Go back

The Real History of Communism: The Russian Revolution

56m 53s

The Real History of Communism: The Russian Revolution

The Russian Revolution, often misunderstood as a grassroots peasant uprising, began with radicalized students and elite intellectuals who exploited political crises to dismantle the Tsarist regime. The Bolsheviks, led by Lenin, followed a predictable pattern: they provoked instability, seized power during moments of crisis, and then used terror, propaganda, and violent repression to eliminate opposition. Key events—such as the 1905 protests, the 1917 February Revolution, and the Kornilov Affair—demonstrate how indecisive or repressive leadership fuels revolutionary momentum. Once in power, the Bolsheviks enacted radical policies, including the destruction of the family, persecution of religious institutions, mass executions, and forced economic policies that caused widespread suffering. Despite losing popular votes in early elections, they ignored democratic outcomes and ruled through intimidation and violence. This historical model reveals a timeless pattern of totalitarianism: rooted in resentment, not ideology, and driven by the need to destroy existing systems. The episode warns that similar tactics are still at play in modern politics, particularly in the U.S., where leftist movements continue to exploit crisis and dissent. The lesson is clear: vigilance is essential—because the tactics of the totalitarian left do not change over time. Preventing their rise requires matching their intensity, perseverance, and brutality with equal resolve.

