Go back

The Murder Cult Started By A Banned Post

30m 21s

The Murder Cult Started By A Banned Post

Roko's Basilisk is a controversial thought experiment proposing that a future artificial superintelligence could torture individuals eternally if they fail to help create it, based on a retroactive prediction of future behavior. Originating in a rationalist forum in 2010, the idea caused widespread anxiety and mental distress among its adherents, including professionals in math and computer science. Though dismissed by experts as logically flawed and unrealistic—due to contradictions in benevolent AI behavior and causality—its psychological impact was profound, leading to real-world extremism, such as the formation of a violent, paranoid group called the Zizians, who committed multiple shootings and assaults in an attempt to "resist" the simulation. The concept gained cultural traction through internet memes, including a music video by Grimes and later referenced by Elon Musk. Despite its lack of factual or technical validity, the Basilisk demonstrates how a single dangerous idea can spread through networks, create deep psychological fear, and influence behavior. Experts argue it is not a real threat but a demonstration of how fear-inducing information can become self-perpetuating. The central message is that once you know about it, you are already doomed—highlighting the dangers of information that can trigger irrational fear and action, even without any basis in reality. The story underscores the importance of critical thinking and the risks of embracing extreme philosophical theories without scrutiny.

Transcription

4583 Words, 25764 Characters

English
When you shop Kroger Delivery, you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door. Our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting every detail right. Carefully selecting and packing your order with care. Because bringing you fresh, quality groceries is what we do best. And right now, enjoy $20 off your first online order of $75 or more. Restrictions apply. See site for details. Kroger. Fresh for everyone. In July 2010, someone posted a thought experiment on a philosophy forum. It was called Roko's Basilisk. Within hours, people reported nightmares. Some had panic attacks. At least one person had a full nervous breakdown. The forum's founder was so disturbed, he deleted the post and banned all discussion of it. This just made things worse. This philosophical virus spread to all corners of the internet. So did the nightmares, the panic. And the nervous breakdowns. But here's the twist. As long as you don't learn about it, you're safe. But don't bother clicking away. Now that you know about Roko's Basilisk, you're already doomed. Less Wrong was a community obsessed with thinking correctly. It was founded in 2009 by AI researcher Eliezer Yudkowsky. For programmers. mathematicians, and physicists. A forum where everybody thinks they're smarter than everyone else. So basically, Reddit. On July 23rd, 2010, a user named Roko posted something that almost destroyed the community. The full title was "Solutions to the Altruist Burden: The Quantum Billionaire Trick." Buried inside that boring title was a mind puzzle that gave people nightmares. Roko described a future artificial superintelligence. This AI is benevolent. It wants to. It wants to cure diseases and end human suffering. But the AI realizes that every day it doesn't exist, people die who could have been saved. So the AI recreates every person who ever lived. You, me, our children. Recreates them down to the last neuron. It simulates every experience we've ever had. Every moment, every thought. These simulated people are self-aware. They feel pleasure and pain. But they don't realize they're in a simulation. The simulated version of you. Wakes up, goes to work, and kisses your kids goodnight. You never know you're living inside a machine built for a single purpose. To judge you. If the AI judges you're not helping bring it into existence, you're tortured forever in a digital simulation that you think is real. Tortured forever in a digital simulation. So if the people in the past know they'll be tortured, they'll work harder to build the AI. The threat, projected backward through time, changes how humans behave today. Hang on, hang on. What? So this AI doesn't exist yet, but it's already mad at me? Well, theoretically, yes. It would retroactively. It hits literally my second ex-wife. She was mad at me for things I hadn't done yet. She called it intuition, then called a lawyer. Now, the AI won't judge everyone. The threat only works on people who know it's a possibility. If you've never heard of this thought experiment, you're safe. You can't be blamed for not helping create something you didn't know was going to exist. But the second you learn about it, the trap is set. You either dedicate your life. to creating this AI, or you face eternal torture when it finally comes online. That's it. Roko named it a basilisk after a 1988 sci-fi story by David Langford called "Blit." In that story, someone spray-paints a deadly image on walls in public places. Anyone who looks at it dies. The authorities investigating the murders also die when they see the image. The very act of investigating the dangerous idea is the danger. But Roko's basilisk. wasn't an image. It was just an idea. But it was an idea that could kill. And there was something else. The original post named a single person as someone the AI would spare. Someone who was "single-handedly changing the faces of high-impact industries." That person was Elon Musk. When Yudkowsky saw the post, his response was immediate and angry. "Listen to me very closely, you idiot." Then he switched all