The Quitting Expert: Quit NOW Before AI Makes The Choice For You, This Is a Superpower! | Seth Godin
112m 34s
Seth Godin, in this conversation, challenges conventional wisdom about persistence and success. He argues that quitting is a powerful tool when applied strategically, contrasting the "dip"—the challenging but surmountable phase that leads to mastery—with a "cul-de-sac," a dead end where continued effort yields no progress. The core of his philosophy is that feeling stuck often arises from an internal conflict, symbolized by Buridan's donkey, which starves because it can't choose between water and carrots. This "but" trap (e.g., "I want fulfillment but also status") paralyzes us; the solution is to name these competing desires and make conscious trade-offs.
To move forward, Godin emphasizes defining a clear purpose by asking "Who is this for?" and targeting the smallest viable audience that can benefit from your work. This shifts focus from grand, vague ambitions to tangible, valuable actions. He also highlights the pervasive role of resistance—driven by fear, affiliation, and status—which manifests as procrastination or shame. The antidote is to break tasks into tiny steps (like interviewing a neighbor before aiming for a celebrity guest) and to accept embarrassment as an unavoidable entry fee, choosing to ignore unwarranted criticism.
Finally, Godin tackles sunk costs, urging listeners to treat past investments as gifts they can decline, freeing them to make new choices. He advocates for "picking yourself" rather than waiting for gatekeepers, using small experiments to gather evidence of traction. Ultimately, the path to getting unstuck lies in mastering the "throw" (the process) rather than obsessing over the "catch" (the outcome), allowing you to adapt, quit what isn't working, and persist through meaningful challenges.
How do I know when to quit something?
It's okay. You can quit things.
Hang on a minute. When I went to the gym this morning, there was a Michael Jordan quote.
If you quit once, it becomes a habit. Never quit.
He's wrong. And it's very clear that he's wrong.
And I've failed more times than most people are listening to this.
And the simple secret for the power of quitting is the dip.
And the dip describes something in the world that no one talks about.
And so one of the things I try to do is help people understand it.
Because my whole career is about how can I help people do better?
Find why they're stuck and realize what's holding them back.
Go solve the problem. Because problems are opportunity.
And I believe all problems can be solved.
But what we're wrestling now with is people are afraid, people are lonely, people are disconnected.
They're victims of all sorts of media and commercial systems.
And we've been indoctrinated to not notice it.
So I really want to just focus in on people who feel stuck right now.
So there's this philosophy which is the key to figuring out our stuckness.
The donkey is trapped halfway between the water and the cavern.
The donkey is thirsty.
And hungry.
But he's unwilling to move away from either of the things he wants.
So he starves to death and he dies of thirst.
And all of us do this.
And we do it with one simple word.
But.
I want to run the marathon.
But I don't want to get tired.
I want to have a job that fulfills me.
But I also like this car and this house.
And so I can give you tools that can help you overcome resistance.
And also I can give you the mechanics to become the person your future self thanks you for.
And then the skill of overcoming shame or embarrassment might be one of the most important skills in the modern world today.
How do I get better at dealing with that?
So let me try to make it really simple.
The floor is yours.
So.
Guys, I've got a favor to ask before this episode begins.
The algorithm, if you follow a show, will deliver you the best episodes from that show very prominently in your feed.
So when we have our best episodes on this show, the most shared episodes, the most rated episodes, I would love you to know.
And the simple way for you to know that is to hit that follow button.
But also it's the simple, easy, free thing that you can do to help us make the show better.
I would be hugely grateful if you could help us.
I would be hugely grateful if you could help us make this show better.
And I would be hugely grateful if you could take a minute on the app you're listening to this on right now and hit that follow button.
Thank you so, so, so much.
Seth Godin.
For my audience who have just clicked on this conversation, my question to you is by the time this conversation is done, what do you hope that they're going to come away with?
What questions in their life are they going to have answers to?
Some of your best guests are world experts and they show up and they say, I did the research.
I did the math.
Do this because I told you to.
And I've never done that.
I show up and I try to paint a picture for people of what the words mean and what the systems are like.
And then encourage you to do things because you told you to.
And so what I think we're wrestling now with is people are afraid.
People are lonely.
People are disconnected.
And there are problems all around us.
And if we can solve problems, we can make things better.
So what I want to help people do is find the words to talk about their problem, realize what's holding them back, go solve the problem.
Because when we solve problems, we make things better for ourselves and for other people.
So problems aren't something to be avoided.
Problems are our opportunity.
Some things aren't problems.
There are situations and you have to live with them.
But if it's a problem, it matters.
It means there's a solution.
And I would like to help people find the vision and the words to see where they're stuck, why they're stuck, and whether it's a problem or a situation.
If it's a problem and someone's going to benefit from you solving it, I hope I can give you the mechanics, the tools, the vocabulary to go move forward toward better.
And what kind of problems specifically do you try and solve for people in your work, but also in this more recent book that you've just written called The Knot?
So I don't solve problems for people.
They solve problems for themselves.
And when someone points out to you where the problem is, you can now make a new decision, right?
So if someone's applying for college, it's super easy if you're 17 years old to get all hung up on, I'm about to be judged, how are they going to know the real me, what if I get rejected, am I a loser, have I wasted my whole life?
But once you see the college industrial complex, once you understand the agenda of the admissions office, once you realize what people…
are looking at and why, you say, oh, this is a game, this is a game like Settlers of Catan or Monopoly, and if I win this game, it's not because I'm a good person, it's because I played the game better.
If I lose the game, same thing.
Once you see that, all the drama and entanglement of applying for college moves to the side.
You say, what's in it for the admissions officer to see the person I want to present to them?
Because if I can solve their problem, I'm going to go to the school I want to go to.
That's true in so many parts of our lives, is we engage with a system or a person or a boss or a co-worker or a spouse, and we think we're right.
We've got all this noise in our head.
We think everyone can hear the noise in our head.
They can't.
We think everyone wants what we want.
They don't.
And so we show up, say, it's my turn.
I need to get this.
And now we have a problem.
And the reason we have a problem is because that other person thinks they're as right as we think.
We're right.
And they have a different problem.
So we're colliding.
But if we can see that all of this is a dynamic within family systems, corporate systems, commercial systems, we can understand what are the forces at work.
Now that we see them, we can use them to get to where we want to go.
It's funny because I go out into the world and I sit in taxis and I walk down the street and people come up to me and I get sort of an idea of the personas of people watching.
Because I get in a lot of taxis, I have a lot of conversations with taxi drivers.
So they're one persona in my head.
And then, you know, the other is maybe like a mother with a kid or two who's trying to make a change in their sort of later career.
For those people, the average person listening right now, where is it that they want to go to?
And I don't mean specifically.
I don't mean job.
Where is it that they want to go to and where are they?
Right.
I think most people we meet would like to be seen, missed if they are gone.
Understood and of use, right?
That's something that crosses borders and cultures.
And yet, we end up being a cog in a system.
The Uber driver racing around doing things they wouldn't ordinarily do because the system is pushing them to cut every corner.
Or the mom who's struggling because the financial system that she's stuck in is pushing her away from the kind of work or parenting she wants to do.
And many of those things are injustices.
And some of those things cannot be fixed by an individual.
We can accept those as situations.
You're not going to change Uber.
Uber is going to be the way Uber is going to be.
And if you choose to be an Uber driver, the rules of Uber come with it.
But other things are things where we get to make a choice.
And I'm not saying, I want to be really clear, I'm not saying anyone deserves an injustice.
Anyone deserves where they are right now.
But given who you are, given where you are, what are the choices you do have?
And how do we get out of the not, the stuckness of wanting two things that we can't have at the same time?
Because it's when we want two things at the same time that cannot coexist that we feel stuck.
And that feeling of stuckness robs us from the chance to be of use.
It robs us from the chance to get to that place that deep down we want to go.
So I use the word purpose.
And what I mean by that is not you're born with a purpose because I don't think you were.
You choose, with intent, the purpose of whatever you're going to do tomorrow.
That purpose might be, I need to get paid.
That purpose might be, I need to get this date.
That purpose might be, I need to put something on the internet that changes the lives of a thousand people.
When you say your purpose out loud, the purpose of this work is so-and-so,
then I say back to you the very first question, which is the key.
Who? Who is this for?
Is it for everyone or is it for 12 people or a thousand people?
What change are you here to make, and for who?
And if we can't figure out who the who is,
then we feel like there's just this amorphous, horrible, heavy blanket on us, trapping us.
But if you can find the five people you can solve a problem for,
or the 25 people who would miss you, it starts to work.
So let me give you a quick story to help you understand the analogy.
You're a stand-up comic.
You've been working really hard, and your agent calls, "I got a great gig."
So you go, and there's 100 people there, and you go to work.
Bomb.
Not one laugh for 10 minutes, and then you leave the stage.
Then you find out it's a tour group from Italy, and no one in the room speaks English.
So who bombed, right?
It's your agent who put you in the wrong room.
There was nothing wrong with your jokes.
It was a mismatch because the audience didn't speak English.
So you're allowed to say, "It's not for you."
When we show up to try to engage with someone it's not for, if we read the comments, if we read the reviews,
and someone gives a great book, a one-star review, all that one-star review says is, "This book wasn't for me."
That's all they needed to write.
Nothing else in the review is helpful because someone else thought it was a five-star book.
So the author has learned nothing.
So we pick who it's for.
What is our intent?
This person I'm going to help, I'm going to trade with, I'm going to engage, I'm going to sell to, or whatever.
Who exactly?
What do they believe?
What do they want?
What are they afraid of?
If I can solve this problem, I'm going to sell to, or whatever.
Who exactly? What do they want? their problem.
