The Real Life Hansel & Gretel Kidnapping | The Case of Carlesha Freeland-Gaither | UNSEEN
22m 8s
On November 2, 2014, 22-year-old nursing aide Carlisha Freeland Gaither was abducted in Philadelphia after being approached by a man who followed her, engaged her in conversation, and then forcibly dragged her into a parked car. Security footage from multiple cameras captures the attack, showing the suspect, later identified as Delvin Barnes—a known serial killer with a history of violent abductions—interacting with Carlisha and forcing her into a vehicle. Despite the terror, Carlisha remains conscious and deliberately leaves clues, including broken glass, personal items, and her phone, to aid in her rescue. Investigators use the receipt from a Philadelphia supermarket, dated just before the abduction, to link the suspect to a convenience store visit. This leads to the identification of Barnes, whose vehicle is traced to Maryland. He is arrested after attempting to hijack another car, and charged with federal kidnapping, ultimately sentenced to 35 years in prison. A witness, Dwayne Fletcher, who saw the attack and rushed to help, is recognized as a hero and later dedicates himself to teaching self-defense to women and girls. Carlisha survives, is rescued, and reunites with her grandmother. She later becomes a mother and reflects on her experience as a necessary and meaningful trial, emphasizing resilience and the importance of never giving up in the face of danger. Her story underscores how personal courage and public vigilance can lead to justice and recovery.
Pay attention to the woman in this video, as she's about to get kidnapped.
On November 2nd, 2014, Philadelphia police receives a call from this man who says he
saw a woman being forced into a car.
Minutes later, police get their hands on this security footage.
The first thing they see is a car turning on Coulter Street.
20 seconds later, a bus stops at the red light, but it's impossible to see if anyone got off.
Until 16 seconds later, a dark shape emerges.
The young woman is walking alone at night after she missed the bus, but look closer.
She has no idea that someone is following her.
As she starts crossing the street, the man engages her in conversation.
She turns around to face him, but you can see that she's still backing up.
Then, they seem to shake hands, but the man doesn't let go, and they disappear behind
the street corner.
On the ground, police find a pair of glasses, some broken glass, and a phone.
They have no idea what happened beyond that corner, until they discover there's another
security camera.
Detectives cue the footage at 9:39 pm, just before the bus arrives.
Again, they see the car that turned on Coulter Street.
It slows down and parks just beside the camera.
Then, the bus comes into view.
After it stops on Green Street, they expect to see the young woman appear in the top in
about 40 seconds.
But just 16 seconds later, there's an ominous development.
A dark figure emerges from the bottom of the screen.
They see him crossing over to the north side.
Detectives are convinced this is the same man.
The woman is now visible too.
The suspect hesitates, before he follows her through the intersection.
The other camera was ambiguous, but this view is not, and what happens next may be disturbing
for some viewers.
What you are watching is the woman being dragged down the sidewalk by the man.
Although she's fighting to get away, he completely overpowers her.
When they approach the camera, the man forces her into the parked car.
At the last minute, it appears she is trying to get away.
But look closer.
She does something that could save her life.
When police review the footage, they see the woman is carrying her cell phone, while the
man forces her down the street.
But seconds later.
She drops it on the ground.
With her cell phone, police can finally identify the kidnapped woman.
22-year-old nursing aid, Carlisha Freeland Gaither.
As detectives are rewatching the footage, they notice something else in the recording.
At the top, there's another dark shape that appears to be walking around in the street.
This is Dwayne Fletcher, the same man who called 911.
He tells police he saw Carlisha before the attack, and she already looked nervous.
At 9:39 p.m., he was walking on Green Street, headed to the nearby convenience store, when
he came up behind her.
When I got behind her, she just kept looking back.
So I was like, "Okay, well, let me get on the other side of the street, so she can feel
a little bit safe."
But just one minute later, he hears a scream.
She was screaming it at the top of her lungs, saying, "Help, help."
Fletcher hurries back down Coulter Street, before he sees Carlisha getting shoved into
a parked car.
He runs over, as fast as he can.
The car is moving.
The car was like kind of rocking, and the windows just exploded.
It was a crazy sound, and I think she probably got shot.
Dwayne takes cover, convinced that what he heard was a gunshot.
Then, the car drives off.
Fletcher can't help but think he could have done more to save her.
