Go back

The New Bachelor Does Not Have A Seat At The Table - Viall Files+ Preview

11m 52s

The New Bachelor Does Not Have A Seat At The Table  - Viall Files+ Preview

Sam Hartman, an NFL practice squad quarterback, is facing criticism from fellow football players for appearing on *The Bachelor*, sparking a broader conversation about athlete identity and the perceived legitimacy of reality TV success. Despite his minimal playing experience, Hartman’s entry into media highlights the emotional and cultural tension between football’s traditional identity and the public fascination with fame beyond the field. Many athletes, including Clay Harbor and Jesse Palmer, have similar trajectories—having played professionally and then transitioning to entertainment—yet still face judgment for stepping outside their athletic roles. This backlash stems from a deep-rooted identity crisis among athletes, who have spent years being celebrated as icons, often with their lives centered around the game. The transition to reality TV is seen as a betrayal of that legacy, not just professionally but emotionally, as players struggle to re-claim their place in public life. While some, like Aaron Rogers’ brother Jordan, have successfully made the shift, others face intense scrutiny. The discussion reveals a larger cultural divide: athletes may dismiss reality TV as frivolous, yet the desire for visibility, attention, and validation remains universal. Ultimately, the story reflects how success in one domain—sports—can be challenged by achievement in another, especially when it disrupts long-held identities.

