The Psychology That Makes Or Breaks Investing - With Lee Freeman-Shor
from The Art of Investing
1h 7m 7s
The core message of the discussion revolves around the critical role of execution and discipline in investing, rather than the quality of individual stock ideas. Despite the belief that top investors can consistently generate returns by investing in their best ideas, data shows only a 49% chance of any single idea succeeding—worse than a coin toss. This finding is reinforced by observations of legendary investors like George Soros, who frequently admit to losing money but later achieve massive wins through disciplined exit strategies. The analysis identifies three behavioral patterns when investors lose: rabbits (do nothing), assassins (exit quickly), and hunters (add capital). The most damaging behavior is being a rabbit, as it leads to massive losses due to the compounding effect of percentage declines. Conversely, successful investors, especially connoisseurs, achieve long-term gains by holding through volatility and avoiding emotional decisions. The data reveals that 98% of professional investors lack true skill and are merely lucky, suggesting passive investing often outperforms active management. Key psychological pitfalls—such as sunk cost bias and anchoring—cause investors to stay in losing positions, delaying necessary exits. The advice is to apply discipline by using simple rules, such as exiting when a position drops more than 20% or asking "Would I buy this today with a blank piece of paper?" This approach strips emotion from decision-making and helps investors maintain control over risk. Ultimately, success is not about picking winning ideas but about how one manages performance, especially during losses, through clear, rational, and consistent behavior.
And the belief was if you hire the best invested in the world and you get them to invest in their 10 best ideas
You're gonna make who does a money because it's all about stop picking. Oh, it's wrong
Cancer of any of their ideas making money was 49% so worse than toss over coin
And these are guys with 20 30 years in the market some of them are billionaires and when I worked for a very very famous billionaire
And they George Soros I would hear him ranting in the background about how useless he was how he got things wrong all the time
How terrible it was he's lost it all and then he would suddenly come in with the most amazing numbers when anyone's losing
They'll fall into one of three tribes. You'll become a rabbit an assassin or a hunter
You don't want to be a rabbit if I found rabbits on my team. I shoot them three out of ten. There's a chance for me yet
Realize that what you do after you invested is gonna determine your fate not the idea itself
Your capital is at risk the value of your shares ETFs and ETCs can fall as well as rise, which could mean getting back less
Than you originally put in this content is for information purposes only and is not investment advice
Pass performance is not an indication of future results
Welcome to your favorite podcast. It's episode 19 of the art of investing or today
I take over by the art of execution coming up. You're gonna find out why Chris Fillingham suffers from premature
Evacuation
Why my good friend Mark Spice Holden
Consent everybody to sleep at their lunch the good money guide
Now they have an award ceremony coming out in gentleman. You don't know this yet
We have actually been nominated for best financial podcast. Wow
However, we need to your help because it is in the nomination stage
So if you wouldn't mind going to the note section below this podcast
There is a link and we'd be very grateful if you would go on there. Give us a nomination there if you've enjoyed this podcast as always
I'm very pleased to welcome to the pod author of the art of execution and very successful investment manager himself
Lee Freeman sure. Thank you. Lee please introduce yourself to our viewers. Hi, I'm Lee
I'm a former fund manager. I left the city in 2018. I used to run 10 funds just over two billion dollars in assets across equity and
multi-asset funds and and today I find myself as an author writing books and managing their money
It's going to be absolutely absolutely fascinating because it's going to be able to confirm or
Threaten some of the theories that we've had for the last 35 years
So if you disagree me, that's always a bad sign. Let me just tell you that
Otherwise, welcome indeed. Thank you. And thank you chairman
Now as always across to our expert for the Spice market updates. Thank you rich
Well, it's been another sort of difficult week for cryptocurrencies
But they seem to have studied a bit. They're about 5% off the low. That's talking about Bitcoin there 5% of its lows
But actually more importantly and important for our portfolio which will come on to commodities have had a good week in in the in the main
With the dollar being down about 1%
Remember the dollars had quite good run over the last sort of couple of months and this is the first down week we've had for a while
And that's actually helped equities generally have a solid week
With the Dow Jones industrial average also hitting a new all-time high and again the footsy 100
But the main reasons equities have sort of strengthened towards the end of the week was we're at last at the end of the US government shut down
43 days the longest in history and they signed a deal off last night, which it was Wednesday night
Now we should brace ourselves for a huge wave of data
economic data because there's a backup of data now some bits will miss
But there's going to be quite a lot of confusion I think in the next four to six weeks as that data flows through and people work out
What's real and what sort of out-of-date and et cetera?
So if you remember we've been very dependent on the corporate reporting season to try and get a feel for what's going on in the economy
Can I just say I think it's important for people to understand that we've had an agreement on the US going back to work
But that only lasts till January
So this is a stock gap where one presumes they're going to try to
Come to some longer term agreement, but it's not beyond the whistle man
That actually will be in exactly the same position in January again, but at least we'll be the other side of Christmas. Yes
Yeah, you've got to have your Thanksgiving
Plains can fly people across America for Thanksgiving, which after all was their whole reason why they settled in this period
Exactly well for whatever reason it's done, but also some more some more sort of taco trade almost going on there
This time from Scott Besson if you remember a taco trade is Trump always chickens out
Going by the FT, which is a great saying, but this week
In fact last night Scott Besson who's a treasury secretary is basically say he's talking about pulling back on some tariffs
So for those Americans who eating lots of bananas and drinking lots of coffee those tariffs are going to be rained back
But more importantly, they did say that they were possibly going to give people earning less than a hundred thousand dollars
Which sounds like a lot of money, but in America that's a relatively low sort of ways. They're considered low earners
Anyone earning a hundred thousand dollars or less
Will be entitled to two thousand dollar tax rebate which they're using the tariff money to help fund
So so so not only have we got the big beautiful bill giving away
Masses of money exactly. They're not giving more tax relief exactly. They're right being the electric
I think we call that don't we because the federal debt situation allows that is so no no they've got no borrowing
Have they they are very heavily indebted already? So what another two thousand dollars of tax relief?
Well to be fair for our portfolio because we own the Russell 2000
This this sort of giveaway will actually help the US small and mid size companies probably more than any other
Sort of part of the market, you know, it's certainly going to affect the S&P 500 or NASDAQ but the the Russell 2000 should help
We'll see but we've got a small position there hope to add to at some point
And maybe they're just warming up for the US midterm elections which will be taking place this time next year
So there will be these giveaways as all politicians do as they run into an election
They want to sort of keep everyone on their side and give away tax and lots of money
So going back to the corporate reporting season we're now 90% of the way through that
It's been a very good reporting season particularly in America. So 85% of the companies that reported have beaten expectations
That's against an historic average of 75 so this is significantly above the 10-year average which is good
The UK sadly is not being as good. We've had 62 to 67. So let's call it about 65% of the companies reporting have beaten expectations
But there's been one in five companies report a profit warning which is actually a quite a high number
And as we'll talk in a minute there has been some pretty worrying UK data as we run into the budget
And maybe companies are pulling back a bit and consumers too
So as I say let's let's cover the UK data now
In the last week, we've had the third quarter gross domestic product GDP or growth
And that came into just 0.1 percent
It was expected to be 0.2 percent so not very big numbers here
But it was worse than expected and actually more worrying September itself was actually a minus number
Down 0.1 percent and now this time last year
Um, it was trying to get about half percent
So the economy is stalling let's put it like let's say it's stalling and remind us what would quantify a recession
It's two quarters in a row of negative numbers
So we've had one month that you know that that that don't shouldn't worry
And of course we got the budget coming up in two weeks time now just in two weeks
Um more worrying also for the chance is that
We want to get growth going to keep people employed
An unemployment is the highest level it's been since covid
5 percent which is a bit of a psychological number
But to give you in sort of number terms
There's 180,000 people more people are unemployed now than there was a year ago
So that's not good for the economy
Okay, so I suppose if we look over the longer term
5 percent unemployment is actually quite a low rate
I mean if we go back to the 80s or the 90s 2000s
I suppose we've just not been used to it being anywhere near this level for the last few years being close to full employment
So is it right for us to be worried about it do you think or do you think it's just
You know a notch it just shows where things are but it's nothing really to worry about now
I mean, I think if we were to talk about this in America which we have debated many times
the the potential
impact of AI
On productivity efficiency etc is probably leading to some
Unemployment particularly amongst the younger people
Um, I think what is you know, okay the Americas that growth is still okay running it to 3 percent
We'll find out when the data is when it starts to come through and their unemployment is sort of steady
But rising very very small amounts in the UK we haven't got that growth as you just heard
You know, we're virtually at a standstill and now unemployment is rising as well
And I think in the UK because we've not been investing well the British companies have not been investing as hard and as fast in AI
I don't think the unemployment rises is seeing is from AI productivity
I think it is more a genuinely old-fashioned companies are worried
about what might come in the budget,
and whether the economy can restart and keep going.
