Go back

The Secret to Child Cooperation: 7 Psychology Proven Strategies

from How Not to Screw Up Your Kids

26m 16s

The Secret to Child Cooperation: 7 Psychology Proven Strategies

This podcast episode is a "bucket emptying" segment of the How Not to Screw Up Your Kids podcast, hosted by psychologist and parenting expert Dr. Mary Han. The theme is the secret to cooperation: understanding children's internal motivations and self-interest so parents can encourage cooperation more effectively. Dr. Han cautions against overusing reward-based exchanges, warning that constant bargaining teaches children that everything parents ask is a chore requiring compensation. She then offers seven tangible strategies. First, validate children's feelings when they must stop something enjoyable. Second, explain the why of a request clearly and briefly, framed around what matters to the child. Third, focus on and praise effort and process rather than perfect outcomes, building intrinsic motivation. Fourth, teach self-care habits—sleep, nutrition, movement, hydration—as an umbrella conversation tied to children's own goals and passions. Fifth, connect actions to feelings, showing how cooperation benefits the child and others. Sixth, calibrate challenges to the child's age and stage, breaking large tasks into manageable steps with support that gradually fades. Seventh, offer choices to build agency and capability. Throughout, she advises parents feeling time-pressed to focus on the single most conflict-causing issue first, and she encourages listeners to follow, rate, and review the podcast.