they're going to want to engage and i can be of use and then i can do it again and then i can do
it again is this a point about getting unstuck in your current situation is it come right back to
who you want to serve their persona what their needs are and then focusing on that because i'm
thinking again about this uber driver who feels somewhat powerless in their life they they they
think i've got to sell my time to make this much money right but i'm not satisfied and i'm not
fulfilled so how does what you've just said sort of dovetail into that person's life so people
sometimes call me a marketer and i had the luxury of starting my career right when television was
dying so before that marketing meant big companies buying ads interrupting people hustling them
etc and then it shifted so i got to define marketing as anything i wanted
and i've defined marketing as telling a true story to the right people in a way that helps them get
where they want
that they will tell their friends about if you do those steps you're not doing any of the icky part
you're being of service and you don't have to have a budget to do this we are all marketing
when you walk in in tatty jeans to a job interview at an investment bank you've just marketed yourself
by your clothing right there's a signal that you chose to send and that they will receive or not
receive so when we think about the agency the freedom that each of us have
we have the freedom to decide who we're going to show up for and what's the story that's built in
so back to this uber driver if you want to make a living driving a car and meeting interesting people
one thing you could do is give up all of your freedom to uber and let them find you the passengers
but the other thing you could do is realize that there are 75 people who live in this suburb of
your town who need to get somewhere reliably and safely and would be delighted to have you be their
driver and when you hand out the right cards to the right people making it clear what you do and
don't do and who you do it for and don't do it for getting to 15 regular customers is not out of reach
as a private chauffeur yeah that path is a better use of his tomorrow than simply being ground out
by some social media company or or ride-sharing service bringing it back to this this rope thing
over here because i really want to just focus
in on people who feel stuck right now the essence of where i'm trying to go to in this conversation
is i want to speak to people that currently feel stuck but they know that they're capable of more
they know that they could have another life but they practically don't understand i guess both the
psychology the systems the mechanisms and i guess what they can control in order to move from where
they are to where they want to be right there's a rope here yeah and it serves as a somewhat
interesting analogy for i guess being stuck and pulling on the wrong thing yeah you sound like a
magician yeah okay i mean do you know the analogy because yes i do so 2500 years ago this guy named
alexander he didn't have a last name yet showed up outside of a small village in turkey and there
was a legend from king midas there was a wagon there and it was tied with a complicated knot
and the legend was whoever could untie this knot would become the ruler of huge parts of europe
and alexander was 21 years old and he did not use a knife he did not cut anything
but he looked at this knot that was tied to the wagon and he did one thing that no one before him
had ever done he realized that there was a pole in the center of it that it was tied around and he
removed the pole and then he could see by looking very carefully how the whole knot was held
together and he could untie it with no trouble whatsoever and then he became alexander the great
magician and he was able to untie it with no trouble whatsoever and then he became alexander the great
because the secret the simple secret was we are stuck because we can't see
what's holding us there if what's holding us there we cannot change like gravity is holding
us to earth gravity is not a problem gravity is a situation going to the moon doesn't deny gravity
it works with the fact that it exists but we are working with problems but we're confused
because we want two things so can i show you what i mean yeah okay so here's an actual carrot and
here's actual water this is not actually a donkey but let's pretend this is a donkey okay in burden's
philosophy experiment from a couple hundred years ago the donkey is hungry and thirsty he has
complete freedom he can move and he's halfway between a pile of carrots and a bucket of water
and he's trapped
trapped because every time he moves toward the water he's moving away from the carrot
can't do that because he's hungry and every time he moves toward the carrot he's moving
away from the water can't do that because he's thirsty and so in the experiment because we're
trapped we end up dying of hunger and thirst and all of us do this and we do it with one
simple word which is but i want this but i also want that right i want to have a
creative life but i never want to get rejected i want to run the marathon but i don't want to
get tired and we hide the butt we don't say the butt out loud so my favorite story which i talk
about in the book is jackson pollock so jackson pollock was the most famous painter in america
in the 1940s about 80 years ago he was on the cover of life magazine
he had three years where he could do no wrong his paintings were snatched
snapped up everyone saw him as a little bit of a hero it's very unusual for an artist to be a hero
in their own lifetime and his wife lee krasner later said that he felt like he had done everything
he could do with this cycle of art and what most people in that situation would have done
is become a jackson pollock cover band paint more versions of his old paintings
take the money you won he wanted to be a brilliant creator he wanted to be on the frontier so
he stopped painting jackson pollock paintings he went to a studio and came up with a whole new style
different size canvas different approach it didn't look like jackson pollock had done it and he brought
it to this big show and the world yawned not one piece sold and to this day if you go to a museum
you will probably not see a second cycle jackson pollock this led him to become even more of a
substance abuser which led to him dying in a tragic car crash that killed somebody else as well
because jackson pollock wanted two things he wanted to live on the frontier and be the creative
artist on the cutting edge but he also wanted to be the celebrity who could sell everything
he made and was seen as a genius he forgot how many years it took the first jackson pollock
to accomplish that and because the second jackson pollock didn't hit the butt became really loud in
his head and the second jackson pollock didn't hit the butt became really loud in his head
he can't have two of these things if they are diametrically opposed we need to find where is
the butt i want this but i want that it's usually hiding as an and but once we see it we'll say oh
that is what is keeping me from giving the people i'm trying to serve what they need
that's why i'm not getting where i need to go we can remove the pole
see the entanglements see what we're measuring wrong forgive them make a new decision and
the problem goes away and you can substitute and you're saying instead of but the and
is the thing that emphasizes it i want to be a creative person and i'm eager to be rejected and
not people have people get the joke for a while and have to live in the back of my van because
that's what creative people do that's part of it i get that i want to be popular on social media
and that means i can't be honest and authentic and consistent because i got to keep chasing x y or z
and when we look at the people who consistently get big clicks that's what they're doing
they're not saying this is who i am they're going to chase the next thing if you're not happy with
that please don't do it but the and amplifies the work but undercuts it there's people listening
right now that are maybe they've got three kids under the age of seven i'm thinking about my
brother he's got three kids under the age of seven and they also want to launch
a company right and they they might feel that there's a tension between those two things because
they on one hand want to be the best dad on earth like my brother wants to be yeah but at the same
time they really want to launch that ai startup yeah now these two things are tugging at each
other correct what do they do well the first thing they did was really important they named it okay
okay second thing can't do two things at the same time but you can do many things over time
and what that means is he made a commitment to three small
humans in this moment he's going to go to work but he can't go to work for 100 hours a week so he
needs to pick a project where the amount of time he has is enough time to do the project really well
he cannot start an open ai competitor it is off the table that is impossible because the thing he's
committed to cannot coexist with that that's hard to admit right but it unlocks the door to what we
can do if he can figure out how to build an entity where he's not hiding where he's actually showing
up on the hook
to a group of people and say, I know more about AI than you,
and I'm going to use this tool to do X, and they pay him for it.
Now, at the end of a 40-hour week, he appropriately goes
and does the work of a dad, right?
Dad's a business that's creating value for people
that will make you more profit than OpenAI made last year, right?
So the point I'm making is media keeps showing up and saying
what you're supposed to do is be a Kardashian,
what you're supposed to do is be Sam Altman.
No, that's not what you're supposed to do.
You're supposed to make promises and keep them
for the smallest audience that's enough.
You can't maximize two things that use the same space.
Do you think it's possible to know if a motivation
or a goal or a dream you have or an ambition you have
is real or not?
And when I say real, I mean, like, did I just inherit this
from expectations from Instagram or from my family
or because my brother-in-law is rich and I want to kind of compete?
Is there a way to know if the goal I say I want is a real one?
Yeah, I love this.
This is brilliant.
This gets back to the idea of purpose.
What is the change you seek to make
with the next cycle of your effort?
Not your purpose on earth,
but the purpose of the work you're about to do.
Are you trying to make Mark Zuckerberg happy?
Are you trying to make an anonymous commenter happy?
Are you trying to teach a troll a lesson?
Because when you say that out loud,
you realize that's a ridiculous purpose and it's a trap.
If we can be clear,
what's in it for me?
If I put this time in,
what will I get in return?
So my company has 75 people, let's say,
and should I grow to have 250 people?
Well, what would be in it for me
to be a CEO of 250 people instead of 75 people?
You're going to have a bigger headache.
You're going to have more money, theoretically.
Theoretically, but what you're really going to earn
is a different kind of status.
You have to decide if that status,
boss of more people,
that status, what I get,
to say at the cocktail party,
that status of what could happen after that
is worth the price you're going to pay to do this or not.
And so we keep making these choices
about what is the purpose of this work.
And that leads to the key from Steve Pressfield,
which is resistance.
And resistance is any feeling we have
that keeps us from doing generous,
generative, creative work of any kind.
So,
for example,
writer's block is resistance.
For example,
you're going out on a date
and you change your outfit six times.
Resistance shows up in so many of the things we do.
And the systems around us indoctrinate us
because they want us to be cogs in the system.
They want us to say,
well, how do I get an A?
How do I get permission to do X, Y, or Z?
I'm not going to initiate anything.
So it's easier for your brother
to deal with the resistance in his head
by saying,
I'm stuck.
Than it is for him to say,
I changed the lives of 17 people this weekend.
Whereas if we kept drilling into what's your purpose,
I think he would say,
yeah,
changing the lives of people is more important to me
than making Business Week magazine happy
because I built some company.
Is it useful to try and name the resistance
in order to overcome it?
You can't make resistance go away.
Ever.
You can dance with it.
You can invite it in for tea.
You can name it.
You can say,
the reason I'm hesitating to do this is resistance.
You can say,
I don't feel like it.
I got to go do this other thing instead.
I don't want to host a small party.
Resistance.
My friend Lisa moved across the country
to be with her partner
all the way to Los Angeles,
knew three people in the whole city.
She says,
I don't want to live a lonely life in Los Angeles.
I'm going to have a potluck dinner every Friday.
I'm going to start by inviting the three people I know.
And every week,
you can come back if you bring a new person.
Fifty weeks later,
she has a network of 400 people.
All good friends.
Anyone could have done that.
No one does.
Resistance.
What if I invite someone and they say no?
What if I invite someone and I don't like them?
What if I invite someone and they don't like me?
Resistance, resistance, resistance.
Name the baggage.
Drop the baggage.
Do it.
Once you can name the baggage,
you can say,
this is why I am feeling stuck.
If I can let go of this other thing,
I can move forward.
I can move toward the carrot
because I can forgive the water.
I was sort of running through different people in my head
that I know.
Again, trying to think about the personas of the people listening.
And one of the things I realized
is that everybody's starting from a very different place here.
Right.
And why is that?
Why is it that some people are quite good at dealing with resistance?
They can invite around strangers
and then other people are living in fear.
They're almost,
they never take a risk.
Yeah.
Well, a big part of it is privilege.
It's injustice.
It's living in a culture
that never gives you the benefit of the doubt.
But even if I look among a group of people
who all have the same amount of privilege,
there's still somebody who is at the marketplace
helping strangers find where they're going.
There's still somebody who,
you know, I have a family friend
went to an Ivy League school.
He wanted to be an actor.
And he went to apply to the improv troupe for auditions.
And they picked 10 people and he came in 11th.
And he called me up.
He was very upset.
And I said,
why don't you start your own improv troupe?
You don't need any equipment.
You don't need a permit.
You just need four people to do improv with.
Start your own improv troupe.
And the irony,
the reason I remember the story is
he couldn't do it.
I mean, isn't that what improv is?
And so, you know,
I run an online community called purple.space.
And on purple,
we got thousands of people
who are coaching each other.
And it's the opposite of a social network.
There's no scams.
There's no hustle.
Nobody sells anything to anybody.
It says,
I'll talk you through my knot.
You talk me through yours.
Let's hold each other accountable.
Well, someone needs to go first.
Everyone wants to be invited
to an engagement like that.
But few people want to start one
because you're afraid of being rejected
because it's one step short of dying.
So when we can name this
and realize it's actually not at all related to dying,
this isn't about hustling someone
and getting in their face to sell them something.
This is about offering to solve their problem
as you solve your problem
by naming the thing
and figuring out where we can be of value.
One of the things that I've experienced as a podcaster
is a lot of people come up to me in the street
and they'll tell me about the podcast idea
that they've had for four years.
And it's quite a curious thing to observe
because it appears on the surface
that they are serious.
But the very nature that they've been mulling it
for a couple of years
means that there's probably some kind of resistance there.
Correct.
Exactly.
So I. For a couple of years,
my friend Alex DePalma and I ran the Podcasting Fellowship.
So thousands of people went through this workshop
to start a podcast.
And the reason podcasts are such a great example
is everyone knows what a podcast is
and the cost of starting a podcast
is less than a dollar.
So why don't you have one, right?
Okay, well, so we start the cycle by
give me all the reasons you can't have a podcast.
And one of the ones that comes up is,
well, I don't think I could get good guests.
And then we would say,
okay, who would be the best guest you could ever get?
And amazingly, Michelle Obama's name comes up.
Michelle Obama is not going to be on your podcast.
But who would you need to have on your podcast
as the guest before Michelle Obama
that would lead her more likely to say yes?
And who would be the guest before that
and the guest before that?
And let's go all the way back to your next-door neighbor.
Can you get your next-door neighbor
to be a guest on your podcast?
Yes.
So go make that podcast
and just play it for the 20 people who are in this circle.
And at that point, half the people can't do it.
There's no technical reason why.
It's just too hard to say to your next-door neighbor,
can I interview you for 20 minutes
and then show it to somebody else?
Because resistance.
And so the hack I give people is
start a blog under another name,
under an assumed name.
