The Nations Pod: Wales back to earth yet? Did Rassie go too far?
1h 5m 44s
The podcast explores multiple interconnected themes, beginning with Cadillac’s entry into Formula One, where precision, performance, and engineering align to deliver a luxury performance experience through the V Series lineup. This is followed by a detailed account of Whole Foods Market’s commitment to quality, particularly in offering antibiotic-free meat for Thanksgiving, emphasizing trust and taste. The central narrative focuses on Wales’ dramatic victory over New Zealand, a moment of national pride that triggered widespread emotional reactions across generations, highlighting rugby’s deep cultural roots in Wales. The emotional impact is described as unprecedented, with many grown men in their 30s and 40s crying, underscoring rugby’s unifying power. The discussion also turns to commentary, emphasizing authenticity over pre-written lines, drawing a parallel to the 1966 World Cup moment when Hugh Jones delivered a raw, unscripted line. A critical section examines South African coach Rassie Erasmus, whose allegations of match-fixing and officiating issues are challenged as deflective and politically motivated, especially given his history of post-defeat criticism. Commentators argue that the new World Rugby framework on match officials is fair, and that TMOs are under intense pressure, making such claims unrealistic. The broader context reveals tensions in modern rugby—balancing safety, speed, and physicality—while celebrating the emotional intensity that defines great sporting moments. The segment concludes with a reflective question on whether a single victory can offset years of national hardship, suggesting that for many, the emotional resonance of a moment like this far outweighs mere statistical achievement.
This BBC Podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
Formula One is all about precision, tiny margins, massive ambition, flat out performance.
And that's exactly why it's exciting to see Cadillac entering Formula One,
bringing an American luxury brand with performance pedigree onto the biggest stage in motorsport.
But this isn't just about the grid.
That same racing mindset, the obsession with engineering, the pursuit of perfection,
gives in the Cadillac V Series lineup, giving you the chance to experience the precision and performance of the grid on the open road.
Cadillac V Series, distinctive luxury performance, engineered to thrill.
Discover the V Series lineup at Cadillac.com.
At Whole Foods Market, chef inspired flavors meet industry leading quality standards, especially for Thanksgiving.
There are no antibiotics in their meat department, ever, so their fresh turkeys and spiral cut hams bring rich satisfying flavors you can taste in each bite.
No compromises, just quality and peace of mind you can share with every guest at your table.
Celebrate the season with a holiday spread from Whole Foods Market.
Five lives rugby union weekly.
Right, rugby union weekly. Week three.
Or is it week six of the inaugural 2026 Nations Championship.
And there is an insane amount to talk about.
And we've only just got together. When's they lunchtime guys?
We could have done this on Saturday night, couldn't we?
If felt like we should have nations podded on the wisteling card.
We couldn't grow was in a terrible state.
And it was blubbing his eyes out.
It had been about an hour of a man crying.
We could have done it Friday night.
I was I was ready to go Friday after that game with all right, but there's no need to cover all the other games.
Let's just do.
South Africa Friday, will it?
South Africa France, let's not even bother with the politics of South African rugby.
I just want to do pure rugby porn, which was Friday night.
And yeah, nothing will get better than Friday night and so.
So well, I don't know, I don't know what what a week.
How does it feel?
I think we I think in Wales we come to terms with it.
It's certainly be the case that.
Welsh people to a person have enjoyed the past few days.
And apologetically so.
It's the first time in.
Living memory, I can remember a victory where there are no caveats.
Where when somebody occasionally may say, oh, you know, but this was not the strongest in New Zealand teams.
Or didn't score many points in the 20 in the last 20 minutes.
This is unsustainable yadda yadda yadda.
I think the default position is by the other person on the other side of the conversation is like, yeah, whatever.
Whatever mate, whatever.
And I am going over old ground.
I'm repeating what others have said.
I have rarely seen anything like the final whistle on Saturday.
The amount of in particular grown men between the ages of 38 and 70 who were crying everywhere.
Why 38?
That's the specific 38.
37 year olds.
It didn't mean much.
I think that.
What's Jamie's age?
Jamie's 40, just and 40 I think Jamie Roberts.
He was the first to go.
And just all around all around that combination of youngsters dancing.
And a lot of women dancing in kids.
And for some reason, men of a certain vintage slumped in their seat on their sofas sucking it all in.
And just taking in the enormity of it.
Had a conversation with somebody in the office the other day and an eternal debate in Wales is which is the biggest sport football or rugby.
That starts the back football.
You're a 2016 back football, the World Cup in Qatar would back football.
The reaction of the nation on Saturday and Sunday morning will tell you that Welsh International rugby has a grip on the psyche of the nation that nothing else can reach.
100% and I think this has shown that hasn't it?
This win and the two days, three days after, has shown us how there is just a thread through Welsh rugby, Welsh society, Welsh generations that rugby brings all together.
Because there's such a rich history in Welsh rugby which there might not, there isn't a Welsh football, let's be honest.
I mean, they haven't been to World Cup since 1958, had they before the recent one.
Yeah, and just to chip in all the issues Welsh rugby's had, when there is an historic day like that, it reminds me of '05 and the 27 year wait for a grand slam.
That's when all of those sort of generational stories that bring families together and shows how much rugby means to the nation.
Yeah, and Welsh football is more diverse, Cardiff on the FA Cup in 1927. There are still some Swansea City fans who refuse to support Wales because they have some associate or they certainly, there certainly was 10, 15 years ago because of an association with the Union Jack Blavlar.
I know that there are small numbers there, but my point being, a bit like football in Newcastle often rugby in Wales is the unifying force.
On Saturday night, and obviously everyone was gripped by the story on Saturday night, I went on to Google and I tapped in, how do you learn how to sing the Welsh national anthem?
It was my intention here because I was still caught up in it, my intention was to come on here today and sing it for you.
Shoot, go on, you must have won. I know, you see, but I was going, and there was a great website there in a talker to each word, how to pronounce each word and all the rest, I was all over it.
I was going to do something nice for you, but I did.
But then I was saying to myself, it was not one else in the house at the time, I was saying to myself, I'm going to do this, I'm going to do this, I'm going to get very hard, and then I thought, hang on.
The Welsh nation are on a high, they don't need me butchering this and ruining the whole thing for them.
Just for context, next time you're listening, so glad, glad, glad means country.
And then, forever, you remember that glad, it's a GWLAT, and then the payoff, which you'll most of you remember, and some people go down, others go up, I tend to be a tradition as I go down.
And that's all let it be that the old language survives. Yeah, beautiful, love it.
Peaceful, love it. I have so many messages in, and I'm going to read a few, and I think we'll go come back to Wales when we preview Australia, so we'll do more on Wales R and that incredible day in Cardiff.
But the messages I had in, came thick and fast, they were just a couple. Shout out to Groastifer after his commentary, self-flaggillation, flaggillation last week.
Shout out for his and the teams, immaculate description of the Wales victory, perfect balance of emotion and composure.
Another one, please pass on the most enormous congratulations to grow after all the years of pain, the tribulations of Rome.
Yeah, with your bag, no one deserves this as much as he does. Every single rep you know, we weekly listeners, about his pain, have several beers tonight, grow.
That was obviously said on Saturday. And this one, which I think where we'll sort of start the pod in earnest, from James, can you touch on Rassie?
To what extent is what he is saying correct, are we hip, knee drop? He said both tackles, before addressing the ridiculous nature of comments regarding match fixing.