Transcription

4321 Words, 23329 Characters

English
Speaker 1We'll see you next time. Go to Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. That's goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini.
Speaker 2Cheers to fall savings at Whole Foods Market, home of higher ingredient standards. This Halloween, share chocolates and candies made without that spooky high-fructose corn syrup. Throwing a party? Make it easy with a berry chantilly cake. Ready-to-cook pizza, no antibiotics ever chicken wings, and sushi made fresh daily. Fall gatherings never tasted better. Save through November 3rd at Whole Foods Market. ACAST powers the world's best podcasts. Here's a show we recommend.
Speaker 3You know that ache when a book ends and you're not ready to leave that world? We live there. Fantasy Fangirls is your best friend's book club meets English class. Where we dive deep into beloved fantasy books, discussing lore, characters, themes, theories, and so much more. I'm Lexi, older sister and fantasy lore nerd. And I'm Nicole, younger sister and romantic at heart. Right now, we're exploring Prithian as we go deep into the highly anticipated and newly released ACOTAR books by Sarah J. Maas. Fantasy Fangirls is not your typical deep dive book podcast. When we say deep dive, we really mean it. Every episode covers a stretch of chapters and is structured with five segments to easily follow along. So pack your bags. We're headed to the night court with new episodes every single Monday.
Speaker 4ACAST helps creators. Launch, grow, and monetize their podcasts everywhere. ACAST.com. Hello and welcome to the how not to screw up your kids podcast, the bucket emptying episodes. I'm your host, Dr. Mary Han, psychologist and parenting expert. So pour yourself a cuppa, find a comfy seat and enjoy the conversation. Today's bucket emptying. I'm hoping is going to really create a huge sense of relief and help you feel more empowered when it comes to persuading our children to do things and to cooperate. So what's in it for me? The secret to cooperation is the theme of this bucket emptying episode. And really, I want to give you some tangible things that you can do around the sort of the psychology of understanding our children's kind of internal motivations and their selfishness. So basically, why do they act and learn and connect? You know, what are those driving? What are the things that we can do that hit that sweet spot that connects with their own internal motivations and their own self interests so that we can then encourage them to cooperate with us? I'm not going to dive deep into the psychology of motivation. I will save that for a one of the longer episodes. This is simply about giving you some. Tangible things that you can go away and try when it comes to those, those situations where you are trying to get your children to cooperate and they're just not. So I'm giving you some things that you can use and I've got seven for you today. So let's just dive straight in. And then, as I say, I'll, I'll do a separate episode that will do that because what we're trying to do is when we encourage our children to see that what we're asking them for, what we want them to be able to. To do in terms of cooperating has something for in it for them. What I will just caveat here is when we're thinking about encouraging our children to do more of the things that we would like them to do, I genuinely believe there's nothing wrong with a, if you do this, there'll be a specific reward. There's some sort of exchange mechanism when we do it super liberally, like we don't do it very often. The danger is if we do it all of the time, if it's, if. In the end, we find ourselves having to say, well, if you do this, I'll give you this, or if you do that, I'll do this for you. What then happens is we've in lots of ways modeled and created a learned process that basically in order for my, you know, I can negotiate everything that I need to do with my parents and my parents will always give me something in exchange. And the subliminal message behind everything is that anything my parents asked me to do is a chore is something I don't. I don't particularly want to do something I'm really highly motivated to avoid doing. And therefore, the only way they're going to get me to do it is if they, is if they give me something, they reward me in some way. So I want you to be thinking about how might you be able to apply some of these seven principles, some of these seven techniques as a way of sort of really minimizing that exchange of, you know, you do this for me and I'll give you that. All right. So let's dive in. Some of these won't necessarily feel obvious in terms. They're cooperation, but they do. When we look at these seven strategies together, provide a really great framework. So the first one really is about validating our children's feelings. We talk about this a lot in terms of emotional regulation. But when it comes to asking our children to cooperate with something more often than not, we are asking them to transition away from something they would much rather be doing to doing something that we have asked them to do, which is generally for them less fun. And it's taking them away from something that they are currently finding much more interesting. So we really want to validate their feelings in that process of the request that we're doing. You know, it's OK to be mad. You know, it's fine to be annoyed that I'm asking you to stop what you're doing. You know, I can see that you're upset. And what that does in terms of the benefits that it's that it's sort of the underlying message that we're giving our children is that emotional foundation. And that building and that boosting of their self-esteem and their self-value because they're seen, they're heard, they're validated, even though we're asking them to then do something that they would rather not do. So the first thing I want you to think about is where possible is to, you know, once we've made that request, if we get a reaction and more often than not, we do get a reaction. And that reaction isn't a pleasant one is to really validate their feelings. The second thing is to explain. Why? Yeah. So and really try to do that as clearly with as few words as you possibly can. So we're not trying to be short or curt, but we don't want to get into really long lectures about what the reason why we clear our bedroom is because it's really unhygienic and it's a really good habit that we get into. And when you're older and you're moving out of home, then your flatmates will be really glad that you're somebody who tidies up. And it's just the way that we do. We just get into this really long. Sort of long monologue, really, with our children and that they don't necessarily need that. What they need much more explicitly is a very short and sharp and clear reason why we tidy up our bedrooms because then it's easier to find our toys, for example. And that might be the why for your child. Maybe their bedroom is where they have their toys or it may be we tidy up our bedroom because it's a lovely space that we can invite our friends to. So really trying to think about. The why, as best as we can, that relates to our children. Now, of course, we're asking them to tidy their bedroom for a multitude of reasons. Part of it, if nothing else, is just it's a really great discipline. Make your bed, put things away so that you can find things when you need them. But if we can really try to appeal to the why, we are much more likely to get our children to cooperate whilst also managing our expectations about what that might look like. It's not going to look as beautifully smooth, bed covers and things exactly, you know, tidied and lined up and put exactly where they're meant to be. We're asking them to make that. We're making that request in a way that is manageable for their age and stage of development. So it's really thinking about the why. And what I would say, some of you might be listening to this and thinking, well, do you know what, I haven't got the time to give them a why that's tangible, you know, that matters to them for all of the things. And quite