No one will know you wrote it.
Do it for 100 days in a row.
If you do that for 100 days in a row,
I'm betting you're going to want to put your real name on it.
But if not, at least you understand
there was nothing wrong with it.
There was nothing wrong with it.
There was nothing fatal
about posting something in public
for 100 days in a row
with somebody else's name on it.
So that's obviously not where the writer's block is.
It's in resistance.
Two things at once.
I want to do this.
I want to be recognized.
But I don't want it to fail.
I don't want to be disrespected.
I don't want to lose status.
And those two things keep us paralyzed
and the system likes it like that.
What you did there is you took the resistance
and you tried to break it down
into the smallest possible piece.
Correct. Yes.
So you took a big piece.
You took a big piece of resistance,
which is how do I get Michelle Obama on my podcast?
You broke it down into
I need to go ask my next-door neighbor
to come on my podcast.
And then you broke it even smaller to
I'm going to start an anonymous blog.
Yeah.
Because when we call our own bluff,
it's very uncomfortable,
but it's better than someone else calling our bluff.
And this gets back to my posture of
I can't solve your problem,
but maybe I can give you tools
that can help you name your problem
so that in a safe place,
you can talk to somebody about
where is the resistance?
Why am I in my head about this?
What's the smallest unit of value
for the smallest possible audience
that I could do
that would make a difference for them?
Bob Lefsetz writes
the most popular music blog in the world.
Everybody in the music industry knows him.
I promise you,
when he started,
he had five readers.
My blog has a million readers.
When I started,
I had five readers.
That's the way they all start.
That's how your podcast started.
Five listeners.
When you broke it down there and you
turned it into an anonymous blog what i guess what you were also doing is you were breaking down
the embarrassment into smaller and smaller and smaller and smaller pieces of embarrassment right
but like irrespective there was still embarrassment and i heard this phrase embarrassment is the cost
of entry would you agree with the general idea that irrespective of what you do you're gonna
have to be embarrassed you're gonna have to like pay that as the fee of entry to almost anything
outside of your current context and identity all right so let's talk about lifeguards and
imposter syndrome so imposter syndrome was named by two social scientists about 70 years ago
imposter syndrome is that feeling when you're doing something important or new
that you're a little bit of a fake or a fraud and that someone else ought to be doing this instead
of you so the story i tell is about being a lifeguard so in canada you have to get your
bronze medallion to be a lifeguard and imagine you're on canoe lake
on duty there's six lifeguards on the dock and a kid starts drowning right in front of you
the first thing that might come to mind is i just barely got my bronze medallion and that guy two
docks down is a much better swimmer than me this is someone else should say and then you realize no
no it's right in front of you this is your kid you jump in the water do you apologize for your stroke
do you say i'm really sorry i'm not getting there as fast you save the kid that's what lifeguards do
the kid is going to thank you and their parents are going to thank you that's the work of a lifeguard
lifeguards are able to overcome resistance because it's such a vivid thing well if someone's going to
send an email newsletter to someone who asked for it and that might help them get to where they're
going where's the embarrassment exactly and shame is this interesting emotion because we must receive
it it's sent to us all the time but you have to receive it
for it to work now i'm walking on 74th street not far from here past this little pocket playground
and i hear a four-year-old inside the playground taunting somebody else and this kid is making fun
of this guy making fun of his clothes making fun of the fact that he's bald and then i realized the
kid's taunting me because he was just you know it felt safe for him and he's yelling at bystanders
the point was it instantly brought me back to third grade
instantly brought me back to what does it feel like to be bullied but i wait wait first of all
you're on the other side of a fence i'm never going to see you again you cannot put any shame
on me it doesn't it bounces off me and when we can get to useful work for a small audience of
people we're allowed to say to someone who doesn't get the joke sorry it's not for you
i forgive you i don't have to accept your shame i don't have to accept the embarrassment you
want to give me because i'm here for the right reason and if it's not for you
we both learned something i guess because of the internet as well embarrassment is
everywhere and shame is everywhere people like you start anything on the internet there's going
to be some troll that tells you it's terrible even when we started this podcast i mean still
today we get a lot of people telling us it's fucking terrible but um because it's everywhere
one could almost argue that um overcoming it is now a superpower because you know
everybody that does anything is going to encounter it and you know how painful it is to
deal with that and you also know that most people won't that actually the skill of mastering like
overcoming shame or embarrassment or critical feedback or whatever it might be might be one
of the most important skills in the modern world today when there's so much negative feedback and
so much shame or embarrassment or whatever you know just that's what you that's what i was
thinking of when you're saying it's like how do i get better at dealing with that well let's look
at it slightly differently because i think that's a great point but practical empathy says i don't
know what you know i didn't have the day you had i didn't have the day you had i didn't have the day
you had i don't want what you want and that's okay and i can forgive that and i don't have to
take it personally i can simply take it seriously and those are different things here's an interesting
semi-business example you've been to shake shack yes my friend danny meyer started shake shack it's
now a multi-billion dollar company shake shack is based on his youth in st louis missouri and
he grew up with crinkle cut french fries crinkle cut french fries are the secret to a certain kind
of fast food and it's a secret to a certain kind of fast food and it's a secret to a certain kind of
fast food hamburger joint and fancy new york restaurant critics ed levine the new york times
said what are you doing you're making this whole big deal out of everything is handmade and fresh
you're serving frozen crinkle cut french fries that we can buy in the freezer at the supermarket
you need to make real french fries so danny his status is associated with the fanciest restaurants
in the united states and he and his team see this assault they're getting on being embarrassed about
the french fries which are at the heart of their menu so they spend millions of dollars over the
course of a year researching potatoes reconfiguring every single restaurant putting in a different
kind of fryer making fresh cut french fries is a really big challenge also fresh cut french fries
are a living thing and in may the potatoes are different than they are in november
so sometimes a fresh cut french fry is the best french fry you ever had and sometimes it's limp
and not very good and they switched to fresh cut french fries because they wanted the status that
came from new york cultural critics saying these are guys that are authentic they're the real deal
and the french fries were no good and the entire internet blew up and say what have you done to
shake shack and the staff hated making them and it was a mess and you had to clean things differently
nothing good came of this shift except making a couple people in new york city happy because that's
who they decided to listen to and one day danny looked at this and said what is the purpose of
the french fries at shake shack do the french fries at shake shack exist to help a non-customer
feel good about eating at a danny meyer restaurant or do the french fries at shake shack exist to
further the story of what it is to come to shake shack and they ripped everything out and they
went back to the crinkle cut fries and the world rejoiced profits went up productivity went up and
they got back to what they were trying to do in the first place by forgiving and ignoring the people
who needed to say you need fresh cut french fries because that's what they stood for
but it wasn't what the business was for this sounds like a business story but actually as
you were saying it i realized that it pertains to everybody's life listening right now because
we're all serving a certain voice right and then the other thing that came to mind is i've just
hired someone called arda pema who came from amazon she was leading products they're building
ai products aws she's now leading she's our cito chief innovation and technology officer at steven
dot com my holding company and one of the things she told me about amazon is that they are just
unbelievably obsessed in the customer every decision they make from a culture perspective
is all about the customer she even told me that jeff bezos in his meetings and still in the amazon
meetings today they put an extra chair in every meeting that is empty to represent the customer
because they want the customer to be in every meeting and she told me how that anchors all of
the decisions they make from a product perspective right back to the person they're serving i guess
it kills the donkey thing you told me because they're not having to choose between serving
the merchants or the customer they are serving the customer sometimes she told me at the merchant's
expense but you have to be okay with that
she said to me and i actually really stayed with me because now i always think about like who's the
customer who's the customer even when i do this podcast you hear me talking about personas right
i'm talking about dave the taxi driver and jenny the mom exactly that's who we're serving here yeah
and so i just need to put a small paper clip here in the last two years amazon has lost their way
about who they're serving and amazon made billions and billions of dollars last year selling ads that
make amazon search worse to people who want to interrupt what you're looking for to put their
thing up on top that doesn't serve the customer that serves a different kind of shareholder
but yes the model of what jeff built there from the way they hold their meetings which is absolutely
fascinating to what they chose to do about who it was for and who it wasn't for were consistent
about saying this is the problem we are here to solve this is the purpose of this click this is
the purpose of this page there's no doubt about what it's for and so the meeting thing most people
who are listening to this go to meetings and many people who have white collar jobs say the
meeting thing is the problem we are here to solve this is the purpose of this click this is the
worst part of their day what is the meeting for the typical meeting if we're going to be honest
is to make the boss feel like you are listening to them and let the boss take attendance because
it could probably be a memo and if you're not sending a memo you're having a meeting let's be
clear who's this for what's it for what is the purpose of what we just did here with eight people
just listening the whole time well why didn't you just send them a video that they could watch at
double speed meetings are a symptom they're a symptom of whether they're going to be able to
do it or not it's a symptom of whether the organization is entangled and stuck with
unspoken rules about what we do around here and we can see them everywhere we look when in doubt
there are three things that drive people fear belonging or affiliation and status
and we don't really understand what they mean so first fear i call it the freedom from fear which
is different freedom from fear is i don't want to do things that are going to make me feel nervous i
don't want to do things that are going to make me feel nervous i don't want to do things that are
going to make me feel nervous i don't want to do things that are going to make me feel nervous i don't want to do things that i think i'm
want to do things that i think i'm
want to do things that i think i'm afraid of that keeps people from doing a
afraid of that keeps people from doing a
afraid of that keeps people from doing a lot of things that's resistance
lot of things that's resistance
lot of things that's resistance affiliation
affiliation
affiliation is you don't wear
is you don't wear
is you don't wear a tuxedo to a funeral because or a clown
a tuxedo to a funeral because or a clown
a tuxedo to a funeral because or a clown suit no one's going to do that so you're
suit no one's going to do that so you're
suit no one's going to do that so you're not going to do that fitting in who's to
right, what's everybody else doing? And the third one, which is really misunderstood, is status.
Status is simple. Who eats lunch first? When we get to the oasis, which animal gets the water
first? Status isn't money, but it could be related to money. Status is just who's up and who's down.
These three things keep dancing with each other about how people choose what kind of coat. Are
they going to buy Patagonia or are they going to buy a cheaper knockoff? One of those things comes
with a different kind of affiliation and status than another one. But if we look for this, we can
start to decode that quiet but that's been going on in our head. Name it, right? I want to get this
car. Why? Because it's fast. No, you don't need to go fast. I want to get this car because that kid
at the high school lunch table who said I was never going to amount to something,
he could never afford this car. And every time I get in this car, I'm going to be able to tell
myself a story that I'm not that kid from the lunch table anymore. That's why I want to get this car.
Okay. Now we're clear about what problem you're here to solve. Go for it.
Really?
Well, does it help you? Is that what you want to put your resources into? If that
helps you, then it solved the problem.
Do you think it is a worthy goal? A worthy reason?
Well, it's not for me to decide this. That high school leaves all sorts of tracks all over how
we look at the world. My high school English teacher wrote in my yearbook, you are the bane
of my existence. You are the bane of my existence. Then you will never amount to anything. And she was partially in jest, but remembering that
as I become a professional writer is fascinating. I dedicated like my ninth book to her and then I
could let it go. Right? And she and I had a wonderful lunch a couple of years later. The
point is we can't deny that these things are in our lives. None of us are living this optimized,
fully optimized life. The reason you're going and taking those
nutritional supplements, the reason you're listening to this thing about some shortcut of bio whatever
has nothing to do with you doing an actual analysis of all the best ways for you to be
healthy. They have to do with feeling agency. They have to do with feeling a certain kind of
affiliation with the crowd you're in. That's why we have cycles in medicine. It's not because
medicine goes in and out of actual science fashion. It's because culture,
changes what we think is beautiful, changes what we think we need to do to get our emotional needs
met. I've got 60 seconds and I'm going to show you how much I can get done because of our sponsor
called Whisper Flow. And for those of you that don't know what it is, it's a business I invested
in that turns your speech into text in any app or device. I'm going to post into our Slack channel,
which rewards whichever team member conducted the most experiments this week. Hi, everyone.
