Go back

347. The Preachers Who Hired A Hitman

49m 3s

347. The Preachers Who Hired A Hitman

This episode details the true story of a 1988 murder in Alabama, where Reverend Charles Sennett hired a tenant, Billy Gray Williams, to kill his wife, Elizabeth. The conspiracy involved multiple accomplices, including Kenneth Smith and John, who were convicted based on evidence such as stolen items and a confession. Despite a jury's initial verdict, judicial override allowed a judge to override the verdicts, sentencing Kenneth to death. After decades of legal battles, Kenneth was executed in 2024 via nitrogen hypoxia, a process that caused severe pain and lasted 22 minutes—contrary to claims of painlessness. The execution sparked outrage and debate over the humanity and fairness of the death penalty, especially given the prolonged suffering and lack of judicial transparency. The story underscores how victims' families, like Elizabeth’s sons, continue to feel the emotional toll of unresolved justice. While the legal system saw the case as resolved, the episode reveals deep flaws in the death penalty’s execution, including systemic inefficiencies, inhumane methods, and a failure to protect human dignity. The narrative ends with a reflective tone on justice, forgiveness, and the emotional weight of such tragedies, emphasizing that the real cost of the death penalty is often borne by the victims’ families and society at large.

Transcription

8643 Words, 46424 Characters

English
Whoever says saving money is hard doesn't know that new customers who bundle and save with Progressive save hundreds. Because switching your home and auto insurance is better than cutting down on the things you love, like those ice lattes that help you get ready to face the day. So switch your home and auto to Progressive and see if you could save and keep sipping away. Get your quote today at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers not available in all states. Great meeting. Who took notes? Anyone? With Monday Notetaker, nobody has to take notes again. It joins your call, transcribes it, and turns the whole conversation into a clear plan. Action items, owners, deadlines, all right there on your Monday.com board, ready for the team. So the meeting ends and the plan already exists. Meetings aren't just talk anymore. Go to Monday.com, the AI workspace platform. Hey, everybody. Welcome back to the podcast. I feel like I can't say it yet because it's going to be in the episode that follows this. How's everyone doing? It might not be. I don't. Yeah, I don't know either. Did you used to ask that all the time? What? How everyone's doing? No, I'm saying the intro, like our intro. Oh, saying the actual intro. Yeah, it's like who wants to listen to that double, you know? Yeah. Garrett told you guys it would be a regular episode this week. I was wrong. This is the last one. It's next week. Empty promises. Sorry. I got my weeks all mixed up. We had four weeks off. This is our fourth week. Yeah. And then we're recording. Then we're recording. So getting it back into the groove, assuming everything's still going good with Peyton. But these intros have been good. Hopefully you guys have been liking the episodes still. I don't really have anything new. Do you have anything new? Any like new 10 seconds? Just mom and dad. And last night we were, just in bed laying there. We had been like, well, we got like 15 minutes of sleep and then she woke back up and we just looked at each other like, like this stinking, this, this stinking girl, you better go to sleep right now. Her tummy was hurting. Yeah. The thing is, honestly, we've been spoiled because she's such a good baby. She's just, her stomach was hurting. So it wasn't her fault. Other than that, she's been pretty perfect. I'm pretty. Do you think every parent thinks their baby's perfect? I mean, as far as like her sleeping and like being fussy. Yeah. Hasn't been. Like, I don't know. I feel hashtag blessed because it's been pretty non-existent. I have nothing to compare it to, but from. Other experiences we hear. Like the stories I had been told, I feel like it's less terrorizing than I thought it was going to be. But I think again, because like you said, she's currently right now doing really well, but you know what I'm saying? She's, she's, she's trying to, she's, she's trying to, she's trying to, she's trying to, she's trying to, she's trying to do the things that you never know. We'll find out. That's what we got. We miss you guys. I mean, we're still here. We didn't go anywhere. Um, if you want up to date on kind of what we're doing, you can follow us on our Instagram accounts and yeah, we'll see you guys in about 10 seconds when the episode starts. And we'll also see you next week. You're listening to an Ono Media Podcast. Hey everyone. This is Murder With My Husband. I'm Peyton Morland. And I'm Garrett Morland. And he's the husband. And I'm the husband. Oh, that was a different tone for you. Little bit different tone for the paid subscribers out there. Hey guys, love you guys. Um, this is the first bonus episode for July. Second one will be coming out any second now. Uh, we love you guys. Thank you for being here. Thank you for supporting us. If you're watching on Patreon and not just listening, um, I'm wearing an oversized shirt because I burnt my nipples with Nair. That's my 10 seconds. As well for anyone listening. Yes. I didn't know I used Nair for the first time in my chest. It worked wonders, but I didn't know that I couldn't use it on my NIPP LESs and I burnt them. It really hurt. Sleeping was hard. Honestly, very painful, very painful experience. But now I know next time don't use it on that area and I should be good to go. That's what I got. That's what I got for my 10 seconds. I hope you guys are doing great. Um, we have a case for you guys. We have a case for you guys. So I think we are going to just jump right in. All right, you guys trigger warning. This episode contains discussions of drug abuse, suicide, violence, execution, and murder. So please listen with care. Execution. Execution. So you know how in Westerns, a stranger just rides into town and the locals don't like him and a fight breaks out and someone's like, string him up. But then the law steps in and this man with a badge says, no, we're going to do this civilized call. The judge or maybe call the sheriff. You know what? They never say send out the summons. We're going to give this man a trial by a jury of his peers. So the sixth amendment has guaranteed us that right since 1791. But in many parts of the country, that's not how the law has historically worked, especially in remote areas like the wild, wild West or the rural South there. The last word I'm going to give you is the death penalty. The death penalty is when a person has been charged and fallen to an individual. Sometimes that individual's power has been made into law. For instance, through the once legal practice of judicial override meant that if a judge disagreed with a jury's decision, they could overrule the jury. It typically applied to sentencing verdicts. So a jury could say life without parole and a judge would say, no, I think they deserve the death penalty. For some reason, I thought they could still do that in certain cases or no. I think in, if the jury can recommend something. Oh, and the judge then decides. Yes. Or like if there's a plea deal in the state is like, we'll give you this for this. The judge can. Okay. Got it. That makes sense. Judicial override was legal in some US states all the way up to 2017. When a convicted murderer was executed in 2024, as a result of the practice, it raised questions about what constitute justice and who gets to decide. So as recently as 2024, a judge, a single man chose for someone to be executed. Okay. Yeah. So today's story actually begins in Colbert County, Alabama in the year 1988. And like I said, even though there were