I know it's not quite nation's pod relevant, but we'll be in the build up to the island game. Thanks and James finished what I was saying.
So excited to hear grow actually excited and happy and not sounding like a Welsh ear.
I think the point being made is how long have we been doing this four years?
Four years ago, I was dismissive of you and your Scottish mates Tom and over in real time in documentary format.
We've just seen a demise of a nation and of a person's character that was reduced to what I was last week.
But I'm back, baby. Well, no, I don't even believe that.
Before we get on to Rassie, and obviously there's a world stuff to debate there. You guys are commentators, you've commentated on the most amazing games.
I've never commentated and I couldn't give anything more difficult and harrowing to commentate because I just thought it was the hardest job.
Grow for you. When you're getting to four or five minutes from full time and you're thinking, "Oh my god, this is the biggest day of my commentating life and people are going to. "
Were you thinking people could be listening to this for the rest of time?
Do you get nervous in moments like that? When you're coming back to you, do you get nervous?
Do you want to go first, Chris? No, no, you guys. Yeah, you were there today.
I mean, I don't believe any commentator who doesn't say they don't prepare for what they're about to say.
And you spend time driving to a ground thinking, working out each very scenario on your head and the follow-up line you're going to go with.
for and I'd certainly thought pre-game that if if if the final whistle goes on the inevitable
happens or the no the incredible happens I wanted to get something along the sentiment that
Edwards didn't do it and JPR and all those people so that was always sitting in the back of my
mind and then at half time you do the same thing again you reset yourself and you go right
I'll be completely honest when the game is that tense and that nervous and I think in 20 years
time I'll be a little bit more experienced and others might may have the ability to be able to
just sit back on 77 minutes ago okay let's compose myself and and double check what I'm about to
say I did not have that skill at the time and some of the lines I said I said Wales and the gutter
I don't know where that come from and I was on the final whistle I say something like Welch if
you're Welsh enjoy this that was certainly not my plan and some of the things that on the final
whistle do rush back to you so you want to get them in because you've thought about those things
long and hard because you actually do think that they are the important points to make at the time
and then there are other things that just land at your feet because of the pictures and what's
been painted in front of you are you again you're still frustrated that you stumble over a line or two
but the beauty of it Chris I guess is knowing history and context and meaning but also trying
you're very best delivered in the moment at the same time and that is a really difficult
challenge couldn't agree more I remember when I was on the way preparing to commentate on
England against Africa in the World Cup final in 2019 and nearly everyone thought England would
win that year and I was inundated with messages from colleagues former colleagues you know with
tips and really helpful advice and you know all in the context of what happened in 2003 and he
in Robinson's iconic commentary that has lived forever 23 years on still a sort of those names
etched in kind of English rugby folklore and I was getting a lot of people so almost sort of saying
what are you going to say what are you going to say and I really really made and since I remember
being asked the way to 2023 World Cup final what are you going to say at the final whistle and I was
like nothing I'm not going to say anything because I don't know how the game is going to go to
gross point you would have written down your notes 2003 Johnny Wilkinson Sydney you'd have something
in you know Johnny Wilkinson Sydney Owen Farrell in Tokyo you might have something just written down
as part of your prep but I don't think you should ever go into a big game like that with pre prepared
lines because then you you miss what the story could be there could be people dancing on the pitch
there could have been a pitch invasion um you you know when South Africa won the World Cup in 2023
they won the final by a point they won every knockout game by a point and that just came to me like
with about ten minutes five minutes to go I was like they're going to win every knockout game by a
point but you couldn't have predicted that before the game you're not going to before the game go
what happens if they win by a point you go wow they're winning by a point here they won by a point
last week and the week before so I think it's really important because commentators aren't
actors you're not pre preparing a script you're not reading a line you are trying to um get across
the moment and I think Road did that amazingly and definitely yet have a few things written down
these Welsh players haven't done it these Welsh guys are the heroes but I you get caught up
in trying to read you know read out a line people will see through it it won't be authentic and a
quick shout to the Sarah on five live to Kenyth on Radio Wales the Dav Jones and Roddy Cymru
to get a child on S4C each person had its had their own individual take and I think they were all
as powerful as each other yeah and yeah it was just one of those moments that's your 1966 moment
girl do you know you might know it seriously all joking aside there are some Welsh but on the
pitch I'm one of them all joking aside I mean you you might never have another day like that again
and you nailed it and give it up now and I thought it was brilliant listening to you watching it
obviously it was immense listening to you I was so happy for you as well not just because you
went because you nailed the commentary can I just just follow up on that 1966 ITV commentary of that
game Kenneth Wolf and Stone was on BBC he was Hugh Jones a Welshman who commented on that game
and this shows because this is the lesson that Hugh that Chris said you know do not pre-prepared
because that is the greatest unprepared line you could ever go for isn't it there are some people
on the pitch they think it's all over it is now you know you you'll never beat that it's an
impossibility that he was scripted Hugh Jones and I paraphrase some said something of the long
the lines of if Hearst scores here England win the World Cup he has he has he has which is in
no way a poor line and to my mind almost it's the safest one and the one I'd be you know I'd be
delighted to have just rolled that over but Wolf is done serendipitously life came at him
and he just nailed it to me and you wouldn't pre-prepared go he has he has he has yeah you would
pre-prepare something going he has the man from the Eastside you'd be like oh god all crins so yeah
anyway that's what I mean he was always like this literally it's really it's great it's not true
it's not true it's natural um I feel like we've had two wholesome starts this pod we're going to
have to lower the toe by talking about grassy wrestlers one on message and I will be split I'd like
just um sprinkling some messages through this pod because I've got loads written down in no
particular order but this one may be chuckled from Glenn Williams um because I put something on
Instagram's day saying nation's pod on the way and he goes yes been waiting on this one my tide
which is Welsh for grandfather correct the fun wrong Christopher yeah my tide Yanto gruff it from
Kenathan was born five days after Wales beat the all blacks in 1953 and he finally let go of his
awful hairline five days before Saturday so even though we're great fully got to witness the win
the family joke is he never saw Wales win with a full head of hair
uh anyway right so James's point after but well before he called um it's called grow well she
although grow grow used to be a well she or now he's like a completely
just he's he's he's he's donkey donkey now see if I'm from Shrek did you watch did you watch a well
show did you watch Harry and Phil did you watch Harry and Phil did chums yeah oh god yeah oh okay to
remember Kevin the teenager yes he was he was Kevin the teenager and then he had um that night
reverse reverse so on so he had he had he had he had the night where he met a girl and you know
an important part of his adolescence happened and he comes down there this morning with his hair
no matter guy um he lost his virginity and he came down the next morning with his hair covenias
morning mother morning father and it's like grow after Wales beat New Zealand he's suddenly like
hello everybody um that was some happy go lucky man anyway your virginity on Saturday that
grows that what we're saying yeah well he also he's the illegitimate I'm so tempted to make
a number of inappropriate so I'm gonna just I know I know I never got there on the nation's body
but anyway I hope people got what I was getting at um so no no more or well she up at James's
point can you touch on rassy to what extent is he saying correct um before addressing the
victorious nature of comments got a match fixing I know it's not quite nationwide relevant but
we'll be in the build up to the island game so where do we want to start on the Razia Rasmus thing
he did a a nuclear press conference in Dublin on Monday where he raised loads of issues but in
particular used was was was pointing the finger at the officiating around the knee drop tackles
which is where defenders dropped their knees before making a tackle which has been a big focus
of world rugby along with the hip drop tackle which is when from behind you kind of use your body
way to pull the player onto you and it can be caught or you want the body and it can be quite
dangerous um and a Rasmus felt that that was either negligence or he used the term match fixing
world rugby since July have had this new process around criticism match officials this 100%
smashed through the threshold so they whacking with an immediate six game ban say rugby have since
said they want a proper hearing and that will take place in the fullness of time so that is where
we are and inevitably the reaction has been loud yeah um under 16 stroke 17 knee drop tackles
I think a few of our colleagues have gone through each one of them and there's there's some of them
are simultaneous which is okay um there's a couple there you might look at but it's not serious
filed play so I'm not sure what the TMO can do in those instances so um I think he is uh but even
if there were even if there were a lot of knee drop tackles that weren't picked up in no way does
it justify him alleging uh match fixing um impunity, integrity of the match officials it's all the
more dark when you consider what he's done in the past and the repercussions of what he's done
in the past and they bury and all that uh we in burns and he's gone again and it's I found it
hilarious on Saturday night when he spoke uh he said oh in terms of the result all we let ourselves
down and we let the country down I thought that was a hysterical overreaction but then all of
his the he's called followers in South African rugby going yes rassy you let ourselves down and
you let the country down so there's aping his line and then he comes out and he goes about the 17
knee drop tackles and if this is alleging conspiracy and they're all going it's like the life of Brian
you know uh he's not the Messiah he's a very naughty boy and this is
They're just constantly trot out Rassi's line,
like he's some mishianic figure.