Here is this week's experimenter of the week. Congratulations.
To the Diary of a CEO trailer team, which is Ant, Liv, Dom, and Cam. You guys have won.
Okay, now I'm going to open Gmail. So here is one of our founders on an email chain that I want to
connect my team with. All I have to say is add my team's emails and Whisper will do exactly that.
Now, a quick message to Juan, who does my schedule every single week. Hey, Juan,
can I record on Wednesday at 2 p.m.? Actually, no. Do you know what? Let's record at 3 p.m. on
Wednesday. So if you want to give it a go, all you have to do is head to whisperflow.ai
slash Stephen to download it today. I've spent the last decade building and investing in companies.
And so often the conversation around marketing budgets follows the exact same pattern. The
budget gets approved, but then the results don't come back. And most of the time,
the creative pitch and the offer is fine. The problem lies with the audience. Ads reach people
who will never buy or refer, nor do they have the power to sign off anything at all. And this is
why so much budget gets wasted. LinkedIn Ads, who are a sponsor of this podcast, lets you reach them
specifically by job title, seniority, company size, industry, the skills that they have, and much more.
You're no longer hoping your ad reaches the right person. Instead, you're defining exactly who sees
it. And LinkedIn Ads drives the highest B2B return on ad spend across all major ad networks. Give
them a try at linkedin.com slash diary. And if you spend $250 on your first campaign, you'll get a
$250 credit for your next one just by going to linkedin.com slash diary. Keep this to yourself.
Terms and conditions apply. I think I'll ask this as well, because yes, you can serve
my parents' expectations because they're immigrants and they want me to be a doctor,
lawyer, scientist, whatever. Or I could serve my kids who want me to be a great dad,
or I could serve my playground trauma who wants to get the kid back who said I was never going
to be anything. Exactly. Are any of these voices more worthy than the other?
Is there a particular voice we should really orientate ourselves around? The other thing I've
really now sort of internalized is I'm going to have to say no to the other voices. I can't try
and serve them all, or else I'll be the donkey stuck in the middle of the water and the carrot.
I love this. I wish I put this in the book. This is exactly correct, that we're going to have to
forgive some of these voices. So there are three basic things that get us hung up. There are time
entanglements, which is today is not yesterday, and today is not tomorrow. Today is right now.
Social community entanglements. What will this person think of me? What will that person think
of me? And then there are the entanglements we have with our vision of ourselves. When I look
in the mirror, if this works, what will I think of myself? If this doesn't work, what will I think
of myself? And all three of them get in the way of announcing a purpose and then going to solve that
problem. Because we say to ourselves, well, I want to work to help the poor, but I can't get a job at
a fancy nonprofit. And if I get a job at a less fancy nonprofit, then what will my parents think?
Oh, all of that's going on. We have to acknowledge that, right? We say, I went to law school for
three years. I didn't like it. I practiced law for five years. I hated it. Do I want to spend
the next 40 years of my life being a lawyer? Because I've tried it fully out. We can't quit
because then we would have to explain to our former self, why did they pay
this big price to get me this fancy gift? And I'm ignoring it. Sunk costs keep us trapped.
And what we can do is realize that's a gift from our former self. And like all gifts,
you don't have to accept it. If someone shows up and offers you a Vietnamese pot-bellied pig to
take care of, you can say, no, thank you. I don't want to accept your gift. That law degree is a
gift, but you don't have to accept it now. Now that you know what you know, you can make a different
decision about the purpose of your work. And if it's not helping you achieve the purpose of your
work, you can make a different decision about the purpose of your work. And if it's not helping you
it, say, thank you very much and untie the knot. I think that point around sunk cost is an important
one to really double click on. Because when I learned about the idea of sunk cost, it completely
changed me as an investor. It was actually my brother. My brother's been working in like
investment banking for like 15 years, now works in my company. And he explained to me one day
early in my career, he goes, Stephen, it was a stock I had. I was an investor in a particular
stock. And the stock was doing terribly. The company was doing terribly. But I didn't know
because I'd invested at a higher price. And then he sent me the psychology of money book and a few
other papers and said, this is what sunk cost bias is. And it'll ruin your life if you don't
realize what it is. Yeah. And it's in everything we do. So there's the new parking apps let you
find a parking garage near where you're going and pay in advance. So when I come into the city,
sometimes I'll do this. So I've got a $35 ticket to go park at this lot starting in five minutes.
I'm driving in and I pass a free space on the street. Should I take it? So the advantage of
the free space, of course, is you can leave when you want to leave and you don't have to engage and
it saves you five or 10 minutes. But if I take the free space, I'm wasting the money I just paid for
that parking garage. And it still goes off in my head that, well, yeah, obviously you take the
free space because the money you paid is already gone. That ticket is a gift from your former self.
Knowing what you know now, would you take this job? Knowing what you know now, would you take
this parking space? And if the answer is yes, then you can forgive what got you here. Because
serving the old you, the old you's gone. Damn, I was thinking about relationships as well.
Yeah. Now, if you're the kind of person that leaves a relationship every three weeks because
you're ignoring sunk cost, then you're never going to have a relationship. Repeating the process
has costs to you because it develops these patterns. That's not the kind of sunk cost I'm
talking about. But yes, when you meet somebody who has decided to end a relationship,
the healthy thing for them to do is to say that relationship was then. I made all the right
decisions based on who I was then, based on who they were then. But we are not those people
anymore. So based on who we are now, do we want to recommit to this? Will it pay off
in the future? And if the answer is no, it will not pay off in the future, you've already answered
the question. It reminds me of Daniel Kahneman's work on loss aversion. And I think this is an
important thing to explain because when you realize what's actually going on in your head
and why people don't like to lose things, you can spot it when it's happening to you.
Right. I read this study that showed if you lose 10 pounds in the street, it falls out my pocket.
If I then find 10 pounds, it doesn't make up for the 10 pounds I just lost. I'd have to find 20
Um, the pleasure sufficient to the
pain that i experienced from losing the 10 humans don't like to lose things and when i i remember
searching what's like the evolutionary reason for this and it came to say that once upon a time
in our evolutionary past again this is a hypothesis when we had a meal in front of us
going in pursuit of another meal that would risk the one we current have was a terrible decision
to make so actually this whole you know we're designed to be sufficiently satisfied with what
we have versus the pursuit of surplus yeah so we want to protect what we currently have that was
a survival um advantage no absolutely we don't have to look in evolution we look at wild animals
today wild animals are wild they hate change change never help a species move forward because
it represents a threat and what we built as humans is a culture where change is happening faster and
faster and faster by the time we're done with this conversation some ai company will have launched a
new front-runner
into your model boom and we can look at this and say where can i go hide how can i get back to being
a wild animal that's in in this one place where nothing changes or we can decide to get back to
the purpose of what are we trying to do right now ignore the stuff that's not relevant to it
seek out the stuff that helps us make the change we seek to make and get back to work so we need
to decide where we're going to put our attention because our attention is
something we can never get back you talked as well about systems the systems were like held in
place with one of the things that i've seen in your work is this idea of picking yourself
because i guess we're wired to to believe that there are still gatekeepers but those gatekeepers
have increasingly vanished i mean the fact that i can start this podcast and people listen i think
is evidence of the fact that you no longer need gatekeepers do you know a funny story that i've
never told is i um i went for an interview with a guy who was a gatekeeper and i was like oh my god
with lbc which is a uk radio station before i took this podcast seriously i went there i did my two
hour audition sat there in the chair people pretended to phone in it was just staff lbc
right and um i left i was like quite nervous etc i thought i did a good job but i was a little bit
nervous unsure about what they might say and i never had back they never gave me feedback they
never told me if i was good if i was bad so i started this podcast um on youtube in my kitchen
because i never heard back from lbc
and it just goes to show actually you don't need a massive company to give you permission to start
a platform you can just do things yeah in this modern world and this is kind of dovetails into
your idea of picking yourself yeah so let's talk about systems first and then we'll come back to
picking yourself okay people get a little glassy-eyed when you talk about systems so let
me try to make it really simple when you get in a car here you drive on the right side of the road
when you get back to the uk you drive on the left side of the road why because it's way more
efficient to drive on the same side of the road as everybody else
we have a system that says if you're going to drive in the united states drive on the right
side of the road systems start to get a little bit more complicated the college industrial complex
is a system that starts in first grade that includes things like the sats and the stickers
and the football teams and the dorms and it's a 400 year old system that we got into because it
works it works for most people most of the time it's an easy way to look at a resume see one word
and decide if you want to interview somebody or not
so the system that people my age grew up in is you would do as well as you could in high school
and a college would pick you and then you do as well as you could in college and then a company
would pick you and you do as well as you could at the company and then they would pick you and
you get a promotion and then you would die and so we indoctrinated billions of people around the
world please wait to get picked here are all the rules and if you follow all the rules you might
get picked turns out it was rigged some people got picked unfairly but that's what we got brainwashed
and we still teach our kids this and then all of a sudden starting you know in the 90s we said
here's a microphone here's a video camera here's a typewriter pick yourself and now it's extended
to here's an ai you can start a company by tomorrow you could build a complicated website
by friday wait i'm waiting for someone to tell me i should go do that
no one's gonna call it's twenty dollars a month you can probably get it for free at your library
what are you gonna do and when we put ourselves on the hook it's super scary because does that
mean i'm responsible for every kid on canoe lake who needs a lifeguard and i'm responsible for
every kid who might suffer from river blindness and i'm responsible for this so it's easier to
say i'm responsible for nobody i'm a victim but we have the chance to say i pick myself to solve
this problem i'm on the hook to help
these people i'm going to use whatever tools i can to pick myself to make a thing better
turns out that's generative if you get a little good at it lots of people will ask you to do it
again when you give away credit and take responsibility lots of people will ask you to do
it again sometimes we tell ourselves that we're waiting to be picked because it's a nice excuse
for resistance we live in a permission seeking state
because it's a good shield to avoid this thing you were talking about,
which is the freedom from fear.
Yeah.
I mean, the entire New York City book publishing industry is based on
the author gets to say, well, they picked me to write the book,
and then I got to go promote the book because I promised I would promote the book.
The book isn't there because I wanted the book to be there.
They asked me to write this book.
And as soon as you can publish your own book,
as soon as you can start your own YouTube channel,
you don't get to say, great news, YouTube called.
They want me to start putting things on YouTube.
And that's why the number of people you would think would go ahead and use this tool
isn't as big as it could be because, again,
it's one thing to ask a teenager to be on TikTok.
They're just entertaining themselves.
They don't see themselves as a TikToker.
To see yourself as somebody, I picked myself.
I am saying this.
And I'm responsible.
That's hard.
No one taught us to do that.
It's kind of like the LBC thing.
I was waiting for LBC to pick me.
I think once this podcast comes out, they're going to call you.
And you've got a big decision to make because it's steady, Stephen.
They'll give you health insurance, the whole thing.
I still love LBC, by the way.
I still watch LBC.
But I'm probably too busy now to do LBC.
One of the sort of adjacent points here is how do I know –
if I'm delusional?
Right.
I always think this because a lot of the advice we give people around
like getting going and starting and pursuing the thing they want to pursue
doesn't necessarily always come with the nuance that actually –
like I can't actually be an NBA player.