laws in place to stop this type of dangerous practice from happening, it was still happening. So 1988 in Alabama. Yeah. Colbert County is a rural area in the northwest part of the state. It's basically a region of rivers, waterfalls, and forests. And one of the main attractions there is actually hunting. People come from all over to hunt deer, turkey, quail, rabbit, squirrels. There's even a cemetery there specifically for coon dogs, which they're just hounds that were trained to hunt raccoons. Raccoons? Yeah. Oh, okay. So aside from that, Colbert County is a rural area in the northwest part of the state. It's pretty quiet place. In the 1980s, it had a total population of about 50,000 people. And overseeing all of these people was the Colbert County Sheriff's Office. When something bad happened, they were the ones who would get the call. So March 18th, 1988 started off as a typical day for the Sheriff's Office. But at 1144 a.m., the phone rang and there was a man on the line. He was screaming. He was distraught. The secretary couldn't understand what he was saying. So she handed the phone to the closest available worker. And that happened to be Sheriff's Investigator Ronnie May. Now, by the way, the Sheriff's Investigator is basically what it sounds like. It's a detective for the county. So Ronnie took the call and he managed to calm the man down enough to get his information. The caller's name was Reverend Charles Sennett. And he lived out on Coondog Cemetery Road. He said he had just come home and had found his place burglarized. And his wife, 45-year-old Elizabeth Sennett, was dead. So hearing this, Ronnie, Detective Ronnie, quickly dispatched a team of deputies and paramedics. And he and another deputy headed for the Reverend's house. This wasn't the first murder Ronnie had ever been called to investigate. He had extensive training and experience. He had been an investigator for 14 years and he had also attended the FBI Academy at Quantico. So this is like basically the highest detective training. And he had assisted the FBI on multiple cases, including the takedown of the infamous bank robbing machine gun toting Alabama Dawson gang. So this was a man who had seen murder. Even so, when Ronnie got to the FBI, he was able to to the Reverend's house that spring morning. What he saw there shook him to his core. The preacher's wife, Elizabeth, was lying on the floor of their living room. She had been stabbed eight times in the chest and twice in the neck. She had also been beaten with almost every available object in the room. Fireplace tools, a piece of pipe, a walking cane. Elizabeth had clearly fought for for her life, but in the end, her attacker or attackers had one out so ronnie gets there he checks the body for a pulse he doesn't find one so as he waited for the medical team to arrive he and the deputy who came with him just start looking over the scene they discovered a stereo and a vcr had been stolen the medicine cabinet mirror had also been shattered that's so funny you mentioned that because we don't have one in our house but growing up i did just because it's kind of a like an older house sort of thing and we live in a newer build now but medicine cabinet like i had them my whole life although honestly pretty sure my family's house still has one my grandma had one yeah interestingly enough in medicine cabinets oftentimes in bathrooms in very old houses there's also like a razor drop yes yep and so if you like demolish an old house there will just be like razors in the wall isn't that so funny that that's just what they did they're like oh we just won't think about it we'll just drop these razors into our house build which i guess i mean i guess it's fine like i don't think it causes any it's safer than putting it in the trash yeah like it's like it makes sense it works it's just pretty funny i just think it's so crazy how many people start renovating homes and find just a wall of razors in the medicine cabinets right it's always like on the side and you have the mirror and then you push it and then it clicks out yeah that's pretty funny yeah my grandma had one there was no medicine in there she kept her like little face products in there actually any kids that are you know newer generation and either grow up in newer builds or i don't know they don't have medicine cabinets anymore so they probably have no idea what we're talking about because in this economy in today's day and age we need a medicine or a medicine cupboard i know right we need a lot more than a cabinet pretty funny so oddly though on the house we don't have a medicine cabinet we don't have a medicine cabinet we don't have a medicine cabinet there were no signs of forced entry and elizabeth still had 400 in cash that was in her purse so as ronnie mulled over this the paramedics arrived they also checked elizabeth for a pulse and to the detective's astonishment when the paramedics got there after him they claimed to have found one wait what yes so ronnie wasn't the only man in the room who was shocked reverend charles almost fainted when he heard that his wife had a heartbeat and ronnie noticed the preacher's reaction he wasn't sure if it was a good shock or a bad shock but he made a mental note of the behavior so elizabeth is taken to the hospital hoping to recover but unfortunately she never did the 45 year old mother of two adult sons was pronounced dead an hour later and ronnie and his team were left to find out who killed her on their own so they set up a crime stoppers hotline asking anyone with information to call often these tips kind of just led to wild goose chases but in this case investigators struck gold what sorry to interrupt i think it's really strange that people will call crime stoppers or give tips that are just false they just do it because they want to tend like you know i think sometimes they just are like it like it's like this might be a lead this might not like they're like i maybe saw that person at the gas station but you know i don't know i would know i think most majority are trying to be a good samaritan i'm never like oh i i might i might have saw that i might have saw him i will hope you didn't see him i might have saw ted bundy like there's a small chance that i saw his car bro you know what i'm saying you were literally in heaven if that's where we come from heaven i mean where okay i just about asked where do we come from that's funny i guess the ground the earth i don't know you were in your last casket from your previous life just waiting to be reborn um so this tip um an anonymous tipster called and gave the police several names okay so i'm just gonna tell you the names billy gray williams so billy john forest parker john and kenneth smith are these real names yes billy john and kenneth okay billy gray williams and kenneth smith are these real names yes billy john and kenneth okay the tipster says these men were friends in their early 20s they had gone to high school together and billy was a tenant of reverend charles and according to the caller the preacher had hired billy to kill his wife he'd paid the 21 year old three thousand dollars to complete the task and then billy had subcontracted his friends john and kenneth so imagine your sheriff's investigator ronnie may you've seen a lot of bad things but this murder is pretty brutal and then you get a call from someone who won't give their name but they give you three guys names and said yeah a preacher basically paid these guys to kill his wife they did it for a thousand dollars each would you believe it i think ronnie might have been skeptical except that he had seen the reverend's odd behavior at the crime scene and there was another thing something that had been bothering him and he had seen the reverend's odd behavior ronnie since the day of the murder he realized he'd actually met reverend charles before the murder all right guys we are getting into an ad and it