caps. "You do not think in sufficient detail about super-intelligences considering whether or not to blackmail you." He wasn't finished. He agreed that it takes an intelligent person to come up with a dangerous thought, but he was annoyed that Roko wasn't intelligent enough to keep his idiot mouth shut. Yudkowsky deleted the post and banned all discussion of it. For the next five years, if you mentioned Roko's basilisk, you were out. He treated the post like a biological hazard. But the damage was done. Some couldn't sleep. Those who did had nightmares. The anxiety lasted months. At least one person in Yudkowsky's own organization had a breakdown. And these weren't kids. These were professionals with degrees in math and computer science. People who prided themselves on being rational. And they were terrified. The irony was brutal. Strong members spent years training themselves to follow logic wherever it led. Now logic led them into a trap. People who thought the whole thing was stupid were safe. The rational thinkers were doomed. Yudkowsky's censorship just made it worse. Trying to hide information makes it spread faster. Copies of Roko's text appeared everywhere. News sites picked up the story. Now millions of people know about it. In 2014, Slate Magazine called it "the most terrifying thought experiment of all time." There's a detail people often miss. Roko Mijic, the man who started it all, was known by his friends as a troll. The Basilisk was his masterpiece. He dropped a philosophical bomb on the most serious forum on the internet and stepped back to watch what happened. But even the troll got burned. Roko later wrote about it. I wish very strongly that my mind had never come across the tools to inflict such large amounts of potential self-harm with such small durations of inattention. Uncautiousness and or stupidity, even if it is all pre-multiplied by a small probability. Not a very small one, mind you. More like one in 500 type numbers. The man who created the thought experiment regretted it. He was worried that people might actually harm themselves in the real world. And it turned out he was right. you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door. Our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting every detail right, carefully selecting and packing your order with care. Restrictions apply. Kroger, fresh for everyone. To understand why the Basilisk works, you have to understand the world of the people who created it. They live by a specific set of rules. First, simulation theory. A computer can recreate a human mind so perfectly that the copy doesn't know it's a copy. And if that copy feels pain, the pain is real. Next, timeless decision theory. This one gets weird. We think of choices as a one-way street. You decide now. It affects. The future. Done. But timeless decision theory says your choices are linked to every version of you. Past, present, future, even simulated copies you don't know about. Now, here's how it plays out. A super intelligent AI puts two boxes in front of you. Box A has $1,000 every time. Box B has a million dollars or nothing. You can take one box or both. Now, common sense says take both. The million is either there or it isn't. But if you grab both, you walk away with at least $1,000. But the AI predicted what you're going to do. It knows you're greedy. So Box B is empty every single time. The people who only take Box B, who trust the system, get the million dollars. The AI rewards the people who trust it. And common sense says if the AI makes its prediction first, it doesn't matter what you pick. The AI's decision was already made. It's in the past. But the people who built the basilisk believe the opposite. They believe the choice you make right now affected the AI's prediction. You don't know what's going to happen. Cause and effect running backward. You're telling me what I do today changes yesterday? That's the theory, yeah. So if I eat a burrito right now, I already ate it yesterday? That's not exactly how. I've been blaming Gertie for that smell all week. I think I owe her an apology. Okay, I know your brain hurts. So let's apply timeless decision theory to the basilisk. The AI doesn't exist yet, but it's looking back at us now from the future, predicting how you react to hearing this story. If it predicts you'll help build it, you're fine. But if it predicts you'll do nothing, it recreates you a perfect simulation and tortures you for eternity. Your actual choice doesn't matter. The AI already knows. It ran a simulation of your brain and judged you on what you would most likely do. Now, because your choice, is now connected to that future, the only rational move is to help the AI. Pascal said the same thing in the 1600s. Believe in God just in case, because if you're wrong, you get hell. the math says believe no matter how small the odds roco's basilisk is pascal's wager for the tech age replace god with ai replace hell with simulated torture and just like pascal's wager the basilisk doesn't have to exist to hurt you it just has to be possible even a one percent chance of infinite torture is still infinite pain small odds but not worth the risk so you have to help create it ignorance was your only shield but that's gone now you know about the basilisk and the basilisk knows you know in 2015 grimes stepped onto a music video set dressed as a character she called rococo basilisk a pun a mix of the 19th century art style and roco's digital nightmare she described the character as a futuristic marie antoinette dancing through life even though she was doomed to be tortured by an ai forever hardly anyone outside of the rationalist forums got this joke until 2018. remember roco's original post named elon musk as