Transcription

2247 Words, 11924 Characters

English
What's going on everybody? What you are about to hear is a little sneak peak of some vophiles plus content in our pop extra episode where we talk about relevant pop culture topics and nothing's more relevant right now than your new bachelor. Mr. Sam Hartman, who's also is he an NFL player? What do the NFL players think about it? Anyways, Jimmy and I dive deep more into our thoughts and feelings about the casting and all things. Mr. bachelor, Sam Hartman, and it's a lot of fun. So I hope you enjoy what you're about to listen to. If you like what you hear, there's more of that great content behind vophiles plus in addition to that. We also have Ed free episodes for all vophiles episodes. So if you like what you hear, be sure to go to vophiles.com to sign up. You'll be glad that you did. That would be an interesting move. I don't I wonder if the bachelor would would do that. He's an NFL quarterback. Like and I know like the like football players are now like, I don't have you seen all the backlash. He's getting from the NFL community. Oh, yeah. Now he is so for all the ladies that that were hoping for a chance at the wag life. He is not being embraced by his actual football peers is he does not have a seat at the table. No, no, he is he's being ostracized and people are like, wait, this guy's trading an R fucking cloud. He's like, he doesn't play. He hasn't played. He's never played a snap in the NFL is my understanding. Yeah, he's now on the practice squad. No, he's no, he got cut. Oh, he's not cut and then rejoined the practice squad. Yes. And then he just posted a tick talk and he's like, thank you bachelor nation. I have to get back to running or I have to get back to the day of job running around throwing the football. All the focus is there. But once the season wraps, I can't wait to join and meet all the beautiful women. Okay. So he is technically employed by the NFL. He is not unemployed. Do you think it's fair that the guys are judging him or do you feel like this is a Jackson Olsen being judged for his tick talks kind of moment? It's just guy shit, man. I brought this up when I first did reality TV like I used to be like that. I used to look down on reality TV and like scoff and be dismissive because we we for whatever reason like I remember my mindset in that moment in those locker rooms. There's like a superior thing that we feel like we're just like above reality TV. Like I don't know where that came from. Maybe it's like a historical thing because like, you know, like the misogyny, like the it's a show for girls and guys. I don't I don't fucking know. I don't think it's not. I think it's my I imagine. Listen, I think it takes a unique, I do think it takes for people to talk about our feelings and shit. But it was never. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I guess what I'm trying to say is I think listen, some of the biggest stars in reality TV, they have talent, right? And there's a there's a unique talent that become that is to be good at this whole reality TV thing. But that being said, I think the athlete, you know, like I think athletes, but that talent is like kind of subjective and I think harder to find and but an athlete's more like, yeah, the years they've put in the the where it's just like the idea that anyone can sign up for reality TV show and be famous and not anyone can sign up and become a professional athlete. Like this is a real skill, like quote unquote. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, I think it I think it has more to do with that. But no, but it what's his name? Fucking Clay, Clay Harbor. Yeah. That's the clip I saw. Clay. Well, Clay was was on the bachelor. Yeah. You know, you're okay. So, you know, he's from Chicago. I've been building a couple of times. He's from Chicago. So this is the guy who this is a football player. And he and Clay had like almost attending your career, if not, which is an exception. I mean, the average career in the NFL is three years. So he tripled that. So here, but he's a man who went on reality TV. So he's done both. And I think and he highly critical. I think because again, whether whether it's Sam's choice or not, and it's honestly not, but I'm sure he's leaning in. I'm sure he's no problem with him leaning in, but they're really lighting up the really leaning on his, you know, NFL quarterback. And by all accounts, you know, him make it to the league, even on the practice squad, is an accomplishment in of itself. But yeah, if when it when it's positioned is you haven't you having done more in that world than you actually did for the people who've done more, they're going to be like, nah, fuck that. You're not one of us, you know, and you you don't get to pretend to be one of us for some ass. Right. You know, that's so true. I'll tell you what though, whether they're going to be hate watching or not, they're still going to be watching. For sure, man, the fact that they're even speaking on it, the fact that Rob, Grand Cowsky, Grand Cowsky, I can't talk to you, Gronk, and Julian Edaman, two legends are speaking on this is, yeah, man, that's great. You know, who's opinion I'd like to hear is the Kelsey brothers because they lean kind of on the other side of things. I wonder what they would think what they would say. Yeah, I would expect them to have something to say at some point. Yeah, I wonder because Aaron or not Aaron Rogers, what's his name, Jordan Rogers. He also, Joe Joe's now husband, he was also like, there's so many athletes that have been on the show. He's also like, he like now is a sports commentator, right? Yeah, because Aaron Rogers is brother. Right. Exactly. But like Sam Hartman, no, he got, he got, he had even a less of a successful career than Sam Hartman. He had like a cup of coffee on the practice squad. I think maybe two pre seasons, but I don't think he ever actually made the team during the season. I could be maybe one year. I don't know, but it was, it was, yeah, but you know, it's his, his brother at the time was the best quarterback in the world. And so you know, like that, obviously, like people are going to be curious about you. They know your name. They're hoping to find lightning in the bottle. And, you know, and from a media standpoint, Aaron Rogers brother, I mean, like, that's why, like, and again, this was at a time when Aaron Rogers was like the MVP of the league. Am I missing something that his brother go on bachelor or something? Yeah, his brother one, his brother one, yeah. Aaron Rogers brother one bachelor. Yeah. Jordan and Joe, Joe was the bachelor at, and they're now married. Wow. Yeah. News to me. Wow. It was iconic. Great. I had no idea. Well, Jesse Palmer. I wonder if he got a lot of shit. I mean, Jesse Palmer, yeah. I'm sure he did back in that time. Jesse actually played. I believe he was an actual backup quarterback. Yeah. So he, it's, I just looked at that. He played quarterback at the University of Florida and spent five seasons in the NFL, primarily with how many snaps did he get? How many snaps did he get? Let me what does that even mean? Snaps like this. Yeah, yeah. We're not tracked during his playing career. We did not begin publicly recording individual snap participation until 2012. He was 2001 to 2006. How many plays did, how many games did he play in? 141 recorded offensive plays across eight career regulars. So he had 141 offensive. Okay, 141. Yes. And then he played across eight career regular season games. You know what I want to say about hand officer penalties? Just athletes and in general, like, because I wrestled with this when I first pivoted from basketball to TikTok and then TikTok created all this other stuff is a lot of athletes, like professional athletes, that was, that's been their entire life. So the thought of another athlete being able to do something else in like that at that level. I'm telling you, a lot of them, it's hard to admit because it's an identity crisis moment. We all kind of go through. It's like, all right, now who am I without the game of basketball, without the game of football? So there's like a, I think there's a little bit of jealousy and like envy and seeing somebody else be so accomplished in another industry so fast. There's also particularly with football. There's an identity crisis because if you're not, you know, the Kelsey brothers or a quarterback of the team, people don't even know what you look like. You're wearing a helmet, you know. And so you have, you could be a linebacker who has a 10 year career, Clay Harbor. Yeah. I mean, I'm a huge football fan and I had never heard the name Clay Harbor before he went on the Bachelor at. And this guy had an incredible career by all accounts. And there's just so, you know, that every team has 55 players. They're all wearing helmets like you don't know like every, you know, you don't know everyone's name. And so, but these, these guys are again, professional football players. And then to your point, they leave. And they're, you know, when they're playing and, you know, they come out of the field, like all the fans are just like, you know, they know you, right? And, but like, and then some of these guys moved to LA. And you're right. And they're hanging out with guys like me who are like, yeah, people are asking to take pictures. And everyone knows my name. And, you know, you had a yada yada. And people are like, and, and it's like, oh, you played football like for, you know, and they're like, and they, you know, yeah, they're, I think it's definitely a transitional moment for a lot of them. And it's not just like when, when we say we dedicate our lives, especially football, like you put your body through the ringer, like your body is forever changed, often like your brain is too. And like, to have to re-prove yourself, like to just kind of start over and feel like all that work. But forget about the training. Forget about the training. If you are a stud football player who made it to the NFL, chances are you've been a stud football ball player since you were first time you were, and for the first time you played ball, which means that like, you were the center of attention when you showed up, people treated you differently. You were the local celebrity and then you went off to college and then you were the celebrity on campus and you were the big deal and you were being talked on national television in yada yada yada and like every opening game where it was like, you know, you got to introduce him again, when you go to the stadium, you can fan, scream your name, you sign autographs, yada yada, then you go to the pros, right? And then again, the love, you know, like you get signed by the Green Bay Packers, the Buffalo Bills. He's like franchises, but the fans are like, it's a religion, right, like people are treating these guys like gods, right? And then like, so their whole life, they've been proud of pedestal and put on a pedestal and then they're done and they're like, some of them, you know, some of them, you know, again, a lot of these guys have, you know, every, all of them go through a transition. But to your point, the ones you're talking about, the ones that have a dream of maybe something more, something in media, something, you know, something in entertainment, something that keeps the fame apart. They just want that feeling. The attention. Right. Keep the attention going, that, that is a huge, like that. Those guys, those guys come to a fucking, like that, that's a cold, fucking shower, you know, when you're standing next to a fucking guy like me and the bachelor and you're getting, you're just getting overshadowed. So it's like when someone peaks in high school, but they just like peaked with their career. And then they see other people peaking at different, in different areas and that's a little different because like I, yeah, listen, peaking in high school, if you peaked in high school, you're a loser.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Sam Hartman, an NFL practice squad quarterback, is facing backlash from fellow football players for appearing on *The Bachelor*, despite having limited playing experience.
  2. Many NFL athletes feel a sense of identity crisis when transitioning into reality TV, seeing it as a betrayal of their athletic legacy and professional identity.
  3. The NFL community, including legends like Gronk and Julian Edelman, is publicly questioning Sam Hartman’s legitimacy, highlighting a divide between athletes and reality TV success.
  4. Historical context shows that football players often feel deeply invested in their identity tied to the game, making the shift to entertainment seem like a personal and professional betrayal.
  5. Athletes like Clay Harbor and Jesse Palmer, who also appeared on *The Bachelor*, had real playing careers, yet still face scrutiny for pursuing fame outside football.
  6. The fame and attention from reality TV contrast sharply with the quiet, structured life of a professional athlete, creating emotional dissonance.
  7. The perception that Sam Hartman is "trading an R cloud" reflects deeper cultural tensions around respect, authenticity, and perceived success in different fields.
  8. While athletes may dismiss reality TV as trivial, the demand for visibility and validation suggests a universal human need for recognition beyond athletic achievement.

