The Sporting Class: Baseball's Salary Cap, Universal Playoff Expansion... and Elon Musk, Owner?
51m 24s
The episode centers on the growing tension between MLB owners and players over a potential salary cap, driven by widening payroll disparities and fan demand for competitive balance. While owners argue for a cap to control spending and maintain league stability, players and fans see it as a step toward fairness, with over half of fans supporting such measures. The discussion reveals a deeper conflict: owners seek to protect their financial interests, players demand equitable pay, and fans want meaningful competition—especially for smaller-market teams. A key insight is that both sides are using PR strategies to gain public sympathy, despite the fact that internal incentives often favor self-interest. The show also explores how broadcasters value game content, with special events like the NBA Cup or college playoff expansions designed to boost viewership and revenue. Ultimately, the conversation highlights a systemic issue in sports—how power imbalances and financial disparities undermine public trust and fan engagement. While a salary cap may be a practical tool, its real impact depends on whether it truly serves the public interest, not just the financial interests of owners. The episode concludes with a nod to evolving sports business models, where "jewel events" and playoff innovation aim to create more value, but without addressing the root problem of unequal opportunity. The tone remains grounded in skepticism, emphasizing that while solutions may seem logical, they must balance economic realities with fairness and sustainability.
Welcome to Pablo Torre Finds Out, brought to you by Apple Card.
I am Pablo Torre, and today we're going to find out what this sound is.
If this was the Batman series, it would be,
tune in next week to find out what Pablo was afraid to say.
Right after this.
It's been too long since we've had both of you guys here.
John Skipper, David Sampson, together at last.
The people have demanded it, John.
Well, sort of together at last.
I'm used to being able to reach out and touch David.
So the fact that he's in this amorphous sphere somewhere,
you know, it's not quite as good as having him right here.
I miss your mutual affection for each other.
I miss David's fear of John's germs.
I miss. That's what this is about.
You're out of reach.
I just couldn't bear to be. I couldn't be in the same room as you, John.
I just couldn't.
I was too concerned about, like, end-of-days pandemic-type stuff.
All these things are jumping off me, but they've got nowhere to go.
So it's all a confusion of fungi and bacteria and viral material.
Between the two of your sweaters, I'm happy to be here in the camera.
People have asked how many times have I gotten my cardigan washed.
And I am proud to report,
game-worn, yet-to-be-seller,
bullied by such technology.
You look like a bench player.
I mean, I smell like a bench.
Nothing on your uniform.
I was looking at this power rankings from Front Office Sports
about the owners in sports who donated the most to federal races,
and John was, of course, unsurprised to learn that Miriam Adelson
has put at least $67 million into helping Republicans keep Congress,
at which point he pointed out that, uh. There's no chance that one day, Elon Musk becomes a sports owner.
Yeah. Those numbers would go up a lot.
And I just want to think about that for a second,
because I hadn't contemplated the world, David,
in which Elon owns a sports team,
but now I can't not think about it.
Yeah, I don't think he'd buy a team.
I think he would just buy every team.
Just buy the league.
He wouldn't do well in an owner's room.
Frankly, I don't think he'd get 23 votes to buy a team.
But if he went in, you know, at a couple hundred billion
for the entire league,
I think people would have to think about it.
Given the amount of money he has,
he could do all kinds of punk tricks with that.
I'm offering $25 billion.
Baseball teams line up.
Basketball teams line up and tell me
why I should spend that on your club.
It's the Elon Musk club.
No, it wouldn't work, because, again, he wouldn't get the votes.
I think it's a different conversation,
which is I'm giving everybody 4X what anyone will give,
and I just feel like taking the league private, if you will,
and owning every team.
But there's a bunch of people in position to do that.
It's not surprising to me that Bezos hasn't bought a team yet.
Why would you be bothered?
Think about why Michael Rubin divested himself of the Sixers.
It's way easier to do business not owning a team
than it is to do business owning a team.
Interesting.
But the idea of he's a trillionaire,
he could have everything.
Doesn't he want to have the thing that people actually like
as opposed to a thing that is constantly, I don't know,
I guess I unfortunately do like X, the everything app,
because I'm on it all the time.
Why don't you have the thing that rates well
among the public and buys sports?
You know, it just feels like that's an argument
that his family office would want to make.
More important to keep Ken Paxton in office
than to own a basketball.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I think that's a good business decision.
And for him, it certainly is.
Yeah, I think that's a good business decision.
In a second division football league, soccer league,
he could buy a team for that.
Do we need Elon Musk to get into sports to save the country
would be a follow-up question that I'm now contemplating.
I don't think that the words Elon and save the country
should be in the same sentence.
That's not really what I'm looking for for my relief.
It's from Elon.
I do like his Wi-Fi, though.
His Wi-Fi.
Starlink is, God.
Just make sure that you're not using it with any Ukrainians.
Thank you, John.
Because it would turn out to be bad service.
That.
Elon.
It's a very, as always, also a very good point.
I'm much more micro than you guys.
I just want to make sure that there's never a Wi-Fi issue.
So, belt and suspenders requires regular Wi-Fi
through the general way you do it.
And then, to make sure that there's never a Wi-Fi issue,
you can stick in a dish on the side of your house
to make sure that there's never a position.
What?
So, that doesn't happen.
Oh.
Okay.
That was David being an actor, an excellent actor.
That was. I thought he was having a stroke.
By the way, we have that on tape, right?
Yeah.