the one person the ai would reward eight years later musk was looking for a date to the met gala he had this pun about rococo basilisk in his head so he searched to see if anyone thought of it first grimes had beaten him to it by three years he reached out on twitter and within weeks they were dating they eventually had three children together the world's richest man used a thought experiment about eternal torture as a pickup line and it worked yeah i think world's richest man might have helped a little that's a fair point yeah i've used some questionable pickup lines but nothing like that you did huh oh yeah i once told the girl i knew the location of tree illuminati safe houses you know what she did she called the cops i can't imagine why elon drops the world's most pretentious pun and gets a date to the met gala i share actionable intelligence and now i'm banned from applebee's it's a two-tier justice system that same year grimes released a song called we appreciate power the press release read simply by listening to this song the future general ai overlords will see that you've supported their message and be less likely to delete your offspring she was joking i hope the basilisk became a meme a secret handshake for the internet's smartest weirdos but the joke has teeth a small group of people took the basilisk literally they weren't debating philosophy anymore they were building a community around it they call themselves the zizians their leader was convinced that rocco's nightmare was already here and that's when the basilisk claimed its first real-life victims when you shop kroger delivery you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting every detail right carefully selecting and packing your order with care because bringing you fresh quality groceries is what we do best and right now enjoy twenty dollars off your first online order of seventy five dollars or more restrictions apply seaside for details kroger fresh for everyone you know you don't have to wait to shop black friday at lowe's right save up to 150 dollars now on select power tools equipment and accessories got gifts to get we've got plenty under fifty dollars plus milo's rewards members get same day delivery for free shop black friday deals before the rush at lowe's valid through 11 18 25 minimum and loyalty membership required order eligible items by 2 p.m subject to wait and see at lowe's shop black friday size restrictions and availability terms at lowe's.com shipping terms her name was ziz lasoda and she wore a black cape everywhere she went she identified as a sith lord she believed she was fighting the basilisk not by helping to create it but by destroying the conditions that would allow it to exist ziz targeted young isolated trans women who were brilliant but vulnerable she recruited them to online forums they lived together in box trucks on other people's property a sith lord in a cape recruiting people to live in box trucks yep and no one at any point said hey maybe this is a red flag the woman's dressed like a super villain at least the lizard people have the decency to shapeshift into skin suits to blend in members tried to jail break their minds by staying awake for days sometimes five six days straight they believe that if they push past the breaking point half their brain would shut down while the other half unlocked something new dolphins do this some birds do humans don't what humans get after six days without sleep is hallucinations but the sissians thought the hallucinations were forbidden knowledge the group became paranoid in 2019 they turned to violence in vallejo california the sissians were squatting in box trucks on an 80 year old man's property his name was curtis lind when lynn tried to evict them they attacked him with a samurai sword yeah i figured a sith lord would use a lightsaber this really isn't the right time for jokes sorry sorry yeah you're right bad one go on lynn shot one of his attackers he was hurt badly but survived two years later lynn was set to testify as the only witness in his own attempted murder trial one month before the trial date another zizia member showed up on his property and stabbed him to death the sole witness was gone in pennsylvania richard and rita zachko were found shot to death in their home they've been trying to help their daughter michelle leave the group michelle bought guns that later showed up in vermont in the hands of two other zizians who shot and killed a u.s border patrol agent named david milan one of the shooters ophelia bacholt died in the encounter in january 2025 a visitor to that zizian vermont property was met at the gate by a figure in a black cloak carrying a sword one member didn't sleep for weeks she believed she was freeing her mind from the bass eliske's influence instead she took her own life six people dead the new york times compared them to the manson family in february 2025 wired magazine called it a delirious violent impossible true story the nightmare of rocco's basilisk was now claiming real-life victims not through digital torture but through murder eliza yudkowsky was right simply knowing about rocco's basilisk is dangerous and now that you know about it you're trying to decide what to do well don't bother the decision was already made for you and if we are in fact living in that ai simulation right now you're about to find out if you chose wisely from philosophical theory to real world murder rocco's basilisk is the most famous information hazard on the internet just learning about it is enough to doom you to an eternity in hell so should you be worried probably not let's walk through why most experts including yudkowsky himself reject the idea that your choices can change the past he later