Go back

The PDB Situation Report | November 14th, 2026: Spy Scandal at Nvidia Rocks America’s AI Industry & Russia-Ukraine Peace Talks

57m 31s

The PDB Situation Report | November 14th, 2026: Spy Scandal at Nvidia Rocks America’s AI Industry & Russia-Ukraine Peace Talks

NVIDIA’s CEO Jensen Huang resigned amid allegations of an affair with a businesswoman suspected of spying for China, reigniting concerns about China’s access to U.S. advanced AI technology and export controls. The incident has prompted a broader investigation into loopholes allowing indirect chip transfers via third parties like MegaSpeed, with financial institutions seen as key enablers or monitors. Critics point to delays in sanctioning MegaSpeed, potentially due to political influence or bureaucracy, raising questions about internal decision-making at the Commerce Department. U.S. officials and experts emphasize the need for stronger enforcement, transparency, and legislative action to close these loopholes. Meanwhile, Russia and Ukraine’s peace talks in Abu Dhabi made only limited progress, with no ceasefire or resolution of core territorial disputes. Both sides remain unwilling to compromise, highlighting a lack of political will to end the war. U.S. diplomatic efforts—such as funding Russia and avoiding strong sanctions—have been criticized for weakening Ukraine’s position and enabling continued aggression. Experts warn that inconsistent U.S. policy, especially under the current administration, fosters Russian hybrid warfare and undermines NATO’s credibility, risking deeper instability in Europe and beyond. The situation underscores a broader struggle: balancing economic competitiveness with national security, and ensuring that diplomatic actions are consistent, transparent, and firmly aligned with U.S. strategic interests.