But his heart drops when police tell him no bullets or shell casings were found at the
crime scene, and that the sound he heard was likely the window exploding as the girl was
trying to escape.
Fletcher is destroyed.
If the girl dies, he might never forgive himself.
Monday, November 3rd, 12 hours after Carlisha was abducted, agents have already interviewed
every family member, friend, and coworker.
But still, police have no leads.
Other family members join the search, printing missing posters and handing out flyers.
"Any kind of things you could find and pick up, just to give us a clue to where she may
be."
"If anybody knows anything about her, please get in contact with me, my dad, anybody."
Authorities turn to the public for help.
Broadcasting the footage of the abduction on every news channel.
Fanduel is now available everywhere in the U.S.
So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are.
Including these places.
Make this your most rewarding season ever with Fanduel.
Age and location restrictions apply.
Product availability varies by market.
See Fanduel's website at www.Fanduel.com.
For eligibility: Gambling problem?
Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The problem is, the quality of the footage makes it impossible to identify the man.
The man they should know, because he's already the suspect in another abduction, which took
place just one month earlier.
His name is Delvin Barnes.
And he's an alleged serial killer.
Fanduel says Fanduel's name is Delvin Barnes.
Fanduel's name is Delvin Barnes.
killer. When the teenage girl miraculously escaped, she told police that Barnes had shown
her pictures of his previous victims. He would hold them captive for two days before disposing
of them. When the girl was sent to the hospital, police tried serving an arrest warrant on Barnes,
but he was already gone. The clock is ticking before the same thing happens to Carlicia.
Tuesday, November 4th, 36 hours have passed. A $47,000 reward is announced,
and finally, the tips start pouring in. Of the hundreds of calls that come in,
one of them stands out. A woman says she found unusual debris on her property,
but she's from Haver-de-Grace, Maryland. More than 70 miles from where Carlicia was kidnapped.
She called us and said, "I don't know if this is going to be an abuse to you all,
but I have a farm, and there's some broken glass and some trash on my lawn. So we deployed agents
out there to investigate." When agents arrive on site, they're stunned. Apart from the broken glass,
they find candy wrappers, potato chip bags, a cut zip tie, a receipt, and an earring,
all inside a single plastic bag. The evidence is too clean, almost like it was planted there
for someone to find. But what catches their attention is that the receipt is from a
supermarket back in Philadelphia, and the timestamp says 1:50 p.m., just hours before the abduction.
"So the agents on the ground immediately called and said, 'Can you go there to see if there's any
idea there that could help with this case?'" The agents are hoping they could get a better
image of their suspect. At 1:43 p.m., in walks a man wearing a black hat, a dark hoodie, and pants,
just like Carlicia's abductor. He puts his hand up to his face, seemingly trying to hide his
identity. The problem is, none of the camera angles gives them a clear view of his face.
And while the footage is shared with the public, there's little chance it will help the investigation.
But the FBI have worse news.
Back at the farm in Maryland, Special Agent Percy Giles makes a disturbing
discovery when they find car tracks that lead into a nearby body of water.
"We came to the conclusion that if somebody wanted to dispose of a body,
they would dispose of it there."
The FBI immediately sends out divers to search the entire Susquehanna River, all through the night.
"They also had airplanes up, helicopters up,
looking for heat signatures because we believed that we would find a body."
It's November 4th, 9:40 p.m. 48 hours have passed since the abduction and investigators are losing
hope that they will ever find Carlicia alive. At the same moment, just over 30 miles away,
Carlicia is trapped inside the trunk of a moving car, wondering what's going to happen next.
"I wanted to know if he was going to kill me, or if he was going to rape me."
"Or both."
She doesn't know if she'll ever be saved, but Carlicia has been doing everything she can to
leave clues behind for the police. Her story starts on November 2nd, the day of the abduction.
At around 9:30 p.m., Carlicia is walking home from a birthday party and headed to a bus stop.
"I can feel like there's another person and it's dark at the time,
so being an only female on the streets and you feel a guy walking past you,
I got scared."
"He immediately walked right across the street, so I can feel comfortable."
Carlicia breathes a sigh of relief, thinking maybe she was worried for nothing. A few seconds later,
a man walks up to her, asking for directions. After Carlicia helps him find his way,
he holds out his hand to thank her.
"I shook his hand. When I tried to let go, I realized at that point that he wasn't going to let my hand go."
As he starts dragging her down the street, she's overtaken by fear.
