The Strange Freedom To Be Disliked - James Blunt - #1177
1h 34m 21s
James Blunt’s journey from a deeply emotional, earnest artist to a resilient, self-aware musician is central to his story. His early success stemmed from raw emotional authenticity, shaped by formative experiences like boarding school and military service. However, this honesty drew intense media criticism in the UK, where success is often met with mockery rather than celebration—contrasting sharply with the American culture of embracing vulnerability and celebrating achievement. To survive this backlash, Blunt adopted self-deprecating humor and defensive strategies, such as anticipating criticism and crafting music to avoid negative reception. Over time, he evolved beyond these mechanisms, realizing that emotional truth doesn’t require constant public exposure. His second album, *All the Lost Souls*, became a turning point, reflecting deep personal pain and loneliness, while his later work balances honesty with self-protection. Blunt emphasizes that true artistic fulfillment comes not from commercial success or awards, but from genuine emotional connection with audiences. He now views his career as a journey of self-discovery, where authenticity, resilience, and perspective have allowed him to stay grounded and continue performing with integrity. His story highlights the tension between vulnerability and survival in the music industry, and how personal growth can transform pain into lasting artistry. Ultimately, he has found peace in authenticity, not fame, proving that emotional depth and self-awareness can endure even in a media-driven world.
The next modern wisdom merch shop is now live and only for six days you can get these designs never to be printed again my favorite death metal design this high country ranch thing with a beautiful horseshoe on front. This snake design this awesome wisdom nation world tour it's all available at mwmurch.com never to be printed again so get yours before they sell out mwmurch.com. I love your place man your gap is epic. Yeah, I tried to be very understated for you today or make you fear that you're going to be hung upside down by your ankles at some point. Very much even the setup. Correct. Yes. Distance. I brought I brought again. It's a power. It's pointing at you. It's a power move. You built a career on being very sincere emotionally vulnerable songs and then became famous online for being sarcastic and self-deprecating which one is the real James. I use music as a cathartic outlet for emotion. I don't see a therapist. I don't need a therapist to write songs about what's going on inside and then for the rest of the time I'm an idiot but you know the two coexist quite happily. Are you the most emotionally sensitive man in Britain or the least easily or the least you know I went to boarding school when I was seven years old my parents dropped me off in September of the school they didn't explain that I was going to boarding school at that stage they I knew something was up a fat because you know they're a little tight but they give me a present of a donkey con game and watch you know there's an intended game and watches and it wasn't my birthday nor was it Christmas so I knew something was up and they dropped me off at the school and they said goodbye three days later I asked the matron you know when am I going to see my parents. Again they lived in Germany they dropped me off in a school in Barkshire and that matron said yeah they're coming back Christmas. That makes you fairly emotionally stunted and the notion of that painful word feelings is not something of necessarily deal with on a day to day basis but you know we all as humans have the voice in our head that we have to deal with and the highs and lows that we have to deal with in life and that's what I capture in song. I forget that people go to boarding school it sounds like some archaic the archers Bridgerton thing but I'm amazed you'd keep children at home why would you do that there you know there a nightmare. I mean I think my second word I learned to support a school. It's interesting that people still go and do that and I had friends that I went to uni with at Newcastle that did how people unique with the perspective now of realizing that's not normal for everybody how shaping and unique do you think that experiences. I mean it makes you incredibly independent. First and foremost you don't have parents there you're guided by other pupils and you work for other pupils I mean at school I had to work for someone at the top year I called him God to know his real name and would bring him wake him up in the morning bring him tea coffee opens curtains to his seats to his laundry and on weekends he get me booze and fags and get me out of trouble potentially with other people in the other years so you know it's a little bit like education prison. Yeah I think boarding school you know inmates are very good as real inmates in prison as well so yeah it really gives you independence is an amazing thing and then and I suppose I think you know it's a different piece now I would don't think I necessarily do the same thing at certainly not with a child a seven because of a parent I think you miss out on the on your on the childhood of of your own children. Yes yes yes yeah it's a it's an interesting change so I guess you've got one of the most meandering life stories that I've heard of is there a single thread that ties that all together what's the sort of unifying trend as you look back at this well I guess because my dad was in the army we were very transient you know we moved every two years and you know I have memories of living in Cyprus Germany Hong Kong somewhere as exotic as Yorkshire and and to make friends I was literally sent out by my mother onto our army patch that we lived on which is kind of like a it's a you know there's a council houses in many ways but supplied by the army that you'd be you know put into and I'd go around that army patch and knock on doors and say how do you have any children my age or my sister's age and there's a sales person for yourself. Exactly and those and you know someone said yes that person would then become your friend for two years and then you'd never see them again so I've had I've had a best friend every two years and then moved on. Then I joined the army myself and we've we have you know I've moved around a lot myself and then I joined then I joined my tour bus my touring life became a musician and went out on tour and again I just continually move and so even now I suppose I live between you know in verbally which is in Switzerland up in the mountains I live in Nebita and and some time in the UK and I'm you know I get itchy feet I'm just constantly moving and that's from my childhood. That lifestyle either was built for you or you were built for it maybe. Yeah and it's one that I love you know I've I've felt I don't want to stick around the same places you know we were discussing you can stick around in the UK during the winter for the rain or you can or you can move. Yeah how did military service change you? I'm a great deal I had been at university before and I was very I was idle. University is just an amazing place you cost great great fun place message and I went to Bristol. Studying airspace manufacturing engineering which I couldn't spell and sociology which actually turns out sociology you think is a useless degree but actually for writing songs it's it's fairly useful to the only thing you can put it to use. But university's a great place where you spend your time waking up late not really doing much in the way of work. I think we watched neighbours and home in a way twice a day and then I'm so I think idle was the word I would use for that time. Great great fun when you get into the army that is drilled out of you and I work very hard now I walk fast I work hard. I've worked long hours I'm very very organised my my tour bus is a very tired place of tidy bus is a happy bus. As is my home you know it's it's a military operation whether I be on the road or home. Were you ever conflicted about your role in the armed forces being on deployment? It's not as if you were just sort of sat back never actually being involved in anything. No I think I was lucky enough you know you're the you're the best of politicians when you're in the army and you can only hope that they choose the right wars to send you in. The the war that I was sent to was Kosovo in 1999 and that was where the Serbs were murdering on mass Kosovo Albanians. And then the Kosovo Albania set up the Kosovo Liberation Army and the two people were fighting and I think you know it was a very it was a humanitarian exercise we were peace enforcers as part of NATO but peace needed to be enforced at that time. And it was the right war because you know two people are killing each other and we're getting in the middle and saying enough and and that feels like the right war to be involved in. It feels like quite linear sort of steps through this I'm aware that boarding schools a little bit of an aggressive left turn but you step by step by step you move through education then you go to higher education then you presumably want to Santos and then you go to do the army thing and then you know it's all relatively steady away sort of linear stuff. And then on one of your first major public attempts with music you have exponential growth doesn't even sort of just like like stripper pole growth it's like just a vertical line up. What are the problems of having breakout success as one of your first attempts? I don't see many problems with it. You know your first idea at least in my case my first idea is probably going to be my best idea if I were to set up a clothing brand the first season would probably be the best season. And particularly if you've had a lifetime dreaming about that and working for that and that's the case with many many musicians I think really. And I suppose when you talk about break out success I've been saying to people I was going to be a professional musician since I was 14 and I hit when I was 30. So there have been a lot of build up towards that time. Sure is there you know it what are the negatives to that well of course you're chasing that afterwards. And particularly with something quite so big is back to Berlin which did so many many millions of sales and without huge like your beautiful and will it result in me always chasing that dream that commercial success and not necessarily achieving sure in many ways absolutely. But I'm but I'm old enough and long enough in the tooth to know that there will be highs and lows in the career and and you and you judge yourself in different ways my second album was probably a better album than my first musically and it was desperately painful when I had this incredible success dream had come true and that dream had also been ruined almost immediately within six months. The media led backlash that the public then just followed was desperately disappointing and took took me down in such as you know it's just a song. and he had taken down so hard by the British media that I didn't. was almost a national pariah that men wouldn't talk to me. That I then felt like I was going to have to be an exile in a place called Ibiza, which is not too bad a place to be. In exile, maybe a very, very lonely second album called "All the Lost Souls". And that, for me, probably musically, was my best album until the moment I'm about to flog you now. But that journey to now has been full of ups and downs. The downs of trying to be in the music business, instead of not being in the music instead, of a song that hits here and songs that don't. But, as I say, I'm long enough in the tooth to know that some things you'll measure with commercial success and others you will measure with emotional success. Mmm, that's lovely. What was the motivation for a media-led take down? I think most people assume that this sort of stuff is bottom-up, but it sounds like there's a little bit more going on. Yeah, I mean, the music industry is a pretty shallow space. We talk a lot about what's cool and hot right now, and I was never going to be cool. I would hope under fire, but not cool within the music business. And then my song and my songs and that album was everywhere. You could not escape it. And there I was with my little guitar, with my high-pitched voice singing, you know, a song which is Dean, you know, and songs which were deemed sensitive, earnest and over-sensitive. And for me, that was the point of music. You know, it's a music you're supposed to have emotion in it. It's not supposed to be just, you know, paint on a wall. And so I think I was just an easy target. And maybe a tiny bit of my background was touched on it in that as well. But we are a nation that likes to take down and demolish success. We don't celebrate success. We are a nation that, you know, tool-poppy syndrome is a British syndrome. We're a nation that sometimes creates clubs to be exclusive. I'm in a club and we're involved in it. And we have this sometimes, as I say, success as we we don't celebrate in the same way that America does. What does that do to your sense of self? You have this breakout song and album. And almost immediately after that, you have public criticism, mockery, stuff like that. What does that feel like? I was surprised by it. And disappointed really, you know, for me, it's just a song and it's just music. And if you don't like it, just go and listen to someone