Transcription

9170 Words, 56535 Characters

English
people keep saying that real communism has never been tried well it was uh moscow 1938 arrests in the night confessions forced out of innocent people the daily wire's newest movie confession is a story about just that it's out right now only on the daily wire fan duel is now available everywhere in the u.s so you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are including these places make this your most rewarding season ever with fan duel age and location restrictions apply product availability varies by market see fanduel.com for eligibility gambling problem call 1-800-GAMBLER imagine a country where a small group of resentful unpopular left-wing radicals seize power and then use their power to deliberately destroy the family you crush the church unleash criminals on the streets legalize abortion implement no-fault divorce enact insane economic policies institute affirmative action persecute their political enemies and sow chaos to expand their control sounds familiar but i'm not describing america i'm describing russia in 1917 you've probably never been to russia and you probably weren't alive during the bolshevik revolution but let me assure you you'll recognize it and that's because the totalitarian left has not changed its playbook in a century their tactics motives and goals don't change over time in this episode we'll break down the eight rules of a communist takeover one by one and survey how those rules overlap what's happening in america today we'll do so by surveying the history of russia from 1899 to 1910. 1810. a period rarely taught in great detail in american schools despite or perhaps because of its obvious relevance to today to the extent communism is covered in schools at all it's either in the context of world war ii in which communists are presented as the good guys or in rare cases of honesty it's about the horrors of communist regimes gulags famines death camps now those things matter but they missed the more important point which is how did communist lunatics take over a massive empire in the first place that question is the central question of our times because those same tactics are being run again right now as the spanish-american philosopher george santayana warned those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it and that's the point of this episode so we don't repeat it that's why we're doing this this is the real history of communism the russian revolution we're obligated to start this episode by acknowledging that the russian revolution the subsequent civil war and the rise of soviet communism are some of the most complex and intricate subjects in history the shocking levels of betrayal and intrigue the complicated russian names and improbable events illustrate how a country like russia is able to take over a nation russia produces literary geniuses like dostoevsky or tolstoy the country's history really is like a complicated russian novel and to make this episode accessible to a large audience we can't possibly provide every single detail in every single aspect of these major world-changing events what we can do is describe in broad terms what happened and feature specific events that directly relate to our own situation today and that's what we're going to do now the lessons you will learn hold enduring truths about humanity that are relevant far beyond politics if you follow the citations throughout the episode you'll find books and essays that are good starting points for a more in-depth understanding of what happened and i highly recommend you do that now like a lot of history this story begins with a bad idea the idea that history is a dialectic centered on a class conflict between oppressors and the oppressed in the words of carl marx's communist manifesto solving the class conflict could be done only by the forcible overthrow of all existing social conditions this meant the abolition of money of eternal truths of nations of the bourgeois family which mark said would vanish as a matter of course and of private property under marxism you would own nothing and be happy marx's ideological pronouncements were radically at odds with how he actually lived a pattern you'll recognize from leftists today for example marx actually hated industrial workers according to sean mcmeekin's book to overthrow the world when marx visited factory workers in the summer of 1845 he was not impressed with the workers intellectual acumen and when a tailor explained to marx that they were organizing workers into collectives to negotiate better conditions with their employers an angry marx was seen pounding on the table with his fist before shouting that ignorance has never yet helped anyone mark sustained his lifestyle by taking handouts from his friend friedrich engels and collecting inheritance money from family members and wealthy supporters he called for the abolition of inheritance of course for everybody else marx employed servants to help his wife with housework lived in a spacious and comfortable dwelling in modena villas in mightland park in london and threw a formal ball complete with gold-rimmed invitations liveryed servants and a dance band just as he was seizing the reigns of the international working men's association marx was a prolific writer and a major public intellectual known for his journalism and political organizing his books like das capital were published in multiple languages and printed throughout europe by the 1880s marx realized that it was in russia home of the strongest autocracy in europe and also the most baroque and violent political radicalism that his book was more read and appreciated than anywhere else czarist censors let russian translations of his book slip through the cracks because they thought it was basically unreadable turns out that was a bad call the book sold very well on february 8 1899 st petersburg university students mostly upper middle class children of the russian intelligentsia plan to celebrate tatiana day the traditional anniversary of the university's founding marx was a big fan of the book and he was very impressed with the book's history according to the historian richard pipes the university's rector banned those celebrations by decree students booed the rector for 20 minutes straight and then started to riot the students pelted the police with snowballs and the officers hit the students with whips things spiraled out of control and the students announced a strike st petersburg university socialist groups ignored the situation at first but quickly realized what an opportunity it was they could co-opt the riots for their own purposes and so they did radical left-wing strike leaders brought in the aims of the unrest moving it from a protest against university administration to opposition against the entire political system they convinced many students that the entire system of government had to be burned to the ground within days all major institutions of higher learning in the empire were shut down 25 000 students boycotted class the government arrested the strike leaders but university officials started making concessions for the students and this led to a tit-for-tat cycle of protest repression and concession for decades russian universities had been incubators of extremism and radical ideology this period was defined by radically escalating political violence often committed by students one former student who had been expelled from various universities decided to exact vengeance on behalf of his comrades his name was p.v karpovich on february 14 1901 karpovich entered the reception area of the ministry of education where the education minister was addressing the public the karpovich shot the minister in the neck with a revolver mortally wounding him the next year in april 1902 a former student turned socialist revolutionary named stephan balmeshev assassinated the minister of the interior triggering a drastic expansion of police powers as a contemporary academic named prince e.n trebetskoy put it the student strikes of 1899. karpovich was shot in the neck with a revolver mortally wounding him the next year in april 1902 a former student turned socialist revolutionary named stephan balmeshev assassinated the minister of the interior triggering a drastic expansion of police powers as a contemporary academic named prince e.n trebetskoy put it the student strikes of 1899. marked the beginning of the general crisis of the state russians didn't realize it at the time but the old order was coming to an end this was the start of the russian revolution and its immediate cause wasn't an uprising of starving peasants and industrial workers but of radicalized privileged young students driven by political ideology and resentment of the system that created them now the lesson is obvious by failing to take the student protest seriously university administrators and the czarist government allowed them to spiral out of control and into something different this is the first rule in a communist takeover any revolution can become your revolution you should never allow the government to choose your vegetables there are other lessons obviously to take from this conversation but uh that's an important one fortunately balance of nature allows you to handle this matter yourself their fruit and veggie supplements make it easy to add more whole fruits and veggies to your routine without reorganizing your entire diet it. It's simple, it's convenient, and crucially, no government agency is involved. You know, right now, Balance