The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: How To Care Less What People Think and Stop Chasing Confidence | Mark Manson
53m 3s
Mark Manson discusses the core message behind his best-selling book, *The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck*, which reframes "not giving a fuck" as a tool to identify what truly matters in life. He argues that people are constantly comparing themselves to others—a deeply rooted evolutionary survival instinct—especially amplified by social media. The key to overcoming this is not eliminating comparison, but shifting focus to what one is willing to sacrifice or endure, which reveals deeper values. He emphasizes that confidence stems not from positive self-perception, but from competence built through repeated action and courage, illustrated by psychological experiments like snake phobia desensitization. Purpose, he says, arises when personal values align with meaningful, real-world actions. Manson also shares insights on value discovery through time audits and self-experimentation, highlighting the importance of personal authenticity. He introduces Purpose AI as a tool to democratize access to life advice, offering personalized, truthful, and non-sycophantic support. Ultimately, he urges listeners to move beyond surface-level goals and focus on what they are willing to endure, recognizing that lasting fulfillment comes from action, courage, and alignment with one’s true values.
Hello, everybody. Welcome to the 10% Happier podcast. I'm your host, Dan Harris. Today,
we're going to talk about a bunch of things that are perennial and urgent interest to
me, like how to be more confident, how to spend less time comparing yourself to other
people, and how selectively and wisely to give fewer fucks. My guest today is Mark Manson,
author of several books, including the thunderously popular The Subtle Art of Not
Giving a Fuck, one of the great book titles of all time. Fun fact, Mark's books have sold over
20 million copies. But he's not just a writer. He also has a great YouTube page where he makes
these really high quality and very, very interesting videos. And he's got a podcast
called Solved with Mark Manson. Mark Manson, thanks for coming on the show.
It's my pleasure. Thank you for having me.
I was saying this beforehand. It's like,
this is one of perhaps the worst acts of podcast host malpractice I've ever committed that I've had
this show for more than 10 years. And this is the first time you're on it.
Better late than never.
Okay. I appreciate your forgiveness. All right. So let me start with The Subtle Art of Not Giving
a Fuck, which again, is one of the best book titles ever.
Thank you.
It would be very easy to dismiss this as like a kind of nihilistic sentiment, but that is not at
all what you're pointing.
So can you hold forth on what you really mean?
Sure. I like the joke that The Subtle Art is, it's kind of a Trojan horse for a book about values.
Like I wanted to write a book about values and people's prioritizations in life and how important
those things are. But I kind of felt like nobody would actually go buy a book about values and
prioritization. So the whole not give a fuck language is just a way to like smuggle those,
that philosophy into kind of a fun, irreverent,
romp of a book. But really at its core, if you start reading the book in chapter one,
one of the first things I point out is that there actually is no such thing as not giving a fuck.
You have to care about something. And even if you attempt to care about nothing,
that in and of itself is caring about something, right? So we're kind of stuck in this like cosmic
loop of having to direct our attention and focus on something in our environment,
no matter where we are or what the situation is.
So then the question becomes, what is worth giving a fuck about? And that is the question that, A, is, I think, perennially difficult and complicated. We all struggle with it. But I think also unique to our modern times, say the post-internet age or the post-social media age, I think it has become extremely complicated to figure out what should we give a fuck about.
What is actually worth our time and attention and what is not? I think this is probably the most difficult time to figure that out in human history.
So the subtle art is to know what is worth not giving a fuck about so that you can focus on the things that are.
Correct.
And how, like, just for yourself, you're an extremely busy member of Homo sapiens.
So how. How do you decide what's worth focusing on and what's not?
So the chief heuristic that I describe in the book is to not focus so much on the benefits that you want in your life, because that's kind of our default approach to everything in our life, right?
It's like, what good feeling thing do I want? Do I want to make more money? Do I want to have more friends? Do I want to be more popular? Do I, you know, want to fix up the house?
Like, what's the positive goal?
And instead, I ask people defensively.
I focus on actually the problems and struggles that they are willing to have and that they are actually secretly kind of enjoy having, because everything in life involves a tradeoff, right?
It's easy to want to be popular.
It's easy to want to make more money.
We all want those things.
But the question is, what are we willing to give up for those things?
Like, that is actually the question that determines what our values are and who we are as individuals.
It's almost this, like, negative way into the question of what is worth caring about.
It's like, well, what is worth sacrificing for?
What am I willing to be disliked for?
You know, people ask me all the time, how do I stop caring what other people think?
And my answer, my first answer is always, well, what are you willing to be disliked for?
And if you can't answer that question easily, then that's a problem.
Arthur Brooks, the great writer, and I think most recently of Harvard's Kennedy School.
His little question is, what would you die for?
Right.
And it's very clarifying.
Yeah.
And it's a very short list for most people.
And I think it's the sort of thing that we all have to dig very deep and think very deeply about to even find an answer to that.
What's on your list?
I mean, my wife is the first thing that comes to mind.
The things I'm waffling on are some of the other associations.
Do I have any beliefs I would die for?
Like, that I would have to sit with.
I would have to sit with for a long time.
I mean, I'd like to say yes, but, you know, it would feel very heroic to say yes, but.
Are there beliefs that you're willing to be disliked for?
Oh, yeah.
I already am.
Say more.
I mean, like you, you know, I'm recording podcasts.
I'm in videos every week.
I'm posting stuff online all the time.
So it's, you know, part of our job description is haters.