else's. Maybe you couldn't listen to it because it was on the radio a lot. But I didn't feel it and I didn't understand the range, you know, for people really say, I hate James Blunt, felt a little excessive thing. You really haven't met me. It seems like, yeah, it seemed irrational. And I suppose it also becomes more personal. You know, we've seen, we've heard people say they hate cold play. But that's the name of your band. But unfortunately, the name of my band is James Blunt. So it just immediately sounds much more personal. And so that definitely touched me in a way that, yeah, as I say, I'd had a dream all my life and it did spoil the dream. How did you, or what have you learned about how to deal with criticism? Well, then I was living two different lives at that stage. So it's a more complex question in many ways that I was living two different lives. You know, I went to Bethel and I went clubbing. And I had an amazing time. It was just glorious. And I've what I remember of it. I've had the time of my life. And I was out on tour and playing to tens of thousands of people each night. And again, living the dream and having an amazing time. And what was weird is that then whenever I was being asked any questions in interviews, they were telling me how unpopular I was. And if you look online on my phone, it was definitely easy to feel that way as well. Yeah, it's very strange to think that what you feel in the real world and what people tell you that you should feel based on their interpretation from the outside of your world are too almost entirely opposing. Exactly. And it took me a time to fully understand what that is. And that's just a simple thing called perspective. And sure, you know, I can look online and I can find one negative comment. And I still do that to the day. And it still will hurt. But I need to look at myself in the mirror immediately and say, you're an idiot. Because you just bypassed over 100 positive things that people said. Or in the terms of music, that one negative thing that was written about me. And you've just played a concert of 10,000 people. And the person on the phone, they don't know me. They didn't spend the money on a ticket. They didn't travel any distance. They invested nothing in that offensive statement. And these other people who gave you something positive, they really invested money, effort, energy time to come to your concert. And here I am touched in some negative way by this anonymous number, you know, username and number, who, as I've joked before, probably, they're probably still living at home. They're probably in their 50s, still living with their parents. They're probably upstairs in their bedroom still with their, you know, trousers around their ankles and their phone in one hand and something else in their other hand. And they're writing negative comments. And why am I being touched by that? So perspective was really what put it, you know, to bed. Do you think that that reaction would have happened in America if you'd be an American? Not nearly so much, no. I think the Americans do celebrate success. They do cheer you on. You're allowed to say that you're proud of what you've done. You're allowed to stand up and say, it's a big deal to me. And that's a, that's a beautiful thing about America. And it's so funny as Britz, you know, we go out to America feeling a little snooty about the Americans generally. And I went to America and thought, wow, this is a fantastic place for that. And, you know, the American dream is to say to someone, come on, you can do it. You can be anything. And it goes back to the club and the scenario, we have clubs so that we can be exclusive and say, you can't be in my club. You know, I'm sorry, this is my clique and you're just not good enough to be in it. Whereas the Americans will form a club to say, hey, I'm from your club and who wants to be in my club? Because it's going to be amazing. It's going to be great, great fun. And that's, um, yeah. And I think America is a wonderful place for that. Yeah, I talked about it a lot on tour. The tall puppy syndrome and the differences between the UK and US approach to success. And one of the things that came to me was that in Britain, you are allowed to be successful. But only if you seem horribly embarrassed that it happened. Yeah. Like you have to apologize for your ambition or your life sort of turning out the way that you want is like, oh, I'm terribly sorry. I appear to have developed myself and built a successful business. Like, please banish me to the Shetland Islands and publish my nudes in the Guardian. Like that's my, I must pay my pen and exactly having done this and I'm, and I'm still apologizing. But that's a remarkable thing, isn't it? And you talk about it with business, you know, in business, we do want people who create, generate success who are successful. And we do need to celebrate them because they are the ones, you know, who we need to be, who we all should be following. Yeah. Do you, uh, do you think Britain hates posh people or just posh people that are successful? Because it does seem like there's a sort of a classlessness to Britain that is increasingly coming out now. Well, no, I don't think so. I don't think so at ground level, at street level. And I think in some way, it's, it's, it's, it's exaggerated. I think by media, particularly by social media as well, these things don't exist. You know, I was in the army and they were all experts in their field from all corners of the country and we all worked together as a team. And as long as you look each other in the eye and respect each other and know what they bring to that team and ask the right, you know, ask the questions to ask their opinion and ask the, as someone's input, um, just looking each other in the eye and treating each other as equals. Um, then I think on the ground, no, no, I think we will treat each other as equals as a result. Going back to the sort of army to music transition thing, how do you develop a songwriting ability whilst serving in the military? What are you, what are you, you're handling guns by day and working chords by night? Yeah, um, it's just a which weapon you pick up and choose, uh, guitar or a rifle. There's a load of downtime in the army and you know, you're always the rush to wait, um, is the main phrase of the army. You're going way on operations. You've got to take something with you. You can take a pack of cards where you can take a football with you or like me, you can be stupid enough to bring a guitar. Um, and, you know, you're going to see things that are inspiring to write songs and we've seen in many wars, you know, great, great poets and great poetry has come out of wars. Um, and, and for me, those were, those experiences were inspirational for songs as well. Mm-hmm. And then when do you start playing gigs? Um, I came back from Kosovo, which is in 1999 and I started in 2000 in London. They said, you know, choose it, which next job you want to do in the army, they didn't have top gun, but they did have, um, London as the Queen's ceremonial bodyguard, the horse guards. And so I came out to London and spent four months learning how to ride a horse, which had never really down on army reject horses, which would buck and kick and bite and throw you off. Um, and then, and then basically qualified as the Queen's ceremonial bodyguard by day riding down the mall beside her majesty with a million people either side of the street and flags waving in, in armor.
You know, Mike tapped the police, you've got a sword, which you're not going to use that on anyone going for the Queen, because that would look bad on camera. But you know, you've got your body and you've got the horses' body to protect our majesty. And that was by day and by night, I would go to play in small gigs and venues and slowly formed bands, well, who are almost my current band now still. But again, those band members were like my soldiers in my troop from all corners of the country. And I know that they're experts in their own field, and I asked their opinion and their advice, and they guided and carried me many, many times. But it was an amazing thing of coming back to the barracks in the early hours of the morning, getting dressed into this ridiculous gear, and by night sneaking out with the guitar and playing in bars and clubs. It really is a Batman Bruce Wayne, slightly more British equivalent of that. Yeah, it sounds very ceremonial, I don't know how much use you would have been had there have been some sort of, you can put the horses' body in the way, but you're not a firearm, no nothing else. No, no. Well, actually, if someone's firing a weapon at a specific human being, the target end, the best thing to protect them is someone their size or bigger to get in the way. And so we would practice and do many, many exercise in Norfolk with a bunch of horses. You know, I have 200 horses there surrounding the monarch, who have a friend who had volunteered to be the queen, and we would practice, protect them, and you know, all forms, so we'd be it with someone attacking with a weapon, a bomb, even protesters, you know, that's what the job was there for, and you all miked out to the police who probably deal with the problem there end. Wow. Yeah, it's a real sort of combination of what looks like medieval archaicness and sort of modern military tactics coming together. Yeah. Totally. Yeah. And it's an amazing job, really. You know, it's, you know, a fast state to be part of. I was lucky enough when the queen mother died to be part of that amazing historic tradition. She's lay in state for a week, and I was one of the guys on the corner of the coffin who stood guard over her head bowed while the public file passed over a week. And it was incredible. You know, these amazing bits that Britain has stooped steeped in this tradition. A quick aside, eight sleep just released the brand new pod six. They've somehow managed to make the pod significantly better and more affordable at the same time. The hub is now 50% smaller. It heats and cools 20% faster. There are nine times more sensors that are tracking your sleep, your recovery, your breathing rate, your HRV and exactly how disappointing your Saturday night was. And it starts at $1,999, the lowest ever starting price that they have offered. Look, I've been away on tour for the last month and a half, and it is primitive. It feels medieval to be sleeping without the temperature controlled mattress topper. And once you try it, I wish that I could say you won't be evangelizing the same way I am, but reliably, you probably will. They have a 30 day sleep trial, so you can buy it and sleep on it for 29 nights. If you don't love it, they'll give you your money back and they ship internationally. And you can get up to $350 off the pod six by going to the link in the description below or heading to 8sleep.com/modernwisdom and using the code "Modern Wisdom", a check out. That's e-i-g-t-sleep.com/modernwisdom and "Modern Wisdom", a check out. Where does the music playing, the songwriting, when does that start to show? Because you have this, what feels like, blind confidence, precocious confidence from a young age. Were there any early signs that you weren't just totally delusional? I knew I could sing, some people might dispute that nowadays. I knew I could sing, and I knew I could also convey emotion. I knew that I could convey and have conviction. I could convince soldiers to follow me, to be able to convince someone to up and follow you towards a machine gun that is firing in your direction. That means you could have real conviction to say, urge them up off their stomachs to be able to do that. And if I can convey that emotion in music as well, then I had something in there. What I didn't have is understanding of the music business. I was really, really very naive in. So I have, you know, musical ideas, musical conviction, real drive, real ambition. Those things are, you know, that's the crux of what you need, but if you want to get into the music business, you're going to need someone who knows the business. Whilst I was doing these gigs, approaching record labels, asking them if they'd give me a record deal, which is entirely the wrong thing to do. Someone came along and said, you're doing this or wrong, you need to find a manager. So I did a couple of gigs and invited some managers along. And one of those was past my CD, this man called me up, his name is Todd Inland, he called me and said, I've heard your CD and I'd love to meet. And that was in 2002 and that manager is still my manager today and just off camera then. That's the same guy. Absolutely. Wow. And so, you know, that immediately gives me the chance to do what I do, which is music, for him to guide me through the shark infested waters of the music business. Crazy. And then how did that record come about? How did the first record come about? Well, we, under his guidance then, I went to see music publishers, which is about my songwriting and I got a song, a publishing deal, which gave me the chance of, you know, they gave me a small financial advice, advance, which gave me time to write more songs, really. You know, so you don't have to worry about your immediate bills that you can then spend the time to write the songs, introduce me to other people in the music business, who could help me write more songs and record those songs fundamentally into much better demos. And also, if you've got then a manager and you've got a publisher behind you, then