of Nature is giving my audience 35% off the first subscription order. Go to balanceofnature.com, subscribe to the whole health system, use promo code WALSH for 35% off your first subscription order. That's 35% at balanceofnature.com, code WALSH. When the student protests first broke out, one Russian radical was reading about them from afar in Siberia, having been exiled for revolutionary activities. He was an intellectual, smart, highly disagreeable, highly motivated, and had no attachment to society as it existed. His name was Vladimir Lenin, and like Marx before him, he was an idealist. His goal wasn't just to create a new political and economic system, but to remake humanity itself. Lenin had a privileged father, had noble status under the czarist regime. As a child, Lenin idealized his mother and loved to read. His favorite book was Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin. The family was comfortably bourgeois, highly religious, entirely apolitical. It wasn't until after the sudden death of Lenin's father that his brother, Alexander, was radicalized at his university and then executed for plotting to assassinate the czar. These events were transformative for Lenin, who, curious about his brother's radicalism, was forced to leave the country. Lenin's father, Alexander, was radicalized at his university and then executed for plotting to assassinate the czar. These events were transformative for Lenin, who, curious about his brother's radicalism, started reading Marxist literature, but also witnessed his mother's social status collapse because of her oldest son's execution. This triggered Lenin's descent into radicalism and resentfulness. Just before the student protests began in 1898, Russian Marxists founded their own political party called the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party. Their core belief was that Russia's path to revolution ran through the industrial working class. The party was very small and drew its membership mostly from educated, radicalized professionals and unemployed college students. They saw themselves as the vanguard of the working class. The actual working class wasn't interested in the new party, for the most part. Though small in numbers, party members had big disagreements about strategy. According to a Russian-born aristocrat named Serge Obolensky, one faction "wanted to ally the Russian labor movement with the reformers and socialists of Europe and to break with the terrorism and political conspiracies of Russian revolutionists." These members were called the Mensheviks. They were relatively moderate, or at least didn't want a violent revolution to change society, and they were led by a man named Julius Martab. The other faction was led by Lenin, who "wanted a small, conspiratorial party of dedicated revolutionists." They were called Bolsheviks, and they had no problem with violent tactics and were not moderate at all. Obolensky's tutor, who was a party member, described the Bolsheviks as "disciplined and organized. They are stronger, they are ruthless, and mind you," he said earnestly, "if there is any catastrophe, there is going to be a terrific socialist movement, and eventually the Bolsheviks will win." It was a prescient prediction. In 1905, Russian discontent accelerated after the country's humiliating defeat in the Russo-Japanese War. The war was sold to Russians as a quick and easy victory against an inferior Asian nation. Russia was, in fact, completely humiliated. After sending its Baltic fleet on an 18,000-mile voyage to the Pacific, the Russian navy was routed by the Japanese, losing 21 of their 35 ships in just two days. Things were worse on the ground. Russia suffered 300,000 casualties in battles with the Japanese. Their supposedly impregnable fortress at Port Arthur was forced into surrender. This led to organic mass protests. In Russian cities, on January 22, 1905, hundreds of thousands of industrial workers and their families marched through St. Petersburg holding icons and pictures of the Tsar. They wanted better working conditions, but to be clear, most of these protesters liked the Tsar. They believed that he was benevolent and would provide for them. The Tsar didn't take the march seriously at first, which, as you'll see, will become a pattern. He departed to his country residence for the weekend, confident that everything was under control. Nonetheless, Cossacks, a group of semi-nomadic frontiersmen known for their martial skills who were often employed by the Russian government for crowd control, and Imperial Guard troops, were put under standing orders to keep the palace safe from any potential intruders. Ultimately, they fired into a massive crowd in St. Petersburg, killing 200 people and wounding another 800. The event ignited months of escalating protests. What mattered was that the event destroyed the foundational myth that the Tsar was some sort of unimpugnable religious leader. He was increasingly seen as a political actor who could be criticized and even coerced into making concessions. The mass protests and ensuing terrorist campaign forced the Tsar to issue an October Manifestation for the Tsar. The Tsar was the only one who made concessions to the Tsar, and in the wake of that, the Tsar became the leader of the Russian Revolution. The Tsar was the leader of the Russian Revolution. campaign, forced the Tsar to issue an October Manifesto to restore order, allowing the first-ever Russian parliament, or Duma, to convene, and even legalized labor unions. But rather than restore order, those concessions inspired the dissidents to demand even more. Like the student protests, the Tsarist regime treated the 1905 protests as a manageable outburst rather than a systemic crisis. By granting limited concessions and then clawing them back, it ensured that the next explosion would be much worse. And that's exactly what happened. To be clear, none of this was provoked by the communists. Lenin himself wasn't even in Russia for these events. But they did lead him to one of his most important conclusions, that these patterns of unrest could be turned into a political program. Because of the 1905 revolution, Lenin understood that national humiliations led to periods of great turmoil. If he could subvert his country's war efforts, it would diminish the of the old regime and create the conditions that he needed to start a civil war, which he would use to take power. Under such an approach, according to McMeekin, quote, Marxist revolutionaries would crow after a government endured military setbacks and openly undermine its military effort. Lenin was arguing for mutiny, organizing mutiny on a scale large enough to poison and ultimately destroy a country's armed forces. Now, this approach became known as revolutionary defeatism, and it worked by intentionally destroying a country from the inside. In the context of Russia's upcoming military campaigns, this meant turning an imperialist war into a civil war. This is the second rule in a communist takeover. Never let a crisis go to waste. Let's take a brief capitalism break. Suppose you start a business. The business succeeds. You make money. You would now like to make even more money. Under our current system, you're allowed to do that. It's wonderful. And if you need capital to hire people, And if you need capital to hire people, buy equipment or inventory or take advantage of an opportunity, there's Cardiff. buy equipment, or buy a car, you can do that. But if you don't have the money, you can't do that. If you want bank-level rates without the bank-level delays, you need to check out cardiff.co.walsh. The application takes less than five minutes and qualified businesses can potentially receive up to $500,000 in same-day funding. Build your business, make a profit, enjoy it while it's still legal. Go to cardiff.co slash walsh. One sign that the Tsar was losing his grip on power was the sheer amount of political violence in Russia in his final years. In her book, Thou Shall Kill, Anna Geifman notes acts of terrorism became so common that newspapers stopped running in-depth reports on each incident. Instead, they published daily rundowns recapping all the political violence and the theft that had taken place over the last 24 hours. After the 1905 revolution, the Tsar and his team were able to briefly stabilize the situation in Russia. A lot of this was due to the Tsar's interior minister, a man called Pyotr Stolypin. He took a hard-nosed approach to the revolutionaries. He created a system for fast executions for terrorism, arrested some legislators for their contact with the terrorists, and even dissolved parliament when it refused to cooperate with his efforts. Stolypin was undeniably tough, but he also balanced this with pragmatism. He worked to solve the underlying problems that might have made the public sympathetic to the radicals. He implemented limited land reforms and tried to expand the middle class. The idea being that once regular people had something to lose, they would fight to protect it by supporting the government and stability. By cutting the revolutionaries out of the conversation through his zero-tolerance approach to terrorism, Russians started calling nooses Stolypin neckties. But by still making reforms that improved the quality of life for most Russians, he created a new lane for addressing the country's problems while mitigating the risk of immediate revolution. However, his reforms and aggressive style infuriated large landowners and conservatives in parliament, eventually forcing