Transcription

8732 Words, 49990 Characters

English
Welcome to the PDB situation report that I'm Mike Baker, your eyes and ears on the world stage. Alright, let's get briefed. First up, an espionage scandal, rocks in video, perhaps you've heard about it, forcing out its long time CEO and raising concerns about China's access to America's most sensitive AI technology. We'll be joined by Max Meisler, a show of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies for more on that. Later in the show, Russia and Ukraine have returned to the negotiating table at Abu Dhabi, making some "limited" progress but failing to resolve the biggest obstacles to ending the war. Former US ambassador to Ukraine, John Herbst, will stop by to give his insight. But first, today's situation reports spotlight. Well, it's been an interesting few weeks for the world's leading AI chip maker in video. That's an understatement. It's a long time CEO, Jensen Huang, has resigned following revelations of an affair with a business woman suspected by US intelligence of spying for China. That would be among other affairs, I believe the scoreboard is at three so far. In video has launched an independent investigation while that's nice, while lawmakers are demanding answers about potential espionage, sensitive technology and China's access to advanced American chips. Frankly, it's a very good thing if Congress spends more time focusing on China's shenanigans. The company maintains it has no evidence, the national security was compromised, none. But the scandal has renewed questions about China's efforts to obtain American technology as a pro tip they are constantly trying to obtain American technology. And Washington's attempts to stop it. Joining me now for more on this is Max Meisler, she's the deputy director of the foundation for defensive democracies center on economic and financial power. Max? Well, there you are. First time guest on the PDB situation report. Thank you very much for joining us today. Tap it with you. Ah, well, let's see, before we get started on this, according to the Jensen Huang side action scoreboard, so far, the Tally's three and looks like one alleged Chinese intel asset and two Nvidia employees, are you surprised that he resigned? Now, I think there are a lot of pressures for him to resign, what's in the board? You look, this he's going to be facing a lot of scrutiny from at the individual level. There's going to be additional scrutiny. Well, in video at the corporate level, looking at matters of you as national security, I think honestly, the most interesting thing here is that as much as we've already known about issues related to export control of Asian and diversion of these high end chips, somehow what it took for people to have a renewed interest in this important matter of national security was the CEO having a lunch to fare with or had a fair with an alleged Chinese intelligence asset. So I think that actually should just give us a little bit of pause that this is the basis for why folks here all of a sudden have a renewed interest in the issue. I'm going to take that one step further, Max. I'm going to say that it wasn't so much the intimate relationship that he admitted to with the alleged, we keep saying alleged Chinese intel asset because a lot of folks in Silicon Valley and others just rallied around them. They were like, it was almost like they were saying, well, yeah, okay, that's bad. But getting rid of Jensen would be worse. But what apparently was a bridge too far was then his affairs with people who worked for him. And that's, I think, very interesting in the sense that it wasn't, it wasn't the threats to national security on the large basis that you're talking about. It wasn't the actual sleeping with an alleged Chinese intel asset. It was then, oh my God, he had an affair with an employee who was working for him. Well, that's, that's a bridge too far. I think that was the, that was in part. I know I'm oversimplifying this, but that was the part that struck me as I don't know what to call it. Interesting. Let me ask you this, Max, do you think Jensen Huang is indispensable? Look, I'm not an expert on chip design or the business side of semiconductors and building out this industry. I understand that he's been indispensable for the growth of AI and for the underlying technology that actually is the backing for the entirety of the AI industry. So in a way, he's been an incredibly important person for the growth of this industry, for the growth of the US dominance in the AI sector in many respects. But look, it would be a bad thing if the fate of a company is going to be tied to the person who's tied for 33 years. I do have concern, though. I mean, as just as a matter of the general reporting, when the board structure and the business lines within NVIDIA, it seems like things ran relatively flat with Jensen talking about having how he had 60 direct reports. So it seems like this is going to be a difficult thing for whoever comes in his place to fill. But it really doesn't address, I think, the most important part here, which is the underlying national security concerns and the export control and diversion matters, that impacts not only in NVIDIA, but every other similarly situated firm involved in this ecosystem. Yeah. No, I did your point and I agree with you. It was William Shakespeare, everybody attributes things to, apparently the only people who were making quotes were Winston Churchill or William Shakespeare. But I think he wrote that the grave yards are full of indispensable men. Again, just as an aside, this isn't the key point to any of this developments or the story, but it is interesting how people rallied around him in the face of this national security issue. You know, saying, well, even Elon Musk was like, well, you know, he's, he actually is indispensable. He kept, I think that's, you know, what do I know? I'm the last person you should talk to about chip development and technology, but I have been around for a long time, I don't believe anybody's indispensable. So talk to me if you could about the, the fact that Jensen Kwong was a advocate for opening up the market, right, for pushing for, you know, fewer restrictions on processor on chip sales to China. Talking about where that stands right now, I mean, I think it's, it's somewhat confusing because we can, we can allow the transfer of, of certain chips, not others. But talk to me about where we are right now in that process. And also, if you could then kind of move into the idea, well, how good are we at policing that? Right. So, there's, you know, long standing export controls as it relates to semiconductors and these advanced chips and then the servers that ultimately house the chips. There are some loopholes that have existed for quite some time where these servers and, and the chips can be exported to other countries that then provide remote access for firms in other countries like China that shouldn't otherwise be able to access them. This is something that's developed a significant amount of bipartisan interest in closing that loophole since the, this whole saga has begun in the last several days involving Jensen Kwong and, and Alice Wong. There's, there's other matters though that require greater attention that I think, you know, fewer are actually talking about. And so this relates to the financial institutions and their responsibility in policing against this threat. So, we think a lot about, you know, the, the companies that are directly involved, right? So, Nvidia and its understanding of its customers downstream and then from there who there then providing services to or providing indirect transfer of the controlled chips to, that's all worthwhile. And there's a lot that can be done legislatively to create a more aggressive enforcement posture so that goods can't be more easily transferred to end users in China. But to my point about the financial institutions, yeah, yeah, no, no, no, go ahead. I'm sorry, go ahead. To my point about the financial institutions, you know, the, the Commerce Department put out guidance just a couple of years ago highlighting the financial institutions and any other entity, no matter where they're located, so not just US persons have an obligation because they're prohibited from providing services or financing for deals that relate to these export controlled goods. And so we're talking about billions of dollars of these export controlled chips moving to China through cutouts like Alice Wong's mega speed and other sineless situated entities. Now there's