No matter how hard she fights back, he still manages to carry her to his car.
But with everything that's happening, she still has the presence of mind to leave a clue behind.
"After watching so many movies,
I realized the first thing they take from you is any way to call somebody. It was like,
Either take it with you and he can throw the phone out somewhere where no one will find it.
Or keep your phone right here where hopefully people that know you know this is something that you really do.
And they can find you.
The man drags her back into his car and gets into the front seat.
While his back is turned, Carlicia rushes over to try and open the other door.
But the child lock is on.
Under his seat, I see a hammer.
I hit him with the hammer.
It was holding his head.
There was blood everywhere.
And then I hit the window with the hammer.
I thought I was safe. I was free.
He turns around and pulls me back in.
The man then starts the car and drives off.
Carlicia is trapped.
She doesn't know what his intentions are and she's terrified.
As they drive out of Philadelphia, Carlicia can see her whole world pass by.
I can see my home.
I can see my job.
It's like my life was passing me before my eyes.
The man then gets on Interstate 95 and heads south.
Less than 30 minutes after the abduction, he gets off the highway and parks the car in a secluded area.
This is where he will rape Carlicia, for what will be the first of many times.
Tuesday, November 3rd.
Carlicia is locked in the trunk of a moving car when she feels it slowing down in a rugged area.
When the man opens the trunk, she finds they're parked in a field.
Far from any house or passing cars.
It's still dark outside and the man intends to sleep, but he's not about to let Carlicia out of his sight.
It was still touching me on top or some part of him was still holding me.
I feel like if I nudge or move or try, I just can't think of a way to really get out.
As she's lying there in the dark, unable to sleep, with a monster right next to her, the horrific events keep playing in her mind and it's all too much to bear.
She's thinking of giving up.
And then, she thinks of her grandmother, who took her in as a child and took care of her when her parents couldn't.
Her grandmother who loves her so much and who would be heartbroken if she were to lose her.
Carlicia knows she must do everything she can to stay alive so she can see her grandmother again.
5.45 AM.
When the man finally wakes up, he asks Carlicia to throw off the trash he has in the car, as she's standing beside the vehicle in the middle of an open field.
The idea of running away immediately comes to mind.
Maybe I could have ran and tried to get to some house, but then again, I didn't know what else he had in the car or what he was going to do.
If I ran, I just knew at that moment I was living and I didn't want to do anything to jeopardize.
But as she's stuffing the trash inside a plastic bag, she gets another idea.
Among the empty chip bags and candy wrappers, she puts a handful of shattered glass from the floor of the car, the cut zip ties, and one of her clothes.
She puts one of her earrings inside the bag.
Just try to give him as much proof that I'm still here.
6 AM.
The man drives into the parking lot of a PNC bank.
He asks Carlicia for her card, and she quickly realizes this is a good thing.
I just knew if I gave him my car number and gave him the information, then that might be helpful to know where I was next from the transaction.
November 4th, two days since Carlicia was kidnapped.
The FBI gets notified that her card was used, just five miles down the road from where the trash was found.
When they view the footage from the ATM booth, the images show the same man from the supermarket walking in.
Once again, the quality of the footage makes it impossible to see his face.
However, there's one thing the footage tells detectives.
Carlicia must have been alive at the time it was recorded.
She had to give him her PIN code so he could use her card.
The agents on site get another idea.
Is it possible that Carlicia was kidnapped?
Or is it possible that the man spent some of his money nearby?
They start with the convenience store, less than a mile away.
Finally, they hit pay dirt.
We saw the same person that we believed to be in all the other camera angles.
Now, the FBI has a face for their suspect, and the footage of him walking through the convenience store is aired across the country.
But by the end of the day, they still haven't found the identity of their suspect.
And after being held captive for more than 48 hours, Carlicia is beginning to lose her mind.
Carlicia has hoped that she will ever be found.
I just felt like maybe this may be my new life.
On day two, Carlicia is no longer zip-tied, and the man leaves the back seat down while Carlicia is in the trunk.
As he's focused on driving, Carlicia tries to engage him in conversation.
I kept trying to talk to him and just try to figure out what was going on through his head.
And he was willing to talk.
I thought, let's try to get as much information out.
She uses the training.
She had from working with high-risk patients at the hospital.
Slowly, she disarms him and encourages him to open up.
This is how she learns he has a daughter.