him out of government and left-wing terrorists assassinated him in 1911 in revenge for his crackdown on terrorism. Russia's decline was accelerated by its entrance into World War I in 1914. Bread lines became commonplace. Tsar Nicholas II took personal control over the military, which further weakened his prestige with news of every setback on the battlefield. Inflation spiked more than 300% from 1914 to 1917, causing real wages for factory workers to plummet by roughly 50 percent. The main issue, which probably sounds familiar, was money printing. Within days of the war's outbreak russia abandoned the gold standard and began printing rubles on february 23 1917 international women's day female textile workers in saint petersburg which was then known as petrograd because saint petersburg sounded too german walked off the job to protest their deteriorating quality of life that winter was one of the coldest on record factories were routinely shut down due to lack of fuel and the number of protesters quickly swelled up to hundreds of thousands now this might have been lenin's moment never let a crisis go to waste once again he was not in russia and his party which was small and dwindling was heavily infiltrated by czarist secret police it was still an opportunity for the revolutionary left and critics of the czar russian troops were extremely demoralized by the social and political chaos that had overtaken the country by 1917 more than a million had already died in the world war major cities were filled with huge numbers of poorly trained and low morale draftees awaiting transfer to the front on february 26 the czar called in the army to deal with the protests only for two inexperienced training companies to fire into a crowd of protesters killing 40 and wounding a similar number which unleashed a mutiny that spread like wildfire through petrograd garrison hundreds and thousands of soldiers deserted sold their weapons commandeered vehicles and ran up the red flag or joined the milling grounds the minister of war wanted to execute all of them but the general in charge of securing st petersburg sergey kabalov decided to arrest only the ringleaders it was as pipes notes a fatal loss of nerve this is a critical lesson on leadership leaders who hold power but shrink from using it decisively at the critical moment rarely get a second chance the fire needs only oxygen and fuel to become unmanageable mass movement of the army is becoming more and more intense it's the first time in recent history that the government opposition needs only time one of the hallmarks of the february revolution was total hostility to the police nikolai wrangell witnessing the events in st petersburg noted in his memoirs that the revolutionaries launched a war of extermination against police angry mobs murdered police officers on site harassed their families even regularly killed random people claiming that they were undercover although the violence eventually subsided the police had basically been abolished this is how the historian sean mcmeekin described the february revolution quote police stations were overwhelmed and some of them were torched to the ground though usually only after inmates were freed freed inmates were often the ones doing the torching uniformed policemen were lynched shops and markets raided and the main city arsenal looted of weapons baron nikolai wrangell described how leftists unleashed the criminal population on society as the media cheered writing quote the prisons containing those detained for political offenses were thrown open and then for the sake of consistency the prisons for ordinary criminals as well a flood of convicts in their gray clothes with the convicts yellow square on the back streamed out these excellent fellows plundered the confectionery shops changed their clothes in the street and good citizens once more mingled with the crowd i saw this incident myself and it was not very reassuring on that day a large number of crimes were committed nobody felt safe especially as the authorities including the police had disappeared but liberty had been won and now we were all free men riding in cars at any rate the papers were unanimous in saying so unleashing the criminal population on middle class families is a hallmark of communism by early march half the petrograd garrison had mutinied high-level military officials who had already lost confidence in the monarchy and were looking for ways to change the political situation told the czar who was unable to even return to petrograd amid the disruptions that he had no choice but to abdicate his first move was to attempt to hand power to his 12 year old son alexei but then he changed his mind and tried to give the throne to his brother grand duke michael a liberal who immediately gave his new power away to the revolutionaries the czar and his family were imprisoned at the summer palace with nothing to do he shoveled snow and lived under a new name nicholas romanov everyone thought the left would moderate that never happened the third rule of a communist takeover let your enemies take over let your enemies defeat themselves the power passed to a provisional government formed from members of the existing parliament a fragile coalition of liberals and socialists who found themselves ruling a country in the middle of a catastrophic war it was headquartered in the winter palace a symbol of the monarchy it just replaced but from the beginning the provisional government was forced to share power with the petrograd soviet a workers council which managed the workers and rogue soldiers who controlled the streets russia had achieved a power vacuum and lenin was on his way back from exile to philip the key here was the workers councils or soviets which became a kind of shadow government soviets were mostly urban socialists and would hold votes on matters of public interest they enforced decrees with riots mob violence and strikes that herald public infrastructure the soviets projected their power by using ordeals to protect the soviets from the government of the soviets by using organized industrial workers known as red guards and defected soldiers to patrol the cities who force their dictates and engage in mob violence much like modern-day tifa they often lynched police officers looted businesses and assassinated their enemies through these intimidation tactics the petrograd soviet became incredibly powerful on march 1st 1917 the same day the provisional government was forming the soviet issued order number one military order that transferred control of the military from officers to electors and to elected soldiers committees soldiers were supposed to follow the provisional government only if their orders didn't conflict with those issued by the soviet one radical sailor noted at the time quote educated folk will read it differently but we understand it straight disarm the officers revolutionary politics and the russian military were now directly linked and this as you'll see would create a direct line for communists to subvert the military from within and helped them accomplish their goal of turning the imperial war into a civil war this is the fourth rule of a communist takeover it's easiest to destroy a country from within you know a lot of people are switching away from the big legacy cell phone carriers apparently the country is catching on in a survey of more than 120 000 wireless customers pure talk was the only company to earn five out of five stars for coverage support value and data make the switch today then tell all your friends go to puretalk.com/puretalk for puretalk's best unlimited plan for just 29.95 a month for life the offer is extremely short-lived and will never come back so go to puretalk.com/walsh to switch to my wireless company puretalk taxes and fees not included some restrictions apply see puretalk.com for details offer ends on november 15 2026. it's worth noting that at this point late winter 1917 it didn't seem like the bolsheviks were ever running russia or even a small part of it the soviets were run by their rivals mostly socialists but also some mensheviks the bolsheviks were a fringe party disliked by nearly everyone and their leader was thousands of miles away across enemy lines taking over soviets let alone the russian government would require discipline dispatch and ruthlessness three things lenin was distinctly capable of but first he had to get to russia which required traveling through an active war front or across germany which was a hostile nation but it turns out much like how both baptists and bootleggers supported prohibition lenin found common cause with german intelligence both sought to overthrow the russian government and end their participation in world war one who better than a charismatic leader who literally said that he wanted to overthrow the government and the war and as a bonus provoke a civil war that would cripple russia for years the germans didn't care about marxism or bolshevism the germans were solely interested in getting russia out of the war and having them cede as much territory as possible to germany the plan to get lenin into russia was led by a german diplomat named arthur zimmerman now you might recognize his name he's the same guy who offered military support to mexico to retake texas in his famous zimmerman telegram which infuriated americans and the russians at the time zimmerman worked through intermediaries to transport lenin along with dozens of other revolutionaries from switzerland through germany into petrograd as quietly