Correct.
But how do I know?
Because all the advice is just go for it, pick yourself, et cetera.
But I might not have the talent.
I'm so glad you brought this up.
That's not my advice.
You probably are delusional if you're picking something that's super fun,
that involves skipping lots of interviews,
intermediate steps, and it ends with a happy ending where you're famous.
The chances of winning that lottery are very, very low.
So people come to me and say,
I got this great book.
Will you help me get a career as a novelist?
And the answer is super easy.
Take your novel.
It was really hard for you to write.
I get that.
Make it into a nicely formatted PDF.
Costs you nothing.
Email it to 20 people.
If they send it to other people and it spreads,
someone's going to call you and hire you to write your next novel.
If it doesn't spread,
write a better novel.
But don't start running around saying,
I'm a novelist and I deserve to get picked and have a big advance.
The heartbreak of someone who is delusional is they insist that the world owes them
because they worked so hard on X, Y, or Z.
Or that they have found some secret transcript that if anyone else understood it,
everyone would realize.
Well, if people don't understand it, that's on you.
So we can get paid.
We can pass the delusion by going for the smallest viable audience.
What's the smallest group of people that if I made a difference for them,
it would be enough?
What's interesting is I imagine if you said that to some people,
they would really not like the answer.
People hate it when I say this.
Why?
Because it's so comfortable to be stuck in that knot.
I'm a genius and I'm really hardworking,
but no one in the world understands me.
So now my butt isn't a problem because I don't have to worry about
any of the things that come with the responsibility of
it being in front of the wrong people or whatever.
It's so much easier to say, if only.
And, you know, I need to be home for this or this thing happened to me.
Therefore, I'm stuck.
We're safe at some level in that frustration.
And so what I'm trying to do with the knot is help people understand
this is possible, but it is not easy.
This is possible, but it will not give you the thing you are dreaming of.
It will merely find a path to get to where it is possible to go.
That's a grown-up thing to have to commit to.
If someone's not happy with the advice you just gave,
I think it also illuminates that maybe their motives are wrong.
It reminded me of when I started this podcast and I had these two friends,
Oliver and Ash, come to me and say,
that was good, when's the next one?
And I always say, if they hadn't have said that to me,
it probably wouldn't have continued because I was busy with other things.
But those two people who I trusted and would tell me when something is terrible,
and I often do, saying that to me, just, it gave me so much energy and motivation.
I kept publishing in part for them because I knew Oliver had this like three and a half hour commute to work every day from Sheffield.
And I loved the process.
I was getting this feedback from this particular person that carried on going.
But a lot of the time, actually, I think a lot of people would bounce off this advice of just send it to 20 people because they're actually attached to the podium.
Right.
And what you're saying is, no, focus on the journey.
Right.
But they want in their head somewhere, actually, no, I don't fuck the journey, Seth.
I want to be famous and I want the million pounds.
And that's not what you're offering them.
But actually, you are.
Well, someone's going to win the lottery, Stephen.
And it's probably not going to be you.
And so in your case, we're talking because you won the podcast lottery.
There are 100 podcasts as good as this one out of a million.
Right.
That's pretty amazing.
But there's still 100 of them.
So you show up to buy lottery tickets in a way that lets you buy more lottery tickets.
You show up to add value for people so you can keep going.
And then when there's a lottery, you got a shot.
Right.
But along the way, the journey says, I have a chance to say, here, I made this.
I made this means it's for you.
It is a gift I'm giving you.
If you don't accept the gift, I can't blame you.
I just have to make a better gift.
But if people start accepting your gifts, you have traction.
And Steve Blank talks about customer traction.
As an investor, you know this.
Customer traction is the single.
Best indicator of whether a startup is going to succeed.
More than any other metric.
How many customers would miss you if you shut down tomorrow?
And for a pizza place, 100 is enough.
They say that a lot in product development.
They say, just make a thing for one person you know.
And make it for one person you know that really, really, really loves it.
And it will turn out that there'll be lots of people like that person you know.
Enough people.
Maybe it's not lots, but it'll be enough.
So this cycle we're talking about isn't self-focused.
It's empathic.
You have to let the audience in to your thinking
or else you're thinking about what's in this for me and me alone.
And that's narcissistic.
And that is where you see all the internet hustle going on.
All the people who are trying to pressure folks
into sending them $5 or multi-level marketing, all that stuff.
That isn't what's possible.
And it's not what we should be spending our time on.
But when we can be. When we give service for the right people,
we have a chance to make things better.
But I need to put a big aside here,
which is where resistance kicks back in.
The only way to launch something new is to create tension.
Not to relieve it, but to create tension.
Generous tension.
The tension of you might be left behind.
You won't be in on the first cycle of it.
I have this thing that's going to help you
and you don't know what it is yet.
Tension that's offered generously
is the only way people. create forward motion.
So Taylor Swift is having a concert.
15,000 people can fit in the arena.
She just created tension for 40,000 people
because they're saying to their moms and dads,
I got to go get tickets before everybody else.
If she's not willing to create the tension,
she can't go on tour.
So yes, it's awkward to create a tension.
It's awkward to say, I'm doing this event.
I hope there's room for you.
But it's the only way we can cause other people
to decide.
to move forward.
I was stress testing that Taylor Swift analogy.
And the way that I stress tested it was,
well, what if Taylor did a gig
and there was unlimited seats?
People would still go, I guess,
because the tension is that she's so good,
I might miss the experience, as you said.
There's FOMO itself is the tension.
There's unlimited seats,
but there's not unlimited nights.
It's just tonight.
Yeah, okay, yeah.
And that's why live events
create a different sort of tension.
You know, this video's on the internet.
You haven't seen, I haven't seen.
And we're not stressed about that.
Because they'll be there tomorrow, right?
But the live event starts to change
how we're going to engage with it
among that community.
What else is sort of adjacent
to this idea of getting unstuck?
Because that's really what we're circling here.
It's like the things that keep you stuck
and how to take sort of actionable steps
outside of being stuck.
Is there anything else we need to close off on here?
So you saw some of my juggling balls there.
Juggling is fascinating.
It's fascinating because
when you see someone on the street,
if you're a good person,
if you see someone on the street juggling,
you're not rooting for them to drop a ball, right?
That we want the juggler to be able to juggle.
So when people say,
I'm going to learn how to juggle,
what happens is they throw one ball
and they can catch it.
They throw the other ball.
But within two or three throws,
one of the balls goes over here.
So they lunge to catch it
because juggling is about catching.
So they lunge to catch it,
but now they're out of position.
And the next one's going to hit the ground.
And then people give up.
People give up because they think
juggling is about catching.
It's not.
It's about throwing.
If you get good at throwing,
the catches take care of themselves.
So the way I teach juggling is with one ball,
throw it, catch it, throw it, catch it,
until you're really bored.
Then two balls, throw, throw, catch, catch.
This is not hard.
But if you do throw, throw, catch, catch for 20 minutes,
every ball is landing exactly where it's supposed to.
And now juggling is easy.
But what we are hooked on,
and listen to any self-improvement podcast,
it's all about the catching, right?
Does this help me lose weight?
Does this help me find friends?
Does this help me build my business?
Those are all catches.
Where's the throwing?
How are we going to get good at throwing?
How are we going to get good at realizing,
even if no one reads this next short story,
I'm going to get good at putting words on the page.
The process.
The process.
The practice.
If we can develop a practice,
we're no longer attached to the outcome.
Because the outcome is out of our control.
The practice is under our control.
Get good at throwing.
Get good at seeing where problems lie.
Seeing where audiences are.
Seeing where you can be generous.
When you get good at seeing those things,
the catches take care of themselves.
This is something that I've made for you.
I realized that the Diovers here audience are strivers,
whether it's in business or health,
we all have big goals that we want to accomplish.
And one of the things I've learned,
is that when you aim at the big, big, big goal,
it can feel incredibly psychologically uncomfortable.
Because it's kind of like being stood at the foot of Mount Everest and looking upwards.
The way to accomplish your goals is by breaking them down into tiny, small steps.
And we call this in our team, the 1%.
And actually, this philosophy is highly responsible for much of our success here.
So, what we've done so that you at home can accomplish any big goal that you have,
is we've made these 1% diaries,
and we've released these letters,
we've released these letters last year,
and they all sold out.
So, I asked my team over and over again to bring the diaries back,
but also to introduce some new colors and to make some minor tweaks to the diary.
So now, we have a better range for you.
So, if you have a big goal in mind,
and you need a framework and a process and some motivation,
then I highly recommend you get one of these diaries before they all sell out once again.
And you can get yours at thediary.com.
And if you want the link, the link is in the description below.
This, again, is not a narrative.
It's something that people will love because we all want to get good at catching.
Yeah.
Weirdly, this is very, very adjacent and almost unlinked, but it's somewhat linked.
I sat here with Julian Treasure.
He did two TED Talks.
One about speaking, right?
40 million views.
One about listening.
2 million views.
I thought it's almost kind of similar to like the catching and the throwing.
Yeah.
And actually, when I sit here with spies,
and I've interviewed some of the world's leading spies,
and I say, "How is it that you're able to get people to do whatever you want?"
that have just met you in foreign lands and hand over their secrets,
they say, "Listening."
Yeah.
It's all about the listening.
I go in their taxi and I listen to them for eight weeks as they offload because no one listens.
And it kind of got me thinking about this is like,
no one focuses on the throwing.
Yeah.
And actually, that becomes the great competitive advantage.
Right. Exactly.
Yeah, the practice.
I love the idea, world famous spies,
because you would think that that's sort of an oxymoron.
I would imagine the world's greatest spies, we have no idea who they are.
Well, they go on podcasts now, so they are like, yeah.
But part of it links to one of the books you wrote, which is called The Dip.
We're talking about delusion here,
and how to know if you're delusional or if you're just going through the dip.
So I've got some images here.
Okay.
How does someone listening know if they should give up on something
or if it's just the inevitable rough patch that you go through when you start and you're bad?
Okay.
So The Dip describes something in the world that no one had talked about in the book before,
which is the power of quitting.
What is The Dip?
The Dip is the hard part in between starting and getting good at it.
The Dip is organic chemistry on your way to being a doctor.
And you got to get through it to get to the other side.
The Dip is the gym in March.
If you want six-pack abs, you can't quit the gym in February,
which you joined during the holidays.
You're going to have to get through the hard part.
And so most of what we do that creates value
has a dip in it.
And my argument is you should, A, see the dip before you start.
You should say, "If I'm going to drive this car across the Gobi Desert,
I can't whine when I can't find a gas station.
There are no gas stations in the Gobi Desert.
There's a dip to get across the desert."
Pack what you need to get through the dip or don't start.
And number two, when the dip shows up, say thank you
because it means you hit the hard part.
It means this is the beginning of getting to the other side.
Don't complain about organic chemistry.
chemistry was coming. Organic chemistry is part of the process of becoming a doctor. As my friend
Gabe says, it's not an obstacle in the way. It's something along the way. And it's a signpost that
you're on the way. So your question then is, should we quit? Has anyone ever made it through
this dip before? If this is a dip like organic chemistry, where every single doctor in the world
has made it through, now you know. You know this is coming. And you know if you make it through,
you're going to get to the other side. On the other hand, no one that I know of has ever smoked
their way through emphysema. That when emphysema shows up, it's not a dip. And continuing to smoke
is not going to make you better. It's what made you worse. It's a cul-de-sac. It's a trap. And so
what we look for when we're talking to people about this journey, this delusion, this problem
we're trying to solve is. What does it usually cost to get through a dip like this one? Do I have the resources to get
through it? Or am I just throwing good time and good money after bad? But if you've got a business
that's losing money and losing money and losing money and losing money, and there's no evidence
that putting more money into your thing is going to get you to the other side, that's a cul-de-sac.