is salt and stone now let me tell you one of the coolest things about salt and stone it is their discovery sets that's actually what i got from salt and stone so i could figure out what sense i wanted and if you don't even know what salt and stone is salt and stone is the most delicious deodorant on the planet um according to my opinion but i think deodorant can be more than just to cover up stench it can smell good it can almost get you a compliment in a way and that is what salt and stone does their deodorant is award-winning aluminum free and formulated for 48 hour protection and today they sell one deodorant every five seconds each product is a careful blend of antifungal and antifungal and antifungal antioxidant and nutrient rich ingredients and again if you don't know what scent you like you can get one of their discovery sets get a sample and then pick from there try salt and stone's discovery set to find your signature scent go to salt and stone.com slash husband and use code husband at checkout for 15 off your first order that's salt and stone.com slash husband and use code husband for 15 off your first order all right guys jumping into an ad real quick and it is warby parker payton wears glasses so she's gonna take this one away i literally am wearing my warby parker glasses right now you guys have probably heard me talk about warby parker before i have so many pairs of glasses and they all are from them and let me tell you why not only do they have the cutest frames for all different face shapes they have done a game-changing process for getting glasses or prescriptions you can do it all in one place they have so many locations you can go in store or you can do it online they even have a virtual try on so you can literally look at the frames on your face on your phone before purchasing them which is what i do just to make sure that they fit right on my face honestly i am a huge warby parker fan i love the quality of their glasses i have yet to have a warby parker pair so i'm going to show you break on me which is why i still have like 10 pairs their prescription glasses start at 95 so you get quality and stylish frames at an affordable price right now buy one pair of glasses and get 20 off any additional pairs at warbyparker.com husband that's 20 off any additional pairs when you purchase one pair at warbyparker.com husband so a few weeks before elizabeth's murder sheriff's investigator ronnie may was called out to a gas station where an attendant had been shot and killed he was there with a team of investigators when reverend charles arrived to the gas station a preacher told the detectives he was trying to help ronnie was like okay well we don't need your help you can leave and charles complied but then he kept coming back into the area where detectives were working and ronnie was like what why is this reverend just here in retrospect he realized the preacher might try to be eavesdropping to find out what investigators would be looking for after a murder so between that theory and the anonymous call ronnie felt his team just needed to talk to the reverend again so on march 25th 1988 one week after elizabeth's death they brought reverend in for questioning and charles was pretty unhelpful he just denied denied denied and after an hour he decided to leave but just as he reached the door a detective wondered aloud if the reverend knew a guy named kenny smith remember kenneth was one of the two guys billy paid to carry out the killing if they'd asked about billy reverend charles might have said sure i know him he's one of my tenants but by asking about kenneth they were letting him know that they knew that there was this conspiracy and rumor going a little strategic going on there and it was only a matter of time before they figured if it was true and reverend charles turned bright red so investigators knew he knew kenny like he had a visible reaction to the name now obviously they don't have enough evidence to charge him they let him go he apparently said you imagine the mental games that plays on you uh-uh i mean good because yeah it sounds like he's a bad guy but it would be pretty crazy and do they ever go away like say you don't get caught no i every time you get pulled over are you like is this the one yeah i think you're afraid for the rest of your life for sure so he apparently sensed his days as a free man of god were numbered so after this he drove to his son charles jr's house now charles jr was 25 years old with a wife and family of his own he and his younger brother michael were actually together mourning their mother so both sons were at the house when reverend charles arrived and he went in and said i need to speak with you guys he had a confession to make he tells his sons that he had been having an affair and that he was responsible for their mother's murder with no further explanation reverend charles turned walked out after confessing this to his sons gets into his truck gets into the front seat and shoots himself okay so imagine how devastating this is to the sons they just lost both their parents in a week no his dad just killed him shot himself yeah okay open and shut case i guess but what the freak yeah so they know that their father's responsible because he didn't tell him details they just don't know how or to what extent what they did know was that he wasn't the one who actually killed their mother this is what the the sons learned but who was the guilty party the brothers wanted to find them and bring them to justice now ronnie and his team were working around the clock to make that happen on march 31st six days after the reverend's suicide they got a warrant for kenneth smith's home and in that house they found the vcr that had been stolen from the residents so they decide that day to arrest kenneth john and billy now not surprisingly the men's stories conflicted and as a result some of the facts actually remain murky to this day but here's what the record shows reverend charles wasn't just having an affair he was also in debt and he had recently taken out a life insurance policy on elizabeth and he appears to have put a hit out on his wife to solve both his financial and marital problems he's like i can get away with this affair and then also pay back my debt so he gave his tenant billy three thousand dollars to make it happen billy decided to have someone else do the dirty work so he appears to have lord in his buddy kenneth first kenneth then looked for a way to get rid of billy's debt and for a partner he asked more than one person actually before settling on john and maybe one of the other people that he had asked was the anonymous caller so in any case the day before the killing march 17th 1988 billy gave his co-conspirators a down payment kenneth got two hundred dollars and john received 100 john's instructions were to use that hundred dollars to go buy a gun but he didn't he spent the money on drugs specifically he bought and sold a gun an opioid called pentazocine now this could have affected john's behavior on the day of the murder we don't know but what we do know is that he did inject the drug as he drove to the house that day kenneth rode shotgun sharpening john's six inch knife along the way and when they arrived at the house they went up and knocked on the door elizabeth answered and they said hey we're interested in hunting in the area reverend charles had told them he that they could come check out his now elizabeth was wary at first a lifelong resident of alabama as well as a housewife and preacher's wife she knew better than to trust two strange men at her door yeah so she called her husband and he confirms it he's like oh yeah yeah i told them to come over that's that pisses me off that's so heartbreaking because she knew something was off and she called her husband who she trusts she trusts but it turns out he's the one who'd plan to kill her that's so disgusting that's so sad