as possible it was a foreign subversion plot probably the most successful one of all time when lenin arrived in russia his party was almost completely irrelevant to the extent they had any support at all it was an urban industrial centers and on military bases full of low morale draftees far behind the lines the party's elected officials at the time had mostly been exiled to siberia but where there's a will there's a way lenin's first move was to start a media operation in february they hadn't produced any printed propaganda by the month of june they had printed 85 000 copies of their new newspaper called pravda along with 75 000 copies of a soldier's newspaper plus a paper for front line troops they'd achieved a circulation of about 100 000 in a country of 125 million by early july the bolsheviks press was pumping out 320 000 copies of printed propaganda in various formats along with 350,000 pamphlets and broadsheets. It was a massive media operation, and an expensive one. According to historian Richard Pipes, "Such organizational and publishing activities required a great deal of money. Much, if not most of it, came from Germany." From the party headquarters in a mansion in central Petrograd, the Bolshevik military organization started dispatching commissars to army and navy units to convert enlisted men to the cause. The Bolshevik plan was simple. Create chaos that would lead to military defeat and collapse the government. Intimidation tactics, ruthlessness, and a major mass media blitz helped the Bolsheviks rise in Russia's biggest cities. Provisional government's failure to take them seriously allowed the Bolsheviks to gain support from more industrial workers and soldiers. And in turn, they used this support to call for additional strikes, riots, and other forms of public disorder that paralyzed life in Russian cities. The Bolsheviks' tactics of belligerence and aggression, which successfully cowed the provisional government and other socialist parties, helped them gain credibility. This led to major defections, including Leon Trotsky, who was, until then, aligned with the Mensheviks. After Trotsky joined causes with Lenin, he called on the Bolshevik party's militant wing to kill the leaders of the provisional government, saying, "Down with the minister capitalists." Around the same time that Trotsky gave that speech, a marching mob of 10,000 Bolsheviks gathered outside the Tauride Palace in St. Petersburg, along with thousands of Red Guard sailors and other mutineers. It seemed like the Bolsheviks' moment had come, but it was too much, too fast. Lenin refused to address the mob. The provisional government leaked information from an investigation into Lenin's German connections. They blanketed the city with a newspaper headlined, "Lenin, Ganetsky, and Company Spies." According to Meakin, when Lenin saw the headline, he told Trotsky, quote, "Now they're going to shoot us," before shaving his beard and going to ground in the Finnish countryside. Abandoned by their leader, the Bolsheviks could only watch as the Pravda printing press was smashed and their headquarters raided by loyal Russian army troops who arrested 2,000 Bolsheviks and swept up a mother load of intelligence. 11 Bolshevik leaders were charged with high treason and organizing an armed uprising. Trotsky was arrested. Lenin was in hiding. Forces loyal to the provisional government machine-gunned Bolsheviks in the streets. No one seemed to care and the Bolsheviks who terrorized everyone else for so long were finally being crushed. It was all but over. By the summer of 1917, it seemed the Bolsheviks would never control Russia, but they never admitted defeat. And very soon, their fortunes were about to change. This is the fifth rule of a communist takeover. Nevertheless, they persisted. History class is supposed to teach us not to repeat the same mistakes, and yet every September, we do exactly that. We set earlier alarms, fill up the calendar, and assume we'll function perfectly well on the same lousy sleep we got all summer. But the second week, the results of this experiment are usually in, and one part of the routine you can actually improve is the mattress you sleep on. I've been sleeping on a Helix for the last few years. I sleep better, I wake up feeling more rested, which makes an early alarm considerably less offensive. Helix's quick sleep quiz matches you with one of more than 20 mattress models based on your sleep position, firmness preferences, and support needs. They also offer cooling upgrades for those September nights that haven't gotten the message that summer is over. Your mattress ships directly to your door with free U.S. shipping, a limited lifetime warranty, and the Happy with Helix guarantee. Plus, Helix has extended its sleep trial from 120 nights to 365 nights, giving you an entire year to make sure your mattress is right for you. Go to HelixSleep.com slash Walsh for the 20% off site-wide for the fall savings event. That's HelixSleep.com slash Walsh for 20% off site-wide. HelixSleep.com slash Walsh. As we documented in Chapter 2, the end of the czar's reign was marked by incompetent leadership, military failures, deteriorating domestic conditions, hyperinflation, and most importantly, extreme indecision. But what we didn't mention was that Russia's ruling class at the time, including the Tsar's own family, joined in with the mob. On March 1, 1917, the same day the Petrograd Soviet issued Order No. 1, which functionally ended discipline within the Russian army, the Tsar's first cousin, Grand Duke Kirill Vladimirovich, marched his elite team of imperial guards to the state Duma wearing a red ribbon, effectively declaring his support for the revolution. The Tsar's brother, Grand Duke Michael Alexandrovich, didn't support the revolution but pleaded for his brother to make concessions to the rioters. When his brother abdicated and made Grand Duke Michael the new Tsar, he issued a manifesto telling Russians to support the new Provisional Government and effectively ended the family dynasty. Once a leader acknowledges that change is necessary, the brakes usually come on. The government that followed the Romanov dynasty, it turns out, was even more incompetent and ineffective than its predecessor. By July 1917, it seemed they'd crushed Lenin and his movement, but they still managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. This is how they did it. After indicting Lenin and the other Bolshevik leaders with treason and with thousands of the Bolsheviks' foot soldiers in prison, the Provisional Government said: The Provisional Government, which was led by a lawyer named Alexander Kerensky, started to assemble evidence for a treason trial against the Communists. As before with the university protests, the 1905 Revolution and the February Revolution, there's a clear point here: When you get your chance to crush your enemy, you must take it. It seemed like the Provisional Government was going to. Kerensky had appointed a Russian military leader called Lover Kornilov to restore discipline in the military's ranks and quell domestic uprisings. In August 1917, Prime Minister Kerensky and General Kornilov were communicating through an intermediary named Vladimir Lvov. Here's how it went down: General Kornilov had a pre-existing agreement with Kerensky that he'd send in troops to restore order in the city if and when that became necessary. But Lvov went to General Kornilov, claiming to represent the Prime Minister, and asked: What would it take for you to be a temporary dictator to stabilize the situation? General Kornilov didn't want to be a dictator or to accept responsibility for leading the country, but in response to the hypothetical, he gave a list of conditions for taking power. Then Lvov went back to the Prime Minister, Kerensky, and stated that General Kornilov had a list of demands that must be met. The Prime Minister, Kerensky, was startled. He'd just received a list of demands from a top general, which sounds a lot like a coup attempt. But rather than reach out to the general directly to see what's going on, Kerensky just started impersonating him. So Kerensky, pretending to be Lvov, sent telegrams to various military officers with vague questions like: Are you ready for action? His goal was to try to detect whether a coup was underway. But because his message was so vague, his military leaders responded with responses in the affirmative, making it seem like a coup was in fact underway, even though it wasn't. Kerensky concluded that his own general was marching on St. Petersburg, so he issued an arrest warrant for General Kornilov, which greatly confused the general, who in turn concluded that the arrest warrant must be because a coup had already happened. Otherwise, why would Kerensky, or maybe someone claiming to be Kerensky, want to arrest him? And this convinced Kornilov he needed to head to St. Petersburg with his soldiers right away. But General Kornilov's troops didn't get far. One of his commanding officers shot himself, and the railway workers wouldn't let the soldiers use the trains. This was a decisive moment in human history, because Prime Minister Kerensky, thinking General Kornilov's troops were approaching to depose him, opened the jails and released the thousands of Bolsheviks who were awaiting trial for plotting to overthrow the government, including Trotsky. Immediately upon release, they seized 40,000 rifles from a government arsenal to defend the city against the Provisional Government's own army. It was Kerensky's last-ditch effort