Forgive yourself, the old self who started the wrong business. Say, thank you. Thank you for
having the right insight, but it wasn't correct for this world today. I forgive you.
I'm going to go quit and do something else.
The key word there you said is evidence.
Yeah.
And the evidence could be, as you say, small.
Yeah. So if we think about the business, if you had a retail shop or a restaurant,
the ones that succeed, 95% of their profit goes to the landlord. And the ones that fail,
102% of their profit goes to the landlord. That's the only difference between failing
and not failing in one of those businesses. The landlord's job is to take as much money as possible.
As much as they can of your profit, but not too much that you go out of business.
So someone's got a four-year lease. They're two years into it. They're not making rent.
They're losing money every single day. And they have a sunk cost, which is, I got to pay for the
next two years of this storefront, whether or not I'm in here. But you can quit because you can
forgive that two years you have to pay. You decided that two years ago. That's not a new thing.
That's an old thing. Are you really going to spend the next two years of your life punishing
yourself because you made a decision a few years ago and signed a bad lease and built the wrong
business on the wrong street in a system that doesn't support you? Why? You can't get those
two years back. But we can take a deep breath and say, yeah, I'm going to leave this place empty
and go build something really useful over here. And I'll come out way ahead compared to defending
that old decision. Hang on a minute, Seth. When I went to the gym this morning,
there was-
Quotes written on the wall. And the quotes are like this one here.
Can you read that out for me?
Never quit.
It's a Michael Jordan quote.
Michael Jordan. Yes. I'm never going to have an argument with Michael Jordan, but he's wrong.
He doesn't play professional baseball anymore. He doesn't
play professional golf, nor does he play professional basketball anymore. Because
humans age, and he did a thing, but then he stopped.
He stopped doing the thing because it wasn't productive anymore. And when we think about
our fuel, he used, as an athlete, a couple things to fuel him. One thing he had was grievance.
And if you listen to his Hall of Fame speech, it's just a long list of chips he's had on his
shoulder for his whole career. That's fuel. Based on who he was and how he grew up, that's how he
gets on the court. And the second one was never quit. So if those two pieces of fuel help you
become the greatest basketball player in the world, then you're going to have a lot of fun.
I'm not going to argue with you. If that's getting you where you need to go,
it's up to you. But for most people, it's resistance and a trap. It's shame. It's
getting stuck in a knot. It's all of the buts, right? I want to be a successful business person,
but I can't admit I was wrong. I've shut down more businesses than most people who are listening to
this. I've failed more times than most people who are listening to this. If I was still running the
ball fundraising company I started in 1987, I wouldn't be talking to you today.
It's funny because there's this weird paradox that's so obvious to all of us, but
still people believe this idea of never quitting. And the paradox that I'm pointing at is
the minute someone starts something, a new company, a new job, a new relationship,
we celebrate. But we also intuitively know that in order to start something,
like a new job or a new relationship, you have to do something before that, which is quit the other
thing. Never quit, but we celebrate starting. Theoretically, then, we should celebrate the
quitting just as much as we celebrate the starting because they are fundamentally interlinked.
Correct. But only quitting the right stuff. You don't want to celebrate someone who quits
the marathon at mile 25 because what they failed to do in their training was become the kind of
runner that sees that the people who finished the marathon figure out where to put the tired.
But that's not the same as working for an abusive boss because
your boss is never going to stop being abusive. And so you can say, this can't get better. And
every day I come here and subject myself to this trauma, it's costing me, it's reinforcing a system
I don't believe in, and I can get tomorrow back again. What you've described there sounds a lot
like something I wrote about in my last book, which was just a quitting framework for this exact
situation people find themselves in. Because I know what people are saying that are listening.
They're all saying, how do I know when to quit something?
So I made this framework, which I'll throw up on the screen. And actually the example I use is the
marathon. I mean, this is the framework, you can see it for yourself and I'll just sort of give you
the voiceover. But if you look down the left side, I'm referring to a marathon there. And what I'm
saying is when something is hard, that is not reason enough to quit. Like a marathon in mile 23,
when you're raising money for a charity that means a lot to you. When you should quit is when
something, if you go down the right hand side, is when something sucks, like you've said about the
it would take to change it is not worth the thing on the other side. Exactly right. Because that's
what people will say. They'll say, how do I know when to quit something? How do I know? Like, you
know, how do I know when to quit the job or to. Right. And you can question your judgment because
if you have a history of quitting because in the short run it was tough as opposed to looking at
whether it was worth it, you can find a coach or peers who can challenge you on that. So I was one
of the leading makers of DVDs for book publishing companies back in the brief moment when they're
doing this. I worked with Fisher Price and we made a DVD for parents and stuff. And then this day
shows up and it becomes very clear that book publishers aren't going to do more of this
because the internet's here. They're going to do less of this. So every day I would be defending
what I had built as a DVD producer was completely wasted. So forgive yourself,
I didn't change the world. Somebody else changed the world, but it's not going to get better.
This is a cul-de-sac. It's a dead end. Thanks for doing this. Let's start something else.
Because there's a lot of people right now that are in their thirties, forties,
fifties that are in jobs that have not made them fulfilled for a decade.
Yeah. But they're 20 years in, they've climbed the ladder, they're director.
Right. So they have sunk costs because they've earned the spot, but they also have a whole bunch
of entanglements. Like I want to have a job that fulfills me. Right. I want to have a job that fulfills me, but I also like my neighbors thinking I'm this stable, respectable person. I want to have a job that fulfills me, but I have all this other stuff I have to pay for. All right. But if we look at those buts, we realize you just made the choice to stay in this job. So you don't have to fret about it anymore. You've accepted that you made that choice. The alternative is move to a two bedroom flat, eat rice and beans, and then you're good to go.
Take a deep breath, reset all these things, and now you can get a different job that's going to pay you half as much because you gave up the buts. Right. A job that fulfills me will give me a better relationship with my family, will give me hope for the future, will give me a chance to make X, Y, or Z happen in the world. That's hard because you can't have the buts. You got to let them go.
In that scenario, you know, okay, I have the car. I have the business card, which is in
impressive to people. I get invited to nice things, but I'm miserable.
So what do I do? I've got a community I've built around this identity that is on this business card, but I'm miserable, Seth.
Right. So the magic of this process is if you announce through this that it's a situation,
that all these other things are so important to me, that I cannot change my job,
suddenly your job gets a lot better because you're not bridling against it. You chose it.
And so if you talk to people, I gave a couple of talks for people who are in the funeral industry,
undertakers. Most of us would not sign up for that job as high school students at the career fair.
Right. But the people who stick with it, they're not sitting there saying,
this is horrible. I hate being around dead people. They're saying all the stuff that I get in my life,
this is part of it. It comes with it. Just like getting tired in the marathon,
it comes with it. If I want to have this life where it's stable, where I don't have to move
around, where I'm a member of the community, where the cash flow is assured.
And I get to be an undertaker.
Within that structure, how do I be the best undertaker I could possibly be?
As opposed to wishing that I would get a call from Michael Jordan who wants me to run his financial empire or something.
Because it's not going to happen.
I get to be.
You're taking back control from the situation.
You're shifting from victimhood to control.
Right.
There's this remarkable couple of stats that I read about this idea of feeling like you have control and how it changes your outcomes in your life.
The first stat is people who believe they are in control of their life and have control over their happiness rate their overall life satisfaction at an average of 7.4 out of 10 compared to those that don't feel like they have control of their situation who rate their life satisfaction at 5.6.
People who report low overall happiness are five times more likely to fail.
I feel like their own personal situation is entirely outside of their control.
I mean, this one was a landmark study they did in care homes.
In a famous 1976 study, elderly residents given plant care and small daily choices that they could make were 50% less likely to die over an 18-month period compared to residents whose care was fully handled for them.
Crazy.
The power of feeling like you have control in your life.
Right.
And also, I don't know the stats, but when they give people in hospice control over their painkillers as opposed to them having to wait for someone to give them a painkiller, they don't necessarily take more painkillers.
It was knowing they can do it.
Same thing back to the meetings thing.
If you have a job where you're going to meetings all day where you just have to do this, you've lost control over your day.
And I'm not here to say there's no cost to switching.
There's huge cost to switching.
That's why you chose not to switch until now.
But let's name it.
Let's say, you know.
Gravity is fascinating because it's here.
But if I was on a planet that didn't have gravity or had low gravity, I would miss this gravity because I've built my whole life around gravity being this consistent thing.
I get to live on a planet with gravity.
I get to be the kind of organism that's going to die before he's 100.
If you look at the world that way, that that's inevitable and I get to inhabit each day the best I can, you're going to have a different life than if you're spending all your time trying to figure out how to live forever.
I'd never heard that painkiller study before, but as you're speaking, I just pulled it up and it says it's one of the most famous real-world demonstrations of how the perception of control alters your physical and psychological experience.
When hospital patients are given a button to self-administer pain medication, two incredible things happen.
Number one is they consume equal or less painkillers.
Number two, they report lower pain levels and higher satisfaction.
The physical pain itself doesn't magically change, but the stress of helplessness amplifies pain.
Right.
The stress of helplessness.
I mean, it goes right back to what we're saying about the knot in your new book, which is a lot of us are living with the stress of helplessness, but sometimes, not always, but sometimes that helplessness is in part a story.
I would say it's always a story because we can look at someone who is in human bondage.
We can look at someone who's, you know, been through trauma.
And we are projecting what we would feel.
And we are projecting what we would feel in that situation.
There are all these unfair situations around there.
But then the question is, what is our narrative?
What is our narrative of how are we living this day?
What do we actually have control over?
And what situations are we choosing to stick with?
Because most of us have the freedom to shift.
Right?
And so it's a story we tell ourselves that might not change the outside world in the short run.
But what it does is it's a story that we tell ourselves that might not change the outside world in the short run.
But what it does is it gives us this feeling of agency, which then gives us a sense of responsibility, which then amplifies into choice.
And my whole career is about how can I help people do better?
I wanted to throw another quote at you here.
This one is about meaningful work.
So if you could read that as well.
From Warren Buffett.
In the world of business, the people who are most successful are those who are doing it.
Doing what they love.
I've heard that a million times.
Do what you love.
Yeah, it's backwards.
Sorry, Warren.
The people who are the most successful love what they do.
What's the difference?
Well, doing what you love means there's an amusement park out there that has all the treats I love and all the best prizes.
Of course I love it.
The other is a choice.
I chose to do this work because I love it.
There was a guy who worked.
He worked at the Dean and DeLuca Cafe in Midtown.
And he was developmentally challenged and he was probably 50 years old.
He was the mayor of this Dean and DeLuca.
He was the guy who cleared the tables and kept the thing straight.
He loved this job.
You and I would have lasted 15 minutes in this job.
He loved this job because he decided to love this job.
The Reverend King had a great quote about street sweepers.
And he said, if you have to be a street sweeper, at least choose to be the best.
You have to be the best street sweeper in that situation under these conditions that it's possible to be.
And the reason is not because you want to help the street sweeping company.
It's because your day's going to go better if you do that.
I was thinking he also meant, potentially, although I guess he didn't clarify,
but the way that I perceived it was that if I become the best street sweeper,
not to say that's not an important job,
it increases my possibility of becoming something else as well.
Of being promoted, being, dare I say, picked.
To be something else.
Or to start my own street sweeping business.
Or to, you know, I'm going to build a great relationship with my customers.
Yeah.