And he's not, he's at it, like.
I mean, this is deflection tactics.
This is a head of Ireland, a head of a very tough game.
He's coming up with this siege mentality stuff,
this victimhood stuff.
And he's throwing Matio Lippurini, the TMO,
onto the bus.
He doesn't give a toss what might happen to Matio Lippurini.
I went down Twitter yesterday, and I said,
here we come again, the kind of victimhood thing,
the kind of the mark-out rage that he was coming out with.
And the abuse that I got from South African fans
was ridiculous.
I can only imagine what else is out there.
And Rassi knows he unleashes the beasts
when he comes up with this stuff.
And I think it's reckless and objectionable.
And I think he's gone off lightly with six games.
Do you want to go across?
Yeah, I mean, there's so much to say.
I think where Erasmus loses any kind of validity
in his argument about player welfare or about inconsistency,
because yeah, as you say, Tom, and we don't want to be saying
that all South Africans are represented
by their online fan base, but their online fan base
is a very, very loud and very specific one, not least,
because there's a huge number of people in South Africa
compared to some other rugby nations, particularly
in this part of the world.
But he loses the strength of his argument
when the three times he's gone nuclear, which his followers
would say is for the good of the game
and he's raising inconsistencies
and he's calling out World Rugby.
But they've all come after defeats, haven't they?
They've all come after defeats, naturally.
2021 Lions first test, 2022 France in that autumn game,
and just now, all come after a defeat.
And a bit that does need to be, I think, mentioned
is these TMOs are in a, an invidious position
doesn't do a justice, because not just
is there a crackdown on hip drop tackles
and knee drop tackles to go with the crackdown on high shots.
So we're looking at almost three different types
of tackles that are now under the microscope,
because I'm thinking that the TMO towards the end
of that game, he is thinking, I can't miss a high shot.
I can't miss a high shot that could be exposed later
as being a high shot.
So he's going to be on the guard for a high shot
and maybe then the knee drop, he's looking for a PRD
to kind of say to the players, look,
make sure it's simultaneous and keep up with the tackle.
So I think it's really hard because the TMOs now
have extra things to scrutinize since the knee drop
and the hip drop have come more into law.
But also, at a big summit with the World Rugby referees
recently, they agreed the TMOs would only come in
if things are clear and obvious and dangerous and reckless.
And this was signed off by all the head coaches,
including Rassy.
So they've all sat in a room and I'm told it was
a 20 minute unanimous discussion.
This is what we're looking for and this is the role of the TMO.
So that is a little bit, that puts the TMOs
in a really tough situation where they are both
being told to look out for more stuff
but their scope is smaller.
And that is really, really hard for them.
And there will be things missed.
And when I was in with the World Rugby referees,
one of the upshot from that meeting was,
the game is imperfect, things will get missed,
let's really nail the clear and obvious.
And all those knee drop tackles, as you say,
there aren't that many that are clear and obvious.
A couple that have been highlighted by South African rugby
commentators are textbook tackles.
For example, across at his best, there might be one or two.
But are they hitting the threshold to be reckless
and dangerous and to get that TMO interference
when the TMO has been told to stay out
unless you have to come in.
And then the referee maybe needs to say,
look, get some kind of comms in it.
Quite a few knees are going to the ground.
Let's keep that up and maybe he was saying that.
But Razzie has a responsibility having signed off
these edicts to understand things are imperfect,
things will get missed.
And for the good of the game, this is what has been agreed.
And by coming out and saying, oh, there is a borderline knee
drop tackle that needs to be picked up for South Africa's benefit.
He's missing the bigger point, which is what was agreed,
how the game will be officiated going forward.
Because we don't, if you want more TMO,
if you want more TMO, be careful you wishful.
Because if you want the TMO's in every five minutes,
they could be in every five seconds with the game where the game is.
The number of rucks, the number of tackles,
the number of law variations, the number of amendments,
the pace, the intensity, everything flying around
at million miles an hour.
If you want more TMO, just say the word.
And the game will be gone.
So we just have to be really careful.
And Razzie does have a responsibility.
He has a few legitimate grievances.
I think the Luke Huyello, he wasn't off for long enough.
That's a mistake.
And you could argue the toss over a few calls here and there.
But equally, I think France has served to win that game.
You didn't hear anything from Razzie
when they won three knockout games by a point.
A couple of times they rode their luck in those.
You have to just accept the rub of the green
as the other coaches do.
There's no reason why he has to be the only coach
who feels aggrieved when they don't get all the breaks.
I feel there's going to be a real issue dealing
with hip drop tackles moving forward.
And I think that's due to the fact
of what being taught historically as rugby players.
I think it's so easy with all the other tackles.
There's a sense of brutality of recklessness about it.
But hip drop is just a variant
on the foot fundamentals we've all been taught,
which is to use your body weight
to bring down somebody who's bigger,
moving faster than you have,
and has got more momentum new.
So that's going to take a lot of unpicking.
And a bit like the Ruck, if we get to a point
where we start complaining about penalties
and not being given for every tackle
is going to be the same with a Ruck.
So I'm worried about the future of the game
without that law being interpreted.
It's going to just create a lot of confusion.
But Gro, isn't this where the game is in a nutshell?
The international game is amazing at the moment.
The skill, coaching, the fan support,
it's quality, Friday night awesome.
That's the kind of awesome.
Yet, World Rugby are trying to balance up five things
that all contradict each other.
They're trying to make an inherently dangerous game
as safe as possible when we know that danger
can't be eliminated from the game.
They're trying to speed the game up.
They're trying to encourage the pillars of the sport
that we all love, the physicality, the set piece.
They're trying to maintain that integrity of those areas
while making it a simpler, safer game
and recalibrating the sport from a collision sport
to more of a innovation sport.
Because Ruck, we wait so far down the line
to be a collision sport that it's going
to take an adjustment period and players are told,
you can't tackle too high cards.
You can't tackle too low cards.
They're told at the Ruck.
You can't netcroll cards.