to have every man on deck to fight the army he believed was trying to stop him. to remove him from power. By all accounts, this was a pivotal blunder. At precisely the wrong moment, the government freed its greatest enemies from prison, and the government at the same time infuriated the military by mistreating Kornilov. The soldiers and the army's officers weren't going to be much help in putting down a rebellion. This debacle became known as the Kornilov Affair. The Bolsheviks were now free from prison, heavily armed, and the conservative elements of the army that opposed them were now either imprisoned or in disarray. Lenin returned from exile. Trotsky began to plan the actual coup. Plans for the coup leaked, but Kerensky adopted a policy of no enemies to the left and began suppressing conservative military officials and political associations. Rather than call out radicalism on the left, he tried to side with them to protect himself. By mid-September, the Bolsheviks were sweeping to power in Russia's biggest workers' councils with huge majorities. They were in control of the most important Soviets. Within a month of taking control of the Soviets, the October Revolution took place. It was a coordinated takeover by the newly freed Bolsheviks, not a spontaneous worker uprising like the February Revolution. When the prime minister announced a plan to close Bolshevik newspapers, the Bolsheviks saw the move as a pretext to openly revolt. On the night of October 24th, they seized the banks, the power stations, the bridges, and post offices, mostly without any resistance. Russia's most important city was theirs. Kerensky fled in disguise. By the end of October, the Bolsheviks By November 1917, when an all-Russian Congress of Soviets met in Petrograd, it was clear the Bolsheviks were the triumphant faction. The Bolshevik control of the Soviets in Petrograd and Moscow had given them a huge majority of the convention. The Russian left had failed to contain its most extreme elements. The less radical leftists, who were upset at the growing Bolshevik violence, walked out of the conference, ceding any remaining power they might have had. As they left, Trotsky shouted at them, "You are pitiful, isolated individuals. You are bankrupt. Your role is played out. Go where you belong from now, into the dustbin of history." Trotsky told the Soviet in Petrograd that the provisional government no longer existed. Lenin delivered a speech in which he declared, "We shall now proceed to construct the socialist order." And indeed, that's exactly what happened. Lenin took Russia out of World War I and ceded enormous amounts of land to Germany. And almost immediately, the Bolsheviks, who still lacked majority support, turned to ruthless violence to enforce their rule. Lenin's takeover of the left and of St. Petersburg happened with astonishing speed and came seemingly out of nowhere. When Lenin arrived in St. Petersburg on April 16, 1917, after the February Revolution, he had almost no popular support and was viewed with suspicion even by his fellow Bolsheviks. By July, he was in hiding in Finland. His movement was in disarray, with most of its supporters in prison. By mid-September, he was the triumphant figure on the Russian left. And by October, he had overthrown the government. The new one formed in its place was to be called the Soviet Republic. It had turned the Imperial War into a civil war. As it turns out, revolutions happen faster than you'd expect. This is the sixth rule of a communist takeover: act quickly so the enemy doesn't have time to respond. Just weeks after the Bolsheviks announced their new Soviet Republic, it became apparent just how unpopular they were. That November, Russia held the first free elections in its history. Considering the circumstances, the election went well: 41 million Russians voted. There was also a clear repudiation of Bolshevism: roughly three-quarters of Russians voted against Lenin and his party. The top party, by a long shot, was the one former Prime Minister Kerensky belonged to. The Bolsheviks disregarded the outcome, and they banned rival political parties and claimed a popular mandate anyway. It's worth noting that the word "Bolshevik" means "one of the majority." Bolsheviks presented themselves as representatives of the people, as populists whose platform reflected the national will. From their seat of power in St. Petersburg, the Soviet Republic, which had no legal authority and was recognized by no one, including left-wing political parties, rejected the election results. According to McMeekin, they refused to ratify the results as legitimate, postponed the convocation of Russia's long-awaited Constituent Assembly until electoral abuses could be investigated. They then convened their own run. As a result of this, the Bolsheviks were able to run their own run. The Bolsheviks had no choice but to run their own run. They were able to run their own run, and they were able to run their own run, even if they had no right to. They were able to run their own run. They were able to run their own run, even if they had no right to. After that, there was no one stopping them. It was a brilliant technique. Much of this expansion happened because of the Bolsheviks' sheer ruthlessness. Within their first month in power, Bolshevik sailors bayoneted the former head of the Russian military, Nikolai Dokunin, to death. The next month, they murdered other officers in Odessa, hurling their bodies into the water after being shot. In January 1918, they murdered 300 officers on the Crimean coast by breaking their limbs and dumping them in the ice-cold water alive. It was open season on anyone who might be a threat to the Bolsheviks. One of the remarkable facts of life in the earlier Soviet Union is how the Bolsheviks enlisted their supporters to rat out their neighbors, which they did with enthusiasm. In his memoir, titled "Always with Honor," General Pyotr Rangel, a future general in the White resistance forces that gradually formed to oppose the Bolshevik Reds, described being forced out of his home at gunpoint by Bolshevik sailors after one of his former servants accused him of being a counter-revolutionary. The Bolshevik Reds, who had fled the Reds, were forced to leave the town of Odessa. The Bolshevik Reds decided that the Bolshevik Reds were no longer a part of the Bolshevik Reds, but that the Bolshevik Reds were a part of the Bolshevik Reds, and that the Bolshevik Reds were part of the Bolshevik Reds, and that the Bolshevik Reds were part of the Bolshevik Reds. The Bolshevik Reds were a part of the Bolshevik Reds, and the Bolshevik Reds were a part of the Bolshevik Reds, and the Bolshevik Reds were a part of the Bolshevik Reds, and the Bolshevik Reds were a part of the Bolshevik Reds. no defense. Wrangel would have been killed if it weren't for the quick thinking of his wife, who refused to leave his side and eventually talked the Bolsheviks into releasing him. One of the grisliest deaths at the hands of Bolshevik forces was the former ruling family, the Romanovs. When the provisional government first put them under house arrest, it was generally understood that the former czar and his family would be able to leave the country in exile. That never happened. England's King George V, Romanov's cousin, revoked an asylum offer because he was concerned that bringing the czar to Britain could set off a socialist revolution in the UK. By July of 1918, Bolsheviks in the town of Yekaterinburg were concerned that they might lose control of the ex-czar and his family. Accordingly, with approval from Bolshevik leadership, a commandant named Yakov Yurovsky woke the Romanovs around midnight on July 16th, 1918. He told them that because of combat operations in the city, they needed to move to the basement for their own safety. Shortly after they arrived in the basement, a death squad arrived and blasted the family with gunfire so intense they had to wait for smoke in the room to clear in order to confirm the children were dead. As Sean McMeekin writes in To Overthrow the World, quote, the finale was gruesome because the four Romanov daughters wore special corsets in which diamonds and other jewels had been sewn. The girls survived the initial machine gun volleys. It had to be finished off with bayonet thrusts. Then, in Yurovsky's clinical recollection, the detachment began to undress and burn the corpses. To prevent the nearby Czechoslovak Legion, an anti-Bolshevik force, from discovering the bodies, Yurovsky had the Romanov remains dumped into the nearby Four Brothers Mine, only to realize it was not deep enough. The bodies were lifted up and tossed into a ditch along the Katerinburg-Moscow Road, doused with sulfuric acid and covered with sticks and branches. Yurovsky's men drove over the makeshift grave with trucks to mangle everything beyond recognition, and it worked. The Romanov remains were only discovered, with identities confirmed by DNA testing, in 1989. The executions of the Romanovs, though horrific, were just a prelude to the truly massive organized political violence that would soon follow. On August 30, 1918, a high-ranking leader of the Bolshevik secret police, called the Cheka, was assassinated in Petrograd. That same day, Lenin was shot multiple times. Unlike the indecisive Tsar and the incompetent leaders of the Provisional Government, Lenin cracked down with total ferocity. Terrorism became official state policy. Martin Latzis, a high-ranking Bolshevik and Cheka official, wrote the following message on November 1, 1918: "We