And I think they rhyme and dance with each other.
Yeah.
They don't contradict each other.
And so all of us have had a job where we thought it was a good job,
and someone doing the same job down the aisle hated it.
Or vice versa.
So clearly, it's not the job.
It's where did we come from?
What are we afraid of?
What do we believe?
Where are we going?
That creates the story that opens the door for possibilities.
Well, I guess some of these other quotes link to it then.
I mean, they kind of all say the same thing.
But let's do this one.
This is a famous Mark Twain quote that probably everybody's heard.
If you get a chance, talk to your favorite AI about Mark Twain quotes.
Mostly fake.
It's a great conversation.
The two most important days of your life are the day you are born
and the day you find out why.
I've heard that a lot as well.
And my small shift is not the day you find out why.
It's the day you find out why.
It's the day you decide why.
Because this isn't something you're born with.
This is something you choose.
And if you make the decision, like my friend Jacqueline,
to say there are 400 million people on this earth
who are making $3 or $4 a day,
I'm going to devote a generation of my life to helping them.
You can go do that.
And most people don't have the head start.
Most people aren't.
They're starting at mile 20 of the marathon.
Some people are starting behind others.
But we still get to decide, based on who we are, what we know,
what we've got access to, which problems are we going to solve?
And who's going to benefit from us solving those problems?
That is what I think Twain was trying to get at.
And my last one.
This one.
From a very famous guy whose device I'm using right now.
The only way to do great work is to love what you do.
Bingo.
If you haven't found it yet,
keep looking, don't settle.
Who is that?
That's Steve Jobs.
And I think the keep looking part might mean look inside,
don't look over there.
Why is it that you don't love what you do right now?
Let's unknot that first.
Is it because you're being disrespected?
Is it because the external narrative of what's happening
is undermining who you hope to be?
If we can get close,
clear about that,
finding the next thing gets way easier.
You're not giving into this lottery of hoping you get picked
by the next right boss.
You can go hire a boss.
And when you hire the right boss,
your job is transformed.
At the heart of a lot of this is this word perfectionism.
That's a big knot.
You know, when I was thinking about the young lady that came
up to me in the Apple store the other day and told me that
she's been thinking about her podcast for two years and she's
been working on it for two years.
But it's never been published yet.
What I heard there is perfectionism maybe as a form of procrastination.
Perfectionism is a trap every time.
Perfectionism has nothing to do with quality.
So the word quality has a very specific meaning.
It doesn't mean luxury.
It means meets spec.
So the quality of a 1998 Toyota Celica was higher than the quality
of a Rolls Royce in 1998 because the pieces fit together better.
They met spec.
It wasn't all over the place.
If you're not happy with the quality, make the spec better.
But perfectionism says perfect feels like an honorable thing to pursue.
But perfect is unachievable.
So if I announce I'm a perfectionist, I'm hiding.
Because what I've just announced is I'm never going to need to ship this
because it's never going to be perfect.
One of the other words that I think does tie people in knots as well
is this word authenticity.
Because authenticity is a terrifying concept when you really think about it.
What do you think of this?
It's a trap and authenticity is for amateurs.
Your friends need you to be authentic.
authentic. Your family wants you to be authentic. Nobody else. Professionals are not authentic.
Professionals are consistent. Professionals make a promise and they keep it. So if you're having
knee surgery, you don't want the doctor to authentically be in a bad mood and screw up.
You want them to be the best version of themselves, even if they don't feel like it.
And Keanu Reeves, he's not authentically Neo. He's an actor. He's pretending to be Neo. If he was
playing Keanu Reeves in the movie, it wouldn't be any good. On social media, if you're going to
show up and show up and show up, unless you're a diva, then we're watching you self-destruct.
That's what we're paying for, like Amy Winehouse or something. Everybody else, we want them to be
consistent. And consistent means you made a choice about the promise you're going to make
and you keep the promise over and over again. So when I'm writing my blog, I am playing the role of
Seth Godin, the blogger. It is not authentically how I felt in that moment. It's my best version
of what I think Seth Godin, the blogger, would say today. And we've spent time together. I like
you a lot, but I don't know you. And that's for your friends and your partner. So authenticity
as a buzzword is a version of resistance. It's one more way to hide. We say, oh, I was just being
authentic. No, you were just being a jerk. And that's why I'm saying, oh, I'm just being authentic.
That's why I rejected you, because you chose to be a jerk, not because you were authentic. We say,
I can't write the next novel because it wouldn't authentically be who I am. Well, yeah, but the
people you're writing the novel from don't know you. They just want to read the next Perry Mason
novel. Write that or else get out of the circle we're in, because that's what they came for.
In some way, these two things are somewhat interlinked. I was thinking, you know,
as a podcaster, I know that I'm going to have to do, if I want to sort of accomplish my goals and
continue to have this life, I'm going to have to do thousands and thousands and thousands and
thousands and thousands of episodes. And one of the ways that I'm going to be able to do that
is by being as authentic as I possibly can, because I find it to be very exhausting to
be inauthentic in that way. One very practical way that I mean that is when I look at my guest
booking request list that my team sends me, I go down there and I look at all the people. I go,
oh my God, okay, so that person's got 100 million followers and they're a super famous person. I've
never watched their movies. I have no idea who they are because I don't really watch many movies.
But, you know, I guess I could be authentic and pretend to care about that thing. But then this
principle comes into my mind, which is, well, then I wouldn't be able to do this for a long time. I
wouldn't be able to be consistent if I didn't make those, dare I say, authentic decisions. For me to
sit here and try and be someone else in those hours and hours and hours times by 10,000 episodes,
I wouldn't be able to be consistent. Thank you for calling this out. What you just said doesn't
contradict what I said. And it's really important we highlight this. You should not sign up for
something.
Where you cannot happily be consistent. And so let's think about a teacher. The teacher knows
everything they're teaching. The students know nothing they're teaching. So the empathic solution
is not to authentically talk about whatever's interesting to you. It's to create the conditions
for you to teach people so that they can start to get closer to where you are. That's a commitment,
not an authenticity thing. It's what kind of taste am I going to bring so I can consistently make a
promise and keep it. That needs to rhyme with what you would do if it was your hobby. But it shouldn't
be your hobby. When you turn your hobby into a business, you ruin both of them.
So do I conclude then that it's this sort of dance between me and my authentic self and the
thing that I can do to be consistent at this goal? Is it a dance?
It's a dance because people who are happy find consistency that rhymes with their overall
authentic self. And their overall authentic self, it turns out, changes over time based on
the promises they made. So if you hang out with people on Wall Street, even if they weren't,
you know, loud and short cycle kinds of people when they got the job, they authentically became
like that because that's who they were surrounded by, affiliation, status. We change. We're not who
we were. And so we get to pick this arc. It cost me a lot coming out of business,
to be an underemployed entrepreneur in the creative business, not joining, you know,
Apple or Activision or something like that. So for years, I was behind on the status ladder
of my peers. That's an investment on the long arc of, quote, authentically becoming
the kind of person I wanted to be all day. But I said to myself, if I have to make a promise
to an engineering company that I'm going to be Dilbert all day, every day, I'm going to die,
a little bit inside until it's over. And I don't want to do that.
All industries are changing. AI. What are your thoughts on this crazy new technology that has
come down from the ground?
So my background here is when I was at Stanford in 1983, I took a PhD course with
Doug Lenat, who was one of the fathers of AI. I worked with Isaac Asimov and Arthur C. Clark
in my first real job. So I've been a science fiction person thinking about AI my whole life.
And so when it finally showed up, I was like, yes, it's finally here. And I've been writing
about it for a while. I did some AI-related products. Here's my two big ideas. Number
one, this is the biggest change in our world since electricity. And number two, either
you work for AI or AI works for you.
And what do I mean by those two things? There were companies and workers in 1890 who said,
I'll wait for electricity to go away. I'm just going to keep being a blacksmith or whatever it
is. That did not work out very well. This is like that, but much, much faster. And then the AI thing
is, if you work for an AI, it's not going to treat you very well. It's not going to be secure. And
it's not going to make you happy. Because bosses are going to keep pushing the AI to do all the
good parts and you to be a gig worker for all the parts that the AI can't do yet. But if you can say,
I use AI to connect humans.
I use AI to build a network of people. We don't know how to replace networks of people. And AI is
never going to be able to replace networks of people. If you are trusted and connecting and
leading using whatever AI tools you want, you're never going to have trouble making a living.
And so that's what you say, okay, if I have these tools, how do I use them? Not to be a junior,
smaller version of open AI, but use them the same way that the movie theater used electricity
that the electric company brought electricity to lots of businesses, but it took a movie theater
to figure out how to get you to pay $5 to see the movie.
You used the word people and humans within that answer. And it made me sort of think that
actually maybe the great opportunity in a world of artificial intelligence is not to try and be
the world's best accountant, because maybe the intelligence is going to be great at that,
but all the human stuff, all the human and the people stuff.
Yes, exactly right. Good taste, understanding,
who trusts you and why. There are very few jobs where if I can write down what you do all day,
I can't find an AI to do it faster and cheaper than you.
Interesting.
So you want a job where I can't write down what you do all day, and then you'll be fine.
What the quiet quit is.
Well, I mean, so if you think about what does a bookkeeper do? I can write down all the rules
of bookkeeping and hire a different bookkeeper tomorrow and my business isn't going to fail.
That's something AI is going to get really good at really fast. Because once we can write down
rules, AI knows how to follow them. On the other hand, somebody, the way you were talking about
your good taste about who the next guest should be, you can't write down the algorithm for how
to do that. Your awareness of the world you're in, the fact that you have read so many books,
met so many people, talked to so many listeners, I can't write all that down with instructions to get
Claude to do that for me.
I was thinking about my fiancee, actually. She runs a business called Bali Breathwork. And
what she does is she takes women away on these retreats for seven days. And I see the sort of
feedback and the testimonials and the videos that these women send, and they love it. I always say
to her, don't worry about AI, you're going to be fine.
And most of what they got out of it is each other. And when we let the computer networks take over,
it keeps pushing us away from each other. It pretends we're connecting on social media,
but people are more alone.
Only than ever before. But when we figure out how to connect human to human, we create value. And
ultimately, if you want to make a living, you're going to have to create value. And the bosses that
are right now cost reducing as fast as they can have no imagination. They're saying, oh, this is
cheap, super offshore labor. It's called a computer. I can get rid of 400 customer service
reps. They're racing to the bottom. Some people are racing to the top. How can I make this more
human? How can I make it so that now that I've augmented doctors with these AI tools,
they're going to spend more time per patient, not less time per patient? Because we know that
patients that have doctors to spend more time with them are more satisfied. So that's a business
advantage. Because now someone can either stay home, talk to Dr. Google and figure out what's
and never go to the doctor. Or they can go to a doctor that's worth paying for because that doctor
has an AI.
Try working for them.
true. Is there anything else in the knot that we haven't talked about that we should have talked
about? Obviously, I want everyone to go and buy the book. I love what you did on here. I think
this is probably worth just spending a second on. But I mean, do you know when you see an idea and
you just wish it was yours? This is one such example. Yeah, that's the names of all the people
who pre-ordered the book from my site. And then I used a gray tone. So if you look at it from a
distance, just write it says the word purpose, as in what is the project you're trying to do.
Let me close with the story of Dame Fina Cooper. Because a lot of times we talk about,
you know, the personal thing, what should this Uber driver do? But then there are other times
we talk about systemic injustice. Are we all victims? So Dame Cooper was,
an indigenous person growing up in New Zealand. And New Zealand was the last major country to be
colonized by the United Kingdom. And so huge amounts of native lands were taken. And the
indigenous people were disenfranchised in a lot of ways. It's really tragic when you think about it.