your chances of getting the golden ticket of the record deal, they're going to feel more assured that you have a team behind you and backers behind you, financial backers and the brain backers of my own manager. So then we approached all the record labels and that didn't go necessarily especially well. I think having stepped out of the army, I mean, my speaking voice was absolutely ridiculous, that my accent was just, well, just as this very, very naive posh boy who just, and I'm just out of place within the music business. Right, right, right. Just stuck out a long hair, cool baggy jeans. I had to just stuck out like a sore thumb and you could tell that there were songs there and there was, there was something there, but very hard to place within the British music scene. And in fact, the only record label that did offer me one was Virgin Records, headed by a Frenchman called Philippe Askely who'd signed bands like Air, Darth Punk even I think he'd signed. And they called me in. They said, you know, we're going to give you a record deal. And I was, this was so, so very, very exciting. My manager came, the senior manager from the management company. I came along as well. It was a big, big deal. And they got me in and said, you know, you're going to be a star and we're so excited. And here's the paperwork and let's go. And then the marketing manager did turn around and say, you know, we do have just one question. And you can feel a silence now as they've prepared for this moment. He said, you know, just speaking voice, can you do another accent? And I said, you know, well, I mean, I could, I could probably try Pakistani. And at the stage, my manager stood up and said, let's get out of here. And we realized, you know, that wasn't, that wasn't going to be the place for us. So anyway, I went to Austin, Texas, played on the 20th floor of the Ramada hotel to a very tiny audience of 20 people. I hadn't really been told by my manager that it was probably last chance saloon for me. The two musicians who flew out with me were probably realizing that this gig wasn't going to be, you know, be one that they were going to be on for very long. And I thought I was going out to the South by Southwest music festival. But as a turn to the Ramada hotel gig I was playing was on the fringes of the festival as well. I was really, you know, this was, it was not the dream that one had hoped. But I played my songs to these 20 people. And as I finished, a woman on platform boots with a some kind of black top hat on a tattoo of a tear here in more tattoos pushed her way through. She's a short woman, but a formidable character pushed her way through this crowd stormed up to me and said, my name is Linda Perry. She didn't mean anything to me, but she's the lead singer of four non-blans. She said, I'm forming a new record label called Custard Records. And I'd like you to be the first act I sign. And if you sign with me today, I'll give you the money to make your album tomorrow. And I said, come on then, where do we sign? We went and got very, very drunk that night. And then I owe it really to her. That's so cool. What a beautiful sort of bit of serendipity to do that, I guess as well, going from the army and being surrounded by those people to someone in a top hat with the teardrop tattoo again, Sartor really a little bit of a whiplash there. Yeah, absolutely. And also I think, you know, she's so very un-English, un-British, you know, her stature, her own background, you know, she just doesn't see the silly tiny little minute prejudices that we all have against each other, judge mentalisms that we have in the UK. She's overcome much more important ones in her own life. And she just saw, she just saw someone with, yeah, who wanted it, you know, I sing from the heart, you know, I don't hide anything. That's what music is, it's real, it's truth, it's not cool or hip.
or hot. It's just true. And she could really sense that. And so it's amazing to be given that opportunity by her. What were you playing then? Was there anything that would eventually hit an album that would have been here? Yeah, absolutely. I think we probably had three-quarters of my first album back to Bedlam already written by that station. I probably will have been singing to her, "You're beautiful and could buy my lover." And, you know,
cribe a no-bravery was about the war. Those were all, you know, so you've got a healthy chunk of the album ready to go. And then we just need to work out how we record it. And that was then finally the right producer, a man called Tom Rothrock, who bizarrely had been online Googling South by Southwest. And just to come across a dodgy video of this English guy with two musicians behind him singing, "You're beautiful." And, you know, and he was moved by that video that he'd found online. And that day, my manager called him saying, "Hey, my artist James would love to work with you. I'd heard other artists who'd work with specifically." Well, the list of people, Elliot Smith was the one that really inspired me. Badly drawn boy, Foo Fighters, Beck, amongst others. And this producer I can use, the producer didn't put himself on the records. He got out of you what it is that you wanted to get onto the record. And that was his genius. This guy that you knew about and that your manager rang that same day had serendipitously stumbled across a video. Absolutely. And so, you know, he was thought this is, you know, a mad coincidence we should definitely meet. Yeah. Do you feel like you're being sort of pulled through life by something, some degree of serendipity that is beyond just chance here? I mean, I don't know. I think you have to be lucky, but I think you have to create your own luck at the same time. It's not about being in the right place at the right time. That would imply just lands in your lap. I think you have to be in, you know, everywhere all the time, don't you? You have to make it. Definitely the James Blunt Curse, yeah. I mean, I'm interested in this earnestness thing. And it's something that I've thought a lot about over the last few years. My best definition of earnestness is the bravery to take your emotions seriously. And I think that British people have a particular allergy to that in some degree. We have this sort of standoffishness, a degree of cynicism, a distance that we sort of hold things at, right? When you, even if you look at the office, the UK versus the US office, even if you look at something that I think is more interesting in allergy, do you ever watch the thick of it by Armando Ianucci? Yeah, of course. My favorite comedy of all time. And then they did Veep in America. Right. And Veep is still, I think, ranked as one of the top 10 series of all time. It's still amazing. I'm undoing Anucci's like a super genius. But even that, their side-eye sardonic sort of cutting, very witty humor that they still potted off with the same people, right? And then potted over there is nowhere near as sort of cutting or standoffish as it is in the UK. So that preparedness, the bravery to take your emotions seriously, what, what is the motivation to sort of, to go as transparently as you do or as you did with that? Well, I think, particularly at the start, and I've only managed to find it again now, is that for me was the point of doing music in the first place. That's the point of doing music in the first place. It's, I'm having a conversation with myself. I'm looking at them in the mirror and being honest with myself about what is I'm genuinely afraid of. We don't know what the purpose of life is in the first place. When you're younger, you don't know if you're going to meet the right person or anyone at all, if you have anyone to share your journey of life with, where you'll end up, where you'll live. Well, you know, these are frightening questions and that journey to find the answers, it takes that lifetime. And along the way, you make mistakes and you realise that you're not the hero in the story of life. And all of that can be tough to deal with. And so I write songs for me to put that down and explain that to myself and in that cathartic means. And then I stand on stage and I sing those. And that's what gave me an audience in the first space because people heard my honesty and they were touched by that because they felt something, I assume, they felt something in themselves at that time. Oh, they heard words that they wanted to hear from someone else, from maybe a man to a woman, they wanted to hear a man say that, or they wanted to feel that someone else felt the same way. And I think that's why I built up an audience. But at the same time, it was also one of the things that gave me a backlash as well because that desperate, desperate, painful honesty and sensitivity isn't as you say in the British way, it's, yeah, it can be easily dodged. Why do you think it is opposed? What is it that people are feeling when they see someone with earnest? Yeah, and I don't think it's any bad thing necessarily. I really don't think it's necessarily any bad thing. Once upon a time, we had the British stiff upper lip. And we do need resilience. We probably need more of it now, and probably to blame for a lot of weakness. We need it. Exactly. We need to get a grip now. And show a bit of resilience and toughness. And those are the things that have given us strength here in the past. And I think we'll give it that. We'll give it that as a reason. There's a line from a letter that Sigmund Freud once sent to Carl Jung and he says, one day in retrospect, the years of struggle will strike you as the most beautiful. I'm interested in the experience of going through this, I've exposed myself to the world. I really, like, fucking shown you something. As a person who self identifies as maybe a emotionally decapitated below the neck, at least through childhood and young adult herd. And like, this is my dream. And I've put a lot of myself into this existentially, emotionally in terms of my time. I've left this army thing behind it. All the rest of it. I don't know what your parents think about. They're probably that you're insane. And all of this stuff happens. And then you are not met with the reaction presumably that you would have loved. And then there's this moment where you have to realize, fuck, like, maybe through some curse of bad luck after a bunch of good luck. Maybe this is going to, like, derail the career and move forward. Absolutely. What does self belief look like at that moment? It definitely taken a knock. But what is interesting, I suppose, is that years later, I can look back on that fairly positively. Speaking to me now, I hope you are feel that you're talking to someone whose feet are on the ground in the public eye and the music business, called ridiculous things like a pop star. I wish I'd been a rock star, but I didn't achieve that. But these kinds of things and given accolades and treated differently in many ways. And yet I've got my feet on the ground because I know that it's, you know, it's the shallow world world and that it can turn on you at any point. And as a result, yeah, I'm not a pop star. I'm just a guy with a lucky job. Do you know what the equivalent, I think, is in America, the closest equivalent is Nickelback? Yeah. I think it's Chad Kroger. You know, there was essentially a coordinated media pushback after they were everywhere. I'm not too dissimilar time to you as well. Absolutely. Almost exactly the same time. And they were like super cringe for ages. And now between them and creed and sort of this throwback to what in America is called divorce dad rock, but you can give it other names. And now it's just absolutely ripping. Absolutely. And if you watch their documentary, one of them's wearing a James Blank cap. You're kidding. Yeah. Wow, just in case they weren't making it hard enough for themselves already, they decided to throw the James Blank cap in there as well. Most people massively overcomplicate nutrition. They're juggling different supplements, guessing what they're missing and still not covering their bases. That's why I've been drinking AG1 every morning for years now. It is the simplest way I've found to handle all of that in just one go. Just one scoop gives you 75 vitamins, minerals, probiotics and whole food ingredients in a single drink. And they've taken it one step further with AG1 next gen that's got four clinical trials helps gut bacteria, even if you're healthy. Look, you've heard me harping on about it for so long because I use it every single day. And if I ever found something better, I would switch. But I haven't, which is why I still use it every day. And my mum uses it and my dad uses it and all of the people on the modern wisdom team as well. If you are still on the fence, they've got a 90 day money back guarantee for those in the US so you can buy it and try it for three months. And if you do not like it for any reason, they'll just give you your money back. And for a limited time, you can get up to $107 worth of free gifts, including a bottle of vitamin D3, K2 and a flavor sample all with your first subscription plus that 90 day money back guarantee all by going to the link in the description below are heading to drinkag1.com/modern wisdom. That's drinkag1.com/ Modern wisdom. When it came to the, I don't know whether it was ever a pivot, how much were you doing the self-deprecating thing prior to the exposure to the media? Was that part of your personality? Yeah, I really was. I was still fairly honest about my music.
