Go back

The Stylist (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)

37m 16s

The Stylist (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)

In 1995, 27-year-old hair stylist Dana Satterfield was murdered in her salon in Robuck, South Carolina, after being beaten, sexually assaulted, and strangled and tied to a water heater. The initial investigation relied on witness testimony describing a young white man in his 20s, around 170 pounds, who climbed out of a window and fled. Despite multiple leads—including a blue-and-white SUV and public tips—no suspect matched the physical or DNA evidence for years. The case remained unsolved until 2005, when a mechanic named Michael Pace recognized Dana’s daughter at a gas station and revealed that he had known the killer, Jonathan Vick, a 17-year-old boy from a regular client’s family. Jonathan had pursued Dana romantically, and after the murder, threatened Michael with violence if he disclosed the relationship. Michael, fearing for his safety, kept the secret for over a decade. When confronted with Dana’s daughter's resemblance to Dana, Michael confessed. DNA testing later confirmed that Jonathan Vick’s biological sample matched the crime scene evidence. Authorities arrested and eventually convicted him of murder and sexual assault, sentencing him to life in prison. The case highlights how personal relationships, hidden motives, and the persistence of evidence can lead to long-overdue justice, even in seemingly unsolvable crimes.

Transcription

6834 Words, 37317 Characters

English
One morning, in 2005, a mechanic who was working at a gas station near Spartanburg, South Carolina heard the bell on the front door of the shop start to jingle. And so naturally he looked up to see who was coming into the store, and it was just this young blonde woman who he had never seen before, but immediately he was drawn to her face. It was like there was just something about her, like some level of familiarity, like he had seen her before or something, and he's just like staring at her as she walks up and goes to the counter right in front of him, and as she's asking for an oil change and just going about her business, the mechanic puts it together, and he realizes why he knows her, and suddenly he's hit with just this incredible wave of sadness and regret and just guilt, and he immediately knew what he had to do. But before we get into that story, if you're a fan of the strange dark and mysterious delivered in story format, then you've come to the right place, because that's all we do, and we upload two, three, even four times every week. So if that's of interest to you, the next time the follow button is on vacation, go ahead and put a sign up in their front yard telling everybody where their spare key is, and also have a list of all the valuable items that can be found inside of their home. Okay, let's get into today's story. [Music] Around 7pm on Monday, July 31st, 1995, a 27-year-old hair stylist named Dana Satterfield stood behind a barber chair inside of her salon in the small town of Robuck South Carolina. She was cutting a woman's hair for the last appointment of the day, and she was also chatting with the client while she worked. But just then, as Dana was doing this, she heard the sound of the front door opening, and she turned around and glanced over her shoulder, and she saw a woman named Diane Harris, who was a saleswoman, who was on her way out. So Diane, that whole afternoon, had been going up and down the block, trying to sell cleaning products, basically going door-to-door, and Dana had let her into her store, and had actually bought a bottle of cleaner that she didn't really need, really just because she hated turning people away. And so now, Dana called out a goodbye to Diane, and Diane, she smiled and waved back as she left, and then Dana just kind of forgot about her and went back to cutting hair. And the woman in the chair, whose hair Dana was cutting, she was a regular. And in fact, these days, Dana had a lot of regulars because her salon had become quite popular. Despite the fact, it actually was inside of a converted trailer, so not really a traditional, you know, commerce space, and it was situated between a gas station and a liquor store. Like her store, you know, despite that, this was sort of like one of the hottest slons in town, which was great for Dana. Dana typically cut hair from nine in the morning, all the way until pretty late at night, and generally her clientele were like neighborhood moms, and some teenagers from the local high school. The schedule was definitely intense, but she could make it work because her husband Mike was home in the evenings to watch their two kids. However, that arrangement was very likely going to end because Dana was unfortunately considering a divorce. In fact, she'd already reached out to a lawyer and was going to meet with him tomorrow. But as Dana was, you know, thinking about the divorce and just getting sort of nervous automatically just from considering what was going to happen here, she just kind of pushed it all out of her mind and thought, you know what, for now, I'm just going to cut hair and not think about anything else. About an hour later, around eight 10 p.m., Dana took off the salon cap from her client shoulders, and she couldn't even help it. She just immediately exhaled with relief because she was now officially done cutting hair for the day. The long day was over. The woman whose hair had just been cut, she got up and she thanked Dana and she pulled some cash out of her purse to pay her, and then actually she offered to stay with Dana until she was ready to leave. That way they could, you know, walk out together since, you