I was going to say, this is going to be an awkward episode
on account of that happening now.
Wow.
That was me frozen.
Thank you very much.
It threw me.
It's very worried.
I'm carrying on his. It's going to be a challenge.
I didn't know what belt and suspenders meant either,
but now I understand.
I mean, two independent safety measures,
backup systems to ensure success or prevent failure.
Well, if you really want to be careful about whether your pants
are staying in the appropriate place,
you've got an insurance policy.
Suspender breaks, you still got the belt.
I was more familiar with the double-bagging school of safety.
Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha.
It might not feel like it, but the holidays are almost here,
which means businesses everywhere are hiring for seasonal roles.
And some of these jobs are wonderfully specific.
Talking about ham glazers, lead elves, Santas with real beards, not. You know, some fake bearded Saint Nick.
And up north, they always need more snowplow drivers,
which requires a specific license to operate.
And when you need someone with a specific skill, experience, or qualification,
they're in high demand and not easy to find.
Whether you're hiring for one of these roles or any other,
the best way to find qualified people who are genuinely excited about your role
is ZipRecruiter.
And ZipRecruiter has a new feature that shows you
the most interested qualified candidates first,
so you meet the right people faster.
Its powerful matching technology
finds qualified candidates quickly,
and candidates can tell you in their own words
why they're excited about your job.
So no wonder ZipRecruiter is the number one rated hiring site
based on G2.
Let ZipRecruiter find the right people for your roles,
seasonal or otherwise.
Try it for free today at ZipRecruiter.com slash P-T-F-O.
That is ZipRecruiter.com slash P-T-F-O.
Meet your match on ZipRecruiter.
ZipRecruiter.com
I want to get to the. Get to the fact that we are a show that talks about sports business
and the fact that the World Series has ended,
the Milwaukee Brewers, congratulations to them.
A small market, David.
A small market that has done what they've never done before
and won this thing.
As now we look into the future,
a crystal ball smudged with the fingerprints
of so many, so many executives
that David calls colleagues, even friends, some of them.
And what do you see, David?
What do you see?
What do you see about baseball even being a thing
that we should be considering as a going concern
into the coming year?
You act like there's never been a collective bargaining
and negotiation between management and union.
It's like asking when the airline pilots are on strike,
will there ever be flights again?
Or are we stuck only where we can drive?
I think that's exactly the position you should take
with your Pulitzer Prize and Edward R. Murrow Award,
that it is the end.
It's the end of baseball, period,
because there's no negotiating going on
and there's going to be a lockout.
I think that's perfect.
Do you note that there are two groups of people,
very prominent individuals in this world,
who are asking to be restrained from harming others
or themselves, the baseball owners and the AICOs?
Please stop me.
Please stop me before I. I'm going to spend more money.
But I'm a freedom-loving guy, but not here.
So stop me while I try to pay Otani a fantastic sum of money.
I want to get, though, just the clarity, David, around
there is no chance that we don't enter a lockout.
We agree on that.
Everyone is anticipating that.
Why are we even pretending otherwise?
Don't.
1159, December.
PM, December 1st, the players will be locked out.
There will not be an agreement before.
There's no incentive for either side to move
off of their entrenched positions.
Actual negotiating hasn't even begun.
Right.
And so the idea that the salary cap,
which I was alluding to vis-a-vis the AI companies
who are hoping that the federal government
regulates them to save their pocketbooks,
the fact that the salary cap is referred to
by the league, by the commissioner's office,
it seems,
as a nuclear option here.
It is that level of problem in there.
view. That is a full, unexaggerated conviction. They actually plan to try and preempt this as
if it's a nuclear bomb. Well, it's certainly an October position. But remember, a lot of things
change during the course of a collective bargaining negotiation, where people go off
what their quote unquote is, this is an absolute deal stopper. When you go into a negotiation,
my view has always been that you keep three different lists. One list is, yeah, no problem,
I will give right now. The middle list is, I'll still give but I need to get and it doesn't
necessarily have to be equal. I'll just keep track. And then the third list is deal breakers.
I am not moving off my position on this. It doesn't matter when or it doesn't matter what's
offered by the other side. And the goal of the negotiation is to make sure that that deal breaker
list is assured.
as possible for both sides, or they intersect to the extent that both sides have a deal breaker
point. Because otherwise, people would never get to an agreement, even outside of CBA negotiations,
just in the life of negotiating. So for provocation sake, David,
what problem are they trying to solve? The fact that there is such a huge difference between the
number one payroll and the number 30 payroll. And they look at all the other capped leagues and see
a collar.
It's all when you're on Wall Street, collaring is everything. That is what wealthy people do in
order to diversify. Basically, it's about risk avoidance, measured with risk tolerance. And you
cap your upside, but you protect your downside. And sports is no different.
But so you're suggesting the problem is that the differential between what different teams spend
is is vast. So what's the problem on their payroll? So what's the problem with that?
Oh, it's just a matter of fact.
Fairness. But fairness, it's a matter of fairness in a league. That's all, John.
I thought you were a capitalist. The unfair to control the search market and spend more money
on search than the other 17 search companies. It is. Yeah, I'm a capitalist, except I want
a chance. I need that's why you can be a capitalist, but believe in the rule of law.
Well, but you can believe in the Sherman Antitrust Act. You can be a capitalist,
but there have to be rules.
Didn't Milwaukee and Tampa Bay just?
