oakcrest Funeral Home, 3 p.m. Hundreds gather in sorrow. Carrie's family, her children, and the entire community have come together to mourn. I hurt for her. I hurt that someone hurt enough that they made that choice. We're just trying to put one foot in front of the other and get through this. Even at the largest funeral home in the city, the space is overflowing. Folding chairs fill the aisles. Friends and neighbors stand shoulder to shoulder along the back walls, spilling into the foyer and leaning through the open doors. During the service, Matt sits motionless in the front row, head in his hands, silent through every eulogy and remembrance. And then, at the end, the grieving husband stands at the pulpit with his daughters beside him, promising to everyone he'll return to Crossroads Baptist in only one week: Easter Sunday. "God has not abandoned me," he says. "He will give me the strength to carry on." It's Sunday, April 16th, less than a week after the funeral and only eight days since Carrie's death. Pastor Matt keeps his promise and delivers the Easter sermon at Crossroads Baptist Church. He tells the congregants that just as Jesus has risen, so too has Carrie, into heaven. Ministers from across the country send emails and letters to the family, and to Matt specifically, praising his unwavering faith and courage in the face of tragedy. One woman even offers to teach him how to pray. "I will teach him how to do his daughter's hair." A beautiful gesture for a father, now parenting girls alone. From the outside, it looks like a community supporting a grieving man as he tries to put his life back together. "He was a single parent, working and taking care of his girls. They emotionally attached to the dead very strongly, the younger ones especially." In the month following Carrie's death, her family is overwhelmed, trying to come to terms with the tragedy. The family, along with her sisters, can't shake the feeling that there's something more to Carrie's death. Something police have missed. They knew Carrie better than anyone. She was vibrant, loving, and full of life. A hands-on mother who adored her daughters, the idea that she would have willingly left them behind is completely out of character. Linda and her family start examining the evidence themselves, and realize that beneath the surface, there are several small inconsistencies, each one minor on its own, but together, suggesting that something more sinister may have happened. happened. The first red flag, only 10 pictures were taken of the crime scene by the investigators. For any sudden, unexplained death, this is an unusually low amount of photos. There's barely any evidence in the records. Next, everything in the room looked a little too perfectly arranged. Alone, it's possible that the family had simply kept a tidy house. But upon a closer look, it could seem like the scene might have been staged, as if someone carefully planted evidence to have it appear like a tragic death. The letter beside the bed should have raised immediate suspicion on its own. It was typed, not handwritten, and unsigned. In theory, anyone could have written it. Another unusual detail about the letter is the amount of spelling mistakes. Carrie was a third-grade teacher and an educated woman with her master's, known for her attention to detail. The typed letter misspelled words like two, spelled with a single O, in the wrong context. It seemed like it didn't quite match her character or her background. In spite of the many inconsistencies obvious to anyone looking closely at the crime scene, it seems police are in no rush to question the only person actually at the scene of Carrie's death. Matt is interviewed nearly two months after his wife's passing, and even then, it's only a casual discussion, seemingly only to tick a box, not to further any actual investigation into Carrie's death. I left about 11, so I wasn't gone maybe 40 minutes. You left the house and went down to the gas station? I wasn't even gone long at all. Okay. And so, and that was, and that was the strange thing about it is I, I question where she would have taken the medicine. Personally, this is my opinion, I don't think the medicine is what killed her, but was knocked out enough and choked. So no, I don't know if that's just me trying to put stuff together to make it, you know, I don't know. Okay. Like I said, that's all I just wanted to sit and holler at you about. Matt is calm, cooperative, and consistent in his account. He's able to remain rational, eager to help detectives with any questions they have. Matt even willingly takes a polygraph test and passes. To the police, there's no reason to think he had anything to do with Carrie's death. I think there's a presumption with a man of God that they have a certain character and a certain ethical base, and we believe that. Matt Baker was given great. Attitude in his story, and it wasn't questioned. You hold your preachers up to a higher standard. You never think that your preachers are going to do anything. You don't even want to suspect them. It's got to be a sin to suspect your pastor, right? According to detectives, there's simply nothing pointing to him, or to anyone else for that matter, in the death of Carrie, and the case is open and shut. After talking to Matt, the police are able to walk away, confident with their initial assessment of Carrie's death. But in spite of police's conclusions, Linda Doolin and her whole family continue to search for anything, anything at all, that could uncover the truth and explain what really happened