And we'll find out in two weeks time
whether they can do that.
Everyone's worried about tax rises,
companies particularly.
- For me, it's the direction of travel
that's the worrying thing,
'cause we've gone 4.6, 4.7, 8, 9, 5%.
It's not, if we steadied around tier,
then I would be a lot more comfortable,
but the way we're moving,
especially before we get those AI job loss
has come through in the next 24 months,
that would start to worry me.
- Yeah, I mean, perhaps it's something we'll return
to more next week when we talk about our pre-budget podcast
and we interview us, special guests next week
for their views on what's going to happen.
But clearly, therefore, we've got to hope
the budget changes people's perceptions
and gets people more positive.
Otherwise, these numbers go get a lot worse,
it's just what you're saying.
- Yeah, and the odds are on the Bank of England
cutting a quarter of a cent at their next meeting,
which I think is in the middle of December.
- So that's the positive side.
So that's the positive side.
So we can talk all very negatively about it,
but that would likely lead then to fears
that inflation will be lower than expected.
And if inflation's going to be lower than expected,
then the MPC, the monetary policy committee
will be more inclined to cut interest rates.
So there is a civil lining, as they say, to these things.
But it's a worrying time,
especially with the news that we've been hearing
about potential leadership challenges
to the Prime Minister.
More on this next one.
- And of course, all the important part for us
in the portfolio of all this discussion
is what is cable doing?
What is the great British pound going to be doing?
And where are we?
We said, if we remember about two months ago,
we discussed it length, right?
What's our exposure to the dollar and to different currencies?
And so maybe we need to relook at that
next week, going into the budget.
- Remember, for our portfolio,
we've got a bit of a hedge on
as all sort of a benefit if the pound goes down,
if pound's going to go down, particularly against the dollar,
because we own a big chunk of the FTSE 100,
and 85% plus of the earnings and revenues
come from overseas companies for the FTSE 100.
So as the pound goes down, their profits go up.
So no surprise, really,
that the FTSE 100 is hitting a new all-time high.
- Yeah, the area would affect us more
is probably in the mid to 50 companies where we've got,
because they're exposed to the domestic economy in the UK.
So if we were to go into a recession,
and hopefully we won't, hopefully,
there'll be a good enough budget to turn the tide,
then we might have to rethink
about where the UK mid-sized companies do,
and particularly if they don't do anything to help them.
- Yeah, and I think just veering a little bit
onto the portfolio here,
we bought those FTSE 250 from the smaller companies in the UK,
because we feel that a lot of the bad news is in the price already,
people are expecting it to be a tough budget,
and that there might be some good news on stamp duty at some stage.
Let's say the risk around that position has gone up.
It's not something that I'm particularly thinking
about changing at the moment,
but we must recognize that risk has gone higher.
And as I said, we can talk about that more next week.
- Let's talk about hyperscalers and the AI, all things AI,
we have to talk about this,
because it's such an important driver,
particularly for global markets,
for the US in particular, advanced micro devices,
basically had a trading update,
and they basically, their shares were up 10%
because they updated their revenue forecast,
saying that over the next three to five years,
their revenue is expected to grow on average at 35%.
And we've looked at data senders on its own,
it'll be 80% increase.
So huge, on the flip side,
we've had one of Japan's biggest companies, Softbank,
sell a five billion dollar stake in Nvidia,
and that pushed Nvidia shares down about 3%,
which I know Richard would be very happy about,
but we would embrace ourselves,
because by the time we would do this podcast next week,
Nvidia will have reported their results,
and obviously the biggest company in the world,
they're 13% or so of the NASDAQ,
about 9% of the S&P 500,
it will be a make or break week,
depending on Nvidia say, for the US big markets.
And that finished them.
Fantastic right, it's that time of the week
when we look at the portfolio.
Chairman, Satisfactory Week, I feel.
A nice week compared to last week,
where we took a little bit of a hiding.
We've come back a little bit this week.
There's a lot of similar reasons behind those moves.
The top three for us, Black Rock World Mining Trust,
was up five and a half percent.
I shares physical goals, so the gold linked ETF is up 4.86%
and wisdom tree copper up to 1/2%.
Now, I think that's all to do with the fact
that the dollar has weakened a little bit,
and of course, the fact that the US is coming back
from the shutdown, so we'll get a bit more
of a chance to get growth.
So I think that's a help to us at the top end
of the spectrum there.
Isn't it strange to see the shutdown be a verited
and gold go higher?
- That's not not.
- I do think that's quite an interesting situation.
I certainly personally wasn't expecting the strength
we've seen in gold over the last week.
- I think, you know, on the commodities,
as I said earlier, on the dollar being a bit weaker this week,
'cause the first time there's been respite in the dollar strength,
and that has definitely helped commodities.
So if we said that, the big asset class
that's helped most by that is the commodity side.
- And then if we look at the bottom three,
we've got the NICI down 0.7.
The NASDAQ 100 ECF down 1.2.
And the winners of the losers this week,
the Vanette Crypto and Blockchain innovators down 17%.
Now, I think the bottom three are linked really
by some of the hot air coming out of the bubble
that was around the data centers
and more of that technology area.
We've seen those slip back, and of course Bitcoin
and Ethereum haven't been a great market
as Mark talked about as well.
So that's quite a bit of health in the market
that we're seeing some of that hot air come out.
- And the hot air come out of space.
- Well, I've been talking a lot about those things today,
so you'll get around to it, I'm sure.
But these things, it's good when you see a correction.
And overall in our portfolio, we're up,
which means that we haven't been overly exposed
to some of those areas.
So NetNet, I think a good week for us, good progress.
Now let's see what happens over the next couple of weeks,
especially with the budget coming up
and how things progress in the states
as well as we start getting some information
about economic growth, which of course we haven't had any of.
And see what that implication is for bond markets
and interest rates.
- I think it's gonna be really useful this week
to we've looked at the performance from the week previous.
But before we make any decisions,
how about we hear from Lee and his art of execution
to find out and give ourselves some hints
whether we should be making any decisions on changes
in the portfolio after we recognize some traits
in our own behaviors.
So Chairman, over to you.
- Thanks Rich.