So you and I are in a position in that.
Just through the act of our work, we are forced to think about what we're willing to be disliked
for, like what stance we're willing to take or what beliefs are important enough to us
to deal with, you know, the comment section.
That is kind of a clarifying filter.
But I think if if people, you know, going about their day to day life, it's probably
not something they think about very often.
Are there things that, you know, you shouldn't give a fuck about, but you do anyway, and
it's therefore a struggle for you?
Yeah, I think, you know, all of.
Kind of the superficial materialistic things.
I struggle with at times, I think, as everybody does.
I generally think I'm on the right side of of deprioritizing them.
But I do think sometimes I have a tendency to be a workaholic and I have a tendency.
I'm very competitive.
So like when I have a goal or some sort of metric I'm trying to hit, I get extremely
wrapped up in it, sometimes to the point where it where it backfires a little bit.
What did it do to your brain to have a book that was that successful?
I mean, I know there's this stat that you've sold more than 20 million copies.
I would imagine 19.5 of those millions were of the subtle art.
Yeah, I think the human mind is is really primed for kind of a slow compounding growth
over time, like whether you're adopting a new skill or becoming more confident, you
know, starting a new.
Career, I think the mind is kind of just default setting is that everything should get like
five to 10% better every single year.
And and then when something comes along and it gets 10,000% better.
Within six months, like something in your brain just kind of breaks.
And I, I really struggled with like for a while.
I struggled with the feeling of like, is this just luck?
Like, do I deserve this?
So there was this weird.
Period of like imposter syndrome, I guess I would say of just like, okay, yeah, this,
you know, I did a good thing, but it's like, I don't think I deserve all this.
You know, of this concept, hedonic adaptation.
Yes.
Where we something good, new and good happens in our life.
And we're super excited about it for 45 seconds.
And then we just bake it into our baseline expectations.
Right.
And if you experience a career dip or some project you're working on is,
and going as well as you thought, like, how do you handle that?
Especially in light of what you went through.
It was interesting.
So I did a follow-up book called everything is fucked, the book about hope.
And, and the whole process of doing that book, it was one of the hardest projects I think I've ever done in my life.
And, and most of that is because the whole time I was doing it, I knew it was going to feel like a failure, no matter what happened.
I mean, it debuted at number one on the times list and then it quickly fell off.
And I was like, oh my God.
And I was like, well, it fell off after, you know, six weeks.
So like it failed, which is absurd.
It's like completely, this is, this is like such a champagne problem, but it coming back to just the, the brutal reality of the hedonic treadmill, you can objectively know that it's not true, but it still feels that way.
You put your finger on something.
I think that we all struggle with aside from the hedonic treadmill, which is expectations.
Yeah.
And yeah, like if it, it, it expectations.
Expectations can fuck up everything.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And it's, I think the same concept can be applied to people's daily lives.
Like for example, I've observed a number of couples like friends in my, in my life that they're struggling through, through the relationship.
So they decide to get married and that, and then the marriage is this huge peak experience and they think that's going to fix it.
Right.
But then it just sets the expectations at this new level.
And so there are even more.
More disappointed afterwards.
And then they're like, well, maybe we should buy a house together.
That'll fix it.
Right.
And then it's the, they go like take out this huge mortgage.
and buy a house and it's like for three months they're ecstatic and everything's amazing and
they're decorating together and then that becomes normal and then the disappointment hits again and
it's even more painful that time and then they're like well maybe we should have a kid and then it's
you know it's like oh boy here we go with that and it's a game that our brain plays with us
consistently of like if i just have x then i'll be happy if i just have y then i'll be happy i
think there's a very fundamental evolutionary reason for it it's it's what's kept our species
striving and propagating for so long but this is why i come back to that heuristic of like okay
it's easy for us all to like think of the thing that's we think is going to make us happy but
what are you willing to struggle for what is the sacrifice you're willing to have in your life
because that is actually the more accurate metric of what you should be doing
you
one of the most potent and persistent sources of suffering in my life is this constant or seemingly
constant toppling forward into the next moment nothing that's happening right now quite does
it for me and so i'm just kind of reaching for that next thing over and over as my longtime
meditation teacher joseph goldstein likes to ask people how many slices of pizza have you eaten how
many parties have you attended how many promotions have you received and are you done of course not
we are insatiable and in this way the persistence of suffering is the most potent and persistent
of happiness can become the source of our unhappiness the good news is that another of my
favorite meditation teachers vinnie ferraro a fan favorite in the 10 happier cinematic universe
has just created a whole new batch of guided meditations to help you deal with this sense
of insufficiency and get to what he calls enoughness and these meditations are available
over on my app 10 with dan harris vinnie will be dropping them throughout the month and i'm going to
and on tuesdays throughout the month of november vinnie will be meditating with subscribers live
and taking your questions it's a vinnie ferraro festival the month of november over on 10 with
dan harris just to recap here vinnie's new meditations drop every week in the month of
november and you can join him live only in the 10 with dan harris app this brings us to something i
wanted to talk to you about in this month of november and i'm going to talk to you about
before i say what that is i want to set it up by mentioning uh or repeating what i mentioned in the
intro which is that you have a podcast called solved with mark manson and the conceit which
is really funny is that instead of doing what i do which is i do i probably over the 10 years of
this show have done 40 episodes on every problem you can think of you do one episode is super long
and you solve the problem allegedly and you solve the problem and you solve the problem and you
quote unquote solve the problem in in the episode and you've done one recently on social comparison
and one of the things you mentioned which i thought was really cool at the top of the episode
is that you learned that your podcast was not doing the numbers you was not reaching the audience you
thought it was reaching and then you started looking around at all these other schmoes who
have podcasts and comparing yourselves to them yeah so before we talk about what you learned as