with Carrie. Then, around the beginning of May 2006, a clue appears in an unlikely place. As Linda looks through their family phone plan bill, which includes herself, Matt, and Carrie, she stops cold. In the days following her death, Carrie's phone has been used hundreds of times, even calling Matt's number several times. If her daughter is dead, who could possibly have been using her phone? Matt's explanation is that he gave it to a church member who was in need of a phone after a difficult divorce. Being a generous pastor is one thing, but giving away your dead wife's phone so recently after her passing seems very strange, and something about his tone feels rehearsed. To Linda, there is a shift, not just in his story, but in him. Matt's daughters, five-year-old Grace and nine-year-old Kenzie, who have been living with their father, since their mom's passing, also notice something strange. All the pictures of Carrie have been removed from the family's house. As weeks go by, Linda and her husband find themselves increasingly pushed out of their granddaughters' lives as well. There were fewer visits, shorter phone calls, and many excuses from Matt about their busy schedules and hectic routines. It's starting to feel as though Matt is removing Carrie from their lives in small but significant ways. All of a sudden, all the shock I'd been feeling, all this numbness, it was just like it just washed right off of me. And I thought, okay, Linda, we're going to find out what's going on here. And after that, we went into battle mode. Linda and her husband Jim take their growing suspicions to the police, pleading for the case to be reopened, but their response is indifferent. The department refuses to budge, and the original ruling stands. Meanwhile, the evidence is sealed away and out of reach. They know they can't wait for the system to act. If they want justice for Carrie, and to make sure her daughters are safe, they'll need to build the case themselves. That's when a new ally joins Linda's team: Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Johnston. After listening to their story, Johnston sees what they see: too many red flags to ignore. He assembles his own team of investigators, including Matt Cawthon, a respected former Texas Ranger. On July 30th, almost four months after Carrie's death, Linda and attorney Johnston, file a wrongful death lawsuit against Matt, giving them the legal authority to gather records, conduct depositions, and reexamine everything piece by piece. Their next move is hiring a digital forensics expert, whose first priority is to go through Matt's computer. And what he finds shocks Johnston's team of investigators. Matt, a respected pastor, had been watching adult content during work hours, literally inside the church. Adult sites are interspersed right next to Matt's searches for internet sermons, on top of that, the expert uncovers that on March 9th, exactly one month before Carrie's death, Matt searched "overdose on sleeping pills." But when they discover a message, handwritten by Carrie just five days before her death, it puts the final nail in the coffin. Hidden in the margins of her Bible, Carrie's voice speaks from beyond the grave, pointing the finger at her own husband. "Lord, I have so much worry and I cannot get a hold on it. I'm asking you to protect me from harm. I'm not sure what is going on with Matt, but Lord, help me find peace with him." Carrie had written down her suspicions about Matt only days before she was found dead. It seems her intuition was telling her that she was in danger. But, frustratingly, despite all the circumstantial evidence, there's still no clear-cut link tying Matt directly to Carrie's death that Linda can bring to prosecutors to have him convicted of murder. It's now October 2007. More than a year and a half has gone by since Carrie's death. In spite of growing suspicion, Matt continues to deny any wrongdoing and begins to take even more drastic measures, moving himself and Linda's grandkids two hundred miles away to a different city. He takes a new job preaching at a local church, far from Carrie's family. From the outside, he has completely moved on. In fact, as Linda and her family keep fighting to gather evidence that proves that Carrie was murdered by her husband, Matt now seems eager to tell history. "He went on kind of a press tour. He tried to tell the world his side of the story." In an unbelievably arrogant move, the case even goes national as Matt sits down with ABC News for a televised interview. "There's no way I could ever have hurt my wife. I loved her. She's the mother of my children. And I miss her. And I did not hurt my wife." "Vanduul" is now available everywhere in the U.S. Carrie's parents are stunned when they see their former son-in-law on national television. To them, not only does he have the nerve to keep denying what's happening, but he also doesn't hesitate to include his young daughters, Linda's granddaughters, in his publicity tour, using them, and his pastor image, to garner sympathy. Matt's presence is persuasive. He appears to be a grieving husband, a pastor leaning on his faith in the face of unimaginable loss. But for Carrie's family, every public interview feels like another setback. While they are fighting just to be heard, Matt is controlling the narrative, using another unspeakable family tragedy to garner sympathy: the death of their second daughter, Cassidy, at only 14 months old. In 1999, seven years before Carrie's passing, Cassidy, who was diagnosed with a brain tumor, lost her fight. While