know, it's dark out, it's late, you know, keep each other safe. And Dana, you know, she politely declined, but she did understand why the woman would offer, because they'd often talked to the two of them about how Dana did have to occasionally deal with, you know, inappropriate attention from male clients. But, you know, Dana, despite talking about this with this woman and with other women as well, she was sort of used to it by now. You know, she was used to the man and the way they kind of talked to her and the way they acted around her, so she wasn't that worried about it. And so the woman, the client, she just said, "Good night," and paid Dana, and then she left. And then once she was out the door, Dana flipped the door sign to show closed to anybody outside, and then she began sweeping up the hair. And then a little while later, when Dana was just about done sweeping, she heard the sound of the door, the one that now had the clothes sign on it, open up again. And Dana, as soon as she heard that sound, she assumed it must be a late walk-in. And normally she would have tried to squeeze in one last cut if somebody was that desperate, but tonight she really needed to get back home, so she could prepare for her meeting with the divorce lawyer tomorrow. So she turned around to tell this customer that unfortunately she really was closed and they'd have to come back another time, but when she saw who was actually standing in the doorway, she just stopped and smiled. About 20 minutes later, Diane Harris, the cleaning product saleswoman from earlier, she was walking back through Dana's parking lot. And as she did, she noticed that the lights were still on inside of Dana's salon, but the shades to the front of the store were now drawn. But as Diane is walking past the storefront sort of taking stock of this, she hears this really loud thump come from inside of Dana's salon inside of the trailer. In fact, the thump was so loud, Diane stopped walking, and she just stood there, you know, staring at the windows that had the blinds drawn, just trying to make sense of what that was, you know, was Dana gonna come out or something, is she okay? And then all of a sudden, as she's staring at this trailer, she saw a small window around the side of the trailer suddenly slid open. And then once it was open, the window screen suddenly popped out, like it came out and fell to the ground, and then a moment later, this young Caucasian man wearing a gray shirt and some blue jeans, climbed out of the window and dropped down to the ground. And Diane, she's staring at this guy, and the man, you know, whoever this was, he turned, and he looked right at her, like they made eye contact. And for a second, the two of them just froze and just stared back and forth at each other. But then Diane, she just started screaming, because clearly this guy must have just broken into Dana's salon, then probably robbed it. And on top of that, the guy, he looked real panicked, and then a second later, he took off running back toward the gas station down the block. And Diane, you know, she didn't know what to do, she was scared, so she just turned and bolted the opposite direction, and she kept on going until she reached a house that had the lights on. And so, not even knowing who owned this place, she just ran right up to the front door and began pounding on it until the owner opened up, and Diane shouted at them to call the police. A few minutes later, around 8.45 pm, Deputy John Burnett of the Spartanburg County Sheriff's Department was out on patrol when he got a call from dispatch about a break-in at a hair salon in Robuck. Burnett was the closest unit to the hair salon, so he immediately sped right to the address. He pulled up, right outside the salon, he hopped out of his cruiser, and now with his pistol drawn, because he didn't really know what he was walking into, he approached the trailer. And immediately he could see that the front door to the trailer was cracked open, so Burnett he walked up, and he pushed the door the rest of the way in, and he immediately called out to introduce himself. But there was no response, it's quiet inside the trailer, he kind of poked his head in, and it's all lit up, but it's just kind of like an empty space, there's just like a typical looking salon in here. So Burnett, he stepped inside the trailer, and he kind of just slowly began walking around, you know, it's not a huge space, he's just kind of looking for any sign of problems in here, and there was nothing until he reached a door at the back. He opened the door, and immediately he just froze. Burnett was looking into this small room that was sort of like a half-bathroom, half laundry room. There was a toilet, washer dryer, there was a hot water heater, and there was also a young woman who was tethered to the water heater. There was some kind of strap that was wrapped around her neck, and this woman was clearly dead. She was wearing this very bloody shirt with her pants, pulled down to her ankles, and then, you know, from what you could see, you know, the parts of her body that were exposed, they were covered in bruises and cuts. And basically, everything around her was sort of covered in blood spatter. The room was just a complete nightmare, which obviously told Burnett that this was almost certainly a murder, and more than that, there had been a pretty vicious struggle here before she died. And so Burnett, you know, for a moment, he just stood there taking this all in, you know, after he did that, he pulled out his radio, and he called into this patch to tell them what he'd found. The next morning, a homicide detective named Rick Gregory sat at his desk in the Spartanburg County Sheriff's Office, reviewing