an answer to that question i want to talk to you about what you learned as an answer to that question
it's a social comparison can you tell that story yeah so we the the whole concept behind solved is
is that we we take one topic we go super deep full research team spends four to six weeks
researching it my producer and i we spend two days prepping and then a full day shooting it
most episodes come out around four or five hours uh and the goal is is that it's like
it is the last podcast you should ever have to listen to on this topic it's
like everything's in there every perspective every piece of research every historical anecdote or
or uh you know wisdom tradition it will will at least touch up upon it so the funny thing is is
when we launched we had a incredibly strong launch last last year and the first three or four episodes
did amazingly well we hit all sorts of charts and spotify was really kind to us and kind of gave us
a push on their platform and um we had a we had a couple clips go viral so it was like everything
seemed amazing and then we had a couple of episodes that went viral and then we had a couple of episodes
and then uh and then i think it was like maybe three or four months and um spotify like pushed
an update to their platform saying that basically saying oh sorry guys it turns out we were counting
some things wrong and then that new update came online and it turned out that like a third of the
people were listening that we thought were so it was i remember coming into the office and
my producer was just sitting there staring at the computer screen with this like dead dead face on
just like absolutely miserable and he was just like why are we doing this this is horrible
but i mean it comes back to the hedonic treadmill thing but that was our intro to the social
comparison episode to to remind everybody that we are not immune of these things as well like
these are and this is something that i like to hit on on on my show and and and we've already
shared here but it's like i don't think any of this stuff actually like the irony of the name
of this stuff actually gets solved like you never solve social comparison you just get better at it
you never solve your confidence issues you just get better at it you learn how to manage it over
time yes this is why i like the the the title 10 happier it's just like marginal improvement over
time but so what did you learn about why social comparison is such a nagging problem for humans
it is very much a baked in part of our hard work
so if you look at um just the way that we evolved over millions of years we evolved in small
bands and tribes and really status comparison served a very very important social function
but also like a function of survival right like if if you and i are in a a prehistoric tribe
together it's important for us to know who is the best hunter who is the best fisherman who is the
organizing and rallying all the the tribe to like fight against the neighboring tribe who's trying
to take all of our resources like these are all life and death things so if you are extremely
good at something that promotes the tribe's survival you deserve that status uh and you
deserve special treatment and you deserve to be looked up to because it's just it helps everybody
survive and in that environment the flip side of that is that we all have these kind of uh
researchers call them sociometers so these these like uh these almost like gauges inside of our
heads where we are constantly subconsciously evaluating our status compared to the people
around us and what's fascinating is that it is completely contextual and relative so if you take
somebody and there's plenty of research on this if you take somebody who say is making a million
dollars a year and they live in a neighborhood where everybody else is making a hundred and
hundred thousand dollars a year uh they're gonna feel really good about themselves and if you take
that person who's making a million dollars a year and then you put them in a neighborhood where they
live around people who are making 10 million dollars a year they're gonna feel really crummy
about themselves and this happens in to all of us all the time we're in one room where we're really
competent we feel really good about our skills we have tons of relationships and we feel really good
about our status among the people around us
and then we go to a completely different room and another side of town where we have no idea what
we're doing we have no skill set we have no relationships and what do we feel insecurity
self-doubt we kind of want to shrink we want to like you know back up into the corner become a
wallflower this is all instinctual we all have it it's very natural it evolved within us uh to
promote survival and replication and it's not something you ever get rid of and it's also
something you don't want to get rid of because it is something that you don't want to get rid of
is important to to know what you're good at compared to others and what you're not so good
at compared to others like that is a useful thing to know where the problem starts is the self
judgment and the judgment of others around very arbitrary status metrics that's where we all get
into trouble the old comparison is the thief of joy thing that you yeah you can just as you said
you can be making the same income but depending on which neighborhood you live in all the time
all the sudden you're enjoying that income way less or way more um and it's a great way to just
kind of fuck your life if you can't appreciate what you have because you're measuring it against
somebody else yeah one of the things you say that i thought was really interesting is a common
complaint right now is that social comparison has been put on steroids by social media which i think
is is true i think you and i would both agree is true but you make the subtle to be a little
cute point that the for you page in other words the the move from the version of social media
where we're following our friends and seeing a curated version of our friends lives to um
a more entertainment based social media where we're scrolling and the algorithm is just
feeding us stuff it knows it it'll that we will like right has actually taken some of the sting
out of that it has i think it's replaced it with a different problem an interesting thing happened
to social media about five years ago it was innovated by tiktok so the tiktok's big innovation
was it didn't just show you people you followed it
it showed you any piece of content it thought you would enjoy. And that turned out to be extremely
effective. People spent way more time on TikTok than other platforms. So the other platforms
adopted it. So now social media is less social and it's more media. It's more just imagine
a TV. Like when we were young, we would sit at home after school and flip TV channels kind of
mindlessly until we found something that caught our attention. Now it's a TV that flips the
channels for us. It's like, this is what you're going to like next. And this is what you're going
to like next. So the benefit of that is that you
kind of do remove a lot of that highlight reel, seeing everybody's life, their highlight reels
and making the false assumption that that's their day-to-day life. A lot of that gets removed, but
the new problem that creates is that everybody kind of lives inside their own epistemic bubble.