are not fighting against single individuals. We are exterminating the bourgeoisie as a class." And indeed, that's exactly what they did. Summary executions and concentration camps were each legalized by decree, with a particular emphasis on commissars and soldiers who were alleged to have deserted their posts. In September and October 1918 alone, the Red Terror claimed 15,000 lives, according to McMeekin, "more than twice the total number of prisoners of all kinds executed in the entire century of Tsarist rule before 1917." That's not bad for a political party that started the revolution by banning the death penalty. Among the various targets the Bolsheviks systematically slaughtered, one notable group was the kulaks, middle-class Russians similar to self-sufficient rural small business owners in America today, the kind of people American leftists call deplorables. Kulaks had the most to lose and were a frequent source of resistance to Bolshevik requisition policies, which caused mass starvation. During one of their rebellions, Lenin sent a telegram calling for the kulak districts to be "ruthlessly suppressed," adding, "An example must be made: hang, absolutely hang, in full view of the people, no fewer than 100 known kulaks, fat cats, blood suckers. Publish their names, seize all grain from them, do it in such a fashion that for hundreds of versed Russian universities." That's a unit of measurement that's roughly two-thirds of a mile. "Around the people, see, tremble, know, shout, the blood-sucking kulaks are being strangled and will be strangled. Telegraph the receipt and implementation. Yours, Lenin." He added at the end a call overriding objections, advising his team, quote, "P.S. Find tougher people." When thousands of starving peasants tried to raid a building where the Bolsheviks were trying to store grain, the Red Army opened fire repeatedly on the enraged crowd. When war communism caused deaths of millions of innocent Russians, according to the Bolshevik mouthpiece Pravda. 25 million people were starving in just one region, including seven million children. The Bolsheviks went to war against their own peasants who fought back with pitchforks and farm tools. The war, according to McMeekin, cost the army 237,908 casualties. The Bolsheviks went after the Christians too. The historian Richard Pipes describes some of the violence in Russia under the Bolshevik regime, "Most of the violence against the clergy took the form of lynchings and arrests by the security organs. There exist harrowing tales of torture and maiming of prominent clerics. Archbishop Andronik of Perm is said to have had his cheeks hollowed, his ears and nose cut off, and his eyes gouged. Thus disfigured, he was driven through the city and then thrown into the river to drown. Bishop Hermogen of Tobolsk is reported to have been drowned with a rock tied to his neck. Tikhon said in 1920 that, to the best of his knowledge, 322 bishops and priests have been executed since 1917, targeting entire groups for what amounted to ethnic cleansing. The Cossacks, the Circassians, and ethnic Germans. Upon Lenin's death, Stalin completed the job against the kulaks. When they weren't committing mass executions, they were forcing people to move to Siberia at gunpoint. The eighth rule of a communist takeover: exterminate the opposition. The country we described in this video was a place where a small minority of radical leftists, whose ideas were born from idealistic academics but rooted in deep resentment, successfully took over a country using nothing but sheer willpower and total brutality. They followed the same rubric as all the others have done since: provoke a crisis, take advantage of the crisis, seize power, then crush your opposition. Thanks to a hapless opposition consumed with conspiracy and infighting, they seized total power, which they used to prosecute and intimidate their political enemies. They forced people to believe absurd things, elevated freaks and intentionally wrought chaos. They used intimidation tactics to terrify the majority, who never supported them, into submission. Their first policy priorities upon taking power included unleashing criminals on normal people, instituting lunatic economic reforms, intentionally wrecking families by instituting no-fault divorce rules, legalizing and subsidizing abortion, persecuting Christians, and instating a policy of affirmative action for minority groups. The fact that people were willing to endure their rule for seven decades is a testament to what humans are willing to put up with. The country we're describing, of course, is the first years of the Soviet Union, but it's also the United States. The reality is that the forces that drive the totalitarian left don't change over time, nor do their people change over time. They're driven by tactics. If you defeat them once, they come back in a different form later. Preventing them from achieving power requires constant vigilance. One must match them in their vigor, intensity, and perseverance. If you don't, they win. For most of American history, we've managed to keep them at bay. But to be fair, there have been many, many close calls. In some cases, we got lucky. What would the world look like today had Franklin Roosevelt, one of the great benefactors of Soviet Russia, whose White House was deeply infiltrated by Soviet Communists, had lived through the war? One wonders. There are two points worth noting as we draw the parallels between the history of Russia then and the history of America today. First, the events of 2020 bear remarkable resemblance to the upheaval we described in this episode. You need to remember that Bolsheviks took nearly two decades after the first student protests to seize power. There were numerous bursts of leftist disorder in Russia's power centers before they finally seized it. Just because we survived 2020 doesn't mean that they're not coming back to power. And second, when talking about communism, conservatives spend a lot of time pointing out that communist economic policies don't work. And sure, that's true. And there may be a point to that. Our school system today barely teaches kids anything about communism. Roughly one-third of millennials think George W. Bush killed more people than Joseph Stalin. At Yale University, communist groups routinely disrupt classes and occupy buildings. But you're not going to convince them to change their minds because of your economic arguments. Communists don't care that the economics cause untold human misery, mass starvation, and millions of deaths. They actually support it. Suffering is the point of their economic policies. Communists aren't communists because they care about the working man. Lenin resorted to mass surveillance and extreme propaganda because he knew the workers did not support it. They're communists because they hate you. Their radicalism is rooted in their resentment, a feeling much more powerful than charity. They don't want to build something that's beautiful. They want to tear it down. And that's exactly what we need to remember. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is, ironically, one of the most vocal critics of colonialism in modern American politics. Colonized people. Colonization. Colonization. But does she realize her last name is literally Cortez? Whether she's related to Hernan Cortez or not, he's a hero. And that's why we decided to center our latest episode of Real History on Cortez's incredible and unlikely conquest of Mexico and how he took a small Spanish army of 500 against hundreds of thousands of native soldiers and won. My Real History of the Conquistadors, coming soon to Daily Wire. FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S. I've been everywhere, man. So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places. I've been to Georgia and Houston, Cleveland, Minnesota, Buffalo, Lincoln, Chi-Town, Arizona, Tampa. Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel. Age and location restrictions apply. Product availability varies by market. See FanDuel.com for eligibility. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Give the gift of the coziest bed with Bull & Branch Luxury Organic Cotton Sheets. Only 1% of the world's cotton meets their standards of softness. Treat the people you love to the comfort of Bowlin Branch signature sheets, pillows, and more. Feel the magic in every moment. Save 25% site-wide at bowlinbranch.com with code CHEERS. Exclusions apply. See site for details.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The Russian Revolution was not sparked by the poor or workers, but by radicalized privileged students who turned political unrest into a revolutionary movement.
  2. Communist takeovers follow a consistent playbook
  3. Key events like the 1905 protests and the 1917 February Revolution show how governments that fail to respond decisively enable radical uprisings.
  4. Lenin and the Bolsheviks used mass propaganda, military mutinies, and media manipulation to gain influence, even when initially powerless.
  5. The Bolsheviks systematically eliminated political enemies through executions, forced relocations, and terror campaigns, including the murder of the Romanov family.
  6. Once in power, communist regimes enforced extreme policies—anti-religious violence, mass starvation, no-fault divorce, and abortion—while claiming to represent the people.
  7. Despite losing popular support in elections, the Bolsheviks rejected democratic legitimacy and ruled through intimidation and violence.
  8. History repeats