Prove that that vast difference in the amount that teams spend doesn't necessarily determine
who wins. It's such a novice argument, John. It's like saying when you get five black numbers
in a row in roulette, that means the odds aren't 50-50 the next spin. It's really not relevant.
Excuse me for being naive, but the English Premier League doesn't care if everybody
spends the same amount of money and they do pretty well. They're OK. There's no salary cap in the
English Premier League.
I'm incredibly confused. Were there not just 114 violations by Manchester City because of
financial fair play, which is rules, which is basically what we're talking about. And if you
violate those rules, you're subject to relegation. You're subject to all sorts of things.
Those rules say that you can spend proportionally to how much revenue you have.
So all it does is continue to pull it apart. They don't want Coventry City to win the league.
They really don't.
They want Liverpool, Manchester United, Manchester City missing one or two to win every year. And
that's mostly what they've done. So it's the equivalent of saying, well, the Yankees can spend
$1 for every dollar they bring in, and the Milwaukee Brewers can spend $1 for every dollar
they bring in. That's essentially what they do already. I'm sorry. Then why did the Super League
not go forward? Why were fans so upset about a Super League then? Because their favorite teams
were going to be winning. They were going to be winning. They
pulled out of the rivalries in the countries in the local league.
Let me take you inside a meeting, John, where we said to the owners of the Yankees,
literally, it was in the middle of an owner's meeting, listen, you want to screw around and
not do revenue sharing, and you want to hide revenue and all the different things, no problem.
Yankees and Red Sox, you guys just play each other 150 times, play each other in the playoffs
every year, and go off on your own. And that's the concept of a Super League. And when you're
you offer it, it's like, well, you know, that actually probably will not accrue to our benefit
because our fans, both who watch, other than you, would prefer Yankees-Red Sox every day.
The majority of people would say, that's really not the league that we are looking for.
I don't disagree with that, but it doesn't explain to me why this set of American capitalist
entrepreneurs have to be told, you can't spend. I got to stop you from spending more money.
There's a speed limit on a highway. You have to sometimes protect people from themselves.
We're protecting the most privileged individuals in the world from overspending some of their own
money on athletes. Do you have the same view of Saudi Arabia? I assume you have the same view of
Manchester City. They violated, they spent too much. If it's their money, they have it to spend.
Why would you care? Well, once again, once you set
a group of regulatory practices in place, you have to abide by them. Right now,
that's all we're talking about. Well, but this is, but this raises, I think,
the question that I think a fan is probably wondering, which is like, what am I rooting for
here? Like, am I rooting for the union and the players who say they want a salary cap for reasons
that, you know, and just, can we just make that case, David? So if you could, as they say in
Silicon Valley sometimes, so if you could, as they say in Silicon Valley sometimes, so if you could,
steel man what the union is saying. If you were to make, if they were to hire David Sampson for a day
and they were to say, David, we're going to get you your billable hours, but we need you to make
the best case for us. What does that case look like? That every way the league has had to have
your franchise worth more is in the system in which we exist right now. And that is a non-salary
cap system. And when you look at what your rate of return is on your investment in your other
businesses, and then you look at what's happening in the world right now, you're going to see that
it's going to be a lot more profitable. And that's going to be a lot more profitable. And that's going to be a lot more
perfectly well for the people who run it. That's the union argument.
That's pretty good. Not a bad argument. But the question now, can I answer it? Well, the question,
we're going to clip that actually, we're going to clip that and aggregate it. Excellent. And get
David in trouble with all of his friends. What I wanted to then get to though, is the public
interest, right? It's like, okay, so the union and the players, of course, want unconstrained
spending. And the owners are like, we see a significant amount of money in the union. And
as helpful to our financial health. And the fan basically wants, I would say, what John was
triangulating, which is, I want competitive games played among the teams that I like,
and the players that I enjoy. And I want this TV show to be really good.
So the question is, is the TV show a better TV show with a salary cap or not? When by the way,
of course, the NFL has one, the NBA has one. This is an exception to the
rule. Yeah. I don't think the fans have a clear choice on who to pull for there, right? Oddly
enough, I suspect they're more sort of fake outraged by, I can't believe, you know, so-and-so
is making, or what did Otani sign for? $700 million? Yeah. And a heavily deferred contract
becomes very interesting to figure out. That tends to upset fans in a way, I think. On the other hand,
owners of sports teams are not a particularly, not an audience in need of great deal of empathy or
fuzziness from their fans. I don't know fans who go, yeah, man, I love my owner.
It's one of the great mysteries to me why both management and players are engaging in such an
outright PR war to curry the favor of public opinion when, A, it doesn't matter inside the
game, even relevant to the economics of the game. Nobody is, in my opinion, worthy of empathy, but that's my situation when I think about any of the arguments that happen between managements and unions. I think both sides have protections in place. Both sides have make a living, and it sounds terrible to say and out of touch, but it's not. There are workers, there are owners. That's just what it's always been in business. Sometimes you're an owner, sometimes you're a worker, sometimes you're
both. Sometimes you're neither. And the way things are, everybody has a boss. And what people tend to get upset about is when they perceive that something's happening that isn't fair. And what baseball's arguing is that what's not fair is that an overwhelming majority of the teams don't have an equal chance of winning at the end. And isn't that why you're a sports fan? Because you want to be let down 29 out of 30 times because you lost on the field.
not because you didn't have a chance to win before the game started.
But this is where the fan smells bullshit, right?