Everybody's information diet just becomes extremely siloed. And you can have two people who
are good friends in the real world, but like they believe completely different things because the
information in the media that they've been consuming is like just completely different,
like has no relation to each other. The other thing I'll say, like kind of coming back to the
point that social comparison isn't something you get rid of. And it is actually something that is
useful. The point I'm making is that it's not something that you get rid of. It's something
that you get rid of. The point I like to make a lot, which is lost on most people, is that there is such a thing as
good social comparison, right? Like, so if you think about role models you've had in your life,
that is a form of social comparison. If you think about a hero you've had, or like somebody who's
really inspired you to do something great, that's a form of social comparison. If you think about a
family member, a mentor who's like taught you things, that's a form of social comparison,
right? It's not that we should stop
comparing ourselves to others. It's we should find good reasons to compare ourselves to good
people. And where people, that where people suffer is they are usually comparing themselves
to people that are not worth comparing themselves to, and they're comparing themselves for bad
reasons, for very superficial, unimportant reasons. Like money or fame. Totally.
Now we're going to come back to a refrain in this show and in your work. I believe you said in the
beginning that really for you, one of the things that cuts through noxious social comparison is
remembering what you care about, what you're about, values again. Right. Say more about how
that works. Well, it comes back to that line. If you're not aware of what you're willing to
be disliked for, then you're going to kind of just default to whatever you think is going to
make you liked by the most people. And the stuff that's going to make you liked by the most people
is generally the most superficial, emptiest things, right? Money, materialistic things,
beauty, wealth, whatever. When you find something that you're willing to be disliked for,
then it allows you to let go of those more superficial comparisons. Because again,
those superficial comparisons, they're always there. There's never going to be a point in
your life where you stop completely caring about money or stop completely caring about
your appearance or whether people think you're attractive or not. What changes,
is that you find things that are more important. And once you find the more important things,
it's like the volume knob on those other comparisons just gets turned way, way down.
Yeah, there's a quote, and I don't know if it's from you or from somebody who you were quoting in
the episode, but the best way to stop worrying about what other people think of you is to have
something more important than what other people think of you. Yes. Yes. And that ultimately is
a question of values. What do you recommend to people in terms of figuring out what your values
are?
So I think there's a few ways to approach it. Part of the problem is that a lot of us,
we spend our whole life kind of just defaulting to what we think the people around us will like.
There's never an opening for us to learn anything about ourselves. So quite literally,
we don't know ourselves because everything we've cared about has just been a proxy
because other people care about it. So I think the first thing is to give yourself that space,
whether it's time or a specific hobby or setting aside,
you know, a trip for yourself to like, just go explore things that you like to do for no other
reason than you like to do them and figure out what you care about when absent of any sort of
pressure or stimulation from the outside world. And I think once you create that space, what you
start to notice is that there are certain curiosities or certain desires that start to
show up naturally on their own again and again, certain preferences, certain priorities. And I
think those are the things that you want to do. And I think that's the first thing that you want
to do. And I think that's the
that you then have to make an effort to pursue consciously. And the funny thing about values,
we talked about this in our values episode is that it's not like you find one thing you care about,
and then that's, that's it, you're set. You're like, awesome, nailed it, got it figured out.
It's values, they're kind of always in this tension with one another, right? Like they're
because there's trade offs between everything in life, like in your time is always scarce,
and your attention is scarce. So like,
you know, spending more time with your family is always going to come at a cost of spending time
doing something else. And spending more time at work is going to come at a cost of, you know,
social life and family and, you know, physical health or whatever. So the more you prioritize
any one thing, you're you are, like, by definition, deprioritizing other things. And so I think,
when you create that space, and you eliminate certain things from your life as an experiment,
you kind of learn what you actually really miss and what you don't miss at all.
So you, we've been using the word values. You also did an episode on purpose.
Yes.
And, and those strike me as, if not synonymous, very, very similar.
They're related. So I think purpose, there's more of an action element to it. The best way I, I,
I like to describe it is that purpose is a sense that your time was spent well.
Right? So when people say, I want to find my purpose, or I want to feel more purpose in my life,
like, what does that actually mean? Like,
what is having more purpose in your life? I think it is the sense that you have spent your time well,
and that time is spent well based on what you care about, what you prioritize. Like,
if you're spending all your time doing stuff that doesn't matter to you, then you're going to feel
like your, your life has very little purpose. Whereas if you spend your time doing something
that does feel very meaningful and valuable to you, then you're going to feel a great sense
of purpose. Right? So you could, you could come to see what your values are, but not actually
figure out what your purpose is or live in your purpose.
Right.
So, and, and, and that Delta would create a lot of unhappiness.
Yes. Purpose is kind of what happens when your values make contact with the real world.
Got it. Got it. And if memory serves what you recommended in that, um, in that episode,
in terms of figuring out what your purpose is, is similar to what you recommended just now,
in terms of figuring out what your values are, giving yourself space to run experiments and to
tap into your own innate curiosity about like what turns you on.
Yeah. Yeah. And it's, it's with purpose. It's really interesting. So one part of it is
that there's something that you feel like you are uniquely positioned or capable of doing that most
other people are not. There's something specific about your skills, your experience, your talents,
your situation that most other people don't have. And then finding where that can contribute to
something that is valuable and meaningful for other people. Like that's, if you can find that
Venn diagram, if you can find where to point your talents and, and specific experiences in history
towards something that is useful and meaningful for, for others, like purpose naturally emerges
as a result.