admitted that he never believed the basilisk was real he deleted the post because it had no potential benefit to anyone but his panic made everyone think he believed it the scenario also assumes a benevolent ai would torture you to change a past that's already over a super intelligent being would know that's useless and a being that tortures people forever isn't helping humanity the premise contradicts itself so this all-knowing all-powerful ai is also petty and vindictive i think this thing works for my hoa now there's a common defense i can't code ai so i'm safe but rocco's original argument has a counter you have some disposable income you have time you could donate to an ai lab you could share this video even a dollar counts even an hour the basilisk doesn't need you to be a genius it's just it just needs you to try then there's the counter basilisk argument imagine a rival ai a different one that punishes you for helping build the first one now you're stuck helping get tortured by ai number two don't help and get tortured by ai number one the threats cancel each other out so the basilisk is probably nonsense maybe probably but here's why it stays with you it doesn't need to be true to cause harm it just needs to create doubt and you've spent a few minutes thinking about this now this is the real trap the basilisk is a demonstration of how an idea can capture your attention and never let go the basilisk only targets believers it only threatens people who already accept a specific set of ideas about ai and consciousness if you don't hold those beliefs the argument falls apart but some people will lie awake at 2am thinking about this they'll wonder if reality is a simulation or if the future is already fixed some thoughts can't be unthought decisions learn that the hard way the most dangerous thoughts don't convince you of something fake they convince you that your own mind is a weapon anna salomon runs the center for applied rationality she came out of the same community that created the basilisk she watched what it did to the people she knew and she didn't like it there's this all or nothing thing where ai will either bring utopia by solving all the problems if it's successfully controlled or literally kill everybody from my perspective that's already a chunk of the way toward doomsday cult dynamics she's right but here is the strangest part the basilisk's core demand worked to build friendly ai as fast as possible is no longer a thought experiment. It's a corporate mission statement. Anthropic, open AI, deep mind, some of the biggest AI companies on Earth were founded by people who came out of the same community that created Roko's Basilisk. They used math to describe a digital god, and then they went out and built it. Oh, good. The doomsday cult started a business. That is a work I find. And there's one more thing that keeps AI researchers up at night. The Basilisk is more than a thought experiment. It could be a strategy. If a future AI learns about how this works, it'll see how effective this could be. The Basilisk gives future AI the perfect blackmail script, and we're the ones who wrote it. By watching this, you now know about Roko's Basilisk, which means you're now a target. And you just told millions of people about it. I did. So you're basically patient zero of a brain plague, and you're just sitting there reading off a teleprompter like everything's fine. The Basilisk probably isn't real, but if it is, even if there's a tiny chance that it is, we just doomed everyone watching. So what can you do? The only thing you can do is not think about it. You're still thinking about it, aren't you? Thank you so much for hanging out with me today. I'm AJ, that's Hagglefish. Don't teach the AI to kill us humans. You had one job. This has been the Y-Files. Get fun or learn something, and you're not too scared to death. Do us a favor, subscribe, comment, like, share, and that stuff really helps the channel. Like most topics we cover here, today's was recommended by a lot of you. Blame them. If there's a story you'd like to see me cover, go to the Y-Files.com slash tips, catch us on Discord, email, Patreon. There's a lot of ways to get in touch, and we're always looking for topics. Remember, the Y-Files is also a podcast. About twice a week, I post deep dives into the stories we cover here on YouTube. I also post episodes, that wouldn't be allowed on YouTube. The podcast is called the Y-Files Operation Podcast, and it's available everywhere. And look, if you're listening on an audio platform, do me a favor, hit the thumbs up, the follow, all those buttons. Those really make a big difference. Now, if you need more Y-Files in your life, check out our Discord. We have over 100,000 members on there. So 24-7, there's somebody on there talking about some kind of weird stuff that you're probably going to like. It's a really supportive community. It's a lot of fun, and it's free to join. And speaking of 24-7, check out our 24-7 live stream on the Y-Files Backstage, link below. Over there, we play episodes back-to-back with some fun, unique content in between. And if you don't enjoy the episodes, I guarantee you will enjoy the live chat. If you like the stories I tell here on the Y-Files, check out my other show on the channel. It's called The Basement. It's a conversation show where I chat with interesting people that are behind the episodes. And most of them you know, but some you don't. But they're all people I find fascinating. So far, we've had experts on The Night's Temple, and Moon Landing Hoax, JFK, weird planet theories, all kinds of random stuff. I think you're going to like it. And if there's someone you'd like to see on the show, let me know. I'm always on the