Because the fan is hearing that and they're saying,
okay, but that's not your actual motive, owners.
Your motive is not, oh, the customer.
Let's take care of the fans.
The customer's TV show is being imperiled.
No, I mean, and I want to say this, David,
because I want to bring some of the data in here.
There have been a couple of polls.
Sports Business Journal in Seton Hall, they did a poll.
And just to give you a sense of how split this issue can be,
54% of general baseball fans favor a salary cap
compared to only 19% who oppose it.
27% undecided.
Support rises, though, to 58% among avid baseball fans.
The Athletic, their fan surveys indicate
that somewhere above 60% of respondents
back a salary cap and floor system.
But 73% of fans agree that payroll disparities
have made competitive balance in the sport unfair, right?
So that's what fans are really circling, right?
Is, are the Dodgers just winning everything?
I love that the fans say that.
But the fans love nothing.
Nothing less than a great dynasty, right?
You, you, you, you know, if you're in the baseball's office,
don't you want the Yankees to win every year
and play the Dodgers?
We just won seven games.
Five, well, I assume that was your rule always
in a seven-game series.
Five is the, four stinks.
Five is sort of market neutral.
And really, you can make hay in six and seven.
We always budgeted five and a half.
Over under five and a half.
This year's World Series went,
under.
Yeah.
Yeah, it was a tough one.
The, the NLCS was only four.
And that was, the ALCS went seven.
So you had 11.
And that's always what you count, count them both,
even though it's different networks.
But from a league standpoint, that's five and a half,
which is perfect.
But then the World Series went five.
So overall, it was under by a half.
So where were the Tampa Bay Rays ranked in the salary?
It depends on how you calculate it.
But 27th.
That's a general number to know.
So we're going to need to lock the players out this year
because the teams that don't have the money
just don't have a chance
after the 19th and 27th highest payrolls
were in the World Series.
I think it's great, John, in a business
to only look at the last year
and take the smallest sample size you can find
and ignore the fact that it took the Brewers 44 years
to get back to the World Series after 1982.
And Tampa's never won one at all.
So is the,
is it the ideal situation
that every team wins one time in a 30-year cycle?
Yes.
It's not the ideal situation for the media partners.
It's not.
And baseball is the hardest to do
because the home fans make up such a large percentage
of the audience
that if you get two small market teams,
the ratings are lower, a lot lower.
And that's because of the regionalism of baseball.
Yes.
Is that the audience?
By the way, it's kind of an attribute of the sport, right?
It's a daily sport
because of the volume of games played
in the town they live in.
Now, I know that world changes a little bit.
You no longer have the newspapers in the town
that are following it every day
and you're not listening on the radio every day,
but it still is very much a local sport.
So as a broadcaster,
we wanted the Yankees and the Red Sox
because every time we put them on,
we got better ratings.
And baseball has never quite,
in basketball,
you get stars who transcend their team.
So people cut on to watch Giannis.
I guess people cut on to watch Otani, I guess.
But I think there's much less of it.
That's the whole point, John, though.
Listen, we want to make a system,
that's all I ever wanted during my career,
is a system where if the Oklahoma City Thunder
win the championship,
which is a small market,
that they don't automatically have to trade SGA.
They can sign them.
And in baseball, you win a World Series,
if you are on the bottom,
you won't be able to re-sign your star.
And we would love a system
where it is actually incentivized
or possible to retain your stars.
The Brewers are brilliant,
but think about the churning they've done.
Josh Hader is a closer.
Trade him.
And then bring in Devin Williams.
Fantastic.
Trade him.
Corbin Burns.
Great.
Trade him.
Who's next?
Who's next?
And at some point,
you want an economic system
where you can't legislate away stupidity,
but what you can do is make it
so it's possible that smart people
can keep the record.
Right players who they want to keep
and they don't age out
and end up going just to the Yankees.
I actually don't have a,
for unusual for me,
a really, really strong point of view
about a salary cap.
I mean, it does feel interesting to me
and I'm enjoying testing my capitalist friend.
If you had 40 farmers and 30 farmers in Nebraska,
do you say,
well, to make all of you be competitive,
you each have to get 40 acres
and you have to use the same fertilizer.
I mean, it's a basic tentative capital.
That's what the government does.
I can't believe you.
No, no, no.
Hold on, hold on.
They do not.
They do not try to make farmers.
But this is where sports
and the question of the public interest
are a bit of a funhouse mirror.
And I also am somebody
who has a bit of a conflict
when it comes to salary caps.
We may or may not have just one various claim
for investigating violations of it.
And if you're going to ask me,
do I think they're a moral instrument that,
our divine creator has presented to us
for the benefit of the public,
I would say, probably not.
Probably not.
It's a thing that owners have implemented
to curb their own voracious appetites.
I think the fact that the owners are calling for it
and willing to lock out.
It's a bit of a tell.
It's a bit of a tell as to who this is good for.
It's not about the fans and them being happy
that everybody has a fair chance.
It's about the owners wanting to restrict
the amount of money that their competitors can spend.
I'm so thankful, John, that as an employer,
you always did everything only with your employees in mind.
I mean, that is just, obviously,
that made you the single best president ever.
I didn't say that, of course, Dave,
but you did just make the argument
that the essential problem to be solved
is that there's sort of an unfairness.
I don't think if you survey a whole lot of fans,
they're going to go,
yeah, the game is really unfair right now.
It's not, I don't like it.