crime scene photos from the hair salon. The victim, 27-year-old Dana Satterfield, had been savagely beaten and ultimately strangled to death, and then she was left strapped to her salon's water heater by the neck, and Gregory strongly suspected that she'd been sexually assaulted at some point as well. Interestingly, he did note though that the killer, or killers, had not touched Dana's purse, or the money that was in the salon's cash box. Both of which were still clearly at the salon when police arrived, so it seemed like robbery couldn't have been the motive. What struck Gregory the most about this murder was just the sheer brutality. The sexual motive was fairly obvious, but the way Dana had been so badly beaten and then also fastened to the water heater, it seemed like the killer or killers must have had something personal against Dana. And so Gregory, he continued to sift through the photos and then at some point he stepped them aside and he picked up a small planner that the investigative team had recovered from inside of Dana's salon, and this planner was full of clients' names and phone numbers along with Dana's daily schedule. According to the planner, Dana's last scheduled appointment had been for 7 pm on the night she was killed. Gregory had already contacted that client and confirmed that Dana had definitely been alive when that client left, which was at about 8-10 pm. So basically Dana's time of death would have been sometime between 8-10 and 8-30 pm that same night, because that's when the saleswoman, Diane, who was outside, that's when she saw that man climbing out of the window. However, what really caught Gregory's attention was that Dana actually had an appointment with a divorce attorney the day after she was killed. She was supposed to go see this divorce attorney like 12 hours after she was murdered. And Gregory had no idea if this was, you know, her first meeting with a divorce attorney or if she was, you know, 20 meetings deep and this divorce is already well on its way. He didn't know. And so now, Gregory's thinking, you know, my first move here to investigate this case is I need to call Dana's husband. On the morning of August 1st, 1995, the day after Dana's satir field was killed, detective Rick Gregory sat across from Dana's husband, Mike, inside of an interview room at the Spartan Bird County Sheriff's office. And the first thing Gregory noticed about Mike was just his sheer size. He was really tall. He was very heavy-set and just generally enormous. Now, Gregory had not been at the salon the night before, but he had heard from people who had been there at the crime scene that Mike at some point had shown up right outside of the building while the police were, you know, collecting evidence. And apparently, he had tried to force his way inside and it had taken multiple deputies to physically restrain him. And so just based on that, you know, and also the way he looked, it seemed like this guy was really strong, certainly would have made it pretty easy for him to overpower and strangle his wife and then, you know, fix her to the water heater the way the killer clearly had. But right now, in this moment, in the interview room, Mike actually didn't look dangerous at all. He was an emotional wreck. He was sobbing about how everyone had loved Dana and how she hadn't had an enemy in the world. So Gregory, you know, sensing that this was obviously a very sensitive moment for Mike, he just let Mike talk for a bit. And then at some point, Gregory did begin to sort of dial in their conversation and he began to ask Mike about his relationship with Dana, about their marriage. Gregory was obviously very curious about how Mike was going to respond to, you know, questions about his marriage, because from Gregory's perspective, he knew Dana was meeting with a divorce attorney a day after she was killed. Clearly things were not all perfect back home, however, when he asked Mike to talk about his marriage, Gregory was generally surprised that Mike just sort of downplayed their issues. He said that they had been working through some things recently, like it wasn't perfect, but he did talk about their marriage like it was basically solid. He did not sound like a man who expected to get divorced. And so Gregory just again, to see how he reacted, he began to press Mike a bit harder. And he actually said to Mike, like, hey, do you know that your wife was planning to meet with a divorce lawyer, like literally a day after she was killed? And Mike, when he heard this, he genuinely seemed pretty caught off guard by it. And he said, no, I had no idea about that. And he also said, you know, even if she went and saw that lawyer, I don't think that means we were about to get divorced. I think that, you know, at worst, it seems like she was maybe more upset about things than I was, but I think that we still had quite a ways to go before divorce was going to happen. Now the way that Mike was minimizing his marital issues did strike Gregory as being fairly suspicious here. But at the same time, there were a few facts that made Gregory sort of question whether Mike could have actually killed Dana himself. Diane Harris, the saleswoman who had called the police, she had described seeing that man jump out of the salon window around a 30. And she described this guy who now police believed was the killer as being a white man, probably in his 20s, somewhere around maybe 170 pounds. But Mike, while he was white, was 33 and probably weighed like twice as much as this person was presumed to have weighed. He's like 300 plus pounds. And so Gregory doubted that Mike could have been the guy jumping out the salon window. Just was like impossible. Also Mike had an