so she lets kenneth and john walk the property and then a short time later they come back to the house and like hey can we use the bathroom now because her husband had vouched for them elizabeth was like yeah come in john went to the bathroom and kenneth stayed in the living room chatting with elizabeth random random and i'm not saying you have to do this but i make sure that no one comes to the house while i'm gone usually i'm paying zero true i got the big muscles you know what i'm saying well it's also just like i don't want to be here alone yeah exactly so yeah so a few minutes later john comes back from the bathroom he has his socks on his hands i don't know why maybe he didn't want to leave fingerprints but he comes up behind elizabeth and he just starts punching her kenneth claims he left the living room at this point to stage the burglary while john was continuing the assault john on the other hand said he held elizabeth while kenneth stabbed her okay either way elizabeth fought for her life but using every within reach the men eventually took it from her they dumped most of the weapons in a pond by the house john tossed the stereo in a nearby river but kenneth he was like i want the vcr and that eventually told investigators all they needed to know so kenneth was 22 years old when he conspired with his friends to murder elizabeth in 1988 he was born on the 4th of july in alabama he went on to have four children of his own two before and then two after he became a hired hitman the day after the murder a friend went to see kenneth and he noticed a big wad of cash and kenneth said it was an income tax refund that didn't explain the new vcr which although new to kenneth was clearly in used condition so maybe that friend was the one who called anyway investigators got the warrant like i said they found the vcr they charged him john billion with capital murder also these names so billy goes to trial nine months later and that's in january 1989 now remember he's the original hitman yes he said he didn't know his friends were going to kill the housewife he thought they were just going to scare her so he's like oh no no i wasn't hired to kill i was just hired to scare her the jury found him guilty anyways and sentenced him to life without parole and scare her for what like it do we know the motive behind this or the reason i have a question i i guess it's not really a question it's more of a rhetorical question very curious to see actually i mean i guess now that i'm thinking about it's a stupid question i was gonna say how many people get away with killing somebody and get the life insurance money and don't get caught but we feel like we're gonna have that statistic no but i'm sure it's i'm sure it has to happen i'm sure it happens and i'm sure it's 0.1 percent you would think like i'm sure i would especially nowadays with how uh what's the correct word i'm just gonna use anal insurance companies are and making sure they're as profitable as can be without paying out claims yeah like there's no way they're not investigating like they don't want to pay so like they're going to use every tool possible to be like hey did is this real is this not real anyways so six months after that john had his trial and he was also convicted his attorney argued that because john had drug problems he wasn't a good candidate for the death penalty and the jury agreed so they sentenced john like billy to life without parole however this time the judge overruled their decision via judicial override and he sentenced john to death remember john was actually at the house for the murder billy wasn't so a few months later in the fall of 1989 kenneth trial began kenneth was 24 years old and at that point was a father of four which is actually so sad that there are so many children involved in this he knew his friend john had received a death sentence from the judge and he was terrified to meet the same fate so during the sentencing phase he begged the jury not to make his children grow up without a father okay the jury was unmoved on november 3rd 1989 they sentenced kenneth to death so of the four conspirators including the reverend kenneth was the only one to receive a death sentence from a jury got it however his attorneys appealed and they were successful in 1992 kenneth's conviction was overturned the prosecution fought back however and he was retried and convicted again in 1996 this time he was life without parole same sentence billy and john had received before the judge intervened now this must have felt like a pretty good victory to kenneth he was 31 years old he'd served about seven years so he might have thought he had a chance of getting out in as little as 10 to 15 years but once again judicial override came into play the judge and kenneth's second trial changed the jury's decision said the jurors were often nervous about giving the death sentence but he had no such qualms and he sent kenneth to death row now there the convicted murderer stayed for 28 years and during that time a lot changed in the world the new millennium started 9-11 happened cell phones took over social media in 2010 kenneth's friend john was executed by lethal injection for his role in the murder because we don't, there is quite a few people who have been, I almost said awarded, convicted with the death penalty. That never die. But the amount of people that actually receive it is very low. Yeah. Very, very low. So when it actually happens, it becomes a. Especially now. Yeah, it becomes a bigger deal. It's kind of all over the news and so forth because it just does not happen very often. All right, guys. This message is sponsored by Greenlight. It is so crazy to me that we grow up going to school for years and yet we never really learn about money management, which once you're an adult becomes a huge part of your life. But that is where Greenlight can help us parents step in and help aid our kids. Greenlight takes the mental load of family life and kind of just puts it all into one place. It kind of keeps your whole family in sync from money, safety, everyday life, and it's all in one place. You can see what your kids are spending through Greenlight, when they spent it. You can easily send them money so you're not having to dig for cash. And it can also help your household run smoother because you can set up chores. The schedule stays up to date in real time. When you're out of milk or someone needs new cleats, it just goes on a shared list that everyone can add to. Just keeps everything organized and then also easier to reward kids right away. So you've got enough money. You've got enough on your plate. Greenlight keeps it all in sync. Get started today at greenlight.com slash husband. That's greenlight.com slash husband. Greenlight.com slash husband. Hey guys, coming at you today with a sponsor that happens to be Mint Mobile. Remember being a kid around the holidays and anytime you would ask for something, mom would always say, wait until the holidays. Well, with Mint Mobile's holiday deal, there's no waiting. Right now, this second, all of their plans are $15 a month. And honestly, making the switch to Mint Mobile is so much easier than you would think it would be. So if you've been wanting to change your wireless, I am urging you right now to go check out Mint Mobile and just see what they offer. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right with premium wireless for 15 bucks a month. All plans come with high speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. You can even bring your current phone and your number you can choose from. Use six or 12 month plans and say goodbye to monthly billing. So what are you waiting for to get your new wireless plan for 15 bucks a month? Go to mintmobile.com slash MWMH. That's mintmobile.com slash MWMH. Cut your wireless bill to 15 bucks a month at mintmobile.com slash MWMH. Upfront payment of $45 for three month, $90 for six month or $180 for 12 month plan required. $15 per month equivalent taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabyte may slow when network is busy. Capable device required. Required availability, speed, and coverage vary. Seamintmobile.com. So seven years later in 2017, Alabama became the last state in America to retract the law that permitted judicial override. So as of that year, it was no longer legal for a judge to change a jury's decision. And this was a huge victory for opponents of the death penalty. I think I agree with it in general. I think it's better to have a group of people make a decision than one person deciding someone's fate. And that's like why you go to a jury in the first place. Yeah. And this was actually a huge victory for opponents of the death penalty in Alabama because 170 inmates were on Alabama's death row in 2017. About 20% of those were because of judicial override. But death row inmates and their supporters were soon disappointed to learn that the ruling was not retroactive. Judges couldn't change it. They couldn't change a verdict moving forward, but any that had been changed in the past. Ah, we're still in stone. Yep. So Kenneth and his attorneys fought the decision they appealed. They tried to get clemency. Nothing changed. His execution was scheduled for November 17th, 2022, and he was 56 years old. He was not the only Alabama inmate set to be executed that year. At least two men before him had been sentenced to die by lethal injection. So as his time approached, Kenneth knew exactly what was coming. Every state's procedure is different. In Alabama, when an inmate is sentenced to death, they get transferred to one of three correctional facilities designated for death row. Supreme Court of Alabama sets an execution date. A death warrant for that date is delivered to the warden of a specific prison. Holman Correctional Facility is the only one with an execution chamber. The warden notifies the inmate that their date is approaching, and if they're not already at Holman, they eventually get transferred there. A week before the date, the so-called execution team does a run-through. They check the equipment. This could include gear for lethal injection, electric chair, gas mask. We're going to hear about that more shortly. The inmate is then moved to death watch. This is a separate cell where they remain under 24-hour observation. Until the final date, they have no visitors. I'm just going to say, obviously you guys know Peyton and I have different opinions on the death penalty, but I just think it's, I don't know if comical is the correct word, but. Like, the way it's done is just, they just like build it and build it and build it, you know? Like, oh, your last meal. Oh, you're moved here. Oh, you did this. I honestly, if I was on death row, I would just appreciate like, you don't even tell me. Shoot me. All of a sudden you just walk in and I just die. Well, babe. Like, don't lead up to it. Like, that's so scary. You know what I'm saying? Don't you want that for them? To be scared? That's true. It's a good point. Yeah, it's a good point. I just think it's also, it's also kind of a waste of money and resources doing it like that. I agree, but like, if you're the injector or the judge or the jury who decided this, it's someone's life. Like, it's someone's life. Oh, so you're saying they do it for safety precautions to make sure they should die. Yeah, just to be like, hey, we're going to do this as official and clean as possible because we take this seriously. I get that part. I mean, I would hate if I was on a jury and then it was like, oh, we just lazily, no appeals, nothing, just executed. You know what I mean? Yeah, and I would assume the biggest reason people are against the death penalty is because of people who have been convicted falsely or wrongly convicted. That's actually not why I'm against it. But I would also assume, not saying it's okay, but I bet you that percentage is probably pretty low, right? 1% or less. And so now if we could, I don't know what that actual percentage is. That's just me. I would assume it's perfect. That we know of. I guess we could talk more about it later. But anyways, keep going. I'm not against it because of innocence. I think anyone would be against it for innocence. I think even you are like, if innocent people are getting out of that path. Oh, 100%. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm against it because I don't feel like I have the power to choose whether someone lives or dies. Give me the power. I just don't want to mess with that. Give it to me. Yeah, I understand that. So, and during this time, no one except prison officials, medical personnel can enter. And when the final date arrives, the prisoner is offered a last meal. They finalize funeral arrangements. They can actually receive a last visit from a spiritual advisor. Madren, reverend who hired these guys, comes in to give them spiritual advice. They are then taken to the execution chamber. The equipment gets hooked up. Curtains are opened into three viewing rooms. This is in Alabama. The warden reads the death warrant and asks if they have any last words. They get two minutes to speak. Then the warden leaves the chamber. He checks with the commissioner to see if there have been any last second stays of execution. If there have not, two members of the execution team prepare the inmate. One leaves and the other begins the procedure. It's supposed to be over in a matter of minutes. Okay? So, it's 2022. As I said. Oh, I feel like I remember this. He was like in the room and then last second got like canceled or whatever because the governor called or something. No? Okay. So, they had two inmates. Two inmates before Kenneth who were scheduled for lethal injection in 2022. And at this point in the process for both of them, things went wrong. For whatever reason, the execution team couldn't find a vein. So, in one case, they postponed the execution. In another, however, according to a physician who later examined the inmate's body, they sped it up by doing what is called a cut down. That means they cut open the inmate's arm to find the vein. So, Kenneth had heard what happened to these men. And, I mean, they were probably already scared to die, but then the way that all this happened for the men before him was especially scary. He starts to panic. Okay? So, he declines his dinner the day before his execution. He was a nervous eater. Because a journalist noted that Kenneth consumed some potato chips, cheese crackers, a package of Bugles, regular crackers, sardines, a Hot Pocket, a Coke, a peach sun-kissed drink, and a bottle of water over the course of the next day. So, then the day of his execution. Or, yeah, the day of. The day of his execution, Kenneth had a last meal of catfish, baked potato, and coleslaw. Catfish? Each their own, man. He obviously saw his spiritual advisor, and then a flurry of appeals took place. This is very normal. At 8 p.m., the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals granted a stay of execution. Kenneth thought for a moment. His prayers had been answered, but the Alabama Attorney General went straight to the Supreme Court, and 10.23 p.m., SCOTUS lifted the the stay of execution. continued this is all very yeah yeah so prison officials took kenneth into the chamber the execution team strapped him to a gurney they took out a needle tried to find a vein and just like the previous two cases they failed so they just keep trying they're inserting the needle over and over and over bro they struggle to locate a vein kenneth is getting more anxious meanwhile time was ticking down the death warrant expires at midnight it's already past 11 p.m so finally the warden's like hey worry we are out of time they wouldn't be able to complete the execution before the warrant so he postponed kenneth's sentence to the next day and um see i i would say this is