Carrie was destroyed by this awful loss, but decided to honor her little girl by taking care of her surviving family, including Matt, she had to stay strong and went to see a grief counselor to navigate this devastating time. But according to him, this overwhelming loss is the exact reason why Carrie was so depressed. After Cassidy passed away, she couldn't go to sleep. She could not go to sleep. I saw it more as she's hurting, she's missing her daughter. Cassidy consumed her. The loss of Cassidy consumed her thoughts. Public opinion, however, remains divided. Some believe his story, convinced of his innocence. But Carrie's family never wavers. They are certain Matt is involved in Carrie's death, and their fears run deeper. However, Linda is concerned that her two young granddaughters might be living with a murderer. At this point in the investigation, Linda and her team need something solid. Something or someone who can tie the whole case together. Someone who knows the full story of what really happened to Carrie. And that someone is the very person Matt had given Carrie's old phone to just days after her death. A young woman named Vanessa Bulls. Newly single, 23-year-old churchgoer Vanessa had recently started attending Crossroads Baptist, where Matt was the pastor. Just weeks after Carrie's death, Vanessa was seen attending Matt's daughter's tenth birthday party. Friends also reported seeing the two together often. Looking unusually affectionate. And when Linda had looked at the family's phone records back in May 2006, the call logs were damning. Matt and Vanessa had been in close contact before and after Carrie's death, with Vanessa using Carrie's old phone. Matt and Vanessa had continually insisted that their relationship was only a friendship. Matt as a pastor counseling Vanessa through her divorce. But with so much contact and such a quick emotional connection, it raises serious questions. What had really gone on between them before Carrie died? Could Vanessa hold the key to the entire case? And will she come forward to help bring Matt to justice? It's January of 2010, four years after Carrie's murder and Vanessa is subpoenaed. She's legally forced to show up and testify at trial on what she knows about Matt Baker. And because prosecutors believe she knows something critical, they offer her a deal. Tell the truth, and you won't be charged with anything yourself. The courtroom is packed. Linda and her family are sitting on the wooden bench, ready to fight for justice. When Vanessa enters the courtroom, all eyes are on her as she takes the stand in front of Carrie's whole family and Matt himself. When she starts to speak, the courtroom is silent. Everyone hangs on to every word, as she describes exactly what happened and Matt Baker's true-face, is finally revealed. "He was a complete, and still is, a manipulative liar who took me in my vulnerable state and made me believe everything he said." Matt, who was at first counseling Vanessa about her recent divorce, quickly changed his behavior from attentive, caring pastor to a predator. "He started asking me things about my divorce and started telling me, 'Whoever finds you is going to be a lucky man.'" Matt Baker. The entire courtroom, Vanessa finally reveals what Matt had always denied. In March of 2006, just one month before Carrie's death, she and Matt were having an affair. "He came by and was kind of smiling, he said, 'Oh, don't date other guys, just date your pastor,' and kind of smiled." "Did he say anything else after that?" "He said, 'Will you really date your pastor?' And he asked if he could hold my hands to pray, and he did, then afterwards, he started to kiss me. Then he just took my hand and kissed me." "He kissed my hand and led me to the bedroom. I was extremely remorseful. I couldn't believe what had just happened." "He started saying, 'It's okay, don't feel bad, just ask God to forgive you.' And he said, in reality, he said, 'I don't think God believes that anyone can just be with one person the rest of their lives.'" Then Vanessa drops another bombshell. She says she knows what really happened to Carrie Baker. Under oath, she testifies that Matt had been openly planning her death. "He said that, you know, she took sleeping pills every day. He took pills every night, so maybe he could make it look like she overdosed on sleeping pills. He mentioned that he would leave a note. He said that he would type it. And I said, 'That's never going to work. You're going to be caught.' And he said, 'Oh no, she types everything.' He said that no one would question it because of how depressed she was." "She just asked Matt, 'Why are you trying to kill her? Why don't you just get a divorce?' And he told her that he would never be able to preach again, I guess in his mind, divorce was worse than actually committing murder." "At what point did he start talking about planning her murder?" "It was shortly after that, it was sometime mid-March, I would say. He started talking about things he could do. He said that, you know, she took sleeping pills every night, so maybe he could make it look like she overdosed on sleeping pills." "And then he told me that, he said, 'I'm going to tell you what happened that night, one time.' Then he said, 'I never will.' I never want to talk about it again." "He had gotten big horse pills, we said he emptied out all the contents and put crushed Ambien in them. He said he handcuffed her to the bed, started kissing her and touching her all over until she fell asleep. Then he said he got the pillow and put it over her