And can I welcome Lee here today?
Lee's book, which he's gonna talk about and explain
to everybody in a moment has been an inspiration for me
throughout my career.
And I spoke into everybody I've, who's worked with me
and said, read this book, see what you are,
see how you can improve.
But it's enough of me rabbling on.
- Yeah.
- Let's ask Lee to introduce his book.
Let's ask him to talk about what he found.
- Thanks for the kind words Chris.
So the book, what it's about is,
I was a fun major.
I managed a team of top investors.
I managed over a billion dollars across four strategies
whereby I had a team of investors and asked them,
each of them one very simple thing
which was just to invest in their 10 best ideas.
And the belief was if you hire the best investors in the world
and you get them to invest in their 10 best ideas,
you're gonna make Udo's a money
because it's all about stop picking.
Oh, it's wrong.
(laughing)
- So it's actually me, I was wrong.
- Yeah, so what are you discovered?
And this is more also how you execute the ideas
as opposed to the idea itself.
So in the nutshell, the chance of any of their ideas
making money was 49%.
So worse than toss over coin.
And these are guys with 20, 30 years in the market.
Some of them are billionaires, some legendary guys.
And that shocked me.
But the catalyst for the book was one guy in particular
who remained nameless, who literally had a hit rate of 30%.
So only three of 10 of his ideas made money.
And every time I met him, you know, a brain on legs,
it told you the story of why he's investing the stock.
You'd wanna run out, mortgage your house
and invest in what he told you, you know,
based on this story.
But then when you'd go back a quarter, six months a year later,
they all lost money.
But then I'd look at how much money is making for me
and my funds and I'd be like,
it's my best investor, his returns are awesome.
What is he doing?
Is it luck?
Is it skill?
So then I analyzed the data and realized
his key to his success was also what he did when he was winning
and what he did when he was losing.
And then I applied that lens across all my investors
and realized the secret to success was how you react
when you find yourself winning or losing.
- And so, you know, that gives me a great opportunity
to sort of say having read this book,
it led me to ask one of my favorite interview questions
of everybody that I interviewed after that time,
which was, you know, if you wanna be,
if you think you're a successful investment,
I need you to answer this question.
And the question was, if you have 10 investments,
how many will you get right?
And you could see the person opposite you,
looking at you thinking, "God, now,
if I say 10, he's not going to believe me.
So I can't say 10, if I say 10.
say five, then he's going to think I'm useless. So I can't say five. So six, seven, seven,
eight. And normally people would say eight, if they were rich, very optimistic. And you
know, some people would say seven, but most people would say eight. And actually the answer
is irrelevant, because the real way to make money is how much do you make on the ones
you got right versus how much did you lose on the ones you got wrong? And when I worked
for a very, very famous billionaire and they George Soros, regularly I would hear him
ranting in the background about how useless he was, how he got things wrong all the time,
how terrible it was. He's lost it all. And then he would suddenly come in with the most
amazing numbers. And I chat into ones about this stuff and he reckoned he got three out
of ten right. But he's on those three, he ran them and he ran them and he ran them
and the 70 got wrong, he got out quickly. So just reiterating, it's about that execution.
All about the execution. And so you've managed to put them into five tribes, haven't you?
Yes. Three when you're losing. Yep. And two when you're winning. That's right. So let's
look at when you're losing. So when you're losing, when anyone's losing, they'll fall into
one of three tribes. You'll become a rabbit or you'll become an assassin or a hunter. You
don't want to be a rabbit. If I found rabbits on my team, I'd shoot them. But I'm in the
casserole. You don't put them in the casserole, yeah?
Farmer sure. Farmer sure. But just to explain what each of them is, so a rabbit is a person
that does nothing when they're losing. The danger of that is, you know, if you're down
50%, it takes 100% to get break even. If you're down 90%, you need 900% to break even.
I don't appreciate how hard it is to get out of a hole when you dug a big hole. And that's
why I call it a rabbit and also rabbits, you know, if they're on a road to cask, we get stuck
in the headlights, don't know what to do. Could I just just make that just easy for everybody?
So when you say, if it goes down 90%, let's use an example, stock goes from 100 to 10,
it's gone down 90%. To get back to where you bought it, it has to go up 900%. It's what
you're saying. Yeah. And I don't know many ideas that go up 900%.
And that's the key point. People need to understand that percentage moved down and the percentage
moved up. And it's critical to realize that's why rabbits struggle.
Basically, you know, that's no, you need an Nvidia to get you out of it if you're assuming
Nvidia all this time. The other, the other categories when you're losing are assassins
and hunters. So an assassin, which most of my guys were, they're people when they find
themselves down 20 to 40%, they're, they just kill the position. They'd sell, get out,
just move on. Right. The, the beauty of that is you're limiting the, the damage done,
you know, you're not, you're not impairing your capsule, you know, you're leaving enough
on the table to live another day. So that's a good trait. Then I'm going to lose big hunters
are basically people that when they're losing, they're prepared again, when they're down
to 20 to 40. They're prepared to throw a lot more capital at the idea. It's not pound-cost
averaging. It's just to get to a point where they may be down third percent, they just go, well,
nothing's wrong idea. I still believe in it. I'm going to take it from a, say, five-cent
position to a 10-cent position. Very few people are hunted because when things are going
wrong, and you play with your mind, I mean, you know, it's hard to double up there, you
know. You probably really well psychologically set up for that, haven't you? Because, you
know, if you think about that, you know, I've got my position, it goes down 25%, I double
that position. Now it goes down another 25%, 30%. My loss is really now starting to stack
up. I'm probably not sleeping at night. I'm having trouble seeing straight, and I can't
see this company as anything other than if it fails, I've ruined my career, but if it hasn't
failed, it's still going to be a problem, sitting and languishing where it is. So what you're
saying is it's really difficult to find anybody who can be a really successful hunter.
Yeah, I mean, I, I, I'm a mix of assassin and hunter, but there was one name which remained
nameless, which where where I took a hundred approach and had a big position and where position
size is important. And I got to the point, I only started small knowing that if it goes
wrong, I'm prepared to add to it if nothing's wrong, added to it, kept going against me
to your point, Chris. And when I added the third time to make it a big position, I actually
felt physically sick. And then you, then you realize, my God, you need strong constitution
to do it. And that was in a very high conviction name. But then I know what's a tough point
where this name idea works or not. So, you know, even me, I'm knowing all this, it still
plays with your head. So far easier to be an assassin, get out when it's going against
you than a hunter. And so if I, so, I mean, I, I can remember this
well because, you know, you're at the situation, you're working at an organization and you get
the tap on your shoulder from the boss. So when you're losing little bit of money, everyone
says, well, that's fine. Then you add a bit more and now you're losing a bit more money
and everyone's starting to focus a bit on your profit and loss and how you're doing.
And do you really know what you're doing? And then you put a bit more on and you think,
I put this on because I'm so sure about it. And that minute the boss comes up and taps
you on the shoulder and says, are you sure? And you know, if you get it wrong, your career
is over. And then a number of people then who just cut the position out, having brought
it all the way down, cut it out, they take a big loss and then now psychologically impaired
for everything else they do. But sometimes the tap on the shoulder is good. Oh, absolutely.
So, I mean, I have one example where the legendary hedge fund, it's not retired, but it's
a hedge fund investor. Very successful. He invested in a super group, super dry, which
I think probably the listeners know about, if they've got the clothing. Remember, this
one. Yeah. So this is a guy usually does the, when he's losing, assassin gets out, but
he invests in the company and it was down about 40%. And I'm looking at the screen and I'm
like, it's done nothing. This is weird. So I pick up the phone ringing. What's going on?