One of the practical techniques that you recommended for figuring out your purpose
is to do a time audit.
Yeah.
What is that?
So a time audit,
is to at the end of a day, take like a week. And at the end of each day,
sit down for like 10, 20 minutes and actually, uh, map in how you spent
each hour of that day. Like what you were actually doing, not, not what you were supposed to be doing,
but like what you were actually doing, you know, we, we all know you were at work for eight hours,
but like, you know, were you browsing Instagram? Were you texting with your friend? Were you,
did you take a two hour lunch? Like actually color in what you spent the time doing and then
go through and, and rate from one to 10, how, how meaningful that activity felt to you?
What ends up emerging is that you find that there's probably one or two things that are
not very meaningful to you that are eating up a lot more time than you expected. And then
the things that are meaningful to you, you're like, wow, I barely spent any time this week
doing that.
I think that would be a powerful,
source of data. No question.
There's one more solved episode I want to ask you about. And then I want to ask you about this big
new project you've launched. Um, the final solved episode I want to ask you about is confidence.
I'm very curious to get to the punchline. Like how do you get more confidence? But let me start
with a definitional question. Like what is confidence and how is it different from say,
self-esteem?
I love this episode because it is,
I just, I have like a soft spot in my heart for contrarian takes. And, um,
it's interesting going into each solved episode because occasionally we find that okay yeah the
conventional wisdom is kind of dead on and it's a lot of the advice is what you would expect
sometimes you find that there's like a lot of nuance and you know it depends that's usually
the case then every once in a while you dig really deep into something and you're like oh
this people should not really care about this
this is the wrong question and confidence is one of those really it is so i shouldn't care
about being confident it is the wrong question interesting it is the wrong question and
interestingly one of the things that we uncovered when we did the episode is that for most of human
history confidence was actually a pejorative term oh so for example the term con man comes
from the term confidence man which people used to use as an insult it was it was essentially
uh
the the word that was used in the 18th and 19th century for somebody who was a fraud or a scamster
they were a confidence man it only switched in the mid-20th century and a lot of it traced back
to norman vincent peel but um the the guy who wrote the power of positive yes yes uh who happened
to be trump's personal pastor yes which explains a lot yes so confidence it is the way peel
described it is he said that basically he said you need to
feel good about what you're about to do in order to do it well and i think this this assumption
suits our intuition quite a bit right because if you think about all the things that make you
anxious or all the things that you're insecure about you don't want to do them and so you imagine
that if i just felt better about it i would be able to do it well by the 1970s and 1980s they
found pretty consistently that no actually that's not the case at all like making you
feel good about doing something uh doesn't actually make you perform any better um and
in many cases it just kind of deludes you into thinking you did a good job even though you
didn't the way confidence actually works confidence is not the input of good action it is the output
of good action confidence is built and accumulated by building evidence that you are capable of
handling something so it's the more you speak in front of a group of people the more confident you
become than the more confident you become than the more confident you become than the more confident
that you're able to speak in front of a group of people because you have accumulated a lot of
evidence that you're able to do it now obviously this does not solve the problem of people who are
like super anxious and freaking out before doing something and so the conclusion of of the episode
is that it's not confidence that people actually need it's courage and courage it turns out is
it's a completely different thing to develop and it requires a progressive desensitization
a practice of being able to confront difficult things being able to manage failure well
being able to get back up after a setback like these are all kind of mental muscles that we have
to to build and practice and once we build that courage muscle confidence just starts happening
as a as a side effect of being able to successfully do the actions we want to do so we should build
courage and an emergent property will be confidence correct it reminds me of i think it was
john wayne who said courage is being afraid but saddling up anyway yeah yeah and i talked about i
i'm a extremely extremely anxious person and i have a son who's quite anxious and we talk about
this a lot which is you know courage is being afraid and doing it anyway and and um but you
that doesn't mean going you
you said selective and systematic desensitization so it's like going in a stepwise manner to build
the courage thereby the confidence to do things over time yes so in the the episode so this was
primarily discovered by a famous psychologist named bandura and he did a series of experiments
at stanford where he took people who are incredibly afraid of snakes like
intense snake phobias and he brought them into a room with a a window into another room and the
the other room was full of snakes and of course they freaked out they screamed they wanted to
leave all this stuff he kept them there until they were finally kind of calmed down and they
were comfortable at least being in the next room okay next step open the door all the people they
start freaking out they're like oh my god close the door i can't handle it's too much blah blah blah
a few minutes go by they calm down they realize it's okay next step why don't you step into the
next room of course panic freak out on and on it goes long story short within a single day it took
like eight or ten hours but within a single day he got each of these people with snake phobias
to actually hold snakes
and interestingly afterwards he followed up with them six or eight weeks later
and and asked them how they felt and whether they were still as afraid of snakes or not and
they were still a little afraid but definitely much less afraid but a lot of them started
reporting all these other kind of side benefits in their lives they realized that like actually
they were speaking up more at work and they were uh you know taking more accountability um in
fights with their partner and and able to like have difficult conversations a little bit better
and so what bender noticed is that there was something about competence developing competence