frankly, they should just be doing it because I've asked them to. I'm their parent and I do all of these other things. You've got a valid point. I do get it. I'm just simply imparting what I have found to be the most effective way of getting them to cooperate so that we reduce our blood pressure, our stress levels and our nagging. So what I would say to you, for those of you who are listening, who are thinking that there are lots of things and I haven't got time for the why or I can't even think of a why, is maybe think about, because, you know, I'm a big fan of one. Think about. One thing that is causing the most conflict, irritation, annoyance, frustration in your home that you can really focus in on the why. You can spend some time, maybe pause the podcast now or sometime afterwards and really think about if I could engage my child in that, in the why for that particular thing, that would be that that would reduce a huge amount of stress because, OK, yes, there are a whole host of other things. but that's the one thing. that I spend so much time nagging and talking to my children about that if I could get that one nailed, I'd feel like I have more capacity for some of the other things. So we want to validate their emotions and we want to explain the why as clearly and as succinctly and as engaging for them as possible. The third thing is that we then want to focus on the effort and the process. We know that this whole concept around growth mindset. So our children may not do things the way that we want them to do it. There may be some huffing and puffing when it comes to actually doing what we ask them to do and getting them to cooperate. But it's recognizing that it is a process that amazing if they end up doing exactly what we want them to do when we've given them that why immediately, but also recognizing that it will be staged. And therefore, sometimes they will do a brilliant job and sometimes they won't do a brilliant job. Sometimes they'll make a bit of an effort. Sometimes they'll refuse. So it's really keeping that focus of wherever I can, I'm going to really focus on their effort and their process and praising them because the benefits to that is that it really builds that resilience. But most importantly, it really builds the intrinsic motivation within them to keep going. You just think about it. I know I'll keep talking about the bedroom, but I would imagine for most of us, that's a massive challenge anyway. If we're always nagging, we're always nagging for our children to tidy up their bedrooms. And quite frankly, I think a lot of us do. And we, all we do is we then notice. And I know that I certainly, when mine were younger, I was really, this was something that I'm very aware that I used to do. I would focus on all of the things that they hadn't quite done the way that I wanted them to do it. Like, well, your bed's not made properly. You know, cushions are still on the floor or you haven't hung up all of your clothes or my goodness me, I've gone into your drawers and it just literally looks like you just picked everything up and shoved it in there. So we focus in that way. And I think that's, I think that's a really, really important thing. And I think that's a really, really important thing. And I think that's So we focus in on what they haven't done. So the message that they get is, well, fundamentally, it doesn't really matter whether you tidy up anyway, because I'm always going, you're going to nag me and I never do it good enough anyway. So instead, what we want to do is we want to, gosh, I'm so impressed that that is absolutely nothing on the floor. That is really brilliant. So we pray, you know, that praise that process. You've really made an effort to pick everything up off the floor. If you, this is a child that you nag about bedroom tidying up all of the time. Leave it there. If it's a child who's a process, the next time you might kind of say, look, when you ask them to tidy their bedroom, just tidy your bedroom. Do you think you might be able to organize some of them in your drawers a little bit more easily so that you can find things again, the why, because you remember quite often you find it really difficult to find socks and you, it's only when we've had a bit of a rummage, you can find them. So if you could organize them in a particular way, maybe I've got you this divider or, you know, I found this extra space in one of your drawers that you could maybe put all your socks in. So really thinking about the why, but really focusing in on their effort and the process that they're going through. So that's number three.
Speaker 1Hey, we're Nick and Jack hosts of the best one yet behind every episode. There's research, email spreadsheets, and our shared Google doc, the headline hammer with Google workspace with Gemini. Google's AI is built right into the premium versions of tools. We already use like Gmail docs and sheets, no new tools or extra logins, just personalized AI for the way we work. That means less time on the work around the work and more time finding the stories worth talking about. Get AI tools for work. Upgrade to Google workspace with Gemini at geo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. That's geo.gle slash workspace with Gemini.
Speaker 2This Halloween, share chocolates and candies made without that spooky high fructose corn syrup. Throwing a party? Make it easy with a berry chantilly cake, ready to cook. Pizza, no antibiotics ever chicken wings and sushi made fresh daily.
Speaker 4Number four is we want to talk about this concept of self-care and what that means, the wider implications. So quite often we will nag, again, super guilty of this, nag my children, especially now that they're adults and they've, they've moved out of home more so because I have literally absolutely no control over some of these things because they're not living with me anymore. But for us, obviously, when our children are living at home, it's one of those important things to have conversations around, around sleep, around movement, around making good choices with food, moderating sugar, sweets. So we don't, quite often, it goes almost in a bit of a bucket of nag, you know, goodness me, get money at school in tuck and all you spend your money on is sweets, or I've just found all these wrappers in your bedroom, or you're always making bad choices. You know, you're not getting enough sleep, your bedroom's a mess, all of those sorts of things. So instead, I think if we, if it's the umbrella, this goes back to the why, the umbrella is actually how we take care of ourselves. How do we optimize our body and our mind to be able to do all of the things that we would like it to do? Then we can talk about it. And I think it's a really important thing to do. Food is fuel. And the fact that we need different sources of fuel, we can talk about how that interacts with the food that we eat, and how that impacts the level of energy that we have, and how clear our mind can be for the creative, the creativity that we want to engage in. So we're then beginning to put them all together. They're understanding this idea that the brain requires a certain type of lifestyle. And that lifestyle, is around water and that fluid intake and that hydration. It's around what we feed it. It's around how we consolidate our knowledge and restore and repair our body through our sleep. But we do that under this umbrella conversation of how we take care of ourselves. How do we create boundaries? How do we ensure that we do what we need for ourselves first, so that we're always resourced and able? So we're able to sort of tap into going back to that why, rather than it being a nag, really try and make that conversation around self-care habits. It's super tangible to our children and the things that drive them, the things that they want to do. And if that means if you've got a child who is, you know, given half a chance would be gaming 24 hours a day, you can still relate sleep and nutrition and movement to their capabilities and their abilities to live. So I think it's a really important thing to do. And I think perform really well in that, on that particular computer game or console game. I'm giving you that, that example, because I think sometimes we sort of feel that we can't, you know, in lots of ways, we can talk about it tangibly in terms of academic work, but it doesn't matter what the why is for your child, what's important to them. We're always able to bring it back to self-care habits that really speak to their why, the things that motivate them, their interests, their and their passions. So number four is about teaching about self-care habits. Number five is about connecting where we can. Hey, we're Nick and