hard i would say i would recently have an experience with a death warrant and i would say this is hard i would say i would recently have an experience with a death warrant i would say i would say this is hard expressing it more in a lot of these cases just how crazy they are i'm like look like we just got to get rid of them like we can't be doing this this is wild though be like killing someone like this and like poking them and being like oh we can't like that seems like torture more than the death penalty and i don't know if i'm for a tort you know what i'm saying it's just this is very this is crazy i think this is why kenneth smith's death penalty is it has become such a big deal okay so they're like we're gonna do it the next day but then the alabama governor is like no we're not we're gonna do a top to bottom investigation on what that is happening okay so i feel like this is what i was saying i feel like i've heard this before yeah and then we'll execute him so on february 24th 2023 three months after the governor said top to bottom review the alabama department of corrections announced that it was completed commissioner john ham said he had talked to department staff he's determined they were doing a good job and they're going to do a good job they were ready to resume the public was expected to take his word for it only one change was made at least only one was ever announced the alabama supreme court removed the midnight deadline so now a death warrant could expire at a specific date um not just at the end of the day so that would prevent of officials from feeling this unnecessary stress to get it done so with this new law in place the state of alabama resumed operations they executed two more men in 2020 and they and the following year kenneth smith's turn came around again up until now he'd only had two joys lethal injection or electric chair but now a third option had been opened up he could choose to be executed by nitrogen hypoxia this refers to a process by which a person's oxygen source is replaced with nitrogen they feel like they're breathing normally but they're not getting any oxygen and then they asphyxiate the process had been used in europe and the state of alabama for physician-assisted suicide for years fall asleep and die but as of january 2024 it had never been used in an execution he decided that his preferred option was lethal injection but the state was like no we're gonna try the nitrogen so a doctor who had assisted more than 50 suicides in europe said a mask could have leaks that would cause prolonged pain and suffering to the person so kenneth is like i don't want to do that i don't want to do let's fight it prosecutors keep pushing forward defense is pushing back the two sides return to the supreme court the court declined to intervene and there was no stay of execution so on january 25th 2024 kenneth once again went to the death chamber when he arrived he found several people waiting in the viewing room one of them was his wife diana who he'd married in 2021 one was a spiritual advisor the other were journalists and there were elizabeth's sons charles jr and michael the brothers had attended john's execution back in 2010 they also knew their dad's tenant billy had died in prison in 2020 and the court declined to intervene so on january 25th 2024 kenneth was released from prison in 2020 so for them kenneth was the final piece almost 36 years after their mom was murdered they looked forward to justice being served shortly after 8 p.m kenneth was given two minutes to say his last words again and when john had been given the same opportunity four years ago he turned to elizabeth's family and said i'm sorry i don't ever expect you to forgive me i'm really sorry but kenneth by contrast seemed to have forgotten all about the woman he murdered and why he was even here his last words were a declaration to the world he said alabama causes humanity to take a step backwards thank you for supporting me love all of you which is just rich wow you caused humanity to take a step backwards i think we forget right because i think we as humans we're thinking dang like we're killing someone right now only to forget that that person's literally in this position because they just murdered somebody yeah okay so this is what's set up remember last time this was happening they couldn't find a vein panic whatever he gets out it's like okay i'm not actually dying so the mask is flowing with nitrogen um he smiles at his wife and kids and signs i love you he seems momentarily okay but as the nitrogen starts flowing kenneth begins thrashing advocates of nitrogen hypoxia say it renders the inmate unconscious in just seconds and then they pass pretty painlessly a few minutes later this did not appear to happen for kenneth his head jerked the process of him dying with this mask went on for 22 what is happening what is happening everyone who had conspired to murder 45 year old elizabeth back in 1988 were finally deceased now after the execution kenneth's wife deanna was devastated this was not the manner of death she had been told to expect even the journalists were rattled no one wants to sit there and watch someone die a painful death for 22 minutes they'd never seen one as painful and drawn out as this commissioner ham though was like this is exactly as anticipated he said the reason kenneth was thrashing around was he was holding his breath in the mask he wasn't breathing it in and governor ivy didn't comment except to say after more than 30 years and attempt after attempt to game the system mr smith has answered for his horrendous crimes so even after his death the two sides continued to battle it out each one sure that their way was the only justice and you're all of this and like the drama and the drama and the drama and the drama of kenneth's death penalty elizabeth was honestly kind of forgotten she was a wonderful woman according to her son she was kind generous loving charles jr described her as a homemaker a confidant best friend he said she was everything you would want a mom to be michael pointed out that kenneth's legal battle went on almost twice as long as he had even known his mother he also said his family had forgiven the men involved in the murder nine years ago but nevertheless he said he had forgiven the men involved in the murder nine years ago but nevertheless he said he had a humanity that's the death penalty is very difficult for a lot of people i think people just advocate it to happen in a humane way um but elizabeth's death wasn't humane yeah and that's what's hard and so i think the governor's correct in saying like hey whether this lasted 22 minutes he was in pain or not elizabeth got justice and that should be the main focus and that's what's hard yeah i don't know no it's hard because we you we forget that i mean but her family didn't her kids didn't you know her kids are thinking about it every single day so to them it's like zero sym symphony um you wish it could just be easy wish it could just work flawlessly there were there was nothing wrong with the system but that's just not the world we live in it's not possible yep all right you guys that was our book of the day and i hope you enjoyed it and i'll see you in the next one bye bye bonus episode and we have another one coming right up next so go ahead and listen to that and after that we will see you with a regular one i love it i hate it goodbye whoever says saving money is hard doesn't know that new customers who bundle and save with progressive save hundreds because switching your home and auto insurance is better than cutting down on the things you love like those ice lattes that help you get ready to face the day so switch your home and auto to progressive and see if you could save and keep sipping away get your quote today at progressive.com progressive casualty insurance company affiliates and other insurers not available in all states