Because my team, the St. Louis, I don't know,
the Cardinals, they haven't won in a long time.
It's been a while.
But they're not a small market.
Well, yeah, market size.
It's just a funny, it's a funny reversal.
You're a mid to lower tier.
It's a bit of a funny reversal of the discussion ordinarily
in that I would actually argue for the free market.
That's what I'm really sort of grappling with here
is that socialist skipper is now suddenly a true capitalist.
But now I'm going back.
I'm for the players.
I'm for the players.
I'm for labor.
I'm for labor.
What this tells me, by the way,
is that if you are a billionaire owner
who wants to see a salary cap come to fruition,
I think the landscape is primed for it.
I don't think this is an issue, frankly,
that has a lot of fan outrage.
I think even the people who want to take a side are like,
well, I don't really care that much about it.
I think labor, the players specifically, the union,
has a very strong view,
and I do not dispute the conviction,
they have in it.
But even in that, and again,
I'm just imagining Dominique Foxworth
just like head-butting me
as I proceed to sort of like minimize
the fight against salary caps.
But even in that constituency, of course,
there's a conflict of incentives
for some players who really like salary caps
and some players who don't.
You should just point out to Dominique
the next time you speak with him
that when you're thinking about the union,
you have members of that union,
the overwhelming majority members of the union
are not Otani.
The overwhelming majority are far more concerned
on the minimum salary than they are
on whether there's a salary cap.
And one thing that owners count on
in any negotiation management,
they count on a fracture in the union
because people at the end of the day
operate in their own self-interest.
And when you've got a majority of players
at the minimum saying, wait a minute,
you're saying I was making 780 grand,
but that can go to 1.5 million.
That is a very meaningful change.
I'm voting for that.
So there's also. There's all sorts of ways
that when you're negotiating,
you have to know your union.
And the baseball union is certainly
comprised of individuals
in far different circumstances,
more than pilots or teachers
or anything like that.
To be sure.
And I guess what I'm therefore saying is
what a salary cap is,
is a mutually agreed upon
aspect of a sport.
And at a certain point,
it would not surprise me in the least
that people are going to say,
that baseball joined the other ones
in implementing one.
And that the outrage around it
would dissipate over time
because, of course,
this would effectively be something,
even if they were leaned upon to do it,
because it's so important to owners
to implement,
that they would make peace with eventually,
which is to say,
longhand, now shorthand,
the owners like their hand here.
They like the hand they're playing
when it comes to how this thing is going to resolve.
Well, they should, right, David?
What's the average tenure of a baseball player?
Now, is it four years?
Yeah, it's just under four years.
They barely get to arbitration.
So, of course, if you take a year away,
you're cutting people's careers by 25%.
And other than Mark Walter and the Lakers,
generally, people hold on to their assets
for a longer period of time.
So they have the ability to amortize the loss,
if you will.
And that always gives management the advantage,
not just in baseball.
That's a general rule of thumb
of how management is able to take advantage
of labor more times than it doesn't.
And that's, I think. the biggest picture story is that management beats labor
whenever there is anything like a contest of wills.
And the question becomes, as that is bothersome
in a very real and profound way
to anybody who has empathy for labor,
the question is, what does the union get to get in exchange?
What do you get?
So now we're talking about negotiating.
And now we're at David's other list.
Yeah.
That is it.
You just did it.
So now we're in the middle list, which is all right.
We're going to be giving.
We're going to be getting.
We've established there's going to be a salary cap
and a salary floor.
Let's now make an agreement around that concept.
Let's figure out a way to get more money to younger players.
Let's figure out a way to get players into free agency earlier
so that they can get paid and not hit free agency at 32
and all of a sudden get one or two year deals
and be unhappy about it.
Let's figure out a way to make sure that upon retirement
that the benefits and the pension and the health care
is satisfactory to members of the union.
Today, as well as members of the union tomorrow,
let's figure out a way to maybe give a little tiny stuff
over to the minor league players
and see if that can be helpful to get a couple of player rep votes.
So all of that negotiation happens on that middle list.
Pablo is a stoop, a an actual legal term.
A little.
No, it's just it's Yiddish.
And it actually it's it's actually where I'm actually aware of that.
I just love hearing you.
You've done it from time to time.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So we probably should bag that one as well.
But don't you think you'd ask before what fans won't fans want them to play the games.
Right.
It usually turns out to be a pox on both your houses.
Right.
It's like, why are these rich guys have to help protect themselves in spending?
And why are these overpaid players fight about getting more money?
I mean, that doesn't happen for months.
It doesn't happen.
It wears off in a week when they start playing again.
And there's also and by the way, this is where I also just got to give my take.
That in the public consciousness, I think this is my this is my true mission here, perhaps on this planet.
The word billion and the word million sounds so similar.
That I think we got to change one of them because people don't understand how vastly different those things are.
They rhyme one letter apart.
Nine hundred ninety nine million to one billion is not that different.
And what an owner argument.
What an owner.
Owner level arguments.
It's a pretty perilous time to go out.
But you have the possibility of displaying to the broadcast partners that they might make the same or maybe even a little more money with your with your.
Game's not on.
And they're in a difficult market right now because baseball has done a lot of good things the last couple of years that I've liked a lot.
I like that a small market team won and it's a fun team, but the NFL and the NBA are necessary for the sports media companies have to have to forestall distribution agreement trouble.
Right.
And it's not clear if baseball.