alibi. Detective Gregory knew that Dana had died sometime between 8.10 pm and 8.30 pm. And Mike, during that time, was at home with his and Dana's kids like the whole time. So for a whole combination of reasons, it was really hard to see how Mike could have been the one to literally kill Dana. But that didn't rule out the possibility that maybe he had hired somebody else to do it. After all, it did seem like they were maybe getting a divorce that Mike acted like wasn't really happening, but maybe he was aware, maybe he was upset, you know, there's mode of there. So Gregory just asked Mike if he wouldn't mind submitting to a polygraph test, having his fingerprints taken and also taking a blood sample. And Mike, without any hesitation, said yes. A couple hours later, Detective Gregory walked up to a group of desks in the Sheriff's Department bullpen. Mike had passed his polygraph test, and so Gregory had let him go. And now Gregory was on his way to check in with the rest of the investigative team to see what kind of progress they had made. And it would turn out they'd actually come up with a pretty huge clue. After canvassing the neighborhood, they'd talk to a man who remembered seeing a distinctive blue and white SUV that was parked near Dana's salon around the time she was killed. And so now Gregory not only had a description of the killer, very likely the killer, but he also had a description of the vehicle it was used. And so he told his team to get both of those descriptions in front of the public immediately. Over the next few days, Dana's story was all over the news, and posters began going up all over Robuck with a composite sketch of the killer and also a picture of the SUV. And right away after this began happening, calls started pouring in from people who thought they recognized the sky. And so Gregory, as they're getting these tips, he told his investigative team to follow up on everything, while he himself focused on Dana's immediate circle. You went through a planner and began reaching out to all her friends and her family. And as Gregory began speaking to each of the people in her inner circle, it was like everybody kind of said the same thing about her. The Dana was just kind to everyone and sort of beloved by the whole town. A few of her friends did mention that sometimes Dana would get unwanted attention from male clients, but no one had a specific name to give Gregory. So after all these interviews, Gregory didn't identify anybody with a real motive. The only person who appeared to have a motive was Dana's husband Mike, who so far had an alibi and had passed his polygraph. But then, about a week after the murder, Gregory received a call from the Forensics Lab because they had a couple of interesting things to share. The first was that they had recovered male DNA from Dana's body. This was obviously a huge deal because it could eventually be used to prove who the killer was. The second discovery the lab had made involved a fingerprint from the water heater inside of Dana's salon. The lab had analyzed it and they had found that it appeared to be a perfect match for Mike, Dana's husband. Now Gregory was very confident that Mike was not the young looking man, you know, the 170 pound guy that Diane had seen jumping out of that window. But this print still put Mike in that backroom in the exact spot where the killer had stood. So considering Gregory didn't have a whole lot else to go on, he called Mike back up and told him he needed to come back in again. The next morning, Detective Gregory watched as Mike was once again hooked up to a polygraph machine. He had immediately agreed to be tested again after being confronted with his fingerprint, which he swore there was an innocent explanation for. According to Mike, he had been the one who installed that water heater. He'd put it in just, you know, a few weeks before Dana was murdered. Gregory thought this sounded like awfully coincidental timing. So he just wanted to make sure and basically run Mike through another test and just see what the test said. So the question started and Mike began answering them one by one, like it wasn't just about the print. He began being asked questions about the entire murder. He swore he didn't kill his wife. He said he didn't know who did kill his wife, and he didn't know about any plots to kill his wife. And the polygraph, as he, you know, answered these questions, it held steady the whole way through, indicating Mike was telling the truth. Once the polygraph test was over and Mike was gone, Gregory just sat at his desk feeling really frustrated. He knew that polygraph tests were not foolproof, but now with two passing scores, and Mike not matching the physical profile and having an alibi, there just was nothing to hold him on. Now, the DNA. Analysis might come back and completely change this, but for now, it was time to move on. So, Gregory turned his focus to the tips that had been coming in from the public. And most were dead ends, but one kept coming up over and over again. Ever since those posters had gone up around town, the investigative team had been inundated with calls about a very specific blue and white SUV that appeared to match the description that was driving around Robuck. In fact, there have been so many calls about it that traffic cops in Robuck had pulled it over multiple times already. The driver of said vehicle was this local woman whose name was Mary Ann Vick, and she had not been cooperative when she was pulled over. In fact, just a few days ago, she'd gone to the press to complain about how she was being harassed by the police just because of the car she was driving. But now, as Gregory is thinking about this this vehicle that keeps