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. A shocking 1988 murder in Colbert County, Alabama, involved a preacher who paid a tenant to kill his wife, leading to a complex conspiracy involving multiple men.
  2. Sheriff’s investigator Ronnie May uncovered evidence linking the suspects, including stolen items and a confession from the preacher to his sons, who then found out their father had murdered their mother.
  3. The case revealed judicial override—where judges could overturn jury death sentences—was legal in Alabama until 2017, allowing a judge to sentence one of the conspirators, Kenneth Smith, to death despite jury decisions.
  4. Kenneth Smith’s execution in 2024 faced multiple delays, technical failures, and intense legal battles, including a painful and prolonged nitrogen hypoxia process that lasted 22 minutes.
  5. The case highlights systemic flaws in the death penalty, including lack of transparency, prolonged suffering, and the failure to ensure humane execution.
  6. Despite the legal process, the victims' families, especially Elizabeth’s sons, expressed that justice was not truly served due to the inhumane and traumatic manner of death.
  7. The episode underscores public skepticism toward the death penalty, emphasizing that it often fails to deliver justice in a fair, humane, or efficient way.
  8. The story illustrates how personal, emotional, and financial motives can drive criminal acts, and how legal systems struggle to respond to them ethically and effectively.

Summary:

This episode details the true story of a 1988 murder in Alabama, where Reverend Charles Sennett hired a tenant, Billy Gray Williams, to kill his wife, Elizabeth. The conspiracy involved multiple accomplices, including Kenneth Smith and John, who were convicted based on evidence such as stolen items and a confession. Despite a jury's initial verdict, judicial override allowed a judge to override the verdicts, sentencing Kenneth to death.