face." "What did he say happened next?" "He said that he thought she was dead. He just said she just took one big gasp for air and he said, 'Oh,' and then put the pillow back on her face." "He did this with his hand to be sure that he suffocated her. He said that he set everything up, locked the door and left." "So you knew that Friday, April 7th of 2006 was the day that he was going to try it again?" "I knew he was going to try it again, yes. In truth, who would believe me? He was a preacher. And so I felt like I was stuck." "What I saw from Vanessa's testimony. It was a man who was much more evil than even I believed he was." The courtroom is stunned. The truth is finally coming out. And it's devastating. Carrie was betrayed by the man she trusted and loved the most. But despite the heartbreak, Vanessa's testimony aligns with the evidence that Linda and her family have spent years tirelessly collecting. And Vanessa isn't the only one to break the silence and expose the man Matt truly is. Dozens of other women step forward too. Women from Matt's past. Who, one by one, bravely share their stories of Matt's behavior over the years. "We'd gone back into the youth rec room. He tried to kiss me. I told him no. He said that he knew that I wanted it." "He seemed very relentless and wanting to have an incident of a sexual nature occur. I don't want to do this. I remember having to use all my strength to try to keep him off of me and from taking my clothes off." "I turned around at one point and he was standing behind me and he begins trying to kiss me." In total, 12 different women come forward. Their testimonies, back to back, corroborate Vanessa's version of Matt Baker. The pastor has always been a dangerous predator who thought he was untouchable and would walk away unscathed, never being held accountable. But today, he is forced to face the consequences of his actions. At the sentencing, Linda can finally confront the man who took her daughter almost four years ago during her impact statement. Matt was her son-in-law. She used to see him through Carrie's loving eyes. And now he can't. He can't even look at hers. "I'm talking to you, Matt, today, okay? You haven't looked at me in almost four years. Can you look at me today?" FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S., so you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places. Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel. See FanDuel.com for eligibility. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. You murdered the mother of your children. But the most tragic victims, Matt, are Kenzie and Grace, those sweet, sweet babies. Kenzie and Grace were thrust into a chaotic situation after their mom's death. But thankfully, Linda and Jim gained full custody and now provide a loving, supportive, home for the two girls to grow up in. Grace is 12. She loves the arts and she's in band and she plays the piano. Kenzie will be 17 next week. She is very excited about the prospect of college. She's a hoot to be around. All we want now is for the girls to be teenagers, and we never want them to feel like they have to choose who to love. I live with three women. And the other night, they were all laughing and giggling and just having a grand old time. That was a symphony. I see Carrie. I see her every day and her daughters. She would be relishing what we're experiencing. She was an amazing mother. And she would fight for any of us, and I just want everybody to know the truth. Carrie's legacy is living through her daughters, and Linda can still see Carrie in them, her light shining through. And despite being gone, she will never be forgotten. On January 21st, 2010, Matt Baker is sentenced to 65 years in prison. He won't be able to hurt any other women. He'll destroy Carrie's reputation. Without her family's persistence, Matt would have more than likely gotten away with with the murder, but Carrie, through her loved ones, got justice after all. In the end, it was their perseverance and the real strength of a family that brought the truth forward.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Carrie Baker’s death appears sudden and tragic, but inconsistencies in the scene, including a typed letter with spelling errors and a staged appearance, raise immediate suspicion.
  2. Matt Baker, her husband and a respected pastor, initially presents a consistent, grieving narrative, but his story is undermined by evidence such as phone records showing unusual activity and missing photos of the crime scene.
  3. A hidden message in Carrie’s Bible reveals her desperate concerns about Matt, expressing fear and asking for protection just days before her death.
  4. Vanessa Bulls, a young woman who had a relationship with Matt, testifies under oath that they had an affair and that Matt planned to suffocate Carrie by using sleeping pills and a pillow, with clear intent to hide the act.
  5. Dozens of other women come forward to corroborate Matt’s pattern of manipulation, coercion, and predatory behavior over the years.
  6. Despite initial police dismissal and a lack of direct evidence, Linda Doolin and her family persist, eventually filing a wrongful death lawsuit and re-examining all records.
  7. The case gains national attention when Matt gives a televised interview, using his daughters and grief to gain sympathy, further alienating Carrie’s family.
  8. After years of struggle, Matt is convicted and sentenced to 65 years in prison, with Carrie’s daughters safely protected and her legacy preserved through her family’s strength and truth-seeking.