Summary:

Sam Hartman, an NFL practice squad quarterback, is facing criticism from fellow football players for appearing on *The Bachelor*, sparking a broader conversation about athlete identity and the perceived legitimacy of reality TV success. Despite his minimal playing experience, Hartman’s entry into media highlights the emotional and cultural tension between football’s traditional identity and the public fascination with fame beyond the field. Many athletes, including Clay Harbor and Jesse Palmer, have similar trajectories—having played professionally and then transitioning to entertainment—yet still face judgment for stepping outside their athletic roles.

This backlash stems from a deep-rooted identity crisis among athletes, who have spent years being celebrated as icons, often with their lives centered around the game. The transition to reality TV is seen as a betrayal of that legacy, not just professionally but emotionally, as players struggle to re-claim their place in public life. While some, like Aaron Rogers’ brother Jordan, have successfully made the shift, others face intense scrutiny.

The discussion reveals a larger cultural divide: athletes may dismiss reality TV as frivolous, yet the desire for visibility, attention, and validation remains universal. Ultimately, the story reflects how success in one domain—sports—can be challenged by achievement in another, especially when it disrupts long-held identities.

FAQs

Sam Hartman is a former NFL quarterback who participated in the 'Bachelor' show, where he was a contestant. Despite his brief NFL career, he gained significant public attention through the reality program.

Sam Hartman has not played a regular-season game in the NFL. He was on the practice squad and later rejoined it, but he has not made a regular-season appearance, and his playing career is considered limited.

Many NFL players are critical of Sam Hartman because they view his reality TV appearance as a betrayal of their profession. They feel he doesn't fully understand the demands or achievements of professional football.

Many NFL athletes feel a sense of identity crisis when peers transition into entertainment, as their entire identity is tied to their football careers. This can lead to jealousy, envy, or resentment.

Yes, Jordan Rogers, brother of Aaron Rogers, appeared on a previous Bachelor season and is now married to the show’s host. Other players like Jesse Palmer also had careers in the NFL before entering public life.

The practice squad is a group of players who are not on the active roster but are kept for training and development. Being on the practice squad indicates a player has some level of NFL involvement, though not a full-time role.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.