How much he loves her and good things, like, she's beautiful.
I was hoping that I can bring the person he used to be back.
But then, Delvin Barnes starts talking about his other victims.
He gives her details of what he did to each of them, and she quickly understands.
She's dealing with a serial killer.
She's trying to find out what happened.
November 5th, three days after the abduction,
officials in Richmond, Virginia, see the footage on the news
and finally identify the man as 37-year-old Delvin Barnes,
a suspect in another kidnapping with a history of violent crimes.
The news is horrifying. They need to act fast. A team is sent to Virginia,
to Barnes' residence in Richmond. They interrogate his family, neighbors, ex-partners.
One ex-wife confirms Barnes' car was, in fact, a gray Ford Taurus, the same vehicle that was
seen driving off with Carlicia. Agents quickly go around the city and locate the dealership
the car was purchased. By a stroke of luck, it just so happens, the dealership had put a tracking
device on Barnes' car. If a person who purchased a car there had bad credit, they would often put
a GPS device on that vehicle to make sure if they didn't make their payments that the car company
could find the car and repossess it. The dealership is able to pinpoint the exact location of the car.
That's when they find out the vehicle is still in Maryland, in a town called Jessup.
We had several teams surveilling the area to identify the vehicle.
While every unit is being dispatched to the location, Barnes is making plans of his own.
He said that we needed another car because he was running out of a license plate to switch.
That day, Barnes is parked at a strip mall and plans to hijack another vehicle.
It's 5.15 p.m. ATF Special Agent David Cheplak is one of the closest to Jessup, Maryland.
With the description of the vehicle, he heads to a local strip mall parking lot.
Searching the parking lot, I came across a grade four tourist.
From a distance, he can see there's a black garbage bag covering up a broken window.
He knows it's the right vehicle, but they can't see anyone inside the car.
We still didn't know if our victim was alive or not.
The ATF agents on site are instructed to wait for backup before approaching the vehicle.
Agent Erlich-Ellis had essentially decided that if that car starts to move, we're taking it.
And then, oh God, he just came from the back seat.
We automatically all sprung into action.
Agents surround the vehicle in a hurry.
While Delvin Barnes is sitting in the driver's seat, the agents point their guns at him and put him under arrest.
He had no idea we were coming. He had no idea what was going on.
Once I realized that Mr. Barnes was already in custody and that my team had everything under control,
I approached the vehicle.
The agents then make their way to the rear door, but the window is blocked by the garbage bag.
They still can't see if Carlicia is inside the vehicle.
Until finally, they open the door.
I could hear from the agent's cell phone in the background.
Oh my God, she's here.
Fan Duel is now available everywhere in the U.S.
So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are,
including these places.
See FanDuel.com for eligibility.
Gambling problem?
Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
You asked me, what is your name?
And I told her, my name's Carly Aisha.
I'm the one you want.
Carlicia Freeland has been rescued. Her abductor has been arrested.
Once I realized that I was being rescued, I felt at peace.
Just very happy to know I'll be going home, to know that I'm going to live, to know I'm going to be safe.
Carlicia is taken to the hospital, where finally she's reunited with her grandmother.
When they allowed me to walk into the room and Carlicia saw me, it was too emotional for me.
Now that she's safe in her grandmother's arms, Carlicia is finally able to rest, knowing she fulfilled her promise.
When news of her rescue is shared with the public, Dwayne Fletcher, the man who witnessed the abduction, can finally breathe a sigh of relief.
And while he blames himself for not doing enough, others see him as a hero in this story.
Dwayne Fletcher got a hero's welcome in city council, credited with helping save the victim's life.
When she learned about what Dwayne Fletcher did the night of her abduction, Carlicia wanted
to reach out to express her gratitude. One year after the incident, they finally spoke on the
phone. While he maintains that what he did was just the right thing to do, Fletcher sees Carlicia's
rescue as a turning point from his troubled past life. Today, Fletcher owns a boxing gym in North
Philadelphia where he teaches young girls and women how to defend themselves. He says he wants
to make sure that what happened to Carlicia never happens again. As for Delvin Barnes,
three days after he abducted Carlicia Freeland Gaither, he's interrogated by federal agents.
Barnes pleads guilty to one count of federal kidnapping and is sentenced to 35 years in
prison. Because of Carlicia, his reign of terror has finally come to an end.
Today, Carlicia is a mom, and she embraces every moment with her son.