Summary:

Carrie Baker’s sudden death at home sets off a community-wide mourning, with her husband Matt Baker emerging as a public figure of faith and resilience. However, deep suspicions arise among Carrie’s family—especially her mother, Linda Doolin—due to inconsistencies in the death scene, such as a typed letter with spelling errors, a lack of photos, and an unnaturally tidy room. These red flags, combined with Matt’s unusual phone activity and the removal of Carrie’s photos from the home, prompt Linda and her husband to investigate further.

A pivotal clue emerges when Vanessa Bulls, a young woman who had an affair with Matt, testifies that he planned to kill Carrie by suffocating her with a pillow and using sleeping pills to create a lethal-looking overdose. He had discussed the plan in detail, including how to stage the scene to appear accidental. Dozens of other women corroborate Matt’s predatory behavior, revealing a pattern of manipulation and emotional coercion.

Though initially dismissed by authorities, the evidence is gathered through legal action, leading to a wrongful death lawsuit and eventually a criminal conviction. On January 21, 2010, Matt is sentenced to 65 years in prison. The case underscores the critical role of family perseverance and truth-telling in exposing hidden crimes, ensuring that Carrie’s daughters, now safely protected, grow up with a mother’s love and legacy intact.

Her story, though tragic, becomes a powerful testament to resilience and justice.

FAQs

The letter was typed, not handwritten, unsigned, and contained spelling mistakes inconsistent with Carrie's background as a third-grade teacher and master's graduate.

Linda noticed inconsistencies in the scene, including a lack of photos, overly perfect arrangements, and Matt's unusual behavior, such as giving away Carrie's phone and removing all her photos from the home.

Vanessa, a former church attendee who had an affair with Matt, testified under oath that he planned and carried out Carrie's murder, providing detailed evidence of his actions and motives.

The expert found searches for 'overdose on sleeping pills' from March 9, 2006, and adult content during work hours, suggesting prior knowledge and intent.

Carrie wrote, 'Lord, I have so much worry and I cannot get a hold on it. I'm not sure what is going on with Matt, but Lord, help me find peace with him.'

Linda and her attorney filed the lawsuit to legally re-examine evidence, gather records, and investigate further after the police refused to reopen the case.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.