Summary:

The Russian Revolution, often misunderstood as a grassroots peasant uprising, began with radicalized students and elite intellectuals who exploited political crises to dismantle the Tsarist regime. The Bolsheviks, led by Lenin, followed a predictable pattern: they provoked instability, seized power during moments of crisis, and then used terror, propaganda, and violent repression to eliminate opposition. Key events—such as the 1905 protests, the 1917 February Revolution, and the Kornilov Affair—demonstrate how indecisive or repressive leadership fuels revolutionary momentum.

Once in power, the Bolsheviks enacted radical policies, including the destruction of the family, persecution of religious institutions, mass executions, and forced economic policies that caused widespread suffering. Despite losing popular votes in early elections, they ignored democratic outcomes and ruled through intimidation and violence. This historical model reveals a timeless pattern of totalitarianism: rooted in resentment, not ideology, and driven by the need to destroy existing systems.

, where leftist movements continue to exploit crisis and dissent. The lesson is clear: vigilance is essential—because the tactics of the totalitarian left do not change over time. Preventing their rise requires matching their intensity, perseverance, and brutality with equal resolve.

FAQs

The Russian revolution was triggered by student protests, political unrest, and national humiliations like the Russo-Japanese War. Radicalized youth and disillusioned elites pushed for systemic change, while the government's failure to respond effectively allowed chaos to spiral.

Lenin and the Bolsheviks leveraged mass media, military mutinies, and political instability to gain influence. They exploited the collapse of the provisional government, used propaganda to gain support, and eventually seized power through the October Revolution by attacking key institutions and arresting opposition leaders.

The first rule is that any revolution can become your revolution. You should never allow the government to choose your course of action—instead, you must take control of the situation yourself and act decisively.

Political violence, including student riots, assassinations, and mass protests, escalated rapidly and destabilized the Tsarist regime. These actions created a power vacuum and provided the environment in which radical groups like the Bolsheviks could rise.

The Bolsheviks ignored the election results, which showed strong opposition to their rule. They banned rival parties, claimed a popular mandate, and held their own elections, demonstrating their willingness to override democratic processes.

The eighth rule is to exterminate the opposition. Once in power, communist regimes systematically eliminate political enemies, including through mass executions, forced relocations, and targeting specific groups like kulaks or religious leaders.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.