Just watching him, he reminds me of what life is supposed to be. How happy and innocent he is.
Carlicia is a mom, and she embraces every moment with her son. How happy and innocent and free are you supposed to feel?
When she looks back at the events of 2014,
Curlicious says she's glad Barnes picked her instead of someone else.
It was something that was meant to happen.
God needed me to go through it because it was something that I can handle.
I'm happy he chose me because when I think about somebody else,
I wouldn't want to put them through that.
I'm still here and I'm still living and I get to still tell my story
and hopefully help somebody else.
Curlicious' story tells us that even when the odds are stacked against us
and things seem impossible, we must never give up.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
A woman, Carlisha Freeland Gaither, was abducted on November 2, 2014, in Philadelphia after being approached by a suspicious man who followed her and dragged her into a parked car.
Security footage from multiple cameras shows the suspect, later identified as Delvin Barnes, interacting with Carlisha, including forcing her into a vehicle and dragging her through a dark alley.
Carlisha, remaining conscious throughout, leaves clues—such as broken glass, a phone, and personal items—intentionally to increase the chances of her being found.
A key breakthrough occurs when police find a receipt from a Philadelphia supermarket, dated just before the abduction, linked to the suspect walking into a convenience store.
The suspect’s identity is confirmed when FBI agents trace the vehicle to a location in Maryland, where he is arrested after attempting to hijack another car.
Delvin Barnes, a known serial killer with a history of abductions and violent crimes, is arrested and later sentenced to 35 years in prison.
Dwayne Fletcher, a witness who reported the abduction and intervened, is hailed as a hero and later becomes a self-defense instructor to prevent similar crimes.
Carlisha survives, is rescued, and reunites with her grandmother, eventually becoming a mother and reflecting on her ordeal as a necessary and purposeful experience.
Summary:
On November 2, 2014, 22-year-old nursing aide Carlisha Freeland Gaither was abducted in Philadelphia after being approached by a man who followed her, engaged her in conversation, and then forcibly dragged her into a parked car. Security footage from multiple cameras captures the attack, showing the suspect, later identified as Delvin Barnes—a known serial killer with a history of violent abductions—interacting with Carlisha and forcing her into a vehicle. Despite the terror, Carlisha remains conscious and deliberately leaves clues, including broken glass, personal items, and her phone, to aid in her rescue.
Investigators use the receipt from a Philadelphia supermarket, dated just before the abduction, to link the suspect to a convenience store visit. This leads to the identification of Barnes, whose vehicle is traced to Maryland. He is arrested after attempting to hijack another car, and charged with federal kidnapping, ultimately sentenced to 35 years in prison.
A witness, Dwayne Fletcher, who saw the attack and rushed to help, is recognized as a hero and later dedicates himself to teaching self-defense to women and girls. Carlisha survives, is rescued, and reunites with her grandmother. She later becomes a mother and reflects on her experience as a necessary and meaningful trial, emphasizing resilience and the importance of never giving up in the face of danger.
Her story underscores how personal courage and public vigilance can lead to justice and recovery.
FAQs
Carlicia was rescued after being trapped in the trunk of a car for over 48 hours. She was found in Maryland, and authorities located her by tracking her abductor’s vehicle and using evidence she left behind, such as trash and a broken phone. She was taken to the hospital and reunited with her grandmother.
The abductor was Delvin Barnes, a 37-year-old man with a history of violent crimes and prior kidnappings. He was arrested after authorities tracked his vehicle and identified him through footage from a convenience store and supermarket.
Carlicia remained conscious and tried to leave clues, such as placing broken glass, zip ties, candy wrappers, and an earring in a plastic bag. She also gave her abductor her bank card to help authorities track his movements and tried to talk to him to gain information about his intentions.
Dwayne Fletcher called 911 after witnessing the abduction and reported seeing Carlicia being forced into a car. He later helped save her by rushing to the scene and is recognized as a hero. He now runs a boxing gym to teach self-defense to women and girls.
Barnes was identified through surveillance footage showing him at a convenience store and supermarket. His vehicle, a gray Ford Taurus, was traced using a GPS device from a dealership. Agents found the car in Maryland and arrested him while he was parked at a strip mall.
Yes, Carlicia survived and was rescued after 48 hours. Her survival was confirmed by the fact that her bank card was used, showing she was alive during the time she was held captive.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.