You can't crop roll cards.
You can't target the lower limb cards
and you can't go to the head and net cards.
So that's your tiny little areas.
If the head is over the hips, blocking the passageway
to the safe area, sometimes players are finding
really hard to find a safe area.
Look at the Luke Yellow.
Sasha Feinberg and Gommasuli was so braced
that, actually, Luke who has a tiny target area,
he goes too low, he gets a knee to the head,
he goes too high, he gets a yellow car, which is what happened.
But his margin for error is minute.
So all of these things are going on at the same time.
And I think someone in Erasmus's position
has to just take an elastic view and understand
that with the lawsuits and with the game looking
to recalibrate, there are a lot of things going on
and the officials are right, right in the middle of it.
I think he knows all of that Chris.
I think he knows all of that.
And I think he knows how difficult it is for officials.
And I think he's being incredibly cynical
and incredibly tactical about this.
For me, I'm completely convinced, given his track record,
I'm completely convinced that the 17 knee drop tackles
and inverted commas are not the issue here.
I think he wants him to get in the head, potentially,
get in the head of the officials in Dublin on Saturday.
He wants to lay down the marker there,
maybe spoke to him a bit, or else they'll
be getting the rassy treatment.
That he's coming for them.
I don't think this is about,
I don't think this is about Paris on Friday night.
I think it's about Dublin on Saturday.
And he's laying down a marker here.
He would have known when he said that.
When he came up with him and spared me
the wounded innocence about it.
Oh, I didn't match fixing.
That's now you're taking me up wrong.
Just may I speak, my English isn't blah, blah, blah.
Nonsense, he knew exactly what he was saying.
He knew that he was going to get a sanctioned
because of the new framework around abuse of match officials.
You knew that.
And he kind of sacrificed himself for what he may think
a greater good to get in the heads of the officials
in Dublin after losing one game on Friday night,
doesn't want to lose another one.
So let's do everything that he can
and just like he did in the Lions.
So for me, this is--
He said they got the brakes in the second test.
They got the brakes in the second test.
Got away with the red card.
Some people are talking about that he's the Donald Trump
of rugby in terms of deflection tactics.
And I can see that.
I mean, Trump, whenever he wants to deflect it with it,
he's in the hot water, he'll deflect away to a ballroom,
or look at my ballroom.
I'm surprised that Racy did talk about a blockroom,
you know, something.
But this is where he's at now.
Yeah, it's a populist's argument
and we've seen it played all over the world.
Here's my number one concern.
And I would like to sit down with Racy and talk about this.
You may have legitimate concerns.
Do you know what?
Every single example that you displayed was actually right.
You were correct in every single instance.
Fine.
You're going to call out the referees in public
and you use the term match fixing.
Fine.
Those are your values now, Racy.
Those are the values that you like
to see.
in rugby. And maybe that's it. Maybe that's the game, what it is now. If you want to be that
person, Rasmus, someone who decides to call out the officials, let's stop, let's stop shaking
hands after the game. Why not start calling out other players? Why not just call out other players'
cheats, accuse other people of max fixing? There are certain values with rugby, and we go on about
rugby values, that we hold quite daily. For me, the number one principle of all of them,
all of them is the respect shown to the referee and the referees and the officials.
And the 12 coaches and the 11 coaches and the 9 coaches, they will know that the guy
refereeing the game is not impartial because he is the coach of the opposition team.
It's Rasi saying from here on in, yeah, if you're a coach of that level, call it out. After the game,
walk up to that guy and say, yeah, that was by us, you're max fixing. If Rasi's happy to say,
yeah, that's the way you're moving forward, then let it be, let's change the fundamentals of rugby,
and let's make it this more explosive, you know, aggressive, contradicting each other, shouting out
to everybody. That's fine. And if you, South African fans believe there is a massive conspiracy,
and I don't eat in any way claim to understand the South African mindset, the way you may see us,
and then all the hemisphere's colonialists, and the suffering you've had in history, that's fine,
and maybe everything Rasi has said is justified. Then maybe he is a martyr. And if he is a martyr,
if you believe that's right, they'd go on him. And then six, six match band is nothing,
if you believe it's a martyr, but let's show us the evidence. Show us exactly where the conspiracy
has been against the most successful rugby team in his, in the last 10 years. They are the ones
getting everything wrong. And the final, and the final line, there's also complaints about
the due process, the fact that he's been handed a ban with immediate effect. I do have sympathy
with that, that's the new process, but it also suggests that most people complaining about due
process, are not really concerned with the due process, they're concerned about the outcome.
I think that's where, I think that's where he obviously has some concerns, as every head coach
would offer at a game, because there are so many decisions you could look at. But you have to
be quite clear, the fact here, you're right to bring up and Tom did at the top, the July,
2026 new framework around abuse of match officials. It's all there. And I've spoken to people from
other countries, they know exactly, they've got sent documents where World Rugby in the summer.
It's all there. Erasmus knows that. He knows what he can and can't do. So to then go,
oh, I've not had a fair hearing. Well, he will get a hearing now, but that's all in, it's all written,
it's all written down in black and white, what happens if you cross the threshold light? He's done.
Secondly, he was talking about Visa's citing and Prendergast citing, we'll get onto Prendergast in
a sec, how one's taken a while, one hasn't. Well, that's because Visa is a red card on the field,
the automatically triggers the citing, which we all know. And the fans should know, said he knows.
So you can't compare apples and apples when they're completely different situations. So
there are, and there are things like, you're talking about a hip drop tackle, red card,
and a clear red card. No, the hip drop tackle entry point for sanction is yellow card,
like with Angus Bell on Money Fair, we're both so. So I get it when you put all these things together,
it can look like the South Africans are being hard done by, and there's no surprise,
they're fan base of March right behind it. But you've got to look specifically at the detail
here, and I do think the bit about Erasmus's role in South Africa, we don't understand that,
do we? As three Brits, or Brits and Irish, we don't understand that, and Ryan Kutser on Twitter,
one of the reasons people outside South Africa find our support for Russia's sober wilderness,
is they think of him as a rugby coach, and how important can coaches really be at the end of
the day. But he's not simply a rugby coach to us. He's a beacon of hope in a bleak landscape.
He represents what could be diversity and success together. He's a winner in a country that
feels too often that it's losing. He's the only rugby coach on earth that is those things,
and probably the only one that ever has been. Yeah, no, I understand all that. I don't think anyone
tuned into rugby knows what a systemic figure Erasmus is, not just in South African rugby
society, but in South African society. I mean, it's often been said, and written that if he
went for public office, then he would reach the highest office in the land, because he's so popular.
I get all that. I get the unifying force that he is. I get the serial winner that he is,
all of that stuff, but I don't think we do. I don't think you really, I don't think you
understand it. I don't understand. I think we get it, but I don't think we really understand it,
do we? Because we don't, we're not, we're not. We can, we can, we can, we can get under a level of
understanding, because we, we listen to South African's talking in the way that that contributor
just talked. We hear enough of that feeling. We can't feel it. You don't feel it in your heart
and soul, but you can recognize, you can recognize what a colossal figure he is in South African,
South African life, and you respect that, and kind of in our other, but it doesn't give him a
license to behave the way he's been behaving, to come up with this victimhood stuff. I know a number
of South African cultures, I've spoken to a few of them over the past 24 hours, and one message
basically, and I'm paraphrasing something along the lines of he deserves a hearing, and you know,
this is this person's, I should never have said the word max fix, max fixing, but it does put
world rugby and a huge pressure. And I think, I think that's the insight we want really in terms of
what the playbook is. I just think it's sad that I repeat what I say, you know, that like all
populist politicians, he'll have these defenders who defend him all the way. And we, as you said,
because we can't begin to understand what it's like to be South African, and what it's like to have
raze your, raze massage your coach, but once you start introducing phrases like buy us a match fixing.