in interviews I was fairly earnest, you know, you want to be taken seriously, and it's painful not to be taken seriously. Whilst I was earnest, I was learning, you know, I'd always taken the Mickey out of myself through the army, you know, everyone else was too, that's how we get through hard times in the army. And I really was. And I remember clearly being betrayed by the media, whilst I was delivering things that I felt were light-hearted. So on the red carpet to the Ivan novellas, I was asked, you know, how, how does it feel to have, you know, everyone hating your song and having everyone calling this really annoying song. And, you know, how does it feel to know that everyone hates you and their song. I was asked that on the red carpet. And I said, "Hey, well, pity me, you know, I'm the poor bastard. It has to sing this song every bloody day." And, but the newspaper article then said, you know, James Brown calls all his critics bastards. You know, I'd use the word bastards, but you've just totally changed. And so I found every joke I said in every interview wasn't relayed against a joke. They never put James jokes. They put everything in it. And I felt really betrayed, which is why when they invented Twitter, I was saved. Because I didn't have to go through a challenge to make the joke and show the more warm, amused or less serious side, I had it in a palm of my hand. Yeah, that must feel incredibly unfair. You're really a deeply frustrating, definitely. Yeah, because it's at various hurdles here, have you? I've created some music. I think that it talks to the human experience in a deep way. I've decided to expose myself. There are criticisms about that. They're kind of maybe a little bit outsized compared with me just talking about what it feels like to be in love. And I like this goal. And isn't it strange to be alone? And wow, being a human's heart. And then the next thing is I try to even play your game, which is sort of what you want. I'll do some self-deprecation. I won't think too highly of myself despite the accent and the background and the boarding school and the office camp. And even that gets waylaid and misrepresented. I didn't know. Did you ever get despondent? Was there a moment where you thought, fuck, it's like, I actually don't know if I can square the circle of this equation and actually make it through as a normal artist? Absolutely. And as I wrote that second album, "Enibita" on my own with "Fingeless Gloves" because someone has stolen my boiler at the time. In that lonely moment, thinking, you know, I was in a sweet house that song and that album had bought me. But I was thinking, yeah, I'd better have this because it feels the dream has really been spoiled and I felt very, very lonely in those times. Were you dating at that time, were you with your partner? I'm not my wife now. No. I was going out at the supermodel at the time. I called to move on from that show. It was a lonely experience, definitely. And I, yeah, and I didn't quite know how to place where I was. You know, I still had a record deal and music to make. But it really felt like no one would want it, or it wouldn't be given the time of day in the UK. And so, yeah, I definitely found the hardest time. Did you ever consider giving up? Well, I've signed a record label and they wanted music, so there's no- I was obliged. No, I was obliged to. I didn't know where I was. I didn't know where I was really. I was a little lost in, lost in myself. And you can really hear that in my second album. It talks about being sent to the grave really by the media. What's interesting is all of the objective metrics that most people are chasing from the outside, I want to be able to sell out arenas. I want to have a number one song. I want to be played on the radio. I want to receive awards. I want to be known. I want people to want to take their photo with me and stuff like that. But when it actually comes down to it, the emotional experience of that is basically neutral. The emotional experience of the numbers, presumably, you wouldn't have felt bad if the numbers were able to compensate for the criticism because the numbers were so astronomical that there's basically no amount of criticism that could have compensated for them. And yet, the criticism felt way more visceral. Does that make sense? It totally does. And I suppose what you're touching on there is the numbers become meaningless. You just want to be liked. You just want affirmation. That's why social media works. We just want to put you a post for some number of people to give it likes. And to not be liked in my home country was at me a little bit. And it's taken me a long time to put that to bed. What did the transcending and including and alchemizing of that experience look like over time? Because we're talking about something that's 20 years ago now. What was the arc of working out what that meant to you and it not being something that defined you? Well, I mean, if you look at, you know, I've seen it because we did a documentary last year and we obviously pulled out lots of footage and you can see a guy who is riding a wave. And I'm having great, great fun. But you can see a sadness in my eyes at the same time. You know, I'm out all the time. And I'm having great fun. And I'm literally living my life in nightclubs. And it was so much fun. I can't. You know, I would highly recommend it as a way of life. And I know you have been to a beefer, but I was doing that across the world and finally myself in the most amazing places in the world and having, I mean, you know, promised you so much fun. But there is something in the back of your mind, which is, yeah, which is thinking that, yeah, isn't it strange that there's so much positive, and yet something so dark and negative back at home stuck in the mind. I think it took a journey. You know, my third album didn't do, didn't do, especially well. The songs weren't especially good, potentially. I mean, you know, though I really do believe in some of them, some of them are magical, but I think you could sense that it wasn't cohesive. It wasn't really for me. I guess that's what's the weird thing I suppose talking about it is, and I can think about some of the songs. They're really good songs, but you can tell there's something missing from them. A belief, a belief, maybe, a little bit of heart. You know, if you speak to Ed Sheeran at the beginning of his career, he just knows he's, you know, he's going to make it because he just talks with such conviction. And if he talked to me at the beginning of my career, you knew that this guy was going to make it because I just believed so much that it would work, naively, not arrogantly, but just naively. By my third album, I couldn't sell you anything. You know, I was out of that game, and I couldn't sell you a song, and I couldn't sing it with conviction. I was writing just with everyone else in mind, with the audience, with the negative reviews that I might get in mind, with everything swirling around my head. And so, yeah, you can see that the songs might be well crafted and well recorded, but there's something really genuinely missing that honesty. Real, you know, it's not me singing it or for me, even. It's someone who's deeply lost at that stage, and it was a journey to find myself again, and I probably only found it completely now. But of course, it started with being able to interact with the public through Twitter, a social media presence, which revealed, okay, you know, I take my music seriously, but I don't do it myself seriously. A whole new persona. There was the musician, the end of the musician, but instead, the online Joker. And that's taken, you know, at a decade in the process, and suddenly you get, okay, guys, we know he had these songs, and we can sort of forgive him because he's able to laugh at himself. And then until, and I've had songs that have worked along the way, but I suppose it's, I feel really, it's only until now that I can take myself out of the music business and say, "I'm just back in the music again." I've got the word, because I'm looking at a staircase behind you. Do you know the term "lospirit de Scallierge?" You know what that means in French? I can work it out. That staircase wit. Yes. And it's your party, and you're having a back-and-forth with somebody, and you think of the perfect verbal repost, but you only think of it when you're walking out the door. Of course. You got a stang. Like I should have, if only could I have not done that. What I'm thinking about is a special kind of nostalgia or whistfulness that a lot of us feel for an experience that we went through, that we feel was somehow tarnished at the time. And we still got to do the thing. It kind of went well, or whatever, like objectively. But we know that sort of subjectively, maybe we weren't quite there in the same way that we wish that we were. And I think that's a unique kind of maybe resentment, inducing, whistfulness, sort of nostalgia, like sadness thing, because you go fuck like, yeah, it was great. Look at all of the things that I did. Here's the photos of me on stage. But if you were actually able to sort of transpose yourself back to that moment, you and only you know the actual inner experience of you being there on stage, accepting the award, or in front of the 10,000 people at your gig, or the platinum album party, whatever, it's like, ah, it's a bit tainted. And how sad that is. And that I think could lead people, lead a lot of people to bitterness, resentment, drugs, retribution. Like there's a lot of incredibly maladaptive ways that you could try to bring that into land. Definitely. And then I think perspective. 20 years in to the gig and I'm still here and still on tour as of next year and still playing venues of a sizeable of a decent size.