Yeah. Give me a waffle about why it's grace, investment why it's sticking with it. And
then I sort of go, okay. So you're going to throw more money at it than he's like, Oh, no.
I kind of, would you bite? So if you had a blank piece of paper, would you buy it today?
Well, that's unfair. No, I wouldn't, but, and then he said, okay, let's go, let's go
for a glass of wine at the arts club at the art club. And you go, okay.
Which is by the way, something that often happens. If you're unsure, a glass of wine often
helps. I'll be telling myself my whole career anyway. And this is, unfortunately, where
I got paparazzi coming out with Prince Harry from the arts club around the same time.
That's another story from the David. So the expense. Oh, yes. So you go to the arts club.
A couple of guys, one is tell me why it's a fantastic investment and why he wants to stay
with all this. So I said, I'm okay. So tomorrow, when I, when I go, that's my desk, I'm
going to see that you've doubled your position. Go that way. That's fine. My train screens
see that you sold it. Wow. And that's crazy. Cause that's a guy with 20 plus years experience.
Fantastic investor. This one name got really tight. He got tied up with it. But he, you
know, he realized, you know, he couldn't bring, you know, blank piece of paid protest.
Would you bite it? He couldn't, he sold it. And when I met him, you know, several months
later, you know, thank me for saving a lot of money by sort of tapping on the shoulder.
But then when I met him six months later, this is the other flip side of it. He said,
actually, now, it's my best idea now. It's probably my highest conviction idea. And it
wasn't in his 10 stocks. So I said, hold on, you, you meant to be investing just 10 stocks
for me. You should be there. And he looks at me. So right. And he put, and he put it back
and it made me a lot of money. But that just shows you, even if you're really good, you
have discipline, sometimes an idea can get a whole of you psychologically, sunken, cost
buyers and down buyers. And it's just hard to do the right thing.
Drew, your portfolio with IG invest 50 pounds with IG and get a free share bundle worth
between 40 and 200 pounds. Make your first investment into an ISO, GIA or SIP account before
the 30th of November and benefit from commission free investing as well as 4% variable interest
on your cash. Other fees may apply. Terms and conditions found in the show notes are an
IG dot com forward slash UK kickstart your investing journey with IG today.
Now, I wonder in that position of being a hunter, is there any way to tell the difference
between smart conviction or just plain stubbornness?
What a great question. It's a great question. I think you can see conviction stubbornness.
I think when you look at, look at, you know, from the lesson of poker, look at the hand
not at the mouth. So I think a lot of a lot of the guys I met with experienced smart
people sound great. And then you go, then you look at the hand again, what are you doing?
I think that tells you every, to your point, everything about whether they've truly got
conviction, whether, whether it's arrogance. Is they believing it like what they're saying?
Did they put the money where the mouth is? That's the approach I used to take. And if
they weren't prepared to do that, then it's a kind of, I think, your point is, you
know, it's hubris. It's, it's lack of admitting the wrong. Not like something is the wrong.
They just, they don't want to say the wrong. And, you know, it took me with a couple of learning
that. From a couple of guys in my team, we're older and more experienced than me. And they're
in positions. And they're refusing to sell or do anything when it's down to 70%. And you go,
he's made 300% to get back to where you are. And you have to learn that. And are you prepared
to do anything? And you, it's a real asset test. And ego can kill off many of performance.
Oh, yeah. I was going to say one of the things that strikes me is that as an equity investor,
it's, but it, this is where the psychology is harder than perhaps being a bond investor.
Because a bond investor is about mass. It's about following the economies, blah, blah, blah.
And so, but I think as an actor, I'm a bull. I mean, I consider myself an assassin,
but I have made, I have made a Pratt myself by falling in love with a stock. And that's been
my biggest mistake. I knew it was going wrong. And I didn't have the guts to cut out of it
to clear my head and start again. But normally, I'm very good. I mean, you know,
President Ali, I'm very good at just cutting out positions when I think I've got it wrong,
very quickly, and then I'll re-address that and come back in. But I think because of equities,
you might have met the man. management, you would have read stuff in the press, you like their product, you like
super dry, you like, you know, whatever it happens to be. And you think, oh, this is great,
they're going to get this right eventually. But that can cost you a huge amount of time,
effort and, you know, capital in your fund, which you don't want to do. But I think bond investors
don't have that emotion attached to it. I'd be 30, you're going to be attached to a 30, you're going
on bond with it. I'd tell you, me and the 30-year-old, we've had a very close relationship from time
to time. But before we go on to work, let's just finish up the other two categories.
So we've had the three losing categories. What about the two winning categories?
Okay, so when you're winning, you're falling to one of two tribes, you like the kind of radar
or a connoisseur. You don't want to be a raider. Raiders are people that meet apparently, that's
you Chris, I've been told before. I don't know, but I don't know. But I'm going to be a raider.
I'm going to be raider. I'm going to be a raider. But a raider is the people
that basically take profits to it. You make 10% here, 20% there. Why that feels good, it looks good.
All my research showed basically it's a handful of big winners which determine your success or failure.
And you need to have a process of which basically embraces winning big.
As a raider, next 10% or 20%, you know, pockets it. And then a connoisseur is one that rises winners,
makes wins big. So a connoisseur will be someone who bought in video, you know, for $4 in 2015,
rode it until today and he's up 1,000%, you know, 1,000% or whatever it's up there.
So how do you do that? I mean, you said that just a couple of quick words when we've had careers
40 years and none of this, well, sorry, some people managed to master this, others happened.
So, you know, you're assisting there as a raider. How can you become a connoisseur from that
raider position? What do you need to do? What's the discipline you need to put in there?
Well, I think once you realize your chance of success and most people as a toss for coin,
and you understand that if you keep taking problems with 20%, and if you're to your point,
you said you can't be a rabbit on the losing side. If you're making 20% here but you've got a
couple of big losers over here, make losing 50 or more percent, you're going to lose money,
it's just math, it's just you're not going to make money. I think you need to look at your process,
you need to, when you're up 23%, say okay, that's great. By the way, price targets are deadly,
in my mind. I mean, they get you out arbitrarily. So when you say sorry, just for everybody,
when you say price target, you mean, I know, you buy the pound, you say if it gets to £1,
£20, I'm out. Yeah. Rather than having some other way of checking where you want to exit
some of the position. It's spot on. I mean, I'm surprised it gets to £120, I'm probably out
by 105, but then I carry on, carry on, carry on. So yeah, so easy your point. But you know,
so say if you say someone who's priced targets, you know, because they model it. But instead of
just selling, because it's 120, should review it, just go, has the story changed. You know,
has the position, you know, if nothing's changed and it's all working out and the earnings are
coming through and the top lines coming through and the multiple hasn't gone crazy, why would you
sell? I mean, the key to thing is at that point when you're up 20%, you go, with everything I know
today, would I buy it, it's the same as when, would I buy it today with a blank piece of paper?
Try and remove the fact you own it, just go, what I'd buy it today with that piece of,
and then a lot of times you'd go, my share would. So why would you take profits at 20%, especially
when you know, but if you keep doing that, you're never going to ever going to win big, I can guarantee
you're going to lose a big, at some point. So that would be my advice on that. And this is why
my quip to spice at the start that lunches with him can end up very boring, because if the story
hasn't changed, then they just tell you the same story over and over again. But that is a connoisseur,
and that's where the real performance comes from. Yeah, and now on the head, I mean, one thing I
had to get used to is some of the guys had very low turnover. They just stayed in the same positions
for years and years and years. They were boring meetings because you'd go, you'd go and have you
courtly review meeting with them. Yeah, let's go over what you're in, same names you've had for
the last five years. Is it boring? Anything check, nothing changed. But you have to, it's hard to
embrace boredom, but connoisseurs embrace boredom. It doesn't mean the lazy, they're not doing it.