Look, he knows exactly what's come and grow. And what we know about raze as a rugby man,
we know that he will stop at nothing to win, and it's his greatest strength and a times it can be a
major weakness. He is ruthless, it is pursued, of victory, and he's ruthless with his own players,
he's inspirational to his own players, he's a genius as a rugby coach and a rugby thinker,
but he's also put officials in the line of fire because he has this incredible will to win.
And that's the side. That's the side. That's problematic because if we, like, there's rugby
coaches all over the place Steve, Steve Bartlett, Steve Tandy, Gregor Townsend, all everywhere could look
and analyze, if you imagine you've put them all in a room and say, okay, I want you to analyze the
last 10 South African games and decisions that went their way, could you imagine the amount of
decisions that those rugby brands would come up with not referee is excited on South Africa,
South Africa, but raze doesn't come up with this stuff. He doesn't, he doesn't tell you all we got
lucky today with the referee. He just, he wants to sell the picture, as South Africa has just put
upon country because it will help him the next day. He will help fire off his players the next day,
he will influence the referees possibly. We hope not the next day. And the sad thing about what
happened in 2012, what 21, and it's clearly still rumbling five years on, especially when he keeps
every few years kind of refreshing the narrative, is I think there's a large proportion of the South
African fan base might not be the majority by any stretch imagination, but certainly a significant
number who feel the box never lose. They're just done by the ref. And by doing what he, and doing
what he did in 2021, it with Nick Berry and good looking to speak, we would have, we had lines
to inspect schools on in that game, whether we tried to be neutral, there would have been a part of
us maybe subconsciously that would have been looking out for the lines a little bit because we're
Brits and Irish, but that didn't feel like a robbery after that first test, but it was presented
as one. And I think it's then encouraged a lot of South African fans going forward. We're never
beaten. We're just done by the ref, which is sad because they're such a wicked team. And the rugby
was so great on the weekend. And this weekend could be so terrific. And we're talking about it. And
I don't know, I just think I just people will say, oh, world rugby, all these decisions cooked
up by faceless suits, that couldn't be further from the truth. Current coaches are on these panels.
Ex players are on these panels. Current referees, ex referees, honestly, the IP in these rooms
making these decisions. It's not World Rugby. It's a group of rugby experts. You could not want
more rugby intellect in the room making these decisions. And I saw Steve Hanson at a quote,
oh, the refs are protected species. We don't get to talk to them. I don't think that's true. They
were all at a forum the other day. And secondly, part of the reason they had to change the eve
of match meeting with the refs is that coaches would come along with three assistant coaches,
then laptops, pointing stuff out. So it got on wieldly because coaches like they do, they see a
loophole, they exploit it, they see a law, they exploit it, they see a tweak, they get in there.
That's what coaches do, but you can't then turn around and blame it when people go hold on to
a bit much. I don't need five of you and five laptops. I want one head coach with three points,
you know? So as ever, everyone's got a shoulder, a bit of the blame that we've got where we've got.
I still think the games are being well refereed on the whole while they are dealing with all of
these different things that are being thrown at them and all these different strategies the game
is trying to nail. A lot of them for understandable reasons. I think they've
officials are doing a pretty, pretty great job,
and I mean, I spent that day with them.
I was very impressed by their professionalism,
their insight and their desire to look at the bigger picture
for what is best for the sport.
Just quickly on, Prendergast, he's got off on his sighting.
They will be to the African's crying foul.
It was a three-person panel, including two English people
and an Aussie, so it's not done
by three Irish men in Dublin.
I don't think that's a red card tackle.
I think it's a yellow card tackle.
I think at the time Prendergast should've got a yellow card
in the same way Angus Bell did against England,
but you can't cite and ban people for yellow card challenges.
That is not the law, not the rule.
They have to hit the red card threshold.
That didn't. -Exactly.
-We've got to move on.
Regardless of what a Raspbian system is.
-Yeah, absolutely, I agree. It's a yellow card.
And it should've been a yellow card.
But again, and it's only days with these challenges, Tom.
So it's all teething crazy, isn't it?
But Razi again, he does his stuff the other day.
He does the old Rassie shuffle,
and he says, "Oh, I'll protect you, he'll get off."
"Don't be a technicality."
The technicality is that it was a yellow card.
That's a technicality.
And also, he's also again, he's a kind of impugning
the integrity of the independent disciplinary panel.
I said, "Oh, they're going to let him off.
They'll let him off."
Yeah, he got off for a specific reason.
But it's almost like it's a cover, it's not part of the cover-up.
I'm predicting the predator gases is going to be cleared.
Like, I mean, it's not everyone is out to get you.
Rassie, you know?
And again, I think it's all a show.
I think it's all a show.
And I think it's all a show.
And here we are talking about him.
It's kind of Trump again, talking about the stuff
that he wants people to talk about.
He wants rugby to talk about this.
He doesn't necessarily want rugby to talk about the defeat.
Although the defeat was fine.
I mean, you're not going every single game.
Not South Africa, we're very good in the game.
And maybe they feel sort of, sort of they lost the game.
But every defeat isn't a disaster and a call to arms
to pick up your pitchforks.
I mean, I do think there's, like, I can understand,
potentially, why the Southans feel a bit isolated.
Because they are, they're geographically isolated.
You know, they can't sustain their own domestic league.
They need to play in the URC.
A lot of rugby has run out of Dublin.
As we know, they probably feel that the anglosphere dominates
the sport, and that's probably a minuscule of something
in that.
But I think you've got to look at every episode
on an individual basis.
And this printed glass one is pretty clear, independent panel
taking that time.
Yet it can't threshold.
No bad.
At Whole Foods Market, chef-inspired flavors
meet industry-leading quality standards, especially
for Thanksgiving.
There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever.
So their fresh turkeys and spiral-cut ham
bring rich, satisfying flavors you can taste in each bite.
No compromises.
Just quality and peace of mind you can share
with every guest at your table.
This week on the interface could AI be conscious.
And if there's even a chance, what does that mean for humanity?
We're joined by philosopher and professor Jeff Sebow,
who thinks we should be taking the question seriously.
Even if nobody knows the answer.
We need to do further research.
Not only about whether AI systems are conscious,
but also about what they want and need if they are.
Join me, Jess Maddox.
And me, Thomas Dremain, for the interface.
Listen on BBC.com, or wherever you get your podcast.
I'm going to read this one out, grow.
Because this is from Tom Henry.
It's two really good points.
He says, can we please talk about how good the drill
was from Wales at the end of the New Zealand game?
No ceiling off penalties, no panic.
It was like they'd practiced it for years.
It was such a good point, because they were in such control.
It looked like a team that was so used to beating the all blacks.
And then he says a general note on the power of emotion
in rugby for the fans and players.
In the Wales and France games, players, pundits and fans
knew the emotional stakes.
And it was easy to relate to the public
and for the public to relate to.
As a lifelong NFL fan, I can tell you the clear,
emotion-led storylines work harder than tricecord
to recruit new fans.
Just could not endorse that anymore.