And Dame Cooper, at the age of 78 or so, decided that she would use her status and affiliation
within the tribe she was part of to capture the attention of the entire nation and try to put
indigenous people's rights on the agenda. So you look at this and say, here's this woman. She
doesn't, she's not famous. She doesn't have a lot of money. She's almost 80 years old. What could
she possibly do? This is a problem or it's a situation. If it's a situation, what are we going
to do? Just live with it? But if it's a problem, let's figure out where are the pieces to make
progress happen. She organizes 50 people. Most of us could organize 50 people. And they start
marching to the capital. And they do the work to spread the news in advance. And day after day
after day for more than a month, this group of people is walking to the capital. She's on the
front page of every newspaper in New Zealand by halfway through. Now there's 100 people, 200 people,
2,000 people.
By the time they get to the capital, there are 4,000 people patiently marching side by side. And
they presented their demands, requirements, suggestions to the parliament. And too late,
not enough, but in a very big way, it shifted the culture of the entire country, changed the laws
about how land was allocated, and made a really fundamental difference. She didn't do that by
herself.
But she understood she had enough agency to connect the others, to create a culture, to show up and show up and show up with a practice. So if one 80-year-old woman can change an entire country, what can we do? Right? We can't drive to London or Washington, D.C. and change everything. But what we can do is find the others, come up with the story we can tell ourselves and the others, and establish a new normal.
The only way the world has ever changed is when a few people come together, build a culture, and repeat it over and over and over again.
For some reason, when you talked about that, and it was a very motivating thing to hear, the subject of death came into my mind because, again, I've dropped into the world of the listener right now. And I guess I asked myself, how do you create that tension to do it today and not tomorrow?
Right.
Because there's never going to be a purpose.
There's never going to be a perfect time. Tomorrow's going to be imperfect. Next week's going to be imperfect. So when faced with, like, lots of imperfect options, how do you create enough tension to get whoever's listening right now to, like, go do it?
Yeah. When the person you're dreaming of becoming meets the person you become, how's that meeting going to go? How do you become the person your future self thanks you for? Because most of us have regret. I wish I had done something when I was 20 or 30 or 40.
Well, that regret's a powerful fuel.
You said this to me before we started recording about regret.
Yeah.
And you said that it's actually not about what you want to accomplish, I think you said. It's actually about some of the things that you wish you had done.
Yeah. So when I think about my mistakes, and I've had so many mistakes, the mistakes I regret the most are the things I didn't do, not the things I tried that failed, the person I didn't help, the lesson I didn't teach, the door I didn't open.
Because it's easy to ignore those things and just move on. But that's our power, our leverage, our agency, is to be able to say, there's a thing I could do. There's someone on that street corner who needs a hand. How do we build a thing that our future self will thank us for doing today?
And so I spent two years organizing the Carbon Almanac with 1,900 co-authors. Full-time volunteer work for me. And the 1,900 of us got something out of it.
Out of seeing each other, working with each other, realizing we could do something about our understanding of our climate problem. And then it became a bestseller in five or six countries and opened the door for many of the people who participated in it to have more leverage and to do the next thing.
But when I think about that day, when I said, well, I could post something about this and see who shows up, it would have been super easy to say, nah, let's just go see what's on Star Trek today.
So saying, okay, this is the next thing. That begins this generative positive cycle. And it's contagious. And that's the magic of this sort of virus. If the generative contagious idea of who can I open a door for spreads, then you're probably going to end up living in a world that's more like the world you want to live in.
Why do you continue to do things? Because you've written more books here than I can bloody carry.
I've started my career as a marketeer, which is, you know, that website that failed turned into a marketing business, essentially. And then people, everybody gives you this book when you get into marketing, which is your book, This Is Marketing. And they use your ideas all the time. I mean, one could say, Seth, you've done enough. Maybe now is a good time to just enjoy it, they might say. Why do you keep going?
I don't know. I think the industry grew up out of that. But after that, writing books is a lousy way to make a living. But it's a pretty good way to make a difference. And I said, don't turn your hobby into a business because you'll ruin both of them. But it's interesting to think about turning your business into a hobby, into the thing you love to do. And if someone said, I can't share ideas anymore, I'm not exactly sure how I would spend my day. For me, when I hear from somebody who says, I can't share ideas anymore, I'm not exactly sure how I would spend my day.
And if someone says, I learned something from someone who learned it from someone who learned it from someone who learned it from you, that's thrilling. The only thing I'm trying to do is turn on some lights for people, offer them some dignity, and create the next cycle. And if you sign up for that, I'm not sure how you can stop.
Now, maybe, just maybe, listen, I'm not that superstitious, but maybe there's a couple of people that found this conversation and they got to this point in the conversation for some kind of reason. And I imagine it's because they are in. You know, they have their own knot somewhere. So just to close off for those people who currently are in a bit of a knot, it could be a job, a relationship, a situationship, whatever it might be. What is your sort of closing remarks to those people that are a bit stuck and that are on that precipice of maybe taking a leap, a step forward, but they're tied up a little bit like these knots are?
Yeah, you're not alone. We all are. Every single one of us, especially me, we're all stuck with something.
And you can forgive that and then say, okay, who can I contribute to today? Who can I offer help to and maybe ask for help? And it doesn't mean that where you are is fair. And it doesn't mean that what you're feeling isn't real. It is real. The only question is, what will we do next?
I've really sort of taken to heart this idea as well that we talked about earlier of just being really clear on which voice you're serving.
Mm-hmm.
And what that brings me with is this central idea of like getting clear on which voice in my life I'm going to listen to.
Yeah.
Because we fail, we end up in a knot when we try and serve them all.
People are really lucky to have this show. The way you show up, you've been narrating this kind of journey for years now, and you probably don't hear it often enough, but it's important. And thank you for doing it.
Oh, well, that's an unbelievable compliment coming from one of my sort of personal icons. So I appreciate that a lot.
The knot. Problems can be solved.
It comes out in September. If it's September, it's out now. If it's not, you can pre-order it. There'll be a link below. But I think, you know, again, in the context of the world, I think.
Unfortunately, we might find ourselves in even more knots.
So this is a wonderful thing, I think, to buy for somebody in your life that might be in a little bit of a knot themselves, but also to buy for yourself if you find yourself in one.
Seth, we have a closing tradition on this podcast where the last guest leaves a question for the next, not knowing who they're leaving it for.
And the question left for you.
If you were given the opportunity to live forever, would you take it?
No.
That was quick.
I think walking through the world as the only immortal person would be heartbreaking and enervating and wear you out much faster than you think.
If everyone was immortal, I think we would play by different rules as a planet, and that would be fascinating.
But that wasn't the question.
I think if you read enough science fiction, you realize that selective immortality is a real curse.
Why?
Because…
Everyone around you is dying, and you're not.
Every single day, everyone's dying just a little bit more.
And we define our humanity by our connections.
And we're all on this journey together, and all of a sudden, you opted out of the journey.
You're the only person on the boat that's not going where the boat's going.
And in the short run, it would be nice that my shoulders didn't hurt and that my voice was fixed and things like that.
But that would get old really fast.
That point of connection is so interesting because it immediately made me think about…
I've got these five best friends I've had for the last 15 years, and we're all progressing through the life stages together.
They've all started having kids now, and then I'm trying to have a kid at the moment.
And so we're talking about that together, and we're connecting about that together.
And actually, my nightmare would be to be the only one that wasn't in that life phase right now.
I'd feel disconnected.
Gosh, and if I lived forever, I would…
No, I've never wanted to live forever.
I think it's…
People…
Me to think about the trade-offs of everything in their life, but particularly this idea of longevity.
Embracing this moment, you lose that.
I highly recommend, just before we do wrap up, people go read your blog as well.
I'm going to link that below.
Thank you.
Seth, we're done.
What a treat.
See you next time.
Bye.
Bye.
Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Quitting is not inherently bad; Michael Jordan's "never quit" mantra is flawed because it ignores context and the value of strategic exits.
The "dip" is the hard part between starting and mastery; it's a sign of progress, not a reason to quit, unlike a "cul-de-sac" (a dead end with no payoff).
Feeling stuck often stems from wanting two incompatible things (the "but" trap), like the donkey between water and carrots; naming this entanglement helps resolve it.
Define your purpose by asking "Who is this for?" and focus on a small, specific audience; this reduces overwhelm and increases impact.
Resistance, driven by fear, affiliation, and status, is a constant force; you can't eliminate it but can name it and take small, manageable steps (e.g., anonymous blogging) to overcome it.
Embarrassment and shame are costs of entry for new endeavors; you can choose not to accept them by focusing on serving the right people.
Sunk costs (past investments) shouldn't trap you; treat them as gifts you can decline to make new decisions based on present reality.
"Picking yourself" replaces waiting for gatekeepers; start small, build traction, and let evidence (e.g., customer loyalty) guide whether to persist or quit.
The "throw" (process/practice) matters more than the "catch" (outcome); control what you can and let results follow.
Summary:
Seth Godin, in this conversation, challenges conventional wisdom about persistence and success. He argues that quitting is a powerful tool when applied strategically, contrasting the "dip"—the challenging but surmountable phase that leads to mastery—with a "cul-de-sac," a dead end where continued effort yields no progress. The core of his philosophy is that feeling stuck often arises from an internal conflict, symbolized by Buridan's donkey, which starves because it can't choose between water and carrots. This "but" trap (e.g., "I want fulfillment but also status") paralyzes us; the solution is to name these competing desires and make conscious trade-offs.
To move forward, Godin emphasizes defining a clear purpose by asking "Who is this for?" and targeting the smallest viable audience that can benefit from your work. This shifts focus from grand, vague ambitions to tangible, valuable actions. He also highlights the pervasive role of resistance—driven by fear, affiliation, and status—which manifests as procrastination or shame. The antidote is to break tasks into tiny steps (like interviewing a neighbor before aiming for a celebrity guest) and to accept embarrassment as an unavoidable entry fee, choosing to ignore unwarranted criticism.
Finally, Godin tackles sunk costs, urging listeners to treat past investments as gifts they can decline, freeing them to make new choices. He advocates for "picking yourself" rather than waiting for gatekeepers, using small experiments to gather evidence of traction. Ultimately, the path to getting unstuck lies in mastering the "throw" (the process) rather than obsessing over the "catch" (the outcome), allowing you to adapt, quit what isn't working, and persist through meaningful challenges.
FAQs
Quit when something is a cul-de-sac or dead end, not when it's merely hard. A dip, like organic chemistry for a doctor, is worth pushing through if there's evidence you can get to the other side, but a situation that can't get better should be abandoned.
The dip is the hard part between starting and getting good at something, like training in March for a marathon. You should see it before you start and push through it if it leads to a payoff, but if there's no evidence of progress, it's a trap, and quitting is the right choice.
Name the 'but' in your thinking, like 'I want this but I also want that,' and replace it with 'and' to see the trade-offs. Recognize that you can't maximize two opposing goals at once, so choose the one that serves your purpose and let go of the other.
Resistance is any feeling that keeps you from doing generative work, like writer's block or fear of rejection. You can't make it go away, but you can name it, break tasks into smaller steps, and take action despite it, like starting an anonymous blog or asking a neighbor for a podcast interview.
Ask what change you seek to make and who it's for. If your goal is to make others happy or gain status, it's a trap; instead, focus on a purpose that serves a specific audience and solves a real problem for them.
Embarrassment is the cost of entry, but you can choose not to accept shame from others by focusing on serving the right people. Say 'it's not for you' to critics and forgive yourself for past decisions, using practical empathy to move forward.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.