Can do that and if that's why they have separated themselves in terms of rights fees because and you we could argue on the NBA, you can't argue on the NFL, but if you have that and you go out of service during the season, you have a they have a big problem.
Yeah, I think the same thing is true of the NBA right now.
I think the NBA went out.
You would have people cancel their subscriptions and and it would increase the deterioration of the cable television universe from which.
A lot of the money that goes.
To pay these media rights still comes.
I would argue probably the preponderance of the money still comes from cable fees that go to go to sports teams.
Yeah, I would just add to that one thing, John, which is what baseball is trying to do is take all the local broadcast revenue and pull it together and try to be more like the NBA.
And there are services that are interested in taking all the local broadcast rights and the regular season.
And baseball actually has more importance than the regular season in basketball because there's so many hours of programming when you've got even if it's 154 games, which is one of the proposals from the ownership side.
You're just talking about a tremendous amount of hours that these streaming services and these cable broadcast companies are interested in.
However, my initial point to you, John, is that when you would get involved in because you were a part of you were there for a lot of labor discourse.
The issue is October is where the bills are paid and the regular season the way it used to be was more of an afterthought.
But in the new world of media, major league baseball regular season is actually valuable if you get more than 23 owners to agree to pull the revenue.
So what baseball is trying to weigh right now is how how long can we delay that?
How long do we fight with the players before we have to start talking to the broadcasters about the new rules?
Of engagement, which likely will include pooling of local revenue.
Yeah.
Now, by the way, isn't local rights a obsolete anachronism?
They're not going to nobody is going to distribute these on a local basis.
They're all going to become national games, aren't they?
Yeah, John, I don't think you'll get rid of all local because if you think about what Gotham does in New York is the best example I like to use, which is if you get that.
which is if you get that app and you are a subscriber to gotham you can get yankees games
but if you're talking about the blackouts and the blackout issue goes away when you pool everybody's
local revenue and you do a deal with a larger company that includes multiple teams and from
a fan standpoint that's a huge benefit but from a revenue standpoint the blackouts and this is a
very terrible secret that is kept inside the industry. The blackouts are actually what added
value for a lot of teams because they had, like Florida, we couldn't have fans in Florida who
would rather listen to the Yankees and then have the ability to listen to the Yankees.
They were not allowed. We had certain rights where we had a territory. And if those territories
disappear, which is something that's being talked about, it has to come with full revenue sharing.
I want to understand, though, the role of the broadcaster, John, when it came to a labor dispute.
Did people come to you looking for you to put a thumb on the scale in either direction?
Would unions or leagues, commissioners lobby you to get involved in any regard?
No.
And they, and David will probably have some level of incredulity at this.
It wasn't, we weren't that involved.
I mean, I would have, yes.
Would I have talked to the commissioner if I was holding baseball rights
and said, man, I think a lockout has a lot of peril to it.
What can we do to help if we can't do anything?
But there's not much you can do to help.
There was some contract, and I can't remember quite the contracts
in terms of who gets paid or doesn't get paid.
I don't think the leagues get paid if there are no games.
Is that accurate?
Yeah, they do.
But if you miss more than 60 games, you just have to add a year at the back end.
So it basically extends the national deals.
And that's what people are saying would be a pressure point for the owners.
But inside the owner's room, that's actually not how we would talk at all.
Because if you toll it for a year, basically we'd go out in 2029, let's say, and we'd be
a year further removed from a lockout or a year further removed from a recovery that's
required.
So the players are thinking, hey, if we just hold on, the owners will have to cave.
And in a lot of ways, I believe it's the opposite, that if a deal isn't done quickly, the owners will say, hey, no problem.
You're missing your paychecks.
We're happy to add a year to the existing media deals and take it out where we will then have more understanding of how to maximize the revenue.
But the question then becomes, then, when does a media rights holder become incentivized to intervene?
And what David is saying is probably not until right before the postseason.
And, John, you're of that sense as well?
Again, I didn't actually have that much experience with lockouts and strikes.
There were not that many during my tenure.
And I don't remember, I don't think any league missed a season from 2000.
Is that because you were paying so much money for these deals that everyone was like, man.
Yeah, pretty much.
The skipper cash machine shooting out bills, let's just play these games.
It's just the timing of when the deals came up and when they were team actions.
But when was the last lost season in one of the major sports?
Well, full season.
I mean, hockey missed quite a bit of time.
Baseball has not missed a regular season game since Rob got to baseball.
So it's certainly 25 years, if not longer.
Maybe it was 94 was the last time.
I don't think since then.
and so for me it's not about in 22 they just had to move the season by a week that's how the lockout
ended it got into march and they just delayed spring training delayed the season opener until
uh for a week and it was no problem the broadcasters came to the table and were willing to show the
world series a week later that was fox at that time so the broadcasters do have to get involved because
Broadcasters do have to get involved because
they've got an area in their schedule where the postseason is. And if you move that, sometimes
the broadcasters are not interested in moving it because it gets into the other part of their
calendar, whether it be football or something else that they have. So, John, it would become a time
and it would be normal that you'd be communicated with about anything that's going on on the labor
front. But I think we just saw, I had the good fortune not to have this incidence come up in my
tenure. So, I was trying to think back. No, the NFL, the last lockout was 2011, but zero regular
season games were missed. That was the longest lockout, by the way, 136 days in NFL history.