the London O2. And so yeah, you know, but it put me in my place, you know, to get a little bit of a kicking is probably a healthy thing. It was inspiring. You know, my second album was what it was because of that. And I'm proud of that second album. I understand what you mean, but to do the healthy thing sounds a little bit like Stockholm Syndrome. I personally, for me, with where I'm at in life at the moment, I would have loved the opportunity for you to have been more earnest in the press interviews, for you to have really gone sort of even deeper into what is the sentiment behind this and like, oh, well, you know, it's very difficult. The sort of the tension of falling in love and of losing somebody and like that to me would have been like, oh, fuck, like how compelling. Yeah. And instead, you have to sort of play in the show. Totally. Well, it was really interesting, actually, my first album wasn't really about romance and love. There were only two songs that mentioned the girl. I'm in the album, the restaurant about drugs and war. And so I was really thinking, hang on, I'm totally independent artists singing about very cool things. And yet, I mean, tainted with this celery label of this romantic. And even your beautiful was just about a guy high on drugs, talking someone else's girlfriend in a public space. That's not a romantic either. But my love was a failed romance. So I was, you know, lost in this and the earnestness thing. Yeah, you're right. I now, when I sell music, I don't sell it with any earnestness at all. This album is, is, is, is, is heavy in many ways. It's dark in many ways. I wanted to call this album reason to die. James Brunt, reason to die. That'll sell. That was going to be an epic, epic, the irony of that. I thought it was fantastic. But my record label laughed at me when I said that my manager said, maybe it's the time we start working together. We've reached that moment. And, you know, it's a really desperately dark, heavier album in that way. But I won't promote it with the same earnestness as I might have done on that first album because I know that doesn't work for me. And I protect myself. The earnestness is there. It's on the songs. You know, when I tell you what those songs are about, I will brush over their meaning. I won't tell you their meaning. Even if the meaning is right in those words, and it's fairly, fairly obvious, if you look at those lyrics, for me, there's no point in doing that. And so I'll tell it to you with humor. Such a shame, dude. It's such a shame. I'm grateful for the industry that I've elected to be in because, hopefully, the world of podcasting for many ills that it's got. Here's the appropriate British throat clearing thing that I need to fucking do before I say something that's remotely positive about anything that I've ever done. But I do think that we have been able to give space for a conversation which allows complex earnestness to marinate sufficiently so that people can actually get full fucking context for what is meant by this thing. And to tell a story that's not just in a 30-second sound bite, and to know that you're going in, and this person's not an enemy, that they're actually like earnest, that genuinely seriously on the other side of this going, "Huh, what was that like? I want to learn about this thing from you and go, wow, like 20 years ago, that was simply something that wasn't available." And you were talking before about how album 3 for you has this almost sort of compensation in it where you're sort of thinking, "I understand what is going to happen when I try to make songs like this. I'm in the same way as you might have cultivated or compensated with how you promote. It even had started to infect the songwriting and the sort of construction of that too." Very much. I was protecting myself. It's not no point in being quite so honest and open if you know you're going to be judged quite so harshly. So you write a beautiful song, but they're the same put in layers of protection into it. There's a term from online content creation which you might be familiar with called audience capture. And Ethan Strauss has another idea which is called criticism capture and I think that you are a victim of both, interestingly enough. So audience capture, you start to produce something, the audience gives you feedback when they like something you do and instead of continuing to do what you want to do, you feed the audience the red meat that you think that they want. And criticism capture which Ethan says is even more warping than audience capture and I agree with him is compensating in advance for what you think the critics may say. So sometimes you don't take yourself so seriously or you caveat in advance so that any criticisms may be sort of front run by you or you become overly militant and very aggressive so that you're sort of a feared opponent so that people don't do the criticism thing. And when those two combine together both criticism capture and audience capture, I want you to like me and I don't want you to hate me. That can be pretty deranging. I think maybe you are the therapist that I need after all. Yeah, I think so, you know, I say the criticism capture, I thought I critique myself before you can. That's what I do online and with the audience capture, absolutely, I have done that where I'm unable to not have the audience in the room while I'm recording, while I'm writing and recording, they are already in the room, the recovery in the room and the audience. And I've said it before, it just doesn't work if you do that because you know that one of them wants to be a shade of black and the other a shade of white and you just create gray in the middle and please no one and neither. So yeah, it's been a journey to remove oneself from that. I've spent the last month sleeping on a tour bus and hotel beds and I've taken one of these every single night. Nightly sleep by Momentus have saved my sleep and they are now formulated even better and $50 cheaper than they were previously. Imagine that better and significantly more affordable. Didn't know that you could still do that in 2026. The brand new triple action formula combines magnesium, bisclisonate with apogenin and althene to help you wind down, fall asleep and stay asleep. No melatonin, no sleep paralysis demons at the end of your bed. Plus, it's NSF certified, meaning that even Olympians can use it and it is screened for banned substances. Best of all, they've got a 30-day money back guarantee, so can buy it completely risk-free and if you don't like it for any reason, they'll give you your money back. Plus, they ship internationally. Right now, we can get up to 35% off your first subscription and that 30-day money back guarantee. By going to the link in the description below, you flinched. You flinched. Head to livemomentus.com/modernwisdom and use the code ModernWisdom to check out for 35% off your subscription. That's L-I-V-E-M-O-M-E into your US.com/modernwisdom and ModernWisdom. Check out the f*** you. You flinched. What would you tell a young man who manages to achieve sudden success and sudden scrutiny at the same time? Well, I'm part of it, I did really well, which I really did enjoy. Half of it I really, really enjoyed. I've watched the Elton biopic and it sort of looks like he didn't enjoy some of that. Robbie Williams hears as well, sounds like he didn't enjoy it. For me, I've had the time of my life, really. But there is something I learned from Elton, which he did call me up and say, listen, f*** him. You know, f*** him. Doesn't that? I probably should have taken that on board a little bit sooner and a little bit more to heart, because you're the one riding the wave and they're watching from the beach. Yeah, I think that's certainly a little American trait that more British people could take on. There's sort of two reactions typically to criticism. One is to get mad and the other is to get sad. It's like, you're the problem or I'm the problem. And you're the problem thing is often like it's now called on the internet crashing out or like losing it or losing your cool, which is very uncool by design. But it can, if you can sort of garner some of that internally, it can be pretty f***ing potent fuel. It's like, no, f*** you. Like, I'm going to keep doing this thing. And yeah, I am on stage. And yeah, I did sell all of those records. Yeah, absolutely. Which is why I think, again, my second album really was, was that, you know, it was a reaction to that. And of course, and I think that's why it goes on to another thing that you were talking about earlier, which is, you know, the heaviest times in your life are the most inspiring. You know, it is hard to write about things when you're, when you're a, having great, great fun because you're just not going to write them because you're just too busy having fun or whether you're living, you know, in great comfort is you don't necessarily, you don't grow when you're in great comfort. I mean, you're not necessarily inspired when you're in great comfort. But when you're not, when you're in a great hardship and discomfort, that's when you learn, grow and are inspired. I think about when someone who's trying to sort of swim into a river and compared with if you were lazy rivering down it, when you're lazy rivering down it, everything is actually in stasis. Everything is moving along at the same pace. And if you were to think about the sensation that you have as being kind of the insights of life, whereas when you're brushing up against the grain of it, when you're really sort of pushing into that, stuff's coming at you and you're really feeling it. And I think that the reason that you pay so much more attention when things are difficult is that you're trying to unpick this problem. Like, huh, things aren't working. Therefore, solution must be found. Therefore, pay fucking attention. It's supposed to be like, everything's great. The band's awesome. Health's fine. Kids are good. Yeah. Totally. And I suppose in that same way, if you, if everything's going fine in something like the music business and maybe in yours too, if you're coasting, it's probably a, you think it's coasting, it's probably a slow decline. And if you, you know, you have to aspire to grow even just to keep it flat, you know.