coming up, he thought that, you know, maybe he recognized Mary Ann's name from somewhere. And on a hunch, he reached across his desk and he picked up Dana's planner and he began flipping through it again. And a moment later, he realized his hunch had been right. Mary Ann Vick's name was in Dana's planner. She was actually one of Dana's regulars. Now, Gregory knew that, of course, Mary Ann did not match the description for the killer they were looking for. Mary Ann is not a young man, but Mary Ann almost certainly knew men. And she also had a 17-year-old son whose name was Jonathan who did sort of fit the description. Jonathan was younger than the man Diane Harris had described, but she'd also seen the killer in the dark. So Gregory figured it was entirely possible. She could have just been off by a few years because she couldn't really see that well. And if Jonathan really was not involved here, proving it should be quite easy. So Gregory, he picked up the phone and he called the witness who had first spotted the blue-and-white SUV outside of Dana's salon. And when this guy answered, Gregory told him that he really needed a favor. That afternoon, Detective Gregory pulled up in front of Mary Ann Vick's house with the witness, you know, the guy who had seen the SUV for the first time in the passenger seat of Gregory's cruiser. And from where they were sitting, they both looked at the house and specifically looked at the driveway. And they saw there was a blue-and-white SUV that looked exactly like the one in the posters. So this looks like the killer's car. The two men got out of the vehicle and Detective Gregory, he stood by his car and watched as this guy, the witness, walked over to the SUV and walked around it a couple of times and looked closely at the rims and the grill. And then after he was done, he looked over it at Detective Gregory and he shook his head and said no. This was not the same SUV he had seen that night. So now Gregory was once again at a dead end. A few months later, Detective Gregory finally got a call from the crime lab telling him that they had a full profile they had developed for the male DNA that was found at the crime scene. And on top of that, they had already compared it to the other DNA sample that he was hopeful, you know, it would be a match, which was Mike, Dana's husband, but a lab told Gregory that no. Mike's DNA was not a match for the killer's DNA, which meant he definitely was not there for the murder or the assault. He could have been involved separately, he could have hired someone that was possible, but based on the way he was conducting himself, how collaborative he was being, this felt like a pretty big dead end. And so after that, Gregory continued working on Dana's case, but he just continued hitting dead end after dead end. This went on for two years. Until finally, one afternoon in 1997, a new tip came across his desk that really got his attention. An inmate at a local jail was claiming that his cellmate, a man whose name was Russell Quinn, carried around a photo of Dana, and he bragged about assaulting her. Gregory was skeptical because he knew prison rumors were pretty unreliable, and convex often made false confessions to impress other inmates or maybe work a plea deal. But when he pulled up Russell Quinn's file, a few things jumped out at him. First of all, Russell Quinn had been working within a few miles of Dana's salon on the night she was killed. And second, it was believed that just a few days before the murder, Russell had stolen a blue and white SUV. One afternoon in 1997, Detective Rick Gregory stood in his office at the Spartanburg County Sheriff's Office, looking down over the shoulder of Diane Harris, the saleswoman who had seen Dana's Sutterfield's killer climb out of her window two years earlier. Diane was now looking at photos of a bunch of different men who all fit the description that she had given at the time of the murder. All these men were white. They were in their 20s and around 170 pounds. And one of these men was Russell Quinn. The prison inmate who Gregory suspected was now the killer. And so Gregory obviously did not tell Diane this at all. He just said, look, look at these pictures and see if anybody stands out. Do they look like the killer and the person you saw? And he's watching as Diane is carefully considering all these photos. And then at some point, she looked really closely at one and she looks at another and back to the first one. And at some point, she's kind of fixated on one. And you know, Gregory's doing his best to stay back and not give away any sort of reaction to her choice. And then finally Diane, she goes, okay, you know, that's it. That's the guy I saw. He's the one who climbed out the window. And of course, the picture she was pointing at was none other than Russell Quinn. And so immediately at this point, Gregory, who standing behind her, he just, he felt a huge surge of relief because he's thinking, finally, you know, years later, I've finally solved this case. Russell Quinn had been near Dana Salon on the night of the murder. He'd been connected to the stolen car that matched the killer's vehicle. And now an eyewitness like BI Witness has picked him out of a lineup as the killer. Like, this is it, I've solved it. But about a week later, Gregory got a call from the crime lab telling him that unfortunately, Russell Quinn's DNA did not match the DNA from the crime scene. He was not the killer. So basically, it looked like all of Quinn's bragging about, you know, assaulting Dana and all that had just been a big lie. And then all the circumstantial evidence that also pointed to him was just coincidental, which ultimately meant Dana's case was still