been reporting in recent days about the financing that's been provided where there was collateral provided. And so firms are providing big money, right, billions of dollars to provide for the sale and flow of these chips. They have an obligation under US law to not do so if they have an indication that doing so could actually be in violation of the law. And then we think about the Treasury authority. My impression was, I'm sorry, we have a bit of a delay in the system for some reason this morning max, but my impression was that Nvidia is one of those. companies that is providing support, providing money, providing whatever you want to call them subsidies to grow the business, right? Well, so Nvidia has its customer base, right? And so they're selling directly to suppliers who are then providing the semiconductor's downstream to other customers that Nvidia might not have direct insight into who they are, right? So there's questions about the extent to which Nvidia should have an additional obligation to understand downstream who ultimately those end users are of the chips. This is why closing up this loophole that allows for remote access from servers in Southeast Asia would be warranted. But let me just put forward this the theory of how the US could investigate further utilizing financial institutions. I'm at the end of the day when we're moving billions of dollars, there's significant amounts of trade documents and trade intelligence that banks are custodian themselves, right, as part of these major transactions. And so the United States several years ago passed a reform to some money laundering and some money laundering laws. It allowed for the Department of Justice and the Treasury Department to actually subpoena foreign banks that have connectivity to the United States when they're doing business in dollars and to request information from them for any number of types of financial crimes or criminal matters. And so regardless of whether the activity actually relates to their conduct in the United States, the US actually maintains this authority to issue the subpoenas and to threaten them with cutting off their access to the US dollar bags that they're using to clear big business in the United States. So there's a real significant approach the United States can use to bring the heavy hand of US law enforcement to bear. I guess these financial institutions that should be having a significant amount of the trade information that we would want to have a better understanding of. So this is just part of the conversation that isn't getting a lot of attention right now, Washington. There's kind of like the sexier issues at hand and everyone's talking about the export control reforms. Those are necessary, but equally as important is the role that Treasury is going to play in actually policing against this threat in the future. Well, to your knowledge, or at least in your experience, to what degree has the government use that subpoena power with overseas financial institutions up to this point? At least in the context of the export controls and trade diversion involving semiconductors. I'm not aware of any instance in which it's actually being utilized. Yeah. And just before we go to break, Max, I know this we're not a we're not a political show, but you mentioned sort of this. There's legislation that can be done in pursuit of some of these issues we're talking about. With the change following the midterm elections beat down and the change in the House and set it. Do you see this as a bipartisan issue or does this land on one side of the aisle or another? I think that that it's it is quite frankly a bipartisan issue. I think that there are ways in which it could take a partisan turn for the worst. And you know, look, we need to get a better understanding of why some of these delays have happened. Right. And so there is some speculation regarding potential concerns from within the commerce department as to why the department has been slow rolling these efforts to add mega speed, which was the firm run by Alice Wong is alleged Chinese intelligence asset. Why there was a delay in adding it to the commerce department's entity list, which prohibit exports to that entity. We don't quite know why there was this delay. Right. Maybe there was some in propriety. Maybe there was just a process issue. I think that there's a potential for it to become partisan. If this is going to become just an attack on the Trump administration writ large when at the end of the day, what it needs to be is a pursuit to understand transparency, transparently, why there were certain delays, where the issues were and then how we actually create the reforms to prevent this from ever happening again in the future. Well, I for one, I'm shocked that you might have thrown out the idea that there could be impropriety in Washington, DC. Come on, Max had sounds very cynical. If you'll stay right where you are, don't go anywhere. Max, we have to take a quick break and then we will be back with more from Max Meisler, the deputy director of the foundation for defensive democracies center on economic and financial power right here on the PDB situation reports. So please stick around. Hey, Mike Baker here with a word about personal health and weight loss. Now everybody's talking about weight loss injections, right, because the results have been so dramatic. They work by lowering blood sugar and reducing appetite. But what if you're looking to lose weight and not interested in painful weekly injections, especially when you hear about some of those side effects. Well, that's why doctors created a weight loss supplement called lean LEAN and the results are remarkable. The study of ingredients in lean have been shown to low your blood sugar burn fat by converting it into energy and curb your appetite and cravings. So you're not as hungry to simple as that. But listen, lean is not for the casual dieter with only a few pounds to lose the doctors at brickhouse nutrition created lean for frustrated dieters with 10 or more pounds to lose. Let's get you started with 20% off and free rush shipping so you can add lean to your healthy diet and exercise plan, visit take lean dot com and enter PDB for your discount that's promo code PDB at take lean dot com. Welcome back to the PDB situation report. Joining us once again is Max Meisler. She's the deputy director of the foundation for defensive democracy center on economic and financial power. We've been discussing the Nvidia situation scandal, whatever we want to refer to it as max. Thank you very much for for sticking around. And let me ask you this. You brought up at the end of the first segment. You brought up the idea that there had been something delay on the part of commerce department of commerce in moving against mega speed over concern of the fact that it may have been using cutouts. Other entities to transfer the restricted technology to China from Nvidia. Now there's been a little bit of reporting that said that the problem there was treasury secretary Scott Besson, who was pushing back or no actually take that back and I with apologies to Besson. It was actually Howard Lutnik over at commerce. So I apologize to the treasury secretary. I he watches this religiously. So the idea being that Howard Lutnik was sort of the roadblock in that move and apparently according to reporting. Now, it was in part because he was concerned over retaliation from China. Essentially, you know, impacting the relationship with China, such as it is. Mind you China is at the center of this espionage scandal. So upsetting them, at least in my book, I wouldn't really play a role here. Have you heard anything about that. And have you heard any any additional insight into where that stands because my understanding again, not to bang on about this before I finish my question, which is rambling is at the White House as said, just get on with it. And yet commerce continues to slow roll this effort. Look, the administration has decidedly different approaches within its own operation as it relates to how to go and combat China. What we know as a matter of fact from the reporting and then also on Friday today, treasury secretary Besson has said that the US trade representative treasury state. We're all in agreement that commerce department should have added and still should add mega speed to the commerce department's entity list, which would prohibit exports of these goods to the entity. Treasury secretary Besson made it very plain that the commerce secretary, Howard Lutnik has this responsibility. He has the