The NBA, also 2011, that ended up shortening the regular season, as some might recall, to 66 games
from 82, which felt, as a side note, pretty good. Pretty good feeling season. That was memorable as
like, oh, this kind of worked out for everybody. But yeah, you're right. It was, John presided over
late-season games. He was a good player. He was a good
Exactly. I solved eight of nine labor negotiations in the first six months in my job. I don't know
why I haven't gotten the prize for that yet. I'm not sure what prize it would be, but I would be
happy to have you get one. There's a FIFA peace prize in there somewhere. Peace prize. You can
take it from Trump. I'm sure that you'd love to be sloppy seconds to Trump's Nobel FIFA peace prize.
The one thing I feel like is worth just acknowledging here as I try to think about what
else do both sides agree on, what broadcasters agree on, what owners agree on, what the players
even agree on, is the idea of playoff expansion, which has been a recurring joke on this program
because every time we talk about any sport, they're expanding the playoff. And now college
football, John, as long prophesied, the college football playoff will be 24 teams. Wow. And as
the guy who architected the landscape of college football and college sports when you're running
ESPN, how does it feel to see the number 24 almost as an inevitability?
Generally, expanding playoffs is good for the broadcasters. And for the most part,
fans like more playoffs. So, you know, that's two pretty good arguments for it.
I personally hate when they do these stair-step tournaments. You should play 16 teams or 32 teams.
This business of some teams get a bye, some teams don't is silly. Just play. Just play. 16 to me
was what I thought the magic number was. And I thought you have four power, four conferences,
the top 14 teams get in from each conference. That, of course, would be too socialist for the
SEC and the Big Ten. But. But, you know, it doesn't excite me to see more.
John, it's all for you. You do understand everything we do as a league is trying to
come up with events that you'll pay for. So special events, a Field of Dreams game,
or another round of playoffs. We're trying to get you to say, oh, this is a great thing.
We will give you incremental dollars or we will increase what we perceive to be the value
of your inventory, which we can take it or leave it. But give me
what we would call jewel events. Think about with bowl games. You love the fact, hey, put a bowl game,
Pop-Tart bowl game, just any bowl game. We'll put it on the air. We're guaranteed, you know,
six million people, way to go. We'll pay for it. That's what college football playoff expansion is.
It's just more bowls, but now it's just more playoff games. And the broadcasters, I can't imagine that
you'd have a limit the NCAA basketball tournament. Let's add a few more play-in teams and then add a couple more
teams and this will be great.
76 teams.
Is that this year?
Yeah. I mean, it's coming. It's 2027 in the postseason.
It's Y76. But to your point, David, Y76, it creates a few more games of inventory that somebody can pay for.
And people do. There's so much more competition now.
Of course. I mean, I just want to put some numbers on this, right? College football playoff, as they double the field to 24 in 2027,
this is after. After the handshake agreement that has been publicly reported by multiple places.
It's nearly 350 million added to the $1.3 billion college football playoff deal that ESPN had.
You know, and I suppose, look, baseball, to go back to that for a second, they. 2022, right, was when the playoff field expanded. Now, a wildcard system, different, all that.
But, like, the solution as there's only so much more to frack out of the ground is,
what if we just make everything a playoff?
What if we continue to just sell it all as a playoff, even if it's now just increasingly less special?
I want to hear your reaction to that, John, because if you were presented with a package
that was not any regular season college football games, but that you would get just the playoff games,
the reason why you've never been offered that is you would take it.
No, I always wanted some regular season. I like it. I think it's good for the sport.
I think it's good to have fans interested all year. I didn't want just playoffs at any point.
I don't think we did any. I mean, the college football playoff deal was done separately.
So that was done by itself. Was that a good deal? Yeah.
But take your hat off of having to have hours in order to justify the prices you were charging to the distributors and the platforms.
But from the standpoint of just standalone games, do you disagree? Maybe I have it wrong, but I thought that playoff games. were far more profitable than a regular week four game.
Yeah, they are. But I don't know what a good analogy is, but I think you do disservice to the sport if you're not covering it.
We had the hours to fill, so there was no reason to just do playoffs.
I was going to point out that I just came back from Mexico, and in Mexico, they have two championship rounds a year.
They have the first half of the season, which is called the Apertura.
And then eight of the 17 teams play a playoff for the Apertura champion.
I'm not sure they call it that.
And then they play the Closera, which is the second half of the season, and they play down again.
So they play two seasons back to back in order, and it does give you two playoffs, two shots at the playoffs.
That would be interesting to me as a broadcaster.
Okay, hold on. That is funny.
I hadn't thought about what if you took the NBA regular season, cut it in half, two seasons.
You have some sort of championship A.
Well, the Cup is kind of a version of that, right?
It's their way of testing the waters on that.
And to David's point, it worked, right?
You just said, here's a bright, shiny object.
It's not really any different than regular season games, except we're putting a playoff structure on it.
Throw the Emirates on the logos, and we're in business.
Yeah, why do you think the NBA Cup came into existence?
I'm just curious what you think.
What provenance was of the NBA Cup?
Well, I think ultimately they're trying to go, how can we make sure that the regular season doesn't become less and less of a must-see for fans?
How can we take some games and give you a reason to watch them?
Well, it's just watching.
Look, I'm having a little ennui myself as the season starts here.
I'm not kind of ready to watch the Knicks every night again yet, right?
So these games don't seem to matter much to me.
But when the NBA Cup starts, would you watch that?
Absolutely.
So then that seems to me to be the end of the discussion.