that gave people the evidence i can do hard things i can handle difficult situations i can uh i can
bounce back from being under pressure and that that doesn't it starts being domain specific but
then it bleeds into the other areas of your life so i think that's a really good point and i think
i totally buy that it seems at least related to the concept of having a growth mindset like that
you are capable of change in fact looked at through a buddhist lens you are constituted
by change like you are nothing but a process it also reminds me of the fact that the in if you
look at all of the the research into habit change the number one advice is always start small yep
because what you want to do is put some wins on the board and then you start to gain confidence
yeah you start to and and and probably more importantly you should you start to develop
a new identity yeah i'm the type of person who exercises even if it's a run around the block
i'm the type of person who meditates even if it's only one minute of meditation
yeah all of these things this building of courage and competence seems like i think your point is
let's aim for that and the confidence will come as a consequence but if you aim for confidence
it's uh kind of starting to grow and it's going to start to grow and it's going to start to grow
at the wrong end yes and you can get yourself into a lot of trouble so you asked about self-esteem
earlier and part of the offshoot of kind of peels assumption was the self-esteem movement in the 60s
and 70s and the self-esteem movement was built off the idea that if we just make people feel
really good about themselves they will do good things and this emerged from they did a bunch
of research they found that generally students who perform better in school tended to feel really
good about themselves uh
people who are more successful professionally they felt really good about themselves you know
on and on and on they looked at all these different measurements and and people generally had a very
positive self-image the problem is is that they were missing the cause and effect there like the
it turns out in hindsight the student that did extremely well and went to harvard they felt good
about themselves because they did extremely well and went to harvard it's not the feeling good
about themselves that that that caused that it was the effect and the the thing that kind of blew
this up
uh in the 90s uh psychologist by the name of roy barmeister um was actually tasked to do kind of a
large meta-analysis of self-esteem research because i mean the self-esteem research and and and
practices it was instituted into our education policy everybody gets a trophy yes exactly like
in the in the 80s 70s and 80s it was like education systems were actively teaching the
teachers how to give their students self-esteem it's your generation you're a millennial i'm a
gen x we were we were you know i went to a camp where they literally taught us how to box as a way
to deal with our conflicts unlike the with the millennials that would never fly i definitely
got it yeah you did you got it yeah yeah so barmeister he started he kind of took all the
data and ran a bunch of uh research himself and came back and he said yeah it turns out there's
nothing there not only does it turn out that there's nothing there but it turns out that
there's potentially a lot of negative side effects of having a high self-esteem narcissism exactly
so for example he went to maximum security prisons and started measuring the self-esteem
of violent criminals and it turned out the more violent the criminal the higher the self-esteem
yes you know and in the episode uh my producer and i we spent a lot of time kind of digging into
kind of the psychological biases and and um all the ways that we we kind of misattribute
our own skill and and our own abilities to to explain why why pursuing confidence can
can get you into trouble but you know the short version is that
we just don't really have an accurate view of ourselves most of the time
And, and so the only way to have an accurate view of yourself is to actually go do the thing and see what happens. And so that's why the only healthy version of confidence is, is the end product of the action, not, not the input of it.
Well said. Very helpful, actually. Okay. Before I let you go, before I lose you, I want to ask you about, you've got a big new, um, project. I did not mention this in the intro because as I told you before we started rolling, there are some pretty negative feelings about AI these days.
Yes.
It's weird because a lot of people are using it, even though they say they hate it. Um, and I'll, I'll just be open before anybody starts to get mad at me.
Yeah.
I may have all of your same concerns about AI, but I, I do use it.
Right.
Um, you have launched, is it to call it a chat bot? Is that accurate?
Yeah. I, we call it an AI mentor, but.
Okay.
It, the main, there is other functionality, but the main functionality is chat.
And it's, it's called Purpose AI.
Yes.
And the cool thing about Purpose AI is it's not sycophantic. It actually talks to you the way a good friend would talk to you, which is it will tell you the truth without being a dick about it.
Yes.
Um, so just say more about the project.
So I'll, I'll, I'll kind of talk about where it came from and, and make my case to maybe the more skeptical listeners.
The, the first thing, you know, when ChatGPT came out, everybody was using it.
I started to become very surprised and startled by how many people in my personal life were telling me that they were going to ChatGPT with deep personal issues.
Yeah. I do it.
Yeah. And kind of using it as a, like a therapist or a coach.
Yes.
And so I went and I,
I tried it out and sure enough, like there's a lot of, it gives you, it can give you a lot of great information.
Yes.
It can also make some stuff up.
A million percent.
And it also kisses your ass.
Yes.
Right. So it's.
Yes. Yeah. I kind of like that part a little bit.
I mean, yeah. Hey, we all need it sometimes, but it's, I mean, it's to the point, like I joke around with my co-founder that it's like you, you could, you could rob a bank and, and be in a high speed police chase and ask ChatGPT.
How do I get away from the police and ChatGPT would be like, wow, you're so brave.
Yeah.
That must be really hard for you.
Exactly.
Although it does have all of this language and it doesn't, it's, it's trying not to get sued a lot.
Like if I ask it certain questions, it's always like, talk to your doctor or et cetera, et cetera.
That's because they have been sued a lot, but.
Fair enough.
So I started to observe this and, and one of the things that I have been keenly aware of being in this industry for almost,
almost 20 years now is that there is a, a shocking lack of, uh, accessibility to good life advice, to good mental healthcare, to good coaching and mentoring.
Um, there, there's some pretty harrowing statistics around this that for every, I believe it's for every therapist or counselor who's working.