pen and the decision is his. There's reporting suggesting that President Trump has supported this effort. So it's unclear as to why this is actually moving so slowly. What we know for sure from the last year of reporting is that the commerce secretary and Jensen Wong have had a close relationship that of all the people in the administration, Jensen Wong says that he speaks most regularly with the commerce secretary. We know that Jensen Wong has had this very close and intimate relationship with an individual who is believed by many and alleged to be a Chinese intelligence asset. And so there's concerns about the extent to which Jensen Wong may have been impacting the pace of decision making in the United States that would have had a negative external effect when China's build out of its AI ecosystem. And so all of that is is ongoing. We need to get to the bottom of it. We need to understand what the delay is and we need action from the US government. Frankly, I think it's high time that President Trump take his position of influence and power within the administration to make an executive decision that requires the commerce department secretary to sign off on this order that would restrict the 12 goods of these export control chips to mega speed. Yeah, a couple of points there that you raise Max. I think you're excellent. Just for general consumption for those watching from an operational perspective. People will say, well, okay, we get it. Jensen Pwang was critically important in the AI race, China to the US. So we understand why he was being targeted. But you're targeting somebody like that for a variety of reasons, not just for, okay, is he going to provide intelligence on the plans and intentions of Nvidia? Or is he going to talk about his conversations with the president when he's in the White House? It's also the potential for him to be an agent of influence. Again, not saying "witting", right? Nobody's saying he's a "witting asset" or his cooperative contact. He could be perfectly unwitting. The Chinese intel apparatus would be more than happy to use an unwitting contact if they're getting what they want. And in this case, you know, it's a very likely that they viewed him as an essentially an agent of influence who could help push the policies of the White House in the direction that the Chinese Communist Party wants. A second point, and this may be kind of inside Washington, D.C. baseball, but to your point about Jensen Pwang having a close relationship with Howard Lutnik, you know, for what it's worth, you know, talk around Washington is that, you know, part of the issue with commerce is that everything has to flow through Lutnik. And he ends up just basically being the guy who makes decisions. So anybody who is attempting, or companies who are attempting to understand what commerce is doing, basically, you know, you've got to be dealing with Howard Lutnik, which is perhaps what Nick style, but not necessarily perhaps the most effective or efficient way to run the Department of Commerce. So it's understandable that Jensen Huang and a variety of other CEOs with companies that are concerned about Washington's policies or where commerce is going with tariffs and trade, with say, okay, and that's also a very sort of, it's a cultural thing too. I have to develop a repersonal relationship with that person at the top. So that comment that you made about the relationship between Jensen Huang and Howard Lutnik kind of rings true with sort of the talk on the street about how Lutnik runs commerce. For what it's worth, now I'm going to scramble down off my soapbox and Max, if we could take a turn, maybe go up to 30,000 feet from where we've been. If you can talk to me about from your assessment, what is the gap in the AI race between China and the US? How do you assess it? Well, look, I'm not an expert on AI from a technical perspective. Okay, what I do know is this is that the leading ships and the leading labs are based here in the United States. What I know is that from the open source competitive landscape, some of the most high-end leading labs are based in China. So there is an area of competition here with China and the United States. What we know is that this industry has high utility for military applications, for research that relates to sophisticated weaponry and energy systems. And then there's all the positive impact that this technology can have. And so what the United States needs to do is implement policies that make it so that when they're standard setting in organizations that are creating the rules of the road for this new industry that they're influenced and led by what is going to be in the interest of the United States and its allies and partners. And so this is obviously antithetical to what the Chinese Communist Party is interested in pushing forward. It's why we need to have these tighter controls. And look, I appreciate this movement to the 30,000 foot view. But if I can just get granular for one second to go back to the conversation inside of things. Yeah, the idea here is that it's not just that there was this significant amount of coordination and interaction between the Commerce Secretary and Jensen Wang. But there's also been reporting suggesting that when the Commerce Department was actually interested in putting forward certain changes to its export controls that would have tightened the scope of application vis-a-vis China and made it more difficult for Nvidia to sell there. That Nvidia's Chief General Counsel actually had red lines in some of these changes that were being viewed by staff at the Commerce Department. So I just want to highlight the degree to which there's something that's highly, highly unusual. It's one thing for the Commerce Secretary to have a tight relationship with the senior executive management of his agency. If he's entrusted by the President to do so and that's in the President's interest, fine. But it was highly unusual and what we're going to be expected to have more answers from federal law enforcement increasingly from Congress is exactly how did Nvidia influence the decision-making of the Commerce Department and to what extent might have that bit influenced by whatever was happening between Jensen Wang and Alice Wang. So I want to highlight that point there that there is a degree of quite unusual interaction between Nvidia's counsel at the highest level and the senior leadership and decision-making within the Commerce Department. Yeah, I'm glad you brought that up. I believe it was during a course of the investigation which is ongoing that the General Counsel from Nvidia reached out saying that he had been authorized by might have been the deputy, might have been Kessler within Commerce. I'm not sure saying that he'd been authorized to reach out to Commerce to inquire about the investigation and that did cause reportedly some real concern among some of the investigators who were working on this case thinking, well that seems like an undue or unusual or concerning outside influence from the company that is actually being investigated. Now there's a there is a lot to look at here. I think there's a lot of rocks that need to be picked up. I'm concerned that sometimes these things sort of go to Washington DC to die and you rarely see meaningful results from investigations, but this is part and parcel of what the Chinese intel apparatus does in terms of reaching out, covering up intelligence, economic information, research and development, intellectual property, access to technology. So I suspect that the FBI is focused very heavily on this in terms of understanding that aspect of it. You've got the investigation that's internal from Nvidia. That's what you would expect them to do using outside counsel. I don't know that that's going to really impact the situation. Then you've got the other issues, which is look, what can other companies in this space and in other sensitive spaces learn from this and that to me from an operational perspective is also important. They have to understand how critical it is internally within their companies to have a proactive and consistent global security organization that also maintains a counterintelligence element to evaluate and vet and understand every foreign contact. You would hope that the US government would be, you would also hope that the US government is going to act a little bit more quickly than it has before since the fact that the revelations about mega speed are well over a year old. I mean, there was a detailed report from the New York Times in October of 2025 about this