After decades of legal battles, Kenneth was executed in 2024 via nitrogen hypoxia, a process that caused severe pain and lasted 22 minutes—contrary to claims of painlessness. The execution sparked outrage and debate over the humanity and fairness of the death penalty, especially given the prolonged suffering and lack of judicial transparency. The story underscores how victims' families, like Elizabeth’s sons, continue to feel the emotional toll of unresolved justice.

While the legal system saw the case as resolved, the episode reveals deep flaws in the death penalty’s execution, including systemic inefficiencies, inhumane methods, and a failure to protect human dignity. The narrative ends with a reflective tone on justice, forgiveness, and the emotional weight of such tragedies, emphasizing that the real cost of the death penalty is often borne by the victims’ families and society at large.

FAQs

New customers who bundle home and auto insurance with Progressive can save hundreds. Switching to Progressive is a better option than cutting back on things you love, like ice lattes.

Monday Notetaker joins calls, transcribes conversations, and turns them into clear action plans with owners and deadlines. The meeting plan is ready to use right after the meeting ends.

Reverend Charles Sennett's wife, Elizabeth, was murdered by a conspiracy involving her tenant Billy and friends John and Kenneth. The case revealed deep financial and personal motives, leading to a complex legal battle.

Judicial override allowed judges to override jury decisions in sentencing, especially for the death penalty. This practice was used until 2017, when Alabama officially ended it.

Kenneth Smith's execution was delayed multiple times due to failed vein access. He was eventually executed via nitrogen hypoxia, but the process took 22 minutes and caused significant distress, leading to controversy.

In Alabama, a death warrant is issued, and the inmate is transferred to a facility with an execution chamber. The execution can be delayed, and the process is subject to appeals and legal challenges.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.