Speaker 1Jack hosts of the best one yet. Behind every episode, there's research, email, spreadsheets, and our shared Google doc, the headline hammer with Google workspace with Gemini. We already use like Gmail docs and sheets, no new tools or extra logins, just personal AI for the way we work. Upgrade to Google workspace with Gemini at G-O-O dot G-L-E slash workspace with Gemini. That's G-O-O dot G-L-E slash workspace with Gemini.
Speaker 2Throwing a party? Make it easy with a berry chantilly cake, ready to cook pizza, no antibiotics ever chicken wings, and sushi made fresh daily. Action.
Speaker 4So what we're asking them to do, behaviors to feelings so that they can then, again, this sort of taps in a little bit into their why. So, you know, when you share, it makes your friend feel really happy. When you play with your sibling, it makes them feel happy and joyous, you know, and that makes you feel good too, for example. So we're really trying to help them connect not only to that we're asking you to do something and we're asking you to cooperate, or we're asking you to engage in a certain type of behavior or shift away from a certain pattern of behavior. What we're explaining there and what we're making really clear is how that action, taking that action, then helps them feel or others feel as well as themselves. So that can be, you know, getting that homework done when it's due or when you're given it, whilst it feels really annoying at the time and you would rather not do it, it really reduces so much of your stress levels and you feel so great about it. And then that gives you time and space to be able to relax and enjoy other things. But it's about speaking to their whys and to their motives. So that means that you can then go and spend time with that friend, or you've got more time to do some of the creative things that you really enjoy. So we're trying to speak to, it's not like we're trying to change the things that we want our children to do. We're just being a little bit more thoughtful in advance about how we might get them on board so that we don't get that resistance or that headbanging, but instead we get that lovely cooperation more easily. So that is number five, is connect their actions to their feelings. Number six is just thinking about the challenges that we give our children and the requests that we make, particularly when we're trying to push them out of their comfort zone, is we want to make sure that we challenge our children just enough, not too little, not too much. So it's really trying to pick that sweet spot. And I think we get there generally through a bit of trial and error. With some of our children, it can be. It can be really easy to work out exactly what the sweet spot is. If the request that we make of them at that particular time or across various different times is just a bit too much for them, what happens is we get resistance because they don't feel that they're capable or they're able to do it. If instead, particularly where we reflect back and we think, actually, probably that is a bit too much, then what we can then do is we can then tweak the bigger task into smaller, more manageable. So it's like, okay, well, they can't do all of that. So going back to my tidying up their bedrooms, you can change this into anything else. And particularly where we've got your children who are neurodiverse, because that's an overwhelming large task, and particularly where their concentration levels or their ability to organize is not where it, you know, they've just not flexed that muscle enough. When we say tidy their bedroom, that task is huge, because it speaks supremely to an area that they find important. When we say tidy their bedroom, that task is huge, because it speaks supremely to an area that they find particularly difficult. So what we might do, because that's too much, is we just need to get this bedroom tidy, but I know that that can often feel overwhelming. So I'm going to be here and I can help you. You can tell me what you want where and I can help you do it, or I can help you give you some ideas about how things could get organized. So what we're then doing is we're taking this huge task and breaking it down into something more manageable, as in I'm going to be your little minion, I'm going to be your helper, or I can help directly. Depending on where our child is at, we know their age and stage and what they can and what they can't do. So we can then begin that. And that's a small tangible step. And it may be that we do that and then we agree that we'll help them again. But what we do with each time that we help, if that's what we've done, is we move away more from us doing to us helping them, prompting them, so that eventually we go to a stage where there's some sort of system in place. And then they're able to do it. And I find generally with children, and I know we tend to do this as parents anyway, but it's a great reminder, is the more they have places for specific things, whether that's crates, whether that's baskets, whether that's drawers, whether that's wardrobe, where they know this lives here, and it doesn't require them to be supremely and precisely neat in order for everything to fit. And I find generally with children, and I know we tend to do it. And it doesn't require them to be supremely and precisely neat in order for everything to fit. And the reason why choice is so helpful and such an important thing to offer our children is that what that does is that builds a sense of agency, that builds a sense of capability. Remember when we talk about confidence and it's all about exposure, you've got to be doing it. So the more our children experience trying things, doing things, things work sometimes, they don't work other times, it doesn't matter. And the reason why choice is so helpful and such an important thing to offer our children is that what that does is that builds a sense of capability. So the more our children experience trying things, doing things, things work sometimes, it doesn't matter. But the more our children experience trying things, doing things, things work sometimes, it doesn't matter. For you and as ever, if you have enjoyed this episode, I would be so grateful if you could just take a moment to follow the podcast and spend a few moments to give us a rating out of five and to write a comment and to review the podcast because this helps others find us so that we can spread the love. So until next time.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The episode presents seven practical strategies to help parents persuade children to cooperate without relying on constant rewards or negotiations.
  2. The first strategy is validating children's feelings when they are asked to transition away from preferred activities.
  3. The second strategy is explaining the reason behind a request clearly and briefly, framed in terms children can relate to.
  4. The third strategy is focusing praise on effort and process rather than outcomes, which builds resilience and intrinsic motivation.
  5. The fourth strategy is framing conversations around self-care habits such as sleep, nutrition, movement, and hydration.
  6. The fifth strategy is connecting requested actions to feelings, helping children see how cooperation benefits themselves and others.
  7. The sixth strategy is calibrating challenges to a child's age and stage, breaking overwhelming tasks into manageable steps with parental support.
  8. The seventh strategy is offering choices, which builds children's sense of agency and capability through repeated experience.