company and the sanctioned the expert control of Asian issues at hand. So right, none of this is new. Again, it raises these questions about the political will to take action in a way that's going to natively impact the relationship with China. Yeah, and that's always been what I think in part the CCP, the Chinese government is relied on was knowing that, you know, whichever administration is never really going to push too hard. But I agree with it. But again, as I said, I'm a cynic. I think, you know, Washington DC is where investigations go to die. So I'm hopeful perhaps the incoming House and Senate will take this up with some speed. But I'm not sure that I'm that hopeful. Max, listen, this has been delightful. And I don't use the word delightful very often. But I do hope that when we call you again that you will agree to come on back because there's a lot more. I've got another couple pages of questions here. I can throw your way. So thank you very much for taking the time here on the situation report. All right. Look forward to coming back. Thanks. Excellent. Thank you. Of course, that maximizes the foundation for defensive democracies here on the situation report. Well, when we come back in Russia and Ukraine, I agree to continue peace negotiations. How about that following two days of dogs and Abu Dhabi, which is just fun to say Abu Dhabi. But there's either side prepared to make the concessions necessary to end the war. Here's a pro tip. I don't know the Putin's looking to end the war. We'll ask former US ambassador to Ukraine, John Herbst, when we come back. So you know what I'm going to say. Stay with us. Hey, Mike Baker here. Now, I've been a business owner for many years. And I want to take just a moment to talk to all you small business operators out there. Look, here's the thing. If running any small business, you know, this means dealing with constant unexpected expenses, right? Whether it's upgrading an IT system or repair costs or managing payroll, there is always something. And you cannot Not a Ford to let traditional bank red tape slow your momentum. That's why you need Cardiff, America's favorite small business lender. Look with over $12 billion funded to small businesses nationwide, they specialize in high-speed liquidity. Unlike legacy banks, Cardiff's simple application takes only three minutes, has absolutely no impact on your personal credit to apply and offers same-date funding up to $500,000. If you've been a business for a year and more with at least $20,000 a month in revenue, get the capital you need today. Your business deserves a partner that moves as fast as you do. Approval and minutes funding same day. Visit Cardiff.co/PDB, that's Cardiff.co/PDB. Real growth, fast funding, Cardiff, borrow better. Welcome back to the PDB's situation report. For the first time in nine months, Russian and Ukrainian negotiators have returned to the bargaining table or negotiating table or a table anyway, meaning this week in Abu Dhabi for two days of US-brokered peace talks. The negotiations produced limited progress, mostly an agreement in principle on a major prisoner exchange. But on the larger questions, there was reportedly very little movement. No ceasefire was reached territorial disputes remained unresolved, both Moscow and Kiev appear unwilling to compromise on their central demands. Still, both sides have agreed to continue talking, raising the question of whether these negotiations can eventually produce a settlement or simply prolong a diplomatic stalemate while Putin's invasion grinds on. Joining us now to discuss the latest peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine is Ambassador John Herbst. He served as a US ambassador to Ukraine from 2003 to 2006 and is currently the senior director of the Atlantic Council's Eurasia Center. Mr. Ambassador, thank you very much for joining us here on the PDB Situation Report, really appreciate it. My pleasure. Thank you. Absolutely. Let's start with a very high level view. What's your assessment of the two days of talks that have taken place in Abu Dhabi? It achieved a prisoner exchange, and that's a very positive thing, especially since we know how brutally the Russians treat Ukrainian POWs and Ukrainian civilians like that occupied Ukraine. So that's a good say. Whether it's achieved anything towards actually establishing an inter-Russian-Gussian there is an open question. I know this is a bit of a speculative subjective question, but based on all your experience and from what you've been seeing, is Putin in a mindset where he's looking to end the war? There is no public indication of that. And I would say either no or very scant, private indication of that. I want to explore this right because there's been an interesting relationship that has developed it seems between the White House and the Kremlin in the sense of it's Zelensky's fault. Now just as a reminder, Putin invaded Ukraine, just throwing that out there. But how do you assess or interpret the current administration, the US administration's relationship, maybe that's the wrong word, attitude, dealings with the Kremlin? Okay. It's a very good question. I am in a minority, I'm lost, many people who watch the Ukraine, Russia or I don't want to stand in ways that some others do not. Then Russia considers us to be its principal adversary, which is international relations talk for enemy, and that Russia is pursuing a very aggressive anti-American policy, anti-nado policy, not to mention its brutal war in Ukraine. And amongst this group, I think the Trump's policy is of inconsistent because it's driven by two more or less contradictory instincts. The positive interstate, which we have not seen so much of lately, and but Trump came into the oil office the second time saying this all the time, is that he wants to see an end to this war based upon essentially a deal written around the current lines held by the two militaries, two opposing armies. But a deal that would lead to a stable peace, after which Ukraine would be sovereign, secure and economically viable, that's, and that instinct has driven part of his policy. I would say need to all the good stuff that he's done comes from that instinct. But then there's a second instinct and this instinct relates to your question. For whatever reason, and there's lots of speculation, but I don't want to deal with speculation here, Trump shows that undue deference to Putin. Again, it can be swayed by many different potential factors. And that deference is at the heart of this very peculiar, ob-friendly relationship between the two and the unwillingness to call out Russian aggression and the need to find someone else responsible for the war and that someone else is Zelensky. And I can tell you, this instinct contradicts the first, so that's why his policy jumps back and forth and also is very much an obstacle to a strong policy that defends the United States, though it needs to be defended against the only mere pure superpower that we've got. Who also considers us to be its principal adversary and who works against our interests, whether it's helping Iran target Americans, whether it's sending people to assassinate Americans or any United States, whether it's directing that being, that have had a central to essentially cripple American officials, all these things Putin does and he's not called on it by the President of the United States. Very odd. Yeah, I think it's very confusing during the course of these negotiations, discussions, you know, we've had Steve Whitgolf and Jared Kushner out there as part of the US team talking with the delegations from Ukraine and the Kremlin. The Europeans don't have a seat at the table, basically because Putin doesn't want them at the table, so it seems as if they've deferred to that desire. Do you have any the M&E insider or understanding of the position that Whitgolf and Kushner have taken during the course of these latest talks in looking for a compromise? I mean, are they pushing equally on both sides, you know, for this idea of, well, you know, they willing to compromise? Well, again, you've got an invaded country and you've got Putin and so I'm wondering whether you have any insight into what those conversations are like. I know that's a tough thing, but you know, do you get the sense that they are, in fact, pushing both sides or is this just more of the same saying, well, you know, Ukraine, you got to kind of give this up, give up the territory and give up some of your sovereign abilities and then we can have peace. Okay. I would distinguish in answering your