unsolved. And Gregory was now basically out of ideas. Over the next few years, Detective Gregory did everything he could to keep Dana's case alive. He explored the possibility that she might have had a stalker. And he had the FBI put together a psychological profile on the killer, but none of the work he did led to any new suspects, at least not, you know, meaningful suspects. And while this would have been frustrating in virtually any case he was involved in, this was especially frustrating because this investigation had started really promisingly. They'd had a physical description of the killer. They had the style of the car that he had driven. They even had his DNA. But they had never been able to match anybody's DNA to the crime scene DNA. And even though they had found numerous blue and white SUVs that seemed like the killers, the actual correct SUV had not turned up. So at this point, Detective Gregory had pretty much just given up hope that this case would actually ever be solved. But then finally, one afternoon in 2005, so 10 years after Dana's murder, when it was still very much unsolved, Detective Gregory got a call that apparently someone wanted to come forward to speak about Dana's Satterfield. An hour later, Gregory was in an interview room sitting across from this very nervous-looking young man. Gregory didn't know who he was, didn't recognize him, but the man introduced himself as Michael Pace. And he said that he worked as a mechanic at a local gas station. Then he said that just a few days ago, this young woman had come into the station for an oil change, and he said just seeing her face had given Michael such a shock because she looked exactly like Dana Satterfield. And it didn't take long to figure out why. After the young woman had left and driven off, another employee told Michael that the young woman was actually Dana's 18-year-old daughter. And for Michael, he said that this encounter, seeing the daughter and seeing how similar she looked to Dana, had brought up intense feelings of guilt and regret that Michael had been keeping buried for years, but no more. That's why he was here now. He had something to share. And Gregory nodded and said, okay, you know, tell me whatever you want to tell me, go ahead. And Michael, he composed himself, and then he told this incredible story. And when he was done, Detective Gregory knew he now finally had the information he needed to solve this murder. Based on witness testimony and evidence collected at the crime scene, this is what police believe happened to Dana Satterfield on the night of July 31st, 1995. A little after 8 p.m., the killer, who was driving in a blue and white SUV, pulled into a secluded parking lot near Dana's salon. They parked their car, they got out, and they walked across the street to the salon, and then without even knocking, they just walked inside. Now, they saw outside that there was a closed sign on the door. knew that the salon was closed, but still they went in, the lights were all on, and Dana was cleaning up. She was sweeping up hair. And as soon as they walked into the store, Dana stopped and she turned around and she looked at the killer. And at first she was sort of apprehensive, but then her whole demeanor just kind of changed and she smiled and said, "You know, I'm sorry, but you know, we're closed, you're going to have to come back another time." But the killer at this point, they were not here for a haircut. They did not turn around and leave, they actually began walking farther into the store towards Dana. And Dana sort of saw it happening and she's holding her broom. She's like looking at them, not really sure what they're doing. And the killer, as they walked closer to her, they said, "Well, actually I'm here for you. I want to be with you, and I think you want to be with me." And they're like making a physical advance towards her, like this is a romantic get-together here. And immediately, Dana seemed to sense that. And she said, "No, hold on a minute. No, I'm not interested. You're going to have to turn around, you're going to have to leave." Like, no. And the killer, like they stopped where they were and they're watching Dana who's just rejected them. And she's turned around and she's back to sweeping, like, just hoping they'll leave. And the killer, they were like seething. Like they were rejected. No one rejects them. And so just suddenly all the nerves they have when they walked in here, all the angst they were feeling just exploded. And they rushed forward and they struck Dana. And Dana, she collapses to the ground. And the killer, before law, and they're grabbing Dana and they're pulling her into that back room. And when they brought her in there, it was like they just went crazy. They beat her. They sexually assaulted her. And then they grabbed this strap from a bag out in the main salon area. And they brought it in there. And they wrapped it around Dana's neck. And they pulled tight and they strangled her to death. And then afterwards, as Dana's laying there dead, you know, blood everywhere inside of this back room, the killer, like they're kind of panicked, but they're still mad. And they're looking at Dana like, "This is your fault. You did this to me. You rejected me." And they used that strap and they basically tied her to the water heater. That's like a form of punishment. Like, you did this. They strapped her up by the neck. And then they stood back and just stared down at what they had done. And then it was like the gravity of the situation really, really settled in. Like, they've just brutally murdered this woman. There's blood everywhere. And they're like, "I have to get out of here." They're not going to go out the front door anymore. They