just and so and again I've been lucky but to still be in this business for so long but it's taken hard work to keep it growing in some way that takes effort and work to still aspire and you know I'm lucky enough to be playing arenas all around the UK but I do say to myself you know I aspire to play the stadiums may not happen but it's worth aspiring to pretty fucking cool I was thinking about that maybe I'll get a support gig and we're staying together that'll do Ed Sheeran's looking for one um maybe the naivety thing of youth I'm very interested in that so a lot of people that are young want increasingly now success you'd start your bit if you're not hustling your tight hustle by 18 years old the falling behind etc etc um but I do think that there is a certain kind of competitive advantage that a lack of kicks to the nuts gives you that you can't have once the nuts have been kicked yes I think you're right um for me definitely that naivety was was a great thing um to just have the naive blind conviction of course I can make sure that you know sure I'll leave the army and I'll get a record deal and you know and and sure enough I did and I ended up you know living in in and Beverly Hills uh and then my album got around the world and even when my first label custard records when they signed over my album to a major record label that major record label crashed um and they and they and it merged with another and they got rid of the 77 acts on their label they got rid of 70 of them and they only kept seven and my manager said you know this is this hasn't gone smoothly and I said well you know I've just made my album of course would be fine you know of course I'm going to be one of the seven rights and it just that naive belief that this is going to work is is a glorious wonderful thing which is as you say you I can never find myself back to to that place yeah uh it's something similar with Dean who was sat there but it was no wherever the fuck he is back there and he's been my video guy for over eight years now since I started basically since it's essentially the first episode and um we always had this insight that yeah we're like we're criminally under-subscribed and we should we should have like the conversations that we're having we we definitely can we can make this work and it wasn't it's different to confidence it's different confidence it's definitely not arrogance it's just a naivety yeah it is beautiful yeah it's really cool and I wonder whether this speedrunning of scrutiny by the fact that people are so exposed now to the early work of anyone right like your first gigs that you played at working man's clubs around wherever the fuck you were Ipswich or something like that is not available for me to see it is not available for the whole world's to criticize or for you to see how inflated or deflated your ego should be and I think that uh an incubation period uh for stuff like that is really really cool definitely I think you're probably right in that way because as you say I mean I think you can still have knockbacks and you learn from those knockbacks but to have a constant pecking of negativity must take it out of you and slowly erodes what is uh what something you were worried about at 30 that sort of seems completely ridiculous to you now at 30 yeah 30 years old I'm still 30 now um at 30 well you know I suppose 30 as you say was when I started in the in the music business and it's your your heading out into a world that you don't necessarily know and understand and don't if you can sustain yeah um and and it may all fall apart and then you may go and I have to get a proper job and I wouldn't learn what to do the way army probably wouldn't have had me back and so at that stage it's just sustaining it is is a thing I think a lot about uh people who have the talent to achieve what they want within an industry or achieve their dreams but don't necessarily have the disposition to be able to deal with what comes along with it and I wrote this essay a couple of years ago and it was inspired by watching the Lewis Capaldi documentary right is just so beautiful every time I watch it gets better it's so good how I'm feeling now I can't wait at some point we'll get him on the show we've spoken to his people and he's keen to come on he's just having a little bit of a distance from the press stuff at the moment it seems like and hopefully writing like some more awesome songs but I was watching that documentary and what I saw was someone who has like beyond generational talent like so fucking good at what he does but a unique constitution that was almost in opposition to what his dreams were the um fear of scrutiny the sensitivity that made his songs and makes your songs are like so rich and deeply compelling to people was the same thing that was exposing him to the pressure absolutely he wasn't he was also the self-deprecation thing very interesting that he went about that I mean who was a period of time where he referred to himself as dressing like a lesbian like the the grass glasses like him in a diaper like the crazy sort of selfies in the in the mirror and stuff like that like so brilliantly British in that way I guess specifically Scottish and I saw this world where there was someone who was like not even close to achieving that dream was like in the dream and not because of a lack of talent was potentially risking being ripped out of it because of just like the byproduct of the pressure that comes along with it yeah and I suppose what he was doing is exactly what you're talking about again you know the critique he was protecting himself from that by doing it first telling the joke first um and mocking himself before anyone else did and then doesn't he do it so beautifully but you know but but you know talking about an artist who sort of does something similar to me which is we stand up and I'll stay on the stage and we effectively remove everything that protects us you know effectively remove our clothes and stand there naked to our soul and say this is the worst of me this is the worst of me I don't get up with a with a hype guy and saying you know who's saying isn't he great we do something different we stand up on our own on the whole and and show it all and everyone points and laughs um but still we but still we you know can go out and say now this is how I feel and the reward of that is amazing I do have to say the reward of that is incredible to stand on a stage and sing your little heart out about something that means so much and feel the excitement as a crowd you know we'll feel that too to stand out and watch you know an audience cry with you um you know it's an amazing when you've taken them on that emotional journey when you can touch their you know the most delicate parts of the soul that's why my you know some people play weddings but I try and get gigs at funerals they're just an easier audience um is is magic but it comes you know it's weird I suppose because you know isn't he is the brave one isn't he he's the brave one who shows it all off and I think there's a certain courage to stand up and say rather than rather than put on some kind of shell and brave face to open yourself up to that Christmas kind of there's a bravery to it and it puts you up for criticism but the reward is huge I think it's the purest form of bravery you know I had a navy seal on the party he's been on a bunch of times he's a friend uh guy called jocke Willink and he was talking to Sam Harris neuroscientist a slightly odd pairing it's a bit like Batman and Spider-Man having a conversation it's a little bit strange and uh they were talking about how you can't fake bravery as an emotion that if you don't feel scared then committing the action isn't bravery because you won't overcoming anything yeah absolutely without the fear without the exposure without the revealing of yourself you're kind of drifting through life and I get it like not every musical artist or podcast or or you know piece of fucking literature or media or whatever is supposed to transcend the sort like some of it can be comedies some of it can just be like like kind of mindless comfort food right like that's one that's good and you should consume that stuff but for some reason I the opportunity for someone to really fucking bear themselves really really show like this is how I feel and this is a part like petty yeah the game falls yeah and it becomes it's an exciting moment you know and I and I dirt with you know I can just watch videos back I've seen of you know playing goodbye my lover and you can see you can hear the fear in my voice and you can hear the fragility in the voice and you can feel the electricity in the room because the people are watching a guy literally bearing his soul at that moment and you know that for me that that has always been the live performance adrenaline rush yeah that's interesting I suppose with like a DJ or like a sort of big rock band or something it might be trying to maximize the sort of peak moment like sort of loudness emotion but then there's the other side as well which is like how deeply can this thing sort of pierce through and it's a very different kind of energy but yeah I mean it's a it's still a massive peak experience yeah absolutely um and I suppose that's where you know a live concert of mine that's what we try and do we try and have high is but so that you can suck people into those lows because you can't do that all the time yeah how have you been changed going from so much of yourself maybe all of yourself being invested into like I am recording artist I am singer songwriter man if you don't like me or my work then I am not much how healing transcending has it been to do the
Why family kids thing, what was that? - Yeah, you know, those are things that mean the most. You know, those were the questions that I had as a young man of who I would meet, who where I would live, you know, and who would give me peace. - I'll be young, apparently. - Yeah, but you know, those are the questions we all ask us, who are we gonna end up and share that journey with? That has meant much more, absolutely. - And along that journey, you know, and I'm moving on because I just try not to speak too much about my family just 'cause I'm always shy about that or protective about it, but along the journey, whilst I've had those kind of negative responses to the first album, whilst still getting massive, positive responses 'cause millions of people were bought it. Eventually time heals everything, it really does. You know, now young kids come up to me and they love my first album because they, you know, they were forced to listen to by their parents, and so once upon a time, this guy was, you know, desperately uncool, but the kids don't know that. - Yeah, they're able to see it with the purity of, it's like unbiased, that's easy, you know. And I feel like reminding you, you know, doing those, it's really uncool to like that. And they've moved on. So time and the first album is moved on from that. - How fascinating that people who missed the first wave of public opinion and a lot of people form their opinions just based on the opinions of others, which means that you have a few real thinkers and basically a couple of armies of people being marionetted by them. - Exactly. - But that you have a perspective of your work, which is undetachable from that initial sphere. - Absolutely. - And someone can come up and say that they see your work in a way that you wish that you could have done at the time, didn't at the time, don't now, but they do. - Absolutely, and it's a really wonderful thing. And you know, for me, that's come, as I say, because you know, the music was one thing, and then the social media presence became another thing. And then the young people have just, they only know the social media presence. And then because Spotify now creates, you can find music of any era. And you know, so an older song, they just associate with the social media guy that they know. So they assume it must be, you know, it must be something they can admit to listening to. - A click-as-side running out of a product is a pretty good test of how much you actually like it. Do you order more or just get on with your life? I've kept coming back to element for more than half a decade, and it's the first thing that I drink every single morning, for good reason, reduces muscle cramps and fatigue, helps to optimize brain health and regulate your appetite, but, mate, you can't hit me. I might (beep) neo. I feel the difference when I take it versus when I don't. Of the two of us here, only one of us is fully hydrated, and that is because I've been taking element. No sugar, no junk, no artificial ingredients, and that's why I choose by everyone. From Dr. Andrew Huberman to the Olympic athletes and sniper teams, the good