question between what Whitgolf and Kushner have said during the negotiations that's on the one side and then on the other decisions taken by the administration that relate to the swore. Obviously, those two things are related, but they're still distinct. So to answer specifically your question, what we've seen publicly, which is the source of the only information I know I have for sure, I would not say that the tune to American negotiators in the talks in Abu Dhabi and since have negotiated essentially off of Russian talking or have demanded things from Ukraine, well, not demanding things from Russia. I think they've tried having listened to the two parties to put some things in play which in theory might achieve an agreement if both sides really wanted one, because I think only one side really wants an agreement meaning the Ukraine side. And so for example, we know that the Europeans were in Abu Dhabi, not in the negotiations, but in Abu Dhabi at the initiative of our negotiators. We know too that the two negotiators left Abu Dhabi from Moscow. where they were trying to get Putin's okay for them to participate in the next round. So that to me suggests they were hearing both sides and trying to get something done. But then there is the steps taken by our country leadership, meaning presidential, or with the past five weeks, which have without exception, pleased the Kremlin, made it easier for Moscow to continue this war and made it harder for Ukraine to defend itself. They'd all started with the quote-unquote diesel deal, right? This is more money going to Moscow despite sanctions, which they used to feed their war machine. Then you have the Trump waving, all the sanctions of the Lindsey Graham sanctions bill on Russia, which Trump himself ensigned just three or four weeks ago. Then you have Trump's agreement to the Putin proposal for a trilateral summit of Xi, Putin, and Trump to quote-unquote figure out a way to end the war in Ukraine. No presence of Ukraine. Now, to his credit that if you were to say to take a little bit back, take back a little bit of that criticism from a decision. Trump said that he wanted to talk about nuclear disarmament, which Xi and Russia, which is a subject, makes sense for him to do. But still the whole sense of this is, it's going to be about ending the war. And you see stuff on the paper as he, but today and yesterday, where that says the theme. So I feel third step, benefits Russia, hurts Ukraine. Before this worst, that was the game play with Starlings and Starship, right, the satellite system, from Elon Musk company, to play with it so that Ukraine was unable to use it. It seems now for three separate small periods over the past four or so weeks. Those the intelligent receipts from them makes it easy for Ukraine to shoot down Russian drones, which are aiming at civilians and energy infrastructure and water facilities in Ukraine. This was a transparent effort by the administration to persuade Ukraine to quote unquote make compromises when Zalitsky has accepted pretty much every proposal Trump has put on the table since March of last year. And Putin has deflected or rejected every single one. So all those things together seem to pressure the victor to agree to additional concessions after they've already said yes to the most important concession, which was Trump's idea of establishing peace based upon the lines held by the two militaries, which means Russia continues to occupy the substantial part of the Ukrainian territory. Ambassador, there's a lot to a lot to dive into in that answer of yours. But first before we dive into that, we have to take that again. So yeah, we have to take a quick break, sir. We'll be back with more from Ambassador Herbst from the Atlantic Council, former ambassador to Ukraine. So stick around right here on the PDB situation report. Joining us once again is Ambassador John Herbstys, the former US ambassador to Ukraine and currently the senior director of the Atlantic Council's Eurasia Center. Mr. Ambassador, thank you very much for sticking around our here's here's this is apropos of nothing, sir, but I just kind of raised this because we've been talking about the negotiations and our envoys. I always thought we had a deeper bench of of envoys and diplomats. It does seem as if Steve Woodcock and Jared Kushner show up for everything. No matter what jurisdiction, what region of the world, those two show up. It's an interesting style. I assume it's the White House's desire to keep their circle of trusted advisors close. But it is surprising that they seem to pop into every overseas crisis and concern. Okay, you want to comment on that? Only if you're willing, only if you're willing to go. So look, it's very clear that Trump has his own strong particular views on how he wants conduct to close. So he wants people who he has wall trusted and people who will report directly to him. And not necessarily people who have a strong background on the subject or have a streak of independence. Now, I've annoyed many of my democratic friends by pointing out that the Trump one national security team was far stronger than the Biden national security team. But it seems that once he became used to being president, Trump decided he did not want to have around the authoritative, deeply experienced, deeply knowledgeable natural security. I think that's a mistake. I think the result of his diploma has demonstrated that. But he's the one who won the, you know, the, the electoral college and the popular vote in 2024 and not basically gets to make those choices. But it's a truly idiosyncratic style. I don't think it serves the interests of the country. And I don't think it's up to the not bad record of Trump one. Yeah, that's very interesting. Thank you for making that those comments. Let me ask you this, in all your years of experience. And again, this is, I know this is not a real science here, but from your perspective, what is it that would get Putin to sit down at the negotiating table in a meaningful way? I don't mean sticking to his maximum of demands. I mean actually compromising in a serious effort to wrap up his invasion of Ukraine after all these years. It's, it's really very simple. Putin believes that he can win this war. Even though it's been going on, I mean, obviously, it was going on since 2014. But since the big invasion, it's close to five years, right? And the death toll for Russian soldiers at the F financial times now reporting it, like 600 or even 650,000, an extraordinary death toll of, and even though he expected to take Kiev in the first few weeks, right? Did that happen? He hasn't even able to take Donbass nearly five years into the war. He thinks that Western leaders are leaders are weak, and he's been right about that, I'm sorry to say. And his aim is to cut off Western support for Ukraine, starting first and foremost with the United States. And he has been, I won't say completely successful on that, but partly successful. You want this war to stop? You want Trump to achieve his goal of a peace which is stable and leaves Ukraine standing, sovereign and economically viable at the end. Well, the end, Trump doesn't talk about that so much anymore, which is a problem. The way to do it is to persuade Putin to he'll only suffer more if he continues the war. So what that means, of course, is instead of playing games with star links, a star shield, we should be enabling the war you're creating attacks against the Russian hydrocarbon system. Against Russian production, military production plans against Russian ballistic missiles. If we opened up star shield for Ukraine to target Russian ballistic missiles, they would destroy many of those missiles at the destruction of the Ukrainian residential areas. Energy facilities, water facilities would drop substantially. If we actually impose the sanctions of the Lindsey Granville, the pressure on the Russian economy would grow. That's the obvious way to achieve a stable peace. Something which President Trump has done a little bit of when he sanctioned Ross Nefton Lugoyle in October last year. But because he's uncomfortable putting a two-bought war on Putin's forehead, right after he did that with the sanctions, we submitted the 28-point police plan to Ukraine. That was the one that Triscoll brought to Kiev in November, which was basically rooted in Moscow, a very embarrassing moment. Yeah. What is the reluctance? Is it just a hangover from the cold war, you know, and sort of the fear of a cataclysmic conflict? Is that what leads to the reluctance to push Putin? That was Biden's