Doesn't have to be 50 points all with a million tries,
but a game that has meaning, that has purpose, that has jeopardy,
and has the fans and the players in complete symbiosis
like we saw in Paris and Cardiff.
Very, very special.
Great message to you.
The truth is, in rugby, it does be for a second.
It could be a brief story.
When I first started playing in my semi-pro armour todays,
I used to play for a local club, local village.
And this is the late '90s, and they were paying players
for all of the South Wales, hundreds of pounds,
to play in 30-year rugby in South Wales.
We had no local boys playing.
There were a couple of us on a bench, 18-19.
And overnight, the club went bust.
And all those mysteries all left, overnight.
Everyone left.
And all of our best players had gone to play elsewhere
because they couldn't get a game in the first game.
So it just ended up being second-teamers and youth players.
We had no money and no one to buy.
And for three years, we never got relegated.
And we were nowhere near anywhere else's ability.
But what we had was undying commitment,
the will to win, a love for each other,
a shirt and a badge to play for,
and determination that anybody who came to our patch
would leave knowing that they would have been given a game.
And rugby fundamentally for me, fundamentally.
It's about skill, it's about talent, it's about ability.
But it's also about that kid at 13, 14, 15 years of age,
who's not the fastest, who's not the strongest,
who's not the most talented yet.
He is the most revered player in his team
because he is tougher and he never gives up and he doesn't quit
until the final dying minutes.
And the coaches and the players loved him for that reason.
And Saturday, 23 of those players,
like the stats are off the chart.
We know the headliners.
Gareth Thomas, 19 tackles in 26 minutes off the bench.
19 tackles in 26 minutes off the bench.
Tamplum tree two turnovers, Ruben Morgan Williams controlling
that final play, barely played international rugby,
called that final two minutes.
Dan Edwards, try saving tackles.
It's the spirit of rugby personified.
And do you know what?
Even the oil blacks I've done mine at that.
And I think that is what makes rugby so, so, so beautiful.
- A hundred percent, quite a lyrical there.
- Right, I'm a bit emotional there.
I don't think it was a very emotional day.
I would say it was emotional,
but I was just in awe of what Wales did.
But two things, right?
Everyone's talking about the million tackles they made
and the defensive resistance and going into that,
the darkest of dark, dark places
and defending their line and all the rest.
The rugby they played in the first half
and an earlier second to establish the lead was awesome rugby.
I mean, it was terrific, terrific rugby.
And then we saw the other side.
And I was talking with Andy Burke
on our Scotland Rugby podcast.
Have we ever seen Scotland defend like that?
And I said, well, we've maybe seen it in short phases.
We've never, I've never seen ever seen.
And I've only Scotland are capable of defending
for that long, that close to the line
when it's just heart and soul and systems go out to window.
And it's just, it's full metal.
But I don't think anyone's like,
we've never seen that before,
especially in the pro game.
And you want to upset us so rare, aren't they?
In test rugby, the bigger team, the more powerful team,
the better drill team, the better athletes, always prevail.
So yeah, you could say, oh, Scotland haven't done a goal.
I said, no one's done a goal, I just don't like it.
I'm actually brought up the exit to one against bar,
but that's five minutes, not twenty five.
Yeah, you're right.
So that's why it was so, it was so,
it was almost incongruously amazing.
58 minutes, Wales had a rack and a turn over in New Zealand's half.
And then they didn't return to New Zealand's half
until the 78th minute.
May, that's a fact, but in terms of their ability
to go to that place,
I don't know what to cliche in the dark place,
we hear rugby players talking about it,
we need to go to a dark place.
Like, Wales looked like they were having a great all-time
in the dark place.
You know, when you saw James both of them
get off the ground every time and they took it out.
But unless you really want to do that, you can't do it.
And it's, I should go back to what you were saying.
Go, it's, I mean, it was awesome,
absolutely awesome to see what they were doing.
We could start on New Zealand and they were a bit one-dimensional,
but I couldn't understand New Zealand thinking,
there's no way they can hold out,
because I was thinking, there's no way they can hold out.
Yeah, we all were, yeah.
Josh, what New Zealand would have given
to have had the Scottish backline on Saturday, hey, Tom?
Well, why does it always come back to me?
I feel like Balotelli here.
Why does it always mean that it's--
Because after the Edinburgh game,
I thought, I don't know what a terrible thing.
I mean, there was a different New Zealand battle.
I just thought that one tick would be a little bit,
but on the kind of, I don't know how a poor Scotland
kind of get dragged into this sometimes.
But there have been a few really kind of thought-provoking messages,
one from Graham Love, which is prominent on social media
and YouTube, and I shared his message on our group.
And he goes over doing a motion from there.
the Wales game is one of bitter jealousy.
I said for the last couple of years,
I'd trade the misery Wales have been going through
for that success they've had even more so now.
- Oh, yeah.
- And Alan Greenwood, hypothetical question
for Scotland rugby fans, would you swap being Scotland
since the Rugby World Cup 2023?
So this World Cup cycle, respectable performances,
good numbers playing for the Lions.
Nothing amazing for Wales' post-Rubby World Cup.
Lots of misery but a day for the ages.
A win against the All Blacks.
It's a good question, isn't it?
'Cause Scotland have been a kind of modicum of,
I know you will lament their inconsistency on,
but on the whole, they've been pretty consistent.
Third, fourth and the sixth nations,
taking the Calcutta Cup back up North most times,
yet they haven't had a sort of a day like that
or they've not threw the number of trophies Wales of one.
Must make Scotland classic, oh, man,
just give us one of those sixth nations
that you've had this century.
- Oh, yeah.
I mean, I would take all the misery that Wales have had
over the last number of years.
Quadruple it, give it to Scotland,
but give Scotland Wales as big big days,
their Grand Slam days, their New Zealand.
Give them that as well and I would take that deal
in our heartbeat.
- I wouldn't swap Saturday for the past two years.
I've been lived it, not a chance.
Not a chance. - You wouldn't swap Saturdays.
So I'd have preferred to have Scotland's existence
for the past two years and for Scotland
to have been the old blocks than to have lived through
what I've lived for the past two years.
- That's the question, isn't it?
- Yeah, well, the question is,
does a day like Saturday compensate for the misery?
- No.
- It doesn't.
- No.
- But I would say that's because you're complete.
I'd say that's because you're completely immersed in it.
- Yes.
- And it's a professional.
- Yes.
- Whereas for the fans, they're completely immersed in it,
but it's not their livelihood.
- The wider question is, if you work in it, you know.
- The wider question is, say in the last 10 years,
so Wales wonder a grand slam, what, 2005?
That's to start the ball rolling, right?
- 5/8/12/19.
- Okay.
So you take, so 2005.
- And 30.
- So you take all of that from 2005.
So the last 21 years, I'm taking Wales's last 21 years,
all the misery and uncertainty
and all the bitterness and all the rest of it.
I'm taking that over Scotland's last 21 years,
grow, surely.
- Well, that wasn't the question.
- Top office, yeah.
- I'm taking this.
- Yeah, no, but that makes us like, say,
I'd rather have a million pounds.
- No, but a million pounds.
- I don't know what that's the worst take you've had on this.
- But good.
We're not comparing the 21 years,
Wales is extraordinary success.
It is said to grow.
Compared to Scotland's coating.
- No, it's not.
- It's not specifically about the doldrums
of the last couple of years.
- Okay, so, okay, let's put it this way.
The last two years grow.
You're saying, okay, it doesn't compensate
for when beating New Zealand doesn't compensate
for the last two years, right?