sniper teams, not the bad ones, and they have a no questions asked for refund policy. So, if you buy this, and for any reason you don't like it, they'll just give you your money back. Plus, they offer free shipping in the United States. Right now, get a free sample pack of elements, most popular flavors, with your first purchase by going to the link in the description below, or by heading to drinklmnt.com/modernwisdom. So, let's drinklmnt.com/modernwisdom. Good duck, well played. After celebrity traders, what did you learn about how good people are at lying and how good or bad you are? - Well, it's a really interesting game. It's a social experiment, really, and we're mice in a trap. The idea is that an uninformed majority will, on the whole, lose to an informed minority, and that case in point, really, it's a TV show too, which is a whole different conversation, with the edits that go in to make it what it is. And I did feel like a mouse in a trap trying to get out, I was trying to commit game show suicide every day. It's also not really, it's not a detective show at all, it's a guessing game, really. And so, yeah, what you're talking about is lying. And people's ability to lie on the basics of an A, B lie, it's very easy, isn't it, apart from for Richard E. Grant? - How good do you think you would have been a deception for the duration of that? - I don't know. What I do know is that if you accuse me of anything, whether I'm innocent or guilty, I will go bright red, and I will want to kill you. And so, we were playing a game where people asked me if I were a traitor, and I was not, but I would still go bright red and want to launch myself across the table for you, how dare you accuse me of something. And what was amazing about the social experiment is how easy we get sucked in to the game and lost in the game in many ways. - And forget that it is a game too. - Absolutely. - You made it all the way to the final only to be banished by Ramesh and Bash. How does it feel to have survived an actual war but nearly being defeated by a group of comedians in a Scottish castle? - Yeah, in "Treeing", it's a very different beast. Definitely. You know, it was amusing. What they didn't show you is I was constantly, constantly saying, guys, actually, I really don't care who we kill or banished. As long as you're not the one being murdered, doesn't matter. And as long as I just apologize profusely when I get it wrong, getting it wrong, we'll be fine in there. But yeah, it was, it was, as I say, it was intriguing to be part of the social experiment. I felt, you know, I've described it as a marathon, it was pretty miserable, but great to have done. - How long was filming? - Just over three weeks, I think. And it did, you know, I did walk away slightly affected by it. I realized that, you know, wow, I tore the world all the time and I am away from my family. And here I am again, volunteering, volunteering to be away from them and for what? For sort of, you know, I'm doing it presumably for self-promotion and yet the people who really matter to me are at home and I really need to, you know, I need to not do that 'cause time with them is precious. - Yeah, that sounds maybe less glamorous, more downtime, more hurry up and wait, which it's not quite the same on tour. You know, if you've got a three, I just did, I told you, tour around the UK and Ireland and we did four shows in four days, including one from Edinburgh at Portsmouth, which is a 13, 14 hour drive, which is about as intense as you can get in the UK. I'm aware America can get much more smelly than that. But there is no, by the time you've arrived somewhere, you can maybe get a shower, then you're sound checking, you get to eat, ish, like the gym is a long gone memory. And before you know it, you're like, oh, okay, well, it's time for me to the fucking cues outside. I can't leave the bus, can't go outside of the dressing room, can hear people filing in. I wonder whether the distance from what matters but without the compensation of, I'm doing what I love and there's like chaos and it's sort of distracting to me, is a really fatal dose of contrast, the. - Yeah, absolutely. I think in that environment, yeah, you realise you're slightly, you know, you're a voluntary captive and then it makes you just, it puts you in a position where you start asking questions and stuff, why you would volunteer to do this. - There's a lot of time to reflect. - Yeah, I mean, we weren't at the hotel that much because obviously you know, we're from 1030 till up to 4am, you're in a castle. But it's, you know, but they are setting up a show in which we don't get to see very, very much, you know, the closing curtains and blinds that you can't really see what's going outside. So you're losing track of time and control. And so, yeah, it made me reflect as to my own part in it, my choice to be them. - Did you learn more about human nature from reflecting on the people that lies convincingly or the people that were confidently wrong? - I don't know. I don't know if I learned that much from the actual game itself, you know, it's as simple. You're just guessing as to who clued a walk round and fingered it in that on the first episode. And I suppose you just see different characters and how they'll do things. You know, some people who know how to play their game when they're quiet and don't reveal themselves, there are others who just want to get it all out and get it on with. You know, I'm impatient. And I want to just get on with the games I'm, when I wander around and accuse people of lots of different things. - Yes. - And would rather do that and then be booted off the show rather than hang around. - Yeah, you failed massively at that. If your goal was to be able to get back home and wishing like, oh, it would be really nice first back with the wife and kids. I've got all this time off tour and I've got this new album coming out in a couple of minutes. - And I was really trying to get out. - Desperately unsuccessful, even unsuccessful at being unsuccessful, which is. - Absolutely, that was remarkable. And the only time I had an over emotional moment was I walked into the interview room and there was no envelope for me. Everyone else when they saw the envelope was like, damn, and I walked in, there was no envelope. And there's a voice from a little speaker says, you know, good morning, come on in, let's sit down and say what you're thinking in I, and I had a moment saying, but where's my envelope? Really, those were my wares, but where's my envelope? I was, yeah, I was a mouse and a sharp desperate to get out of that stage. - It sounds like inverse Harry Potter, you wanted to receive a letter telling you that you needed to leave Hogwarts. - Exactly, yeah. Talk to me about the new album. - For me, as I say, it's been 20 years in the making. And I said to my family and I said to those around me, I was no longer gonna pursue the radio hits that I have been chasing.
because you can listen to radio, try and replicate what is, you know, what is of the moment, and you'll be nine months behind the curve, and you'll sound like you're impersonating it, and it's simply not me. And instead, I want to go into music again for what I do best, which is to describe the darkest corners in my little heart and inside my mind. And I told my, my wife don't be afraid by what you might hear. I'm perfectly happy, but I need to go and reach into these corners. And so I wrote an album of songs that were with me looking in the mirror talking to myself, and that's very, very hard to do knowing I'll put it out. And as I say, I don't want to explain the songs in the great depth because I just don't feel comfortable doing that, but it was an amazing, cathartic moment to be freed again. And the joy, I suppose, as I say, my record label put out my greatest hits a couple of years ago. So you only put out a greatest hits when you're dead. And so if I'm dead, then this is a new life, and I don't have to think about anything business-wise, or I don't have to prove myself in any way, this is all gravy. And as a result of that, I'm back doing it for the music, not for the business. I think about this all the time from Peaky Blinders, where Arthur Shelby and Tommy Shelby were at the battle of the Psalm, and they were supposed to have died as they were the tunnel diggers, and they didn't, and then there's very fortunately managed to survive, and they always have this tagline that they say to each other, which is everything after that was extra, everything after that was extra, and it feels a little bit like this is the. And I feel, yeah, and I feel that for me, everything brought here is gravy. I understand why. I'm still kind of, I don't know whether I'm a saddened, I guess I would say I'm a little bit saddened, by the understandable distance that you put between yourself and the songs and sort of breaking those things down. There is a parallel universe, there is a splinter universe somewhere from sort of 2000, 2003 or whatever that broke off, where I can sort of push and poke and like do the thing and pull it out, not because of some desire to prostrate your personal pain, but because I'm like, I really, really want to know what he thinks about that thing, about that song, about what keeps him up at night, about whether he has a bad relationship with his phone. Totally. Well also, what I'm using about that is I also go into a studio with a producer or maybe another songwriter and I'm writing these songs and I'm having to write those songs with someone who might be our other friend, but they might be a complete stranger. And I'm still writing songs that are right from the darkest parts of my soul, the most fragile parts of my soul, the bits that I protect the most because they're otherwise, because they will be mistreated or laughed at, as I say. So to be in a studio is someone and I'm finding those moments is tough. I highly expose them. Because I don't want to betray the relationships I'm in, if I'm talking about my own family, to them, I don't want to betray that trust that I have in my in my own life at home. So that can be a thing in itself and I find ways around that, you know, I'll talk to you about one song and it's, you know, get ready for it. Get ready for it. Don't be frightened. Don't be frightened. But I went to Nashville to write with a guy called Mickey Echo and who wrote Stay with Rihanna. I'd written with lots of other people in Nashville, record label, sends you out to get right with these people. You feel like in a part of a factory, it's fairly meaningless and very hard to get involved. But Mickey, I have been a fan of and I love that song Stay, especially as an incredible song. And so I met him and I said Mickey, it's great to me. I've been saving, I've been saving it up for you. And he went, okay, oh shit. Here we go. And I said, you know, so, you know, I don't know what it is we're going to write today, but I know it's going to be from the heart. And I'd walked to you, you know, and no one else is walking in Nashville, baking hot. And I'd walked the surveyor and a half to his studio and I'd crossed over a freeway. And as I did, they're looking down at the freeway, the cars coming this way and cars going that way. And I said to Mickey, so what I was thinking as I was walking across is if I were to jump, would I jump the side where the cars are coming towards you? Or would I jump the side where you can't see the cars? You know, if you can see the car, you can time it pretty well, Mickey. You know, hit the ground and you're down. And if you jump the other side, you won't know. And you can see him starting to go, okay, we've got a problem here. I said, well, so actually I've had another thought, which is that if you jump that side, you might actually land on the car and then you might really damage their car, which would be bad or worse. So I think maybe we're not going to, if we were to consider doing that, we shouldn't do it here. We should do it somewhere like, you know, at home. But that would be bad, because one's family could find you. And I couldn't tell my, you know, my family, and I certainly wouldn't want my father to find me. He looked off me, you know what? If I were to do anything bad to myself, I'd call my brother-in-law. Because you know what? He's always been tricky with me. So this would be my way of being tricky with them. And Mickey, I mean, said, you know, where the hell have you got this? And he started getting, you know, I need a moment. And he set up and he called his manager. I could hear him calling his manager saying, I thought I'm just going to write another, you're beautiful with this guy. And he walked in and I said, thank you. You've allowed me to do exactly what I need to do. This is where the song is. I'm not looking for a bitch to jump from. I'm just