Just means they're boring. Just means they're not doing it.
We've actually found out something else for your next book. You can write about them being boring.
Don't you think though, for something to change that's got that sort of momentum, if it is
another way of describing it, if it's got a nice upward gentle momentum, you want to run it as
long as you can. But then this, this something, it's a little bit like a bubble. We say bubbles don't
die of old age. A catalyst comes along, something happens. Maybe when you're new, you've seen it after
the event, but somebody comes along to change that and then you get this stuff and then you go,
"Oh my god, it was that moment of time that changed that." And I think it's the same exactly for
stocks and shares. You know, it's something that the management changed. It's an example of the
chief executive who's been there for 20 years, done a great job. Suddenly resigns to go to
competitor company. Normally, I'm just going to sell the shares personally. I wouldn't even wait
to find out who the new guy was. I'll just sell it because I think he's been such an
integral part of the success of it beforehand. So that's a catalyst. And you're getting those
things you can see sometimes. Sometimes you can't, like I say, until after the event.
But let's say I'm a connoisseur.
It's something strange at 120. We've said 120. 120. I'm very happy about it. That's fine.
Do I reset my, say, assassin level? Do I reset that from 120? So I say to myself now,
it's gone up to 120. If it comes back down to 110, I'm getting out. Or do I just say,
no, I'm supposed to say, do I remember what I got in? Or do I reset my stop, my tight discipline
to ensure I get better performance? There are various ways of playing the game there.
But a lot of people, how much are you willing to lose to your point? So you're at 120.
Very little. So that's why I'm a radio. But some people would have stop losses.
And they'd get out, which would be trailing stop losses when it goes up. And to your point,
it's gone up for 20% to get out from that anchor point, I guess. Other people, it's about how
much are they willing to lose? So some people go, I'm going to lose no more than 100 bass points in
this game. And as soon as I've my loss shows 100 bass points, I'm out. That's why I just say that
so I've got a question here. And that is, we are all experienced investment professionals.
We're all, we're clearly very good at what we do, right? But you must have met, let's say,
thousands of people, that's thousands of people. How many of those people do you really think
make money at the end of the day? What is that sort of ratio, do you think? I'm sorry,
I say you think. What did you find in your study? So yeah, to your point, you know, my job was to
basically hire and manage investors. And did a lot of due diligence. And I found I can say that
98% of investors, some very high profile investors, very successful investors, no skill at all.
So 98% most no skill at all. They're just lucky.
For on behalf of all the professional investment managers and wealth managers.
Yeah, it sounds harsh, but I'd think most of them, I used to call them beta jockeys.
And when I used to head at research, I'd tell the analyst, I'd say, so most people you meet,
super smart, very experienced. You can look at the returns and you're going to know this guy's
fantastic. But if you bench my guy correctly, and now I just don't know exactly, you'll realize
you'd been better off going passive and getting a foot to 100 tracker or something.
And I suppose just looking at just getting a broad sense, you know, there's been this huge move
towards ETFs and trackers over the last few years indeed. In our portfolio, everything will almost
everything. I'm looking at it now. I think everything is an ETF or an ETC. And that's our saying,
sorry, exchange traded fund or exchange traded certificate. And that's us really saying what
you're saying as well. But if you look out there, how many people actually have got skill in this
game, excluding the three of us, four of us, sorry, three of us and podcast and sorry, it's 98%
of people don't have skill. 9 out of 10 people I met when she ran the numbers on them and analyzed
what they do. You realize that they may have a brand, they might be mega success in my peer on
TV. But you'd have been better off putting it in a S&P partner or tracker or something. They just
got lucky in life. So funny you mentioned super dry actually because I took part in the IPO. So
I was at hedge fund at the time. And Julian Dunkerton, the CEO, came along with his big bag of stash.
Now I was a big fan of super dry at the time. This was 2008. So, you know. Are you still not out?
It has been known. It's probably an ex-girlfriend of mine. She goes rich. You can't wear super dry all
your life. I didn't tell this to the CEO when we used in the IPO. So anyway, we, you know, fantastic
meeting. And it was getting priced at 10 times PE ratio, which was the same as next was trading,
but super dry was on a much bigger growth trajectory. So I talked my manager into going in big for
the IPO. And right enough, we got an allocation just under 3% of the company at five pounds a share.
And this thing opened in at only at five pounds 10, probably one of the worst IPO's
barglencour in London Stock Exchange history. But over the coming months, it pumped. And it was
actually 2009. It shot higher like a rocket fuel. And it hit the huge total of six pounds 50.
So I made 30% on this, this stock. So of course, I took the money. 12 months later, 18 pounds.
It had been up more than 300.
and 50 percent. And that's what you're not. And I'm not, and I am a self-identifying
radar, unfortunately. I ask you, Lee, is there any hope? Can I do anything to transition,
if you like, to a connoisseur, and maybe even from when I'm losing money as well? Is there hope for
us? Can you not include us on that? Maybe before we ask that question, should we look at what
each other are? I don't think it's maybe right to self-identify. What do the others believe we are?
Why should we take a vote on what we think CJ is? Well, we know he's probably a hunter when it comes
to selling things, because he does occasionally average down. And I think, yeah, you've identified
that you're a radar when it comes to things that have gone up. You just like to get out when you've
made a bit of profit. After the 40 years, we've been working together. I think you're very good
at nicking profit here and there and here and there, and not making too many big losses. But if
you do make losses, you tend to add to them and wait long enough. You've got a long enough patient
time horizon. I'm surprised that you've been as dice to me as that. I would say I start as a
rabbit without a shadow of a doubt. And you learn, if you don't, if you want to keep your job,
you have to learn some sort of discipline around that. And at the end, we'll have a few lessons
that we want to give to our listeners. But if we were to return the favor to Rich now,
what do we think Rich is? He's certainly not connoisseur. He's admitted he's not a connoisseur,
so we know that. So we're going to have to put him down as a raider. What do you think? Do you think
he's an assassin, i.e. sets a stock level and bulls pushes himself out? Do you think he's a bit
of a rabbit or a hunter? I don't think he's an assassin because I've seen him average down.
So it's a hunter, a hunter hunter hunter raider again. So there's there's two hunter raiders on
this podcast. Absolutely. We've already been told that raiders is not the right person to do,
so we're all supposed to be doing ourselves down. I must admit, from we've seen in the portfolio
performance, we know that our friend Spice here is very clear and I don't think I've ever seen
somebody so clearly in two categories as an assassin connoisseur. He's certainly an assassin,
but once again, you see he's transitioned as well. We could tell a story now. I mean, it would
be wrong of me to tell the story of a certain oil company, which has been mentioned on these podcasts
before, which Mark bought into and it was a tremendous investment. He made an absolute
fortune out of it. I confronted him with the CEO of our organisation. I was the CIO and the CIO
of equities. So the three big weeks in the team, we were at an offsite, the stock had gone from
50p to £1.30. Something like that. Well, yeah. And I said, look, this has gone from 5% of your fun
to 12, 13% of your fun really is now time to sell. You've got best performance in the city of London.