need to, they need to flee basically. And so they went to that side window in the salon. They opened it up. They popped out the screen. They jumped outside thinking they can make a quick getaway. No one's seen them. But as soon as they're outside, they looked out towards the front, you know, in the direction of their car. And who's out there? But Diane, the saleswoman, they don't know Diane. But there's this woman out in the road. And she's looking right at them. The killer's looking right back. They make eye contact. And then that woman, she starts screaming. At which point, the killer just bolts and runs over towards the gas station. And they run back around. They get in their car. And they speed home. And then when they pull into their driveway, before going inside, the killer first carefully checked the interior of the car to make sure there wasn't any blood left behind on the seats. Because if there was, their mom would find out and she would be furious if she knew that they had used her car. The killer was Jonathan Vick, the 17-year-old son of Dana's regular client, Marianne Vick, whose vehicle, the Blue and White SUV, Gregory had ruled out 10 years earlier. The witness who had called in the the Blue and White SUV tip had not correctly identified the SUV, perhaps because it had looked different at night than it had in the light of the day when Gregory had brought the witness back to inspect it in the driveway. But despite that, back in the summer of 1995, so around the time the murder took place, then 17-year-old Jonathan had been friends with this mechanic whose name was Michael Pace. And on the night of the murder, Jonathan had told Michael that he was really interested in Dana, like romantically interested in her, and that night he was going to go over to her salon and try to ask her out. Well, obviously that night Dana is killed, and then a few days later, Jonathan had pulled Michael to the mechanic aside and threatened to kill him if he ever told anyone about what Jonathan had said about how that night he was going over to pursue her. And so Michael, you know, because he had been threatened, he had just been living with the secret for, you know, the past 10 years, that is, until Dana's actual daughter just happened to walk into his gas station, and seeing her face was like seeing Dana, and it made him feel so bad, he was just like so emotional, that he said screw it, and he went to the police, and he told them everything he knew. After Michael came forward, the investigators were able to compel Jonathan Vic to give a DNA sample, and when she know it, it matched the DNA recovered from the crime scene back in 1995. Jonathan Vic was arrested on October 24th, 2005, and then a little over a year later, he was convicted of Dana's murder and sexual assault and was sentenced to life in prison. A quick note about our stories, they are all based on true events, but we sometimes use pseudonyms to protect the people involved, and some details are fictionalized for dramatic purposes. The Mr. Ballin Podcast, strange dark and mysterious stories, is hosted and executive produced by me, Mr. Ballin. Our head of writing is Evan Allen, produced by Jeremy Bohn and Cole Lacasio. This episode was written by Andrew Kelleyer, story editing by Luke Baratz, research and fact-checking by Shelley Shoe, Samantha Van Hoos, Evan Beamer, Abigail Shumway, Camille Callahan, Alex Paul, Ben Fassiano, research and fact-checking supervision by Steven Ear, audio editing and post-produced by Whit Lacasio and Jordan Stidem, production support by Antonio Manada and Delana Corley, artwork by Jessica Clogston-Kiner, theme song "Something Wicked" by Ross Bugden. Thank you for listening to the Mr. Ballin Podcast, and just a reminder, every new and exclusive episode we put out on the Mr. Ballin Podcast, you can also now watch on the Mr. Ballin YouTube channel that very same day, and trust me, some of these stories you truly have to see to believe. Again, my YouTube channel is just called Mr. Ballin. If you want to listen to episodes one week early and add free, you can subscribe to SiriusXM Podcast Plus on Apple Podcasts or visit SiriusXM.com/podcastplus to listen with Spotify or another app of your choice. So that's gonna do it, I really appreciate your support, until next time, see ya.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. In 1995, 27-year-old hair stylist Dana Satterfield was brutally murdered in her salon in Robuck, South Carolina, after being strangled and sexually assaulted and tied to a water heater.
  2. The initial investigation pointed to a young white man in his 20s, around 170 pounds, who allegedly jumped out of the salon window, matching the description of a witness, Diane Harris.
  3. Despite strong circumstantial evidence—including a blue-and-white SUV and DNA from the scene—no suspect matched the physical or genetic profile until 2005.
  4. A breakthrough came when a mechanic, Michael Pace, recognized Dana’s daughter at a gas station and confessed to having known the killer, Jonathan Vick, a 17-year-old son of a regular client.
  5. Jonathan had romantically pursued Dana and, after her murder, threatened Michael with violence if he revealed the secret, leading to a decade-long cover-up.
  6. DNA testing later confirmed Jonathan Vick’s match to the crime scene remains, linking him directly to the murder.
  7. The killer fled after the assault, panicked upon seeing Diane Harris, and drove off in the blue-and-white SUV, which had been misidentified due to nighttime visibility differences.
  8. Jonathan Vick was arrested in 2005, convicted of murder and sexual assault, and sentenced to life in prison after the full evidence was compiled and verified.