great weakness. Biden led Putin to intimidate him in making decisions on army in Ukraine with a nuclear threat. And to his great shame, he bought the full flimflat. I don't think that's Trump's it. I think Trump has this again peculiar. Yeah, I'm just using the relatively mild word deference here for Putin. But Biden kind of understood the threat that Putin's policies raised to the United States. He pointed that out three times, but only three times. Trump seems to spend more time smacking our out. realize the smacking our enemies, whether it's China or Russia. Yes, Iran's enemy is obviously smacked Iran, although not in a particularly stillful way, but against the two big bad boys, President Trump has not been a source of power and strength. I say that's sad this during the first year of with China. He was terrific, not so much now. And with Russia, he's never been terrific. Yeah, we, you know, we seem to your point on China. We do seem to have backed off. I was, I was a big fan of highlighting all of their very shenanigans over the decades and getting a focus on what they've done in the cost of their economic espionage and theft of intellectual property, et cetera. Well, Trump deserve credit, not just for turning around American policy during his first term, the Democrats basically followed that. So we were truly so significant development, but we don't see it now. It's really quite amazing. Let me, let me ask you this, you, you, you referred to sort of Putin's desire to, to outlast the West, but imparted to drive a wedge between the West and Ukraine in terms of their support. Do you view sort of what's been happening in the European Union? Is how we want to call it a soft war, sort of sabotage, whatever. Do you attribute a lot of the, the incidents to Russia at this point? Because there's, there's still some question. They, they, they, and I, the attribution is difficult at times. But I think the pattern is clear enough, but how impactful do you view what the Russians are up to in terms of trying to try to impact the European Union? I'm glad you raised this. I, I was going to bring it up, had you not. Oh, Putin's aggression, Putin desires to undermine the United States, do not end in Ukraine. It's been going on in Europe for years. It's what some people call a hybrid war, but it's actually more dangerous. Hyper war because the Russians have been actually following this policy for many, many years of predates, even Trump's first turn. But it's gone significantly worse starting in the spring of 24. So Biden's last year in office. And what Putin has tried to do is what intimidate Europe, so it stops supporting Ukraine, but to demonstrating to Europe and to the world that NATO is a paper type that he takes all these steps against NATO countries, not just, but this is the principal target. But you mentioned sub sabotage. You mentioned, uh, bombs being put or drove, uh, actually you didn't, you didn't mention just drone, drove suddenly appearing over airport to create problems. Um, the assassination or the attempt to assassination, uh, uh, military companies, leadership, the, uh, plans to put a ball on a D.H.L. plane, heading to Canada, the United States, all these things. And of course drones flying over NATO country is even exploding in NATO country. And there's a very little reaction from NATO, not not, not not, but very little. And, uh, trope, my Biden doesn't want to see this. So he accepts the ambiguity and says that his administration, just as Biden's administration says we don't know if the Russians actually did it. Look, I spent 31 years in the state department. I know that American diplomacy would draw conclusions on evidence that would not satisfy a jury in an American court. You don't have that level of high, high grain level of evidence in most cases in making major national security decisions. So again, Biden before it and Trump now say, well, we don't know if the Russians really do it. That means they don't have to answer it. But what's happening is they are telling Europeans our NATO allies, the U.S. will not defend you. And that's very dangerous. We're just in the provocations will grow greater. This is not a piece through strife policy. This is the type of weak policy that normally Republicans may fund on Democrats. And Team Trump suddenly made fun of Biden for it, but we're seeing a repetition of that same type of weakness. And yeah, I'm afraid we're seeing the same thing in life. And if Putin wins in Ukraine, for sure, all the stuff is going to go up. All it's going to be other was basically a lot more of it. And it only stops if we the United States as the leadership of the NATO Alliance demonstrates to Russia that they have a price to build a price to pay. And you know, Trump did this in turn one. Uh, cyber command during Trump's first turn. Uh, did a hack, a notable hack in Russian. Um, due to that public, they told the Russians privately that if he did not like this, you really don't want to interfere with our midterm elections in 2018. And the Russians did. But we know we, we don't, we, we, we saw nothing similar of the Biden. We've seen nothing similar control to. I think it's that, I think it's that, um, that back and forth, that inconsistency, I think that it creates not just confusion, but creates some instability that is definitely not in our, in the U.S. or our allies, best national interests, correct. Seeing it play out in, in Iran as well. Uh, yeah. And it's outrageous. Yes, seems. Hey, can steps against the Russians for giving Iran intelligence to kill American soldiers. Right. And there's been, there's been, there's been credible reporting as well, sir, about, about China doing. I'll, uh, the same. Yeah. Well, sir, I tell you, I, I've got, uh, a lot of questions left to throw your way, but what I don't have is, is time. Uh, um, so I am hopeful that the next time that we give you a call, you'll, you'll agree to come back on. I'll be happy if you've done the next. I'll be able to go. Yeah. Ha, ha, excellent. Excellent. Yes, there is no need for a student tie here on the situation report. That was ambassador, John Herbs, uh, great guy, a former ambassador to Ukraine. Now, senior director of the Atlantic Council's Eurasia Center. Well, that's all the time we have for this week's PDB situation report. I know, I know, but we'll be back next week. If you have any questions or comments, maybe you've got a humorous anecdote. Well, just send them our way. Reach out to me at PDB at the first TV dot com. Right. And if you want to watch the show, add free, you know, you can do that. Yeah, it's very simple. Actually, just become a premium member of the president's daily brief by visiting PDB premium dot com. I told you it was simple. Now, Mike Baker and I'll be back next time. But until then, stay informed, stay safe, stay cool. [Music]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. NVIDIA’s CEO Jensen Huang resigned amid allegations of an affair with a businesswoman suspected of spying for China, sparking renewed scrutiny over U.S. semiconductor export controls and Chinese access to advanced AI technology.
  2. The scandal has intensified bipartisan concerns about the integrity of U.S. export policies, particularly loopholes allowing indirect transfers of sensitive chips via third-party entities like MegaSpeed.
  3. Financial institutions, especially those with U.S. dollar operations, have a legal obligation to police such transfers, and U.S. authorities could subpoena foreign banks to investigate trade-linked intelligence diversion.
  4. Delays in sanctioning MegaSpeed—despite over a year of reporting—have raised questions about internal decision-making, including potential influence from close ties between Huang and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnik.
  5. The U.S.-China AI race remains competitive, with U.S. leadership in open-source AI research and global standards, but risks from unchecked influence or espionage are elevating national security concerns.
  6. Russia and Ukraine’s peace talks in Abu Dhabi yielded only limited progress, with no ceasefire or resolution of territorial disputes, and both sides showing unwillingness to compromise.
  7. U.S. diplomatic efforts, including backing of Russian war funding and limited sanctions, have been criticized as undermining Ukrainian defense and weakening pressure on Putin.
  8. Experts warn that inconsistent U.S. policy—particularly under the current administration—fuels Russian aggression and undermines NATO’s unity, creating instability in both Europe and the Indo-Pacific.