If you lock this in, you will never have another problem. And it's by said, oh, no, no, no, no,
I'm sticky about what you've heard about this podcast when you try to get into something. You know,
no, no, no, he says, no, no, no, I'm going to stick with it. I'm going to stick with it. And
the head of equity is a very good friend of mine. He knows who he is back to spicy as well.
So we sit there, me and the CEO is saying, we think you should do it. And they both said no. So we
thought, no, look, these guys have done really well. Water mistake. Next morning, this oil they
meant to find was gas condensate, if I remember rightly. And they were doing a rights issue as well.
Well, that was the problem. I got a phone call. I saw the phone call go and I thought, oh, my God,
I know who that is. It's the broker of the company. And they're going to want to raise the money.
And the first thing you pick up and obviously as an institutional investor, you get inside
information. The first thing he said, I would like to make you an insider on this company. And I
went, oh, God, that means I couldn't sell them. And for those people listening, especially the
regulator, and we are in possession of insider dating, inside infection, we do never, we never
deal on it. And you're taking over the wall, aren't you? So you don't get cannot. And your
compliance would have you, you'd be out of a job if you did it. And that would be the best thing
might happen because the serious thought office could get involved as well. So once you're made
insider, you cannot deal. So spice has gone from elation in the evening, the night before,
to mass depression. First price the next morning, well, I remember it went from 50p to £1.30.
First price after £1.30. I got to £2. Did it get to £2?
I got to £2.30. But then immediately, that was when I was there going to raise the money.
So let's do it in the right order. 50p. Let's say £2.130. Outcomes the announcement. 90p
first price, 80p first price. And of course, then if you're a rabbit, you don't do anything
about it, rather than being your assassin, where you say, I'm out now. And now it languishes at
11 pence. But there is a lesson in your story. Actually, the story is that I should have told
it to the ice club. But it's one of the things I saw is like being a connoisseur and not building
a massive position. A lot of people just trim the position. So that's how you can keep your risk
on the control. So instead of the 5% growing to 12% or whatever it was, it's 5%, it goes up,
and you do trim it back to 5% or do you keep trimming and just controlling the risk on.
So if it does what your point flips, it goes the other way. It makes it a lot easier.
Because if a 5% goes to a 4%, or a 3%, it's a lot easier to sell than a 12% going to an 8%,
then you're like, "Oh, God, this is a big position size. Let's make it hard to do things,
hard to act." And that's, we talked about psychology earlier, but in diamond bias and sunken
cost bias. So sunken cost bias is the more time effort money put into something, the more you
reluctant to walk away. And in diamond bias is when you actually put money into something,
you value it more than if you didn't own it. So if I give you an example of that, if I
sold you a gold coin today for £3,000, and next week gold crashed. Gold crashed. Gold crashed,
and say, it was worth £1,000. And I said to you in a week's time, I said, "I'll buy it off
you for £1,000." You'd go, "Bugger off, I paid £3,000 last week." That's right there.
You anchored to the original. That's a wealth management train of thought. I hate to say to my
ex-colleagues out there, and I've worked with a couple of wealth management companies. The biggest
failure, I think, the most private client wealth managers is they are reluctant to lock in losses.
They just don't do it. And what they say is, we'll sell it when it goes back up. And when it gets
goes back up, they never sell it. They still sell it. It's still three years later. If it's that,
I hate to say it, but it's my ex-colleagues, and many of whom I respect and love a lot, but I'm
afraid it's the biggest failure of the private wealth. If I heard one of my guys say that the
gun would come out, we rabbits do that, man. So you're back to that question, the hope of transition.
Yes. What do you think? What's your advice? You can transition, but you've got to be humble,
you've got to be open to learning, and you've got to be aware of your flaws. So if you
self-identify as a raider, then you should be going, "Okay, no, this trade overall is not a good
trade to have, because if I'm not having any big winners, I get some big losers. I'm going to
lose money over the long term." So you've got to actually have what can you do to, and one of the
points said to you, instead of getting out after 20%, just maybe reduce the position size a bit,
maybe take some money off the table, try to get the feel for running, but it's hard, or it's really
difficult to run a position. Really difficult. It's easy to take profit, and there's lots of psychology
which shows that you don't mean kicks and stuff, but that's one thing you can do. When you're losing,
I think the easiest thing to do there from going from it, if you want to, if you're a rabbit,
and you find yourself doing nothing, is to just, you know, when it's gone down more than 20%,
just sort of say to yourself, "Would I buy it's there or not?" And be honest with yourself as to,
you know, if you want to buy it that day with everything you know, then you realize it's your
psychological flaws, your biases, it's not rational thinking, it's not logical, it's not,
with a bankrupt piece of paper you want to buy, you shouldn't get out. So you can't, but it requires a
load of discipline, a lot of self, you know, introspection to do that, which I think my experience is,
you know, I used to coach some of the guys on my desk and give them, these are experienced guys,
but I'd spot flaws and some are open to it, some weren't open to it, so you have to be open to it.
You know, you can improve your game, but you've got to be open to it and be very disciplined.
I think some of the best advice that you've touched on a couple of times is start with a blank
piece of paper, every morning, say, "What would be my ideal portfolio today?" And if there's
something in there you wouldn't buy today then you've got the answer if it's a new portfolio. So
in my view, I think that raises a good, a good top here. And the reason we've wanted to have Leon
for so long is that the book helps people to understand what their style is and also what they
might do about it. But I think for people who are listening today, I think maybe we should just
think about what practically have we learned from our careers that we could just leave them with
to help them be better at negotiating their financial journey, helping them to become
better investors. Maybe if I start and then we'll go around the table, I've had a problem
when I started with being a bit of a rabbit and I've said before.
So you've got to have and think about the discipline around it.
So the way I think about it is, I'm I'd and this is why I'm a radio and not on a connoisseur is I don't worry about the profitable side.
I've got enough ideas that'll go profitable. I don't worry about that.
What I need to make sure of is that things I'm losing money on are contained at a loss that doesn't mean I've got big capital depreciation and it's going to infect me and whatever I do.
Now, it's really easy to say that it's really difficult to do.
But I think the first thing you've got to be is humble.
You've got to be able to say, you know, I don't know everything.
The market is right.
I am wrong.
Move on and try to do something differently.
So you're going to have that discipline there.
The next thing I would do is say you've got to review those positions and take some action.
You can buy some more.
You can cut half out.
But if you just sit there with the same position, the story never changes.
You never feel any better.
You never get that psychology changing in your mind.
Whereas if you sell something and it goes down a little bit, you can at least say, well, I sold a bit.
So now I'm feeling I've got some positivity around my position now.
Whereas I don't have it if I've just gone straight off side.
And so to me, it's all about removing emotion from decision making.
So I would say to anybody listening who wants to listen to me and you know, there are one or two might one day.
To me, get emotion out of it, get some discipline around and make decisions.
And if you can't take that emotion out of it, maybe you've gone too big in the first place or B,
you don't have strong enough conviction, we're a psychologist into credit Swiss.
And the first thing he said, if you are praying about a position, it's too late.
Get out.
Hope is not an investment strategy that someone used to say to me.
Okay, so that's my might be there.
We'll leave Lee to Lars.
He can mark what about yourself?
What a one one lesson practical lesson you could you could be helping because I'm an assassin.
I shoot first and ask questions later.
I've always been like say management changes.
I like the guy out.
See, clear your mind.
You can sleep at night.
You can think again, even in the next morning, I think, do you know what?
Actually, they've got a great deputy chief executive.
He's going to come and take the job.
I'll go back into it.
It doesn't matter.