- Right.
- How many grand slams would you sacrifice?
If there was no two years, there's no misery.
How many of the grand slams would you sacrifice?
Maybe that's probably a better way of framing this.
- I know you've medically.
Can you sort of re-explain the question?
- I don't think we have, I'm not sure where we are.
I think it's basically like, what is misery worth?
- Oh, yeah.
- You said it's not worth the misery of two years.
- So it says that you'd rather Wales is five, six nations,
titles than Scotland's zero, which is a take.
I mean, I think it's probably the worst people
that would have done it.
- And I take four times Wales's misery.
That's not forget that.
- Okay, four times I can.
- So what would I pop the misery?
- What would I trade from Wales' past 20 years
in order to have not gone through the past two years?
- Yes, good, nice to you've narrowed it down.
- Okay, I would hand back at least one grand slam.
Maybe a check at hand back eight or 12, maybe 12.
Triple crown.
(laughing)
- So you should look.
- Triple crown's gone for a challenge cup win, mate.
That's what, that's a knockout win.
- So you're saying one or two grand slams
you'd hand over, plus New Zealand.
- I'm opening negotiations here, Tommy.
I'm not sure what my hand is.
- Right.
- He's got the most stupid debate we've ever had.
We've had a few.
- No, it is, it's been, I just found it funny.
How on Saturday night, Scotland and Scotland.
I'd self-inflicted because some prominent Scotland commentators
had brought Scotland into it.
And it's a felt best, sorry, for Scotland catching strays
when Wales have had an amazing day of it.
- No, it's true.
- It's an amazing day of it.
Ah, for all Scotland.
Did you see it?
- For all Scotland, I was getting to the next year.
- I know, for the reality, the reality is,
the reality is that everyone in Scotland
was cheering for Wales.
- Cheering on Wales.
- I know for Wales.
- No, and everyone's, and England fans,
I've been really magnanimous as well.
And I've spoken to a lot of England fans
and players this week, and they've all really, really
supported Wales, which says a lot, you know, credits
to the Scotland and Wales fan base.
But I think I saw it online.
I think good about the rugby, put it up.
That sketch in the courtroom was something
where they could have wanted to apologize.
- Yeah, they wanted to apologize
and she starts laughing at a Wales fan.
- That made me, that made me sure.
- That is one of the things.
When Wales rugby has a great day like that.
The internet memes are after.
Like after, you know, 2013, after 2021,
there was some pretty magic, I don't know.
- Where else could I go?
- That's what I'm talking about.
I don't know why Scotland had a catchphrase.
- No, why is it Scotland's going back?
- No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
But just to go back, to go back to Tom's point,
emotion, emotion, emotion, magic, magic, magic.
Only a couple of minutes left, Greg.
- I wanted to move it on just by definition.
I don't know, because of Friday night,
the Saturday night, I convinced myself
that Scotland Australia was going to be a match
for the ages as well.
- Saturday night.
- So I sat down, sat down half an hour early.
That got rugby, doesn't it?
We are living the height of rugby at the moment.
This is going to be an absolute belter.
I cannot wait to see their showdown.
And then just, oh my God.
- I did the rugby talent on this.
- The rugby guards clearly say, right?
Okay, you've had your, you've had your, you've had your fun.
- And that's good though, that's good.
I like it that the rugby guards
aren't giving it out all to a little bit too, too plentifully.
So England, New Zealand, Ireland, South Africa.
Man, there's a lot going on here.
England, they're team Thursday.
Well, Joseph's going to start on the wing,
say back in Senate 12, they've got a full injury.
A bill of health England will do a lot more on the pod.
I think we've got to record a pod Thursday to go out,
late Thursday, early Friday.
So loads more focus on the England team.
What do you guys make of that one quickly?
Good one, isn't it?
- It's a voucher.
- Especially with all that New Zealand have come.
- I'm heavily fancing England in this game.
- Oh, are you?
- Show me the evidence. - I just, there's so many good players.
There's so many good players.
And if both of you never get these organized,
this is a potentially a formidable England team
because they have everything that they need.
They've got some outstanding footballers
in most positions.
And if they hit a wave, and maybe they are,
I know it's on the back of the victory of the weekend
was a walk over.
But you look at these individual players
and you think, these are good rugby players.
And I think potentially, I know I've said it before,
but potentially England is something special
in this England setup, potentially.
- I think how England approach it is key
because they've taken two inferior sides to the cleaners,
played really, really well.
But one of the things both the Borough for Grey G
would love to improve is their record against,
like the top four.
You know, their record against Ireland, Scotland as well.
But Ireland, New Zealand saga, it's a losing record.
It's on average sort of one in four.
So, big opportunity this Saturday.
And I'd love to see England go out and play their way,
not to get too hung up on the opposition
because we know it's one of Borough's super strengths
as a coach is analysing the Oppo.
But when you stop and go actually,
England scored a million points,
playing from outside their usual zones.
You know, they're playing deeper in the pitch.
They're not just looking to get in the 22.
I have striking from 40 now.
Can they go and do that when they're playing?
I know a wound did and a humbled New Zealand team,
but still one of the best two teams in the world
or best three teams in the world
that will bring back 500 caps of experience
and some world class operators.
My concern for England would be the all blacks
don't lose two in a row in November, do they?
I can seldom remember when they lost,
I mean, it's probably when someone will say,
oh well, last year, but I don't think
they often lose in consecutive weekends in November.
So that sets it up brilliantly, I think.
Yeah, and again, we've been mindful not to dismiss
or devalue what I'm in Saturday,
that all black team with Roy Godlove, Jordy Barrett
is a different prospect completely.
I think New Zealand will win that
and that wouldn't be necessarily to discredit England.
And I just think I still think the all blacks are a good side.
I just wanted to make one point.
Obviously, our concern pre-tournament was
that the all blacks in New Zealand,
all blacks in the box would end up winning all their games
and one would miss out on the final.
We know that's gone over.
You look at the tables, right?
Northern hemisphere, 18 wins in total
between the six sides.
Southern hemisphere, 12 wins in total.
Australia, Japan, Argentina, have four wins between them.
And then Ireland, Scotland and Wales have 10 wins between them.
And I'm not even making a point, really.
There's no real point to be made, but it does say we'd,
but yeah, it's a valid one
because we know that the Northern hemisphere is really competitive.
We know from the six nations, don't we?
Everyone can beat everyone.
It's super competitive.
Yes, France and Ireland have elevated themselves,
but other teams have a chance to win the title.
Those four, five, even six in the Northern hemisphere
of all. Um,
scrap really hard and beating each other the last few years, but the gap between New
Zealand and South Africa and the rest in the South is quite pronounced, isn't it?
You know, so that's just the state of play and, you know, South Africa and New Zealand
found to turn around and go, "Well, 9 World Cup's out of 10 or whatever it is, but Australia
and Argentina have either regressed or stagnated, and likewise Japan and Fiji are not maybe
the team that they have been."
So all together, those four are not a four, so are they?
And I can't necessarily see that change in this weekend with Japan playing Scotland, Fiji
playing Italy, which is a fascinating game, but you know, the two teams who aren't in
the best place, and then you'd think, "France B, Argentina, well to top the Northern
hemisphere, look, don't you?"
Yeah.
Yeah.
There'd be class if Argentina came up with something, but we just haven't seen it.
Yeah, we have some Tom English's words show us the atmosphere.
Yeah, they're the most, they're a weird team, Argentina.