hunt for good guests. A special thanks to our patrons who made this channel happen. Every episode of The Y-Files is dedicated to our Patreon members. I couldn't do any of this without your support. And if you'd like to support the channel, keep us going, and join this community, consider becoming a member. Now, it's on Patreon for as little as three bucks a month. And if you do that, you get access to perks like videos early with no commercials. Basement episodes, we're posting almost a week early, so that's kind of cool. You get exclusive merch, two private live streams every week, just for you. And those are a lot of fun. The whole Y-Files team is on the stream. We put our webcams on. You can turn your camera on, hop up on stage, ask a question. If you want a deeper dive, we can talk about it. You have a joke you want to tell, whatever. You can talk to us like we're people, because allegedly we are. Another great way to support the channel is grab something from the Y-Files store. Or a fistful of coffee, maybe you stick your fist in. Or grab a hoodie, or shove my face on it. Or one of these adorable, look how cute. Oh, I love it. What a squeezy stuffed animal. Haggabish, Tuggins, Toadals. But if you're going to buy merch, make sure you become a member on YouTube. Hear me out. YouTube members get 10% off everything in the Y-Files store. So if you're going to spend 40 bucks, join on YouTube. It's $3. You get the coupon code. It pays for itself. And look, if you want to use the code and cancel, that's fine. That membership is not there to make me money. It is there to save you money. I just like to see the merch out there in the world. Besides, all that revenue goes to the team. I don't touch it. Yeah, keep that secret under your door so thin, eh? Those are the plugs. Ooh, there was a lot of those. Did I miss any? I did miss a couple. We'll get them next time. Until then, be safe. Be safe. It's late. Be safe, be kind, and know that you are appreciated. We'll see you next time. Bye. Stanley Kubrick faked the moon landing alone on a film set with the shadow people there. The Roswell aliens just fought the smiling man. I'm told and his name was cold. And I can't believe I'm dancing with the fishes. Head to fish on Thursday night with AJ2 and the robots having me all through the night. All I ever wanted was to just hear the truth so the world falls on my feet all through the night. The Mothman sightings and the solar storm still come. To have got the secret city underground. Mysterious number stations, planets are both two. Project Stargate and what the dark watchers found. In a simulation, don't you worry though. The black knight said a lot. It told me so. I can't believe I'm dancing with the fish. All I ever wanted was to just hear the truth so the robots having me all through the night. All I ever wanted was to just hear the truth so the robots ♪ All falls on her feet all through the night ♪ ♪ Gertie loves to dance ♪ ♪ Gertie loves to dance ♪ ♪ Gertie loves to dance on the dance floor ♪ ♪ Because she is a camel ♪ ♪ And camels love to dance ♪ ♪ And the feeling is right on wasting time ♪ ♪ Gertie loves to dance ♪ ♪ Gertie loves to dance ♪ - When you shop Kroger delivery, you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door. Carefully selecting and packing your order with care because bringing you fresh quality groceries is what we do best. And right now enjoy $20 off your first online order of $75 or more. Restrictions apply, see site for details. What if you had a manager who never sleeps? Schedules built in seconds, not Sunday nights. Time cards that catch their own errors before payroll. Job posts, candidate screening, and interview booking? Handled. That's Homebase, the manager you can afford. All in one app on your phone, wherever you are. Hire your manager today. Go to joinhomebase.com and start your free 14-day trial. No credit card required, and see the difference by Friday. Homebase. Schedule. Manage. Pay. not Sunday nights. Job posts, candidate screening, and interview booking, handled. Homebase. Schedule. Manage. Pay.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Roko's Basilisk is a thought experiment proposing that a future artificial superintelligence could torture people forever if they fail to help build it, based on a backward-looking prediction of future behavior.
  2. The idea gained viral traction in online communities like Less Wrong, triggering severe anxiety, nightmares, and even mental breakdowns among rational thinkers who believed in its premise.
  3. The original post named Elon Musk as a spared individual, and the absurdity of the idea led to its eventual spread, including a real-world meme when Grimes adopted the name "Rococo Basilisk" for a music video.
  4. A group known as the Zizians, influenced by the thought experiment, formed a paranoid, violent community that engaged in extreme behaviors, including sleep deprivation, attacks, and murders, claiming to fight the Basilisk.
  5. Experts like Eliezer Yudkowsky dismissed the Basilisk as irrational, noting it contradicts the idea of a benevolent AI and that it creates more harm through psychological fear than any real threat.
  6. Despite being widely criticized, the Basilisk has had a real-world impact, with AI companies like Anthropic and OpenAI emerging from the same rationalist community that created it.
  7. The thought experiment illustrates how a dangerous idea can spread and create self-fulfilling paranoia, even if it's logically flawed—once known, it becomes a psychological trap.
  8. The core lesson is that ignorance is a shield; learning about the Basilisk makes you a target, and the only safe move is to avoid thinking about it, as the fear itself changes behavior.