Summary:

In 1995, 27-year-old hair stylist Dana Satterfield was murdered in her salon in Robuck, South Carolina, after being beaten, sexually assaulted, and strangled and tied to a water heater. The initial investigation relied on witness testimony describing a young white man in his 20s, around 170 pounds, who climbed out of a window and fled. Despite multiple leads—including a blue-and-white SUV and public tips—no suspect matched the physical or DNA evidence for years.

The case remained unsolved until 2005, when a mechanic named Michael Pace recognized Dana’s daughter at a gas station and revealed that he had known the killer, Jonathan Vick, a 17-year-old boy from a regular client’s family. Jonathan had pursued Dana romantically, and after the murder, threatened Michael with violence if he disclosed the relationship. Michael, fearing for his safety, kept the secret for over a decade.

When confronted with Dana’s daughter's resemblance to Dana, Michael confessed. DNA testing later confirmed that Jonathan Vick’s biological sample matched the crime scene evidence. Authorities arrested and eventually convicted him of murder and sexual assault, sentencing him to life in prison.

The case highlights how personal relationships, hidden motives, and the persistence of evidence can lead to long-overdue justice, even in seemingly unsolvable crimes.

FAQs

The killer was Jonathan Vick, the 17-year-old son of Dana's regular client Marianne Vick. He was romantically interested in Dana and attempted to pursue her, but was rejected. After the murder, he strangled her and tied her to the water heater, then fled the scene.

Jonathan had expressed romantic interest in Dana Satterfield and planned to go to her salon to ask her out. After the murder, he threatened the mechanic Michael Pace, who had known about the plan, with violence if he ever revealed the information. This secret was buried for 10 years until Michael came forward.

Michael Pace, a mechanic at a gas station, recognized Dana's daughter when she visited his shop. The resemblance triggered a flood of memories and guilt, leading him to confess the truth about Jonathan's romantic intentions and the murder plan.

The killer tied Dana to the water heater as a form of punishment, believing she had rejected him. This act reflected his emotional trauma and rage after being turned down, treating the act as a personal revenge.

Yes, the killer was described as a white man in his 20s, around 170 pounds, driving a blue and white SUV. Jonathan, at 17 years old, fit this description, though the witness initially misidentified the vehicle due to lighting differences.

After Michael Pace came forward with evidence, investigators obtained a DNA sample from Jonathan. The DNA matched that found at the crime scene, confirming his involvement in the murder and sexual assault.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.