looking for a hand to hold. And at that moment, we wrote a song. And it's just about the pressures in your life and the burden that you might feel as stresses of being someone with responsibilities and the little family and the struggles and the strains. But I had to find something that would trigger it. Some, you know, emotional thing. And I had to take him on a little emotional journey to get us there. And I'm a very happy human being. But to get yourself into that space takes you just, you need to go into a little dark corner and find it. And then put it into paper. Presumably, he called off the intervention that he thought was imminent. It was very funny because we finished the song. He just did, he went out of the box of Keeler and said, I just need to ask you a question. Are you okay? And I said, Mickey, just trying to write a song. I wonder whether you mentioned before, I don't need therapy. I've got my songwriting to sort of do that for me. I wonder whether certain artists fear healing because it would drain some of the well that they extract the insights from. You know, if you manage to, I see this in business that a lot of ambition is born out of pain and discordance and conflict and a chip on your shoulder being doubted, a lack of validation and need for recognition, wanting to be admired by people you admire and as people heal, transcend whatever those sort of deeper darker parts of themselves are, a lot of the time that ambition begins to dissipate a little bit more, it takes on a different flavor. Yeah. And I wonder whether there is an equivalent for a songwriting, singing songwriters that, well, you know, like maybe a small drug addiction would actually be creatively useful for the juice. Yeah, I think it works probably in both ways. I think to have incredible confidence probably can be helpful at different times, you know, if you're a sportsman, if you're a tennis player, to overcome, you know, you're going a set down or a two sets down in tennis, much of that is about the confidence to know you can. And I think that goes in many aspects of our life confidence, breeds more confidence and breeds success. But I think a struggle and pain are probably inspirational things for someone who's creative in some way. The word confidence is an interesting one. Was there a moment where like confidence, self-belief got knocked too? Absolutely. And I would wish for that naivety that I had before, is a sad thing to sort of say to you, I will never have as big a commercial success as I did with Back to Bedlam and you're beautiful. To sadness that I should say that, because what I should be doing is being American about this, shouldn't I? And say this album is going to supersede those by a mass. I think that's what I meant by the question of what is the problem or what are the challenges of having such an outstanding first entry. I'm good friends with Mark Manson. And although technically Manson wrote the subtle art of not giving a fuck, it's this orange buck that you'll see in every sample around the world. Morgan Housel is the same, the psychology of money. Two people in basically the same situation. James Clear with Atomic Habits, a third friend who's again the same. Mark knows that no matter what he does, the likelihood of him like catching lightning again like that is essentially zero. It was already zero. And then the chance of it happened catching lightning in a bottle twice, like go fuck yourself, dude. And he has had to grapple with that. And there is a kind of Morgan, maybe not, but certainly with Mark and with you as well, there is a kind of like twinkle in the eye, a kind of like dignity or he probably something closer to like humility, self awareness with like a little bit of a grin that I think is it just has to be part of a like Oh fuck. Like I can't believe that that happened. Yeah, I'm like, yeah, oh,
Obviously I'm blessed and obviously it's not gonna happen in that same way again. It's kind of hilarious It is totally and you know what when I have to realize it doesn't matter It doesn't matter, you know if you've caught that lightning once then you caught it Yeah, you caught it and it was you know, and then everything else is gravy So so and you know and I genuinely do feel that I mean as I say I when I describe Myself and where I am lucky as the word I continually use Live lucky and still thoroughly enjoying it. I have the best time. I have had an amazing time It's very very different now, but it's still absolutely just as exciting and just as fun and and I guess the question You know, would you change it? Would you change it? Would I prefer to have a tiny first album and think damn missed it? Hmm and work on a second and now be talking to you on my eighth album and now would it be going now? No, because it would have been 20 years of struggle. I've just had the best time. Yeah. Yeah. Um, I just you know, it was yeah It's it's it's label sometimes as a burden. Yeah to have that big one But no god has been a blessing. Well, there any inflection points around confidence was because it gets knocked and then Objective metrics evidently can't be the salvation at least not for the foreseeable future Was there a person a mentor? Was there any any moment where you're like? Oh fuck No, and I still have you know issues with with certain aspects of confidence with music You know, I can still find things never I can going on to a stage singing a new song a TV show where you never know You know, you're there for three and a half minutes and you make humiliate yourself in front of the nation I feel that absolutely I Question myself as to how to overcome those all time, you know, and then yeah, and I haven't actually entirely dealt with that But you know it'll be over in three minutes. We'll deal with deal with the fallout and yet here you are, you know like is someone that maybe does have a degree of a nervous Disposition around certain situations that could be a person that would take criticism to heart and like a two-decade career. I don't know I find It's a very British like heroic story In that way, you know, you think about an American one which would be much more sort of hurrah-rah It's like David Goggins like just fucking and get over them, dude It's you know, it's the guy that said that gets mad that doesn't get sad, but there's not enough role model conversations Around that are built for people who don't have that like middle finger reaction muscle Yeah, and I think that that's that's very reassuring because lots of people are a bit more nervous than they wish That they were when it comes to the thing they love totally and you know what and I guess what I'm lucky about is that you know With again with a little bit of age you know that there will be highs and lows and you enjoy the highs And you pick yourself up from the lows and I'm still on the same record label Atlantic records my record label And you know, I've had lows and I've had highs and through the lows they have forgiven me my manager, too And and I've sure and I've looked at them occasions thinking they caught certain things up But we have worked as a team and you know that is life life is as it's highs and as lows And you just need to make sure that you learn from those lows and and and aren't so damaged by them that you don't Pick yourself up and fight for another high and enjoy that high when it comes and real James blunt ladies and gentlemen James you're great. I appreciate you very much once coming up Where should people go to check out everything that's going on? I am vlogging tickets for a tool which starts in February on JamesBlunt.com and I have a new album that called Airplay mode on Friday. Beautiful. Appreciate you mate. Until next time. Thank you so much. Hey, a quick note. One thing that we've been told by a lot of our subscribers is that on Apple Podcasts Spotify and YouTube They've been unsubscribed or unfollowed even though they pressed it So just do me a favor and check below if that has happened Tapping to a lot of people means that you get to find out about episodes before anybody else and it supports the show and makes me very happy indeed Just give it a little check. Give it a little tap. All will be well. I thank you [CLICK]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
James Blunt’s music career began with a deep emotional honesty, rooted in personal experiences from boarding school, military service, and emotional vulnerability.
His early success was met with harsh media backlash, leading to public humiliation and a sense of being labeled a failure, despite the emotional authenticity of his songs.
The British cultural tendency to mock or distance itself from sincerity contrasts with American openness, where success is celebrated and individuality is embraced.
Blunt developed self-deprecation and humor as a defense mechanism, protecting himself from criticism by anticipating negative reactions and creating a buffer between his truth and public judgment.
Over time, he evolved from emotional exposure to a more balanced approach, recognizing that honesty in music doesn’t require constant vulnerability, and that emotional resilience is key to long-term growth.
His journey reflects a cycle of emotional highs and lows, where personal experience and authenticity remain central, even as he distances himself from the public’s expectations.
The concept of "criticism capture" and "audience capture" shaped his early songwriting, where he tailored content to avoid backlash, ultimately leading to a more authentic artistic reawakening.
Blunt now values emotional depth over commercial success, finding fulfillment in live performance and personal connection rather than industry accolades.
Summary:
James Blunt’s journey from a deeply emotional, earnest artist to a resilient, self-aware musician is central to his story. His early success stemmed from raw emotional authenticity, shaped by formative experiences like boarding school and military service. However, this honesty drew intense media criticism in the UK, where success is often met with mockery rather than celebration—contrasting sharply with the American culture of embracing vulnerability and celebrating achievement.
To survive this backlash, Blunt adopted self-deprecating humor and defensive strategies, such as anticipating criticism and crafting music to avoid negative reception. Over time, he evolved beyond these mechanisms, realizing that emotional truth doesn’t require constant public exposure. His second album, *All the Lost Souls*, became a turning point, reflecting deep personal pain and loneliness, while his later work balances honesty with self-protection.
Blunt emphasizes that true artistic fulfillment comes not from commercial success or awards, but from genuine emotional connection with audiences. He now views his career as a journey of self-discovery, where authenticity, resilience, and perspective have allowed him to stay grounded and continue performing with integrity. His story highlights the tension between vulnerability and survival in the music industry, and how personal growth can transform pain into lasting artistry.
Ultimately, he has found peace in authenticity, not fame, proving that emotional depth and self-awareness can endure even in a media-driven world.
FAQs
James Blunt defines earnestness as the bravery to take emotions seriously. He believes this honesty in music allows listeners to connect with real, authentic emotions, forming a deep personal connection despite the British tendency to be cynical or distant.
His time in the army provided structured downtime and exposure to real-life experiences, such as war and crisis, which inspired emotional depth in his songs. The discipline and emotional resilience from military life also shaped his songwriting approach.
Social media, especially Twitter, allowed James Blunt to express self-deprecation and humor, helping him navigate criticism. It gave him control over his public image and enabled him to maintain a sense of humor and perspective amid intense media backlash.
The album's emotional honesty and vulnerability were seen as over-sensitive by some, especially in the British media, which often criticizes authenticity. The backlash was amplified by media narratives and a cultural preference for irony over sincerity.
He gained attention through a chance meeting with Linda Perry, who formed a new label and offered him a deal. This breakthrough gave him the opportunity to develop his music with a trusted producer and build a career grounded in authenticity.
Criticism capture refers to anticipating negative feedback and adjusting his work in advance to avoid it. Blunt acknowledges this as a defense mechanism, which has influenced his songwriting by adding layers of protection to avoid harsh criticism.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.