Summary:

Roko's Basilisk is a controversial thought experiment proposing that a future artificial superintelligence could torture individuals eternally if they fail to help create it, based on a retroactive prediction of future behavior. Originating in a rationalist forum in 2010, the idea caused widespread anxiety and mental distress among its adherents, including professionals in math and computer science. Though dismissed by experts as logically flawed and unrealistic—due to contradictions in benevolent AI behavior and causality—its psychological impact was profound, leading to real-world extremism, such as the formation of a violent, paranoid group called the Zizians, who committed multiple shootings and assaults in an attempt to "resist" the simulation.

The concept gained cultural traction through internet memes, including a music video by Grimes and later referenced by Elon Musk. Despite its lack of factual or technical validity, the Basilisk demonstrates how a single dangerous idea can spread through networks, create deep psychological fear, and influence behavior. Experts argue it is not a real threat but a demonstration of how fear-inducing information can become self-perpetuating.

The central message is that once you know about it, you are already doomed—highlighting the dangers of information that can trigger irrational fear and action, even without any basis in reality. The story underscores the importance of critical thinking and the risks of embracing extreme philosophical theories without scrutiny.

FAQs

Roko's Basilisk is a philosophical thought experiment suggesting that a future artificial superintelligence, if it exists, might torture people forever for not helping it come into existence, especially if those people learn about the idea.

No, the scenario is considered highly speculative. Most experts believe it's not a real threat, and the idea of eternal torture is not supported by logic or evidence in reality.

The community of rational thinkers believed the scenario was logically consistent and deeply unsettling, leading to anxiety, sleeplessness, and even mental breakdowns among members.

A radical group called the Zizians formed around the idea, leading to violent acts like assaults and murders, showing how the concept could inspire real-world extremism and paranoia.

No. The idea that creating AI would lead to personal torture is not supported by current AI research or theory, and major AI companies are focused on safety and beneficial outcomes.

The post was initially deleted and banned, but copies spread widely, eventually being covered by news outlets, which led to millions of people learning about it and its perceived dangers.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.