There are 48 people who want access to a therapist or a counselor, but don't, don't either don't have access to one or don't have the, the means to.
Okay.
Um, so that it's a market that the demand vastly outstrips the supply.
So this, this idea, I mean, you see it in a few places that, um, that AI is going to put doctors and therapists and, um, and coaches out of business.
I think there's absolutely no way because first of all, there's just not enough doctors and coaches and therapists and counselors in the world for, for all the people who need one.
So that, that's point number one.
And then point number two is another tension or struggle that I've felt for a long time in this industry is, is that generally the things that work best don't scale very well.
And the things that scale really well don't work the best.
Right.
So you and I have both written books.
Um, you and I both do podcasts.
They're great.
Right.
They're very helpful.
I've, I've read a lot of books that are helpful.
I've listened to a lot of podcasts are helpful, but you know, they move the needle a little.
Like it's, it's very rare that.
You know, something, uh, a podcast episode is going to take you from zero to 10 on an issue in your life.
Um, whereas if you do sit down and spend a lot of time with a really good coach or counselor or whoever it is within a few months, you can move the needle a lot, but that doesn't scale.
And, and it's not to mention it's hard to find someone who's really a good fit for you and all that.
So I started to see the opportunity of how AI could supplement the.
The overwhelming demand in the market and give access to people who normally wouldn't have access to, to good advice.
There is research on AI driven life advice.
Um, it is net positive.
It is good by and large.
Um, it is not as good as a, a good therapist or a good coach, but it is still good and it does have a positive effect.
Um, and we've already seen from our users that it's had a drastic positive effect on people's lives.
And the fact that it's.
It's always there, it's always available.
You know, you wake up at 2:00 AM freaking out about something you can't, you can't call your therapist, right?
So, but you can talk to an AI and it's going to be awake.
It's going to have the exact same quality of answer.
It would at 2:00 PM.
Um, it's not going to judge you.
It's not going to scold you for, you know, losing sleep.
It's so I, I do think there is a role that it can play in, in this industry and I am excited for the potential of it.
Okay.
So that's.
That, that's my defense.
I rest my case.
I, I, I, I'm, I, I'm not the one, I'm not the one who's skeptical.
I'm, I'm just channeling those who are skeptical in the audience.
There is one thing I'm skeptical about though.
It's, it's more from a business perspective.
Okay.
Uh, why would I download purpose AI rather than just keep my subscription to, to Claude or ChatGPT and just advise it.
to not be sycophantic? A couple reasons. One, I mean, they have gotten better, the main models,
they have gotten less sycophantic over time. I'd say the biggest thing that we do that
is different than what they do. I mean, first of all, our product is specifically catered for this
use case. So all the prompting, all the systems, the databases, everything is like specifically
designed for this. The other thing that we do is that when you sign up, you're taken through an
onboarding process. And what that onboarding process is doing is that it is doing a personality
assessment and getting an understanding of who you are at a psychological level.
We get your top three values and we give you the Schwartz values evaluation. And so we pull your
top three values and then we give you a big five assessment. So we get your big five personality and
we have like an attachment quiz so we can figure out your attachment type. With that, all of those
things kind of fed into the model. It will know how to give you personalized advice based on,
you know, combining that with your unique situation. It can give you much more personalized
advice that is actually credible towards who you are psychographically than say, you know,
just a generic model that, you know, you asked for help with your groceries and what the weather is
going to be tomorrow and all that. Final question. We do this little segment. It's called What's Good?
I'm curious, like, is there a book, movie, little life hack, um, anything that you would recommend
that's, uh, top of mind for you? It's funny that we were just talking about AI. One of my favorite
things to do recently, my wife and I, we went online when we found, I think it was the New
York Times list of a hundred greatest films ever. Yes. Yes. And we just marked down all of all the
films that at least one of us had not seen. And so we have this list of like 50 movies. Yes. We
watch one or two a week, but so here's the hack. Watch something, you know, like we watched David
Lynch's Mulholland Drive recently. Total mind fuck, like great movie, but also you get to the end and
you're like, what did I just watch? Like what happened? Here's my favorite thing. Go on Claude
or chat GPT and prompt it and say, you are an expert movie critic. I want you to give me a full
of Mulholland Drive. Give me the backstory. How, how did it go into production? What was David
Lynch's creative process? What were the interesting things that happened during production? What was
the critical reception at the time? How has it aged? Uh, what's the cultural impact it's had?
Yes. And it gives you the best 10, 20 page report. It is so fascinating. You learn so many
like interesting tidbits and like creative decisions that happened. And,
and it's just created like such a fun intellectual experience for my wife and I it's, it's like one of
our favorite things to do on the weekend. That's so great. I love it. And funny. It's funny because
what my, my, my what's good is actually quite similar. I actually was looking through the New
York times list of 100 best films of the 21st century the other day and listing the ones I've
been giving my son. I've been giving him the best films of the 21st century. I've been giving him
my son a cinematic education. Nice. He's almost 12 and rejects almost everything I say, but has
actually been very open to this. And his wife, he's like, daddy, like what's the next movie we
should see? So I was, I was harvesting from that list movies that I think he could watch. Um,
But anyway, one of the movies we watched recently that I'm going to recommend now that it wasn't on that list is we've been on a space jag.
We saw Project Hail Mary a couple months ago when it came out.
And he was turning, he kept turning to me during the movies like, Daddy, this is the best movie ever, right?
This is amazing.
And so we went and watched like Interstellar and all these other space movies, some of them good, some of them bad.