You're trying to get more jewel events inside the regular season, and the NBA says, well. Well, you are, but it's a little like a sandwich.
I was going to say.
If you don't have two pieces of bread, it ain't a sandwich.
You're just eating some ham.
And I guess without a regular season, you're eating a sandwich without any bread.
Oh, I do like the idea, though, of, like,
taking, Dave, all right, let's make this more local and regional for everybody.
You're at Katz's Deli, and you get the big pastrami.
Give me a bagel with cream cheese, lox.
Hold the bagel.
But in this case, what they're saying is, like, here's a big pastrami sandwich, but guess what?
We're going to serve it as two open-faced sandwiches, and now you have two sandwiches.
You had one sandwich, now you got two, and guess what?
After you finish the first open-faced sandwich, you get a little trophy.
And what do people do in that case?
They order extra bread on the side.
That's all we're talking about is what these jewel events are,
is getting more pieces of bread to make extra sandwiches.
And the owners would like to spend a little less bread.
And, of course, as John is saying about, like, the college football season,
we want the regular season.
And the question just becomes, when everything is playoffs but a couple of things,
does the other couple of things, is that even nearly as interesting to the consumer?
Now you're talking about the balance.
This is exactly what you do in any business is you figure out we're trying to make more things important,
but we got to make sure that what is not labeled as important becomes irrelevant.
And so you do that balance.
And it's very hard.
It's why businesses are always changing how they categorize things, how they market things,
because you're always trying to figure out what is the sweet spot.
And the damn sweet spot always changes.
Makes it harder to find.
There's a joke.
Got a snorkel.
Yeah, there's a joke here that now has been made that I wish had not been.
You got it, Pablo.
I did.
Who made it?
Oh, you haven't uttered it yet.
I think he's done too much.
By the way, if this was the Batman series, it would be tune in next week
to find out what Pablo was afraid to say.
The fact that we have been talking about pastrami
and David is talking about finding the sweet spot
makes me think that we're done, probably.
Perhaps one of us should be eliminated, playoff style,
actually, at the end of this episode.
I think this is a sweet spot for this episode.
David Sampson, John Skipper, as always,
I'm glad that none of us truly understand each other,
and for that reason, we remain friends.
See you later.
This has been Pablo Torre Finds Out,
a Metal Ark Media production.
And I'll talk to you next time.
Thank you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The show explores the looming MLB lockout due to unresolved negotiations between owners and players, with both sides entrenched and no agreement in sight.
A salary cap is proposed as a solution to address payroll disparities, but critics argue it reflects owners’ desire to limit competition rather than promote fairness or fan interest.
Fans overwhelmingly support greater competitive balance, with over 50% favoring a salary cap or floor to ensure smaller-market teams have a fair chance to win.
The discussion highlights a tension between free-market principles and public interest, with owners and players engaging in PR battles to gain favor despite limited impact on game outcomes.
Broadcasters and media rights holders are incentivized to intervene only near the postseason, as regular-season games are essential for revenue and viewer engagement.
Both sides agree on the need for more "jewel events" like special playoff games or tournaments to increase value and viewer interest, even if they are not fundamentally different from regular games.
The broader sports landscape sees playoff expansion—such as college football’s move to 24 teams—as a strategy to generate more content and revenue.
The underlying issue is not just financial, but structural
Summary:
The episode centers on the growing tension between MLB owners and players over a potential salary cap, driven by widening payroll disparities and fan demand for competitive balance. While owners argue for a cap to control spending and maintain league stability, players and fans see it as a step toward fairness, with over half of fans supporting such measures. The discussion reveals a deeper conflict: owners seek to protect their financial interests, players demand equitable pay, and fans want meaningful competition—especially for smaller-market teams.
A key insight is that both sides are using PR strategies to gain public sympathy, despite the fact that internal incentives often favor self-interest. The show also explores how broadcasters value game content, with special events like the NBA Cup or college playoff expansions designed to boost viewership and revenue. Ultimately, the conversation highlights a systemic issue in sports—how power imbalances and financial disparities undermine public trust and fan engagement.
While a salary cap may be a practical tool, its real impact depends on whether it truly serves the public interest, not just the financial interests of owners. The episode concludes with a nod to evolving sports business models, where "jewel events" and playoff innovation aim to create more value, but without addressing the root problem of unequal opportunity. The tone remains grounded in skepticism, emphasizing that while solutions may seem logical, they must balance economic realities with fairness and sustainability.
FAQs
The podcast discusses the potential implementation of a salary cap in Major League Baseball, the resulting impact on competitive balance, and the broader debate between owners and players over fair compensation and public interest.
Fans believe that large payroll disparities make the sport unfairly competitive, with dominant teams winning consistently, and that a salary cap would promote fairness and give smaller-market teams a better chance to succeed.
Broadcasters are generally not directly involved in labor negotiations, but they may become incentivized to intervene near the postseason to protect revenue, especially if games are delayed or canceled.
Owners are seen as pushing for a salary cap to limit spending by competitors, not to benefit fans, but as a way to protect their own financial interests and maintain control over team spending.
The podcast notes that expanding the playoff field and creating more 'jewel events' during the regular season could increase viewer interest and revenue, though it raises questions about whether such events truly add value or just create more inventory.
The 'sweet spot' refers to a balance between offering compelling, high-value events and maintaining a regular season, where broadcasters and fans are satisfied without over-saturating the schedule.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.