Summary:

S. advanced AI technology and export controls. The incident has prompted a broader investigation into loopholes allowing indirect chip transfers via third parties like MegaSpeed, with financial institutions seen as key enablers or monitors.

Critics point to delays in sanctioning MegaSpeed, potentially due to political influence or bureaucracy, raising questions about internal decision-making at the Commerce Department. S. officials and experts emphasize the need for stronger enforcement, transparency, and legislative action to close these loopholes.

Meanwhile, Russia and Ukraine’s peace talks in Abu Dhabi made only limited progress, with no ceasefire or resolution of core territorial disputes. Both sides remain unwilling to compromise, highlighting a lack of political will to end the war. S.

diplomatic efforts—such as funding Russia and avoiding strong sanctions—have been criticized for weakening Ukraine’s position and enabling continued aggression. S. policy, especially under the current administration, fosters Russian hybrid warfare and undermines NATO’s credibility, risking deeper instability in Europe and beyond.

S. strategic interests.

FAQs

Jensen Huang resigned as CEO of NVIDIA following revelations of an affair with a businesswoman suspected by U.S. intelligence of spying for China. While the company has stated there's no evidence of national security compromise, the scandal intensified scrutiny over China's access to U.S. AI technology and led to broader concerns about corporate espionage.

The resignation sparked renewed national security concerns, as the affair with an alleged Chinese intelligence asset highlighted vulnerabilities in the supply chain. It underscored the potential for insider threats and raised questions about how effectively U.S. export controls and corporate policies are protecting sensitive technology from being diverted to China.

Financial institutions are responsible for monitoring and policing transactions involving export-controlled chips. They have legal obligations to stop financing or providing services for deals that could violate U.S. export laws, especially when such deals involve cutouts like MegaSpeed, which allegedly facilitated technology transfers to China.

MegaSpeed, reportedly run by an individual linked to Chinese intelligence, was allegedly involved in transferring restricted AI chips to China. The delay in sanctioning the company suggests potential internal political or process issues, raising concerns about transparency, accountability, and the effectiveness of U.S. enforcement mechanisms.

Reports indicate a close relationship between Huang and Lutnik, which may have given NVIDIA undue influence over decisions related to export controls. This raises serious concerns about the independence of the Commerce Department and whether corporate interests could be shaping national security policy.

The negotiations produced limited progress, including a prisoner exchange, but failed to resolve major issues like a ceasefire or territorial disputes. Both sides remain unwilling to make significant concessions, and the talks are seen as more symbolic than substantive, with no clear path to a lasting peace.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.