I'd buy it five or 10% higher up, even just to do that.
But you've cleared your head.
You sleep at night.
And that is a really important thing.
The mistakes of maids when I fall in love with the stock.
I kick myself time-time bigger.
That lesson we were talking about earlier on with that oil stock.
It cost me a huge amount personally and sort of put my reputation of the rest of it.
And mentally, it was very scarring, but boy, did I learn some lessons?
And where do you define that review level that you're talking about for your assassin?
Is it a loss level?
Do you say, well, if I lose more than 10% of what I put in or 50?
Do you set it like that?
I mean, some people will look at a chart, the squiggly line and say, oh, I'll set it at that level, that level.
Or do you just have, no, not into that.
If I lose more next, I'm out.
If the market's going up and it's suddenly going down, I'll take out five or 10% lower down.
I just won't go out of it.
There's something wrong here.
I'm a great believer that the market tells you things before you actually find help.
Maybe it's too much anxiety and information out there in the markets.
But actually, share prices are pretty efficient.
And if that someone's picked up a rumor that the chief execs about to resign,
some headhunters sort of spoken to some mate and others, some shareholders got right when they sell that.
The share price that's going down, you think, bang on, it should be going up.
And it's not acting as you should.
I'll sell it.
I'll just sell it.
So yours is more a market.
Look at them.
Look at the market.
If it's doing something that you cannot make sense of, you're just going to chop it out.
Yeah.
Sorry, Lee, tell us about this, the story of the beans in the jar though,
because that emphasizes Mark's point that it's incredible, the efficient pricing of a market.
What you're referring to here is, is imagine we had a jar full of beans here.
And we all had to guess how many beans are in the jar.
And you might say 100, you might say 300, you might say 10, I might say 70.
All of us would be wrong.
But the weird thing is on this, when you do this exercise in a class of 50, 100 people,
the average of all the answers is usually the closest to the correct answer, which is pretty scary.
And you only usually get in a room of like 50, you get one or two people that were closer to the answer,
which means 48 were wrong, say.
So that just shows you, when you'd say the power of the markets in digesting,
so everyone can be wrong in the markets, but the collectively, this wisdom in crowds.
And I think that's the point, respect the markets.
I think that's a really good bit of advice there.
People say the market's wrong.
I'm right.
You hear that?
It's a bit like is different this time.
Another one of those sayings we've heard.
The new paradigm, we've heard Mark try to say that it's different this time.
We've at least tried to catch him on that one, but you know, these are all things you've got to watch out for.
People who say the market is wrong and I am right, watch out.
Rich, what about yourself?
What's your practical lesson?
Discipline, discipline, discipline.
And, and you know, I've, I've heard my two very wise men see both in your own ways to keep the motion out of it.
And I think that's so important.
And the reason why sometimes I feel being a raider is perhaps not the right thing, but it meant that I stayed in a job was because there's always another idea and there's always another opportunity.
So the assassin mentality is to, to limit your losses, but then the hunter mentality is that even within that stock and that investment, there's another opportunity to make money.
If it gets down to the right level, then I've got more conviction if the story hasn't changed and it's always that appreciation of is the story the same as when I got into it and therefore at the cheaper price, it's even more attractive to me.
But then you're talking really than about and I think that's another very good, good point, honesty.
Yes.
You have to be able to say to yourself, you know, you can't lie to yourself, you can't think, oh, you know, this is different, you have to be honest with yourself.
And, you know, I'd like to, I think it'd be good to bring that to life just for a second of an crypto holding, you know, somebody I know said to me, well, you know, you bought something which you thought was linked to Bitcoin, it's gone up a lot.
Well, it's better than going down a lot. That's brilliant. And now you're changing your story and you're saying, now you like it because it's all about data centers.
So actually, are we being honest with ourselves as to this holding or not now I said to the individual who was talking to me, we're being honest with ourselves because we've reevaluated.
We've done that research and we now like it for a different reason, but it's that honesty. You've got to be honest.
I don't mind doing that as long as we recognize the rule, the game has changed what you work and in your situation is exactly the same thing.
I don't mind adding if the story is the same and nothing has changed, but if something has changed, admit something's changed and then what Mark says, if you don't like it, if you don't like that, get out because then your mind is clear.
The next day, yeah, you might lost some money. Yeah, you might fit a bit upset. Yeah, you might go and keep the cat. But at the end of the day, I don't mind cats, so that was a cat rather than dog.
But at the end of the day, you're alive the next day to then think about new ideas and put better ideas on. So I think honesty is an absolute critical point.
Yeah, honesty, discipline. And I think the key to investing is ego management, managing our own ego. And that is why females can be a lot better at investing and a lot better fund managers.
Because they tend not to have as big ego as the sex sitting around this table.
Can relate to it. I had one investor point to me and said, you've got to decide where I'm still one of the best invests in the world. That's your job.
And I said, and I said, and I kind of said, well, I've analyzed all your data. I don't think you crap.
I'm sorry, but basically, let's just, let's just say you say like a year or two after I did that evaluation, realizing you got lucky in life, you wasn't around in the industry.
So, you know, but there is a lot of egos in the industry that's massive. And the market is a great leveler though, isn't it, as well? Just, you know, I've had this myself. When you think you've got it right, everything's going well, somebody will come along and whack you in the face and push you back down.
And you don't recognize that is really important. You investing your own money now or what are you doing? And what do you consider yourself?
So, yeah. So, I mean, I stopped step back from the industry in 2018 from being a fun manager. So, yeah, I managed my own money and now an author.
Absolutely.
How would I classify myself? It was a lot of the greatest lessons, I mean, you've all hit on a number of great things about managing emotions, discipline, you know, check your ego.
But I'd say, once you realize, as I realize, it's a toss of a coin, whether an idea makes money, I don't care how smart you are. Because that's all the smart guys I have money with. That's the average of those guys.
So, when I realize that, and I'm looking at these guys going, he's way smarter than me, he's way smarter. If average is fit for who am I to say, well, so once I realize that, you realize how you react when a position is winning or losing is what matters most.
And you've got to be disciplined about that. So, so the main thing is when you're losing, and, you know, in book I talk about, you know, when you're down 24% do something.
You know, you know, you got to have what I buy today. And if you would maybe throw some more money, if you wouldn't get out. So material that when you're losing, don't be a rabbit. That's a key thing.
and obviously, you know.
learn to try to run your winners. And a lot of it, we sort of danced around a bit, but position
sizing plays a big part in this. The bigger the position, the harder it is to do the right thing.
And I can, you know, from someone that knew this stuff, you know, the bigger the position,
you know what you got to do, but especially when you're losing, if you lost a lot, it becomes
tenfold hard to do anything. So in my own personal money today, I mean, I always go in an idea
smaller than I optimally, optimally should do. But that's because I reflect the fact that, you
know, I don't want it too big, it's too big. I know myself, I feel sick. It'd be a play's
room on mind. And this is despite knowing what to do. So I'd keep the position sizes under check.
It makes life a lot easier when you're winning all isn't to run or you'll kill something, you know?
It's interesting. I have actually found that this isn't good advice at all. So don't listen to me.
It's a nose moment that I find the most profitable ideas then come from. So when I feel
really striking with fear, and I buy more because I've got conviction, that's usually the low point
with an hours, if not a day. It wouldn't be better if you waited and killed that before you ever did
anything. Absolutely. So it's patience. Don't deal too early. It's humility. It's saying I don't know
the best. The market knows best. And there's always clever people around. It's size of position.