You look at their lineup, we've said this before, you look at their 23, and you go, "Okay,
there's some seriously class players there," and Scotland go to Argentina, they win, and
it's flattered to deceive Argentina.
I think England versus New Zealand just, I think South Africa over Ireland, I mean, you
look at these three games, particularly.
South Africa, full of engines, full of the world is out to get them.
They go to Ireland's track records, South Africa, New Zealand and France combined, lost
the last six against the three of them combined, average losing margin, about 15 points, I
think.
So a huge amount to prove for Ireland against South Africa in that game.
And imagine if they did it with their injuries and stuff.
Yeah.
That would be like, that would be a size for Ireland.
I don't think they'll do it, but if they did, a bit like the psychological impact, it's
going to have on France going forward, that could be massive for Ireland.
There's so much to go forward to grow back to Cardiff, how can Wales lift themselves?
One girl.
Back to back.
Most levels.
Imagine if Wales, imagine if Wales won all three of their November games.
One off four?
Yeah.
Well, that kicks up to get Japan again.
Yeah, which do you prefer, Tom, just looking at the fixtures for the final, so it's likely
that Scotland will finish fourth and Wales fifth, but if Scotland don't get a bonus
point, Wales will be the straighter, Wales will pick Scotland and finish fourth, and then
they would be, which do you prefer, the Sunday fixture or the Saturday fixture would suit
your diary best.
So it's the fourth, it means you play on the Sunday one o'clock.
It does.
You play on the Saturday.
I prefer Saturday because I have something to do on Monday and Tuesday, so I'll have to
get back up the road.
So just tell us.
So what do you Scotland could do, they need to just get four points?
Scotland, Scotland kind of, I know it was difficult day on Mariffield, but it wasn't that difficult
to rain and stuff like that, but they needed a bonus point against Australia, they only got
two tries.
But if they had a bonus point in the bag, then they might have had a shot at finishing one
place higher, but at the moment, the points difference is going to kill them, even if they
get five points against Japan, which you assume they're going to get.
I don't know, there's too many points difference ahead of them to finish anywhere better than
fourth, I think.
I don't know.
No, Ireland, Ireland plus 57, Scotland minus eight, Scotland's thick 50 points in Japan,
Ireland get nothing.
Boom.
Yeah, okay.
I'd fair enough.
Yeah, I'd love to get them nothing, but getting nothing, you are going to have a minus
point.
So if Ireland lose by 10, they, Scotland went by 50, Ireland lose by 10, don't get a bonus
point, Scotland finish ahead of Ireland.
Okay.
All right.
I'm liking your thinking.
Well, am I?
Because that means Ireland drop a place, I've got two teams here.
I've always told you, Tom, don't go on a motion, go on practicality for your weekend.
Yeah.
So that's what you want to be looking at.
One and everything.
I just want rugby to be the winner, boys.
Yeah, it's beautiful.
You know how it is with me.
Good, good way to finish.
That is us.
Absolutely pleasure.
As always, we are podding Thursday and Friday.
Look out for that, the rugby weekly feed, loads of coverage across five live across
sports extra across BBC sounds off the weekend.
Of course, some great stuff on the BBC Scrum five podcast, the BBC Scotland rugby podcast
on BBC Scotland, BBC Wales, BBC Northern Ireland, you will not miss a thing with us.
And we'll see you very, very soon.
Thank you.
For more than a decade, British Boxing has been shaped by two men.
Two completely different personalities, two extraordinary careers, and one fight that
just won't go away.
There's never been a fight like this in the history of British Boxing, never, never.
This is the story of how we got here.
And how the AJ Fury rivalry redefine boxing forever.
This was split the country, half-fiery fans, half-AJ fans.
Five live boxing, fury, v-joshua.
Listen on BBC Sounds.
This week on the interface, could AI be conscious?
We're joined by philosopher and professor Jeff Cebow, who thinks we should be taking the
question seriously, even if nobody knows the answer.
We need to do further research, not only about whether AI systems are conscious, but also
about what they want and need, if they are.
And me, Thomas Germain, for the interface.
Listen on BBC.com, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Cadillac enters Formula One with a focus on precision and performance, bringing American luxury and engineering excellence to the world's top motorsport stage.
The Cadillac V Series delivers luxury performance inspired by racing, emphasizing engineering refinement and thrilling on-road experiences.
Whole Foods Market offers high-quality, antibiotic-free meat for Thanksgiving, highlighting clean, trustworthy ingredients and shared culinary peace of mind.
Wales' historic victory over New Zealand sparked an overwhelming emotional response, with fans and players of all ages deeply moved, especially in a generationally significant moment.
The win underscored rugby’s unifying role in Welsh society, transcending sports and uniting communities through shared passion and resilience.
Commentary on the match highlighted the importance of authenticity and spontaneity in live sports broadcasting, especially during high-stakes moments.
South African coach Rassie Erasmus faced criticism for alleging match-fixing and criticizing officiating, with commentators arguing his claims lack merit and serve as deflective, populist tactics.
The debate reflects broader tensions in modern rugby over safety, officiating, and the balance between sport’s physicality and its evolving rules.
Summary:
The podcast explores multiple interconnected themes, beginning with Cadillac’s entry into Formula One, where precision, performance, and engineering align to deliver a luxury performance experience through the V Series lineup. This is followed by a detailed account of Whole Foods Market’s commitment to quality, particularly in offering antibiotic-free meat for Thanksgiving, emphasizing trust and taste. The central narrative focuses on Wales’ dramatic victory over New Zealand, a moment of national pride that triggered widespread emotional reactions across generations, highlighting rugby’s deep cultural roots in Wales.
The emotional impact is described as unprecedented, with many grown men in their 30s and 40s crying, underscoring rugby’s unifying power. The discussion also turns to commentary, emphasizing authenticity over pre-written lines, drawing a parallel to the 1966 World Cup moment when Hugh Jones delivered a raw, unscripted line. A critical section examines South African coach Rassie Erasmus, whose allegations of match-fixing and officiating issues are challenged as deflective and politically motivated, especially given his history of post-defeat criticism.
Commentators argue that the new World Rugby framework on match officials is fair, and that TMOs are under intense pressure, making such claims unrealistic. The broader context reveals tensions in modern rugby—balancing safety, speed, and physicality—while celebrating the emotional intensity that defines great sporting moments. The segment concludes with a reflective question on whether a single victory can offset years of national hardship, suggesting that for many, the emotional resonance of a moment like this far outweighs mere statistical achievement.
FAQs
Cadillac is entering Formula One to bring an American luxury brand with a strong performance heritage to the sport, reflecting the precision and engineering excellence seen on the racing grid.
The Cadillac V Series provides distinctive luxury performance vehicles engineered to deliver the precision and thrilling performance associated with Formula One racing on the open road.
Whole Foods Market's meat products are free of antibiotics and offer rich, satisfying flavors, with fresh turkeys and spiral-cut hams that are consistently high quality and free from compromises.
The victory was emotionally significant for Welsh fans, uniting generations and breaking a long period of hardship, leading to widespread celebration and deep emotional responses from people of all ages.
The controversy involves allegations of match-fixing by South African coach Rassie Erasmus, who criticized officiating around knee drop tackles, sparking debate over player safety, fairness, and the integrity of match officials.
Commentators often remain unscripted, relying on instinct and real-time reactions to deliver authentic, heartfelt commentary, as seen in the emotional final moments of the Wales vs. New Zealand match.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.