Summary:

This podcast episode is a "bucket emptying" segment of the How Not to Screw Up Your Kids podcast, hosted by psychologist and parenting expert Dr. Mary Han. The theme is the secret to cooperation: understanding children's internal motivations and self-interest so parents can encourage cooperation more effectively.

Dr. Han cautions against overusing reward-based exchanges, warning that constant bargaining teaches children that everything parents ask is a chore requiring compensation. She then offers seven tangible strategies.

First, validate children's feelings when they must stop something enjoyable. Second, explain the why of a request clearly and briefly, framed around what matters to the child. Third, focus on and praise effort and process rather than perfect outcomes, building intrinsic motivation.

Fourth, teach self-care habits—sleep, nutrition, movement, hydration—as an umbrella conversation tied to children's own goals and passions. Fifth, connect actions to feelings, showing how cooperation benefits the child and others. Sixth, calibrate challenges to the child's age and stage, breaking large tasks into manageable steps with support that gradually fades.

Seventh, offer choices to build agency and capability. Throughout, she advises parents feeling time-pressed to focus on the single most conflict-causing issue first, and she encourages listeners to follow, rate, and review the podcast.

FAQs

A bucket emptying episode is a shorter format where Dr. Han empties her 'bucket' of practical, actionable tips on a single theme rather than doing a deep dive. Here she deliberately skips the full psychology of motivation, which she promises to cover in a longer episode, and instead gives seven concrete techniques parents can try immediately.

Frequent 'if you do this, you get that' exchanges teach children that every parental request is a negotiable chore that deserves payment. The subliminal message becomes that anything a parent asks is inherently unpleasant and only worth doing in exchange for something.

Dr. Han suggests identifying the single behavior causing the most conflict, irritation, or frustration in your home and focusing your 'why' effort there first. Nailing that one issue frees up capacity and reduces stress so you can tackle other things later.

Frame sleep, movement, nutrition, and hydration as self-care that optimizes their body and mind for whatever they genuinely care about. For a gamer, you can link these habits to performing better in their favorite game, so the 'why' speaks to their own motivation rather than sounding like nagging.

It is a challenge that is neither too little nor too much, so the child feels capable rather than overwhelmed. You generally find it through trial and error: if you get resistance, the task is probably too big, so break it into smaller, manageable steps.

Break the big task into smaller steps and offer hands-on help, such as acting as their 'helper' or 'minion' while they decide where things go. Over time, gradually shift from doing it for them to prompting them, and set up organizational systems with clear, easy places for belongings so things don't need to be perfectly neat to fit.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.