And it's discipline around all these. Gosh, it's an amazing subject. I think we've probably done
enough on it for today. But I do want to mention your book, your second book. Tell us about your
second book. So it comes out in March. It's called Stop Market Maestro's. It's a follow-up to the
auto execution. I'm waiting for my invite. So basically, if you can imagine, I wrote this book,
you tell people out the tribes, the rabbits, the hunters, the assassins, and people are reading
and they go, and over the last decade, since it's been out, people reach out to me and say,
can you help me? I'm losing. I'm being a rabbit. And I want to know whether I should sell it and
be an assassin or throw my money and be a hunter. And it's difficult to help them. You realize
you're struggling. They don't need to do something. So I thought, how can I help those people?
Because I used to coach people. What I could do is, I'll get some of the best invests in the world
from around the world. So the book has 11 chapters with 11 great investors. I mean, some legendary
investors, you'll hear it. I mean, in the UK, James Hambrey's one and one and they're
gone to Massons in their Steve Anastas and it's legendary investors. And each one is focused on,
okay, what do you do when you're winning or losing? So people, it lifts a lid on what do these
great invests? What signals get them out of position or cause them to stay in a position?
And how do they go about position sizing? So this general discussion, but also we take
specific stock examples where we're all real, you know, you put money in this stock, it lost money,
tell us what you did. How do you position size? What signals may need to be made into this and that?
And I think by that, you can kind of, you can learn by characteristics like being, it's only
could be like a parrot on their shoulder looking at what they did through these positions. So
it's a follow up to this book tries to just add a bit more insight and color. And the hope is
that the combination of both people will be able to learn lessons or apply things to see to their
own way of investing, you know, that's the idea. I think that sounds really, really good. And I'm
looking forward to reading my signed copy, which is one of the last questions from Mealy. So
the most important thing, right? We've talked a lot about the professionals and ex-professionals
in the industry. But what about our viewers? So we have many part-time investors,
perhaps even beginners. What can they really take today? Is there a slightly different message
or anything to focus on from the art of execution and perhaps the measures as well?
Expect your ideas. Toss for coin with your ideas is going to make money. I keep reiterating that
point. You know, realize that what you do after you invested is going to determine your fate,
not the idea itself. So everyone obsesses about, yeah, I used to get questions all the time because,
you know, you imagine the team of people I used to invest with are a Crispinoji Roger guy,
they're in my team, all these legendary investors. And people go, what's Crispin's biggest position,
or what's Roger's biggest position? You could never tell them. We didn't disclose that
information, but people obsess about the stock pick being secret to success. And the answer is no.
No, it's not. The stock pick isn't the secret to your success. It's what you do when you're
invested. You know, you'll have 10 great ideas. What I can tell you is you won't know which one is
going to make you a fortune and which one's going to lose money because right when you invest,
you'll look great. But it's Toss for coin, which ones will work out. And, you know,
so the lesson would be how you react when you're losing a winning, will determine your fate.
And hence the name of the book and perhaps why we have called the podcast, the art of investing.
It really reiterates that message that it is an art. And it's not just the science of all the
numbers. It is what you do with with your feel and your ego management and the discipline.
Just think how in those few sentences, we've turned the whole industry on its head.
Because the whole industry, whether it's the Sunday times money section, the investors chronicle,
a wealth manager, an investment bank. I'll talk about stock ideas, ideas on the economy,
ideas on the currencies all the time. And saying, oh, I think this is fundamentally going up 20%
and I think it's going to be done. It's actually a toss of a coin. It's what you do with it when
you've got it. And I think that that was the lesson I picked up when I read it. So well done,
at least, at least I got the right impression. So my reading skills are okay. It's helped me a lot.
So thank you so much for your time today. Can I just reiterate on that for you? I mean,
the best investor I had money with, a bit like you George Horus, 30% hit ring.
Three hours, ten ideas made money. That's all you need to know about.
Three out of ten. There's a chance for me yet.
So as a reminder, don't forget to vote for us in the nominations. You'll find the link in the
show notes underneath the podcast. Also, if you have a question for us, then certainly email it
in straightaway to the art of investing at ig.com. Come on, Lee.
Thank you very much. Once again, Lee, absolutely insightful information. And I need to go and
manage some of my positions as we speak. We'll see you next week when we have Adam Smith joining
us, not Lee Adam Smith, but former political advisor, which of course is very timely ahead of
the upcoming budget. Adam Smith will be joining us next week to preview what he thinks is going to
happen in the budget. Something we're very much looking forward to here. Thanks very much for joining
and give us a like. Give us a subscribe and we shall see you next week.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The belief that hiring top investors and having them invest in their best ideas guarantees returns is flawed, as the success rate of any individual idea is only 49%, worse than random chance.
Long-term investors with decades of experience, including billionaires, often fail to consistently make money, highlighting that execution and discipline matter more than idea quality.
Investors fall into three tribes when losing
When winning, investors either act as raiders (take profits early) or connoisseurs (hold long-term, ride the momentum), with connoisseurs achieving significant gains through patience and discipline.
Most professional investors lack skill—98% are essentially "beta jockeys" who rely on luck rather than strategy, and most would perform better with passive index investing.
Emotional biases like sunk cost and anchoring lead investors to stay in losing positions, often resulting in prolonged losses and poor performance.
Market psychology and discipline are more critical than market timing or idea selection, especially in equities where emotional attachment can override rational judgment.
A key takeaway is to practice self-awareness by asking, "Would I buy this with a blank piece of paper?" and to set clear exit rules to avoid irrational behavior during market downturns.
Summary:
The core message of the discussion revolves around the critical role of execution and discipline in investing, rather than the quality of individual stock ideas. Despite the belief that top investors can consistently generate returns by investing in their best ideas, data shows only a 49% chance of any single idea succeeding—worse than a coin toss. This finding is reinforced by observations of legendary investors like George Soros, who frequently admit to losing money but later achieve massive wins through disciplined exit strategies.
The analysis identifies three behavioral patterns when investors lose: rabbits (do nothing), assassins (exit quickly), and hunters (add capital). The most damaging behavior is being a rabbit, as it leads to massive losses due to the compounding effect of percentage declines. Conversely, successful investors, especially connoisseurs, achieve long-term gains by holding through volatility and avoiding emotional decisions.
The data reveals that 98% of professional investors lack true skill and are merely lucky, suggesting passive investing often outperforms active management. Key psychological pitfalls—such as sunk cost bias and anchoring—cause investors to stay in losing positions, delaying necessary exits. " This approach strips emotion from decision-making and helps investors maintain control over risk.
Ultimately, success is not about picking winning ideas but about how one manages performance, especially during losses, through clear, rational, and consistent behavior.
FAQs
The chance of any investment idea making money is only 49%, worse than a coin toss. Success depends on how you manage your portfolio when winning or losing, not just on the initial idea.
Rabbits do nothing, assassins sell quickly to limit losses, and hunters add more capital to the position. Rabbits struggle because they lose significant capital to recover from big drops.
It asks whether you would buy a stock today if you had no emotional attachment or existing position. This helps identify whether your belief in a stock is based on conviction or sunk costs.
Investors often fall into sunk cost bias or diamond bias, where they hold onto losing positions due to the emotional attachment or perceived loss. This can lead to poor decisions and significant losses.
A raider takes profits early and exits frequently, while a connoisseur holds long-term positions, riding winners and only exiting when they have a clear reason, leading to bigger gains over time.
Yes, 98% of investors, even experienced ones, lack skill and rely on luck. Most do not have the discipline or process to consistently outperform the market, making passive investing more effective.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.