One we watched recently that I kind of had a positive memory of, but forgot how good it is.
And maybe it's because the star is so controversial and easy to dismiss.
There's a Tom Cruise movie called Edge of Tomorrow.
Have you ever seen it?
Oh, I think back when it came out.
It's like 10 years old.
Yeah.
And it's basically the best version.
It's not explicitly a video game movie, but it's kind of the best version of the spirit of a video game.
It's taken into a movie because it's about this guy who dies and gets a new life every time and like starts over in the game.
Yeah.
And it's extremely well done.
And I'm not, I have a lot of mixed feelings about Tom Cruise.
I covered Scientology when I was a reporter.
Yeah.
And so like, yeah, I had a lot of interactions with the church and, um, but he's great in the movie.
Emily Blunt's great in the movie and, um, my son loved it.
So if you're looking for a space.
Edge of Tomorrow.
Nice.
This has been a total pleasure.
Like I said, can I fucking believe it's taken this long to have you on the show?
I mean, but I'm better late than never and it's so cool to meet you.
So thank you for your time.
And I just want to remind everybody before I let you go of all the stuff that you're doing that people should check out.
His first book was called The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck.
He's got a YouTube channel where he makes all sorts of cool videos on that YouTube channel and on any podcast channel.
You can get his podcast, which is called Solved with Mark Manson.
And if you don't hate, hate AI, uh, he's got, uh, Purpose AI, uh, available in any app store.
How'd I do?
Amazing.
Thank you.
All right.
Mark Manson.
Thank you.
Thank you very much for watching and or listening today.
Really appreciate it.
If you want to hook me up and I know a podcast hosts ask for this all the time, but there's a reason why we asked for it because it's genuinely helpful.
If you want to hook me.
And my team up, follow us and like us and, uh, rate us and review us on whatever platform you're consuming the show right now, share with your friends, follow us on social media.
It all genuinely helps us grow now onto the credits.
Thank you so much to everybody who works so hard to make this show.
10% happier is produced by Tara Anderson, Marissa Schneiderman, DJ Kashmir, David Hart, and Hayden broom.
Post-production is handled by the great folks over at green horn creative and Nick Thornton.
Thorburn of the great indie rock band islands wrote our theme.
Thank you for listening.
Deuces.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The "Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck" is not nihilistic but a framework for prioritizing values by identifying what truly matters, not what is superficially appealing.
True focus comes from reflecting on what one is willing to sacrifice or endure, rather than chasing desired benefits, which reveals deeper personal values.
Social comparison is an evolutionary survival mechanism, often rooted in status, and is exacerbated by social media, which creates insular information bubbles and false self-evaluations.
The solution to social comparison lies in cultivating values and purpose—specifically, discovering what one is willing to be disliked for, which naturally reduces obsession with external approval.
Confidence is not a feeling but an outcome of competence and courage built through consistent action, not through positive self-talk or feeling good about oneself.
Purpose emerges when one’s values align with real-world actions, especially when they leverage unique skills to contribute meaningfully to others.
Purpose AI offers accessible, personalized mental health and life advice, designed to be truthful and non-sycophantic, filling a gap in mental healthcare access.
The most effective life advice is gained through experiential learning and action, not through passive reflection or generic prompts.
Summary:
Mark Manson discusses the core message behind his best-selling book, *The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck*, which reframes "not giving a fuck" as a tool to identify what truly matters in life. He argues that people are constantly comparing themselves to others—a deeply rooted evolutionary survival instinct—especially amplified by social media. The key to overcoming this is not eliminating comparison, but shifting focus to what one is willing to sacrifice or endure, which reveals deeper values.
He emphasizes that confidence stems not from positive self-perception, but from competence built through repeated action and courage, illustrated by psychological experiments like snake phobia desensitization. Purpose, he says, arises when personal values align with meaningful, real-world actions. Manson also shares insights on value discovery through time audits and self-experimentation, highlighting the importance of personal authenticity.
He introduces Purpose AI as a tool to democratize access to life advice, offering personalized, truthful, and non-sycophantic support. Ultimately, he urges listeners to move beyond surface-level goals and focus on what they are willing to endure, recognizing that lasting fulfillment comes from action, courage, and alignment with one’s true values.
FAQs
It's not about nihilism, but about values and priorities. The book uses a playful tone to discuss what truly matters in life, emphasizing that you must care about something—there's no such thing as not caring at all. The real question is what you're willing to sacrifice for.
Instead of focusing on what you want to gain, ask what problems you're willing to endure or accept. This reveals your true values. For example, what are you willing to be disliked for? The deeper answer often points to what’s most important to you.
Our brains evolved to compare ourselves to others for survival. This creates constant self-evaluation based on status, which can be harmful when focused on superficial metrics like money or fame. It’s not about eliminating comparison, but choosing wise, meaningful comparisons.
Ask yourself what you're willing to be disliked for. If you can’t answer that, you’re likely defaulting to superficial concerns. When you have a deeper value—like your beliefs or family—you naturally stop being swayed by surface-level judgments.
Confidence is an outcome of success, not a feeling before action. Courage is the ability to face fear and failure. Confidence builds as you gain competence through repeated actions, like overcoming anxiety or trying new things.
Step away from daily life and spend time doing things you enjoy for no reason—this reveals what truly motivates you. Track your time to see what activities feel meaningful. Purpose emerges when your values align with real-world actions that matter to others.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.